The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
January 6 f 1956 Dear Elmert . so much for your fine l e t t e r of the 3rd, which just came i n , I will treasure your advice about the Keedinaa problem* and p&ss i t on to the Conaittecu Tour former pupil, Moiaa Pingle f was her a t #he yeer*end economics ne©tingsf and I had tlia pleasure of takiiog her to lunch at th© Harvard Club ^jhioh sh©fd never seen* She f s a very able person* and I'm glad you called her to siy attentl greetings for what is left of yours* Mildred P*S* Kr* Sproul's speech i s a particularly goo<! on©* His secretary will see that you get & copy. Dr. Hiaer ¥ood School of Business Administration University of Missouri Missouri UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI COLUMBIA SCHOOL OF BUSINESS AND PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION January 3 , 1956 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS RECEIVED Miss Mildred Adams Jflfl g t$eg Executive Director * Committee on the History of tbOMMfftft Off IMg HttTOftY Federal Reserve System #f TNf 33 Liberty S t r e e t IHHEMlttSCWVtfffSTtM New York k%9 New York Dear Mildred: I t was awfully nice t o have your note l a s t week. I should c e r t a i n l y have enjoyed being a t the lunch with you and Karl and Lester, a s I am sure you a l l had a nice and i n t e r e s t i n g time. A book of Readings i n Federal Reserve History would undoubtedly be of value for courses both in f i n a n c i a l h i s t o r y and i n monetary p o l i c i e s . Since the material t h a t could be included would be only a small portion of the amount a v a i l a b l e , the volume would necessarily r e f l e c t i n high degree the e d i t o r ' s views a s to what i s important. But I am sure that i f an independent parson l i k e Lester made the selections they would contain what the great majority of people i n the f i e l d would consider most r e l e v a n t . From here on my thoughts are r a t h e r provisional and more of the nature of questions. Should material from books and p e r i o d i c a l s be included? I should be inclined to exclude such items except possibly those that are extremely hard to get hold of. There i s also the question whether f a i r l y recent o f f i c i a l sources should be used, since they are r e a d i l y available t o students where courses i n advanced monetary subjects are given. On the other hand, material t h a t has never been published ought t o have a c e r t a i n p r i o r i t y . Of course, a s e l e c t i o n dependent on whether the material i s r a t h e r inaccessible would lack balance. But t h i s d i f f i c u l t y could be handled by including a selective bibliography of material t h a t i s r e a d i l y a c c e s s i b l e . The second p r o j e c t you mention a s a p o s s i b i l i t y — a volume of material h i t h e r t o unpublished but shedding new l i g h t — would presumably be intended primarily for scholars specializing in monetary subj e c t s , or a t any r a t e people doing research for p u b l i c a t i o n . I think you would do well t o bring out such a volume, or s e t of volumes, and perhaps you should give i t the p r i o r i t y . One of the problems here i s -2- to determine what size units should be used. Rather sizeable pieces would perhaps be preferable. If one is using the work for research, he would want to feel that such limited areas as he did cover were covered completely. On the other hand, if he had only relatively small excerpts, he would feel that he would have to cover everything again from the unpublished sources. For instance, if a speech or a letter were given, it ought to be given in full. But I realize it would be hard to follow any simple rule — a diary would have to be excerptedj You asked about the book I am working on. I made some progress during the summer — a chapter on "The Acceleration of Expenditure" and one on "The Quantity Theory of Money". Though I reject the Quantity Theory approach, I think there is real value in analyzing it in some detail and in stating why I reject it. This next semester I am getting a sabbatical with half pay and hope to do some more chapters, The Ford Foundation has asked our Department to make one application for a faculty research fellowship in economics for next year. Whether I can get in on that I donft know. There seem to be a number of difficulties. I am sorry to have missed the AEA Meeting. I should have liked especially to hear Mr. Sproulfs talk. My guess is that he spoke out plainly. A very Happy New Year to you. Cordially, Elmer Wood EW: uigr o December 20, 1955 Dear Kisser: Having just lunched in Philadelphia vlth JUrl Bopp and I#eater Chandlei', X feel that you should know how much you were aissed, end how brightly your eciro should htve buuned if the old &&; ing about ©firs burning iflien people talk about you holds true, as a l l old sayinge should in thie leonocitstic fe£e« Both men seemed in exceedingly good forau Karl h&d just sj;ent most of the previous night serving Ghrietttas dinner to the night staff &t the Bankj he should hrre been sleepy, but he seemed remarkably a l e r t and full of wit t&cL wisdom. Les w.s his u&u&l ebullient self, and the tvo men pley«d wall together* We a l l three mourned your absence* The subject of this three-cornered discussion vas r proposed volume of "Headings in Federal Reserve History*." and I w&g» asking how useful such a thin£ aslght be for their students* We talked about bringing to light important material that might nov be h&vd to come by. We flso discussed the value of a volume of materiel hitherto unpublished but shedding new light* If either of these ideas appeal to you as useful (or not), do l e t ise know. as the idee ia s t i l l being discussed* Also we asked each other about your book* but no one seeaied to know how i t was progressing, or whether the summer's work jn Esteo Park had been fruitful this year* Bo send ae word on that so that we Cfen know how the opus i s going* Meanwhile, the best of Christmas greetings to you and your good wife, and may the Hev Ye&r be good to you both* Cordially yours, Mildred Adams Dr* Elmer Wood School of Business and Public Administration (University of Missouri Columbia, Missouri c October 20, 1955 Dear Elmers Thanks ever so xauch for sending me a copy of your paper on "Recent Monetary Policies*11 I am delighted to have it and exceedingly interested in ^h&t you beve to a«y» Sitting in the middle of this Bank does not mean that I know much about whet goes on except wa&t I re&d in the papers or pick up from chance conversation, so that I find your critique v&ry provocative• I shall see that it goes to Mr, Sproul -Ao will also be interested whether or aot he agrees with you. How is the book coming on, and have you set any date vhen you thiiik you a#y have it ready for a publish erf The Cossiittee1© interest in it keeps being i&entioned by one individual or another, and I would like to be ebie to give them at least a word concerning its progress* Thanks again and best greetings to your wife* Cordially yours, Mildred Dr. El»er 603 Hock Hill Road Columbia, Missouri June 21, 1955 Dear Elmer* lour letter of June 14th was waiting for Be when I got beck fro» Minneapolis and Kansas City. My geography is so bad that I did not know quite -what the distance between Kansas City and Columbia was, but the Bank discouraged enj idea that I could hop over for a quick converse, tion with you. Under those circumstances, I was doubly glad to hear by letter that all was well. Thanks for the Midwest Economic Association program* It sounds like a good meeting, I had hop«d, however, that you made a President1s address, and I an atill so eager to know what you said that I aa hereby making a formal request for a copy of said Presidential address. Also, I am interested to see that Werner Hochwald of Washington University, who is used as consultant by the St. Louis Bank, talked about his Measurement of Money Flaws. I heard a good deal about it when I was in St. Louis last year and am curious to know how it sounded to you in that speech* fhanks for suggestions of young people* I did not see Chsrls Walker of the Dallas Bank chiefly, I think, because I kept emphasizing ay need of talking with the older sen. It was an oversight which I shall hope to remedy at a later time* Ross Robertson of the St. kouis Bank has 8 new HEoonomic Histoiy of the United States" which has just been published by Harcourt Brace as a text-book* I haven't seen it yet, but he was working on it •when I was there last year* As for Mona Dingle* I Kill certainly keep her in mind* She is a very appealing person, and I hope we may be eble to include her* Tou vill went to know that thus far the Historian has not yet been found. We ere in a stege where I think we will try to carve up the big project into monographs and get more of them started* The influence of tester Chandler as e. worker on the Strong papers has been so beneficial for this office that we ere eager to get one or two more of his calibre to work quickly* I may have intimated this in my previous letter, but it seems to be more and isore of a possibility, and I will use your suggestions of the young in that connection. I hope by this time that you have set out for Estes Park* Ve too have had a cool June, but lato June is a chengeeble jade in these parts, and I do not trust her. I shotild think you would w n t to drive across those plains vhile it was istill chilly rather than braving them in tropic veather* I shall think of you installed in that charming study with a brook babbling below you Bnd the birds calling fro® abovr?# Bo give ay beat greetings to your wife, and have & lovely Boomer. Cordially yours* Mildred Adams Dr. Elmer Wood 603 Rock Hill Road Columbiaf Missouri UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI COLUMBIA t SCHOOL OF BUSINESS AND PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION June DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS RECEIVED Miss Mildred Adams Executive Director Coromittee on the History of the Federal Reserve System 33 Liberty Street Mew York l£9 New York HE tux. Dear Mildred: I am sorry that I got a l i t t l e behind on my correspondence* We have been moving — to a house which we bought on the other side of town (603 Rock Hill Road)* Also we have been having exams* Professor Ketchum, editor of the Journal of Finance told me he would j publish a revision of "Recent Monetary Policies". That i s now in the mail j and I hope he does not change his mind* He wanted a shorter version and I f e l t i t ought to be a l i t t l e more up to date. * I am glad you talked with Mona Dingle. Her mind really clicks* Howard E l l i s told me she had read about everything that was worth reading on money. If she should do a piece of work for you i t would be awfully well done. You could not do better. Also she would be independent and objective i n her analysis. Did you meet CharI s Walker a t the Dallas Bank? We have exchanged some l e t t e r s , and he seems a very nice fellow. Ross Robertson was over here from the St. Louis Bank a few weeks back and spoke to my graduate c l a s s . He seemed to me quite an able man* You spoke of the Midwest Meeting in Omaha. I t seemed to be a real nice meeting* I am enclosing a copy of the program. George Mitchell of the Chicago Bank did not speak at the luncheon — doctor's orders* Ernest Boughman came in h i s place and made an excellent impression. I am sure you w i l l do a fine j©b on your Report. And I hope you can find the right man — or woman for the job — before long* For months I have had no time to work on my book but hope to again i n Colorado this summer* Same place* We are not hastening to get out there because we have been having the furnace on here* Why go out to Colorado when we can freeze right here in Columbia? With best regards* Sincerely, EW:mgr http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/ Enc. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Elmer Wood May 10, 1955 Deer Elmer* How that the winter has gone m& spring has cosie to the middle vest as to the east, I a& beginning to wonder about that Midwest Economic Conference of yours in the first place, end in the second place about your boojc. Hov did the spring meeting of the Midwest Economic Association go, and were there papers which we should know about? And perhaps even more important, what has happened to the book since last siasEer, or is it waiting for another summer amid the beauty of Estes Park? I know hov busy you are and how hard it is to get to sit down to unnecessary letters. At the same time, what you had to say about both the conference and the book interests me enormously, and I should not like to lose track of them. At the same time, you may like to know that after your account of your former student, Miss Mom* X&ngle, I looked her up the last time I was in Washington and had a very pleasant lunch with her. She has the reputation there, as with you, of being an extremely able person and Is obviously popular in the Boards staff. I still have to find and read studies which she may have made and which are directly credited to her in the Bulletin. I could tell you that there was interesting news of ihis project, but since the Princeton meeting we have been mostly absorbed in the daily grind and as yet without any solution -2- to the problem of "who** I went to Dallas and San Francisco in April by air, which was a very nice interlude, but even that failed to lift the burden of the problem off shoulders. At present, I as in the midst of drafting an annual report to the Rockefeller Foundation, an occupation full of opportunity to tell the world how good we are. It is a dreadful temptation, and I am not at all sure that I am going to be able to withstand it, or even that it Is vise to withstand it* Such, I am ;# afraid, is the morality of the unbewecU All this is by way of sending you best greetings and hoping that you will keep this distant place informed of things that go on which we should know about. Please give my warm regards to your wife as well as yourself. Cordially yours, Mildred Adams Dr» Elmer Vood School of Business end Public Administration University of Missouri Columbia, Missouri UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI * COLUMBIA APR 1 1 SCHOOL OF BUSINESS AND ; AND PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION * * DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS AND BUSINES Miss Mildred Adams Executive Director Committee on the History of the Federal Reserve System 33 Liberty Street New York h£9 New York Dear Mildred: I will try to get any suggested changes for the Record of the Second Meeting of the Committee to you by April 11, I am assuming you do not want substantive changes, but merely clearer statements. Last minute problems of the Midwest Economics Meeting, which comes April lk - 16, keep me pretty well occupied. With best regards, Sincerely, EW:mgr Elmer Wood p- » ,'i —T* l % % U» Editorial Changes of Elmer Wood p - 40 DR. WOOD: material, here. I am the one who wrote a good deal of this Since I believe that the crisis of 1951-53 was essentially due to a progressive decline of liquidity (whatever other objectionable features may have been present), the leading question in my mind in studying the period is "why should a country permit itself to suffer such devestating effects from monetary contraction?" The answer seems to be that some of the basic ideas then dominant were at fault. A. C. Miller, for instance, testified that the Federal Reserve should not buy securities to stop a decline in business. There was quite a little testimony given by various people to the that effect/an expansion of credit, or an expansion of money, in an unsound and declining business situation would cause further unsoundness and further decline. Beginning in 1933 theiv* was quite a revolution in ideas, and the change in ideas that were dominant seems to be related to the change in the kind of action that was taken, P. 41 DR. WOOD: Was there not a general idea in the business and financial world at that time that you did not deal with business depression by monetary expansion -- or, as it was often expressed, by tinkering with the currency? P. 55 DR. WOOD: I was thinking of a conversation with James Harvey Rogers about 1936 -- I am not certain of the exact year. Rogers told me the Administration had given up attempting to expand general demand by means of monetary measures but was going to depend more on government spending. P. 55 (lower on page) DR. WOOD: But in this period (about 1936) there was a less active effort at monetary expansion than in the period when the Thomas Amendment was passed. P. 60 DR. WOOD: Following some of the meetings of the two agencies where credit policy decisions were made, there was a public announcement that the decision was arrived at jointly by the Treasury and the Federal Reserve. I think there were two such occasions. P. 63 DR. WOOD: I wonder whether anyone here could help me to establish a little closer the date when the Treasury decided — and to what extent it decided independently -- that the two-anda-half per cent rate would be the maximum? The first point in time I can be sure about is the summer of 1941. ?• 72 DR. WOOD: Karl made a suggestion earlier that you might just take the transcript of comments that were made today. That would give the future historian a pretty good picture of the Committee's ideas. March 31, 1955 Dear Dr. Wood: Miss Adams has asked me to tell you that this office is in the process of revising the transcript of the conference at Princeton on January 29th. We have already received corrections from two participants, and we wish to add any further corrections you may suggest* ¥111 you therefore let us know before Monday, April 11th, of any changes you wish made* In the event you have no corrections, it would be most helpful for us to receive a note to that effect. Very sincerely yours, Ellen Singer Research Assistant Dr. Elmer Wood School of Business and Public Administration tfoiversity of Missouri Columbia, Missouri February 23, 1955 Beer Rimer: lour latter snd your expense account came In this morning* I was delighted to note teat the Congressional Committee had transported you from Coxuaibia to Washington end return and that we were being charged only for the Washington to Princeton expenses. Somejow, guarding one's funds becomes a kind of occupational disease, and it is always a pleasure to have them more lightly taxed then one expected* I*i8 glad you thought the meeting was interesting. The fact that you did not all egree at all times was one of the things which m&de it most valuable. We will be sending you the transcript very shortly, and I do hope you will have time to let me know how it seems to you* I will give your message to Karl and Lester. You saw, of course, that the latter had been formally ntimecL Head of the Economics Department at Princeton. Hews of it with a picture appeared in Tuesday1 s Mew Xork times. Also, you nay or aay not have heard that Bandolph Burgess is going to marry a niece of J. F. Morgan named Hrs. Helen Woods. That too was announced in Tuesday*a Times, all of which, I suppose, proves that the world does move even if we haven't yet picked an historian. Hy warmest greetings to your wife and yourself Cordially yours* Mildred Adams Dr» Blaer Wood School of Business and Public Admini s tra tion University of Missouri Columbia* Missouri U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I S S O U R C O L U M B I A r SCHOOL OF BUSINESS AND ^PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION February 20, 1955 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS RECEIVED Mr. Donald B. Woodward Committee on the History of the Federal Reserve System 33 Liberty Street New York FEB 2 3 1955 COMMUTEZ ON THE HISTORY OF THE FEDERAL RESERVE SYSifcM Dear Mr. Woodward: Thank you very much for your recent letter and for the honorarium. Though I should have been glad to do what I could without a money reward, I appreciate the Committee's thoughtfulness. It was nice to meet the members of the Committee, a majority of whom I had not met before, but whose writings or testimony I had read. With my best regards, Very sincerely, Elmer Wood U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I S S O U R I C O L U M B I A SCHOOL OF BUSINESS AND PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION February 20, 1955 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS Miss Mildred Adams Reasearch Director Committe on the History of the Federal Reserve System 33 Liberty Street New York RECEIVED FEB 2 COMMITTED Cfl THE HISTORY Of THE FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM Dear Mildred: I hope the delay in sending my expense account has not been an inconvenience. Some of the details were not immediately available. It seems to me we had an interesting meeting even though we did not all agree at times. I had an awfully nice letter from Donald Woodard. It was very thoughtful of the Committee to send me the honorarium. Tell Karl and Lester I have been intending to write to both of them about a question asked by Congressman Patman. With very best regards, Sincerely, Elmer Wood c c February 11, 1955 Bear Br* Woods The ©embers of this Cosasittee h«T« asked me to thank you in taeir manes for th© cure, the irctive thought, end the fine scholarship vhich you end your colleagues put into the memoranda you prepared for th<m end the discussions held with them* fhej recognise that th© success of the tm Frincetoa conferences held in ifioveaoer arid itmu&ry v»s solidiy oased on the work vhieh you t^iree did in advance &nd the contributions •which you m&de in the eours© of the discussion* As a sskaJLL token of their appreciation, tiiey hope you will accept the enclosed honor&rlusu Ihi» i s by no sseane to b© considered es an attempt a t compensation, but r&taer fts an earnest of their gretitude sjsd tineir esteem* May I &M my personiLl regret ihet circ*aastances beytjno my control prevented my scaring eo interei?ting &n& re a session as that of Janusry 29th must have been. With vans personal regards I am, Very sincerely yours, Donald Woodv&rd ¥ood BcnooX of Business exid Public Adteiaifftmtion University of Hisaouri , Missouri Check for $200.00. Letter and check sent to DbW for signing and mailing. January 3, 1955 Deer Elmer: It is fine news that we may expect you in Princeton at the end of January. The last time I talked with Karl, he thought that the three of you s&ight meet at the Inn on the evening of the 28th in preparation for the Saturday meeting with the full Committee, but he may have changed his idea in the meantime* If he sends us any other word, I vill let you know. Thanks for the names of James Bhodes and Cortland Peret. Both are new end sound interesting. As for Mona Dingle, I am hoping to see her next time I go to Washington. Cordially yours, Mildred Adams Dr. Elmer Wood 205 Edgewood Avenue Columbia, Missouri UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI COLU M Bl A SCHOOL OF BUSINESS AND PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION December 28, 195k DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS RECEIVED «• M L „*„ Miss Mildred Adams Research Director Committee on t h e H i s t o r y of t h e F e d e r a l Reserve System 33 Liberty Street New York US, New York Dear Mildred DEC311954 COMMITTEE ON THe HISTORY OF THE FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM I j u s t received your note of December 22 — the mail has been moving a l i t t l e slowly l a t e l y . I think I can arrange to be there a t the appointed time. Perhaps I can make my peace with the University Committee on Schedule for holding part of my examinations early, I will check with Karl as to the exact time he would prefer to have me arrive* I have been making a l i t t l e check as to possibilities for writers. Though I have not come up with anybody for the Comprehensive History, I have two or three suggestions for some of the work. No doubt you have long ago checked with Arthur Cole on any recommendations he might have; also with Howard E l l i s . Would you think Roland Robinson's former connection would disqualify him for writing a monograph? He has been a t Northwestern for some time now. One of our former students, James Rhodes, who went to Harvard and is doing his thesis there in Agricultural Economics might do a good job on the Federal Reserve.and Agriculture. He was a major in History who went over to Economics. He is back here writing his thesis under a government grant and is regarded as a very able man. Another of our former students, Cortland Peret, who one time taught sections of Money and Banking here^Ts'T^eaching fellow at Harvard. He is now doing work on the national income accounts for his thesis. He did a very good M. A.^r thesis for me on the Investment Outlook in the Agricultural Implement Industry. He would do a very careful job. When it comes to sheer genius in handling great masses of material without getting lost in it, Mona Dingle (of the Board) would be hard to equal. Her talents ougfrt to be used in some capacity if possible. . Professor Williams could probably give you some estimate of the two Harvard men mentioned above. I will be looking some more. Very sincerely Elmer Wood December 29, 1954 Dear Dr. Voodi By this time you will have received *ny Ir-tter of December 2Zr=d which explains arrangements for tiie Coajmittee meeting on January 29th, I do hope that thia is not too inconvenient for you* I as looking forward to seeing you again at Princeton. Sincerely yours, Mildred Adaras Dr. Elmer Wood School of Business and Public Administration University of Missouri Columbia, Missouri UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI COLUMBIA SCHOOL OF BUSINESS AND PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION RECEIVCD DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS M . December 26, 1954 BEC28tt$4 CN Miss Mildred Adams fCDCMU.ftlttftittIWtH Research Director Committee on the History of the Federal Reserve System 33 Liberty Street New York 45, New York Dear Mildred: In answering your letter I wanted to wait until things were in less of a rush. Karl has my suggestions for revising the Outline or Aide Memoire for the Comprehensive History. It may be that some of my suggestions are too detailed, since the real purpose of the Outline is simply to specify the kind of study that ought to be made. As to the other items you suggest, I am sure we shall be glad to do whatever might help you in your investigations. It will be interesting to see what the various members consider a "key event". As I interpret the meaning intended, it would include both outside events, such as an important bank failure or the suspension of gold payments by the Bank of England, and important developments within the System. In a sense, any major change of policy is & key event unless the change fits into a general pattern already agreed upon. The decision to have cheap money in 1924 would seem to be a key decision. The one in 1927 I should feel less certain about, as it seems to fit into the regular pattern. The decision of the Federal Reserve Bank of Hew York in 1929 to tighten credit "until the situation was corrected" (until the stock market broke) was not part of a general pattern, but a key decision, since it involved an important change of criteria of action. But one should not expect too much from a list of "key incidents". Tyhat one is faced with is a continuous development of pressures and of ideas. The decision, or whole set of decisions, to take issue with the Treasury in 1950 was a key incident, but it was a result of ideas that had been building up for some time. I expect you got my telegram regarding the time of the next meeting. I hope the matter will not give you too much trouble. A very happy New Year to you. Very sincerely, Elmer Wood Deceabe-r 22* 1954 Ur* Wood* I itai sorry th#t v* H«T« set th&t postponed Princeton me* Hag in the middle of exufitm-tlon v$ek» Oafortumiteiy for you, v© &«?# h**rd from fill but one oth^r i&rtielptat that they otm. »rriing© effairs «o fig to came to Princeton for the 29th* Under tiesse clrcieaetaiices, X &sa sure you v i l l uJKtor&t&ud th*t w®- itMltftte to aafc* 9. Mcond l a Udldag idth Kerl Bopp, I find he seesit to ^tink that i f The three of you. co^id get taget&fer oa Frld«/ evening, tfe® 23tti» thia would give you a l l the #iLtra. tla* you ne#d ia preparation for tixe ing of Uife 29tb« Peife&|?s5 this^ yhioii r®X®mm you from «in/ tw®& to coaae oa 7hur*diQrt a«y atk« taicgs €e.»l#r for you.. C*rt«daly X hop« I do h o ^ you v l l l be cbl* to «rr«iage so es to arriT^ for «. Friday ftectingfctFrioe^ton or FhlJUdtlphia^ vhich«vffr i s the more coafor the three of you. Cordially Hildreci. &*• IXmer Wood School of Business and Fufelie A&tini&tmti of Hiasourl Missouri - Br» Bopp J \ WESTERN UNION ( A V. CLASS OF SERVICE ' This is a full-rate Telegram or Cablegram unless its deferred character is indicated by a suitable symbol above or preceding the address. FX420I f W, Thefilingtime shown in the da' ' P. MARSHALL. PRESIDENT y ldUera ia STANDARD TIME at point of origin. Time of receipt ia STANDARD TIME at point j>i destination S.CMAQ56 NL PD=COLUMBIA MO 18= 1*4 I B 18 4 07 MISS MILDRED ADAMS= COMMITTEE ON HISTORY OF FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NY NYK= THE DATE SUGGESTED IS DURING OUR EXAMINATION WEEK STOP WOULD PREFER TWO WEEKS LATER THAN THAT BUT IF LATTER NOT PRACTIABLE WILL TRY TO ARRANGE FOR JANUARY TWENTY NlfcTH= ELMER WOOD=., http://fraser.stlouisfed.org/ THE COMPANY WILL APPRECIATE SUGGESTIONS FROM ITS PATRONS CONCERNING ITS SERVICE Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis i MISC. 34 (MISC. 34.3—60M—2-52) DITCCSEE- B A M * c c n I - D . . COPY.OF FEDERAL RESEfPWE BANK TELEGRAM SEND T O M i S S AGCMRA History of Tmd9 &e«. System Dec. 1£, 1954 SENT BY Tos Br, Imatmr Chandler tor. Fri»e«ton University Friac«ton, Kew Jersey Ela«r Wood Ordversity of Missouri Columbia, Missouri B*gret v« sRist postpoo« Frinc«ton ae«tlng. of January 29th. letter follovs. Sow tryin^^td arrai^fi it^for we«kerai * Mildred Ad&ras y\ * December 14, 1954 Dear Dr» Woods This is to verify in gret- ter detail the telegram I sent you this scorning saying that the meeting scheduled for Princeton on January 3th had "been postponed. Whi\t happened wa3 that both Mr. Sproul and Mr. Voodw&rd vere incapecite.ted and unable to attend the Executive meeting scheduled for December 14th. That sieent postponement of the Executive Committee meeting until after Christmas, vhich crovded the January 3tli meeting too close for anyone's comfort. It is now being suggested that the second meeting of the Committee with its consultants be set for Saturday, Jsnuery 29th, vhich would mean that you would want to plan to be here a dey or so ahead to confer with Karl Bopp and Lester Chandler. Would you let me know at your earliest convenience whether January 29th is possible for you? We do hope so* The best of the season1s greetings to you and your wife* I hope the "leather will be kind. Cordially yours, Mildred Adams Dr. Elaer Wood School of Business and Public Administration University of Missouri Columbia, Missouri December 9, 1954 Dear Dr. Wood: I have been re-reading the verbatim record of Sunday's conference, &nd the memo of Monday1s discussion, in an attempt to see vhere the/ seemed to be headed in terms of the tiling to do next, l a the process, I hay© been again impressed vith the value of the work "•mich you three experts did, not only in building the chronological fre&evork which the Coffiinittee htts been looking for, but slso in helping to per3Ui-.de the Committee iies-here to ao siucii active and interested discussion. I t i s of the greatest help in meny vsys. We will know more about the next step after the Executive Coiamittee meets on December 14.th» Me&nuhile, stay I make two suggestions In view of the importance *aiich "key incidents 8 have in the Kinds of the Committee, whtt vould you think of uuing the chronological pattern in the mexor&ndua of Monday, 2-1 av ember 22nd, as a fraesework into vhich to throw incidents, any incidents vhich occur to the minds of any of you as pertinent? Such a l i s t , fraised in appropriate periods, could provide a sketchy unc provocative basis for Committee discussion (and addition} on January 3ta* Second, &ey I suggest th&t the three of you consider, a® a besi5 for your proposed meeting on January 6th, the value of presenting the Comalttee &t the joint meeting on January 3th vith three document ss !• A re-cast *grand design" of history and monographs to replace fee one which they tore epart on. xfoveaber 21st} 2* The chronological aeao eiabodying period divisions and topics -which Les dictated on the 22nd, witli &ny changes you aey vaat made) 3» A 3Ugge?*tiV0 sketch of key incidents in their chronological fraise work j (though this is tentative) A trial questionnaire for interviews on a trial period, as Stewart suggested at Princeton, this quartet ougnt to set going discussions that vculd keep them active end interested f&r past 3*40 p»nu they vould also be of inestimable aid to the research functions of tais office* I'll be e&ger to know -what you think of these suggestions. Cordially yours, Mildred A (Dictated by Miss Adams but 3i^ned in her absence^ Dr* £lmer ¥00 d School of Business and Public Administration University of Missouri Columbia, Missouri December 1, 1954 Dear Br* Wood: I am hastening to forward to you a cofy of the stenotyi e record of the rrinceton meeting which came ir* this worning. There has not been tiae to do more than letf through it, but even *dth such slight scanning it appears bcth interesting and provocative. Ve shall be looking forward to the fruit of your consideration of this tuad the rough draft which you will hive had from Karl Bopp. Hastily yours, Mildred Adams Dr. Elmer Wood. School of Business and Public Administration University of Missouri Columbia, Missouri UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI COLUMBIA SCHOOL OF BUSINESS AND PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION November 27, 1954 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS Miss Mildred Adams Research Director Committee on the Hiptcry of the Federal Reserve System 53 Liberty Street New York 45, New York Dear Mildred: I feel I should write you a bread and butter letter with capital M B"s. You certainly took care of us royally and it was a most pleasant meeting. I thought our little group worked together amazingly well. The 1TA plane reached St. Leuis about midnight and our little Ozark plane got to Columbia about 10:30 the next morning. Lots of letters were waiting for me, not to speak of classes. I wish 1 had a secretary like Karl's. My list of expenses is inclosed. Tomorrow I will send back the folder you loaned me. Don Woodward sent me an exceedingly nice note, which I appreciated very much indeed. If I could only show it to our University President 1 With very best regards, Sincerely, Elmer Wood Expenses of Elmer Wood - Columbia, Mo. to Princeton Plane tickets, Columbia to Philadelphia and return $123.53 "Limousine" in St. Louis - evening of Nov. 22 and morning of Nov. 23 3 .20 Hotel, night of Nov. 22 6 .12 Food and incidentals 3 .00 Total 135.85 SEC 17954 November 2J+, 1954 Dear Dr. Wood: I know that I sm speaking for the entire Coiaaittee when 1 tell you how very grateful we all are for the skill, knowledge ana juogeaent which you poured so generously into the recent three-day Meeting at Princeton* Those of us who ©rijoyea the beaei'it of your wisaom on Sunday can only guess at what we Kissed by not being able to sit in on your expert sessions Saturday asd Hondsy, In &uuitioii to acknowledging the value of the fresh viewpoints which you brought to Cosaaittee members, Miss Mams tells me that we also owe you gratitude for the clearer definition and sharper focus which you brought to the research functions in which she is engaged• She would like me to add her tlmnks to ours. We will be looking forward with great interest to the second session in January. Sincerely yours, Donald Woodward Dr. Elmer Wood Professor of Economics School of Business and Public Administration University of Missouri Columbia, Missouri This letter elsossent to Dr. Karl Bopp Federal Reserve Bank Philadelphia Dr. Lester Chandler Princeton University Princeton, N. J. October 29, 1954 Dear Dr. VoocU Just a email note to tell you how delighted I am that you have consented to collaborate with Karl Bopp and Lester Chandler in this special attack-by-conference on the problems vith which this Cossaittee is grappling. Quite aside from the pleasure which has been expressed by Committee members, and which I share, I feel ss though a load ves being lifted off my own shoulders by the fact that you three ere willing to have a go at this. It will be good to see you in Princeton on the 21st of November. I wish we could furnish a fourteen thousand foot peak as background, but at least the town has towers. My wans regards to your wife. Cordially yours, Mildred Adams Dr. Haer Vood Professor of Economics School of Business «md Public Administration University of Missouri Columbia, Missouri Cowtitte* on th« liatezy of the t*&mX 8«*«rve Sjstm Septee&er 9, 1954 Baa* Ky. Sttwurt* Vhen v» wag* talking lust weak about Dr. User Vood of Hlstourl X prottl«#d to s«a<l you paragraphs frcaa A recent l«tt«7 la vhich he si&do cert*in s^g«3tionf- cope^rnlng the history, I •n •aelotlRg a p«ge nopl#d fion tHat letter vhlch, as I told s* f w l th»t the aowi m mm k»«P Hia thinking for tit tht off n# ncmld b«« Z h*re not b»»n abl« to ?•« Don&ld gir* him your m#«««g« bat vh«n h« «aerg«» from, e ®ert#« of d^f oonf#r*no«» I vLU d© »o. Wi«t either of in H»« v»y of & mmmrmSm of vhat v# BMH by talking of « •definite history 1 i s «oi*«thtt!g I v i l l try to get at X hope ymi h*d no difficulty at Trenton. I realised after y©u l«ft that I bud not <rr«n ttumk«d you for © »©«t ing <tiaa#r, and hoyt y««i to©k ny eb^orption in OUT t s i t s ova for© of thanks. Mont ffincerely yours, M&ldrad Director Enclosure Council of Econoaic AJvice White Houae 01 ?H1 HISTORI OF TRS WBMML 33 Liberty Street* Hew Torfe 45* Kev Tork BEetor 2-5700, Retention 2S6 c August 31, 1954 Bear Dr. lour sugg#§tl©&0 of August 18th have hem soat gratefully received* and I ttj.mil hope to put then to work. If only it vere possible to eooduet this operation in sueh at fashion that portions of it could b© assigned, to esslnsnt gcbolsrs, includtug the t&gk would b& far easier• tlhfortunately for us* the end skilled are alt© the busy ones who clo not encourage i All o»® oan hope is that they vill fee caught by »& idea end be to think about* Tfee more of this v# can enoours.ge* the happier vill fee, and ths nearer to g®ttlag a top level job going# On the v*ath»r front, I &ot# that tl» mercuxy out your way dropped elo§@ to frt«si&g, vhieh ought to m®m that ^ will btgin to turn before jou l©aY@. They b®v© alwaye s»«aied to to form oa® ©f the ®ost attractiv® gold displays in the eouatry. H©r# ¥@ hare just b##a swept hj the skirts of a hurrie®a# a*ss®d Carol, to the detrinent of soft aaple trae# m& eXeotrie power lines in Conaeetlcntt* thanks again, and ^© contiotte to think of ms feaek 1A the aeaieaic huiry of Mltsearl* when My mini greetings to your wif©# Cordially yours* Mildred. Ad air, 8 Keseareh Director Box 1041 Est®8 Park, Colorado Box 1041 Estes Park, Colorado August 18, 1954 • Bear Miss Adams: It was nice to get your note and the extra copy of my paper you sent me came in very handy. Roy Harrod!s book on The Dollar came in the last mail, and I want to tell you how very much I appreciate your sending it to me. I am enjoying reading it and seeing our System through English eyes. I have thought a good deal about your project on the History of the Federal Reserve. It seems to me that the mass of material is so great that it would be well to break up the work into several studies before any attempt is made to have a definitive history — and perhaps histories are never really definitive. In addition to the biographical studies, there might be the following types of books: The Founding of the Federal Reserve (which might or might not be combined with the Operations during the First World War) The Development of Federal Reserve Policy during the Nineteen Twenties (into the classic form in which B. Strong left it) International Monetary Cooperation of the Nineteen Twenties The Crisis of 1929 to 1933 and the Recovery The Federal Reserve System and the Treasury, with Special Reference to the Period since 1933 Then there might also be a History of Federal Reserve Procedures and Policies for the period as a whole, which, though not attempting to cover all the sourcematerial, would get some of the cream, but in the main would be analytical. Of course Karl ought to do this; but if not, he ought to keep in very close touch with it. I hope New York, or at least Connecticut, is pleasant. Last night we nearly froze here -- it got down to 361 The letter I wrote to Karl at Candlewood Lake was returned. My wife sends her very best regards. With best wishes, Sincerely yours, Elmer Wood ti Ct>fv^K EXCERPT FROM LETTIB TO MISS ADAMS FEOH EL«IR HOOD, AUGUST 18, 1954 "I have thought a good deal about your project on the History of the Federal Reserve. It seems to me that th« mass of material is so great that it would be well to break up the work into several studies before any attempt is mads to heve a definitive history — and perhaps histories are never really definitive. la addition to the biographical studies, there might be the following type* of booksi The Founding of the Federal Reserve (which slight or might not be «o«bined with the Operations during th« First World War) The Development of Federal Peserve Policy during the Nineteen Twenties (into the classic fora in which B. Strong left it) International Monetary Cooperation of the Nineteen Twenties The Crisis of 1929 to 1933 *®& the Recovery ' The Federal Reserve System and the Treasury, with Special Reference to the Period since 1933 Then there might alao be a History of Federal Reserve Procedures and Policies for the period as a whole, which, though not attempting to cover all the source material, would get some of the cream, but in th« fflaln would be analytical. Of course Karl ought to do this; bat if nott he ought to keep in very close touch with it, I hope Hew Xork, or at least Connecticut, Is pleasant. Last night w® nearly froee here — it got down to 3&t Sari at Candlewood Lake was returned,M The letter I wrote to AIK MIL o August 3, 1954 Bear Mr. Wood: It ie just a week since you were kind enough to let oe invade your st-saaer peace, and already the clear dry beauty of Estes Park has become a lovely drean. Ve doji't have aspens quivering and brooks chuckling in Liberty street, now is the supply of chipmunks really adequate • I am returning vith this note the copy of your paper for the Midwest Economic Association vhich you so kindly loaned me. Knowing bow eager others were to reed it, I have taken advantage of your permission to show it to interested friends and have had copies 23s.de for several people including Dr. Knrl Bopp and Mr. Allan Sproul. (An extra carbon is enclosed for your own files.) Also I am taking the liberty of sending you under another cover a. copy of the Harrod book on The Dollar of which we talked. I hope you will accept it as a very small a&eaento of a very stimulating pair of days. Please give ay warm regards to your wife and your sister. And do let m» know how the book progresses, and what ideas you evolve vhich isight be valuable for us. Gratefully yours, Mildred Adams Research Director Enc. Dr. Elmer Wood General Delivery Istes Park, Colorado imgust % X95A Dear Br, lopp* Is terms of interest and stimulus my visit to Ifr% ¥ood at Bstes Psrk was all tbist could be scked. He has. his typewriter set «p is & saa.ll cabin which looks out on silver aspeas, cfclpraunks &ad a talkative brook - a setting so eharaiag that only a veil disciplined intellectual could be aoved to work there* H« finds it ideal - the i* dry©r than that ia fermoat, and the interruptions fever* Be does sot, hav#v#r, vast to be considered a candidate for writing the history of t&e Federal timtervm Systea, The book on which h© it prasently «agaf««2 id.ll take st least « solid year of vork, and a^rtm thou^j he applied for a sabbatical ye^r to begin in the sonis^r of 1955, this would »e#R 1956 at the •©ry earliest before he could finish it« *fhe amount of nev fiat®rial which the Coiraittee has been turning up seemed to veigh M m down rather tt&n to ch##r him. R® gET® ae the impression that he thought himself mst the age vh«n h# would consider undertaking so voltta¬jm a task. The interriev resulted in tvo suggestions - os© froa «e {vhich he turned esside) that the book now tiader way might conceiTahly belong is the galaxy of books vhich the Co^aittee hopes to further and that therefore he *dght vast to think about applying for a grantj the other from his, ttea&t you yourself were the ideal person to do the definitive hi«tory* This second suggestion will come as no shock to you, \mt it leaves us hairing come baek to © door vhieh ve tried to enter ©arlier in the springs I had read with interest $ wmmHBf of the p&per vhich £r« Vood pres^atecE to the spring meeting of 1^te Midwest Economic Association , and I told him I had been seeking a full copy. He was kind «mough to let m» bring his own m&miseript hack, B,nd to say ttt*t I might h&r® it copied aad show it to interested friends. I an therefore enclosing a carbon, (though you may already have one) and I shall see that it goes to Mr. Sproul, Mr. Boelse &nd Dr. John Williams, all of who» imre interested ia the su?nary» c Dr. Wood wanted ise to give you his warmest greetings* Re says you are to spend your ovn vacation on C&ndlewood Lake, and he vns estger to know store about that section of New l&gltuad. I only hope that Connecticut vill prove as good a vacation spot for you as Colorado seems for him. X sal ever so grateful to you for providing &a introduction which opened «o pleasant a door. Iven though we hcv* not yet fotind our history writer ve have, I hope, awMie a valuable new friend for the Cojaaittee1 s work* Further suggestions vill be most fery sincerely yours, Mildred Adams Research Director Enc, Dr# Karl Bopp Vice President Federal lesenre Bank of riiilsdelphia 1, Peansylvaaia Paper presented at the spring 195A meeting the Kidvest Economic Association. Copied 7/30/54. from original manuscript by cermission of Elmer Vood. Copies sent to Messrs Sproul, Poelse, John Villi&msj and Karl Bopp. !•*£**« ltoe*itt tim*%*tf Palietw Is g the **y ©f of ¥ | in to not #f s t i l l %M4 * f«f%»i i>i««« i n tit* #4MMI«IW1« «ft*ljr#li It wrnmm o f 1% ***** fetlJU*** t$w&* initrntt ***** niffct «* v*U it* £**•«•« of at X«nr I * * * ! , if vitl* Igr It to * It in of tmr »htft fact In ft^|ti#i$ to th* fa* rm ill* of of ft far t it # or &mm f**r* ttm** fe*« INN* l a tfe* n#v«pfip«r* **«i in c» #f in aowrturr e«*« if It $ of Mil tmim mmi&rf follsioa #*iU«>*oai*, *»4 turn pit** «*|)fK}f*tt, fur »« i t {t©F **» $&« 4oajr that } 4a for »mr ^m a#«i# sn.-i ts £*&# our* t f eoo0tli««att to Him) / thfc rvrapo.^ntf of a f,Ujcil»l# I t v l l i fe* r«3-,*^feftr«4- tfvat UMI leMtrd ©f Q«v«i*»rs si of ar#»«rr* r«i|«ir«M ly tlt#ory **» ^«ti ^ t l i ««f«S|ll#m* fit*? S**«**5 to ibo of of tfet * *114 f«*«*;ei#& im IH4$* lawtv**, for «««* «ont^B fe#f«r» the for g<^G» thai $mm% wmr with r*t#s f«>*»« *t th» low at *&• MI4 $f th«i ymr,) it g I* wit to tliftt #nd* Al»©# Ttm s In 4*t*y«tftl*ff tmwttyy polity} *ltHmigk *t*# t* «^sb«t ?#«*s*|$ii if It In eorrtnt #? of i t tc te« for t-oftetarf r#««9H9 or ^s « control* of la to ftm*% Jftm*tsry f t l t t t a r m* H* wmm% to 1* but Is It of mm it it 1* tor «MI •xt»tX»ai 4i»«»5»'?l:ia of fey S*rl »*|^ fet^rti t^» kamxtsm $%®mm fgli&U* ie tfe* ** m of i n far a* fit* *&$£*#* $mm&mm i# I w Urn of # &* I t to mm of **i« f«4«ml ^iw»rr# ©ff 1©1*1# w» «fl«^ t$ think § It »•«§«£ te tn ^l# first plmm$ i t t* i t ft •*••»#*tty**-* t t $**»plii**t tfetir *MI UtftgWMpi *^ tot l&MAmteiHHtf thm ^ U but It it tit* first tm mm *$vm$%m l# mm M b f ^ t it#ftf|tt«» HMI% *l* fm^ml %mmm wmM- hmm fmmi ttUar ¥»tit%i#mf In i i M * * * * * * * tss Ufet* #f tlwi ln%i»iti^B» #f f«,1 nt# willing » flit # f f | # | t l «ttitiMl« t#'wmr«l tfeit XI «tttii*rlU*** t t » fmWte afee«14 %* to e&a»£#* of tret** ***&•? tinm to !#»»*• Bat 1% la I&MM* «4t&* to tutors*i*t *fea% t l » *iga*i« $«** t f %b» r»4 «*4 $ * * » * f * In « * • p»##ftt% of #f r*t« policy n#«v t t s r i i y in^felT** « «•§»»• #f tut *hm m$Mm%%*& wtlnt if t>«i a of of In ©awrl is y / In 1st Vmtm «af fc» aft** * tla#«. ft &i% in %!i$ lost ma 1% uwl®. b* In It to k& of tv,«tr to of it- it *§§»!£•• of th* ««-i# or ** It . In t i t * asfcMSttt * f i t 1« not in to it i* tm pm*ml% of tfc* f i l l e r of t i i w i a g mmm?t *&£ im pvftOtto* to #r 4# 4iffl9ttlt to tttlBftt* thm mrnmt* %hm% will %& at«4ti« itt If *b»lr of Imflicitly tf tol»r%«ee vhil« f«xiaf ^««&ii# to tbt turn ( of to imflis«fiflmf imt#»« f In perfttt^sf to th<? *^ort omi of tut 14 j *% tfcat tla* l i t *•»*•#»• for tfc* rul«, »t*t#* ih*i » aef* 4*f> i f p J i v « « of to suppor k of for ^3* p f) ^ y nt Hr« apareul ih* r«il# v t t r*»«ii&4««y with to four 5a*»Wjr* #f %IN» nrUU.it llui m l # *iw Urn tor $rmv&&mi ®wrp**** ^n rul# *** full » flit i i t t t UNMAKI? ?$H©i*» 1$ •*«#$% |n ttt« «*§• of corr<*Qt la* & -il»o^«rly ^rk«%. fh#ir em** mpt #f tfe* #ftn **ik#t for , "fait t^^t, in b« l i v«« |««»i»is«4 tlNfc% pgirt^#$^i 0: tr%ttu»7 t i l l * f In. la f # I t wm m%m ^ll#Y«i i ^ $ t to Xaag nt i t of In | ham to p»% l a (In J • In directly for tb« imrp@^ ®f providing «r -i in thm «»rr#«tloss o f * r * fc©t to m to b* ->&U^im4 by # tfe# ****** «B4 of th# it 1* In iftt*tf9*%llli tfe* lftt**Um» * itttm If, rwd it act in s ^rlu<l of but nttlmi. or «##*%#* tlm Comwitl— For # ** th* in of in i to *• is I* If, * to t mm m 1§ It It m*t mm It Is If 1% in Wmm fey i* t# ®t It it Mil ti f l a i l*14#*s for %hm* A §«r*fml s«*lftt§ * f j %m W*m %hm& tfc» to tfc* *- If f«r bill*, tin m% remit 1% %m for *s If f mmmm if this mart «# Is In for tmrnmrnp mfm. tl V lan«<ti*ttftiy r«t« •trtKfeiat m%M &m&m* i t * af rise of tm%6-« wis* In»l»«a%* %o W l«if»* ftit «*«B S««fc i«is^a4* for #»«h if ft g IMNMI J of §t»t«Kt fey j^mtNtnt f M v m l ltM»r« It ymrnmsm* tarn trmmary ^f fi«i«l« to Mr. it policy to ;^*?tt*lR # 5t?l>l* «oll«r* %h*ir «i»*. tint? 49 aw** "**»» ^It&^ot cl«i«l»g t#» «xwh for INmnat i n gift*!**! l i tttiAKL* wiife * * tftw m » M a n w i l l of it r*fl«ot lit torn 9pm was f©r »f of %&*? m&imm #f t til* «f # I* •* im F*ll«i*# 34 forts** tfc* volley, imt %li *t&t»ift«»t# *» € wfeol* #h« *» ««Mmi4«f«d tli# 4«»i#i f#r JO^R* &*«tljr r*g|M?»«itel», «t « • * %li»« Urn &m*&& fwt mm$ flit Hr* Ii»iJ»r>y» la %# Imv* l t » mnpnitl s«s4 return i #f f««% 4, for I f f I *%*%** Swam, I t ^#^*'i* a^ftr»«it %hm% h e e l e r ^<MI fc#-^ %#«^ ^ t i e i ^ t * ^ , *&§ th* primim $mmml far tea* «5r*4ii far aw*- a^ss«y et.&«#$ ifc* **ttf*l*% at i&ft *«*#* ••*•#»* Tte# &£«* tfeftwt €$imltt*# (in Jta* Iff!} to I s ift» 95*5^*%*. (B.*|^rt for of to. m 4ml&j is i t mt timm to do of IfHT^Ta v«mt l i g h t l y fe#l»w 10 of loag term mito*%+ 3Ni tfe«y «t»jr^ $*% en of ffi Itt «§ If t* t« it if 2m* tor. You n«y b*? lfti«r*#t$<£ i& ^wi»g th* f u l l %m% tfe« pap«r vhieb Br, Elsitr Vocwt ®f the Huiverslt/ of d#liv*r«d «t tfi* ©prlag MMttliig of tfe© Mldtmtt Association. X \ici«r»t«nd th^t only & h*a txwm &v«llebl« h*ro in fi«v i'ork. Host B»f *rch Director MT. Harold Bo#lt« 33 LiWrty li»v York 4 THIRTY THREE LIBERTY STREET c NEW YORK 45, N.Y August 6, 1954 Dear Miss Adams: Many thanks for a copy of Elmer Wood's paper, which I am sure others in the Bank as well as myself will want to read. I hope you enjoyed your visit with him. I have not seen him for years, but I liked him very much when he was at Harvard doing his thesis. lours sincerely, >/• John H. Williams Miss Mildred Adams Room 807 August 3 f 1954 Dear Dr. WlHlaast lou ai*y be int#r*at*d in ammttig the full text of the p&p«r vrilcii l;r* Elaier ¥oo4 of th« Univ#rsity of Miawmri delivered at the spring mating of t)i# HIdv«8t /,rsoci&tion. I unutrstuiiu that only it ntveilfthl« hor« in .-,«v fork. Most i-i rector Dr. John ¥llli«M» 33 Libert/ WOOD, Elmer July 27, 1954 Dear Boat Any trip which takes me out of the heat of St. Louis and sends me to Estes Park thereby pays off in my book. This one is, X hope, also profitable for the Committee, even though in & negative sense* Xt has, X suspect, dieposed of the idea that Elmer Hood Is the person to write the definitive history. Whatever X may or may not think as to whether he could do it is less Important than tke double fact that (a) he <loes mot want to, and (b) he has a book of his own under way which could conceivably come within our scope if he and the Committee both chose. As a third benefit, X am bringing batik Sr* Hood's own copy of the much distasted paper which he delivered before the Midwest Economic Association this spring, a paper which in summary attracted attention from both Br* Williams and Mr. Sproul. This gives the flavor of his thlrlcing, and in its various controversial points of view would certainly have an impact on certain of our Committee members. X have permission to have it copied and to show it to anyone who is interested* •ut to go back — before X left St. Louis, X asked William Abbott, head of research in the St. Louis bank, about wood and found less enthusiasm than X would have expected for a Missouri product. Xt may have been partly an instance of the "prophet not without honor save in his own country,* and partly a reflection of a certain lack of sympathy on Wood's part for the direction St. Louis research is taking* In may event, they think him 6ry as dust, and not the person to do this job* I am not prepared to agree that that opinion is justified. X saw/ Wood for a short time on Friday afternoon, when X arrived from Beaver and stopped at hie cottage before X went on to my own Inn, and twice for a considerable period of time on Saturday, both morning and afternoon. All in all, X must nave spent four or five hours with him, first presenting the project, and then probing (as best X could without making cosmdtments) to see what part, if any. interested him* Wood is a refreshingly independent person who follows his own line of thinking wherever It leads, sad prefers to make his own judgments* He would rather talk plain &glish than take refuge in economic jargon. He is interested in theory* but he is also interested in fact, and in the relationship which prevails (or fails to prevail) between toe two. laere ma/ be about him a alight timidity} there is certainly a hint of Hie handicaps felt by a sensitive provincial who lives far fro* the centers of power and does not see very such of the Mr. Donald B. Voodw&rd Page a July 27, 1954 powerful. Bat there Is nothing stuffy or pretentious about him. His intent Is clear and direct, and his Qind is keenly analytical. He is perhaps overly aware of what he considers his ova limitation*. If we could somehow turn bade the clock and teltseope the years which hare passed since he wrote his book on English theories of central beak* ing, so that he could begin on an i&erlcan equivalent of that book, I think he sight produce something of considerable value. Obviously we can't, the next best thing is to plan some other nay of bringing the thing he wants to do into our orbit* Tiro possibilities have presented themselves! one, an easing of the nay so that he can finish the book he has in hand, the other, a monograph. The book has been in the writing for some time. He works on it in i « M r vacationB, but not during the academic year* He thinks that there It another year's work to be done on it, and it is possible that he could persuade the University of Missouri to give him a sabbatical year on half pay. He approached Chester Davis for a subsidy vhea the latter was vith the Ford Foundation, but never got an answer, which is curious in view of the latter1* decade as President of the St. Louie Federal Reserve Bank. Whtn X asked if he would like to have our Committee consider the book for a place in the project, he was doubtful — he wants it to stand on its own feet, and he wants to be free to exercise his own judgment in regard to Federal Reserve and/or Treasury activities* I assured him no censorship would be exercised, and left the matter open for further thought on both sides* He has been writing under the title "Monetary Control,* but Is not content with that. "Monetary Control in American theory and Practice11 is perhaps a better description of what he has in mind* Be has nine or tea chapters writtent one on Open Market Operations, one on Discount Rate, one on Reserve Requirements sad the changes that hare taken place in then, three on Deposit Expansion, two on Interest, one on Adjustment of Cash Positions, Be Is now working (la a cabin facing a bubbling brook which furnishes a running obligate to the chatter of chipmunks) on the Relation of Monetary Procedures to Expenditures, studying general monetary controls in their relation to expenditure*! he expects to come out with a criticism of both the Keyaesian theory and the quantity theory of money. He has ahead of him a consideration of International Monetary Relations and Controls, of Federal Reserve Procedure, with or without techniques, of later nineteenth century English practice as it illumines American practice. I asked Dr. Wood if he had & publisher. He is thinking In terns of one of the more popular publishers such as Doubleday, rather than a strictly academic publisher like Macmlllan. Ho commitment has b«en made* Mr. Donald B. Woodward Page $ July 27, 1954 the monograph idea cam© up in conversation, and after reeding the paper which w s presented to the Midwest Economic Association. Vood 1* very euch interested in the accord of 1951* end he hat been thinking of going to talk with Truman about it. He Might, I think, be interested in embarking upon a etud7 of wliat accord — *het conditions it arose from, m a t made it necessary, what the Tarious parties concerned thought they vere doing, what the result ha* been* I did not ask bin whether he would like to do a monograph — I onljr suggest it now for consideration* Hood1 s ovn reeoemendation of the man to do the definitive history la Karl Bopp, but he doesn't think Bopp mould do it* So we cofte full circle again* I do not, however, think this has been wasted time, energy or travel noney, Ve now know Wood, know what he is about, what he wants to do (or doesn't). Ve have his interest, and ve may in the end get something valuable frost him* In any event* he is out of the class of vague but enticing enigmas* Is talking over other possible candidates, he showed Interest in Howard Ellis of California, shook his head at Harold Heed of Cornell, wondered vhather it might be possible to interest Karl Hamilton, now at the University of Chicago* I have asked Mi as McKinstry to type this and send it on to you before t return* Xou may think it wall to have soae part of it sent to the other aeabers of the Executive Gonsittee, but ve can talk about that when I return, X also have some interesting data for you from St, Louis* So glad you urged se to go to Estes Park* A day in those Eountains Is a whole vacation in itself* Best, as always, Mildred M a m Mr* Donald B. Woodward Viok CbeaiCAl Coapany 122 East 42nd Street Hew fork 17, Mew fork MAtta Tuesday, July 20 Dear Miss Adams: Thank you for your letter of July 16th from New York. Your Office added a note saying you would not be at the Brown Palace in Denver, and I am expecting to find word today at the Post Office as to where you will be. If I should not find where to reach you by letter, I shall try to reach you by telephone Thursday evening or Friday morning at one of the Denver hotels, trying the Olin and Shirley Savoy first. I shall be free during the week end and can see you either Friday or Saturday, If you have no commitments here we should be glad to show you some of the sights in our car. We live in Fay Bralnard!s Cottage on a short winding side road the entrance to which is opposite Perkins Trading Post. That is elenen miles out from Estes Park on route 7 and (from the other direction) about a mile or so from St. Malo Catholic Church, a very prominent landmark on the main road (route 7 ) . In last resort you could ask the people at the Caldwell Real Estate Agency in Estes Park to help you. Their office is not far from Western Union, before you get fully in to the main business section. But I would be glad to pick you up in Boulder since you are going there, if you will tell me when and where to meet you . I do not know the names of the hotels there. As to hotels around here, friends of ours recommend the Aspen Lodge, about 2^ miles toward Estes Park from our cottage. A room American with private bath is $12.50 per day. It seems a very nice place. Another of the same general character is Sprague's Lodge. The big hotels are the Stanley and the Crag or Cragg. These seem unnecessarily expensive. If you don't get a reservation, we will help you find a place after you get here. I hope this is all clear! Sincerely, Elmer Wood ' Tuesday. July 20 Dear Miss Adams: Thank you for your letter of July 16th from New York. Your Office added a note saying you would not be at the Brown Palace in Denver, and I am expecting to find word today at the Post Office as to where you will be. If I should not find where to reach you by letter, I shall try to reach you by telephone Thursday evening or Friday morning at one of the Denver hotels, trying the 01in and Shirley Savoy first. I shall be free during the week end and can see you either Friday or Saturday. If you have no commitinents here we should be glad to show you some of the sights in our car. We live in Fay Bratnerd*s Cottage on a short winding road the entrance to which is opposite Perkin's Trading Post. That is elesten miles out from Estes Park on route 7 an? (from the other direction) about a mile or so from St. Malo Catholic Church, a very prominent landmark on the main roed (route 7 ) . In last resort you could ask the people at the Caldweli Real Estate Agency in Bstes Perk to help you. Their office is not far from Western Union, before you get fully in to the main business section. But I would be glad to pick you up in Boulder since you are goin^ there, if you Fill tell me when amd where to meet you • I do not know the names of the hotels there. As to hotels around here, friends of ours recommend the Aspen Lodge, about ?\ miles toward Estes Park from our cottage. A room American with private bath is $12.50 per day. It seems a very nice place. Another of the same general character is Sprague's Lodge. The big hotels are the Stanley and the Crag or Cragg. These seen unnecessarily eypensive. If you don't get a reservation, we will help you find a place after you get here. I hope this is all clearl ' 79 _ Sincerely, c July 19, 1954 Dear Professor Hoods I em happgr to report that since -writing you last Friday we have received a confirmation on our request for a rooa for Hiss Adams at the Olin Hotel in Denver* the address is 1420 Logan Street, and the telephone number is Main 4211. Miss Adams expects to reach there on Thursday night, July 22nd (via Continental-Braniff plane from St. Louis) and will get in touch with you at an early opportunity. Sincerely yours, Secretary and Assistant Dr. Elmer Wood e/o General Delivery Esteg Park Colorado July 16, 1954 Dear Professor Wood! Since HI go Adams dictated the enclosed letter, ve have received a telegram from the Brown Palace that they cannot accept her reservation for July 22*24* I have requested as an alternative a room for her at the Olin Hotel and as a second choice the Shirley Savoy, I do hope ve will have an immediate confirmation froo either of these, preferably the Olin, and I will let you know what, her Denver hotel Is as soon as X get the word* Sincerely yours, Research Assistant Professor EUaer Vood e/o General Delivery Xstes Park, Colorado July 16, 1954 Dear Dr. Voodt _•."" ' ' , :.*' "•••• .') Thank you so much for your return wire indicating that you would be willing to discuss the Federal Reserve System in the aldst of a Pocky Mountain vacation. It is exceedingly kind of you, and I shall be looking forward to the conversation vith great interest. My present plan is to arrive in Denver by plane from St. Louis on Thursday evening the 22nd, end to spend that night at the Brown Palace Hotel. From there on a certain vagueness sets in. I would like to go to Boulder to see a friend or two there, but as I have no specific appointment until Sunday,, when I aust start back to Chicago* I could cose to see you either Friday or Saturday to suit your convenience. l<r. Bopp has given ne your locale as "eleven adlee out of Estes Park on route 7*. The available saps indicate that that means eleven miles south. I would probably cone up from Denver in a Drive-R-Self car, and could coiae direct to you if you can give ae more specific directions. Or if there is an inn somewhere near-* by I aight stay overnight there. The hotel guides at hana in the Bank give us names of inns, but no exact information as to where they are in a large territory, so that I will be grateful for suggestions. I vould therefore be grateful if you would send me word, to be avsiting ae at the Brown Palace Hotel on Thursday and covering the two points (a) would Friday or Saturday be more convenient for you, (b) what neeting place will be most convenient^ and (c) is there a near-by inn where a isountainloving New Yorker could spend the night? V " r;^ ' Thank you so aucb for your courtesy in this, ae in your willingness to let ae invade your vacation peace. Most sincerely yours, Mildred Ada-ae Dr. ELaer Vood c/o General Delivery Kates Park, Colorado " " WU CD047 22 COLLECT \/f(hr>*x <f<9 7 ESTES PARK COLO JUL 14 1212PMM MISS MILDRED ADAMS FRB OF NY ' . WILL BE GLAD TO SEE YOU AT TIME STATED IN YOUR WIRE STOP WRITE ME BOX 1041 WHERE TO MEET YOU ELMER WOOD 243PME MISC. 34.1 35 M 10-29 RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK Brookings Institution SENT BY SEND TO FILES Miss Mildred Adams COPY OF TELEGRAM Cods i SBT Inly 13, 1954 follovijtwgp Carl Bop|^ letter of July S, am planning Denver trip for July tw«nty-thlid/(5»*ekend. Please wkU collect whether convenient to arrange meeting at Erie* park them. Mildred Adam* Ida FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF PHILADELPHIA POSTAL ZONE 1 July 8, 1954 Mr* Elmer Vood e/o General Delivery Bates Park, Colorado Dear Elmers I do not know just how well you progress being made by the Coaaittee oj Heserve System. The Coiamittee, you Sproul as Chairman, Randolph Burgees, Stewart, Don Woodward as Sj Director* Miss Adams experiences^ Journ for to itions Nrtfth nen daye\ She has uncovered Reserve system nted with the of the Fe<5er sts of Ulan \ till Martin, Walter s as ResearchY^ has had considerable rican correspondent ting a pilot project als in the form of papers and tarn, particularly i t s early amount of materials outside the •stand i t i s now intended to proceed with the writing of a series^of mojtfgraphs and major works* Among the monographs might be one onVfifli^ctire Credit Controls* - possiblytoyCarl Parry, one on "International Financial Operations of the System in the 1920'•*, and a biography of Ben Strong* Tfre major -work, of course, would be a reason-* ably definitive history of the System* Other major works might include biographic essays on key figures in the history of the System and another on crises. In addition to appropriate authors for such works, the Committee will probably also wish to have available some eraokerjaok monetary theorists as consultants. I am telling you a l l this lay way of preliminary* As you must know, your name has been advanced from a number of places as one who could make a genuine contribution to this history of the Federal Reserve System* Hies Adams would like very nuch to have an entirely exploratory conversation with you as to the possibilities in this direction* The conversation would be, of course, without any ooooitmefit on your part or on the part of the Cozaraittee* She has asked me to get in touch with you concerning the possibility of such a meeting* She plans to be in St. Louis late in July and i s prepared to visit you in Estes park later in the nonth (perhaps the weekend of July 24)* Incidentally, her willing* ness to do this indicates something about your standing* FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF PHILADELPHIA PAGE NO. 2 TO Mr*H»arVbod I hare had a nuaber of conversations with Mis hare found her oharmlng, enthusiastic, and oompetent* urge you to hare a talk vith her* and uld like to Sinoe there i s not too muck time an hare a phone In your cabin, I told Mies Adams that you call her at the Federal Reserve Bank of H charges1) tonetlme when you are in £stos-HPark« This to get some feel directly from HXaa Jtdmsti^o vhat sight Just before Lee Chan rae that he would be interested 1 the biography on Ben Strong* Ve hope you, to go to Candle pe this auBBMr he told e peaeiteility of doing t sysmer* Ve plan the aosth of August* Karl R. Bopp f i c e President WOOD, Elmer July 8, Bear Don: Dr. Bopp, whom I celled Immediately after talking vith yon this corning, sounded very cheered at the suggestion that I go out &nd talk with Professor Vood* Re is entirely villing to call the latter fay telephone, but fee is afraid tfc&t there is no phone in as Istes Park cabin. Therefor*, he will write Professor Vood "an extended letter" telling him about the Committee, the project, the search for an historian, etc. He seems to think that Professor Vood will see me with pleasure, I am, therefore, planning to fly fro® St. Louis to D©rrrer on Thursday, the 22nd, aad spend the veekend there rather then in Chicago. I ^aist say the prospect is very isuch isore pleasant than the one which I had had scheduled. I will let you kaov as soon as I hear fro® Professor Wood that this is a fira date. Best as always, Mildred Adaas Mr. Donald B. Tick Chemical 122 East A2nd Kew Xork City Woodward Company Street 17, H. I. U N I V E R S I T Y O F M I S S O U R I C O L U M B I A S C H O O L O F BUSINESS A N D PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION OFFICE OF THE DEAN July 2, 19^. Mildred Adams Federal Reserve Bank of New York 33 Liberty Street, New York k$9 New York Dear Hiss Adams* Mrs* Patta C. Anthony has ask me to send you Dr. Wood's summer address. The addres is as follows: Dr. Elmer c/o General Delivery Estes Park, Colorado This address will be Dr. Wood f s only address\ untill we hear further from him. Sincerely yours, Joyce A. Violett WOOD, Elmer July 7, 1954 Bear Dr. Bopp: Thanks so much for jour not® of July 6th giving us the straner address of Professor Elmer Wood. I can imagine so ple&santer place to spend the suaaer than Estes Park ©ven including the General Delivery. I wish I thought I could get out to Colorado -while he is there. Probably I shall have to postpone talking vith hi® 'until he gets back to the University. Thanks again for your courtesy in this. Sincerely yours, Mildred Adams Research Director Dr. Karl Bopp fice President Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia Philadelphia 1, Pennsylvania FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF PHILADELPHIA (ZONE I) July 6, 1954 Miss Mildred Adams Research Director Committee on the History of the Federal Reserve System 33 Liberty Street Nev York 45, New York Dear Miss Adams: I just received a postcard from Professor Elmer Wood in which he gives his summer address as General Delivery, Estes Park, Colorado. Sincerely, KRB/b Karl R. Bopp Vice President WOOD, Elmer m trying ts ret eh you "by telej&«n«, b«t id.th*trt o plea** consider t h i s l e t t e r In Hen of the telepbciut eon* vhitsh right ^are bees && e&sler t'lyr to diecu** tH# ^ue^tion I would Ilk* t& p6^« I sev you earHer it* tl%* apring you talked with reel 4 in uad.«rtoki!if ^a# nistofjr of y th«im, Professor V^r^.*» HJRR* h«-t «!#?» ba#a n to our ConaittMy » ^ I issfortmiiort «^out iiiv>* Ir, viev ®f thi^r;© tvr> y«gsflf.t:: nr for quit© |&rt vf fr^fffs«or Woo'3, I vowld grtatly mv^ytcttti t*i© klu^s a f 1st th* f i r s t pl«e©, ^» #«®^^ t - h«v# a vmtf mmll b i b l l o * >f#s^r Vood» I issri«rstaBd that h i s b«»t lail.lsh 1h,«?Tl««f ?>f Central SanHng Ccistrol ISl^l^^S 1 1 , but T ^i^«rabl« l i s t of tli# wiriodiccl K&t«rl«l nhich I •» soar* written, Hat «f 'wfc&eh «» h»vt- net y « t foi»J- t r^ooyd* ¥« oiifli on t i l l s , or t i t l e s i f TSi# 9»eoiid «|^«tlosi 1« vlt#tli«r x©tt till flic ft&t*amt VotnS a Bs»r« u??#ful p*rt in t h i s norlr I f h# vtr# s i t t i n g on th« i f he v«r# vrrittsg oa #osm $&m of the project. Ve both knov , no to ®p«ilcf s k i M of habit «si^? that soisati»«« thos* mXl pr&Svtetiltm <!.© #a b«e»««# th#y ftr«! v r i t i a g a i t t t i i i r %»n & lik«abl« ?««ap*t!«!u f f thi« i f ?rofe«tior vtoo&*t frame of I <SK>ttl& vssittr i f St# voul^ vaat to be anlta^ to $a^#rt&k* an v t l l ba gratefully r«ceiv#^« I bate to J>?VF;S y*u tor ai<! In t h i t , but,, i f tc»iili!? by &«^r chftac*,, c a l l »# at th« Bank oa tHBrsa«2f t I ?*>i&4 fee gratefid* I f that i a i^po«sibl«> I eau b« r«a«hed aa Friday »a4 7-5455 f e 4 e f m l so at '^u!«ly I R a^^tB^e^ I am ?>e»ai^wi Sank o f 0 PI PRIHCETOH Princeton, If. J# Department of Eoonomicg and Social Institutions a, 1954 Br« Robert D, Calkins President, The Brooking© Institution 722 Jackson Plaee, N. V, Washington 6, P, C# Bear Bobt I as afraid this will hare to be an extremely hurried note owing to the fact th^t a death in the family has made i t almost impossible for us to catch our plane even without answering a m»ber of letters* However, I do -want very siuch to ?ay two things. The f i r s t i s that the l e t t e r outlining the arraagesents for the study—Benjamin strong Central Banker i s satisfactory in every respect. I shall be glad to eonforsi to i t and to try to justify your faith in making the grant to me* The other matter relates to Klmer jfood as a possible person to write the hietory of the Federal Reserve $rst«R» I have the highest respect for WoscU He i s thorough, a hard -worker, and an excellent student of central banking, Foreover, his voxfc on "the Bank of England Indicate? that he has en interest in the historical approach to central, banking problem a* My one big worry would be Aether he ceuld finish such a projectT in any period of time that vDuld be acceptable to ym end the committee. le he.?, vritten very l i t t l e Indeed, and the pxjblications •feat he did turn out "Here in the works for »any years* If he could bring himself to work steadily on the history and to bring I t to a completion in an acceptable time, he -wouLd be an excellent prospect, I thinkt however, that you had better cheek very carefully vith others vho perhaps know hiss better than I in or^er to find out Aether he i s a good prospect for the reasons that I .indicated* On the my to Eagland, I shall try to think of someone who might be considered for the job and shall certainly l e t you know i f I have any bright ideas* I an enclosing a copy of otir itinerary in case there i s anything urgent about -which you would like to oomsiunieate* Thank you again for the faith that you &n6. your eoffis&ttee have shown in me in staking the research grant* Sincerely yours> (signed) Lester V* Chandler