The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR Frances Perkins, Secretary B U R E A U OF L A B O R ST A T IS T IC S Isador Lubin, Com m issioner (on leave) A . F. Hinrichs, A ctin g Commissioner in cooperation w ith W O R K PROJECTS A D M IN IS T R A T IO N + Salaries and Hours o f Labor in M unicipal Police Departments July 1, 1938 VOLUM E V South Atlantic Cities + Prepared by the DIVISION OF CONSTRUCTION AND PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT H E R M A N B. B Y E R , Chief B u lletin ?*lo. 685 U N IT E D ST A T E S G O V E R N M E N T P R IN T IN G OFFICE W A S H IN G T O N : 1941 For sale by the Superintendent o f Documents, Washington, D . C. Price 10 cents U N IT E D STA TE S D E P A R T M E N T OF LABOR F rances P e r k in s , Secretary + BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS Is a d or L tjbin, C o m m issio n er A. F. H inrichs, (on leave) A c tin g C o m m issio n er Ary ness Joy, Chief, Prices and Cost of Living Branch Donald Davenport, Chief, Employ ment and Occupational Outlook Branch N. Henry J. Fitzgerald, Chief, Business Management Branch Arnold Tolies, Chief, Working Conditions and Industrial Relations Branch Sidney W . Wilcox, Chief Statistician Hugh S. Hanna, Chief, Editorial and Research C H IE F S O F D I V I S I O N S Herman B. Byer, Construction and Public Employment Florence Peterson, Industrial Relations Charles F. Sharkey, Labor Law In formation J. M. Cutts, Wholesale Prices W . Duane Evans, Productivity and Technological Developments Boris Stern, Labor Information Service Swen Kjaer, Industrial Accidents Lewis E. Talbert, Employment Sta tistics Stella Stewart, Retail Prices John J. Mahaney, Machine Tabula tion Robert J. Myers, Statistics Emmett H. Welch, Occupational Out look Wage and Hour Faith M. Williams, Cost of Living ♦ STATE, COU N TY, AND M UNICIPAL SURVEY Jesse M. H adley , n D irector CONTENTS Page Summary-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Employment and salaries: Range of salaries---------------------------------------------------------------------------------Salaries in various occupations_______________________________________ Types of duty for patrolmen---------------------------------------------------------------Comparison of employment and salaries in various occupations______ Comparison of size of departments and per capita salary costs_______ Hours and working conditions: Platoon systems and hours of duty___________________________________ Promotion of patrolmen______________________________________________ Vacations with pay___________________________________________________ Items supplied to uniformed force____________________________________ Appendix: Table A.— Cities covered by this report______________________________ Table B.— Number of employees and annual salaries in cities of 100.000 or more, by occupation_________________________ Table C.— Number of employees and annual salaries in cities of 50.000 to 100,000, by occupation_______________________ Table D.— Number of employees and annual salaries in cities of 25.000 to 50,000, by occupation________________________ Table E.— Total salaries and total number of employees____________ Table F.— Average hours and days on duty by occupational division- in 1 2 3 7 7 8 9 11 11 11 13 14 18 22 26 28 Letter o f Transmittal U nited States D epartment of L abor, B ureau of L abor Statistics, W ashington , D . C., June 15, 1941• The Secretary of L abor: I have the honor to transmit herewith the fifth of a series of nine reports on Salaries and Hours of Labor in Municipal Police Depart ments. This report covers cities in the South Atlantic States. An explanation of the purposes of the survey was given in the preface to volume I, New England cities. A. F. H inrichs, A ctin g Com m issioner . Hon. F rances P erkins, Secretary o f Labor . v B u lletin T^o. 685 (Voi. V) o f the U n ited States B u rea u o f Labor Statistics Salaries and H ours o f Labor in M unicipal Police Departments, South A tlantic Cities, July 1, 19381 Summary The 39 cities covered by this report2 had approximately 7,000 police-department employees on July 1, 1938, with annual salaries amounting to $14,000,000. Baltimore and Washington, with 1,900 and 1,480 employees, respectively, accounted for almost half of the total number of employees and for over half of the total salaries. On the basis of the United States Census of Population for 1930, the 3,700,000 persons in the 39 cities were provided police protection at an annual salary cost of $3.78 per capita. In general, the salaries in the large cities were the highest. The salaries of heads of departments for the group of largest cities, for instance, ranged from $3,600 paid in Norfolk to $8,000 paid to the superintendent of police in Washington. The $3,600 paid to the chief in St. Petersburg was the highest salary paid to any employee in group III.8 More than three-fourths of all salaries were between $1,650 and $2,450, this concentration being greatly influenced by the salary rates of the largest cities. Patrolmen, who comprised more than two-thirds of all police em ployees, received salaries between $1,150 and $2,450. All of the 3,049 patrolmen receiving $1,850 or more per year, which number represented 64 percent of all patrolmen, were in group I. Eighty percent of the patrolmen were classified as first-grade, and 28 out of the 39 cities provided for automatic promotion of patrolmen from the lowest grade to the next higher grade after a specified period of service. Approximately nine-tenths of the police-department employees worked 8 hours a day. In addition to the time off which most of the employees received periodically, three-fourths of all employees were given paid vacations ranging from 7 days to 30 days. 1 Analysis and presentation of data by Gerald M. Whitright and M. F. Thurston. Editing and tabula tion of data by Mahlon B. Buckman. Carol P. Brainerd, technical adviser. 8Includes all cities in the South Atlantic region with populations greater than 25,000 in 1930, except Savannah, Ga. (85,024), and Clarksburg, W. Va. (28,866), for which data were not available. See appen dix table A for a complete list of cities covered by this report. 1 The cities have been divided on the basis of the U. S. Census of Population for 1930 into 3 size groups, as follows: Group I, cities with a population of 100,000 or more; group II, cities of 50,000 and under 100,000; and group III, cities of 25,000 and under 50,000. Baltimore, the only city with a population of more than 500,000 in 1930, has been included in group I because data for Baltimore did not vary sufficiently from data for other cities to justify separate treatment. 1 2 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS Employment and Salaries Range o f Salaries Employees in the nine largest cities accounted for about threefourths of all employees; consequently, the salary rates in these cities influenced the general level of salaries for the region. The pre dominance of high salaries in group I is evident in the accompanying chart. Eighty-three percent of the employees in cities of group I P E RC EN TA G E DISTRIBUTION OF SOU TH A TL AN TI C P OL IC E DEPARTMENT E M P L O Y E E S BY SALARY GROUP AND SIZE OF CITY POPULATION OF C IT IE S PER CEN T OF EM PLOYEES 0 40 60 ALL CITIES 2 5 .0 0 0 A DU D R N NE 5 0 .0 0 0 5 0 ,0 0 0 A DU D R N NE 1 0 0 ,0 0 0 1 0 0 ,0 0 0 OVER UNOER $ 1 ,5 5 0 $ 1,550 $ 1,8 5 0 $1,850 U.s. D P R M N O L A R EA T E T F &O • R A O L B R STA UEU F A O T^TIC S A DU D R N NE A DU D R N NE $ 2 ,1 5 0 $ 2,150 AD N OVER received salaries of $1,850 or more, whereas only 14 percent and 9 percent of the employees in cities of groups II and III, respectively, received salaries above $1,850. Of the 116 employees receiving $3,050 or more, all but 10 were in the largest cities. The $8,000 paid to the superintendent of police in Washington, in group I, was the maximum salary for the region. Highest salaries in the other population groups were $4,000 and $3,600 paid to the chiefs in Macon and St. Petersburg. Minimum full-time salaries in each of the 3 groups of cities were between $450 and $550. 3 SOUTH ATLANTIC CITIES T a b l e 1 .— Police-department employees in South Atlantic cities classified according to salaries and size of city , J u ly 1 , 1988 1 Number of employees Salary class Percentage City group 2 All cities III II I All cities City group i I III II. 3 6, 998 5,070 1,129 799 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 Under $1,050. __________ _ $1,050 to $1,149 $1,150 to $1,249_____________ $1,250 to $1,349_____________ $1,350 to $1,449_____________ 72 3 127 70 263 4 24 3 85 21 31 *23 «25 3.1 12 33 112 .5 .1 1.7 .4 .6 2.0 30 16 120 1.0 (7 ) 1.8 1.0 3.8 2.7 1.4 10.6 1.5 4.1 14.0 $1,450 to $1,549_____________ $1,550 to $1,649_____________ $1,650 to $1,749_____________ $1,750 to $1,849_____________ $1,850 to $1,949_____________ 280 368 834 525 476 30 73 242 330 383 110 121 441 115 69 140 174 151 80 24 4.0 5.3 11.9 7.5 6.8 .6 1.4 4.8 6.5 7.6 9.7 10.7 39.1 10.2 6.1 17.5 21.8 18.9 10.0 3.0 $1,950 to $2,049______ _____ _ $2,050 to $2,149_____________ $2,150 to $2,249_____________ $2,250 to $2,349_____________ $2,350 to $2,449_____________ 367 1, 766 170 99 1,118 314 1,740 164 92 1,1C5 36 18 4 5 6 17 8 2 2 7 5.2 25.2 2.4 1.4 16.0 6.2 34.3 3.2 1.8 21.8 3.2 1.6 .4 .4 .5 2.1 1.0 .3 .3 $2,450 to $2,549..... ........... . $2,550 to $2,649_____________ $2,650 to $2,749..... ........... ... 52 57 32 68 67 47 55 26 68 67 2 2 1 3 .9 1.1 .5 1.3 1.3 .2 .2 .1 .4 5 .7 .8 .5 1.0 1.0 $2,950 to $3,049_____ ______ _ $3,050 and over......... ............. 68 116 64 8 106 2 *8 2 1.0 1.7 1.3 2.1 .2 .7 .3 .3 All salaries________________ $9,760 t.n $2,849 $2,850 to $2,949 10 2 .8 .6 1 For a more detailed analysis of data, see appendix tables B, C, and D. 2 This and the following tables include data for 39 South Atlantic cities, grouped on basis of the U. S. Census of Population for 1930, as follows: Group I, cities with a population of 100,000 or more; group II, cities of 50,000 and under 100,000; and group III, cities of 25,000 and under 50,000. 8 Includes only regular, full-time employees. 4 Includes employees with salaries ranging from $468 to $945. * Includes employees with salaries ranging from $548 to $900. 6Includes employees with salaries ranging from $521 to $945. 7 Less than Ho of 1 percent. 8Includes employees with salaries ranging from $4,171 to $8,000. 9Includes employees with salaries ranging from $3,060 to $4,000. i° Includes 1 employee with salary of $3,300 and 1 with salary of $3,600. Salaries in Various Occupations The distribution of employees in various occupations and divisions according to salary is shown in table 2. The salaries in each of the 2 groups of smaller cities showed a remarkable similarity in range and level. The salaries in group I, in contrast, were more widely dis tributed and at a higher general level. Of the 39 chiefs, 23 received salaries of $2,950 or more. These included all 9 of the department heads in group I, 10 out of 13 in group II, and 4 out of 17 in group III. Eighty-three officers held the rank of captain. The highest salary rate for captains was $3,650 paid to 13 officers in Baltimore. Wash ington’s 15 captains each received $3,600, which was equivalent to the highest salary for chiefs in group III. Groups II and III each had 16 captains, the majority of whom received between $1,750 and $2,150. 3 2 3 4 4 8 ° — 4 1 ------- 2 4 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS The distribution of the 190 lieutenants and the 399 sergeants fol lowed the same pattern with respect to population groups as that of captains, except that the lower level of salaries in each case was in keeping with the rank of the officers. The fairly even distribution of the 532 detective-bureau employees over a wide range resulted not only from variations in situations in different cities but also from the number of different official ranks within individual bureaus, this being particularly true in group I. The distributions of policewomen, fingerprint employees, radio and telephone operators, and 758 miscellaneous workers are also shown in table 2. T able 2 .— Police-department employees in South Atlantic cities, classified according to salaries and occupational groups, July 1, 1938 1 City All group a All cities cities III I II III City group a Salary class All cities I Number of cities re porting indicated occupations______ Assistant chiefs Chiefs All occupations II City All All grp.2 cities cities * II III I II I 13 17 39 9 13 17 13 5 4 4 39 9 13 17 13 5 4 4 9 Under $1,050_______ $1,050 to $1,149_____ $1,150 to $1,249.___ $1,250 to $1,349_____ $1,350 to $1,449.......... 72 3 127 70 263 24 3 85 21 280 368 834 625 476 30 73 242 330 383 110 140 121 174 441 151 115 80 69 24 367 314 1,766 1,740 170 164 99 92 1,118 1,105 36 17 18 8 4 2 5 2 6 7 5 i 4 3 3 1 1 2 5 4 1 24 I II III 9 7 8 83 <51 16 16 120 112 $1,450 to $1,549_____ $1,550 to $1,649_____ $1,650 to $1,749_____ $1,750 to $1,849_____ $1,850 to $1,949_____ 4 3 1 11 10 City group a 30 12 16 33 31 Captains City group a All salaries................ 6,998 5,070 1,129 799 39 Inspectors $1,950 to $2,049_____ $2,050 to $2,149_____ $2,150 to $2,249_____ $2,250 to $2,349_____ $2,350 to $2,449_____ $2,450 to $2,549_____ $2,550 to $2,649_____ $2,650 to $2,749......... $2,750 to $2,849.......... $2,850 to $2,949.......... $2,950 to $3,049_____ $3,050 and over_____ 52 57 32 47 55 26 68 64 106 116 See footnotes a t end of table. 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 2 I 1 1 2 1 1 7 9 4 7 7 7 4 3 1 3 3 "I 3 1 1 67 68 1 68 67 23 25 2 2 1 1 9 4 2 2 4 2 19 9 8 3 3 4 1 2 8 9 4 2 2 4 4 1 9 9- 29 29 3 2 7 4 5 SOUTH ATLANTIC CITIES T able 2. — Police-department employees in South Atlantic cities, classified according to salaries and occupational groups, July l y 1988 1 Continued — Lieutenants Sergeants City group 8 Salary class All cities I II III Number of cities re porting indicated 32 8 occupations______ 13 All salaries............. . 190 124 8 44 Under $1,050_______ $1,050 to $1,149_____ $1,150 to $1,249_____ $1,250 to $1,349_____ $1,350 to $1,449_____ $1,450 to $1,549.......... $L550 to $1,649_____ 8 3 $1,650 to $1,749_____ $1,750 to $1,849_____ 10 6 $1,850 to $1,949.......... 16 15 $1,950 to $2,049........ . 20 14 5 8 $2,050 to $2,149_____ ‘ 13 1 1 $2,150 to $2,249_____ 6 6 $2,250 to $2,349_____ $2^350 to $2,449.......... 15 15 $2,450 to $2,549_____ $2,550 to $2,649_____ 24 24 $2,650 to $2,749_____ 4 $2,750 to $2,849.......... 4 $2,850 to $2,949_____ 36 36 $2,950 to $3,049_____ 34 34 $3,050 and over_____ III 35 8 12 291 53 5 4 8 10 3 4 48 25 ” 5 23 1 21 14 25 9 7 6 43 43 11 11 9 10 11 II 5 35 1 I 3 13 10 35 4 30 1 206 103 103 9 84 101 194 266 39 95 132 651 211 352 88 367 259 63 45 304 304 213 213 1,537 1,537 105 105 60 60 830 830 _ 58 Fingerprint section, all occupations 1 2 City group3 13 13 2 I III II 2 26 37 7 15 13 3 1 10 9 9 18 115 6 3 16 4 2 7 7 3 1 2 1 2 2 1 4 2 8 8 3 3 14 2 2 II I 8 13 113 16 83 6 16 34 28 12 22 12 11 18 1 20 21 11 1 1 29 62 12 8 5 20 5 4 3 5 4 1 2 5 16 3 3 3 ~’ _6 ’ "*7 3 5 3 6 ” 5 1 3 4 3 3 1 1 2 18 1 1 39 3 1 1 1 1 2 3 1 1 1 1 I 38 758 63 3 103 32 40 46 50 45 63 71 15 141 II 9 547 19 3 79 13 138 20 24 15 26 13 58 60 6 140 2 6 3 i For a more detailed analysis of data, see appendix tables B, C, and D. 1 in group III. 17 7 40 1 1 2 2 6 1 7 18 7 40 1 1 2 1 1 6 2 City group3 2 2 13 All others III 79 5 39 1 2 3 See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. 3 No employees in this occupation in cities of group III. 4 Includes 1 captain from women's bureau. 8 Includes 1 lieutenant from women's bureau. 6Includes 3 sergeants from women's bureau—2 in group I and 9 336 All cities 2 18 III 19 47 27 52 3 34 City group3 All cities 4 2 1 2 18 17 72 41 50 61 34 55 4 39 23 Operators, radio and telephone ' 1 1 1 38 532 II 12 1 1 I 29 62 58 1 1 II III 12 2 1 14 14 151 151 9 9 III 3 3 City group 3 All cities 15 9 13 17 39 55 4,781 3,568 711 502 All cities I 10 II 6 399 All cities 40 I 11 City group3 Salary class City group3 All cities 22 Policewomen Number of cities re porting indicated occupations______ All salaries................. Under $1,050 _____ $1,050 to $1,149____ $1,150 to $1,249.......... $1,250 to $1,349_____ $1,350 to $1,449_____ $1,450 to $1,549_____ $1,550 to $1,649 ____ $1,650 to $1,749 ___ $1,750 to $1,849 $1,850 to $1,949 $1,950 to $2,049 ___ $2,050 to $2,149 $2,150 to $2,249 $2,250 to $2,349 ___ $2,350 to $2,449 $2,450 to $2,549 $2,550 to $2,649 ____ $2,650 to $2,749 $2,750 to $2,849 ___ $2,850 to $2,949 $2,950 to $3,049 ___ $3,050 and over City group3 All cities Detective bureau, all occupations Patrolmen 2 6 III 20 15 9 13 19 15 25 1 1 0 8 1 1 1 16 73 24 9 3 3 12 9 7 4 1 1 6 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS Salaries of patrolmen, who comprised almost seven-tenths of all employees, ranged between $1,150 and $2,450. No patrolmen in groups II or III received a salary in excess of $1,850, but over 85 percent in group I had salaries above this level. While four-fifths of the patrolmen were classified as first-grade, patrolmen in some cities were classified in as many as 5 or 6 grades. T a b l e 3 . — Police patrolmen in South Atlantic cities, classified according to salaries and grades, July 1, 1938 All grades Number Number of patrolmen by specified grade First 3 Percentage Second Salary class City group * City group All cities I All salaries___ II III II City group2 All cities II III III II III 4,781 3,568 711 502 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 3,837 2,861 571 465 $1,150 to $1,249 $1,250 to $1,349. $1,350 to $1,449. $1,450 to $1,549 13 35 206 194 $1,550 to $1,649. $1,650 to $1,749. $1,750 to $1,849. $1,850 to $1,949. 266 651 367 304 $1,950 to $2,049. $2,050 to $2,149. $2,150 to $2,249. $2,250 to $2,349. $2,350 to $2,449. City group 3 All cities All cities .3 .7 4.3 4.1 5.6 13.6 7.7 6.4 39 211 259 304 .6 6.0 (») 1 .2 11.8 20.1 14.5 20.5 135 158 1.1 13.3 26.3 5.9 49.5 17.5 7.3 8.9 9.0 8.5 192 579 280 197 172 211 211 20 4.4 6.0 32.1 43.1 2.2 2.9 1.2 1.7 17.4 23.3 213 213 1,537 1,537 105 105 60 60 830 830 42 20 1,406 1,406 25 830 25 830 Number of patrolmen by specified grade Fourth Third Fifth and below Probationary Salary class All cities City group 2 I III II All salaries............... 266 $1,150 to $1,250 to $1,350 to $1,450 to $1,249......... . $1,349........... $1,449........... $1,549........... 2 5 10 5 $1,550 to $1,650 to $1,750 to $1,850 to $1,649........... $1,749........... $1,849........... $1,949........... 43 22 87 $2,049.......... $2,149......... $2,249........... $2,349........... $2,449......... .. 12 24 78 12 24 78 City group 2 I III II All cities City group 2 I 87 $1,950 to $2,050 to $2,150 to $2,250 to $2,350 to All cities 224 29 13 165 151 7 1 149 *127 8 III 8 14 5 17 7 "9 6 1 14 14 4 30 30 63 63 41 71 41 71 64 64 I n m 21 21 3 18 18 13 10 City group2 3 8 4 10 1 Includes cruiser-car and motorcycle officers. 2 See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. 2 Less than Ho of 1 percent. 7 2 II All cities 7 SOUTH ATLANTIC CITIES Types o f D u ty for Patrolmen Patrolmen regularly assigned to traffic direction constituted nearly a fifth of all patrolmen in each of the three groups of cities. Table 4 shows that for all cities 18 percent of the patrolmen were assigned to traffic duties. Of these 8 percent were on foot, 7 percent were on motorcycles, and the rest were assigned to automobiles, to the mounted squad, or to other special duties. Of the 82 percent engaged on other than traffic duty 51 percent were on foot patrol, 27 percent were on automobile or squad-car duty, 2 percent were on motorcycles, and 2 percent were assigned to clerical or other miscellaneous work. T a b l e 4 .— P o lic e patrolm en in Sou th A tla n tic cities , classified according to typ es o f d u tyt J u ly 1, 1 9 8 8 Number of patrolmen Type of duty All cities Percentage City group 1 I II All cities III City group 1 I 11 III A 1 types of duty__________ .1 4,781 3,568 711 502 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 Traffic duty___________ ___ 882 645 148 89 18.4 18.1 20.8 17.7 Automobile.............. ...... Foot_____ ____ ________ Motorcycle-___________ Mounted______________ Other assignments 99 385 332 15 51 74 263 242 15 51 24 73 51 1 49 39 2.1 8.0 6.9 .3 1.1 2.1 7.4 6.8 .4 1.4 3.4 10.2 7.2 .2 9.7 7.8 Other than traffic duty_____ 3,899 2,923 563 413 81.6 81.9 79.2 82.3 Automobile..................... Foot_________ _______ Motorcycle____________ Other assignments_____ 1, 300 2,426 79 94 965 1,860 27 71 176 363 20 4 159 203 32 19 27.2 50.7 1.7 2.0 27.0 52.1 .8 2.0 24.8 51.0 2.8 .6 31.7 40.4 6.4 3.8 i See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. Comparison of Employment and Salaries in Various Occupations The uniformed force accounted for 83 percent of the personnel and for a slightly larger proportion of total salaries. Patrolmen in the large cities comprised 70 percent of the total personnel, an appreciably larger proportion than the 63 percent in the other two groups of cities. The smaller proportion of patrolmen in the cities of groups II and III is due to the large proportion of supervisory officers and detective-bureau employees in these cities. The detective bureau was the only other division with a percentage of salaries greater than the percentage of employees, as shown in table 5. Supervisory em ployees 4 constituted 13 percent of the total in group I, as compared with 15 percent in group II and 19 percent in group III cities. The corresponding percentages for total salaries were 17, 18, and 22. 4 Includes all officers with the rank of sergeant or above in the uniformed force, detective bureau, and women’s bureau, identification chiefs, telephone and radio superintendents, chief clerks, and maintenance superintendents. 8 SALARIES A N D H O U R S , POLICE D E P A R T M E N T S T a b l e 5 . — P ercentage d istribution s 1 o f 'police-departm ent em p lo yees a nd salaries in S outh A tla n tic cities , by d iv isio n s , J u ly l y 1 9 3 8 Percentage of all employees Division and occupation Percentage of total salaries City group 2 All cities I II III All cities City group 2 I II III All divisions............. 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 Uniformed division.. 83.1 84.0 81.2 80.6 84.0 84.7 81.6 81.2 Chiefs_________ Assistant chiefs. _ Inspectors______ Captains_______ Lieutenants....... .5 .2 .2 1.2 2.7 .2 .1 .2 1.0 2.4 1.2 .4 .1 1.4 3.8 2.1 .5 .4 .2 .4 1.4 3.1 2.2 .5 .1 1.7 4.5 3.5 .6 2.0 2.8 1.0 .2 .3 1.6 3.3 Sergeants______ Plainclothesmen. Patrolmen_____ Patrol drivers. _. Turnkeys______ Miscellaneous... 5.6 1.0 68.3 1.9 .9 .6 5.7 1.3 70.4 1.9 .6 .2 4.7 .5 63.0 2.2 1.5 2.4 6.8 .1 62.8 1.0 1.9 .6 6.3 1.2 67.1 1.7 .8 .5 6.4 1.4 68.9 1.7 .6 .2 5.0 .6 61.2 2.0 1.4 2.4 7.2 .1 61.0 1.0 1.6 .6 Detective bureau___ Women’s bureau___ Fingerprint section._ Telephone and radio. Clerical division____ Maintenance........ . Miscellaneous....... . 7.6 1.4 .5 1.9 2.6 2.5 .4 6.6 1.6 .3 1.8 2.7 2.5 .5 10.0 .9 1.1 1.9 2.3 2.6 10.4 .4 1.1 2.4 2.5 2.1 .5 8.3 1.2 .5 1.7 2.2 1.8 .3 7.5 1.4 .3 1.7 2.2 1.9 .3 11.1 .7 1.2 1.7 1.9 1.8 11.2 .3 1.3 2.3 2.0 1.3 .4 2.5 3.1 1 Based on figures in appendix table E. 2 See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. Comparison o f Sise o f Departments and Per Capita Salary Costs The exceptionally high increases in the size of some South Atlantic cities, as revealed by the 1940 census, make a comparison of police departments with regard to relative size and salary expenditures somewhat misleading. The entire South Atlantic region showed an increase for the decade from 1930 to 1940 of 12.9 percent, which was surpassed only by a percentage increase of 18.8 for the Pacific region. A fourth of the cities covered in this report showed increases in excess of 20 percent in the decade, and an additional fourth, increases from 10 percent to 20 percent. Figures shown in appendix table A are on the basis of the 1930 census, the latest population figures available at the time the earlier reports in this series were prepared, and are presented to show relative comparisons rather than to give actual figures. The use of the 1940 census figures greatly diminishes the relative sizes and costs of some of the police departments. Table 6 shows the comparisons of number of employees and salary expenditures on July 1, 1938, in relation to size of city in both 1930 and 1940 for the 10 cities with the greatest population increases in the decade. For instance, Miami, with an increase of 56 percent in population, had 16 employees per 10,000 population and a per capita cost of $3.05 on the basis of the 1940 census as compared with 25 employees per 10,000 population and a salary cost of $4.74 per inhabitant on the basis of the previous census. 9 SOUTH ATLANTIC CITIES Again, these figures show only relative comparisons rather than actual figures, which would be possible only if authoritative population data were available for 1938. T 6 . — N u m b er o f police-dep a rtm en t em p lo yees and sa la ry cost on J u l y 1 , 1 9 3 8 , in relation to po p u latio n in 1 9 3 0 and in 1 9 4 0 f o r 1 0 Sou th A tla n tic cities with greatest percentage o f increase i n p o p u la tio n able Census of 1930 City Census of 1940 Per capita Per capita Population Employees salary cost Population Employees salary cost per 10,000 per 10,000 Charlotte, N. C__................... Columbia, S. C........................ Columbus, Ga_........................ Jacksonville, Fla...................... Miami, Fla.............................. 82,675 51,581 43,131 129,549 110,637 13 14 16 16 25 $2.30 2.28 2.54 3.61 4.74 100,899 62,396 53,104 173,065 172,172 10 12 13 12 16 $1.89 1.89 2.06 2.70 3.05 Orlando, Fla..........- ................ Raleigh, N. C__...................... St. Petersburg, Fla__.............. Washington, D. C_................. West Palm Beach, Fla............ 27, 330 37, 379 40,425 486,869 26,610 19 17 13 30 14 2.82 2.75 2.01 7.18 2.39 36, 736 46,897 60,812 663,091 33,693 14 13 8 22 11 2.10 2.19 1.33 5.27 1.89 Hours and Working Conditions Primary factors affecting hours and working conditions are the size and financial condition of the city. State or local legislation frequently influences the organization of a department and the work ing conditions of police employees. Organization is also influenced by the cost and the need for sufficient flexibility to meet the varying demands for police protection throughout the day and to take care of such events as parades, fairs, conventions, and emergencies. P latoon Systems and H ours o f D u ty In table 7 are presented the various systems of hours of duty in South Atlantic police departments. Nine systems of groups or pla toons are shown in addition to the so-called continuous duty required of some chiefs, and a miscellaneous classification for maintenance, clerical, or other employees who do not work the same hours as the uniformed force. Under a platoon system, a department is divided into groups, which are assigned to different tours of duty so as to provide adequate protection during all hours of the day. Ninety percent of all employees worked under some variation of the 3-platoon system requiring 8 hours a day and a workweek ranging from 48 to 56 hours. One small city had a 2-platoon system, and two had 3-platoon systems with overlapping 9-hour work periods. In general the average workweek was longer in the small cities, which allowed less time off. The use of overlapping tours enabled several small cities to provide for the best use of the relatively small forces at hours of peak demand. When 1 full day off each week was provided for, an attempt was usually made to arrange the schedule for each group in such a way 10 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS that the time off rotated through the days of the week. T o accom plish this, the force was divided into seven groups, each of which had a different day off. It was frequently the custom to arrange for changing tours periodically so that the patrolmen did not work the same set of hours throughout the year. Where no such alternation of tours was provided for, the more desirable hours were usually assigned on the basis of seniority. Only 3 employees in the 39 South Atlantic cities were constantly on call, and they have been classified as being on continuous duty. The 9 percent of all employees classified as “ Other” were for the most part nonuniformed workers. The average workweek for this group was 55.6 hours. T a b l e 7.— P o lice-d ep a rtm en t em p lo yees in Sou th A tla n tic cities, classified according to hours and d a ys on d u ty p er week, J u l y 1, 1 9 8 8 Cities reporting various systems Average hours on duty per week System of operation Continuous duty________ ________________ 2- platoon: 10-hour tours overlapping, off 0.5 day per week_______ _________________ ______ 3- platoon: 9-hour tours overlapping, no time off...... 8-hour tours, no time off_______________ 8-hour tours, off 1 day per month______ 8- hour tours, off 13 days per year_____ 9- hour tours, overlapping, off 1 day per week______________________________ 8-hour tours, off every 15th day________ 8-hour tours, off every 9th d ay................ 8-hour tours, off 1 day per week________ Other___________________________________ Average days on duty per week 168.0 7.0 3 65.0 6.5 1 63.0 56.0 54.2 54.0 7.0 7.0 6.8 6.7 1 22 6 1 5 1 1 54.0 52.3 49.9 48.0 55.6 6.0 6.5 6.2 6.0 5.8 1 2 1 4 37 1 1 8 Number of employees 1 System of operation All cities City group 2 III I II All systems__________________ _________ 6,998 5,070 1,129 3 2 1 4, 724 977 904 271 389 Continuous d u ty ...................................... 2- platoon: 10-hour tours overlapping, off 0.5 day per week____________________________ 30 3- platoon____________ _______________ 6, 361 9-hour tours overlapping, no time off___ 35 8-hour lours, no time off_______________ 1,863 601 8-hour tours, off 1 day per mouth........... 8- hour tours, off 13 days per year____ 389 9- hour tours, overlapping, off 1 day per 48 week____________________________ 87 8-hour tours, off every 15th day_______ 1,768 8-hour tours, off every 9th day.—........ 8-hour tours, off 1 day per week............ . 1, 570 604 Other________________________________ 1, 768 1,392 344 1 See appendix table F for greater detail by divisions. 2 See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. 2 Less than Ho of 1 percent. City group2 All cities I II 2 III 1 1 1 1 2 13 1 16 Percentage of employees All cities City group 2 I II 100.0 100.0 100.0 (3 ) 799 1 10 2 7 3 <*) 535 254 30 660 35 424 76 .4 90.9 .5 26.6 8.6 5.6 55 48 32 133 151 45 109 .7 1. 2 25.3 22.4 8.7 m 100.0 .1 93.2 86.5 17.8 5.3 7.7 47.3 22.5 3.8 82.6 4.4 53.1 9.5 4.9 6.0 4.0 11.8 13.4 5.6 13.6 34.9 27.5 6.8 11 SOUTH ATLANTIC CITIES Promotion o f Patrolmen Twenty-eight out of thirty-nine cities made provision for automatic promotion of patrolmen from lower grades. In 25 cities the period of service before promotion from the lowest to the next higher grade was a year or less; in 3, promotions were made on the basis of civilservice examinations. Patrolmen were promoted by appointment on the basis of merit as judged by superior officers in 5 cities. Three cities had but one classification for patrolmen. T a b l e 8 , — P o lice departm ents in S outh A tla n tic cities classified according to method o f p rom otin g patrolrrpen, J u ly l j '1 9 8 8 Number of cities City group1 Total 1 year 6 months All cities............. . 39 Group I ___________ Group II__________ Group III................. A Vith promotion by— i With automatic promotion after—i ! .i i__ ■ Civil service 5' years 21 4 2 1 3 5 3 5 8 8 4 9 13 17 2 years With pa trolmen all 1 Appoint grade ment 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 2 2 1 1 See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. Vacations With Pay More than a fourth of all employees received no vacation with pay. Practically all of these were in cities of group I. Nearly all other group I employees received from 2 weeks to 1 month, the average paid vacation being slightly more than 22 days. In smaller cities, vacations were shorter, averaging about 2 weeks. T a b l e 9.— P o lice-d ep a rtm en t em p lo yees in South A tla n tic cities classified according to d a ys o f vacation with p a y , J u ly 1, 1 9 8 8 City group 1 Total num ber of em No va ployees cation days All cities___________ 6,998 1,807 6 Group I . . __________ Group I I ___________ Group III__________ 5,070 1,129 799 1,789 13 5 6 Number of employees receiving— 10 days 12 days 14 days 15 days 20 days 648 107 555 1, 484 501 1,478 102 310 12 95 161 144 250 768 505 211 500 1 1,478 102 266 1 43 453 195 26 days 28 days 30 days 1 See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. Items Supplied to Uniformed Force Nearly two-thirds of the South Atlantic cities provided uniforms free of charge or gave a cash allowance for uniforms, and 11 provided raincoats or capes. 323448°— 41------ 3 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS 12 Revolvers and badges were furnished by the majority of cities, and such items as belts, holsters, and night sticks were provided in many departments. T able 10 . — P o lic e departm ents i n S o u th A tla n tic cities classified according to item s su p p lie d the u n ifo rm ed forces^ J u l y 1 , 1 9 3 8 Number of cities supplying— City group1 Total num ber of cities Cash Trim Rain Hol Full mings allow coats sters ance Re uni for or volvers and for forms uni belts forms uni capes forms All cities.................... 39 22 3 Group I ____ ______ Group I I __________ Group I I ................... 9 13 17 4 9 9 2 11 25 14 12 18 29 1 1 7 5 13 2 2 6 8 4 3 7 5 4 9 9 14 12 4 2 Hand Clubs, Other cuffs, night twist sticks Badges items * ers 2 6 8 27 7 i See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. * Flash lights, cartridges, whistles, overcoats, short leather coats, white gloves, caps, cloth for uniform, eto. Appendix Appendix table A contains a list of 39 South Atlantic cities with their 1930 populations and information regarding the number of police-department employees per 10,000 persons and salary cost per capita. Tables B, C, and D give the number of persons employed and individual occupational salaries in each group of cities. Table E summarizes total employment and total salaries paid in eaoh division and occupation for all cities and for each size group. Table F shows average weekly hours and days on duty under various systems of operation by divisions for all cities and for each size group. All data in the tables, except population, are as of July 1, 1938. T A .— S ou th A tla n tic police-dep a rtm en t em p lo ye es and sa la ry costs in relation to p o p u la tio n in cities with a p o p u la tio n o f 2 5 ,0 0 0 or m oret 1 J u l y 1 , 1 9 3 8 able Popula tion 2 City All eit.ies . G roup!—cities of mu,900 and over At.1fl.ntA, G a Raltimnra, M<i lanksnnville, Fla Miami, FIa Norfolk, V a Riehmnnd, V a TATnpA, F1a Washington, D r O Wilmington, Del ... . _ - __ Group IT—oities of 50,000 to 100,000 _ _ __ _ _ _ $3.78 3,712,225 . _ ______ __ . ___________ Asheville, N, O . _ _ Augusta, Ga __ ........... _ Charleston, 8. O ____ _____ Charleston W_ V a Charlotte, N. C ____________ _ _ Columbia S. C ...... _ _ _ _ . Durham, N. C ..... ..._ Greensboro, N. C ........... _ TTnnt.ington, W, Va Macon, Ga___________________ ____________ _______________ Roanoke, V a __ ___ Wheeling, W Va Winston-Salem, N, G . . . . GrO"P TD—oities of 9.5,000 to 50,000 Colnmhns, Ga __ - .... Cumberland, Md ___ Greenville, S. G___________________________________________ Hagerstown, A/fd ____ . _ __ TTigh Point, N O ________________________________ Tiynnhhnrjr Va _ _ Newport News, Va __ ...... . ..... __ r Orlando, Fla ................................. .. . Parkersburg, W, Va Pp.nsa^nla, Fla . __ Petersburg Va _____ - - - _________ Portsmouth, Va Raleigh, N. C ................................................................................. St. Petersburg, Fla _ . . . Spartanburg, 8. C ___ ______________________________________ West Palm Reanh, Fla _ __ Wilmington, N. C._....................................................................... 19 2,322,692 ___ __ Employees Per Capita per 10,000 salary cost 22 4.68 270,366 804,874 129,549 110,637 129,710 182,929 101,161 486,869 106,597 16 24 16 25 18 16 10 30 15 3.23 5.07 3.61 4.74 3.16 2.83 1.79 7.18 3.08 808,610 14 2.32 50,193 60,342 62,265 60,408 82,675 51,581 62,037 53,569 75,572 53,829 69,206 61,659 75,274 14 17 22 14 13 14 14 14 9 14 13 11 14 2.34 2.50 3.36 2.32 2.30 2.28 2.25 2.42 1.58 2.36 2.31 1.81 2.46 580,923 14 2.20 43,131 37,747 29,154 30,861 36,745 40.661 34,417 27,330 29,623 31,579 28,564 45,704 37,379 40,425 28,723 26,610 32,270 16 13 21 13 13 13 14 19 6 14 13 9 17 13 16 14 13 2.54 2.06 3.02 1.82 2.10 2.37 2. 51 2.82 1.03 2.14 2.03 1.53 2.75 2.01 2.53 2.39 2.03 i Includes all cities with a population of 25,000 or more in the South Atlantic Division except Savannah, Ga. (85,024), and Clarksburg, W. Va. (28,866), information for each of which was not available. * Based on U. S. Census of Population for 1930. 13 T a b l e B .— P o lice-departm en t em p lo yees in each o f 9 South Atla ntic cities o f group 7 ,1 classified according to individ ual occupations and corresponding salary rates , J u ly 1 , 1 9 3 8 Division and occupation District of Columbia Wilmington Washington Georgia Florida Jacksonville Miami Tampa Maryland Atlanta Baltimore Virginia Norfolk Richmond Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary rate rate ber rate ber rate ber rate ber ber rate ber ber rate ber rate ber rate Inspectors Captains.._____ _______________________ _____ _________ _______ Lieutenants Sergeants Plainclothesmen ____ Patrolmen: 1st grade____________________________ 2d grade_____ .. _____ _____ . . . . 3d g rade._______________ _________ 4th grade . __ . . . 5th grade 6th grade Other: Motorcycle officers Patrol drivers . ________ _____ ____ Turnkevs _ Miscellaneous: Court, clerks Lieutenants, desk Lieutenants, traffic Probation officers Property clerks Sergeants, traffic Detective bureau: Chiefs of detectives ______ Assistant chiefs of detectives Inspectors ............ Captains Lieutenants.................... .................. ........... D ol. 1 6,000 1 4,000 D o l. D ol. 3 1 2,825 2,400 1 1 6 14 34 12 2,280 56 2, 750 38 2,640 830 35 78 71 64 63 2,400 2,300 2.200 2,100 2,000 1,900 1 5,040 8,000 5,000 4,500 3,600 3,050 \ 1 1 104 273 205 1,478 161 Uniformed division: Chiefs or superintendents..................... ........ 1 3,561 4 2,778 2 2,300 ) 3 2,394 } 9 2,489 I D o l. 1 5,000 1 3,120 1 2,760 5 2,520 6 2,280 1 4,200 3 2,132 5 1,920 25 27 24 41 2,300 2,201 2,106 2,011 1 2,300 2,100 1,838 90 17 1 1,920 1,620 1,320 20 48 3 1,980 1,920 1,920 54 1,740 3 3 1,838 i 3,000 1 6 1 3,600 3,050 1 3, 561 1 3,245 2,592 2,376 2,100 2,088 2,016 1,944 3 13 f 24 \ 36 5,000 1 1 3,600 2,436 1 4,000 4,500 3,650 2,685 } 2,868 J 3 1 2,196 2,064 4 4 2, 520 2,100 26 2,016 17 1,980 1,800 172 3 17 1,800 1, 680 1,560 9 1,560 1 2 2, 520 2,100 2,100 210 36 12 30 2,880 i 2 2,580 2,340 1 3,000 1 2,040 D o l. D ol. 8 1 148 2,425 1,196 76 87 2,086 1,955 1,825 37 24 2,086 2,086 3 2,220 1 3,120 1 2,448 25 2,868 1,728 1,656 1,584 1,524 4,171 i 143 11 5 9 2,448 1 1 2,489 1 2. 778 5,000 4 14 1, 740 1,740 1 3,066 1 1 5,000 1 3,066 285 235 D o l. D o l. 20 11 1 121 1,897 432 D o l. 1 2,064 {SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS Delaware 2 2 Sergeants,. Detectives- , 6 53 0 , 2 Women’s bureau: Captains____ Sergeants____ Policewomen. Matrons.. 1 1 Secretaries. ..................................... 2 1 21 1 2 , 8 , 6, , 1 1 2 1 2 , 5 2,160 0 7 2 2 , , , 0 if 2 4 0 3 1 2 1 2 0 1,740 , 0 2 2 0 0 0 1 0 5 0 0 2,100 0 , 4 0 0 1 1 , 3 { 1 l 1 1,838 1,500 0 0 600 1,200 } 3,066 1,560 1,800 2,425 25 2,220 / \ 2,340 1,200 1,200 0 28 30 6 , 1,080 4 3,246 2,489 3 6 1,959 16 3 5 2,106 2,201 } ....... i 3 4 1,260 0 5 6 2 1 2.040 (2,690 1 2,086 5 2,086 2 1,800 1,825 1 1,200 18 1 1 , 1, 4 6 2,011 i 2,106 l 2,300 1 1 2,280 1 1,980 1 2,100 1 1,980 3 1,620 1 3 2,100 14 2,425 3 900 3 1,200 25 2,425 1,200 1,200 \ 1,560 / 1,728 2,100 2,100 1 1,800 3,650 4 1,980 1 1,872 < *) (5 ) 1 3 1 23 19 0 4 8 0 0 1 1 3 1,416 2,100 3 (6 ) 1,800 2 900 1 (4 ) 3 1 1 1 1 1 , 16 , 0 2,903 6 , 1 6 2,588 , 8 , 4 5 / , 2 {80 4 0 I 1 0 0 1,800 0 960 0 0 0 1,920 2 1,500 fl 2 l 2 } ....... J 1 1,380 1 3,066 ( 1,500 1 } 1 1 / * 2,256 1 2,100 3 1 See footnotes at end of table. 3,129 } (5 ) (») 1 (2 ) 1 to 1 Telephone operators. Assistant secretaries............. .......... 3 35 1 Miscellaneous: Radio mechanics____________________ Superintendents of signals and burglar alarm systems....................... .............. Signal operators____ ________________ Clerical: Chief clerks...................................... ........... Bookkeepers.. .................... ......... ......... ....... Clerks, junior.......... ........................ 3 0 0 2,778 ) 0 7 2,873 f2,300 • 22 \ 0 to \ 3 1,872 2 1,800 2 1,800 3.000 ) 4.500 2.500 ) . 3.000 / ------ APPENDIX M iscellaneous: Plainclotheswomen. Fingerprint section: * Identification chiefs.......................... Identification clerks____ _________ Fingerprint operators............ Miscellaneous: Photographers_________ Assistant photographers. Telephone and radio division: Superintendents___________ Radio operators........... ......... Clerks, senior.................................. 1 2 1 1 3 , 6 1 0, i l T able B .— P o lice-departm en t em p lo yees in each o f 9 South A tla ntic cities o f group 7, classified according to individ ual occupations and corresponding salary rates , J u ly 1 , 1 9 3 8 — Continued Division and occupation District of Columbia Wilmington Washington Georgia Miami Jacksonville Tampa Maryland Atlanta Florida Baltimore Virginia Norfolk Richmond Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary rate ber ber rate ber rate ber ber rate ber rate ber ber rate ber rate rate rate Clerical—C ontinued. Stenographers _ 77 Maintenance: _______ _ _ __ ____ Superintendents8 Electricians_____________________________ n Janitors, including janitresses and porters... 1,200 1,320 1,380 (5 ) 1 1,200 l 34 { { ! ! 1,200 1,560 / 945 1,680 { 1,320 1 780 1 883 3 1,200 - 5 1,173 5 16 1.980 1,200 I 1,200 3 2 1 (9 ) i 468 1,460 1,825 2,086 1,200 i 2,100 1 2,868 i 1.980 2 (9 ) 1,800 3 I! 1 1, 576 (9 ) 4 3,650 2,425 18 1,548 1,980 \ 1,800 / 1 1 1,260 1 . 14 1 ' 2,106 1,890 1, 920 I 2,086 1 13 2,394 I2,654 / - 1 1 { Automobile, including assistants______ Building maintenance________________ Foremen____________________________ Painters_____________________ _______ Painters, sign____ ______ _. ____ Street-sign construction and mainte nance men.. __________________ Miscellaneous: Car checkers.._____ ____ ____ _______ Custodians. _______ ______ _________ Elevator operators____ _____________ Miscellaneous: Surgeons ..... ................... ...... ... ______ Nurses_ _____ ____________ __________ _ Physical directors..--------------------------------- 1 1,860 1 1 Typists______________________________ __ Hostlers. _________ ____________________ Laborers_______________ ____ _______ ___ Linemen___ ____ _____________________ . Machinists ____________________________ General mechanics: fl, 620 to [2,300 1,260 1,440 1,500 \ 708 1,200 1,667 1,800 1,950 1,800 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS Delaware Oa Pistol range officers............................ Inspectors, taxicab________________ Chauffeurs, police cranes ................... Messengers......................................... House of detention: Clerks, assistant-....................... . Clerks, under. ............................ . Domestic attendants................... Mechanics, minor.... ................... Parking-meter division: Superintendents......................... . Mechanics..... .............................. Stenographers-.......................... Supervisors of weights and measures. 6 1,200 1 1,440 1 1,200 1 1,920 1 1,260 1 1,320 1 1,500 1 1 1,680 1 2 1,200 1 3 1 1,920 1, 320 1,200 1 2,100 * Men assigned to this work. « Includes 4 at $1,440, 5 at $1,500, 1 at $1,560, 2 at $1,620, and 1 at $1,680. 2Includes 2 at $1,620, 1 at $1,680, 1 at $2,200, and 3 at $2,300. 8 Superintendent of maintenance in Baltimore ranked as lieutenant. • On call. APPENDIX 1 Cities with a population of 100,000 or more, based on U. S. Census of Population for 1930. 2 Totals include regular, full-time employees, but do not include part-time employees or call men. » Includes 1 at $2,300, 5 at $2,394, 18 at $2,489, 10 at $2,584, and 1 at $2,690. 4Work of this section performed by detective bureau in Wilmington, Washington (except for photographers), and Richmond. 1 2,520 18 T SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS able C.— P o lice-dep a rtm en t em p lo yees i n each o f I S S ou th A tla n tic cities o f sa la ry ra tes , Georgia Augusta North Carolina Macon Asheville Charlotte Division and occupation 1 u $ 4 ) X > z l 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 All divisions *____________________________________ Uniformed division: Chiefs or superintendents_____ ___ ______ _______ Assistant or deputy chiefs __ ___ _____ Inspectors___ _______________________ ______ _ Captains________________ __ _____ _ ___ _ Lieutenants___________________________ _____ _ Sergeants_______ ______________________________ Plainclothesmen______________________________ Patrolmen: 1st grade...................... ............ ................. ........ 2d grade________________________ ______ ___ 3d grade ____________________ ___________ 4th grade_________________________________ 5th grade . ______ _ _ _ ___ Other: Motorcycle officers Cruise-car officers. ___________________ 2 O Q 1 104 37 38 39 Fingerprint section:3 Identification chiefs______ _____________ _____ Identification clerks__________________________ Fingerprint operators______________________ . . . 43 44 45 Telephone and radio:3 Superintendents___________________________ Radio operators________________ _____________ Telephone operators____ _____________________ 46 47 48 49 Clerical: Chief clerks__________ ______ __________________ Clerks________________________________________ Secretaries____________________________________ Stenographers_______________ _______ _________ 0 3 '3 fc m 75 © 2 < 3 a a £ • a O Q z 68 D o l. 1 2,460 1 2,100 1 4,000 6 1,860 5 1,530 4 1,800 5 1,800 4 1,680 59 1,440 12 1,380 42 1,620 < 3 x> a 3 z 1 O Q 105 D o l. 1 1 1 3 1 3 < x > 2 >» 3,000 2,400 1,920 1,920 1,860 1,800 27 1,680 13 1,512 D o l. 1 3,300 3 2,250 3 2,040 5 1,860 25 1,800 36 1,740 3 1,770 3 1,620 2 1,500 3 1,740 1 1,920 1 2, 250 1 1,980 1 1,500 1 2,040 1 1,680 3 1,980 1 1,860 1 2,100 1 2,400 1 2,700 5 1,560 10 1,800 7 1,800 8 1 2,100 Women’s bureau: Lieutenants__________________________________ Policewomen.______________________ _________ Matrons_____________________________ ____ 40 41 42 >> D o l. Patrol drivers_____________________________________ Turnkeys____________________________ ___ Miscellaneous: Captains, traffic____________________ _____ Clerks of court _________________ __ _ Assistant clerks of court_________ __________ ____ Convict guards. _________________ Court bailiffs _______ _____________ _____ Jailers. ._ _______ _ ___ Jailer’s assistants_________________________ Lieutenants, desk.. _____________________ Lieutenants, motorcycle________ ____ _______ Park police . _________ ____ _______ _______ Property clerks____________________________ Sergeants, desk___________ ______________ Sergeants, traffic____________________ _____ Special officers_____________________ ____ Detective bureau: Chiefs of detectives________ ___________________ C aptains.._____________________ _____________ Lieutenants_______ __________________________ Sergeants________________ ______ __________ Detectives______________________ ___ _____ ____ < 3 1 1,200 1 1,680 3 1,200 3 960 1 900 1 2,100 1 1,320 1 2,100 2,040 1 1,560 1 1,860 1 1,740 1 2,400 . . . . 0) ’ i,"’260 1 1,200 1 1,320 1 1,500 3 1,200 1 1,440 1 Cities with a population of 50,000 and under 100,000; based o n U .S . Census of Population for 1930. 2 Includes only regular, full-time employees. » In Asheville fingerprint duties are performed by a joint city and county bureau employing 1 chief at $150 per month and 1 clerk at $100 per month. These employees are not included in any of the tables. 19 APPENDIX D o l. 1 3,000 1 3,600 3 1,920 4 lj 860 3 1,800 1 2,160 3 i;980 4 1,800 1 2,400 4 2 ; 100 7 1,920 30 1,680 21 1,680 9 1,440 2 lj 200 35 1,800 15 1,680 , 14 1 560 5 X, 440 3 1, 560 2 1,380 8 1,200 5 1,500 8 1,680 3 1,680 1 1,500 90 D o l. correspond ing 69 D o l. 1 Salary rate j Number j 83 D o l. Hunting- Wheeling ton ^ Salary rate § 0 1 fc Charles ton Number 1 | Salary rate 0 JO and West Virginia Number Columbia Roanoke 73 D o l. D o l. 1 3,600 1 2,000 Virginia j Number i j Salary rate j 140 5 77 D ol. | Number Number 1 j Salary rate Salary rate Number 72 Charles ton occu p a tion s 1 j Salary rate 1 WinstonSalem j Greens boro individual South Carolina North Carolina—Continued Durham to 1 I Salary rate 1 1 1 according J Salary rate grou p I I 1 classified J u ly 1 , 1 9 3 8 67 D o l. 1 D o l. 1 3,336 1 3,060 1 2,310 1 3,517 1 3,300 1 2,400 1 2, 640 3 1,884 7 1,686 1 1,500 1 2,160 7 1,710 3 1,980 4 1,860 4 2,100 5 1, 680 5 1,980 3 1,920 . 1 1,914 1 1, 848 1 1, 769 54 1, 500 4 1,422 10 1,356 36 1,560 4 1,260 57 1,740 1 1,680 56 1,656 43 1,680 52 1,650 2 1,470 / 2 1,422 \ 1 1 0 1, 500 J 1, 224 1 ( ? 1; 356 / 3 1,560 1 1 2 1,620 3 1,560 3 1,656 3 1, 500 3 1,680 1 1,680 2 1,650 1 1,560 1 1, 500 3 1,860 4 1,356 2 1,686 3 1,500 1 1,920 7 1,800 1 1 4 3 1 2 3 9 2,220 2,070 1,980 1,800 2,400 2,100 1,920 1,860 1 1,157 1 2,636 1 1,440 1 2,160 11 1,686 6 1,860 1 2, 520 5 1,740 1 1,920 3 1 1,800 1 1,800 1 1,500 1 1,980 1 1,200 1 1,500 (4 ) (4 ) (4) 1 1,260 894 { 5 1,680 1 1,980 8 1,680 1 1,769 5 1,650 16 17 40 41 42 2 1,680 1 2,040 1 1,740 43 44 45 3 1,620 3 1,740 1 1,806 (4 ) 1, 598 600 i 1,686 } 1 1 1,560 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 1 2,100 (4 ) 3 1,356 (4 ) 2 1,560 2 1,020 1 2,100 1 1,380 1 1,500 1 1,260 1 1,860 9 10 11 12 13 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 1 1,356 1 1,380 5 6 7 8 14 15 6 1,740 3 1,500 2 3 4 1 1,680 1 1,680 1 1,320 46 47 48 49 1 1,320 1 1,500 1 1,320 I 1,260 * Men assigned to this work. •Work of this division performed by men assigned from uniformed force in Charleston (W. Va.) and Wheeling. 20 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS South A tla n tic cities o f ■salary rates, J u ly Georgia D o t. 1 548 1 1,860 1 960 548 1 1 Asheville Charlotte Number Salary rate Salary rate Number Maintenance: • Cleaners______ _____ ________________ ________ Electricians___________ _______ _____ ________ Janitors_______________________________ _______ Laborers____________________________ _____ Machinists____________________ _______ _____ General mechanics: Automobile_____________________________ Painters__________________________________ Street-sign construction and maintenance men. Miscellaneous: Car washers_____ ______ ____ _______ _____ Firemen____ ___________ _____________ __ . Gatemen.................... ........................ ................ Utility men_______ ______ ____ ___ ________ Macon | Number Augusta Division and occupation North Carolina D o t. 1 1,200 i 1.620 960 « Work performed by separate automobile division of city government in Charlotte. D o t. 1 1,680 Salary rate em p lo yees in each o f 1 8 Number C.— P o lice-d ep a rtm en t Salary rate T able D oL APPENDIX ro u p II classified , 1 9 8 8 — Continued according to in dividu al occu p a tion s and correspond 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 T a b l e D .— P o lice-depa rtm en t em p lo yees in each o f 1 7 South Atla ntic cities o f group I I I ,1 classified according to individual occupations and corresponding salary rates, J u ly l y 1 9 8 8 Georgia Florida Pensacola St. Petersburg West Palm Beach Columbus North Carolina Maryland Cumberland Hagerstown High Point Num- Salary Num* Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary ber ber ber rate rate ber rate rate ber rate rate ber ber rate ber rate 53 Uniformed division: Chiefs or superintendents-___ _____________ Assistant or"deputy chiefs_________________ Captains_________________________________ Lieutenants______________________________ 1 Sergeants _ ________________________ _____ P lainelothesmen_____________________ Patrolmen: 1st grade.___ _________________________ 2d grade_________________________ ____ 3d grade______________________________ 4th grade_____ ______________________ 5th grade_____________________ ____ ___ 6th grade___________ _____ ____________ Probationary_________________________ Other: Motorcycle officers......... ..................... ( l Cruiser-car officers.............................. Patrol drivers____________________________ Turnkeys____ ___________________________ Miscellaneous: Desk officers....................._........................ Probation officers______________ _____ Wardens________ ______ _____ _____ ___ Detective bureau: Chiefs of detectives..... .............. ...................... Captains______ __________________________ Lieutenants______________________________ Sergeants__________________________ ____ Detectives................... .................. ................. 1 1 3 21 43 51 1 $3,000 1 1,920 i 1,800 1,620 } ......... 1,800 1,560 3 1,512 1,440 22 1,440 1,320 1, 500 } 6 3 49 70 $3,600 2,100 1,980 1 $2,700 1 $3,300 1 2,100 4 3 1,782 3 1,860 4 1,740 17 1 1,650 1,440 25 1,680 18 4 5 6 5 9 18 1, 320 1,548 1,476 1,452 1,428 1,404 1, 380 3 1,477 1.620 1,500 $2,400 2,040 1 1 4 1,680 1,680 1 2 1,800 1,620 30 1,620 24 2 1,500 1,380 3 1,200 3 1 $2,700 1 1,920 7 1,680 26 1,620 1,620 2 980 1,680 1 1,800 1,620 5 1,680 $2,400 1,770 4 1, 782 2.400 1 1,860 ( i l 1 1,500 1,800 1,200 1 1,620 1 1,260 (3 ) 3 1 1 1,770 3 7 47 1,980 1 1 39 ____4 $2,400 I £ 5 1 1 3 37 4 1 1 1.620 1 1,800 l 1,980 I 1 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS Orlando Division and occupation to to 1 1 1,782 1,860 1,800 1 1,800 1 1 1,476 900 1 1,200 600 2 1,020 1 1,800 1,440 1 1 1 1 3 1,770 1,980 1 1,200 (3 ) 1 Clerks.............................................. 1,620 1 1 945 1,200 1,500 1 720 1,043 i 900 1,440 / i 2 1 1,500 1,200 521 3 1 1,200 900 1 1 750 600 1 1 1 960 APPENDIX Women’s bureau: Sergeants Policewomen Fingerprint section: < Identification chiefs _______________ __ Fingerprint operators ___________________ Telephone'and radio:« Superintendents_________________________ Radio operators _________________________ Telephone operators ____________________ Clerical Chief clerks................................... .................. ............. Secretaries __________________________ Stenographers ____ __ Typists............................................................. Maintenance: * Electricians ___________________________ Janitors__ ____________ ____ ____ ____ General mechanics: Automobile ................................. Painters ______________________ Painters (sig n )______________ _______ Parking-meter repairmen______________ Street-sign construction and maintenance men. i Miscellaneous: City physicians__________________________ Superintendents of stockades______________ Guards at stockades______________________ __________________________ Watchmen See footnotes at end of table. to CO T a b l e D.— P o lice-depa rtm en t em p lo yees in each o f 1 7 South Atla ntic cities o f group I l l y classified according to individual occupations and corresponding salary rates , J u ly 1 , 1 9 3 8 — Continued North Carolina—Con. Raleigh Wilmington Greenville Spartanburg Lynchburg Newport News West Virginia Petersburg Portsmouth Parkersburg Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary Num Salary ber rate ber rate ber rate rate ber rate ber rate ber ber rate ber rate ber rate 42 63 Uniformed division: Chiefs or superintendents________ __________ Assistant nrdeputy r»hipfs Captains Lieutenants_______________________________ Sergeants.__________________ _____________ Plainclothesmen . Patrolmen: 1st grade______________________________ 2d grade_______________________________ 3d grade . ____ _ 4th grade ......... 5th grade_ _____ _ ___ _ __ 6th grade - - - - - _______ ____ _ __ _ Probationary___ __________ __________ Other: Motorcycle officers_________________ Cruiser-car officers Patrol drivers ____ Turnkeys _______ _ Miscellaneous: Desk officers__________________ _______ Probation officers ________________ _____ Wardens______________________ ________ Detective bureau: Chiefs of detectives _ _____ ______ _ Captains _ _ ............. ........... ......... ... Lieutenants__________ _________ ________ ____ ________ Sergeants _ _ _ ___ __ Detectives.... ............................................... Women’s bureau: Sergeants .. _______ _______ _ ________ Policewomen______________________________ 53 47 60 41 38 48 18 1 $2,400 1 2,100 1 $2,520 1 $2,280 1 1 5 1,920 1,860 1,680 2 2 1,740 1,590 4 3 1,620 1,620 3 35 1,560 23 1,500 31 5 1,440 1, 380 11 7 1,560 1,260 8 1 $3,000 3 1 4 1 2,100 2,040 1,860 1.740 21 6 4 1 1.740 1,680 1,560 1,500 1 $2,205 3 1,800 2 2 5 19 1 4 1,500 1,440 1,320 1,740 1,560 5 1 $2,700 1 $2,500 1 1 $2,700 1,844 1,781 { 1,748 1,560 2 1 1.500 1.500 1,620 3 3 2,012 1,830 38 1,770 1 2,400 1 2,100 2 1,740 6 1,680 i 1.500 1 1 1 3 1,740 1,590 1,500 1,500 1 2,280 1 8 2, 400 1,560 2,153 1 2,500 1 1,920 1,890 2 2 1,860 1, 740 1 1,800 1 1 1,500 900 1,620 4 1 5 1,680 1,708 1,456 3 3 18 2 1,708 1 900 1 1,844 5 1,708 1 $2,100 i 1,968 1,992 1 14 1,800 1,620 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS Division and occupation Virginia South Carolina 2,700 1 1 3 1.500 1.500 1 1 1 1,440 3 1,590 1,800 2,000 1,680 1 1, 500 3 1 1,680 1, 440 1 (3 ) (3 ) (3 ) 1 (3 ) 1 1 (3 ) (3 ) (3 ) (3 ) 1, 400 1,708 1,000 (3 ) 1,860 1,000 521 1,043 / ------ 2 521 1 900 1,825 1 Cities of 25,000 and under 50,000, based on U. S. Census of Population for 1930. 2Includes regular full-time employees but not part-time employees or call men. 3 Men assigned to this work. 4 Work of this division under supervision of detective bureau in Orlando, Cumberland, and High Point. Fingerprinting is done by a county investigator in Hagerstown and by a joint city-county bureau in Wilmington. In Petersburg, Va., the work is done on assignment by employees from other divisions. 1,500 1 936 APPENDIX Fingerprint section:4 Identification chiefs_______________ ____ ____ Fingerprint operators. ................. .................... . Telephone and radio:5 Superintendents___________________ ____ ___ Radio operators____________________ _______ Telephone operators________ ______ ________ _ Clerical:6 Chief clerks_______________________________ Clerks____________________________________ Secretaries________________________________ Stenographers_____________________________ Typists___________________________________ Maintenance:7 Electricians_______________________________ Janitors.______ ___________________________ General mechanics: Automobile___________________________ Painters______________________________ Painters (sign)_____ ___________________ Parking-meter repairmen .. .. ... _ ... Street-sign construction and maintenance men_________________________________ Miscellaneous: C ity physicians___________ _____ ___________ Superintendents of stockades........ ................. Guards at stockades________________ ____ ___ Watchmen.......... ............................................ . 3 Work of this division done by men assigned from uniformed force in Pensacola, St. Petersburg, West Palm Beach, High Point, and Portsmouth. 6 Clerical work in High Point is done by the detective bureau and in Portsmouth by men assigned from uniformed force. 7 Work of this division performed by department of electricity and department of custodians in Lynchburg. * On call. bO o* 26 T SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS able E .— P olice-dep a rtm en t em p lo yees and total salaries in S o u th A tla n tic cities , classified according to d iv isio n s, J u ly 1 , 1 9 8 8 1 Number of employees Division and occupation Total annual salaries City group !» City group * All cities All cities I II III I II III All divisions......... .................................... 6,998 5,070 1,129 799 $14,037, 223 $10,880,977 $1,875, 599 $1, 280, 647 Uniformed division.............................. . 5,818 4,258 Chiefs..._______ ________ ______ _ Assistant chiefs____ ________ _____ Inspectors.____ __________________ Captains............ ................................ Lieutenants_______________ ______ Sergeants.____ _____ ____________ Plainclothesmen_________________ Patrolmen: 1st grade..................... ................. 2d grade...................... ................. 3d grade..________ ___________ 4th grade_____________________ 5th grade and below.................. Probationary____ ____________ Other: Motorcycle officers_______ Cruiser^car officers________ Patrol drivers_____ _________ ____ Turnkeys_______ ________ _______ Miscellaneous______ _____________ 916 644 11,784,650 9,215,591 1,529,039 1,040,020 9 5 10 50 124 289 66 13 17 4 4 1 16 "1 6 43 22 53 54 1 6 131,958 34,592 45,180 219,450 465,306 878,092 169,260 45,840 17,622 43,260 155,918 342,308 692,809 156,720 41,213 8,810 1,920 31,944 83,820 92,951 10,800 3,758 2,841 343 205 266 224 165 151 149 127 21 537 380 96 42 29 13 7 7 8 14 21 7,522, 594 629,771 502,131 323,615 276, 740 27,360 6,041,140 414,471 440,871 303,587 247, 700 879,156 152,364 42,480 9,960 9,600 602,298 62,936 18,780 10,068 19,440 27,360 39,600 39 13 11 82 189 396 73 51 20 28 130 "'9 7 63 31 41 9 44,905 8,160 31,588 39,178 92,332 1,740 14 20 25 17 27 17 8 8 15 5 90,510 43,764 239,374 111, 435 73, 518 188,602 63,344 21, 799 23,250 31,284 37,788 27,120 44,579 27,660 12,480 12,984 20,971 7,140 532 336 113 83 1,169, 557 816,851 208, 771 143, 935 21 1 1 10 44 148 307 5 1 1 5 36 125 163 8 8 17,673 2 3 10 60 18,171 2,040 3,561 14,945 101,328 326,916 349,890 18,476 3 5 13 84 54,320 2,040 3,561 25,129 117,138 368,615 598, 754 6,540 10,350 23,849 149, 556 3,644 5,460 17,850 99, 308 Women’s bureau...................................... 95 82 10 3 169,996 153, 274 12,822 3,900 Captains_____ ____ ______________ Lieutenants________________ _____ Sergeants____________________ Policewomen____ _______ ________ Matrons____ _________ ___________ Miscellaneous__ ____ ____________ 1 1 3 40 49 1 1 3,600 41 6 3,600 1,920 7,000 84,984 69,852 2,640 5,500 78,444 63,090 2,640 4,140 6,762 Fingerprint section________ __________ 37 15 13 9 69,516 30,216 22,500 16,800 Identification chiefs______________ Identification clerks________ _____ Fingerprint operators....................... Miscellaneous.................................... 19 5 5 7 3 2 3 40,231 14,189 9,448 5,648 13,619 8,249 2,700 5,648 13,200 5,940 3,360 13,412 6 7 4 2 Telephone and radio............................... 131 90 22 19 243, 708 182,070 31,908 29,730 Superintendents-............................. Radio operators.................................. Telephone operators. ............... ......... Miscellaneous..................................... 11 58 57 6 30 49 2 12 16 5,100 24,630 5 14,610 64,847 92,713 9,900 4,380 16,308 11,220 5 24,090 105,785 103,933 9,900 Clerical division........................................ 184 138 26 20 302,895 241,321 36,470 25,104 Chief clerks ............... ........................ Clerks and bookkeepers.................. Secretaries....... .................................... Assistant secretaries______ _______ Stenographers and typists............... 14 84 19 6 63 7 4 4 13 7 8 5,316 10,620 6,405 57 2 3 13,859 88,724 17,466 13,000 108,272 7,026 16,424 10,440 62 26,201 115,768 34,311 13,000 113,615 2,580 2,763 Detective bureau........................... .......... Chiefs........................................ .......... Assistant chiefs________ __________ Inspectors______________________ _ Captains_______ ____________ ____ Lieutenants____ __________ ____ _ Sergeants__________ _ ____ _____ Detectives____ ____ ______________ 9 5 2 35 5 1 .... 3 3 8 2 2 3 5 1,920 1,500 2,400 3, 388 1 Complete details on the number of employees and the range of salaries for each occupation are shown in appendix tables B, C, and D. 8 See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. 27 APPENDIX T able E.— P olice-dep a rtm en t em p lo yees and total salaries in Sou th A tla n tic cities , classified according to d iv isio n s , J u l y 1 , 1 9 8 8 — Continued Number of employees Division and occupation All cities Total annual salaries City group I II Maintenance...... ............ ......................... 173 127 Superintendents______ _____ _____ Cleaners_____ ___________________ Electricians. ............. ................... . Janitors___________ ______________ Hostlers_____ ____ _______________ Laborers________ ______ _________ Linemen___ ____ ________________ Machinists_______ ______ _______ General mechanics ______________ M iscellaneous............................... . 1 1 19 61 5 20 4 19 31 12 M iscellaneous________________ _______ 28 24 1 III 1 15 46 5 16 4 16 18 6 1 Medical division_____ ____ ______ Instruction division........ ................. Inspection division........................ . Miscellaneous____________________ 2 20 1 I II m $256,960 $206,134 3,650 3 6 _ 7 6 3,650 548 42,843 63,961 7,300 32,512 5,706 37,844 48,528 14,068 36,573 51,754 7,300 29,200 5,706 33,014 32,345 6,592 4 39,941 35,520 4,421 4 1,800 3,300 2,520 32,321 1,800 3,300 2,520 27,900 4,421 29 17 i 3 ""I 9 6 4 2 24 City group All cities 1 $34,089 $16,737 548 5,520 5,461 750 6,746 3,312 4,830 6,942 7,476 9,241 T able F.— P o lice-departm en t em p lo yees in South A tla n tic citiesf classified according to hours and d a ys on d u ty and d ivisio n s, J u l y 1 , 1 9 3 8 U) 00 Number of employees System of operation Aver age days on duty per week All systems............ Continuous duty.. 2- platoon: 10-hour tours overlapping, off 0.5 day per week. 7.0 65.0 6.5 Other- 55.6 7.0 7.0 n 5,070 1,129 4,724 977 904 271 389 535 254 6.2 6.0 1,768 1,392 133 5.8 604 344 151 6.7 6.0 6.5 City group1 All cities in 799 5,818 4,258 916 30 30 35 1,863 601 389 48 87 1,768 1,570 6.8 m Detective bureau 644 Women's bureau City group 1 City group 1 All cities All cities in III 532 336 83 425 319 51 86 17 32 10 95 113 2 3 6,361 63.0 56.0 54.2 54.0 54.0 52.3 49.9 48.0 Uniformed division City group 1 All cities 6,998 168.0 3-platoon.................................- .................................. ...... 9-hour tours overlapping, no time off............... 8-hour tours, no time off.............. ..................... 8-hour tours, off 1 day per month..................... 8hour tours, off 14 days per year__ 9hour tours overlapping, off 1 day per week. 8-hour tours, off every 15th day........................ 8-hour tours, off every 9th day.......................... 8-hour tours, off 1 day per week........................ All divisions 55 30 660 5,734 4,239 31 1,639 153 235 527 332 332 44 85 1, 628 1, 628 1,448 1,291 52 18 897 53 32 4 2 78 83 107 81 SALARIES AND HOURS, POLICE DEPARTMENTS Aver age hours on duty per week T able F .— P olice-dep a rtm en t em p loyees in South Atlantic cities , classified according to hours and d a ys o n d u ty and d ivision s, J u ly 1 , 1 9 8 8 — Continued Number of employees Telephone and radio division Fingerprint section System of operation All cities III 37 15 13 9 9 2 7 6 3 3 City group 1 I II 131 90 22 19 1 104 76 18 31 19 11 19 7 11 6 12 27 14 II III I II III City group i All cities I II III 39 III I City group i All cities 6 39 4 City group i 10 1 All cities Miscellaneous 184 138 26 20 173 127 29 17 28 24 184 138 26 20 173 127 29 17 28 24 4 . __ 9-hour tours overlapping, no time off.. __ 8-hnnr tours, no time off 8-hour tours, off 1 day per month__________ 8-hour tours, off 14 days per y e a r ............... 9-hour tours overlapping, off 1 day per week. 8-hour tours, off every 15th day _____ 8-hour tours, off every 9th day _ _________ 8-hour tours, off 1 day per w e e k ._________ _ _ ____ _. . _ _ Other................................................. ........................................ 2 25 2 6 11 8 APPENDIX _ II All cities Maintenance division _ __ 2-platoon: 10-hour tours overlapping, off 0.5 day per week 3-platoon I 12 All systems..................................................... ....................... . Continuous duty City group 1 Clerical division 4 4 9 4 1See footnote 2 of table 1 for size of cities in each group. o fcO CD