The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
The Papers of Charles Hamlin (mss24661) 366_04_001- Hamlin, Charles S., Scrap Book — Volume 230, FRBoard Members P05.001 - Hamlin Charles S Scrap Book - Volume 230 FRBoard Members 6 BOARD OF GOVERNORS OF THE FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM Office Correspondence To From The Files • Date August 6, 1941 Subject: Mr. Coe After correspondence with Mrs. Hamlin (see letters of May 25 and June 4, 1941) the items attached hereto and listed below, because of their possible confidential character, were taken from Volume 230 of Mr. Hamlin's scrap book and placed in the Board's files: VOLUME 230 Page 15 Confidential letter to Governor Calkins from Governor Harrison re open market operations. Page 53 Letter to Senator Glass re draft of amendment to F.R. Act. Page 73 Confidential - Preliminary Memo for the Open Market Policy Conference July 14, 1932. Pagejv_79 & 8a (X-7199) Tentative Draft - Discounts for Individuals and Corporations. Page 84 Earnings and Expenses of Federal Reserve Banks, June 1932. Page 85 Analysis of New Paragraph of Section 13 of the F.R. Act as provided for by Section 210 of H.R. 9642 as amended and passed by the Senate on July 11, 1932. Page 88 Letter to Senator Glass re Section 13 of F.R. Act. Page 89 Memo to Board re operating efficiency of F.R. Banks. Page 111 Report of Carl P. Dennett, Chairman of the Banking and Industrial Committee of the First Federal Reserve District. Page 119 Memo to Board from Mr. Wyatt re Comments of Chairman and Governors of F.R. Banks on July 16 Draft of Circular re Discounts for Individuals, Partnerships and Corporations. Page 137 Memo to Mr. Hamlin from Mr. Wyatt re Glass Amendment to so-called relief bill. RURAL 41 ( \ SfREW ,0141( July 5, 1932. COMPI:ENTIAL Dear lovernor Calkins: In view of the chunges in the,-;ystem position resulting from gold losses, recent bank disturbances, and mid-year events, it seems desirable to review recent open market operations in their relation to the present position of the System and the general banking sitwAion. Since Februar 24 the government security holdings of the system have been increased by .t'1,060,000,000, including some purchases by the FederA. Reserve Bank of Chicago for its own account durin.7 last week. The disposition of the funds put into the market through these purchases nny be tabulFsted as follows: DisitionofFundsi_m211ablebsecadurit?urchases (In millions of dollars) Net loss of gold through exports and earmarking Repayment of discount6 of Federal reserve banks Reduction in Federal reserve bill holdings Increase in money in circulation Increase in member bank reserve balances Total 430 365 69 57 156 1,077 The difference between these fi7ures end the fi5rures for movernment purchases is wide up by number of miscelle.neous items. This t7;ble indicates that the turtle mode evailabl by security purchases were largely absorbed by heavy losses of gold and by a reduction in Federal reserve discounts and bills. able to for Only a relatively anall remainin/mount has been m de avail-- excess member bank reserves which might support an increase in member bank credit. Axring this period the excess gold reserves of the System have been reduced from $1,392,000,000 to :942,000,000, tht is a decline of $450,000,000, VOLUMF 230 PAGE 15 a\ 2 Governor Call 7/5/32 3 and the combined reserve ratio of the System has declined from 68 per cent to 57 per cent. It is interesting to observe, however, that only a very small part of this change in the System's gold position and the reserve ratio is attributable to purchases of government securities. Most of it has been due to the repatri- ation of foreign central bank dollar funds, which very probably would have occurred regardless of the policy of the System. The country's gold stock has declined as shown in the above table ;430,000,000, or only t20,000,000 less than the decline in the excess gold reserve of the Federal reserve banks. Had there been no increase in the System government holdings this gold loss would necessarily have been accompanied by considerable increase in Federal reserve bank discounts over and above the discounts held at the time security purchases were commenced. In other words member bank borrowings in the Reserve banks instead of declining from $835,000,000 to $470,000,000, would most surely have been increased to well over $1,000,000,000, in addition to some increase in acceptances, and the drastic credit deflation in process in February inevitably would have been accelerated as a consequence. Thus we see that the open market program was not only effective in pre- venting the increase in discounts which would have followed such large gold exports, but on the contrary was responsible for a substantial reduction of discounts in spite of such gold losses. Most of the increase in reserve funds resulting from security purchases has been required to meet demands for reserve credit which had to be met in some form. Whether that reserve credit was provided by purchases of government securities, by rediscounts, or by bill purchases, the effect upon the gold position and the reserve ratio would be precisely the same. The reserve ratio is now less than 2% under what it would have been had no securities been bought, and that 2% difference is accounted for by the fact that our open market operations have increased reserve credit about 4125,000,000 in excess of overnor 3 Ce 7/5/32 .ne excess rethe 0-ctLal demend, and member banks hold approximately this mount of serve deposits. The required reserve against these excess deposits accounts for the difference in the reserve ratio. These excess reserves are, of course, support available to meet any demand for currency or gold Which may arise or to an expanstion of member bank credit about ten times the amount of the excess. The following table gives these figures in detail. (In '4illions of Dollars) Y. R. Credit: U. S. Securities held Discounts Bills bought Other Y. R. credit Total F. R. credit Tune 29 lime 741 835 133 25 1,801 470 84 11 + 1,060 365 89 14 - 1,734 2,346 612 Feb. 25 Principal Demands for F. R. Credit: Reduction in U. S. gold stock Net increase in currency circulation Total increase in demand laces. of increase in F. R. credit over increased demand Increase in member bank and other deposits in F. R. banks 430 57 487 125 134 posiApart from the effect of open market operations on the technical of the more 7enera1 tion of the System it is important briefly to summarize some results of the System's purchases of securities: Cl) The very large repatriation of foreign central bank funds has been accomplished without any strain on the position of member banks, and thus one important obstacle to a more normal credit position has been removed. (2) The pressure for liquidation of bank credit which usually results from the indebtedness of member banks has been materially lightened by a reduction in their total borrowings from more than $800,000,000 to leas than $500,000,000. 4 Governor C, ins 7/5/32 (3) The decline in member bank deposits has been checked, and the liquidation of bank credit which had been proceeding at an alarming rate has been substantially retarded. The alternative to purchases of government securities would have been a large increase in member bank indebtedness which would have exerted still further pressure towards liquidation, the continuance of which at the rate it was proceeding in February might well have been disastrous. With the gold outflow apparently checked except for the export of some *20,000,000 during the next three weeks, about which we shall write you, the only factors which appear likely to influence the System's reserve position in the near future are changes in the currency demand, and changes in member bank reserve balances. If there Should be a farther increase in the currency demand the form in which the Federal reserve credit is supplied will make no difference in the effect on the System's reserve position. Member bank reserves have recently fallen short of the 250 to 300 million of excess which it was proposed to maintain, as pointed out in the minutes of the last meeting of the executive committee. In the absence of a return flow of the currency that has recently gone out, it would require the purchase of about $125,000,000 more Government securities to restore member bank reserves to that level. Even such an amount would reduce the reserve ratio of the System by only about 1 1/2 points, from a little over 57 per cent to slightly under 56 per cent. it SOOMB If excess member bank reserves should now be restored to that basis likely that they will for tha first time have an opportunity to exert their full force unless or to the extent that gold exports or currency hoarding should revive. In any event there is now more reason to expect that when excess reserves are restored they can be maintained until bank credit begins to expand - 5 Governor Celkins 7/5/32. the real objective of the policy which the System inauFurated in the spring. While the recent experience shows th'It the purchases of government securities do not adversely influence the position of the reserve banks as a whole, they may affect the position of individual reserve banks, and the present situ?tion in which a number of the Reserve banks have percentages of about 50 per cent whereas others have considerably higher percentar,es, clearly requires reconsideration of the allotment of securities as a necessary accompaniment of a further program of security purchases. 7ve have already received a number of com- ments on the letter and tables mailed to all the Reserve banks on June 24, and shall write you further when more arc, received. Very truly yours, George L. Harrison, Governor. Vs. John U. Calkins, lovernor, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, San Francisco, Cal. Enc. •••J 111 COPY July 9, 1932. personal and Confidential. Dear Senator Glass: i am sending you this confidential note enclosing a hastily prepared draft of amendment to the Federal Reserve Act, giving the Federal reserve banks, in emergencies, the power to loan directly on eligible paper, exactly as they can now purchase eligible trade acceptances. Of course it will be clained that the banks will be deluged, but t do not believe this at all. I firmly believe, but cannot prove, that there are many merchants in the United States today who are unable to obtain credit, althou01 they can give satisfactory collateral. t know that there are large areas where there are no banks left. I therefore, personally, would favor giving this power in emergencies to Federal reserve banks. It is clear that practically all the central banks of Europe have this power today, and t do not believe it will be disastrous to extend this to the Federal reserve banks under the control of the Federal Reserve Board.. i enclose a list of central banks which have this power to deal direct with individuals. Sincerely yours, Hon. Carter Glass, United States Senate, Washington, D. C. VOLUME 230 PAGE 53 =TRai BANKS 'MICK 7,T111,23. WI am ass AMTHOTIITY TO MAn LOANS TO INDIVIDUALS OR ZS,* AU NOT OPIIMI CALLY PROHIDITM AN! DOING 30. Kisch and akin (1930) Ccmonwealth Bank of Australia Page 166 National Bank of Austria a a II 173-4 a " Bolcium u 181-2 " " Dulcaria a 169-90 n " Czodhoslowlida At 2.:2-3 Bank of DansiG a 2324 National Bank of Oopenhacen tt 240-1 Bank of Paigland Si 11 a " Elstonio It "Finland 243 252-3 a 261 a " France a 264.5 German Reichsbank t! 271-2 Bank of Greco° u 281 National Bank of Hun,-;ary o 292..3 Banos dlItalia a 301.2 Bank of Japan. n 310-1 Bank of Latvia u 317-6 Bank of Lithuania a 324-5 Netherlands Bank a 330.1. Norgos Bank n 336.7 1 Bank of Paw& Pt.i.o 352-3 National Bank of Runaztia • 362-3 Bank of ,32ain • 380-1 Swedish Riketani: • 38443 R 393,04 Swiss ;Iational Bank BE IT =ACTED BY THE SMATE AND MUSE OF REPRMENTATIVES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IN CONGRESS ASSEMBLED, That Section 13 of the Federal Reserve Act, as amended, is hereby further anended by. adding at the end of the seccnd paragraiih taereof a new paragraph reading as follows: "In unusual and exigent circumstances, the Federal Reserve Board, by the affirmative vote of not less than five members, may authorize any Federal reserve badk, S uring such periods as the said Board may determine, at rates establidhed in accorcionce with the provisions of Section 14, subdivision (d) of this Act, to discount for any individual or corporation, notes, drafts and bills of exchangp of the kinds and maturities made eligible for discount for member banks under other provisions of this Act, when such notes, drafts and bills of exchange are indorsed and otherwise secured to the satisfaction of the Federal reserve bank; provided, that before discounting any such note, draft or bill for an individual or corporation the Federal reserve bank shall obtain evidence that such individual or corporation is unable to secure adequate credit accaamodations fran other banking institutions. All such discounts for individuals or corporations Shall be subject to sudh limitations, restrictions and regulations as the Federal Reserve Board may prescribe. No note, draft or bill of exdhange discounted under the provisions of this paragrajh shall be eligible as collateral security for rederal reserve notes." ....1100 6). • • Pt ,Le,L COIIFIDENTIAL ME' OPEN 1/131:ET POLICY COTIFERaTCE .E0R PREL31:INOY JULY 14, 1932. The results of purchases of government securities by the System since March were reviewed in a letter of July 5 from the chairman of the Conference to the governors of all Reserve banks. This letter indicated that the funds made available by security purchases had been largely used to enable banks to meet .gold losses and to repay indebtedness at the Reserve banks, and that only a relatively small amount rumained to provide excess reserves. In the absence of purchases of governmcnt securities there would have been a considerable increase in borrowings at.the Reserve bianks and a continuation of the drastic credit deflation which had been going on. to the effect on the Reserve System the purchases of government securities were a very snall influence upon the reserve position of the Federal reserve banks, the declines in reserve ratios over this period being due almost • altogether to gold losss:s rather than to purchases of governments. The general results of the Systamls purchases of socuritic;s were summarized as follows: "(1) The very large repatri:_tion of foreign central bank funds has been accomplished without any strain on the position of mmber banks, and thus one important obstacle to a more normal credit position has been ramovcd. 2 The pressur for liquidLtion of bank credit which usually results from the indebtedness of mmber banks has been materially lightened by a reduction in their total borrowings from more than $800,000,000 to less than $500,000,000. "(3) The decline in member bank deposits has been checked) and the liquidation of bank credit which had been proceeding at an alarming rate has been substantially retarded." VOLUME 230 PAGE 73 2 All of these results are real accomplishments in themselves and have probably avoided very serious consequences of continued or increased credit liquidation. Nevertheless the ultimate purpose of bringing about an increase in the volume of bank credit, which might in its turn influence business activity has not yet been achieved for the results so far accomplished are not such as would be expected to exercise a very direct or affirmative influence upon business activity. It, therefore, seems desirable at this time to review the s general business and industrial situation as a basis for determining the extent to which further purchases of government securities would be likely to prove effective. Production, Trade, and Employment A further decline in the volume of production and trade and in numbers of workers employed is shown by the available figures for May and June. Indexes commonly used to measure fluctuations in busi- ness now show greater declines than this country has ever before experienced. The depressions of the 70s and the 90s brought with them nothing approaching the cessation in activity which occurred in recent months. The following table shows the percentage decline in production in this recent period compared with the decline in other important depressions: • • •." 3 Declines in Industrial Activity * (Computed normal = 100) Date Tan. 1873 Feb. 1892 Jan. 1906 Jan. 1920 Apr. 1923 June 1929 Actual Data 114.6 113.9 112.6 111.2 115.2 114.7 Decline Low Point High Point Date Feb. Jan. May Apr. July June Actual Data 1878 1894 1908 1921 1924 1932 (est.) P.31. Cent 87.3 80.1 81.9 73.0 87.3 50.6 24 30 27 34 24 56 * From index published by Cleveland Trust Company. The total number of wholly unemployed workers in the United States is now estimated at about 10,000,000, an inorease of about 3,000,000 to 4,000,000 from a year ago. This is more severe unem- ployment than we have ever before experienced in this country and constitutes a major social and economic problem for it carries with it the threat of social disturbance and radical legislation. To bring about reemployment before winter is the problem which faces the country. Looked at from the point of view of business and finance the problem is almost equally pressing, for a continuation of the present restricted volume of business activity over an extended period of months would man the bankruptcy of many business concerns including many railroads, and the insolvency of many banks. Favorable Factors Fortunately, at this point a nutter of the principal obstacles to business and financial improvement have been removed. The practical completion of the removal of foreign short time balances from our money market has removed a threat to our gold position. Domestic gold hoarding has practically stopped. A tax bill has been passed by Congress which it is hoped will place the budget in approximate balance. The relief bill with added powers to the Reconstruction Finance Corporation will probably soon be passed. The reparations agreement has been signed at Lausanne. Definite settlement has been effected of a number of individual domestic situations which threatened to prove disturbing. The bonus bill and a number of other unsound legislative proposals have been defeated. Business has effected many readjustments in costs and ha begun to evidence a more hopeful sentiment. Already the course of financial events has begun to reflect these favorable developments. The bond market, and particu- larly the market for foreign bonds, has shown improvement as indicated in the following figures: 1932 Low Standard Statistics corporation bond average 57.45 Baker-Kellogg foreign bond average 54.22 * July 8 figure July 11, 1932 60.19 59.58* • • • 4 Basic commodity prices, after a month of approximate stabilization, have begun to show improvement as indicated by the following figures for principal basic commodities. Low Wheat, cash, at Minneapolis, per pound Corn, cash, at Chicago, per pound Hogs, average, per hundredweight Steers, average, per hundredweight Hides, per pound Sugar, raw, per pound Cotton, middling, New York, per pound Wool, per pound Silk, per pound Rubber, smoked ribbed sheets, per pound Copper, electrolytic, per pound per pound Pig iron, per ton Finished steel, per pound Scrap steel, Pittsburg, per ton Petroleum, crude, per barrel The establishment of banking and industrial committees in the different Federal reserve districts should also be listed as among the favorable factors, for they provide machinery available to carry out in the several districts any plans agreed upon for industrial and financial rehabilitation. Capita/ Goods Industries Most Depressed In considering the effectiveness of various means which may be employed for stimulating employment or industrial activity, consideration may well be given to the variation between different industries as to their extent of activity and employment of workers. These figures which are shown in full in the tables at the end of this memorandum, show that the greatest cessation of activity has been in the basic industries producing what may be termed capital goods. This my be illustrated by the following index figures for activity in different industries. • _• 5 Industry Pig iron Steel Bituminous coal Cement Lumber Percentage of Computed Normal 20 23 48 44 33 As contrasted with these figures production of the following consumption goods may be listed: Industry Boots and shoes Hosiery Live stock Wheat flour Sugar Tobacco Percentage If Computod Normal 87 67 83 78 56 79 The whole group of industries classified under producers goods in the index compiled by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York are operating at 49 per cent of computed normal, whereas the industries classified under consumord operating at a rate 77 per cent of computed normal. goods are Unemployment and wage figures support this same general conclusion, that the greatest cessation in activity and the greatest amount of unemployment has taken place in the capital goods industries; that is, those industries which produce for the use of other industries primarily, and the activities of which are largely financed through the capital market. The extrem depression in these industries appears to reflect, first, som over-production of capital goods in the years just before the depression, and second tho disorganization of the bond market to a point where new financing has become practically impossible, and capital is no longer available for business even at prohibitive prices. long-term capital. What is most required to revive these basic industries, is cheap • • • 6 The surveys thus far conducted by banking and industrial committets in a number of districts appear to indicate that there are a considerable number of sound enterprises which can go forward as on as capital is available upon There are three principal fields in Which these enterprises now moderate terms. appear: (1) Building Construction. Mille there has been over-production of office buildings and high class apartments there is a considerable demand for cheap apartments and moderate-priced private dwellings, and for modernization of old buildings. (2) Modernization of existing industrial facilities to keep pace with recent inventions and improvements. (o) Public and semi-public projects. In addition to these three major forms of capital goods there appear to be many other small enterprises in 'Which a more adequate supply of capital and of bank credit would find profitable employment if it were available upon moderate terms. In the consumption industries also stocks are low and trade is retarded by shortages of capital and credit. Function of the Banks In the furnishing of both credit and capital to business the banks occupy the key position. For the past year and a half the banks have not only de- creased greatly their extensions of credit to business but also have withdrawn large amounts of funds from the capital market as illustrated in the following figures for weekly reporting banks: (In millions of dollars) Dec. 31, 1930 July 6, 1932 7,814 8,449 4,632 6,484 2,992 3,701 4,210 3,206 22,956 18,532 Loans: On securities All other loans Investments: U. S. securities Other securities Total loans and investments • than Governments By their decrease in investments in secures other in this anS their decrease in loano upon securus these banks have thus withdrawn whereas ordinarily the period nearly four billion dollars from the capital market, a year in banks of the United States pour into this market about a billion dollars those two forms. In recent weeks since the Reserve System began its policy of vigorous purchases of government socuritiJs there has boon sone change in this tendency. and the Bank credit as a Whole stopped its rapid decline and tended to level out contribution of the banks to tho capital market showed a similar tendency until used the latter part cf Juno when bank disturbances and mid-year and holiday demands up most of the surplus reserves and caused scne resumption in the ducline in credit. Any program for meeting the present emergency must dopund upon two forcos for increasing business activity and employment; first, the natural stimulation which will arise from a general improvement in tho security market and in the b ness and financial situation generally, end second, tho stimulation of activity through the ugoncies of the government. The problem has now become so acute and the time has become so short that it has now been generally agreed that artificial methods are necessary. The arcial methods used appear to depend upon the S8 rticular form of the relief bill which Congress may adopt. In any event such a S ill is likely to require a considerable amount of additional government financing, the floating of which on the murkot during coming months is essential to the entire program. Along with this governmental program it is to be hoped that r. natural re- covery in the security. markets and in prices and business itself may be accompanied by an increased use of the normal channels of financing. To achieve both of these purposes vigorous support by the banks of the country is essential, and an increase in bank credit. 11 a APPM\IDIX CHANGES IN MPLOY1‘.= AND PAYROLLS BETWEEN MAY 1929 AND MAY 1932 (1923-1925 averaEe = 100) Employment 1929 May Iron and steel Machinery Textiles Food products Paper and printing Lumber and pr oduc ts Transportation equipment Automobiles Loather and products Cement, clay, and glass Nonferrous metals Chemicals Petroleum refining Rubber products Tobacco products 1932 May Payrolls 1929 May 111.6 57.2 100.7 II I 131.9 54.4 119.1 99.3 62.0 97.3 103.1 81.0 97.3 114.3 83.8 102.8 92.8 6 38. 89,2 nei.o 52.4 101,5 147.1 59.7 130,0 88.1 90.3 'I 91.8 47.0 93.1 123.1 51.4 105.3 113.1 78.3 110.3 114.4118.9 146.5 66.0 115.3 86.1 67.3 90.3 1932 May 30.4 35.9 41.5 72.9 77.0 22.2 45.9 53.5 45.7 30.2 34.5 66.9 72.5 48.7 48.4 9 .INDEX2S OF PRODUCTION (Conputod normal = 100) 1929 May , 1932 May. 1932 June Pig iron Steel ingots Lead Zinc Tin METALS 114 121 112 113 141 131 22 24 43 35 48 31 20 23 Cotton consumption tool mill activity Silk consumption TEXTILES 109 102 101 105 55 38 60 51 Bituminous coal Coke Petroleum, crude Cement Lumber Newsprint paper Cotton receipts Wheat receipts OTHER PRODUCERS GOODS TOTAL PRODUCERS GOODS 110 120 112 115 104 98 103 92 103 113 52 40 72 44 33 79 109 73 66 49 Items 32 48 - 1111100•••••• 48p Ort. MO ••••••••• Ole •••••111110 lInthracite coal Petroleum products Boots and shoes Finished cotton goods Hosiery Knit underwear Livestock Wheat flour Sugar Tobacco Farm produce TOTAL CONSUMERS GOODS •p preliminary 90 101 111 116 108 115 93 108 80 112 96 103 52 67 87 53 67 84 96 78 56 79 92 77 40p 83 4 3,0.1 fo • J.0 INDEXES OF _ BUSINESS ACTIVITY (Computod normal 100) 1932 Items 1929 Ea7 1932 Tune Carloadings, mdse. and misc. Carloadings, other Exports Imports W..terway traffic Wholesale trade PRILLARY DISTRIBUTION GROUP 104 111 102 115 113 103 106 56 42 50p 60p 34 76 57 55 38 Department store sales Chain grocery Other chain 1ail order Advertising Automobile registrations DISTRIBUTION TO CONSUMER GROUP 101 104 107 116 102 115 105 76 77 78 75 59 31p 70 Life insurance Postal receipts Electric power Corporations formed GENERAL GROUP 99 101 107 101 102 73 69 68p 83 68 TOTAL VOLUME OF DISTRIBUTION OF GOODS 105 65 Production of producers goods Production of consumers goods Automobile production Employment Building construction PRODUCTIVE ACTIVITY GROUP 113 103 136 105 115 110 49 77 37 64 31 57 TOTAL VOLUME OF PRODUCTION AND DISTRIBUTION OF GOODS 106 63 New York City debits s sold on N. Y. Stock Exchange pital issues in grain futures CIAL GROUP 130 237 130 98 130 57 56 14 48 44 debits 107 63 LUHE OF TR;JE 106 61 minary 4WD 41. OW OW WO .1 OW OW 1•111 /Oa .1 WO •••••••••• ONO OW f_2_13 59 4.0 S lt-i-t, t-te "1-41.-44 X-7199 (TENTATIVE DRAFT - Intended only as basis for discussion and not recommended for approval.) July 14, 1932 SUBJECT: DISCOUNTS FOR INDIVIDUALS AND CORPORATIONS. TO ALL FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS: The third paragraph of Section 13 of the Federal Reserve Act, as amended by the Act of July , 1932, provides as follows: "For a period of two years in unusual and exigent circumstances, the Federal Reserve Board, by the affirmative vote of not less than five members, may authorize any Federal reserve bank, during such periods as the said board may determine, at rates established in accordance with the provisions of section 14, subdivision (d), of this Act, to discount for any individual or corporation, notes, drafts, and bills of exchange of the kinds and maturities made eligible for discount fcr member banks under other provisions of this Act when such notes, drafts, and bills of exchange are indorsed and otherwise secured to the satisfaction of the Federal reserve bank: Provided, That before discounting any such note, draft, or bill of exchange for an individual or corporation the Federal reserve bank shall obtain evidence that such individual or corporation is unable to secure adequate credit accommodations from other banking institutions. All such discounts for individuals or corporations shall be subject to such limitations, restrictions, and regulations as the Federal Reserve Board may prescribe. No note, draft, or bill of exchange discounted under the provisions of this paragraph shall be eligible as collateral security for Federal reserve notes." In view of the exceptional and unusual nature of the power conferred upon the Federal reserve banks by this provision, and in view of the limited period during which it is effective, the Federal Reserve Board has not prescribed any formal regulations governing the exercise of this power; but the requirements of the law and the procedure which the Federal Reserve Board will expect to be followed are outlined below for the information of the Federal reserve banks and any individuals or corporations who may apply to them for discounts. VOLUME 230 PAGE 79 -2. I. X-7199 LEGAL LIMITATIONS. It will be observed that, by the express terms of the above provision of law: 1. Federal reserve banks may discount eligible paper for individuals and corporations only: (a) In unusual and exigent circumstances, (b) Within two years from July (c) When authorized by the affirmative vote of , 1932, not less than five members of the Federal Reserve Board, and (d) During such periods as the Federal Reserve Board may prescribe; 2. They may discount for individuals and corporations only notes, drafts and bills of exchange of the kinds and maturities made eligible for discount for member banks, under other provisions (Sections 13 and 13a) of the Federal Reserve Act. 3. Such paper must be indorsed and otherwise secured to the satisfaction of the Federal reserve bank; 4. Before discounting paper for any individual or corporation, the Federal reserve bank must obtain evidence that such individual or corporation is unable to obtain adequate credit accommodations from other banking institutions; 5. Such discounts may be made only at rates established by the Federal reserve banks, subject to review and determination by the Federal Reserve Board; - 36. X-7199 Paper discounted for individuals and cor)orations is not eligible as collateral security for Federal reserve notes; and 7. All discounts for individuals or corporations are su,ject to such limitations, restrictions, and regulations as the Federal Reserve Board may prescribe. II. 1. PERMI'lSIOY OF THE FEDERAL RES7aVE BOARD. Permission to disco-nt eligible notes, drafts, and bills of ex- change for individuals and corporations will be granted by the Federal Reserve Board only upon written apthcation of a Federal Reserve Bank containing a full statement of the exceptional and exigent circumstances which, in the judgment of the Board of Directors of the Federal reserve bank, justify such action. 2. Federal Such permission will be ,:_;ranted for neriods soecified by the eserve Board, not excec?ding six months; but annlications for re- newals of extensions of the Board's permission will be accepted and considered at any time during the two weeks nreceding the expiration of an existing authorization. 3. Requests for renewals or extensions of such permi-sion must be made in the same manner as an ori,Tinal anplication. III. 1. ELIGIBILITY. 7".'.en authorized by the Federal Reserve Board, the Federal reserve banks may discount for individuals or corporations, eligible commercial, industrial and agricultural papor actually owned by such individuals or corporations and bearing their indorsement. 2. In order to be eligible for such discount, notes, drafts and bills of exchange must comnly as to maturity and in all other resoects —4, X=7199 with the provisions of Section 13 or Section 13(a) of the Federal Reserve Act and with the applicable requirements of the Board's Regulation A. IV. APPLICATIONS FOR DISCOUNT. Each application of an individual or corporation for the discount of eligible paper by the Federal reserve bank must be made in writing on a form furnished for that purpose by the Federal reserve bank and must contain, or be accompanied by, the following: 1. A statement of the circumstances giving rise to the application and of the purposes for which the proceeds of the discount are to be used; 2. A statement of the efforts made by the applicant to obtain adequate credit accommodations from other banking institutions, including the names and addresses of all other banking institutions to which appli— cation for such credit accommodations has been made, the dates upon which such applications were made, whether such applications have been definitely refused and the reasons, if any, given for such refusal; 3. Financial statements of the applicant and the principal obligors on the paper offered for discount; 4. A list of all banks with which the applicant has had banking relations, either as a depositor or as a borrower, during the preceding year, with the approximate dates upon which such banking relations commenced and terminated; 5. Evidence sufficient to satisfy the Federal reserve bank as to, a. X7-7199 —5— (a) the legal eligibility of the paper offered for discount and (b) its acceptability from a credit standpoint; 6. A list and description of the collateral or other security offered by the applicant; and 7. An agreement by the applicant, in form satisfactory to the Federal reserve bank, (a) to furnish to the Federal reserve bank when requested, additional financial statements, copies of recent auditorst reports, and other credit information, and (b) to submit to audits, credit investigations and examinations by representatives of the Federal reserve bank, whenever the Federal reserve bank shall so desire. V. GRANTING OR REFUSAL OF APPLICATION. Before discounting notes, drafts, or bills of exchange for any individual or corporation, the Federal reserve bank shall ascertain to its satisfaction by such means as it may deem appropriate: 1. Whether any member bank located in the territory served by such applicant is willing to grant the credit accommodations for which application has been made to the Federal reserve bank; 2. Whether the applicant is unable to obtain adequate credit accommodations from other banking institutions; 3. The financial condition and credit standing of the applicant and the need for the credit accommodations applied for; 4. Whether the paper offered for discount is acceptable from a credit standpoint and eligible from a legal standpoint; 5. Whether the security offered is adequate to protect the Federal reserve bank against loss; and - 6 _ 6. X-7199 That the proceeds of such discount will be used for a purpose which would give rise to paper which would be eligible for discount under other provisions of the Federal Reserve Act, if offered by member banks. In discounting paper for individuals or cornorations, a Federal reserve bar_k should not make any commitment to renew or extend such paper or to grant further or additional discounts. ' 1 VI. LIMITATIONS. No Federal reserve bank shall discount for any one individual or corporation paper amounting in the aggregate to more than one per cent of t;rie paid in capital stock of such Federal reserve bank. VII. ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS. Any Federal reserve bank which obtains permission from the Federal Reserve Board to discount eligible paper for individuals and corporations may issue a circular prescribing such additional requirements and procedure respecting such transactions as it may deem necessary or advisable; provided that it is not inconsistent with the provigions of the law and the Board's regulations and with the terms of this letter. By order of the Federal Reserve Board. Chester Morrill, Secretary. (Preliminary Rough Draft) 00 IOARD ==m N8 118 ====e2ii DISC PUNTB i7 =g) = III : lUt z2====== = . I. STATUTORr The third paragraph of Seotion 1$ of the Federal Reserve Act, as amended by the Act of July * 1932, provides as follows* "For a period of two yew* in unusual and exigent circumetancos* the Federal Reserve Board, by the affirmative vote of not less than five members* may authorize any Federal reserve bank* daring such periods as the said ooard ger determine, at rates established in ascordance with the provisions of section 14, subdivision (d), of this Act, to disoount for any individual or corporation, notes, drafts, and bills of exohmmge of the kinds and maturities mad.: eligible for discount for member banks unctzer other provisions of this Act *when suoh notes* drafts, and bills of exchange are indorsed and otherwise secured to the satisfaction of the Fed-. eral reserve bank: Provided, That before discounting any such notea draft, or bill of exchange fOr an individual or corporation the Federal reserve bank shall obtain evidence that such individual or corporation is unable to secure adequate credit aceemmodations fr.Aaother banking institutions. All such discounts for individuals or corporations shall be subject to suoh limitations, restrictions and regulations as the Federal Reserve Board may prescribe. No notes draft, or bill of exchange di/sot:ranted under the provisions of this paragraph shall be eligible as collateral security for Federal reserve notes," IlAugosiammir The eligibility of notes, drafts* and bills of orohange for redisoount, when offered by member banks* is pverned by the provisions of Seotions 15 and 13(a) of the Federal Reserve Act and by Regulation A of the Federal IA•surve Lioard; and, in order to be eligible for discount when offered by individuals or corporations, such paper must comply as to maturity and in all other respects with those requiremmts and, in addition thereto must oemply with the requirements of the third paragraph of Section 13* quoted above* and with this Regulation. VOLUME 230 page 83 itted to make The Federal Reserve banks will not be jerm or oor)orations but only direct loans or advanoes to individuals such individuals or corporations, to discount, upon the indorsement of by law and regulations, eligible and within the limitations prescribed paper actually owned by such coinercial, industrial mad agricultural inAittiMals or oorporaticns. D. III. PERMISSION OF THE FEDERAL R::RVE B1AR drafts, and bills of Permission to disoount eligible notes, ions will be ;ranted by the Federal exehanre for individuals and corporat ion of a Federal Reserve Bank Reserve Board only upon written applicat lution of its Board ..)f Directors a000mpanied by a certified copy of a reso ement of the exceptional and containing a complete end definite stat ment of the Board of Directors exigent circumstances which, in the judg ifies such action. of the Fed,)ral reserve bank, just definite periods of time Such pernisstion will be grant d only for Federal Reserve Board at any time. .„nt will be subject to revocation by the , permission must be levests for renewals or extensions of such ication. made in the same manner as an original appl a period in excess of six No such permisSion will be granted for of months, but applications for renewal xtensions of the Board's per- od at any time during the two weeks mission will he eeespted and eonsider existing authorisation. qr4seding the elmiration of an IT. APPLICATIONS FOR DISCCMIT. al or corporation for the Nish application of an individu Fe eral Reserve bank sust be filed discount of eligible paper by the reserve for that purpose by the Federal in writing on a fora furnished *Wit lad Mit eontain, or be aocompanied by the followings Is A statement of the ciroumetanoes giving rise to the applicatida and of the purposes for which the prooeede of the discount are to be used; 2. A statenent of the efforts made by the applicant to obtain adequate credit a000mmodations from other banking institutions, including the manes and addresses of all other basking institutions to which application for such credit a000mmodations hes been made, the dates upon 'thick suCh applications were mode, whether such applications have been definitely refused and the reasons, if any, given for such refusal 3. Financial statements of the applicant and of all nakers, drawers, acceptors, endorsers, sureties, and guarantors on the paper offered for disoount; 4. A list of all banks with which the applicant has aad banking relations, either as a depositor or as a borrower, during the preceding five years, with the approximate dates upon which such banking relations commenood and terminated; 6. Evidence sufficient to satisfy the Federal reserve bank as to (a) the legal eligibility of the paper offered for discount and (b) its acceptability from a credit standpoint; and 6. A list and description of the collateral or other seourity offered by the applicant. The application and all statements made by the applicant, inoluding his financial statement, mist be verified by affidavits, and all other financial statements supporting the application, must be supported by affidavits. V. INVESTIGATION BY FEDERAL RESERVE BANK. Before granting spy discount to an individual or corporation, a Federal reserve bank shells 1. Consunioate with every bank to which the applicant has applied for such credit accommodations and obtain from each such bank a report as to (a) the truth of the statements made bir the applicant, (b) itelber such credit accomodations were in fact refused, and (o) If so, the reasons for such refusal. 2. Furnish to each bank with which the applicant has had banking relations during the preceding five years and to each member bank located in the territory served by such applicant a copy of the application and supporting documents and obtain frosteach such bank a statement as to whether such bank is then willing to grant to such applicant the credit a000mmidatiome for lila he has applied to the Federal reserve bank. VI. MIAMI* Op IMINBAL OF DINDOMT• No Pelona reser,* bank shall discount notes, drafts, or bills of exchange for ma individual or a corporations 1. if ow other bank bas advised the Federal reserve bank that it is willing to extend adequate credit accommodations to the applicant; 2. lithe paper offered for discount is not clearly acceptable fros a oredit standpoint WI veil as eligible from& legal standpoint; 3. Unless the sesarity offered is entirely adequate to protect the Foderal reserve bank against lose in view of the fact that the Federal r,,serve bank woad not have the proteotion of the endorsement of a menber bank; 4« If avg material statement rode Iv the applies,* la Ms applioation or asr sutrortiryi liseilment is found to be false; or 6. Unless the finael iSimitsieents of the applioant and of the prineipal obligors at the paper offered ter disoount disclooe a reasonable *mess of Tisk assets ever sweat liabilities. Ja disocunting paper for imdividaale I esrporations, a Federal reserve bank shall emter into no oommittimMOIAMAMmWer as to the renewal or extension of suah pa-per or as to the speating of further or additional di...aunts* IMECTATIMIS In detersdaing ~thee to diesount paper for individuals esd esrperations, the federal reserve blahs shall have des regard to ths probable future needs of their own member bash*, and. 20 Federal reserve bleak shAll disoommt paper for aw individeel or corporation vdmat its eau reams essamit to less than filly' per sent of its own wregegb, liabilities for 44.1411itli and Arderel voisne wimps in actual eireulatiom4 The 041r0$160 smut striver diseommted tiv Fcderal reserve Usk fer eerparatimel end liettivideals *hall at as Was easesi GMOunt 4101pia to the paid." aid isitipired capital and surplus of seek Federal reserve bask* No Federal reseratisitsball disoount for amy imdtvideal or essipisvatiesi paper amsmuttng is the iimpesite Ito ster• that ono per out 000 emits' of suet Federal room bast. VIII. RATE OF RISMNT. Discounts kor individuals and corporations shall be made by Yeasral reserve ,a,r0cs only at special rates estab lished by the 'Board of directors 01: the Asderal reserve bank for that purpose, The Federal li.eserve i3oard will not prove any rate established for this purpose which is less than, (a) 2,* per annum above the current rate at which the ied)ral reserve bank disoounts stroller paper for its member banks, or (b) six per cent, whiohever is the grater. C ONFIDENTIAL Not for publication 3-811 EARNINGS AND EXPENTES OF FEDERAL RESERVE BAIIKS, JUTE 1932 Federal Reserve Discounted bills Purchased bills U. S. securities Other sources Jan. - June 1932 Current net earnin,7s Less accrued dividends and Ratio net charges to Total Ratio to (current) to Total Daid-in cppital profit and loss capital Per cent Per cent $621,549 10.8 $95,262 10.1 $2c: ,736 3,20 ,695 4,935,346 15.5 956,011 19.6 1,265,599 20.9 1,709,521 251,030 19.6 1,156,182 22.6 1,615,618 220,168 18.6 19_32 June Current net Current expenses earnings of Month Earnings from Total Exclusive of cost of F.?.currency Total $246,835 $10,274 $141,291 $9,005 49,351 1,039,695 146,966 137,252 19,765 13,580 236,465 22,285 13,927 1,494,286 412,420 425,r:in $144,016 511,256 140,629 197,785 $151,523 536,275 151,390 205,513 7,987 5,413 18,790 4,660 68,251 7,992 71,904 14,778 344,707 55,533 86,499 5,515 157,085 189,888 517,255 134,790 111,366 93,602 257,955 107,099 111,930 98,522 288,920 108,051 45,155 10.5 91,36 22.9 228,345 15.1 2.6,729 7.3 290,702 42'=:,733 1,481,620 119,378 11,0 17.3 17.0 5.3 133,335 277,375 948,212 -26,057 2,643 30,859 Minneapolis 3,575 70,279 as City 3,619 40,074 as 15,901 265,503 San Francisco TOTAL 1,396,968 149,730 June 1932 1,417,181 169,044 May 1932 407,969 120,687 June 1531 7.932 11,451,151 2,013,849 1931 2,759,704 1,155,651 FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD • 'DIVISION OF BAIT OPERATIO7S JULY 12, 1532. 84,843 2,548 73,432 30,435 56,554 3,051 142,505 1.6,955 120,903 177,722 103,406 441,8551 73,552 129,187 90,729 181,538 74,946 131,890 90,812 182,347 45,957 19.2 45,832 13.7 12,596 3.9 259,518 29.3 213,`187 258,433 107,255 1,685,841 14.6 13.1 5.4 30.6 123,931 140,570 -19,394 1• ,330,166 2,535,518 337,962 4,422,198 2,046,956 2,456,046 190,262 4,232,553 2,040,235 897,925 371,852 1,798,633 2,108,007 11,437,424162,439 26,384,863 12,375,109 6,460,513 939,946 11,336,054 12,767,672 2,132,229 2,109,566 2,143,358 12,907,580 13,567,250 13,477,283 -2,251,196 17.3 6,604,561 -6,256,051 Boston 7ew York Philadelpia Cleveland Richmond Atlanta Chicago St. Louis $86,315 256,264 191,803 150,963 72,855 97,793 97,135 38,115 2,289,969 2,122,965 -344,725 13,477,283 -2,251,196 18.0 15,2 17.3 VOLUME 230 PAGE 84 abf--(441. C).01.4.044 PtPAAPH ANALY AL PROVInl) _ ;',ECTI2N 13 :)F THE FEDERAL RESERVE ACT 311.;11 .1i 210 of H.R. 9642 AS AMENDED AND PASSED BY THE ',:ENATE a& 'VII 11 (C,'ILE,72k,. DAY JULY 12), 1932. At any time durink; the next two years, when in the judgment of the Federal heserve ioard, unusual wld exigent circumstances exist, it may, by the affirmative vote of not less than five of its members, authorize any ?ederal reserve bank to discount notes, drafts, or bills of exchange for any individual or corporation, subject to the following conditions and limitations: (a) In order to be eligible for discount for an individual or corration, a note, draft or bill of exchange must be of suoh a kind and r:f such a.naturity that it is eligible for discount for a -ember bank under the existing provisions of the Federal Reserve Act, except that the indorsement of a member bank is llot required. (b) Such discounts may be made only during such periods is may be determined ;the Federal Reserve Joard; but, during any such period, it is Aot necessary for any Federal reserve bank so authorized to obtain the Board's consent in each °a e before discountini; paper for an individual or corporation. Upon the ex- piraLion of any soh period no further discou-Its for an i_dividual or corporation may be made unlesL and until the _doard, uy the affirmative vote of five ..conlbers, has extended such period or again granted perdission for such discounts. If it should so desire, the Federal Reserve 3oard might require that its permission be obtained in each case before the discount of paper for an individual or VOLUME 230 oor orati,". PAGE 85 (0 The rates at which such disoounts may be ma& shall be established fronting) to time by the Federal reserve banks, subject to the review amd derimandmatian or the Fed3ral 'Amery. Board, and shall be rimed with a view of &accommodating oommeroe and business. (d) A mote, draft or till of emehemis dismounted for an indiFederal vidual er eorperstioa mere be indoresd tolls* Satisfaction of the reserve bank. as imdersement *Mother of a temiter otherwise is sufficient, if szAisillatory to the Federal reserve bunk. If wudh note, draft or bill eitemsbauga /las been aoquired framer bears be discouatod ladereeeemt or signets.* at a MoMmeiser bank it may not und,:lr emeept in oases aim" it may be, diseemeted for a member bank existinc U. (e) A. notevdraft or bill discounted for an individual or ()corsecured poration nust net only be indorsed but must also be otherwise reetrie. to the satisfaction of th,t discounting Federal reserve bank. No tion as to the kind or class of security is provided. (f) Such a note, draft or bill may be disco:sated only when the Federal reform bank has obtained evidence that the individual .: is unable to or corporation for which such discount is to be nad, other secure adequate credit aocommodations from bankine institutions than Federal reserve bank's. (i) All such discounts shall be scdideot to such libe restrictions and regulations as the Velma iteeersellaerd reseribe. .3— (h) No such mote, draft or bill of ccohange disoount3d for an individual or corporation shall be eligible as collateral security for Federal reserve notes. 64A July 13, 1932 honorable Carter Glass, United States Senate, Washington, D. C. Dear Senator Glass* At a meeting of the Federal Reserve Board held this afternoon, 1 was requested to suggest to you that wherever the words, "individual or corporation" occur in the new amendment to Section 13 of the Federal Reserve Act, the following be substitute& "For any individual, partnership, association or corporation", was very glad that you approved the suggestion that WiernOr lieyer be relieved of his dutiea as Chairman of the heconstruction Finance Corporation and I sincerely hope you will be able to arrange this. The Governor is very much fatigued and his associates feel that he should be relieved of the work on this Corporation which he has done so well. ancerely yours, P. S. I enclose a memorandum showing just where the chankAs above suggested should be made. VOLUME 230 PAGE 88 COPY • June 23, 1932. To Federal Reserve Board From Mr. Smead Subject: Operating efficiency of Federal reserve banks. Attached hereto is a cony of our usual annual statement, covering the year 1931, on output per employee and output per unit of cost in the principal operating departments at the head offices of the Federal reserve banks. As compared with 1925, the first year for which these data are available, output per employee, for the head offices atrial Federal reserve banks combined, was approximately 37 per cent higher in 1931, while output per unit of cost was 27 per cent higher. The aaaller increase in output per unit of cost is accounted for by the fact that the average salary paid clerical employees in these departments increased from $1,351 in the first half of 1925 to $1,486 in the first half d1931. The increased output per employee is directly reflected in the fact that, although there has been a substantial increase in the volume of work handled, the number of ennloyees in these principal departments declined. from 3,550 in 1925 to 2,943 in 1931, or by 607*. The average number of employees in 1931 in the operating units for which a measurement of volume of work is available, 2,943, was about 50 per cent of the total number of clerical employees at the head offices of the reserve banks. The cost figures shown in the attached statement represent the cost of handling work in the operating units of the departments exclusive of administrative costs. It will be noted from the statement that both output per employee and output per unit of cost increased substantially in 1931 as compared with 1930, which is a relatively good showing considering the fact that the volume of work declined somewhat in 1931. It will also be noted that, in a few of the smaller VOLUME 230 PAGE 89 -2— units, there was an abnormal change in the volume of work handled. This is due in some cases to a change in operating procedura or method of reporting. For example, in 1931 the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis began handling grain drafts for local banks in the City Collection departments. As these items are handled in practically the sane manner as checks, and since it was possible to handle such items without increasing the personnel, the increase in output per employee shown for this unit does not measure the Change in relative efficiency In handling these items during the year. Similarly, the increase in the number of City Checks (clearings) at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, and the corresponding decrease in the number of City Checks (other than clearings), is due largely to a change in the Manual of Instructions governing the preparation of functional exnense reports, as a result of which items collected through suburban clearing house associations are now counted as City Checks (clearings) rather than as City Checks (other than clearings). Items reported as City Checks (other than clearings) are now limited to those collected by messenger. Expenses as reported in the functional expense reports, form E, are not published by the Board, the published expense figures being classed merely according to object of expenditure as shown in current expense reports, form 96. According to these current expense reports, the salaries of clerical employees declined $556,000 between 1925 and 1931. This decline was approximately offset by an increase of $324,000 in officers' salaries and of $222,000 in salaries of "other employees," largely building employees, cafeteria employees, guards, etc. The increase in "other employees" resulted • largely from the moving of a number of branches out of rented ouarters into buildings constructed by the Federal reserve banks for their use. Between 1925 mi 1931 there was a decrease in total current exoense, exclusive of cost of currency, of $164,000, and in total current expense, including the cost of Federal reserve curreicy, of $487,000. *Of the decrease of 241 in the number of em-aloyees in these departments in 1931 as c =pared with 1930, approximately 70 was due to a decline in the volume of work and the remainder to an increase in the output -oer employee. Report of Carl P. Dennett, Chairman of the Banking.and Industrial Canmittee of the First Federal Reserve District, dated Jul457. 12, 1932. Analysis. Reports received from 142 Committees, representing approximately 40% of the population of the Union: 1. Banks unable or unwilling to grant sound loans for business purposes other than real estate loans: Yes 27. (19) No. 115. von.••••••••• 2. Are there any projects, canmercial, industrial, or municipal, that are held up for lack of credit? Would they be executed if credit from some source outside were made available? Yes 17. (12=A No. 325. WON.WO MO 3. Is there a sound basis and need for additional housing facilities? Yes 11. (76%) No 133. 111Mia••••••sal 4. What is the situation with respect to real estate loans? Answer: Difficult or impossible with reference to obtaining money on real estate mortgages. Yes 79. (60%) NO 51. mob VOLUME 230 PAGE 111 .••••• 2. 5. Is outside capital required for real estate loans? Yes 24. (18%) No 106. 00••••mara• In arellyzing these reports, it is astonishing to find a lack of complaint with reference to credit conditions. There are some exceotions, but generally speaking, there is no complaint about the credit conditions in New England. Real Estate Situation. 6. Are building and loan associations in your section in position to loan money on sound mortgages? No 19. (704) 24s 94 ••••••••••••=0 7. Is there any considerable demand for real estate loans which can not be satisfied with present facilities? Yes 21. (75%) 7. No , .. 01111more 8. Is there any need for additional housing facilities in your section? Yes 4. (15%) No 23. 9. Is there a demand for souna real estate loans for repair purposes on existing homes? Yes 22. (78%) 6. No Mame.. • 10. Would any considerable number of new homes be built if loans could be arranged on a sound basis, - say 600 Yes 6. (22%) No 21. Summary. 1, 19% declare instances of banks unable or unwilling to grant sound loans for business purposes other than real estate loans. 2. 14 state that there are projects, commercial, industrial, or municipal, that are held up for lack of credit which would be executed if credit fran same source outside were made available. 3. 78% state that there is a sound basis and need for additional housing facilities. 4. 60% state that the situation as to real estate loans is difficult or impossible with reference to obtaining money on real estate mortgages. 5. 18% state that outside capital is required_ for real estate loans. Real Estate Situation. and loan associations are not in 6. 70% report that building position to loan money on sound mortgages. 7. 75% report that there is a considerable demand for real estate loans which can not be satisfied with present facilities. 8. 15% report that there is need for additional housing facilities. 9. 78% report that there is a demand for sound real estate loans for repair purposes on existing homes. 10. 22% report that a considerable limber of new homes would be built if loans could be arranged on a sound basis, say 64010. R usi+• alava..4.23Dui 1. July $26 T91 Prom RfsptrIts roard Subject* Gemasnte et OWJemaa uld governor* at Federal rile:wive *u =July 11 Draft ot Circular re on Disesunts ter Individualsn Partasorehipe and Corporation** 1ter ttlat o General ceAnsol. • Sim et 'elle roJeral reserve banks (Cleveland. Attlantao chieages, Sto Louis, Dillas smd San Promisee) and Deputy (*moor Witt of the TedersiBesorTe 15krA of PhilodelPhis ther stated that they were *satisfied with the draft of the oiroular regarding disomanUt ter individuals° partnerships 0r ivvporations sent to tbWaioa4uly les 1933 (xfr9014) irt suggested 110 materiel ehangoe theeein. flit ef the Pederal reserve banks (ostem. low York Riohmondo Minneapolis and Kansas City) and Chaim.* AuStin of the Federal laserve Dalk of PhiladelphIa euiselted material shangee. The important question* 0)04 whioh ditrerences of aping.* devacw4 and the views expressed by the larious banks will be slmmarised below. In inatekrialme, their slows on these questions, those banks which stated generalAr that they're,* Matifified with the ciroglAr itna those which made no *peeing oommeint oaths particular question being discussed will be treated as favoring th,.. position taken in the draft oe July 16, 19.2ELWARP Seetioa III of the draft of July le provided that Federal reserve banks oould discount ter individuals0 partnorships or oorporations eligible cemmeroial„ industrial and agricultural paper aei_j...a . .. raedbr such law uala dividusls, partuershipe corploatioos and bearing their indorsement. I left open the queltionwhethae 7eders4. reserve banks could sake direot WITP° • imal to individuals. pattnerehipe er eerporatlens, but the Federal reserve banks apparently interpreted it as not permitting them to do so. Ofttble points eight of the bank* (Gleveland. Riohnond, Atlanta, Waage, St, Lode, Dallas and Bea Praneigeo) and Doputy Governor Nutt (Philadelphia) favored the clingier as drama Pour of the banks (Boston, hew York. Minneapolis and Zama* Cr' And chairman Austin (Philadelphia) feared that the benefits of the -11t 03123d be restrieted too svverely if the Federal reserve banks were not permitted to make direat loans. the Time or those who commented speeifically an this part are summarised belosi MOST014 We approve at letter omeept the words in Sea, III, "aetually owned hy mob individuals, partnerships or oerparations and bearing their indorsement*. Believe this should be eliminated because °MAU loan *aortae, are about the only corporations that we can recall at the mown* that mould be able to fUnationo 4-4 believe if we are to Nestles in slaking loans direst that it will be necessary for borrowg to set up oerporatiens with capital etas* main business will be indorsing. NV Tab Seetios three, paragraph one, would operate id Unit eligible paper tø the notes receivable of the borrow. au.thiS will probably be desirable in most oases, it would appear to be ump necessary and perhaps unwise to Is Unit paper wide* een be ameepted, R/CIMOIDI Section 20 Legal Dequirements.— Subsection 2 states IJ a • •• J• • a• that the Pedcrol Reserve Minks =my dieeOunt ter individualSo partner* ships or corporations only notes. drafts and bills of eschan6.0 of the time.* and maturities nade eliGible tor discount for womb-Jr banks. etc. In tads 04$0. under the present Aot amber banks' own notes areeligi. blo for disocuuto whereas under 3ectien Ins subornation I of the Board's memorandum° 4211gibillW° the direct obligations of indiviOuals. part* nerships or eorporations# was a endorsed or seoured. are not made all. giblea but only the business peva. actua14 awned by audh Indivithelles partnerships or corporations bearing their endorsement and secured iS made eligiblo• YrankIy.wo should prefer to hum the Board's memorandum main as it is beeaussi capitol leans arm under Section?' of the Sotrets 7,Jemorandum. subsection 50 prohibitld o and it would not be possible for all$ individual° firm or oerporation to obtain a oapital loan. dirookly or indireotly under &motion tlIo utioh makes eligible only paper setually owned by applicants. nevertheless. tThs oonment seems °ailed for* 0, :r oareut consideration end eonsulting with coumceI it is out understanding troll both the aotjand regulation' VI:a we limy rediscount for individuals. partnerships and corporations Quay such eligible paper of others which thqy ney own and ender:1m tbe e5.ms as we nos redisount for member banks their own paper endorsed by them this would preolude our taking direct Trentham their note* Signed ay themselves as their eomasrelat banks would de• le also understan d eligible mar does not baud* typO of toans provided by Olass..3te agall Bill and that Apar *doh wean rediseount as above mr4 be available to secure eurrenoy iseums, If clu. unetarstandim; as outlined abva • • • de" •I• 44. wrest no think proposed regulations are in satisfactory for*. WAPOLDIs Motion 5 regarding eligibility says paper =et be setually owned by the individual1 partnership or corporation offering it1 which would 804311 to limit offerings to concern* like agricultural ercdit corporation and livestock lean companies. There might be a night be unable te situation where a eanrina factory in a moll to sot the neeessary credit to peek LAd carry their peas and corn. They eould however, offer us their note with the endoreovent of the direutors and **cured by warehouse receipts for canned go040; in storage& which mould Monk to eome under the terns of the act and yet would not be paper actually amid by the endorsee who night offer ZAIIAS 022fs It is the opinion our counsel that tentative draft proposed valvular X.4801a oorreetly interprets elaesimmaimsat providing for dismounts for Individuals partnerships end corporationS under strict eonetruction at the amendment in the 116ht of the provision* of the Federal Reserve Aft which are emended and the Act of which it is 4 pertsbut that standing *lane the act would permit of oonstruction author. Wog 'arena* direst to borrowers of the *lasses mentioned' Debates in Cien.:rolis and promoting' Won/ Ofalattele OW the amendment not yet available here but it is our underetanillas that Congress Intended to • ftuthoritie &treat loans whore credit not available through oemmorei4 banks or other credit Manna*, the pro-vision or the sot which reeds "When such notes, drafts and bills of *whinge are endorsed and Otherwise *soured to the satiotaetien of the Federal Reserve lamVe should ba interpreted to mean° in our opinion, it the same is at all permiesables 'When such notes1 drafts and bills of exchange am* endorsed or otherwise • 3.• • • secured to the satisfaotion ot the Federal Reserve BArk". Otherwise ordinary commercial and industrial loans as a practical natter oannot be rediamounted at the Federal Reserve Banks for the reason that industrial and commercial corporations in the main have no security to pledge even . though their financial statements may entitle them to credit. Suoh concorns could probably furnish accommodation endorsers and we consider the final test should be whether such notes are eligible and are good and collectible° We beliwie the =,:entative dratt of the circular wnuld make 1 the act almost wholly inoperative in this diwtrict except possible for livestock and agrioultural loans throuch cattle loan companies or other such organisations. With funda *mailable thro101 the intermediate oredit banks and the RFC it should be possible for the latter class of loans to be handled as satisfactorily as could be dens under the protisions of this act( ) The suggest3d oonstruotion of the words nand otherwise seoured" might be justified on the theory that the loan is otherwise *soured if in. addition to bearing an endorsement it ia accompanied by a satisfactory finande l s'Fatemente In shaft we believe that as an aid to commerce. industry and agrisulture this aot is a mere gesture unless there aan be read into it an intent on the part of Congress that loans may be made direct when the paper is endorsed even though by an accommodation endorser and further in any event that a oonstruction of the words "and otherwise secured" vbioh requires a pledge of or a lien= property will largely deprive commeroe and industry of the benefits of the act° (Soo alternative substitute for Sectian III) wommo BOTH INDOESEMZET AND swum! See Governor Hamilton's telegramwhich is quoted in full above. No one else obj7,cted to this requirements, which is contained in tile law itself. This is not one of the rare oases where "and" can properly be oonstrued as neaning "ern° MING PROCEEDS TO PAT OFF /IDEBTEDRESS0 The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapoliso Chairman Austin Mil.. adelphia) and Messrs. Goldenweiser and Snead question the advisability of the provi3ion in Section V (po6) es the draft of July 16o which forbade Fatima]. reserve banks to discount paper for individuals* partnerships or corporations if the prowled* are to be used to pay off existing indebted.. ness to other banking institutionsg and the revised draft (Sec. III, p. 4) modifies this prohibition by inserting thewordso "Except with the permission of the Federal Reserve Boareo Tho colrnients were as follows; GOLDENWEISERe I az inclined to question the absolute pro. hibition of borrowing under this proviso for the purpose of Mb* off existing indebtedness. While ordinarily suoh loans should nob be granted, aircumstances might arise where& bank is pressing a firm forremment of t loans and this is threatening failwre to the firm. I should think that if all other circumstances are all right, tha Federal reserve bank might very well be permitted to grant a loan to such - a firo. MR. WAD: In the uaragraph on page 6 relating to the purposes for which the proem/44s of the discounts are to be used It is stated that they mut not be used for the purpose of pking off existing indebtedness to ether bankinz institutions. While this in gneral is no doubt a good pro • ae rie* vision* 1 =wondering whether it is Vi30 to close the door against all such loans. Might there not be instances where the granting of such loans may be in the best interests of the oormunity? XINNEAPOLIS8 We feel too that the provision that loans cannot be made to pgy off existing indebtedness is too drastic. Cases might arise where it wyuld be advisable to make a loan to pay off a receiver of a closed bank: who would otherwise sell the debtor outo *". =TM As the paper's) might discount would be what is so- of called "self-liquidating paper" that is such paper would be obligations not other parties and fora a part of the capital of the borrower, he would have to provide for its payment, and we do not see why there wculd be any objection to allowing the proceeds of such paper to be used for fixed invlstment or other capital purposes* or even liquidating indebtedness to other bankan which banks might be pressing the borrower for payment. , The intended purpose of the Act is to provide moans for stimulating business y starting up factories, etco and in such cases it probably would be necessar to make some expenditures for capital purposes or other fixed investments* and we cannot see any objection to so using sone of the proceeds of such discounts. RATE OF DISCOUNT. The following are the only comments on this subject, except a comment by Governer Seay regarding a natter of prooedures OOVENNOR WD0UGAL8 In respect to interest ratca to be charged on .4 t. • 04. discounts it is important that consideration be given to the fact that the average borrower from& commorsial bank is expeoteJ to maintain a deposit balance. Under thee* circumstances the minimum rate charged by Federal Reserve Badks should be kept at least a fraction higher than prevailing counter rates otherwise borrower wovld 2r..vo) a preferential rate here. Incori=daction with toot/our/ way we assume in BAN FRAI3CO view of widelmriatical Ia twelfth district in interest rates for came class of paper board would approve a 2% spread between nin3.3=1 and MillaiMaR discount rates. DR. QOIDiwisISR I a3a inclined to think that the rate of interest should always be somewhat higher than the prevai1/11g rate an the same class of paper, PERMISSION OF FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD. There were some helpful suggestions regarding the phrassolou of Section 14 but the following are the oriy comments on matters of substance GOVERNOR Sage Sub-sootian I states that permission to a hoderal Reserve Bank sea only be granted upon 'written or telegraphic application of a Federal Reserve Bank, containing a full statement of the unusual and exigent circum0Wummit'Ai& in the judgment of the Board of Directors of the Federal Reserve Bank Austifiss such action. In the ease of this bank, and of some other Federal Reserve; Bank, directors' meetings sewer only *ace a month, and unless a wpocial meeting of the directors of this bank is called (their monthly meeting having just been held), this br.mk would .aot be ab3.6, to aot and. in the as .. •Ute me..tar :.'"Qr a mont3-... i'rcra Vnia ti.'.,-,refore not be ablo f'or issue k.vay otroulare SP-sti on VIII rif the r Jard ' a ,....nnoa%icylt.ar.. :e7r.....E.sAcuo::-... es thi, alc:r.td-Inont -to 1,-,:La Aei; and 3.311katni.tti`., S X.14" Oil a porin9.1., ion.* 4-ituation are well k3.1:17. L Air3 and unrs!-- ;odo Itac inach a.a ell letal .rve Banks Is good fae.th are atIld Ivor to tot moald sem that uncli,r aniendnonts s.xiatL„,?, ...501ar Y.,..), Ar be it$nd R Sere* Banks -thritr.z7;1. quats :::emor:4 as to the tu.1.12.attai extes. applioptior. of a Federal or C;oisalt-:;eao alie;ht• be ate- ;:ais LIZS k ra • r ,133.15 es a f "Vij Wh.1 - 1v pia.afTaph oon4iLaer sta ux.o,;-! zv.7. SIVIS th.e 741.11 not tuulartf.. ti us tha'.; the u.r•lante-1. dad. Jxigant eiroume-IA.a.Ges E4Z, slAnsc alvityz ir 1.:141T-f,c1.-..a2. Gases ratheT .1..han. -. with th4 rot marg. oeu.v1;t1 hat; 7`f" t".'-./27:' ".!le?,:laalary o . ;: raw-. - Ard. and. be dilks tA.S .-"; are inte-r.ded. t17.11,t the Fitrita'.-..-.1 reserve .b..nka -t* the, tiwsar. • T4at'z Generel, Cotrazelo ir. the light: .3i Office Correspondence Form No. TO_ Mr. Hamlin FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD Subject: From Mr. -,4-yatt General Counsel. Date July 22, 1932 Glass Amendment to so-called relief bill •PO Dear 2-8495 Hamlin: The following information -with reference to the Glass Amendment to the bill to authorize supplemental appropriat ions to provide Federal aid in connection with the const ruction of &Late highways (H.R. 9642, 72nd Congress, 1st Sessi on - now known as the "Elmergency relief and construction act of 1932" ), is furnilph d to you in response to the request contained in 7our memorandum of July 19, 1932. This act, which amends Section 13 of the teder al Reserve Act, was siTned by the President on July 21, 1932, and is now known as Public Act No. 302. As originally introduced by Senator Glass on July 11, 1932, his amendment to H.R. 9642 provided as follo ws: "In unusual and exigent circumstances the Federal Reserve Board, by the affirmative vote of not less than five members, may authorize any Feder al reserve bank, during,such periods as the said board may determine, at rates established in accor dance with the provisions of section 14, subdivision (d), of this Act, to discount for an:: individual or corpo ration, notes, drafts, and bills of exchange of the kinds and maturities made eligible for discount for membe r banks under other provisions of this act,' when such notes, drafts, and bills of exchange are indor sed and otherwise VOLUME 230 PAGE 137 secured to the satisfaction of the Feder al reserve bank: • 11 • -2- "Provided, That before discounting any such note, draft, or bill for an indi-idual or corporation the Federal reserve bank shall obtain evidence that such individual or corporation is unable to secure adequate credit accommodations from other banking institutions. All such discounts for individuals or corporations shall be subject to such limitations, restrictions, and regulations as the Federal Reserve Board may prescri-oe. No note, draft, or bill of e7change dis- counted under the provisions of this paragraph shall be eligible as collateral security for Federal reserve notes." On the saare day, Mr. Wagner, Mr. Robinson oce. Arkansas, Tam. Pittman, L'r. Walsh of flontana, and /L-. Bulkley, proposed another amendment in the nature of a substitute for the bill as passed by the House, and, included in that amendment was a section which provided precisely the sane as that contained in the amendment of Senator Glass, except for two unimportant changes in punctuation and except forthe inclusion of the words "of e,:Lchange" the after the word "bill" in the language imiaediately follaning/proviso clause. As passed by the Senate on July 12, 1932, except for inserting the words "For a T)eriod of) two years" before the words "In unusual and exigent circumstances" and except for one immaterial change in punctuation, this section read exactly the same as that contained in the amendment of Lessrs. Wagner, Robinson, Pittman, Walsh and Bulkley. As agreed upon by the conference committee, which, of course, is also the form in which it finAlly passed Congress, this section reads as • • _3_ follows (the part shown in capital letters being new wording inserted in the Senate provisions and the part stricken through being wording omitted therefrom): "i2op-a-14ope4-eP-4we-yeaPe In unusual and exigent circumstances, the Federal Reserve board, by the affirmative vote of not less than five members, may authorize any Federal reserve bank, during such periods as the said board may determine, at rates established in accordance with the provisions of section 14, subdivision (d), of this Act, to discount for any individual, PARTNERSHIP, or corporation, notes, drafts, and bills of exchange of the kinds and maturities made eligible for discount for member banks under other provisions of this Act when such notes, drafts, and bills of exchange are indorsed and otherwise secured to the satisfaction of the Federal reserve bank: Provided, That before discounting any such note, draft, or bill of exchange for an individual or A PARTNERSHIP OR corporation the Federal reserve bAnk shall obtain evidence that such individual, PARTNERSHIP, or corporation is unable to secure adequate credit accommodations from other banking institutions. All such discounts for indi- viduals, PAPT;ERSHIPS, or corporations shall be subject to such limitations, restrictions, and regulations as the loederal Reserve 3oard may prescribe. 4e-ne*ey-dPaty-P-1311-ef=-emeliaRge di.seeRE4ed-linder-tke-pPeveleRe-ec-4kio-paPagFaph-skall-be-eligil4e as-eel4qt*epal-seewPity-LgeP-i:edepal-peserve-no*se." •••2 1.111 In short, the legislative action upon this amendment may be described as follows: As orizinally introduced by Senator Glass, the amendment permitted the Federal Reserve Board, in unusual and exigent cumstances and upon the affirmative vote of not less than 5 of its members, to aut orize the Federal reserve banks to discount for any individual or corporation paper eligible for discount for member banks under the Federal Reserve Acts if such paper was indorsed and otherwise secured I o the satisfaction of -the Federal reser-Ye bank. It was also provided that the discounts were to be made only where the individual or corporation was unable to secure adequate accommodations from other banking institutions and that no paper so discounted should be eligible as col2ateral security for Fecleral reserve notes. The bill as passed by the Senate on July 12, 1932, incorporated Senator Glass' amendment but limited the authority to discount :paper for individuals or corporations to a period of two years. The bill as agreed to in conference and as finally passed by Congress retains the substance of the Senate provisions, but extends the discount privilege to partnerships as well as to individuals and corporations, removes the two year limitation and eliminates the provision that the paper so discounted should not be eligible as collateral security for Federal reserve notes. I am also attaohing for your further information a copy of your original draft of this pruvision and a copy of 1:!r. Vest's revision. R:spect ully, 'Walter Gene • • July 9, 1932. Mr. Hamlin's Draft. Proposed amendment to Section 13. Federal Reserve Act : The second paragraph of Section 13 of the Federal Reserve Act is hereby amended by adding the following : "The Federal Reserve Board, by an affirmative vote of five members, in times of emergency, is hereby given the power to permit Federal reserve banks, for such periods as it may determine, to discount paper eligible under the Act directly for individuals or corporations said paper to have a satisfactory indorser but without requiring an indorsement of any bank, said paper to be subject to the maturity and other limitations now prescribed by said Act. The Federal reserve bank, before discounting any such paper, shall satisfy itself that the borrower can furnish satisfactory collateral and that it is unable to procure a loan from a member bank, and, on passing of the emergency, shall revoke its consent as to any future loans under this provision. " A Mr. Vest's Revision. BE IT ENACTED BY THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DI CONGRESS ASSEMBLED, That Section 13 of the Federal Reserve Act, as amended, is hereby further amended by adding at the end of the second paragraph thereof a new para- graph reading as follows: " In unusual and exigent circumstances, the Federal Reserve Board, by the affirmative vote of not less than five members, may authorize any Federal reserve bank, during such periods as the said Board may determine, at rates established in accordance with the provisions of section 14, subdivision (d), of this Act, to discount for any individual or corporation, notes , drafts and bills of exchange of the kinds and maturities made eple for discount for member banks under other provisioS s of this Act,when such notes, drafts and bills of exchange are indorsed and otherwise secured to the satisfaction of the Federal reserve bank; provided, that before discounting any such note, draft or bill for an inSividual or corporation the Federal reserve bank shall obtain evidence that such individual or corporation is unable to secure adequate credit accommodations from other bankinginstitutions. All such discounts for individuals or corporations shall be subject to such limitations, restrictions and regulations as the Federal Reserve Board may prescribe. No note, draft or bill of exchange discounted under the proons of this paragraph shall be eble as collateral security for Federal reserve notes. "