View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation

Division of Supervision

550 17th Street NW, Washington, DC 20429

Capital Standards
November 7, 1997

Proposed Revisions to the Risk-Based Capital Treatment of Recourse and
Direct Credit Substitutes




The FDIC Board of Directors is seeking comment on the attached proposal to make consistent
the risk-based capital standards for two types of credit enhancements - "recourse"
arrangements and "direct credit substitutes." The proposal would also require different amounts
of capital for different risk positions in asset securitization transactions.
The proposed rule is being issued jointly by the Federal Reserve Board, the Office of the
Comptroller of the Currency and the Office of Thrift Supervision. The agencies will accept
comments on the proposal through February 3, 1998.
Banks provide credit enhancements to protect investors who purchase loans and securities from
incurring losses. Recourse arrangements arise when an institution retains all or part of the risk
of loss on an asset or pool of assets it has sold to another financial institution, a government
agency or some other party. A direct credit substitute is an arrangement, such as a standby
letter of credit or a guarantee, in which an institution assumes all or part of the risk of loss on an
asset or pool of assets owned by another party, even though the institution had not owned and
sold the asset.


Under the current risk-based capital standards, different amounts of capital can be required for
recourse arrangements and direct credit substitutes that expose an institution to equivalent risk
of loss. In addition, the standards do not recognize differences in risks associated with different
loss positions in asset securitizations. To eliminate these inconsistencies, the proposal would:

Extend the current risk-based capital treatment of recourse obligations to direct credit
substitutes. For both types of credit enhancements, this generally would mean that capital
must be held against the entire outstanding amount of assets that the enhancement
supports, except for qualifying enhancements in asset securitizations that would receive a
more favorable risk-based capital treatment.


Implement a multi-level approach to capital requirements for asset securitizations. For
positions in securitizations that are traded, the multi-level approach would base the riskbased capital treatment on credit ratings from nationally recognized rating agencies. For
positions in securitizations that are not traded, the proposal presents three alternative
approaches for determining the capital requirements. In general, these approaches would
use ratings from two rating agencies, benchmark guidelines developed by the banking
agencies for standard securitization structures based on information available from the
rating agencies, and statistical evaluations of historical loss data.

The proposal would require institutions to maintain higher amounts of capital against certain
direct credit substitutes, but would reduce the risk-based capital charge for positions in asset
securitizations with the highest credit quality. In addition, loss positions in securitizations that
meet the proposed criteria would receive a more favorable risk-based capital treatment than
would otherwise apply to recourse obligations and direct credit substitutes.
The attached Federal Register notice contains a detailed discussion of the proposed rule and a
series of specific questions for comment. For further information, please contact Robert F.
Storch, Chief of the Accounting Section in the FDIC's Division of Supervision, on (202) 8988906.

Nicholas J. Ketcha Jr.


Attachment: (Available on the FDIC's web site, Federal Register, Nov. 5,
1997, pp 59944-59976.


Distribution: FDIC-Supervised Banks (Commercial and Savings)


NOTE: Paper copies of FDIC financial institution letters may be obtained through the FDIC's
Public Information Center, 801 17th Street, N.W., Room 100, Washington, D.C. 20434 ((703)
562-2200 or 800-276-6003). Electronic versions are available on the FDIC web site