View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Princebay, Staten Island, N.Y., Jan 50,1957
Mr Marriner S. Ecolee,
Chairman , Federal Reserve Board ,
Washington , D.C.
Dear SirrHaving just read your remarks before the New England
Bank Management Council

at Boston on November 15, I an tempted to

write you an appreciation of what seems to me

to be a very

excellent and inspiring piece of work. Of course, ny opinion is
of no

interest or consequence, for I am not a banker j merely

a former financial writer for newspapers now out of a job but
still interested

and concerned

economic and financial problems .
might

with what is transpiring in our
It is just possible that you

like to

learn how your remarks impresssed an "outsider."
h
Some of the ^.ngs you said reconciled me to accept with better

grace and more approval

soma of the steps that have been taken by

the Government- changes which upset and threw out of the window some of
the old , conservative notions we had been taught. I am thinking
specifically of the
taxation of corporate
dangerous

strenous opposition that

was made to the

surpluses . It has been made to appear a

step toward the dissipation of reserves j yeti believe now

you are right in pointing out that they should have been used
to increase

consumers' purchasing power > instead of fattening

foreigp loans

and stock market speculation.

It appears , looking backward, that stinginess and greed
on the part of those profitting most generously from our prosperity
contributed

potently to plunge us into

distress . It is evident

that some of those profits, a larger part, should have been
distributed to the people to enable them to
and so stimulate further production.

supply their needs




I have heard

bank presidents talk about "maldistribution” as one

potent cause of the great depression but I never saw any of them
try to correct it - and I recall particularly

remarks of

the

president of one of the largest of New York's great banks .
In the nadir of the depression they not only did not know
what to do but they resisted these things that were done to
lift the country to a higher level of prosperity.
shocked and alarmed by many of the
and

X also was

seizure of

They were

steps the Government has taken-

shocked , surprised and puzzled- by the Government's

gold, of control of the Federal Reserve Banking system,

expansion of the basis of credit.
It seems that we become hidebound by traditions and
cannot refcognize the road out until wiser leaders not only
show the way but lead us out . There is a great inertia
overcome by daring men,

to be

a heavy resistance to be overcome .

Your talk at Boston ought to contribute to enlisting the bankers
to stop

resisting and put their shoulders to the wheel # to

collaborate .
Undoubtedly the movement of foreigj funds into and out
of our financial

and

securities markets ought

somehow to be

regulated , controlled . It has made plenty of trouble and will
continue to do so unless restricted . There

is resistance to

overcome there , also.
The

wider* the distribution of such an analysis and challenge

*s yours p the better it will be

for the country. It seems

too bad

if it were limited only to bankers.All thinking people should
hear it . I thank you .
Very truly yours,

0.

<

5806 Amboy Road,
Princebay, Staten Island, N.Y.




February 11, 1937.

Mr. Pierce 0. »«otton,
5806 Amboy ¿toad,
Princebay,
Staten Island, New York.
Dear Mr. »»ooton:
Chairman Eccles requested me to acknowledge your
letter of January 30th which he read with much interest
and particular appreciation of your present viewpoint with
regard to taxation of corporate surpluses.
It is most gratifying to receive a letter such
as yours which recognizes how much inertia has to be over­
come and how difficult it is to gain a general understand­
ing by the banking and business world of various measures
undertaken for the purpose of rectifying what are con­
sidered to be defects in the functioning of tae economic
system. It is especially encouraging to hear from one who
has specialized as a financial writer and therefore has a
broad background and understanding.
Very truly yours,

Elliott '¿hurston
Special Assistant
to the Chairman.

ET:b