View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/reserve-requirements-and-monetary-policy

Reserve Requirements and Monetary Policy
Robert H. Rasche
Reserve requirements are enshrined in introductory economics textbooks as one of the "tools," albeit a crude
one, of monetary policy. Such regulations are understood to affect the banking system, and, ultimately, the
economy by influencing the proportion of total assets that depositories hold as cash assets (either vault cash
or balances with the Federal Reserve).
In recent years, different trends have emerged across industrial economies. The Bank of Canada has
abolished reserve requirements. The new System of European Central Banks, in contrast, has established a
2-percent reserve requirement on almost all liabilities. In December 1990 and January 1991, the Federal
Reserve reduced reserve requirements on non-personal time deposits to zero. Then, in April 1992, marginal
reserve requirements on transactions deposits for the largest class of depositories were reduced from 12
percent to 10 percent.
In the absence of reserve requirements, depository institutions would continue to hold cash assets. Such
assets are required to satisfy normal business operations, including settlement of interbank transactions (such
as wire transfers and check clearing) and the exchange of retail deposits for currency on request. This
represents a transactions demand for cash assets.
The evidence from recent U.S. data strongly suggests that the amount of cash assets demanded by most
depositories now is determined by institutions' transaction demands. Under the legal reserve requirement
ratios that were established in December 1990 and April 1992, and the "home-brewed" ratios allowed via the
implementation of retail deposit "sweep" programs since 1994, reserve requirement regulations no longer are
binding constraints on the portfolios of most depository institutions.
An environment in which the demand for cash assets by depositories is determined by transactions demands
rather than regulatory constraints has several implications:
1. On March 26, 1998, the Board of Governors announced the return to a lagged reserve requirement
structure, beginning July 30, 1998 (Federal Reserve Bulletin, May 1998, p. 337). Under the new
system, the reserve computation ends two weeks before the beginning of the reserve maintenance
period. Hence, depository institutions can know with certainty their level of required reserves before
the maintenance period begins, and, similarly, the Federal Reserve can know the level of aggregate
required reserves. In the near future, it is unlikely that this regulatory change will have any substantive
effect on depository behavior, or on the conduct of the Fed's Open Market Operations.
2. It is important to distinguish between the concept of a reserve requirement as a pure tax (in exchange
for which depositories receive no services) and as an implicit user charge for which the depositories
receive clearing services from the Fed that are not explicitly priced. When legal reserve requirements
are not binding constraints, the forgone interest from holding Federal Reserve deposits to meet a
transactions demand should be viewed as a normal operating expense. Under these circumstances,

payment of explicit interest on Federal Reserve balances would constitute a subsidy to the depository
industry.
3. A number of recent studies conclude that funds rate volatility has not increased in recent years. This
suggests that the evolution from an environment in which demand by depositories for cash assets is
dominated by reserve requirements to one in which this demand is determined by patterns of
payments activity does not introduce any fundamental problems for the current Federal Reserve
operating procedures that are focused on federal funds rate objectives.
Changes in reserve requirements in the U.S. over the past decade are consistent with reducing the regulatory
burden on depository institutions, but have not had a significant impact on the ability of the Federal Reserve
to conduct monetary policy.
A longer version of this article will be published in the Jan./Feb. issue of the St. Louis Fed's Review.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/fed-forms-financial-services-advisory-group

Fed Forms Financial Services Advisory Group
The St. Louis Fed has established a District-wide Financial Services Advisory Group to facilitate the exchange
of ideas relative to payments system issues. The group will encourage a dialogue between the Fed and
financial institutions about product development, service improvements, marketing strategies and emerging
issues.
Participating financial institutions will serve staggered two-year terms and will meet two or three times a year
at Federal Reserve offices within the Eighth District.
"This initiative will provide valuable feedback from our customers," said Hank Bourgaux, senior vice president
at the St. Louis Fed. "We look forward to hearing their views about our services and marketing, and using this
information when developing our future strategies."
The members who will be serving three-year terms beginning this year include: Rowe W. Belcher Jr. of Trust
One Bank in Germantown, Tenn.; Camden R. Fine of Midwest Independent Bank in Jefferson City, Mo.;
Carolyn E. Hudson of Bank of Benton in Benton, Ky.; Don Hughes of Farmers Bank and Capital Trust Co. in
Frankfort, Ky.; and Phil Porter of Bank of Bentonville in Bentonville, Ark.
Serving two-year terms are: Thomas Bangert of First Banks Inc. In St. Louis; James Clayton of Planters Bank
and Trust Co. in Indianola, Miss.; Judy R. Loving of The Bank of Yellville in Yellville, Ark.; and Reynie
Rutledge of First Security Bank in Searcy, Ark. The first meeting was held Feb. 10 at the St. Louis Fed. For
more information, call Ronda Sauget at (314) 444-8698.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/preparation--communication--extermination-of-cdc-bug

Feditorial: Preparation + Communication =
Extermination of CDC Bug
W. LeGrande Rives
With the clock ticking closer and closer to the end of the century, many of us are quickly reaching Century
Date Change (CDC) saturation. Airwaves, newsprint and web sites are cluttered with dire warnings about the
potential for Year 2000 computer failures. We in banking have an opportunity and obligation to send a positive
message regarding our industry's CDC readiness. Indeed, besides solving a computer problem, financial
institutions must also deal with a perception problem among their customers. Overcoming this obstacle will
take a great deal of work. I believe the industry must take two steps to meet this challenge.
First, we must make sure that our systems are thoroughly tested. You are, no doubt, aware of the emphasis
the Federal Reserve has placed on the CDC issue because of the potential impact on the financial services
industry. We are executing an extensive Century Date Change initiative to prepare our own internal systems.
But the continued strength of our industry depends on financial institutions proactively renovating and testing
their own internal systems and external interfaces. Since June 27, 1998, we have been testing with our
customers and will continue to test into late 1999. We strongly encourage customers who have electronic
connections with the Federal Reserve to test with us. It is promising to note that we have had no CDC
problems reported by our customers as a result of these tests.
Our other important task is to diminish public anxiety by communicating frequently and concisely with our
customers. The Fed is continuing to keep you informed regarding our progress. Because you are on the front
line with your customers, it is essential that you, in turn, inform them about your organization's sense of
readiness. Your effort in sending a positive message or calming a nervous customer reduces the likelihood of
a perception problem as we approach Jan. 1, 2000.
I urge you to keep in touch with your CDC coordinators to ensure all preparations are proceeding on
schedule. Thorough testing and effective communication will eliminate the CDC bug and your customers'
concerns.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/fed-issues-report-summarizing-attitudes-on-direct-depositand-direct-payment

Fed Issues Report Summarizing Attitudes on
Direct Deposit and Direct Payment
On the heels of a Federal Reserve-sponsored comprehensive study on attitudes toward electronic payments,
the Fed recently published a summary report that captures the results in a briefer format. The report was
mailed to financial institutions across the nation last month.
Through text, charts and graphs, the 23-page booklet provides a synopsis of consumer and business
attitudes on direct deposit and direct payment. The question-and-answer format allows readers to quickly
skim the findings.
In addition, the summary also reveals how the researchers broke down the population into five segments and
how each of these segments perceives direct deposit and direct payment. By analyzing these results,
financial institutions can better understand the most logical directions to target their marketing of electronic
payments.
For additional copies, call Cheryl McCarthy at (314) 444-8459. The complete results of the study are available
at http://frbservices.org/communications/payment_system_research.html.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/century-date-change-readiness-hits-critical-strength

Century Date Change Readiness Hits Critical
Strength
With just under nine months remaining until the new millennium, Century Date Change (CDC) testing and
readiness is of the highest importance in the banking industry. In terms of internal readiness, the Federal
Reserve System has tested nearly all of its 105 mission-critical systems. More than 5,000 of the Fed's
customers, including the Treasury, have conducted tests with Federal Reserve Banks. Although these figures
are encouraging, financial institutions still must take key steps to ensure that all of their systems are CDC
compliant. By March 31, 1999, financial institutions should have:
substantially completed testing with service providers; and
begun testing with their material data exchange partners.
By June 30, 1999, financial institutions should have:
completed testing of mission-critical systems; and
substantially completed implementation of renovated mission-critical systems.
This issue of Central Banker examines some of the most important aspects of CDC preparation for financial
institutions (see checklist). For additional information, please call Jeff Dale at (314) 444-8400.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/fed-asks-institutions-to-review-cdc-contingency-funding

Fed Asks Institutions to Review CDC Contingency
Funding
As part of preparations for Century Date Change (CDC) compliance, the Federal Reserve is asking financial
institutions to establish contingency funding arrangements. Institutions may wish to consider making the Fed's
Discount Window one of their liquidity sources. The Fed encourages credit unions to contact their corporate
credit unions first.
Most depository institutions are eligible to borrow from the Discount Window. Although loans must be fully
secured, the Fed accepts a variety of assets as collateral. A small discount is applied to the assets pledged to
determine collateral value. Most pledged assets can be held in book-entry form or remain in the borrower's
possession.
Institutions that already have the required borrowing documentation in place should review the amount of
collateral pledged in comparison to their potential needs. Those institutions that would like to borrow from the
Discount Window must have an account with the Fed or with a correspondent that does. In addition, they will
need to submit a letter of agreement, authorizing board resolution and certified copy of the minutes
documenting approval of the resolution. For more information, call the Fed's Credit staff at (314) 444-8316 or
(314) 444-8622.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/fed-monitoring-international-preparation-for-century-datechange

Fed Monitoring International Preparation for
Century Date Change
U.S. offices of foreign banks lag behind U.S. financial institutions in planning and testing for the Year 2000.
These banks, however, have made good progress in recent months, according to Federal Reserve
supervisory reviews. The Federal Reserve is working closely with international bank supervisors to better
understand the level of Century Date Change readiness worldwide.
Although the Federal Reserve cannot be responsible for CDC preparations among foreign institutions, it is
involved in a number of initiatives with the President's Council on Year 2000 Conversion to develop accurate
perspectives. The Fed's direct supervisory authority over foreign banks is limited to the offices of those banks
operating in the United States, but the Fed will receive information on foreign bank Year 2000 readiness
through its participation in several exchanges with international supervisory bodies and private sector forums.
The Fed has been involved with the Basle Committee on Banking Supervision to survey international CDC
readiness. This committee has issued guidance for examiners to use in assessing bank readiness. In
addition, Fed Governor Roger Ferguson chairs the Joint Year 2000 Council, which is working to promote
awareness and information about the CDC issues.
The New York Fed is taking special steps to address CDC issues with the largest institutions in New York that
comprise the infrastructure for the U.S. financial and global markets.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/fed-to-increase-cash-inventory-for-year-2000

Fed to Increase Cash Inventory for Year 2000
Toward the end of the year, the Federal Reserve plans to increase the amount of currency in circulation by
about 14 percent over current levels. The increase is in anticipation that some financial institution customers
will decide to withdraw greater sums of cash as a result of Year 2000 uncertainty.
Consumers who are concerned that alternative payment methods will not work next Jan. 1 may choose to
withdraw more cash than usual for routine household purchases, such as groceries, medicine and gas. But
the Fed expects only a small percentage of individuals to significantly increase cash demands toward the end
of 1999.
The level of increase in the currency in circulation was determined after the Fed reviewed high currencydemand periods (such as holidays), assessed household spending patterns, and reviewed potential
international demand. The currency order does not reflect a Fed recommendation, or even a projection for
cash demand in the rollover period. If necessary, the Fed may choose to adjust the increase as it continues to
assess the situation throughout the year.
Also throughout 1999, the Fed will work to communicate a positive message to the media and general public
concerning the safety of the banking system during the century date change. For additional information about
cash inventories, call Jerry McGunnigle at (314) 444-8732.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/regional-roundup

Regional Roundup
St. Louis Fed Names Rasche Director of Research
On Jan. 4, 1999, Robert H. Rasche assumed the position of senior vice president and director of Research at
the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
Rasche joined the Fed from Michigan State University, where he most recently was an economics professor.
Rasche, who joined the Michigan State faculty in 1972, also chaired the university's economics department
from 1980 to 1984. He has been a visiting scholar at the St. Louis and San Francisco Federal Reserve Banks
and at the Bank of Japan. He was a member of the Michigan governor's Council of Economic Advisers and a
consultant to several business organizations.
Rasche succeeded William G. Dewald, who retired from the St. Louis Fed at the end of 1998.

Fed Public Information Catalog Online
Publications, periodicals and videos from all Federal Reserve Banks now can be ordered online from one
central site: www.newyorkfed.org/publications. Categories are arranged by individual Reserve Banks and
publication topics. The site also indicates which publications are available online.

Fed Tells Its Story In Plain English
The St. Louis Fed has published an educational booklet about the Federal Reserve, written and illustrated to
appeal to the general public. The booklet, called In Plain English: Making Sense of the Federal Reserve,
describes, in straightforward language, the history, components and functions of the Federal Reserve,
including the roles of the Board of Governors, the regional Reserve Banks and the Federal Open Market
Committee.
Financial institutions may want to keep copies of the booklet in their lobbies for customers. To request copies,
free of charge, call Debbie Dawe at (314) 444-8809.

CENTRAL BANKER | SPRING 1999
https://www.stlouisfed.org/publications/central-banker/spring-1999/fedfacts

FedFacts
Year 2000 Teleconference Videos Available
More than 200 bankers participated in a Year 2000 teleconference Dec. 14 at the St. Louis Fed and its three
branches. Approximately 100 additional bankers viewed the teleconference through down-link sites at
universities and banks around the Eighth District.
Last month, the Fed sent a video of the teleconference, including the question-and-answer session, to those
financial institutions that registered to attend. Additional copies are available, free of charge, by calling Bernie
Berns at (314) 444-8321.

Fed Working to Upgrade Data Security
To upgrade the security and integrity of data transmitted between the Federal Reserve and financial
institutions, the Fed is evaluating several alternative encryption methods. The Fed is pursuing a retrofit
solution for existing encryption boards through software modifications.
The Fed currently is working with its encryption suppliers to finalize and test the retrofit solution for roll-out to
financial institutions later this year. Additional information on this new encryption standard will be available in
the next few months.