View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

■

m n n

30030005363370

ANNUAL REPORT

O F THE

SECRETARY OF COMMERCE

W A SH IN G T O N
G O V ER N M E N T P R IN T IN G O F F IC E

1919

CO N TEN TS.
(Foi complete alphabetical Index to this report, see page 231.)

Page.

American-Canadian Fisheries Conference...............................................................
Vessels of the Department’s marine services...........................................................
Vessels urgently needed for the Bureau of Lighthouses........................................
Buildings.....................................................................................................................
Bureau of Standards— Industrial laboratory building...........................................
Bureau of Standards— New dynamometer and altitude laboratory......................
Bureau of Fisheries— Laboratory aquarium............................................................
Housing for the Bureau of the Census......................................................................
Cooperation by the Bureau of the Census with other services and organizations.
Archives building........................................................................................................
Urgent needs of the Department..............................................................................
Use of motion pictures in industry...........................................................................
Pacific cable situation................................................................................................
Appropriations and expenditures.............................................................................
Estimates for fiscal year ending June 30, 1921........................................................
Personnel.....................................................................................................................
Superannuation and retirement...............................................................................
Salaries.........................................................................................................................
Transportation of families and effects of officers and employees..........................
Transporting remains of officers and employees dying abroad..............................
Printing and binding..................................................................................................
"International Price Comparisons” publication....................................................
Motor-vehicle equipment...........................................................................................
Stock and shipping section..........................................................................
Department library.....................................................................................................
Division of Supplies....................................................................................................
State fair exhibits.......................................................................................................
Liberty loans...............................................................................................................
Contributions...............................................................................................................
Employees’ Relief Association..................................................................................
Purchase of Dutch Harbor, Alaska...........................................................................
Abolition of the Official Register..............................................................................
Work of the Solicitor’s Office.....................................................................................
Development of waterways........................................................................................
Industrial Board..........................................................................................................
Industrial Cooperation Service..................................................................................
Waste-Reclamation Service................................................................................
Introduction of new fish food by the Bureau of Fisheries.....................................
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce...........................................................
Unprecedented totals for American foreign trade...........................................
Letters of appreciation show practical results accomplished.........................
Period of readjustment in commercial-attaché service...................................
Activities of attachés in Europe........................................................................

3

8
9
12
13
15
17
17
18
19
19
19
21
21
22
36
42
46
47
58
58
59
63
63
64
65
65
65
66
66
66
67
67
67
67
68
69
70
73
76
77
78
78
79

CONTENTS.
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce—Continued.
Page.
Results attained by far-eastern offices..................................................................
82
Work of attachés in Latin America.......................................................................
83
Usefulness of attaché service clearly demonstrated............................................
84
Vital work accomplished by trade commissioners..............................................
85
District and cooperative offices.............................................................................
87
Work in connection with Latin America.............................................................
88
Promotion of trade with Far East.........................................................................
91
Establishment of Russian division.......................................................................
92
Extraordinary demand for commercial information...........................................
93
Division of statistics...............................................................................................
94
Original research and compilation of foreignstatistics........................................
97
Division of foreign tariffs.......................................................................................
98
Editorial division....................................................................................................
98
Recommendations...................................................................................................
99
National Bureau of Standards......................................................................................
102
Weights and measures............................................................................................
103
Electricity...............................................................................................................
106
Public utilities........................................................................................................
108
Radium....................................................................................................................
no
Heat.........................................................................................................................
in
History of the production of optical glass by the Bureau of Standards........
113
Light........................................................................................................................
115
Chemistry................................................................................................................
118
Materials..................................................................................................................
119
Aeronautical instruments......................................................................................
122
Metals.......................................................................................................................
122
New industrial laboratory.....................................................................................
124
Ceramics...................................................................................................................
125
The bureau and industrial progress......................................................................
126
Bureau of the Census.....................................................................................................
128
Current and completed work on statutory inquiries..........................................
128
Electrical industries........................................................................................
128
Transportation by water.................................................................................
129
Shipbuilding...................................................................................................
129
Religious bodies..............................................................................................
129
Vital statistics..................................................................................................
130
Financial statistics of cities...........................................................................
131
General statistics of cities...........................................................................
131
Financial statistics of States..........................................................................
131
Cotton and cotton seed..................................................................................
132
Stocks of leaf tobacco.....................................................................................
132
Official Register...............................................................................................
132
Special and miscellaneous lines of work..............................................................
132
Marriage and divorce...................................................................................
132
Special censuses of population......................................................................
133
Statistics of fats and oils..............................................................
United States life tables.................................................................................
133
Special investigation of influenza epidemic................................................
133
International Statistical Yearbook................................................................
134
Statistical directory of State institutions.....................................................
134
Searching of census records to determine ages............................................
134
Miscellaneous information supplied other governmental agencies and
outside organizations...................................................................................
134

CONTENTS.

O

Bureau of the Census— Continued.
PareWar work..............................................................................................................
135
Census of materials and commodities for use of war agencies...............
135
Census of commercial greenhouses.............................................................
135
Work done for Provost Marshal General....................................................
136
Determination of ages of registrants...........................................................
136
Liberty-Loan work.......................................................................................
136
Compilation of statistics relative to foreign countries for peace con­
ference.......................................................................................................
136
Information for United States Shipping Board.........................................
136
Miscellaneous war work..............................................................................
136
Members of force enlisted and drafted into military and naval services..
137
Publications issued.............................................................................................
137
Preparations for the Fourteenth Census...........................................................
138
Fourteenth Census law.................................................................................
138
Joint advisory committee of American Statistical and Economic Asso­
ciations......................................................................................................
139
Field force.....................................................................................................
139
Office force....................................................................................................
141
Preparation of schedules, etc......................................................................
142
Encumbrances on homes and farms...........................................................
142
Outlying possessions....................................................................................
143
Mechanical equipment................................................................................
143
Bureau of Fisheries.....................................................................................................
145
General considerations.......................................................................................
145
Planting the waters.............................................................................................
146
Humpback salmon in Maine..............................................................................
146
Rescue of stranded food fishes...........................................................................
147
Loss of a Pacific salmon hatchery.....................................................................
147
Relations with the States in fish-cultural work..............................................
148
Biological investigation of fishes........................................................................
148
Shellfish investigations.......................................................................................
149
Use of fishes in controlling mosquitoes.............................................................
150
Increased utilization of aquatic products.........................................................
151
New sources of aquatic leather..........................................................................
131
Alaska fisheries service...................................................
152
Alaska fur-seal service........................................................................................
153
Alaskan seal herd................................................................................................
155
Marketing products of the seal islands.............................................................
155
Minor fur-bearing animals of Alaska.................................................................
157
Fishery legislation needed.................................................................................
158
Bureau of Lighthouses...............................................................................................
159
Cooperation with Navy and War Departments...............................................
159
Aids to navigation...............................................................................................
159
Vessels...................................................................................................................
161
Lighthouse depots...............................................................................................
162
Improvement of apparatus and equipment.....................................................
163
Personnel.............................................................................................................
164
Saving of life and property................................................................................
164
Administration.....................................................................................................
164
Special legislation needed..................................................................................
163
Appropriations for special works...............................................................
167

6

CONTENTS.

Coast and Geodetic Survey.......................................................................................
Important publications.......................................................................................
F ieldw ork...........................................................................................................
Needs of the Survey to better accomplish its field work................................
War work of the Coast and Geodetic Survey...................................................
Need for a new building.....................................................................................
Steam boat-Inspection Service..................................................................................
Organization.........................................................................................................
Summary of activities and statistics.................................................................
Reconstruction....................................................................
Centralization of approval of hull and boiler construction............................
Examination of applicants for licenses.............................................................
Boiler pressure.....................................................................................................
Civil service for the supervising inspectors. 1..................................................
Bureau of Navigation.................................................................................................
World’s tonnage...................................................................................................
Main maritime facts............................................................................................
Maritime problem...............................................................................................
Subdivision of hulls............................................................................................
Shipping commissioners.....................................................................................
Navigation receipts.............................................................................................
Radio communication.........................................................................................
International Radiotélégraphie Conference.....................................................
Load line, measurement, bulkheads.................................................................
Enforcement of navigation laws........................................................................
Motor boats...........................................................................................................
Conclusion....................................................................................................................
Need for a unified Government commercial organization..............................
Appendixes:
A. Vessels for the United States Lighthouse Service— Urgent necessity for
replacement of vessels worn out and destroyed.....................................
B. The dogfish campaign and controversy, and the increased consumption
of food fishes...............................................................................................
I ndex ...........................................................................................................................

Page.
168
168
170
173
180
181
182
192
183
184
184
185
185
186
188
189
192
193
194
195
195
196
198
199
200
201
202
202

207
213
231

ANNUAL REPORT
OF T H E

SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
Department oe Commerce,
O ffice of the S ecretary ,

Washington, October 30, 1919.
To the President :
I have the honor to submit herewith my seventh annual report,
covering the operations and condition of the Department during
the fiscal year which ended June 30, 1919, and tracing in a general
way its operations to October 1 of the present year.
Recommendations have hitherto been often made respecting
the inadequate subsistence allowance for Department employees
when traveling. Force is added to these by present prices. It
has always been wrong to require Government officers when
traveling to pay out of their own pockets part of the cost of the
public work they do. The situation is worse to-day. This in­
justice can not be too speedily corrected, either by increasing the
subsistence allowances or by authorizing some flexibility in the
matter under the direction of the Secretary.
It has been heretofore pointed out that the Bureau of Standards
may and does send its representatives to meetings and conven­
tions at public expense. The law especially permits this. It
does not, however, grant a like privilege to the representatives
of the Coast and Geodetic Survey, the Bureau of Fisheries, the
Bureau of the Census, and other services. The same obligation
and usefulness exists as regards this matter in connection with
the work of all services. There is no reason why one bureau
should be preferred to others. The privilege should be extended
to all alike.
Your attention is particularly asked to Appendix B, giving in
detail the record of the efforts of the Bureau of Fisheries to intro­
duce new foods, in connection with statements that have been
made in Congress respecting this work. The successful work of
7

8

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

this service in developing the use of existing aquatic foods and in
introducing new ones has been stopped because one part of its
work was confused with another part which has no relation to
the matter. It has been thought best, therefore, to make the
whole record clear in this report.
American-Canadian Fisheries Conference.
The appointment of the American-Canadian Fisheries Confer­
ence and its general purpose were referred to in my annual report
for last year (p. 7).
Some of the questions that came before the conference are as
old as the American Republic, others are of comparatively recent
origin; and they differ greatly in national and international
importance. Some of the questions were satisfactorily disposed
of by executive action of the two countries, some can be settled
only by treaty and others by legislation, and at least one was
left for fuller consideration at a more auspicious time.
During the course of the inquiries conducted, action was taken
as follows in the settlement of pending questions, or as affecting
the fishery relations of the two countries:
t . The Canadian Government, by order in council, prohibited
net fishing in Lake Champlain and thus gave to fish in the Quebec
portion of the lake the same protection that was already afforded
in New York and Vermont.
2. The Canadian Government, by order in council, modified the
provisions of the modus vivendi so as to accord fuller facilities
to American fishing vessels using Canadian ports and harbors.
3. The United States Government, by order of the Department
of Commerce, permitted Canadian fishing vessels (and the fishing
vessels of other nations acting with the United States in the
prosecution of the war) to enter United States ports from the
fishing grounds and clear for the high seas, this authority, how­
ever, like that granted by the Canadian Government in extension
of the modus vivendi, being a war measure.
4. The United States Government, by order of the Department
of Commerce, removed discriminatory navigational regulations
applying to Canadian fishing vessels passing through the terri­
torial waters of Alaska to and from the fishing grounds on the
high seas.
A treaty covering the subject of reciprocal port privileges for
the fishing vessels of the United States and Canada is pending.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

9

Legislation is before Congress to restrict the use of lobster wellsmacks by citizens of the United States in waters off the Canadian
coast when there is a close time on lobster fishing in Canada, but
no affirmative action has been taken on the measure.
Recommendations have been made to the respective Govern­
ments in regard to the protection of the Pacific halibut and the
protection of sturgeons, and action thereon is pending. The
international protection of whales, which the conference regarded
as deserving careful attention, was recommended for considera­
tion at a later date.
The protection and rehabilitation of the sockeye salmon fisheries
in the contiguous waters of the State of Washington and the
Province of British Columbia, perhaps the most important subject
considered by the conference, was covered by a comprehensive
system of regulations recommended for the adoption of the two
countries. A treaty covering this subject was signed by the
representatives of Great Britain, Canada, and the United States
on September 2, 1919.
Vessels of the Department’s Marine Services.
The steamer Surveyor, the only vessel especially designed and
constructed for the work of the Coast and Geodetic Survey, went
into the Navy a month after completion. The ship returned to
the Survey with the honor of having assisted in disabling, on
May 17, 1918, the German submarine U-39, which sank the Lusi­
tania. She is now at her post of duty in Alaska and there pro­
vides for the first time a vessel adequate to the vast and difficult
work of surveying those dangerous waters, the scene of so many
disastrous wrecks. The Surveyor alone, indeed, is not sufficient
for the task of covering the 26,000 miles of coast to be surveyed
in Alaska. She will be assisted by other vessels which the
Navy has turned over for that purpose, namely, the Sialia,
the Natoma, and the Wenonah. Even with this equipment,
now for the first time available, it will be long years before
the waters of Alaska will be so well charted that they can be
traversed in all parts with confidence. Great as the development
of Alaska has been, it has been held back, as every navigator of
those waters knows, by the failure of the country heretofore to
visualize the size of thé task of surveying its shores. We have
waited until a sad series of wrecks, with their accompanying
losses of life and property, have shocked us into activity in work
which should have been adequately undertaken decades ago.

IO

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

For the first time launches designed and built for the special
duty have been provided for the wire-drag work of this service,
and with these and two others which the Navy Department
turned over to us under your Executive order of May 24, 1919,
we are now able to carry on this important work in Alaska with
more effectiveness. It is strange that in order to do a great duty
of peace we should have to depend upon supplies assembled for
war. It does not reflect credit upon our judgment and foresight
that this should be so, but it is well to be thankful for what we
have without worrying as to the way in which it came. The fact
is that the Coast and Geodetic Survey has some vessels for
service and a few launches for wire-drag work and that if sufficient
funds are provided for their use and for the necessary field and
office forces and equipment, the service is in a position to give
assurance to our commerce and navigation of safety in all our
waters such as it never had before.
On July 1, 1919, the Navy Department returned to the Bureau
of Lighthouses 47 lighthouse tenders and 4 light vessels, trans­
ferred to that department for war uses by your Executive order
of April 11, 1917. This Service has also acquired two small
vessels (Cosmos and Poinsetiia) from the Navy Department and
during the year built two small tenders (Elm and Pine). Six
lighthouse vessels have recently been lost: Diamond Shoal Light
Vessel No. 71 was sunk by enemy submarine on August 6, 1918;
Cross Rip Light Vessel No. 6 was destroyed by the ice in February,
1918; while in the shipyard awaiting repairs necessitated by
damages from ice, the 35 Foot Channel Light Vessel No. 45 was
burned on March 3, 1918; Relief Light. Vessel No. 51 was sunk
on Cornfield Point light vessel station by Standard Oil Co.’s barge
on April 24, 1919; the tender Gardenia., after 40 years of valuable
service, was condemned on March 1, 1917, as was Bush Bluff
Light Vessel No. 97 on October 23, 1918, after 43 years of sendee.
The commandant of the fifth naval district, in his formal letter
of June 30, 1919, returning some vessels of the Lighthouse Service
to this Department, says:
The district commandant wishes to use this opportunity to express his high appre­
ciation of the cordial cooperation of the Lighthouse Service in the solution of many
problems arising during the period when they were under N avy control. The Light­
house Service has responded quickly and efficiently to every demand made upon
them by the naval district. The services of the lighthouse vessels were of immense
value in the laying of submarine-defense nets and, after the armistice, in removing
those nets. This was a task which would hardly be possible of accomplishment with­
out the assistance of the lighthouse vessels.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

II

The Navy Department has also turned over to the Bureau of
Fisheries four scout patrol boats, two of which will be used as
patrol boats in southeastern Alaskan waters and two for fish-cul­
tural work. Four vessels, loaned by this bureau to the Navy
Department during the war, have been returned. The Roosevelt
was condemned and sold in early July of this year. The bureau
purchased the Eider, formerly a deep-sea halibut vessel, for use as
a tender between the Pribilof Islands and Alaskan Peninsula.
The work of the motor-vessel fleet of the Bureau of Navigation
has been greatly increased because of the admirable working
arrangement made with the Treasury Department, whereby such
boats enforce not only the navigation and motor-boat laws,
but the internal-revenue tax laws also applying to motor vessels.
By this arrangement the Department has furnished during the
fiscal year the motor vessels Kilkenny and Tarragon, with their
officers and crews, and the Internal Revenue Bureau of the Treas­
ury Department supplied the sum of $5,000 as a part contribution
toward the cost of fuel for the vessels, and paid also the salary of
one officer.
Date in the year the motor vessel Dixie, belonging to this serv­
ice, was restored by the Navy, and in addition two other vessels,
the Siwash and Psyche II, were turned over by them, so that
the "service will have during the current fiscal year five good motor
vessels. The record of the past year shows the same satisfactory
results as in previous years, but the number of vessels was less
because the Dixie was in the Navy.
The mitigated fines and taxes collected as a result more than
paid for the service. The work done for the Treasury resulted in
the collections of large sums that would otherwise have been lost
to‘'sight, and was fully satisfactory to the officers of that Depart­
ment.
It is proposed in the next calendar year to station the Siwash
to cover the coast from New York east, the Kilkenny to patrol
from New York to Wilmington, N. C., including Delaware and
Chesapeake Bays and North Carolina sounds, the Tarragon to
cover South Carolina and Florida waters, the Dixie the Mississippi
River and tributaries and the Gulf coast, and the Psyche II to be
on the Great Lakes. Full operation of these vessels in these areas
will be contingent upon the funds available for their use. It can
not be, however, emphasized too often that the work done by
these patrol boats in enforcing the navigation laws in connection

12

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

with vessels plying our rivers, bays, sounds, and the inland waters
along our coasts insures safety to navigation both for large and
small vessels, and collects taxes which otherwise would not be
collected, in such a way as to cost the Nation nothing, because
the penalties which are imposed for violations, together with the
taxes gathered, more than cover the cost of the boats and their
repairs, maintenance, and operation.
The Department had the following vessels in its marine service
on October i, 1919:
Service.

In op­
eration.

N ot in
opera­
tion.

Being
built.

Sold.

B ought.

T urned
over by
N avy.

Loaned R eturned
by
Total.
to
N avy.
N avy.

Coast and Geodetic
I

*5

15

Bureau of NavigaB ureau of
houses:

Light­
47

54
63

,

B ureau of F ish eries..
T o ta l.................

143

1

4

1

„■

52

54
«3

63

60

137

«»One sunk.

This is exclusive of 2 vessels loaned to the Coast and Geodetic
Survey by the Philippine Government and of 54 motor boats of
all sizes operated by the Bureau of Fisheries, and a large number
of launches used at the various stations of the Lighthouse Sendee.
Incidentally it is worth mentioning that the steamer Surveyor,
being constructed with that in mind, was ready without a day’s
delay to enter the naval service. Her successors will be similarly
designed and built. It should be the case that every vessel of
every maritime sendee of the Government should be designed so
that if needed for the national defense they would be ready with­
out alteration to do their special part. Such is the definite plan
of this Department in the vessels that it builds, and it takes no
small pride in the contribution that its ships, small as they are,
rendered the national cause.
Vessels Urgently Needed for the Bureau of Lighthouses.
In the operation of the Lighthouse Service, covering 47,300 miles
of general coast line and rivers, there are at present employed 54
lighthouse tenders and 63 light vessels, 1x7 in alt. To maintain

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

13

this number 2 tenders and 2 light vessels should be built each year,
and recommendations and estimates submitted yearly have
emphasized this fact.
Since 1910 the number of aids to navigation has increased from
11,660 to 16,075, a total increase of 4,415, or 38 per cent. This
increase has added greatly to the work of the tenders, so that the
present number has become inadequate to maintain the service
as required in the interests of navigation. There has also been an
unusual number of casualties to vessels recently, 6 vessels having
been lost, or condemned, as before stated.
As a result of careful study of the matter, it has been found that
within the next five years 18 light vessels and 10 tenders should
be replaced, and funds should be provided now for 17 of these
vessels most urgently needed.
On May 15, 1919, in a letter to the Speaker of the House of Rep­
resentatives, request has been made for a provision authorizing the
construction or purchasing and equipping lighthouse tenders and
light vessels for the Lighthouse Service of $5,000,000. (See
Appendix A.)
Buildings.
The buildings occupied by the Department of Commerce are:
1. Commerce Building, Nineteenth Street and Pennsylvania
Avenue NW.
2. Bureau of Fisheries Building, Sixth and B Streets SW., and
new adjoining fishery products laboratory.
3. Coast and Geodetic Survey Building, New Jersey Avenue
near B Street SW., directly opposite the House of Representatives
Office Building, and new adjoining chart, instrument, and archives
building.
4. The Bureau of Standards, Pierce Mill Road, near Connecti­
cut Avenue, is housed in 13 principal buildings and 7 minor build­
ings, 5 of the latter being temporary structures.
The fishery products laboratory had its rise in the necessity of
developing under war conditions, as rapidly and broadly as pos­
sible, additional food supplies. Funds for the building were
provided from the appropriation for the national security and
defense. This laboratory is unique and its operations are expected
to have a great and beneficial effect upon the fish industries and
upon the food supplies obtained from them.
The new building for the Coast and Geodetic Survey, for which
provision was made from the fund for the national security and

14

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

defense, though long delayed in its construction by the difficulty
of securing the necessary materials during the war and since its
close, is completed and its equipment in place. It was none too
soon to meet the vastly increased demands for charts and service
arising from the great increase in our merchant marine. If it is
considered that to this well-known growth there was added also
during the war an immensely increased demand for charts for the
Navy, it will be clear that this service was called upon for an
enormous expansion of its work at a time when a very large portion
of its staff was absent, serving either in the Army or Navy at
home and abroad, and when most of its vessels were taken from
their regular duties to do naval work. It was only by untiring
efforts, with equipment not intended for any such emergency,
that sufficient charts were ready for the vessels as they were
wanted. Fortunately, the crisis was met by new equipment,
procured from war funds, without which the situation would
have been serious. The new Harris automatic press was put into
operation on January 7, and immediately made possible the
mechanical production of charts in sufficient numbers to meet the
need. The service is now better equipped than at any time in
its history for the rapid production of charts, so far as its
mechanical appliances are concerned
The new building for the first time provides fireproof protection
for the valuable records of the Coast and Geodetic Survey, which
cover a period of over 100 years and represent an actual cash
outlay of many millions of dollars.
These two buildings, in common with several erected at the
Bureau of Standards, though built during and for the war, were
so designed as to be equally useful and effective in peace. Every
dollar of their cost is an investment, and not an expense, and will
be permanently productive.
Land for a new building was acquired for what was then the
Department of Commerce and Labor under the act of May 30,
I9°8 (35 Stat., 545), and, by the act of June 25, 1910 (36 Stat.,
698), the Secretary of the Treasury was directed to prepare de­
signs and estimates for a fireproof building to occupy the new
site. On March 3, 19x3, the plans for the proposed building were
approved by my predecessor. Since that time three bureaus of
the former Department have been transferred to the Department
of Labor; one has gone to the Federal Trade Commission; two
of the present services were omitted from the plans. The new

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

15

building, when redesigned, should be made to accommodate the
office, the lithographing establishment with its accessories, the
drawing room, and the instrument shop of the Coast and Geo­
detic Survey, and the administrative offices, and, if practicable,
the laboratory of the Bureau of Fisheries. When this is done
the property on Capitol Hill, adjoining the Public Health Service,
opposite the House Office Building and near the Capitol itself,
now occupied by the Coast and Geodetic Survey, could be used
for other Government purposes, and in like manner the buildings
now occupied by the Bureau of Fisheries will become available
for other uses. The new buildings erected in connection with
these two services are so designed as to be useful in other
connections.
Five of the eight services of the Department, as well as the divi­
sions of the Secretary’s Office, are housed in the Commerce
Building. The normal growth of these services, which are the
Bureaus of the Census, Foreign and Domestic Commerce, Navi­
gation, Dighthouses, and the Steamboat-Inspection Service, will
overcrowd the building before the new one can be constructed.
During the present year it has been necessary to house the divi­
sion of statistics of the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Com­
merce in the building occupied by the Council of National Defense.
The annual rental of the Commerce Building is $65,500. This
is at the rate of $0,358 per square foot, gross. The lease of the
building was renewed on July 1, 1919, for five years. During
the pendency of this new lease the proposed Commerce Building
should be redesigned and constructed, so as to be occupied by
or before the lease terminates. In addition we are now paying
an annual rental of $1,225 for 4,900 square feet of storage space.
The comments heretofore made respecting the unfitness of the
buildings occupied by the Coast and Geodetic Survey and by the
Bureau of Fisheries are renewed. Reference is made to pages
10 and 11 of my annual report for 1918 and pages 218 to 220 of
my annual report for 1917.
Bureau of Standards— Industrial Laboratory Building.
The great demands placed upon the bureau by the Government’s
war program made it necessary, early in the year, to build a larger
laboratory building to house the work along the lines of structural
materials and industrial research and related subjects.

I6

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The building is four stories, including basement, and has a front­
age of 351 feet and depth of 166 feet. The main wings are 62
feet wide and the extensions 105 feet, forming an E-shaped ground
plan.
The entire center wing is of special construction to provide for
large testing machines. The central part is open from basement
to third floor, with galleries surrounding the open well at first and
second floor levels. The central well will ultimately be occupied
by large vertical testing machines and the galleries by smaller
testing machines. The two vacant spaces included in the E form
of building have one-story courts covered by concrete roofs, each
lighted by three large skylights.
Directly north of this building, separated from it by a driveway,
is the new, one-story kiln building, 50 by 350 feet, which houses
in its basement the heating plant for these two buildings. The
end walls are connected with the industrial laboratory building by
a brick wall, which contains an open archway for a driveway, so
that the two buildings are in effect one large unit.
In the west extension is housed the section on cement, concrete,
and building stone. It is fully provided with all necessary equip­
ment for carrying out the research studies in this line, as well as
attending to the large demands for routine tests of cement and
concrete. Space is also provided for chemical research in the
manufacture of cement.
On the second floor are the laboratories and offices of the section
on lime, magnesite, and gypsum, these branches being similar in
character to the cement work.
Various portions of the building are occupied by the sections on
clay products and optical glass. They occupy the entire west
court, which is equipped with special grinding machinery. The
several types of furnaces used in the study and manufacture of
these products are installed in the kiln house.
The central extension and the surrounding space for three floors
are occupied by the metals-testing section, which is fully equipped
to handle all physical tests of metals and metal structures, etc.
The basement of the east extension will house the large horizontal
Emery machine. When the installation of these machines is com­
pleted, this will be the most complete materials-testing laboratory,
with machines of the largest capacity, in the world.
The work in textiles, paper, leather, and rubber is housed in the
east part of the building, equipped with a large chamber in which
is maintained an atmosphere of constant humidity and constant

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

17

temperature and various types of machinery necessary for the
manufacture and research work in these materials.
On the third floor, in the central section of the building, are the
laboratories for the work on lubricating oils.
The east court houses a machine shop for repairing the test­
ing machines, preparing test specimens, and making new apparatus
as required by the various lines of research.
The bureau’s photographic department has a complete labora­
tory in the center wing on the third floor and is equipped to handle
a large range of photographic work, from blue printing to the
making of moving pictures.
Space is also allotted for a museum and display room to exhibit
the various products and specimens of work accomplished, for a
general library of books and periodicals dealing with industrial
subjects, and for a lunch room and kitchen required to serve meals
to the employees of the building.
Bureau of Standards— New Dynamometer and Altitude Laboratory.
The temporary wooden buildings, in which the altitude and
dynamometer laboratories have been housed for the last year and a
half, have now been replaced by a permanent structure of brick
and concrete. This building has a rectangular floor plan meas­
uring 50 by 150 feet.
Bureau of Fisheries— Laboratory Aquarium.
I have twice called attention to the need of a laboratory aqua­
rium for the Bureau of Fisheries. (See pp. 12-14 of my annual
report for 1917, and p. n of my report for 1918.) The prevailing
cost of food is a continued, forceful argument in favor of the erec­
tion of this building.
It is true, of course, that in those features common to aquaria,
the institution would be a source of education as well as of
general popular interest, as are all of the famous aquaria. This,
while valuable, is, however, not the essential purpose on which
stress should be laid. Most important is the use of the aquarium
as a laboratory for selecting and developing fishes as food, for
their definite cultivation as food-producing animals, for treating
this whole side of the animal kingdom with the same study and
care as regards its possible service to mankind as is given to
breeding cattle and sheep as producers either of dairy products
140261—19----2

i8

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OP COMMERCE.

or of meat and of wool and leather. It does not reflect special
credit upon our intelligence that, while doing so much and so
well upon certain phases of animal industry, we neglect, indeed
leave entirely untouched, another phase of which we know only
that great possibilities exist which we have not tried to develop.
Long ago the Bureau of Fisheries established the fact that an
acre of water on the farm could be made as productive of food as
an acre of land. We have agricultural colleges dealing with the
land acre and a great Government department ably cooperating
with them. The water acres of the world are more in extent than
are those of the land, and we are blest as a Nation with possibili­
ties for aquatic life along our coasts and in our Great Lakes and
streams such as is given to no other people of the world, yet we
have not a single such station as is proposed,wherein, at an invest­
ment less than many an agricultural college has cost, we may
study an even greater extent of food-producing possibilities.
The experience of the Bureau of Fisheries has shown that he
would be very rash who would put limits to what our water areas
could do in supplying food of many kinds. To argue from the
past in this matter is to argue from times of ignorance, for within
the last five years many fishes have become objects of common
food, of which men knew hardly at all, and this process in many
respects is capable of what seems unlimited extension.
Whatever the cause of the high price of food, its effect should be
to make men eagerly study how food can be made to cost less, and
that is what is now proposed.
Housing for the Bureau of the Census.
The Bureau of the Census will be housed during the census pe­
riod, which began on July i, 1919, in building “ D ,” at Four-and-ahalf Street and Missouri Avenue. The offices of the Director, of
the division of manufactures, and of those portions of the service
which are not specifically engaged upon the decennial census
remain in the Commerce Building. The other branches have
already been transferred to the new quarters and the force therein
is being rapidly enlarged to cope with the work of the coming
census. A clerical force of about 4,000 maximum will be em­
ployed in Washington on this work, and a great deal of space will
be required for the many machines that will be used in tabulating
the results of the census, and for storage for the millions of sched-

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

19

ules containing the data gathered by the field force and the
300,000,000 or more cards which will be used in tabulating the
population and agricultural statistics.
Cooperation by the Bureau of the Census With Other Services and
Organizations.
The Bureau of the Census and the Bureau of Education, De­
partment of the Interior, are cooperating in taking the census of
Alaska for 1920. The schedules, blanks, and other supplies have
already been sent and work will begin immediately.
A conference was held between the Director of the Census,
the chief statistician for manufactures of that bureau, and
members of the National Industrial Conference Board of Boston
and the National Association of Manufacturers, in order to insure
the inclusion in the manufactures schedules of such inquiries as
will be helpful and beneficial to industry. Schedules satisfactory
to the industries and the bureau are being prepared.
The Geological Survey and the Bureau of Mines are cooper­
ating in the compilation of information relative to the census of
mines and quarries, in order to prevent duplication of work.
Archives Building.
It is earnestly to be hoped that the archives building, a design
for which was authorized by the public buildings act of March 4,
1913, may be promptly constructed. The Department of Com­
merce will need not less than 85,000 cubic feet of space therein,
with such additional room as will provide for ready accession
and constant use of the records of this Department, dating back
to the beginnings of the Government.
Urgent Needs of the Department.
Among the urgent needs of the Department are :
1. The provision of vessels for the Lighthouse Service, to
which reference is made on preceding pages and in Appendix A.
2. The provision of funds to continue the work of the Light­
house Service throughout the current fiscal year. The funds thus
far appropriated are not sufficient, in view of necessary official in­
creases of wages in other services, to carry the work of the Service
much beyond the opening of the coming calendar year.
3. A building at the Bureau of Standards for a suitable power
plant as recommended in my last annual report (p. 14).

20

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

4. A laboratory aquarium for the Bureau of Fisheries, treated
earlier in this report.
5. A Government-owned building to house all the services of
the Department, as recommended previously in this report.
6. An additional Assistant Secretary of Commerce to assist in
the administration and supervision of the greatly increased work
of the Department.
7. Special attention is invited to the recommendation under
the title Steamboat-Inspection Service that the supervising
inspectors of that important bureau be placed under the classified
civil service.
A number of the urgent needs of the Department mentioned in
my last report have already been met. Among these are:
1. The enlargement of the funds and the organization of the
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce and a small but insuf­
ficient provision for more commercial attachés. The matter of
proper payment for their clerks is still untouched.
2. Through the transfer of five vessels from the Navy the more
urgent needs of the Coast Survey in this connection have been
for the present met, and by the transfer of launches from the Navy
the need for wire-drag launches in the Coast Survey is partly
covered.
Following a suggestion made upon the floor of the House of
Representatives by the former chairman of the Committee on
Appropriations, Hon. Swagar Sherley, an effort was made with
your approval to secure two special surveying steamers, similar in
type to the Surveyor, from the United States Shipping Board,
Emergency Fleet Corporation. The former chairman of the
Shipping Board cooperated actively in the matter. A t this
writing, however, the subject is held up pending the discussion
of certain legal questions, and its outcome is uncertain. Mean­
while the two vessels are greatly needed for deep-sea surveying,
which can not be carried on upon any sufficient or properly eco*
nomical scale without them.
3. An additional clerical force has been provided for the field
work of the Steamboat-Inspection Service. An additional appro­
priation provided by the deficiency bill now pending may re­
lieve the difficult situation in which the Coast and Geodetic
Survey found itself by reason of the inadequate pay and the in­
sufficient number of its draftsmen.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

21

4. Provision was duly made for the census of 1920 and for hous­
ing the force necessary for that work.
5. An assistant has been provided for the Secretary of Com­
merce.
In the above way five out of eight urgent needs of the Depart­
ment mentioned in my last report on pages 13 and 14 have in some
measure received care.
Use of Motion Pictures in Industry.
Developments during the year confirmed the opinion that motion
pictures can be made an important factor in governmental foreigntrade promotion. Experimental work initiated and carried on in
China by Commercial Attaché Julean Arnold has been so success­
ful that it has been impossible to supply films enough to meet the
demands. It is a significant fact that the Chinese are keenly inter­
ested in films showing quantity production in American industry.
There has, however, been no appropriation available for carrying
on this work on a suitable scale. Such films as could be obtained
without expense from interested and far-sighted firms were sent to
Mr. Arnold, who got such distribution as he could through cham
bers of commerce and other bodies. The success attained in this
way indicates what could be accomplished with sufficient funds to
carry on the work on a broad scale in all promising fields.
The case for the motion picture as a means of promoting our
foreign trade in foreign countries was presented at a special hearing
on March 1, 1919, before the House Committee on Interstate and
Foreign Commerce, when attention was called especially to the
fact that the value of this means of trade promotion had been
proved, and that other Governments were already using it.
Reference is made to House resolution 571, Sixty-fifth Congress,
third session, and to the report of hearings on moving pictures as a
means of commercial promotion.
Pacific Cable Situation.
Existing facilities for transmitting cable messages across the
Pacific Ocean are far from sufficient to meet the commercial
demand. Chambers of commerce, business houses, and various
commercial organizations have presented constant complaints of
injurious delays, requesting that some remedy be applied adequate
to meet the very unfortunate situation that exists.

22

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The delays vitally impair the effectiveness of our foreign trade
and have obliged business houses to undertake unusual and ex­
pensive expedients in order to transact their business at all.
We are in this important respect at a serious disadvantage
compared with other commercial nations. Prices are often quoted
and options given subject to acceptance within a given time, but
in many cases when replies accepting quotations were delivered
promptly to the cable they did not arrive in time to complete the
transaction. There have, from this and similar reasons, been
heavy losses in American export and import trade.
The subject has been one of careful study and of keen interest.
On July 3, 1919, a report representing the joint views of the
Bureau of Standards, the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Com­
merce, and the then existing Industrial Cooperation Service was
submitted to the Senate in connection with Senate bill No. 1651.
It is earnestly to be hoped that steps may be taken which will
provide another cable under American control to the Far Fast, for
to-day the United States is at a disadvantage in doing business
with the Orient as compared with other countries.
Appropriations and Expenditures.
The itemized statement of the disbursements from the con­
tingent fund of the Department of Commerce and the appropria­
tion for “ General expenses, Bureau of Standards,” for the fiscal
year ended June 30, 1919, required to be submitted to Congress
by section 193 of the Revised Statutes of the United States; the
itemized statement of expenditures under all appropriations for
propagation of food fishes during the fiscal year ended June 30,
1919, required by the act of Congress approved March 3, 1887 (24
Stat., 523) ; and a statement showing travel on officiai business by
officers and employees (other than special agents, inspectors, and
employees who, in the discharge of their regular duties, are re­
quired to travel constantly) from Washington to points outside
of the District of Columbia during the fiscal year ended June 30,
1919, as required by the act of Congress approved May 22, 1908
(35 Stat., 244), will be transmitted to Congress in the usual form.
The table following shows the total amount of all appropria­
tions for the various bureaus and services of the Department of
Commerce for the fiscal year ended June 30, 1919.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Legislative S u n d ry civil
act.
act.

B ureau.

Office of th e Secretary —
B ureau of L ighthouses. . .
B ureau of th e C en su s.. . .
Bureau of Foreign and
f Domestic C om m erce...
S te a m b o a t-In s p e c tio n

Special
act.

6 5 ,4 3 0 .0 0

1, 3 4 9 ;

N ational se­
c urity and
defense.
$ 2 0 5 ,0 0 0 - 0 0

§ 3 2 7 1 5 4 0 .0 0
$ 6 ,4 8 3 ,0 0 0 .0 0

$

753 , 5 7 7 -8 7

2 4 0 .0 0

$ 7 4 8 ,2 9 7 .0 0

1 6 -3 5

5 5 4 ,1 2 0 .0 0

143 ; 9 3 4 -

4 0 ,0 0 0 .0 0
t; t

3 0 , 9 4 0 .0 0

107 ;

24O . 4 S

$ 53 2 ,

54 0 . 0 0

8 ,3 2 5 ,3 0 4 .8 7

1 6 0 ,0 0 0 .0 0

1 ,5 0 9 ,2 5 6 .3 5

8 7 9 , 1 2 0 . OO

8 5 6 ,6 7 4 .1 7

17

2 1 7 ,0 4 5 - 0 0
1 , 2 9 9 ,8 6 0 .0 0

Total.

2 7 5 ,0 0 0 - 0 0

3 2 5 ,0 0 0 - 00

7 1 2 , 7 4 0 .0 0

B ureau of N avigation___
Bureau of S ta n d a rd s........

Deficiency
act.

23

7 3 6 .6 5

4 0 ,0 0 0 - 0 0

2 5 7 ,7 8 1 .6 5

1 0 5 ,0 0 0 .0 0

5 x 0 ,8 0 0 - 0 0

2 ,0 6 2 ,9 0 0 .4 8

I 6 0 , o o o - 00

1 , 3 0 1 , 3 7 9 - 60

4 7 ;1 0 4 .5 6

1 ,4 1 2 ,0 6 4 .5 6

1 0 ,4 3 9 . 60

Coast and Geodetic SurX ;3 0 4 ,

T o ta l....................... 4 » 5 2 5 ; 9 7 5 - 0 0
Increase of com pensation. 6 4 8 , 8 0 2 . 3 7
A llotm ent for p rinting

9 6 0 .0 0

9 ,0 l8 ,9 0 0 .0 0

1 ,0 1 5 ,2 0 8 .4 7

8 5 4 ,0 3 3 .6 5

I , 7 2 2 ,9 0 4 .5 6

17, i

3 7 » o a x . 68

6 4 8 ,8 0 2 .3 7

400, 000.

OO

5 ; 174 ; 7 7 7 -3 7 9 , 4 1 8 , 9 0 0 .0 0

4 0 0 ,0 0 0 .0 0

1 , 0 1 5 , 2 0 8 .4 7

8 5 4 ,0 3 3 - 6 5

1 ,7 2 2 ,9 0 4 - 5 6

1 8 ,1 8 5 ,8 2 4 .0 5

The disbursements by the authorized disbursing officers of the
Department of Commerce during the fiscal year ended June 30,
1919, arranged according to items of appropriation, are as follows:
By Disbursing Clerk, Department of Commerce.
OFFICE OF TH E SECRETARY.

Salaries, Office of the Secretary, 1918....................................................
Salaries, Office of the Secretary, 1919....................................................
Contingent expenses, Department of Commerce, 1917........................
Contingent expenses, Department of Commerce, 1918........................
Contingent expenses, Department of Commerce, 1919........................
Rent, Department of Commerce, 1918..................................................
Rent, Department of Commerce, 1919..................................................
National security and defense, Industrial Board, 1919.......................
National security and defense, Industrial Cooperation Service, 1919..
National security and defense, waste-reclamation work, 1919...........
Total...............................................................................................

87,388. 15
167, 753. 66
3,098.20
24,458. 73
86,288. 03
5,458.34
61,404. 16
5,334. 49
10, 241. 52
4,895.89
376,321.17

BUREAU OF FOREIGN AND DOMESTIC COMMERCE.

Promoting commerce, Department of Commerce, 1917......................
Promoting commerce, Department of Commerce, 1918......................
Promoting commerce, Department of Commerce, 1919......................
Promoting commerce, South and Central America, 1918...................
Promoting commerce, South and Central America, 1919...................
Commercial attachés, Department of Commerce, 19 18 ......................
Commercial attachés, Department of Commerce, 19 19 ......................
Promoting commerce, Department of Commerce, Far East, 1919 . . .

106. 50
3, 707. 51
51,842. 73
4,342. 15
40,043. 03
922.68
3,442- 23
7, 791. 67

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

24

Foreign and Domestic Commerce, 1918.................................
Foreign and Domestic Commerce, 1919.................................
security and defense, import and export statistics, 1918...
security and defense, import and export statistics, 1919.. .
security and defense, commodity experts, 1919..................
security and defense, special statistical work, 1919..........

$5,959. 96
127, 773. 07
1, 767. 35
59,194- 31
20, 796. 68
10,803.80

Total................................................................................................

338,493.67

Salaries,
Salaries,
National
National
National
National

bureau

of stan dards.

Laboratory, Bureau of Standards...........................................................
Chemical laboratory, Bureau of Standards...........................................
Radio laboratory.......................................................................................
Equipping chemical laboratory, 1916-17..............................................
Equipping chemical laboratory, 1917-18..............................................
Salaries, 1918............................................................................................
Salaries, 1919............................................................................................
Equipment, 1917......................................................................................
Equipment, 1918.....................................................................................
Equipment, 1919......................................................................................
General expenses, 1917............................................................................
General expenses, 1918............................................................................
General expenses, 1919............................................................................
Improvement and care of grounds, 1917................................................
Improvement and care of grounds, 1918................................................
Improvement and care of grounds, 1919...............................................
Testing railroad scales, 1917....................................................................
Testing railroad scales, 1918....................................................................
Testing railroad scales, 1919...................................................................
Testing structural material, 1917...........................................................
Testing structural materials, 1918..........................................................
Testing structural materials, 1919..........................................................
Testing machines, 1918........................................................... ................
Testing machines, 1919................ ..........................................................
Investigation of fire-resisting properties, 1918.....................................
Investigation of fire-resisting properties, 1919......................................
High-potential investigation, 1918.........................................................
High-potential investigation, 1919.........................................................
Investigation public utility standards, 1917.........................................
Investigation public utility standards, 1918.........................................
Investigation public utility standards, 1919.........................................
Investigation public utility companies, 1918-19..................................
Investigation railway materials, 1917....................................................
Investigation railway materials, 1918....................................................
Investigation railway materials, 1919....................................................
Testing miscellaneous materials, ig i8 ...................................................
Testing miscellaneous materials, 1919...................................................
Radio research, 1917................................................................................
Radio research, 1918................................................................................
Radio research, 1919................................................................................
Investigation of clay products, 1918......................................................
Investigation of clay products, 1919......................................................
Determining physical constants, 1917...................................................

278. Si
302. 35
28, 592. 69
3,850. 15
10, 175. 09
13,456.82
343,167.46
4,997.28
10,426.13
58,374.46
304. 65
6, 289. 73
17,343.40
486.37
1, 183. 29
4, £>72. 18
8, 588.35
11,321.11
35,220. 83
86. 74
61, 923. 56
212,166. 50
7,359. 66
26, 314. 13
2, 615. 54
21,057. 38
2, 764. 09
11,429.08
.32
4, 244. 22
44, 594. 04
38,813. 98
100. 25
3,959. 02
12,053.25
235.17
24, 706. 35
6. 57
1,455.50
18, 763. 23
2. 00
16,329. 91
102. 50

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

25

Determining physical constants, 1918...................................................
$406.99
Determining physical constants, 1919...................................................
4, 540. 40
Standardizing mechanical appliances, 1917.........................................
47-70
52. 52
Standardizing mechanical appliances, 1918..........................................
Standardizing mechanical appliances, 1919.........................................
SiStS^S
827. 99
Color standardization, 1917.....................................................................
Color standardization, 1918.....................................................................
1,036.87
Color standardization, 1919.....................................................................
8,143.04
536. 04
Investigation of optical glass, 1918........................................................
Investigation of optical glass, 1919........................................................
70, 213. 74
81,153.82
Gauge standardization, 1917-18.............................................................
Gauge standardization, 1919...................................................................
367,291.84
Military research, 1917-18.......................................................................
82,661.11
Military research, 1918-19.......................................................................
510, a n . 49
Investigation of mine scales and cars, 1918-19.....................................
10, 796. 17
1,995. 55
•Repairs, power plant, 1918.............................. '......................................
Standard materials, 1919.........................................................................
3,278.02
15, 73x. 47
Sugar standardization, 1919....................................................................
Investigation of textiles, 1919................................................................
6,407. 06
2, 575.09
Renewal of storage batteries, 1919.........................................................
Industrial research, 1919-20...................................................................
13,808.31
Equipping laboratory, 1919-20...............................................................
3, 026. 92
4,177.14
Aviation, Navy, commerce transfer, 1919...........................................
Armament of fortifications, commerce transfer....................................
58,872. 71
National security and defense, production of optical glass, 1918 . . . .
23, 645. 93
18,145. 51
National security and defense, new building, 19x8..............
National security and defense, Roberts by-product coke oven, 1918..
22, 534. 94
National security and defense, metallurgical work, 1918....
56,947. ox
642, 279. 89
National security and defense, industrial laboratory, 1918................
National security and defense, production of fabrics, 1918................
24, 577. 48
National security and defense, thermite investigation, 1918.
729.
29
National security and defense, thermite investigation, 1919.
3, 45425
National security and defense, Roberts by-product coke oven, 1919.
9,972. 60
59,897.
19
National security and defense, altitude laboratory, 1919......
National security and defense, completing laboratory, 1919.
169,327. 32
National security and defense, military researches, 1919...................
59,941.04
National security and defense, industrial laboratory, 1919.................
34-86
T o ta l... ........................................................................................

3,414,708.87

STEAMBOAT-INSPECTION SERVICE.

Salaries, Office of Supervising Inspector General, 1918......................
Salaries, Office of Supervising Inspector General, 1919......................
Salaries, Steambbat-Inspection Service, 1918.......................................
Salaries, Steamboat-Inspection Service, 1919.......................................
Steamboat-Inspection Service, Tampa, Fla., 1918..............................
Clerk hire, Steamboat-Inspection Service, 1918..................................
Clerk hire, Steam boat-Inspection Service, 1919..................................
Contingent expenses, Steam boat-Inspection Service, 1917................
Contingent expenses, Steamboat-Inspection Service, 1918................
Contingent expenses, Steamboat-Inspection Service, 1919................
Total

742. 52
20, 089. 70
34,322. 88
507, 287. 19
505. 50
7, 757. 35
97,057. 25
6. 00
24,996. 18
112, 271. 40
8°S. °3 5- 97

26

REPORT OE THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
BUREAU OP NAVIGATION.

Salaries, Bureau of Navigation, 1918.....................................................
Salaries, Bureau of Navigation, 1919.....................................................
Salaries, Shipping Service, 1918............................................................
Salaries, Shipping Service, 1919............................................................
Clerk hire, Shipping Service, 1918........................................................
Clerk hire, Shipping Service, 1919........................................................
Contingent expenses, Shipping Service, 1918......................................
Contingent expenses, Shipping Service, 1919......................................
Enforcement navigation laws, 1917.......................................................
Enforcement navigation laws, 1918.......................................................
Enforcement navigation laws, 1919.......................................................
Enforcement wireless-communication laws, 1918................................
Enforcement wireless-communication laws, 1919.................................
Preventing overcrowding of passenger vessels, 1917............................
Preventing overcrowding of passenger vessels, 1918...........................
Preventing overcrowding of passenger vessels, 1919...........................
Admeasurement of vessels, 1918............................................................
Admeasurement of vessels, 1919.............................................................
T o ta l...............................................................................................................
bureau

$i, 578. 81
33>9I9- 7I
2,333- 01
26, 232. 64
3,919- 39
42, 495- 27
1 ,341- 27
5 ,475- 00
150.00
5, 368. 24
24, 067. 78
9, 646. 13
38,198.26
2. 00
2,478. 61
15,413- 08
910. 22
1,972. 70
215,502.12

o p p is h e r ie s .

Fish hatchery, Bozeman, Mont..............................................................
Fish hatchery, Cape Vincent, N. Y ., 1918...........................................
Fish hatchery, Edenton, N. C., 1918....................................................
Fish hatchery, Puget Sound, Wash.......................................................
Fish hatchery, S. C ..................................................................................
Fish hatchery, W yo.................................................................................
Fish hatchery, Cold Spring, Ga.............................................................
Fish hatchery, St. Johnsbury, V t..........................................................
Fish hatchery, Rhode Island.................................................................
Trout hatchery, Berkshire, Mass............................................................
Marine biological station, Florida..........................................................
Biological station, Mississippi River Valley.........................................
Repairs, steamer Fish Hawk, 1918.........................................................
Building and improvements, fur-seal islands, Alaska.........................
Investigating damages to fisheries.........................................................
Salaries, Bureau of Fisheries, 1918........................................................
Salaries, Bureau of Fisheries, 1919...............
Miscellaneous expenses, 1917.................................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1918.................................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1919.................................................................
Protecting seal and salmon fisheries of Alaska, 1918........................... _
Protecting seal and salmon fisheries of Alaska, 1919............................
Developing aquatic sources of leather, 1917-18...................................
Power lighter, fur-seal islands, Alaska..................................................
National security and defense, food-fish supply, 1918........................
National security and defense, food-fish supply, 1919........................
National security and defense, rescuing food fish, 1918..........
National security and defense, seal-oil plant, 1918..............................
National security and defense, demonstration plant, 1919.................
T otal..............................................................................................

9. 94
4.385. 29
2, 500. 00
690. 14
245. 85
1» 469. 50
107. 10
10. 00
40. 86
1,608. 70
1,922. 66
2, 048. 74
33,442- °°
2,320. 05
671. 83
25, 812. 32
342, 567- 59
320.92
69, 293. 90
437. 152- 79
6,327. 04
100, 280. 19
1, 554- 33
38. 31
5,442. 97
30, 286. 17
7, 548- 60
19,706. 01
83, 760. 71
i, 181, 564. 51

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

27

BUREAU OP THE CENSUS.

Salaries, 1918............................................................................................
Salaries, 1919............................................................................................
Collecting statistics, 1917........................................................................
Collecting statistics, 1918........................................................................
Collecting statistics, 1919........................................................................
Tabulating machines, 1918......................................................................
Tabulating machines, 1919......................................................................
Uniform nomenclature, 1919..................................................................
National security and defense, special statistical work, 1919............

$27,283.24
623,406. 16
63.45
45,418. 07
433, 665. 90
13, 614. 33
32, 444. 86
6,293.17
124, 725. 43

Total...............................................................................................

1,306,914.61

BUREAU OP LIGHTHOUSES.

Aids to navigation, Alaska.....................................................................
Aids to navigation, Lorain Harbor, Ohio.............................................
Light station, Navassa Island, West Indies..........................................
Light station, Sand Hills, Mich.............................................................
Aids to navigation, Fighting Island Channel,Detroit River, M ich..
Aids to navigation, Delaware River, Pa. and Del...............................
Aids to navigation, Wash, and Oreg......................................................
Light vessels for general service.............................................................
General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1917........................................
General expenses, Lighthouse .Service, 1918........................................
General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1919........................................
Salaries, Bureau of Lighthouses, 1918....................................................
Salaries, Bureau of Lighthouses, 1919....................................................
Salaries, Lighthouse Service, 1918.........................................................
Salaries, Lighthouse Service, 1919.........................................................
Tender, third lighthouse district...........................................................
Tender for engineer, sixth lighthouse district......................................
Repairs and rebuilding aids to navigation, Gulf of Mexico................
Repairing and rebuilding aids to navigation, Atlantic coast..............
Lighthouse depot, Detroit, Mich............................................................
Nantucket Harbor Fog-Signal Station, Mass........................................
Point Boringucn Light Station, P. R ....................................................
Salaries, lighthouse vessels, 1919...........................................................
Salaries, keepers of lighthouses, 1919....................................................
Fifth lighthouse district, gas b u o y s......................................................
Joe Flogger Shoal Light Station, Delaware River...............................
National security and defense, aids to navigation, Caribbean Sea,
WW.........................................................................................................
Total...............................................................................................

7. 03
61. 37
135. 06
15, 719. 39
101. 22
8,183.30
2. 16
75,790. 22
209.11
44, 286. 43
49, 360. 49
2, 792. 98
53,839. 12
202. 50
6, 296. 00
5.40
. 3.91
98. 40
20. 58
7,432. 03
4. 50
13. 20
16, 391. 14
4, 008. 78
40. 61
6. 04
23- »5
285,034.12

MISCELLANEOUS.

Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 1918...............
Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 1919...............

8,117. 76
234, 238. 19

Total...............................................................................................

242,355.95

Grand total

8,165,930. 99

28

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE
By disbursing officers of the Lighthouse Service.

Repairing and rebuilding aids to navigation, Atlantic coast.............
Light vessels for general service.............................................................
Oilhouses for light stations......................................................................
Dog Island Light, Me..............................................................................
Woods Hole Lighthouse Depot, Mass....................................................
Nantucket Harbor Fog Signal, Mass......................................................
Staten Island lighthouse depot, N. Y .................................................
Aids to navigation, Hudson River, N. Y ..............................................
Aids to navigation, East River, N. Y ...................................................
Great Salt Pond Light Station, R. I ......................................................
Aids to navigation, Delaware River, Pa. and D el...............................
Joe Flogger Shoal Light Station, Delaware R iver...............................
Thimble Shoal Light Station, V a...........................................................
Aids to navigation, Cape Charles City, V a............................................
Aids to navigation, Chesapeake Bay, Md. and V a...............................
Fifth lighthouse district gas buoys.........................................................
Tender for engineer, sixth lighthouse district......................................
Aids to navigation, St. Johns River, F la ..............................................
Galveston Jetty Light Station, T ex .......................................................
Aids to navigation, Mississippi River, L a .............................................
Aids to navigation, Atchafalaya Entrance, L a....................................
Repairing and rebuilding aids to navigation, Gulf of Mexico...........
Aransas Pass Light Station, T ex............................................................
Navassa Island Light Station, West Indies...........................................
Point Boringuen Light Station, P. R ....................................................
Aids to navigation, Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio........................................
Aids to navigation, Lorain Harbor, Ohio..............................................
Aids to navigation, Conneaut Harbor, Ohio........................................
Aids to navigation, Toledo Harbor, Ohio..............................................
Aids to navigation, Huron Harbor, Ohio..............................................
Aids to navigation, Fairport Harbor, Ohio...........................................
Superior Pierhead Range Lights, Wis...................................................
Detroit River Lights, M ich................................... ......................•.........
Aids to navigation, Fighting Island Channel, Detroit River, M ich..
Sand Hills Light Station, Mich..............................................................
Aids to navigation, Keeweenaw Waterway, Mich...............................
Detroit Lighthouse Depot, Mich............................................................
Aids to navigation, St. Marys Island, Mich..........................................
White Shoal Light Station, Mich...........................................................
Chicago Harbor Light Station, 111..........................................................
Manitowoc Breakwater Light Station, W is...........................................
Aids to navigation, Alaska......................................................................
Cape St. Elias Light Station, Alaska.....................................................
Depot for sixteenth lighthouse district..................................................
Aids to navigation, Puget Sound, Wash................................................
Kellett Bluff Light Station, Wash.........................................................
Aids to navigation, Wash, and Oreg......................................................
Aids to navigation, Pearl Harbor, Hawaii.............................................
National security and defense, lighthouse depot, Tompkinsville,
N. Y „ 1919............................................................................................
National security and defense, aids to navigation, Caribbean Sea,
I9W........................................................................................................
General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1917........................................

$124, 289. 30
3.442. S3

464.03
2, 718. 20
i, 270. 21

5>012.34
50, 624. 40
77,492.06
6,603.18
16. 62
i, 063. 81
7,920. 00
725.00
3, 524.00
i, 201. 80
39.093-37
552- 79

7,171.97

3i5-°o
18,090. 50
4, 132- 92

62,834. 59
10,445.20
151. 62
488.13
55°- 20
2,469.46
18,309. 04
321.41
3. 509- 70

995.00
x, 837. 00

13- 70
4, 639. 54
34. 253. 26
51,319. 61
7, 447. 04
640. 06
545- 55
3B957- 44

19, 859. 30
8,127. 00
103. 20

48,589.95
783- 83
35.028-75
15,671.99
7,741.91

15,26!. 96
12,658. 56
59. 789- 95

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

29

General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1918........................................
General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1919.........................................
Salaries, keepers of lighthouses, 1918.....................................................
Salaries, keepers of lighthouses, 1919.....................................................
Salaries, lighthouse vessels, 1918...........................................................
Salaries, lighthouse vessels, 1919...........................................................
Salaries, Lighthouse Service, 1918.........................................................
Salaries, Lighthouse Service, 1919.........................................................
Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 1918................
Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 1919...............
Retired pay, Lighthouse Service, 1919..................................................

$633,310. 97
2 ,436> 73°- °8
26,192. 88
1,109,101. 76
53,889. 07
1,332, 539. 92
3,925.88
363, 520. 43
7, 851. 10
365,418. 62
20,987. 65

Total................................................................................................

7.165,538.34

By special disbursing agent, Coast and Geodetic Survey.
Salaries, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1918...........................................
Salaries, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1919...........................................
Party expenses, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1917..............................
Party expenses, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1918..............................
Party expenses, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1919..............................
Party expenses, Coast and Geodetic Survey........................................
Repairs of vessels, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1918..........................
Repairs of vessels, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1919..........................
General expenses, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1917...........................
General expenses, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 19x8...........................
General expenses, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1919...........................
Pay, etc., of officers and men, vessels, Coast and Geodetic Survey,
1917 ....................................................................................................
Pay, etc., of officers and men, vessels, Coast and Geodetic Survey,
1918 ....................................................................................................
Pay, etc., of officers and men, vessels, Coast and Geodetic Survey,
1919 ....................................................................................................
Charts, Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1917-18........................................
Two new vessels, Coast and Geodetic Survey......................................
Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 1918...............
Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 1919...............
National security and defense, Department of Commerce, Coast and
Geodetic Survey, new building.........................................................
National security and defense, Department of Commerce, Coast and
Geodetic Survey, new building, 1919................................................
National security and defense, Department of Commerce, Coast and
Geodetic Survey, printing press, 1919...............................................
National security and defense, Department of Commerce, Coast and
Geodetic Survey, building equipment, 1919....................................
Motor-driven vessel and launches, 1919................................................
Total...............................................................................................

$9, 671. 23
363,471.97
182.15
64,173. 64
266, 740. 65
476- 45
763.11
8,307. 09
44-54
25,258. 11
70,835. 82
50.00
20,663.34
105,344.83
1,253.02
- 9®
1 ,939- 5°
29,942. 41
84,991. 42
2,967. 45
11,646.96
6, 849. 56
4°> 631- 79
1,116,206.02

By special disbursing agents, Bureau of Fisheries.
Miscellaneous expenses, Bureau of Fisheries, 1919..............................
Pay, officers and crews of vessels, Alaska Fisheries Service, 19 19 ....
Protecting seal and salmon fisheries of Alaska, 1919...........................
Marine biological station, Fla.................................................................
Increase of compensation. Department of Commerce, 1919...............

$24,691.92
23, 725. 45
1, 710.00
68. 24
*>000. 00

Total...............................................................................................

51. J9S- 61

30

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

By the commercial agents investigating trade conditions abroad, Department of Commerce,
acting as special disbursing agents.
Commercial attachés, Department of Commerce, 1918........................
Commercial attachés, Department of Commerce, 1919........................
National security and defense, Department of Commerce:
Commodity experts, 1919................................................................
Import and export statistics, 1919..................................................
Promoting commerce, South and Central America, 1919...................
Promoting commerce, Department of Commerce, 1918......................
Promoting commerce, Department of Commerce, 1919......................
Promoting commerce, Far East, 1919....................................................
Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 19x8...............
Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 1919...............

§6,227.67
111,398.65

Total...............................................................................................

322,308.58

88, 525. 8a
2, 556. 00
44, 600. 15
609.03
39,410. 78
28,915. 49
18. 76
46. 25

Warrants drawn on the Treasurer of the United States to
satisfy accounts settled by the Auditor for the State and Other
Departments, during the fiscal year ended June 30, 1919, classified
according to items of appropriation :
Office of the Secretary :
Contingent expenses, Department of Commerce, 1917................
Contingent expenses, Department of Commerce, 1918................
Contingent expenses, Department of Commerce, 1919.................
Increase of compensation, 1918.......................................................
Increase of compensation, 1919.......................................................
National security and defense, Industrial Board, 1919...............
National security and defense, Industrial Cooperation Service,

i<U9 ...........................................................................

§70. 68
186. 57
4, 704. 33
7- 5°
75-67
5,637. 34

963-5*

National security and defense, waste-reclamation work, 19 19 ...

820. 24

Total........................................................................................

12,465. 85

Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce:
Commercial attachés, 1918...............................................................
Promoting commerce, 1918..............................................................
Promoting commerce, 1919..............................................................
Promoting commerce, South and Central America,
1918.
Promoting commerce, South and Central America,
1919.
National security and defense, import and export statistics, 1919.
National security and defense, commodity experts, 1919...........

134.41
171.46
86.90
37-87
14-84
1,331. 98
9. 00

Total........................................................................................

x, 786. 46

Bureau of Standards:
Equipment, 1917...............................................................................
Equipment, 1918...............................................................................
Equipment, 1919...............................................................................
Gauge standardization, 1919............................................................
General expenses, 19x8.....................................................................
General expenses, 1919.....................................................................
High-potential investigation, 1919..................................................
Investigation of public utility standards, 1919.............................
Investigation of railway materials, 1918.......................................

328. 76
14. 17
623. 83
7,712.56
75-33
5>8i5.95
41.80
403. 66
36. 68

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

31

B u rea u of S tan d ard s— C on tin u ed .
M ilita ry research, 1 9 1 7 -1 8 ..........................................................................
$ 2 ,6 5 7.3 1
M ilita ry research, 19 1 8 -1 9 ..........................................................................
1,0 55.52
In vestig atio n of o p tica l glass, 19 18 .........................................................
121. 00
In vestig atio n of p u b lic u t ilit y com panies, 19 18 -19 ..........................
44. 90
Stan d ard m aterials, 1919.............................................................................
53-89
Sugar stan dard ization , 19 1 9 ...................................................................................
16.11
R ad io research, 1 9 1 7 .................................................................................................
14.45
Salaries, 19 19 ...................................................................................................
42.22
S tan d ard izin g m ech an ical ap p lian ces, 19 1 9 ........................................
42. 65
T estin g m achines, 19 1 9 ............................................................................................
59.10
T estin g stru ctu ral m aterials, 19 18 ...........................................................
161.46
T estin g stru ctu ral m aterials, 19 1 9 ...........................................................
94. 41
N ational se c u rity and defen se, m eta llu rgical w o rk ..........................
42. 00
N ational se c u rity and defense, n ew b u ild in g .....................................
97-47
N ational se c u rity and defense, produ ction of op tica l g la ss...........
3. 60
N ational se c u rity and defense, com p letin g laboratory, 1919........
2, 595. 95
589. 09
N ational se c u rity and defense, m ilita r y researches, 19 1 9 ..............
C ertified claim s—
T estin g stru ctu ral m aterials, 19 1 2 ..................................................
2. 05
In vestigatio n of ra ilw a y m aterials, 19 15 ......................................
n o . 00
114.00
E q u ip m en t, 19 1 6 ...................................................................................
G eneral exp en ses, 19 16 ....................................................................................
x.ax
T estin g railroad scales, 19 1 6 .............................................................
6.00

T o ta l..............................................................................................

22,977. 14

Bureau of Navigation:
Refunding penalties or charges erroneously e x a cted ....................
Contingent expenses, Shipping Service, 19 17.................................
Contingent expenses. Shipping Service, 1918.................................
Contingent expenses, Shipping Service, 1919.................................
Enforcement of wireless-communication laws, 19 17......................
Enforcement of wireless-communication laws, 1918.......................
Enforcement of wireless-communication laws, 1919..................

721.63
1.94
to. 65
1. 07
2. 05
3-93
1. 35

T otal......................................................................................................

742.62

Steamboat-Inspection Service:
Clerk hire, 1919.................................................................................................
Contingent expenses, 1917.............................................................................
Contingent expenses, 1918....................................................................
Contingent expenses, 1919...................................................................
Salaries, 1919...........................................................
Steamboat-Inspection Service, Tampa, Fla., 1918....................................
Certified claims— Contingent expenses, 1916...................................
T otal...............................................................................................................
Bureau of Fisheries:
Building and improvements, fur-seal islands, A laska...................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1917..............................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1918..............................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1919..............................................................
Protecting seal and salmon fisheries of Alaska, 1917......................
Protecting seal and salmon fisheries of Alaska, 1918......................

566.67
4a 17
200.86
354. 46
1,11 1.9 4
23.08
1. 52
2,298.70
219. 37
148.97
486. 70
r, 115.31
2. 02
282.81

32

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Bureau of Fisheries— Continued.
Salaries, 1919..................................................................................... ..
Repairs to steamer F i s h lla -w k , 1918.................................................
National security and defense, food-fish supply, 1918..................
National security and defense, seal-oil plant...................................
Certified claims—
Miscellaneous expenses, 1905......................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1908......................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1909......................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1910......................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 19 1 1......................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1912......................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, 1916......................................................

S50. 00
340. 59
4. 37
38. 16
.88
.70
4. n
2.82
1.74
4. 97
.3 1

T o ta l..............................................................................................

2,703. 83

Bureau of the Census:
Collecting statistics, 1918......................................................................
Collecting statistics, 1919......................................................................
Salaries, 1919...........................................................................................
R elief of A lice V. Houghton for injuries..........................................

97. 25
14- 42
35. 00
900. 00

T otal......................................................................................................

1,046.67

Coastfand Geodetic Survey:
General expenses, 1917.........................................................................
General expenses, 1918..........................................................................
General expenses, 1919.........................................................................
Party expenses, 1917..............................................................................
Party expenses, 1918...........................................................................
Party expenses, 1919...........................................................................
Repairs of vessels, 1918.........................................................................
Salaries, 1919...........................................................................................

1, 4 39 - 14
78. 10
6,434. 58
1,184.83
12, h i . 91
3.37

Total......................................................................................................

21,462.27

Bureau of Lighthouses:
Aids to navigation, A laska...................................................................
Aids to navigation, Washington and Oregon....................................
Lighthouse tender for generalservice...........................................................
Radio installation for lighthouse tender...........................................
Repairing and rebuilding aids to navigation, A tlantic coast.......
Tender for engineer, sixth lighthouse district.................................
General expenses, 1917..................................................................................
General expenses, 1918..........................................................................
General expenses, 1919.........................................................................
Salaries, Lighthouse Service, 1918.....................................................
Salaries, Lighthouse vessels, 1918...............................................................
Certified claims—
General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1915............................
General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1916............................
Total.....................................................................................................

34. 60

175. 74

317. 56
80. 05
250.07
281. 87
x. 94
5. 98
6,447.10
25,481. 59
64, 534. 85
4. 00
1,727. 5 °
174. 37
2, 579. 80
101,886.68

Miscellaneous: Judgments, Court of Claims, Department of
Commerce.............................................................................................

3)378-66

Grand total...................................................................................

170,748.88

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

33

The following statement shows the expenditures during the fis­
cal year ended June 30, 1919, on account of all appropriations
under the control of the Department, giving the total amounts
disbursed by the various disbursing officers of the Department,
and miscellaneous receipts for the same period :
EXPENDITURES.

B y the Disbursing Clerk, Department of Commerce, on account of
salaries and expenses of the Office of the Secretary of Commerce,
the Bureaus of Foreign and Domestic Commerce, Navigation,
Standards, Fisheries, the Census, and Lighthouses, the office of
the Supervising Inspector General, Steamboat-Inspection Service,
salaries and expenses of the Steamboat-Inspection Service at large,
and public works of the Lighthouse and Fisheries Services (shown
in detail in the first of the foregoing tables of disbursements). . . .
B y the authorized disbursing officers of the Lighthouse S e rv ice . . . .
B y the special disbursing agent, Coast and Geodetic S u rv e y ..........
B y special disbursing agents, Bureau of Fisheries................................
B y the commercial agents of the Department investigating trade
conditions abroad, as special disbtirsing agents..................................
B y warrants drawn on the Treasurer of the United States to satisfy
accounts settled by the Auditor for the State and Other Depart­
ments.........................................................................................
Printing and binding.....................................................................................
T otal.............................................................................................. ..

$8, 165,930.99
7,165, 538.34
1,116, 206. 02
51,195. 61
322,308. 58

170,748.88
399,961.32
17,391, 889. 74

MISCELLANEOUS RECEIPTS.

Coast and Geodetic Survey: Sale of charts, publications, old prop­
erty, e tc ........................................................................................................
Bureau of the Census: Sale of publications, e tc .....................................
Bureau of Fisheries:
Sale of 18,223 sealskins..........................................................................
Sale of fox and other skins...................................................................
Sale of seal bones....................................................................................
Sale of old property, e tc .......................................................................
Bureau of Navigation:
Tonnage ta x .............................................................................................
Navigation fees......... , ...........................................................................
Navigation fines......................................................................................
From deceased passengers....................................................................
Bureau of Standards: Sale of old property, e tc ......................................
Steamboat-Inspection Service: Sale of old property, e tc .....................
Bureau of Lighthouses: Sale of old property, rentals, e tc ....................
Office of the Secretary: Sale of old property, e tc ...................................
T o ta l..............................................................................................................
1 4 0 2 6 1 — 1 9 ------ 3

24,052.10
282. 00
741,197.42
67, 588. 33
2, 752. 80
11,615.66
1,265,229.23
143, 492, 19
162, 146. 50
460. 00
12. 50
31 - 55
35,372. 69
1,054. 58
2,4 55,287.55

34

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
The

fo llo w in g

unexpended

b a la n c e s

of

a p p r o p r ia tio n s

w ere

t u r n e d i n t o t h e s u r p l u s f u n d J u n e 3 0 , 1 9 1 9 , in a c c o r d a n c e w i t h t h e
a c t o f J u n e 20, 18 7 4 (1 8 S t a t . , i i o - m ) :

Office of the Secretary:
Salaries, Office of Secretary of Commerce, 1917......................................
S2,314. 05
Increase of compensation, Department of Commerce, 1918..................
13,429.68
3.02
Contingent expenses, Department of Commerce, 1917.........................
Bureau of the Census:
Salaries, Bureau of the Census, 1917.........................................................
15,387.92
Collecting statistics, Bureau of the Census, 1917.................................... 106,140.43
Tabulating machines, Bureau of the Census, 1917.................................
495. 74
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce:
4,155. 25
Salaries, Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce, 1917................
Commercial attachés, Department of Commerce, 1915.........................
342. 75
Commercial attachés, Department of Commerce, 1916.........................
483.03
3,365.62
Commercial attachés. Department of Commerce, 1917..........................
Promoting commerce, Department of Commerce, 19 17........................
2,853.02
3, 799.83
Promoting commerce, South and Central America, 1917.....................
Investigating cost of production, Department of Commerce, 1 9 1 7 ...
15, 075.30
Steamboat-Inspection Service:
Salaries, Office of Supervising Inspector General, Steam boat-Inspec­
tion Service, 1917.......................................................................................
18.97
Salaries, Steamboat-Inspection Service, 1917.........................................
4,219.95
Clerk hire, Steamboat-Inspection Service, 1917.....................................
577. 59
Contingent expenses, Steamboat-Inspection Service, 1917..................
4,597.25
Bureau of Navigation:
Salaries, Bureau of Navigation, 1917.........................................................
411.97
Salaries, Shipping Service, 1917.................................................................
763.67
24. 50
Clerk hire, Shipping Service, 19 1 7 ............................................................
7. 97
Contingent expenses, Shipping Service, 1917.........................................
Admeasurement of vessels, 1917.................................................................
15. 90
Preventing overcrowding of passenger vessels, 1917..............................
1,162. 24
Enforcement of navigation laws, 1917.......................................................
20.10
2,831. 68
Enforcement of wireless-communication laws, 19 17..............................
Bureau of Standards:
Salaries, 1917........................................................................................... .'.. .
21,978.87
Equipm ent, 19 17..................................................................................................
815.13
General expenses, 1917.................................................................................
522.22
64.33
Improvement and care of grounds, 1917...................................................
Color standardization, 1917........................................................ ................
272. 66
Determining physical constants, 19 17.......................................................
528. 38
Equipping cnemical laboratory' building, 19 16 -17................................
327. 24
26. 61
Investigation of clay products, 19 17 .........................................................
Investigation of fire-resisting properties, 1917.........................................
78. 41
High-potential investigations, 1917...........................................................
125. 17
Investigation of public u tility standards, 19 17.......................................
297. 56
Investigation of railway materials, 1917....................................................
106.34
Radio research, 1917.............................................................................................
756.40
Refrigeration constants, 1917.......................................................................
5 7 -7 4
Standardizing mechanical appliances, 19 17............................................
468. 38
Testing machines, 1917.................................................................................
283. 73
Testing miscellaneous materials, 19 17....................................................
107.08
Testing railroad scales, etc., 1917...............................................................
189. 63
Testing structural materials, 1917..............................................................
898. 68

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
Coast and Geodetic:
Salaries, 1917...................................................................................................
Party expenses, 1916.....................................................................................
Party expenses, 1917.....................................................................................
General expenses, 1917.................................................................................
Pay, etc., officers and men, vessels, Coast Survey, 1917......................
Repairs of vessels, Coast Survey, 19 17......................................................
Outfitting Coast Survey steamer S u r v e y o r , 19 17 ....................................
Bureau of Lighthouses:
Salaries, Bureau of Lighthouses, 1917.......................................................
General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1916...........................................
General expenses, Lighthouse Service, 1917............................................
Salaries, keepers of lighthouses, 1917.........................................................
Salaries, lighthouse vessels, 19 17................................................................
Salaries, Lighthouse Service, 1917.............................................................
Staten Island and West Bank Light Station, N. Y ................................
Newark B ay beacon lights, N. J .................................................................
Cleveland Fog Signal Station, O h io ..........................................................
Bureau of Fisheries:
Salaries, Bureau of Fisheries, 1917.............................................................
Miscellaneous expenses, Bureau of Fisheries, 19 17................................
Motor launches, Alaska fisheries service, 19 17........................................
Pay, officers and crew of vessel, Alaska fisheries service, 19 17...........
Protecting seal and salmon fisheries of Alaska, 1917..............................
Fish hatchery, Gloucester, Mass., 4917.....................................................
Steamer A lb a tr o s s , repairs, 1917..................................................................
Reimbursement to officers and crew of lighthouse tender M a m a n i t a . .
Total

35
$5,196-86
38.15
12 , 9 4 5 - 04
63. 37
24,321. 88
1, 794. 95
626. 04
2,619.63
14,275.09
30, 592. 40
8,046.02
105, 311. 62
6,825. S3
26,027. 36
7. 19
26.37
18,913. 70
4, 792. 13
31. 26
26. 24
170. 18
2, g8r. 85
5. 25
7. 00
476,045. 10

In the last seven years the Department of Commerce has turned
back unused into the Treasury the following amounts:
June
June
June
June
June

30,
30,
30,
30,
30,

1913
1914
1915
1916
1917

$618,970. or
347» 162. 48
247,482. 22
227,941. 92

June 30, 4918
Ju n e 30, 1919

$149,009. 51
476,045. 10

T o ta l. . . .

2,244,606.51

1 7 7 »9 9 5 - 27

There is a general impression that money appropriated means
money spent. Yet here is a total of $2,244,606.51 which could
have been expended for the purposes named, but was not. In
business circles such action would be deemed commendable and
would win confidence of financial authorities in the wisdom of
the disbursing organization. The reverse is true, however, in the
Government under the existing system. The inference is not
drawn from such facts by appropriating committees that care has
been used in expenditure and so something has been saved for
the Government, but rather that the estimates were, in the first
instance, extravagant and blameworthy. Almost the first ques­
tion asked when considering estimates is what the unexpended

36

REPORT OK THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

balance was the previous year, and it is argued that if last year a
considerable balance remained less is needed for the coming year.
The very economy resulting in the balance saved is made the
basis for mulcting a service on its necessary expenditures in the
future.
This is here pointed out as one of the faults, minor but real, of
the present system of appropriating funds for Government pur­
poses which it may be hoped a modern budget system would
remove. When the writer was an officer of the City of New York
a direct incentive to saving was provided by the city charter
which peimitted unexpended balances to be used under the
authority of the board of estimate for other work. Under such a
system an executive naturally saved all he could in order to do
as much work as possible with what remained. Under the pres­
ent Government system the temptation is direct to use as nearly
as possible all of the appropriation lest one be mulcted in the
coming year and have insufficient funds for necessary work.
Estimates for Fiscal Year Ending June 30, 1921.
The estimates for the fiscal year 1921 aggregate $35,318,068.40,
and exceed the appropriations for the fiscal year 1920, amounting
to $29,052,955, by $6,265,113.40.
The estimates include an item for the Fourteenth Decennial
Census amounting to $6,215,000.
The estimate is submitted in this form in view of the fact
that it is impossible to apportion, with any approach to accu­
racy, the cost of the work during the second year of the decennial
census period.
As the legislative, executive, and judicial act, approved March
1, 1919, carries an appropriation of $15,000,000 for Fourteenth
Census work, this will make a total of $21,215,000 required for the
Fourteenth Decennial Census period.
The total amount requested in last year’s estimate for the
Fourteenth Census period was $20,500,000, or $715,000 less than
the total amount now estimated. This is accounted for as
follows:
Since the original estimate was prepared, provision for an addi­
tional inquiry, relating to encumbrances on homes, was inserted
in the census bill by the Senate and was enacted into law. The
inclusion of this inquiry will add approximately $1,000,000 to the
cost of the Fourteenth Census. An additional estimate of $50,000
has been made necessary for the construction of a fireproof vault

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

37

installation of freight elevators, the strengthening of floors, etc.,
at the temporary war building, which has been assigned to the
bureau for the use of the Fourteenth Census force.
The original estimate of $300,000 for rent of buildings in the
District of Columbia, and $35,000 for fuel contained in last year’s
estimates, have been eliminated on account of the assignment to
this bureau of the temporary war building. The cost of heating
that building will be paid by the Office of the Superintendent of the
State, War, and Navy Building.
These changes are equivalent to a net increase of $715,000.
The estimates submitted by the Lighthouse Service show an
increase over appropriations of $9,329,338.40. They include items
of public works approximating $8,000,000, of which items amount­
ing to $1,500,000 have been heretofore authorized by Congress.
Fourteen items amounting to $6,375,750 have not yet been author­
ized, but are urgently needed for the Service.
The increase for the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce
is $74} ,910, of which $117,410 is for salaries for additional em­
ployees in Washington to enable the bureau to keep abreast of the
ever-increasing work and $410,000 additional is needed for the
field service in this country and abroad. Sixty-nine thousand
dollars is required for the development of trade by motion pictures,
and $151,500 is asked for post allowances for men in foreign service,
for transporting their families, and for bringing home the remains
of such as may die abroad.
The Steamboat-Inspection Service submits estimates increasing
the amount appropriated for 1920 by $97,320, as the Service is
being called on continually to do more work incident to the
country’s shipping program.
The increase for the Bureau of Navigation is $174,204 to enable
the bureau to take care of the ever-increasing shipping problems
which by law are imposed on this bureau.
The war added many new investigations to the Bureau of
Standards, the cost of which during the war was borne by other
departments and the President’s fund, and approximately
$2,000,000 additional is required to enable the bureau to pursue
these investigations, which will result in great benefit to the
Government and general public in peace times.
The Bureau of Fisheries asks $637,880 additional, and the
Coast and Geodetic Survey submits estimates which exceed the
appropriations for 1920 by $2,000,000, over $1,000,000 of which
is required for new vessels.

RBPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

3«

Increases of salaries for employees in the District of Columbia
are not included in the recommendations of this Department
because the matter is under consideration by the Joint Com­
mission on Reclassification of Salaries, and request will be made
in the Book of Estimates that appropriations for these salaries be
adjusted in accordance with such recommendations of the com­
mission as receive the approval of the Congress.
This Department desires that such recommendations for in­
creased salaries as may be recommended by the Joint Commission
on Reclassification of Salaries be considered in connection with
the estimates of this Department.
C o m p a r is o n o p t h e

I t e m s o f E s t im a t e s f o r t h e

S u b m i t t e d f o r t h e F is c a l Y e a r

1921

w it h

D epa r tm en t of Co m m erce

the

A p p r o p r ia t io n s A c t u a l l y

M a d e b y t h e C o n g r e s s f o r t h e F is c a l Y e a r 19 2 0 .

Estim ates,
1921.

A ppropria­
tions, 1920.

Increase.

Decrease.

O F F IC E O F T H E S E C R E T A R Y .

Salaries..........................................................
Contingent expenses..................................
R e n t...............................................................
Total.

$214,950.00 I $196,050.00
50,000.00
60,000.00
68, 500.00
68,500.00
3 4 3 *450- 00

S18,900.00
jo, 000.00

28,900.00 ;

314* 5 5 ° -00

L IG H T H O U S E S E R V IC E .

Salaries.................................. ....................................
79,668.40 j
65,430.00
General expenses......................................................
4,300,000.00 j 3,500,000.00
Salaries of keepers....................................................
1*330,000.00 j 1,300,000.00
Salaries, light vessels.................................................... 2,100,000.00 j 1,400,000.00
Salaries, Lighthouse Service........................................| 490,000.00 j 380,000.00
85,000.00
45*000 00
R etired pay, Lighthouse Service............................... j
Public works:
Tenders and light vessels..................................... 5,000,000-00 ;.
Lighthouse tenders and light vessels................. j 760.000.
00 j.,
Diamond Shoal L ight Vessel.............................
450.000.
00 i .
H aw aiian Island lighthouse d e p o t.....................1 :20,000.00
350.000.
00 1.
Fifth lighthouse district dep o t...........................
5 0 , OOO. OO : ..
Virgin Islands, aids to n avigation..................... !
95.000. 00 .
Potom ac R iver, aids to n avigation...................
132,750-00 :.
E ighth lighthouse d istrict d e p o t........................
60.000.
00 j.
Charleston, S. C., d e p o t.......................... ............
250.000.
00 .
Seventh lighthouse d istrict d e p o t......................
19.600.00 j.
Conneaut H arbor, Ohio, aids to n av ig atio n ..
75.000.
00 !.
Ludington, Mich., aids to n avigation..............
17,500- 00 i .
Tam pa B ay, aids to n avigation.........................
148,500.00 ;.
Delaware B ay Entrance, aids to navigation.
82, 300. OO ! .
N ew port, R . I., lighthouse d e p o t.....................
4 4 *7 5 0 - 0 0
California and N evada, aids to n avigation---18.000.
00 .
D epot keepers' dw ellings.....................................
150.000.
00 \.
Cape Spencer, Alaska, Lighthouse Service—
6,500.00 j.
G alveston Je tty , Lighthouse S ervice...............
44.600.00 i .
Fifth lighthouse d istrict, additional b u o y s ...
6 5.0 0 0 .
00 .
S taten Island, N . Y ., lighthouse d e p o t...........

j
j
I
j
j
i

14,238-40
800.000.
30.000.
700.000.
n o , OOO-00
40.000 00

j
00
00 j
00
;

5,000,000.00 ;
760,000-00
450.000.
00 1
120.000.
00 ;
350.000.
00 j
50,000-00 !
95.000. 00 ;
132*750.00
60, ooo- co
250.000.
00 1
19,6oo-00 j
75.000.
00 :
17,500-00
148.500.00
82,300.00 ;
4 4 *7 5 0 - 0 0

18, ooo-00
150.000.
6, 500.00

'
00

4 4 ,6 0 0 .0 0
6 5 .0 0 0 .

00

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
Co m p a r is o n o p t h e : I t e m s o f E s t im a t e s f o r t h e D e p a r t m e n t
S u b m i t t e d f o r t h e F is c a l Y e a r

1921

w it h

the

op

39
Co m m e r c e

A p p r o p r ia t io n s A c t u a l ly

M a d e b y t h e C o n g r e s s p o r t h e F i s c a l Y e a r 1920— Continued.

A ppropria­
tions, 1920.

Estim ates,
1921.

l ig h t h o u s e

s e r v ic e

—continued.

Public works—C ontinued.
D etroit lighthouse d e p o t....................................
Execution Rocks, Lighthouse Service...........
P oint Jiquero, P. R ., Lighthouse Service—
M anitowoc Breakw ater, Lighthouse Service.
Chicago H arbor, Lighthouse Service...............
Lighthouse keepers’ dw ellings..........................
Tom pkinsville lighthouse d e p o t .....................
Third lighthouse d istrict, rip ra p ......................
Alaska, aids to n avig atio n .........................................
Total.
Decrease. . . .

$50,000.00

$50,000.00

2 4.0 0 0 .

00

2 4.0 0 0 .

6,400. 00

6 .400.00
50.0 00.

50, coo. 00

00

30, c o o . 00

30 .000 . 00

150,000.00

150,000.00
75 .0 0 0 .
7,0 44 ,830 .00

1 6 ,3 7 4 ,16 8 .4 0

7 5 .0 0 0 .

00
9 ,6 8 3 ,7 3 8 .4 0

354,400.00

354,400.00

b u r e a u

9.3291338.40
o f

t h e

c e n s u s

.

Expenses, Fourteenth D ecennial C ensus.
O K F O R E IG N

AND

6 ,2 15 ,0 0 0 .0 0

T o tal.

33 7 , 9

220, 5IO.OO

00

500.000.

00 3 2 5 . 0 0 0 .

150.0 00.

00 IOO, OOO. OO

15 0 .0 0 0 .

00

300.000. 00
6 9 .0 0 0 .
100 .000 .

S T E A M B O A T -IN S P E C T IO N

117 ,4 10 . 00
0 0 175,000. 00

50.0 00.

100.000. OO

so, 000.00

165, OOO. OO

13 s, 000.00
6 9 .0 0 0 .

00

50.0 00.

00
9 10 ,5 10 -0 O

T o ta l.

24, 14 0.00
73 0 . 55 0 . 0 0 I

74 7,9 10 .0 0

2 2 , 9 4 0 - OO

I , 20 0- 00

69 7 , 95 0 - 0 0

32.600.00

115,000 .00

3 3 . 5 2 0 .00

l60,000.00

30,000.00

1,0 9 3 ,2 10 .0 0

9 9 5 ,890- 00

9 7,32 0 .0 0

4 5 .13 0 .0 0

3 9 , 7 3 0 - 00

5.400.00

36.200.00

30 ,10 0.0 0

6 .10 0 .0 0

85.800.00

50.0 00.

148 .520.00 I
190 , 0 0 0 . 0 0

:

O F N A V IG A T IO N .

Salaries, B ureau of N av ig atio n............................
Salaries, Shipping Service.....................................
Clerk hire, Shipping Service.................................
Contingent expenses, Shipping Service.............
A dm easurem ent of vessels.....................................
In strum ents for counting passengers..................
Enforcem ent of navigation la w s..........................
Preventing overcrowding of passenger vessels.,
Enforcem ent of wireless-communication la w s..

Total............................................

00 35,800.00

12,365-00

8 ,365.0 0

4,000.00

5,000.00

3 , soo. 00

1.50 0 .0 0

250.00

250.00

8 0.142 .0 0

43.000. 00

18,000.00

18 .0 0 0 .

00

12 9,2 6 2 .00

4 5 .0 0 0 .

00 84,262.0 0

412,149.00

00

1 , 500.00

X, 500. 00
50.0 00.

S E R V IC E .

Salaries, Office of Supervising Inspector G en eral..
Salaries, Steam boat-Inspection Service.............
Clerk h ire ...................................................................
Contingent expenses...............................................

00

IOO,OOO-00

00

1 ,6 5 8 ,4 2 0 .0 0 .

BUREAU

8, 785,000.00

15,000,000.00

D O M E S T IC C O M M E R C E .

Salaries...........................................................................
Prom oting commerce..................................................
Prom oting commerce. South and C entral A m erica.
Prom oting commerce, F ar E a s t..........................
Commercial a ttach es...............................................
Developm ent of trade, m otion p ictu res.............
Post allowances........................................................
Transporting rem ains.............................................
Transporting fam ilies.............................................

23",945-00 ;

00

9 ,000.00

9.000 - 00

N et increase..

BUREAU

$10,000.00

$10,000. oc

00

00

40

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

C o m p a r is o n o p t h e

I t e m s o f E s t im a t e s

S u b m it t e d f o r t h e F is c a l Y e a r

1921

for

D epa rtm en t

the

w it h

the

of

Com m erce

A p p r o p r ia t io n s A c t u a l l y

M a d e b y t h e C o n g r e s s f o r t h e F is c a l Y e a r 1920— Continued.
Estim ates,
1931.

BUREAU

A p p ro p ria ­
t io n s , 1920.

Decrease.

OF STA N D AR D S.

Salaries...........................................................................
E q u ip m e n t...................................................................
R epairs and a lteratio n s..............................................
General expenses.........................................................
Im provem ent and care of grounds............................
Testing stru ctu ral m aterials.......................................
Testing m achines........................................................
Investigation of fire-resisting properties..................
Investigation of public utilities.................................
Investigation of railw ay m aterials............................
Testing miscellaneous m aterials................................
Radio-com m unication research.................................
Color standardization...................................................
investigation of clay p roducts...................................
Physical constants........................................................
Standardization and testing of mechanical ap­
pliances......................................................................
Investigation of optical glass......................................
Standard m aterials.......................................................
Investigation of tex tiles...............................................
Sugar standardization................................................
Gauge stand ard izatio n .................................................
Mine scales in vestigation.............................................
M etallurgical research................................................ .
In dustrial p y ro m etry ...................................................
Sound investigation......................................................
In dustrial research........................................................
Industrial safety stan d ard s.........................................
Standardization of instrum ents, m achinery, and
e q u ipm en t...................................................................
Investigation of electrodeposition of m etals.........
Investigation of chemical reagents...........................
W eights and measures cooperation. . . : ..................
Gas-measuring instrum ents investigation..............
Electrical investigations..............................................
M otor combustion and lubricating! s tan d a rd s.......
Construction w o rk ........................................................
Standardization and investigation of internalcombustion engines..................................................
Low -tem perature research and stan d ard izatio n ...
A eronautic in stru m en t investigation......................
'l'esting large scales.......................................................
Testing car d e p o t..........................................................
Building for power p la n t...................... ....................
A lteration of n orth laboratory.................................
Moving and in stallatio n ............................................
A dditional la n d ...........................................................

$18 4,680 .00

$ 6 71,4 4 0 .0 0 ! $486,760.00

100.000.

00 50.0 0 0 .

00

3 5 .0 0 0 .

00 8 .0 0 0 .

002 7 .0 0 0 .

00

10 0 .000 .

00 60.0 0 0 .

15 0 .0 0 0 .

2 5 .0 0 0 .
2 50.00 0.

00

00 40, ooo. 00
17,5 0 0 .0 0

00 7, 500.00

00 125, ooo. 00

00 12 5 .0 0 0 .

2 5 .0 0 0 . 00

5 5 .0 0 0 .

00 30.000. 00

6 5 .0 0 0 .

00 2 5 .0 0 0 .

00 40, ooo. 00

200.000.

00 8 5 .0 0 0 .

001x5,0 0 0 .0 0

2 5 .0 0 0 .

00 1 5 .0 0 0 .

5 0 .0 0 0 .

00 30 .0 0 0 .

75 .0 0 0 .

•00 30,000.00

1 5 .0 0 0 .

00 10, ooo- 00

5, ooo. 00

5 0 .0 0 0 .

00 20, ooo. 00

30, ooo. 00

25,000 ■ 00

00
00

5 .0 0 0 .

10,000-00
20.000.
00
45, OOO. 00

20, OOO.OO

00

40 .00 0.

00 1 5 .0 0 0 .

75 .0 0 0 .

00 20, ooo. 00

15 .0 0 0 .

00 5,000.00

10, ooo. 00

75 .0 0 0 .

00 13 .0 0 0 . 00

60,000.00

30 .0 0 0 .

00 20, ooo. 00

10, ooo- 00

6 0 .0 0 0 .

00 40, ooo. 00

2 5 .0 0 0 .

00 1 5 .0 0 0 .

00

75 .0 0 0 .

00 2 5 .0 0 0 .

00 50, ooo. 00

10 .0 0 0 .

00

5, OOO. 00

250,000.00

50,000-00

5 0 .0 0 0 .

00 25,00©- 00
55, ooo. 00

20, ooo. OO

10,000- 00

10.000-00

20, 000- OO

00

15,00 0.00

200, ooo. OO
50, ooo. 00

75 , 000-00

75,000-00

20, 000-00

20,000 ■ 00
15 .0 0 0 .

00

1 5 .0 0 0 -

00

3 5 .0 0 0 .

00

35.000-

00

10 .0 0 0 .

00

10, ooo- 00

5 0 .0 0 0 .

00

50, ooo- 00
50, o o o -00

50.000. CO

10.000.

00

10-000*00

150,000.00

150, ooo- 00

20, OOO- OO

20, OOO- OO

25. 000. OO

25, o o o - 00

00,000-00

20.000- OO

So, 000.00

5 0 .000- 00

50.0 0 0 .

00

5 0 ,o o o •00

6 0 .0 0 0 .

00

60, OOO. 00

100, ooo. 00

T o t a l ...................................................................................... ! 3,2 4 6 ,4 4 0 .0 0 ; 1,3 9 7 ,2 6 0 .0 0
D e c r e a s e ............................................................................................ •.............................. \ ..............................

N et increase..

Increase.

$IOO, OOC. OO

r, 949,180- 00

100,000-00
1,8 4 9 ,18 0 .0 0

100,000.00

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
C o m p a r is o n o p t h e

I t e m s o f E s t im a t e s f o r

S u b m it t e d f o r t h e F is c a l Y e a r

1921

thf.

w it h

D epa rtm en t of

the

41
Co m m e r c e

Ap p r o p r ia t io n s A c t u a l l y

M a d e b y t h e C o n g r e s s f o r t h e F i s c a l Y e a r 1920— Continued.

Estim ates,
1921.

BUREAU

OP

A ppropria­
tions, 1920.

Increase.

F IS H E R IE S .

$112,940.00
Salaries, B ureau of F ish eries...................................... $146,460.00
347,250.00
478,610.00
Salaries, field service....................................................
719,000.00
864,000.00
Miscellaneous expenses................................................
30,000.00
A uxiliary station, Mississippi R iv e r........................
Fish hatcheries:
,000.00
4,000.00
D u lu th .....................................................................
», 000.00 ..............................
New H am p sh ire....................................................
1,000.00 j .............................. !
NorthviUe, M ich....................................................
», 000.00 ! ..............................
R hode Is la n d ..........................................................
>,000.00 ! ..............................
St. Johnsbury, V t..................................................
■ , 500.00 j ..............................
San Marcus, T e x ....................................................
»,OOO.OO:..................
Saratoga, W y o ........................................................
;,ooo.oo ; ........................
W oods Hole, M ass.................................................
»,000.00 ,
5,000.00
W ytheville, V a ......................................................
................ !
8,000.00
Cape Vincent, N. Y ..................................................
», 000.00 ; ..............................
Marine Biological Station, K ey W est, F la .............
», OOO. OO ! ..............................
Fur-seal islands, A laska...............................................
Developm ent and im provem ent of herring fish­
eries, A laska................................................................
10,000.00
Biological station, Fairport. Io w a ............................
7,500.00
Power lighter for Pribilof Islan d s................................

$ 33,520.0 0 j.

T o ta l..................................................................... 1,851,570.00
Decrease....................................................................................................

663,380- OO
2 5 , 500.00

x, 213,690- OO

145,000.00 j.
30 .0 0 0 .

00

.

11.0 0 0 .

00

.

20.000.

00

.

50.0 00.

00

40 .00 0.

00

10,000-00
7 ,5 0 0 .0 0

10 .0 0 0 .

00

15 .0 0 0 .

00

5,000.00

$8,000.00
n o , 000.00
20,000.00

10,000.00
7,500.00

637,880.00

N et increase..........................................
COAST AN D

13 1,3 6 0 .0 0 j.

G E O D E T IC S U R V E Y .

P a rty expenses..........................................
R epairs of vessels......................................
Pay, etc., officers and m e n .....................
Salaries........................................................

4 9 4 i 600.00 i

SÓjOOO.OO

460,000.00
523,680.00 ;

282,621.00
26,500.00
416,000.00
223,330.00

..............
68,000.00

Four or more lau n ch es............................
Total.
Decrease

3,737,231.00

N et increase..
Printing and b in d in g .............................

tf

638,280

2.107.951- 00 ;
9,000.00 »
2.098.951-

t
386,430.00

300.000-00

00 i

86,430-00

R E C A P IT U L A T IO N .

Office of the S ecretary.........................................
lig h th o u se Service..............................................
Bureau of the Census..........................................
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce.
Steam boat-Inspection Service..........................
Bureau of N avigation.........................................

314,550-00
28,900.00 ....................
3 4 3 , 4 5 0 -0 0
354,400.00
16,374,168. 40 7,044,830-00 9,683,738.40
6,215,000.00 15,000,000-00 ........................8, 78s,000. 00
747.910.00
1,658,420.00
9 1 0 , 510.00
995,890-00
97.320.00
1,093. 210. 00
174.204. 00
412,149.00
2 3 7 , 9 4 5 -0°

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

42

C o m p a r is o n - o f t u b

I tems

S u b m it t e d f o r t h e

of

E s t im a t e s f o r t u b

F is c a l Y e a r

1921 w i t h

the

D epa r tm en t o f Co m m erce
A p p r o p r ia t io n s A c t u a l l y

M a d e b y t h e C o n g r e s s f o r t h e F i s c a l Y e a r 1920— Continued.

Estim ates,
192t.
R S C A P ir u L A T iO N —

.
A ppropria­
tions, 1920.

Increase.

Decrease.

continued.
$3,246,440.00 $1,397,260.00 $1.949, xSo-00
663,380-00
11851,570.00 i, 213.690.00
r ,638, 280.00 2,107,951-00
3 . 7 3 7 , 23X. 00
300,000.00
86,430- 00
386,430.00

$100,000.00
25,500.00
9,000.00

35.318,068.40 29,052,955.00 15,539,013-40 9,273,900.00
9,273,900.00
6,265,113-40

Personnel.
The accompanying table shows, by bureaus, the number of
permanent positions in the Department on July 1, 1919, and the
increase or decrease in each bureau as compared with July 1, 1918.
The figures do not include temporary appointments, nor do they
include the following appointments or employments not made by
the head of the Department: Persons engaged in rodding, chain­
ing, recording, heliotroping, etc., in field parties of the Coast and
Geodetic Survey; temporary employments in field operations of
the Bureau of Fisheries; mechanics, skilled tradesmen, and laborers
employed in field construction work in the Lighthouse Service.
Enlisted men on vessels of the Coast Survey in the Philippine
islands and officers and men of the Navy Department employed
on vessels of the Bureau of Fisheries are also excluded. The total
of these excluded miscellaneous employments and enlistments is
approximately 5,000, as compared with 4,444 for the fiscal year
1918. At the close of the fiscal year 1919 there were 1,262 em­
ployees in the service of the Department serving under temporary
appointment or employment.
The total number of permanent positions referred to in the
accompanying table, together with the employments and enlist­
ments just mentioned, on July 1, 1919, was approximately 12,349,
as compared with 11,051 on July 1, 1918.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

S ta tu ­
tory.

Bureau.

N onstatutory.

43
I ncrcase
(+ ) or
decrease
(-).

In
D istrict
of Co­
lumbia.

Outside
D istrict
of Co­
lumbia.

->348
305
996
428
5.818

° 695
a 174
902
82

653
*3 *

— 49

94

“ 65
8

43

5 »7 7 5

«369

5 73

Total.

..........
Bureau of the Census.......................................
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce
Bureau of S ta n d a rd s........................................
Bureau of Fisheries..........................................
Bureau of Lighthouses....................................
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey ............................
Bureau of N avigatio n ......................................
Steam boat-Inspection Service.......................
T o tal.........................................................

636

712

153
381
424
56
336

-S3
615
4
5*702

606

b

d 45

1 59

3-

97

942
204
408

8,108

10,632

2*524

8s

346

45

1 59

14

394

“ 5
c 403
— 29
61

2*507

8,125

4*3

a Employees engaged in work in th e field for a p art of each year, w ith headquarters in W ashington, are
treated as w ithin th e D istrict of Columbia.
b Includes th e following positions, appointm ent to which is n o t m ade by th e head of the D epartm ent:
415 mechanics, skilled tradesm en, and laborers employed in field construction work in the Lighthouse
Service and work of a sim ilar character a t th e general lighthouse depot a t Tom pkinsville. N . Y .; 1,513
laborers in charge of post lights; and 1,343 m embers of crews of vessels.
e Includes employees on vessels retransferred from th e jurisdiction of th e N avy D epartm ent.
Com oar
able statistics in last year’s report showed a loss of 250 for th is Bureau.
d Includes 2 stenographers and typew riters authorized b y law, for n o t exceeding 6 m onths during the year*

The following table gives a summary of changes in the personnel
of the Department for the fiscal year ended June 30, 1919:
A ppointm ents.«
Perm anent.
Bureau.
Com­
peti­
tive.
Office of the Secretary............................

90
178

Ex­
cept­
ed.
2

U n­
classi­
fied.

Total.

Tem po­ Grand
total.
rary.

Promo­ R educ­
tions. tions.

104
666

186

488

27

59S
1* 4

**3 * 4
1x8

1,909
232

774

■4

76

23 7

303

98

*59

80

239

300

>

2.407

3*095

c 5 *5 ° 3
_______

4.147

x22

<7

290

76
410

,

Bureau of Foreign and Domestic
88
Bureau of S ta n d a rd s..............................
Bureau of Fisheries................................

554
94

*4

6

46
b

44*

Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey ..................

60

Steam boat-Inspection S ervice.............

*59

T o tal................................................

l, 708

xo

*45

6

54

23
3
79
14

° Includes app o in tm en ts of th e following characters: Presidential, b y selection from civil-service certifi­
cates, u n d e r E xecutive order, to excepted positions, b y reinstatem ent and b y reason of transfer w ithin
th e D epartm ent or from o th er d e p artm en ts or in d ep en d en t establishm ents.
&M ainly voluntary reductions accepted by employees to secure more desirable conditions of living.
c Includes a large n u m b er of ap p o in tm en ts by reason of increase of compensation.

44

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
Separations.«

Bureau.

From perm anent positions.
Competi­ E x ­
tive.
cepted.

Office of the S ecretary ............................

82
ias

3

372

Bureau of Foreign an d Domestic ComBureau of S ta n d a rd s...............................

U nclas­
sified.

2

T o ta l................................................

41
41
1,258

Grand
total.

Miscel­
laneous
changes.*»

87
995

X12
34

199
X,029

45

19 .........
X
5
2

89
378

58
1,127

i-50s

»9

2

;8
45
AT

89
36

4i3
Bureau of N avigation.............................

Total.

From
tem po­
rary po­
sitions.

2

81
■

’

...

32

88l

2,171

51:

1.764

3.935

23
X“
396

° Includes separations by reason of resignations, discontinuances, removals, deaths, transfers w ith in the
D epartm ent, an d transfers from th e D ep artm en t to other d epartm ents or independent establishm ents.
&Includes reappointm ents by reason of change of station, nam e, designation, extensions of tem porary
appointm ents, changes from tem porary to p erm anent statu s, etc.

In spite of the unusual number of losses of employees during
the last fiscal year and the difficulty of securing qualified ap­
pointees, the Department has maintained its policy of filling
upper-grade vacancies by promoting employees whenever possible
and discouraging the filling of such vacancies by making appoint­
ments from outside its service. This policy is well established
and is appreciated by the employees, who thereby have an incen­
tive to prepare themselves for more responsible duties, thus
acquiring a more general knowledge of the Department’s activities
and increasing their value to it. It also has a tendency to mini­
mize the desire to seek better-paid opportunities elsewhere, which
has become abnormally evident and causes much derangement of
governmental work.
Among certain classes of the Department’s employees where
outside competition was keen, the Department, in order to main­
tain efficient service, has been compelled from time to time to
increase the salaries paid. In no other manner was it possible to
retain a sufficient force among such classes as mechanics, crews,
and officers of vessels, etc.
The following table shows a net decrease in the average amount
of leave utilized by employees during the last year, in spite of a
considerable increase in the amount of sick leave used, resulting

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

45

from the epidemic of Spanish influenza prevalent in the latter
part of 1918:
T o ta l a n d A v e r a g e A m o u n t o f A n n u a l a n d S ic k L e a v e , b y B u r e a u s , S t a t e d
S e pa r a t e l y a n d T o g e t h e r , T a k e n b y E m p l o y e e s o f t h e D e pa r t m e n t in t h e
D i s t r i c t o f 'C o l u m b i a , A r r a n g e d A c c o r d i n g t o S e x , D u r i n g t h e C a l e n d a r
Y e a r 1918, a n d A v e r a g e L e a v e f o r 1917.
M A L E.
A nnual leave.«
B ureau.

Number.b

A ver­
age.

Days.
Office of the Secretary...............
Bureau of the Census................
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce...........................
Bureau of S ta n d a rd s.................
Bureau of Fisheries...................
Bureau of Lighthouses.............
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey __
Bureau of N avigation...............
Steam boat-Inspection Service.
Total and average...........

67
283

Sick leave.
Days.
r

A ver­
age.

Total.
Days.

A ver­
age.

A ver­
age,
1917.

1,711

25- 54

514

7- 67

2,225

3 3 -2 1

28. 55

8,030

28.37

2.284

8 .0 7

10 ,3 14

36 .45

3 4 - 83

35- 1 7

74

1 .9 7 9

26.74

-s s

10.61

2,764

37- 35

398

5.880

14- 77

2.096

5- 27

7,9 7 6

20. 04

24- 59

41

1.0 4 7

25- 54

247

6. 02

I, 294

3 1-5 6

3 0 72
3 3 - 78

21

597

28.43

221

10. 52

818

38 .95

128

3 ,5 7 8

27- 95

1,230

9. 61

4,808

3 7 - 56

3 2 . 24

16

386

24- 13

64

4.00

450

28. I3

32.

5

132

26. 40

50

10. 00

182

36.40

29. OO

I »033

23.340

22. 59

7,4 9 1

7- 25

30,831

29. 85

3O. 7O

I?

FE M A L E .
Office of the Secretary..............
Bureau of the Census................
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce..........................
Bureau of S ta n d a rd s.................
Bureau of Fisheries...................
Bureau of Lighthouses.............
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey__
Bureau of N avigation...............
Steamboat-Inspection Service.
Total and average...........

43

I; I86

27-58

472

■ 0.98

1,6 5 8

38. 56

3 5 - 29

245

7 .3 4 5

29. 98

3 .2 1 7

. 3 - 13

10.562

43- II

41. 85

26

744

78. 62

429

l6. 5O

1 . 173

4 5 * 12

37- 62

26

482

28. 54

200

7. 69

682

26. 23

5f . 00

22

64O

20. 09

253

IT. 50

893

40. 59

41 - 57
53- SO

4

II8

29 - S®

68

17. OO

186

46 .50

20

573

28. 65

256

12. 80

829

41. 45

42. 29

7

210

30. OO

82

I I . 71

292

41. 71

42. S3

120

30. OO

36

9. OO

156

3 9 - OO

5 .0 13

12. 63

16 ,431

4 ri .19

41. 08

4
397

11,418

28. 76

TO T A L.
Office of the Secretary.............
Bureau of the Census..............
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce...........................
Bureau of Sta n d a rd s.................
Bureau of Fisheries...................
Bureau of Lighthouses.............
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey __
Bureau of N avigation...............
Steam boat-Inspection Service.
T otal and average...........

no
S»8

2,897
15.375

26.34

986

8.96

3,883

3 5 " 30

3«. 8l

29. 12

5.501

IO. 42

20,876

3 9 - 54

3 7 - 97

3 5 - «O

ZOO

2 .723

- 7-

214

12. 14

3 .9 3 7

39*37

424

6,362

15-00

2, 296

5 -41

8.658

20. 42

24 85

63

26.

77

500

7 -94

2 .18 7

34- /I

.13- 67

25

1.677
7I5

28. 60

289

II- 56

x.004

40. 16

3 5 - 30

148

4 . IS*

28. c s

1.48 6

10. 04

5 , 6 )7

38.09

3 3 - 17

23

596

25- 9 *

146

742

32. 26

3 3 - 56

9

253

28.00

86

6.35
956

338

3 7 - 56

29. OO

1.430

34 ,75 8

24- 30

12,504

8.74

4 7 ,263

3 3 -05

3 3 -3 0

23

1,

a In th e count of th e an n u al leave, all periods of one-half day and over were counted as full days; periods
of less th a n one-half d ay were om itted.
6 Only those employees were included who are considered as being en titled to th e full yearly allowance
of both annual and sick leave.

46

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Superannuation and Retirement.
The annual reports of this Department during the past six
years have presented the subject of retirement of superannuated
and disabled Government employees. Hence it may hardly be
necessary to add further expression of my views; yet I regard the
subject as of such importance that I must not leave undone
anything within my power to advance it. I look at it from the
standpoint of common justice, on the one hand, and from that of
efficient service, on the other hand. Large private concerns
recognize that a lifetime spent in their service carries with it an
obligation of honor toward the employee who has thus served
faithfully when years make him incapable of further effective
work. The business house that would turn out an aged employee,
saying to him in substance “ Now look out for yourself” after a
long and good record would be damned by the common opinion
of the business world, and deservedly so. The only conceivable
excuse that could be made would be that the employer had paid
during the long service a sufficient salary over and above all the
exigencies of life to have enabled the employee to provide himself
for his own old age. No one will charge the Government with
doing that. Failure to be as just in these matters as private
concerns are, injures the Government either by causing the
ambitious to seek better opportunities elsewhere or by relaxing
the efforts of its employees generally through the unconscious
drag that comes from hopeless service. The result of the present
condition is seen in the survival of many old people in the Govern­
ment work who struggle on because they needs must, when they
should have ceased from their labors. Enactments requiring these
aged workers to be discharged are substantially repealed by the
higher law of humanity. They are demoted and maintained at
reduced pay, thus creating what is in substance a pension with­
out retirement, without the dignity of a recognition by the Gov­
ernment of their worth, and maintaining the inefficiency which
everyone seeks to remove.
I am not especially concerned as to the details of any measure
that may ameliorate this evil. During the present Congress many
bills have been introduced for this purpose, one, the LehlbachSterling bill, has passed the House of Representatives and has
been introduced into the Senate. It may, perhaps, be susceptible
of improvement, but it is a recognition of a claim and an attempt
to remove an incubus on the wheels of governmental business.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

47

It is to be hoped that the bill may shortly become law, and thus
at once justly provide for those who have served many years,
open the door to more rapid promotion and to larger opportuni­
ties for younger and more active employees, and make the Govern­
ment work more efficient not only through the removal of ineffectives, but by the unconscious but very real self-discipline that
comes in response to wise and far-seeing treatment of the employee.
I firmly believe that after a year of experience with any sound
retirement system no voices will be lifted against it.
Salaries.
The Department has followed its usual practice of filling vacan­
cies by promoting the clerks in the service instead of filling the
higher-salaried positions with appointees from the civil-service
registers without experience in Government work. It has been
shown by experience to be a wise course, for it gives to every
clerical employee assurance that faithful attendance to duty will
bring about promotion in due time. It has developed, however,
that many of the $900 positions can not be filled permanently, as
that entrance salary, even including the bonus of $240 allowed
during the present year, possesses no attraction as compared with
the compensation offered by private employers. Competent
clerks could be secured before the war at an entrance salary of
$900. They can not be had now. The positions that are thus
vacant are needed for the work of the Government. The inability
to fill them reduces the force, already insufficient, and imposes an
undue strain upon employees in the higher grades whose duties
are already heavy.
The present $900 entrance salary for clerks should be abolished.
Even with the bonus it is not sufficient to secure experienced
clerks, notably stenographers and typewriters, who can readily
obtain from $1,200 to $1,500 per annum elsewhere. There is a
chronic dearth of this class of eligibles on the registers of the
Civil Service Commission. The entrance compensation for clerks
should be at least $1,200 per annum, which is not more than is
paid in many places for common labor.
The Nolan minimum compensation bill now before Congress is
an attempt to minimize the hardship involved in the combination
of low salary and high cost of living in cases where it bears most
heavily. It ig, however, but a partial solution of the problem.
It is hoped that systematic and adequate relief in this respect
will be accomplished through the work of the congressional Joint

48

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Commission on Reclassification of Salaries established under the
act of March i, 1919.
The Department has cooperated actively with the joint Com­
mission on Reclassification of Salaries and hopes that the studies
of that commission will result in an improvement of existing con­
ditions. The plain fact is that many of the Government workers
are to-day unable to live, even with the severest economy, upon
the pay winch they receive. They are forced to run into debt,
are obliged to seek separate means of adding to their income, or
are forced to withdraw from the service because other employers
are more appreciative than the Government of existing conditions.
The legislative, executive, and judicial appropriation act ap­
proved March 1, 1919, provides $240 per annum increase of
compensation for the fiscal year 1920, in lieu of the $120 bonus
allowed during the past fiscal year, in recognition of the necessity
under present living conditions for upward revision of salaries.
This but partially meets current necessities. The temporary
increase is not comparable with the increase in the cost of living.
If, to the high prices of all necessary articles required for living,
there be added the demands for subscriptions to Government
loans, to the Red Cross, calls for the purchase of War Savings
Stamps, and other outlays which, however fine, useful, or even
thrifty, still call for payment from a fixed sum of amounts which
are large in proportion thereto— if, let it be repeated, these de­
mands are aggregated and against them is weighed the fact that
during one fiscal year a bonus of but $120 was added and in a
second year a bonus of $240, it must be evident not only that
these bonuses are hopelessly inadequate to meet the situation,
but that the net result of the pressure upon many faithful and
hard-working people has been really tragic. It is astonishing
how generous the working force of this Department has been in
matters of public helpfulness (see detailed description on p. 66)
when the conditions of life have been so hard.
/
There have, furthermore, been cases where real injustice has
been done. In the Lighthouse Service the salaries of keepers
have been raised by the act of Congress approved June 20, 1918.
In the same Service the wages of seamen and officers on board
vessels have also been raised, following the official action of the
Navy Department and the Shipping Board. This, however, has
left the field supervising and clerical force where they were before
the war, save for the bonus. The result has been an actual dis­
crimination against a portion of a service quite as worthy as those

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

49

who have been more favored. Yet the requests made of Con­
gress for funds sufficient to remove this act of real injustice have
been refused. Under date of August 14, 1919, the superintendent
of the eighteenth lighthouse district (San Francisco, Calif.) wrote
the Commissioner of Lighthouses as follows:
The base pay of $960 per annum with a bonus of S240 per annum is practically the
lowest paid b y any Government service in this city , and only the poorer class of
eligibles w ill accept an appointment in this district. It is feared that with this low
base pay a class of clerks far below the average in efficiency w ill enter the Lighthouse
Service and in the course of time prove a very serious handicap to the handling ol
the district work.

Indeed the funds allotted for the Lighthouse Service in all re­
spects, whether as to keepers’ salaries, the wages of seamen and
officers on vessels, or the wages of its field supervising and clerical
force, are far from sufficient to carry that Service through the
fiscal year, and a very considerable sum will be necessary unless
the work of that Service is to be actually shut off in large part
before the year closes.
During the last two years the Bureau of Standards has lost
nearly or quite 50 per cent of its technical staff. This applies to
all grades of trained scientific and technical men, but is especially
true of the leaders in specific lines. The salaries of these men in
the laboratories of the industries or in consultation work are
usually double those which the Bureau of Standards is permitted
to pay. To make this entirely clear a table is given below in which
the names are represented by letters, stating actual cases of ex­
perts who have left the service for other salaries and giving the
salaries paid elsewhere:
Bureau
salary.

Salary
outside.

Name.

T itle a t Bureau.

A .........

Chief of paper section................

$2,700

$7, 2 0 0

B .........

3 >3 ©o

5 ,0 0 0

C ..........

Senior associate physicist in
m etallurgical division.
Electrical engineer.....................

D .........

Chief of tex tile section..............

2 ,5 0 0

E .......... Associate physicist, in charge
paper laboratory.

3 ,5 0 0

F .......... Chief, m agnetic la b o ra to ry .. . .

2,

G .........

3 ,5 3 0

Gas engineer................................

3 ,3 0 0

500

4,500 and
promise.
A bout
double.
N early
double.

T itle outside.
Director of departm ent of technical
control of th e largest paper concern
in the country.
Research m etallurgist in large m etal
corporation.
Electrical engineer.
Consulting tex tile expert.
H ead of research utilization aud new
developm ents in a large paper con­
cern operating 12 mills.
Consulting expert.

Tw o or
three tim es
mo re.«
3» 300 Gas engineer in large gas corporation.

o Refused’outside offer of $7,500.
1 4 0 2 6 1

—

------- 4

50

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The following table gives cases in which private firms have
offered the technical experts of the Bureau of Standards higher
salaries than those they are receiving. In some of these cases the
experts were asked by outside employers to name their own price,
yet they have remained at the Bureau of Standards at a personal
sacrifice, which it is wholly unfair as well as unwise to ask them
longer to continue.
Name.

Title a t Bureau.

H .........

Chief, division of ceramics and
optical glass.
Physicist an d chief of the
m etallurgical division.

I ...........

Optical-glass e x p e rt...................
Associate physicist and m etallographist.
l .......... Chief, gage section......................
...........
K .........

j

a

B ureau
salary.

Salary
outside.

$4,800

$10,000

4,000

7 »5 °°

2,500
2,700

5,000
4,©oo

3,000

° 5 >o°°

T itle outside.

Ceramics chief.
Scientific m etallurgist in charge of
A merican end of large m etal corpora­
tion.
Technical expert in optical-glass factory.
M etallograpliist in alum inum corpora­
tion.
Chief of gage m anufacture in large in­
d u strial concern.

C ontract arranges for increase; base salary is guaranteed.

The above examples are chosen from the higher grades, but
facts in the same proportion exist in all grades of the scientific
and technical staff. If this process is to continue, many lines of
the bureau’s investigational work will have to be abandoned.
The best we can hope to do at the low salaries now provided is to
maintain a few untrained men for routine and testing work, and
even this will suffer for lack of proper supervision.
The Bureau of Standards has more than ioo specialized lines of
scientific and technical work. Each demands an expert of expe­
rience and ability, able to plan and supervise research and testing
of a superior grade. The bureau can not pay the salaries de­
manded by men who are already trained and have the requisite
administrative experience, since there are but 30 positions in the
grades from $3,000 to $3,500 per annum, inclusive.
A critical situation, therefore, arises, since, even when the bu­
reau trains competent men and fits them to become chiefs of sec­
tions, the industries pick them off as fast as they become thor­
oughly competent. The reason is solely the low salaries the
bureau is able to pay and (even at such salaries) the relatively
small number of good positions compared with the number of
specialized fields in the bureau. The case becomes even more
serious when it is remembered that the Bureau of Standards is

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

51

expected to be the leader in each of these specialized fields of
scientific and technical work.
At least 10 Government boards and commissions have chiefs
who receive in excess of that paid at the Bureau of Standards.
The salaries of such chiefs range from $7,500 to $12,000 for train­
ing and experience not more highly technical or exacting than that
required for the Bureau of Standards. The highest technical
salary (apart from Director) at the Bureau of Standards is $4,800.
The following partial list shows Government positions paying
in excess of the bureau’s maximum :
Federal Trade Commission:
5 commissioners..................... $10,000
5,000
i secretary...............................
U. S. Tariff Commission:
Chairman.................................
7, 500
7, 500
5 commissioners.....................
Secretary.................................
5, 000
U. S. Shipping Board:
5 commissioners.....................
7, 500
Secretary.................................
5,000
5, 000
3 special exp erts....................
Chief counsel.......................... 10,000
Board of Mediation, etc. :
7, 500
Commissioner.........................
Assistant commissioner........
5,000
Interstate Commerce Commis­
sion:
9 commissioners..................... 10,000
Secretary'.................................
5, 000
Federal Board for Vocational
Education :
Chief of division....................
2 chiefs of division s..............
2 assistant directors..............
1 assistant director................

6,000
5,000
4, 500
4,250

Pan American Union:
Director gen eral.................... $7, 500
Assistant d irecto r..................
4, 700
Federal Reserve Board:
Chairman,
Secretary
of
Treasury (ex officio).
G o vern o r................................. 12,000
Vice govern or........................ 12, 000
3 members............................... 12, 000
Comptroller of Currency (ex
officio) ( p l u s
$5,000,
Comptroller’s salary)........
7,000
Secretary.................................
9,000
6, 000
1 chief of d iv isio n ................
1 chief of division .................
5, 500
International Joint Commission:
Chairman.................................
7, 500
7, 500
2 commissioners.....................
4,000
Secretary.................................
Panama Canal :
General purchasing o ffice r..
4, 620
Inspecting engineer..............
4,400
Chief clerk purchasing de­
partm ent..............................
4,000
Assistant auditor....................
4,000
Assistant engineer.................
3, 720
I

The above table shows that 19 positions outside of the Bureau
of Standards pay double the maximum expert salary. Salaries
of $10,000 and over per annum are not at all unusual with large
industrial corporations for experts carrying on scientific and
technical work; yet these men thus paid are those who consult the
experts of the Bureau of Standards and are assisted by them.
It would be interesting to compare the salaries paid in the Rail­
road Administration not only with those given members of the
Cabinet, but those paid the heads of country-w'ide services em­
ploying thousands of men and large equipment. It is a plain
truth that on the whole the insufficiency of Government salaries
in the higher, responsible positions approaches the scandalous.

52

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

By the act of Congress approved July 2, 1918, the pay of the
inspectors of the Steamboat-Inspection Service was materially
increased. The increase was, however, not as great as it should
have been, nor proportionate with the increase received by men
in outside employment doing the same kind of work.
The clerks in the Steambpat-Inspection Service should also
receive an increase in pay. The work of the field clerks of the
Steamboat-Inspection Service is of a peculiar nature. It is well
known that the maritime law is entirely different from the com­
mon law, and that the rules and procedure in admiralty are
entirely different from the other procedure, and in the same way
the organization of the Steamboat-Inspection Service is peculiar
to itself. No other bureau in the Government has as many
unusual and peculiar conditions to meet as the SteamboatInspection Service. The clerks must, therefore, be especially
trained for the work they have to do before they are in any way
efficient. The expansion in shipping has been tremendous, and
incident thereto an enormous increase in the amount of work of
that service. This work has been done without a murmur, and,
as the inspectors have been rewarded, so should the clerks be.
The salaries for the vast majority of the classified positions in
the Bureau of Fisheries have remained virtually stationary for
about 30 years.
There is a large loss of effectiveness because of the grossly
inadequate salaries paid throughout the service, but especially
in the technical grades. It is unfair and demoralizing to employees
qualified in fish culture, biology, and fishery technique to receive
on the average much lower compensation than is given to unskilled
laborers in private business.
The bureau has 13 clerical positions at $900 each, and only 22
of higher grades, with salaries ranging from $1,000 to $1,800.
The service is overcrowded at the bottom, and there is little
opportunity for advancing capable and deserving employees.
From July 1, 1917, to July 1, 1919, there have been 16 resignations
in the $900 grade because better pay could be obtained elsewhere.
The present condition is very serious, due to the difficulty of
obtaining and retaining intelligent employees with ability and
initiative. The time of chiefs of division is occupied to such an
extent by routine -work that should be handled by subordinates
that they have altogether too little opportunity for the important
administrative matters of their divisions.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

53

A readjustment of salaries in the field force attached to hatch­
eries is imperative. The present rate of pay was established
more than a quarter of a century ago. The bureau for several
years has been unable to induce desirable and qualified persons
to enter this service at the meager compensation offered. The
statutory base pay for apprentice fish-culturists is from $600 in
the United States proper to $900 in Alaska; $900 to $1,200 for
fish-culturists and foremen; and $1,500 for station superin­
tendents. The latter officials are responsible for Government
property valued at thousands of dollars and for the efficient
operations of their respective hatcheries where important fishcultural operations are carried on. The lowest base compensa­
tion for the grades mentioned should be $900, $1,200, and $2,000,
respectively.
It must be remembered that the Bureau of Fisheries requires a
force especially equipped for its work. All of its employees must
be trained for the business, and before receiving permanent
appointments must pass a suitable civil-service examination.
The wage problem in the vessel service is a similar one. The
positions of assistants in charge of divisions require men with
long, technical training and experience and are now filled by
highly qualified persons whose work is most effective and meets
with the hearty support of the fishery interests and the general
public. The present salaries attached to these positions are
materially under those for corresponding positions or similar
service in other bureaus of the Government. In 12 bureaus of
3 departments, excluding the Bureau of Fisheries, the average
salary paid to a division chief or for similar positions is $3,473,
while in the latter Bureau it is $2,600.
The bureau is now faced with the serious problem of prevent
ing the inevitable deterioration of the service if it is to be com­
posed of only those who can find no other employment, those who
have independent means, or of those who will voluntarily forego
the privileges and responsibilities of family life or condemn their
children to the deprivation of many ordinary comforts and the
opportunities for special education.
I invite attention to the nature, extent, diversity, and amount
of the work performed by the Commissioner, Deputy Commis­
sioner, chief clerk, and chief of tonnage division of the Bureau of
Navigation in the hope that these officers may be paid properly.
All these officers are men who by long training and experience
are especially qualified for the work. The increase recommended

54

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

is not based entirely on the work of this bureau during the past
four years, which was increased rather than diminished by the
multiplication of marine agencies and the scattering of marine
work among them during the war. Although most of the statu­
tory work of the Bureau of Navigation continued to be performed
during this period, much of its time and efforts were required to
assist other branches of the Government, hurriedly organized,
and in consequence not conversant with all the subjects with
which they had to deal or with the acts of Congress governing
those subjects and not to be ignored.
My recommendation is based on the elementary principle that
the laborer is worthy of his hire. The Bureau of Navigation since
1884 by statute has general superintendence of the commercial
marine and merchant seamen. This general jurisdiction of late
years has been extended by the addition of new specific duties
developed by inventions and progress such as the administration
of laws relating to wireless apparatus and operators, motor-boat
legislation, and other services specially provided for. The essential
fact, however, is that we now have a merchant fleet in tonnage
alone almost double the commercial fleet of 1914. Of more
consequence, however, than the amount of tonnage is the fact
that we now have in foreign trade alone a tonnage equal to that
of our entire merchant fleet in 1914. During the current year
this fleet will probably be increased by nearly 4,000,000 gross
tons. In the foreign trade our ships must conform in many
respects to the laws of the countries they visit, and the whole
range of duties involved in Government supervision over and
cooperation with merchant shipping is thus extended and made
difficult by comparison with the simpler duties the Government
assumes in the regulation of the domestic or coasting trade.
My own observation accords with the views of practical shipping
men and shipbuilders that the great increase in our fleets and their
radius of commercial activity, due partly to the stimulation of
the early years of the war, partly to the great appropriations by
Congress after we entered the war, call for a better-paid and
increased force to deal with shipping matters. With the con­
currence of the Bureau of Navigation the necessary steps to
remedy this condition were held in abeyance during the war,
and since the end of the war nothing has been done in this con­
nection.
The Commissioner of Navigation is probably the country’s
leading expert in the law, customs, and practice of the maritime

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

55

profession. His long service of over a quarter of a century has
given him peculiar familiarity with our national maritime laws.
He is personally acquainted with the leading maritime officers,
private and public, of other nations, and his counsel is by them
sought and respected. It is a pitiful thing that such an officer
should have to serve for a salary as small as $4,000 per annum.
This is the smallest salary paid any bureau chief in the Department
of Commerce and less than is paid in other positions of inferior
authority.
The work of the Deputy Commissioner requires not only a
knowledge of the application of the many laws administered by
the bureau, but also judicial sense in the consideration annually
of about 7,000 applications for the mitigation or remission of
penalties in which he takes the pi'eliminarv action and makes
recommendations. Direct administrative supervision of the va­
rious services of the bureau in the field requires also good business
sense and promptitude. The Deputy Commissioner has amply
demonstrated to my own satisfaction, and, I am confident, to the
satisfaction of those who have dealings with this office, the pos­
session of those qualities.
Through long experience the chief clerk has an intimate ac­
quaintance with all phases of the bureau’s work and with its
relations to other branches of the service both here and in the
field which it is hard to assess in money terms. I know of very
few others who do so much wmrk on which general reliance for
accuracy must be placed who receive pay so incommensurate with
the work.
The record and statistical work of this bureau in charge of the
head of the tonnage division of only eight clerks is accepted as
authority both here and abroad, and during the past four years,
when attention has been focused on shipping, the work and fore­
casts of the chief of this division has stood all tests of criticism.
The salaries provided for the executive officers of the Bureau
of Foreign and Domestic Commerce are entirely inadequate for
the class of men demanded and the services performed. Increases
should be provided, at least, for the Director, the two Assistant
Directors, and the chief clerk. It is recommended that the salary
of the Director be raised to $8,000, of the First Assistant Director
to $4,500, and of the Second Assistant Director to $4,000, and
that the chief clerk be made an administrative assistant at $3,500.
A number of new positions should be provided in order to carry
on the more important work of the bureau, as well as in the cler-

56

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE

ical grades. Requests have, therefore, been made for one addi­
tional chief of section at $2,500, one at $2,250, and four at $2,000
each, and an increase of six assistant chiefs of divisions at $2,250.
Recommendations for 1 additional clerk at $1,800, 14 at $1,600,
2 at $1,400, and 56 at $1,200 are also submitted.
In arriving at the estimate for increases in the statutory force,
the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce believes that the
force recommended is the absolute minimum if it is to distribute
to the public properly and promptly the mass of material fur­
nished by its field employees, as well as by the consular officers
throughout the world.
As a result of the funds appropriated by Congress to meet the
increased cost of living abroad, the Bureau of Foreign and Domes­
tic Commerce was able to grant post allowances (which were
urgently needed) to the commercial attachés and their secre­
taries. Even with these increases in income, three of the attachés
resigned during the year to accept more remunerative positions
in private employ. It has been impossible at many posts to
obtain or retain capable secretaries because of the low salary
limit imposed by law and the exceptionally high cost of living
abroad.
The question of obtaining living salaries for the employees of
the Coast and Geodetic Survey is a vital one. This bureau was
organized in 1816; and is the oldest scientific arm of the Federal
Government. At its beginning the entire field force consisted of
the Superintendent at a salary of $6,000 per annum and the two
or three engineers under him, and necessarily the work, though
most important, was comparatively limited in extent. To-day
the field extends over and around the entire United States pos­
sessions, and the field and office force are commensurately greater
and the labor far more arduous. The only element that has not
largely increased is the recompense of the officers and men.
Beginning with the Superintendent, his salary 103 years ago was
$6,000 and still remains the same. The hydrographic and geo­
detic engineers, while receiving slight increases during the past
five years, should have years ago been paid salaries as large as
those paid officers in the Army and Navy performing similar
services.
Nearly 20 per cent of the commissioned officers of this service
have resigned during the period January 1 to October 1, 1919.
These officers give in every case as a reason the fact that they
can not live on the wages which the Government pays. As this

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

57

is written, there is published a statement respecting the officers
and men of the Navy to the effect that hundreds of naval officers
are resigning because of insufficient pay, and an increase is said to
be sought in the officers’ pay of 30 per cent and in the pay of
seamen of 50 per cent over the present rate. It is earnestly
hoped these increased recompenses may be permitted, and that
the bill providing for this increase may be amended to include
the commissioned personnel of the Coast and Geodetic Survey, as
requested by me in a letter dated October 1, 1919, to the Speaker
of the House of Representatives.
Further, the bureau has need for many more computers than
are now authorized, and the entrance and lower-grade salaries
should be made higher. There are portfolios of field observations
containing thousands of triangulation and precise leveling obser­
vations in the archives of the bureau that have never been com­
puted. Indeed, so inadequate is the computing force of the
bureau to meet the present needs, that the expedient has been
adopted of putting into print the results from the latest field work
and gradually working backward into the old material. If this
were not done, the work would be very many years old before it
would be put into print. As it is, the public is deprived of the
benefits of this information that has cost many years of labor and
many thousands of dollars. The cost of the computation and
printing would be but a fractional part of the expenditures that
have already been made. The publications of the bureau con­
taining triangulation and precise-level data are issued in a form
that is neither satisfactory nor economical. They met conditions
that existed years ago. In order to issue the publications, in the
form now most useful— that is, so that each of the State publica­
tions would contain all the data available at the time the publica­
tion was issued— would require additional computations in the
Washington office of the Survey.
The instrument makers of the Survey are trained along the lines
of a physicist and mechanical engineer, yet these experts, who
make the most delicate instruments in the world, arc in some cases
paid no higher salaries than a fair clerk, and in no case as high a
salary as he would receive in the Navy or Shipping Board.
One of the most conspicuous evidences of injustice is the marked
discrimination against the clerks. Of the number called “ clerks ”
in the Survey nearly half are specialists and have technical knowl­
edge that is of the greatest value to the Government; yet the
plea to have them properly designated and given just and fair

58

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

salaries has thus far gone unnoticed. The request to no longer
carry the $720 statutory places has been heard, but this is only a
beginning, and until it is realized further in the shape of tangible
action, the service must continue to suffer by resignations and
inability to fill the places except with incompetent persons. There
are but 43 clerks in the Survey, and during the past fiscal year 66
clerks left that service.
The bureau’s valuable and highly trained copper engravers have
been for years without salary increases, and now their righteous
dissatisfaction is evident, and unless action is taken in their behalf
the service will permanently suffer.
And so on down to the messengers and laborers. A man with
ambition will not work for $1.50 or $2 per diem when he can earn
$3 somewhere else in the Government service. This bureau has
had to hire boys to do men’s work, who on account of age and
education are totally unfit to fill the positions, and with such
conditions even boys will not stay long.
Transportation of Families and Effects of Officers and Employees.
It has been very difficult in the past, owing to the small salaries
we are able to pay, to secure properly qualified men to take charge
of our commercial-attaché offices abroad and to conduct special
investigations in the various foreign countries. One of the greatest
drawbacks has been the fact that in nearly every case the men
selected desire to take their families abroad, especially when they
are to remain abroad for an extended period. They also often
wish to take at least some household equipment. Under the
present scale of salaries we are denied the services of many highly
qualified men owing to their financial inability to take with them
their families and effects. To meet this situation I am recom­
mending that Congress allow $50,000 to pay the actual and
necessary expenses for transporting families and effects of officers
of this Department who are sent abroad on official business. It
hardly seems proper to require these men to pay, out of their own
pocket and from a small salary, expenses necessitated by Govern­
ment business, and which would not be otherwise incurred.
Transporting Remains of Officers and Employees Dying Abroad.
Under present
the family of the
pense of having
occurs at a time

conditions, if deaths occur in our force abroad,
deceased would have to assume the care and ex­
the remains returned to this country. This
when it is possible the financial affairs of the

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

59

deceased are in such condition that the family would be consider­
ably embarrassed. The State Department has a fund to provide
for such expenses, and I earnestly recommend that provision be
made to remove this weakness in our provision for foreign service.
An estimate has been submitted to Congress covering this
matter.
Printing and Binding.
The Department’s allotment of the appropriation for printing
and binding for the fiscal year ended June 30, 1919, was $400,000.
In addition, the allotment was credited to the extent of $23.47 for
miscellaneous blank forms furnished by the Coast and Geodetic
Survey to the Chief of Engineers, War Department, thus increasing
the amount to $400,023.47. Of this sum $399,961.32 was
expended, leaving an unused balance on June 30 of $62.15. From
allotments made to the Department from the national security
and defense fund there was expended for printing and binding the
sum of $5,573.96. The increase in expenditures in 1919, compared
with 1918, was $10,583.04 (or 2.68 per cent), the expenditures
in 1918 being $394,952.24.
During the decennial census period of three years beginning
July 1, 1919, the Bureau of the Census will not participate in the
Department printing and binding allotment, as the work for that
bureau, including the cost of completing operations on its work
remaining unfinished at the close of the fiscal year 1919, will be
paid for from the appropriation for the Fourteenth Census. The
estimated cost of unbilled and uncompleted work of the Depart­
ment, exclusive of that of the Bureau of the Census, at the Gov­
ernment Printing Office on July 1, 1919, and chargeable against
the allotment for 1920, was $27,117.40, while such work at the
Government Printing Office on the same date in 1918 actually
cost $43,615.41. Including the work of the Bureau of the Census,
the figures for this item for the past two years are as follows: 1919,
$64,994.75; 1918, $74,882.95. There was also at the Government
Printing Office at the close of the year work for the Department
chargeable against the national security and defense fund esti­
mated to cost $23,266.89.
During the fiscal year 1919 the Department issued on the
Public Printer 2,460 requisitions for printing and binding, com­
pared with 2,871 during the preceding fiscal year, a decrease of 411.
Of the requisitions issued in 1919 there remained at the close of
the fiscal year 174 on which deliveries of completed work had not

6o

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

been made, compared with 501 in 1918, 416 in 19x7, 379 in 1916,
436 in 1915, 355 in 1914, and 344 in 1913.
The following table shows the cost of printing and binding for
each of the bureaus, offices, and services of the Department during
the fiscal years 1918 and 1919, together with the increase or
decrease for each bureau, office, and service and the estimated
cost of the work on hand but not completed June 30, 1919:
I
Cost of work.

Increase ( 4 -) or
decrease ( —).

E stim ated
cost of
completed
June 30,
1919

B ureau, office, or service.

Office of the Secretary (Secretary, A ssistant
Secretary, Solicitor, Chief Clerk, and D ivi­
sion of Publications).......................................
A ppointm ent D ivision..............................
Disbursing Office............. ^ ........................
Division of Supplies....................................
B ureau of th e C ensus.........................................
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey ..............................
B ureau of Fisheries...........................................
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce
B ureau of Lighthouses......................................
Lighthouse Service......................................
B ureau of N avigation........................................
Shipping Service..........................................
R adio Service...............................................
B ureau of S ta n d a rd s..........................................
Office of the Supervising Inspector General,
Steam boat-Inspection Service......................
Steam boat-Inspection Service..................
Custom s Service.................................................. i

1918

1919

Cost.

P er cent.

$18.388.96

$17,112.36

651- 23
364.78
202. 55

Ó4 5 - 3 4
i, 101. 97

—$1,276.60
5-89
+
537-19
+
1 4 1 -7 7
+ 17,483-87
—1 5 , 0 0 3 . 14
" 2 , 9 7 0 .3 1
4 \ I , 5 8 l. 28
— 1, 9 9 1 .0 9
4 * 1,136.70
+ 3 , 9 5 4 - 12
+ 2 , 3 9 5 -4 7
+
188.15
— 3,090. 19

— 6.94
— .90
+ 95- il
+69.99
4 -x8 . 12
—32.89
—1 9 - 3 3
+ 1 -3 3
—IO. 71
+17-64
+30.65
4 - 6 9 . 63
-f42 06
~ 8 .6 7

— 572.36
+ 3 , 3 9 7 - >5
— 897- 04

—3 2 . 51
+ 34-6«
— 8.93

4 * 5 , 0 0 9 .0 8

4-

96,487-31
43,610.93
15.364- 28
118^617. 02
18,586.42
6 , 4 4 3 - 32

ta. 902. 86
3,44a 4s
4 4 7 - 29

35,638.74
i, 760.34
9 . 7 9 5 -13

3 4 4 -3 2
1 I 3 . 9 7 I-

18
30,607.79

12, 3 9 3 -9 7
120,198. 30

.6 , 5 9 5 - 3 3
7 , s8o. 02
16,856. 98
5,835- 92
635-44
32,548.55
x, 187.98
13,X92. 28

10,05a 63

9 . 153-59

T o tal............................................................ ' 394,952-24

399,961.32

E xpenditures chargeable against allotm ents
from the national security an d defense
fund:
W aste-Reclam ation Service...................... j
Ind ustrial Cooperation Service................. :.................
In dustrial B o ard ..........................................
Im port and export statistic s....................

1

T o ta l........................ ................................
G rand to ta l............................................... !|

3 9 4 . 9 5 2-2 4

684. 20

4*

I. 27

*3 5 1 - 16

58. 22
37,877.35
6,456. 30
1» 738- 70
13. 4 1 7 -9 4
I 9 t - 1.1

4 4 - 55
109. 93
170. 84

3-288. 9 5

3X
6 . OO
9 7 3 -6 8

a

64,9 9 4 - 75

684.20

4,854-43
3 5 - 33

+ 4.854-43
+
3 5 -3 3

4-100.00
4-100.00

10,000. 00

5. 573-96

+

4 -xoo.

00

23, 266. 89

2.68

88,261.64

13,266. 89

4 0 5 , 5 3 5 - 28

5 , 5 7 3 -9 6

4 -10,583.04

4-

a Of th is am o u n t $37,877-35 *s f°r worh ordered b y th e B ureau of th e Census, which will be paid for from
the appropriation for th e F ou rteen th Census an d will not be chargeable against the D epartm ent’s allotm ent
for printing and b inding for 1920.

The amount and cost of each class of work during the fiscal years
1918 and 1919 are shown in the following statement:

6l

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
Class.

1918

1919

N um ber.

B lank form s............................................................................... 25.605, 702
Reports, pam phlets, e tc .......................................................... 4*560,340
L etterheads................................................................................ 3,360,000
58,000
Envelopes...................................................................................
1,562,625
Circulars, sum m aries, an d notices.......................................
1,318,500
Index cards................................................................................
Guide cards and folders...........................................................
151.817
M emorandum sheets...............................................................
2, 240,000
74.578
B lank books...............................................................................
2,819
Miscellaneous books (b in d in g )..............................................
C o st.

Blank form s............................................................................... $52,441-17
Reports, pam phlets, e tc ......................................................... 305,761.33
L etterheads................................................................................
5,380.60
Envelopes...................................................................................
146.97
Circulars, sum m aries, and notices.......................................
4,083.13
Index cards................................................................................
1,153-60
2, 779. 80
Guide cards and folders..........................................................
M emorandum sheets...............................................................
2,122.46
Blank books............................................................................... 14,348.41
Miscellaneous books (b in d in g )..............................................
6,055.63
Miscellaneous.............................................................................
679.14
T o ta l.................................................................................

3 9 4 .9 5 2 -3 4

N um ber.

25,801,745
3.601,129
3,464,000
4.324*50°
236,700
i ,706,700
265,700
2,630,000
69,629
3,288
C o st.

$58,650.45
305.279. 76
6,253-41
1 , 7 5 4 -2 1
I , 703.62
2,167.73
1 .7 9 2 .9 S

1,832.86
20,022.95
5,116.37
960.94
4 0 S , 5 3 5 - 28

Increase ( + ) or de­
crease ( —).
P e r c e n t.

N um ber.

0. 77
196,043 421-03
9 5 9 . a ii
+ 104,000 +
3* 10
+4,266,500 +7,356.03
— , 3 2 5 .9 2 5 84-8s
29. 44
+ 388,200 +
l6 6 ,II 7
38-47
+ 3 9 0 ,0 0 0 +
1 7 -4 1
183.30
+
4 S.OSI +
ifi- 83
5 31 +

C o st.

P e r c e n t.

n-82
+ $6,209.28 +
. 16
481.57 872.81 +
16. 22
+
+ 1,607. 24 + 1 0 9 3 -58
- 2 , 3 7 9 -5 1 58.28
87.91
+ 1 , 0 1 4 - 13 +
986.82 3 5 - 50
18. 18
389. 60 + 5.674 - 5 4 +
3 9 - 55
9 3 9 -26 1 5 -Si
41.49
28I. 80 +
+
+ 10,583.04

+

2.68

The following table summarizes the publication work of each
bureau of the Department for the fiscal years 1918 and 1919:
Bureau or office.

Office of the Secretary......................
Bureau of the Census........................
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey .............
Bureau of F isheries..........................
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic
Com m erce........................................
Bureau of L ighthouses...................
Bureau of N avigation......................
Bureau of S ta n d a rd s........................
Steam boat-Inspection Service.......
T o ta l.........................................
.Services for which expenditures
were chargeable against allotm ents from th e n ational security and defense fund:
Industrial Cooperation Service
T o ta l.........................
Grand total ............................

Publica­
tions.

Copies printed for
D epartm ent.

Pages.

Cost.o

1918
1918 19x9 1918 1919 19x8
19*9
1919
70 82 2,860 2,212 231.050 964,350 $6,909-31 $12.947-92
83 49 4.528 17,282 427,87s 2X5,35° 73.150-95 86,301. 14
ss 40 5.378 3.4S8 93.600 88.050 37-775-82 26.927.71
91 65 2.852 I,808 981■ 840 159-35° 13,833-.8 6,014-94
544 554 16,373 17.519 2.235,850 2,368,900 107.35938 1141848.02
too
93 3.5X7 2,91° 309,050 327.65° 19,129.So 16,521. XO
r6 8 1,576 2.047 22.065 25,025 12,435-29 15.°97-34
is* 104 4.591 5.169 238,95° 215.15° 23,15469 19,180.87
24 21 970 886 263,900 274.900 6,634.33 8,600.85
1,141 I,Ol6 42,644 S3-29" 4.8O4.l80 4,638 72s 300,382. 7s 306,440-49

a
I

4.822. 70
3,000
6
3
,0
0
0
447
1,141 1,0X9 42,644 53.138 4,804,lS0 4.701.725 300.382.75 3iX.896.24
4O8

~

* Figures relate to publications actually delivered to th e Department, during th e year; consequently they
do not agree w ith sim ilar figures in a preceding tab le giving th e cost of work done b y the G overnm ent
Printing Office d uring th e fiscal year. F req u en tly th e cost of a publication is charged against allotm ents
for tw o or more fiscal years.

62

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

More than 75 per cent of the allotment for printing and binding
for the Department is expended for publications of various kinds,
and to keep such expenditures within due bounds careful editing
and preparation of manuscripts are necessary. This work re­
quires not only long experience and careful training, but a certain
degree of natural aptitude on the part of editorial clerks. Owing
to the limited salaries available, it has not always, or even as a
rule, been possible to procure and retain the best talent in this
line. A great deal has been accomplished, however, by the De­
partment’s editorial clerks, whose knowledge of matters having to
do with the production of books has resulted in many economies.
At the same time much attention has been given to the matter of
mproving the character of publications.
The volume of work now devolving on the few editorial clerks
in the Division of Publications is so great that all of it can not
possibly be given the attention that it requires. Every folio of
manuscript should be carefully read, edited, and prepared before
being forwarded to the Government Printing Office, and every
proof should be revised as carefully before being returned to the
printer. To do this work properly would require several addi­
tional clerks, and the Department’s personnel estimates for 1921
will include an increase in the editorial and proof-reading force of
the division. It is believed that the results would abundantly
justify the increased expenditure.
The Department issues annually, with monthly supplements, a
pamphlet containing a complete list of its publications available
either for free distribution by the Department or by purchase
from the Superintendent of Documents. The free distribution of
many of the publications of the Department is limited, the mis­
cellaneous distribution being made through the Superintendent
of Documents on a sales basis. On January x, 1919, under special
authority of Congress (sec. 4, act of June 20, 1918), the light and
buoy lists issued by the Bureau of Lighthouses were placed on a
sales basis, the free distribution being confined to official uses.
The following statement gives the number of copies of the pub
lications of the Department sold by the Superintendent of Docu­
ments during 1918 and 1919 and the amount received from such
sales:

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
Copies.

63
Receipts.

Sales.

T o ta l.................................................................................
a

1918

« 1919

1918

0 1919

a ,884.213

2.478,186
116,465

$15,921.04
16,965. 75

$19.451. 20

90.047
2.974.260

2,594.651

32,8*6. 79

42.550.94

2 3 . 099- 74

Prelim inary figures.

Coast pilots, inside route pilots, tide tables, and charts are sold
by the Coast and Geodetic Survey, receipts from these sales being
$24,620.71 in 1919 and $20,194.19 in 1918. Thus, the total re­
ceipts from sales of publications of the Department was $67,171.65
in 1919 and $53,080.98 in 1918.
During the last fiscal year 3,800,503 publications and printed
circulars of the Department were distributed to the public through
the Division of Publications, compared with 3,863,594 during the
fiscal year 1918.
There were received and acted on during the year 57,738 requests
for 419,689 copies of publications, compared with 61,538 requests
for 568,703 copies in 1918.
Mailing lists for use in sending typewritten or multigraphed
information, as well as publications, are maintained by the
Department. On July 1, 1919, there were 349 of such lists,
containing 285,928 names.
During the year the Department expended $2,969.21 for adver­
tising for proposals for furnishing supplies of various kinds, for
construction work, and for the purchase of condemned property.
“ International Price Comparisons” Publication.
The War Industries Board had compiled valuable information
on the subject of international price comparisons, but about the
time this data was in such shape that it was ready for publication
the board ceased to exist. The Department published it under
the above title, in view of its importance to the commerce and
industry of the country.
Motor-Vehicle Equipment.
The motor-vehicle equipment of that part of the Department in
the Commerce Building has been increased by one 500-pound
truck for light hauling and special-delivery work.

64

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The following table shows the operation data for the fiscal
year 1919 relating to this equipment:
500
lîo im d
tru c k .

1 , 50 0 Pound
tru ck .

2 ,0 0 0 pound
tru ck .

i- c y lin 2 - c y lin d e r m o t o r d e r m o to r
c y c le .
c y c le .

M i l e a g e ................................................................................................................

5 » 743

8 ,6 1 7

1 1 ,5 0 4

3 .0 9 8

O p e r a t i n g d a y s ............................................................................................

168

3or

288

129

43

A v e r a g e m i l e s p e r d i e m ........................................................................

3 4 - 18

2 8 .6 3

3 9 - 94

24. 03

23- 26

i . 000

G a s o l i n e c o n s u m p t i o n ( g a l l o n s ) ....................................................

438

967

1 *3 4 -’

80

55

M i l e s p e r g a l l o n o f g a s o l i n e ................................................................

x.V IX

8 .9 1

8* 57

3 6 73

18 . 18

C y l i u d e r - o i l c o n s u m p t i o n ( g a l l o n s ) ............................................

12. 88

6 3 .1 9

71 . 56

6 .3 I

I- *3

M i l e s p e r g a l l o n o f o i l .............................................................................

4 4 5 - 89

1 3 6 .3 7

I6O. 76

49O. 9 7

884. 96

Stock and Shipping Section.
There were received and filled by the stock and shipping section
during the year 7,079 requisitions for supplies of all kinds, of which
2,918 were for the offices and bureaus of the Department located
in Washington and 4,161 were for the outside services. Of the
total number of requisitions received 1,896 were for blank forms,
551 were for printed stationery, and 4,632 were for miscellaneous
stationery supplies.
Filling the 4,161 requisitions for the outside services required
the packing and shipping of 6,457 pieces, weighing 201,438
pounds, or nearly 100% tons, of which 4,957 pieces, weighing
112,026 pounds, were sent by ordinary mail, 214 pieces, weighing
1,363 pounds, were sent by registered mail, and 1,286 pieces,
weighing 88,049 pounds, were sent by freight or express.
The following table show's the number of books and blanks
sent to each of the outside services during the year:
Service.

Custom s Service (B ureau of N avigation and Foreign and Domestic Commerce).

B lank
books.

9 ,4 7 4

204
11,652

B lank
forms.
1,805,801
509,4x7
772, 9 3 *

B ureau of Navigation:
357

216,761
418
T o tal...............................................................................................................................

249,7 9 ?

230, 960
116, 205
653,183
164,255
4 ,25 2,752

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

65

The following statement gives the quantity of each class of
printed stationery supplied during the year:
Letterheads..............................
855,500 1 Blank forms..............................
383,672
Memorandum sheets............... 2,936,000 ! Index cards.............................. 1,572,400
Embossed letterheads.............
7, 500 Guide cards.................................
179,150
Stenographers’ notebooks.......
3, 676 j Vertical folders.........................
75,300
Blank books.............................
6, 702 Continuation sheets....................
497,000

Department Library,
The activities of the Department’s library included the acquisi­
tion of 2,244 bound volumes and 562 pamphlets, compared with
3,396 volumes and 926 pamphlets for the previous year. In
addition, about 1,500 books were carded and filed.
Duplicates disposed of numbered 2,250 and 574 books were
oorrowed from the Library of Congress and other libraries.
Weekly and monthly periodicals were currently received, recorded,
and sent to divisions of the various bureaus. The reference work
is increasing daily and the library is in constant use by the bureaus.
During the year the library has been of great assistance to
other departments and Government establishments in connection
with research work incident to war activities.
Division of Supplies.
The Division of Supplies handled 2,787 requisitions during the
year, and the clerical work in connection therewith included the
writing of 4,446 orders and 7,040 invoices, and the issuance of 2,158
sets of proposals. Supplies ordered through the division during
the fiscal year reached a total value of $198,361.85, and 4,324
vouchers were audited for payment.
Receipts from the sale of old and condemned furniture, office
equipment, and miscellaneous other property of no other use to
the Department amounted to $216.08.
The cost of the 273 new typewriters purchased during the year
was $18,124. Deducting the allowance on old machines of
$2,218.50, shows a total net cost of $15,905.50, and an average
of $58.26 each.
State Fair Exhibits.
This Department’s participation in a joint Government exhibit
for the summer and fall State fairs was necessarily restricted
through lack of any fund from which expense of preparing
exhibits could be paid. The agricultural appropriation bill pro­
vides a fund for exhibit work, but this fund is limited entirely
140261—19----- 5

66

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

to that Department. However, the Bureaus of Standards, Fish­
eries, and Lighthouses, the Coast and Geodetic Survey, and the
Steamboat-Inspection Service contributed such material as was
in their possession. Because of the unusual educational value
of such activities, appropriation should be made for real work
along this line.
Liberty Loans.
The employees of the Department have done their part nobly
and patriotically toward financing the war. The number of sub­
scribers and the total subscriptions for each loan are shown in the
following table:
S ub­
scribers.
a, 5*6
3 >3 7 7
4 .7 9 3

Victory L iberty L o a n ........................................................................................................
Total in b o n d s..........................................................................................................

S, 8.9
4,607

S ub­
scriptions.
$500,850.00
604, 700.00
607, 550- 00
883,650. 00
846; 050. 00
3,442,800. 00
**5>430.03

The sales of War Savings and Thrift Stamps cover a period of
18 months, January i, 1918, to June 30, 1919. The stamps are
being regularly purchased by the employees, there being wellorganized committees in each bureau to handle and promote their
sale.
Contributions.
The employees contributed liberally during the year to the
numerous drives for the Red Cross, United War Work Campaign,
Relief in the Near East, the Victory Memorial Building, and other
worthy and patriotic causes.
Employees’ Relief Association.
On April 16, 1919, the U. S. Department of Commerce Imme­
diate Relief Association was organized, its object being to make
immediate payment in cash to the family on the death of a member.
Two death benefits have already been paid, both within an
hour after notification of death, and the relief furnished was
prompt and substantial.

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

67

Purchase of Dutch Harbor, Alaska.
I renew the recommendation made in my reports for 1915, 1916,
1917, and on page 44 of my report for 1918, that the Government
should purchase Dutch Harbor, the abandoned village of the
North American Commercial Co. in Alaska.
Abolition of the Official Register.
The recommendation made on page 44 of mv annual report for
last year, for the abolition of the the Official Register, provided
for by House bill 2354, is renewed. This publication represents
a waste of paper and labor, since tire purpose for which it was
intended is no longer served by it. The card system for which
the measure provides would be less expensive and far more
efficient.
Work of the Solicitor’s Office.
During the fiscal year ended June 30, 1919, 217 contracts,
totaling $1,541,221, together with 18 contracts of indeterminate
amounts; 91 leases, amounting to $423,938; 20 revocable licenses
amounting to $3,801; 2 deeds in the sum of $3,305; 108 contract
bonds, amounting to $323,796; 115 official bonds, amounting to
$590,500; and insurance policies amounting to $137,400 were
examined (approved, disapproved, drafted, redrafted, or modified).
The number of legal opinions rendered, formal and informal
(memorandum), totaled 258. Legislative matters handled, which
concern the Department of Commerce (drafting and redrafting of
bills, reports relative thereto, etc.) numbered 366. In addition,
1,534 miscellaneous matters, embracing everything submitted for
the advice or suggestion of the Solicitor, or for the formulation of
departmental action, not included in the foregoing items, were
handled by this office.
Development of Waterways.
I renew the suggestion that every economic, military, and naval
argument urges the earliest possible development of a Govern­
ment-owned waterway connecting all the great cities of our Atlan­
tic seaboard with one another, with the New York State water­
ways reaching to the Great Lakes and Lake Champlain, and wit It
all the railroad terminals along our eastern coast.
An important step forward in this connection has been the
beginning of condemnation proceedings for acquiring the Cape
Cod Canal. This was done, pursuant to the act of Congress

68

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

(Public No. 37, 65th Cong.) approved August 8, 1917, which pro­
vided that the Secretary of War, the Secretary of the Navy, and
the Secretary of Commerce should examine and appraise the value
of the works and franchises of the Cape Cod Canal with reference
to the advisability of the purchase of the canal. The Secretary
of War was authorized, if all the Secretaries mentioned were in
favor of the acquisition, to enter into negotiations for its purchase.
The three Secretaries having concurred in a recommendation that
the purchase was desirable, the Secretary of War caused con­
demnation proceedings to be begun on January 30, 1919. Bills
are now pending (S. 2083 and S. 862), providing for the acquisi­
tion and operation of the canal by the Government, which have
been approved by this Department.
It remains to recite the brief but effective service of several
branches of the Department’s work undertaken during the fiscal
year which have ceased to exist.
Industrial Board.
The Industrial Board of the Department of Commerce was
organized with a view to expediting the process of commercial
readjustment. When it was formed prices were in a state of
flux. The general expectation in the business world was that
prices were, in the near future, to fall and every one hesitated to
purchase lest they should buy upon a falling market.
It was a voluntary organization of business men composed of
seven members, three representing, respectively, the Railroad
Administration, the Department of Commerce, and the Depart­
ment of Labor, and four representatives of industry. Under the
then existing circumstances the board undertook to promote
general confidence and hasten the revival of trade by securing the
voluntary assent of industries to reductions in prices which were to
be such, however, as did not involve either reducing the wages of
labor or closing down those individual factories whose efficiency
was not as great as the larger ones and who were generally known
as “ high-cost producers.”
The board succeeded in obtaining the assent of the steel industry
and of other considerable industries, and marked reductions in
prices of steel were announced and recommended to the Govern­
ment purchasing departments. From these recommendations
the Railroad Administration dissented, thinking the prices recom­
mended too high. The final refusal of the Railroad Administra­
tion to accept the recommendations of the board resulted in the

REPORT OK THE SECRETARY OK COMMERCE.

69

resignation of the board, which ceased to exist on May 9, 1919.
The reduced prices which have been arranged with other industries
were never promulgated for this reason. Since then the Railroad
Administration has purchased (under protest) steel rails at the
prices recommended by the board.
Industrial Cooperation Service.
On January 1, 1919, the Industrial Cooperation Service was
formed to take over certain peace-time functions of the War
Industries Board. Your approval on December 3, 1918, of my
request for $100,000 from the fund for the national security and
defense made it possible to carry on this work during the last six
months of the fiscal year. While some of the work had been
developed by the War Industries Board, it was carried on there in
a restrictive and administrative way, while the Industrial Coopera­
tion Service’s policy was promotive and cooperative.
Generally speaking, the Service established a focal point in the
Government for the discussion of business and industrial problems.
As the work progressed the problems fell within well-defined
classes; i. e., those concerned with the standardization of products;
those concerned with the search for outlets for waste products and
the commercial development of new products; and those concerned
with plans for minimizing business abuses. It also acted for this
Department with other Government departments in the considera­
tion of industrial matters.
The Service was asked in numerous different cases to seek
outlets for by-products or waste products of various industries.
The most striking example was the development of the uses of
cottonseed-hull fiber, hitherto practically a waste product of the
cottonseed-oil industry. Three uses for the fiber were developed:
(1) As an insulator for fireless cookers, incubators, etc.; (2) as a
binder in the manufacture of composition soles for shoes; (3) as
a material for making paper.
It also found an outlet for cotton linters, used so extensive^
during the war. Cooperating with the War Department, the
Bureau of Standards of this Department, and the Forest Products
Sendee of the Department of Agriculture, this Service demon­
strated that linters could be used to make a good grade of book
paper, and a number of mills have started to work along these
lines.

7°

REPORT OK THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

At the request of the Secretary of State this Service investigated
the possibilities of starting a submarine telegraph-cable industry
in the United States. The reports of the Service were valuable
in the consideration of the proposed Government trans-Pacific
cable, provided for in Senate bill 1651. One of the important
duties of the Industrial Cooperation Service was cooperation
with business organizations in formulating plans for minimizing
what are known as ‘‘ trade abuses.” A t the request of the pub­
lishers of books and the National Credit Men’s Association the
“ returned-goods ” question was studied. The lowest estimate
ever made as to the cost to American business of the unjustifiable
return of merchandise was $25,000,000 annually. This loss, of
course, is borne by the ultimate purchaser. The Book Publishers'
Association’s problems were treated to the satisfaction of all
concerned. The larger general problem of the unjustifiable
return of merchandise had to be dropped in its early stages be­
cause Congress did not appropriate money for the continuance
of this Service.
In every instance the assistance rendered by this Service was
requested by the industry or business concerned and its activities
embraced many fields. The Service provided an admirable
place in the Government where business men could come and
discuss their difficulties and be assured of sympathetic attention.
The refusal of Congress to provide the sum of $56,000 for the con­
tinuance of this productive organization necessitated the con­
clusion of its activities on June 30, 1919.
Waste-Reclamation Service.
Organized to meet a vital war emergency, resulting from a
shortage of war materials, the Waste-Reclamation Service ren­
dered very valuable permanent service during its short existence,
in beginning the campaign of education necessary to get the
American people in the habit of saving the many things that
they have been throwing away. Its chief function was that of
education, the action resting with the State and subdivisions
thereof, as the advantage accrued to them. Through speeches,
publications, and specific advice by letter when so requested, and
all the other means open in matters of this kind, this Service
sought to aid in the reclamation of waste inorganic materials.
By the proper disposal of ashes, garbage, etc., by the communities,
not only the materials themselves would be made of use again,

. REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

71

but there would be a surplus of money receipts that would reduce
taxes proportionately.
The system of disposing by public sale of unused war materials,
now being used, was suggested by this Service. Through its
initiation and efforts a drive was launched, in conjunction with
the Treasury Department, for the saving of materials usually
destroyed in the annual clean-up compaign, and payment made
therefor in Government Thrift Stamps rather than cash. The
Salvage Division of New England estimated that $250,000 worth
of Thrift Stamps would be dispersed by this method during the
months of May and June.
A new method of handling waste tin cans was also investigated
and called to the attention of the country. The old system of
handling these cans emphasized the redemption of the tin re­
moved from the can, while the new system deheads the can and
uses the tin in a flat form. Besides reducing the cost of handling
the cans, this method increases by about 300 per cent the return
to the contractor.
As a means of advising other communities how to proceed, the
Akron Industrial Salvage Co. (Inc.), a community waste-saving
system, was investigated and a report made covering its operation.
Over 15,000 copies of the first edition of this publication were
distributed in two weeks and several communities were, after
looking into the subject, ready to launch similar systems wheh
this Service had to be discontinued.
An investigation of the present means of disposing of waste
paper in Government services was made through the courtesy of
the Public Printer, and the report, which was published as House
document 87, Sixty-sixth Congress, first session, showed that in
the year 1918 the Government should have received at least
$86,869.35 niore for its waste paper than under the contract price.
The report also made definite recommendations which, if carried
out, would secure from $50,000 to $100,000 annually additional
from this source.
At the request of the Wool Stock Graders’ Association this
Service released to the press a statement dealing with the value
of shoddy and recommended that the interested associations con­
fer with a joint committee to be composed of representatives of
the Departments of Agriculture and Commerce, with the idea of
establishing tests for the evaluation of woolen fabrics. The in­
terest shown by several organizations established the constructive

72

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

value of the statement, and steps were taken to organize the joint
committee. At about that time the Service had to be discon­
tinued on account of lack of funds.
Tests were being made to determine the method for utilizing
old shoes. This problem was pressing, and demanded immediate
study, but also had to be discontinued.
A study of the Army system of garbage segregation as a means
of elimination of waste in the preparation of food was in the
course of preparation. It is believed that the Army system can be
applied to all institutions. An American machine used by the
British army was being studied with the idea of recommending
that a machine of this type be installed in the institutions for the
recovery of fat.
A training course for salvage managers had been outlined and
one institution was prepared to institute such a course as soon as
this Service had developed the field. Plans for the development
of an association of salvage managers had been drawn up and sub­
mitted to several leaders in this field for consideration.
The refusal of Congress to appropriate $25,000 in order that this
productive work might be carried on necessitated the disbanding
of the Service on June 30,. 1919. It will be noted that in one item
alone— the study of conditions governing the disposal of waste
in the Government Printing Office— a saving of from $50,000 to
$100,000 per annum could have been made, which would have
paid the cost of the entire Service for two years.
Introduction of New Fish Food by the Bureau of Fisheries.
It seems most extraordinary that at this time of high prices
for all matters entering into the cost of living, and when urgent
pressure is being exerted to add, because of sore need, to the ani­
mal food supply of the world, a work which was successfully
developing large quantities of unused, nutritious, and cheap foods
should be deliberately cut off.
It is, therefore, with deep regret on behalf of many thousands
of our population living in crowded centers along the Atlantic,
Pacific, and Gulf coasts and on the shores of the Great Lakes, that
I saw the refusal of Congress to grant the sum of $15,000 to main­
tain the small but effective staff of our persons that have been suc­
cessfully engaged in the work of introducing new, abundant, and
cheap fish foods, available in large quantities, but either unused
or little used. Such fishes, for example, as the Pacific mackerel,
the ordinary cod, and the so-called black cod, or sable fish, in the

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

73

same ocean, find as yet a limited market. The same is true of the
burbot and the bowfin of the Great Lakes, and of the whiting of
the Atlantic. There are many others. It appears to have been
the case that this productive work, having begun during the war,
was assumed to be strictly war work, whereas the daily evidence
to every housewife in the land of the price she must pay for food
is itself witness that the continuance of this work is needed.
It is difficult for me to understand the mental processes whereby
so small a sum as $15,000 was refused for so great a work and one
that bore so directly upon the homes and happiness of many times
ten thousand people who feel the pressure of current prices. The
work had received nothing but praise, which wras well deserved.
Economy of the sort which stops an effort to bring cheap and abun­
dant food to the knowledge of our people, and forces them, with­
out this knowledge, to buy high-priced foods, is of a curious type.
The matter was brought by me personally before the Appropria­
tions Committees of both the House of Representatives and the
Senate, and its peculiar importance at this time was urged upon
them, but in both cases without success. Feeling, however, that
the subject could not have been fully understood, it was brought
before the attention of the House of Representatives by a letter
dated July 19, 1919, which forms House Document No. 155,
Sixty-sixth Congress, first session, and is printed in full, with in­
closures, in an Appendix B to this report, in connection with the
discussion of another subject. Subsequent to this the matter
was again brought before the Appropriations Committee of the
House of Representatives by the Commissioner of Fisheries on
September 2, 1919. No appropriation, however, has been made.
One is at a loss to understand the reasoning, if it be such, which
leads to cutting off three productive services at a time when their
results were effectively helping the solution of a concededly
difficult situation. The Industrial Cooperation Service was not
an expense to the country, neither was the Waste-Reclamation
Service, still less tire food demonstration work of the Fisheries
Service. On the contrary, these three Services produced wealth.
The country was the richer for every month in which they operated.
The country is poorer for their stoppage. There is less food
to-day available because the Fisheries demonstration work has
ceased. Products that are valuable are being wasted in great
quantities and values because the Waste-Reclamation Service no
longer exists. For lack of the Industrial Cooperation Service pro­

74

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

duction now so sorely needed is, in many places, either delayed
or hampered or rendered more expensive for lack of the mutual,
helpful touch that Service provided. There is no doubt of these
facts. They are denied by no one.
The psychology seems to have been that anything that was
born during the war was warlike, in its nature unfitted for peace,
extravagant. No discrimination seems to have been made ip
favor of services which, coming into existence during the war, yet
were meant for peace. The besom of destruction was laid upon
them. They have been destroyed without regard to their pro­
ductiveness or their advantage to the country.
This, naturally, leads to the suggestion that Congress makes
no difference between productive and unproductive services. It
does not practically recognize the difference between expenditure
and investment. It adds no force, so far as my experience
goes, to demonstrate that the money expended in one case pro­
duces a direct profit to the Nation as a whole. It is all treated as
expense alike. It is all regarded as something to be cut away, if
it be possible, and men who have by careful forethought devel­
oped services to a self-sustaining basis are discouraged to find
that their efforts not only bring no thanks or appreciation, but
that, if the facts concerning them are not disbelieved, they are
at least ignored.
Just as the system which Congress uses in dealing with un­
expended balances is calculated to promote, and does, in fact,
promote, the avoidance of such balances by the deliberate spending
at the close of the fiscal year of all available balances for any
proper use, so the failure to discriminate between productive
and unproductive services directly encourages looseness of admin­
istration and leads men to become careless as to whether their
work is profitable or not.
The public in no small measure takes its mental cue from the
attitude of Congress, reflected through the press, and assumes all
Government appropriations to mean expense, and would be
surprised to learn the extent to which many of them are profitable
investments. The motor-vessel fleet of the Bureau of Navigation,
of the Department of Commerce, costs the Government nothing;
instead it has turned into the Treasury, through mitigated fines,
a sum sufficient to pay the original cost of the motor vessels and
their maintenance, with a surplus. The Bureau of Navigation
tself gathers, through the medium of the collectors of customs,
navigation taxes which far more than cover its entire outlay.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

75

The value at current cash prices of the fish rescued by the seining
parties of the Bureau of Fisheries from the overflowed ponds of
the Mississippi River between St. Paul and New Orleans is more
than sufficient to pay the entire expense of maintaining the 52
fish hatcheries of that service and to present their entire work of
producing over seven billion small fish and fish fry per annum as
a clean gift to the Nation, free of all expense.
In an industrial corporation the outlook is always toward the
productiveness of expenditure; in the Government services the
productiveness of the expenditure is almost or quite ignored. It
may be said, indeed, that the assumption is that all the services
are deemed to return to their value in work, else they would not
be permitted to exist. If this be so, what shall be said in favor
of those services which not only do return their value in work,
but in so doing return into the Treasury in cash more than their
cost of operation? These, under private management, would be
deliberately and necessarily encouraged. These, under public
management, are, so far as my experience goes, given no special
consideration.

BUREAU OF FOREIGN AND DOMESTIC COMMERCE.
(P hilip B . K e n n e d y , Director.)

The decisive factor iii the work of the Bureau of Foreign and
Domestic Commerce during the fiscal year 1919 was the signing, on
November 11, of the armistice between Germany and the allied
powers. By that event the year was divided into two distinct
periods characterized by divergent aims. It may be said with
truth that the termination of hostilities in Europe altered, as by
an abrupt shock, the aspect of the commercial world and the trend
of all activities in trade promotion. With the achievement of
the great goal, tremendous forces were immediately relaxed,
recently created mechanisms were divested of their purpose, and
the need arose for diverting to new channels the energies that
had been devoted to the winning of the war.
While the armies were still struggling on the western front,
private interests were subordinated to the national cause. Trade
regulations and restrictions that ordinarily would have been
considered shackling were met in a spirit of willing sacrifice. Under
circumstances such as these the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic
Commerce aided in every possible way the war organizations 01
the Government and recognized that its researches in foreign
markets should be considered as preparation for the change that
would inevitably come with the laying down of arms.
The conclusion of the armistice produced a striking change.
Dangerous sea lanes became safe again. Artificial economic
barriers were gradually let down. New States arose, with freedom
of entrance for the investigator and the salesman. In Europe
“ reconstitution” became the potent word. Provinces had been
devastated; industries had been wrecked; the whole normal course
of existence had been warped or stifled or turned to alien ends.
There was the menace of starvation. Stocks were depleted.
Machinery that had supplied the wants of millions lay in twisted
heaps of useless rubbish. And, for replenishment, the nations
which had suffered looked to the United States. Here, then, was
a situation representing at once commercial opportunity and
social duty. To Europe the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic
Commerce has sent many men to study the needs of the people
and the best means of satisfying them.
76

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

77

Since the armistice American producers have been free to
resume their trade in South America, the Far East, the Near
East, and the many countries where the war emergency had
involved a slackening of our effort, and a further incentive is given
by the urgent desirability of providing new outlets for the manu­
facturing facilities called into being by the war. As the industries
of the war-racked European nations revive— as adjustments are
effected and secure economic bases are evolved— those nations
will reach out beyond the seas to find markets for their wares.
American exporters will find their path no easy one. They
will need the firmest resolve, the most efficient methods, and,
above all, the most accurate knowledge. This knowledge it is
the function of the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce
to supply. American producers should not enter new fields in
any groping or hesitant way; they must be equipped with infor­
mation as comprehensive as it is practical, as pertinent as it is
sound. In the gathering and disseminating of such essential
facts, the Bureau is proving signally useful to American business.
Its aim is to stimulate, to vitalize, and, with patience and con­
tinuous application, to smooth the way for export trade. It is
expanding and driving ahead with a clear comprehension of the
object sought. Its present opportunity is remarkable; and it
may be expected to respond with effective sendee.
Unprecedented Totals for American Foreign Trade.
During the fiscal year 1919 new high marks were established
for both the import and the export trade of the United States.
Imports of merchandise totaled $3,095,876,582, as compared with
$2,945,655,403 in 1918 and $2,659,355,185 in 1917. Domestic
exports amounted to $7,074,011,529, as against $5,838,652,057 in
1918 and $6,227,164,050 in 1917. Not considering reexports of
foreign goods, the visible balance of trade in favor of the United
States on merchandise transactions for the year just ended was
$3,978,134,947, a figure never approached in the commerce of any
nation in the history of the world.
The exports of domestic and foreign merchandise to the several
grand divisions during the fiscal year 1919 were as follows: Europe,
$4,634,816,841; North America, $1,291,932,342; South America,
$400,901,601; Asia, $603,924,548; Oceania, $208,351,493; Africa,
$85,157,432, making a total of $7,225,084,257.

78

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Letters of Appreciation Show Practical Results Accomplished.
That the services of the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Com­
merce have contributed appreciably to the great growth of Ameri­
can trade with all parts of the world is shown by the many un­
solicited letters of commendation received— communications tell­
ing of large sales effected through the bureau’s aid, mentioning
the receipt of data satisfying specific needs, and expressing grati­
fication at the essentially practical and productive character of
the work performed. And it is to be remembered in this connec­
tion that the concrete results brought directly to the bureau’s
attention doubtless represent only a small fraction of the trade
development that may fairly be attributed to its efforts.
Period of Readjustment in Commercial-Attaché Service.
The bureau’s commercial-attaché service the past year has under­
gone a period of readjustment. War work continued up to the
signing of the armistice, while immediately thereafter plans were
made for the resumption of the normal activities of trade promotion
and investigation. The readjustment period, however, brought its
own special problems. For example, in Argentina, Brazil, Japan,
and Australia the representatives have been busy with the diffi­
culties involved in the sudden arrival of goods far in excess of
immediate needs. Through their efforts the situation was handled
effectively without loss to importers, exporters, or bankers. In
England, France, Italy, Spain, the Netherlands, and Denmark the
attachés have had to deal with questions arising out of the relaxa­
tion and modification of war-time trade restrictions.
An important development in connection with the commercialattaché service was the sending out of trade commissioners to con­
duct general investigations under the direction and supervision
of the commercial attachés. Early in the fiscal year Herman G.
Brock was sent to London to assist Commercial Attaché Kennedy
in carrying on the strictly commercial activities that were neces­
sarily being pushed aside by the war work. Mr. Brock furnished
the bureau with timely reports and was also able to assist Mr.
Kennedy materially.
Shortly after the armistice the Department of Commerce recog­
nized the necessity for a greatly increased force in Europe to keep
in the closest possible touch with important developments and
trade tendencies. The President allotted $200,000 from the fund
for national security and defense, and by the latter part of February
trade commissioners and clerks were dispatched to Europe.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

79

Ten trade commissioners worked on general investigations
directly under the supervision of the commercial attachés. Their
investigations covered a wide variety of commercial, financial,
and industrial subjects.
Activities of Attachés in Europe.
Coming now to a consideration of the commercial-attaché posts
themselves, the London office should be mentioned first. Com­
mercial Attaché Philip B. Kennedy was engaged in war work in
addition to the normal activities of his office. Besides handling
mineral and tin problems for the War Trade Board and aiding
the War Department in the purchase of urgently needed materials,
Mr. Kennedy took over during the latter part of the year the entire
handling of the Swedish iron-ore and Norwegian molybdenum
contracts, for which the President put at the disposal of the
Secretary of Commerce $6,000,000 from the fund for national
security and defense. Mr. Kennedy has cooperated closely with
the ambassador and the consul general in the matter of British
import restrictions. One of the most important features of the
work in London during the year was the cooperation between
the office of the commercial attaché and the American Chamber
of Commerce in London. The attaché was an ex officio member
of the trade information committee, and his office was represented
at its weekly meetings. The office in London made first-hand
investigations of markets for American products. For example,
the possibilities for the sale of American cottonseed-hull fiber were
carefully analyzed. Through the commercial attaché American
producers of dyestuffs were put in touch with officials of the Italian
Government. Mr. Kennedy represented the United States unoffi­
cially at the Interallied Parliamentary Conference held in London,
July 2 to 4, 1918, and submitted reports upon the deliberations of
the conference. During April Commercial Attaché Kennedy
returned to the United States to confer with the officials of the
bureau and meet business men interested in post-war conditions
in England. The customary tour of commercial centers was
made and many conferences held. As a result of an invitation
extended through Mr. Kennedy to the Chamber of Commerce of
the United States in behalf of the Associated Chambers of Com­
merce in Great Britain, the former body decided to bring to this
country in the early fall, for a discussion of industrial and financial
reconstruction problems, commercial delegations from the allied
nations in Europe. In July, 1919, Mr. Kennedy was appointed
Director of the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce.

8o

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Pierce C. Williams accompanied to Paris the War Trade Board
representative and, under his direction, organized and operated for
several months the American office of the Interallied Contingent
Commission and continued to assist, to an extent, in the work of
the War Trade Board. He submitted timely and valuable reports
on such subjects as French industrial reconstruction, the formation
of consortiums and comptoirs, import restrictions, and cooperative
selling by American interests. He made an investigation of eco­
nomic conditions in Switzerland. Mr. Williams resigned to enter
private employ, and Chauncey Depew Snow, formerly Assistant
Chief of the Bureau, was appointed commercial attaché and took
charge in Paris March 24, 1919. Mr. Snow also has kept in inti­
mate touch with reconstruction problems. Tariff questions and
changes in import restrictions have been closely followed. The
attaché has cooperated with the Rhineland High Commission, the
officials in charge of the sale of Army supplies and equipment, and
the Supreme Economic Council, as well as with the American
Chamber of Commerce. As an example of the tangible results
accomplished by Mr. Snow, I may mention the assistance given to
individual import applications for American goods, even to the
extent of preventing the confiscation of such goods.
At the beginning of the fiscal year Commercial Attaché Erwin
W. Thompson was in London, continuing the work with the War
Trade Board begun in March. He returned to Copenhagen in
July and resumed his intensive study of the Scandinavian and
German press. This study and daily contact with commercial
and financial men throughout the Baltic region enabled him to
furnish authoritative reports on economic subjects. Through one
of his reports the United States Shipping Board was enabled to
obtain from a Danish factory large Diesel engines urgently
needed. Mr. Thompson worked out plans for financing ship­
ments of American cotton and other commodities into the new
Baltic countries by a system of dividing up the credits between
the American shipper and the Danish institutions :n a way that
keeps the American shipper always secured by safe shipping or
warehouse documents. Other special activities included an
investigation of textile substitutes, a study of methods to be used
in reconciliation of trade disputes, a survey of Scandinavian
sources of supply of foodstuffs and other products for the American
Expeditionary Force, and inquiries as to the establishment of an
American chamber of commerce in Copenhagen.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

8l

During the entire year Commercial Attaché Paul L. Rchvards
acted as the American representative on the Interallied Trade
Committee at The Hague. Mr. Edwards served as the agent of
the War Trade Board and the American minister in carrying out
the various agreements with the Dutch Government, including the
handling of the correspondence with the Netherlands Oversea
Trust. During November, 1918, he visited London to confer
with allied representatives regarding the various Dutch economic
agreements. Several trips were made to Paris to confer with the
Supreme Blockade Council concerning blockade administration
and the shipping of foodstuffs to Germany under the Brussels
agreement. Mr. Edwards also reported on current commercial
and financial matters.
Commercial Attaché William C. Huntington spent most of the
year in the United States because of the unsettled conditions in
Russia. During the early part of the fiscal year he was in Moscow
aiding our diplomatic and consular officers. He left Russia in the
fall, reaching the United States in November after visiting Stock­
holm, London, and Paris. In Washington, Dr. Huntington has
held many conferences with officials of other Government depart­
ments interested in Russia. Besides making numerous addresses,
he has organized the Russian division of the bureau.
In the fall of 1918 it was decided to establish a cominercialattaché post at Madrid, and the position was offered to William A.
Montavon, who had served in Lima, Peru. After the resignation
of Mr. Montavon, Chester Lloyd Jones was appointed and opened
his office March 5, 1919. At this post the work has been largely
of a trade-promotive character. Mr. Jones has assisted the
embassy in connection with our commercial treaty relations with
Spain, and kept in close touch with proposed tariff legislation.
He secured the revision of discriminating tariff classifications
affecting American trade. Our ambassador in Spain has expressed
his gratification at the valuable services rendered by Mr. Jones,
and has recommended the assignment of additional assistants in
the office of the commercial attaché at Madrid. The representa­
tions of our attaché were largely responsible for the recent granting
to a New York company of the important concession for exploiting
extensive potash deposits north of Barcelona. This single achieve­
ment is sufficient to justify the maintenance of the attaché’s office
and the expenditure it involves. Other activities worthy of
special mention include assistance to the Liquidation Commission
140261—19----- 6

82

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

of the Army, cooperation with the American Chamber of Com­
merce in Barcelona, and special reports on Spanish trade
conditions.
The second new post opened during the year was at Rome.
Commercial Attaché Alfred P. Dennis reached his post in March,
1919. Through his efforts and those of his assistants, import
permits were issued for 8,000 packages of American goods that
had been held for six months at Genoa. Among other products, I
American tractors, shoes, hosiery, tubing, steel, and chemicals
were admitted upon the representations of the attaché’s office.
Mr. Dennis assisted the embassy in obtaining equal treatment for
American goods discriminated against in Italian treaties with
other nations. He has discussed with the Director of Economic
Policy and the Director of Customs questions relating to the
admission into Italy of American products. He has also aided
firms seeking to establish themselves in the Italian market.
Results Attained by Far-Eastern Offices.
During the first half of the fiscal year Commercial Attaché Julean
Arnold was in Shanghai, serving as chairman of the International
Maritime Customs Conference. During Mr. Arnold’s absence the
office at Peking was in charge of A. W. Ferrin and Paul P. Whitham. In cooperation with a representative of the War Trade
Board, Mr. Ferrin initiated negotiations for the sale of 5,000 cars
and 100 locomotives to the Chinese Government Railways under
a car-trust agreement. Mr. Arnold assisted in the organization
of a new American bank in China, as well as in that of a joint
Chinese-American bank. As a result of his efforts, equipment for
10 cotton mills was purchased and installed in China. He aided
in establishing an American tannery, had a share in the sale of
American cars and railway equipment, and aided American archi­
tects to obtain contracts in China. American industrial films have
been exhibited to acquaint the Chinese business public with Ameri­
can equipment and methods of production. The attaché has
worked for the protection of American trade-marks, and has
furthered the establishment of an American news sendee and
better shipping facilities to China. With the aid of American
consular officers he has prepared a comprehensive handbook of
China. Mr. Arnold is now on his way to the United States.
Up to the signing of the armistice Commercial Attaché Frank R.
Rutter, at Tokyo, was chiefly engaged with problems arising out
of trade restrictions and with the study of industrial and economic

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

83

conditions. Dr. Rutter left for the United States in December to
accept an, important position on the staff of the bureau in Wash.
ington. James F. Abbott was appointed to succeed him. Since
his arrival at his post in March, Mr. Abbott has been renewing
contacts in Japan and has been keeping Americans acquainted
with commercial developments.
In Australia, A. W. Ferrin, by addresses before commercial
bodies and through press contributions, has aided in removing
misunderstandings as to American trade methods and ideals.
Another important service has been in connection with the
amicable settlement of large claims made against Americans by
Australian importers. Mr. Ferrin has done excellent tradepromotion work, and substantial business has resulted from his
aiding Australians to obtain American agencies.
Work of Attachés in Latin America.
The office at Buenos Aires was largely occupied with war work.
Commercial Attaché Robert S. Barrett was also the representa­
tive of the War Trade Board and the Shipping Board. Mr.
Barrett obtained the cooperation of the commercial representa­
tives of the allied Governments and organized a committee, of
which he was elected chairman, to take joint action on all enemytrade matters. He also suggested and assisted in the organiza­
tion of the Allied Chamber of Commerce of Buenos Aires. To the
.Shipping Board Mr. Barrett made important and exhaustive
reports. During the shipping strike he rendered notable service.
Mr. Barrett also devoted considerable time to trade promotion.
Largely through his efforts, the United States Chamber of Com­
merce in Buenos Aires was organized. Many representatives of
American firms were assisted, and in one instance an initial order
of $100,000 worth of rubber goods was secured. Mr. Barrett made
frequent and extensive reports on timely subjects. He resigned
April i to enter private business, but returned to the United States
and spent three months conferring with business men before his
resignation was accepted. Dr. Julius Klein, who had served as
chief of the bureau’s Latin American division, was appointed
commercial attaché at Buenos Aires.
J. E. Philippi was appointed commercial attaché at Rio de
Janeiro, arriving at his post November 3, 1918. He has devoted
considerable time to a unification of the American commercial
organizations in Brazil into an effective body, the American
Chamber of Commerce for Brazil. The organization, with the

84

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

aid of Mr. Philippi, lias assisted in negotiations concerning arbitra­
tion of commercial disputes. The attaché has made a close study
of the Brazilian tariff. Following the armistice unusually heavy
import shipments were received, and in many lines stocks were
largely in excess of immediate needs. The attaché was instru­
mental in working out plans for handling the situation without
loss to the parties interested. Mr. Philippi has kept the Depart­
ment informed with respect to shipping facilities, freight rates,
etc., has submitted many valuable reports on other important
subjects, and has aided in various ways American exporters.
During the greater part of the year the office at Dima, Peru,
has been in charge of Robert E. Hurd, secretary to the commercial
attaché. Mr. Montavon returned to Washington in October to
confer with exporters. However, Mr. Montavon decided while in
this country to accept an important place with a private organiza­
tion. His trip through the United States was highly successful.
While at Lima the attaché was chairman of the subcommittee of
the Allied Conference of Ministers that considered war-trade
problems. After the departure of the attaché, Mr. Hurd con­
tinued these activities, acting as secretary for the organization.
Usefulness of Attaché Service Clearly Demonstrated.
The commercial attachés in South America have submitted
special reports on the openings for American marine-insurance
operations, markets for drawing instruments and architects’
supplies, and German competition in all its phases. The attachés
at Copenhagen, The Hague, and Paris have studied the status of
the German dye industry. Our representatives in Paris and
Rome were able to assist the important commissions representing
the National Industrial Conference Board and the World Cotton
Conference, while the London and Paris offices were of similar
assistance to the commissions representing the shoe and leather
trades and the Merchants and Manufacturers’ Board of the Cleve­
land Chamber of Commerce. The attaché service created interest
in the exhibition held in Philadelphia in June under the auspices of
the National Association of Hosiery & Knit Goods Manufacturers.
A striking example of the usefulness of the service is found in
its cooperation with the United States Sugar Equalization Board,
which asked the bureau whether the attachés could assist in
opening up foreign markets for sugar. The attachés were in­
structed to give the matter publicity as well as take it up directly
with foreign importers. Soon the export demand became so

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

85

heavy that the board found it necessary to restrict the exportation
of sugar.
As another example of the utility of the service, I may mention
the cooperation of the Bureau with the Bureau of Markets of the
State of South Dakota in finding markets for range horses in
Europe.
Vital Work Accomplished by Trade Commissioners.
The division of foreign investigations has aided the war activities
of such organizations as the War Trade Board, the War Industries
Board, the Council of National Defense, the Shipping Board, and
the War Department. Trade Commissioner Axel H. Oxholm ren­
dered important services in connection with the inspection ôf
timber for the American Expeditionary Force. Trade Commis­
sioner Norman L. Anderson kept closely in touch with matters
of interest in the Scandinavian countries, Finland, Germany, and
elsewhere. Nels A. Bengtson, trade commissioner at Christiania,
cooperated with special representatives of the War Trade Board in
Norway.
The lumber investigations conducted by Trade Commissioners
Axel H. Oxholm, Roger E. Simmons, Nelson C. Brown, and John
R. Walker were practically completed at the end of the fiscal
year, and their reports will appear shortly. Upon returning to
the United States, each of the investigators made a tour of the
principal lumber centers, giving first-hand information con­
cerning the results of his trip abroad. Great benefit will un­
questionably be derived from the personal suggestions of the
commissioners, as well as from the material in the forthcoming
monographs. The regions covered in the investigation were
Finland, Sweden, and Norway; Russia and Siberia; the Spanish
Peninsula, Italy, and Greece; and Great Britain, France, Belgium,
and the Netherlands.
The year witnessed the completion of the field work in the
investigation of South American furniture markets by Harold E.
Everley and the publication of his book entitled “ Furniture Markets
of Chile, Peru, Bolivia, and Ecuador.” His reports on the eastcoast countries will soon appear.
Trade Commissioner W. W. Ewing finished his study of the
opportunities in South America for the sale of American construc­
tion materials and machinery. A bulletin was published embody­
ing the information that he gathered in Chile, Peru, and Ecuador,
and reports on Argentina, Bolivia, Uruguay, and Brazil are being
prepared.

86

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Charles C. Hanch conducted a short investigation of the auto­
mobile situation in England and on the Continent of Europe.
“ Jewelry and Silverware in Cuba’’ represented the first tangible
result of the investigation by Samuel W. Rosenthal into the Latin
American markets for the articles indicated. Various other mono­
graphs are soon to be published.
Trade Commissioner J. W. Sanger finished his study of advertis­
ing methods and conditions in the Latin American countries. His
reports are most pertinent and interesting.
Oliver M. Smart has returned to the United States with valuable
data on the market for electrical goods in Italy.
>During the past year William M. Strachan investigated the pro­
duction and exportation of certain tropical products in Central
America and Colombia, at the request of the United States Shipping
Board.
Henry Wigglesworth made a short survey of the general situa­
tion in the chemical industries of Eurojpe.
There is now in press a monograph on “ Electrical Goods in
Argentina, Uruguay, and Brazil, ” written by Trade Commissioner
Philip S. Smith to complete the series resulting from his South
American investigations.
The other specialized investigations completed during the year
include those of W. G. Marshall on industrial machinery in Italy;
H. Lawrence Groves on agricultural machinery in France; Charles
P. Wood on industrial machinery in France and Belgium; and
Arthur N. Young on financial conditions in Spain.
Trade Commissioner Edward F. Feely made a survey of general
commercial and economic conditions in Mexico and has now been
appointed commercial attaché at Mexico City.
Louis E. Van Norman was appointed trade commissioner to
investigate general trade conditions in Rumania and was stationed
at Bucharest for about six months. Having obtained important
data on fundamental economic factors, he has returned to this
country to give American business men the benefit of his observa­
tions.
Leslie C. Wells was assigned to the party of the French Institute
in the United States that has been making a tour of France, in­
cluding the devastated regions.
Among other general investigations should be mentioned those
of Nels A. Bengtson in Norway, Harry T. Collings in Belgium, and
Eliot G. Mears in Greece. Mr. Mears has been ordered to proceed
to Constantinople, to report on general commercial and economic

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

87

conditions. Mr. Bengtson and Mr. Codings are returning to the
United States. General investigations that are continuing as the
fiscal year ends are those of P. L. Bell in Colombia and Venezuela,
John A. Fowler in the Dutch East Indies and Straits Settlements,
Vladimir A. Geringer in Czechoslovakia, and R. A. Lundquist in
South Africa. Upon the completion of his work in South Africa
(including the preparation of a report on the electrical-goods trade),
Mr. Lundquist is expected to proceed to India to study the market
for electrical goods in that country.
William L. Schurz was appointed trade commissioner in Febru­
ary to make a general investigation in Bolivia and Paraguay. No
trade commissioners have been located in those countries before,
though short visits to the principal centers have been made by
several commodity investigators of the bureau.
Special investigations now in progress include those of J. Morgan
Clements of mineral resources in China; Courtenay De Kalb of
mineral resources in Spain; L. S. Garry of textiles in South America;
Harry F. Grady of financial conditions in England and on the
Continent; Norman L. Hertz of leather in Europe; Alexander
Luchars of machine tools in England and on the Continent; W.
H. Rastall of industrial machinery in the Far East; Paul P.
Whitham of transportation and port facilities in China.
District and Cooperative Offices.
As with other branches of the bureau’s activity, the work of
its district and cooperative offices during the past year falls natur­
ally into two divisions— that performed before the signing of the
armistice and the work undertaken subsequent to that date.
While the actual handling of export and import licenses was
taken out of the hands of the district and cooperative office man­
agers some time before the beginning of the past fiscal year, a
great many requests and inquiries continued to reach these offices
with respect to the war regulations of this country and of foreign
nations. It is estimated that approximately 25 to 35 per cent of
the time of the employees of these offices was taken up in furnish­
ing information of this character and in advising business men as
to the proper procedure in complying with these war-time regula­
tions while still conducting as much foreign trade as possible.
After the armistice, the urgent demands from American busi­
ness men for advice and assistance in relation to the new markets
taxed severely the limited personnel of the bureau’s branch offices.
Manufacturers and exporters have, for the most part, expressed

88

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

deep appreciation of the manner in which their requests were
handled.
Probably the most notable feature of the work of these offices
after the signing of the armistice was the arrival in this country of a
comparatively large number of foreign business men desiring to
be placed in touch with American merchants. This is a service
for which the district offices are peculiarly fitted, each office man­
ager being in close contact with the business interests of his dis­
trict and being able, therefore, to place foreign buyers in direct
communication with firms which can supply their requirements.
Another feature of the work that has developed greatly during
the past year has been the investigation of complaints made
against American firms by foreign dealers. In such abnormal
conditions as those prevailing during the war it was inevitable
that misunderstandings and mistakes should occur. The district
and cooperative offices of the bureau have been eminently suc­
cessful in adjusting these difficulties amicably and without recourse
to legal procedure. The effect of this work upon foreign good
will toward the United States is evident.

Work in Connection with Latin America.
June 30, 1919, marked the end of the busiest and probably the
mc st useful year in the history of the bureau’s Latin American
division, organized in 1916 for the general purpose of promoting
American trade with all countries and colonies in the Western
Hemisphere to the south of the United States. During its com­
paratively short existence a large quantity of economic informa­
tion has been accumulated, the development having been espe­
cially rapid subsequent to the entrance of the United States into
the war. Like all public and private institutions, the Latin
American division has found the fiscal year 1919 composed of two
distinct phases— that from July 1, 1918, until the signing of the
armistice on November ix, and that after November 11, 1919.
Early in the war the division was called upon to cooperate
actively in many aspects of war work involving Latin American
affairs. About 50 per cent of the time of the division during the
duration of the war was given to the preparation of economic mate­
rial for war uses and to assistance rendered to investigators from
other Government offices. In some instances the war organizations
found it necessary to maintain in the division members of their
staffs on full-time work. The four offices of the War Department
maintaining closest contact with the division were the military

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

89

intelligence branch, the air-craft procurement division, the gasdefense service, and the Surgeon General’s Office.
The division was in particularly close touch with the Shipping
Board because of the necessity for careful study of ship service
to Latin America with a view to curtailing that service to a min­
imum in order to supply tonnage for trans-Atlantic troop and
munition movements. The files of the division were used as the
foundation for data relating to such questions as Mexican petro­
leum, Latin American merchant marine, fuel supplies of South
American countries, interned German shipping in Latin American
ports, and Japanese ship movements to South America.
The division was called upon constantly by the War Trade
Board for advice on the granting of licenses for exports to Latin
America, with special reference to the actual necessity for the
given commodity in the consuming countries. As the board
undertook to establish its own field service, its various appointees
were given special preliminary training in the Latin American
division before departing for their posts in the southern countries.
The division furnished to the Food Administration a number
of comprehensive tabulations relating to the trade in sisal fiber,
sugar, bananas, coffee, and cereals.
Aid was given to the Geological Survey in its investigations of
the Latin American supplies and the proprietary control of such
minerals as nitrate, petroleum, coal, tin, zinc, manganese, plati­
num, antimony, and tungsten.
For the Federal Reserve Board members of the division wrote
brief treatises covering the effects of the war on exchange in
Brazil, Uruguay, Argentina, and Chile.
Data and suggestions were supplied to the Committee on Public
Information.
Investigations were conducted regularly for the F'oreign Trade
Adviser’s office of the State Department.
The division also cooperated in collecting economic data for use
at the Peace Conference. Numerous reports were prepared for
this use.
While the time of the Latin American division was primarily
occupied with the war activities above enumerated, prior to the
signing of the armistice, the work of supplying trade information
to private interests was not neglected. It was often called upon
to act as a mediator between private business and the Govern­
ment war organizations.

go

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The revolution in commercial activity that took place after
the cessation of hostilities was reflected in the work of the Latin
American division. Manufacturing industries turned to foreign
markets as outlets for their production. The average number of
letters of trade information written weekly by the division, in
response to inquiries received from business houses, increased
from 89 in July, 1918, to 220 in April, 1919. The number of
visits by export managers, salesmen, and officials of manufactur­
ing firms and export houses grew to 35 or 40 per week.
One of the most encouraging features of the trade-promotive
work of the Latin American division has been the regularity with
which its services have been used by business institutions recog­
nized as among the most important in the United States. Among
them may be mentioned practically all the American banks that
have branches or affiliated houses in Latin America, the more
prominent steel companies, many of the strongest export and
import houses, investment and financial institutions, and many
others among the leaders in their respective industries, such as
textiles, chemicals, paints and varnishes, jewelry, rubber, motor
cars, agricultural implements and machinery, industrial equip­
ment, railway supplies, electrical manufactures, explosives, timber,
hardware of all kinds, construction materials, foodstuffs, and, in
lesser volume, practically every variety of manufactures.
So far as has been practicable in view of the time necessarily
occupied by work of more immediate importance, the division
has prepared, on subjects of timely interest, articles involving
original research. These reports, to which the name of “ Latin
American circulars ” has been given, were issued during the past
year at intervals of approximately two weeks and have been
published in Commerce Reports. The series has included reports
on the trade balance and foreign exchange of Uruguay and
Brazil; railways and railway development in Mexico, Brazil, Peru,
and Argentina; petroleum and general trade conditions in Mexico;
studies of paint and varnish and automobile markets; and other
miscellaneous subjects. A gratifying appreciation of this phase
of the division’s work has been evidenced not onfy by personal
letters but also by the reprinting of such studies in trade journals
and the daily press.
During the last weeks of the year the division prepared a com­
plete syllabus for the use of instructors in Latin American trade
courses and of students who desire to pursue such study inde­
pendently. This work comprises four courses on the main divi­

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

91

sions of Latin America, including preliminary references to the
history and social heritage of each nation as well as a review of
the physical features, transportation, native products, banking
and finance, and economic characteristics peculiar to the region
under consideration. Commodity studies based mainly on the
official reports published by the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic
Commerce form the practical end of each course. This syllabus
will be embodied in a bulletin to be issued by the Federal Board
for Vocational Education about the first of September, 1919.
Promotion of Trade with Far East.
The Far Eastern division accumulates and distributes trade
information in a variety of ways. It clips and files all pertinent
articles appearing in about 20 representative Far Eastern trade
papers. In order to insure as extensive a circulation as possible
for data of this character, a weekly digest of the clippings is made
and published in Commerce Reports. These “ press notes” are
widely copied in trade and news papers throughout the United
States. The value of thus directing intelligent inquiry is mani­
fest; it discourages the old type of “ dragnet” inquiry that is so
difficult to handle and, with more beneficial results, excites the
interest of merchants and manufacturers in available material of
a specific nature. Lists of selected titles, from the clipping files
and the card index of articles in periodicals, are distributed to the
bureau’s district and cooperative offices.
The duplicate replies of consuls to trade inquiries are filed in
the Far Eastern division, and their gist is summarized on cards.
Letters of special interest form the nucleus of articles in Commerce
Reports, under the heading “ Far Eastern trade notes.” For Com­
merce Reports, also, the division prepares summaries of forth
coming monographs by the field investigators of the bureau.
Special lines of investigation for commercial attachés and trade
commissioners are suggested by the division, based upon inquiries
received from American sources.
The division is assembling a library of great practical value.
Yearbooks, directories, studies of economic conditions, official re­
ports of foreign Government departments and bureaus have
expanded the bookshelves from 4 to 15 sections.
In the distribution of the information thus accumulated prob­
ably two-thirds of the effort has been expended in answering indi­
vidual inquiries. These have increased from about 25 per week
in July, 1918, to more than 125 per week at the termination of

92

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

the fiscal year. In a surprisingly large number of cases the divi­
sion has been completely successful in supplying the exact data
required.
It was early discovered that there was a steady call for compre­
hensive surveys of the Far Eastern markets for certain articles
entering largely into the export trade of the United States. To
meet this demand, 18 circulars discussing the opportunity for such
goods in practically all important Far Eastern markets have been
prepared and given wide circulation through Commerce Reports
and by mailing to a special list comprising virtually all the Ameri­
can manufacturers and exporters actively engaged in trade with
the Orient. These circulars have had gratifying results.
The miscellaneous activities of the division during the year have
been numerous and exacting. It was called upon for advice con­
cerning the desire of the Chinese Government to purchase railway
equipment. It gave attention to the bill introduced in Congress
for the incorporation under Federal law of companies engaged in
foreign trade exclusively. The subject of better cable facilities
across the Pacific was taken up. A t the request of the Shipping
Board, the division suggested two routes for transpacific steam­
ship service, the accumulation of the necessary data involving
much research. The division has been called upon frequently to
clear up trade disputes of a peculiarly aggravated nature. A
number of addresses before trade bodies have been made by mem­
bers of the division.
Establishment of Russian Division.
Among the important undertakings of the bureau during the
fiscal year was the organization of a Russian division, under the
direction of Dr. William C. Huntington, commercial attaché to
Russia. Dr. Huntington was in Russia during the last days of
the imperial régime and the entire period from the revolution of
March, 1917, to the withdrawal of the American diplomatic
representatives.
The Russian division was organized in January, 1919, the staff
consisting at first of only the chief and a stenographer. Two
additional persons were engaged in March, and since April the
work has been very actively carried on. The aim of this work is
(1) to make a thorough study of Russia and to build up a collation
file of sound, tested information, as well as to form a good library ;
(2) on this basis to furnish accurate information to business inter­
ests; and (3) to form a center for all sorts of American-Russian
trade relations.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

93

Numerous articles and translations prepared by the division
have been published in Commerce Reports. Russian currency,
mineral resources, the flour-milling industry, the beet-sugar
industry, the market for textiles and clothing, the port of Arch­
angel, the resources and trade possibilities of Poland, etc., have
formed the subjects of such reports.
Many business men, both Russian and American, have visited
the division. The cooperative societies and their projects have
occupied much time. A large number of inquiries have been
answered relative to general conditions in Russia and Siberia,
as well as special branches of trade and manufacture. About
300 of these letters have been in the nature of real reports to the
inquirers.
The division has endeavored to obtain publications from all
sources and has worked in close cooperation with other divisions
of this Department and also with the Department of State, the
Department of Labor, the Shipping Board, and the War Trade
Board. It has worked with the military intelligence division of
the War Department.
The division has cooperated effectively with such organizations
as the American-Russian Chamber of Commerce, the RussianAmerican Committee for the Far East, the Russian Embassy,
the consulate general of the Republic of Poland, the Russian
Economic League, the National City Bank of New York, the
National Bank of Commerce, the National Association of
American Manufacturers, and various chambers of commerce.
Attempts have been made to get in touch with chambers of com­
merce abroad, in Harbin, Omsk, and Archangel. Arrangements
have been made with the State Department to obtain periodi­
cally data from representatives in the United States of States
organized from portions of the former Russian Empire.
It is confidently believed that this new Russian branch of the
bureau’s activity will contribute very substantially to an under­
standing of the Russian problem, aiding Americans to take
advantage of an ultimate opportunity for the utilization of capital
and the supplying of merchandise to 180,000,000 people.
Extraordinary Demand for Commercial Information.
The bureau’s division of trade information, which supplies,
through correspondence and personal interviews, data on foreign
markets other than Latin America, the Far East, and Russia,
sent out approximately 45,000 communications during the past

94

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

year. Since the signing of the armistice the facilities of the division
have been taxed to meet the truly phenomenal demand for com­
mercial information. Upon the cessation of hostilities American
manufacturers whose establishments had grown as a result of war
orders began to seek means to keep their plants and organizations
intact, and thus avoid the unpleasant task of reducing their forces
and curtailing production. The inquiries received by the bureau
show that a remarkably large proportion of these concerns have
turned to foreign trade as a solution of their problems.
In connection with its trade-promotion work the bureau main­
tains close cooperative arrangements with the principal com­
mercial organizations throughout the United States. An impor­
tant supplemental publicity is thus given to the bureau’s publica­
tions and special services. In turn, the division of trade informa­
tion is often able to be of definite assistance to such associations
and their individual members. It is called upon frequently by
newly established associations, planning the organization of
foreign-trade departments, for advice and constructive suggestions
that will assist them in initiating, developing, and carrying on a
special service of this kind.
Division of Statistics.
During the first half of the year the efforts of the division of
statistics, aside from the regular work of preparing the statistical
publications, were directed mainly toward furnishing the special
war bureaus with the detailed foreign-trade statistics required by
them.
The various divisions of the United States Shipping Board made
probably more extensive use of the statistics than any of the other
war offices. As a basis for the control and allocation of ships for
imports of essential war materials for which the United States was
dependent upon foreign sources, the division of planning and
statistics of the Shipping Board was supplied regularly with
reports of imports during io-day periods. The port and harbor
facilities commission of the Shipping Board made extensive use
of the monthly reports showing imports and exports of each
customs district by articles and countries. The division of oper­
ation made extensive use of the bureau’s reports of “ Vessels
entered and cleared in the foreign trade,” while the division of
trade was given aid in the construction of tables showing commerce
in leading staple articles by ports and countries.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

95

The Food Administration and the Bureau of Markets of the
Department of Agriculture were furnished with io-day reports
of imports and exports of foodstuffs and agricultural raw products.
The several divisions of the War Industries Board and the Coun­
cil of National Defense made constant inquiries for foreign-trade
statistics in connection with their work of priority rulings, price
fixing, and other war restrictions, and received numerous special
monthly and io-day statements.
The Geological Survey, the Bureau of Mines, and the inter­
departmental War Minerals Committee were kept regularly sup­
plied with the latest statistics on imports and exports of nonferrous metals, coal, mineral oil, nitrogenous materials, and other
essential minerals.
The War Trade Board made constant use of the import and
export statistics, its bureau of research being regularly furnished
with copies of the io-day and monthly export reports, and every
facility was afforded its officials to keep their statistical records
up to date. Numerous special tables were also furnished to that
board.
Among the other Government establishments to which infor­
mation was supplied by this division were the Central Bureau of
Planning and Statistics, the Committee on Public Information, the
Alien Property Custodian, and the Director General of Railroads.
In many cases extensive research and compilation were required.
Since the signing of the armistice this extensive use of the
bureau’s foreign-trade statistics has gradually diminished, so far
as the war boards are concerned, while there has been a corre­
sponding increase in the demands by private industries and com­
mercial organizations. It is the policy of the division to furnish
as complete statistics as possible bearing upon the inquiries
submitted.
For several years the division has maintained a limited service
of special monthly statements to certain parties, giving more
details than the published reports. It was decided to extend this
service by furnishing it to such trade journals and commercial
organizations as would agree to give publicity to the statements.
The demand has exceeded all expectations. The work was started
with statistics for December, 1918. After it had been in operation
for six months, 1,178 copies of 81 statements of imports and
exports during May, 1919, were furnished to about 300 different
addresses, mostly those of trade organizations and commercial
journals.

96

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Special arrangements have been made with local correspondents
of trade publications by which they are given access to the copy
for the Monthly Summary before it is sent to print. Thus the
figures of imports and exports in the principal lines of industry—
including, among others, automobiles, textiles, iron and steel, and
hides and leather— appear in the trade journals a week or more in
advance of the official statistical publications.
The Department of Commerce is aware of the importance of
promptness in the statistical service and is giving much attention
to the coordination of the bureau’s work with that of the Customs
Service of the Treasury Department, through which the reports
are collected. In recent months there has been a notable improve­
ment in this regard.
An act of Congress approved January 25, 1919 (S. bill 4924),
amended section 336 of the Revised Statutes by requiring that
the annual report shall be issued to cover the calendar instead of
the fiscal year, because of the greater demand for figures relating
to the former period. For 1918 the bureau undertook to prepare,
in addition to the fiscal-year report, an annual report on the
Foreign Commerce and Navigation of the United States for the
calendar year. In order to provide a continuous record for the
intervening period between the fiscal and calendar years, the figures
for the half year from July 1 to December 31, 1918, are shown in
all of the tables in addition to the calendar-year figures.
Steps are being taken to change the tables in the foreign-com­
merce section of the Statistical Abstract from fiscal to calendar
years.
The usual publication Trade of the United States with the
World, showing imports and exports in the trade with each
foreign country by articles, was brought up to date for 1918 and
issued as Miscellaneous Series No. 78. A special compilation was
made and published in Commerce Reports of the imports into and
domestic exports from the United States during the calendar
year 1917, stated in the terminology of the international classi­
fication agreed upon at the International Statistical Congress at
Brussels in 1913.
To remedy the lack of detail in the foreign-trade statistics, a
revision and extension of the export classification was undertaken
in the latter part of the fiscal year. An interdepartmental com­
mittee was appointed, comprising representatives of the Treasury,
Agriculture, and Commerce Departments, the Shipping and War
Trade Boards, and the Tariff Commission, for the’jpurpose of pre­

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

97

paring an entirely new classification applicable to both imports
and exports. It was decided that the present alphabetical ar­
rangement should be discarded and that the commodities in the
new classification should be grouped in io great classes according
to their character, the origin of the component materials rather
than their use being the guiding principle in classifying. Each
of the io main groups is to be divided and subdivided into sub­
sidiary groupings, the decimal system of numbering being used in
order to facilitate mechanical tabulation and to provide elasticity
for future expansion. Comparability between imports and ex­
ports is to be preserved, but in cases where the imports or exports
are not of the same importance for certain groups the classification
need not be shown in the same detail. Quantities are to be shown
in all cases either in standard commercial units or in weights.
Trade organizations and experts have prepared detailed sched­
ules for their particular lines. The arrangement and condensation
of the various classifications submitted has proved a huge task.
It had been planned to put the new classification into effect on
January i, 1919, but this was found impracticable, and the work
has continued uninterruptedly up to the present time. It is
expected that January 1, 1920, will be the effective date, unless
some now unforeseen event should make further postponement
necessary.
Original Research and Compilation of Foreign Statistics.
In the research division of the bureau there were prepared
during the year, in addition to the Statistical Abstract of the
United States and the annual pamphlet on wholesale prices, spe­
cial publications on Statistics of German Trade, Statistics of
Austro-Hungarian Trade, International Trade in Footwear, and
International Trade in Cement. The two reports on the commerce
of the cential Empires have proved of great value to students of
their economic development, as well as to business men who are
interested in the markets formerly supplied from Teutonic sources.
Studies are in course of preparation covering the international
trade in cotton goods, motor vehicles and bicycles, horse-drawn
vehicles, agricultural implements and machinery, paper and its
.manufactures, electrical goods and machinery, and manufactures
of leather other than boots and shoes.
The research division prepared the statistical tables for the
bureau’s monograph on Economic Reconstruction in European
Countries.
140261— 19------7

98

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

In order to assist in placing American oversea trade on the
firmest possible basis, one of the experts of the research division,
during the last half of the fiscal year, has paid special attention
to the possibilities of employing American capital abroad. In the
Far Hast and Latin America are great resources that have scarcely
been touched, and it is believed that this branch of the bureau’s
activity will conduce very materially to the profit of American
financiers and merchants.
Division of Foreign Tariffs.
During the past year the publication work of the bureau’s divi­
sion of foreign tariffs had to be largely subordinated to the rapidly
growing correspondence, dealing primarily with the great number
of foreign restrictions on commerce. The increase in the divi­
sion’s mail was particularly noticeable after the armistice, reaching
a monthly average of nearly 1,000 letters, compared with an
average of less than 250 during the preceding year. Inquiries
regarding foreign rates of duty were comparatively few. The
foreign import restrictions, on the other hand, formed a very
serious obstacle to export trade, and it required a considerable
amount of ingenuity and diplomacy to get the average exporter
to see the broader problems of exchange, international commercial
policies, and national interests involved in the import prohibition
on the particular article in which he was interested.
The work of the division in connection with foreign trade-mark
legislation, and especially the examination of official publications
with a view to detecting attempts to pirate American trade­
marks, has been considerably extended and has resulted in a
number of very desirable new connections among American firms.
The division has also succeeded in aiding American firms to recover
trade-marks that had been appropriated by their agents.
The question of the expansion of American parcel-post facilities
with foreign countries has figured rather prominently in the work
of the division, which has kept in close touch with the activities
of the Post Office Department along those lines. It is gratifying
to note that the economic importance of parcel post is receiving
increased recognition and that parcel-post service to a considerable
number of countries has been inaugurated during the past year.
Editorial Division.
Up to the time hostilities ceased there was so pronounced a
shortage in incoming reports from the bureau’s field staff that for
a time the editorial division seemed confronted with the inevitable

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

99

necessity of reducing the size of Commerce Reports. But within
a month after the armistice was signed there were so many reports
in hand that the facilities of the division and of the entire bureau
were taxed to give them proper distribution.
The work performed in the division during the year amounted
to approximately 12,800 printed pages, as compared with 10,872
pages during the preceding year. Fourteen monographs were pre­
pared for publication in the Special Agents Series and 12 in the
Miscellaneous Series. The number of pages in Commerce Reports
jumped from 4,912 in 1918 to 5,760 in 1919, the increase occurring
during the last six months. The number of foreign-trade oppor­
tunities published in this daily paper increased from 806 for the
first six months of the fiscal year 1919 to 1,897 for the six months
just closing. An increase of more than a thousand in the paid
circulation of the paper has also taken place.
A new series of publications, designated Industrial Standards,
which will give substantial aid in trade promotion with Latin
America, made excellent progress during the year. The first 62
numbers in the series have been issued. They are bilingual
editions, in Spanish and English, of standard specifications of the
American Society for Testing Materials. This wrork will be con­
tinued during the current year by the translation of these specifi­
cations into French and the publication of French-English editions
for distribution in the several countries of Europe where that
language is used. It is also planned to publish a bilingual edition,
in French and English, of the Standardization Rules of the Ameri­
can Institute of Electrical Engineers.
Recommendations.
i.
The commercial-attaché service has, during the four years
that it has been established, amply proved its value. There has
been a distinct field to be filled by men with broad economic and
business training devoting their entire time to the important
problem of promoting American commerce abroad. Commercial
attachés have in almost every instance been of continued assist­
ance to the embassies and legations to which they have been
attached, because important commercial questions have been con­
stantly coming up where the advice and assistance of a trained
man were of great value. It can further be said that commercial
attachés have constantly been of assistance to other departments
of our Government which have sent important official repre­
sentatives abroad. Commercial attachés have turned their hands
to whatever task of a commercial character was at hand to do.

IOO

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

At the same time constant assistance has been given to visiting
American business men who have been endeavoring to enter new
markets and to organize their business along sound lines. The
commercial attaché has been a commercial counselor of high grade
whose service has been found so useful that his time and energy
have been taxed to the utmost. It is in accordance with proved
usefulness that I strongly recommend the extension and improve­
ment of this service. The kind of men who are useful for this
work can obtain large salaries in the employ of American com­
panies engaged in export business, as evidenced by the fact that
commercial attachés have been lost again and again on this ac­
count. After an official of this class has the advantage of sev­
eral years’ experience it is a distinct loss to the Government to
have him leave and to have to put in a new man. The responsible
nature of the commercial attaché’s work and the high-grade men
required make it necessary to pay higher salaries than we have
been able to do. It is also necessary to provide more clerical
assistance than has been permitted under the organic law. I
recommend substantial increase in the appropriation for the commercial-attaché service.
2. Under the general head of “ Promoting commerce” come the
special investigations made by trade commissioners, the functions
of the district offices, and other work of similar character. It has
been possible to obtain high-grade specialists to make investiga­
tions in specific lines. Reports and monographs which have been
published at regular intervals have been utilized to a great extent
by the different trades. This is a work which I feel should be
continued. The district offices, established in principal cities,
have come to be focal points for foreign-trade information and
have done splendid work in making available a large amount of
commercial information received from American representatives
abroad These offices are in need of larger staffs and higher
salaries. Again and again district office managers who have done
excellent work have been given positions with private firms at
higher salaries.
3. The Latin American, Far Eastern, and Russian divisions
have coordinated commercial information relating to their re­
spective territories and have made it available to American
exporters. This specialized service has met with an excellent
response. It is a kind of work which I believe should be extended.
4. It is important that the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic
Commerce should have an adequate sum for post allowances to be

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

IO I

granted to its representatives abroad to offset unusual high cost
of living charges and uncertain conditions prevailing at the present
time in different countries. The wisdom of granting post allow­
ances has been demonstrated in the case of the American diplo­
matic and consular service under the Department of State.
5. The Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce distributes
to the American business public not only information received
from its own representatives abroad but also a large amount of
valuable commercial intelligence.which comes in from American
diplomatic and consular officers. During the present period of
international trade adjustment it is important to have frequent
reports to indicate changes which are constantly occurring. This
current commercial information should be transmitted to inter­
ested American exporters without delay. The statutory staff of
the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce is the medium
through which this information must pass. With an unprece­
dented amount of valuable information to distribute and a greatly
increased demand on the part of the public for information of
this character, the strain placed upon the statutory staff of the
bureau has been very great. It is necessary to have an increased
clerical force and also added provision for competent adminis­
trative officers. The salaries in the bureau in Washington have
not been sufficient to hold highly trained men, who have left the
service to enter private employment.
6. The international trade situation is to-day a matter of vital
importance to the prosperity of this country. It is essential that
the most authentic information about foreign markets be obtained
and distributed. In order to do this work effectively, sound
constructive plans should be made. Men trained in foreign
investigation and in the analysis of foreign-trade conditions are
to-day in very great demand in private business. The Bureau
of Foreign and Domestic Commerce has been to a considerable
extent a training school for men who have later obtained impor­
tant positions with private companies. It is my opinion that the
time has come when sufficient means should be provided so that
the foreign-trade service of our Government, represented by the
Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce, may be placed on
some permanent self-supporting basis, so that accumulated expe­
rience may be retained. The service of the Bureau of Foreign
and Domestic Commerce deserves to be given increased appro­
priations necessary to enable it to carry on successfully the
valuable work which it is attempting to do.

NATIONAL BUREAU OF STANDARDS.
(Dr. S. W. S tr a tto n , Director.)

The National Bureau of Standards is organized in nine scientific
and technical divisions, the office, the mechanical plant, and the
technical shops— 88 separate sections in all. The bureau’s staff
during the year included 1,150 employees. The scientific library
has 17742, volumes, chiefly in physics, chemistry, and the special
technologies, and 442 scientific periodicals from all parts of the
world are currently received. There are 13 principal laboratory
buildings, 'connected by service tunnels, and the equipment
includes a liquid-air plant, a refrigeration system, power plant,
gas and electric generators, and a system of technical services,
such as time signals, electric current, gas, steam, compressed air,
vacuum refrigerating brine, and others which are connected to
the various laboratories. The bureau also has woodworking
shops, instrument shops, a glass-blowing and a glassworking shop,
and a well-equipped photographic laboratory.
The transition from war to peace brought special problems of
reconstruction of work in the face of reduced funds, and many
resignations, aggregating 378 (exclusive of 1,127 separations of a
temporary character). To maintain the staff, 1,909 appointments
were made. Certain military researches were continued because
of their permanent value to the Army and Navy. Researches for
other departments and for the industries— deferred somewhat
during the war— were resumed, and peace programs of industrial
research were taken up vigorously. Estimates were submitted
to Congress for this industrial work.
The scientific and technical knowledge derived from researches
and investigations is disseminated through printed publications,
51 of which were issued during the year, comprising 36 new
issues (12 scientific papers, 15 technologic papers, 6 circulars, and
3 miscellaneous publications) and 15 revised editions. A descrip­
tive list of publications was issued, in which there is given a
brief technical abstract with each title, which, with a subject index,
makes it specially useful to experts interested in any of the
bureau's varied fields of work. In addition, the bureau issues a
series of monthly technical news bulletins, in which during the past
vear 426 separate topics were treated, thus giving promptly sum­
mary news notes of the bureau’s researches. An important func­
tion of the bureau is to make quickly accessible the results of
new scientific researches.
102

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

IO3

Weights and Measures.
During the year, in its new circular on the measurement of mass,
the bureau announced new standards of construction and accuracy
for weights. This type of service in the interest of national
uniformity is of great value to science and industry. The bureau
also certified weights, giving corrections for each, so that fairly
accurate weights may give very accurate results when the certified
corrections are applied.
In the bureau’s weighing laboratory 2,594 weights and 36
balances were standardized. Many interesting problems were
handled, new methods of determining the weight of a bushel of
wheat from samples, verification of standard grain testers, errors
in weights caused by brittle lacquer, and the discovery that
atmospheric humidity seriously affected the behavior of the
bureau’s new precision balance for assay weights.
In a larger way the bureau standardized mine scales and rail­
road track scales, using its traveling test cars, each equipped with
weights totaling 100,000 pounds. During the year bureau experts
inspected mine scales in Ohio, West Virginia, Kentucky, and
Maryland, where bad conditions were investigated and rectified.
The necessity of regular testing was clearly proven, the State
mining laws were clarified on the points involved, effective safe­
guards assured, and the suspicions and discontent of the miners
allayed. In all 352 railroad track scales were tested by the
bureau in 33 States of the Union on behalf of the U. S. Railroad
Administration, including 10 master scales used as standards to
check locally the weights of the railroad’s track-scale test cars.
The results of the bureau’s work are being incorporated in standard
specifications for railroad track scales, prepared in cooperation with
the technical interests concerned. These will promote efficiency
and accuracy in large scale weighings on railroads, the importance
of which may be gauged by the freight revenues collected on the
readings of railroad track scales amounting to several billion
dollars in a year.
The Twelfth Annual Conference on Weights and Measures at
the Bureau of Standards, attended by 180 experts and delegates
representing 29 States, adopted specifications for gasolinemeasuring pumps, recommended that the bureau be empowered
to pass upon types of measuring devices, approved the decimal
flour bill, favored the sale of dry commodities by weight, the
marking of net weight on wrapped meats, standardization of

104

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

packages, and advocated the adoption of the international metric
system of weights and measures.
The bureau has formulated model State laws, held conferences
on the technical details of inspection service, and consulted State
and local officials on technical legislation. Much of the new legis­
lation is developed with the cooperation of the bureau. Several
States, notably Texas, North Dakota, and South Dakota, have
just enacted laws establishing State-wide inspection services for
the first time. Many States ask aid in establishing State depart­
ments of weights and measures, in field investigation, and in
deciding the fitness of measuring devices. Specific aid was
given Maine and Texas where new laws provide that after July i,
1920, no weighing or measuring apparatus may be sold unless it
is approved by the Bureau of Standards. These actions em­
phasize the need of a similar national law.
The bureau’s length laboratory is the agency for the basic
control of all length measurements and all measures derived
therefrom. The distribution of accuracy in length is mainly
through the standardization of the manufacturers’ standards,
which control output, and through the standardization of the
State standard by which local inspection is regulated.
The bureau also devised means to measure the thickness of
paint films— a problem of protection of ordnance shells, the
paint film on which must be thick enough to protect and thin
enough to avoid rubbing when fired. Methods were also devel­
oped to measure, with a high degree of accuracy, the celluloid
photorecords of gunfiring. The wide range of technical uses of
sieves in industrial laboratories and the great importance of
fineness determinations led the bureau to a scientific study of the
whole subject which has resulted in a revised scale of sieve sizes.
No length measures are more interesting than the modern
precision gauge blocks by which the dimensional accuracy of tools,
machines, and countless other factory products is assured.
The bureau’s successful development and production of gauges,
which excel by 100 per cent the quality and accuracy of the best
imported gauges, is now well known. The high precision of these
gauges is controlled by the direct use of waves of light to measure
the errors, some of them less than one-millionth of an inch. The
Government was unable to obtain the needed gauges of this type
from foreign makers during the war. It is interesting and sig­
nificant that the bureau was able to develop the methods and
make up enough gauges to supply the Government need at a total

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

10 5

cost less than the market value of the imported gauges needed at
the outset.
The bureau conducted courses of instruction in measurement
and in the use of the bureau’s special gauge-testing apparatus
and methods in field work. The courses were attended by Gov­
ernment supervisors and inspectors from both War and Navy
Departments and from manufacturers of munitions and military
material.
Valuable work of the highest precision attainable is being done
on the measurement of the expansion of materials with tempera­
ture. Two examples of the 121 tests made will illustrate. The
bureau developed a new type of porcelain for use in spark plugs
of motors. To prevent cracking at the high heats encountered,
the expansion of spark-plug porcelain in service should be exactly
the same as tha,t of the metal electrodes used in producing the
spark. So, too, dental filling amalgams must be “ balanced” ;
that is, made up to expand equally with the teeth. The measure­
ment of the minute changes of size involved required optical
methods, the expansion being measured by the use of light waves.
As a result of this.work, specifications will be drawn up for these
materials by the bureau in cooperation with the research institute
of the National Dental Association.
The need for the bureau’s work in standardizing capacity meas­
ures for technical uses is shown by the fact that only two-thirds
of the volumetric apparatus tested by the bureau during the year
passed the test. These measures included burettes, cylindrical
graduates, dilution pipettes, transfer and measuring pipettes, and
flasks. One-sixth of the density-measuring devices, hydrometers,
salinometers, etc., were rejected. In addition to the testing of
gas-meter provers, the bureau made an inspection of 103 large
natural-gas meters used in supplying towns with natural gas, and
disclosed the fact that several million dollars’ worth of gas is being
lost in a year by leakage in the distributing systems.
The Government shipbuilding program involves, among other
things, a continuance of the testing of special timepieces for the
new ships. In the time laboratory nearly 10,000 timepieces were
tested, ranging from 12 minutes for stop watches to roo days for
master-clock systems. Class A certificates were given for 19 out of
82 watches tested. The system for testing is thoroughly established
and the fundamental time indications of the Riefler standard
clock of the bureau is maintained with a constancy within a small
fraction of a second a month.

io 6

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Electricity.
Electrical science and industry depend upon the bureau’s
fundamental standards for uniformity in the electrical measures
and data which are the basis of all electrical work. These stand­
ards are applied to the industries largely through the makers of
electrical measuring instruments and appliances. The manu­
facturers’ standards are checked up at the bureau, thus assuring
nation-wide uniformity at the source.
The bureau’s electrical testing for the industries keeps it in close
touch with industrial needs, and its testing for the Government
assures suitable quality of delivered supplies and yields data
needed by the bureau for perfecting standards of quality and per­
formance. Such standards gather up new scientific results and
service experience and apply them in the industries through the
specifications for supplies and equipment, and ,thus become an
agency for stimulating industrial progress.
The electrical laboratories cover work in photometry, radio
communication, X ray and radium, and public utilities.
'Phe bureau’s researches in the war involving electrical princi­
ples covered many subjects— the location of ejiemy batteries by
means of sound-recording mechanisms, the electrical control of
airplane guns to fire between the propeller blades, time studies of
gunfiring, variation of gun pressures, ejection-velocity studies by
recoil meters, the development of kinemometers to measure the
jumps and whip of a gun on firing, the measurement of projectile
velocities inside the gun, and scientific studies of the gun blast.
A special investigation of battleship-turret firing was made and
the firing circuits greatly improved. From experimental work
and the theoretical studies involved the bureau was enabled to
develop numerous new devices and methods of measurement ap­
plied to artillery problems The bureau’s technical resources
and ingenuity were applied to perfecting the plans of experiment
and the devices themselves. The results in actual practice have
been gratifying. A bureau expert was sent to France and England
to further study the problems of gunfiring, and the basis for new
and important work has been thus established. Other electrical
military work included the investigation of technical methods of
protecting ships against mines, the measurement of speed of bullets
fired by centrifugal guns, and a large amount of technical con­
sultation work on electricity applied to warfare. A recent report
of the War Department announced that the latest sound-ranging

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

IO7

system developed at the Bureau of Standards for the location of
enemy batteries proved to be superior to all such systems in use
when the armistice was signed.
An electrical method was also developed for measuring the
velocity of flame propagation in the cylinders of internal-com­
bustion engines. This is a contribution to the general problem
of automotive power plants, the full program for which is being
vigorously taken up by the power-plant laboratory of the bureau.
The electrical principles involved in the design of spark plugs,
magnetos, and complete ignition systems are carefully studied.
It is of interest to note that in connection with the investigation
of the design of this new spark plug, the bureau’s ceramics staff
developed a new type of porcelain, having the electrical and
thermal properties required.
The war made necessary the standardization of military supplies.
The bureau’s cooperation was sought, and some of its experts gave
their full time for several months with a highly gratifying result.
In fact, the success opened up the subject of standardization on a
much broader scale, and, especially in connection with the elec­
trical supplies and equipment, a most thorough standardization
was completed. The results are embodied in the new catalogues
of military supplies.
A valuable standardization work was the development of
standards of quality and performance for electric dry cells. The
vast number of these cells used throughout the country and by
the Army and Navy made the subject one of considerable economic
importance. The investigation was successfully completed and
the results embodied in a published circular giving the specifica­
tions for and methods of testing dry cells. A similar work on
storage batteries is well under way.
The bureau developed a method by which aviators may land
in the fog or dark. The system involves the use of automatic
radio signaling equipment on the landing field in combination
with suitably designed direction finders on the airplane. Practical
trials proved entirely successful. The development was under­
taken for the Air Mail Service. A landipg field was equipped
for the purpose. Automatic signals are encountered by the air­
plane as high as 6,000 feet from the ground, and with the direc­
tion finder the aviator locates his position with respect to the
ground and descends safely in fog or darkness. The bureau also
developed and successfully applied the most successful submarine
radio system, making possible signaling from a submerged sub­

108

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

marine for a distance of 12 miles and the receiving of signals
transmitted thousands of miles exactly as when received in the
air. This work involved the development of a satisfactory direc­
tion finder for use under water.
The bureau has rendered special service to radio communica­
tion in connection with the so-called “ electron tube,” sometimes
called by the more general name “ vacuum tube.” The new
electron tubes have revolutionized methods of radio communica­
tion since the outbreak of the war. The development has been
so rapid that it became necessary to completely standardize
electron tubes, so that their performance could be predicted in
every essential respect. This theory was worked out, and the
methods developed are described in a bureau publication now in
press. Radio-research headquarters for the Army and Navy
radio service are located in the laboratories of the Bureau of
Standards, and there has been most cordial and complete coopera­
tion between the Bureau of Standards, the Navy, and the War
Department experts.
Public Utilities.
The standards for public utilities developed by the bureau relate
especially to electric light and power, gas, street-railway, telephone
service, and miscellaneous industrial utilities. The bureau con­
ducts scientific and engineering research, studies the public-rela­
tions question, prepares specifications for the quality of such
service, outlines methods of testing and inspection, formulates
safety rules to safeguard the employees and the public, and collates
and distributes information impartially to all concerned. Publicutility standards are based upon standards of measure, quality,
and performance, and embody in numerical terms the ranges of
the pertinent factors defining quality, safety, economy, conven­
ience, and efficiency. Owing to the unusual conditions, the publicutility staff of the bureau during the past two years has been
called upon for an unprecedented amount of work. The bureau
attained an enviable position as an impartial referee in such sub­
jects and settled disputed questions on a scientific basis. The
work has been especially fruitful in assuring to the public a means
of specifying adequacy and safety in the production and distribu­
tion of electric power, gas, and other forms of service.
The bureau’s gas-service standards have proved of great use­
fulness. Cooperative investigations have been made on behalf of
State and local public-service commissions in several States and

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

109

for many cities. On behalf of the State commission for Indiana
cooperative tests at coal-gas plants in the State resulted in new
features of gas standards fully set forth in the bureau’s report—
the most complete and convincing effort ever made on behalf of
a public-service commission to determine the best requirements
for a State. The data will be valuable to the gas industry.
The bureau’s investigation of an industrial-gas enterprise in
Maryland resulted in technical recommendations to the manage­
ment which will “ ultimately turn a loss into a substantial profit."
The bureau’s staff visited 14 different localities, in addition to
supplying many requests for information by correspondence and
in conference. Much valuable data were made available for the
gas companies and the municipalities on matters of controversy
or public agitation.
The bureau’s standards for electrical safety service are being
revised on the basis of experience. In this work the bureau has
had the cordial cooperation of public-service commissions, munici­
palities, and public-service corporations, as well as of national
technical societies and individual experts interested in the produc­
tion and use of electricity.
A new publication is now in preparation which will give the
bureau’s new ‘‘ Standards for street lighting service.” The ex­
perimental and field investigations of street lighting upon which
these standards are based, comprised inspections of municipal and
private plants, the direct measurements of street lights, and con­
ferences with illuminating engineers and plant managers. Some­
what new in kind is the bureau’s study of standards for central
station, hot-water heating service undertaken for the State of
Indiana. Technical rules covering the factors of adequacy and
safety of such service formulated by the bureau were adopted
substantially as recommended. These standards are included in
a circular on “ Standards for steam and hot-water service” now
nearly completed.
Telephone service standards are of nation-wide importance, and
the bureau is preparing two publications on the subject. The
bureau gathers technical data for impartial dissemination to the
telephone industry, to regulatory commissions, and to the telephone-using public. One new circular will give an account of the
modern telephone service, and a second will describe in detail the
service in selected cities. The bureau assisted in standardizing
and defining the technical terms employed in telephony in America
and Great Britain.

I IO

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Standards of safety have engaged the earnest attention of the
bureau's staff with a view to reducing life and property hazards
arising from the use of electricity and from general industrial
processes.
The Electrical Safety Code, of which a new edition is now in
preparation, has been adopted by at least 20 administrative
bodies throughout the country and recommended for use by many
others. In several States, notably Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and
Montana, this code is now mandatory. It has been voluntarily
adopted by a large number of industrial concerns and, in general,
has met with nation-wide approval.
There was held at the Bureau of Standards a conference on
industrial safety codes which was attended by more than 100
representatives of different interested organizations. The con­
ference agreed that the Bureau of Standards should lead in the
work, and plans are now under way to arrange the most effective
cooperation in the preparation of industrial safety codes. The
bureau has already prepared a number of such codes, namely,
National Elevator Safety Code, National Code for Safeguarding
Machines and Machine Drives, National Code for the Protection
of Head and Eyes of Industrial Workers, and National Code for
Safeguarding Remote Control Apparatus.
The bureau’s technical investigation of the damage to structures
by stray electric currents from street mains has resulted in the
development of standard electrolysis surveys and standard pro­
cedure for electrolysis mitigation. Solutions were recently arrived
at in several cities in Missouri, Ohio, and Indiana. New apparatus
for use in electrolysis surveys has been designed, constructed, and
tested at the bureau. The results are so satisfactory that they
will be applied to the bureau’s field work during the next few
months.
Radium.
The importance of radium in surgery and in dermatology has
caused a rapid growth in the bureau’s testing-of-radium prepara­
tions, 474 of which were tested during the year, containing a total
of 13,159 milligrams, having a market value of $1,500,000. These
specimens were certified about equally for the military depart­
ments, for commercial export, and for domestic use.
An important use of radium salts is in the self-luminous paints
for marking watch dials and other objects.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Ill

The modern use of such materials containing radium salts has
rapidly developed. The demand for their standardization resulted
in the bureau’s taking up the work at the request of the Army and
Navy. The bureau furnished information concerning the proper­
ties of luminous materials, methods of measuring their brightness,
estimates of cost of preparation of apparatus and supplies for
factory inspection of the dials, extended study of selected speci­
mens by experiment, and the preparation of models. In this work
the bureau has had the most- cordial cooperation of the manufac­
turers and civilian users. Much information is included in a cir­
cular on “ Self-luminous materials,” prepared by the bureau for
early publication.
Heat.

The measured control of temperature is a vital factor in many
industries. The Bureau of Standards maintains the standard
temperature scale for the country, conducts researches in heat
and temperature measurements, the measuring apparatus used,
and distributes samples of standard pure metals having certified
melting points, and of standard materials having certified com­
bustion heat values. These certified materials are used locally
to standardize the heat and temperature measuring apparatus in
industrial laboratories for the control of processes of production.
During the past year 20,000 thermometers and other heat­
measuring devices were tested and certified in the bureau’s
laboratories. The heat division also serves as a national bureau
of information on temperature and heat measurements; hundreds
of letters and scores of visiting experts have called for a wide range
of data needed in the conduct of industrial researches or in the
control of industrial processes.
The maintenance of the fundamental temperature scale requires
elaborate researches and exacting experimental work. The scales
are fixed by the melting and boiling points of metals and other
materials, the basic ioo° interval lying between the freezing and
boiling points of water. A type of research required is illustrated
in a paper, published during the year, on the standardization of
the sulphur boiling point, one of the fixed points of the tempera­
ture scale. To secure constancy of indication of this boiling
point, specific experimental conditions must be carefully observed.
Similar precautions must be adopted in all other fixed-point
determinations. A new thermometer comparator was devised in
which melted metal secures the needed temperature uniformity.

I I2

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Success in producing high-quality optical glass depends upon
the removal of internal strains by effective annealing methods.
The heat experts of the bureau recently developed methods for
such annealing and for determining by simple tests the practical
temperatures required and procedure to be followed. The timetemperature curves for producing ovens were worked out by
bureau heat experts for two leading types of coke ovens. The
determination of the properties of ammonia now7 completed sup­
plies refrigeration engineers for the first time with complete and
reliable data on this important material, for the calculation of
tables covering ranges from — 750 to + 70o in place of the meager
data previously available.
During the year 106 structural columns were tested in the sys­
tematic program of investigations on the fire-resistive properties
of structural materials to furnish needed basic data as to materials
commonly used in buildings under fire conditions. Fire tests
were followed by water application to determine the final resistance
of the columns to fire and their action when suddenly cooled by
hose streams. The resulting data are the most comprehensive
ever available. Unprotected steel was found to sustain loads for
less than a half hour, concrete columns for over eight hours.
Duplicate tests checked within 10 or 20 per cent. The bureau
also cooperated in fire-safety w7ork and in the movement for fire
protection and prevention. Special conferences were held on the
hazards in cotton ginning, fertilizer handling, petroleum shipping,
pyroxylin plastics, including motion-picture films.
The Bureau of Standards has the only “ altitude laboratory"
in the country. This is a small room which may be made air­
tight and the air partially removed to produce the low pressures
encountered at high altitudes. The laboratory and results obtained
have been described in four published reports. The engine to be
tested is operated in the room and is supplied with cold air at
temperatures actually encountered at any altitude desired. Avi­
ation engines of several types, including the “ Liberty 12,” have
thus been tested at simulated altitudes of 30,000 feet under the
most scientific observation and measurement.
The new “ altitude laboratory,” now nearly completed, will fur­
nish ampler space and exceptional facilities for testing internalcombustion engines for automotive purposes. Scientific studies
on basic problems are in progress; for example, on the rate of
flame propagation in a gas-engine cylinder and on pressure cycles,
carburetion, ignition, lubrication, etc. The work is a splendid

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

113

example of technology developed during the war and adapted
almost without change to important industrial uses.
A series of informal bulletins were issued to disseminate the
results of the bureau’s engine researches. Seven such bulletins
treated of spark-plug problems, seven of engine radiators, and
other reports will appear in the next volume of the proceedings of
the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics. The demand
for the bureau’s tables of melting points of the chemical elements
exhausted the edition, and a more complete edition, recently
prepared, completes the present data on fixed temperatures. The
bureau has published a number of scientific papers on high tem­
perature subjects; e. g., optical methods of temperature measure­
ments above 1,500° centigrade; recording pyrometry for use
where a printed record is useful; automatic control of high tem­
peratures by which, for example, the supply of fuel is automati­
cally varied to maintain the furnace at any desired temperature.
Serious losses entailed by furnace failures make a recent paper
on the melting points of refractory materials a timely contribu­
tion to industrial economy.
History of the Production of Optical Glass by the Bureau of
Standards.
The removal, now in progress, of the optical-glass plant from
Pittsburgh to Washington closes the first period of its history.
A brief risumi of its work foljows:
For some time prior to 1914, the bureau had felt the necessity
of the United States shaking off the yoke of complete dependence
on Europe for its optical glass. European manufacturers had so
carefully guarded the secrets of their technique that the necessary
preliminary investigations were far too extensive and too expen­
sive to expect commercial corporations to undertake the pioneer
work. With this object in view, a scientific expert, with a knowl­
edge of glass making, was appointed in July, 1914, to take up
experimental investigation of the production of optical glass.
He was not an expert in optical glass, however, for there were
none in this country at that time. The necessary preliminaries
had been completed by December, 1914, is shown by a report of
three “ runs of optical glass” for that month.
In 1915, 76 melts and 54 pots were made, a new furnace built,
3 different types of optical glass produced, and some annealing
experiments carried out.
140261—19---- 8

I 14

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The new developments of 1916 included the building of a threechamber furnace, comparative corrosion tests of the molten glass
on pots made of domestic and imported clays, the production of
a “ very satisfactory” new mixture for pots, and, finally, a batch
of borosilicate glass, free from striae, although not entirely free
from bubbles.
The investigations of 1917 brought out the fact that the poor
melts were largely due to unsatisfactory pots. So, the solution
of this problem was attacked with increased vigor, resulting in
one of the most important steps forward in the history of glass
production anywhere; i. e., the casting of pots instead of making
them by hand. This method greatly reduces the difficulty, the
time, and the cost of making the pots. Those obtained on the
market were strongly attacked, especially by the barium glasses,
sometimes being eaten entirely through by the molten glass,
with the result, of course, that the glass mixture was both impure
and discolored.
When this country entered the war in April, 1917, the bureau
had made over one hundred melts of glass and nearly that many
pots.
Furthermore, it was at that time making melts of the important
borosilicate and barium crown glasses on a commercial scale. In
November, 1917, 16 melts of 600 pounds each were reported and
shipments to the factories made. From then on regular ship­
ments continued, that one in the month preceding the armistice
being recorded as 3,021 pounds of first-grade binocular glass, rep­
resenting more than 15,000 pounds of glass actually produced.
True to the original object in view, the bureau, in addition to
the production of considerable optical glass for military purposes,
has at all times given freely all possible assistance to those engaged
in the manufacture of jglass. They have frequently consulted its
experts as to methods of manipulation, materials, and the manu­
facture of pots. Conferences have been held at the bureau and
its experts sent to the factories when requested. These efforts
have been cordially received and appreciated, as shown at one of
the meetings of the optical-glass section of the War Industries
Board, where the president of a large glass corporation stipulated
that they would take up the production of optical glass for one
of the entente nations provided the Bureau of Standards would
send experts to the factory to lend technical help.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

1 15

Light.
The bureau develops light standards, instruments, and methods
for measuring light illumination, and determines the optical
properties of materials and optical instruments. The precise
measurement of light waves, apparently of purely scientific inter­
est, proved to be of the utmost practical value during the war,
since light waves were used by the bureau to control the accuracy
of the master gauges used in the manufacture of munitions.
The bureau continued the precise measuring of standard wave
lengths of selected radiation of the various chemical elements.
Special experience and facilities in red and infra-red photography
enabled it to do useful work in this field of radiation in the study
of solar radiations which could not be photographed heretofore
nor observed visually. The bureau’s recent spectrographs of the
sun in the red and the invisible radiation beyond the red proved
the presence in the sun of 27 known elements. In the red-region
radiation, or spectra, 8 metals and 2 rare gases were examined,
new work nearly completed on 10 other elemental metals, and
work on rare earth elements begun.
The bureau has had success in photographing through light
fogs or haze. Color screens to cut off the characteristic light of
the haze in combination with red, sensitized photoplates enable
the plate to record only the light from the landscape behind the
haze. The pinacyanol-stained plates proved four times faster
than the best commercial panchromatic plates in use. New and
important fields of optical research are thus opened in photography
which will demand the design of new lenses adapted to red light,
the study of radiation reflection by landscapes, and special studies
of sensitizing dyes.
Color standards and methods of color measurements are now
being placed on an excellent scientific basis. The bureau pro­
poses, in certain cases, to discontinue color grading in terms of
material color standards which are difficult to obtain, duplicate,
or certify accurately. The new method is to determine the color
transmission of light of a definite wave length. This gives an
essential property of the material itself independent of the color
vision of the observer. The observation easily made in repro­
ducible units eliminates arbitrary, ill-defined standards. System­
atic color standards and measurements are of interest in many
industries— paints, dyes, inks, textiles, paper, flour, soap, tobacco,
butter, and other products— all make the field one of much com­

I l6

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

mercial and economic value. The special work of the year
included the color grading of papers, pyralin ivory, cottonseed
oil, and other materials. The terms used in colorimetry need
standardization, and the bureau has aided in systematizing not
only the nomenclature, but the units, standards, and symbols.
At the request of the eye-hygiene committee of the American
Medical Association, the bureau is investigating various glasses
now on the market purporting to suppress harmful radiations.
A technologic paper was prepared on the basis of tests of 82
samples of eye-protective glasses now on the American market.
With this data, oculists or buyers may now prescribe or order
glasses having any desired color transmission, acceptance being
based upon color tests.
Research on quartz resulted in a new means of fixing one point
on the high-temperature scale in a region not otherwise well
defined; i. e., 573°-3. A very sudden change occurs in the
optical properties of quartz, the sharpness of which makes it
suitable for the purpose. The action of quartz in twisting the
direction of vibration of light waves is known as polarization.
This is the basis of polarimetry. The subject has a high theoretical
value in physics and many practical uses; e. g., it is the practical
basis of sugar testing. Sugar technology is based upon the read­
ings of the polarimeter, which indicate the percentage of pure
sugar in a raw sample. The bureau standardizes the quartz
plates, instruments, and accessories used, and a new fund granted
by Congress has recently given special impetus to the work, which
is proceeding vigorously in cooperation with sugar technologists
and the sugar industry.
The distribution of the bureau’s standard samples of highly
purified sugar for verifying polarimeters is an important means of
technical control in the industry. The optical analysis of sugars
at the bureau has been a useful service to the industry and in the
control of the precision of sugar analyses of imported sugar for the
Customs Service.
The Medical Service of the War Department requested the
bureau’s aid in producing certain rare sugars, about 25 in number.
The bureau has tested a number of these by methods devised by
careful research. The insistent demands for these rare sugars has
led the bureau to study the sources and production. These sugars
range in value from a few dollars to several hundred dollars a
pound. The bureau has already developed successful methods

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

11 7

for producing pure, white crystals of the so-called d’mannite sugar
by double crystallization from the crude manna and at a reason­
able cost.
An example of the use of abstract physics for practical purposes
is the use of interference of light waves in studying the behavior of
the porcelains and amalgams used to fill teeth. The bureau has
for some time been investigating the expansion of such materials
when exposed to changes of temperature. This calls for exact
measurements of the expansion of these materials when heated.
Light waves and the phenomenon of interference are used to
measure this expansion with great precision. These dental mate­
rials were found to expand four times as much as the natural
teeth themselves. The data will aid in the development of more
perfect filling materials for the teeth.
The bureau designed and constructed or cooperated in the developement of many military optical devices. It designed a
spotting camera, for example, and redesigned a triangulation
camera for the Navy. The spotting camera complete with a
manual of instructions was turned over to the military authori­
ties, and the triangulation camera is now completed. The bureau
designed another camera for the panoramic photographing of the
inside of a machine-gun barrel. Related work included a night­
firing device, a marine position finder, a tank sight, a 37-milli­
meter gun sight, a periscope alidade, Army binoculars, and many
other instruments. The bureau also tested 2,000 binoculars, 54
lens systems, 436 samples of optical glass, and made 111 tests of
miscellaneous optical devices.
Radiometry comprises the field of visible and invisible radia­
tion. The work is mainly experimental and theoretical, but its
immediate application to the industries is both direct, interesting,
and important; for example, in high-temperature measurements
and researches on efficiencies of light sources. The bureau’s expert
reported to a Government department that plain glass is as useful
in greenhouses as the ribbed and hammered glasses sometimes
considered for such purposes. A radiophonic system of secret
signaling was developed by the use of the radiation properties of
molybdenite. The sensitiveness of this material made it possible
to secure a loud, musical sound by the invisible radiation of wave
lengths longer than red light. A system of invisible light signals
was also developed, using the ultra-violet waves. Recent use of
applied radiometry was made in connection with the glass roofs

II8

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

of balloon hangars. On request of the War Department, the
bureau recommended a substitute for the special colored glasses
designed to exclude the ultra-violet rays which have serious effect on
balloon fabric. The bureau’s advice was that they use asphaltum
varnish on plain glass, which, of course, is much more economical.
Chemistry.
In addition to distinctly chemical standardization, chemistry is
required in all fields of physical standardization. Many articles
published on chemical subjects on work done at the bureau show
the variety of application of chemistry in physics and the special
technologies. During the year, 18,436 chemical tests were made
by the bureau, largely of materials purchased by the Government.
Many researches were under way during the year, among which
several examples may be cited. Pure materials and their uses
form a series of standardization problems. The purification of
mercury is now on a routine basis. Pure methane was produced
for determining accurately its heat properties. Pure ethyl alcohol
was prepared for use in measuring its density and other properties.
The bureau’s electrochemical work included several useful
researches, such as the lead plating of gas shells, black nickel
plating for military equipment, and zinc plating to protect steel
from corrosion. Gas chemistry has had at the bureau certain
useful applications in aircraft. Balloon fabrics were tested for gas
permeability and lasting qualities, and methods and instruments
were developed for conducting such tests.
A new automatic gas-analysis apparatus, constructed at the
bureau, is now in operation at the Government nitrate plant at
Arlington. Apparatus was also constructed to record the amount
of helium in preparing the gas for use in balloons, and a set is now
under construction for the large helium plant of the War Depart­
ment by which 12 simultaneous and continuous analyses of helium
output are automatically made. The shortage of platinum during
the war led the bureau to the study of platinum substitutes and
certain alloys of gold containing palladium wrere found suitable for
many chemical operations.
The bureau has continued its interest in standardizing reagents
and in the proper labeling of chemical reagents, so that the serious
difficulty attending their use by chemists may be reduced. The
bureau has organized an interdepartmental committee on paintspecification standardization, and a conference was held at the
bureau. The first results are embodied in the Standard Specifica­

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

I 19

tions for Linseed Oil, recently published by the bureau. A new
edition of the circular on soaps was issued.
In addition, the bureau has continued technical analyses and
chemical researches on a very wide range of materials.
Materials.
The bureau’s work in materials includes a wide range of struc­
tural and miscellaneous materials, such as metals, cement, lime,
paper, textiles, rubber, leather, oils, clay products, etc.
All cement used by the Government, by Executive order, must
conform to the United States Government standard specifications
for cement. The cement tested by the bureau covered shipments
of 6,588,923 barrels, practically double that of the previous year,
and 12 times the amount tested in the year 1916-17. The rejection
of 10 per cent of the cement tested shows the need for such testing.
Researches were made on the properties of cement and concrete,
fineness of grinding, air analysis, standard cement sieves, volume
changes in finished mortars and cements, concrete oil storage,
waterproofing of concrete and stucco, and the acceleration of
hardening of cement. The bureau’s samples of finely ground
cement of definite and certified fineness of grain enables the tech­
nical laboratories of the country to standardize their own sieves
accurately.
The construction of concrete ships was initiated in the bureau’s
cement laboratory, the chief of which became the directing head
of such construction. The bureau has since continued its tech­
nical cooperation with the Shipping Board in numerous ways.
During the year, a study of the cement gun, by which the material
is shot in place instead of being cast, was completed and reported
upon. Improved methods were developed affecting the proper­
ties and ingredients of cement and concrete and the time of
mixing. A useftd improvement consisted in the use of papei
molds in place of the steel molds hitherto used for casting concrete
test cylinders.
Lime has commercial uses not only as a structural material,
but in other industries. Standards of quality for lime are quite
recent. In the work on lime the bureau has had the cordial
cooperation of the National Lime Association and similar organ
izations, all of which have committees on cooperation with the
bureau. Important researches under way during the year have
included the compressive strength of cement and lime mortar,
the effect of hydrated lime on the properties of cement, causes of

I

20

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

“ unsoundness ” in lime plasters, and the measurement of plas­
ticity. The bureau’s methods developed for the study of plasters
apply also to gypsum and other wall plasters.
Rubber has such varied and important uses that the bureau
endeavors to handle basic problems of the physics and chemistry
of rubber and develop methods of test. Methods of determining
the ingredients have been developed, and many samples of manu­
factured rubber goods were analyzed during the year, including
balloon fabrics, rubber tires, rubber packing, hospital supplies,
fire hose, and others. The bureau tested within a year samples
representing the purchase of about 250,000 tires and established a
local laboratory at one of the large rubber centers. Assistance was
rendered to makers of solid-rubber tires in improving compounds
used, and as a result a solid tire was developed which met all
requirements. The possibilities of rubber research are as broad
as the usefulness of the material. In the new quarters in the
industrial laboratory it is expected that the work may be extended
to include important and fundamental investigations.
The technology of leather is an important part of the bureau’s
work. A research completed during the year had to do with
certain chemicals, including glucose and salts, which are put into
the leather. The bureau is working in close cooperation with the
Tanners’ Council, the American Leather Research Laboratory,
and the War Department. Special studies were made on sole
leathers and on leather for shoe uppers to be used in the making
of Army shoes, and also on the physical properties of harness
leathers in connection with the stuffing material. Miscellaneous
tests in the leather laboratory cover leather packings, water­
proofed leather, and artificial leather.
The bureau cooperated in an advisory capacity in the develop­
ment of specifications for leather for the General Supply Com­
mittee, the War Department, and the Panama Canal. Much
progress may be expected during the coming fiscal year in this
direction. In this connection, arrangements have been partially
completed for installing an experimental tannery at the Bureau
of Standards for use in leather research. The new laboratory
provides ample space for extensive research and testing in accord­
ance with an outlined program.
The Government uses approximately 50,000 toils of paper per
year; this is bought on specification and tested at the Bureau of
Standards. Five thousand samples were examined, of which 4,213

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

I2 1

were for the Government, which included more than 19,000 separate
tests. The bureau demonstrated that 700,000 bales of munitions
linters left unused when the war closed could be used for the making
of paper. Samples of paper were experimentally made on its paper
mill to demonstrate that good paper could be made from such
linters. As a demonstration, the programs of the annual conven­
tion of the Interstate Cotton Seed Crushers^ Association of New
Orleans were printed on paper manufactured at the bureau from
cotton linters. About 700,000 bales per year are available for
paper making, and, if care is taken to keep the linters clean, a still
larger amount can be utilized.
The physical, chemical, and microscopic testing of textiles is an
important field of the work of the bureau which has had special
value during the war in connection with Army uniforms, blankets,
airplane and balloon. fabrics, tent material, and other fabrics.
The examination of English, French, and German fabrics showed
that few of them were as good as the average of American manufac­
ture. Woolen uniforms were examined for fastness of color, nature
of dye, and the amount of cotton present. During the year an
investigation has been in progress on sizing compounds for cotton
yarns preliminary to the work on practical experiments in the
bureau’s cotton mill. In connection with airplane fabrics a
study was made of stress in flight and new fabrics were designed
and manufactured to improve serviceability. The increasing size
of airplanes makes it important to have a stronger fabric. With
the same object a tautness meter was designed and constructed
at the bureau for the study of the wing fabrics in flight. Numerous
readings taken on wing coverings of planes showed that tautness
may be used to interpret the effects of humidity and tempera­
ture on the life of the fabric. With the occupancy of the new
industrial laboratory, the textile section will have unusual equip­
ment for research— a small felting unit, a complete unit of
cotton machinery, and a similar outfit of woolen machines. These
are of the latest manufactured design improved for the accurate
requirements of laboratory work. One important object in view
is the development of exact specifications for fabric, especially
for the military departments. Such specifications will also be
useful for other purposes, and the general results of the investiga­
tions will all be of service to the textile industry and the general
public.

1 22

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

'

The testing-machine laboratory has continued a long list of use­
ful investigations during the year, the tests numbering 3,000 in all.
Some of these were extensive researches such as the test of a 150ton floating crane for the Norfolk Navy Yard, the experimental
study of electric welding for the Emergency Fleet Corporation, and
technical investigations of motor-truck wheels and their behavior
under stress.
$
Aeronautical Instruments.
Measuring instruments are vital to control in aviation, and the
standardization of such instruments is of the utmost urgency.
The bureau reached mathematical solutions of the theory of such
instruments, so that the results may be applied to particular cases.
The failure of the metals used in the construction of aeronautic
instruments to be perfectly elastic proved to be a critical source
of error, and alloys were developed which are believed to be
superior to the metals previously used. The bureau has tested
578 airplane instruments, completed researches on the errors of
instruments, studied different types of tachometers, and deter­
mined the complete corrections for the barographs used in the flight
which established the world’s altitude record.
Members of the bureau’s staff conducted flight tests of airplane
instruments, making airplane flights in the dark to demonstrate a
projection-type, night-altitude indicator. A series of high-altitude
flights was made to study the oxygen-supply apparatus, the rate-ofclimb indicators, the gyroscope, and other inclinometers. Tests
were also made in flights across the English Channel and in the
suburbs of Paris.
An interesting example of the bureau’s work in technical educa­
tion was the school of aeronautic instruments conducted for avia­
tors. This included a three-weeks’ lecture and laboratory course
covering the theory and testing of aeronautical instruments. The
data and other illustrative materials for similar courses were also
furnished for the use of the Army.
Metals.
The metallurgical division of the bureau engages in fundamental
researches affecting the improvement of metals, the development
of new metals, and methods of avoiding metal failures and pro­
longing the useful life of metals and metal products. For this
purpose, the bureau has a well-equipped experimental foundry,
rolling mill, metallographic laboratory, heat-treatment laboratory,

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

123

chemical laboratories, and a full equipment of electrical furnaces
and pyrometers. The standardization of the purity, the compo­
sition, microstructure, and heat treatment are possible only
through the measured control of all the factors, such as tempera­
ture, rates of heating and cooling, pouring temperatures, etc.
Many practical problems of metal failures have been solved in the
laboratory and a great amount of work done on improving the
quality of metals by heat treatment and the standardization of
pouring temperatures and finishing temperatures.
An important output of the metal laboratory consists of specifi­
cations for metals for special uses. During the war a series of
aircraft-materials standards were developed. In peace times the
specifications cover the regular supplies needed by the Government
departments, and special cases, such as statuary bronzes and
metals for other special uses. Several cases of the bureau’s aid
to the metal industries will illustrate the work. Collapsible tin
tubes are used for many classes of materials, and at the request of
manufacturers of such tubes the bureau pointed out the several
causes of defects. The behavior of aeronautic-pressure instru­
ments depends upon the metal diaphragm. The success of several
new alloys designed to correct the errors in such instruments de­
pended upon proper annealing, for which suitable methods were
developed by the metal experts. The bureau studied the deteri­
oration of zinc-aluminum alloys used in die casting and reported
upon the limitations of such material for this work. In another
case the causes of certain defects in sterling-silver ware were pointed
out after careful study of the ware. Manufacturers of razors and
cutlery have recently requested the bureau to devise methods for
measuring and defining the sharpness of fine cutting edges. Since
this is practically a new field of standardization, there is little or
no available or published experience to serve as a basis.
Changes in the rate of cooling observed in any metal are indi­
cations of quality and composition. The study of these is called
“ thermal analysis.” An inexpensive method for such work was
applied at the bureau during the year, a stop watch being substi­
tuted for the expensive chronograph usually used. Heat treat­
ment is being examined with great care, and work is in active
progress on a widely used structural alloy steel (containing 3)/%
per cent nickel). The purpose is to correlate the properties with
certain tests now made throughout the country. A detailed
study of high-speed steels is being made to gain knowledge of their
constitution and properties and to develop a method for comparing

124

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

the relative value of two cutting steels. An important investiga­
tion is under way to find suitable steels and treatments for the
same for use in making precision length gauges. The important
factors in this work are the determination of the resistance to
wear and deformation with time, the resistance to corrosion,
soundness, expansibility, and economy under varying heat treat­
ments.
Small amounts of gases like nitrogen, hydrogen, and carbon
dioxide affect the breaking strength and other properties of
metals. These questions must be attacked in a fundamental
way, and the work in pure metals has this study as one of its
objects. Such pure metals are melted in vacuum furnaces, and
the product is practically gas free. In the making of alloys
uniformity is an important result to be attained, as segregation
naturally is detrimental to the quality of the alloy. The bureau
has conducted many studies of the “ segregation” of the ingre­
dients in the alloys. Work now in progress includes the prepara­
tion of electrolytic iron and melts or alloys prepared in. vacuum,
the making of pure aluminum, methods of determining gases in
steel, deoxidizing agents for steel making, and the development
of methods of steel analysis.
The bureau foundry is for experimental casting of metals and
alloys and also is used practically as a commercial foundry sup­
plying special castings for instrument parts required at the bureau
and by other Government laboratories. This is one of the very
few experimental foundries in the country, and it has many
possibilities for service to industry. The work of the foundry
included studies of Government bronze and its substitutes, studies
of the relation of statuary bronzes to their weathering efFects,
efficiency studies of electric furnaces, investigation of light alu­
minum-casting alloys, and practical and experimental castings for
laboratory use. An auxiliary investigation of molding sands of
various types is of great importance to the foundry industry.
New Industrial Laboratory.
The branch laboratory of the bureau which has been maintained
for some years at Pittsburgh, Pa., is to be discontinued and the
equipment, staff, and work consolidated with the main laboratories
of the bureau in Washington. On the completion of the new
industrial laboratory designed to house this work, the installation
began, and at this writing much of the equipment is transferred
from Pittsburgh into the new quarters. In this connection,

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

125

attention should be called to the excellent design of the new build­
ing and the unusual facilities which will be afforded for industrial
research, facilities probably unexcelled in any laboratory. The
facilities of the new laboratory include the full resources of the
well developed and equipped laboratories of the scientific divi­
sions, chemistry, heat, light, electricity, and the measures of
length, mass, capacity, density, pressure, and time.
Ceramics.
Clay products form a whole group of useful and art industries,
ranging from the crudest brick and tile to the finest porcelains
used in the household, including the art porcelain ware, vases,
and other art products. The bureau’s laboratories have been able
to reproduce many of the finest qualities of foreign ware, both
body and glaze. Chemical porcelain ware is a type of successful
work accomplished. Much remains to be done in placing the clayproducts’ industries on a thoroughly scientific basis, but great
progress has been made.
The refractory materials used in numerous industries have been
the subject of investigation at the bureau and new substances
having superior qualities have been developed. Several com­
panies have undertaken to manufacture, for example, a new type
of refractory proposed by the bureau last year, which combines
light weight, porosity, good heat-insulating properties, and a high
refractoriness, and is especially suited for use in marine boilers as
furnace crowns, and for kiln blocks for terra cotta. The bureau
has been able to produce pyrometer tubes more than 7 feet in
length of American porcelains, similar to those imported from
Germany before the war.
The investigations of hard-fire porcelains which have been under
way for three years are nearly completed. The properties of more
than 300 compositions have been studied to acquire the technical
data needed in the industry. Several thousand pieces of table­
ware were glazed and fired. The results will shed much light on
practical aspects of hard-fire porcelain manufacture.
Tiles used in wall construction were the subject of an important
investigation by the bureau. The results of about 250 tests are
published in a bureau technologic paper. The data will be valuable
for the building industries. It is found that the source of the clay
profoundly affects the clay behavior. The correlation data will
be complete when the results of similar tests from other labora­
tories are assembled. Gratifying results were obtained in the

126

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

study of architectural terra cotta. Much attention was paid to
examining materials in actual buildings for various periods of
time. Two striking types of failure were studied and accounted
for. The laboratory work included absorption tests, artificial
freezing, and strength determinations of terra cotta made from
various clays largely used by manufacturers. The test pieces
were burned at seven different temperatures. The resulting data
will soon be announced in a final report covering all the work of the
bureau on this building material.
Two technologic papers have been issued on the principles of
iron enameling and researches are under way to solve problems
met with in the manufacture of such materials.
The new industrial laboratory will give unusual facilities for the
work in clay products. All of the contracts for the new kilns
and furnaces have been let, the machinery has been purchased,
and the installation of the equipment has been begun.
*
The Bureau and Industrial Progress.
The Bureau of Standards occupies a pivotal position in indus­
trial reconstruction following the war. The great lesson of the
war was that standardization was a first essential to efficient war­
fare. War industry differs from the industries of peace mainly
in its urgency. The fundamental technical knowledge and
requirements are similar. The military work of the Bureau of
Standards during the war, therefore, will be of value to the indus­
tries during the critical days to come. The applications of science
to industry are now recognized as of priceless value by the lead­
ing countries of the world. For this reason England, Australia,
and Japan, among others, have on a new and large scale decided
upon national programs of scientific research on the vital problems
of industry. There is some danger lest we miss the full lesson
of the war while other nations make prompt application.
Technical experts, societies, and the industries begin to realize
the supreme importance of standardization, and the era of stand­
ardization may be said to have fairly begun. The bureau is
represented on practically all of the great standardizing commit­
tees of the technical societies and is working in close cooperation
with them. For the Government the bureau is a scientific advisor
on the subject of standard specifications and has performed this
service for practically every department and governmental
agency, notably the War Department and the General Supply
Committee.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

I 27

In many cases the Bureau of Standards conducts fundamental
researches in the laboratory on points which the specifications
disclose. It is only by such research that it is possible to formu­
late standards of quality and performance of materials and
appliances. The universal interest in standards reflects the grow­
ing appreciation of standardization as a means of industrial
progress. The annual review of existing specifications for the
purpose of incorporating new knowledge has had a most fruitful
effect in stimulating the prompt application of new scientific
knowledge.
It is doubtful whether there is another subject as fruitful of
improved economy and efficiency as the standardization which is
basic to all industry. It is the standard of quality which deter­
mines the materials to be used, the form which they take, and the
processes by which they are produced in the factory. It is also
the standard of performance which is the user’s ultimate test.
In other words, standardization involves nothing less than the
complete technical control of industry, by which is meant that
modern industry must be based upon scientifically ascertained
standards whether of measure, of quality, of performance, or of
practice. From a national point of view, the work of the Bureau
of Standards, therefore, is directed toward making itself as effect­
ive as possible in stimulating and in actively cooperating by
research and investigation in all standardizing movements in which
its cooperation is sought. The annual report of the Bureau of
Standards shows many interesting examples of the variety and
usefulness of this work.

BUREAU OF THE CENSUS.
(S am . L. R o g e r s , Director.)

The end of the fiscal year 1919 marked the close of the sevenyear intercensal period during which the Bureau of the Census
carried on numerous lines of statistical work at decennial, quin­
quennial, biennial, annual, quarterly, monthly, and semimonthly
intervals, as prescribed by law; and on July 1, 1919, began the
three-year decennial census period, within which time censuses of
the population, agriculture, manufactures, mines and quarries, oil
and gas wells, and forestry and forest products of the United
States will be taken, compiled, and published.
During the fiscal year 1919 the Bureau of the Census carried
on the compilation of the results of its quinquennial census of
electrical industries; completed the work on its decennial inquiries
relating to transportation by water and shipbuilding; brought
well toward completion the preparation of its decennial report on
religious bodies; completed and published a special report on
marriage and divorce; conducted the regular annual inquiries
relating to births, deaths, States, and municipalities; published
quarterly statistics of stocks of leaf tobacco; made monthly and
semimonthly collections and publications of statistics on cotton,
cotton seed, and cotton-seed products; made special enumerations
of the population in four counties; carried on the publication of
weekly mortality reports for certain large cities; compiled statistics
relating to the mortality from the influenza epidemic; performed
a large amount of war work for other governmental establishments ;
complied with numerous requests for information; and made de­
tailed preparations for taking the Fourteenth (1920) Decennial
Census.
The work done along the above lines during the fiscal year and
since its close is described below.
CURRENT AND COMPLETED WORK ON STATUTORY INQUIRIES.

Electrical Industries.
This quinquennial inquiry, covering central light and power
stations, electric railways, telephones and telegraphs, and munici­
pal electric fire-alarm and police-patrol signaling systems, was
made as of December 31, 1917.
128

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

129

The greater part of the data were obtained through correspond­
ence, but it was necessary to send a number of men into the field
to obtain information. The field canvass was begun in April,
1918, and was substantially completed in the following December.
Preliminary reports pertaining to the several inquiries covered
by the canvass were prepared and issued. The final reports on
telegraphs and on electric fire-alarm and police-patrol signaling
systems were issued in the form of a single bulletin on July 19,
1919; and the work on the reports for the other inquiries is nearly
completed.
Transportation by Water.
This decennial inquiry was made as of December 31, 1916. In
order to avoid the disclosure of information of value to the enemy,
the report was not made public during the war. After the signing
of the armistice the report was completed and sent to the printer,
and will be ready for distribution in the near future.
Shipbuilding.
Statistics for this industry were collected in connection with the
last quinquennial census of manufactures, covering the calendar
year 1914, and afurthe ' canvass was made in conjunction with the
census of transportation by water, taken as of December 31, 19 6.
Although the results of these two investigations were compiled and
the preparation of the combined report completed prior to the
beginning of the fiscal year 1919, they were withheld from publi­
cation because of the inadvisability of giving out the information
during the war. The figures, however, were placed immediately
at the disposal of the Shipping Board and other war agencies of the
Government. In January, 1919, the manuscript was sent to the
printer, and the report was issued, in bulletin form, on May 16,
1919Religious Bodies.
This decennial inquiry covered the calendar year 1916. The
work was done almost entirely through correspondence. The
preparation of the report was frequently interrupted by war work.
On May 2, 1918, the bureau issued preliminary figures, subject to
correction, showing the basic facts, and on January 17, 1919, a
revision of the first statement was published presenting additional
statistics. The complete report is being issued in the form of two
bound volumes having a total of 1,318 pages.
140261— 19— 9

130

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Vital Statistics.
Births.— The “ birth-registration area,” which, when established
in 1915, comprised 10 States and the District of Columbia, approx­
imately 31 per cent of the total population of the United States,
grew rapidly, until in 1917 it embraced 20 States and the District
of Columbia, about 53 per cent of the country’s population. No
changes have been made since 1917. During the year 1919 tests
were made in Illinois and Mississippi, but the birth registration in
both States failed to measure up to the bureau’s standard of 90
per cent of completeness.
A press summary of the birth-statistics report for 1917 was
issued in June, 1919, and work is progressing on the report for
1918.
Deaths.— The “ death-registration area” now comprises 30
States, the Terri lory of Hawaii, the District of Columbia, and 23
cities in nonregistration States, and contains approximately fourfifths of the population of the United States. The most recent
additions are Illinois and Louisiana, admitted for the year 1918,
and Mississippi, admitted for 1919.
A press summary giving statistics of deaths covering the cal­
endar year 1917 was issued June 25, 1919. The annual mortality
report for 1917 has been completed.
Weekly Health Index.— The publication of the Weekly Health
Index, inaugurated in October, 1917, giving mortality reports for
46 of the largest cities of the country, has been continued. During
the epidemic of influenza and pneumonia, additional sheets were
included, which gave the number of deaths resulting from those
causes. Beginning with the issue for June 17, 1919, there have
also been presented in each week’s issue statistics, obtained from
the leading industrial insurance companies, showing number of
policies in force, total number of death claims, and number of
claims per 1,000 policies in force.
Need of Federal legislation providing for registration of births and
deaths.— In the matter of birth and death registration the United
States has not kept pace with many of the other countries of the
world. This condition is due to the fact that registration has been
left to the control of the State governments, many of which have
failed to establish and maintain adequate systems of recording
births and deaths. The practice of the Census Bureau is to admit
to the birth-registration area those States, and to the deathregistration area those States and those cities in nonregistration

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

131

States, in which the bureau’s tests indicate the registration to
represent at least 90 per cent of all births, or of all deaths, as the
case may be, if the registration systems justify the expectation
of a more nearly complete registration in the future.
Thus far the only legislative action taken by the Federal Govern­
ment toward the improvement of our vital statistics is found in a
joint resolution of Congress, approved February 11, 1903, re­
questing the State authorities to cooperate with the Census
Bureau in securing a uniform system of birth and death registra­
tion. The bureau has achieved some success in arousing the
interest of the States in the matter. Under present conditions,
however, it is likely to be many years before the last one of the
48 States enacts and properly administers adequate registration
laws. It will thus be necessary, if the birth and mortality records
of the country are to be reliable, permanent, and readily available
for reference, to provide for a comprehensive system of Federal
control and supervision.
Financial Statistics of Cities.
The report presenting financial statistics of cities having over
30,000 inhabitants, for the fiscal year 1918, has been completed.
This report presents detailed statistics of revenues, expenditures,
value of municipal properties, municipal indebtedness, assess­
ments, and taxation; and also gives certain data relating to gov­
ernmental organizations. The field and office work on the 1919
inquiry is now in progress, and it is expected that copy for the
report will be sent to the printer early in 1920.
General Statistics of Cities.
In addition to its reports giving financial statistics of cities, the
Census Bureau issues reports on various phases of municipal gov­
ernmental activities, in addition to those pertaining to finances,
under the title “ General Statistics of Cities. ” For 1918 the sub­
ject covered under this head was municipal markets, and on July
23, 1919, the complete report was published in the form of a
56-page bulletin. The subject is a timely one, and the information
presented will be of value to cities that are contemplating the
establishing of municipal markets.
Financial Statistics of States.
The report presenting financial statistics of States for the fiscal
year 1918 has been completed. This report follows closely the

132

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

lines of those giving financial statistics of cities. Work on the
inquiry for the fiscal year 1919 is now in progress, and it is expected
that copy for the report will be ready for the printer early in 1920.
Cotton and Cotton Seed.
During the fiscal year the Bureau of the Census conducted its
regular inquiries in regard to cotton and cotton seed. In addition
to an annual bulletin on cotton production and distribution for
the season of 1917-18 and a pamphlet giving complete statistics
of cotton ginned from the crop of 1918, there were issued 10
reports relating to cotton ginned to specified dates during the
ginning season; 12 reports, at monthly intervals, on cotton con­
sumed, imported, exported, and on hand, and active consuming
cotton spindles; and another monthly series relating to cotton seed
received, crushed, and on hand, and cottonseed products manufac­
tured, shipped out, and on hand. The pamphlet presenting the
final figures on cotton ginned from the crop of 1918 (together with
data for earlier years) was distributed in time to be of use in mak­
ing comparisons between the ginnings from the crop of 1919 and
those for corresponding periods in earlier years.
Stocks of Leaf Tobacco.
Four reports on stocks of leaf tobacco held by certain classes of
manufacturers and dealers were published at intervals of three
months. In addition, Bulletin 139, “ Stocks of Leaf Tobacco:
1918,” was prepared and distributed. This bulletin, which pre­
sents data contained in the quarterly reports, with comparative
figures for earlier years and various other statistical information
pertaining to the tobacco industry, is the second of an annual
series designed to compile for ready reference the statistics of the
various phases of the tobacco industry published by the several
Federal bureaus.
Official Register.
Preparations were begun during the latter part of the year for
the compilation of the July 1, 1919, edition of the Official Register
of the United States, which consists mainly of a directory of Fed­
eral employees, showing name, designation, compensation, etc.
SPECIAL AND MISCELLANEOUS LINES OF WORK.

Marriage and Divorce.
Marriage and divorce statistics for the calendar year 1916 were
collected in 1917. A t the close of the fiscal year 1918 the prepa­
ration of the report had been substantially finished. A press

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

133

summary was issued March 20, and the report itself was pub­
lished April 7, 1919. The work of compilation and preparation for
printing was delayed somewhat by war conditions.
Special Censuses of Population.
Special censuses of the population of Okmulgee, Ottawa, and
Tulsa Counties, Okla., were taken, at local request and expense,
in August, 1918, December, 1918, and January, 1919, respectively.
A special census of Charles County, Md., was taken in March, 1919,
at the request of the Secretary of the Treasury, in order to deter­
mine the effect of the recent influenza epidemic therein. The
work was done in cooperation with the Public Health Service.
Statistics of Fats and Oils.
In December, 1918, the monthly collection of data in regard to
the production, consumption, and stocks of fats and oils was dis­
continued by the Food Administration. In view of the need for
reliable information concerning these commodities during the
reconstruction period, the Bureau of the Census was authorized
to collect and publish, quarterly during the calendar year 1919,
similar statistics. This work is now in progress.
United States Life Tables.
As stated in my last report, the bureau computed a series of
‘ life tables” supplementary to the series issued in 1916, exhibiting
mortality conditions in certain areas for the years 1890 and 1901
and during the decennium 1901-1910. These tables, which provide
valuable comparative data for use in studying changes in mortality
rates, will be included in a new edition of the life tables, materially
enhancing their value. In connection with certain of the original
tables there will be given commutation columns, annuities, and
premiums at various rates of interest; and the data on which the
various tables were based, the derivation of the theory, and an
explanation of the methods of computing them will also be shown.
Special Investigation of Influenza Epidemic.
A compilation of data in regard to the mortality resulting from
the epidemic of influenza and pneumonia during the last four
mouths of 1918 was made for the States of Indiana and Kansas and
the city of Philadelphia. The results, in the form of tables and
graphs, are now ready for publication.
Thanks are due to the United States Public Health Service for
its generous financial assistance in this work.

134

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

International Statistical Year Book.
At the request of the secretary of the International Statistical
Institute at The Hague, the Bureau of the Census compiled detailed
data relating to the United States as a whole and to the States
individually for inclusion in the International Statistical Year
Book (Annuaire Internationale de Statistique). The work was
begun in February, 1919, and completed in the following June.
Statistical Directory of State Institutions.
During the fiscal year 1918 the bureau brought to substantial
completion the compilation of a statistical directory of State
institutions for the dependent, defective, and delinquent classes;
but because of the great amount of war work and other current
work, the publication of this directory has been delayed. It is
now in the hands of the printer, however, and will be issued at an
early date.
Searching of Census Records to Determine Ages.
During the fiscal year 2,315 searches of census records were
made for the Pension Bureau, in order to determine the ages of
applicants for pensions and increases of pensions. Other searches
were made for genealogical purposes and for the purpose of supply­
ing statements as to the ages of children affected by the child-labor
laws. A vast amount of work was done in searching the records
to establish the ages of men who had not registered for military
service, but were believed to be within the prescribed ages.
Miscellaneous Information Supplied Other Governmental Agencies
and Outside Organizations.
Numerous compilations of statistical information from the
bureau’s records were made in compliance with requests received
from other Federal bureaus and from private concerns, consisting
chiefly of industrial statistics. Among the organizations for
which they were made were the Chamber of Commerce of the
United States; the U. S. Tariff Commission; the Office of the
Surgeon General, War Department; the General Electric Co.;
Power Plant Engineering (periodical); the Sinclair Refining Co.,
Chicago; the Southwestern Electrical & Gas Association, Dallas,
Tex.; and the National Association of Cotton Manufacturers.

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

135

WAR WORK.

Census of Materials and Commodities for Use of War Agencies.
This work, which was authorized on April 8, 1918, was described
on pages 92 and 93 of my report for 1918. It was undertaken to
secure statistical information needed by the War Trade Board,
the War Industries Board, the Shipping Board, the Food Admin­
istration, the Council of National Defense, and the Commercial
Economy Board, in regard to the production and stocks on hand
of the following-named classes of commodities, listed in tlje order
in which work upon them was begun: Kapok fiber; jute; leather
stocks; boots, shoes, and manufactured leather goods; silk; anti­
mony; graphite crucibles; wool manufactures— machinery and
production; and iron and steel products. For each of these
classes of commodities, except leather stocks, boots, shoes, and
manufactured leather goods, and graphite crucibles, only one
report was made, beginning with that for kapok fiber, which
referred to May 1, 1918. For leather stocks, monthly reports
relating to the last day of each month, May to December, 1918,
and quarterly reports, as of March 31 and June 30, 1919, have been
compiled; for stocks of boots, shoes, and manufactured leather
goods, the reports referred to the last day of each month, June to
December, 1918, and to March 31 and June 30, 1919; and for
graphite crucibles, two reports were issued, as of June 30 and Sep­
tember 30, 1918.
The collection of statistics of leather stocks and stocks of boots,
shoes, and manufactured leather goods is of great importance as
a conservation measure. The collection of these statistics, at
quarterly intervals, was accordingly continued at the request of
the War Industries Board and upon the recommendation of the
war service committee representing the shoe and leather industries
of the United States Chamber of Commerce. A simplified form
of schedule was tised for the quarterly statistics.
Statistics for all the war commodities covered by the several
inquiries have been revised and rearranged for printing in a con­
densed form more convenient for reference. This is designed to
be the final presentation of these statistics, and will constitute a
permanent record of the census of war commodities.
Census of Commercial Greenhouses.
This inquiry was made at the request of the priorities division
of the War Industries Board, which desired the information for
use in connection with fuel restrictions.

136

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Work Done for Provost Marshal General.
The 293,788 enlistments in the Navy, the Naval Reserve, the
National Naval Volunteers, and the Marine Corps during the
period from April 2, 1917, to June 30, 1918, were allocated by the
Census Bureau. Estimates were prepared in July, 1918, of the
number of British subjects in the United States subject to draft
under the terms of the conventions concluded between this country
and Great Britain, and also of the numbers of men in the United
States from 18 to 20 and from 32 to 45 years of age, inclusive.
Determination of Ages of Registrants.
District attorneys and other officials of the Department of Jus­
tice were, at their request, supplied with age certificates for men
who, although of military age, had not registered for the selective
draft; and men requesting it were given statements showing their
ages as indicated by the census records.
Liberty Loan Work,
In connection with the Liberty Loans made during the fiscal
year, the Bureau of the Census aided the Treasury Department by
sending out literature to various mailing lists.
Compilation of Statistics Relative to Foreign Countries for Peace
Conference.
This compilation comprised statistics of the movement of cereals,
salt, oil, coal, and wood on the railways and waterways of Russia
in 1908, 1909, and 1910, the latest years for which figures were
available ; a tabulation showing the distribution of manufacturing
establishments and wage earners in Austria by industries and
factory-inspection districts ; and statistics in regard to the exports
and imports of countries and colonial possessions in Africa.
Information for U. S. Shipping Board.
A t the request of the U. S. Shipping Board, detailed tables were
prepared showing the population and value of agricultural products
within a radius of 100 miles of each of 28 cities located on the
Atlantic, Pacific, and Gulf coasts.
Miscellaneous War Work.
In addition to the foregoing, the Census Bureau performed
numerous small amounts of war work for the Post Office Depart­
ment, the Navy Department, the Department of Labor, the Bureau
of Foreign and Domestic Commerce, the Fuel Administration, the
Federal Trade Commission, the Telephone and Telegraph Admin­
istration, the Office of the Chief of Engineers, the General Engineer

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

13 7

Depot, the Office of the Director of Military Aeronautics, the
Emergency Fleet Corporation, the Railroad Administration, the
War Industries Board, the War Trade Board, the Capital Issues
Committee, the Central Statistical Clearing House, the Employ­
ment Sendee, the Reconstruction Survey, the War Service Com­
mittee of the Rubber Industry of the United States, and the
American Electric Railway Association War Board.
Members of Force Enlisted and Drafted Into Military and Naval
Services.
During the fiscal year 25 office and field employees of the Census
Bureau entered the military and naval services (not including
those who joined as Army field clerks). The total number who
entered those services from the outbreak of the war to the signing
of the armistice was 79.
PUBLICATIONS ISSUED.

Following is a list of the more important reports published by
the bureau during the fiscal year and since its close. In addition,
various bulletins and press summaries have been issued.
Class an d title (q uarto except as otherwise indicated).

D ate issued.

Deaf-mutes in the U nited S ta te s ...........................................................................................
Stocks of leaf tobacco (octavo)—B ulletin No. 136............................................................
Statistics of fire departm en ts of cities having a population of over 30,000: 1917.........
Census of th e Virgin Islands of th e U nited States: N ov. i, 1917....................................
Specified sources of m unicipal revenues: 1917.....................................................................

Ju ly
Ju ly
Aug.
Aug.
Aug.

Pages.
221

5>19i 8
17» 1918
13» 1918
27,1918
28,1918

44

IOS
* 47

140
513

Financial statistics of cities having a population of over 30,000: 1917........................... Oct. 5,1918
Financial statistics of States, 1917.......................... .............................................................. Oet. 10,1918
Negro population in th e U nited States: 1790-1915............................................................. Oct. 28,1918

373

129
844
5 35

Birth statistics for the registration area of th e U nited S tates: 1916.............................. Nov. 6,1918
Cotton production an d distribution, season of 1917-18—B ulletin No. 137.................. Jan. 1,1919
Census of m anufactures, 1914—Vol. I, reports b y States and principal cities 0 .......... Feb. 26,1919
Shipbuilding (including b o at building): 1916 and 1914....................................................
Census of m anufactures, 1914—Vol. II, reports for selected industries and detailed
statistics for industries b y States ° .................................................................................T.
Census of w ar commodities:
Statistics of leather.............................................................................................................
Iron and steel.......................................................................................................................
A ntim ony, and graphite c ru cib les.................................................................................
Textile fibers—wool, silk, jute, and k a p o k ...................................................................

96
13 5

1,677

&May 16,1919
Ju ly

i

35

2,1919

*»047

Dec. 12,1918
Jan . 31,1919

XX
x6
10
16

A pr. 4,1919
A pr. 17,1919
J u ly 29,19x8
Apr. 30,19x9
(June 14,1918

Thirty-four reports, in card form, relating to cotton and cotton seed .......................... !

[June to
19,1919

0The various reports bound together iu these volumes had previously been published separately.
&Withheld from earlier publication for military reasons.

34

138

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.
PREPARATIONS FOR THE FOURTEENTH CENSUS.

Fourteenth Census Law.
As set forth in my annual report for 1918, a bill to provide for
the Fourteenth and subsequent decennial censuses was drafted
by the Census Bureau and submitted to the House Committee on
the Census. The bill was passed by the House of Representa­
tives July 2, 1918, and by the Senate, with amendments, January
14, 1919; the conference report was adopted by the Senate Feb­
ruary 28, 1919, and by the House March 3, 1919; and the bill was
approved by you on March 3, 1919. In many respects it follows
the lines of the Thirteenth Census legislation, but there are de­
partures in regard to a few important features and numerous
unimportant ones. The most significant points of difference are
as follows:
Section 1.— Insertion of provision for census of forestry and
forest products.
Section 6.— Reclassification of clerical salaries, so as to provide
a much larger number of classes, differing from each other by only
$60 per annum between $900 and $1,440, and by $120 per annum
between $1,440 and $1,800; increase in compensation of clerical
and subclerical employees generally; and provision for preference
to honorably discharged soldiers, sailors, and marines, and their
widows, in making appointments to positions in all executive
departments and independent governmental establishments.
Section 7.— Provision, applying to Federal service generally,
requiring Civil Service Commission to examine applicants tem­
porarily absent from the places of their legal residence without
requiring them to return for the purpose of examination; and
provision authorizing selection of temporary Census employees
from reemployment registers established by Executive order of
November 29, 1918.
Section 8.-—Omission of provision for securing information in
regard to uneihployment on census date and during preceding
calendar year and in regard to Civil War veterans; insertion of
provision for obtaining information as to encumbrances on homes
and farms; omission of provision for enumeration of inmates of
institutions for dependent, defective, and delinquent classes
(this inquiry to be made after close of census period) ; inclusion of
inquiry as to sex of farm operators; amplification of irrigation in­
quiry; and addition of drainage inquiry.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

139

Section g.— Provision for appointment of supervisors by Secre­
tary of Commerce, upon recommendation of Director of Census,
instead of by President, by and with advice and consent of Senate.
Section 20.— Change of census date from April 15 to January 1;
reduction of minimum size limit for cities in which enumeration
must be completed within two weeks, from 5,000 to 2,500.
Sections 21-24.— These sections, which provide penalties for
violations of the Fourteenth Census act, have been so drawn as to
make them more effective and more readily enforceable than the
corresponding sections of the Thirteenth Census act.
Section 31.— Provision for mid-decennial census of agriculture,
to be taken in 1925 and at 10-year intervals thereafter.
Section 32.— Provision for biennial census of products of manu­
facturing industries, beginning in 1921.
Joint Advisory Committee of American Statistical and Economic
Associations.
At my invitation, under date of November 18, 1918, the presi­
dents of the American Statistical and American Economic Associa­
tions appointed a joint committee to advise the Director of the
Census and the Department of Commerce in connection with the
work of the Fourteenth Census. This committee was composed
of six members, namely:
Representing American Statistical Association— W. S. Rossiter,
chairman, formerly chief clerk, Bureau of the Census, now presi­
dent Rumford Press, Concord, N. H.; Prof. Carroll W. Doten,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology; Dean Edwin F. Cay,
Harvard University.
Representing American Economic Association— Prof. Wesley C.
Mitchell, Columbia University; Prof. E. R. A. Seligman, Columbia
University; Prof. Walter F. Willcox, Cornell University.
The joint advisory committee has thus far held six meetings.
It has given very careful consideration to all phases of the census
work thus far planned, and has made a number of helpful recom­
mendations. The members of this committee have rendered val­
uable assistance in connection with the preparatory work of the
Fourteenth Census.
Field Force.
Continental United States (exclusive of Alaska) was divided
into 372 supervisors’ districts. These districts, outside the large
cities, were as a rule coextensive with the congressional districts;
and each of the large cities was placed under the charge of a single

140

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

supervisor, with the exception of New York City, which was
divided into four districts.
A t the Thirteenth Census the enumeration was made as of
April 15, and at earlier censuses as of June 1, but under the exist­
ing law the next and subsequent censuses will be taken as of Jan­
uary 1. This necessitates the appointment of the supervisors at
an earlier date than heretofore, and with the least possible delay.
In regard to the selection and recommendation for appoint­
ment of candidates for supervisors, I issued, under date of March
4, 1919, the following instructions to the Director of the Census:
Conforming to the assurances given the President in my letter to him of March 3,
you will please be guided by the following instructions respecting appointments to
the post of supervisor in connection with the taking of the Fourteenth Census of the
United States:
A test examination, of which a record will be kept, is to be required for appoint­
ment to the post of supervisor. In addition to this, a careful personal inquiry is to be
separately made respecting the qualifications of each candidate. Of this inquiry,
also, a record will be kept.
In making appointments from those who shall have passed the test examination
and the separate inquiry as to qualifications, preference is to be given to those candi­
dates who have had executive, administrative, statistical, or accounting experience
and to those who have had charge of bodies of men as administrators, provided in all
cases that men with the experience stated possess the other qualifications necessary.
You will arrange to give notice to the above effect to every candidate applying for
appointment and to his sponsors, and no candidates are to be selected for appointment
who do not pass both the test examination and the personal inquiry.
You arc requested to ask the Civil Service Commission to prepare the blanks for
tlie test examination or to cooperate with you in the preparation of them. You will
welcome the assistance of the Civil Service Commission in this and in any other
respect in which they can be helpful to you.
It is my earnest desire, as I know' it is your own, that this census shall be an example
in its quality, as well as in its promptness. I need hardly say that neither result
can be had unless the supervisors are selected with special care to their individual
fitness for their task. I am depending on you as the responsible officer in immediate
charge of the work to see that every precaution is taken to achieve this result. In
particular, the appearance as well as the fact of political patronage are to be avoided,
and fitness for the work to be done will be the controlling factor in the appointments.

Under date of March 17, 1919, the bureau issued a press notice
announcing the date of the coming census, the approximate
number of supervisors to be appointed, and the method of their
appointment, and quoting the above instructions. Approximately
5,500 persons were supplied, upon request, with application
blanks for the position of supervisor, similar to the forms used by
the Civil Service Commission for “ nonassembled ” examinations;
and about 2,200 of these applications were filled out and returned
to the bureau. A suitable scheme of rating was devised, the
papers were graded, selections were made, and a list of candi-

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

I + I

dates recommended to me for appointment; and during August
the appointments were made and announced through the public
press.
The following letter, which I addressed to the Director of the
Census under date of July 12, 1919, in regard to political activity
on the part of supervisors and enumerators, has been embodied
in the instructions to these classes of census employees:
The taking of the Fourteenth Census involves the appointment of some four hundred
supervisors, upon whom in turn will rest the serious duty of selecting and appointing
many times that number of enumerators. The success of the census will depend upon
the efficiency, impartiality, and the strict attention to duty of the supervisors and
upon the intelligence of the enumerators and their faithful devotion to the important
public business which is to be placed in their hands.
The vast country-wide system thus created can be perverted to political uses if both
supervisors and enumerators are not forbidden to use it as an instrument for influencing
either local or general elections, or primaries, in the interest of particular candidates
or parties.
The work of the census itself is a sufficient task to tax the powers of those concerned
in it, and it is a reasonable requirement that whoever accepts an appointment as
supervisor or enumerator shall, during the term of his employment as such, strictly
avoid any active part in politics.
Attention is therefore directed to the following order of the President of the United
States, dated August 16, 1909:
“ I therefore order that, in the preparation of regulations for the taking of the census,
you and the Director of the Census embody therein a provision that any supervisor or
enumerator who uses his influence with his subordinates or colleagues to assist any
party or any candidate in a primary or general election, or who takes part, other than
merely casting his vote, in politics, National, State, or local, cither by service upon a
political committee, by public addresses, by the solicitation of votes, or otherwise,
shall be at once dismissed from the service.
" I wish to make this regulation as broad ¡is possible, and wish it enforced without
exception. It is of the highest importance that the census should be taken by men
having only the single purpose of reaching a just and right result, and that the large
amount of money to be expended in the employment of so vast a machine as the cen­
sus shall not be made to serve the political purposes of any one.”
The above order, applicable to the census of 1910, is now confirmed and made appli­
cable to the work of the census of 1920. It is an essential factor in the appointment
of every supervisor and enumerator and is to be obeyed by those officers in letter and
in spirit. Departure from it will be considered as warrant for dismissal from the
service, as therein stated.

The enumerators will be selected by the supervisors, with the
approval of the Director of the Census. Each candidate will be
required to undergo a practical test.
Office Force.
It is estimated that the total office force of the Fourteenth
Census will reach at its maximum about 4,000, as against 3,738 at
the last census. The estimated increase is proportionally smaller
than the increase in the work to be done, but it is expected that

142

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

certain changes in organization, improvements in methods, and
developments in tabulating machinery will make possible some
increase in the average amount accomplished per employee.
Of the 4,000 officials and employees who will compose the census
force when at its maximum, between 3,000 and 3,500 will be tem­
porary clerks. Most of these clerks will be appointed as the
result of special examinations to be conducted by the Civil Service
Commission this fall throughout the United States; and the
remainder will be secured (1) by selection from the reemployment
registers of the Civil Service Commission established under au­
thority of the Executive order of November 29, 1918, as amended
April 30, 1919; (2) by selection from the registers maintained by
the commission for the departmental service generally; and (3)
by transfer, reinstatement, etc., under the civil-service rules.
The office force on August 31, 1919, comprised 23 officials,
717 clerical employees, 39 subclerical employees, 30 mechanicallaboratory employees, and 42 special agents for general field
work, etc., a total of 851. In addition, there were employed
throughout the cotton belt 694 local special agents to collect
statistics of cotton and cotton seed. These agents perform their
work only at intervals and are paid on a piece-price basis.
Preparation of Schedules, Etc.
The various schedules, instructions, and other fonns to be used
at the coming census have been prepared, and most of the popu­
lation and agricultural schedules have been distributed to the
supervisors. In connection with the preparation of the agri­
cultural schedule, the division of agriculture held numerous
conferences with representatives of the various governmental
departments interested in agricultural statistics, as well as with
professors in agricultural colleges, and representatives of agricul­
tural periodicals and of farmers’ associations. As a result, a general
farm schedule was formulated which has been very widely indorsed
and has received the unqualified approval of the joint advisory
committee of the American Statistical and Economic Associations
Encumbrances on Homes and Farms.
Section 8 of the Fourteenth Census act contains a provision,
inserted by the Senate, for ascertaining the amount of encum­
brances on mortgaged homes occupied by their owners, of which
in 1920 there may be approximately 4,000,000. In order to
obtain a part of the information required— that relating to the
market value of the home, the amount of encumbrance, and the

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

143

annual rate of interest— it will be necessary to use a special
schedule. It is estimated that the additional cost of collecting
and compiling this information will be at least $i ,ooo,ooo.
Outlying Possessions.
The Fourteenth Census act provides for censuses of Alaska,
Hawaii, and Porto Rico, to be taken by the Bureau of the Census,
and also for censuses of Guam, Samoa, and the Panama Canal
Zone, to be taken by the respective governors of those possessions
in accordance with plans prescribed or approved by the Director
of the Census. In taking the census of Alaska the Bureau of the
Census will cooperate with the Bureau of Education. The work
will be done under the direction of William T. Lopp, in charge of
the Alaskan division of the Bureau of Education. Arrangements
are being made, through the War and Navy Departments and the
Panama Canal officials, with the Governors of Porto Rico, Guam,
Samoa, and the Canal Zone, for taking the censuses of those
possessions.
Mechanical Equipment.
Work in mechanical laboratory.— The object of the mechanical
laboratory, to have produced or to have on hand at the close of
the fiscal year 1919 all parts entering into the construction of
certain tabulating machinery for the work of the Fourteenth
Census, has been practically attained.
Five automatic tabulating machines have been completed and
tested, of which four are in actual use; and the remainder of the
equipment of tabulating and sorting machines will be completed
on or before February 1, 1920.
The original estimates pertaining to the card-sorting machines
took into consideration merely the work of overhauling. It was
later found expedient to introduce some radical changes in design
and method of operation, and the result has been the production
of a practically new and much more efficient machine.
Integrating counter.— In my last two reports I have referred
to the progress of the development of an “ integrating counter’’—
that is, a counter which will record and add numbers instead of
mere units, thus performing automatically the work done by the
operator of an adding machine— for use in tabulating certain
classes of census data. The numbers will be indicated on cards
by punch marks, the cards will be fed into the machine, and the
numbers will be automatically totalized. Several sets of figures

144

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

can be totalized at the same time. The principal advantage to
be derived from the use of the integrating counter lies in the
facility with wliich the data may be regrouped or rearranged.
Work on the integrating counter, which began on July 6, 1917,
is still in progress. The first model has been completed as an
experimental machine, and it has added and recorded numbers
as indicated on punched cards at the rate of from 20,000 to 25,000
cards a day. A complete set of drawings and all patterns neces­
sary for manufacturing this type of machine have been made.
A tentative card system for tabulating part of the manufac­
tures census has been developed and will be tested.

BUREAU OF FISHERIES.
(Dr. H ugh M. S mith , Com m issioner.)

General Considerations.
While the work of the Bureau of Fisheries has been resumed
along normal lines, following several years of special adapta­
tion to war requirements, changed economic conditions resulting
from war demand, and are receiving, serious attention.
It is quite apparent that, owing to food shortage and the active
campaigns that have been waged for the purpose of offsetting
that shortage, the use of aquatic products has acquired a more
prominent place. That place can be enlarged and firmly estab­
lished with marked benefit to the entire country. The bureau
seeks to render this service. It is incumbent on Congress to
authorize and support the effort.
All the vessels placed at the disposal of the Navy during the
war have been returned, and the use that the Navy was making
of the marine biological stations at Woods Hole, Mass., and Beau­
fort, N. C., has been relinquished.
The discrimination against this service in the matter of the
attendance of technical employees of the bureau at- meetings
of societies should be removed.
The bureau deserves liberal, whole-hearted, unsuspicious treat­
ment at the hands of Congress. It is rendering a large public
service in a modest, loyal, effective manner. It more than pays
its own cost in each of several ways. The direct revenue accruing
to the Government through the operation and administration
of laws affecting the fisheries of Alaska exceeds all the appropri­
ations for the support of the bureau. The actual revenue returns
for the operations of the calendar year 1918 will be found to ex­
ceed $2,865,000, a sum which includes the tax levied on pre­
served salmon, fish oil, and fish fertilizer; the net sales of furseal skins taken on the Pribilof Islands; the net value of fox skins
from the same locality; the returns from other Alaskan products
and enterprises coming within the purview of the Department;
and fines resulting from convictions for violations of law (the
amount involved in this last item being small).
140201—19----- 10
145

146

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Of even more importance is the indirect and immeasurable
value of the food fish produced and planted and the food fish
rescued and restored to the waters. Any attempt to represent
by dollars the value of the fish-cultural work woidd be futile;
but it may be noted that if the hatcheries had been commer­
cialized their output in the fiscal year 1919, together with the
fishes salvaged from the overflowed lands of the Mississippi Val­
ley, would have had a market value of not less than $2,000,000.
No cognizance need be taken, in this connection, of the com­
mercial value to individuals and industries of the biological and
technical inquiries conducted by the bureau, although this is
great.
Planting the Waters.
The comprehensive and varied operations of the Bureau of
Fisheries in artificially propagating food fishes and planting them
in suitable waters have reached a high degree of effectiveness.
This work has had a gradual development in response to the
urgent needs of the country, and meets with hearty public support
because of the obvious benefits. There is demand for an extension
of operations into sections not adequately covered by existing
hatcheries, more particularly for the purpose of maintaining and
increasing the supplies of common species like the catfishes and
buffalofishes that can be produced in large quantities and are
wholesome food.
The output of the fish-cultural stations during the fiscal year
1919 aggregated over 5,875,000,000 fish and fish eggs, most of
the latter being consigned to State hatcheries. The distribution
was more extensive than ever before, exceeding the best previous
record of 1917 by more than 715,000,000 and surpassing the year
1918 by 1,779,000,000.
Humpback Salmon in Maine.
In March, 1917, over 900,000 humpback salmon were planted in
Maine waters, that had become unsuitable for the Atlantic salmon.
This year the results of this introduction of a Pacific species are
becoming apparent. It is reported that the fish have been seen in
thousands in the Dennys and Pembroke Rivers, and the herring
weirs in Passamaquoddy Bay have taken considerable numbers.
The success of this experiment, for which there is every reason
for the bureau to be gratified, is confirmed by the taking of nearly
400,000 eggs from humpbacks in the rivers named, which will be
incubated at the hatchery at Craig Brook, Me.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

1 47

Rescue of Stranded Food Fishes.
Too much stress can not be placed on the importance of the
work of rescuing food fishes from the overflowed lands in the
basin of the Mississippi River and its tributaries. All of the fish
left behind when the freshet waters subside inevitably succumb
to the drying or freezing of the pools or ponds in which they
congregate unless rescue parties seine out the cut-off waters and
restore the fishes to the main streams.
The aggregate number of salvaged fishes in the summer and
autumn of 1918 was upward of 55,800,000, comprising practically
every species of food fish of the Mississippi Valley. About 600,000
of the rescued fishes were distributed by the bureau’s cars to outside
waters; the remainder were deposited locally in the main river
channels.
These operations for the season of 1919 have been resumed on a
larger scale. Although the work is still in progress, there is already
a substantial increase over 1918, and the fall season may close
with a record of 125,000,000 rescued food fishes. A summary to
the end of September is here given:
H eadquarters.

Cairo, 111 ..............................

Fish sal­
vaged.
680,583
1.033,391
233,267
24,882,420
4,830,820

H eadquarters.

Fish sal­
vaged.
a .3 4 9 .4 0 4
23,229,430
28,800, 510

T o ta l.................................................

101,039,825

The extent of this work may be better realized when it is stated
that a score of hatcheries would be unable to produce fishes in
number and size equal to those rescued. Nothing affecting the
welfare of the fisheries of the Mississippi basin is of greater
importance than the prevention of the losses that occur under
natural conditions.
Loss of a Pacific Salmon Hatchery.
Among other items in the deficiency bill as reported to the House
of Representatives September 11, 1919, is one providing $50,000
for the reconstruction of the fish hatchery and other buildings at
Baker Lake, Wash., which, with the exception of the bunk house
and barn, wTere completely destroyed by fire on July 24, 1919.
The disaster occurred at a most unfortunate time, as the season was
but half over and the prospects for a large output were the brightest

148

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

in years. Immediate steps were taken to prevent the failure of the
work in progress, and as soon as the appropriation becomes avail­
able the reestablishment of the station in accordance with the most
modern practice will be pushed to the utmost.
Relations with the States in Fish-Cultural Work.
The fish-cultural operations of the bureau bring it into close re­
lation with the various States, some of which are engaged in similar
work, while others depend wholly on the Federal Government for
the stocking of their waters with food fishes. In several States
field stations are jointly operated by bureau and State employees,
the eggs being incubated at the hatcheries most conveniently
located or from which the resulting fish can be most advanta­
geously distributed.
During the fiscal year 1919, upward of 670,000,000 eggs of fresh­
water and anadromous fishes were donated to 24 States for hatch­
ing and distribution under their own auspices.
The shad hatchery at the mouth of the Susquehanna River, Md.,
has remained closed because of the continued failure of the State
legislature to take action in harmony with the stipulations of Con­
gress. The equipment of this station has been distributed among
various other hatcheries.
Biological Investigation of Fishes.
Many of the vital problems connected with fisheries and aqui­
culture require for their elucidation the application of scientific
methods of investigation, and questions are constantly arising
which require the services of trained biologists. The branch of
the bureau that gives particular attention to these matters has
during the past year conducted a number of investigations
addressed to definite needs.
Among the fishes that have been the subject of special inquiry
is the paddlefish of the Mississippi Valley, one of the important
food fishes of our interior waters, now in danger of commercial
extinction because of the intensity of the fishery conducted chiefly
for its eggs, which are made into caviar. Up to the present time
no efforts to hatch the paddlefish artificially have been successful,
and there has also been lack of definite information regarding the
natural spawning of the fish. In cooperation with the depart­
ment of conservation of the State of Louisiana, there was under­
taken during the past year a special study of the breeding habits
of the paddlefish, and groundwork has been laid for further
inquiry which it is hoped may save this valuable fish.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

149

There have been instituted various investigations of the Pacific
salmons. A special inquiry was directed to the very extensive
practice of taking immature salmon by trolling and seining off
the coasts of California, Oregon, and Washington. The con­
clusion was reached that any method of fishing which destroys
immature salmon is so destructive and wasteful that it should be
discontinued. The Department has communicated the results of
the inquiry to the interested States and has indicated its readiness
to assist them in determining the best means of meeting this
menace to the salmon industry.
Shellfish Investigations.
Important scientific investigations have been devoted to
oysters, mussels, and other shellfish. A study of great practical
significance has been conducted in Dong Island Sound, the scene
of very extensive oyster-cultural operations, that have become
seriously impaired by failure of the spat to set. In some sections
more than half the grounds have ceased to be cultivated because
of the small yield of oysters thereon, and for the past two years
the set of spat has been entirely negligible. A temporary field
laboratory has been maintained at Milford, Conn., and inquiries
indicate that the wholesale death of spat in the shore waters may
be attributable to pollution in the form of sewage and trade
wastes. It has therefore been found desirable, in cooperation
with the water laboratory of the Bureau of Chemistry, to make
special studies of the nature and effects of the various pollutants.
Further investigations pertaining to the propagation, feeding,
and growth of oysters have been conducted in Great South Bay,
Long Island; Narragansett Bay, R. I.; Barnegat Bay, N. J.; all
in cooperation with the State authorities. In extensive oyster
beds in the York River, Va., a serious affection has for several
years rendered the oysters unmarketable. The malady consists
of a green discoloration associated with a watery and lean con­
dition of the meat. No cause or remedy has yet been found, but
the investigation is still in progress and will be continued until
definite conclusions are possible.
The sea mussel continues to be one of the great unutilized
aquatic resources of the north Atlantic coast. While the food
value of this mollusk is well recognized, there has been curious
delay in its general adoption into the dietary, even in the regions
where it abounds and is best known. In continuance of its task
of popularizing this valuable food article, the bureau has con­

150

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

ducted a survey of the mussel beds of Maine, southern New England,
and Long Island Sound, with a view to demonstrating the avail­
ability and abundance of mussels for use in a fresh condition and
for preserving.
Between Portland and Eastport, Me., in six sections where the
most important grounds are located, the survey showed upward
of 1,200 acres of natural mussel beds, estimated to contain over
1,275,000 bushels. The best beds yield from 2,500 to 5,000 bushels
to the acre. Leading packing houses on the north Atlantic coast
are giving special attention to the canning of mussels, and there
is reason to believe that the development of the mussel industry
will not be long delayed and will add materially to the wealth and
food supply of the country.
The practical operations in the artificial propagation of fresh­
water pearly mussels, conducted at various points in the Missis­
sippi Basin, resulted in the inoculation of 137,000,000 glochidia
on suitable fish hosts. The output was less than in the previous
year, owing chiefly to disturbed labor conditions. Investigations
and experiments in the field of fresh-water mussels have continued
to yield valuable results bearing on artificial propagation.
Among the crustacean shellfishes, the spiny lobsters of Cali­
fornia and of Florida have been the subjects of studies addressed
to their habits and growth. Upon the basis of the information
furnished by the bureau to the State authorities of Florida, more
effective protection has been provided by the legislature. Com­
prehensive reports on the life history of the blue crab and on the
blue-crab fishery have been issued and are expected to be useful
to State officials concerned with the protection of the crab and
the maintenance of the fishery. It may be noted with gratifica­
tion that an increased catch of blue crabs in Chesapeake Bay has
recently been had; and it is conceded that this has been due to
the adoption of wise measures of conservation based on the
bureau’s investigations and recommendations.
Use of Fishes in Controlling Mosquitoes.
A novel and highly important extension of the scientific activi­
ties of the bureau has been the eradication of mosquitoes and the
prevention of malaria in the vicinity of Army cantonments in
cooperation with the Public Health Service. The duty devolving
on the bureau in this cooperative work was the propagation of
mosquito-eating fishes, their distribution in waters infested with
mosquito larvae, and the maintenance, in bodies of water that could

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

151

not be drained, of conditions that promoted the effectiveness
of small fishes in the control of mosquitoes. The most extensive
operations were conducted in the vicinity of Camp Hancock and
the city of Augusts, Ga., and the success there attained was so
marked as to constitute a distinct advance in antimalarial work.
The Surgeon General of the Public Health Service has expressed
his appreciation of the assistance rendered, and has authorized
the publication of a report setting forth the methods followed and
the results achieved by the bureau in the extra-cantonment zone
at Camp Hancock.
Increased Utilization of Aquatic Products.
The Bureau of Fisheries has continued to render a large and
important service to the fishing industry, the fish trade, and the
public generally through its efforts to popularize neglected fishes
and find uses and markets for wasted water resources. The work
has consisted of practical demonstrations, technical investigations
and appropriate publicity, and has been made possible chiefly by
the allotment by the President of funds placed at his disposal for
the national security and defense. Undertaken primarily during
the war to increase the supplies of food and permit the exportation
of meats to Europe, this campaign has, of course, equal value as a
means of reducing living costs and of giving aquatic foods a larger
permanent place in the national dietary.
Appeal has been made to Congress for adequate funds for carry­
ing on this work, and meanwhile it has been necessary to greatly
curtail all activities and to abandon some that were rendering
important benefits to large numbers of people. Attention is asked
to Appendix B, relating to this subject.
New Sources of Aquatic Leather.
Material progress has been made in finding and utilizing new
sources of leather from the skins of aquatic animals. The feasi­
bility of producing commercial leather from such animals has been
amply demonstrated, and the actual business has passed beyond
the experimental stage, although work remains to be done in
perfecting methods and in making generally known to the manu­
facturers of leather goods the availability and merits of the new
products.
Many samples of aquatic leathers and of various articles made
therefrom have been submitted to the bureau by private firms
and have been favorably criticized by disinterested persons.

152

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

Among the manufactured objects made from fishskins that have
come to the attention of the Department are traveling bags, brief
cases, pocketbooks, belts, shoes, and ladies’ hand bags. It is
reported that the demand for shark leather for traveling bags is
now greater than the supply, and plans on a very extensive scale
are being executed for increasing and maintaining the output of
shark hides by the establishment of special shark fisheries on the
Atlantic, Pacific, and Gulf coasts. Excellent leather for shoes
is also being derived from sharks.
The duty imposed on the Department by Congress in June, 1917,
when there was made available the sum of $10,000 “ for develop­
ing by the Bureau of Fisheries, in cooperation with the Bureau of
Standards, new aquatic sources of supply of leather” may be
regarded as having been accomplished, and private enterprise
will now undoubtedly do what may be necessary to develop and
give permanancy to the industry.
Alaska Fisheries Service.
The usual duties involved in the administration of the Alaskan
fisheries have been performed. The corps of agents and wardens
was supplemented by a stream-watchman patrol inaugurated in
the season of 1918, consisting of 10 men engaged for the active
fishing season. In addition to the enforcement of the laws and
regulations governing fishing, the inspection of private salmon
hatcheries and the taking of the census of red salmon entering
Wood River, special investigations of a scientific and practical
nature were made; work was done in opening up salmon streams
for spawning; public hearings were held at Seattle concerning
commercial fishery operations and conditions in the Copper and
Yukon Rivers and all streams of southeastern Alaska; and de­
tailed statistics of the fishery industry were compiled.
The returns for 1918 show a larger production than that of 1917,
which far exceeded previous records. The number of persons em­
ployed in all branches of the industry was 31,213, an increase of
1,722 over 1917; the capital invested was $73,750,789, an increase
of $18,813,240; and the value of products marketed was $59,154,859, an increase of $7,677,879. The increased value of products
was chiefly owing to the larger pack of canned salmon in 1918
resulting from the strenuous effort to meet the food shortage.
The canned-salmon industry surpassed all records, the pack reach­
ing the grand total of 6,605,835 cases of forty-eight i-pound cans,
valued at $51,041,949. Of this, approximately three-eighths of

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

1 53

the quantity and nearly one-half of the value represented red
salmon. The salmon sold in a fresh, frozen, salted, and smoked
condition brought the total value of the salmon to $53,514,812.
Thus 50 years after the acquisition of Alaska, the salmon output
alone was worth seven and one-half times the purchase price.
The Alaska fisheries service merits liberal appropriations from
Congress. The corps available for enforcing the laws and regula­
tions and for carrying out other obligations arising out of admin­
istrative responsibility is still inadequate. The vast extent of
the salmon industry and the heavy drains that are being made on
the supply necessitate an enlarged personnel for maintaining and
extending the patrol, for making special investigations, and for
conducting various lines of constructive work in the interest of the
industry. Several large hatcheries should be established in regions
of most extensive fisheries, such as Karluk and Nushagak.
The following is a summary of results of efforts of the Bureau of
Fisheries to introduce the Scotch method of curing herring in
Alaska during 1917 and 1918. The figures for 1919 are not yet
available.
Total cost of work, about....................................................................................... $12, 000
Pack, as follows:
1917, 7,622 barrels (1,905,000 pounds)......................................................... 114, 350
1918, 38,977 barrels (9,744,250 pounds)........................................................ 748, 606
Total value.................................................................................................... 862,936

Alaska Fur-Seal Service.
The calendar year 1918 was the first after the expiration of the
law imposing a close time on the commercial killing of seals on the
Pribilof Islands. The quota of skins that might be secured was
fixed at 35,000 and the number actually taken was 34,883, all but
1,002 of which were procured by August 10, when operations have
usually ceased because of the beginning of the stagy season.
For the season 1919 the quota was tentatively fixed at 35,000,
and the number of skins actually secured to August 10 was 25,381.
The conditions of the herd warranted the taking of a considerably
larger number of skins, but the scarcity of experienced men, com­
bined with the increased labor involved in removing and han­
dling the skins of the larger seals, to which special attention was
given, reduced the season’s output. The epidemic of influenza
which ravaged Alaska necessitated the establishment of a quaran­
tine to protect the susceptible natives of the seal islands, and it

154

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

became impossible to carry out the plans for obtaining additional
labor.
In an effort to improve transportation facilities on the seal
islands three tractors and a number of wagons for trailers have been
sent this year. This equipment will not only be of the greatest
value in transporting sealskins from the killing grounds to the
salt houses, but will furnish the means of hauling carcasses from
the killing grounds to the newly established by-products plant.
'I'he tractors will also be very useful in constructing roads.
With a special appropriation made by Congress, there has been
purchased a power lighter for use at the Pribilof Islands and be­
tween the islands and Unalaska, the nearest commercial port, 250
miles distant. This vessel will be equipped with wireless appara­
tus, and a rapid-fire gun for use in any emergency that involves
the protection of the seal herd.
Most of the supplies required for the Pribilof Islands and the
products derived therefrom were transported on the steamer
Roosevelt, which made three voyages between Seattle and the
islands during the year. On the final voyage the vessel did not
leave the islands until December 12, which appears to be the
latest recorded date for any vessel in that part of Bering Sea.
Certain supplies and products were carried by the Coast Guard
cutter Bear and the naval radio tender Saturn. The lighthouse
tender Cedar of this Department transported heavy pieces of ma­
chinery for the by-products plant.
The very trying service required of the steamer Roosevelt during
the years actively engaged in the Alaska work, combined with
the heavy duty that the vessel had performed in her memorable
Arctic career, developed defects the repair of which would have
necessitated a large outlay out of proportion to her total value.
She was, therefore, sold at public auction in Seattle on July 15,
1919, for the sum of $28,000.
A very comprehensive account of the fur-seal service in 1918
is contained in a special report on Alaska fisheries and fur indus­
tries published by the Bureau of Fisheries. The native wards
of the Government and their physical, mental, and financial
condition are discussed at length.
There is need for an enlarged administrative personnel on the
Pribilof Islands, including a superintendent and a biologist. With
the acquisition of a vessel for interisland service, the islands
need not hereafter be managed as distinct entities, but should be

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

155

affiliated under one coordinating head. Vital scientific and
technical problems are involved in the management of the rapidly
increasing seal herd, and the creation of the position of biologist
is demanded.
Alaskan Seal Herd.
The fur seals resorting to the Pribilof Islands are continuing
to increase under the bénéficient protection afforded by the
international agreement prohibiting pelagic sealing. The only
untoward feature has been the accumulation of older male seals
far beyond the requirements for breeding purposes during the
5-year close time. Fortunately, the bureau has found a means
of utilizing to the pecuniary advantage of the Government the
skins of surplus bulls, and the gradual elimination of dispropor­
tionate elements is proceeding.
The seal census of 1918 gave 496,611 animals of all ages as
composing the herd on August 10, after the close of the regular
killing season. The corresponding census for 1919, the results
of which have been communicated by telegraph and are subject
to slight revision, showed 524,260 seals in the herd as of August
10, in addition to the 26,383 seals that had been taken for their
skins subsequent to the previous enumeration. The numerical
strength of the herd increased about x1 per cent from 1918 to 1919.
The detailed figures for 1919 are as follows: Breeding females,
157,172; new-born pups, 157,172; yearlings of both sexes, 92,891;
2-year-olds of both sexes, 66,352; males 3 years old, 13,576;
males 4, 5, and 6 years old, 20,080; harem bulls, 5,158; idle and
surplus bulls, 11,859; average harem, 30.47.
Marketing Products of the Seal Islands.
During the fiscal year ended June 30, 1919, there were two
sales of sealskins held October 7, 1918, and April 28, 1919. Fox
skins were also sold at the October 7, 1918, sale.
The sealskins numbered 12,002, and were dressed, dyed, and
machined before being offered for sale at public auction in St.
Louis, Mo. The gross proceeds were $777,931; the expenses,
including cost of preparation of skins, transportation, agents’
commission, discount for cash, etc., aggregated $233,195.52;
the net proceeds were thus $544,735.78.
The fox skins sold at public auction in St. Louis numbered
692 blue and 19 white pelts. The gross receipts were $58,179.50,
the expenses were $6,280.86, and the net proceeds were $51,898.54.

156

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

On September 10, 1919, there were sold at St. Louis by Messrs.
Funsten Bros. & Co., agents of the Department of Commerce,
9,055 dressed, dyed, and machined fur-seal skins and 665 blue
and 30 white-fox skins. ' The total gross price realized was
approximately $960,000. The sealskins averaged $91.35, an
advance of 30 per cent over the prices realized last April. The
blue foxes averaged $195.90, an advance of 135 per cent over
prices realized last October, when the last sale of Government
blue foxes occurred. The market was strong, bidding was
spirited throughout, and there was a very large attendance of
buyers. The results of this sale are highly gratifying.
A noteworthy development of the fur-seal industry during the
year has been the demonstration of the high value of the skins of
old male seals usually designated as “ wigs” and the creation of an
active demand for such skins. A t the public auction sale in
October, 1918, the best prices received for any sealskins were for
“ wigs,” an experimental lot of which brought $75 each. A t the
sale in April, 1919, a considerable number of “ wigs” were offered
for sale in a dressed and dyed condition; these sold for $77 to $88
each, while the average price for all skins was $66. It should be
noted that formerly “ wigs” in the raw state were regarded as
having little or no value in the London market.
The seal-island natives continue to collect old seal bones at
times when they have no other work. They are encouraged to
do this, and are paid for their labor. In 1919 about 300,000
pounds of bones were gathered, sacked, delivered on board
Government vessels, and landed in Seattle and San Francisco.
The net proceeds amounted to $3,891.03.
It is estimated that, when the entire take of sealskins for the
calendar year 19x8 shall have been dressed, dyed, machined,
and sold, the net revenue to the Government, based upon the
proceeds obtained at the sale of September 10, 1919, will be in
excess of $2,450,000. To this should be added an approximate
net revenue of $123,000 for the sale of fox skins. It is safe to
say that, when the proceeds of the sales of bones, oil, and other
by-products are taken into account, the net revenue for the
products of the calendar year 1918 will reach a sum in excess of
$2,600,000. This would more than pay all expenses of every
nature connected with the administration of the Pribilof Islands,
the Alaskan salmon fisheries, and the care of the minor fur­
bearing animals of Alaska for a period of 12 years.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

157

The accumulated experience of the Department under the
contract with Funsten Bros. & Co., of St. Louis, Mo., for dressing,
dyeing, machining, and selling fur-seal skins and for selling fox
skins from the Pribilof Islands has proved very beneficial to the
Government. The contractors have rendered highly satisfactory
service in every feature. They have not only scrupulously
observed every (xpressed and implied obligation of their contract,
but they have willingly assumed other responsibilities and duties
which, while meaning nothing to them in a pecuniary way, have
meant much to the Government. The service rendered has been
of a high order; the quality of the finished products has been
superior to the best obtainable elsewhere; the methods of con­
ducting the public auction sales have deserved and received the
approbation of the entire fur trade; and the financial interests of
the Government have been constantly safeguarded. The Gov­
ernment-owned furs have been in active demand and have
brought the highest prices in the history of the fur business.
As a result of the profit to the Government under the contract,
the latter has been extended so as to expire on December 15, 1926.
Minor Fur-Bearing Animals of Alaska.
The minor fur-bearing animals of Alaska have received the
usual attention, with assistance from special wardens whose
services have been available through a reciprocal arrangement
with the Governor of Alaska. There have been a number of
prosecutions for violations of the regulations, and seizures of furs
have been made from time to time. The furs thus confiscated
have been sold at public auction and the proceeds covered into
the Treasury of the United States.
There have been two modifications of the regulations: The use of
dogs for pursuing and killing fur-bearing animals for which close
seasons exist has been prohibited, and the open season on foxes
in the region drained by streams flowing into the Arctic Ocean
north of the sixty-eighth parallel of north latitude has been
extended 30 days, or until April 15. Fur-farming operations have
been continued at a number of places along the coast and in the
Yukon region, and some successful results have been reported.
Through the cooperation of postmasters, collectors of customs,
shippers, and others, the usual compilations of statistics of furs
shipped from Alaska have been made possible. The value of furs
for the year ending November 15, 1918, was $1,363,330, as com­
pared with $1,064,249 for the previous year, due largely to the

158

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

advance in the price of furs. With the exception of lynx, there
was also an increase in the number of pelts of the more important
species of fur-bearing animals shipped from Alaska. The more
notable increases were of ermine, foxes, mink, muskrat, land otter,
wolves, and wolverines.
Fishery Legislation Needed.
The most urgent requirement in connection with the fisheries
of Alaska is for a new code covering the salmon fisheries to replace
the existing obsolete and inadequate laws. Proper administra­
tion, efficient regulation, rational conservation, and fair revenue
to the Government can not be secured unless the salmon laws are
revised to meet present conditions. Legislation is desired also to
lodge the administration of the minor fur-bearing animals of
Alaska elsewhere than in the Bureau of Fisheries, an agency whose
legitimate functions are entirely irrelevant to land mammals.
There is urgent need also for amendment of the law of June 14,
1906, prohibiting aliens from engaging in the fisheries of Alaska.
The defects in the present law result in the violation of the spirit
of the law and permit the actual exploitation of the fishery re­
sources of Alaska by alien fishermen operating independently and
having no regard for laws or regulations designed to perpetuate
the industry.
The prevention of waste in the Alaskan halibut fishery and
protection to the halibut grounds should be promptly brought
about by legislation in accordance with the recommendation of
the American-Canadian Fisheries Conference. Legislation to be
effective should be uniform in the United States and Canada.

BUREAU OF LIGHTHOUSES.
(G eo rge R. P u tnam ,

C o m m is s io n e r .)

Cooperation with Navy and War Departments.
The lighthouse vessels and stations operated under the j unsdiction of the Navy Department during the war were returned to
the Lighthouse Service July i, 1919.
The Lighthouse Service, in addition to the work done by the
tenders directly under the orders of the War and Navy Depart­
ments, during the war provided facilities at various depots for
the berthing of naval vessels, and at the general lighthouse depot
at Tompkinsville, N. Y ., provided special coaling facilities and
quarters for naval detachments. Additional buoys were placed,
and other changes in aids to navigation were made, as required.
Repairs to naval patrol boats were made at various points, and
various buoys, moorings, and other appurtenances were trans­
ferred to or purchased for the Navy and War Departments.
The Lighthouse Service also cooperated with the Navy Depart­
ment and Treasury Department in connection with improve­
ments in coast-communication facilities by telephone and radio
and in the transmission of reports received from light stations
and considered of possible military value.
Because the tenders of the Lighthouse Service are particu­
larly well equipped for handling buoys, moorings, etc., and their
officers are thoroughly familiar with the coast line and waters
of the United States, these vessels were effectively used by the
War Department in mine-planting operations and by the Navy
Department in laying submarine-defense nets, etc., during the
war and later in removing these defenses.
Aids to Navigation.
In addition to this cooperation with the military service, the
regular work of the Service in maintaining and improving aids
to navigation was actively carried on during the year. During
the fiscal year three important light and fog-signal stations were
established from special appropriations— namely, at Lorain
Harbor, Ohio, at the end of the west breakwater, to mark the
entrance to the harbor; at Sand Hills, Mich., to mark a dangerous

l6 o

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

locality on the south shore of Lake Superior; and at Lime Kiln,
San Juan Island, Wash., to mark an important point on the route
from Puget Sound to British Columbia and Alaska.
Three unwatched acetylene lights were established in the
Caribbean Sea to mark the traffic lane between the Gulf coast
of the United States and the Panama Canal through Yucatan
Passage. This important maritime track lies between low coral
reefs and islands in the northwestern part of the Caribbean Sea.
The work was done in cooperation with the Navy Department,
which furnished a gunboat to transport the working party and
materials.
An unwatched acetylene light was established at Dog Island,
Me.
During the year 36 new aids were established in Alaska, includ­
ing 19 light stations, 1 gas and bell buoy, and 16 other aids. The
total number of aids to navigation in Alaska at the end of the
fiscal year was 475, being a net increase of 36 over that of the
preceding fiscal year, and the total number of lights was 180.
The appropriation by the sundry civil act approved July 19, 1919,
of $75,000 for aids to navigation in Alaska has permitted active
steps toward further safeguarding those dangerous waters.
The work to be done was already listed, ready, when the money
became available and instructions to proceed were given by tele­
graph in order to accomplish as much as possible during the
present season.
A total of 736 new aids to navigation were established during
the year, including 178 fixed lights, 6 float lights, x light vessel,
73 gas buoys, and 469 other aids, the total number in commis­
sion on June 30, 1919, being 16,075, a net increase of 400 over the
preceding fiscal year.
Considerable work was done during the fiscal year in repairing
damage to aids to navigation caused by ice floes during the
winter of 1917-18, especially to screw-pile structures in Chesa­
peake Bay and Potomac River. Much was also done in repairing
hurricane damage to aids in the Gulf of Mexico, reconstructing
stations, so far as practicable, in a manner calculated to better
withstand future destruction.
Various special works were actively in progress during the year,
including the establishment of important new fight and fog-signal
stations and lighthouse depots, improvements in systems of fixed
aids and buoyage, etc.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

l6 l

Improvement in illuminating and fog-signal apparatus of exist­
ing aids was continued. Fixed lights were replaced by flashing
or occulting lights at 20 stations, including two light vessels;
incandescent oil-vapor lights were substituted for oil-wick lamps
at 4 stations; and acetylene or electric incandescent illuminant
was substituted at 36 stations, including 5 light vessels and 2 buoys.
The fog-signal apparatus at 7 important stations was improved
by the substitution of air diaphones for less efficient apparatus.
General repairs required to maintain aids to navigation in
efficient condition were continued, but insufficiency of funds
prevented this work being done to the proper extent.
Damage to lighthouse property, estimated at $13,500, was sus­
tained on December 8, 1918, by a fire at Execution Rocks Light
Station, N. Y. The fog-signal engine and machinery, also the
tower, oil house, and dwelling, were damaged.
On March n , 1919, a gas buoy burst while being tested at a
lighthouse depot by means of hydrostatic pressure, injuring two
employees, one of whom died later as a result of injuries received.
The accident was carefully investigated and steps taken to insure
the observance of precautions.
An earthquake and tidal wave of considerable intensity occurred
in Porto Rico- and vicinity on October 11, 1918. Lighthouse
property was not seriously damaged, except at Point Borinquen
and Point Jiguero Light Stations.
The mild winter of 1918-19 presented a great contrast to the
severe weather of the preceding winter, and permitted the re­
moval of buoys from their stations for the winter without loss or
trouble, and in some cases buoys usually removed for the winter
were kept on station throughout the year. This rarely happens
in north Atlantic waters.
Vessels.

There is a very urgent need for the construction of additional
vessels for the Lighthouse Service, to replace those worn out in
service, those lost through various casualties, and to meet the
■ considerable growth of the Service in recent years. A full state­
ment of this situation is given in Appendix A to this report.
Relief Light Vessel No. 51, stationed on Cornfield Point light
vessel station, Conn., was collided with and sunk by a barge
barge in tow of a Standard Oil tug on April 24, 1919. The light
ship went down in eight minutes after being struck. Good judg­
ment and discipline on the light vessel were shown in the emer140261—19------ 11

I 62

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

gency. No injury was sustained by the crew. The lifeboat and
log and fog-signal books were the only property of the light vessel
saved. This vessel was of iron, built in 1892. The owner of the
tow has been called upon to indemnify the Government.
Bush Bluff Light Vessel No. 97, was surveyed and condemned
for sale, being in such a poor condition as not to warrant repairs.
Bush Bluff Station is now marked by a gas and bell buoy, the bell
being operated by carbonic-acid gas, a test installation of this
apparatus.
The tender Cedar performed urgent special duty in connection
with the influenza epidemic last fall. Physicians and nurses in
charge of a medical officer of the United States Public Health
Service were carried to isolated localities in southeastern Alaska,
principally native Indian villages.
Lighthouse Depots.
Construction of the lighthouse depot for the sixteenth district,
at Ketchikan, Alaska, for which an appropriation of $90,000 was
made by act of July i, 1918, was actively carried on during the
year. On June 30, 1919, the wharf was about 95 per cent com­
pleted, and the entire work, including storehouse, shops, etc.,
about 35 per cent completed.
Important improvements are in progress at the general light­
house depot, Tompkinsville, N. Y. The act of March 28, 1918,
appropriated $60,000 for repairs to the wharves. This work
includes the removal of the old wooden wharf decks and con­
struction of concrete decks with cast-iron pile columns and other
improved features. In order to permit use of the wharves while
improvements are in progress, the work is being done in three
¡sections. The first section, the south wharf, was completed in
February, 1919. It is expected that the second section will be
completed about September, 1919.
In August, 1918, you allotted from your fund for national
security and defense $175,000 for improvement of coaling facilities
at this depot, with particular reference to cooperation work with
the Navy. This work is in progress, and it is expected will be
completed about February, 1920.
The act of July 19, 1919, appropriated $30,000 for extending
and enlarging the machine shop at this depot, and plans are
being prepared.
The act of June 12, 1917, appropriated $21,000 for improving
the office and laboratory at this depot. This work has been

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

163

completed, except the installation of a heating system and other
work of minor importance.
The act of July 1, 1918, appropriated $85,000 for the construc­
tion of a depot for the second lighthouse district. A portion of
the old marine-hospital property in Chelsea has been transferred
as a site for this depot. The work is in progress, but the amount
available is quite insufficient for the complete construction.
The act of June 20, 1918, authorized $275,000 for improvements
at the lighthouse depot at Portsmouth, Va., or establishing a new
depot, but no appropriation has been made for this work. This
is the principal depot of one of the largest lighthouse districts
and is the headquarters for five tenders and two light vessels.
The facilities for berthing these vessels is entirely inadequate,
and the efficient operation of the vessels is much hampered in
consequence. The inadequacy of space for storing and handling
buoys also causes delay and loss.
A new depot for the seventh lighthouse district, at Key West,
Fla., is urgently needed for the efficient and economical handling
of the work of the district. The present depot is located on
property belonging to the Treasury Department, with naval coal
sheds and piers on either side. The space allotted the Lighthouse
Service for buoys and appendages is entirely inadequate. The
depot consists of a wooden storehouse built on a wooden pier.
There is no oil house at this depot, due to lack of space, and
kerosene, gasoline, and other inflammable supplies have to be
kept in the storehouse, constituting a constant menace of fire.
Suitable depot facilities at Honolulu for the nineteenth light­
house district are also much needed, and an estimate has been
submitted for this purpose.
Improvement of Apparatus and Equipment.
Radio equipment was installed on 28 light vessels and on 12
tenders during the fiscal year. At the end of the fiscal year
41 light vessels and 23 tenders had been equipped with radio
installations.
The installation of telephones at light stations was continued
during the year. This work was done by the United States
Coast Guard under an appropriation to develop coastal commu­
nications, including connections with important light stations.
On June 30, 1919, there were 139 light stations so connected.
Experiments and tests ■ with various devices and equipment
used in lighthouse work have resulted in developing improvements

164

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

in the interests of efficiency and economy. Among these may
be mentioned improvements in diaphone installations, resulting
in simplicity of operation, reduced space required for machinery,
and lowered initial cost. A new type of metal buoy was developed
for use in defining shoal-water channels, being an improvement
over wooden spar buoys, which are less conspicuous and more
expensive to maintain. The stability of the type L gas and bell
buoy moored in the exposed waters of Alaska was improved.
On account of immunity from submarine boring insects the
use of palmetto piles has been extended in southern waters.
An improved device for fastening moorings to buoys in the
upper Mississippi River was tested and proved satisfactory.
Investigation of the use of radio for fog-signal purposes was
interrupted by war activities, but is now resumed.
Personnel.
On June 30, 1919, there were 5,964 persons employed in the
Lighthouse Service, including 125 technical, 156 clerical, and
5,683 employees connected with light stations, vessels, and depots.
This Service is charged with the maintenance of aids to naviga­
tion along 47,300 statute miles of coast line and river channel.
The retirement system for the field service of the Lighthouse
Service was put in effect upon the appropriation by Congress
of the necessary funds by act approved November 4, 1918. By
the same act the retirement law was amended to the extent that
the provisions of the law do not apply to persons in the field
service whose duties do not require substantially all their time.
The effect of the retirement system has been very advantageous,
both to the Service and the personnel, and at a moderate expense.
Saving of Life and Property.
During the fiscal year services in saving life and property were
rendered and acts of heroism performed by employees of the
Lighthouse Service on 1x1 occasions. Many of these acts were
considered especially meritorious, and the employees were indi­
vidually commended by me.
Administration.
The system of cost keeping for the Service was modified, reduc­
ing the amount of detail work required in district offices without
sacrificing the essential data furnished. This modification was
necessary in order that other important work might be kept up.
The Department approved regulations for the distribution of
lighthouse publications on a sales basis, pursuant to act of Con­

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

165

gress of June 20, 1918. This was put in effect January 1, 1919.
Sales agencies have been established at the principal ports.
Returns of sales are made to the Superintendent of Documents,
Washington, D. C., who supplies the necessary copies of the
publication.
The appropriations for the maintenance of the Lighthouse
Service for the fiscal year 1920 are $6,625,000, being $474,570
in excess of those for the preceding fiscal year, and include $45,000
for retired pay. In addition, there are special appropriations
aggregating $794,400, including $440,000 contained in the defi­
ciency act of November 4, 1918.
The appropriations for the maintenance of the Lighthouse
Service for the fiscal year 1920 were $1,054,600 less than the
estimates submitted, and additional funds will be necessary for
even the minimum maintenance of the Service during this fiscal
year.
During the last fiscal year $774,000 was transferred from Navy
Department appropriations to make good deficiencies in the
maintenance of the Lighthouse Service, but as the vessels and
stations were transferred back on July r, 1919, funds will not
be available from the similar provisions in the naval appropriation
act this year.
Systematic inspections have been continued in the various
lighthouse districts of the technical w'ork, business methods, and
property accounts.
Special Legislation Needed.
The act of August 29, 1916, authorizing the President to trans­
fer to the Navy or War Department portions of the Lighthouse
Service when there is a national emergency, should be amended
so as to definitely define the status of the personnel transferred.
All persons so transferred who serve on vessels or at stations where
they are exposed to the risks of war, should have a suitable mili­
tary status, and be entitled to all relief provided by legislation for
those in the military services. Although the personnel trans­
ferred during this year were, under rulings of the Treasury Depart­
ment, given the benefits of the war-risk insurance, there was con­
siderable conflict in decisions as to their standing under the act
of August 29, 1916. All of the personnel were in an indefinite and
anomalous position in their relations with the military and naval
personnel. Specific recommendation is deferred until conditions
become more settled. In any future transfer of vessels there
should, if practicable, be more definite understanding as to the

166

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OE COMMERCE.

extent to which tenders are to be diverted from their lighthouse
duty. The upkeep of the system of aids to navigation requires
every effort of the present equipment of tenders, and their efficient
maintenance is even more important in time of war than in
normal times.
Legislation is recommended to cover adjustment of claims by
lighthouse employees for loss or damage to personal property,
such as clothing, furniture, etc., caused by storm, tidal waves,
collisions, or fire at light stations, depots, and on vessels. Such
provision should be made in justice to these employees engaged
on hazardous duty. By act of June 17, 1910, it was provided that
claims against the Government for damages not exceeding $500
arising out of collisions for which lighthouse vessels are respon­
sible be determined and settled by the Commissioner of Light­
houses. This provision has enabled the Government to adjust
claims promptly and has relieved Congress of the annoyance of
many petty claims; and similar legislation covering losses of per­
sonal property by lighthouse employees would be advantageous to
the Government and result in more equal justice to employees.
Legislation is also recommended providing for medical relief
for lighthouse keepers without charge at other than hospitals and
stations of the Public Health Service. The hospitals and stations
of the Public Health Service, at which free treatment is now pro­
vided for lighthouse keepers, are obviously inaccessible for a
large number of keepers.
Legislation is recommended authorizing the establishment and
maintenance of post-lantern lights and other aids to navigation on
the Yukon River and its tributaries, Alaska. The waters of the
Yukon delta are already being marked, but congressional authority
is required for the Lighthouse Service to extend its jurisdiction
to the non tidal waters of these rivers. Navigation of the Yukon
River is increasing, and as it is navigable for a long distance many
lights and day marks are required.
An appropriation of $50,000 is strongly recommended for estab­
lishing and improving aids to navigation in the Virgin Islands of
the United States, West Indies, and adjacent waters. This work
was authorized by Congress by the act approved June 20, 1918
(40 Stat., 608), but no appropriation has been made. The Naval
Governor of the Virgin Islands in a letter dated July 15, 1919,
strongly urged that this matter be given the serious consideration
it deserves in order to facilitate and safeguard the very large
amount of shipping in these islands.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

l67

The act of June 20, 1918, providing for voluntary reti.ement
at the age of 65 after 30 years’ service, and compulsory retire­
ment at the age of 70, for certain classes of employees of the
Lighthouse Service has proved beneficial both to the men eligible
to reti.ement and to the Service in replacing such men with
younger and more capable employees. Still greater efficiency,
however, will result and hardship to deserving employees will be
avoided if the same benefits are extended to persons who become
disabled from efficiently peifo ming their duties by reason of
disability incident to their work, such disability being'distinct
from that caused by injury received in the line of duty, for which
compensation is now provided by law. Legislation to this end
is recommended.
Appropriations for Special Works.
The sundry civil act approved July 19, 1919, made the follow­
ing app; op; iations lor special wo.ks in the Lighthouse Se.vice:
Restoring and improving Execution Rocks Light Station, N. Y ..................... $10, ooo
Rebuilding Point Jiguero Light Station, P. R ................................................... 24, 000
Improving the light and fog signal at Manitowoc Breakwater Light Station,
Wis........................................................................................................................
9,000
Completing the removal and rebuilding of Chicago Harbor Light Station, 111.,
6,400
and establishing lights on the new breakwater in Chicago Harbor.............
Constructing light keepers’ dwellings and appurtenant structures, including
sites therefor, within the limit of cost fixed by the act approved February
26, 1907................................................................................................................. 50,000
Extending and enlarging the machine shop at the lighthouse depot, Tompkinsville, Staten Island, N. Y ............................................................................. 30,000
Providing riprap to reinforce foundations of light stations and constructing
or improving boat landings in the third lighthouse district.......................... 150,000
Establishing new aids to navigation and improving existing aids in A laska.. 75, 000

Measures were taken to inaugurate work on all these projects
and to push them to completion as promptly as possible.
The deficiency appropriation act now pending contains the fol­
lowing items for the Lighthouse Service :
Constructing or purchasing and equipping tenders and light vessels to replace those worn out in service....................................................................... $760,000
Diamond Shoal Light Vessel, N. C .................................................................... 450,000
Completing the light and fog-signal station at Conneaut, Ohio.......................
19, 600

The item of $760,000 is of special importance, marking the
beginning, and only the beginning, of the process of replacement
of the many old and worn-out vessels in the Se. vice, leferied to
in Appendix A of this report. The item of $450,000 for Diamond
Shoal is for the replacement of the light vessel sunk by a German
submarine on August 6, 1918.

COAST AND GEODETIC SURVEY.
(C ol. E . L e ste r Jo n e s , Superintendent.)

Important Publications.
Two publications of special importance were issued during the
fiscal year 1918.
One of these is the series of publications on the Lambert Con­
formal Conic Projection. The principle of the Lambert projec­
tion is in a measure graphically illustrated in the figure opposite.
Many methods of projection have been designed to solve the
difficult problem of representing a spherical surface on a plane.
As different projections have unquestionably merits as well as
equally serious defects, any region to be mapped should be made
the subject of special study and that system of projection adopted
which will give the best results for the area and purposes under
consideration.
The Mercator projection, almost universally used for nautical
charts, is responsible for many false impressions of the relative
size of countries differing in latitude. The polyconic projection
widely used and well adapted for most topographic and hydrographic surveys, when used for the whole of the United States in
one map, has the serious defect of unduly exaggerating the areas
on its eastern and western limits. Along the Pacific coast and in
Maine the error in scale is as much as 6l/ i per cent, while at New
York it reaches 4% per cent.
The value of the new outline map on the new Lambert projection
can best be realized when it is stated that throughout the larger
and most important parts of the United States— that is, between
latitudes 30% and 490— the maximum scale error is only one-half
of 1 per cent. This scale error of one-half of 1 per cent is fre­
quently less than the distortion due to the method of printing
and to changes from the humidity of the air. Only in southern­
most Florida and Texas does this projection attain its maximum
error of 2J/3 per cent.
The Lambert projection is well adapted to large areas of pre­
dominating east-and-west dimensions, as the United States,
where the distances across from east to west is one and four-fifths
times that of the distance north and south.
168

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

169

The strength of the polyconic projection, on the other hand, is
along its central meridian. The merits and defects of the two sys­
tems of projection may be stated in a general way as being at
right angles with each other.
Special features of the Lambert projection that are not found in
the polyconic may be stated briefly, as follows:

LIM ITS

of p r o j e c t io n

LAMBERT'S CONFORMAL CONIC PROJECTION
Diagram illustrating the intersection of a cone and Sphere
along the two standard parallels.

1.
The Lambert projection is conformal; that is, all angles
between intersecting lines or curves are preserved, and for any
given point (or restricted locality) the ratio of the length of a
linear element on the earth’s surface to the length on the corre­
sponding map element is constant for all azimuths or directions
in which the element may be taken.

170

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

2. The meridians are straight lines and the parallels are con­
centric circles.
3. It has two axes of strength instead of one, the standard
parallels of the map of the United States being latitudes 330
and 450, and upon these parallels the scale is absolutely true.
The scale for any other part of the map, or any parallel, can
be obtained from tables contained in one of the series of these
publications. By means of these tables, the very small scale
errors in this projection can be entirely eliminated.
The other publication is the Report on the Connection of the
Arcs of Primary Triangulation Along the Ninety-Eighth Meridian
in the United States and in Mexico and on Triangulation in
Southern Texas.
An event of the greatest importance in the history of geodesy
was consummated in the spring of 1916, when observations were
made at stations on the northern and southern banks of the Rio
Grande, which connected the arcs of primary triangulation which
had been established in the United States and in Mexico along
the ninety-eighth meridian. The connection is interesting to the
geodesist, because it makes available a very long meridional arc
of connected and completed triangulation.
This connectioh will make available data from which to com­
pute with greater accuracy than heretofore the dimensions of the
earth. This will in itself make the work a notable contribution
to science. But of even greater moment is the fact that the con­
nection of the triangulation of the United States and Mexico will
enable the latter country to extend to new areas from the ninetyeighth meridian arc geodetic control for surveys and maps in the
form of triangulation which can be made on the North American
datum.
This datum had been called the United States standard datum
previous to the year 1913, when it was also adopted by Mexico
and Canada for their geodetic coordinates. Its designation was
changed to the North American datum when it had thus attained
an international character.
Field Work.
This country was at war with Germany during the period this
report covers, and the naval needs of the country required all
available vessels. It was, therefore, very' late in the fiscal year
1919 before any vessels could be released for civil duties. The
five vessels of the Coast and Geodetic Survey that had been trans-

171

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

ferred to the Navy Department to meet its needs were retrans­
ferred to the Coast and Geodetic Survey April 1, 1919, by Executive
order. These vessels are the Surveyor, the Bache, the Isis, the
Explorer, and the Patterson (temporarily renamed the Forward).
Under authority of the act of Congress, section 8557, Compiled
Statutes (R. S. 4686), the President is authorized to transfer such
vessels, boats, and auxiliary ships or any of them which are not
necessary to the needs of the Navy to any other executive depart­
ment of the Government that has need for such vessels. Acting
under this authority, the following vessels of the Navy Department
were transferred to the service and jurisdiction of the Coast and
Geodetic Survey : Natoma, April 9, 1919; Wenonah, April 12, 1919;
Onward, April 19, 1919; Ranger, April 28, 1919; Arcturus, May
5, 1 91 9 The following table gives a condensed statement of the vessels
at the disposal of the Coast and Geodetic Survey within the fiscal
year:

N am e of vessel.

Owned by
Loaned to
Coast and
Coast and
Transferred
Sold during
to Coast and Geodetic Sur­ Geodetic Sur­ the fiscal
Geodetic Sur­ vey by Phil­ vey a t begin­
year.
vey by Navy. ippine Gov­ ning of fiscal
year.
ernm ent.

1
..

..............

T o ta l..................................................................

5

a

9

X

Transferred from N avy..................................................................................................
Loaned by Philippine Government.............................................................................
Owned by Coast and Geodetic Survey........................................................................

5
a
9

Total.....................................................................................................................
Sold during the year......................................................................................................

16
i

Total vessels at disposal of the Survey at end of fiscal year..........................

15

172

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The following statement is instructive as to the size of the vessels
now operated by the bureau:
Gross tonnage.

Surveyor.......................................... i, ooo
690
Pathfinder........................................
Patterson..........................................
500
Areturus...........................................
456
Fathomer..........................................
431
Rotnblon........ »...............................
411
Isis........................................................

377

Bache................................................

370

Gross tonnage.

Explorer...........................................
Wenonah...........................................
Ranger..............................................
Onward.............................................
Matchless..........................................
Hydrographer...................................
Natoma..................

335
240
219
157
118
116
112

Summarized, the hydrographic accomplishments during the
fiscal year are as follows:
Square
sta tu te miles.

Ship hydrography....................................................................................................... 784.2
Launch hydrography.................................................................................................. 89.1
Wire-drag surveys....................................................................................................... 510.6
Revision surveys........................................................................................................ 82.0

Last year Congress authorizeda nominal extracompensation
to employees of the Bureau of Lighthouses stationed on lightships
when they are engaged in making current observations for the
Coast and Geodetic Survey. Under this arrangement observa­
tions were begun as soon as instruments could be procured and
installed on the various lightships. Within the year such observa­
tions were made on 23 different lightships stationed on both the
Atlantic and Pacific coasts.
Short series of current observations were made at 57 different
stations on both the Atlantic and Pacific coasts.
Tidal observations were made throughout the year at 12 perma­
nent tidal stations, 9 on the Atlantic and Gulf coasts, and 2 on the
Pacific coast. Besides the tidal observations at the permanent
stations, important observations were made at 44 different stations
on both coasts of continental United States, and on the coasts of
Alaska and the Philippine Islands. In connection with the hydrographic work, 96.7 square miles of topography were executed.
Primary triangulation was executed from theninety-eighth merid­
ian, in the vicinity of Waco, Tex., to Robeline, La. The length of
this scheme is 255 miles, and an area of 3,570 square miles was
covered. Secondary triangulation was run from Sanford, N. C.,
to the vicinity of Madison, N. C. The length of the scheme is 120
miles, and the area covered is 1,700 square miles. Secondary tri­
angulation was also run from Turkey Point Light to Sandy Point
Light, Chesapeake Bay. The length of this scheme is 37 miles,
and the area covered is 210 square miles.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

1 73

Tertiary triangulation was executed as follows: Morro Bay,
Calif.: Length of scheme, 5 miles; area covered, 8 square miles.
Key Biscayne in the vicinity of Miami, F la.: Length of scheme,
15 miles; area covered, 42 square miles. Vicinity of Charleston,
S. C .: Length of scheme, 14 miles; area covered, 27 square miles.
A primary traverse was run from Vaughan, N. C., to Blaney,
S. C. The length of the line is 235 miles. Another primary trav­
erse was run from Wilmington to Sanford, N. C. . The length of
this line is 125 miles.
One arc of reconnoissance extends from the vicinity of Waco,
Tex., eastward to Robeline, La. The length of this reconnoissance
is 255 miles. Another reconnoissance, 50 miles in length, was run
in the vicinity of Prescott, Ariz. A line of reconnoissance, also 50
miles in length, was run in the vicinity of Richfield, Utah.
There were 1,190 miles of precise leveling run during the fiscal
year 1919. Magnetic observations were made during the year at
77 stations in 11 States, of which 34 were new primary stations,
17 auxiliary stations, 22 repeat stations for the determination-of
secular change, and 4 new stations in old localities. The regular
observatories of the bureau at Cheltenham, Md.; Vieques, P. R.;
Tucson, Ariz.; Sitka, Alaska; and near Honolulu, Hawaii, were
in operation throughout the year.
Needs of the Survey to Better Accomplish its Field Work.
The end of the fiscal year finds the Survey with a fleet of 15
vessels, a truly considerable number when compared with those
available in previous years and probably more than has ever been
at the disposal of the bureau at any one time in its history. This
comparatively large number of vessels is due to the fact that five
vessels have been transferred to the bureau from the Navy
Department under authority of the Executive order of May 24,
1919. These five were part of a number of vessels that the Navy
Department had acquired to meet the temporary naval need for
patrol boats, etc., during the war. Even with these additions
from the Navy Department, however, the condition of the Sur­
vey’s fleet is unsatisfactory. While there are numbers, there are
inefficient units. When it was learned that the Navy had vessels
that could be transferred, a board of Coast Survey officers was
appointed to consult with the proper officials of the Navy Depart­
ment to learn what vessels were available for transfer that were
suited to the needs of the Survey. After a thorough examination
of all the vessels that the Navy Department had available for

174

REPORT OE THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

transfer, the board recommended that the five vessels above
named be taken over. These vessels were accepted not because
they are wholly suited for our work, but because they are the best
means to an end at the present time. I feel that we have a great
responsibility in meeting the marine needs of this country in find­
ing and charting the dangers to navigation. The need is so
pressing that we are confident that we are justified in doing what
can be done with these vessels turned over by the Navy Depart­
ment, though at an overhead cost considerably more than if vessels
designed for the use of the Survey could be had.
The vessels we have thus acquired, after a careful investigation
of those available, can not be efficiently operated as surveying
vessels. Ship hydrography can not be economically carried on
with a vessel that is too large, because too large a complement of
officers and men is required, nor can the work be done with safety
with a vessel that is too small, because she can not live through
the severe weather that will be met. Furthermore, the character
of the area to be surveyed seldom permits clean-cut classification,
so that it can be determined before hand that this portion of it will
be done by vessel and that by launches. Greater and more econ­
omical progress is made if the vessel is equipped to carry launches
on her deck, and when the field of operation is reached the launch
hydrography (in waters too shallow for the vessel to operate) is
done in conjunction with the ship hydrography. Thus the entire
area is covered by the same party during the same season.
There are two classes of ship hydrography: Offshore, such as
that off the coasts of California, Oregon, and Washington, out to
the 1,000-fathom curve. The other class is known as combined
hydrography, such as that along the coast of Alaska, where there
are many areas of which the deeper water hydrography must be
done by a vessel and the waters inshore by launches.
The particular reasons why the yachts that we have obtained
from the Navy Department are not suitable for either of these
classes of hydrography are these: The offshore hydrography that
must be done by ships along the coast of Washington, Oregon, and
California out to the i ,ooo-fathom curve extends a general average
distance of 30 miles from shore. Along these coasts the harbors
of refuge are few and far between. Furthermore, the storms
encountered within the area that must be surveyed are generally
very severe. To buffet the storms that will surely be encountered
a stanch sea-going vessel is required. The yachts now in our pos­

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

175

session have neither the strength required of hull nor machinery
to stand the strain to which they would be subjected in these
storms. Furthermore, if they were stanch enough for this out­
side work, they have not the fuel capacity to make it economical
to operate them there. Too much time would have to be expended
in running to the widely separated ports to obtain fuel supplies.
This class of hydrography is done by running lines of soundings
at right angles to the shore to and from the shore out to the 1,000fathom curve. If a vessel only has fuel capacity to enable her to
make but a few trips from the shore out to the 1 ,ooo-fathonr curve
and back to shore and then she must abandon her work and steam
some hundreds of miles to a port to obtain a fresh supply of fuel,
it is readily seen that there is an enormous loss of time, and conse­
quently a great overhead cost to carry on this class of surveys
with such a vessel. Vessels properly designed for this work are
oil-burning and have a cruising radius of several thousand miles.
The other class, known as combined hydrography, covers areas
where for the sake of economy the ship hydrography and the
launch hydrography should be executed at the same time. The
vessels that came to us from the Navy Department were yachts.
They were built for speed and along narrow lines. They neither
have the deck room for the storage of launches or for installation
of hoisting apparatus for hoisting them aboard the vessel, nor
the stability to carry the apparatus.
It seems to be the impression that there is no justification
in our asking for appropriations for new vessels especially de­
signed for the work of this bureau so long as there would be sur­
plus vessels after the war; but such views are erroneous. A great
public need would be more quickly met, and in the long run dol­
lars that come from the Public Treasury would be saved if proper
surveying vessels were provided for this bureau. It costs prac­
tically as much in personnel, food, fuel, and supplies to operate
an inefficient vessel as it does to operate an efficient one. As
it is, we will make what progress we can at a very considerable
loss of efficiency in picking here and there sheltered waters where
these vessels can be used, and equip the larger ones with as many
launches as they will carry, probably not more than two, so that
the vessel hydrography will progress more rapidly than the launch
hydrography and delays will be enforced in regions where com­
bined vessel and launch hydrography are necessary. There is
as much necessity for vessels of special design for making surveys

176

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

as there is for use as tugs, ferries, lightships, and for freight or
passenger vessels.
In 16 years, or from 1903 to 1919, but one effective appropri­
ation was made for vessels for the Coast and Geodetic Survey,
and that was for the fiscal year ended June 30, 19x6, when the
sum of $289,000 was authorized for two new vessels, including
their equipment. Through this appropriation we procured two
vessels, one especially designed and built for a surveying vessel,
and the other was purchased. For the fiscal year ended June
30, 1919, an appropriation wras made in the following words:
“ For one new vessel, including equipment, to cost not exceeding
$354,000, $50,000.”
The question was submitted to the Comptroller of the Treasury
whether there was authority to enter into a contract for the con­
struction of a vessel to cost not exceeding the limit mentioned.
The Comptroller held that the legislation did not in specific terms
declare that a contract could be executed in excess of the amount
appropriated, and therefore such a contract would be in violation
of the act of June 30, 1906.
We have never had the vessels and personnel to bring the sur­
veys of our waters up to a proper standard. The charts of Alaskan
waters are incomplete, and the information shown on many of
them is from exploration surveys by the Russians before Alaska was
acquired by the United States and with a lack of exactness that
would not be tolerated at the present time. The charts of the
waters of the three Pacific Coast States do not contain sufficient
information for offshore navigation and many of the charts of
the Atlantic coast and Gulf coast of the United States are
lacking in the same respect. And this should be borne in
mind, that heretofore the vessels that plied our waters have
been largely of foreign registration, and, therefore, losses on
account of inadequate surveys have been borne to a considerable
extent by other countries than ours, but that the war has brought
about a great stimulation of shipbuilding in this country so that
our vessels have increased from 26,397 with a gross tonnage of
8,871,037 on June 30, 1917, to 27,513 with a gross tonnage of
12,907,300 at the end of the fiscal year 1919. What is more sig­
nificant still is that the increase of our merchant fleet has been
not in small coasting craft, but ships of a size and type adapted
to ocean service. While on July 30, 1914, just before the out­
break of the great war, our seagoing merchant ships of 1,000 gross

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

177

tons or over numbered only 755, of 2,128,731 gross tons, these
vessels of more than 1,000 gross tons number on June 30, 1919,
no fewer than 2,058, of 7,300,022 gross tons, or a net gain of more
than 5,000,000 tons in vessels capable of ocean navigation.
In the sundry civil bill for the fiscal year ended June 30, 1919,
the sum of $62,500 was appropriated for wire-drag launches, in­
cluding their equipment for the Coast and Geodetic Survey. Out
of this appropriation four 6o-foot launches have been built and
equipped and three 30-foot tenders. One 30-foot tender was
purchased.
While these launches have been in commission but a very short
time, they have already demonstrated their efficiency in carrying
on our wire-drag surveys. They are trim vessels, with sufficient
strength to propel the wire drags and yet economical of fuel con­
sumption. They are especially designed for this class of work,
and therefore have the proper amount of space, and in right place,
for storing all the necessary equipment and implements for making
wire-drag surveys. They are far superior to the weaker, lumber­
ing fishing vessels that have been hired heretofore for pulling the
wire drag and which we have been forced to alter in order to
install the wire-drag equipment, reels, engines, etc. With this
demonstrated efficiency and economy that has resulted from the
use of these vessels especially designed for this work, there is the
stronger reason that such vessels should be utilized for carrying
on all our wire-drag surveys. The wire-drag vessels that have
been built for us out of the appropriation for 1919 arc sufficient to
operate two wire-drag parties. There are four regions where the
wire-drag survey only is capable of finding the hidden, under­
water dangers to navigation. These are all along the coast of
New England, and Long Island Sound down to the entrance to New
York Harbor. In this region are found the glacial deposits of
bowlders left beneath the waters bordering the coast. The second
general region is the coast of Florida from Palm Beach southward
around the southern shores and up to the neighborhood of Cedar
Keys. In these waters the coral reefs are dangers to navigation.
Some of these reefs are in the form of small islands, known locally
as keys, while others are entirely submerged and are grave menaces
to navigation. While coral reefs are characteristic of all these
waters, the regions where wire-drag examinations are most
urgently needed are in the vicinity of Key West and to the west­
ward from there and then northward through the channels that
140261—19---- 12

i?8

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

commercial vessels take in and out of the Gulf from Mobile, New
Orleans, etc. The third region where wire-drag surveys are re­
quired is in the coral-infested waters of Porto Rico and the Virgin
Islands. The fourth general region where wire-drag surveys are
required is along the coast and through the passages of south­
eastern Alaska. The danger to be found here is the pinnacle rock,
which is found in the form of a narrow needle-like rock that ex­
tends from a very great depth to very near the surface of the
ocean. Ordinary soundings with the lead and line are of little
avail in finding these pinnacle rocks and, indeed, are often quite
deceptive in that such soundings show a very considerable depth
and give assurance of safety, while danger may be at hand.
Instances are known where the pinnacle rocks come to within a
very short distance of the surface of the water, while soundings
showed depths of hundreds of feet in their immediate neighbor­
hood. There is one other small area where the wire drag should
be used. This is at the Atlantic entrance to the Panama Canal.
The total area in square statute miles of these four general regions
yet to be covered by the wire drag is 54,319.
From this it follows that two wire-drag parties that can be
operated with the modern wire-drag vessels that we now have
can only accomplish a fractional part of the wire-drag work that
remains to be done. In the belief that the remedy should be
applied where the danger is greatest, one of these parties is
operating in Long Island Sound and the other off the coast of
Maine. Wire-drag work can be effectively carried on in these
waters from about the 1st of April until the close of November.
We have acquired from the Navy two fairly large power
launches. While these har e not been built for wire-drag purposes,
we believe that with some alteration they will fairly answer for this
purpose. These will be used in Alaskan waters. The wire drag
requires two power launches, one at each end of the drag. These
launches are too large to be used both on the same drag. A very
efficient drag would be for med by using one of these launches
acquired from the Navy and one of the type of those that have
been built for us out of the appiopiiations for 1919. Therefore
what is needed is four additional 6o-foot launches of the type of
those built out of tire appropriation for 1919. Two of these in
conjunction with the two launches acquired from the Navy would
make up two w'i.e-diag parties for the Alaskan waters, and the
other two would provide a wi. e-drag party for the coast of Florida.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

179

There is more wire-drag work than can be completed by the five
wire-drag parties that would be thus provided within the life­
time of the launches, a period of about 10 years. After that time
the upkeep would be excessive.
Another need of the field sendee of the bureau is an investiga­
tion of the possibilities of the use of the aeroplane in making
topographic surveys and hydrographic examinations, as well as
revision surveys. Aeroplane photographs were used to a very
great extent during the war in locating military features of the
enemy. The same principle can be used in surveying and mapping,
but a large amount of research work will have to be done before
the aeroplane photograph will give the accuracy required of the
highest grade of surveying done by the Coast and Geodetic Survey.
It is a very difficult matter to keep the topographic features up
to date on the 700 charts of the United States Coast and Geodetic
Survey with the old methods, but it is possible in many cases,
and especially in a flat country, to make very rapid revision of the
shore line and adjacent land areas by means of photographs taken
from aeroplanes.
The mapping of the country adjacent to the shores where there
is considerable relief is at present not practicable from the aero­
plane on account of the great amount of work that would be
involved in reducing the photograph to the map. It is believed
that methods will be developed by which this will be done more
expeditiously, and then there will be no limit to the character of
terrain on which the aeroplane can be used for surveying.
It must not be supposed that the aeroplane can entirely super­
sede the usual methods of surveying. We shall still need trian­
gulation and traverse to give the fundamental control for the
work, and much planetable work will have to be done to locate
topographical features which may be used in the control of the
position of the aeroplane photographs. It is also probable that
the planetable will still be the method for placing the contours on
the map. While it is possible to obtain some idea of the relief of
the country from overlapping aeroplane photographs, at the
same time the problem of placing contours accurately on the
map is one which will be difficult to solve. The office expense of
contouring a map from aeroplane photographs will undoubtedly
be greater than by an instrumental party working in the field, if
the contouring is to be of a high grade of accuracy. The most
promising field for surveying and mapping from an aeroplane is

i8 o

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

over flat country, or country with low reliefs, and in revision sur­
veys where the contouring has already been accurately done. The
changing features are shore lines, woods, roads, bridges, etc.
These features can be readily placed on the old map by fitting in
the new features shown on the photograph.
What seems to be most desirable at present is that we should
have a research laboratory connected with the air service of the
Army or the Navy in which various methods and instruments
might be tested. Such a laboratory would preferably be in the
vicinity of Washington, where the Government survey and map­
ping organizations are located.
War Work of the Coast and Geodetic Survey.
The Coast and Geodetic Survey bore an important burden
during the war, both in the field and in the office. All told, 268
men drawn both from the field and the office took part in the war.
These were drawn from all ranks of the employees of the bureau,
ranging from the Superintendent to temporary men employed by
the field parties.
The bureau contributed five of its survey vessels to the fleet
operated by the Navy. One of those vessels, the Surveyor, was
employed on convoy duty to and from Mediterranean ports.
While on one of these trips the convoy was attacked by two Ger­
man submarines, one of which was the famous U-39 which sunk
the Lusitania. The U-39 fired a torpedo which grazed the bow
of the Surveyor and was visible from the deck of that vessel. The
wake of the submarine was picked up by the Surveyor and she was
able to get in a position for favorable discharge of the depth charge.
As the Surveyor was unable to leave the convoy, she was unable to
return and finish the submarine, but did succeed in disabling it to
the extent that the submarine was compelled to enter Cartagena,
Spain, and intern there. Another vessel of the bureau, the Isis,
was on duty at New York as flagship of the commandant of squad­
ron 2, cruiser force, from November 16, 1917, to October 14, 1918,
and was on duty at Yorktown and Hampton Roads as flagship of
division 4, battleship force 1, from October 15, 1918, to April 1,
1919. A third vessel, the Bache, was assigned to squadron 5,
fifth district, and performed general salvage work, outside patrol,
and guardship duty off Virginia Capes. Her primary' duty was
identification and passing of all inbound and outbound vessels.
She was the means of communication between naval authorities
and these vessels. She handled mail, gave medical assistance to

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

1S1

passing vessels, and performed important salvage operations.
Two other vessels of the bureau were assigned to patrol duty in
Alaskan waters. They were the Explorer and the Patterson
(re-named the Forward).
Besides this direct assistance to the military branches of the
Government by the contribution of men and vessels, the Coast and
Geodetic Survey rendered valuable service to both these branches
through its field and office force. In the field, assistance consisted
of furnishing certain control for maps in critical areas selected by
the chief of military mapping of the Corps of Engineers of the
Army. These areas were in Texas, Georgia, Florida, South Caro­
lina, North Carolina, and Virginia. The work was chiefly triangu­
lation, traverse, and leveling. Special hydrographic examina­
tions were made by means of the wire drag at points designated
by the Navy Department. Among such were the wire-drag sur­
veys in Long Island Sound and in York River (Chesapeake Bay).
An extensive wire-drag examination was made of the waters of the
vicinity of Eastport, Me. Besides this, surveys were made for the
location of points for naval fire-control experiments, the reestab­
lishment of the speed trial course at Lewes, Del., for torpedo-boat
destroyers, the location of the Port Jefferson trial course in Long
Island Sound, and the Block Island (R. I.) trial course.
Need for a New Building.
Year after year I have called attention to the need of a modem
and adequate building to house the Coast and Geodetic Survey.
Efficient work can never be done in a building so unsuitable for
the needs of the bureau it houses.
It is physically impossible to bring together under proper super­
vision the different units of the organization. Where artisans, la­
borers, and employees of all kinds are scattered here and there in
small rooms, under insanitary conditions, without proper light and
ventilation, the best of results can not be expected. So acute did
this become during the war, and so essential was the progress of that
bureau to the successful prosecution of the war, that you authorized
the use of $105,000 from your fund for the national security and de­
fense, for the construction of a small building adjoining the present
buildings occupied by the bureau to relieve the congestion. This
building is now completed, and the facilities that it affords only
emphasize the great drawback and handicap under which the bu­
reau is operating in its present old quarters.

STEAMBOAT-INSPECTION SERVICE.
(George UhlER,

S u p e r v is in g I n s p e c to r G e n e r a l .)

Organization.
There were the following positions in the Steamboat-Inspection
Service at the close of business on June 30, 1919:
At Washington, D. C. (central office force):
Supervising Inspector General.......................................................................
Deputy Supervising Inspector General (who is Acting Supervising
Inspector General in the absence of that officer).....................................
Clerks................................................................................................................
Messenger............................
In the Service at large (field force):
Supervising inspectors....................................................................................
Traveling inspectors........................................................................................
Local inspectors of hulls.................................................................................
Local inspectors of boilers..............................................................................
Assistant inspectors of hulls...........................................................................
Assistant inspectors of boilers........................................................................
Clerks to boards of local inspectors................................................................
Total

i
i
io
i

---- 13
u
3
48
48
82
83
97
----- 372
385

Attention is specially directed to the small size of the central
office force.
Sixty-four permanent positions were added to the Service
during the year, as follows:
One supervising inspector at Seattle, Wash., and one traveling
inspector with headquarters in the office of the Supervising
Inspector General.
One clerk in the office of the Supervising Inspector General,
Washington, D. C.
The following assistant inspectors: Two assistant inspectors of
hulls and three assistant inspectors of boilers, San Francisco,
Calif. Two assistant inspectors of hulls and two assistant inspec­
tors of boilers, Cleveland, Ohio. One assistant inspector of hulls
and two assistant inspectors of boilers, Philadelphia, P a.; Seattle,
Wash.; and Portland, Oreg. Two assistant inspectors of hulls
and one assistant inspector of boilers, New York, N. Y. One
assistant inspector of hulls and one assistant inspector of boilers,
Boston, Mass.; Milwaukee, Wis.; Los Angeles, Calif.; New

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

183

London, Conn.; and Portland, Me. One assistant inspector of
hulls, Baltimore, Md.; New Haven, Conn.; and Norfolk, Va.
And one assistant inspector of boilers, Chicago, 111.; Jacksonville,
Fla.; and Toledo, Ohio.
Twenty-four additional clerks were added in the Service at
large.
Summary of Activities and Statistics.
Following is a summary of activities and statistics for the
fiscal year 1919:
The force inspected and certificated 7,407 vessels, with a total
gross tonnage of 11,562,166, of which 7,134 were domestic vessels,
with a total gross tonnage of 9,128,911, and 273 were foreign
passenger steam vessels, with a total gross tonnage of 2,433,255.
Of the domestic vessels there were 5,880 steam vessels, 709 motor
vessels, 17 passenger barges, and 528 seagoing barges. There was
an increase of 392 in the total number of vessels inspected and
an increase of 3,097,470 in the total gross tonnage of vessels
inspected, as compared with the previous fiscal year. Letters of
approval of designs of boilers, engines, and other operating
macliinery were granted to 23 steam vessels, with a total gross
tonnage of 672. There were inspected for the United States
Government 79 hulls and 2,337 boilers. There were 2,053 rein­
spections of passenger and ferry steamers.
Licenses were issued to 28,069 officers of all grades. There
were examined for visual defects 9,753 applicants for license, of
whom 108 were found color blind or with other visual defects
and rejected. Certificates of service were issued to 8,796 able
seamen, and 760 were rejected. Certificates of efficiency were
issued to 3,910 lifeboat men, and 344 were rejected.
Steel plates for the construction of marine boilers to the num­
ber of 35,427 were inspected at the mills, and a large amount of
other boiler material was inspected. There were examined and
tested 435,337 new life preservers, of which number 8,311 were
rejected.
The total number of accidents resulting in loss of life was 194.
The total number of lives lost was 543, of which 202 were passen­
gers. Of the lives lost, 170 were from suicide, accidental drown­
ing, and other causes beyond the power of the Service to prevent,
leaving a loss of 373 as fairly chargeable to accidents, colli lions,
iounderings, etc. There was an increase of 43 in the number of
fives lost, as compared with the previous fiscal year. Passengers

184

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

to the number of 323,317,657 were carried on vessels required by
law to make report of the number of passengers carried. Divid­
ing this number by 202, the total number of passengers lost,
shows that 1,600,582 passengers were carried for each passenger
lost. The number of lives directly saved by means of the life­
saving appliances required by law was 2,349.
Reconstruction.
One of the great problems to which the Nation must give its
attention is that of transportation, and, so far as transportation
by water is concerned, the Steamboat-Inspection Service must
necessarily have an important part, because vessels of the American
merchant marine are subject to the inspection of that Service.
Therefore, if there can be any improvements made in the methods
of administration, those improvements should be made now, so
that the American merchant marine may not only be placed in the
first rank of all the nations but that it may remain there. There
will be briefly discussed the proposition of an improvement to be
made in the approval of hull and boiler construction, the question
of the licensing of men, and changes that should be made in the
law with reference to boiler pressures.
Centralization of Approval of Hull and Boiler Construction.
It is important at this time to improve the methods of the
approval of hull construction. This could be accomplished by
creating in the office of the Supervising Inspector General a corps
of experts, whose business it would be to examine and pass upon
blue prints and specifications submitted by persons purposing to
build ships. When approved, the blue prints would be referred
to the respective boards of local inspectors in whose district the
vessel or vessels were to be built. The inspectors’ duty would be
to see that they were built in accordance with the blue prints.
The result of this procedure would be to standardize in a large
measure hull construction and hull inspection.
Although the regulation adopted by the Board of Supervising
Inspectors in regard to the stability of vessels provides that when
inspectors have any reason to question the stability of any vessel
under their jurisdiction they shall require the owners of the vessel
to make inclining tests on such vessel under the supervision of
expert naval architects provided by this Department, the Service
does not discover the condition until after the vessel is navigated
and until after the risk has been assumed by those who travel

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

185

upon the ship. It is proposed, therefore, to have enacted by the
Board of Supervising Inspectors, without delay, a rule that will
require a stability test of all vessels that are built, the tests to be
conducted under the direction of naval architects provided by this
Department. While this is a narrower proposition than that of
the creation of a board of naval architects working under the direc­
tion of the Supervising Inspector General, it is one that will meet
and possibly control the situation until proper action can be taken
to provide for the corps of naval architects.
It is also quite as necessary that boiler construction should be
approved in the office of the Supervising Inspector General by a
corps of expert engineers in the same manner as hull construction.
It will be clear that, in order to have that uniform administran of the law with reference to the approval of hull and boiler
onstruction, with which the Supervising Inspector General is
charged, there must be centralized authority.
Examination of Applicants for Licenses.
It has been suggested to the Steamboat-Inspection Service
that, if uniform methods were used in examining applicants, a
better class of licensed officers would be obtained, and that the
procedure of the Civil Service Commission should be followed, so
fixing one general practice in this respect. On the other hand, it
may be stated that the United States covers a vast expanse of
territory, representing many varied local conditions, and it is felt
that, in the matter of examining applicants, the local inspectors
are better informed than any central authority could ever be.
Furthermore, there would be considerable congestion in connection
with obtaining licensed officers for the ships. These men do not
come for examination once or twice a month, but usually every
day, and the local inspectors adjust their business so as to examine
them when they appear. As a result, the Service has been able
under war conditions to obtain licensed officers for the rapidly
increasing number of ships.
Boiler Pressure.
The rules of the Steamboat-Inspection Service are not up to
date with reference to boiler pressures, proper credit is not given
for the riveting plan above double riveting, and improvements
can be made with reference to hydrostatic pressure. The Service,
therefore, caused to be drafted a bill looking to the amendment
of sections 4433 and 4418, Revised Statutes. That bill is Senate
bill 574.

i86

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The purposes of the proposed amendments in section 4433,
Revised Statutes, are, first, to do away with the obsolete rule
contained in the law, prescribing a working steam pressure for
single-riveted joints, without taking into consideration the per­
centage strength of the riveted joint, and allowing 20 per cent
additional pressure for double-riveted joints, but not allowing a
greater working pressure for triple-riveted and quadruple-riveted,
etc., lap and butt joints. For these, greater working pressure
should be allowed on account of the greater strength of the tripleriveted and other similar joints.
This greater allowable working pressure for the stronger forms
of riveted joints has for years been desired by boiler users.
The present law furnishes no incentive for building boilers
with stronger kinds of joints than double-riveted joints that will
carry a greater working pressure with but slight increase in the
amount of material required for boiler shell.
Further, by placing the authority to prescribe rules for working
pressure on boilers with the Board of Supervising Inspectors,
with the approval of the Secretary of Commerce, that board will
prescribe rules that will meet the various conditions of boiler
construction, taking into consideration the percentage strength
of the various kinds of riveted joints.
Rules for calking would be prescribed by the Board of Super­
vising Inspectors in connection with rules for riveted joints.
The purpose of the amendments in section 4418, Revised Stat­
utes, is in order to leave with the Board of Supervising Inspectors
the authority of determining the hydrostatic test in connection
with the rules for riveting that would be adopted by the board
and approved by the Secretary of Commerce.
The proposition of giving the Board of Supervising Inspectors
the authority to make modern its rules with reference to boiler
pressures is consistent with the whole theory of reconstruction.
It is absolutely necessary that it be adopted, in order that the
rehabilitation of the American merchant marine may go forward
without delay.
Civil Service for the Supervising Inspectors.
The supervising inspectors of the Steamboat-Inspection Service
are not under the classified civil service. They are all presi­
dential appointees. They should be under the classified civil
service. Quite generally the supervising inspectors are men who

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

187

have been promoted from the position of local inspector. When
they come from the position of local inspector, they come out of
the classified civil service, and they should be given the same
protection under the classified civil service when they become a
supervising inspector. At every presidential election there is
a feeling of uneasiness and uncertainty as to what the future of
the supervising inspectors will be. That condition ought not to
exist, and, looking to increased efficiency in the SteamboatInspection Service, I urgently recommend that this important
branch of that Service be placed under the classified civil service.

BUREAU OF NAVIGATION.
(E u g e n e T y l e r C h a m b e r l a in , Com m issioner.)

American shipping registered for the foreign trade and enrolled
and licensed for the coasting trade, including the fisheries, on
June 30, 1919, comprised 27,513 vessels of 12,907,300 gross tons,
compared with 26,711 vessels of 9,924,518 gross tons on June 30,
1918, an increase of 802 vessels and 2,982,782 gross tons. The
following statement shows the total of our tonnage at the close
of each of the past six fiscal years and indicates the great changes
which have taken place within that period:
C o a s tin g t r a d e .
J u n e 30—

F o r e ig n
tra d e .

T o t a l.
G reat
L akes.

Sea and
r iv e r s .

1 9 1 4 ...............................................................................................................................................

* » 0 7 6 ,1 5 2

2 ,8 8 2 ,9 2 2

3 .9 6 9 ,6 1 4

7 ,9 2 8 ,6 8 8

* 9 * 5 ...............................................................................................................................................

1 .8 7 1 ,5 4 3

2 ,8 1 8 ,0 0 0

3 ,6 9 9 ,8 8 6

8 ,3 8 9 ,4 7 9

1 9 x 6 ................................................................................................................................................

2 , 1 9 1 , 7*5

2 ,7 6 0 ,8 1 s

3 , s * 7 ,* * 9

8 ,4 6 9 ,6 4 9

* 9 * 7 ................................................................................................................................................

7 ,4 4 6 ,3 9 9

2 ,7 6 9 .8 2 4

3 ,6 5 4 ,8 1 4

8 ,8 7 1 ,0 3 7

3 1 6 0 3 ,7 0 6

2 ,7 0 8 ,5 2 3

3 ,6 1 2 ,2 8 9

9 ,9 7 4 ,5 1 8

6 ,6 6 9 ,7 2 6

3 ,6 3 5 .6 8 0

3 ,6 0 1 ,8 9 4

* 2 ,9 0 7 ,3 0 0

These figures show for the dates named the gross tonnage of
ships registered, enrolled, or licensed; but they must not be
taken unqualifiedly as the evidence of commercial growth. Of
the total tonnage 3,827,201 gross tons were vessels over 1,000 tons
owned by the Shipping Board and represent appropriations by
Congress and the sacrifices made by the American people to win
the war. The figure just stated does not fully represent the
extent of the Government’s ownership in ocean carrying, for
on June 30, 1919, the War and Navy Departments were operating
mainly as troop transports 405,021 gross tons of ships, including
most of the former German merchant ships seized in American
harbors. These ships are not under register or enrollment on
account of their temporary employment, but in any adequate
statement of our maritime resources should be added to the
3,827,201 gross tons of Shipping Board ships.
Since 1914, as during the Napoleonic wars, American ships
have appeared in large numbers in ports all over the world. Of the
188

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

189

total increase in our shipping since June 30, 1914, almost 5,000,000
gross tons, nearly all has consisted of ocean-going steel steamers
of 1,000 gross tons or over, of which on June 30, 1914, we had 429
of 1,589,733 gross tons and on June 30, 1919, 1,436 of 6,072,901
gross tons. Though effected by war causes, this growth is in the
direction of normal mercantile-marine development. The increase,
on the other hand, in wooden seagoing steamers of over 1,000
gross tons from 8 of 10,595 gross tons on June 30, 1914, to 293 of
693,541 gross tons on June 30, 1919, is to be counted in large
measure as among our sacrificial efforts to win the war.
The vessels built in the United States and documented as
vessels of the United States during the fiscal year numbered
1,953 of 3,326,621 gross tons, compared with 1,528 of 1,300,868
gross tons during the previous fiscal year. The standard by
which the output of the United States should be measured is
that of the rest of the world during prewar years. During the
calendar year 1913, the year of the greatest prewar output,
Lloyd’s returns show a total of 1,932,153 gross tons launched in
the United Kingdom, her greatest output, and 1,124,276 gross
tons launched by the rest of the world, excluding the United
States, a grand total of 3,056,429 gross tons. During that year
the United States launched 276,448 gross tons. In a word, the
people of the United States, mainly through war loans and war
taxes, have expanded the shipbuilding industry until in tonnage
output it has equaled the world’s former annual commercial
output of shipping. It is quite evident that this great industry
can be maintained only if it is in a position to meet not merely
the requirements for new tonnage of American shipowners, but
also the requirements of shipowners of other nations less favor­
ably placed by natural causes and legislative support than are
we for shipbuilding.
World’s Tonnage.
The world’s merchant tonnage is larger now than at any other
time in history. Lloyd’s Register for 1914 stated the world’s
total tonnage (vessels over 100 gross tons) at 49,089,000 gross
tons, and the same authority for 1919 gives the world’s total
as 50,919,000.
A comparison of the volume of tonnage will be seriously mis­
leading unless the quality of the tonnage also is considered when
estimating the work it can now' perform. About two-thirds of the
tonnage now afloat was built before the war and has undergone

190

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

not merely five years of ordinary wear and tear, but, in addition,
the strain of constant service, with limited repairs hastily made.
Furthermore, submarine warfare was directed against the best
types of passenger ships, and the loss of ocean liners was especially
heavy. This has been partly, not wholly, made good by the
transfer of the former German passenger fleet to the flags of the
maritime powers. The repair and restoration to a fair measure
of usefulness of the ships built before the war has been undertaken,
but it has involved temporary withdrawal of considerable tonnage.
The ships built during the war, taken as a whole, are inferior
to the ships built before the war. This statement involves no
reflection upon shipbuilders and shipowners. Indeed, they have
had much less authority than usual over the plans or methods of
ship construction, Government here and abroad having assumed
virtually entire control over the building and operation of ships.
The aim of Government generally has been to turn out the greatest
volume of tonnage in the shortest possible time. The average
speed of ships built during the war was below the average of pre­
war construction. Very few passenger ships were built, and the
urgent need for engines involved the building of cargo boats
slower on the average than those building in 1914. The aver­
age size of ships was also smaller, because many of the yards
formerly engaged in building larger ships were employed dur­
ing the war on naval construction, and many of the new yards
hastily established could turn out only smaller ones. Finally,
hurried workmanship by labor in process of training can not be
expected to produce the best results. The new oil-burning ships
have, however, plain advantages in many trades over coalburning ships.
These factors in the situation, though not easy to reduce to
mathematical form, must be weighed in drawing conclusions from
a comparison of the world’s total tonnage now and before the war.
A true guide for present purposes would be a statement of the
tonnage clearances of shipping in the world’s foreign trade by
sea, but such a statement is not now available.
The total clearances with cargo, however, from the ports of the
United Kingdom for ports in foreign countries (excluding Ger­
many) and British possessions during the seven months ended
July 31, 1919, were 19,286,256 net tons, compared with 13,114,208
net tons for the corresponding period in 1918 and 36,261,475 net
tons for the corresponding period in 1914. The tonnage clearances

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

191

from the United States for Europe, Asia, Australia, Afr'ca, and
South America for several fiscal years are at hand, stated in net
tons (each of 100 cubic feet of closed in ship space). The following
table shows the shipping actually available and employed for
cargo and passengers clearing in overseas trade from the United
States during the fiscal year ended June 30, 1914, the year of our
greatest clearances before the war, during the year ended June 30,
1918, and the year ended June 30, 1919:
For—

T o t a l.............................................................................................

1914

19 18

1 9 X9

1 6 ,4 3 1 ,1 2 3

l6 ,I 4 4 ,I l8

* 4 ,2 6 3 ,5 4 7

2 »4 2 9 . 6 5 9

2, « 7 . 976

2 ,7 0 5 ,3 6 s

1 , 9 9 0 ,1 0 5

2 , 0 9 5 ,3 2 4

2 , 5 2 9 ,9 9 8

4 0 6 ,4 s 7

2 3 5 ,6 4 9

2 0 , 9 7 0 ,3 3 9

1 8 , 8 3 2 ,4 9 6

393,97 >

2 2 ,0 0 0 ,4 5 7

From the clearances for Europe are excluded those for Ger­
many, of which in 1918 there wrere none and in 1919 only 9,734
net tons, but 3,902,073 net tons in 1914. The figures for 1918
and 1919, however, do not include the shipping employed in
transporting troops and our munitions of war, which greatly ex­
ceeded the tonnage clearances in previous times for Germany.
In ordinary times, on account of the greater bulk of our ex­
ports, ships usually clear from the United States with ample
cargoes, while many enter in ballast or with part cargoes. In
1914, for example, 15 per cent of the shipping from Europe en­
tered the United States in ballast, and at the present time the
proportion is much greater, though the precise figures are not at
hand. To a greater extent than usual, accordingly, foreign con­
sumers must pay high freights on their imports from the United
States, for those freights must often cover the charges of the
voyage in ballast to America. Evidently such conditions can
not long continue.
So far as the production of shipping to meet the situation is
concerned, good progress is shown by Lloyd’s report that on June
30, 1919, the merchant ships under construction in the world’s
yards aggregated 8,017,767 gross tons, of which 3,874,143 gross
tons were building in the United States and 2,324,050 in the
United Kingdom. The largest tonnage building under prewar
returns was 3,445,000 gross tons reported by Lloyd s for June 30,
1913-

192

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The growing share of American shipping in the overseas trade
of the United States is shown by the following statement of the
net tonnage of clearances of American ships for overseas during
the fiscal years ended June 30, 1914, 1918, and 1919:
For—

T o tal........................................................................................................

1914

1918

4 3 9 »261

1,671,081

1 9 2 ,4 7 9

100,833
4,263

823,354
287,386
49,460

7 3 6 ,8 3 6

2,831,281

1919
2,535,265
X,290,248
4 9 4 ,548

99,034
4,419,095

As in the preceding statement of total net-tonnage clearances
(which included American), these figures do not include Ger­
many, to which in 1914 the American clearances amounted to
8,406 net tons, none in 1918, and 9,734 net tons in 1919.
The net tonnage of many merchant ships converted into Army
transports are not included in the figures above.
Main Maritime Facts.
The main facts in the general maritime situation at this time
are as follows:
1. The world’s merchant tonnage is the largest in history, but
its average efficiency is below that of 1914 for inherent reasons
in construction and for extraneous reasons such as port conges­
tions, labor troubles, and management. The world’s net gain in
steam tonnage is 2,500,000 gross tons, the gain of the United
States 7,600,000 gross tons, the loss of the rest of the world
5,100,000 gross tons.
2. The merchant tonnage now' under construction is more than
double the prewar output and is of increasing efficiency in the
main.
3. The volume of the world’s ocean-borne commerce is less than
in normal times and will continue less until industrial and agri­
cultural Europe has more fully recovered from the effects of the
war.
The proportion exports to Europe bear to the world’s total
sea-borne commerce is above the average, involving high oceanfreight rates.
Our maritime situation, mainly as the result of expenditures
authorized by Congress equal to the book value of the whole
world’s merchant fleets in 1914, is as follows:

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

193

1. Our seagoing steel steam tonnage (ships of over i ,ooo gross
tons) on June 30, 1919, was over 6,000,000 gross tons, four times
greater than in 1914, and is increasing at the rate of over 350,000
gross tons a month, equaling our best annual outputs before the
war.
2. The annual output of our shipyards exceeds the greatest
annual output of the world’s shipyards before 1914.
3. Steel-ship building plants have been extended or established
with new machinery, methods, housing, and transit accommoda­
tions equal, and in some respects superior, to those abroad.
4. American tonnage clearing in overseas trade in the fiscal year
1919 was six times greater than in 1914.
Maritime Problem.
The maritime problem now before the United States is more
difficult than in former years, because we have created with public
funds a vast war plant of ships and shipyards which must be read­
justed to the requirements of commerce.
Few will contend that shipbuilding and ship operation can be
successfully maintained and developed in this country if Govern­
ment is to furnish the funds and almost exclusively control both,
as for the past two years. The question of raising the money by
loans and taxes for the purpose is not for the moment in mind,
though evidently there is a limit to that not far off in time. The
building and operation of ships are two forms of industrial activity
which least of all admit of monopoly or combination. The ocean
is free to those who wish to navigate it. The most ingenious legis­
lative devices, even in war times, have not restricted the individual
of any country, except an enemy, from purchasing ships where he
chooses and operating them. Limitations may be prescribed and
obstacles erected, but these confirm the essentially competitive
nature of shipbuilding and shipowning. These occupations ac­
cordingly offer some of the best fields for individual skill, appli­
cation, enterprise, and foresight and the least advantageous
fields for a system of Government ownership and management in
which the qualities named are more likely to be stunted than
developed.
It seems clear, therefore, that the restoration of our maritime
affairs to individual control and operation is desirable for the
healthy development of our national life. The sooner this action
is taken the better for the future of the industries, because the
next two years bid fair to be the crucial years in commercial mari140261— 19----- 13

194

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

time development. By that time it is reasonably safe to presume
that the world’s ocean-borne trade will be conducted on terms of
the closest and, it may be hoped, the fairest competition.
American shipyards, accordingly, should be allowed to build
freely for all comers, and in the long run they will gain by the
withdrawal on equitable terms of Government contracts and the
substitution therefor of private contracts. We already have steelship building plants nearly all of which are equal to and many
superior to the older plants of other countries. The past two
years have developed hundreds of thousands of shipbuilders who
numbered only tens of thousands before the war. The supremacy
of our steel industry is unchallenged. The same general principles
should be considered in relation to the fleet afloat, the ships in
operation or launched. Every interest suggests that these ships
be disposed of to men trained to the most effective and economical
operation of ships. The industrial and commercial situation of
the world is too uncertain to warrant experiments in the operation
of ships which might be inviting in times of general prosperity.
There will doubtless be opportunity, and probably necessity, for
some lines operated either partially or indirectly by the Govern­
ment in which to provide an outlet for our commerce to points
that can not be profitably reached by private enterprise until
commerce with them shall have been developed. Our ocean fleet
is the servant of our trade, and where that trade can not be served
effectively by private enterprise the Nation, through the Govern­
ment, must do its part in opening the way in which our commerce
is to flow. There is room, therefore, in the ocean trade for full
and free opportunity for private enterprise and for the helping
hand of the Government to meet special conditions in order that
our commerce and industries shall by both be adequately served.
Subdivision of Hulls.
The recommendations of the International Conference on
Safety of Life at Sea, in so far as they relate to the subdivision of
hulls and other structural details of ocean passenger ships, have
been held in abeyance during the war, although British transAtlantic passenger ships have been built during the period in
voluntary compliance with those recommendations. Although
during the war we confined our efforts to building cargo ships,
we must now include ocean passenger ships, and the recommenda­
tions of the conference and experience gained from the past five
years should be considered in making plans for such ships. The

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

195

subject called for prompt action, and I have accordingly requested
the American members of the construction committee at the
international conference to recommend a course of action and
the administrative machinery required. These gentlemen—
Rear Admiral W. U. Capps, U. S. Navy; Mr. Homer L. Ferguson,
president of the Newport News Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Co. and
of the Chamber of Commerce of the United States; and Mr. Alfred
Gilbert Smith, president of the New York & Cuba Mail S. S. Co.—
are of acknowledged standing and authority. It will undoubtedly
be desirable to provide for a small technical staff to be permanently
attached to the Department of Commerce to consider questions
of the construction of passenger ships, whether the conference
regulations or modifications of them be adopted.
Shipping Commissioners.
During the year 485,796 officers and men have been shipped
and discharged, included repeated shipments and discharges, by
United States shipping commissioners, compared with 457,248 for
1918 and 506,941 during 1917. Collectors of customs acting as
shipping commissioners at ports where those officers are not estab­
lished shipped and discharged last year 37,978 men, compared
with 35,131 for the previous fiscal year and 18,439 for the fiscal
year 1917. The great increase in American shipping in foreign
trade is not reflected in these figures, because during the wrar our
ships were manned to a great extent by men in the Navy. These
naval crews are being discharged and merchant crews provided,
as contemplated by law, for merchant ships. The work of ship­
ping commissioners is increasing, especially at the principal sea­
ports, and it has been necessary to submit deficiency estimates to
cover this increase.
Navigation Receipts.
The receipts from tonnage duties during the fiscal year amounted
to $1,265,229.23 (including $2,041.98 Philippine Islands fund and
$5,028.50 alien and penal tonnage duties and light money). The
total is $93,810.87 greater than for the previous fiscal year. The
largest annual receipts from tonnage duties were $1,454,565.83
for the year ended June 30, 1916, and during the current fiscal
year receipts from this source should become normal and ap­
proach that amount.
Receipts from navigation fees amounted to $143,492.19, com­
pared with $146,508.02 for the previous year. The receipts from

1 96

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

navigation fines and penalties amounted to $162,146.50, compared
with $32,097.68 for the previous year. The increase is almost
wholly due to the forfeiture of the steamer Sacramento. This ship
was a former German ship which by fraud secured an American
register at San Francisco and forthwith under German direction
proceeded with supplies to the squadron of Admiral von Spee, off
the Juan Fernandez Islands, thus enabling that squadron to sail
to its destruction off the Falklands. The steamer Sacramento was
decreed forfeited and the forfeiture compromised for $250,000, of
which $125,000 was paid last year, and the balance is to be paid
during the current fiscal year.
The total navigation receipts for the year thus have been
$1,570,867.92, compared with $1,351,492.66 for the previous fiscal
year. It may be noted that the appropriations by Congress for
all branches of the Navigation Bureau amounted to $217,045.
Radio Communication.
Under the Executive order of April 30, 1917, “ to insure the
proper conduct of the war against the Imperial German Govern­
ment and the successful termination thereof ” coast radio stations
were operated by the Navy Department or closed, and the order
is still in force, pending ratification of the treaty of peace. The
Navy Department continued the supervision of the allotment of
radio apparatus to ship and shore stations and supplied naval
radio operators to many ships. The regular force of radio in­
spectors of the Bureau of Navigation continued to serve with
our armed forces ashore and afloat, and I am pleased to add that
the value of their services in many instances has been recognized
by our Government and the Governments of the allies by pro­
motion and by the award of decorations. Many of our force
have now been honorably discharged from the Army or Navy
and with a few exceptions have returned to the bureau.
During the past year the bureau’s Radio Service made 4,243
inspections on ships subject to the radio ship act, compared with
4,341 similar inspections during the previous fiscal year and, in
addition, 917 inspections of the apparatus on ships voluntarily
equipped. The inspections developed 425 cases of apparatus
more or less defective or of inadequate complement of radio
operators.
The inspection of ship apparatus was of the first importance
for security, particularly during hostilities. It was not possible
with the force available to make the critical examination of

REPORT OP THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

197

apparatus preliminary to the issue of licenses to ship stations
under the act to regulate radio communication and the treaty
to which it gives effect. Only 250 ship stations were thus fully
examined, but, in addition, provisional licenses were issued to
1,196 ship stations. In some instances the apparatus for these
stations was furnished by the Navy Department and was at
times necessarily incomplete or imperfect. In addition, 866 ships
are equipped with wireless apparatus, requiring licenses which it
has not been practicable to issue even provisionally.
This branch of the work is very much in arrears, and the laws
can be carried out only by a considerable increase in the inspec­
tion force for which a deficiency estimate has been submitted to
Congress. On July i, 1915, only 897 American ships were
equipped with apparatus for radio communication, while on
July 1, 1919, the number was 2,312. Meanwhile the appropria­
tion for the maintenance of the wireless-inspection service in all
its branches has remained $45,000. With the coming of peace
it will be necessary not only to overcome the arrears, but to
provide for regularly continuing inspection, which soon will
involve three times the number of American ships subject thereto
in 1915.
The total number of examinations of applicants for radio oper­
ator’s license was 2,729. One thousand one hundred and twentyfour passed the examinations and received operator’s licenses. In
addition, the licenses of 579 operators were renewed. After years
of effort, the Bureau of Navigation has secured for its license to
radio operators a reputation in the technical world so that the
license is sought for as an evidence of proficiency by foreign
operators, as well as by our own. The bureau decided not to
lower the standard of its examination and license, but to meet
emergencies due to the shortage of radio operators by authorizing
inspectors to allow operators with some experience, but unable
to pass the examination, to go to sea under a temporary permit.
At the end of the fiscal year June 30, 1919, there were outstanding
48 commercial extra first-operators’ licenses, 2,436 commercial
first licenses, and 610 commercial second licenses, in all 3,094
operators, a number insufficient even if all were fully employed
all the time to fully man the 2,312 American ships equipped with
radio apparatus on June 30, 1919. The deficiency, however, is
being partly overcome by the radio inspectors, who are instructed
to give special attention to the examination of operators.

198

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

The examination and license of amateur operators and stations
ceased in April, 1917. The amateur field has recently again
been opened.
The volume of radio inspection will thus be very much greater
than it was before the war; furthermore, the commercial radio
equipment of the near future will differ in many respects from that
of the past because of the improvements, developments, and
inventions resulting from the intensified use of radio communica­
tion during the war. More flexible and efficient equipment will
come into use, including the radio telephone. The invention and
improvement of directional radio apparatus by which position
may lie determined, to a great extent the result of investigations
by an expert in the Bureau of »Standards, this Department, have
a special and obvious value at sea. Improvements in the tuning
of apparatus permit a greatly increased amount of traffic. Radio
telegraphy in certain localities where the maintenance of wire
lines is impossible for physical reasons or prohibited on account
of cost must hereafter be reckoned with. The wonderful ad­
vances in aerial navigation with the use of wireless for communi­
cation between ships in the air and stations on the earth intro­
duces another complication.
The subject of the scientific development of radio communica­
tion during the war is too technical and complicated to be set
forth in detail in this report. It is mentioned as showing that
operators hereafter must have a broader theoretical training and
a more accurate knowledge of the radio art than hitherto, the
standards of the inspection service and the scientific qualifications
of the inspectors must be advanced. These considerations have
led the Department to ask for a deficiency appropriation of
$55,000 to meet conditions and requirements when radio com­
munication resumes its normal place as an instrument of com­
mercial communication.
International Radiotélégraphie Conference.
The developments in radio communication and the great
improvement in transoceanic radio communication point to the
need of a revision of the International Radiotélégraphie Con­
vention of 1912, to which the United States is signatory. The
International Radiotélégraphie Conference adjourned at London
with the understanding that the next conference should be held
in 1917. The war made that impossible, but all are agreed that
the conference should be held as early as possible in 1920, and
Congress will be asked to provide for American representation.

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

199

Load Line, Measurement, Bulkheads.
The necessity for legislation to provide for load lines on cargo
vessels has been referred to in my former reports. A bill (S. 575;
H. R. 3621) embodying the views of this Department has been
favorably reported to the Senate and the House of Representa­
tives. The bill enables the Secretary of Commerce to avail himself
of the facilities afforded by the American Bureau of Shipping and
gives that useful organization an official status, establishing rela­
tions between our Government and the American bureau similar
to those between the British Government and Lloyd’s Society.
To give effect to the legislation, several high-grade technical
experts will be needed in the Department of Commerce, and at
some ports it will be necessary to provide officers competent to
make the surveys preliminary to the establishment of load line's
in the case of ships which are not classed by the American bureau
or by other classification societies. The estimates to give effect
to the load-line bill, if enacted, are being prepared.
In my report for 1917 mention was made of the need for creating
in seaboard and Great Lakes shipbuilding districts a small corps of
men trained to the accurate measurement of ship tonnage instead
of relying upon the detail of customs inspectors. This matter has
not been pressed during the war. Hundreds of ships have been
built in this period from a few sets of plans supplied by the Govern­
ment simplifying the work of measurement. When one ship of a
certain type had been carefully measured, it was necessary merely
to send blue prints and results for their guidance to customs officers
in districts where other ships of the same type and dimensions were
under construction. In normal times many ships are built with
regard to the particular trades in which they are to engage. This
is the only way in which the fullest use can be secured from them
and is necessary to success in the highly competitive business of
shipping in foreign trade. In time we shall return to normal
conditions. The Department of Commerce will then require a
force of measurers of ships. Legislation and the estimates to give
it effect await surer signs of the return to normal conditions in
shipbuilding than are now in sight.
With the return of normal conditions it will be necessary also to
give closer attention to bulkheads and other important details of
construction.
Here, too, any intelligent action by the Government will require
a small technical staff in the Department of Commerce and officers

200

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

at certain seaports capable of giving effect understandinglv to its
recommendations and conclusions.
The three subjects load line, measurement, and bulkheads in­
volve considerations of the safety of the ship and those on board
which are paramount. They involve also issues of commercial
competition on equal and fair terms. For both reasons it is
plainly desk able that there should be substantial accord between
the maritime powers in their legislation and administrative meas­
ures. Again, conditions at present are too iemote from normal
to warrant the suggestion of early and formal meetings of the
maritime representatives of those powers to consider measures to
effect such accord. It is not, however, too early to begin those
informal conversations which necessarily must go before more
formal action, and the Bureau of Navigation has the general
subject under consideration.
Enforcement of Navigation Laws.
During the year 1919 the various services of the Bureau of
Navigation reported 8,172 violations of the Navigation Laws, the
largest number acted upon by this Department since its creation.
These violations resulted in the collection of $162,146.50 as fines,
the largest amount collected from this source at least during the
last 25 years, due mainly to the collection of a single penalty of
$125,000 in the case before described.
The work of enforcing the law was performed through the offices
of the collectors of customs, navigation inspectors, Steamboat-In­
spection Service, and the Department’s inspection boats. In ad­
dition to these, 56 owners of motor boats, most of them members
of the United States power squadron, tendered their services and
boats on Sundays and holidays at $1 per year.
During 1919 there were 11,071 counts of passengers going on ex­
cursion steamers aggregating 7,783,791 passengers, as compared
with 4,916,772 passengeis for the previous year. Of this number
the navigation inspectors made 7,380 counts of 6,250,948 pas­
sengers.
O11 408 occasions it was found necessary to prevent more pas­
sengers going on board vessels. This involved the safety of
186,307 passengers. The navigation inspectors are employed only
during the months of June, July, and August. While not count­
ing passengers they are employed in the general enforcement of
the navigation laws, especially those relating to motor boats.
During the fiscal year passenger ships on 314 voyages brought
55,603 steerage passengers to the United States, compared with

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

201

67,988 such passengers in 1918, 147,493 passengers in 19x7, 154,057
in 1916, 211,057 in 1915.
Motor Boats.
The general resumption of the use of motor boats has extended
the usefulness of our inspection vessels in safeguarding the lives
of those using them.
The act of June 7, 1918, requiring the numbering of undocu­
mented motor boats went into effect December 7, 1918, and is
quite generally complied with, especially in those sections where
we have facilities for the enforcement of the law. Up to July 1
of this year there had been numbered 91,916 motorboats. It is
estimated that there are approximately 250,000 motor boats in
the United .States, perhaps 200,000 of which are subject to this
law. For its enforcement it is essential that the Department
should have additional facilities.
There have been turned over to us by the Navy Department
two small motor boats used by them during the war as station
patrols which are especially adapted to our service. The House
Committee on Appropriations has included in the deficiency bill
for 1920 a provision which will enable us to place these vessels in
operation about the first of March and continue their use during
the balance of the fiscal year. We wall thus be able to cover with
our five vessels the Atlantic and Gulf coasts, Mississippi River
and tributaries, and place one vessel on the Great Lakes.
The inspection forces of the Bureau of Navigation are cooper­
ating with the Internal Revenue Bureau in the collection of taxes
imposed on the use and business of motor boats. The revenue
derived from the work of these inspection boats of the Depart­
ment in the collection of taxes and navigation fines should be
greatly in excess of their cost of operation.

CONCLUSION.
Need for a Unified Government Commercial Organization.
Section 3 of the organic act of February 14, 1903 (32 Stat., 825),
provides as follows :
It shall be the province and duty of said Department to foster, promote, and develop
the foreign and domestic commerce, the mining, manufacturing, shipping, and
fishery industries, the labor interests, and the transportation facilities of the United
States; and to this end it shall be vested with jurisdiction and control of the depart­
ments, bureaus, offices, and branches of the public service hereinafter specified, and
with such other powers and duties as may be prescribed by law .

So much of the foregoing as relates to labor interests is super­
seded by the organic act creating the Department of Labor.
The balance remains in full force and vigor. There is no other
department of the Government charged by law with the broad
duty to foster, promote, and develop the foreign and domestic
commerce, etc., of the United .States. It is assumed that this law
was meant to be taken seriously; that the duties imposed by it
upon the Department of Commerce were real duties; and that it
should have the authority and the responsibility of performing
them. It is, perhaps, not too much to assume that the Depart­
ment of Commerce was, within the sphere which is above out­
lined, intended to have the same authority and influence that the
Treasury Department has in finance, the War and Navy Depart­
ments in their respective fields of military effort, the Agriculture
Department in the field of agriculture, the Department of State
in diplomacy, and, indeed, each of the other executive depart­
ments within its lawful field.
Such is, however, not the case. Other bodies exist who per­
form in whole or in part the duty charged by law upon the Depart­
ment of Commerce. In writing frankly of the actual situation it
should be premised that the matter is not discussed in any spirit
of complaint, nor is there any thought of criticism of persons or of
specific bodies. The subject under review is a matter of organiza­
tion, and the question being discussed is whether our present
organization is fitted to cope effectively with the serious com­
mercial problems that face the country.
Any review of the commercial work of the Government must
show that the absence of organization is its most conspicuous
202

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

203

feature. There is an excess of organizations; too little system.
Numerous bodies exist, functioning more or less in the same field
or with direct action therein, each independent, without coordina­
tion, without liaison, without the obligation on the part of any of
them to inform the others. In short, there exists in our public
commercial organization very much the same condition that
existed in the allied armies before unity of command was secured.
It would not be questioned that before that time the commanders
of the allied and associated forces were sincere, competent, and
devoted men. Each, in his own separate sphere, was doing his
best and trying to support his allies as fully as he could. The
difficulty was, of course, that the spheres were separate. Just so
it is in our Government commercial organization. Different
bodies, composed of able and earnest men, function separately on
commercial subjects at home and abroad, without mutual plan,
without frequent consultation, and often in entire ignorance of
what the others are doing.
The War Finance Corporation is given authority to furnish
credits to the extent of a billion dollars “ in order to promote
commerce with foreign nations. ” There is no doubt this function
will be performed by them wisely and well, so far as the law
permits; but there is no obligation to coordinate their work with
that of the Department of Commerce, although this last is charged
to “ foster, promote, and develop the foreign and domestic com­
merce” of the country. The management of the War Finance
Corporation has shown marked courtesy to the Department of
Commerce, but there exists no close cooperation.
The Federal Reserve Board admirably performs a function of
vital importance to our commerce and finance. One can only
speak of it in terms of approval and admiration, but, so far as
the Department of Commerce is concerned, it functions separately,
without obligation of either consultation or of cooperation.
The Interstate Commerce Commission performs functions of
high value in our domestic and foreign commercial life; but it
performs them as a separate organization. It probably does
not occur to the distinguished members of that useful body to
either consult or cooperate with the Department of Commerce,
or that the latter has any interests or functions in common with it.
The Shipping Board provides for the carrying of our commerce
to the ends of the earth and, through its officers and representa­
tives abroad, takes an important, if not a vital, part in our com­

204

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

mercial activity, but the Department of Commerce is not repre­
sented upon the Shipping Board and, except as a matter of
courtesy, can not influence or guide it.
The Federal Trade Commission has duties of high importance
vitally affecting our domestic and our foreign trade; but no rep­
resentative of the Department of Commerce forms a portion of
that body, nor is there existing any obligation for that commission
to function in close relation with the Department of Commerce.
'the International High Commission, of which the Secretary
of the Treasury is the ex officio chairman, is a composite body
representing the United States and the other American Repub­
lics. It has distinctly commercial functions, among them the
provision of unifoim regulations for commercial travelers, of
uniform arrangements for the classification of merchandise, for
customs regulations, for consular certificates and invoices, and
for port charges. It gives special consideration to the protection
of patents and trade-marks and deals with the extension of arbi­
tration for adjusting commercial disputes. It is a useful and dig­
nified body, whose work touches closely that of the Department
of Commerce. It is in no respect inharmonious, but it is separate.
The Department of Commerce has no legal relation to it. A list of
its publications is found upon page 59 of the Hearings Before the
Committee on Foreign Affairs, House of Representatives, Sixtyfifth Congress, third session, on the diplomatic and consular service
appropriation bill, under date of December n , 1918.
The Railroad Administration, through its power to embargo
freights, to grant or remove export rates, may at times exercise a
controlling power over both our domestic and foreign commerce;
but it has under the law no relation to the Department of Com­
merce and, save as a matter of courtesy, does not assume that
there is any joint field of endeavor.
The Department of State, for reasons admitted by all to be
good and sufficient, maintains foreign-trade advisers and a force
for the purpose of gathering foreign-trade information. The
relation between that department, especially through its Consular
Service and the foreign-trade advisers and the Department of
Commerce, is intimate and cordial. It has been a privilege to
express admiration for the fine and fruitful work of the Consular
Service. There is a “ no man’s land” wherein the diplomatic
field runs parallel with the commercial and the commercial field
touches closely upon the diplomatic. It will probably always

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

205

be necessary to maintain a species of joint endeavor between the
two departments.
The Department of Agriculture, through several services, assists
or supervises large commercial transactions at home and abroad,
and does so ably and with advantage to the country.
Again, let it be emphasized that the relations between these
various bodies are not frictional, but cordial. The men com­
prising the various groups are friends. They realize they are
working to a common end. I repeat, the question is not one of
individuals, but one of organization. There can be no clear-cut
commercial policy carried out by separate bodies in the commer­
cial field that do not interfunction. Any industrial organization
composed as is the commercial organization of the Government
would fail, for the seeds of decay are planted in the very separate­
ness of the component parts. It is not urged that these bodies
should cease to be or that their functions should be altered.
There are separate duties belonging to each, although many of
those duties lie in a common field with the Department of Com­
merce.
It is, however, strongly urged that each and every one of these
separate services should be linked formally to that Department
which alone the law charges with the duty to “ foster, promote,
and develop the foreign and domestic commerce ” of the country.
Is there sound reason why there should not be a representative
of the Department of Commerce upon the War Finance Cor­
poration, upon the Federal Reserve Board, upon the Federal
Trade Commission, upon the Shipping Board, upon the Inter­
state Commerce Commission, or upon the Railroad Administra­
tion? If such reason exists, what is it? On the other hand, is
it the public purpose and intent that the Department charged to
“ foster, promote, and develop the foreign and domestic com­
merce” of the country should do it only in part, subject to the
kindly and unintentional, but nevertheless real, competition and
control of others charged with different duties, indeed, but so
acting as in some measure to perform or to control the perform­
ance of this work?
Very clearly either the Department of Commerce should be so
organized as to perform its important function effectively or it
should not. If it should not do so, then the organic law dic­
tating its functions should be modified, and it should cease to
be in name what it is hardly in fact, the Department of Com­

2o 6

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

merce. Or, on the other hand, it should be recognized that it
is really the center of commercial organization on the part of
the Government, and as such these various independent bodies
should so be headed up into it that the world of commerce and
the business man may know there is one head for commerce as
there is one for agriculture, as there is one for war, as there is
is one for the Navy, and not a congeries of unrelated parts which
operate, indeed, in personal harmony and peace, but without
those effective results which alone can come from systematic and
unified effort.
The foregoing report is respectfully commended to your at­
tention and to that of Congress.
Respectfully,
W illiam C. R edfield ,
Secretary.

APPENDIXES.
Appendix A.—VESSELS FOR THE UNITED STATES LIGHT­
HOUSE SERVICE—URGENT NECESSITY FOR REPLACE­
MENT OF VESSELS WORN OUT AND DESTROYED.
Services Performed by Lighthouse V essels.

In the operation of this the most extensive lighthouse service in the world, covering
47,300 miles of general coast line and rivers, there are at present employed 117 vessels,
of which 54 are tenders and 63 are light vessels.
The tenders serve both as supply ships and buoy tenders, carrying supplies and
personnel to lighthouses and lightships, placing and caring for buoys, and doing
construction, repair, and inspection work. They are the arteries of the Service,
and maintain a continuous patrol of the entire coast of the United States. If any­
thing is amiss with lightship, lighthouse, or buoy, they are promptly dispatched
in aid, and very frequently succor other vessels or persons or property' in danger.
The light vessels are floating lighthouses, located in the most important positions
for safeguarding shipping. Many of them are on very exposed and hazardous stations
off our coasts. Equipped with distinctive lights, powerful fog signals, submarine
bells, and radio communication, and guarding the dangerous points of the coast and
the approaches to the great harbors, they are the most indispensable of the aids to
navigation.
No vessels are exposed to more severe usage than the vessels of the Lighthouse
Service; the tenders arc continuously in service, and handle buoys of great weight
in proportion to the size of the vessel, as well as quantities of coal and other supplies.
In working buoys the tenders must navigate close to the edge of reefs and shoals,
and in waters which other vessels shun. Furthermore, the light vessels must remain
at anchor in exposed positions during the most severe gales and hurricanes. The
handling of buoys and supplies must often be done in a seaway, under difficult or
dangerous conditions.
Relation to Other Government Activities.

The United States is investing largely in shipping. The total amount authorized
or appropriated by Congress for the Emergency Fleet Corporation to October 15,
1918, was $3,671,000,000, covering the purchase and construction of over 3,100 vessels,
or more than double the number of seagoing merchant vessels of the United States
at the beginning of the war. The expenditures of the Navy Department for the
construction of new vessels for the fiscal year 1918 were about $450,000,000. The
expenditures for vessels for the Lighthouse Service should be considered as one of
the relatively small items of insurance for this great investment of the Government
in shipping, as well as for all the privately owned shipping of this country and the
shipping of other countries which visits our shores. The United States expends
about $40,000,000 a year in river and harbor improvements. The maintenance of
the aids to navigation is indispensable if these improvements are to obtain their
maximum usefulness.
Present Condition of Vessels and N ecessity for Upkeep.

Under normal conditions the useful life of a lighthouse tender is about 25 years
and of a light vessel about 30 years. The average age at present of the vessels of
the Lighthouse Service is for tenders 22 years and for light vessels 28 years, and for

207

2 o 8

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

each class this average age has increased by 3 years since 1914, owing to lack of
replacement of vessels. Of the light vessels now in use 20 are more than 30 years
old and of the tenders 17 are more than 25 years old. Some of the light vessels are
over 50 years old.
To maintain 54 tenders and 63 light vessels of a useful age it is evident that on an
average 2 tenders and 2 light vessels must be built each year, and the recommendations
and estimates submitted have yearly emphasized this fact. In the 9 years since
1910, however, but 11 tenders and 7 light vessels have been built, a total of 18, or
less than half the number of replacements necessary to maintain the Service on its
former basis, without allowing for any increase. However, since 1910 the number
of aids to navigation maintained by this Service has increased from 11,660 to about
16,073, a total increase of 4,415, or 38 per cent, and 3 new districts— Alaska,
Porto Rico, and Hawaii— have been added; also the number of gas buoys
maintained has increased from 225 to about 600, and the number of automatic
gas shore lights has increased from 117 to about 600. All of these increases, and
particularly the gas buoys and automatic shore lights, have added greatly to the
work of the tenders; so that notwithstanding important economies in tender
service that were effected at the reorganization in 1910, the present number
of tenders, even if they were efficient modem vessels, has become inadequate
to maintain the Service as required in the interest of navigation. Many of the
present tenders are, moreover, of a type not suitable to perform efficiently the
work required (4 of them are side-wheel vessels built 36 or more years ago) and
were not designed to handle the heavy gas buoys which have been developed since
tney were built. Some of them are not sufficiently seawortny to be sent on outside
work on account of their age, and a great deal of time is lost in making the frequently
needed repairs. Many of the present lightships are not suitable to be placed on ex­
posed stations. The cost of repairs and overhaul becomes so heavy that it is not
economical to keep in commission vessels after they have reached a reasonable limit
of usefulness. The continued use of these old vessels often results in a greatly dimin­
ished output with the same or greater cost of operation and upkeep. Of more im­
portance than the question of efficient and economical operation, however, is that
of safeguarding life. Both lighthouse tenders and lightships are engaged on haz­
ardous duty, and their officers and crews should not be required to serve on vessels
which have passed a reasonable limit of usefulness, nor can the Lighthouse Service
properly perform its part in the safeguarding of life and property on the navigable
waters of this country without necessary vessel equipment.
Recent Conditions Affecting V essels.

The deficiency of vessels in the Lighthouse Service has been accentuated by an
unusual number of casualties in the last year and a half. Since January, 1918, Diamond
Shoal light vessel has been sunk on station by a German submarine, Cornfield Point
light vessel has been run into by a barge and sunk on station, Cross Rip light vessel
has been destroyed by the ice, Thirty-Five Foot Channel light vessel has been de­
stroyed by fire at a contractor’s dock, and Bush Bluff light vessel and the tender
Gardenia have been condemned as worn-out and not worth repair.
All the tenders of the Lighthouse Service, except one, were by your order placed on
duty with the Navy Department during the period of the war, and from April, 1917,
to July, 1919, have been performing various duties for that department in addition to
their regular lighthouse work. Some of this naval duty, such as the handling of pro­
tection nets, has been strenuous work for these vessels. As a result of this, as well as
the shortage of tenders and the difficulty of effecting repairs under war conditions,
there has been an unusual deterioration of vessels. Experience of the last two years
has proven that the lighthouse vessels are of especial value in time of national emer­
gency. This is an additional reason for the proper maintenance of these vessels. The

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

209

tenders are the best available type of small vessels for handling moorings, nets, etc.,
and the light vessels are valuable signal stations at strategic points off the coast.
No appropriations for lighthouse vessels have been made since the act of June 12,
1917, or for more than two years. Of the appropriations made at that time, that of
$150,000 for a tender for the third district has been impracticable to use, as the lowest
bid received for the vessel was $333,800, and, on readvertising, $357,250, not including
equipping the vessel. The appropriation of $150,000 intended for two small light
vessels for the Great Lakes was barely sufficient to contract for one such vessel. Pres­
ent conditions in the shipbuilding industry render it impossible to use several appro­
priations or balances of appropriations, as they are quite insufficient under present
shipbuilding costs. Under the appropriation of June 12, 1917, of $130,000 for a light
vessel, recent bids were $297,000, $396,700, and $496,000 for the vessel, without outfit.
Due to war conditions and insufficiency of appropriations, no new contracts for
lighthouse.tenders have been made since September, 1915, and since June, 1916, only
one light vessel has been contracted for.
Very thorough investigation has been made as to the possibility of obtaining vessels
suitable for work of the Lighthouse Service from the Shipping Board or from vessels
no longer needed by the Navy. It was found that the Shipping Board had no vessels
in any way suitable. From the Navy two small vessels have been transferred which
will be used for shoal-water tender work, but will be of but limited usefulness. Both
lighthouse tenders and light vessels are vessels of unusual requirements, and it is
impracticable to meet the special needs of this work by adapting vessels built for other
purposes.
Essential Program for Maintenance of V essels for Lighthouse Service.

From careful estimates and examinations as to the condition and further service­
ability of vessels of the Lighthouse Service, it is found that within the next five years
18 light vessels and 10 tenders, as shown in the following list, should be replaced with
vessels of the types indicated, and 1 light vessel should be built for new station. As
it will require under favorable conditions from two to three years after appropriation
is made before vessels are available for service, funds should be provided now for 17
of these vessels urgently needed, in addition to 3 vessels for which estimates have
been heretofore submitted, 2 to be built under the authorization of June 20, 19x8, and
1 to replace Diamond Shoal light vessel.
Tlie vessels for which appropriation should be made now are the following, with
estimated cost:
To replace Diamond Shoal light vessel.
Light vessel to replace No. 71, Diamond Shoal, fifth district, class 1.

Estimated cost.
. “ $450,001

To be built under authorization of June 20, IQ18.
Tender to replace Jessamine, fifth district, class B ........................................
Tender to replace Gardenia, third district, class B .........................................

400,000
400, 000

Total.........................................................................................................

b goo, 000

Additional vessels, authorization of which is now necessary.
Light vessel for Bamegat, N. J. (new' station), class 2...................................
Light vessel to replace No. 57, relief, third district, class 2 ..........................
Tender to replace John Rodgers, third district, class B ..................................
Tender to replace Holly, fifth district, class B ...............................................
Tender to replace Mistletoe, third district, class B .........................................

335, 000
335,000
400,000
400, 000
400, coo

a

Covered b y pending deficiency bill.

140261— 19—

14

& Covered b y pending deficiency b ill in am ount ol $760,000.

210

R EP O R T OF T H E SE C R E T A R Y OF COM M ERCE.

Light vessel to replace No. 43, relief, eighth district, class 2........................ $335, °°°
Light vessel to replace No. 20, Cross Rip, Mass., second district, class 2 ...
335,000
Light vessel to replace No. 3, Handkerchief, Mass., second district, class 2 335, 000
Tender to replace Goldenrod, fourteenth district, river..................................
100, 000
Light vessel to replace No. 11, Scotland, N. J., third district, class 2 .........
335,000
Light vessel to replace No. 44, Northeast End, N. J., third district, class 2..
335, 000
Light vessel to replace No. 68, Fire Island, N. Y ., third district, class 2. . . .
335, 000
335,000
Light vessel to replace No. 6g, Overfalls, Del., third district, class 2..........
Light vessel to replace No. 46, Tail of Horseshoe, Va., fifth district, class 2.
335,000
Light vessel to replace No. ¡6, North Manitou, Mich., twelfth district,
class 3................................................................................................................
160,000
Light vessel to replace No. 57, Grays Reef, Mich., twelfth district, class 3 ..
160,000
Light vessel, to replace No. 60, Eleven-Foot Shoal, Mich., twelfth district,
class 3................................................................................................................
160,000
Total......................................................................................................... 5,130,000
On May 13, 1919, in a letter to the Speaker of the House of Representatives in con­
nection with legislation affecting the Lighthouse Service, this Department requested
that a provision be included authorizing the “ Constructing or purchasing and equip­
ping lighthouse tenders and light vessels for the Lighthouse Service, $5,000,000.”
This, with the estimates pending, would provide for the above immediate necessities.
The large number of new vessels required now is directly due to the conditions of
recent years, which have prevented replacement of vessels in this Service at a proper
rate. The situation is not unprecedented, however, for in the sundry civil act of
March 4, 1907, appropriations were made for building or completing 21 light vessels
and tenders, and an amount of $2,180,000 was included for vessels; for 10 of these
vessels there had also been previous appropriations.
The building of vessels for this Service should not be deferred on account of present
shipbuilding costs. The expense will undoubtedly be higher than the costs a few
years back, but there is no likelihood of any early reduction in shipbuilding costs.
This replacement of vessels has already been so repeatedly deferred on account of
war conditions that the fleet of this Service is in a seriously depreciated condition,
which can not safely be permitted to continue. The costs of these vessels on a ton­
nage basis will be higher than costs announced by the Shipping Board for building
fabricated ships for the following reasons: The lighthouse vessels are small, are of a
special type, will be built in small numbers, and must be unusually stanch for their
size; also, the Shipping Board per ton price does not include investment charges
and depreciation of plant, which every contractor must include in bidding on work.
The Lighthouse Service can, however, undoubtedly obtain more favorable bids by
constructing, as is proposed, several vessels of one type at one time. The following
are some comparisons as to the costs of vessels of small size and special types, some­
what comparable with the required vessels for the Lighthouse Service. In January,
1919, the Coast Guard contracted for building five cutters, at $687,000 each; these
vessels are of 1.200 tons construction weight, or will cost $572 per ton. The tender
Cedar, completed in 1917, according to sworn statements of the contractors, cost
$448 per ton construction weight to build; since 1917 there has been material increase
in cost of shipbuilding. The lowest bids, received within the past year, were $565
per ton for the tender Oak, and $539 per ton for a vessel for the Coast Survey. The
recent contract price for steel barges for the upper Mississippi River was at $401 per
ton; these barges are of much simpler construction than seagoing vessels. The above
comparisons are on the basis of construction weight, actual weight of vessel without
supplies or load.

R E P O R T O P TH E S E C R E T A R Y O F COM M ERCE.

211

List of lighthouse vessels requiring replacement within the next five years (not allowingfor
any losses of vessels).
V e s s e l.

Age

R em ark s.

R e p la c e b y —

N e c e s s a r y t o b u i ld .

LIGHT VESSELS.
Y rr
N o . 71— D ia m o n d S h o a l .
C la s s 2, l ig h t v e s s e l.
28
38

D o.
D o.

D o.
66

D o.
D o.
D o.
D o.
D o.

28
28

D o.

N o . 60— E l e v e n - F o o t

D o.

S h o a l.
18
28

L . V . N o . 73 . .

44

I ,. V . N o . 69 . . .

D o.

TENDERS.
38
D o.
D o.

36
H o l l y ..........................................

38

D o.
D o.

47

......... d o ................................

Additional vessels required for new station.
Light vessel, Barnegat, N. J.................................................................................. Class j
Tender for Alaska.................................................................................................... Class B
General types of vessels proposed.
V e s s e l.

L e n g th .

C o n s t r u c t io n w e i g h t a n d
c o s t.

E s t im a t e d
c o s t.

LIGHT VESSELS.
F eet.
C la s s 1. m o s t e x p o s e d s t a t i o n s ......................................................

147

61 s t o n s , a t $650 p e r t o n . . .

&400-000

C la s s 2, e x p o s e d s t a t i o n s ...................................................................

i

3S

515 t o n s , a t $650 j>cr t o n -----

335.000

96

240 t o n s , a t $650 j>er t o n . . .

160,000

C la s s

3,

G r e a t L a k e s s t a t i o n s .........................................................
TEN DERS-

C la s s A , s e a g o in g ....................................................................................

190

i .o o o t o n s , a t $650 p e r t o n . .

650,000

C la s s B , c o a s t w i s e .................................................................................

170

620 t o n s , a t $650 p e r t o n . . .

400,000

C la s s s p e c ia l, in l a n d r i v e r s ..............................................................

150

3 50 t o n s , a t $400 p e r t o n . . .

100,000

Appendix B.—THE DOGFISH CAMPAIGN AND CONTRO­
VERSY, AND THE INCREASED CONSUMPTION OF FOOD
FISHES.
There is widespread interest in the dogfishes, their ravages, and the measures
proposed for their amelioration, and there has been much misconception and mis­
statement regarding the relations of the Department of Commerce to the movement
for combating the dogfish nuisance by making commercial utilization of these fishes.
It therefore seems desirable that a full statement on this subject should be made,
particularly in view of recent criticism in Congress in which the dogfish campaign
was associated with another wholly unrelated activity of the Department and was
used in a misleading argument for defeating a meritorious service hitherto success­
fully executed for the purpose of increasing the consumption of aquatic products,
adding to the food supply, and reducing food costs.
For many years the fishermen of the New England coast have complained of their
serious losses from the destruction wrought by dogfishes, two species of small sharks
which appear in the coastal waters in large schools during the summer. A related
species, with similar habits, is the subject of like complaint on the Pacific coast.
Measures intended for the relief of the fishermen from this serious trouble, embodying
in one form or another the payment of a bounty, have been considered by Congress.
On May 2, 1913, Hon. Asher Hinds, of Maine, introduced in the House of Represent­
atives the following bill (H. R. 4584, 63d Cong., 1st scss.):
A

B i l l T o p r o t e c t o u r n a t io n a l fo o d s u p p l y b y t h e e x t e r m in a t io n o f c e r ta in e n e m ie s o f fo o d f is h e s o f t h e
A t l a n t i c c o a s t.

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United Stales of America
in Congress assembled, That a Federal bounty of not less than 2 cents shall be paid by
the United States for each dogfish or dogfish shark caught and exterminated by citizens
or fishermen of the United States in the waters of the Atlantic Ocean between Cape
Hatteras and Eastport, Maine, by the delivery of the tail section only of said dogfish
or dogfish shark to such vessels, works, or places as may be designated, which shall be
paid for on delivery to the United States Government authorities, under regulations
prescribed by the Secretary of Commerce.
S e c . 2. That the Department of Commerce shall annually, in the estimates made to
the Congress of the United States of the sums required or deemed necessary to be
raised for its department, recommend such a sum to carry out the provisions of this
bill as it deems requisite to accomplish the purpose herein intended, and which
shall include all sums necessary for carrying out completely the objects herein sought,
the extermination of said dogfish. S ec . 3. That this Act shall go into effect on its passage.
A t the request of the chairman of the Committee on the Merchant Marine and
Fisheries, the Department made the following report of its views on this bill in a
letter from the Acting Secretary to the chairman of the Committee on the Merchant
Marine and Fisheries, House of Representatives, dated April 21, 1914:
In reply to your letter of April 15 enclosing a copy of H. R. 4584, “ To protect our
national food supply by the extermination of certain enemies of the food fishes of the
Atlantic coast,” you are advised that the Department believes that the principle
involved in the proposed legislation is inimical to the public interest. If the practice
of paying bounties for the destruction of the enemies of food fishes is begun it will
eventually develop into a burden on the Nation. It will be but a question of time
when the demand will arise for bounties on star-fishes, drills, and druinfishes which
destroy great quantities of oysters, on the dogfish of the Great Lakes and the garfishes
of the same waters and the Mississippi Valley, and a host of other aquatic animals
concerning which more valid pleas can be raised than in respect to the dog shark.

213

214

REPO R T OF T H E SE C R E T A R Y OF COM M ERCE.

The Department docs not believe that the latter is as destructive to food fishes as
is generally supposed, although it is a great nuisance and a source of loss to the fisher­
men. Both of the common species are principally bottom feeders, and the fragments
of food fishes found in them are generally bafts stolen from the lines or fish eaten from
the nets. There is even no support for the reiterated statement that the species found
on the Maine coast is destructive to lobsters, the quotations to that effect attributed
to the publications of the Bureau of Fisheries applying to the southern species.
The Bureau of Fisheries estimates that about 2,700,000 dogfish were taken in the
fisheries on Georges Bank, South Channel, and Nantucket Shoals alone in 1913, which
would require the payment of $54,000 in bounties under the provisions of this bill in
addition to the costs of administration. It is believed that $500,000 annually would
be required to give effect to the proposed legislation. Moreover, there would be no
way by which the Department could assure itself that the dogfish tails on which boun­
ties were claimed were from fish taken within the limits prescribed in the bill and
undoubtedly there would arise a lucrative business of importing dogfish tails from
other parts of the coast.
I recommend an adverse report on this bill.
On May 9, 1913, Hon. Charles F. Johnson, of Maine, introduced in the Senate the
following bill (S. 1868, 63d Cong., 1st sess.):
A

B i l l T o p r e s e r v e o u r n a t io n a l se a -fo o d s u p p l ie s a n d r e s e r v e a n d t o a s s is t in f e r t i li z in g t h e la n d t o b e t t e r
t h e c o n d it io n s of o u r fa n n e r s , o u r f is h e r m e n , a n d u lt i m a t e c o n s u m e r s o f fo o d b y F e d e r a l f e r t i li z e r u t i l i ­
z a t io n of s m a ll s h a r k s , c a lle d d o a fis h , a ls o s e v e r a l s p e c ie s o f u n u t il iz e d s a lt - w a t e r fis h e s , a l l p r e y in g u p o n
a n d d e stro y in g ^ o u r n a t io n a l s e a a n d s h o r e fis h e r ie s , o f e n o r m o u s c o m m e r c ia l a n d e c o n o m ic v a l u e , a s
p l a i n l y s h o w n in a n d b y t h e U n it e d S t a t e s B u r e a u o f F is h e r ie s D o c u m e n t n u m b e r e d S i x h u n d r e d a n d
t w e n t y - t w o , d a t e d n in e te e n h u n d r e d a n d s e v e n .

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United Stales of America
in Congress assembled, That a Federal bounty of not less than 2 cents each, or a pur­
chase price of not less than $8 per ton of two thousand pounds, shall be paid to the
American fishermen from Eastport, Maine, to Cape Hatteras for the labor and ex­
pense attending the catching of and delivery of the entire carcasses of the said small
sharks, called Dogfish, to the proper Federal authorities at Federal dogfish and shark
reduction works, when and where established between said places upon the Atlantic
coast, or to such Federal collecting vessels as may be designated by the proper Fed­
eral authorities.
The said purchase price of not less than $8 per ton shall also be paid to American
fishermen for all said sharks, skates, and other shark species delivered by said fisher­
men to said dogfish and shark reduction works, or delivered to said Federal collecting
vessels as may be designated by the proper Federal authorities.
Sue. 2. That by and under the authority of the proper Federal authorities not less
than twenty-five to one hundred of said Federal dogfish and shark reduction works,
with a daily reduction capacity of not less than fifty tons dogfish or sharks, shall be
located, built, equipped, and operated at the most suitable and efficient points from
Eastport, Maine, to Cape Hatteras, as efficient or more efficient than those of Canada,
built since nineteen hundred and tlirec, including one of said reduction works lo­
cated, built, equipped, and operated at or near Eastport, Maine; one of said reduc­
tion works at or near Cutler, Maine; one of said reduction works at or near Jonesport,
Maine; one of said reduction works at or near Milbridge, Maine; one of said reduction
works at or near Stonington, Maine; one of said reduction works at or near Vinal
Haven, Maine; one of said reduction works at or near Boothbay, Maine; one of said
reduction works at or near Elm Island, near Orrs Island, Maine; one of said reduc­
tion works at or near Bangs or Stave Island, Casco Bay, Maine; one of said re­
duction works at or near Woods Island, Maine; one of said reduction works at or
near Cape Porpoise. Maine; one of said reduction works at or near Portsmouth, New
Hampshire; one of said reduction works at or near Monhegan Island, Maine; one of
said reduction works at or near Newburyport, Massachusetts: one of said reduction
svorks at or near Gloucester, Massachusetts; one of said reduction works in or near
Boston Bay, Massachusetts; one of said reduction works at or near Cape Cod, Massa­
chusetts; one of said reduction works at or near Woods Hole, Massachusetts; and at
such other places southward on the Atlantic coast as may be designated by the
proper Federal authorities between Eastport, Maine, and Cape Hatteras.
S ec . 3. That regular annual sums of money sufficient shall be appropriated to
operate and maintain efficiently all the said dogfish and shark reduction works that
are located, built, equipped, and operated at all places between Eastport, Maine,
and Cape Hatteras, and the said sums of money shall be sufficiently large to pay the
said American fishermen not less than 2 cents Federal bounty on each said dogfish
caught and delivered to said described Federal authorities in said manner, and to

REPO R T OF T H E SE C R E T A R Y OF COM M ERCE.

215

pay said fishermen not less than $8 per ton purchase price for all sand sharks, skates,
and other shark species, including the dogfish, delivered to said Federal authorities
in manner herein described.
S e c . 4. That the said sums of money so appropriated shall be sufficiently large to
pay the said fishermen not less than 2 cents Federal bounty on each dogfish and upon
the basis of the probable delivery of one million dogfish or more annually at each
said Federal dogfish and shark reduction works.
S e c . 5. That the said Federal reduction works shall be manned ready for opera­
tion when located, equipped, and built for a period of time not less than from June
first to November first annually.
SEC. 6. That all dogfish or shark fertilizers produced at said Federal reduction
works shall be sold only and direct to the bona fide farmers and planters of the
United States, and said fertilizer shall contain no filling or make weight of nonfertilizer materials, and the price of said fertilizers shall be only the gross cost of pro­
duction of said fertilizers, and the said fertilizers shall be bagged and the analysis
of said fertilizer in said bags shall be plainly stamped thereon, showing the particular
nitrogen, phosphoric acid, and bone phosphate contents in any form, in pounds and
percentage; likewise of nitrogen, phosphoric acid, or bone phosphate; and all orders
for said fertilizers from bona fide farmers and planters received by the said proper
Federal authorities shall be filled and shipped in regular order of receipt.
S e c . 7. That all rules, regulations, estimates, and expenditures, necessary con­
cerning the locating, building, equipping, and operating of the Federal dogfish and
shark reduction works, and disposition of said fertilizer, oil, and other by-products
derived from the reduction of said dogfish or other sharks or unutilized fishes, shall
be made by or under the direction of such proper Federal authorities as may be de­
termined b y Congress and the President of the United States, but all said rules and
regulations shall not be in conflict with the provisions of this Act.
S e c . 8. That this Act of Congress shall go into effect from the date of its passage
and as herein specified.
In response to a request for an expression of opinion on this bill, the following report
was made by the Department in a letter from the Acting Secretary to the chairman of
the Senate Committee on Fisheries, dated October 24, 1913:
The Department is in receipt of your letter of the 20U1 instant, transmitting a copy
of Senate bill 186S, providing for the purchase of dogfish by the federal government,
or the payment of a bounty thereon.
The Department has for some time been accumulating information on the entire
subject of dogfish and their utilization, in the expectation that there would be a
hearing before the appropriate committees of Congress. The question is so large and
has so many features that it could not well be discussed within the limits of an official
letter. 1 therefore venture to express the hope that your committee will hold a
hearing on this bill at some convenient time and give the Department an opportunity
to present its views in regard to the merits of this bill and of similar bills which have
from time to time been introduced in Congress.
No definite action appears to have been taken on either of these bills; and, urged
by the fishery interests, particularly of Maine, Mr. Hinds, acting on behalf of the
Committee on the Merchant Marine and Fisheries, requested the Commissioner of
Fisheries to draft a bill which would meet the practical requirements and have some
prospect of passage. Accordingly the following bill (H. R. 16477, 63d Cong., 2d sess.)
was prepared and submitted by Mr. Hinds on May 12, 1914, and favorably reported
by the. House Committee on the Merchant Marine and Fisheries on June 8, 1914, with
an amendment providing “ that the said sum [to be appropriated by authority of
sec. 3I shall not exceed $15,000 in any fiscal year” :
A B i l l T o c o n d u c t in v e s t ig a t i o n s a n d e x p e r i m e n t s fo r a m e li o r a t in g t h e d a m a g e w r o u g h t t o t h e fis h e r ie s
b y p r e d a c e o u s fis h e s a n d a q u a t i c a n im a ls .

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United Stales of America
in Congress assembled, That the Commissioner of Fisheries be, and he is hereby,
authorized and directed to conduct investigations and experiments for the purpose
of ameliorating the damage wrought to the fisheries by dogfish and other predaceous
fishes and aquatic animals.
S e c . 2. That the said investigations and experiments shall be such as to develop
the best and cheapest means of taking such fishes and aquatic animals, of utilizing
them for economic purposes, especially for food, and to establish fisheries and markets

2 IÓ

REPO R T O F TH E S E C R E T A R Y OF COMMERCE.

for them; and for these purposes the Commissioner of Fisheries is authorized to employ
such persons as mav be necessary, and to catch, buy, or otherwise obtain, and to sell
at cost or less or distribute gratuitously such quantities of the said aquatic products
as may be necessary for tests or demonstrations of their qualities or the establishment
of a demand among prospective consumers: Provided. That the proceeds of any such
sales shall be accounted for and covered into the Treasury as miscellaneous receipts.
S ec . 3. That the Commissioner of Fisheries, through the Secretary of Commerce,
shall submit in his annual estimates of appropriations for the Bureau of Fisheries an
estimate of the sum of money necessary to give effect to this Act.
This bill was amended on the floor of the House of Representatives by the elimina
tion of section 2 and by the reduction to $5,000 of the annual appropriation authorized,
and was passed on February 3, 1915.
Objectionable features of this bill, from the standpoint of tile Bureau of Fisheries,
were set forlh in the following letter from the Commissioner of Fisheries to me, dated
February' 5, 1915:
I desire to call to your attention certain facts relating to H. R. 16477, which was
amended and passed by the House of Representatives on February 3. The bill was
prepared by this Bureau at the request of Representative Hinds, its proponent, and
as a step towards a practical solution of the problem presented by the damage to the
fisheries by' predaceous fishes, and particularly the dogfish.
As you will recall, various bills having for their purpose the destruction of dogfishes
have been introduced in Congress, but all of them have received adverse reports
from the Department on account of their economic and scientific defects and their
manifest inadequacy to accomplish their avowed purposes.
I am convinced that the destruction of any quantity of dogfishes, sufficient to
materially reduce their destructiveness, is chimerical, and that the only rational
thing to do is to convert them to usefulness, and a source of profit instead of loss,
by bringing them into consumption as food. This can not be accomplished by mere
investigation and experiment, and the bare publication of the results. It will require
in addition an active practical campaign in introducing and marketing the products
and bringing them to the consumer’s actual physical attention and test, in other
words, an elaboration and extension of the methods which were employed in intro­
ducing the sea mussel. I am of the opinion that in the sea mussel propaganda the
bureau’s discretion in the expenditure of its appropriation was stretched to its limit,
and I should not care to be responsible for an elaboration of that kind of work unless
given additional authority, the character of which is indicated in section 2, of H. R.
16477, a copy of which is inclosed.
The amendments which the bill suffered were the total elimination of section 2 and,
a comparatively minor matter, the reduction of the permissible appropriation to
$5,000 in any fiscal year. The emasculated bill leaves the bureau with no more
powers than it already possessed, and is, therefore, wholly futile and unnecessary,
while on the other hand it places a limit, not previously imposed, on the appropria­
tion for which an estimate may' be submitted.
Unless section 2, or an essentially similar provision, can be supplied as a Senate amend­
ment and retained in the bill in conference, it will be worse than useless to pass it.
This proposed legislation rested without further action by the Sixty-third Congress.
The Legislature of the State of Maine had authorized the appointment of a com­
mission for investigating the dogfish nuisance, and that body pressed the Maine
delegation in Congress for action toward the abatement of the trouble by establishing
Government reduction works and paying bounties along the lines provided in above
bills. Senator Johnson and Mr. Hinds, therefore, again submitted bills identical
in terms with H. R. 16477, Sixty-third Congress, second session, excepting that the
animal appropriation authorized was increased to $25,000. The House Committee
on the Merchant Marine and Fisheries reported the bill (H. R. 11254, 64th Cong., 1st
sess.) favorably, after hearings at which representatives of the Bureau of Fisheries, this
department, the Maine Dogfish Commission, and others interested expressed their
views. The report submitted by this committee was as follows:

R EP O R T O F T H E S E C R E T A R Y OF COM M ERCE.

217

PREDACIOUS FISHES AND AQUATIC ANIMALS.
M

arch

8, 19 16 .— C o m m i t t e d t o t h e C o m m i t t e e o i t h e W h o l e H o u s e o n t h e s t a t e of t h e U n io n a n d o r d e r e d
t o b e p r in t e d .

[M r. H i n d s , f r o m t h e C o m m i t t e e o n t h e M e r c h a n t M a r in e a n d F is h e r ie s , s u b m it t e d t h e f o llo w i n g r e p o r t
( to a c c o m p a n y H . R . 11254).]

The Committee on the Merchant Marine' and Fisheries, having had under considera­
tion the bill (H. R. 11254) to conduct investigations and experiments for ameliorating
the damage wrought to the fisheries by predacious fishes and aquatic animals, report
the same back with the recommendation that the bill do pass.
For 15 years at least and perhaps much longer, this committee has had referred to it
bills dealing with the so-called dogfish nuisance. At first it was proposed to offer
a bounty for dogfish, and afterwards to use them for fertilizer; but it was not until the
Sixty-third Congress that the committee formidated a definite proposition with the
concurrence of the Commissioner of Fisheries, and in that Congress a bill was reported
and passed the House but was not considered in the Senate. Meanwhile the Maine
Legislature had taken the matter into consideration and a commission was appointed
to go to Washington and make known the extent to which the fisheries are being
interfered with. One of the Maine commissioners has met the Secretary of Commerce,
and the following correspondence shows the importance of this subject;
" D epartm ent of C om m erce ,
" O ffice of the S e c r e t a r y ,

“ Washington, February g, 1916.
“ M y D e a r J udge A l e x a n d e r ; The inclosed copy of letter to Mr. Luther Maddocks
regarding the dogfish will explain itself.

“ Yours, very truly,
“ William C. R ed FIELd , Secretary.

“ Hon. J. W. A l e x a n d e r ,
“ House of Representatives, Washington, D. C .”

“ D epartment of C om m erce ,
“ O ffice of th e S e c r e t a r y ,

“ Washington, February 9, 1916.
“ M y D ea r M r . M a d d o cks : In response to your request for information as to the

methods proposed by the Bureau of Fisheries to deal with the dogfish problem, I beg
to advise you as follows:
“ We asked in the Sixty-third Congress authority to make a special study of this
subject, including an appropriation of 815,000, with the view to determining whether
the dogfish could be introduced as food and whether it had any other economic values
that could be made available. The bill failed of passage in such form as to give
us the requisite funds and authority. We have asked Senator Johnson to consider
with the chairman of the House Committee on the Merchant Marine and Fisheries
the introduction of this measure at the present Congress with a view to an appropria­
tion of 820,000. If this bill shall pass we will undertake immediately upon its pas­
sage to put a force of trained experts upon the problem and to use all our powers
toward its early and satisfactory solution.
“ We are strongly hopeful that a demand would be created for the fish for use as
several varieties of food and possibly for other purposes. In any event, we think
the experiment should be thoroughly tried and shall be very glad to try it. I have
assured Senator Johnson that I will appear before his committee or the House Com­
mittee on Fisheries and do anything in my power to get the thing started.
“ We doubt the lawful power of the Government to enter into the fertilizer end of the
matter and think it quite possible that the study we purpose to make, if given the
authority and the funds, may be quite as efficacious, if not more so.
“ Yours, very truly,
“ W i l l ia m C. R e d F i e l d , Secretary.
"M r. L uth er Madd o cks ,

“ St. James Hotel, Washington, D. C ."

2 l 8

R E P O R T fo F TH E S E C R E T A R Y OF COM M ERCE.
“ D epartm ent op C om m erce ,
“ B u reau of F is h e r ie s ,

“ Washington, February iy, iq i 6.
“ T he S olicitor , D epartm ent

of

C om m erce :

“ In reply to your letter of February 14, requesting an, expression of opinion of
House bill 11254, ‘ To conduct investigations and experiments for ameliorating the
damage wrought to the fisheries by predacious fishes and aquatic animals,’ I report
thereon as follows:
“ This bill is intended primarily and immediately for the relief of the fishermen
of the Atlantic coast, and eventually those of the Pacific coast, from the effects of
the ruinous inroads of dogfishes. These are small sharks which congregate in schools,
and there are two species common on the Atlantic coast, the spiny dogfish found
north of Cape Cod and the smooth dogfish occurring in a more southerly habitat.
These differ more or less in habits, but are alike in being great nuisances on account
of their practice of eating baits and seizing the food fish caught on line and in nets.
It is not believed by the bureau that the smooth dogfishes, at least, destroy very
considerable numbers of free fish— that is, those whicn are uninjured or untrammeled
by nets. The food of the smooth dogfish consists mainly of bottom animals, mussels,
scallops, sea snails, crabs, starfishes, etc., and it also, unlike the spiny dogfish whose
food is less known, in certain places and at certain seasons destroys considerable
numbers of lobsters. The stomachs of both species often contain food fishes and frag­
ments of fishes, but there is good reason to believe that they come largely from lines
and nets.
“ The fishermen justly regard these small sharks with strong disfavor as sources of
annoyance and of very considerable loss to the fisheries, and in many places fishing
has to be abandoned when the dogfish appear.
“ Three methods of meeting this situation have been proposed: (1) To offer a
bounty for the destruction of the fish; (2) to establish a number of Governmentowned reduction works for their conversion into fertilizer and oil, paying for the
fish in excess of their economic value in order to induce the fishermen to catch them;
and (3) to endeavor to establish them in the markets as a food fish, using the liver,
oil, eggs, and skins as economic by-products.
“ The first two pro|>osals are predicated on the assumption that the dogfish can be
exterminated or materially reduced in number, a belief to which the bureau can
not subscribe. Both of the little sharks are found on the European and American
coasts and they range over the greater part of the North Atlantic. They- are highly
nomadic and a school on the coast one week may be far away the next and may never
return. Their wanderings are so wide, their numbers so great, and the reservoir
from which the coastal visitors may be drawn is so vast that it is futile to expect that
catching them at even a considerable number of places along shore can have a material
effect in reducing their numbers.
“ If these fish could be utilized for fertilizer at even a small profit there would be
justification for their use in that way, but the experience of the Canadian Govern­
ment. which operates three dogfish-reduction works, shows that they can be converted
into fertilizer only at a heavy loss, and this experience is corroborated by this bureau’s
investigations of the oil and fertilizer constituents of the fish.
"Tlic proposition to pay a bounty-, without utilizing the fishes, is open to obvious
objections.
"W hile the bureau is opposed to these proposed measures on account of their
impracticability and economic unsoundness, it is in sympathy with their purpose,
and it believes that H. R . 11254, on which you now ask an opinion, affords an oppor­
tunity to attack the problems involved anil in the course of time to solve them in a
manner to afford relief to the fishermen -and benefit to the people as a whole. The
belief is entertained that the proper method of procedure is not to exterminate the
dogfish bv indiscriminate destruction, but to convert a nuisance into an economically
useful product and a source of profit. It is believed that the only way in which
this can be accoinplished is to induce the utilization of this pest as food. Although
this has been scoffed at by some who would be the first and principal beneficiaries,
the project is practical and economically sound. The dogfish is not eaten in the
United States solely on account of prejudice. It is palatable and nutritious, and its
food is but little different from that of tne haddock and other valued food fishes.
It is extensively eaten in Europe, and during the past few years it has grown in favor
in England, where 5,000,000 pounds, with a value to the fishermen of $82,000 were
marketed in 1914. This large and increasing production of a cheap and excellent
food is a boon to the people at large, while the fishermen receive about $28 per ton
for their catch as against $8 which they would receive if the Government were to
engage in the unprofitable production of fertilizer under the conditions recently
proposed in this country.

R EP O R T O F T H E S E C R E T A R Y O F COMMERCE.

2 19

"T o introduce the dogfish or any other unutilized fish into consumption in the face
of general prejudice and ignorance of its qualities, and the lukewarm interest of the
fishermen themselves, will require time and a well-considered practical campaign.
It will involve demonstrations and publicity to acquaint the people with the qualities
of the fishes and the methods of cooking and preparing them and marketing experi­
ments on a commercial scale. H. R. 11254. appears to give authority for effective
work of this character, and moreover it makes it possible to extend it not only to the
dogfish, but to other marine pests of equal or greater destructiveness. The bureau
regards the bill as a piece of valuable constructive legislation, and urges that it be
given favorable consideration and passed.
" I am inclosing a memorandum on the dogfishes which was submitted to a preceding
session of Congress when a similar measure was under consideration.
"H. M. S mith, Commissioner.”

“ D epartm ent
" O ffice

op C om m erce ,
op the S olicitor ,

“ Washington, February 14, 1916.
“ Hon. J. W. A l e x a n d e r ,
“ House of Representatives, Washington, D. C.
“ M y D ear J udge A l e x a n d e r : I am in receipt of yours of the 12th instant, inclos­
ing H. R. 11254, ‘ to conduct investigations and experiments for ameliorating the
damage wrought to the fisheries by predacious fishes and aquatic animals, ’ and asking
my opinion with reference to the merits of the bill and the wisdom of enacting the
same into law. The department approves this bill in every particular, and earnestly
hopes that it will be enacted into law. I have forwarded your letter to the Commis­
sioner of Fisheries, asking him for a special report, and as soon as it is received I will
forward it to you.
“ Yours, very truly,
“ A. L. T h u r m a n , Solicitor.”
The Bureau of Fisheries has made a careful study of the dogfishes, and this inter­
esting subject is herewith attached to this report as a “ Memorandum respecting
dogfishes” :
“ The dogfishes are little sharks, weighing, when adult, from 5 to 15 pounds. They
get their popular name from their habit of traveling in large schools or packs like
dogs or wolves, and their chief present interest to the fishermen arises from their pre­
dacious habit and ravenous appetite. They feed solely on animal food, which they
get wherever it is most readily obtainable, and on the fishing grounds this is usually
on the trawl lines or in the nets of the fishermen.
“ Trawl lines are long, stout lines to which shorter lines, each with a hook, arc
attached at intervals of about 6 feet. They are stretched on the bottom, held in
place by suitable anchors, and marked by buoys, and as a single dory or fishing boat
will often fish several thousand hooks, each baited with a piece of herring, alewife,
or other fish, the fishing banks are strewn with food which the dogfish finds acceptable
and readily obtainable. When a school of dogfish appears, they greedily seize these
baits and either carry them away or are themselves hooked, the result to the fisher­
men being essentially the same in either case, for the line, set for merchantable fish,
is either denuded of its lures or is loaded with dogfish for which the fisherman can
find no market. The address and rapacity of these pests is such that when they arc
on the banks or along shore in large bodies the baits are seized before the valuable
fish can take the hook, and the fisherman loses his time, the labor expended in
setting and hauling his lines, the value of his bait, and all of the other items which
enter into the expenses of the fishery.
“ In the case of the gill-net fishery, the dogfishes are attracted by the helpless food
fishes enmeshed in the nets, and they either tear them bodily away and devour them
or bite them in two, leaving nothing but the head to show where a valuable fish had
been. Worse than this in some respects is the damage wrought to the nets, the sharp
teeth of the dogfish cutting them like shears and often leaving of the poor fisherman fs
property little but a string of tatters attached to the foot and lead lines.
“ Under these conditions the fisherman can do nothing to protect himself, and
his only recourse to save his property and avoid an utter waste of effort is to abandon
the fishery, often his only source of livelihood, until such time iis his enemy has
departed. This is no rare occurrence, but a common one on all parts of the New England
coast, over a wide stretch of the Pacific coast as well, and to some extent on the shores
of the Middle Atlantic States. Even the purse seiner fishing at sea will sometimes

220

R E P O R T OF TH E SE C R E T A R Y OF COMMERCE.

inadvertently inclose a school of dogfish and have his net cut and tom to pieces,
the pound-net fisherman along shore will find his trap filled with dogfish to the exclu­
sion of fish of value, and lobster pots take dogfish instead of lobsters.
“ The loss entailed by the destruction of gear and the enforced abandonment of
the fisheries by all classes of fishermen over wide areas amounts to large sums annu­
ally. The Massachusetts Fish and Game Commission states that the observable
damage to the fisheries of that State alone can be conservatively estimated at not
less than $400,000 per year, and this loss to those immediately concerned must have
its reflex in the increased cost of fish to the consumer. The effects of the dogfish
nuisance, therefore, are not only observable over a considerable part of the imme­
diate coast line, but are indirectly distributed over the large section of the country
depending on the sea for its supply of fish. Owing to the abundance of the dogfishes,
their wide distribution, their remarkable swimming powers, and their wandering
habits, which carry' them over broad expanses of the seas in which they live, it is
probable that but little can be done toward the material reduction of their numbers.
A school marauding on the coast one week may be far away the next and its place
may be occupied by another host that has come from an unknown distance in the
open sea. If they can not be exterminated, the only economic solution of the prob­
lem which they present is that they should be utilized and the curse of their presence
converted into a blessing. This can be done only in accord with sound economic
principles. A bounty, aside from other objectionable features, merely distributes
the loss and can have no other effect. It acts like a system of fire insurance with
no provision for preventing fires or minimizing their destructiveness. The loss still
exists, but its burden is home by a large number of persons.
“ Leaving out of consideration certain secondary or subsidiary uses, principally of
waste parts, fishes are economically utilized for fertilizer and for food. For the first
purpose they must be cheap as compared with other species which are abundant, in
fairly regular supply, easily caught, and easily handled. If the dogfish be economi­
cally available for tire manufacture of fertilizer it will be utilized by factories privately
owned and always on the watch for a supply of suitable and cheap raw material.
There is no doubt that fertilizer of good quality can be produced from dogfish, the only
questions being whether the fish can be obtained at a price low enough to show a
profit on operations. If they can not be profitably used by private works there is no
reason to suppose that they can be by those under Government control.
“ The value of the fish will be governed competitively with other fishes and if the
price be arbitrarily fixed too low the fishermen will not supply the fish, and if too high
as in bills proposed for the establishment of Government reduction works, there will
be an operating loss and the excess price of raw material will be in effect a bounty to
the fishermen.
"None but the cheapest fish will be used for fertilizer, and, considering the heavy
wear and tear on gear involved in taking dogfish, it is doubtful if they can be taken
profitably except for food, and that appears to be the only means by which they may
be converted into ail economic product. That they are not at present eaten in the
United States is no justification for the belief that they can not be introduced into the
national diet. There are numerous instances of despised fishes and other aquatic
animals attaining high favor after their qualities became known. Within a compara­
tively recent time the sturgeon, especially in the Great Lakes, was regarded as a
nuisance and ruthlessly destroyed, but to-day a single large female fish may sell for
as much as $150. The silver hake of the New England coast was formerly wholly
unutilized, but is gradually coming into the markets; the catfishes are becoming
high-priced fishes, and frogs are regarded as a delicacy, and the subject of frog farms is
exciting interest as a source of profit, instances might be multiplied.
“ The failure to eat dogfish in the United States appears to be due to prejudice
against them rather than to any lack of nutritiousness of palatability. There are two
species of dogfishes on the Atlantic coast, the spined or horned dogfish, which has the
more northern range, and the smooth dogfish, which is generally more abundant south
of pipe Cod. These differ somewhat in the character of their flesh, the spined species
being more oily and resembling in composition the medium grades of salmon. This
fish is well suited for canning.' The smooth dogfish is drier and when used fresh its
flavor and qualities have been likened to those of halibut and swordfish. Neither of
these fish lias objectionable or unclean feeding habits, one feeding on organisms
similar to icily fishes and possibly on true fishes, and the other on crabs, starfish, and
other bottom-dwelling animals. Both, so far as food is concerned, resemble other
fishes highly esteemed on the table. Their flesh is white, and in external appearance
they are not repulsive; their skins secrete little mucus and they never look slimy,
like cod and haddock, when massed in the holds of vessels. They are eaten exten­
sively in various parts of Europe. In Norway and Sweden they are used both fresh

REPORT OF THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE.

221

and salted or dried. In England, where there was formerly the same prejudice exist­
ing as in the United States, the spined dogfish has emerged from its odium and is
gradually assuming a position of importance as a food fish, about five and one-half
million pounds being used in 1912. In tire fried-fish shops it masquerades and is
readily eaten as Plaice, one of the most popular of English fishes, thus demonstrating
that the elimination of prejudice against it is a prime factor in its introduction into
consumption.
"Certain secondary products of the dogfish could probably find a market if the
value of its flesh could be established. The liver is rich in oil, having most of the
qualities of cod-liver oil; its skin makes an attractive leather, and is unsurpassed
abrasive for fine wood and ivory workers, and the fins are rich in gelatine. All of
these utilities should be convertible into profit and if they can be availed of on a com­
mercial scale the dogfish problem could be solved to the satisfaction of both fishermen
and the consuming public, and a heavy annual industrial loss would be converted
into a profit.
"This bill is intended to provide authority and means for the attempted attainment
of these ends by inducing the consumer to recognize the qualities of the dogfish and
other waste fishery products and in educating the fishermen to prepare them and
market them in such manner as will conduce to that result. It is a practical measure,
and it is believed that it will yield practical results.
" While the dogfish is the most destructive probably of all the predacious fishes, yet
the depredations that are wrought by other predacious fishes and aquatic animals is
of itself a serious menace to our fisheries, and this bill will be of advantage to all the
Coast and Gulf States.”
The Senate Committee on Fisheries also held full hearings, but the proceedings
were not recorded. This committee amended the bill and the Senate and House of
Representatives passed the amended measure as follows:
An Act To conduct investigations and experim ents for am eliorating th e damage w rought to the fisheries
b y predacious fishes and aq u atic animals.

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America
in Congress assembled, That the Commissioner of Fisheries be, and he is hereby,
authorized and directed to conduct investigations and experiments for the purpose of
ameliorating the damage wrought to the fisheries by dogfish and other predacious
fishes and aquatic animals.
S ec. 2. That tile said investigations and experiments shall be such as to develop
the best and cheapest means of taking such fishes and aquatic animals, of utilizing
them for economic purposes, especially for food and to encourage the establishment
of fisheries and markets for them.
S ec . 3. That the sum of $23,000, or so much thereof as may be necessary', is hereby
appropriated, out of any money in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated, to enable
the Commissioner of Fisheries to carry out the provisions of this Act, the same to be
immediately available.
Approved, June 21, 1916.
This act withheld from the Commissioner of Fisheries certain authority conferred
by the second section of the original draft which was regarded as important for the
efficient performance of the duties imposed, and to the omission of which from a pre­
vious bill the Commissioner had called attention in his letter of February 5, 1915,
previously quoted. The demand for some action to alleviate the dogfish nuisance
was so urgent, and as the measure appeared to be the best obtainable, its approval
was recommended and the plans already formulated were modified to meet the new
conditions.
The Bureau of Fisheries had long before found that fresh dogfish were excellent
food, and had had them placed on the market in limited quantities in connection
with its campaign for the introduction of the tilefish. It was found, however, that
like certain other food fishes, they could not be shipped far from the coast without
deterioration. In order that the work should be most effective, it was necessary to
find a sale for large quantities of the fish, and that the market should be almost country­
wide. The most feasible plan, therefore, was to present them to the public in a canned
condition.

222

R EP O R T OP TH E S E C R E T A R Y O P COM M ERCE.

In anticipation of the passage of an act granting the necessary authority to proceed
with the undertaking as originally planned, the Bureau, about December i, 1915,
had had a small quantity of dogfish canned by one of the largest and most experienced
packers of New England. The product was excellent in appearance and flavor, and
was favorably reported on by the various persons to whom it was distributed for trial.
Samples were tasted by some of the members of the committees of the Senate and
House of Representatives during the hearings previously referred to, and no adverse
criticism was offered. It was assumed, therefore, that the product was of a quality
to warrant an attempt to place it on the market, especially as it could be sold at a
very low price, a desideratum already strongly appealing to those interested in com­
batting the increasing cost of foods.
The original plan was to have these fish packed at the expense of the Bureau of
Fisheries and to sell them to distributors at cost, with an understanding that the
Bureau was to undertake a publicity campaign to promote their sale, and to accept
the return of and make reimbursement for such of the product as for any reason might
prove unsalable. This proposed procedure appeared to be direct and businesslike,
as the Bureau would maintain control over distribution, could confine its campaign
to the most favorable localities, would be in direct touch with such difficulties as
might arise, and could take immediate steps to curtail losses. As the authority to
buy and sell was not conferred by the law, and as the amendment of the bill originally
submitted indicated that Congress was averse to granting such authority, it was neces­
sary to proceed otherwise.
This legislation was not sought by the Department, and it was not passed in the form
suggested by the Commissioner of Fisheries to the Committee on Merchant Marine and
Fisheries to meet a situation which had confronted that committee for many years,
but it appeared to permit a workable plan for meeting the conditions which the
Bureau of Fisheries proceeded at once to put into execution.
Arrangements were made with the canners who had prepared the experimental
pack to can 5,000 cases of 24 one-pound cans each, which w er. to be handled b y them
in the ordinary course of their business and sold at the lowest price consistent with a
reasonable profit. The Bureau of Fisheries, on its part, undertook a publicity cam­
paign to establish a market for the new commodity and authorized the packers to
place on their labels a statement to the effect that the fish were packed at the request
of the Bureau of Fisheries and according to a method approved by it. The name
dogfish, lacking precision on account of its application to a number of distinct and
widely varying species of fishes, and having acquired an approbrious implication on
account of the destructive habits of the species, was changed to “ grayfish” (gray being
the natural color of the fish), and the packers were authorized to use that name on
their labels. All of these arrangements and understandings were informal.
During the last quarter of 1916 the pack agreed on was ready and the Bureau of
Fisheries launched its campaign. The packers were furnished with placards recom­
mending grayfish which they were requested to send to their customers and the latter
were furnished directly by the Bureau with circulars containing recipes which they
were urged to place in the hands of consumers. Simultaneously the public press,
household journals, and other agencies of publicity were provided with reading mat­
ter and news notes which were widely published. This marketing campaign was
successful beyond expectation, the original pack was soon exhausted, and inquiries
began to be received as to sources of supply and complaints because the demand
could not be satisfied. The grayfish had left the shore waters of the Atlantic coast
and the pack in New England could not be increased, but agents of the Bureau were
sent to the Pacific coast and arrangements for a pack were made with several experi­
enced canners in Washington.
The reports received by the Bureau of Fisheries from consumers, experts in die­
tetics, and others were at first all favorable and often highly commendatory of the

R E P O R T O F TH E SE C R E T A R Y OF COMMERCE.

223

quality and low price of grayfish. This continued several months, during which a
large quantity of the food found a market with success. About July, 1917. a com­
plaint was received that some of the fish canned by a Pacific coast packer gave
forth a strong odor of ammonia, and this was followed, by others of similar tenor. It
was known that the grayfisli developed this odor when stale, and it was at first assumed
that some of the fish had been kept too long before being dressed and packed. The
company whose pack had been complained of was first warned to be more careful
and later was ordered to cease using the name of the Bureau of Fisheries on its labels.
Suspicion having been excited by these complaints, further investigation was made
and it was found that even when perfectly fresh grayfisli are packed by the best meth­
ods employed in canning other fish, such as salmon, there is a gradual evolution of
ammonia in the cans, which, while not inimical to health, is objectionable to the
sense of smell. There also develops, more slowly, a progressive deterioration of the
cans which eventually causes minute perforations and gradually darkens the contents
through the deposit of tin and iron salts in the fish, rendering them totally unfit for
food.
Detinning of the cans occurs to some extent in a large number of canned products,
but in most cases to but a small extent. It is particularly troublesome in certain
vegetable products, and considerable losses have resulted, but in the common food
fishes the reaction is not excessive and the difficulties in canning usually have not
been with the keeping qualities but in the first preparation. * In some cases, the tuna
for instance, many thousands of dollars have been expended and much time has
passed before a satisfactory product has been prepared and established on the markets.
Neither the Bureau of Fisheries nor the several experienced fish packers who canned
grayfish anticipated these difficulties, as it was expected that when oticc palatably
prepared and thoroughly processed and sealed the product would behave like other
canned fish. It is easy to see now why this was not the case, but it was no more
surprising that unexpected technical difficulties should be encountered in this case
than were experienced in the early history of the canning of crab meat and shrimp
and even lobster, entire packs of which spoiled to the heavy cost of the packers, ¡us
is well known. Such experiences are common when making new products.
The mistake in the case of the grayfish was an overeagemess to get results in order
that the fishermen quickly should obtain the benefits intended by Congress in passing
the act and that the food supply of the country might be enhanced in a time of urgent
need. It is apparent now that the canned fish should have been held for at least a
year to test its keeping qualities before effort was made to enlist the interests of the
packers and involve them in the possibility of loss.
Between 1,200,000 and 1,500,000 cans of grayfish were packed before the difficulties
described were recognized, and apparently over half of this quantity was consumed
before deterioration. The remainder was left unsalable in the hands of the packers,
jobbers, and dealers. If the original plan of action had been followed, and the fish
had been packed at the expense of and sold by the Department, these unsalable goods
which by limitation of the appropriation would have been smaller in quantity, would
have been taken off the hands of the holders and the money refunded, the usual busi­
ness procedure in such cases.
As it appears that the Department’s moral obligation in the premises was not altered
by the changes in plan consequent on the terms of the act of June 21, 1916, I trans­
mitted to Congress an estimate for the sum of $45,000 to reimburse losses sustained by
packers who had cooperated in the undertaking. I submitted the following explana­
tory letters with the estimate, my letter to the Secretary of the Treasury, dated
January 23, 1919, reading as follows:
There is transmitted herewith for submission to the Congress an estimate of appro­
priation in the sum of $45,000, to reimburse fish packers for losses sustained in cooperat­
ing with the Bureau of Fisheries in the canning and marketing of grayfish. Also a
letter from the-Commissioner of Fisheries in support of submission of the estimate.

224

R E P O R T O F T H E SE C R E T A R Y OF COM M ERCE.

Having given careful consideration to the matter and feeling with the commissioner,
that there is at least a moral obligation resting on tire Government to reimburse those
who in cooperation with the department in this enterprise have suffered financial
loss, I recommend the submission of tire estimate at this time and its consideration in
connection with the sundry civil bill.
Letter from the Commissioner of Fisheries to me, dated January 22, 1919:
There is transmitted herewith, with the recommendation that it be submitted to
Congress, an estimate in the sum of $45,000 for inclusion in the estimates for " Expenses,
Bureau of Fisheries, 1920.”
An act approved June 21, 1916, appropriated $25,000 for alleviating losses sustained
by the fisheries from the acts of predaceous marine animals, especially the grayfish
or dogfish, and provided for a campaign to convert such animals to economic uses,
particularly as human food. This measure was based on one suggested by the depart­
ment as a substitute for a proposal made by certain representatives of the fishermen,
which was regarded as not only economically unsound but which would have involved
heavy initial appropriations for reduction works and annual appropriations for opera­
tion. The project was thoroughly discussed at hearings of the Senate Committee on
Fisheries and the House Committee on Merchant Marine and Fisheries, specimens of
canned grayfish being presented and tested at both hearings.
Based on the authority granted by the bill as it passed the House, tentative plans
had been made by the Bureau of Fisheries to have several thousand cases of grayfish
canned with the purpose of selling them to dealers for a consumer’s test, the proceeds
of the transaction to be covered into the Treasury as “ Miscellaneous receipts.” The
act as amended by the Senate and approved did not authorize this direct business
transaction, and as a practical alternative arrangements were made with an experienced
canner to pack 5,000 cases after a method which the preliminary experiments appar­
ently had shown to be satisfactory. The packer was to handle the product in the
regular course of his business, but he was to be permitted to state on his label that it
was recommended by the Bureau of Fisheries, and was packed at its request by a
process approved by it. The bureau was also to undertake a publicity campaign to
acquaint the consumer with its qualities and availability.
The original quality of the canned grayfish was excellent, as was attested by culinary
experts to whom it was submitted for test, and by the ordinary consumer, and this
in combination with its low price and its effective exploitation created a demand
which the original pack could not satisfy. To meet this demand, arrangements,
similar to those described, were made with competent and experienced fish packers
on the Pacific coast in January, 1917.
In July, 1917, complaints began to be received in regard to an ammoniacal odor of
the contents of some of the cans. At first it was believed that this was the result of
carelessness in packing or the use of stale fish, but further investigation has shown
that this odor develops normally in fish when canned according to the original method,
and that, furthermore, there is a progressive detinning of the interior of the cans so
packed, resulting in the absorption of metallic tin by the fish which renders it in time
unsuitable'for food. The product in which these effects occur was canned by essenti­
ally the same method employed with salmon and the difference in keeping qualities
is due to inherent differences in the character of the fish which neither experienced
canucrs nor the Bureau of Fisheries nor the expert physiological chemists consulted
by the latter had reason to believe would result in these unfortunate reactions. The
defect was not noticed in the first lot of fish packed because they were so promptly
consumed, but later when the relation between supply and demand was in better
equilibrium, and the goods, like other canned products, remained for six months or
more on the shelves of dealers a serious situation developed; the grayfish canned by
this method began to be condemned as unfit for food and the packers received many
claims for reimbursement on account of spoilage and numerous complaints were
received b y the Bureau of Fisheries.
The bureau recognizes that there is properly lying against it no legally enforceable
financial responsibility in this matter, but I am convinced that there is a moral obli­
gation that it should not subject to serious loss those whose cooperated with it in an
effort to introduce this commodity and those who purchased it on the recommendation
made respecting it, and I earnestly recommend that the appropriation asked for the
relief of these persons be granted. They entered into the transaction in good faith
and with reliance on the recommendations officially made to them. They would
have made little or no profit on the venture even if this product had not undergone
deterioration as representations were made to them that in order to introduce it the
selling price should be but slightly above the cost of production. If the Bureau had
followed the original plan to have fish canned for its account and the product had been

REPO R T O F T H E S E C R E T A R Y O F COM M ERCE.

225

sold to distributors with the usual implied guaranty of keeping qualities, there would
have been a direct obligation to make refund for spoilage. That a somewhat different
procedure was followed should not be used as an excuse for evading this obligation.
Although the canning of grayfish by this original method has been in part unsuc­
cessful , the original appropriation of $25,000 has been very productive. Other methods
of canning grayfish with better keeping qualities have been devised, and the new
product has been on the market for a year without complaint. The same fish is being
sold in considerable quantities smoked, and is now regularly on the markets in a fresh
state in New York, Boston, Seattle, San Francisco, and other places. The fund has
been used, also, in exploiting various other neglected or little used fishes, with the
result that over 15,000.000 pounds of certain hitherto neglected fishes, valued at about
S i,000,000, were marketed during the present season, in addition to unknown bu.t
considerable quantities of a number of other species, concerning which quantitative
data are not available. Most of this will result in permanent annual addition to the
food supply, which undoubtedly will grow under the impetus imparted to these
specific fisheries.
The above statement has been unofficially placed before the chairman of the House
Committee on Merchant Marine and Fisheries, and the course suggested has his
personal approval.
SUPPLEMENTAL ESTIMATE OF APPROPRIATIONS REQUIRED FOR THE SERVICE OF THE
FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUN E 3 0 , 19 2 0 , BY THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE, BUREAU
OF FISH ER IES.

Miscellaneous expenses, Bureau of Fisheries:
To reimburse fish packers for losses sustained in cooperating with the
Bureau of Fisheries in the canning and marketing of grayfish, to be
expended under regulations to be prescribed by the Secretary of Com­
merce, to be immediately available (act June at, 1916, vol. 39, p. 232,
sec. 1), submitted........................................................................................ $45,000
The appropriation was urged by the Commissioner of Fisheries and Deputy Com­
missioner of Fisheries and myself at hearings before the Committee on Appropriations,
but was not allowed. On May 19, 1919, this recommendation was repeated and
$15,000 additional requested: this also was refused.
A t the present time two companies on the Pacific coast are producing, monthly,
about 70 tons of stock and poultry feed from grayfish, and kippering the fish for human
consumption, which was suspended during the summer, is about to be resumed.
This latter product is placed on the market both fresh and canned.
Through some complete misunderstanding this grayfish work has been confounded
in discussions in Congress with a scries of demonstrations in fish cookery, another
undertaking in which this Department engaged through the Bureau of Fisheries.
The two had no relation to one another. The grayfish project dealt with the commer­
cial preparation of a particular fish for the market, and the establishment of a fishery
for it. The cooking demonstrations were for the purpose of instructing cooks and
housekeepers in the best and most economical methods of preparing all kinds of fish
for the table, particular attention being devoted to the cheaper varieties available
in each locality' but which are not adequately utilized because their merits and the
proper methods of cooking them are not known to the public. In other words, one
of these projects was a manufacturing and mercantile undertaking and the other
was concerned solely with the home. The cookery' demonstrations, furthermore,
were more fortunate than the grayfish undertaking in that they were successful from
the beginning, and were received with unalloyed satisfaction and thankfulness by
all to whom they were, directed. They were a direct and effective contribution to the
welfare of the home, and not only aided in reducing living costs through the use of
cheaper fish, and usually wasted parts of fishes, and more economical cooking mate­
rials, but they were contributions to health through the exposition of more wholesome
methods of cooking.
This work was initiated as an emergency measure during the war under an allot­
ment from the appropriation for national security and defense, but it was received
140261— 19----- 15

22

Ó

R E P O R T OF TH E SE C R E T A R Y O F COMMERCE.

with such general favor and had so conclusively demonstrated its value under existing
economic conditions that Congress was asked for an appropriation of $15,000 for its
continuance during the fiscal year ending June 30, 1920. The following correspond­
ence relating to this request explains this work and what it accomplished:
D epa rtm en t of Co m m erce,
O f f ic e o f t h e S e c r e t a r y ,

Washington, June 7, IQIQ.
There is herewith handed you for transmission to
Congress an estimate of an appropriation in the sum of $15,000 for the conduction of
demonstration and the imparting of instruction in cheap, wholesome, and correct
methods of preparing fish for consumption and in cooking same for use as food.
The work thus far done of this kind has been under an allotment from the fund for
the national security and defense. It has been fully appreciated by the public all
over the country, and it is deemed of special importance in this time of high food
prices that the work should be continued.
Yours, very truly,
W i l l ia m C. R e d f i e l d ,
Secretary of Commerce.
My D ear Mr . S ecretary:

T h e S ecretary of th e T rea su ry .

D e p a r t m e n t o f Co m m e r c e ,
B u r e a u o f F is h e r ie s ,

Washington, June 6 , I Q I Q .
There is transmitted herewith for submission to the Congress an estimate of appro­
priation in the sum of $15,000 to enable the Bureau of Fisheries to continue during
the fiscal year 1920 demonstrations of the best and most economical ways of preparing
and cooking fish. This work was inaugurated on the Pacific coast in May, 1918, and
w as made possible by virtue of an allotment for the increase of the food supply from
the appropriation for national security and defense. It proved effective and success­
ful beyond all expectations and was extended to a number of the larger communities
in the Mississippi Valley and as far east as Boston and its vicinity. These demon­
strations originally were regarded as war work and it was assumed that should the
war continue the expenses incurred in their prosecution could be defrayed from
appropriations similar to that under which it was inaugurated. It was not until the
demonstrations had been extended to the Mississippi Valley, after the bureau’s esti­
mates for the next fiscal year had been submitted, that it was appreciated that they
were of such extraordinary public value as to demand that they should be continued
under peace conditions.
From every city in which the meetings have been held the bureau has received
expressions of appreciation and commendation from chef associations, women’s organ­
izations, individual housekeepers, and the fish trade, and the quality of the service
rendered has been further indicated by the extent and nature of the press notices,
especially during the period since the signing of the armistice and after nearly two
years of surfeit of food-conservation propaganda. The work is blazing a new trail in
the field of domestic science, a fact which is attested by those most highly skilled
in cookery as well as by the most humble housekeeper. After a demonstration
attended by the chefs and stewards of the principal hotels of Chicago, the Inter­
national Stewards’ Association requested most urgently that a similar demonstration
be given at the national convention of that organization. Innumerable housekeepers
have informed the bureau and its agents that after pursuing the methods advocated
they have been able cheaply to prepare fish in a manner acceptable to their house­
holds, which had before held fish in low esteem.
The work is directed principally toward the introduction of more wholesome and
appetizing methods of cooking fish, the use of the cheaper and more abundant species
in each locality, and the utilization for food purposes in the home of those parts of
the fish usually thrown away. It is the bureau’s most direct and effective contribu­
tion to the needs of the women of the country and the improvement of home and
health. At this time, when the difficulties of the household are manifold, it is particularly important, and I urgently recommend that provision be made for its con­
tinuance.
H. M. S m i t h , Commissioner.
The S e cr eta r y of C om m erce .

R EP O R T OF TH E S E C R E T A R Y OF COM M ERCE.
D epa r tm en t o f Co m m erce,
B u r e a u o f F is h e r ie s ,
W a s h in g to n , J u n e 6 , 1 QIQ.
M e m o r a n d u m R e g a r d in g D e m o n s t r a t i o n s o n F i s h C o o k e r y :

in one yeaT we have given 125 demonstrations on fish cookery and directly reached
some 15,000 women, and, as has repeatedly been shown, those attending have been
so enthusiastic with our work that they have carried our message into many other
ho nes. Meetings have been held on the Pacific coast, from Bellingham to San Diego,
in the principal cities of the .Middle West, and in Boston and vicinity.
The women have been taught a new way of cooking fish which eliminates 75 per
cent of the labor and of the expensive cooking fats or oils, as well as most of the odors.
The housewives all over the country are loud in their praise of finding an easy and
inexpensive way of cooking fish, and particularly interested in finding all sorts of
cheaper fish and fishery products of which they had never heard before. We have
tried to show them how to get a dinner of fish for four persons at a cost of 25 cents,
or two meals for 40 cents. In spite of the high prices ruling we have always been
able to introduce them to cheaper varieties, procured from their own markets.
I find the housewife is much gratified to think her Government is taking enough
interest in her problems to send us through the country teaching and preaching
economy and showing her how to get two dinners for what she has been paying for
one. She is keen to recognize, when it is pointed out to her, that at present there
is not much hope for cheaper meats, poultry, eggs, or milk, and that she must look
to fish for cheap protein food for her children’s building materials.
I also use these meetings for the dissemination of helpful propaganda for the building
up and holding together of the home. In these days of unrest. I try to calm down the
women by suggestions for them to meditate over, pointing out that, with a country at
war, the Government takes into consideration the morale of its soldiers but with a
nation at peace the morale of the country is in the hands of the wives and mothers;
they are the hidden stones which hold up the whole edifice of civilization. The
humblest little woman, toiling to serve her family a well-cooked meal, and looking
well to the ways of her household, is setting an example in her community for which
her Government will rise up and call her blessed, as well as her husband and children
E v eu en e Sp e n c e r ,

Demonstrator in Fish Cookery.
The recommendation failed to meet with the approval of the Committee on Appro­
priations, and when the bill carrying appropriations for the Bureau of Fisheries was
being considered by the House of Representatives on June 21, 1919, the chairman of
the Committee on Appropriations cited the dogfish case as a reason for not granting the
item of $15,000 “ for the conducting of demonstration and the imparting of instruction
in cheap, wholesome, and correct methods of preparing fish for consumption and in
cooking same for use as food. ” I brought this matter to the attention of the chairman
in the following communication dated June 25, 1919:
My attention has been called to your remarks in connection with the omitted item
of $15,000 for the demonstration and imparting of knowledge and instruction in the
proper cooking of fish, appearing on page 1605 of the Congressional Record for June 21.
The description I have ttsed is neither yours nor mine, but it is sufficiently accurate
to make the subject clear.
My purpose in writing you is merely to point out for your information and that of the
Committee on Appropriations that there is no connection whatever between the item
of $15,000 omitted and the item of $60,coo with respect to the gray fish, and also to
advise that as regards this latter matter there are facts apparently not before you at
the time.
The item of S i j . o o c has nothing whatever to do with any canned fish. No person
concerned with it had any relation to or part in the matter of the grayfish, nor has any
criticism ever arisen in connection with the matter for which tiic Si5,oco was asked.
The reverse is true. That work has been the means of putting on the market millions
of pounds of new, unused foods and of greatly enlarging the use of foods now little used.
Public expressions of gratitude and appreciation have come from many parts of the
country. No word of fault has ever been found.
The matter of the grayfish refers solely to canned foods put up by Cahners themselves.
It is as distinct and different from the other as day is from night. It refers to a past
that has gone. To-day grayfish is being satisfactorily prepared for the market and is a
regular article of food The difficulties in connection with it are merely such as were
normal to the initial stages of a new article and the problems have been satisfactorily
solved.

228

R E P O R T O F TH E SE C R E T A R Y OF COM M ERCE.

The Department thereupon renewed its estimate for an appropriation for this work,
and increased the amount required to $75,000. The representation of the matter to
Congress was made the occasion for a full statement of the work already accomplished
and crying need for its continuance in my letter to the Speaker of the House of Repre­
sentatives, dated July 19, 1919, as follows:
In respectfully asking the attention of the House of Representatives again to House
document 88, Sixty-sixth Congress, fust session, kindly let me say that the reason for
so rloinji is the high price of food and the insistent, imperative demands which these
high prices make upon the modest incomes of the poor.
It is true that the estimate submitted under date of 7th June, and concerning which
I had the privilege of writing on the 13th ultimo to the chairman of the Committee on
Appropriations, has been considered both by that committee and by the Committee
on Appropriations of the Senate and has by both been rejected. Nevertheless, X
venture again to bring it before you because the demand for cheaper food is insistent
and will not down; because the prices demanded for food are high and have little, if
any, tendency to reduction: and because Congress has itself since the matter was
brought up before expressed a keen interest in the subject of the excessive cost of
living Furthermore, it is my duty to insure that neither the department nor myself
has failed to make clear to the thought of Congress that for a modest sum it is possible
to continue a great and successful work in providing supplies of cheap, nourishing,
and palatable food and thus to assist in solving the problem which presses so severely
upon every household. For these reasons it is earnestly requested, not so much on
behalf of the Department of Commerce or the Bureau of Fisheries, as on behalf of the
people of the United States, many of whom are oppressed with high prices, that this
matter be given further consideration at the hands of the appropriate committee.
The purpose of the fund of $15,000 which is now asked, is to conduct demonstrations
and impart instructions in correct, cheap, wholesome methodsof preparing and cook­
ing fish for consumption. This work has been successfully carried on in the leading
cities of the States of Washington, Oregon, and California; in St. Louis, Chicago, St.
Paul, and Minneapolis; Cleveland and Cincinnati; Boston and Cambridge, Mass.; in
St Augustine, Key West, and three other cities in Florida; Savannah and Valdosta,
Ca ; in connection with the Agricultural and Mechanical College of the State of Mis­
sissippi; and at Washington, D. C., itself. This work is now' stopped; unless it can
be resumed at an early date, the trained personnel who have done it will be lost.
If there is question as to the necessity of this work, the answer is the price of food.
If there is question as to whether the Government should do the work, the answer is
that thete is no other agency which is nation wide that can do it, and to use separate
agencies for the pur;tose would be both expensive and impracticable. If the ques­
tion of economy is raised, the answer is that by the services of four persons the whole
country can be reached at an expense of S15.000, and one might ask in turn by what
other means so great a result can be had for so little. If the question of urgency is
raised , the answer is that the pressure of high prices is a living, hurtful fact which calls
for every possible step showing hope of either improvement or remedy. Finally, if
there is question as to the success of this work, the answer is that in every State in
which meetings have been held voluntary expressions of appreciation of the useful­
ness and importance of the w'ork have come from housewives,-from women’s clubs,
from organizations for food conservation, from stewards’ associations, from restaurant
owners’ associations, from hotel owners’ associations, from chambers of commerce,
from the heads of domestic science schools and colleges, and from the fishery trade.
Voluntar)' letters commending the work have come from—
San Francisco Center of the California Civic League.
Twentieth Century Club, Berkeley, Calif.
Director of food conservation for city and county of San Francisco, Calif.
Community Service Organization, St. Louis, Mo.
Home Demonstration Office, St. Louis, Mo.
International Stewards’ Association, Chicago, 111.
Again and again iromen have called attention to the fact that they had been using
little or no fish food because of some groundless prejudice or because of ignorance, and
have testified to the value of the meetings to them in teaching the value and excel­
lence of properly cooked fish. Fifteen thousand women have received direct instruc­
tion and many thousand more have been indirectly but effectively reached.
There is lack of appreciation of the food value of fishery products. There is ignor­
ance of the relative merits of the different fish. There is failure to employ the best
methods of preparing them for the table. For these reasons, there is a failure to util­
ize an abundant and available supply of aquatic foods, which are both wholesome
and cheap. There was no need for cheap food during the war that does not now exist.

R EPO R T OF TH E SE C R E T A R Y OF COMMERCE.

229

It can be by no means said with truth that an emergency existed which has passed
away. Tire answer to such a suggestion is found in every household.
The demonstrations have emphasized the need of eating little-used or neglected
products Among those that have been demonstrated are the flounders, roekfishcs,
sable fish (Pacific black cod), sand dab sharks, skates, sole, squid, whale, whiting,
• the milts and livers of salmon, and the roe and buck’ roe of various fishes. In the
Middle West, however, special emphasis was laid upon the use of frozen fish, of which
there were abnormally large stocks in the cold storages of the country.
The careful buying of fish has been taught and also the way of utilizing the head
and trimmings, which parts are richer in flavor, but usually thrown away, as well as
correct methods of cooking, insuring economy in the use, not of the food alone, but
of the fats and oils, and saving time in both cooking and serving.
The Department of Commerce, through the Bureau of Fisheries, has been fortunate
in the personnel employed upon this work, and particularly in obtaining the services
of women able to combine with their demonstrations of how to live more cheaply in
these trying times such teachings of domestic management as tend to build up and
hold together the home. Housewives all over the country arc loud in their praise
of finding an easy and inexpensive way of cooking fish, and particularly at finding
many kinds of cheap fish and fishery products of which they never heard. Our dem­
onstrations have shown them how to get a dinner for four persons at a cost of 25 cents,
or two meals for 40 cents, and in spite of the high prices ruling they have always been
able to introduce cheaper varieties procured from the local markets in which the
demonstrations were held. Literally, this is the work of showing how two dinners
can be had for what has been the cost of one, and the lesson has been taught that while
there is perhaps little immediate hope for marked reduction in the price of meat,
poultry, eggs, or milk, there can be found in various kinds of fish now little used, or
not used at all, cheap and sustaining food in abundance. A work of such profound
benefit to our people, which so directly promotes the welfare of every home ought
not, in my judgment, to be set aside. I am convinced that the Bureau of Fisheries
in tapping supplies of little-used or unused food has done a service which will out­
weigh manyfold the monetary value of the appropriation requested and I am equally
convinced that when the importance of this work is known and realized there will be
but few voices raised save in its favor. It has been the most direct and effective con­
tribution of the Bureau of Fisheries to the needs of the homes of the country and to
the improvement of health and to removing the anxious cares which the price of living
impose upon many of our people.
This subject came up incidentally on the floor of the House of Representatives, at
which time mention was made that in connection with the introduction of certain
fishery foods faults had been found, and that an estimate had been presented to make
good certain claims believed by this department to be morally sound This is men­
tioned only to point out that the two subjects are neither the same nor are they alike.
They originated in different branches of the Fishery Service The out had to do with the
preservation of canned goods by business houses who are packersof such goods; the other
lias to do only with domestic cooking. No argument from the one can bear upon the
other. This is the more true that the faults tn connection with the canned product
were long since corrected and the product itself is now an established article of food.
Finally, may I suggest that if there be force in the statement that any group of
producers do in any measure dominate the markets for food, here is a practical means
of competition, opening a supply not dependent upon the will or the interest of any
man or group of men, but found on every shore, in our lakes and streams. It can be
had in many places for the taking if its value is made known and the people are taught
its use. Let me conclude by quoting from the Fisheries Bulletin for March 1, a letter
from a student in the San Diego (Calif.) High School*
" * * * I would like to say a few words of commendation and praise in regard to
the wonderful work your representative, Mrs. Spencer, is doing here in our city.
She is waking the women and girls up to see what their duty is to their country,
themselves, and others.
“ For two years I have done a goodly part of the family cooking, but I never had
any realization of the nourishment in fish. I thought beef and other meats were
the only animal foods of any value, but Mrs. Spencer has opened my eyes, and I
intend to use a great deal of fish, and I feel sure that other people feel the same way.
" I received, though, a greater lesson from Mrs. Spencer’s talks than the use and
utilization of fish. She made it so plain that the young girl of America must become
proficient in all the housewifely arts; that unless she does she will wreck not only
her own life but the lives of her family. I think that this part of Mrs. Spencer’s work
is going to run deepest, and I sincerely hope she will 'drive it home’ in every part of
the United States, for the girls of America need to be educated out of the false con­
ceptions they have of what a lady should be proficient in .”

230

R E P O R T OE TH E S E C R E T A R Y O F COMMERCE.

I may add also the following from a Chicago broker and wholesale dealer in frh
“ I take pleasure in advising you that your Mr. H. L. K elly and Mrs. Spencer did
the fish industry a great benefit in their recent exhibition of cooking and serving
fish in Chicago. Not only were the meetings a success but the amount of advertising
given the fish industry through their efforts has had immediate effect upon the con­
sumption of fish in Chicago. Mr. K elly did everything possible to interest not only*
the fish dealers but also the stewards and chefs of the leading hotels in Chicago. Work
of this kind tends to bring the fish prominently* before not only the housewife but the
patrons of hotels and restaurants, and tends to the general good of the fish business.”
For the reasons above stated, I beg to renew* my request that the matter be again
considered.
The same fate befell this second effort of the Department to secure the support of
Congress in a successful endeavor to reduce the cost of living, as a part of the general
movement of the Government to that end. The unfavorable action w*as based on
the same erroneous argument as in the first place, namely, that the Department wa
striving to get authority for a project similar to that undertaken with regard to the
dogfish. The official judgment of Congress was pronounced as follows:
[E xtract from rem arks in th e H ouse of R epresentatives b y Hon. J. W . Good, chairm an of the Com m ittee
on A ppropriations, Sept. 16, 1919, during consideration of th e first deficiency appropriation hill (H . R
9205) See Congressional Record. Sept. 16. 1919, p 5869.]

Of the estimates submitted by the Department of Commerce for relief of the high
cost of living, $75,000 was for the purpose of demonstration of methods of preparing
and cooking fish. Congress has had some experience with this department on this
very same subject. In the act approved June 21, 1016, the Department of Commerce
was given $25,000 to conduct investigations and experiments with regard to dogfish.
Out of that appropriation the department did make an investigation and demonstra­
tion in the matter of cooking and canning dogfish and gave the results of its investi­
gation to the eanners. A great many canncrs of fish canned dogfish in accordance
with the instructions of this department. The result was not satisfactory. After
these fish had been canned and disposed of tiie cans commenced to explode, and
hist year the Department of Commerce came before Congress with an estimate of
$60,000 to reimburse these eanners who had canned dogfish in accordance with the
methods which had been demonstrated by the Department of Commerce.
A great many of these estimates for reducing the high cost of living are of the dog­
fish character and if granted would give just about as much relief as did the $25,000
previously appropriated for dogfish demonstrations. The people want relief from
high prices, not dogfish demonstrations.
This more recent statement, like the former from the same source, contains impor­
tant misstatements, omits essential facts in regard to the dogfish work, and wholly
ignores the main issue. A partial and temporary* failure in a pioneer effort that was
deliberately curtailed by Congress is used as an argument against a wholly different
piece of work that has proved highly successful.
The assumption of a moral obligation to reimburse eanners to the amount of $45,000
or $60,000 for losses incurred in an effort originating with Congress itself to mitigate a
great public nuisance may be a highly* reprehensible act for which this Department
should be held up for criticism and blame. The other side of the balance sheet,
however, should be considered. It should be remembered that, as an alternative t°
the course recommended by the Department, there was pending in Congress and
strongly backed a proposition that the Government should go into the business of
manufacturing fertilizer from sharks and should pay a bounty on sharks, and that
there should be built and operated as many as too fertilizer plants which were
avowedly* to be maintained at a large annual loss. For a period of five y*ears the amount
of money* required to carry* out the terms of the proposed legislation would have been
not less than $20,000,000, and at the end of that time the Government would have
had on its hands some expensive plants of no further usefulness, and the permanent
abundance of dogfishes would have been affected no more than by a debate in Congress.
This Department has with justice opposed measures which involved the possibility
of such inroads on the Treasury* and prevented, at least temporarily, any further
efforts in the same direction. It has been prevented, on grounds wholly unrelated
to the subject, from continuing a successful, cheap, and efficient work of adding to
our food supply in a time of need.

INDEX
Page.
A bbott, Jam es F ., commercial-attaché activi­
t i e s . . . , ............................ *............................
83
Acciden ts on vessels..............................................
183
A dvertising for proposals, ex penditures..........
63
Aeronautical instrum ents, S tandards Bureau
te sts...............................................................
122
Aeroplane, use in hydrography and topog­
ra p h y ............................................................
179
Ages, pensioners’. Census B ureau searches...
134
registrants. Census Bureau tran scrip ts.........
136
A griculture D epartm ent, close cooperation
needed w ith Commerce D e p a rtm e n t.. 205
Aids to navigation, A lask a............................ 27» 28,32
appropriations and e x penditures................... 27,28
Lighthouse S ervice...........................................
159
1910 an d 1919........................................................
208
A ir Mail Service, cooperation of Standards
B ureau..........................................................
107
Air service, A rm y and N avy, research labora­
tory needed..................................................
180
Akron In d u strial Salvage Co. (Inc.), report.
7*
Alaska, aids to nav ig atio n ...................... 27,28,32,160
appropriations an d expenditures, Fisheries
B u re au ..........................................................
31
census, 1920..........................................................
X9
fisheries service...................................................
152
Fourteenth C ensus............................................
143
fur-bearing an im als...........................................
157
fur-seal service....................................................
153
K etchikan, lighthouse d e p o t..........................
162
navigation aids, legislative n eed s...................
166
seal h e rd ...............................................................
155
surveys, wire-drag, n eed ed..............................
178
unexpended balances, fisheries service.........
35
waters, surveys n eed ed ....................................
176
Alien P roperty Custodian, cooperation of
statistical division, Foreign and Domes­
tic Commerce B u re au .......................
95
Allied Cham ber of Commerce, Buenos Aires .
83
A llotm ents and expenditures, national se­
c urity and defense fu n d .............................
23,
24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32
A ltitude laboratory. Stan d ard s B u reau......... 17,112
Ameriean-Canadian Fisheries Conference....... 8,158
A merican Cham ber of Commerce, Barcelona,
cooperation of commercial a ttach és___
82
Brazil, cooperation of commercial attach és.
83
London, cooperation of commercial attachés
79
American Economic Association, coopera­
tion of Census B u reau ............................ 139.142
A merican Electric R ailw ay Association W ar
Board, cooperation of Census B u re a u ..
137
A merican Expeditionary Force, cooperation
of trade commissioners..............................
8s
food surveys........................................................
80

Page

American Leather Research Laboratory,
cooperation of Standards B u reau ...........
120
American Medical Association, cooperation
of Standards B ureau.................................
116
Am erican-Russian Cham ber of Commerce,
cooperation of Russian division, Foreign
and Dom estic Commerce B u reau...........
93
American ships, steel and wooden tonnage,
1914 and 1919...................................................
189
Am erican Society for Testing Materials, co­
operation of editorial division, Foreign
and Dom estic Commerce B u reau....................... 99
American Statistical Association, coopera­
tion of Census B ureau............................ 139,142
Am erican vessels, registered...............................
188
tonnage, 1914-1919.............................................
18$
Anderson, Norm an L ., trade-commissioner
a c tivities......................................................
85
A ppointm ent Division, printing and binding,
co s t...................................
60
Appreciation, letters, Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B u reau .....................................
78
Appropriations and expenditures, aids to
navigation .................................................... 27,28
bureaus and services.........................................
2a
Census B u reau .............................................. 23,27.32
Coast and Geodetic S u r v e y .............................. 23,32
estim ates, 1921....................................................
36
com parison......................................................
38
fish hatcheries....................................................
26
Fisheries B u reau .................................... 23,26,29.3*
Foreign and Dom estic Commerce B u r e a u .. 23,30
increase recom m ended..................................
xox
increase of com pensation...................... 23,27,29,30
Lighthouse Service, details.............................
28
1919 and 1920....................................................
165
special w o rk s...................................................
167
vessels...............................................................
209
Lighthouses B u reau .................................... 23,27,32
Navigation B u reau ..........................
23,26,31
printing and bin d in g........................................ 23.59
river and harbor im provem ents.....................
207
Secretary's O ffice........................................... . 23,30
shipbuilding, Em ergency Fleet Corporation
207
N a v y D epartm en t........................................
207
Standards B u reau ....................................... 23,24,30
Steam boat-Inspection S erv ice................. 23,25, 31
wire-drag launches............................................
177
Aquarium , laboratory, Fisheries Bureau . . . .
17
Archives b u ild in g.................................................
19
A rm y, air service, research laboratory needed.
x8o
Census Bureau em ployees...............................
137
cooperation of Standards Bureau. 102,107,121,122
Arnold, Julean, comincrcial-attaché activi­
ties. ................................................................
8«
3 3 1

234
Council of National Defense, cooperation.

IN D E X .

Page.

Census B u reau ............................................
135
foreign-investigations division. Foreign
and Domestic Commerce B ureau .........
85
statistical division, Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B ureau.....................................
95
Coast and Geodetic Survey, aeroplane, use in
hydrography and topography................
179
appropriations and expenditures.................. 23,32
building, need of suitable................................
181
charts, etc., sales................................................
33
contributions. State fair exh ibits.................. 65,66
cooperation. N a v y D epartm en t.....................
181
W ar D epartm ent...........................................
181
employees in A rm y and N a v y .......................
180
estimates, 1921....................................................
37
compared with appropriations, 1920.........
41
fie ld w o rk ........................................................ 170,173
hydrographic work, A tlan tic coast...............
172
Pacific coast....................................................
172
hydrography, ship, described........................
174
launches, wire-drag, needed...........................
178
m agnetic observatories.....................................
173
marine service....................................................
12
national security and defense fund, allot­
m ent ..............................................................
29
new b u ild in g......................................................
13
personnel, changes............................................ 43,44
precise levels, ru n .............................................
173
printing and binding, cost..............................
60
publications...................................................... 61,168
sales...................................................................
63
receipts, m iscellaneous....................................
33
salaries, inadequate...........................................
56
surveys needed, A laska............................... 176,178
A tlan tic co ast.................................................
176
Florida coast...................................................
177
G ulf coast........................................................
176
Long Island So u n d .......................................
177
N ew England coast.......................................
177
Pacific coast....................................................
176
Panam a C anal................................................
178
Porto R i c o . . . ................................................
178
Virgin Islands.................................................
178
tidal observations, sum m ary.........................
172
triangulation, sum m ary..................................
172
unexpended balances.......................................
35
vessels, condensed statem en t..................... 171,172
construction costs, comparisons.................
210
hydrographic sum m ary...............................
172
operations........................................................
180
returned b y N a v y .........................................
170
transferred from N a v y ........................
171,173
transferred to N a v y ......................................
1S0
urgent needs...................................................
174
war w o rk.............................................................
180
Cross R ip Ligh t Vessel No. 6, destroyed__ 10,208
Custom s Service, cooperation of statistical
division. Foreign and Dom estic Com­
merce B ureau.............................................
96
printing and binding, cost.........................
60
supplies...............
64
Deaths, Census Bureau statistics.....................
130
registration. Federal legislation needed . . . .
130
D e K a lb , Courtenay, mineral-resources in ­
vestigation, S p a in ......................................
87

Page.

Dennis. Alfred P ., com m ercial-attache a c tiv ­
ities ................................................................
82
Depots, Lighthouse Service, construction---16a
Diamond Shoal Light Vessel No. 71, s u n k . . . 10,208
Director General oi Railroads, cooperation
of statistical division, Foreign and Do­
m estic Commerce B u re au .........................
95
Disbursem ents. S e e A ppropriations and
expenditures.
D isbursing Office, printing and binding, c o st.
60
D istrict and cooperative offices, Foreign and
Domestic Commerce Bureau, iticreased
appropriation recom m ended...................
100
sum m ary of w o rk ..........................................
87
Divorce statistics. Census B u re au .....................
132
D ocuments, S uperintendent of, publications
sold, 1918and 1919...................................... 62,63
Dogfish cam paign and controversy...................
213
D utch H arbor, .Alaska, purchase recom­
m ended .........................................................
67
Duties, navigation, receipts...............................
195
D ynam om eter laboratory, S tandards Bureau.
17
Editorial clerks, Publications Division,
additional, needed.................................. *
63
Editorial division, Foreign and Domestic
Commerce Bureau, cooperation w ith
A merican Society for Testing M aterials.
99
sum m ary of w ork..........................................
98
Education B ureau, cooperation of Census
B ureau........................................................ 19*143
E dw ards, Paul L.. commercial-attache activ­
itie s................................................................
8i
Efficiency, certificates issued, Steam boatInspection Service.....................................
183
Electrical industries. Census Bureau in q u iry . 128
Electrical safety code. Standards B u re au ---no
Electricity, Stan d ards Bureau division, w ork. 106
Electrolysis surveys. Standards B ureau .........
no
Em ergency Fleet Corporation, appropria­
tions, shipbuilding....................................
207
cooperation of Census B ureau........................
137
Employees. S e e Personnel.
E m ploym ent Service, cooperation of Census
B ureau........................................................*
1 37
Encum brances on homes and farms, Four­
teenth Census.............................................
142
Estim ates, appropriations, 1921........................
36
Coast and Geodetic Survey, 1921...................
37
comparison w ith appropriations, 1920.........
38
Fisheries Bureau, 1921.....................................
37
Foreign and Dom estic Commerce B ureau,
1 9 2 1 ................................................................
37
Lighthouse Service, X921..................................
37
vessels, appropriations needed....... ...........
209
N avigation Bureau, 1921.................................
37
Standards B ureau, 1921...................................
37
Steam boat-Inspection Service, 1921.............
37
Everley, H arold E., furniture-m arkets inves­
tigations........................................................
85
Ewing, W . W ., foreign-trade studies...............
85
Exam inations, applicants for licenses, Steam ­
boat-Inspection Service............................
185
Executive orders, A pril zi, 19x7. and M ay 24,
1919................................................................
10
E xhibits, S tate fair, cooperation of D epart­
m e n t..............................................................
65

IN D E X .
Pace.
E xpenditures, advertising for proposals.........
63
S e e a l s o A ppropriations and expenditures.
Explorer, Coast and Geodetic S urvey vessel,
operations................................................. 171,181

235
P ace.

Fisheries B ureau, fish culture, relations
w ith S ta te s .....................................................
148
fish hatcheries, B aker Lake, W ash., burned
147
Susquehanna River, Md., d o sed ...............
148
food fishes, consum ption.................................
213
F a r E astern circulars...........................................
92
new, in tro d u ctio n ..........................................
7
F a r Eastern division. Foreign and Domestic
propagation.....................................................
146
Commerce Bureau, contributions to
supply, n ational security and defense
Commerce R ep o rts....................................
91
fu n d ..............................................................
151
cooperation, Chinese G overnm ent............
92
fur-bearing anim als. A laska...........................
157
Shipping B o ard ..........................................
92
general considerations.................................... •
145
extension recom m ended.. .*........................
100
herring, Scotch-cured, 1917 and 1918............
153
lib rary ..............................................................
91
laboratory a q u a riu m ........................................
*7
sum m ary of w ork...........................................
91
legislation, fishery, needed..............................
158
F a ts and oils. Census Bureau statistics...........
133
m arine service..................................................
*2
Federal Reserve Board, close cooperation
m osquito-eating fishes, propagation.............
150
needed w ith Commerce D e p a rtm e n t...
203
mussels, p ropagation........................................
'49
cooperation of L atin A merican division,
new fish food, introduction, appropriation
Foreign and Domestic Commerce Bu­
urg ed .............................................................
7»
reau ...............................................................
89
Pacific salmon, investigations.................
149
Federal T rade Commission, close cooperation
personnel, changes............................................ 4 3 » 4 4
needed w ith Commerce D e p a rtm e n t...
204
Pribilof Islands, adm inistrative recommen­
cooperation of Census B u reau........................
136
d atio n s..........................................................
*54
Feely, Edw ard F., economic conditions,
printing and binding, cost..............................
60
Mexico, su rv e y ....................
86
public hearings, Seattle, W ash ......................
152
Fees, navigation, receipts...................................
195
publications............................................... 61.150,154
Ferrin, A. W ., commcrcial-attaché activities. 82,83
receipts.................................................................
33
Field force, Fourteenth C ensus.........................
139
salaries, in ad eq u ate...........................................
52
Field work, Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey — 170,173
sales, sealskins....................................................
*55
Financial statistics, cities, Census B ureau re­
salm on, hum pback, M aine..............................
'46
p o rt................................................................
131
seal census, 1918 and 1919................................
'5 5
States, Census Bureau re p o rt.........................
131
seining parties, v a lu e .......................................
75
Fines, navigation, receipts........................ ri, 193,200
shellfish investigations................................... .
'4 9
Fire-resistive tests, Standards B u re au ............
112
stranded fishes rescued....................................
147
Fish-cooking dem onstrations, allotm ent, na­
s u p p lie s ...,........................................................
f)4
225
tional security and defense fu n d ...........
unexpended balances...................
35
Fish culture, relations w ith S ta te s ...................
148
urgent needs.................................................
'9
Fish hatcheries, appropriations and expendi­
vessels, returned by N a v y ....................... "> * 4 S
tu re s ..............................................................
26
Roosevelt, operations.................................
*54
B aker Lake, W ash., b u rn e d ..........................
147
W oods Hole, Mass , station, relinquished by
estimates, 1921....................................................
41
N a v y .......................................................
*45
compared w ith appropriations, 1920.........
41
Fisheries treaty , sockeye salm on................
9
salaries, inadeq u ate...........................................
53 Fishery legislation n eed ed...........................
*58
Susquehanna R iver, Md., closed...................
148 Fishing vessels, port privileges...................
8
Fisheries, American-Canadian C onference...
8 Florida coast, surveys, wire-drag, needed---177
Fisheries Bureau, Alaska, fisheries s e n d e e ...
152
F lorida S tate authorities, cooperation of
fur-seal service................................................
153
Fisheries B u re au .......................................
' so
seal h e rd ...........................................................
155
Food A dm inistration, cooperation, Census
allotm ent and expenditures, national se­
B u reau ...................................................
'3 5
curity and defense fu n d ............................ 26,32
Foreign and Domestic Commerce B ureau. 89,95
appropriations and expenditures....... 23,26.29,3*
Food fishes, consum ption............................
213
aquatic leather, new sources..........................
151
new , in tro d u ctio n ............................................. 7 »7 »
Beaufort, N . C., station, relinquished by
p ropagation..................................................
'46
N a v y .............................................................
145
biological investigations..................................
148 Foreign and Domestic Commerce B ureau,
after-war service..................................
76
contributions, State fair e x h ib its.................. 65,66
allotm ent and expenditures, national secur­
cooperation. C hem istry Bureau, Agricul­
ity and defense fu n d .......................... 24.30
tu re D ep artm en t.......................................
149
appreciation, le tte rs..................................
7&
Florida S ta te au th o rities.............................
15e
appropriations and expenditures.......... 23,30,101
Louisiana S ta te conservation d epartm ent 148
classification, export, revision................
96
Public H ealth Sen d ee..................................
150
clerical force, increase recommended . . . . . . .
iot
dogfish campaign and controversy...............
213
Commerce R eports, p u b lication......... 9'.96,99
estim ates, 1921....................................................
37
commercial attachés, appropriation, in­
compared w ith appropriations, 1920.........
41
crease reco m m en d ed ............................
'o °
fish-cooking dem onstrations, allotm ent, na­
V
a c tiv itie s.................................................. 7 8 . 7 9
tional security and defense fu n d ..........
225

236

IN D E X .

Page.
Pagp.
Foreign an d Dom estic Commerce B ureau,
Foreign an d Domestic Commerce Bureau,
cooperation, American Cham ber oí Com­
electrical-goods m arkets, I ta ly ...................
86
merce, B arcelona................................
82
S outh Africa and In d ia ............................
87
B razil....................., .................................
S3
South A m erica...........................................
86
financial conditions, England and the
L o n d o n .....................................................
79
C o n tin en t.................................................
87
Interallied C ontingent C om m ission___
80
S p a in .............................................................
86
Interallied Trade C o m m ittee.................
81
furniture m arkets. South A m erica...........
85
Liquidation Commission of A rm y........
81
industrial-m achinery m arkets, F a r E ast.
87
M arkets B ureau, South D akota.............
8s
France and B elgium .................................
86
National'Association of Hosiery & K n it
I ta ly ..............................................................
86
Goods M anufacturers............................
84
jewelry and silverware, L a tin A merican
N ational Industrial Conefrence B o ard ..
84
m a rk e ts.....................................................
86
R hineland High Commission.................
80
leather m arkets, E urope..............................
87
Shipping B oard.........................................
83
lum ber m a rk e ts.............................................
85
Suprem e Economic Council.................... 80,81
m achine-tools m arkets, England and the
U nited States Sugar Equalization
C o n tin e n t.................................................
87
B o ard........................................................
84
m ineral and tin problem s............................
79
W ar D ep artm en t.......................................
79
m ineral resources, C hina..............................
87
W ar T rade B o ard ........................... 79,80,81,83
S p a in .............................................................
87
W orld Cotton Conference.........................
84
textile m arkets, South A m erica....................
87
food surveys, A merican Expeditionary
tex tile su b stitu te s.............................................
80
Force.............................................................
80
trad e conditions, R u m a n ia ..........................
86
national security and defense fund, allot­
transportation and port facilities, C hina---87
m e n t.........................................
78
tropical products, Central A m erica..............
86
readju stm en t...................................................
78
K ennedy P hilip B., appointed director---79
cooperation. Census Bureau, w ar w ork.......
136
L atin America, syllabus..................................
90
Council of National D efense.......................
85
trade prom otion.............................................
99
Shipping B o ard ........................................... .
S5
L atin American circulars................................
90
S tate D ep artm en t.........................................
204
L atin A merican division, extension recom­
W a r D ep artm en t.....................................
85
mended .........................................................
10
W ar Industries B o ard ..................................
85
sum m ary of w ork ..........................................
88
W ar Trade B o ard .........................................
85
library. F a r Eastern d ivision.........................
91
d istrict an d cooperative offices..................... 87,100
personnel, changes............................................ 4 3 » 4 4
editorial division, sum m ary of w ork............
98
post allowances recom m ended.......................
100
employees, additional n e ed ............................
56
p rin tin g and binding, cost..............................
60
estim ates, 1 9 3 1 ....................................................
37
publications................................................... 61,85,86
compared w ith appropriations, 1920........
39
research division, sum m ary of w ork............
97
F a r Eastern circulars.......................................
92
R ussian division, cooperation, AmericanF ar Eastern division, cooperation. Chinese
R ussian Cham ber of Commerce.........
93
G overnm ent............................................
92
cham bers of com m erce.............................
93
Shipping B o ard ..........................................
92
L abor D e p artm e n t..................................
93
extension recom m ended..............................
100
N ational Association of American Man­
sum m ary of w o rk ..........................................
91
u factu rers.............................................
93
Foreign Commerce and N avigation, publi­
N ational B ank of Commerce...................
93
catio n ............................................................
96
N ational C ity B ank, New Y o rk .------93
foreign tariffs division, cooperation, Post
Poland R ep ublic........................................
93
Office D e p artm e n t....................................
98
Russian-American C om m ittee' for F ar
sum m ary of w o rk .............. ...........................
98
93
E a s t.......................................................
foreign trade, allotm ent, national security
R ussian Economic League......................
93
and defense fu n d ........................................
78
R ussian E m bassy................................ ..
93
investigations.................................................
78
Shipping B o ard ..........................................
93
totals.................................................................
77
S ta te D ep artm en t......................................
93
in dustrial standards series, p u b lic a tio n .. . .
99
W ar D ep artm en t.......................................
93
investigations, advertising m ethods, Latin
W ar Trade B oard......................................
93
A merican countries...................................
86
extension recom m ended..............................
100
agricultural-m achinery m arkets, France.
86
R ussian division, lib rary ............................
92
autom obile m arkets, England and th e
sum m ary of w ork..........................................
9a
C ontinent....................................................
86
salaries, in ad eq u ate..........................................
53
Bolivia and Paraguay’s tra d e ...................
87
S tatistical A bstract, publication................... 96.97
chem ical industries, E u ro p e ......................
86
statistical division, cooperation, Alien
construction m aterials and m achinery,
P roperty C u sto d ian ...............
95
S outh American m a rk e ts........................
8s
C entral Bureau of Planning and Sta­
cottonseed-hull fiber m ark ets............. .
79
tistics ........................................................
95
economic conditions, Greece......................
86
Council of N ational D efense...................
95
Mexico. ..................................................... •
86
Customs Service, Treasury D epartm ent
96
S w itzerland......................................... .
80

IN D E X .
Page.
Foreign and Dom estic Commerce Bureau,
D irector General of R ailroads....................
95
Food A dm inistration........................ i ........
95
Geological S u rv ey ..........................................
9S
M arkets Bureau, A griculture D epart­
m ent ..............................................................
95
M ines B u re au .................................................
95
Public Inform ation C o m m ittee..................
95
Shipping B oard..............................................
94
W ar Industries B o ard ..................................
95
W ar M inerals C om m ittee............................
95
W ar T rade B o ard ..........................................
95
Swedish and Norwegian contracts, allot­
m en t, national security an d defense
fund...............................................................
79
trad e commissioners, cooperation w ith
American Expeditionary Force.............
85
investigations.................................................
78
v ital w ork .............................
85
trade-inform ation division..............................
93
trade-m arks, legislation and p iracy ..............
9S
Trade of U nited States w ith W orld, publi­
cation ............................................................
96
unexpended balances.......................................
34
w ar w ork............................................................. 83,136
Foreign Commerce and Navigation, publica­
tion ................................................................
96
Foreign-tariffs division, Foreign and Domes­
tic Commerce B ureau, cooperation w ith
Post Office D e p artm e n t...........................
98
sum m ary of w o rk ..........................................
98
Foreign Trade A dvisers, S tate D epartm ent,
cooperation of L atin A m erican divi­
sion, Foreign and Dom estic Commerce
B u re au ..........................................................
89
Foreign trade, to ta ls.............................................
77
Forest Products Service, A griculture De­
partm ent, cooperation w ith In d u strial
Cooperation Service..................................
69
Forw ard (formerly Patterson), Coast and
Geodetic Survey vessel, o p eratio n s.. 171,181
Fourteenth Census, A laska................................
143
changes, legislative, from T h irte en th Census 138
encum brances, homes and farm s...................
142
estim ates, 1921......................................
36
field force.............................................................
X3 9
G u a m ...................................................................
143
H a w a ii..................................................................
M3
mechanical e q u ip m e n t....................................
143
office force, exam inations................................
142
Panam a Canal Z one.........................................
143
Porto R ico...........................................................
143
preparations........................................................
138
Sam oa...................................................................
143
schedules, preparation......................................
142
supervisors, Secretary's in stru ctio n s........ 140,141
14°
test e x am in atio n ...........................................
Fowler, John A., foreign-trade investigations,
D utch E a st Indies an d S traits Settle­
m ents ............................................................
87
Fuel A dm inistration, cooperation of Census
B ureau..........................................................
136
F u n stcn Bros. & Co., seal skins, sales.............
156
Fur-bearing anim als, A laska......................
157
Fur-seal service. A lask a......................................
153

237

Page.
G ardenia, lighthouse tender, c o n d em n ed .. . 10.208
G arry, L. S., textiles investigation, South
A m erica.................................................
87
Gas buoys, Lighthouse Service, 1910 and 1919.
208
General Electric Co., cooperation of Census
B u reau ...................................................
134
General statistics of cities, Census Bureau
re p o rts...................................................
131
General S upply Committee, cooperation of
S tandards B u reau .................................. 120,126
Geological Survey, cooperation, Census B u­
reau ..................................................................
j9
L atin American division, Foreign and
Domestic Commerce B ureau.............
89
statistical division. Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B ureau...............................
95
Geringer, V ladim ir A., foreign-trade investi­
gations, Czechoslovakia......................
87
Glass, optical, Standards B ureau studies---113
G overnm ent commercial organization, uni­
fied, needed...........................................
202
G rady, H arry F ., financial-conditions in­
vestigation, England and th e Conti­
n e n t.........................................................
87
Crayfish (dogfish) cam paign and controversy
213
Greenhouses, commercial, census.....................
135
Groves, H . Lawrence, agricultural-m achinery
investigations.............................................
86
G uam , Fou rteen th Census.................................
143
Gulf coast, surveys n eed ed .................................
176
tidal observations..............................................
172

;
|
i
!

I
j
j

H anch, Charles C.. autom obile investigations.
86
H awaii. Fou rteen th Census...............................
X43
H ealth Index, W eekly, Census B ureau pub­
lication..........................................................
130
H eat m easurem ents, S tandards B u re au .........
1x1
H erring, Scotch-cured, 19:7 and 1918.............
153
H ertz, N orm an L., leather investigations,
E u ro p e ..........................................................
87
Honolulu, lighthouse depot, urgent n e e d .. . .
163
m agnetic observatory.......................................
173
H ull and boiler construction, centralization
of approval n eed ed ....................................
384
H untington, Dr. W illiam C., commercialattache a ctiv ities........................................ 81,92
H urd, R obert E., commercial activities.........
84
H ydrography, A tlantic coast ..........................
172
Pacific coast........................................................
X72
ship, described...................................................
174
su m m ary.............................................................
172
use of aeroplane.................................................
379

! Increase of com pensâtiou, appropriations, and
ex penditures........ ........................... 23? 2 7 , 39» 30
; unexpended balances.......................................
34
; In d ian a S ta te commission, coal-gas tests,
S tan d ard s B u re au ....................................
109
j In d u strial Board, allotm ent and expendi­
tures, national security and defense
fu n d .....................................................
23,30
p rin tin g and binding, expenditures, na­
tional security and defense fu n d ............
60
sum m ary of w ork....................................
68

23
,

»

IN D E X .

Page.
ind u strial Cooperation Service, allotm ent
and expenditures, national security and
defense fu n d ........................................... 23,30.69
cooperation. Book Publishers' Association.
70
Forest Products Service, A griculture De­
p a rtm e n t...............................................
69
National C redit M en’s A ssociation..........
70
S tandards B u reau ..................................
69
W ar D ep artm en t...................................
69
need for continuance.................................
73
printing and binding, expenditures, na­
tional security and defense fu n d ..........
60
publication w o rk ........................................
61
sum m ary of w ork.......................................
69
Industrial laboratory, new , S tandards B ureau
124
Industrial reconstruction, Standards Bureau
cooperation...........................................
126
In dustrial safety codes. S tandards Bureau
conference.............................................
110
Industrial standards series, publication........
99
Influenza epidemic, Census Bureau inves­
tigatio n..................................................
133
Inspections, rad io .......................................
196
steel plates for boilers, Steam boat-Inspec­
tion Service.................................................
183
vessels, Steam boat-Inspection Service........
183
Integrating counter, tabulating device. Cen­
sus B ureau.........................
143
Interallied C ontingent Commission, Paris,
cooperation of commercial a ttach és. . . .
80
Interallied Parliam entary Conference, Lon­
don, cooperation of com m ercial a t­
tachés ...........................................................
79
Interallied Trade Committee, cooperation of
commercial a tta ch é s..................................
81
Internal R evenue B ureau, contribution, fuel
and salary....................................................
11
cooperation of N avigation B ureau................
201
International Conference on Safety of Life a t
Sea, recom m endations..............................
194
International High Commission, close co­
operation needed w ith Commerce De­
p a rtm e n t......................................................
204
International Radiotélégraphie Conference ..
198
International S tatistical Y ear Book, Census
B ureau publication.............................
134
In terstate Commerce Commission, close co­
operation needed w ith Commerce De­
p a rtm e n t.................... \ ..............................
203
Isis, Coast and Geodetic Survey vessel, op­
era tio n s..................................................... 171,180
Jones, Chester Lloyd, commercial-attaché
activ ities................................................
81
Justice D epartm ent, cooperation of Census
B ureau ....................................................
136
K ennedy, P h ilip B., appointed director. For­
eign and Domestic Commerce B ureau.
79
commercial-attaché activ ities.................. 78,79
K etchikan. Alaska, lighthouse d e p o t........
162
K ey W est. Fla., lighthouse depot, urgent
need............................................
163
Klein. D r. Julius, commercial-attaché activ ­
itie s..........................................................
83

Page.

Labor D epartm ent, cooperation, Census B u­
reau ..............................................................
136
R ussiaif division. Foreign and Domestic
93
Commerce B ureau.....................................
Laboratories, altitude. S tandards B u re au ... 17,113
17
aquarium . Fisheries B u re au ..........................
industrial. Standards B ureau...................... 15.124
shellfish, Milford, C onn....................................
149
L am bert conformal conic protection, p ub­
lications........................................................
168
L atin America, preparation of syllabus for
instructors an d s tu d e n ts ..........................
90
tra d e prom otion.................................................
99
L atin American circulars....................................
90
L atin A merican division, cooperation, Fed­
eral Reserve B oard...................................
89
Food A d m in istration....................................
89
Foreign Trade Advisers, S tate D epart­
m en t ..........................................................
89
Geological S u rv ey..........................................
89
Peace Conference...........................................
89
Public Inform ation C om m ittee.................
89
Shipping B o ard.............................................
89
W ar D ep artm en t...........................................
88
W ar Trade B o ard ..........................................
89
extension recom m ended..................................
100
sum m ary of w ork..............................................
88
Launch hydrography, su m m ary ......................
172
Launches, wire-drag, appropriations...............
177
needed..............................................................
178
n e w ....................................................................
10
Leaf tobacco. Census B ureau reports...............
132
Leather, aquatic sources......................................
159
S tandards Bureau studies...............................
120
Leaves of absence d uring y e a r...........................
45
Legislation, boiler pressure, needed.................
186
bulkheads construction, needed....................
199
load-line, needed................................................
199
special. Lighthouse Service, needed.............
165
tonnage m easurem ent, needed.......................
199
Liberty Loan. Census Bureau subscriptions .
136
subscriptions, su m m ary ..................................
66
Library, D ep artm en t...........................................
6s
bar Eastern division, Foreign and Domestic
91
Commerce B ureau.....................................
Russian division, Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B ureau.....................................
92
Standards B u reau .............................................
102
Licenses, applicants, exam inations. *...............
185
issued, Steam boat-Inspection Service..................... 183
Life preservers tested. Steam boat-Inspection
Service..........................................................
183
Life tables. Census B ureau .................................
133
Light, Standards Bureau studies......................
115
Lighthouse Service, aids to navigation,
Alaska, legislation recom m ended..........
166
1910 and 1919...................................................
208
su m m ary ..........................................................
151
Virgin Islands, appropriation recom­
m en d e d ........................................................
166
Lighthouse Service, allotm ent and expend­
itures, national security and defense
appropriations and expenditures................. 28,165

IN D E X .

239

Page.
Page.
183
Lighthouse Service, special w o rk s...................
167 Lives lost, accidents, vessels..............................
Lives saved b y appliances..................................
184
vessels...............................................................
2°9
Lloyd’s Register, vessel tonnage................... 189,191
Bush Bluff light vessel, condem ned..............
208
Load lines, legislation needed............................
199
cooperation. N avy D e p artm e n t................... 10.159
T reasury D e p artm e n t..................................
159 Long Island Sound, surveys, wire-drag,
needed..........................................................
I77
W ar D e p artm e n t...........................................
*59
Cornfield Poin t Shoal light vessel, s u n k ---208 Louisiana S tate conservation departm ent, co­
operation of Fisheries B ureau....................
I4s
Cross R ip light vessel, destroyed...................
208
Luchars, A lexander, machine-tools investiga­
depots, construction and rep air.....................
162
tion, England and the C ontinent.........
87
H onolulu, urgent n eed .................................
163
Lundquist, R. A., electrical-goods investiga­
K etchikan........................................................
162
tions, South Africa and In d ia .................
87
K ey W est, Fla., urgent n eed......................
163
Portsm outh, V a., appropriation n e ed e d .. 163 Magnetic observatories. Coast and Geodetic
Tom pkinsville. N . Y .................................. 28,162
S u rv ey .........................
i 73
208 Mailing lists, Publications D ivision.................
D iam ond Shoal light vessel, s u n k ................
63
estimates, 1921.........................
37
M arine services. D ep artm ent’s ................
9
compared w ith appropriations, 1920.........
38 M aritim e problem .................................................
IQ3
I9a
Gardenia, lighthouse tender, condem ned...
208 M aritime situation, facts.....................................
gas buoys, 1910 an d 1919..................................
208 M arkets B ureau, Agriculture D epartm ent,
cooperation of statistical division. For­
gas shore lights, 1910 an d 1919........................
208
eign and Domestic Commerce Bureau.
personnel.............................................................
164
South D akota, cooperation of commercial
printing and binding, cost..............................
60
a tta ch é s............................................................
gs
publications, sales basis...................................
164
x3a
radio eq u ip m en t................................................
163 Marriage statistics, Census B ureau......................
relation to other G overnm ent a ctiv ities. . . .
207 Marshall, W . G., industrial-m achinery inves­
tigations...........................................................
86
retirem ent sy stem ......................................... 164. 167
industrial-gas
investigation,
salaries, field.......................................................
48 M aryland,
Standards
B
ureau.................................
.
109
saving of life an d p ro p e rty ..............................
164
135
special legislation need ed ................................
165 M aterials and commodities, war, census........
stations, returned by N a v y ............................
15Q Materials, structural aud miscellaneous.
Standards
Bureau
t
e
s
t
s
..........................
supplies................................................................
64
Meats, Eliot G., economic-conditions investi­
T hirty-F ive Foot Channel light vessel,
gation, Greece.................................................
86
b u rn e d ........................................... ............ xo, 208
199
urgent needs.......................................................
xg Measurement, tonnage, legislation needed__
vessels. C edar......................................................
154 Mechanical equipm ent. Fourteenth C en su s.. 143
condition and necessity for u pkeep..........
207 M erchant marine, supervision, Navigation
B ureau..............................................................
54
construction costs, com parisons.................
2x0
122
estim ates, appropriations n eed ed ..............
209 Metals, Standards B ureau studies........................
149
lost and condem ned.................................. 161,208 Milford, Conn., shellfish laboratory....................
Mines B ureau, cooperation, Census B u re a u ..
19
operations.................................................... 162,707
requiring replacem ent..................................
211
statistical division, Foreign and Domestic
returned by N a v y .........................................
159
Commerce B ureau.........................................
95
transferred to N a v y ......................................
208 M ontavon, W illiam A., commercial attaché,
unobtainable from N a v y .............................
209
activities..............................................................
84
unobtainable from Shipping B o ard ..................... 209
resignation..........................................................
81
urgent needs...................................................
207 Mosquito-eating fishes, Fisheries Bureau
war w ork..........................................................
208
propagation.................................................
iso
Lighthouses Bureau, allotm ent and expendi­
Motion pictures, use in in d u s try ...........................
at
tures, national security and defense fund
27 Motor boats, num bering undocum ented........
201
appropriations and expenditures............. 23,27,32
transferred b y N a v y .........................................
201
contributions. S tate fair ex h ib its................. 65,66 Motor vehicles, equipm ent and operation ---- 63,64
m arine service....................................................
12 Motor-vessel fleet, N avigation B ureau ............
11
personnel, changes............................................. 4 3 > 4 4
Mussels, propagation...........................................
149
printing and binding, c o st..............................
6o
N ational Advisory Committee for A eronaut­
publication w o rk ...............................................
61
ics, cooperation of Standards B ureau..
1x3
receipts.................................................................
33
tenders and vessels returned by N a v y ..........
10 N ational Association of American M anufac­
turers, cooperation of R ussian division,
unexpended balances.......................................
35
Foreign and Domestic Commerce Bu­
vessels, lost an d c o n d em n ed ... ...................
10
reau ...................................................................
9
n e ed e d ..............................................................
xa
N ational Association of Cotton M anufactur­
Lights, gas shore, Lighthouse Service, 1910
ers, cooperation of Census B u re au ........
134
and 19x9........................................................
208
Lime, S tandards Bureau researches.................
119 N ational Association of Hosiery & K nit
Goods M anufacturers, cooperation of
Liquidation Commission of A rm y, coopera­
commercial a ttach és.................................
84
tion of commercial attachés.....................
81

f

240

IN D E X .

Page. '
Page.
N avigation B ureau, m otor boats, num bering
N ational Association of M anufacturers, coop­
undocum ented............................................
201
eration of Census B u reau........................
19 j
N ational B ank of Commerce, cooperation of
transferred by N a v y .....................................
20X
Russian division, Foreign and Domestic
motor-vessel fleet. •............................................ 11 ,74
200
Commerce B u reau ....................................
93 j navigation laws, enforcem ent.........................
officers and m en, shipped and discharged..
195
N ational City B ank, New York, cooperation
overcrowding vessels, prevention.................
200
of Russian division, Foreign and Domes­
200
tic Commerce B u reau..............................
93 ; passengers counted............................................
N ational code, elevator safety, S tandards B u­
personnel, changes............................................. 4 3 »44
60
re a u ...............................................................
n o j printing and binding, cost..............................
publication w o rk ...............................................
61
protection of head and eyes of industrial
workers, Standards B u reau .....................
no
radio communication, su m m a ry ...................
196
safeguarding machines and machine drives,
radio inspections................................................
196
196
S tandards B ureau.....................................
n o 1 radio inspectors in A rm y and N a v y .............
safeguarding remote control apparatus,
radio operators, exam ined and licensed---197
receipts from duties, fees, and fines'.. . 33,195,200
S tandards B u reau .....................................
no
salaries, in ad eq u ate...........................................
53
N ational Credit M en’s Association, coopera­
shipping cleared from U nited States, 1914,
tion of In d u strial Cooperation S ervice..
70
1918,1919................................................... 191,192
N ational D ental Association, cooperation of
shipping commissioners, rep o rts...................
195
Standards B ureau.....................................
105
steerage passengers to U nited States, 1915N ational Indu strial Conference Board, coop­
eration, Census B u reau ............................
1919................................................................
19
200
sum m ary of w ork..............................................
188
commercial attach és.....................................
84
supplies................................................................
64
N ational Lim e Association, cooperation of
tonnage, American, 1914 and 1919.................
189
Standards B ureau.....................................
119
unexpended balances.......................................
34
N ational security and defense fund, allotm ent
vessels, American, registered..........................
188
and expenditures, Census B u reau..................... 27
docum ented....................................................
189
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey ....................... 29,181
operations..................................................
201
Fisheries B u reau .................................. 26,151,225
N
avigation
laws,
enforcem
ent...........................
200
Foreign and Domestic Commerce Bu­
N avy, air service, research laboratory needed
180
reau .................................................... 24,30,60,78
Beaufort, N. C., Fisheries Bureau station,
Industrial B o ard.......................................
23,60
relinquished..........................................
145
Industrial Cooperation Service....... 23,60,61,69
Census Bureau em ployees.........................
137
Lighthouse Service................................ 27,28,162
cooperation of S tandards B u re au .............. 102,107
printing and binding......................................59,61
145
Secretary’s Office............................................
30 j Fisheries B ureau, vessels re tu rn e d .........
Standards B u reau .......................................... 25,31 j m otor boats, transferred to Navigation
B u reau ....................................................
201
Swedish and Norwegian co n tracts.............
79 !
vessels, transferred from Lighthouse Service 208
W aste-Reclamation Service.................... 23,60,61
transferrer! to Coast and Geodetic Survey
171
N atural-gas m eters, Standards B ureau in­
unobtainable for Lighthouse Service........
209
spection ........................................................
105 I
N aval radio tender S a tu rn ...................................
154 ; Woods Hole. Mass., Fisheries Bureau sta­
tion relin q u ish ed.................................
145
N avigation aids, A laska.................................. 160,166
N avy D epartm ent, appropriations, shipbuild­
su m m a ry .........
159
in g ............................................................
207
N avigation B ureau, appropriations and ex­
cooperation, Census B ureau........................ 136,143
penditures.............................................. 23,26,31
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey ...................
181
bulkheads, construction, legislation needed
199
Lighthouse Service.................................. 10,159
commissioned officers, losses..........................
56
Standards B u reau ...................................... 108,117
com puters, additional n eed............................
57
Fisheries Bureau, vessels re tu rn e d ..........
11
cooperation, collectors of custom s.................
200
Lighthouse Bureau, tenders and vessels re­
Internal R evenue B ureau...........................
201
tu rn e d .....................................................
10
Standards B u reau .........................................
19S
supervision, radio stations........................
196
Steam boat-Inspection Service.....................
200 j troop transports, tonnage..........................
188
estimates, 1921.....................................................
37 j Needs, urgent. D ep artm ent..........................
19
compared w ith appropriations, 1920.........
39
m e t.........................
20
Internal Revenue Bureau, contribution,
New E ngland coast, wire-drag surveys,
fuel and salary............................................
11
needed.....................................................
177
Norwegian contracts, allotm ent, national se­
International Conference on Safety of Life at
curity and defense fu n d ......................
79
Sea, recom m endations..............................
194
International Radiotélégraphie Conference.
198 Observatories, Cheltenham , M d..................
173
load lines, legislation need ed .........................
199
Honolulu. H aw aii........................................
173
m arine service....................................................
12
magnetic. Coast and Geodetic S urvey..........
173
m aritim e problem .............................................
193
Sitka. A laska.................................................
173
m aritim e situation, facts....................
192
tidal. Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey ............
172
m easurem ent, tonnage, legislation n eed ed .. 199
Tucson, A riz.................................................
173
m erchant m arine, supervision.......................
54
Vieques, P. R ...............................................
173

i

24I

IN D E X .
Page.
Office force, Fou rteen th Census, exam inations 142
Official Register of U nited States, abolition
re c o m m e n d ed ................................................
67
preparations for p ublication...........................
132
Oils, Census Bureau statistics............................
133
Okmulgee C ounty. Okla., population, special
census...............................................................
133
O ptical glass, S tandards Bureau stu d ies........
113
O ttaw a C ounty, Okla., population, special
census...............................................................
133
Overcrowding vessels, p rev en tio n .......................
200
Oxholm, Axel H ., lum ber-m arkets investiga­
tions ..............................................................
85
Pacific cable, situ a tio n ........................................
21
Pacific coast, hydrographic w o rk .....................
172
surveys n eeded......................................................
176
Panam a Canal, cooperation of Standards
B ureau..........................................................
120
Fourteenth Census...............................................
143
surveys, wire-drag, needed.............................
178
Paper, Standard s B ureau te sts............................
120
Passengers, counted on steam ers.........................
200
P atterson (tem porarily renam ed U . S. S.
Forw ard), Coast and Geodetic Survey
vessel, operations................................... 171,181
Peace Conference, cooperation, Census B ureau 136
L atin A merican division, Foreign and
Domestic Commerce B u reau......................
89
Pension B ureau, cooperation of Census B u ­
re a u ...............................................................
134
Pensioners’ ages, Census B ureau searches___
134
Personnel, A ssistant Secretary of Commerce,
additional, needed.....................................
20
Census B u re au ...................................................
14*
changes during y e a r......................................... 42,49
Coast and Geodetic Survey, inadequate
salaries..........................................................
56
editorial clerks, additional, needed...............
62
employees, in A rm y and N a v y .....................
180
promotion. D ep artm en t’s policy............... 4 4 / 4 7
relief association.............................................
66
retirem ent of su p eran n u ated......................
46
Fisheries Bureau, inadequate salaries.........
52
Foreign and Domestic Commerce Bureau,
56
employees, additional, needed...........
inadequate salaries....................................
55
leaves of absence during y e a r.................
45
Lighthouse Service...........................................
164
field salaries.....................................................
48
N avigation Bureau, commissioned officers,
losses..............................................................
56
com puters, additional, needed...................
57
inadequate salaries........................................
53
salaries, entrance in ad eq u ate.........................
47
increase of $240 g ra n te d ................................
48
S tandards B ureau, changes during year . . .
102
technical staff, inadequate salaries...........
50
losses.............................................................
49
Steam boat-Inspection Service, inadequate
salaries..........................................................
52
Philippi, J. E ., commercial-attach6 activ ities.
83
Poland R epublic, cooperation of Russian
division, Foreign an d Domestic Com­
merce B u re au .............................................
93
P o rt privileges, fishing vessels...........................
8

140261— 19----- 16

Page.
Porto Rico, F o u rteen th Census............................
143
surveys, wire-drag, needed.................................
17*
Portsm outh, V a., lighthouse depot, appro­
priation needed..............................................
163
Post allowances. Foreign and Domestic Com­
merce B ureau, recom m ended.................
10«
Post Office D epartm ent, cooperation, Census
B ureau..........................................................
136
foreign-tariffs division, Foreign and Do­
mestic Commerce B ureau........................
98
Power lighter, Fisheries B u re au ..........................
154
Power P la n t Engineering, cooperation of
Census B u reau ............................................
134
Precise levels ru n ..................................................
173
Pribilof Islands, adm inistrative recommen­
dations..........................................................
X54
A laskan seal h erd ..............................................
15s
tur-seal rep o rts....................................................
153
power lighter, Fisheries B ureau....................
154
Price Comparisons, International, publica­
tio n ................................................................
6j
Printing a n d binding, allotm ent and expend­
itu re s ............................................................. 23,59
national security an d defense fu n d ...........
59
estimates, 1921....................................................
41
compared w ith appropriations, 1920.........
4c
publications, d istrib u tio n ................................ 62,63
uncom pleted w ork.........................................
59
Prom otion of employees. D epartm ent’s policy 44,47
Public H ealth Service, cooperation, Census
B ureau..........................................................
131
Fisheries B u reau ...........................................
15«
Public Inform ation Committee, cooperation,
Latin American division, Foreign and
Domestic Commerce B u re au .................
89
statistical division, Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B ureau.....................................
9S
Public-service commissions, cooperation of
Standards B u reau ......................................
10Í
Public utilities, research work and testing.
Standards B u reau ...............................
10Í
Publications, Census B u re au ............................. 128,
129,130,131,132,1 3 3 »*3 4 , *3 5 »*37
Coast an d Geodetic S u rv ey ............................
16$
Fisheries B u re au ........................................... 15°» * 54
Foreign and Domestic Commerce B ureau. 85,84
Lighthouse Service, sales basis......................
164
sold by Superintendent of D ocum ents, 1918
and 1919..........................................
62,63
Standards B u reau ............................................. 101,
103,109, xzo,zix.1x3,116,xs8, t j f
Publications Division, allotm ent and expend­
itu res............................................................. *3 »5 *
national security an d defense fu n d ...........
59
editorial clerks, additional, needed...............
6*
editorial w ork.....................................................
6»
estimates, 1921....................................................
4*
compared w ith appropriations, 1920.........
4«
publications, d istrib u tio n ............................... 62,63
sum m ary, by bureaus...................................
61
uncom pleted w ork.........................................
§9
R adio
R adio
R adio
R adio

communication, sum m ary of w o t Ic ---equipm ent, Lighthouse Service............
inspections.................................................
inspectors in A rm y and N a v y ..............

199
163
*96
196

242

IN D E X .

Page.
R adio operators, exam ined and licensed........
197
R adio Service, printing and binding, cost__
60
supplies................................................................
64
R adiom etry, Standards Bureau stu d ies........
117
R adium . Standards Bureau te sts .....................
no
Railroad A dm inistration, close cooperation
needed w ith Commerce D e p a rtm e n t...
204
cooperation. Census B u reau...........................
137
S tandards B u reau .........................................
103
R astall, W . H ., industrial-m achinery investi­
gation, P a r E a s t.............................................
87
Receipts, Census B u reau ....................................
33
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey ............................
33
Fisheries B u re au ...............................................
33
Lighthouses B u reau .........................................
33
miscellaneous......................................................
33
N avigation B u reau ............................ 33, 7 4 >195» 20°
navigation duties, fees, and fines............... 195,200
Secretary’s Office...............................................
33
S tandard s B u reau .............................................
33
Steam boat-Inspection Service........................
33
Reconstruction, im provem ents, Steam boatInspection Service.....................................
184
industrial, Standards Bureau cooperation..
126
survey, Census Bureau cooperation.............
137
R ed Cross, contributions....................................
66
Register, Official, Census Bureau prepara­
tio n s..............................................................
132
R egistrants, ages. Census Bureau tran scrip ts.
136
Registration, b irth an d death, Federal legis­
lation needed...............................................
130
Regulations, Supervising Inspectors’ Board 184,186
Relief Association, Em ployees’.........................
66
Relief iu Near E ast, co n trib u tio n s...................
66
Relief Light Vessel No. 51, s u n k .......................
10
Religious bodies, Census Bureau in q u iry ----129
Research division. Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B ureau, sum m ary of w o rk ..
97
R etirem ent, superannuated em ployees...........
46
system , Lighthouse Service........................ *64,167
R hineland High Commission, coooperation
of commercial a ttach és.............................
80
R iver and H arbor im provem ents, appropria­
207
tio n ..............r ................................................
R oberts by-product coke oven, national
security and defense fu n d ........................
25
Roosevelt, Fisheries B ureau vessel, con­
dem ned an d so ld...................................... 11,154
R osenthal, Samuel W ., jewelry investiga­
tions ...............................................................
86
R ubber. S tan d ard s Bureau te sts......................
120
R ussian-A m erican Com m ittee for F a r East,
cooperation of Russian division. Foreign
and Domestic Commerce B u re au ..........
93
R ussian division, cooperation, American R us­
sian Cham ber of C ommerce.....................
93
cham bers of commerce.................................
93
L abor D e p artm e n t........................................
93
N ational Association of A merican M anu­
facturers..................................
93
N ational Bank of Commerce......................
93
N ational City Bank, New Y o rk ................
93
Poland R ep u b lic............................................
93
Russian-A m erican C om m ittee for F a r
E a s t...............................................................
93
R ussian Economic L eague..........................
93

Page.

R ussian division, Foreign and Dom estic Com­
merce B ureau, cooporation, R ussian
E m b assy ......................................................
Shipping B oard..............................................
S tate D e p artm e n t..........................................
W ar D ep artm en t...........................................
W ar T rade B o ard..........................................
extension recom m ended..................................
lib ra ry ..................................................................
sum m ary of w ork..............................................
R ussian Economic League, cooperation of
R ussian division, Foreign and Domes­
tic Commerce B ureau ..............................
R ussian Em bassy, cooperation of R ussian
division, Foreign and Domestic Com­
merce B u reau ..............................................
R u tte r, F ran k R ., commercial-attachd activi­
tie s .................................................................

93
93
93
93
93
100
92
92

93

93
8a

Sacramento, steam er, forfeited...................
196
S t. Louis, Mo., sealskins auction...............
355
Salaries, entrance, in ad eq u ate....................
47
Fisheries B u re au ...............................................
52
Jo in t Congressional Commission on R e­
classification, cooperation of D epart­
m e n t....................................................... 38,47
Lighthouse S e rv ic e ....................................
4$
Standards B u re au ......................................
50
Steam boat-Inspection Service.......................
52
Sales, charts, Coast and Geodetic S urvey ___
33
seal, fox, and other sk in s............................... 33,155
Salmon, canned, in d u s try ..................................
152
hum pback, M aine......................................
146
Pacific, Fisheries B ureau investigations.. .
149
sockeye, fisheries tre a ty ............................
9
Samoa, Fou rteen th C ensus..........................
143
Sanger, J. W ., advertising m ethods, s tu d ie s..
86
S aturn, naval radio te n d e r.................................
154
Saving of life an d property, Lighthouse
Service...................................................
164
Schedules, Fourteenth Census, prep aratio n ..
142
Schurz, W illiam L., foreign-trade investiga­
tions, Bolivia and Paraguay ............
87
Seal census, 19x8 and 19x9............................
155
Seal, fox, and other skins, sales..................
33
Seal herd. A lask an ......................
155
Seattle, W ash., Fisheries Bureau hearing___
152
Secretary’s instructions, Fourteenth Census
supervisors........................................ 140,141
Secretary’s Office, allotm ent, national secur­
ity and defense fu n d ..........................
23
appropriations an d expenditures.............. -. 23,30
estimates, 1921.............................................
38
compared w ith appropriations, 1920.
38
personnel, changes......................................
43
p rinting and binding, cost.......................
60
publication w o rk ........................................
61
receipts..........................................................
33
unexpended balances................................
34
Seining parties. Fisheries B ureau, v a lu e .. . .
75
Shellfish, Fisheries Bureau, investigations...
149
laboratory. Milford. C onn.....................
149
Ship hydrography, described......................
174
su m m ary ......................................................
172
Shipbuilding, appropriations, Em ergency
Fleet Corporation...............................
207
N avy D ep artm en t..................................
207
Census Bureau re p o rt.......................................
129

INDEX.
Page.
Shipping Board, close cooperation needed
w ith Commerce D ep artm en t.................
203
cooperation. Census B u re au ................ 129,135» 136
commercial attachés. Foreign and Domes­
tic Commerce B ureau............................
83
F a r Eastern division. Foreign and Domes­
tic Commerce B ureau............................
92
foreign-investigations division, Foreign
and Domestic Commerce B u reau---85
L atin A merican division. Foreign and
Domestic Commerce B u reau ...............
89
R ussian division. Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B ureau..................................
93
Standards B ureau .........................................
1x9
statistical division, Foreign an d Domestic
Commerce B ureau..................................
94
tra d e commissioners. Foreign an d Domes­
tic Commerce B ureau............................
86
vessels, tonnage.................................................
x88
unobtainable for Lighthouse Service___
209
Shipping cleared from U nited States, 1914,
1918, 1919.............................................. 191,192
Shipping commissioners, reports...............
195
Sim m ons. Roger E.> lum ber-m arkets investi­
gations ..........................................................
85
Sinclair Refining Co., cooperation of Census
B ureau...................................................
134
Sitka, Alaska, m agnetic observatory........
173
Sm art, Oliver M., electrical-m arkets investi­
gations ..........................................................
86
Sm ith, Philip S., electrical-goods investiga­
tions ..............................................................
86
Snow , Chauncey Dcpew, eommercial-attaché
activities................................................
80
Solicitor's Office, sum m ary of w ork...........
67
Southw estern Electrical & Gas Association,
cooperation of Census B u reau.........
134
S tandards B ureau, aeronautical instrum ents,
te sts.........................................................
122
a ltitude laborato ry .....................................
112
appropriations and expenditures........... 23,24,30
cem ent, te sts................................................
119
ceramics, studies.........................................
125
chem istry, te sts...........................................
118
coal-gas tests, In d ian a S tate com m ission..
109
contributions. S tate fair ex h ib its........... 65,66
cooperation, A ir Mail Service..................
107
American Leather Research Laboratory.
120
A merican Medical Association.............
1x6
General S upply C om m ittee................ 120,126
In d ustrial Cooperation S ervice............
69
industrial reconstruction.......................
126
N ational A dvisory Com m ittee for Aero­
nautics .......................................................
1x3
N ational D ental Association................
105
N ational Lim e A ssociation...................
1x9
N avigation B u re au .................................
198
N avy D epartm en t...................... 102,107, xo8,1x7
P anam a C anal..........................................
120
public-service commissions...................
108
R ailroad A dm in istratio n.......................
103
Shipping B oard.......................................
119
T anners' C ouncil.....................................
120
W ar D epartm en t..................................... 102,
106,107,108,1x6, x i8 ,120, xai, 122,126
dynam om eter and a ltitu d e laboratory, new
17

243

Page.
S tan d ard s B ureau, electrical safety code---i to
S tan d ard s B ureau, electricity division, w ork.
106
electrolysis surveys...........................................
xxo
estim ates. 192X................................................... 3 7 . 4 °
com pared w ith appropriations, 1920........
4°
fire-resistive te sts...............................................
112
h e at m easurem ents...........................................
111
industrial-gas investigation, M aryland.......
109
in d u strial lab o rato ry .........................................15*124
in d u strial safety codes.....................................
xxo
leather, stu d ies...................................................
120
lib r a r y ................................................................
102
light, stu d ies.......................................................
115
lime, researches.................................................
119,
m aterials, stru ctu ral an d miscellaneous,
te sts...............................................................
119*
m etals, stu d ies...................................................
122n ational code, elevator safety........................
xxo
protection of head and eyes of industrial
w orkers.........................................................
ixo
safeguarding m achines and m achine
drives...........................................................
no
safeguarding rem ote control a p p a ra tu s ..
xxo
n ational security an d defense fund, allot­
m e n t and expenditures............................ 25,31
natural-gas m eters, inspection.......................
105
optical glass, studies.........................................
1x3
organization........................................................
xoa
paper, te sts..........................................................
120
personnel, changes...................................- 43,44,102
p rin tin g and binding, cost..............................
60
public u tilities, research w ork axtd testing
108
publications........................................................
61
X02, X03,109, n o , xxx, 1x3,1x6,118,125
radiom etry, stu d ie s..........................................
117
rad iu m te sts .......................................................
xxo
receipts.................................................................
33
Tubber, te s ts .......................................................
120
street lighting, studies.....................................
109
technical staff, inadequate salaries...............
50
losses.................................................................
49
telephone service, studies...............................
109
textiles, te sts......................................................
121
therm om eters, te sts ..........................................
xxx
timepieces, te sts.................................................
X05
unexpended balances.......................................
34
urgent n eed s.......................................................
19
w ar w ork.............................................................
106
w eights and m easures, annual conference..
103
division, w ork................................................
103
S tate D epartm ent, cooperation of Foreign
an d Domestic Commerce B ureau___93,204
S ta te institutions, statistical directory. Cen­
sus B ureau re p o rt....................................
134
States, financial statistics. Census Bureau
rep o rt............................................................
131
Stations, lighthouse, returned b y N a v y ........
159
Statistical A bstract, p ublication...................... 96,97
Statistical directory of S ta te institutions,
Census B ureau re p o rt.............................
134
S tatistical division. Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B ureau, activities.................
94
cooperation. Alien P roperty C ustodian..
95
C entral Bureau of Planning and Sta­
tistic s........................................................
95
Council of N ational Defense...................
95
Custom s Service, T reasury D epartm ent
96

INDEX.

244

Page.
S tatistical division, Foreign an d Domestic
Commerce, cooperation, B ureau Di­
rector General of R ailroads..................
95
Food A d m in istratio n...............................
95
Geological S u rv ey ......................................
95
M arkets Bureau, A griculture D epart­
m e n t..........................................................
95
Mines B u re au .............................................
95
Public Inform ation C om m ittee..............
95
Shipping B o ard ..........................................
94
W ar Industries B oard..............................
95
W ar M inerals C om m ittee........................
95
W ar Trade B o ard ......................................
95
Steam boat-Inspection Service, accidents on
vessels...........................................................
183
appropriations and ex p en d itu res............ 23,25,31
boiler pressure, legislative am endm ents
recom m ended.............................................
186
contributions, S tate fair ex h ib its.................. 65,66
cooperation of N avigation B u re au ...............
200
efficiency certificates, issued..........................
183
estim ates, 1921................................................... 37,39
compared w ith appropriations, 1920........
39
hull and boiler construction, centralization
of approval n eeded....................................
184
licenses, applicants, exam inations...............
185
issued...................................................................... 183
life preservers tested .........................................
183
lives lost and sav e d ..........................................
183
organization........................................................
182
personnel, changes ..................................... 43,44,182
printing and binding, co st..............................
60
publication w o rk ...............................................
61
receipts.................................................................
33
reconstruction im provem ents.........................
184
salaries, inadequate ........................................
52
steel plates for boilers, inspections................
183
sum m ary of w o rk ..............................................
183
Supervising Inspectors' Board, regulations 184,186
supervising inspectors, civil-service classi­
fication recom m ended..............................
186
supplies.............................................
64

unexpended balances............................

34

urgent needs.......................................................
vessels, inspected an d certificated................

20
183

Steel plates for boilers, inspections, Steam­
boat-Inspection Service....................
Steel tonnage, American ships, 1914 and 1919.
Steerage passengers to U nited States, 191519 19 ...............................................................................

Stock and shipping section, summary of
work............................................
Strachan, William M., tropical-products in­
vestigations...................................
Stranded fishes rescued............................

183
189
200
64
86
147

Subscriptions, annual, copies and receipts. . . 62,63
Liberty loan. Census Bureau w o rk ..............
136
sum m ary ..........................................................
66
Superannuation and retirem en t........................
46
Supervisors, Fourteenth Census, test exam i­
n a tio n ............................................................
140
Supervising Inspectors’ Board, regulations. 184,186
Supervising inspectors’ Steam boat-Inspection
Service, civil-service classification rec­
om m ended ...................................................
186
Supplies Division, printing and binding,
c o st................................................................
60
sum m ary of w o rk ..............................................
65

Page.

Suprem e Economic Council, cooperation of
commercial a ttach és.................................. 80,81
Surveyor, Coast and Geodetic Survey vessel,
operations................................................. 171,180
Surveys, A laskan waters, needed ................. 176,178
hydrographic, revision ...................................
172
sum m ary of w o rk .......................................... 172,181
wire-drag needed, Alaska .............................
178
Florida coast...................................................
178
Long Island S ound........................................
177
New England coast.......................................
177
Panam a C anal................................................
178
Porto R ico.......................................................
178
Virgin Islan d s.................................................
178
Susquehanna R iver, Md., fish hatchery
closed.............................................................
148
Swedish contracts, allotm ent, national secur­
ity and defense fu n d ..................................
79
Tanners’ Council, cooperation of S tandards
B ureau..........................................................
120
Tariff Commission, cooperation of Census
B ureau..........................................................
134
Taxes, collected b y N avigation B u re au ..................... 11
Telephone and Telegraph A dm inistration,
cooperation of Census B ureau ................
136
Telephone service, S tandards
Bureau,
studies...........................................................
109
Tenders, lighthouse, returned b y N avy De­
p a rtm e n t......................................................
10
Textiles, Stan d ard s Bureau te sts......................
121
Therm om eters. S tandards Bureau te sts.........
nr
T h irty -F iv e Foot C hannel L ight Vessel No.
45, b u rn e d .................................................. 10,208
Thom pson, E rw in W ., eommercial-attaehd
activities.......................................................
80
Tidal observations. Coast and Geodetic Sur­
vey, su m m ary .............................................
172
Timepieces, S tandards Bureau te sts ................
105
Tobacco, leaf, Census Bureau reports ............
132
Tom pkinsville, N . Y ., lighthouse depot,
allotm ent and expenditures, national
security and defense fund ......................
28
im provem ents.................................................
162
Tonnage, A merican vessels, 1914-1919.............
188
Shipping Board vessels....................................
188
steel and wooden ships, A merican, 1914 and
19*9.................................................................
189
troop transports, N avy D e p artm e n t....................... 188
W ar D ep artm ent...........................................
188
w orld’s ..................................................................
189
Topography, use of aeroplane............................
179
Trade commissioners, cooperation w ith
A merican Expeditionary Force.............
85
investigations.....................................................
78
vital w ork............................................................
85
S e e a l s o Commerical agents.
Trade, foreign, to tals............................................
77
Trade-inform ation division. Foreign and
Domestic Commerce B ureau ................
93
Trade-m arks, legislation and p ira c y ................
98
Trade of U nited States w ith W orld, publica­
tio n ....................................................................
96
T ransportation, officers and employees,
families an d effects..................................
58
rem ains.............................................................
58
w ater, Census B ureau in q u iry .......................
129
Travel allowance, recom m endations...............
7

INDEX.
Page.
Treasury D epartm ent, cooperation of Lighthouse Service...............................................
X5 9
T reaty, p o rt privileges, fishing vessels............
8
sockeye salm on fisheries..................................
9
Triangulation work, su m m ary ..........................
172
Troop transports, W ar and N avy D epart­
m ents, tonnage..................................................
188
Tucson, Ariz., m agnetic o bservatory..............
173
Tulsa C ounty, Okla., population, special
census............................................................
133
U ndocum ented m otor boats, num b erin g.......
U nexpended balances, Alaska fisheries service
b y b ureaus......................................................
1913-1919..............................................................
U nited States Cham ber of Commerce, Buenos
A ires..............................................................
U nited States Sugar Equalization Board, co­
operation of commercial attach és.........
U nited W ar W ork Cam paign, contributions.

201
35
3 4 » 35
35

83
84
66

Van N orm an, Louis E., trade-conditions in­
vestigations, R u m a n ia .............................
86
Vessels, accidents..................................................
183
American, registered................
188
tonnage, 1914-1919.........................................
188
Coast and Geodetic Survey, condensed
sta te m e n t................................................. 171,172
hydrographic su m m ary ...............................
172
operations........................................................
180
returned b y N a v y ..................................... 170» i 7 t
transferred to N a v y ......................................
180
urgent needs...................................................
174
construction, cost comparisons......................
210
N avy D epartm en t.........................................
207
D epartm ent’s .....................................................
9
docum ented......................
189
Fisheries B ureau, returned b y N a v y ..........
145
Roosevelt....................................................... 11,154
inspected and certificated...............................
183
Lighthouse Service, appropriations.............
209
C edar................................................. '. ............
154
condition and necessity for u p k e ep ..........
207
estim ates, appropriations n eeded..............
209
lost and condem ned............................ 10,161,208
12
needed..............................................................
operations.................................................... 162,207
requirin g replacem ent..................................
211
returned b y N a v y ....................................... 10.159
transferred to N a v y ......................................
208
urgent n eeds...................................................
207
war w ork..........................................................
208
m otor fleet, Navigation B u reau ....................
11
Navigation Bureau, operations.....................
201
N avy, transferred to Coast and Geodetic
S u rv ey ..........................................................
173
unobtainable for Lighthouse Service.......
209
overcrowding, p rev en tio n ...............................
200
passengers coun ted ...........................................
200
power lighter, Pribilof Islan d s.......................
154
purchase and construction, Emergency
Fleet C orporation......................................
207
Sacram ento, forfeited.......................................
196
S hipping Board, tonnage................................
188
unobtainable for Lighthouse Service.......
209
tonnage, Lloyd’s R egister....................... 189,191
Victory Memorial Building, c o n trib u tio n s...
66

Vieques, P . R ., m agnetic o bservatory............
Virgin Islands, navigation aids, appropriation
recom m ended.............................................
surveys, wire-drag, n e e d e d .............................
V ital statistics, Census B ureau reports...........

245
Page.
173
166
178
130

W alker, John R ., lum ber-m arkets investiga­
tio n s ..................................................................
8s
W ar D ep artm en t, cooperation, Census B u­
re a u ............................................. i 3 4 >136,1 3 7 >*43
Coast an d Geodetic S u rv ey .........................
181
commercial a tta ch é s.....................................
79
foreign-investigations division, Foreign
an d Dom estic Commerce B u re au ..........
85
In d u strial Cooperation Service......................
69
L atin A merican division, Foreign and
Dom estic Commerce B ureau..................
88
Lighthouse Service.......................................
159
Russian division, Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B u reau.....................................
93
S tandards B u reau ........ 106,108,116,118,120,126
troop transports, tonnage................................
x88
W ar Finance Corporation, close cooperation
needed w ith Commerce D e p a rtm e n t...
203
W ar Industries Board, cooperation. Census
B u reau........... ......................................... 135» *37
foreign-investigations division, Foreign
and Domestic Commerce B u re au ..........
85
statistical division, Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B u reau.....................................
95
W ar Minerals Committee, cooperation of sta­
tistical division, Foreign and Domestic
Commerce B u reau.....................................
95
W ar Service Com m ittee of R ubber Ind u stry
of U nited States, cooperation of Census
B u reau ..........................................................
137
W ar Trade Board, cooperation, Census
B ureau..................................................
135» * 37
commercial attachés, Foreign and Do­
mestic Commerce B ureau............. 79» 80,81,83
foreign-investigations division, Foreign
85
and Domestic Commerce B ureau.........
L atin A merican division, Foreign and
Domestic Commerce B ureau..................
89
Russian division. Foregin and Domestic
Commerce B u reau .....................................
93
statistical division. Foreign and Domes­
tic Commerce B ureau............................... • 95
W ar work, Census B ureau.............................. 135,136
Coast and Geodetic S u rv ey ........................
180
commercial attachés, Foreign and Domes­
tic Commerce B ureau...............................
83
S tandards B u re au .............................................
106
W aste paper, disposal, investigation...............
71
W aste-R eclam ation Service, cooperation w ith
Wool Stock G raders' A ssociation..........
71
need for continuance........................................
73
printing and b in d in g ........................................
60
publication w o rk ...............................................
61
sum m ary of w ork..............................................
70
W aste-reclamation work, allotm ent, national
security and defense fu n d ................... 23,30,60
W aterways, developm ent u rg e d .......................
67
W eekly H ealth In d ex , Census Bureau pub­
lication..........................................................
130
W eights an d measures, annual conference. . .
103
Standards Bureau d ivision.............................
103

246

INDEX.

Page.
Wells, Leslie C., d evastated regions, France,
to u r................................................................
86
W hitham , Paul P.. transportation an d port
facilities, China, investigation................
87
Wiggles w orth, H enry, chemical industries,
surv ey ...........................................................
86
W illiams, Pierce C., commerical-attachd
a ctiv ities.......................................................
80
W ire-drag launches, appropriations................. ‘ 1 7 7
needed.....................................................................
178
n e w ...............
10
W ire-drag surveys, needed, A lask a.....................
178
Florida coast...................................................
177
L o n g I s l a n d S o u n d .........................................................

177

coast..........................................
Panam a C anal....................................................
Porto R ico..........................................................

177

N e w E n g la n d

W ire-drag surveys, needed, Virgin Is la n d s...
su m m ary ..............................................................
war w ork..............................................................
W ood, Charles P., industrial-m achinery in­
vestigations ..................................................
W ooden tonnage, American ships, 1914 and
1919................................................................
Woods Hole. Mass., Fisheries B ureau station,
r e l i n q u i s h e d b y N a v y .........................................

Wool Stock G raders’ Association, coopera­
tion of W aste-Reclam ation Service.......
W orld Cotton Conference, cooperation of
commençai attachés, Foreign and Do­
m estic Commerce B ureau........................

178 Young, A rth u r N., financial conditions,
Spain, investigations................................
178

O

Page.
178
172
183
86
^89
145

73

84
86