View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

X-5055

FEDERAL RESERVE :BANK
OF NEW YORK

November 22, 1927.

Dear Governor Young:
On November ·17 I forwarded to yo1J. a. copy of the Minutes of the
recent Conf-erence of G9vernor.s a.nd .. I ha.ve today

:t:o~a.rded

a. letter referring

speqifica.lly to certain matters act-ed upon a.t the Conference which were submi tted to the Fede:ra.l Reser.ve Board for its advice a.nd approval or upon
which the :Board ha.s asked for the opinion or r.ecommendation of the Confer-ence.

As indicated in .the Minutes a.s.well as in the letter of today•s
dat·e, the Conference vot·ed (see paragraph 17, ·Secretary's Minutes) tha.t in
its opinion it would be advisable for the .Federal Reserve :Board to call a
conferenc-e of the counsel of the several Federal reserve batiks in
Washington at a reasonably
to consider the

e~ly

vario~s le~l

date to meet with Mr. Wyatt and Mr. :Baker

questions pending before the System.

While

the Conference voted to request the counsel of the several Federal reserve
'

.

banks to bring to that meeting, if called, a.n:y legal questions now pending
before them which they

thi~

should be submitted to the meeting,

nevertheless~

I was asked as Secretary of the Conference to submit to the :Board a list of
thoae questions pending before the Conference of Governors which it was
thought should be considered by the Conference of Counsel.

For your informa-

tion I am glad to list below the topics referred to.
(a) Wha.t effect will ruling of Supreme Court of Texas
that trade acceptances are non-negotiable which
bear the legend - "The obligation of the acceptor



-2-

hereof arises out of the purchase of goods from
the drawer, ma. turi ty being in conforr.1i ty with the
original terms of purchase 11 -have upon the
negotiability of barucers acceptances containing
similar lanc;uage, e. g., 11 This accepta.."lce arises
from the donestic storage of cotton and was secured at tir.:1e of acceptance by documents securing
and conveying title to --- bales and will remain
so secured throughout the life of this acceptance. 11
(b)

In view of recent decision of Supreme Court of Kansas
(Colorado and So. Railway Co. vs. Docking, Receiver
of American State Bank, 124 Kansas, 48), in which it
was held that directions contained in cash letters to
remit by draft, changed the relationship between the
forwarding bank and collecting bank from principal and
agent to that of creditor and debtor: Vfhat change, if
any, should be made in methods of procedure no~ followed to obtain imr.1ediately available remittances for cash
letters?

(c)

The action of certain member banks in stamping on
cashier's checks the phrase 11 not payable through Federal
reserve banks. 11

(d)

The action of member banks in stamping on cashier's checks
the phrase 11 Payable in New York Exchant;e. 11

(e)

The par clearance case of the State Bank of Hugo, Minn.

(f)

The individual reports by each Federal reserve ba11k outlining the procedure followed by each bank in handling
cash and non-cash collections. These reports were prepared as a result of a request made at the Spring Conference of Governors to be submitted to Mr. Eaker for his
review and recom.nenda.tions.

(g)

The right of a Federal reserve bank to charge to the
reserve account of a.."l insolvent member ba:ik checks received by the Federal reserve bruik for collection and
transmitted to the member ba..Jk for payment prior to the
insolvency. (See Board letter (X-4976) dated October 1927.
In the opinion of tho Governors Conference all of the.se topics

listed above should be subnitted to the Conference of Cotu1sel of the Federal




f

..

~.

X-5055

-3-

'

reserve banks for their consideration if tho Federal Reserve Board agrees
with the bovernors that such a conference should be called.
Very truly yours,
GEORGE L. HARRISON,
Secretary, Governors Conference.
Honorable R. A. Young,
Governor, Federal Reserve Board,
Washington, D. C.