View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

1

FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD
WASHINGTON
ADDRESS OFFICIAl.. CORRESPONDENCJi! TO
THE FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD

X-6285

April 9, 1929.

SUBJECT:

Improper methods in obtaining
confessions of violations of
bankint; laws.

Dear Sir:
There are enclosed for your information copies of two letters addressed
to the Comptroller of the Currency and the
Governor of the Federal Reserve Board, respectively, by the Attorney General of the
United States with reference to the actio~
of a private detective agency investigating
apparent violations of the national banking
laws which obtained a confession 11 by promise
of irmnu.ni ty and with considerable coercion. 11
You are requested to call this
matter to the attention of all of your examiners and to warn them not to use such
methods, since they are likely to interfere
with the due administration of justice and
perhaps to prevent a subsequent successful
investigation by the authorized agencies of
the Department of Justice.
Very truly yours,

E. M. McClelland,
Assistant Secretary.

:Enclosures.
TO AGENTS OF .ALL F. R • :BANKS •



338

! 339

X-628'5-a
DEPARTMENT OF .nJSTIOE

WHR:DOK

WASHINGTON, D. C.

ORL-WHR

March 29, 1929.

29-36-37-

The Governor,
The Federal Reserve Board.
Sir:
.
This Department has received from the Comptroller of
the Currency ~ copy of a report made to the United States District Attorney at Boston, MassaChuse~ts, by Chie£ Natib~l Bank
Examiner F. D• Williams, concerning il.pparent violations of the
national banking laws by one Ralph L. toung, an amployEie of the
Brockton National Bhnk of Brockton, Massachusetts.
The co:py of the report of Chie:t' Examiner Williams is
accompanied by; a co~'Y of a teport dated the 21st instant addressed to the 1i'e'diral R~serve Bank at Boston, "Attention: l4r. WilliWnl, Chief itttt:i.onal Bank Examiner" and signed by G. 0. Breach
as Ct~inal Manager of the William J. Burns International Detective .Agency. The latter report contains certain statements whieh
have attracted the earnest attention of this De~artment and which
are referred to in a letter of this date to the Comptroller of
the Currency, a copy of which I am enclosing herewith for your
attention and such action as you deem proper.
Respectfully,
For the Attorney General,

(S)

O. R. LUHRING,

Assistant Attorney General.

Encl, 110643.




340
X-6285-b
WHR:DCK

031..-

29-36-37-

March 29, 1929.

The Comptroller of the Currency.
Sir:

...

I desire to aCknowledge your letter of the
25th instant, enclosing two copies of a. re'9ort made
to the United States Attorney at Boston, Massachusetts,
by Chief National Bank Examiner F. D. Williarus concerning apparent violations of the national banking
laws by Ralph L. Young, an employee of the Brockton
National Barik of Brockton, Massachusetts.
A copy of the report of Chief Examiner
Williams is accompanied by a copy of a report signed
by G. o. Breach, Criminal Manager for the William J.
Burns International Detective Agency, Inc., in whiCh
the writer states that an effort was made to obtain
an admission from the accused without promising immunity or compro~ising himself in any way, but adds
that this effort was unsuccessful and that 11 seeing
that there was no possibility of obtaining an admission under these circumstances, I socured a full
confession by promise of immu.ni ty and with considerable coercion."
This quotation is presented for your earnest
consideration and for such action or suggestions as
you deem proper, with a view to discouraging and suppressing such methods on the part of this and any other
unofficial organization which are so likely to interfere with the due administration of justice and perhaps
to prevent a subsequent successful investigation by the
authorized agencies of this Department.
Respectfully,
For the Attorney General,

0 • R • LUHRUTG,

Assistant Attorney General.
Copy to;
The Governor, Federal Reserve Board.