View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Do we really want
government off our backs?
The call to “get government off our backs” grew louder during the late 20th century and soon rose to a full-throated roar. The prevailing belief seemed to be that
private industry and “the markets” were better able to deliver just about anything citizens might want or need, if only government would get out of the way.
“Government is not the solution to our problem,” President Reagan told
us in 1981, “government is the problem.” Fifteen years later, President Clinton
declared “The era of big government is over.” And in 2001, antitax activist Grover
Norquist insisted that he didn’t want to abolish government but simply “reduce
it to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it in the bathtub.”
Surprising? Not really. America, after all, was founded by people wary of
concentrated government power. To this day, we pride ourselves on our selfreliance and rugged individualism. Ours is a country where we “pull ourselves
up by our bootstraps.”
But what would our economy be like—what would our lives be like—without government involvement? Do we really want government off our backs?
We examine these questions in this issue of The Ledger.
We’re not out to convince you that more
government is better government, nor are we
“You can have a
market economy, saying that government should be the default for
but not a market addressing the challenges we all face. But in this
day and age, when so many people seem to have
society.”
lost faith in government’s ability to do anything of
Ricardo Lagos value, we figured the time was right to look back
Former President
of Chile at some of the positive contributions government
has made to the lives of so many Americans.
One last thing: The government programs and initiatives we’ve chosen to
highlight do not represent a complete list, and you may not agree that those
we’ve selected have had a positive impact. In either case we’d enjoy hearing
your thoughts. Because as Thoreau wrote in Civil Disobedience, “Let every man
make known what kind of government would command his respect, and that
will be one step toward obtaining it.”

4

“EVERYBODY’S
BUSINESS
IS NOBODY’S
BUSINESS.”

Boston Light

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: Boston Public Library

Boston Light has guided ships safely into port since
1716. It is a long-standing example of government
providing an essential public service that private companies might be unwilling or unable to provide.
When the British blew it up on their way out of
town in 1776, the Massachusetts legislature appropriated funds for a new structure (1783), and shortly
thereafter, Massachusetts turned control over to the
U.S. government. Federal tax dollars have kept it operating ever since (except for the years during World
War II).
5

Images: iStockphoto.com

Economist Paul Samuelson may or may not have
had Boston Light in mind when he cited lighthouses as
a “typical example of government service. These save
lives and cargoes; but lighthouse keepers cannot reach
out to collect fees from ships. So we have here a divergence between private and social advantage.”
Samuelson went on to note that “government
provides certain indispensible public services without which community life would be unthinkable and
which by their nature cannot appropriately be left to
private enterprises.” Think national defense, public
safety, and the judicial system.
But over the years, our sense of what constitutes
essential public services has expanded, and that has created varying degrees of political and social tension. To
what extent is government responsible for providing
services? Can we afford to provide the level of services
people seem to want? What services do they actually
want? And what are the limits of government’s regulatory authority over industry, commerce, finance, and
personal behavior?
That tension arises because government action
or government involvement introduces a level of
coercion, often in the form of taxation and increased
regulation. Samuelson makes that point in the following passage (which is worth reading for the nostalgia
value alone):
“It is true that that the citizenry as a whole imposes
the tax burden upon itself; also, each citizen is sharing in the collective benefits of government. But there
is not the same close connection between benefits and
tax payments as holds when the individual citizen
puts a dime into a gum machine or makes an ordinary purchase. I need not smoke Winstons or buy
nylon carpeting or choose fried eggs, but I must pay

my share of the taxes used to finance the various
activities of government.
Moreover, a second form of coercion is involved
in the universal custom of passing governmental
laws: thou shalt not sell false weight, thou shalt not
employ child labor, thou shalt not burn houses, thou
shalt not pour out smoke from thy factory chimney,
thou shalt not sell or smoke opium, thou shalt not
charge more than the ceiling price for food, and so
forth. This set of rules gives the framework within
which private enterprise functions; it also modifies
the direction of that functioning. Together with government expenditure and taxation, the commands
of government supplement the price system in determining the economic fate of the nation.
It would be fruitless to debate whether public
enterprise or private enterprise is the more important—as fruitless as to debate heredity versus
environment. Without either, our economic world
would be an entirely different one.”
Those words were written a lifetime ago. Times
have changed, and so have attitudes toward government. Today, even using the words “public” and
“enterprise” in the same breath invites controversy. But
the fact remains that “our economic world would be an
entirely different one” without government involvement. Whether it would be different-and-better or
different-and-worse is yet another source of tension
and controversy.
6

The Green Economy

Government regulation and involvement in the economy didn’t begin with
Franklin Roosevelt and the New Deal.
Early New England towns set aside land
for common use, and town selectmen
closely controlled who could use it and
how. The Boston Common is among the
best surviving examples, but dozens of
picture postcard village greens throughout New England also serve as reminders
of colonial-era government planning.
Bonner Map of Boston, 1722
Image: Mapping Boston/Boston Public Library

Grafton Common, Grafton, MA

Image: John Phelan, National Register of Historic Places/from Wikimedia.org

7

Images: Springfield Armory National Historic Site

“Innovation” isn’t a word that 21st century
Americans ordinarily associate with government.
But since the earliest days of the Republic, the U.S.
government has been a catalyst for technological
advances.
In 1815, when Congress established national
armories in Springfield (MA) and Harpers Ferry (VA),
its primary purpose was to promote production of
military firearms with standardized, interchangeable parts. But the infusion of government money
8

Innovation

had a much broader impact, particularly in the area
surrounding the Springfield Armory, where skilled
gunsmiths, mechanics, and machinists exchanged
ideas and sometimes established factories and machine
shops of their own, using the techniques they perfected
while working at the armory.
“By the 1850s,” write the authors of Inventing
America, “armory methods could be found in factories
making sewing machines, pocket watches, padlocks,
railway equipment, shoes, wagons, and hand tools.
And the key transmitters of these methods were New
England machine-tool firms closely connected with
the Springfield Armory.”
And not to belabor the point, but it was a government initiative that set everything in motion.
“All well and good,” you say, “but has the government done anything to spur innovation in more
modern times?”
The short answer is yes. (Think “rocket science.”)
In 1961, President John Kennedy committed
America to putting a man on the moon by the end
of the decade. NASA—the National Aeronautics
and Space Administration—got the job done with a
few months to spare. In July of 1969, astronauts Neil
Armstrong and Edwin “Buzz” Aldrin walked on the
moon’s surface, thanks to a government-funded, government-managed program.
Still not convinced? There’s more. (This time,
think “cyberspace.”)

Buzz Aldrin on the Moon, 1969
Image: NASA

9

<p>innovation</p>
LINCOLN

ARPANET, 1974

MOFF

RADO

LBL

AMES
HAWAII AMES

UTAH

GWC

LLL
SRI

PURDUE

STAN
USD-O
RAND
USC-I

FNWS
USCB
UCLA
SDC
USC

DOCB

CCA
BBN
NCC

BBN

TYMS
XEROX

MIT IPC
MIT MAC
MIT MAC

CARNEGIE
CASE
RUTGERS
URPAT

ILL

SDA
MITRE
ARPA

HARVARD
ABERDEEN

BELVO

NORSAR
NBS
ETAC

UCL

AFWL

RML

Early Computer Scientists
Image: Wikimedia Commons

10

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Before the Internet there was ARPANET, a creation
of the Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA),
which began in 1958 as a U.S. Department of Defense
think tank for “high risk/high reward” research projects. ARPANET came into being not long after that
because the ARPA scientists working at universities
and defense contractors scattered throughout the
country needed a way for their computers to “talk to
one another”—they needed a network.
Since then, private companies have refined it and
turned it into something that has affected almost every
aspect of modern life. But it’s hard not to see irony in
the fact that cyberspace is now crowded with websites
and blogs critical of government programs and the
public sector, yet the Internet evolved from a need to
link computers used in government work.

Water Celebration on Boston Common, 1848
Image: Boston Public Library

“… in 1848, 300,000 people from all over New England
gathered on Boston Common. They came to celebrate the
completion of the city’s first municipal water system.
With the construction of an aqueduct that brought fresh
water 15 miles from Lake Cochituate in Natick to Boston,
the city for the first time had a pure supply of water for
drinking, bathing, cooking and cleaning.”
Excerpt from “October 25, 1848: Boston Celebrates
Opening of Aqueduct”
11

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Infrastructure

City Dwellers:
Turn on your faucet, and clean water comes out. Flush
your toilet, and the opposite of clean water goes away.
It may not be magic, but few things have had a greater
beneficial effect on public health and modern urban
life.
In the vast majority of U.S. cities clean water
and effective sewage disposal are provided by public
entities. You pay for those services, of course, but on
balance they are worth (almost) every penny.
Even if you’re one of those people who buys bottled water because you don’t trust what comes out of
the tap, you probably use municipal water for bathing,
doing laundry, and general washing up. If so, consider this fact from Stanley Lebergott’s book Pursuing
Happiness: In the days before running water, housewives (because it was almost always women who got
stuck doing this) had to haul 10,000 gallons a year into
the kitchen, laundry, or bath.
Ten thousand gallons a year averages out to 27 gallons a day. Not much by modern standards, but it’s still
a lot to carry. Anyone who’s ever bought gallon-jugs of
bottled water at the grocery store, knows what it’s like
to lug one or two from the car to the kitchen. Imagine
carrying 27 of them up two or three flights of stairs …
every day … for your entire life.
Now consider this: Indoor water use currently averages around 75-80 gallons of water per person, per day.

How Much Water Do We Use?
Other 5.3%
Leaks
13.7%
Faucet
15.7%
Shower
16.8%
Clothes
Washer
21.7%
Toilet
26.7%

Source: American Water Works Association Research Foundation,
“Residential End Uses of Water.” 1999

That’s in the neighborhood of 300 gallons per day for a
household of four.
Think about that for a minute. Without the infrastructure and maintenance that municipal water
agencies provide—and we all pay for—we’d be spending a lot more time toting water into our homes. We’d
also be taking a lot fewer showers and washing our
clothes far less often.
The only people who might be happy with that are
the makers of Febreze® and underarm deodorant.
Country Folks and Denizens of Deep Suburbia:
You might have your own private water wells and septic systems, but what about electricty?
By the 1930s, most American cities were wired
for electricity, but 90 percent of America’s farms were
without power. Private utilities had little incentive to
run high-cost lines to isolated homesteads. (For a more
modern parallel, think “broadband internet service.”)
Things only began to change when the U.S. government created the Rural Electrification Administration
(REA) in 1935. Thanks to the REA, almost every farm
had electricity by the 1950s.
12

Image: Library of Congress

Getting From Point A to Point B
Fact: A ton of goods could be brought 3000 miles from
Europe to America for about nine dollars, and for the
same sum it could be moved only 30 miles overland
in this country. (Excerpt from a U.S. Senate Committee
Report issued in 1816).
Fact: In 1812, a freight wagon drawn by four
horses took 75 days to travel from Worcester, MA to
Charleston, S.C. (Source: The Transportation Revolution,
George Rogers Taylor).
Fact: In the 1840s, the voyage from Boston to San
Francisco took 150 to 200 days aboard a conventional
sailing ship or 110 days by clipper ship. Today, commercial jets make the trip in under five hours. (Source:
The Transportation Revolution, George Rogers Taylor).
In preindustrial times, travel was slow, costly,
uncomfortable and dangerous. People often spent
their entire lives within a few miles of where they
were born. There was no easy way to get from Point A

Interstate Highway System, 1976

Background images: iStockphoto.com

Image: Library of Congress

Joining the Tracks for the First Transcontinental
Railway, Promontory Point, Utah, 1869
Image: National Archives

to Point B, and even a simple shopping excursion to a
market town ten miles away could turn into a daylong
odyssey.
The convergence of private enterprise and government involvement helped to change all that. Two huge
undertakings, separated by almost a century, serve as
examples.
One was the completion of America’s first transcontinental railroad in 1869. The ceremonial driving
of the last spike at Promontory Point, Utah, marked
the completion of a project that was an engineering
marvel and a testament to human perseverance. The
financiers and the laborers who laid the tracks were
the ones who took the project from dream to reality,
but they had considerable help from the U.S. Congress.
The Pacific Railroad Act of 1862 provided two key elements: 1) millions of acres of public land to serve as
rights of way for the rail lines, and 2) financial backing
in the form of 30-year government bonds.
Nearly 100 years later, Congress passed the FederalAid Highway Act of 1956, which funded most of the
Interstate Highway System: $25 billion to construct
41,000 miles of modern, limited-access highway.
Without federal involvement and funding, the
Interstates might never have been built.
13

Education

School Days, Boston, Circa 1900

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: Boston Public Library

We’ve been hearing it for years: “The schools in (fill
in the name of another country) are much better
than ours.”
In the late 1950s, after the launch of Sputnik,
schools in the Soviet Union were said to be better
than ours. In the 1980s, the Japanese economy was
ascendant, and Japanese schools were thought to be
better than ours. But today the Soviet Union exists
only in history books, and the Japanese economy
lost much of its steam in the 1990s, so now China
and India are “filling in the blank.”
14

Image: Jack Delano, Library of Congress

Time will tell. But universal public education still
stands as one of America’s most successful government programs.
America’s public schools have taken their share
of criticism, and some of it may be warranted. But
given what we expect them to do—meet the needs
of students who come from very different economic,
social, and cultural backgrounds and often act as
caregivers to those students—our public schools do
a pretty good job.

15

Background image: iStockphoto.com

College Students, Iowa State, 1942

Anyone who has attended a public college or
university has also benefited from government
involvement in education. When Congress passed the
Morrill Act of 1862, it gave each state at least 90,000
acres of public land. The states were then free to sell
that land and use the funds for:
“the endowment, support, and maintenance of at
least one college where the leading object shall be,
without excluding other scientific and classical
studies, and including military tactics, to teach such
branches of learning as are related to agriculture
and mechanic arts, in such manner as the legislatures of the State may respectively prescribe, in
order to promote the liberal and practical education
of the industrial classes in the several pursuits and
professions in life.”
The Morrill Act helped to establish more than 70
“land grant colleges,” some of which are now among
the world’s most renowned institutions of higher
learning. It also put a college education within the
reach of many more students … and brightened the
lives of countless college football fans.
Eighty years later, the Servicemen’s Readjustment
Act of 1944—better known as the G.I. Bill of Rights—
opened college campuses to an even broader student
population. The G.I. Bill’s generous education benefits provided returning World War II veterans with
an opportunity to improve their lives through higher
education. As a result, college enrollment increased
sharply and campuses expanded to meet the demand.
Few measures, public or private, have done as much to
reinforce the relationship between education and the
prospects for a better life.

A Run on American Union Bank, New York, 1931

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: Wikimedia Commons

Helping to Protect Your Money
One thing you almost never saw during the financial crisis that’s come to be known as The Great
Recession: Lines of panicked depositors hoping to
withdraw their money from their banks. In large
part, that’s because the federal government, through
the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC),
has insured bank deposits since the 1930s. Few measures have done more to shore up confidence in
the banking system. Today (2012), FDIC coverage
is $250,000 for single accounts, joint accounts, and
individual retirement accounts.
16

Consumer Protection
There was a time when caveat emptor (buyer beware)
was the only form of consumer protection. But today
there are federal regulations in place that give consumers a measure of protection from unsafe products and
unscrupulous dealings.
Improvements in auto safety provide a striking
example. Today automakers emphasize safety and
point to their “five-star” safety ratings, but that wasn’t
always the case. “Safety doesn’t sell” used to be the
refrain among auto executives. Then in 1965, a young
lawyer named Ralph Nader published Unsafe at Any
Speed, which detailed the auto industry’s indifference
to safety concerns. Congress invited Nader to testify
on his findings, and his testimony ultimately led to
new safety regulations, safer cars, and fewer highway
fatalities.
Consumer demand eventually might have
prompted automakers to take safety more seriously.
But how much longer might it have taken if Nader’s
book had not spurred Congress to take action?

Safer Behind the Wheel
Highway
Fatalities

Per 100 Million
Vehicle Miles
Traveled

1900

36

36.00

1910

1,599

44.66

1920

12,155

25.54

1930

31,204

15.12

1940

32,914

10.89

1950

33,186

7.24

1960

36,399

5.06

1970

53,816

4.85

1980

51,091

3.35

1990

44,599

2.08

2000

41,945

1.53

2010

32,788

1.09

Source: U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Highway
Administration, and U.S. Census Bureau

Woman Poses with 1960’s Era Chevrolet
Image: iStockphoto.com

17

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Also during the “Great Recession” the Federal
Reserve System, America’s central bank, helped to stabilize the banking system by acting as “lender of last
resort” to financial institutions and providing liquidity to the financial markets. It also worked with the
U.S. Treasury Department to coordinate the Troubled
Asset Relief Program (TARP) and continued to conduct
“stress tests” to evaluate whether or not the largest U.S.
bank holding companies “continue to meet supervisory expectations for capital adequacy.”

Safer on the Job
No one worried much about workplace safety when
the Industrial Revolution began in the early 1800s.
Employers figured it was less expensive to find new
workers than to make safety improvements. And that
was pretty much the prevailing philosophy for the
next 150 years.
One of the things that helped to bring about a
change was the Occupational Safety and Health Act of
1970, which created OSHA, the Occupational Safety &
Health Administration.
Yes, OSHA regulations can be a pain: Wear your
helmet! Wear your goggles! Wear your earplugs! Wear
your respirator! Blah! Blah! Blah!
But losing your eyesight, a limb, or a finger can be
an even bigger pain. Chronic lung disease is nothing to
sneeze at either. And dying on the job can really ruin a
person’s day.

U.S. Workplace Deaths
(Rate per 100,000 workers)
1960

21.0

1970

18.0

1980

13.0

1990

9.0

2000

4.0

2010

3.5

Source: U.S. Department of Transportation,
Federal Highway Administration, and U.S.
Census Bureau

Worker Poses with Safety Equipment

18

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: iStockphoto.com

Americans don’t have the same level of cradle-tograve security available in some European countries,
but our social safety net offers us far more protection
than our ancestors had from life’s uncertainties.
Three programs in particular—Social Security,
Medicare, and unemployment insurance—are
extremely popular, even though we worry about
the cost.
19

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Maintaining
the Social
Safety Net

Social Security Poster, 1935

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: Library of Congress

When President Franklin Roosevelt signed the
Social Security Act in 1935 he noted that, “We can
never insure one hundred percent of the population
against one hundred percent of the hazards and vicissitudes of life but we have tried to frame a law which
will give some measure of protection to the average
citizen and to his family against the loss of a job and
against poverty-ridden old age.”
Before Social Security came into being, few
Americans had the option of looking forward to retirement. The main alternatives to work were death or
disability, and those who were unable to work had to
rely completely on the kindness of family members
or the benevolence of local politicians and charities.
As Roosevelt noted in a 1938 radio address, “Men and
women too old and infirm to work either depended on
those who had but little to share, or spent their remaining years within the walls of a poorhouse … The Social
Security Act offers to all our citizens a workable and
working method of meeting urgent present needs and
of forestalling future need.” (An often overlooked fact
is that unemployment insurance was also a key element of the Social Security Act.)
The other popular safety net program is Medicare,
which covers many of the health-care costs for people
who are 65 or older. In fact, Medicare is so popular that
some people can’t bring themselves to believe that it’s
a government program. “Keep your government hands
off my Medicare!” was a rallying cry often heard during
the debate over health-care reform in 2009-2010. (You
couldn’t make this stuff up.)
20

Preserving
the Common Wealth

Glacier National Park Poster, Between 1936 and 1939

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: WPA Federal Arts Project, Library of Congress

Protecting National Treasures
In 2011, Ken Burns and PBS did a six-part series
called The National Parks: America’s Best Idea. We
could argue over whether or not the parks and our
national forests are America’s absolute-numberone-best-idea, but they would almost certainly
make everyone’s top-ten list.

21

It’s hard to stand in a national park or national forest without feeling a deep sense of gratitude: Gratitude
to The Almighty for creating such wonders, and to the
humans who cared enough to preserve them.
Concessionaires and entrepreneurs might have
been willing to develop some of our natural treasures
on a for-profit basis. But a Yellowstone Inc. would not
have belonged to all of us. And who knows what might
have happened if a private developer decided that
Yosemite or Glacier National Park could be put to a
more profitable use?

Wire Mills along the Monongahela River, Donora, PA, 1910
Image Credit: Library of Congress

22

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Working Toward a Cleaner Environment
Over the past half-century, state and federal agencies
have adopted standards for smokestack emissions,
sewage treatment, automobile emissions, hazardous
waste disposal and pesticide use. Meeting these standards costs money, and those costs are reflected in the
higher prices we pay for a broad range of things—
higher sticker prices on cars, bigger water bills, higher
utility rates, and more. But on balance, environmental
regulations have helped to improve the quality of the
air we breathe and the water we drink.
The environment isn’t yet as clean as it could be,
but it is a lot better than it was—and far better than it
is in places around the globe where regulation is minimal and enforcement is nonexistent.

Public Health + Safety

Philadelphia Firefighters, 1850s

In the 1800s, police officers only had to be tough
and willing to work for low pay. Fire brigades were
staffed by volunteers or hired by insurance companies to protect policyholders. Neither arrangement
worked very well.

23

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: Library of Congress

Advertisement for Republic Fire Insurance, Co., mid-1800s
Image: Library of Congress

Trash-strewn yard, early 1900s
ImagE: Library of Congress

24

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Picture this …
A house in the middle of a densely-settled city block
catches fire. The fire brigade, hired and paid by a fire
insurance company, pulls up to the burning house and
checks for a medallion that indicates whether or not
the owners have insurance coverage. Unfortunately,
the house isn’t covered, so the private fire brigade lets it
burn. Worse still, the fire jumps to houses on the same
block—some of which are covered by insurance—but
the firefighters don’t have the resources to battle the
multiple blazes.
That happened all too often in the days before
municipal fire departments.
Today, government provides police and fire services by using tax dollars to pay trained professionals
and purchase the necessary equipment. These services
are expensive, but when the worst happens, they prove
their worth.
And while we are on the subject of essential services, let’s not overlook the value of municipal trash
management. Anyone who has ever been to a country
where it is a low priority can attest to the impact efficient trash management has on public health and the
overall quality of life.

Equal Access:
More Seats
at the Table

Blatant Ethnic Prejudice Used in Advertising, 1886

Not so long ago, a commentator on one of the
Sunday morning news shows suggested there ought
to be “a museum of the 1950s,” and it should be a lot
like his old neighborhood in a Maryland suburb of
Washington, D.C. It was a sweet story delivered by
someone who obviously had a wonderful childhood
in a lovely neighborhood.
Sounds harmless enough, but let’s think this one
through before we get too nostalgic for old Chevys,
sock hops, and drive-ins.
25

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: Library of Congress

The Pittsburgh Crawfords, Negro National League Champions, 1935
Image: National Baseball Hall of Fame Library

The “good old days” weren’t that good for everyone. Black Americans were denied the full rights of
citizenship. Ethnic prejudice and anti-Semitism were
common and widely accepted. Women routinely experienced discrimination at work and in the courts. Gay
and lesbian Americans were subject to arrest. Persons
with disabilities had to depend on the whims of others.
True, we are still a long way from utopia, but
as a society we’ve made significant progress toward
addressing injustice and inequality. Much of that progress has come as a result of government action:
1948: President Harry Truman issues Executive Order
9981 to end segregation in the armed forces.
1954: A U.S. Supreme Court decision in Brown v. Board
of Education declares segregation in public schools
unconstitutional.

Segregated Bus Station, Durham, NC, 1940
Image: Library of Congress

1956: U.S. Supreme Court upholds a lower court ruling that segregation on public buses in Montgomery,
Alabama is unconstitutional.
1964: The Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires equal access
to public places, facilities, and accommodations, and
outlaws discrimination in employment.
1964/1965: Legislation ends immigration quotas based
on race, national origin, and ancestry.
26

1965: The Voting Rights Act of 1965 outlaws discriminatory practices that prevented citizens from exercising
their constitutional right to vote.
1972: Title IX, Education Amendments of 1972 provides
that “No person in the United States shall, on the basis
of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the
benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any
education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.”
1990: The Americans with Disabilities Act prohibits discrimination against qualified individuals with
disabilities.
2003/2004: A ruling by the Massachusetts Supreme
Judicial Court clears the way for Massachusetts to
become the first state to allow same-sex marriage.
2010/2011: President Barack Obama signs the Don’t Ask
Don’t Tell Repeal Act which leads to ending the ban on
openly gay people serving in the U.S. armed forces.

Wheelchair Racers, Boston Marathon
Image: Wikimedia Commons

Celebrating the 40th Anniversary of the 1969 Stonewall Riots

Background image: iStockphoto.com

Image: Wikimedia Commons

27

“WHEN THE PEOPLE
LEAD, THE LEADERS
WILL FOLLOW.”

So, there you have it: Some—but certainly not
all—of the ways in which government can have a
positive impact on citizens’ lives.
But government doesn’t necessarily come up
with the energy and ideas that lead to those positive
impacts. That’s where citizens come in.
Often, those positive impacts begin with an individual—or group of individuals—whose energy,
eloquence, and persistence capture the imagination
of the public and the attention of elected officials.
A few examples …
28

Yosemite Falls, Yosemite National Park, California
Image: Library of Congress

John Muir loved the Yosemite Valley as much as any
human being has ever loved a place. In his quest to protect it and preserve it as a national park, Muir invited
President Theodore Roosevelt on a three-day camping
trip to Yosemite. During those three days, Yosemite,
with Muir’s help, worked its magic on TR, who ultimately supported the inclusion of Yosemite Valley in
the Yosemite National Park.

Theodore Roosevelt and John Muir, Yosemite Valley, 1903
Image: Library of Congress

29

Chicago Meatpacking Plant, 1906
Image: Library of Congress

The Jungle, First Edition, 1906
Image: Wikimedia Commons

Upton Sinclair’s novel, The Jungle, spurred President
Theodore Roosevelt to throw his full support behind
passage of the Pure Food and Drug Act (1906). More
than a century later, the novel’s description of conditions in Chicago’s meatpacking plants still has the
power to jolt readers.

30

March on Washington, 1963
Image Credit: National Archives

Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. was the face of the historic
1963 civil rights March on Washington, but one of
its principal organizers was A. Phillip Randolph. And
in 1947, a year before President Harry Truman ended
segregation in the U.S. armed forces, Mr. Randolph
organized the “Committee Against Jim Crow in
Military Service and Training.”

A. Philip Randolph

Image Credit: Library of Congress

31

Rachel Carson

Image: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

The first Earth Day—April 22, 1970—drew huge, exuberant crowds and was a big success, thanks in large
part to the efforts of Senator Gaylord Nelson, who had
called for a nationwide environmental teach-in. But a
case could be made that Earth Day and the creation of
the Environmental Protection Agency (1970) both had
their roots in 1962 with the publication of Silent Spring
by Rachel Carson. Ms. Carson’s book drew public attention to the misuse and long-term hazards of synthetic
pesticides such as DDT; another instance in which
the energy, eloquence, and persistence of one person
captured the public’s imagination and prompted government to act in the public interest.

Earth Day, Flyer for 25th Anniversary Celebration

Image: Nelson Collection, Nelson Institute for Environmental Studies & Wisconsin Historical Society

32