View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

VOLUME I I

CONFERENCE O F GOVERNORS O F THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS

FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD
Treasury Building
Washineton, D . C .

May 9 - 12, 1927

Walter S$. C o x

Sharthand Renorter
Washineton, D.C,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ATTER

R E C E S S .

The Conférence reconvened pursuant t o recess a t 3:30
o'clock ».m.

The Chairman, The Conference will «indly come t o order.
I have j u s t b e e n a s k e d b y Governor C r i s s i n g e r

matter that is not on the program.

t o bring u D a

O n yesterday the Federal

Reserve Board passed a resolution that I

will a s k Mr. Harri-

son t o read.

wir, Harrison. M r , wjller moved:

t I t is the opinion

of the Board that t h e issues i n the par clearance case o f
the State Bank o f Hugo, mynnesota, against t h e Federal Reserve B a n k o f winneapolis, a r e o f interest t o every Federal

Reserve Banks and that arrangements should therefore b e made
for presentation o f the System interests, and further that
for this vurpose: the Board recommend t h e emoloyment o f Mr.
Baker a 8 special counsel o n behalf o f the Reserve Banks, t h e
cost. o f his enployment t o b e prorated among t h e various Fed—

eral reserve banks."

The Chairman, The point i s this:

I n almost all cases

where special counsel h a s been retained i n connection w i t h

par collection litigation i n various cases the Federal Reserve
Board h a s first made inquiry o f the Conference o f Governors


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

259
as t o whether the particular case presented elements o f such
importance that i t should b e déalt with a s a System matter.

This i s simply following that precedent, a n d from what I have
learned o f the case from Governor Young a n d Mr. Baker,

my om

opinion i s that i t would b e a very good i d e a t o have System
counsel.

i r , Young c a n explain t h e character o f the case.

Governor Young, T h a t i s entirely agreeable t o me.
Governor Fancher.

W h a t a r e the points involved?

Governor Vellporn, W a s i t a member bank?
Governor Young, N o , a non-menber bank,

I n 1919 when we

started o u r universal p a r collection campaign w e put t h e e n

tire State o f Minnesota o n the par list,

O n April lst.

W e

wrote several letters t o this bank i n an effort t o get then
to agree t o remit a t par, w h i c h they refused t o do. T h e y

even went further than that and notified u s that they did not
want t o be o n the par list, When the items started t o come i n
we p r e s e n t e d t h e m a t t h e b a n k ' s c o u n t e r f o r payment

i n cash.

They were paid i n cash) n o argument about it, n o question
about it. T h a t r a n along f o r about t w o w eexs.

T h e n the

bank wrote u s a letter that t h e y h a d started t o renit f o r
those items a t par a n d i f we would send t h e m through t h e mail

they would renit for them at par. T h a t w e did for three, four

260
or five months, I

forget which, Then the banx, according t o

their testimony, said that they read about the Cattletspurg c a s e a n d the Brookins CABE, a n d they went t o s e e a rather

prominent attorney b y the name o f Syllivan, a n d he told them

to get off the par list, and t o notify our bank.

W e took

them off the par list. T h e y brought suit against u s for

nineteen thousand-odd dollars, forty-two hundred dollars loss
of exchange a n d fifteen hundred dollars punitive damages o r
exemplary damages. T h e case h a s been i n the courts e v e r since
1925, transferred f r o m one court t o another, o u r attorney
finally getting t h e case into Minneapolis, w h e r e h e wanted it,
Governor Fancher.
Governor Young,

I n what court there?
I n the District Court,

T h e Board has

been acquainted with all of the conditions surrounding the
case. W e invited legal assistance but n o one seemed t o consider

of sufficient importance to have anyone else in it, thinking
that Judge Ulemd could represent u s as well as anyone.

H e had

hoped that the Judge would take the case from the jury, but
he did not d o so, T h e y claim that when t h e bank sent t h i s

signed letter to us agreeing t o rqnit at par that it was under
coercion and that they were entitled t o recover for exchange
Charges, a n d they convinced the judge o f i t and they convinced


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

261
the Jury, a n d that i s where i t is.

W e plan o n avpealing t h e

case.
The Chairman.

W a s a verdict rendered against you?

Governor Young, O h , yes, against us.
The Chairman, F o r the whole sum?
Governor Young,

very
N o , T h e evidence they p u t u p was

poor, T h e y did not have a n y o f our letters.

A l l they h a d was

was a transit
the draft registry, a n d they assumedthat that
were non-cash
Letter. T h e y showed that m a n y o f these items
they wanted to.
items o n which t h e y could charge exchange i f

brought d o w
But the judge threw that out. T h e amount was

to$1334.99 o r something like that.
agains”
The Chairman, D i d they assess a n y punitive damages
you?

Governor Young,

n o ev~
N o , t h e y threw that out. T h e y h a d

damage done along those
idence t o show that there h a d been a n y

w e ceased i n
lines. I , s o far a s Minneapolis i s concerned
1920 o r '21 making collections o v e r t h e counter.
two o r t h r e e y e a r s b e f o r e t h e A t l a n t a d e c i s i o m

T h a t was
M y c h o f this

for many o f
will b e outlawed, b u t there i s still opportunity
these b a n s

upheld.
t o collect f r o m u s i f this decision j s

4s a n extremely important case, I

think,

I t

a n d has some bearing


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

263

onthis Atlenta situation. I do not know whether it is good
law or not. T h e attonusife tell m e it i s not;
Governor Fancher. D o e s Jydge Ubdnc want the Board'e
counsel i n o n it?

Governor Young. H e has made n o such request, A b o u t
him that w e
a year ago I. told sir. Wyatt about i t and told
would welcome Mr.

r anybody w h o wanted t o cooperate.
Bakero

cases.
Jydge Uldnc has been extremely successfulwith our
This i s the first case that h e has lost.
number o f c

uso
a s te there.

he c a n win this case. I

H e has won 6 great.

H e seems t o be convinced that

know w e will b e very glad t o have

Mr. Baker's assistance end I am heartily i n favor o f the pro.
posal o f the Boards

The Chairman,

I f there i s no further discussion, t h e

guestion i s o n Governor Young's suggestion that: he favors

the Board's recommendation for the employment o f Mr, Baker
- yn thig case and that the Board b e so advised. A

,l those

in favor o f t h e motion will signify i t py? saying ayes

(The motion, having been duly seconded, w a s unanimously

carried.)
The Chairman.

Now, I

have been advised b y Governor

about
-Griggsinger, a n d I think h e spoke t o Governor Fancher


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

263
be present
it, that the Federal Reserve Board would like t o
proposiat further discussions o f the non-cash axkietk hte
tion which w e were discussing before lunch»

Mr. Baker has requésted that h e sa sticoal to have a
copy o f t h e d i s c u s s i o n

i n which h e took p a r t yesterday m o r n -

e understood t h a t h e
s n o objection t o t h a t w
ing, I f t h e r e i

may have a copy.

Baker
(On motion, duly seconded, i t was agreed that ur.
should have a copy of the discussion, which motion was unanimously carried.)

The Cpaizman: Now the Board would yike to be present,
this Minneapolis
as I said, a t a n y further discussion o f

collection proposition, 2 f there i s n o objection.
Governor Young.

N o n e whatever,

will that Mr.
The Chairman, I f there i s n o objection I
Eddy notify t h e Board,

(Whereupon, a t 3:05 o'clock p.m, Governor Orissinger,
James and
Vice-Governor Platt, Mr. wigzller, sir, Hamlin, mr.
R o o m a n d the follonm
wir, Cunningham entered t h e Conference

ing proceedings were had):
Governor Grissinger.

T h e question pefore t h e Conference

the Federal Reserve Board
4s the discussion o f the ruling b y

264
on t h e optional c h a r g e o n n o n - c a s h c o l l e c t i o n i t e m s a n d

the siinneapolis method o f handling non-cash collection
4tems.

T h a t i s o n the program a n d i t was thought advisable

when that matter was taken u p and considered that the Board
be present. ,

Mie. F ancher, I

think your district raised the question

a well as Richmond, Cleveland
and put it on the program, s
and S a n F,ancisco,

W i l l y o u please o p e n u p the discussion?

Governor Fancher. I
morning a

presented t o the Confermce this

review o f the particular transaction that l e d t o

its being brought t o the at tention o f the Board, a n d a

summary o f the correspondence which was had with the Board
bearing o n the matter, S p o r t l y after maxing that presenta-

tion this morning I was called out of the meeting and 7 am
not i n a position t o summarise the discussion,

I brought out the inns that a n arrangement had been
/

sanctioned

o n t h e part o f the Board w i t h t h e Mynneapolig

Bank which was a t variance w i t h the Board's letter X-4677 ,
which meas q u i t e e x p l i c i t

a s t o t h e d b spification

t o be

applied t o items payable a t street addr eeses. Slaturally
we were somewhat embarrassed a t o u r bank w h e n this charge

‘was made o n these items paid a t the Midland National Bank

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

265
& Trust Company, b u t w e found that t h e permission g i v e n t o
the Minneapolis B a n k applied t o all items whether payable
at banks o r payable a t street addresses.

T h a t w a s a t va-

riance with the Board's letter and I found that the other
eleven banks h a d not b e e a d v i s e d o f the change i n the
arrangement.

Governor CGrissinger.

W a s i t changed b y the Board i n

letter?
Governor Fancher. Y e s .
Governor Crissinger.
Governor Fancher.

W i l l y o u just r e a d t h e Letter?

s h a l l I read f r o m your letter?

Governor Grissinger.
Governor Fancher, I

Yes.
will read the Board's letter

X¥-4677, dated Séptember 24, 1926, a n d addressed t o Gover~
nors o f all Federal Reserve Ban*s,
"FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD
WaSHI'NGTON
K- 46:77
September 34, 1926,

Dear Sir:
"In the considerations which have been given during
the past t w o years t o the question o f whether o r not t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

366
handling
Federal reserve banks should discontinue t h e

of so-called non—cash colleotion items, consider
t o t h e céntinuance

opposition h a s d e v e l o p e d

l e

o f t h e service

as at present; that is, without charge and without limitation as t o items payable a t street addresses.
"The provisions o f the Federal Reserve A c t authorize,
put d o not require t h e Federal reserve banks t o handle

non-cash items and the inauguration of the function was
Board,
not t h e result o f a n o r d e r b y t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e

but rather a t its suggestion.

I think with respect to that the Board found that at
was a direction o n the part of the Board. The banks were
directed b y letter f r o m the Board i n September, i9Li.:

The

letter then continues:

"Phe Board wishes t o suggest t o the Federal reserve

banks that eaoh bank exercisé 4ts own option as to the
collection o f non—cash items a t street addresses, b u t continue t h e collection o f non-cash items geEseotites a t banks. ®

Governor Crissinger,

Governor Fancher.

W h a t i s the qpher letter?

I n reply to a letter which I a d

dressed to the Board under date of March and, the Board
wrote to me on april 7, 1927, as follows:


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

¢ ‘"PEDERAL RESERVE BOsaD
Washington

April 7, 1927.
Dear Governor Fancher:
Receipt i s acknowledged o f your letter o f warch and,
with r e s p e c t

t o a collection c h a r g e o f o n e t e n t h o f o n e

per c e n t made b y the Midland National B a n k a n d Trust Company o f Minneapolis o n two items payable a t that bank which
had been forwarded f o r collection p y the Mellon National

Bank o f Pittsburgh direct t o the Federal Reserve Bank o f
Minneapolis.

T h i s matter h a s received t h e careful consid—

eration o f the Federal Reserve Board but apparently there

is ,othing that the Board can d o a t this time b y way o f
bringing about a

change i n the present procedure o f the Minne

apolis b a n k i n t h e m a t t e r

o f handling non-cash items payabie

at banks located i n iijnneapolis a n d Helena, unless i t c a n
be shown that t h e effeot o n t h e collection system a s & whole

4g detrimental.

e equested the Board's
T h e ijnneapolis b a n k Y

approval prier t o its adoption o f the change i n its procedure
and the prOp0sal m a d e b y the bank, a n d approved b y the Board,
clearly p e r m i t s t h e h a n d l i n g

o f items p a y a b l e a t banks

in

Minneapolis a n d Helena i n the manner i n which i t . s handled


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

268269
the two items referred t o i n your letter.
i n the procedure
tJn giving i t s approval t o the change

with the distinct
of the sijnneapolis bank, the Board did s o

it sh ould
understanding o n the part of the bank that if
i s having 4 detri-appear a t a n y time that t h e n e w procedure

system
mental effect upon the Federal Reserve collection
o f the
as a whole the Mynneapolis bank would a t the request
o f handling
Board discontinue same and revert t o the practice
Minneapolis a n d Helena items a s i t h a d been doing.

After

s i x months,
the changed procedure h a s been i n operation f o r

colthe Board wikl give consideration t o its effect o n the

lection system as a whole and at that time special considera
tion will ‘be given to the advisability of modifying the plan,
representaif it i s t o continue, s o as to provide for direct

tion by the Minneapolis bank itself of ali items received by
Helena,
it which are payable a t banks located i n iinneapolis o r
Crissinger
Very truly yours, {Signed) D.R.
Governor. "

Then further,

i n a letter under date o f way 5 , there

the
48 enclosed t o me copies o f letters exchanged between

o f t h e FederFederal Reserve Board a n d Mr. Mitchel, Chairman
which t h e
al Reserve Bank o f Mynneavolis, a n d a resolution

Board o f the swiinneapolis Bank adopted,

i n refer@mce t o the

t h e Fedhandling o f non-cash items, w h i c h was acceptable t o
eral, R e s e r v e Board,

Governor Orissinger. I

%

understand the complaint t o be

Board changed
that after the original letter of Dec ember the

it without notifying the other banke; i s that Lt?
the
Governor Fancher, Y e s . W e received a letter from
their
i
n
change
Minneapolis Bank along i n January, a s t o t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

270
procedure o n February 1, w e notified our direct sending

b Brger banks
,Our
member banks, amtall of our b a n k stu
prothat were sending direct t o Minneapolis, t o change the
a
cedure, t h a t o u r information w a s t o the effect that

charge

that
would b e made o n items payable a t street addressee a n d
beitems payable a t banks would b e received a n d handled a s

fore.

W

e assume that w e understool t h e situation, i n

the Federthe absence o f a n y advice different f r o m that i n
weré n o t
al Reserve Board's letter X-4677; b u t apvarently w e
fully informed.

Governor Young.

o that statement.
J I rather o b j e c t t

resolution
Minneapolis notified a l i t h e other banks what t h e

was, b y letter — - very short, v e r y concise, understood b y
sent
four Reserve banks and not understood b y eight. They
i n this
in many wires t o o u r bank a s t o what w e would d o
ease,

wire t o
i n that a n d t h e other oasé, 8 0 I prepared a

tellall t h e Reserve Banks covering a l l t h e inquiries made,
do, s o that
ing t h e m what w e would d o and what w e would not
Sleveland was o n notice pefore February 1 .

Governe Crissinger.

H o w does i t happen that your

before that?
bank changed the original order that was made
Governor Young,

i the ruling that t h e Board
Because,n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ath
made, there was n o possible chance o f Manneapolis eliminat~

ing the liability and working ‘it. out under the old method
and I suggested a

new method, w h i o h was approved b y the

Federal Reserve Board.

Governor Crissinger.

i y recollection i s that letter

says "street addresses".
Governor Young. N o .
létter w e reGovernor Wellborn. H e r e i s a copy o f t h e
ceived f r o m Governor Young:

we O P T
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK --

MINNEAPOLIS, MINN 920 Abb
Jen. &

1927

WELL BORN
ATLANTA GA
ily Letter o f January 17 i n refermece t o non cash collections

has prompted a number of inquiries. Inasmuch as the time
is short, I

a m venturing t o reply t o all communications

by

a
4

this method and advise as follows: ©.
1. Federal Reserve Bank of Mgnneapolis will continue
in the future a s i n the past t o accept a l l n o n cash items

for collection, reserving the right t o refuse t o handle any
non c a s h item payable a t a non p a r peint w h i c h m s t b e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

collected through a

non par dank »

Be W o n c a s h collections payable i n Minneapolis w i l l
be delivered t o winneapolis member banks f o r collection

and return t o us, This applies t o Helena also.
ser
3. ifinneapolis and Helena Banks charge for, this

wice one

o ten
d o l lthousand
a r a with a minimum c h a r g ef

cents,

b e de4. A n y charge made b y a collecting agent will
dycted b y us when proceeds o f items are credited.
t turn. all non cash items
5. I t is not our i n t e n t i o n o
ever t o menber b a n k s

sien.

i n Manneapolis

o r H e l e n a for. collec.

n Minneapolis o r Hel ena.
O n l y those which are p a y a b l e i

b e handItems payable ,utside o f Mignneapolis o r Helena will
ted a s i n the past.
receiv—
6, W e will n o t refuse + o handle non-cash items
ed from direct sending member banks,

S u c h items will b e ,

handled t h e seme a s i f sent t o u s b y another Federal reserve
bank.

yOuNG, *
That covers everything a n d there couldn't b e any mis—
understanding about it.

Governor Strong, B u t I do not think that answers the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

main question,

Governor Young,

I t answers that question satisfact-

orily,

Governor Strong. I

beg t o differ with you there, G o v

ernor Young. :
did not s a y the main question. I

Governor Young, I

say

4t a n s w e r s t h a t o n e question,

Governor Strong, A s to whether you gave notice of the
particular arrangement made i n slinneapolis?
Governor Young.

Y e s , sir.

Governor Strong, I
here,

do not think that has been disvuted

h a s it?

Governor Orissinger. T h e eritieism I understood you t o
make was that the Board did not d o it,
Governor Strong, T h e r e a r e really t w o questions involved
here.

O n e i

t i e question o f the e v i e u o f the proposition,

is
which has been discussed for the last four years, that
a charge;
of handling non-cash collection items free o r with

i a particular procedur¢ which has been adoptand the o t h e r s
notice
ed here i n creating a n exception. W h e t h e r adequate
Was sent o u t o r y o t i s not s o material anyway.
ant thing i s that o n e reserve

T h e import-

s undertaking a
b a n k i

method


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

274

nine o f the
of collection, with a charge, which a t least
t o the collec.
reserve banks think 4 s a very dangerous thing
tion system.

Instead o f having the matter reviewed b y the Board
this
and acted upon, i n behalf o f all the Reserve Banks,
particular method was sanctioned.
Sere ce te t e

absence,
I discussed this morning, i n Governor Fancher's
t o g o over i t
simply because h e a n d I have h a d opportunity

asked t o do so, Tetogether, a n d I do not want, unless JT am
position which i t
peat all I said this ‘morning, t h e general
b y reason o f this
gseens t o u s the whole matter i s left i n

t h e discussion
isolated exception a t wynneapolis. However,
will b e o n the record.
i s i n a posi.
Governor Seay, I n a s m i c h a s Governor Strong
place this morn—
tion t o summarize t h e discussion which took

h e be request
ing I suggest, i f there i s n o objection, that
o f getting i t brief
ed to do 80, T h a t i s about the best way
Board w h o a r e
ly before t h e members o f the Federal Reserve
now present,

H e m a y feel disinclined t q repeat what position

t h e views
he took this morning, b u t i t 5 0 well reoresents

I think h e could
of the mijoarity o f the Reserve Panks that
do n o better t h a n present t h a t

~ ~ t o the Board a t t h e pre-

sent time.
Governor Crissinger.

V e l l , w h y not, Governor Strong?

Governor Strong, I

think the subject should b e present-

ed i n its logical sequence.

T h e history o f the non cash

collection system is, briefly, this:

Following the adoption o f the par collection system,

the Heserve Banks were struggling with the subject o f noncash collections.

W e knew, a s did the Board, that i t was

@ puzzling a n d difficult s u b j e c t a n d n e e d e d study,

W e defer

red handling these items completely, w e handled none o f them


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

until,

i n 1917, t h e Board sent u s a sepitic direction t o

undertake the handling o f the collection o f items for the
menber banks,

I t was done, m i t h a service charge o f 1 5

gents a n item.
Leter, when the Reserve Banks had-their large earnings
and were endeavoring t o increase the membership o f State
banks, t h a t charge,

a s well a s a

service c h a r g e f o r t h e c a s h

items of a cent a n iten, was discontinued, N o w , ‘by 1924

these complaints had arisen, largely by the members of the
American Bankers! Association, a n d subsequently b y the B a r

ton Committee, a n d the whole subject was turned over t o a
committee o f the Governors.

T h e report was made i n 1924 |


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

B76
we handle
which recommended that we handle the items, that
all items, a a h Mont w e d o i t without charge.

nine
Now, that report, which represented the views o f
meeting
of the Reserve Banks, has been considered a t every
since then, a n d t

w i

year:
c
e it
a has peen recomnendéd.:.to the-

the Board, .
Board that that b e the action o f the System and
t o it, e s p e c i a l l y
But there has- undoubtedly b e e n opposition

in three o f the Reserve Banks. Now,.as°I: understand

our last.Fall.meeting, t h e
i t ,t,a

Reserve Banks t o o k u p for consideration a

Tuling which h a d

which was read
just been made b y the Federal Reserve Board,
itself about:
here, that each Reserve Bank might decide*for:
handling items o n street addresses, I

d o not understand

service. charge
that that dealt: with the question o f e i t h e r a
t o each re-.
or. an exchange charge, b u t left i t very: largely
the Confere-.
gexrve bank t o decide what. it’ shoul do, W h e n
ence reassenbled a

menorial o r recomnendation. was promptly

the dan ger o f
submitted t o the Reserve Board pointing out
as I an
the possible developments a n d the Board s o far
recomnenda—aware a t this time, has taken n o action g n that.
Mr..
tion. W e have never received any action ber te: haveewe.,
Harrison?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. Harrison.

W o , sir..

Gov. Strong:

/I think the particular objection as to the method of
dealing with the difference o f view,. arises i n this point;
That immediately following the Governors® Conference, a

menoriel being placed with the Board, urging need for uniformity, a
n arrangement was made with one individual bank which,
4n point o f fact, a n d which I believe, h a d all the aspects
of the

b the Board
action been c o n s i d e r e d y
o
r e s u fl that
t

in discussion w i t h t h e Governors,

i t i s quite unlikely that

the Board would have taken the action,

s

i

s gah

Let me point out, i f I may, some o f the things that o/-ecour..

L e t us suppose that the Mynneapolis Reserve Bank

went aheal with its partioular method o f dealing with the.
non-cash items. T h e n suppose Governor Bailey, having a n idea
t collect everything
that h e thought w a s better, u n d e r t o o k o
except street address items. T h e n l e t u s suppose t h a t i n New
York w e should undertake t o handle everything with a

15 cent

service charge instead o f one-tenth o f one per cent exchange
charge, Then suppose San Francisco should decide not to handle
any a t all o f these street items?

T h e ye would be such c o n

fusion i n the Federal Reserve System thet p t once the F e d
era] Reserve Board would h a v e t o resolve t h e point a n d decide


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

upon some uniformity.

As I

l o o tkait now, with the Federal Reserve Bank of

Minneapolis alone undertaxing to collect items by this method,
will
if i t continues t o d o so, t h e Federal Reserve Board
shortly b e o b l i g e d

to

subject
t o r u l e that. all t h e s e i t e m s a r e

consequence
acharge o f one-tenth o f o n e per cent, T h e

i
n the Reserve
to the Reserve Systen i s that o n e bank a l o n e

make the first
System, b y being given this opportunity t o
i going t o force the other
break i n the dike, 5 0 to s p e a k , s
eleven banks t o adopt its partiouler view,
at tention
And aside from that, I would like + o call the
p
of the Board t o one curious thing about t h i s

polis.

l

fa sinneao
n

do not d i s
I t meets Governor Young's situation, W e

h
a have been raised t o the
pute that, but the o b j e c t i o n s t
line o f the
par collection system have never been along the
that i s b y
partiquler plan n o w undertaken i n Mgnneapolis |

th ose within the Federal Reserve S y st em.

W e have discussed

address
here whether w e would o r would n o t handle street
items.

would o r would n o t
W e have discussed here whether w e

make a service charge for them,

B u t I never renember joining

door would b e
in any discussi o n of any plan b y whgch the
make these colgradually opened t o allow t h e menber banks t o
;§


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Bs
1b ctions f o r u s a n d t o make a
per c e n t f o r d o i n g s o .

charge o f one-tenth o f o n e

T h e discussion h a s largely c e n t e r

ed i n the phase a s t o whether i t was o r was not going t o
cost u s t e n t o fifteen million dollars t o perform t h e s e r

vice. T h i s doesn't remedy that, i t doesn't remove that
objection. I t always has had t o do with a very difficult problen i n Mynneapolis o f whether they should undertake the re~
sponsibility i n collecting items through banks that were o f

doubtful solvenoy. T h e question of oubtful solvency is only
solved a t the street addresses o f the two cities o f Mjnnea-

polis and Helena, A 4 1 1 the other collections made through—
out that district a t e made exactly a s they have been made
heretofore.

I do not want t o exaggerate the consequences o f this,
but I am very sure that i n a short time there will not b e
one c i t y i n this c o u n t r y , w h e r e t h e r e i s a

Federal R e s e r v e

bank o r branch, w h e r e t h e member banks wil] n o t insist upon
however
charging o n e tenth o f o n e per cent o n these items,
they i o n bol tketed, I

am afraid t h e consequences a r e going

to be very widespread and cause great dissatisfaction,
This particular method o f dealing with i t does not


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

280
should
solve our problem a t all, O y r problem was whether w e

c

e

a t all, or, if we did, whether we would get some

t o handle
of the expense back... T h i s c ontenplates continuing

all these items and t o pay a large revenue t o the menbex
banks. G o v e r n o r Norris says i t has cost eleven t o twelve

thousand dollars i n the last year, a n d i t would amount t o
$170,000 i n the city o f Philadelphia.

T f i t is $270,000 i n

the city
the city o f Philadelphia i t will b e $750,000 i n
of N e w York —- a n d t o the member banks;

w e d o not g e t 1%.

Governor Young, O f course that i s 4

s s

statement.

The facts are that the menber banks would not /$170,000.
where they
They wouli route i t t o get i t there i n some way
a hundred,
wouldn't pay a hundred and seventy thousand, o r
or fifty, o r even twenty-five thousand.
Governor Fancher.

H o w vould t h e y g e t then there — ~

colGovernor Young, O h , a n y bank i n Philadelphia c a n
—Lect o n New York, Pittsburgh, Chicago o r elsewhere
Govemor Fancher,

B u t c a n any bank i n Philedelphia c o l -

lect o n Minneavolis?

for
Governar Young, T h e y cannot, and there i s a reason

Governor Strong, That is the answer, and the unfortunate


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

aol

b y which
part o f the plan now i n operation i n wiinneapolis,
M y nneapolis
all t h e s e M i n n e a p o l i s i t e m s a r e c o l l e c t e d t h r o u g h

all
member banks, i a that they are going t o d o it free for
other
member banks i n that District and not member banks i n
districts.

world.
Governor Young, The most natural thing i n the
Governor Strong. Sure, i t i s naturel,
accounts
Governor Young, P h i l a d e l p h i a doesn't carry a n y

district car—
in Minneapolis, E v e r y member bank i n the ninth
to
ries accounts i n Minneapolis. T h e y don't send the items
us and haven't done i t for five years.

h y should they get

then free non?
Governor Strong. H o w about Dallas?
Governor Young. Dallas carries accounts i n Minneapolis
to get then handled free.

W e have had a large automobile

six
concern collecting items i n Mynneapolis for the last
have they
years through our bank, Since this has gone i n what

done? T h e y opened u p an account i n Minneapolis.
Vice-Governor Platt. That explains the Barton committee
attitude.

Governor Fancher, w r . Barton has gotten exactly what
he has contended for.

I n the non-cash collection items

282
handled under t h e o l d clearing house arrangement w h i c h was

inaugurated 20-odd years ago 4h Minneapolis and the charges
still prevail today.

Governor Young. T h e r e # 6 a bond dealer i n Minneapolis
t hat hasn't even got a pay-roll account with the Twin City

banks, and yet he did a hundred million dollars worth of
business last year, M a y b e t h e Federal Reserve System i s in-

_tended for that, but I do not think so.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Strong, I

do not think this plan will correct

that.

Governor Wellborn

I t looks t o me like w e are not going

to get anywhere i n discusding this.

I t has been going o n

for three or four years, It has been said that unsettled
questions h a v e n o p i t y f o r t h e r e p o s e o f nations, I

a n sure

this question h a s h a d n o pity o n u s for t h e last f e w years,

At the Conference this morning I suggested a compromise,
Usually things like this are compromised, T h a t compromise
y the Kansas City Bank, which was
was a resolution a d o p t e d b

submitted to me by Governor Bailey. T 4 didn't suit me exact~
ly. I want t o abolish non-cash collections —
off. H o w e v e r ,

just wipe them

i n his resolution there i e a very liberal pro-

vision t o take care o f the collection o f a good many o f such


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

233
items, a n d I think i t i s a very reasonable compromise,
Therefore I

a m i n favor o f that a s a compromise a n d I bejive

{t is the only way you will ever settle this question satisfactorily. G o v e r n o r Strong spoke o f not saving any money
through the Mynneapolis plan, That i s true, but i t satisfies

the Minneapolis Bank,
Governor Young, I
bit. .

will correct that statement a little

W e have saved o n i t because w e have relieved our~

selves from a tremendous Liability,
Governor Strong,

D o you mean a s to items payable a t

banks i n Minneapolis?
Governor Young,

A t street addresses,

Governor Strong, I an talking about items payable at
banks.

Governor Young, A n d I am talking about items payable
at street addresses,

Y o u say I haven't accomplished a n y

thing that I hoped t o acoomplish, b u t I have.
Governor Strong, T h e original p i a n contemplated b y the

Board, o f which we all had notice, had to do with street address items.
Governor Young.

Yes.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

384
Governor Strong, T h e result o f the arrangement w i t h
you gives t h e Myinneapolis banks a

charge o f one-tenth o f

one per cent o n all items payable a t street addresses o r
banks too?
Governor Young. T h a t i s true,
Governor Strong,

T h a t i s certainly a

surprise t o every

reserve bank, quite a surprise,
Governor Young, I
Governor Strong,

do not s e e why i t is,
I n the first place,

i t i s a n exception

from t h e Board's ruling, their o n l y ruling.
Governor Young, T h e Board made another ruling a n d I

wired your bank about it.
Governor Yellborn, I

had not quite finished, I

would

like t o say another word.

Governor Crissinger.

G o ahead | Governor Wellborn.

Governor Wellporn, Now, t h e letter which w a g sent o u t
by the Board i n September h a s b e e n discussed a n d the genticmen s a y i t has been changed. J

think there i s one thing i n

4t that n o one disputes, a n d that i s that the Federal Reserve Act authorizes b u t does n o t require Federal Reserve

‘banks t o do this.
Governor Seay; B u t t h e Board requigzes it.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

285
Governor Wellporn,

I t authorizes but does not require

the Federal Reserve Bank t o handle these items.
Governor Fancher,

B u t the Board b y direction, a n d you

have the letter i n your files, directing you to procced t o
collect these items.

Governor Wellborn, Tyat i s a matter o f courtesy.

W e

are just trying t o get together,
Governor Harding,

M a y I say a word o n this subject?

Governor Grissinger. Y e s , Governor Harding,
Governor Harding, Reference has been madeto the fact

that i n 1917, i n September, I think it was, the Federal Reserve Board directed the Federal Reserve banks t o put into
operation a non-cash collection system. T h a t i s correct,

That letter was inspired, primarily, because of ite bearing
on the par renittance o f checks, a n d this action today has
an equally direct bearing o n the par remittance o f checks.

The situation i
n September o f 1917 was this: Shortly
after the passage o f the Hardwics amendment, which was twist.

ed around s o that i t reversed exactly ies its proponents
wanted i t t o do, there w a s a little S e p liay against t h e par
remitting system o n the part o f various country banks, T h e y

complained they were obliged, under the amendment of June 21,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

286
1917, t o keep their entire reserve with t h e Federal reserve
bank; t h a t t h e y h a d their balances with their c i t y corres—
pondents; t h a t t h e y were constantly having iteme that t h e y
had t o send t o these various reserve banks cities, a n d they

wanted the privilege o f sending those items t o the Federal
Reserve bank a n d have then attended t o a n d not t o some other

bank where they had n o account probably and would b e charged
for it. T h e y s a i d those banks i n the cities g e t checks o n
us a n d t h e y p u t t h e m i n t h e F e d e r a l r e s e r v e b a n k a n d t h e y

are sent t o u s a n d w e have got t o renit f o r them a t par.

It seemed t o the Board, a s a matter o f forecast, that w e
had t o put i n this direction. I

assume m y part o f t h e re-

sponsibility f o r it.

It has gone along and the main question u p to date has
been t h e question o f little drafts, i t e m s o n street a d d r e s
Bes | and I do not think i t i s material whether t h e banks

collect those street address items o r not,
to a row o f p i n s i n Boston. I
other cities.

I t won't amount

d o not k n o w n o w i t i s i n

‘ h e r e a note o r a n acceptance i s payable a t

a bank i t seens t o m e that t h e Federal Reserve Bank ought.
t that, because i t i a compensated
to continue t o a t t e n d o
for a n d y o u d o not have t o g o there a n d present it.

a s a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

matter o f fact all you have t o do is t o present i t a t the
bank where payable, T h e r e i s where you get the check for
it. T h a t i s a different proposition f r m a n ordinary acceot-

ance draft o n a street address,
Just a s this question wassrelated t o the par collec-

tion of checks i n 1917, the reverge practice will have a n
equal bearing o n the par collecting system, because the
country banks will s a y here i s a n item o n Mynneapolis, w h y
should w e send i t there when t h e y make a n exception o f their
own Member banks, a n d i f all t h e other banks adopted some
plan such a s winneapolis h a s adopted t h e n w e h a v e aunivere

sal system of charging o n non-cash items. Then the coyntry
banks are going t o use that a s an argument, and justly 80,
as t o why they should b e penalizedby Having t o give u p ,

their exchange

o n their checks when they don't get all the

advantages i n the collection o f these other items.

S o TI

think there i s a good deal t o think about i n this,
I should think that a s the matter h a s been u p before

the Board s0 very long, that it i g important that the Board
ake some definite and final ruling o n the subject. I t was
suggested this morning that a committee b e appointed t o go
e

out t o Minneavolis t o study t h e situation f o r s i x months,

288
or something o f that sort, a n d report t o the next Conference,

either next October o r November, A n y damage that is going to
be done b y this thing will have been done i n the meantime.
I very much hope that t h e Board will give very vrompt
consideration t o this s u b j e c t w h i c h i s a very important o n e
at a great m a n y banks.
take a

I f i t cannot r e a c h a unanimous vote,

majority vote a n d settle this question, because y o u

are t h e only people w h o c a n d o it. T h e people sitting around

this table cannot decide it, but the Board under the Federal
Reserve Act has the power t o d o s0, I

know that you are vit—

ally interested i n the successful operation o f the system a n d
I want t o warn y o u that this i s a situation which needs a t t e n
tion a n d which needs a ruling o n e way o r the other, a s t o
uniformity.
Governor Young,

Y o u a

Seana

t h a t t h e section o f

the Act, under which we handle notes and bills, i s section 13,
which specifically authorizes u s t o handle these items and
nothing é¢lse, I

will b e glad t o compromise i f the Board will

issué & ruling t o the effect that w e shal] handle these notes
end bills and nothing else -—~


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Strong, A n d other i t e m s.
K
Governor Young, N o other items, S e c t i o n 1 5 authorizes

289
you t o handle matured notes a n d bills.

I t does not m e a n

i t does not m e a n a pending draft,

past d u e notes,

i t does

of
not mean a draft with a lot o f securities attached, bills
lading o r anything else.

I t means a matured note o r bill.

Governor Seay. D o e s i t mean matured bills o r just bilis?
Governor Young, M a t u r e d notes a n d pills,

Governor Seay, T h a t qualification does not neoessarily
apply t o the word "bills", but applies t o matured notes,
Governor Young.

L e t the Board rule definitely what

in line. That is
they do mean by it, and Mynneapolis will get
what i t means, matured notes and bills,
o me that the question o f these
I t occurs t

Mx. James.
eh

e

a

s

i t e m s a n d the handling o f them affects o n l y

twelve bank cities and 33 branch cities, W h e t I am trying
procedure a t the
to get through m y mind i s whether o r not t h e

Minneapolis Bank discriminates i n any way for or against the
banks i n Mynneapolis a s relate t o other member banks i n your

district?

I

n other words, y o u have a t the Federal Reserve

South Dakota,
Bans o f Minneapolis collection items O f Bismark,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Young,

O n Bismargk?

idr, James, Y e s , payable a t gome place i n Bismarck.
Governor Young,

ur. James.

Y e s ,

A s I understand it, your procedure i s to


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

290
handle i t i n Minneapolis just a s you would handle i t i f it
came t o y o u i n Bismarck;

i s t h a t right?

Governor Young, Y e s , sir. That is, i f the menber bank
would send us a non-cash item o n Bismarck, North Dakota, w e
t the member b a n k there i f there
would send i t t o B i s m a r c k o
is o n e ; i f there i s not a member bank w e would s e n d i t t o

the non-member bank provided i t i s o n the par list.

That

benk m a y charge o r m a y not charge.
Mr. James..

I t i s optional?

Governor Young, Y e s , sir. The chances are that i t won't
charge | because a

great m u m b e r

o f them a r e under t h e impres—

gion that t h e y have t o renit t o u s for non-cash items without
deduction f o r exchange.
Mr. James.

T h e last circulars t h e t I

have s e e n o n t h e

subject f r o m the banks state that this does n o t prevent y o u
from making a charge,

Governor Young, Y e s , that i s i n our circular.
Mr. James.

@ & member bank i n cities other than Federal

Reserve Bank a n d branch cities i s o n notice that a charge i s
legitimate a n d that there i s n o objection t o its making i t
if i t s o desires?
Governor Young,

T h a t i s right.

Mx. James. Consequently, a s I understand the procedure,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

291
the same basis,
you have placed t h e banks i n Winneapolis o n
a s though they

as f a r a s non cash collections a r e concerned,
were located i n the same city.

Governor Young.
Mr. James.

Yes.

a n d t o be specifio y o u have put t h e sinnea-

w i t h t h e St. P a u l
polis branches o n exactly t h e same plane
bank 8
?

Governor Young, Yes, a uniform pasis.
Governor F a n c h e r .

E x c e p t t h a t i n idg4nneapolis t h e y h a v e

@ clearing house rule and they d o not i n Bismarck.
iv. James.

H o w about St. Paul?

Governor Fancher.

T h e same thing i n St. Paul,
o also:
think there i s this d i f f e r m e

Governor Strong, I

The Federal Reserve B a n k o f dinneapolis 4 s located i n -iinnea-

arise,
polis, a n d naturally one of two things will

A s I un-

dis.
derstand it, the Federal Reserve Bank of idjnneapolis now
does i t
tributes a l l o f the items o n t h e banks i n zqnneapolis,
y

not?

Governor Young,

T

o six member banks.

do that
Governor Strong. N o w , supoose w e undertook t o
in NewYork?
wr. James. I

do not think t h e Board's ruling goes that


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Strong, W e l l , that i s what i t has done. Y o u
have g o t t o c h o o s e b e t w e e n o n e o f t w o courses.

Y o u have

either got t o distribute those itemsmfaiRL¥ among all the
member banks i n the city, a n d I think w e have 115 i n New
York City, o r y o u have got t o concentrate t h e m i n a few,
and i f w e concentrate t h e m i n a few those will charge e x -

ghange for collecting drafts o n all the others, a n d i f
you distribute i t among 112 banks i t i s a perfectly ridiculous situation, y o u have got t o admit, i f we should run 112
collection accounts i n the City o f New York, Something

goes against the grain with me to send a collection item
of ten thousand dollars or a hundred thousand dollars t o
the First National Bank, when your messenger c a n walk d o m
the street t o the bank and make a collection a t the bank,
and t h e n charge o n e tenth o f o n e per cent, 4

and, I

dollar a

thous.

do not think w e would ever b e able t o justify i t

with t h e public o r with t h e member banks o r the country banks,

Now the fact i s we happen t o occupy 3 5 cities i n the
United States with head offices andbranches, andwe ought t o
be able t o collect these items ourselves without facing a l l
these problens a n d handing o u t a

big revenue t o the member


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

2935

banks.

W e have always gotten along pretty well a t New York,

than
and I am sure they have a s large o r a larger volume
they have i n Mjnneapolis.
Mr. James. T h e trouble i s that t h e thing i a not o n l y go-

cities besides
ing to be in ifjnneapolis. T h e r e are other
New York, and as I see it they have Some rights too.
Governor Strong, Yes, I xnow, Mr. James, and I say that
size
after consideration o f the importance o f N e w York, t h e

of it, and all that, but I cannot believe that these difficulties o f this character are more peculiar t o those three
districts where the opposition i s encountered i n the reserve
banks than to other districts. I

do not see that the menber

banks are s o different from the member banks i n all the other

districts that these ¢~rce situations are peouliar t o these
three districts.

Mir. James. W o , I cannot agree with you, i f you will ver~
mit m e t o say so, because o f t h e physical relationship that
exists between Minneapolis a n d St. Paul,
fair t o m e t o the bank i n .inneapolis

I t does not s e e m

t o allow the St, Paul

banks t O have their items collected through the mioaneapolis
bank without charge a n d then t h e Minneapolis banks h a v e
their items o n St. P a u l subjected t o charge,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

394
the
Governor Strong. W h a t i s the difference between
of
situation i n winneapolis and St. Paul and i n the city
New York, where w e have the Borough o f Manhattan, t h e Borough
of Brooklyn, Staten Island, Jersey City, Hoboxen and the
Bronx, w h e r e this has a l l been worked out?
Governor Harding,

M r . J a m e s n o doubt remembers t h e

competition between t h e various cities i n 1914 for reserve
banks.

They
N o city declined t o b e a reserve b a n k city,

were a l l a n x i o u s f o r i t . I

d o not think a n y city e v e r de-

reclined t o b e a branch city o r objected t o raising i t s

serve from seven t o ten per cent t o be a branch city,

Then

t h e bank i n
wr, J a m e s spoke about Minneapolis operating with

these
Dismarck o r some other place, that t h e y charged
i s relat~
drafts while Minneapolis could not. T h e whole thing
cheeks. E v e r y Fed.
ed again t o the par colleotion system o f
checks i n imeral Reserve B a n k prefers remittance f o r those

mediately available funds.

T h e fact that usneseaeise i s the

tremendous
site o f a Federal Reserve B a n k gives t h e c i t y a

advantage i n getting accounts o f country banks,

I t certainly

o f these
gives t h e m a tremendous advantage i n getting accounts

o f exchange
country banks, which completely offsets a n y loss
they might have.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr, James. T h a t i s a valid argument.

Governor Harding, I

do not try to make any other kind,

related t o the par
wir. James, T h i s whole thing i s directly
Board
Y o u will remember originally t h e

collection system.

these drafts,
authorized a service charge o n checks and o n
i g n o more trouble
based o n the amount o f the item, T h e r e
thousand dollars t h a n
attached t o presenting a n item f o r t e n

one o f

there ie for /two and a half dollers. a

service charge is

o f oné p e r cent o f the
one thing, b u t t o charge one-tenth
4
amount o f t h e instrument i s not

service charge b u t a n

exchange charge,
ir. James. I

agree with that.

Governor Harding,

A n d thereby you get this whole propo-

thing,
sition of exchange worked right back into this
Mr. Miller.

sinneapolis
I s i t not a l s o a fact t h a t t h e

Bank and
Bank gets a seoondary service and the signneapolis
emaller reserve
the St. Paul Banks are i n effect working o n 4
than t h e o t h e r b a n k s ?

ide. James.

the
I s n ' t that offset b y the differace i n

reserve requirenent?
Governor Young,
Mr. Miller,

S t . Paul has the same requirement,

T e n per cent.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

296
Governor Young, T h e y have practically Advantage that
Minneapolis b a n k s have.

wr. Miller.

H o w do they get it?

Governor Young. They get currency within half a n hour;
they c a n g e t clearing within half a n nour, They c a n beat

our Mail schedule > by‘. half an hour.
Mr. Willer.

B y t how actually physically d o they g e t

Governor Young, M o t o r trucks, armored cars,
ir, silgller.

D o the slinneapolis banks a l s o have a r m o r

ed cars t o get their supply from the Reserve bank?
Governor Young,

N o ,

Mir. Mller. S o that it does put them under a certain
advantage.

e@cross
Governor Young, The two largest banks are just
the street, a n d just around the corner.
vir, gller. Exactly, a n d the winneapolis Reserve
Bank » practically speaking,
annex,

i s their bank.

I % i s their

T h e y use i t and they probably dominate it. I

suppose the plain fact i s they want revenue.
Governor Young, There isn't any argument o r question
about that.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Vice-Governor Platt, T h e y want balances,

Governor Young, They want balances o r they want revenue,
one o r the other, o r both.
Mr. Miller, T h e y want both.
Governor Young,

W o , b e c a u s e i f they have the balances

they d o not take t h e revenue,

wir. Maller. A n d in order to placate them we are going
to nibble into, and probably disintegrate, the non-cash colleotion system which has been i n vogue, which i s well establish
ed and which i s useful.

I t strikes m e that t h e Federal Re-

gerve System in this matter, i f you gentlemen around the
table eannot compromise i t among yourselves, i s very incapable.

A i m e e Strong, I
not compromise this.

would like t o answer that.

W e did

W e did not settle it, T h e Federal Re-

serve Board settled it by a private arrangement with this
bank, without advance notice t o us,

Mr. Miller,

A s I remenber, there were three banks voting

in the negattive.

Governor Strong.
Mr. Miller.

Yes.

I f the Governors had been unanimous o n j t —

Governor Strong,

I s the Board always unanimo\s?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ir. Miller.

No.

Mr. James. V e r y rarely.
Govemor Strong.

T h e fact i s that if, when this appli-

cation came i n from Minneapolis, t h e Board had said "We are
going t o decide t h e principle o f this p a r collection system

for the reserve banks, for all the banks} this thing never
would h a v e arisen.

Governor Grissinger,

I n the use o f the Reserve bank

don't the Minneapolis benks have a n easier use o f your bank
than the St. Paul banks?
Governor Young.

B y thirty minutes, I

should say.

Governor Crissinger. T h e y have t o maintain motor cars?
Mr. Miller, T h e y c a n get i n after half past two, a n d
the St. Paul banks cannot.
Governor Grissinger.

A s a matter o f fact your banks

have a n advantage o v e r the St. P a u l banks,

d o they not?

Governor Young, Y e s , sir.
Governor Norris. W i t h o u t going into the details o f the
advantages a n d disadvantages a s between Minneapolis, S t .

Paul, o r any other cities, I

venture t o say that every one

the
of u s constantly hears t h e remark f r o m member banks that
the city
Reserve b a n k i s a splendid thing f o r t h e banks i n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

299°
where i t i s located B u t & great many o f them are constantly

saying that i t i s of very little use t o a bank i > locate &. outside o f the reserve city.

Governor Strotig, There i s one sitvation that has not

been brought out. I

do not know that i t is clear to anybody

‘in the room, and that i s that this arrangement with Minneapolis

necessitates sending all items p a y a b l e t
a the Northwestern
National Bank t o the First National Bank, a n d sending ell:

items payable at the First National Bank to the Nor thwestern National Bank i n order that t h e y m a y chatge exchange t o
each other,

Governor Young, N o , sir,
Governor Strong, I s there any exchange charged o n those
items which g o direct t o the bank where payable?

Governor Youngs Y e s , sir.

Governor Strong, They are still charged?
Governor Young, Y e s , sir.
Governor Strong, Right a t the bank where the item i s

payable?
Govern o r Young, Y e s .
Governor Strong. I

em glad t o know that.

Governe F a n c h e r . T h i s would not b e a controverted


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

300
point i f there were not clearing house arrangements with
ertain o f these cities, a n d that i s all there i s to it.
You have a n old arrangement i n St. Paul and mnneapolis
that h a s been i n effect f o r more than twenty years a n d t h e
rates have not b e e n modified a t ell. T h o s e rates were built

up for exohange charges o n the basis that a t certain times
ef t h e y e a r i t c o s t s m o r e t o m a k e exchange, c u r r e n c y w a s

pershipped back and forth, a n d o n that basis today you are
mitting t h e member banks o f Minneapolis

t o make a charge.

There ien't a n y justifioation i n the world today f o r charging

the Midland National Bank $17 o n an item or note of its customerpayable a t that bank, a n d y o u cannot justify t h e charge

today, I t is oniy made because there is an iron-colad clear~
ing house rule that h a s stood for more than twenty years,
be
If you did not have that arrangement t h i s thing wouldn't

bothering you a t all,
Mrs Barton has gotten just exactly what h e started out

to get, This has been a complete laydow o n our:partas i t
stands today, There isn't any other explanation o f it. W h a t
Barton went o u t t o get h e has gotten,
Governor Seay, T h i s matter h a s s o many ramifications

that i t is not easy t o follow. Governor Harding has @ l i e d

301,
par oollection
attention t o the fact that i t involves t h e

not vaying interest o n
system; i t involves the subject o f
the Federal
reserve deposita, a n d te /involved menbership i n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

reserve systen.

moved to
Governor Harding stated that the Board was
handle items bemake this ruling requiring reserve banks t o

had
o the country banks that they
cause of the complaints’ f
had n o means o f
abandoned o r reducedtheir correspondents a n d
collecting these things.

I t has been argued i n defense o f

members o f the
not paying interest o n reserve deposits thet
t o maintain
Federal Reserve System were n o longer required

city correspondents because the Reserve banks could handj}e
been argued that
these items for them, Furthermore, i t has
compensathe reserves set free b y that were i n leTge measure
deposits.
tion f o r the lack o f interest o n reserve
bank that wanted
Now i t has been brought o u t here that o n e
been compelled
to oollect these items over i n Mgmneapolis h a d

to place a n account there.

W e are going back t o just where

important State bank
we atarted, Recently w e had quite a n
j o i n t h e Sysand trust company i n Cperleston, W e s t Virginia,
tem.

s o m o f these items
V e r y soon thereafter t h e y handled

charge, a § I remenber it,
on Minneapolis and they had t o pay a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

308
of t w e n t y d o l l a r s a n d t e n dollars.

T h e y wrote i n and asked

benks had t o pay &
to know i f it was possible that member
addresees but a t bank
charge o n notes payable not a t street
ing institutions

i n those places,

T h a t b a n k i s managed b y

that I have e v e r come i n
geome o f the most intelligent people

banks, a n d they
contact with, either member o r non-menber

were emazed that that state of affairs could exist»
Federal Reserve SysNow, i t involves membership i n the
banks can
tem, a s I have stated, because i f theme country
maintaining city corresmaintain all of these advantages b y

aetion to plf&oe
péndents, and if they are driven by this
t h e n i t has a
again bank accounts with city correspondents,

future menbership i n
decided influence upon the question o f
the Federal Reserve System,
Governor Strong,

have g o t
T o collect o n Minneapolis y o u

to have a n account there.

the Federal
Governor Young, I s there 4 menber bank i n
Reserve System that has not a

correspondent account?

T h e

about it,
answer i s n o and there i s n o use thinking
I
Governor Seay, I f you s a y t o the same degree
it no,

Governor Young.

T h a t i s right,

can answer


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

303
Governor Seay, I

can answer n o t o the question i n

a s it formerly
another way. H a s i t as many correspondents
amount which the
say no. Therefore I say that the
had? I
its correspondent
member ban’ i s compelled t o keep with
business taken c a r e o f has
for t h e vurpose o f having their
been tremendously reduced.
Governor Young. I
a minute.

think I

can answer that inquiry jin

being v e r y
Y o u spoke o f the v a n i n Charleston

t o ,@y a n exchange charge a t
much surprised besause i t had

Paul?? W o u l d they
Minneapolis, That would they do in St.
be surprised a t St. Paul?
a reserve city, that
Governor Seay, Minneapolis being
was t h e nature o f their surprise.

ifr. M y ller.

rrould i t d o
L e t m e make a suggestion. H o w

and reduce the required
for the Boare t o reclassify St, Paul
reserve t o seven per cent?
want that.
Governor Strong, O h , they would all

per cent basis
Governor Young, P u t St. Paul o n 6 seven
and Minneapolis

o n a

ten p e r c e n t pasis,

o n account

o f this

coliection business?
Mr. Miller, Exactly.
made that I resent
Governor Young, There was one remark

304,
just a bit, a n d that i s that Barton accomplished what h e

wanted t o arid that I laid dorm t o hin.

T h e only time I ever

lay down t o anybody i s when t h e y xnock m e down.

Governor Bailey.

W e look a t the thing froma little

different angle than you do,

W e have elways contended that

the Federal reserve bank h a d n o business t o have i t s messeng-

ere out o n the street collecting street address items.
When w e received that letter f r o m t h e Board o n the 27th

of last September,.we waited until I came u p here t o talk i t
over with Mr, Young and Mr. Wellborn, b u t w e did not come t o
any agreement, a n d we agreed t o go home and talk with our
boards o f directors and try t o come t o some agreement.
We have always felt that t o put t h e Federal reserve bank
out o n the street collecting items was n o t t h e purpose o f the
Federal Reserve Aot; t h a t i t wags a n institution which d i d busi-

ness with the banks rather than with the individual, s o we
drafted this a n d w e sent i t here a n d exvected t o shoot, I

thought w e had the authority, under that September business,
but before I could get the ramrod jamned down we got word t o
lay off. T h i s i s the way i t reads;


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mifective January 1, 1927, t h e Federal Reserve B a n k

of Kansag City will limit the operation o f its non-cash


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

305
collection department t o the handling o f items drawn o n

or payable a t banks™ » and will discontinue the handling
of items payable a t street addresses which necessitate

either presentation o r notification, T h e following condi-

tions, effective January 1, 1927, should therefore be oarefully observed:
Section I . G E N E R A L PROVISIONS.

Character of Items Which May be Forwarded as Collections.
Member banks may forward t o the Federal Reserve Bank
of Kansas City for collection anderedit, checks o r drafts
dravm o n or payable a t banks; oertificates o f deposit;

coupons and bonds payable a t banks; notes and acceptances
payable at banks; orders o n pavings banks. checks previously
protested; a n d other similar items drawn o n o r payable a t
banks.

W e will also handle f o r colleotion, couponsmdetached

from bonds held i n safekeeping b y Federal Reserve Banks for
their member banks, a n d sight o r demand bill o f lading drafte
discounted

b y F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k s f o r t h e i r members.
<r,

a

m

e

,

(Footnote) *Wherever the word ‘banks! i s used in this
jetter, t h e word shall b e held t o mean incorporated b a n k s

o r trust c o m p a n i e s ,

o r

regularly organized commercial banking i n stitutions receiving deposits subject t o check,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Items “hich Will N o t Hereafter b e Handled:
C i t y w i l l n o t hereThe F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k o f Kansas

notes; time, s i g h t
after handle f o r collection, promissory

school
and demand drafts; creamery checks; city, county,
similar nature;
district andstate warrants; o r items o f a
except

d r a w n o n o r payi n cases w h e r e a n y s u c h i t e m a r e

able a t banks.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

If w e get that w e will b e perfectly satisfied.
Now, speaking about equipment,

w e have armqed equipment
W e

at Kansas City, w e have o n e a t each o n e o f our branches.

don't know whether they are any

o $200,000. I
were r o b b e d f

tore virtuous i n Minneapolis t h a n w e are, b u t w o got a

of the money back,

part

W e got i t in Denver.

Governor Young. T h a t was a non-cash collection that
we were Quite willing t o collect gratuitously,
Governor Bailey, T h i s i s as far a s Kansas City feels
do not believe i t would disturb the

that i t wants t o go. I

colle ction system i f we were t o keep off the street and let
us clear the rest o f it.
Vice Governor P l a t t . I

would l i k e t o h e a r w h a t Goveryjor

Fancher has t o say about that, W h y wouldn't that work all
right?
Governor Fancher.

W e have gone o n here, Governor Platt,

since 1917, a n d obtained nothing f r o m the large volume o f

business.

D o you want now t o be i n a position o f declining

to handje all items upon street addresses? T h a t will leave
a very small volume cof items payable a t banks»
Vice-Governor Platt.

W o u l d n ' t t h e result b e that most

of them would b e drawn payable a t banks?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Fancher.

T h e y could not bes

Governor Young, I

think all of them would be,

a l l o f them
Vice Governor Platt. G o v e r n o r Y o u n g says
grain drafts.
Governor Fancher. I

d o not agree w i t h that.

Vice Governor Platt.

B u t i f they would d o it?

Governor Bailey, I

know that out i n the ididdle West

collection.
the b i g banks a r e opposed t o this non-par

They

Association, t h e y
have h a d i t u o with the American Bankers!
have h a d i t u p i n their State conventions,

I

n attending a

surrounded b y
State convention o n the Pacifié Coast I was
h o w I stood o n the
a number o f bankers a n d they asked m e
thing a n d I told them flatly. I

do not think t h e Federal

out, but I found
Reserve Bank o f San Francisco has found that
44 out when I got o u t there,
Governor Galkins.

I n answer t o that suggestion I will

San Fyancisco k n e w i t
say that t h e Federal Reserve B a n k o f
before y o u went o u t there,
Governor Bailey, Y

o u were not trying t o follow out

this was 60; that i s alt.
the dictates o f your constituents, i f
Governor Orissinger.
formity i n the System?

M h a t d o you say about having uni+


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governoy Bailey,

M a k e i t all this way.

Governor Grisginger. A l l your way, you mean?
_Governor Bailey, . Yes. —
rates
Governor Fancher, W h a t are the clearing house

“i Kaneas City for clearing items?

a e

-:
Governor Bailey, O h , this won't change them.

Governor Fancher. H a v e you a clearing house arrangement
which charges. for non-cash items?

Governor Bailey, Yes, I think w have.
Governor Seay, Has Atlanta? ,
Governor Bailey, I

don't know, b u t this doesn't con-

of i s this
template changing that, W h a t w e want t o get rid
a bank a e = a
busimess o f someone wanting u s t o go down t o
sent collease a mortgage, a n d all that kind o f thing. T h e y
into twenty diflections from the Pacific Coast divided u p
fish, a n d
ferent drafts, a n d one bill o f lading o n canned

wehave to meite aedty letters. W e finally concluded we
from the
wouldn't d o that any more, and without any authority
Board w e just s e n d them baok.
Mr. Miller.

was a n
W h y was that b e c a u s e y o u thought i t

improper service?
Governor Bailey, Y e s , I

thought i t was a n imposition o n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr, Mjller.

B u t didn't y o u think i t was a disadvantage

tothe commerce of the country and to the customers of the
bank that were using your facilities?
Governor Bailey, I

think i t ought t o have m e e

to 8

commercial bank. T h e y would make a charge for it.. I do not
think they have any right t o send that kind o f thing i n t o
us and have us write: .

twenty-odd jetters., W e did under

take t o do that.once and we lost three thousand dollars o n

it, and iat Sux ea uk of sucking eggs."
hr M a Lier. D o you think your member banks should lose
$3,000 on it?
W e lost it,

Governor Bailey,

W e didn't take the right

kind o f receipt f r o m this fellow t o whom t h e fish were shipped.
Governor Fancher,

W h a t would haopen i n the case o f

a bank in Youngstown, Ohio, with a collection dram o n a
street address in Kansas City, sent to some bank selon Kant
4t t o the bank a t Kansas City —- what would happen?
‘Governor Bailey, They would charge him for it,
Governor Fancher,
Governor Seay.

T h e clearing house rate, certainly.

I t is significant that a t these three

places a t which this controversy arises there a r e clearing


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

310
Atlanta, Mjnneapolis
house arrangements charging éxchange — —
and <ansas City.
Governor Wellborn:

H o w about Birmingham, Nashville

and Jacksonville?
Governor Seay, I

do not ‘now. Y o u might carry i t fur-

w e are o n the subject.
ther, T h e r e i s o n e other thing while
h a s been raised t o Fed.
A large part o f the objection t h a t
has arisen
eral Reserve banks collecting street addresses

the character o f
from the fact that they would not receive
funds that t h e commercial banks have received.

T I think G o v

was the custom
erner Young stated that i n Minneapolis i t
but t o receive
to receive checks, not certified checks,
the payer o f the
checks for etain drafts and not require
draft t o have his oheck certified, A

very large part o f

arisen because o f
the dissatisfaction and comp lait has
practices
the loose practice, loose banking practice and

in this country,
which have prevailed in certain localities
reason o f competition,
There is. no winting at it. Banks, b y
thei customers
have engaged t o take from their oustomers,

funds which they
peing the public, almost any character of
o f getting a
tender a n d put themselves t o the trouble

check

forth, a n d many
certifieé o r converting i t into oash, a n d 6 0


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

311
practices which may justly b e regarded a s loose banking
practioes,which prevail i n certain localities because o f
competition. That i s the basis for a great deal of the ob.
jection which has arisen a n d f o r complaints against t h e
Federal Reserve S y s t e m and t h e Federal Reserve Banks f o r
exacting f u n d s w h i c h r e a s o n a b l e b a n k r e q u i r e m e n t s w o u l d e x a c t

under t h e same conditions.

Governor sicDougal.

I f the First National Bank o f Chi-

cago s e n d s a n i t e m o f this c h a r a c t e r

t o t h e First National

Bank of wijnneapolis, 1 8 that iten exposed to the same charge
as if you forwarded the same item?
Governor Young. I

Governor mM cDougal,

think so,

Y o u are sure o f that, n o matter

what the relations might be?
Governor Young.

I f Chicago h a d a balance i n -iinneapolis

they would handle i t gratuitously, -:..: Chicago has.not a
balanee, b u t sijnneapolis h a s o n e i n Chicago,
Governor .ioDougal, T h i s thing puts t h e banks i n the un—

fortunate position o f not being able t o get through Minnea_
polis the service that the imynneavolis banks oan still get
through the other thirty-~odd units o f the Federal Reserve
System. T h a t i s where the trouble comes in.

312
Governor Young.

No, I

d o not agree with that. M g n n e a -

polis oan get certain services i n New York and certain ser
vices i n Chicago a n d S a n F r a n c i s c o

o r a n y place where t h e y

happen t o have a n account.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor McDougal, T h a t i s indirectly,

T h e y d o get i t

through the Federal Reserve System but w e cannot?
Governor Young,

N o ,

Governor wicDougal, I t i s available t o them if they want

Governor Young, I t is slower, T h e y do not want it. T h e y
send i t out themselves a n d get i t quicker.

T h e y d o not u s e

it for the same reason that o u r member banks i n our o w n dis-

trict d o not use the collection system very much. T h e service is quicker through the correspondents,
Governor Strong. I

was wondering mhat t h e consequence

would b e i f in every city where there was a reserve bank or.
branch they discover t h e fact thet there i s 4 profit h e r e a n d

all
set u p a system o f clearing house charges and subject
of these non-cash collection items t o charges i n those cities.
I suppose t h e customers o f the i y nneapolis banks would begin

to cick like steers i f they had t o pay o n these items.
Governor Young, I

do not thipk so. T h e y have paid t h e m


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

for a

long while.

Governor Strong, I
be o n business generally,

ee h e

an wondering what the effect would
I n our bank i n the month o f april

exchanges

-

we collected i n non-cash items $162;4G2,00Qrat encharge of

|

$11,400 .-~ n
“about /

o r about sév/cents a thousand, I

am wondering i f

that whole amount w a s charged a t one-tenth o f one per cent
what w o u l d happen. I

d o not t h i n k t h e Federal Reserve S y s t e m

e purely f o r t h e benefit o f the banks, I
was o r g a n i z d

think

there is something beyond all of that»
Governor Norris, This practice i s for the benefit o f
a favorite f e w menber banks i n a particular reserve city, a n d

at the expense o f all other banks i n the country and their
customers, except those i n the Eleventh District.

O f course

t o the
conditions v a r y i n different parts o f the country a g
popularity o r u n p o p u l a r i t y o f this service,

O f course I

can

in
only speak a s t o our o w n district, T h e popularity o f i t
that t h e
our district i s pretty well evidenced b y the fact
every
number o f items w e handle i n @ollar amount h a s inereased

year from 1920, B e t w e e n 1921 and 1926 i t grew from 321,000
items t o 522,000 items,

W e were used f o r that service last

those
year b y 4 1 city banks and 429 country banks, a n d i t i s
i1country banks w h o would most strenuously object t o a n y ourta


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

314
ment o f the service,

W

e might a s well all recognize

one
and bear i n mind the fact, which w e xnow, that the
thing m o r e t h a n a n y t h i n g e l s e t h e t m i l i t a t e s a g a i n s t t h e

t h e joining o f
popudarisy o f the Federal Reserve c i t y a n d

additional members i s the fact that the member bank i s
obliged t o xeep i t s reserve without getting a n y interest

on it. N o w if i n addition t o requiring that o f them w e
are going t o subject then t o a charge that w e are now rend-

them
ering as a compensation for that, and still cépel
has
to keep balances with other banks -- Governor Young

the banks might
suggested that Philadelphia o r any other o f
avoid this charge by opening accounts i n idgnneavolis —~ and
be
4f this System continues i n wignneapolis i t has got t o
extended t o all the other Federal Reserve cities and branch
cities. MNeiher o u r banks n o r those o f N e w York o r s a n

Francisco o r anywhere else are going to stand by and see
the Federal Reserve B a n k o f Mynneapolis |« . t h r o v a trémensatis,
dous profit t o 4ts member banks i n its city a n d b e

the
fied that the banks i n their cities should not extend
maxing charges
same f a v o r t o them, T h e r e f o r e t h i s s y s t e m o f

will either beoome universal o g else the manber banks, i n
addition

t o Keeving their reserve without interest

a t the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

315
maintain balances
Federal Reserve bank, will b e required + o
all over t h e country t o make these collections.

Governor Young,

from,
I f a bank i n wanneapolis receives

say, @ bank i n Philadelphia, a

draft o f a thousand dollars

make a street present
with stock attached, a n d they have t o
check o r i n any
atién o f that, a n d collect i t b y certified

takes labor and they
way they want to, i t taxes time and i t
are entitled t o pay for that, I

won't s a y one-tenth o f one

something.
per cent, b u t t h e y a r e entitled t o

T h e r e cannot

be any argument about that.
Govemor Norris.

not
I f they receive i t direct, a n d

through you.
some p a y for
Governor Young. Y e s . T h e y a r e entitled t o
isn't a n y argument about
the wort that t h e y have done. T h e r e
that»
Governor Strong,

Y o u think not?

W e have quite a

large

a n d the menber banks i n
security business i n New Yor’ C i t y

o n all of those
New York City have abolished their charges
{tems a n d d o all o f that f o r nothing.
Governor Young.

Y e s , a n d they a

subsidiary corpora

t h e w a y from ten t o fifty
tions that a r e selling bonds a l l
dollars —


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

31,6
A l l seourities are delivered o n

Governor Strong.

collection i n New York without a n y charge.
Governor Young, T h e y a r e m a d e i n sldmneavolis w i t h o u t a n y

charge.
Governor Strong. I

Governor Young. §
more.

mean those that c o m e into N e w York.

wre, a n d you are going t o get a lot

J t is going t o grow and I make the prediction that

4t i s going t o cripple your bank some day»
wi. Hamlin, I

a m reminded o f the story o f the lady w h o

watched the regiment march b y i n which her son was, a n d said

that Johnnie was the only man i n step, that the otheré were
all out o f step. I

havehad a good many doubts, but I telieve

this i s one o f the cases where uniformity i s absolutely desir.

able and essential, a n d either w e should take Governor Young's
rule a s the wniform rule o r w e s h o u k a c c e p t t h e feeling o f
nine o u t o f the twelve banks.

have reached. +

T h a t i s the conclusion that I

seems t o me monstrous for a bank t o make

a charge f o r collecting f r o m itself e n d when t h e payer o f
the note has a n account a t t h e bank, I

believe i n lots o f

States the banks are allowed to pay that off and charge it
to t h e account.

Governor Strong, Some have that’ andsome have not,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

317
Mr. Hamlin.

from
A t any rate i t seems, wholly apart
monstrous charge t o mes.

any legal question, a

Govermmor Young, I

wi 11 agree with you. I f you could

I would
discriminate i n the items from a practical standpoint

that
be willing t o do that. B , t you cannot discriminate and
46 all there i s t o it,

I t cannot b e done, e v e n b y the sug-

t
all due r e s p e c t o
gestion that Governor Bailey makes, w i t h

Governor Bailey. A

sharp, clever Man can beat ite

Governor Bailey,

W e never contenplated that this would

only presentechange a n y o f our collections a t banks, b u t

tion a t street items.

I t i8 a growing proposition.

I f

present i t four o r
there i s a mistake i n a bill w e have t o
five times.

regard t o
T h e statement h a s been made, w i t h

country banks, P e :

d

o not g e t paid o n their balances,

they a r e willing t o
you have taken a w a y their exchange, a n d

for them t o do
accept cash items. T h e y believe i t necessary

other items
business and it reduces the float, With these
get credit for them
you don't know whether you are going t o
I
that day, t h e next d a y o r next weed,

xnow the feeling

country i s that t h e y
of the banks o u t i n our section o f the
a n d t h e y say that every—
want t o get back s o they c a n charge,

is free —thing that goes t o the Federal Reserve Bank

318
Governor Seay.

H o w about the 440.odd country banks

which use Governor Norris' reserve bank for the collection
of these items?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Bailey, Well, those fellows down there are s o
Slow that they didn't catch it.
Governor Crissinger.

i r , Strater, d o you want t o en-

jighten u s o n this subject?
Mr. Strater. I

will b e glad t o give m y views o n it.

between
There does not appear t o be any distinction made
and c o Llection
colleotion items pe. yable out i n the country
tremen.
items payable i n a Federal “eserve City, There i s a
dous distinction. T h e y d o not have anything i n common,

T h e

from a reserve bank
country bank that gets colleotion items

them
has @ perfect right t o charge for them, T h e y handle

they got them
juet exactly as they would handle them if
direct f r o m a memoer bank i n the district.

T h e y have g o t

it
to take then, present them and renit for them, Therefore
is n o hardship o n the country bank.

I t does n o t mean anything

items f r o m the
to the country b a n k whether i t gets non-oeash

Federal
Federal “eserve Bank o r some other bank. « I n the
proposition
Reserve Bank cities i t t s an entirely different

because, a s Governor Young has undertaxen t o do in Mgjnneapolis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

319
he
if he turns over t o the menber b a n these collections
could d o
is doing something which the Federal Reserve bank
house.
just a s well a s not, probably through t h e clearing
but it
Now i t m a y b e that i s not pnossible i n Minneapolis,
is possible i n a great m a n y cities,

I t i s done i n New York,

Philadelphia, Pitteaburgh, St. Louis and doxens o f other
places.
I think t h e real important factor about this thing

I f you are going t o consider a note payable

4s this;

i t i s not
at a bank subject t o a n exchange oharge I think

checks.
much o f a step t o justify a n exchange charge o n
o n checks
If you are going t o justify a n exchange charge
are going t o
in a Federal reserve bank c i t y o f coyrse y o u

justify i t i n every city i n the country, I

think the check

thet accollection system i s right n o w i n great peril o n

count. I t is my opinion it is not at all lixely that that
just a s
Ajabama situation m a y have arisen o u t o f something
intangible a s this.

I t i s possible that other suits m a y

@ result o f this
be brought i n Governor Young's District a s

thing,

of
H e is now confronted with a suit f o r collection

exchange.
the

Then there i s / matter o f reserve,

I t will affect t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

330
reserves, because a member bank o r any bank that i s obliged
to oarry accounts i n 3 5 cities h a s got t o tie u p a tremend-

ous lat o f money i n addition t o its reserve i n the Federal
reserve bank.

N o w they c a n g e t that service through t h e

Federal reserve b a n k a n d they a r e not required t o keep a i l
of those accounts. T h a t t o a bank i n a n ordinary c i t y i s

something that i s going t o be a tremendous hardship t o
them,

T a k e the banks i n cities like Youngstown a n d Colum-

bus a n d various other cities i n our district.

T h e y a l l have

collections payable i n Minneapolis a n d i n other Federal Reserve banksoities.

I f they are going t o be required t o carry

ten, twenty o r fifty thousand dollars i n 35 different places
they a r e going t o pretty nearly exhaust Sneir resources;

or

if they have cot t o pay very heavy exchange charges i t i s
going t o run w i e ®

lot o f money.

Governor Young, w r . Strater, y o u send items out t o
the small country banks i n your district, a n d they have every

right t o charge exchange.
Drainage &

I t may be a note o n the Great Lakes

Dock Company f o r $17, 000, payable a t their o w n

bank, The customary charge of one tenth of one per cent is

$17, W h e n you meke a charge of that kind M A that kind of
an operation d o y o u ever complain t o the Federal Reserve

32k
Board about i t ?

I s the charge p a i d o r isn't i t ?

I s one-

tenth o f one per cent a fair charge for that bank t o make?
wr, Strater, N o , I wouldn't say that i t was,
Governor Young.

D i d you complain t o the Federal Reserve

Board?
Mr. Strater. I

do not Quite get your point.

Governor Young, Y o u are conplaining about Minneapolis
maxing a

charge o f this kind.

W h y don't y o u clean u p your

own district first?
wr, Strater. T h e average cost i n our district i s six
cents a thousand,

Governor Young, I don't care about the average cost. I
am interested i n the maximum cost, which i s one-tenth o f one

per cent, which some o f them charge.
Governor Strater. S o m e o f them may charge that, non-~membe:
bank 8

Governor Young, B u t d o you complain about that?
Mr. Strater, There i s no occasion t o complain t o the F e d
eral Reserve Board about the action o f a non-member bank.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Young, T h e n w h y bother Minneapolis?

wir, Strater. You are dealing with member banks.
Governor Young.

A n d you are dealing with member banks-~


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

32
Governor Bailey. Suppose i t comes t o .ijnneapolis and
Minneanolis sends i t t o Bismarcs, i f Bismarck charges—~
SeCee

4

Governor Young.

B i s m a r c h d o e s charge;

s o y o u can taxe

Bismarok.

Governor Bailey.

T h e y don't o n all items.

Governor Strong.

I f we are going t o be forced t o make

a charge i n New Yor’ to collect these items, w e are going to
collect t h e m and get t h e charge,

Governor Young. T h e r e i s one point I wanted t o take u p
with «wr. Streter,

There is a

having some more losses.

possibility

o f winneapolis

T h i s non-cash collection i s one

of the evils o f the System,

W e are going t o have more law

suits, but they are not, going t o come from Atlanta o n noneash collections b u t they a r e going t o come f r o m some drug

store d o m a t Cattletsburg o r some such place as that. T h a t
is where i t i s coming from,
Mr, Miller.

W h a t would b e your position before a

commit,

tee of Congress i f you had ‘to justity the imposing of an ex.
change charge o n items payable a t banks i n Minneanolis?
Governor Young. - T h a t would be m y position before Congress?

wir. wiiller. . T h e y haven't abandoned the system which was

pursued u p t o last January, w a s i t not?
Governor Young, J u s t the same a s i t was two o r three
years ago, I

have s k t habe the liability o n the part o f

our bank and we want t o avoid i t and get rid o f it.
ir, Myller,

B u t wherein i s the serious Liability?

Governor Young,

I n collecting checks with securities

attached, bills o f ladi n g attached.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

mx, miller.

A t banks?

Governor Young, N o .
a m talking about a t banks,

wir. Miller. I

Governor Young,

A t banks, t h e only argument I can vut
no t

up a t all i s that i t i s possible t o discriminate between
items,
Mr, Miller.

D i d y o u find. that t o b e a sort o f handicap

@ hardship when y o u were practicing that system?

Governor Young, Y e s , sir.
Mr, -Miller.

D i d the member banks f i n d i t 60? W h a t

is the difference between t h e situation i n Minneapolis a n d
in the other reserve cities?
Governor Young,

wir, Miller,
at banks?

I t i g e x t r e m e l y different.

I n what way? I

mean, f o r items payable


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

34
think the Board can correct that

Governor Young. I

very easily b y issuing a regulation,

air, Mgller. I

understand, b u t w e want t o know what kind

of a regulation t o issue, w e want the information o n which
uw c a n proeeed; a n d I want t o see whether there i s some
rationale i n this thing.
cannot s e t u p a very good defense,

Governor Young. I

ily. willer.

Y o u cannot?

Governor Young,

N o .

Vice-Governor Platt, T h e Board might t r y i t out b y having

Minneapolis change the proposition t o apply wholly t o street

address items and seé how that would work, S t o p collecting
tems

o n street addresses a n d simply collect those a t banks.

I think there i s n o reason whatever,

i n the case o f notes pay—

able a t a bank and charged t o a men's account, f o r taxing a n y
thing o u t o f i t whatever.

Governor Bailey.

W e never charge t h e m i n Kansas City,

Vice Governor Platt, W h e t h e r h e draws a check o n <

or whether i t is charged, i t doesn't make any difference,

They do not do any work at all,

A l they do is charge

some thing.

Governor Fencher,

I n many cases there i s an order filed

325
with the bank authorizing them t o charge t o the account o f
the depositor matured notes a s they come in, whether presented
at the counter o r passed through t h e clearing.

Governor Strong. S e c u r i t y drafts have been mentioned,
that you got for collection, which cause liability - ~ those
came fromNew York?
Governor Young, N o t all o f them.

$ o m e came f r o m Chicago.

B u t most o f them come from Federal

Governor Strong,

reserve cities, d o they not, like New York and Chicago?
Governor Young.

Yes.

Governor Strong.

H a v e y o u ever taken that u p with u s i n

New York t o see whether those were sent t o y o u direct,
accordance with t h e regulations i n New York.

in

W e d o n o t re-

ceive t h e m ourselves.

Governor Young. I

think w e have received some direot

from you,

Governor Strong, Mighty few of them. O u r rule is not to
receive them, a n d i t strikes m e that i f y o u had taken that

up with the Federal Reserwe Bank o f New York you might have
gotten rid of that liability,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Young, I

think I mentioned i t in 1923 or 192],

Tet A e one of m y objections t o the non-cash collections,

326
Y o u spoke o f your great r i s k i n h a n d

Governor Fancher.

ling these street address items,

H a v e y o u ever made a n y

loss o n them i n Minneanolis?

Governor Young.

N o ,

Governor Fancher. I

do not n o w o f a n y Federal reserve

bank that has ever sustained any losses through the handling
of those items i n their cities.

I f they have done s o I would

like t o xnow of it.
Governor Bailey,

N e had one.

Governor Fancher,

B u t t h a t w a s not because anything

haopened t o the collection b u t perhaps w a s failure o n your
part t o exercise d u e diligence.

Governor Strong,
They h a v e t o g o direct.

W e d o not handle seourity drafts.
B u t t h e fact i s that t h e l o s s between

bankprand b r o x e r s a n d b e t w e e n t h e p r o x e r s t h e m s e l v e s

i n del—

ivering seourities i n Ner York, where orobably t h e hazard i s

a thousand times a s great every day as i t “ould be i n a year
in Minneavolis,

i s practically negligible.

I n fact I cannot

nor recall o s instence where any such losses occurred,
Governor Young. W e l l , t h e passibility o f loss i s there,
Now, I have repeatedly tried t o get m y story with regard
to wdinneapolis over, I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

do not s e a n t o get very f a r with it, T I

am going t o try i t once more,

between 200,000 and
We get grain drafts thetrun s u c
600, 000 dollers a day.

to
W o w i f w e took that draft d o w n

t o give u s cash for i t w e
the grain concern a n d asked t h e m

wouldn't get anywhere with that,
concern w e wanted a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

with that.

I f we stated t o the grain

certified check w e wouldn't g e t anywhere

i s this:
T h e method o f procedure w e follow

Our

a n d leaves t h e drafts.
collector goes t o one grain concern

attached,
some oases there i s a till o f lading
away a n d goes t o the next place.

all o f these grain concerns.

I n

H e comes

I t takes h i m a n hour t o sover

I t i s true with the bill o f lading

B u t he goes
attached there wouldn't b e as much liability,
in, and b y the time
to these places and he throws the draft
h e gets a checs.
he gets back t o the first n a n

T h e n h e goes

and gets his check,
to the second, third and fourth fellows
a n y liability there?
Now d o y o u tell m e that there isn't

go back?
Governor §trong, W h y does h e have t o
t o get his check, t o
Governor Young. H e has t o g o back
save time.
Governor Harding.

A r e they bill o f lading drafts?

Governor Young, T h e great majority are,
Governor Harding.

around
W h y couldn't y o u send &@ Man

328
to leave notice saying that they would find the draft and
to
bill o f lading attached a t t h e Federal Reserve Bank a n d
send a

certified check.

man u p w i t h a

W e could d o that.

Governor Young,

Governor Harding That would relieve you from liability
in t h e t w a y ,

Governor Young, Y o u could do that but you would get 4
how] f r o m y o u r merchants.

Governor Harding, L e t them howl,
Governor Strong,

T e have been conducting the business

have ever
for a little o v e r t e n years, a n d the only loss I
heard o f ‘is the o n e Governor B a i l e y mentioned o f several
thousand dollars,
Governor Young,

W e have lost money f r o m cash collections~—

country.
not i n sijnneapolis, b u t w e have lost i t out i n the
Governor Strong, I

mean i n the city.

Governor Young, L e t me g o a little further,

W e have

and
the N o r t h w e s t e r n N a t i o n a l Bank, t h e F i r s t N a t i o n a l B a n k

the siidland National Bank, w h o charge more O n these grain
drafts t h a n w e do,

N o w i f our grain draft facilities a r e

open t o one bank they are open t o any bank,

J I have talked

back o n
them out o f i t before but just a s sure a s y o u g o

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

329
o n us and we
that other basis they are going t o dump them
taxing a liability
have got t o collect them, a n d instead o f
will take a million
of from two t o six hundred thousand w e
or more dadly.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Strong,
wir, James.

W e d o not have that i n New York,

is a
H o w d o y o u handle items where there

+ ¢ bo given for
pill o f lading attachedwita the privilege
f o r inexamination o f goods? T a k e the cotton drafts,
stance,

Governor Young, I

do not x n o w about that,

Y o u would

have t o leave them.

where @ Tan
cider. Jamese W i t h regard t o cotton drafts,
o f lading,
dovm i n the country ships cotton with bill

thing with us.
Governor Strong, T h a t i s not a serious
o f i n NewYork,
Se d o not r e c e i v e m u c h cotton t o speak
wr. James.

I have
I t i s a very difficult t h i n g a n d

a r e responsible
contended a l l along that local conditions
for a lot o f these troubles. Governor Strong»

York,
I n the handling o f fruit i n New.

i t would b e useless i n
4+ i s perishable stuff a n d a lot o f
48 hours.

o f this c h a r
I t i s almost a l l handled 6 n drafts

a t t h e Reserve Bank:
acter a n d many o f t h e m a t e handled

handling
We have sone special arrangements t o facilitate


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

w e never
d o not ‘ n o w what t h e detail o f i t i s but

them, I

have a n y losses.

W e have never l o s t a

penny o n a n y o f t h e

non-,ash collection items.
d o not think t h e Reserve panss have, b u t

air, James. I

how about their customers?

‘ h y should the customers lose i f the

Governor Strong,

through m e m
drafts are handled through u e any more than i f
bers?
i n memphis w h o
wiz. Jemes. T h e r e was aprominent cotton m a n

bank handcomplained t o me very bitterly about the Rese@ve
necessitated
ling non-cash business, because this transaction
o'clock n o o n |
his carrying t h e cotton between Saturday trrelve

and wionday, and it lost him a good many thousand dollars, h e
claimed,

Governor Strong, I
Governor Seay.

would like t o see that contract.

H o w about t h e other s i d e o f the question?

o u t o f the funds
Would t h e drawer o f the draft h a v e been xept
equitable right t o colduring that time? w l a y b e h e h a d a n
lection o f the draft.

wir. James.

B u t the point h e made was that handling the

a t Memphis
item through the Federal Reserve bans o r branch

in
he was prevented from getting the document completed
time t o make t h e transfer a n d ship the cotton.
was practically s o l d t o McFadden &
was c o m p e l l e d

T h e cotton

Son o f Philadelphia.

t o l e t t h e c o t t o n l a y t h e r e uncovered,

H e

I n

mér—
the cotton industry i n Memphis cotton buyers a n d cotton


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

that
chants seldom have money enough t o pay f o r the cotton

they buy and handle, b u t they must take the documents t o
their bank and negotiate a loan against them, o r at least
in
have a draft against the party t o whom i t i s sold, a n d
but
that w a y they are able t o clear o n e against t h e other;

they cannot get a loan and cannot get a certified check un‘less the documents a r e placed i n the bank that i s going t o
cash t o
certify the check o r take t h e l o a n o r give t h e m t h e

pay it.
Governor @

rissinger.

T h a t occurred o n Saturday about

noon?

air, James. A

little before noon o n Saturday.

Governor Orissinger.

H e didn't have time t o get down

to the Federal Reserve Bank,
hand.
Governor Strong, This question o f responsibility for
Fed
ling collection items has been considered i n the New Yors
o n our board
eral Reserve bans t e n years o r more, a n d wehave

332
bankers o f great experienoe; a n d I myself h a d some reserva—

tions about the non-cash collection service a t New York, where
the items are very large a t times, lest i t might not put some
liability o n us.

A f t e r a great deal o f discussion w e de-

cided t o set uo a reserve fund against a n y unusual losses
because o f this service, ‘ Y i t h the approval o f the Federal

Reserve Board we set aside a fund o f a million dollars,
which w

invested i n Government bonds, T h i s business h a s

grown through one o f t he most perilous periods i n our
history o f bank credit generally, t h a t i s during t h e war,
and t h e amount that w e hold i n that fund today i s nearly
a million, n i n e hundred thousand dollars, w i t h accumulated

qnterest, because w e have never charged one penny o f loss

against it. I

cannot believe, i n the face of the record

in New Yor’ im.” the Federal Reserve bans, through this period
of ten years o f very great peril t o American banking, t h a t

in
these. alarming things that w e hear about the liability
the collection service are very material. I
maintain i n the reserve banks a

thins w e should

reasonable reserve t o d r a w

from i n case of some unexpected loss, like a ° grain draft
minds
for fifty thousand dollars coming baok, andl make u p o u r

to tackle this proposition and g o ahead and perform the ser-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

333
vice; I

a
think i f w e d o that w e will eliminate

great m a n y

s y s t e m which w e never
of the risks f r o m the whole collection
w i t h this non-cash c o l l e c
will eliminate i f w e xeep monkeying

i t invites further
tion business. Z v e r y time i t comes u p


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

discussion from a dozen different banks.

N o w this thing has started i t all

all settled a t one time.

off again. I

W e thought i t was

am not afraid of the liabilities. 1

had some

years ago, b u t o u r
thought o f the possibility o f i t some t e n
experience has dissipated a l l that.
Mr. James. I

a m not concerning about t h e liability

T h a t has never
of the Federal reserve bank making losses.
matter a t all,
entered into m y consideratim o f the

Governor Strong,

I f we can collect a draft a s promptly

that with our connecas any commercial bans can, I maintain
tions w e ought

t o d o i t better than t h e y cen.

Governor Harding,

I f they don't want a

draft t o come

them kegp i t out,
through the Federal Reserve Bank let

W e

o n account o f it,
do not want t o disrupt t h e whole system
we, James. I

understand t h e t that i s being done,

do it,
Governor Harding. A 4 1 1 right, l e t them
Governor Calsins, I
sequential observations.

would like t o make t w o o r three incon
a T h e first i s I cannot s e e w h y


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

334
Federal Reserve B a n k should not b e a s well equipped a n d
as well qualified t o transact t h e business that w e have

been discussing a s any commercial bank i n the country. I
believe that t h e y are.

Second, i t i s a very curious thing, a n d this conviction
has been growing upon me for four years, that all o f the
aifficulities that w e have been discussing i n connection with

the non-cash collection system have occurred o r arisen i n
the t h r e e d i s t r i c t s t h a t h a v e a l w a y s b e e n o p p o s e d t o t h e n o n -

gash collection system; that n o difficulties o f any oonsequence have arisen i n any of the other nine districts, Third,
that t h e a r g u m e n t u o o n which t h e Federal Reserve B o a r d

directed the setting u p of the non-cash collection system

was that the meber banks, particularly the remote country
banks, h a d been deprived o f a n opoortunity t o maintain relaions for the purpose o f mating these colle ations, That rea—

son is just as good today as it was when i t was first given,
and v o s s i b l y stronger,

F o r u s t o abandon t h i s s y s t e m a t

this t ime i s for us t o akandon those banks f o r whom i t was
set U p e

Governor Seay. I

3

w o u l d l i x e t o say that I

am convinced

that a very lerge portion o f the evil which comes from the

335

situation lies i n its uncertainty,

A s long as there i s

any uncertainty o r a n y doubt about t h e action o f one Federal
o the system,
Reserve B a n k o r another o r about t h e a c t i o n f
s going t o b e one
then that uncertainty about t h e s i t u a t i o n i
of t h e chief evils.
Governor Strong. Y o u asked. for a

recomnendation f r o m

the Conference, Governor Crissinger, T h e r e was a difference
of views, a s y o u are aware. T h r e e members o f the Conference
are o p v o s e d t o it.

N i n e favor it. T h o s e three w h o a r e supposed

to i t have some differences between themselves a s t o what t h e y
would l i k e t o do, T h e r e f o r e I

can only speak f o r t h e nine

members w h o are agreed woon continuing it. I

would l i k e t o

express again w h a t Ibelieve t o be their recomnendations,
They will dissent f r o m i t i f 1 do not express it. I

think

i their recomnendation and thei# desire
they are unanimous n
é&hatothe non-cash collection service should continue; t h a t
it should cover items norm handled a n d should b e conducted

free o f charge; that i f the Board desires t o take the respons—
ibility o f any change i n that respect t h a t i t should b e made
as a

principle a n d n o t a s e

particular m e t h o d i m a n y o n e bank;

and that that change o f principle should b e such a change

as will not permit any group o f member banks t o make a profit


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

out o f this business; t h a t i f w e surrender a n y o f our present

336
methods o r abandon a n y o f t hem that a n y charge that i s i m
posed should inure t o the benefit o f the Federal Reserve

think most o f these

banksfor services that they p e rform. I

nine men, i f not all o f them, believe that t h e only material
dissent n o w i s i n relation t o the street address items; t h a t

there would not b e any difference o f opinion b y any o f the
Governa@ s98 t o the continuance o f the service a s t o all

items except those.
Governor Young,

I s that right?
N o , I

Governor Strong, I

w o u l d h a v e t o c h a n g e that,

understood y o u t o s a y 6 0 this m o r n —

ing.

Governor Harding.

W o u l d you be willing t o go as far

as matured notes and bills?
Governor Young. I

think I am prepared t o recomnend t o

our directors that i f i t i s made a s t o matured notes a n d
bills a n d i t i s specified what matured notes a n d bills are,
and not l e t i n a let o f drafts withnbills o f lading attached,

and whet not, that they approve it. I

think our people would

be willing t o agree t o that.

Governor Strong, H o w about coupons?
Governor Young. I
oF out,

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

don't care whether you leave them i n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

337
and
D o you refer t o matured notes

Governor uicDougal,
drafts v a y a b l e

a t banks?

Governor Young. Y e s .

Governor .icDougal.

A n d not a t street addresses?

Governor Young, N o ; matured notes and drafts payable
at banks.
Governor Orissinger. I

d o not think there i s anything

further that canecome o u t o f this discussion.

I t i s f o r the

Board t o take action i n the matter,
( Thereupon, a t 4:55 p.m,, t h e Federal Reserve
a n d the ConferBoard retired f r o m the Conference R o o m

ence of Governors proceeded as follows: )
) Governor
The Chairman (Governor ideDougal presiding:

extra session,
Norris, I think you are responsible for this
What topics have y o u i n mind?
Governor Norris.

T h e r e a r e t w o o r three topics which

we might dispose of,
aisposed of.
Governor Seay, T o p i c J ~ H has not been
The Chairman,

V e r y well.

w e will take that up-

I. CREDIT TRANSACTIONS A N D POLICIES
o f Supreme Court
H. T h e possible effect o f decision

358
Texas i n rendering trade accept ances non-negotiable where
they contain the clause:

" T h e obligation o f the acceptor

hereof arises out o f the nurchase o f goods from the drawer,
maturity being i n conformity w i t h the original terms o f purchase."

Governor Norris.

I f I may make a suggestion, i t seems

to me that i f that decision o f the Supreme Court o f Texes

o the word “maturity being i n conformity with
was ‘esussdicbyf
the original terms of purchase", that the decision was per
feotly right a n d i t does not affect t h e business generally,
If A t was o n any other ground i t was a wrong decision, b u t
wust a s l i k e l y t o b e followed.

I s there anything e l s e that

we can s a y o r d o about 1 % ?

Governor Talley, I

had a n idea that w e might just refer

that topic t o the acceptance committee.

The Chairman l e t me interrupt just a moment, w r , Hurria
son h a s m a d e t h e s u g g e s t i o n t h a t wir. D e w e y h a s e x p r e s s e d

desire t o come before t h e conference a n d take u p the currency
program,

i r , Harrison says h e believes t h i s i s a good time t o

procure ar. D e w e y ,
ir. H a r r i s o n , I

do not x n o w that I

can, b u t i f a g r e e

able t o him, i t would b e a good time t o d o it.

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

339
think t h e Governors w h o are absent

Governor Biggs. I

would b e very much interested i n that.

Governor Norris. Y e s , I think they would be.

Mr. Harrison.

T h e n I will withdraw the suggestion,

Governor Norris.

G o v e r n o r Talley w a s saying that h e

to
had i n mind suggesting that this matter b e referred
the standing committee o n acceptances.
J I so move.

Governor Calkins.

Governor Fancher. I

Governor Talley. I

will second the motion.

just want t o say further that I

that t h e
asked o u r counsel t h e direct question i f h e thought
largely
deoision o f the Supreme Court o f Texas w a s inspired

oonformby the latter part o f that clause, tmaturity being i n
emity with the original terms o f purchase", a n d he stated
phatically that h e thought not.

: Governor Calkins. I

think h e is wrong about that G o v e r —

nor Talley.
The Chairman. I

have n o doubt, Governér Talley, t h a t most

of those present h a v e brought something from their counsel
on
on this, but i f it is going t o be referred t o the committee
acceptances w e need g o no further with it.
Governor Talley, I

will undertake t o have the whole

340
question briefed f o r that committee, including t h e argument

for a motion for rehearing before the Supreme Court o f Texas,

which was denied.

T h e thought i s in my mind that if is like-

ly t o affect n o t o n l y the negotiability o f the trade accept—

ances but the eligibility clause o f the bankers’ acceptances
that i t might have t h e same effect i n every State.

The Ohairman, T h e motion i s t o refer this question t o

the standing committee o n acceptances, T h a t motion has been
6 econded.
Governor Seay, I

would l i k e t o ask i f i t i s not t h e

opinion o f Dallas and its counsel that this matter could b e
easily reached b y a change i n the formla.

I t seems t o me

h
t formula so as to
44would be a very easy matter toctrahese
accomplish the purpose the Board h a s i n mind andyet avoid

eny alteration of the negotiability of the instrument, M y
thought i s that i t might be handled mor e expeditiously b y
being r e f e r r e d

t o t h e Board's c o u n s e l t h a n t h r o u g h a

comnittee,

and w e might get quicker aotion.
Governor Norris. P e r h a p s Governor Talley will accept

that amendment.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Talley, Y e s , I will b e glad t o try that.
Governcr Seay, I

am taking i t for granted that our own

34],

secretary would b e willing t o collaborate with the Board's
counsel i f desired.

would b e glad t o do s o if it would help.

Mr, Harrison. I

will offer a substitute motion that

Governor Seay. I

our secretary b e requested t o

t e

c o u n s e l o f t h e Fed-

eral Reserve Board t o determine whether o r not this question,

which has arisen from the decision o f the Texas Supreme Court,
might not b e obviated b y a change i n the formula, which would
answer t h e purpose which the Board had i n mind i n making
the original formula.
Governor Calkins. I

will seoond the motion.

(The motion, h a v i n g b e e n d u l y seconded,

w a s unanimously

carried.)
N o w , m a y we not take u p &-D?

Governor Norris.

O r was

that done this morning before I came in?
Governor Seay, I t was, and no action taxen.
might
Governor Norris. I think we/disposec. of IV“B, Revision
of Treasury Department Circular No. 9 2 . "
*I

suggest t h a t o u r secretary take t h e matter u p with

Mr. D e w e y a n d t r y t o secure action,
to the Conference I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I f that i s satisfactory

will withdraw that f r o m the program.

Governor Fancher.

o page
M a y w e not take u p the r e p o r t s n

IV. O P E R A T I O N AND ADMINISTRATION.
Ie Repott o f Leased Wire Committee.

The Chairman, Report o f the Leased Wire Committee is
‘as follows:


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

REPORT O F THE LEASED WIRE COMMITTEE
- TO THE GOVERNORS! CONFERENCE
May 9, 1927,
At the last Governors! C o n f e r m c e t h e question o f a n
additional supply o f Federal Reserve C o d e Books was discus—

sed and referred t o the Leased Wire Committee with power t o
act.

In order t o determine how many, i f any, books should
be printed a t this time, t h e committee wrote t o all o f the

Federal Reserve banks t o ascertain b e condition o f the books
which they n o w have o n hand a n d the probable length o f time b e
fore they would n e e d additional copiés-

T h e replies receivwé

indicate that most o f the banks h a v e asufficient number o f

code books t o meet their requirementg f o r a minimum period
supoly
of approximately t w o years | and i t i s believedthat t h e

held by. the Board will take care o f the needs o f the remaining

banks for a similar period.

343
that the
In view of the foregoing, t h e committee feels
another y e a ,
printing o f extra copies e a n b e deferred f o r

at which time the desirmility

o f some revision i n the

will
code, a S well a s the question o f a n additional supply,
be considered.
With respect t o the Leased Wire System, y o u r committee
the arrangehas t o report that there h a s b e e n n o change i n
that
ment o f the circuits since t h e last conference a n d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

apparently
the p r e s e n t f a c i l i t i e s a r e a m p l e a n d t h e s e r v i c e

satisfactory.

Governor Norris. I

move that t h e report b e received

and filed.
Governor Fancher. I

will second that,

(Te motion, having been duly seconded, was unani—
mously carried.)
the Insurance
The Cy,airman T h e next i s the report o f

Committee, which i s as follows:
REPORT O F THE INSURANCE COMMITTEE T O THE GOVERNORS' CONFERENCE - Way 9, 1 9 2 7 .
Since t h e l a s t Governors!

Conferm

A

c e n o nermmatters

n o matters h a v e come
have been referred t o this committee a n d

6 0 that
up requiring a meeting o f the committee,
is nothing t o b e reported a t this c u e s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Respectfully,
F. Taylor
H. Dillard
k. Kenzel, Chairman
Insurance Committee.
Governor Norris. I

move that the report b e received

and filed.
Governor Fancher, I

second the motion.

(The motion was duly put, seconded and carried.)
o the reGovernor Fancher. ifr, Chairman, I have 4 c o p y f
port o f the subcommittee o f the general Committee o n Bankers!
Acceptances.

I t does not s e e m t o be o n the vrogram,

Mir. Harrison.

A t the t ime the program was made u p

the Committee told m e they had nothing t o report.

The Chairman.

M r . Harrison, you read that report, pleas:

(The report referred t o i s a s follows :)
REPORT O F THE SUB-COMMITTEE O F GENEPAL COMMITTEE
ON BANKERS ACCEPTANCES T O GOVERNORS! CONFERENCE,
May 2, _3987.
Since the last conferenée n o question has been reported
nothing n e w t o
to the SubCommittee, consequently there i s

report a t this time.
Your Committee, however, a g a i n respectfully calls attention t o the fact that t h e matters referred t o i n the report

of the General Committee o n Bankers Acceeptances, submitted
to the Conference o f March 22, 1926, printed o n page 570-378
of t h e S t e n o g r a p h i c R e c o r d o f t h a t Conferenoe, o u t l i n i n g

certain principles a n d rules desired b y the Conference i n its
consideration o f a general broadening o f practice i n bankers!
domestic acceptance credits a n d approved b y that Conference,
have, y o u r Comnittee understands, s t i l l t o b e disposed o f
by the action o f t h e Federal Reserve Board.
Respectfully submitted,

W. W.
0. R.
F. J.
BE. R,
Governor Fancher. I

Paddock,
McKay,
Zurlinden,
Kenzel, Chairman.

move that t h e report b e received

and that t h e Secretary b e directed t o caJl t h e attention o f
the Federal Reserve Board t o the matter touched o n i n the re.

port, a n d transmit a copy o f the report t o the Federal Reserve
Board.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Talley, I

will second that,

(The motion was ,ut, duly seconded and carried.)

346

Governor Talley, There i s one topic w e can dispose of,

Topic I-G, at t he bottom of the first page, Desirability
of amending that part o f Section 1 3 relating t o discount
of demand a n d sight drafts secured b y shipping documents
covering domestic shipment o f agricultural products s o i t

will include all staple non-perishable commodities, s u o h for

example as flour, bran, cot tonseed meal, eto, a s well as
reimbursement drafts for the proceeds o f other bille’ carry.
ing shipping documents.

The Chairman, d r e you ready t o take that up, Governor
Talley?
Governor Talley,

Y e s , Mr. Chairman, I

move that that

matter b e referred t o the Advisory Committee o n Legislative
Matters,
Governor Fancher, I

will second that motion.

(The motion w a s put, a n d being d u l y seconded, w a s unani-

mously carried.)


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairmen Now, gentlemen, a r e there any other topics
that weeoan take u p a t this time?

wir: .Harrison, wir, Chairman, I might report o n the matter
of the gold holdings o f the Federal reserve banks.
The Chairman V e r y well, ir. Harrison.

347
(ir. Harrison t h e n reported t o the Conference o n the
matter o f the gold held b y the several Federal reserve

benks, a n d was requested t o send the table o f figures t o
each o f the reserve banks for their information. )

(Whereupon, a t 5:30 o'clock p.m., upon motion duly
seconded, t h e Corf erence o f Governors adjourned until tomorrow, Wednesday, M a y 11, 1927, a t 9:50 o'clock a.m. )


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

TRiRD-

D A T s
May 11, 1927,
9:%0 o ' c l o c k a.m.

CONFERENGS

O F GOVERNORS

O F T H E F E D E R A L RSSERVSE BANKS.

The Conference o f Governors o f the Federal Reserve

Banks reaséinbled in the Hearing Room of the Federal
Reserve Board, Tyeasury Building, Washington, D.C.
PRESENT:

(As indicated in the record of the first day's proceed
ings.)

The Chairman (Governor Strong presiding!)

W e will

pass Topics & and B for discussion then w e meet with the
Board, unless there i s objection.
Governor Seay, H a s t h e time been s e t f o r t h e meeting
with t h e Board?
The Chairman l o t yet.
like t o skip Topic ©

N o r , i f y o u please, I

because I

would

have t o b e absent f o r a few

minutes, a n d I would like t o be here when that i s discussed.

We can take up topic D, continuous borrowers, T h i s was
os?

°


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

carried o v e r f r o m t h e f o r m e r conference,

I. O R E D I T TRANSACTIONS A N D POLICIES
D. C o n t i n u o u s Eorrwoers.

Report t o b e submitted b y each Federal reserve bank
showing number o f borrowing banks i n each district w i t h

particular reference t o number o f banks which have been
borrowing for a year o r more, t h e amount o f their capital,
surplus and total resources, a n d the average amount o f
their b o r r o w i n g s f r o m t h e F e d e r a l r e s e r v e bank.

(See par—

agraph 5 of Secretary's Mnutes o f November, 1926, Governors! Conference. )
Governor Wellborn. O y t o f 500 and some—odd member

banks i n our District we have 47 who atethe present time
are continuous borrowers, including jJast year and this. I
have a

list o f t h e m here,

Governor Harding. W e have banks borrowing continuously
for one year o r more a s of January 1, 1987, seven banks,
all comparatively small banks, a n d the borrowings a r e neglible. wm%>st o f them are o n Government seourities,.

Governor idcDougal,

H o w many members have you?

Governor Harding. 4287,
Governa Y o u n g , I

have a

report prepared o n that,

350
The Chairman, S u p p o s e w e hand these reports t o the
Secretary?

Governor Young.

W e have 2 3 banks w h o are borrowing con-

tinuously, o u t o f 760-odd banks.

I n the State o f montana

every bank out there cleared u p last vear with the exception
of o n e bank.

T h e continuous borrowing

i s not a

vrobdlem

with u s any more, except some banks that are just about d o m
and out,

Governor Seay,

W e have 5 8 member banks whowere continu-

ous borrowers, from May 1, 1926, through April 30, 1927; one
of them continues from 1917, two from 1919, two from 1920,
three from 1921, two from 1922, three fr om 19283, six from
1924, nineteen f r o m 1925, a n d 2 6 from 1926,

T h e average

amount borrowed i s $5,873,000,
Governor Biggs.

W e have 618 member banks. S i x t e e n

of them have been borrowers continuously f o r twelve months,
Four o f them have borrowed continuously f o r four o r five

years and have never gotten out. The rest o f t hem are i n
the northern p r t o f Illinois a n d along t h e Iowa line, w h e r e

they are pretty hit o n land, T h e y are not i n serious condition b u t have not been able t o clean up.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Talley, O yt of a total o f 838 member banks, 1 3 4


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

351
were borrowing from us a t the close o f business o n April
30th, O f this number 3 8 have b e e n continuously i n debt t o

us since May, 1926.
We have also included i n the report a

liat showing

sixteen banks w h i c h have been i n debt t o u s almost continuousiy f o r + h e past year. T h e y have b e e n i n and out, a n d

have cleaned up only for a short time.

W e compiled our

report for the twelve months! period just prior t o May 1,
1927,

I f we compiled i t o n the basis o f the calendar year

1926 there would only b e three banks borrowing for a period
of three months.

Governor Fancher.

O u t o f 853 borrowers, 2 1 3 o f the

tanks were borrowing o n April 30th,

borrowed since May 1, 1926.

O f that number 4 3 have

O f that number 18 banks were

borrowing exclusively , n Governments o r o n Governments a n d

rediscounts, and 17 of them were borgowing o n rediscounts.

They are small banks, The total borrowing of the 43 banks
is three and a half million dollars. O n l y two of the number
are borrowing i n excess o f capital a n d surplus,
Governor McDougal,

O n t h e basis o f the year 1926 o f

1320 menber banks 1 1 5 have been borrowing continuously d u r
ing t h e year, Fifteen o f them have paid o u t entirely since


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

the first o f the year, That. i s about t h e status now.

Governor Bailey,

O t o f 1190 banks the total borrowing

for the year. was 49, total capital $2, 260,000,. and surplus

$536,000, and t he average borrowing $49, 520,.
W e have 7 1 9 member banks, o f w h ich

Governor Calkins.

about 176 have borrowedthroughout t h e year 1937 for a
three months period,

A s I recall i t w e have about. twenty.

banks t h a t h a v e - b e e n b o r r o w i n g continuously...

T h a t number

a n d have
does not include some very small banks t h a t a r e
been borrowing f o r four o r five years, m a i n l y o n Government
securities,

W e have n o contin uous borrowing problem i n

our District a t present.

The Chairman, I

will ask Mr. Harrison t o maxe @ report

for New York, and I will asx Governor iucDougal t o take the
chair for a few moments.
(Governor McDougal thereupon took the Chair.)
ir. Harrison, I

York,

would l i k e t o make 4

report f o r N e w

A t the end of 1926 w e had 919 member banks. D u r i n g

the year 6 0 3 o f those banks h a v e porrowed f r o m us.
end o f t h e year 3 1 7 were i n debt t o us.

A t the

A t the close o f

business a s o f April 25, 1927, w e had 935 banks, 2 7 8 o f

mhich sere-eon borrowing from us, W e have had no bagks i n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

353
debt t o u s for a

year o r more gince the year 1925.

W e

have n o w 3 2 menber banks t h a t have been borrowing f o r s i x

months o r more, b u t not i n excess o f a year,

W e have four

member banks who, a t the end o f April, were borrowing i n
excess o f their capital a n d surplus.

The Chairman. I

would suggest that w

dispose o f this

matterby recording i n the minutes simply t h e number o f banks
that a r e reported t o b e continuous borrowers f o r the period
of a year.

O u r s was 115,

Governor S e a y , W o u l d i t not b e well t o also incor—
porate t h e average amount i f available, f o r that would b e

the most signifioant part o f it?
The Chairman. O u r average amount would b e approximately $50,000 per bank.

Governor Seay, The main object, a s I understand it, i n
finding the a m ount that has been borrowed continuously,
is how much o f the resources o f the Federal reserve banks
have b e e n monopolized b y these catinuous borrowers,

Governor Norris. I

do not think the report from the

Philadelphia district h a s been entered o n the minutes,

The Chairman, Governor Seay suggests that m w report the
number o f o c ontinuous b o r rowers

i n each district a n d t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

involved.
aggregate amount a n d the average amount
believe
Governor Seay, I just suggest that because I
business.
that i s the most significant part o f t he whole
be
The Cpaisman. W q t h o u t objection, that course will
pursued,

dur—
I n Chicago, w e had 115 continuous borrowers;

ing 1926 t h e average borrowings w e r e $5,800, 000.
will
t h e accurate figures b u t
Governor Y o u n I As ohaven't
were @
there
1987
April
o
f
end
f
a
t
e
r
.
*
(
h
e
n
supply

a n aggrebanks, borrowing. continously for a year o r more with
gate average o f about 890 thousand.
4 7 banks have been borrowing cont iGovernor Harding,
nually,

be
T h e average o f the aggregate porrowings can

figured f r o m this,

Governor Seay,
have handed in.

I t is incorporated i n the statement I

5 8 banks with a n aggregate average o f

$5,873, 000,
Governor Oalxins. I
Governor Biggs.

will supply the figures called for.

W e have 1 6 borrowing banks, o f which

15have an average borrowing of $40,000, or a total of $600,_
000,

a
W e have o n e large bank that has been

rower for about half o f that amount.

continuous bor-

T h e 1 5 banks are i n

$80,00C,
the agricultural sections. The total average i s about
the 16 banks,
or a little i n excess o f a million dollars for
Governor Talley,

w y report i s made o n the basis o f a

year a n d shows t he average borrowing o f each bank, I

haven't a summary,
The Chairman, H a v e you a statement a s t o the number o f
current b a rowers?

Governor Talley. Yes, 28.
The Chairman.

D o you know abcut h o w much they a r e bor—

rowing i n the aggregate?
Governor Talley.

N o , m y report isn't made u p o n that

basis. I t shows the average borrowing o f the individual] banks,
and t h e aggregate c a n b e determined f r o m the report ,
Governor Fancher.

A

s o f April 3 0 t h 4 3 banks borrowing

continuously f o r a year; total average borrowings o f the 4 3

banks $3,331,000, C o m b i n e d surplus o f the 4 3 banks $9,960,000

T w o banks borrowing i n exoess o f capital a n d surplus,

Governor Norris.

O , t o f 771 member banks w e had 6 0

that b o r r o w e d continuously during t h e calendar year 1926.

Eleven o f t hem have since paid off, being 4 9 continuous

borrowers a s of April, 1926,

O f that number borrowed entire-

ly on Government obligations,

1 3 on Governments, a n d paper;

9 entirely o n paper. I

think w e should f i l e a

complete state~

ment giving t h e names o f those banks, t h e i r capital a n d sur.

plus, deposits, maximum and minimum borrowings i n 19286, I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

356
haven't thae figures totalled. I

did not understand i t

was the desire they should b e totalled. I

haven't a n adding

now,
machine w i t h m e s o I cannot g i v e t h e t o t a l

Governor Bailey.

Q , ¢ o f 1100 banks 4 9 i n the District

T h e i r capital i s
have borrowed continuously f o r a year,

.

a little over three million dollars. 7

The aver—

borrowings $2,416,—
age borrowings w e r e $49,320 a n d the total

000, I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

banks
also have i t by States, giving the name of the

beweet Whe oe cur Biateds YJwill file tee whole thing.
out
Governor McDougal. Fifteen of my banks have been
entirely since the first o f the year.

4 7 banks will pvrobab-

ly be out and 43 vrobably will a e b e out.
ir. Harrison.

the
I n 1926 o f the 919 member banks i n

a t that time which had
New York District there were n o banks

@ rer:
been continuous borroweis f o r as long a s
The Cpairman,

W e will n o w take u n Topic I-E, T h a t

Board. Dees any
topic i s submitted b y the Federal Reserve
notes t o contend with?
bank representative here have those

I. C R E D I T TRANSACTIONS A N D POLICIES
bearing endorsée—
E. S h o u l d notes held b y a member bank
considered eligible
ment o f officers o f nonmember banks h e
for r e d i s c o u n t

a t F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k 8?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

357
would like t o talk about that a

Governor Bailey, I
minute. I

notice that i n reply t o the letter that t h e

Board sent out t o every bank, every bank have answered
that they have n o such paper, T h a t would b e true with us
if we answered i t i n the abstraot, that a t this time w e
have n o member baikkpaper, b u t w e have had a good deal o f
trouble t o eliminate it.
This condition prevails w i t h us, I

prevails a t Dallas o r at Mynneapolis.

do not think i t

T h e cattle indus-

try must b e financed outside o f the territory where t h e
range i s located. T h o s e a r e little e a e

o u t there a n d

they cannot d o it, and at every stock yards center there are
banks organized for the purpose o f maxing these loans o n
these ranch cattle. I

know o f n o other way that they can

finance that great industry t h a n b y coming d o m t o the stock
yards centers a n d borrowing money t o carry these herds d u r
ing the summer o n the ranches.

I t i s cussbumary f o r every

one o f thee stock yards banks t o have a representative a t

each section,

I n a especial case, let me say, they had a

stock yards bank a t Omaha.

M r . V a n Zandt was president a t

the time. H e has since left t h e bank b u t t h e principle there

is just the same. H e selected a man out i n the N,jrthwest,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

358

in Nebraska, t o make those loans for him, S o m e b o d y said

that it was a poor system to sdliit loans, but it is done
the
by every live stock bank that I snow of. They xnov
they will
good cattle men out there and they tell them that
be glad t o carry t h e m for a certain gmount o n their cattle.

They
They select a man who is familiar with the country,

have to know cattle, they have to inspect them and count
them and watch them during the summer and see that they have
grass a n d water.

In this special case the man was president o f a little

non-member bank with a len basis of $3,000, N o w these
loans run fran ten t o fifty thousand dollars o n these cattle.
They are counted and a chattel mortgage i s given and they
are handled i n that way, N o w because this man was president
of a little non-menber bank, t h e idea teated o u t some w a y

that the non-member bank was getting advantage o f it, and
that t h e thing should b e decided o n its merits.

N o w

non-member banks get n o benefit from that, a n d I know that
to b e true i n this case because I

have looked a t the state-

@
ment» N o w we have our managers come i n once & month t o
meeting a t the head office and w e tell them that before they
a n d see
make a n y loans t h e y must carefully review the matter


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

359
whether t h e y h a d a n y non-member paper park i n there, a n d
they assured m e that t h e y d i d not.

W e went through o u r o w

some Man
paper» T h e fact i s I asked him why he didn't take
that w a s not the president o f a bank a n d t h e question c o u l d

a
not b e raised, a n d he said "Well, I knew this man; h e is
competent cattle man; h e was a man I would l i k t o have

that h e
represent m e out there, a n d I didn't think the fact
would
was president o f a little bank that could loan $3,000
Make his paper eligible."
Now I would like a

resolution passed that i t i s t h e

ought t o g o v
sense o f the Board o f Governors that t h e facts
ern these cases.

T h a t i f i t i s t o the benefit o f these

t o b e eligible.
little country banks that t h e paper ought
There i g n o other w a y t o finance this great industry,

gen

tlemen,.
Governor Harding. I

will offer a

resolution a n d l a y

it open for discussion.

Resolved, that i n the opinion o f this Conferen ce,
any offer t o it for Semsdaiast b y a member bank which bears
bank, p u t s
the endorsement o f ‘am: officer o f the non-member
investithe Federal Reserve bank o n notice that i t should

gate the facts; that i f t h e facts show that i t

f

i


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

360
is not i n effect a rediscount f o r the Bedefai o f the nonmember bank, that there i s nothing i n the endorsement t o
impair t h e eligibility o f the paper.

Governor Bailey.
Governor Harding.

T h a t i s absolutely satisfactory.
T h a t i s a s clear a s a bell.

T h e

endorsement cannot possibly affect the eligibility under
the law.
Governor Young. I
The Chairman, I

second the motion,
think Governor Harding's resolution

covers t h e case perfectly,
Governor Bailey,

Yes.

(The motion, having been duly seconded, was unanimously
carried.)
The Chairman,

T h e next topic is submitted b y the New

York Bank, and I think it advisable to await Governor Strong's
y
e
. eturn,
Governer Seay, M r . Chairman, { 1 suggest that we take
up Topic ZV, F and G, Should not Fedepal Reserve Banks b e
reimbursed

b y Federal L a n d B a n k s f o r e x p e n s e i n v o l v e d

in

paying Federal Farm Loan couvons? A n d , G , Air Mail Service;
to w h a t e x t e n t i s i t b e i n g u s e d o r s h o u l d b e u s e d b y

Federal Reserve banks, and, seco#d, i t s effect o n time sched—

ules?

IV. OPERATION AND ADMINISTRATION.
F, S h o u l d n o t Federal Reserve Banks b e reimbursed b y
Federal Land Banks f o r expense involved i n paying Federal
Farm Loan coupons?

At the last conferm o e i t was voted that each Governor
submit a

new estimate o f expense involved i n handling these

coupons.

( S e e paragraph 4 1 o f Secretary's Mjnutes o f Nov—

ember, 1926, Governors! Conference.)
G. a i r M a i l Service.

1. T o what extent i s i t being used o r should b e
used b y Federal Reserve Banks?
2, I t s effect o n Time Schedules?
The Onairman,

W 4 1 1 y o u discuss that topic, Governor

Seay?

Governor Seay, T h e question is, should n o t h e Federal
exReserve Bank b e reimbursed b y Federal L a n d Banks for


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I
pense involved i n paying Federal Farm Loan coupons?
move, iir. Chairman, that i t i s the sense o f the meeting that
the Federal Reserve banks should b e s o reimbursed.

Governor Norris.

T y a t topic has been o n the program

that
at o n e o r two previous conferences, a n d i t d e v e l o p

362
there was a very wide difference i n the different banks
in their estimates o f t he cost, For that reason i t was

voted at the last conference that a new estimate of expense involved should b e submitted a t this Conference.

Therefore I think we had better get the respective estimates
of cost s o that w e may know what the size o f the problem 4s,

Governor McDougal, W h a t i s the cost t o the Philadelphia

,

Bank?

Governor Norris. During 1926 our coupon department hands
led approximately 3,700,000 Sekip ota o f which n e s

129, 681 were Land Bank coupons, ebout 3.1/2 per cent.

“The total salaries of the Department emount to $8,220,
and at 3-1/2 per cent the proportionate share would be $300.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

However, as it takes twice as long to handle Land Bank coupons a s Lyberty b o n d coupons, g 6 0 0 would s e e m t o m e t o b a a

fair estimate of the expense t o be reimbursed.

Governor Harding,

O n that basis $500 would be a fair es—

timate f o r Boston,

Governor Fancher.

W e estimated that the Cleveland bank

has a n expense o f $960,

Governor Talley, O y r expense i s negligible, $9.73 for
c l e r k hire,
a month's o p e r a t i n g , a h d i n d t e r i é b e d r s o m e thing for

363
I think t h e reimbursement s h o u l d b e made o n application
by the bank, a n d w e would n o t want t o make application.

Governor Biggs.

I t is $341 for St. Louis and the

three branches f o r a year,
W e would not want t o make application

Gevernor Talley,

because i t would cost u s more t o go through the form of mak-

ing the application-than we would receive.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Calkins.
tion, I

S e c o n d i n g Governor Talley's sugges—

will s a y that unless t h e expenditures o f other banks

justify it. o r the cost increases,
for u s t o make a

i t would b e extravagant

claim because i t would cost more t o set

up the machinery t h a n w e would get; o u r bill f o r 1926
LwaGe $57.39.
Governor Seay.

O u r experience coincides ‘ith that

ofthe Philadelphia Bank: That is that it takes twice as
long t o handle L a n d Bank coupons a s i t does t o handle G q v

ernment coupons.

T h e amount i s insignificant i n our case,

anounting t o only $271.

B u t i n view o f t h e fact that i t

Banks
seems t o b e the practice t o ask t he Federal Reserve

to absorb this, that and the other services a t their o w n
expense, . . I might s a y the increasing practice, I

believe

a matter o f principle that t h e reserve banks should b e

364
reimbursed f o r this expense, particularly when t h e y a r e
called upon t o perform that b y governmental agencies. 1
would b e perfectly willing t o accept t h e amendment suggested
by Governor Talley, b u t I d o believe a s a matter o f prin-

ciple, f o r the reasons that I have stated, that these people
should b e asked t o pay the expenses incurred b y the Federal
Reserve Banks i n rendering these services.

Governor Wellporn.

T h e expense involved t o us i n hand—

ling Federal L a n d Bank coupons i s s 0 inconsequential that
it i s i m m a t e r i a l

t o u s whether

Governor Young,
that I

w e a r e reimbursed.

I t i s such a small thing i n ijnneapolis

cannot figure t h e expense o n it.

The Chairman. That is the case in the Chicago bank,
according t o figures submitted, that i s about $660 a year.
But Governor Seay h a s stated i t i s not s o much t h e expense

involved as it is the matter o f principle. W h a t was the
amendment y o u suggested, Governor Talley?

Governor Talley, I

suggested that Governor Seay'!s motion

be amended that the Federal Reserve banks B e reimbursed for
the expense whenever they make ojaim for it.

Mr. Harrison.

I n New Yorks we handled practically 600, 000

coupons during the year 1926, aggregatiag about $18 ,800, 000.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

365
As c l o s e a s w e c a n e s t i m a t e

i t the total c o s t o f our h a n d

ling these coupons was $2400.

O n the other hand, w e be-

yieve v e r y clearly that i f w e should abandon t h e handling
of t h e s e c o u p o n s t h a t w e w o u l d n o t s a v e $2400, b e c a u s e t h e

Liberty l o a n coupon department handles them, a n d t h e dates
are s o well staggered that t h e y don't interfere with t h e
work o f our Liberty lcan department.

W e would not make a

proportionate s a v i n g b y a n a b a n d o n m e n t

tice.

o f t h e present p r a c —

O u r recommendation s o far a s te a r e concerned i s

that w e should not a s k for reimbursement.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor F a n c h e r . D o e s n ' t t h e Land Bank marry with

you, Mr. Harrison, a n account o f some magnitude?
Mir. Harrison. &

balance i s maintained b y the Land Banks

with u s aropaciae about t w o million dollars.

Governa Fancher. There i s nothing o f that sort i n the
other eleven banks,

Mr. Harrison.

I t does us n o good s o far as earnings are

concerned.

The Opairman,

T h e question i s o n Governor Talley's

amendment t o Governor! Seay's motion, W h a t was that motion,
Mr. Harrison?

wir. Harryson. Governor Seay moved that the Federal Re—


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

366
serve banks b e reimbursed f o r the expense, a n d Governor

Talley amended i t b y suggesting they b e reimbursed i f and
when requested b y the Federal reserve banks.
Governor Seay, I

would l i k e t o suggest some qualifica-

tion i n regard t o the amount, that is, i f the amount involved i s sufficient.
Governor Talley, I

would b e perfectly willing t o s a y

"If t h e amount involved i s sufficient t o warrant a

Federal

reserve benk i n maxing claim f o r reimbursement."

Governor Norris. I s n ' t that implied?
Covernor Seay.

I t is implied, b u t I think i t would

preserve t h e principle more clearly i f i t was stated,
Governor Norris.

B u t i f w e adopt that amendment t o

Governor Seay‘s motion, as suggested by Governor Talley,
pee fish pra dically impose obligation o n the New York Bank
to a s k f o r reimbursement,

i f i t acted i n accordance w i t h

the expressed sentiment o f the Conference. I

take i t they

do not wish t o make that request.

The Chairman, I

do not think 4 t will impose such a

responsibility o n the New York Bank, because they would not
file their claim.
Governor N,rris.

B u t Governor S e a y a s k e d Governor T a l l e y

to add to his amendment,"if the amount is material."


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairmen.

E e c h bank i s entitled t o determine

for itself whether t h e amount involved justifies t h e request.

Governor Bailey. I

Governor Seay, I

think t h e first amendment covers

am not a t all insistent, because i t

is perfectly clear that t h e amount i s insignificant; b u t I
would l i k e t o get a t the opinion here, a n d I

d o not believe

we have gotten a t it, a s t o whether t h e principle I

have

endeavored t o present i s a correct one, that the Federal
reserve banks should, a s a rule, b e reimbursed for services
which they render t o other governmental agencies which a r e
sustained b y their o w n income,

Governor Norris. I

think w e are all i n agreement

with that a s a matter o f principle,
Governor Seay, T h a t i s the vrinciple I
see established.

O f course I

would l i k e t o

d o not want t o bind a n y Fed-

eral Reserve Bank t o do anything that is not wholly agreeable t o it.
Governor Calxins. S u p p o s e w e do this: Resolved, that
in principle the Federal reserve banks should b e reimbursed

368
for services performed for governmental agencies, other
than t h e Treasury,

w h e n t h e expense

i s sufficient

t o justify

the filing o f a claim b y the individual bank n g concerned,
Governor Seay, T h a t substitute i s perfectly satisfac-

tory to me, wr, Chairman.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Fancher. I

will second t h e substitute.

Governor Young. W o u l d thet apply t o the War Finance
Corporation?

Governor Seay, I
Governor Young,

had that i n mind.
T h e reason I

make t h e i n q u i r y i s this:

a
h we cannot possibly
We have a building i n s y n n e a p o l i s t
rent space t o anybody in. T h e building i s not designed s o
that w e can, T h e W a r Finance Corporation occupies s o m e space

there which we have given them,

I + does not cause U s any

incenvenience o r trouble a t all a n d i t saves t h e Government

in the neighborhood o f six o r eight thousand dollars a4 year.

Governor Harding, T h e r e i s a difference between the War
Finance Corporation a n d other agencies,

i n that t h e War Fin—

ance Corporation i s omed entirely b y the Treasury,

I n the

case o f the Farm Loan banks i t amounts t o very little. T h e

War Finance Corporation would come under the Treasury,
Governor Young,

I t costs u s nothing and saves the

Treasury s i x o r eight thousand dollars a

year,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

369
Governor Seay,

A t the seme time I have this i n mind:

bi-mrtisan
The work done b y the Wat Finance Curporation w a s
her
work v e r y largely. N e v e r t h e l e s s i t i s doubt fullwhet
the
the corporation c o u l d have performed this work without

aid o f the Federal Reserve Banks, a n d the Federal Teserve
banks, I

imagine,

i n the popular estimation received v e r y

little credit f o r t h e work t h a t they have performed, w h i c h

was very onerous a n d very expensive, a n d for which the War
the

Finance Ccrporation reaped benefits.
The Chairman, I

thins i t i s the policy o f the War Fi-

a
nance Corporation t o reimburse t h e banks f o r a t least
considerable part o f it.
Governor Seay, Y e s , b u t I

d o not think either t h e pub-

t o the
lic o r the War Finance Qorporation itself accorded
. they

“ “ performed.
banks recognition o f the great deal o f work that
Governor Calins.

w i r . Chairman, m y purpose i n this

o f it
was t o state the principle and leave the application
to each bank.

(There were calls for the questions and the motion
carried.)
having been numerously seconded, w a s unanimously
Governor Harding.
Topic I-G?

i r , Chairman, c a n w e not take u p

The Chairman.

Yes.

I. C R E D I T TRANSACTIONS a N D POLICIES

G. D e s i r b b i l i t y o f amending that part o f Section
13 relating t o discount o f demand and sight drafts secured


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

agriculby shipping documents covering domestic shipment o f
tural p r o d u c t s

s o i t will i n c l u d e a l i s t a p l e n o n - p e r i s h a b l e

commodities, such for example a s flour, bran, cottonseed
Meal, e t c . a s well a s reimbursement drafts for the proceeds
of other bills carrying shipving documents.
Governor Harding, I
throw some light o n it,

think I can say something that will
I t seems t o me the guestion o f

authorizing the discount o f denand o r sight drafts seoured
é

by s h i p p i n g d o c u m e n t s c o v e r i n g staple, n o n - p e r i s h a b l e c o m m o d i -

ties, such, for example, a s flour, bran, cottonseed meal, and
so forth, can b e handled b y regulation o f the Board.
not require a n amendment t o the Act. I

I t does

base that opinion o n

this: L o o k a t Section 13, i n the paragraph above the one
which authorizes these transactions there i t Says "Nothing
such
in this A c t contained shall b e construed t o prohibit
notes, d r a f t s a n d b i l l s

o f exchange, s e c u r e d b y s t a b l e a g r i -

cultural vroducts, o r other goods, wares, o r merchandise,
from being eligible for such discount, a n d the notes, drafts


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

371
such maxing adand bills o f exchenge o f factors issued a s
vances exclusively t o producers o f staple agricultural prosuch discount, *
aucts i n their r a w state shell b e eligible f o r
and s o forth,

wir.
T h a t i s the very section applicaie t o

Talley's question, whether a

reserve bank might purchase

are
bills o f exchange payable a t sight o r o n demend, w h i c h

drawn t o finance domestic shipments o f non-perishable, readily marketable, stable agricultural products.
say ‘in the raw state" there. I

I t does not

think the Board can very

easily rule that t h e refinements o f these agricultural

s o forth,
products o f wheat, flour, bran, cottonseed meal, a n d
should b e included.
Governor Young.

W e had these flour drafts f o r a

long

agricultural prowhile a n d i t was interpreted that they were
ducts.

whether o r not
B u t someone t o o k u p the question o f

it was a n agriowltural praduct a n d i t was stooped.

that, and
Governer Harding. T i e Board could rule despite
ruling,
Let S o m e o n e r a t s e a n o t h e r c a s e a g a i n s t t h e

B u t you

i n their
have a distination between agricultural products
staple, non—per ish—
raw state, i n . this factors proposition o f
able agricultural nroducts.
exactly contrary
Governor Talley. T h e Board has ruled


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

872
to w h a t G o v e r n o r H a r d i n g h a s suggested,

T h e Board's c o u n -

in its
sel has construed that paragraph you have just read
in
entirety, £ 0 s h e n you t o include agricultural ordducts
their r a w state.

Governor deaerstct I

think it ought t o come lip ‘again

for Soqnuidatstion.

t
u
b
Governor Talley. | I agree with that e x a c t l y , I
am unable t o get the Board t o rule that way:

the
duremer Caltins. H , w rould it do to suggest t o
deter
Board t o ieee’ whe matter reviewed again i n order t o
the question.
mine whether i t had rower t o rule? T h a t i s

There i p ac Seabt that the matter c m be oaured by a ruling,
if the —

h a c authority t o make such a ruling. Personally

I believe that iat have, as Governor Harding has said, but
‘the Bisse''s coonset advises them t o the contrary,

we

Talley, The Board's counsel has predi cated

Governor
his Opinion upon the Gourt decisions referred to by
Young. <

yesterday
The Chairman, T h i s question " a s disposed o f
o n legislative
by passing i t along t o the advisory committee
matters.

b e reovened
N o w Governor Harding suggests t h a t i t

for reconsideration,

I f there i s n o objection t h e question


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

is open for reconsideration.
Governor Bailey,

W h y not form # resolution asking t h e

Board t o reconsider i t ?
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r Harding, w i l l y o u put your state—
ment i n the form o f a motion?

Governor Harding, I

offer a motion that this Conference

request t h e Federal Reserve Board t o reconsider i t s previous

ruling that agricultural products i n the secondary stage,
such a s flour, bran, cottonseed meal, a n d s o forth, cannot
be included o n the ground that i f Congress wished t o confine this t o non=perishable, r e a d i l y marketable a n d staple

agricultural products i n their r a w state, i t would have
said so, j u s t a s i t said i n the preceding paragraph,

in

regard t o factors, w h e r e i t specifically s a y s that these
products must b e i n the r a w state.
Governor Bailey, I

will second that.

Governor Norris. I

have n o personal interest i n this

thing, b u t I

think t h e gentlemen w h o a r e anxious

t o get

this action will get i t quicrer b y an amendment t o the act
than b y undertaxing t o get t h e Board t o review o r change i t s
previous decision, because I
that,

d o not believe t h e Board will d o

I f they rule that anything, t h e base. o f which i s agri-

374
cultural, still retains t h e character o f a n agricultural p r o

duct, where o n earth i s it going t o end? T h e Board, I think,
has ruled that canned goods i n which the base i s tomatoes,

or whatever i t may be, representing 2 5 or 30 ver gent of the
value o f the finished product, a r e net agricultural producta.
Now, would you say that broom, f o r instance, w a s a n agricul.
tural »roduct?
Governor Calkins. There-is t h e most delightful o p p o r t u n
ity t o argue i n regard t o the definition, T h e r e i s n o question
about that,

I t appears

t o me, however,

t h a t i t i s perfectly

pra Gicable and possible t o get a definition which would b e
sufficiently inclusive, G o v e r n o r Norris illustrates w i t h a
broom, w h i c h i s good, b u t which i s not a s good a s i t might
De.

Governor Norris. I

have n o doubt you could improve o n

it, Governo®, 2 2 4 . $2147
Governor Oalkins. Taking what Governor Harding has said,
you notice the list o f absuridities that arise i n thie, F o r
instance, s w e e t votatoes a r e a
VOOR

non-perishable agricultural

S S t h e y a r e put i n a dry xiln a n d dried s o that

they a r e less perishable t h e y a r e outside t h e ruling o f the
Board. T h e r e a r e many other caseg that a r e just a s absurd a s

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

that.

think Governor Harding's motion

Governor Bailey, I

forth, will
covering bran, flour, cottonseed mea, a n d s o
cover it. Thoge are the things that affect us.
Governor Seay,

I t might g o a little further than that,

and t h a t i s t o c o n s i d e r w h e t h e r

o r n o t b y a n amendment

to

bills o r
the act i t would n o t b e desirable t o have denand
ing

drafts cover /other commodities.
Governor Harding.

O f course i f y o u want t o amend t h e

ACt t h a t i s one thing,
make a

I t i s easier t o get the Board t o

a n d much safer.
regulation t h a n i t i s t o amenathe Act,
Governor O a l k i n s . I

agree with Governor Harding i n

I
his last statement, a n d for that reason

suggest t h a t a

re-

refer—
solution b e adopted, a n d that the other resolution
b e not rescind—
ring t h e matter t o the legislative committee

ed, the status being then ( a e
regulations;

i e Board did not amend the

duty.
t h e legislative committee could d o its

Room and
(Governor Strong returned t o the Gonference

resumed the Chair.)
Under—
The Chairman, Gentlemen, i f I e y interrupt,
the menbers o f this o r Secretary wills h a s n e v e r m e t a l l o f
ganization,

balance
H e i s just publishing t h e call f o r the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

276

of the second Libertys, which have t o be paid off i n Novenber. T h e Treasury has a n extensive orogram ahead o f it.
In view of that fact I thint i t would b e very desirable i f
we could have opnortunity n o w t o hear from him something o f
what h e proposes.

H e will b e i n shortly.

Governor Harding,
man,

L e t u s dispose o f m y motion, «ar. Chair:

I t has been made and seconded.

(.dr. Harrison then read the motion. )

(The motion, having been duly seconded, was unanimously
carried.)
The Chairmen I

have a message j u s t received from wr.

Newton D. Baxer, addressed to mr. Wyatt:
"Jill b e glad t o have Governors’
I appreciate t h e i r

e R

e

e

C a n f e r me
c know that

T i 1 1 arrange

t o g o t o wiinneaL

polis a t a n early date but will await your wire before matting
plans t o meet P a r k e r . "

(Thereupon Under § ecretary Ogden wills entered the
Conference R o o m and a

u t e c d i e s follow:d, t h e Revorter r e

tiring f r o m t h e C o n f e r e n c e R o o m a t t h e d i r e c t i o n o f t h e C h a i r .

V.FISCAL aGzvoy.
AePossible improvements i n method o f allotting Treasury Notes o r Certificates. ( i t h particular reference t o

desirability of reasonably firm district quotas.)
(The discussion o f this subject was opened b y Governor
Norris i n the eosence o f the Reporter, T h e Reporter w a s r e
called t o the Conference R o o m a n d the vroceedings continued

asfollows:)
Governor N,jrris. I

put this topic o n the program f o r the

purvose o f ascertaining whether i t would b e nossible f o r the

Treasury t o eliminate the preferential allotment o n small subscriptions and t o fix a reasonably firm quota for each district.
Governor Fancher.

W e were i n corresvondence w i t h under-

Seoretary Winston i n November o f 1926, T h e y sent a communica—

tion received from the Denuty Governor o f the Kansas City
Bank, t o the other districts, a n d I am sure you received it.
In our reply t o wr. Winston's letter w e wrote very fully a s

to the basis o f the allot nents and the abuses w e had observed,
and all that sort o f thing, T h o s e are about the views o f our
bank a t the present time. I

suggest that they are o n file i n

your office, m r , Secretary.
Under S e c r e t a r y sills. I

Governor Harding,

have t h e m h e r e w i t h me.

W e have a considerable number o f fic-

titious subscriptions handed i n to us at Boston, O y r situation
is a good deal like that o f Governor Norris. I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

was wondering,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

378
+ o want t o have
in view o f the fact that t h e Treasury seems

the individual s u b
popular c i l sevkiins and t o encourage
soriber, i f a certain amount f o r indivifual subscriptions
reserve bank,
could b e set aside a n d forwardeddrectly t o each
get
in addition t o the district quota, a n c i f the banks

individual
shut out o r if there i s any deficiency i n the
~
subscriptions, give the banks their allotments
The Chairman.

W o u l d n ' t t h e y j u s t g e t around that

O n e difficulty
by sending these subscriptions indirectly?
notice
is that i n some o f the districts, n o t i n ours, t h e
for the
of the subscription i s not far enough i n advance
individual subscriptions t o b e made anyway-

a little
Governor Harding, Couldn't t h e notice b e given
further

i n advance?

Under Secretary Mills.

I t i s pretty difficult t o d o

that.
Governor Calkins.

on that ground.

W e h a v e a s rauch c o m p l a i n t

a s anyone

I t i s a fact that i n some cases the notice

of t h e issue does n o t reach a

subscriber until a consider—

been closed.
able time has elapsed after the subscription has
That i s a common s t a n t o n .
Isn't
Governor Norris. D o e s that anount t o anything?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

379
it true that t h e fellow who does not get t h e announcement
would n o t subscribe i f h e d i d g e t it?

The Chairmen I don't xnow about that, Governor Norris.
The Treasury mailing list i s six o r eight hundred thousand
names, w h i c h they g o t f r o m their subscriptions t o Liberty
loans. T h e s e people have received circulars o f every o n e o f
these offerings a n d a very large number o f them have been
received after t h e sale has been concluded; t h e y have sent
in subscriptions w h i c h have h a d t o b e returned.
Governor Calkins. T h e y have sent i n subscriptions a n d
payments.

Governor Fencher. T h i s situation has developed.

Going

back t o the time when t h e small banks h a d subscriptions

from their depositors, w e have some 1900 banks, b u t the fact
are that w e haven't h a d subscriptions f r o m a number o f the

small banks.

W e send the notice t o them, but w e do not

hear f r o m them a t all because anything under four per cent
they a r e n o t i n t e r e s t e d

i n a n d have n o t been interested

in

for a long time. The subscriotions we get now may come from
100 t o 120 banks, a n d going back two o r three years w e
would have them from four o r five o r six hundred banks. V e
attempt t o reach t h e small banks b y wire, a n d I think n o w


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

that i t i s both money a n d effort wasted.

Governor Young, Two or three years ago we had a great
deal o f difficulty with these small subscrribers who would
not g e t t h e notice i n time,

W

e rather adopted a plan,

something along the line suggested b y Governor Harding,
of taxing a hundred o r two hundred thousand i n addition,
and i f some little subscription o f five hundred o r a thous—
and dollars comes i n we taxe care o f it.

W e haven't had t o

do that i n the last year and a half,
Governor Fancher. I

think t h e small b a n h a s passed

out o f the victure i n this matter ~ith regard t o buying low
rate Government certificates»

Governor Oalxins. I

agree t o a certain extent with

Governor Fancher, b u t I think the enall subscriber still e x

ists. T h e r e is throughout the country a considerable nun.
ber o f individual s u b s c r i b e r s w h o s t i l l b u y t h e s e l o w r a t e

government securities i f they have opvortunity,
ther t h a t g r o u p i s o f e n o u g h c o n s e q u e n c e

A s t o whe-

t o m a x e i t desir-

able for the Treasury Department t o permit them t o survive,
or not, I

do not <now. I

think i t i s very doubtful myself,

but i f the Treasury Department does feel that i t ought t o
make offerings which c a n b e availed o f b y these subscribers

381
doing that
to past issues, that t he best opportunity for
the war
4s through some modification o f the conditions o f
loan deposit accounts.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T h a t i s the pest opportunity t h e

Treasury h a s s o far a s I can see.

I n addition t o that I

o f accept
think i t would b e effective t o revise t h e list
able securities v e r y closely.

import—
Governor S e a y , T h a t last suggestion i s the most
ant feature o f it, fron our point o f view.
Governor Young. I

would like t o give you the benefit

of the experience i n uinneapolis o n that proposition,

F o r

Gov
five years we have accepted nothing but United States
i t does not i n ernment securities o n war loan account, a n d

terfere with Rie, subscriptions a t all; not a bit.
Governor Oalkins. I

think that i s probably t h e experi-

all. I
ence o f a great many o f the districts, b u t not

do not

would i n Minn—
think that would w o r k a s well i n New York a s i t
eanolis, f o r instance.
Governor Young, I

just wanted t o give t h e experience that

we have had i n Mynneapolis f o r five years.
Under Secretary Mills. I

fence o f New York.
than anything else.

would like t o hear t h e experi-

Y o u have done more t o eliminate padding


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

382
The Chairman,

‘ W e recognize that these securities

in our district a r e mainly sold t o large banks for the
advantage o f the devnosits, a n d t o some extent t o yery

large corporations who have funds t o invest and who sub—
scribe through their banks, a t the solicitation o f their
bank,

i n arder t o get the benefit o f the deposit,

had s o m e padding,

b u t whenever

W e have

i t has become amparent

we

have tacten i t u p with the bank and I believe i t is almost
entirely eliminated,

It occurred t o me that the experience i n the different
districts varies s o that w e might g e t t w o o r three o f the

banks + 0 send experienced menaver here t o Washington t o
handle this e n d o f i t , i n consultation w i t h ir, Mills! men,
and c o n s i d e r w h e t h e r s o m e r e v i s i o n o f t h e o r e s e n t p r a c t i c e
is n o t desirable.

T h e y could make recommendation

Governor Fancher.’ I
way t o handle it.

o n it.

think that would b e a very practical

I t would b e well for Mr, Mills t o have

the advantage o f the experience o f these men who have lived
devwith these various issues f o r s o m e years a n d «now all the
lopments, s h o r t cuts a n d abuses that have sprung up.

Governor Harding, I

think Governor Young has indicat—

ed a solution o f this thing.

I n the Federal Reserve Bank o f

383
Boston, f o r instance, t h a t bank got the entire subscription
for i t s o m m account, a n d i t resulted i n i t s getting a

timate 350,000,

legi-

O u t o f that allotment w e could take care

of the legitimate, bona fide small subscriber.
Under Secretary willis,

W o u l d y o u compel t h e individual

subscriber t o deal directly with the Federal Reserve Bank?
Governor Harding, N o t necessarily, b u t t o investigate
it a n d find o u t i f i t was a legitimate proposition, a n d then
send i t t o them a t cost.
We followed exactly t h e vractice t h a t Governor Young referred to, ‘ T e used t o take a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

few hundred thousand o f these

to meet legitimate small subscriptions, b u t w e have stooped
doing that because w e have n o t a n y more calls,

The Cyairman. S u p p o s e the practice was changed t o this
extent, that the Treasury, i n its next circular, i n a rather
prominent way, possibly o n @ separate niece o f vaper, n o t i f y
everybody - — putting i t i n the cireulars going t o the banks
as well, t h a t t h e r e q u i r e m e n t

f o r a

fairly short n o t i c e

on

o
“ the subscriptions could not b e changed, b u t that
closingf
by
arrangements h a d been made w i t h the Federal reserve banks
which a moderate f u n d o f these certificates would b e taxen b y
the r e s e r v e b a n k s e n d t h e s m a l l s u b s c r i b e r s m o u l d b e a l l o t t e d

334
out o f that amount

i n the order i n which applications were

received.

the
Under Secretary Mylls. T h e n n y o u would eliminate

class?
small subscribers entirely, those of the thousand dollar
Governor Norris.

I t would c u t o u t t h e preferential a l -

fotment t o than .
Under Secretary mills. Y e s , c u t i t out entirely.
pracGovernor Norris. Y e s , because the small subscriber
a n d t h e only effect

tically d o e s n o t exist,

o f t h e preferen-

a big bunch
tial allotment i s to make the bank that wants
units, inofthem enter its subscriptions i n thousand dollar


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

a million or
stead of sending i n a single subscription for
five million, o r whatever i t wants.
Under Secretary Mills. I

think i t would b e a mistake t o

Inother
admit officially that that class does not exist.
words, I

f o r the
think i t rould b e a n unfortunate position

securities a r e n o w
Treasury t o take sind. that t h e Government
simply b a n k investments,

Governor Norris.
The Chairman.

I t i s not necessary t o admit i t a t all,

the
W h y not c l a i m that i t exists, t h a t

a n d that this
Treasury wants t o encourage i t s development,
means i s being employed t o d o it?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

335
Governor Fancher. I

t h i n k i n s o m e cases, p e r h a p s t h e

prompt closing
email sibecriber h a s bean discouraged b y the
of t h e offer.

H

e g e t s h i s n o t i c e a n d then, p e r h a p s b e f o r e

he gets t h e notice f r a m us, i n some cases,

h e gets official

and
notice mailed t o h i m that t h e off’em h a s been closed

he thinks"what

i s the use; I do not have opportunity, W e

have done a s the other banks have done.

W e have taken a few

thousand t o take care of our small subscriptions, i n order
to keep t h e small banks s a t isfied.

Governor Wellvorn,

I n the Atlanta District we do not

certain times
think m u c h o f making district quotas because a t
we c a n take more t h a n w e c a n a t others. “ B y s i n e s s conditions

vary.
Under Secretary Mills. I

think that w a s o n e o f the prin-—

ciple reasons which’ led t o the abandonment

o f the former

system which existed, a s I understand, until 1922.

T h e chang

thorough study.
was made i n view o f experience a n d efter v e r y

Governor Wellborn.

W e made a special effort t o get the

came into the
individual subscribers and a great many o f them
bank and subscribed,

Governar Norris.
Governor Wellborn,

T o 3-1/8 and 3-1/4 securities?
Y e s , sir.

586

Nolen Remrdtaty Mills. D i d you take eare o f the indivi-

dual subscriptions aiong the line suggested b y Governor Young?
Governor Wellborn, Y e s .

W e made a special effort t o

take care o f the individual subscribers.

O f oourse some o f

the individual subscriptions, f r o m corporations, come through

the banks themselves, from customers that have surplus funds
they want t o use i n that way, T h e present method i s satisfac
tory i n our district.

Governor Seay. T h e only effect of these various sugges

tions to restrict the subscriptions would be to. greatly re
duce t n e volume o f these apparent bona f i d e subscriptions,

as i t now stands, I take i t that that i s not only misleading
but harmful.

Governor Ngrris. Yes.

I t ig a clear evidence of the

absurdity o f the situation when a n issue i s four o r five times

afterwards i s

oversubscribed, and then for weeke/offered around at a dis.
count,

Governor Wellborn, D o n ' t you think the last offer will
rather correct that abuse?
Governor Norris.

T h e result o f the last offer will b e to

make i t easier t o get a correction o f this situation now than
it has ever been before, b u t I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

do not think i t will i n itself


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

entirely cure it unless there i s some action,
The Chairman H e r e i s a suggestion o f a solution.

Sup-

pose Governor Harding, Governor Norris, Governor Fancher,
and w e i n N e w York, d e s i g n a t e a

man,

i f t h e Treasury de-

sires it, a n d have those m e n a t t h e call o f the Treasury

to attend ta* meeting here, discuss the matter with the
men i n the Treasury and handle this matter.

W i l l that b e

satisfactory?
Under Secretary wills, T h a t will b e satisfactory.
Governor Calkins.

M i r . Chairman , there i s another topic

that w e might include with that. ‘ p e y i s i o n o f Treasury Department Circular No. 9 8 i s directly related.
Governor Talley,

I s i t t h e understanding that there

would b e p u b l i c i t y g i v e n b y t h e T r e a s u r y t o t h e f a c t t h a t

the Federal reserve banks w o u l d guarantee allotments o f

small subscriptions?
The Chairman.

N o , there would not b e anything o f the

sort.
Governor T a l l e y ,

I t was sugzested a

moment a g o t o p u t

an extra sheet i n the circular t o the effect that t h e banks
would t a k e c a r e o f them,

The Chairman, Y e s , but they would only be allotted i n

388

e.hT be 70 different
the order of their r e c e t p t e.rwould
rule p o p lied t o the original offer.
i c a

3 ‘Governor calc ine. L i r e

I

would like t o ask
Tepre-

include, with, S e e
wabhies i t would H o t b e Ten izacte t o

c o s e ’ .

sentatives t o meet here a

o f s o m e more remote

you have
benk, ‘aaviek a somewhat different situation than

e

“heret i


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

e 3

pomne y e s s
“the oneizaan, i f you c a n set h e n t o
‘Wocuecee Galtine.

b e glad
o t think Gevereut ‘Talley. would

to s e n d a ‘man,

b
l to send some. one
‘Governor Talley. Y e s , we w i el glad

igMt 46 desired.
Geveee

vp

Fancher.

o

man.
W e w e e be glad t o send a

Boston,
Then i t will be understood that

a

dePhiladelphia, Cleveland, Dallas and New York, if it is
sired,

t o a send men et t h e coe

o f the Under Secretary, of

>

the t r ents
| a oeathoy b

e

T h e n thet “will a l s o include, I

suppose,

a aipouseion o f + he revision o f dicular 92,
The Chairman,

Yes.

N e might suggest t o the Under bea.

call he give ample time for
retary now that i n sending his
a statement o f the
preparation of the data and should include

matter t o de discussed,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Under Secretary ills.

H o w mich time d o y o u think

should b e allowed?
The Chairman, Y e l l , considering t h e distance f r o m Dallas, I

should s a y about t e n days will b e suffi cient.

Governor Talley.

T h e notice t o reach u s ten days be-

fore t h e d a y o f the meeting.
The Chairman,

I

s there anything e l s e that w e “ish t o

discuss with wir. sigl1ls?

W e have taken u p @ lot o f his time,

alWe have o n the program a discussion that the conference
ways h a s i t h t h e Treasury Currency Committee,

o f which air,

Dewey i s Chairman...
Under Secretary Mills.

H e i s away today, b u t I think h e

will b e here tomorrow.

The Chatrman. W e coulidiscuss the topic | . III-C.
III. C O I N , CURRENCY a N D CIRCULATION.
CG. Future Currency Program.
Has the time approached t o consider i n anticipation
held t o
some program a s t o the two per cent gonsols n o w

secure national bank note circulation?
The Chairman,

I n connection with the discussion o f our

the pos sibility
portfolio situatiog t h e question came u p a s t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

390
of t h e T r e a s u r y f i n d i n g m e a n s

o f carrying o u t t h e real pur-

pose o f the Federal Reserve A c t i n retiring national bank

notes, which would a d d a great deal t o the portfolio o f the
reserve banks,

7 5 million twos can be called now, a n d the

reme.ining 5 0 0 million c a n b e called i n 19350.
There seem t o b e two o r three important questions.

T h e

first one is that effect will i t have o n the banks with regard t o their right t o issue currency i n these national bank

notes.

I t ig one of their privileges. Another question

has t o d o with the handling o f the igsued currency required
to t a k e t h e p l a c e o f a

national b a n k note, b e c a u s e w e a r e

now deprived o f the means o f issuing Federal Reserve b a n k

notes eauake tne lapse o f time. T y e opportunity t o acquire
Act
500 millions o f twos for that purpose has pesdedjand the
contains n o provision b y which thet operation i s cumulative.
There are difficulties i n connéction w i t h that, T h e r e i s

the diffioult y of the Treasury issuing higher rate securi-

ties and increasing the debt held b y the public i n arder t o
Banks.
retire t h e two per cent bonds h e l d b y the National

T h o

are the three principal difficulties, I think.
The Tpeasury i s now at work o n the technical arrangement
that
for the retirement o f the twos i n case i t i s decided

391
should b e done.

B y t the chief question i s t o find out what

will b e the reaction o f the national banks.

T h e r e i s a con-

cern i n Washington that i s opposed t o the retirement o f
national ban: notes a n d they a r e agitating t h e question
among t h e n a t i o n a l banks.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

What would b e the feeling o f the National Banks i n your
country, Governor Young, about retiring the national bank
notes?
Governor Young.

‘ i t h t h e larger banks I

d o not think

it would make any differece a t all, because they haven't
any circulation,

o r a very small amount,

It i s t r u e t h a t t h e s m a l l e r o a n k s

i f they have any.

l i k e t h e circule tion,

regardless o f whether t h e y maxe money o n i t o r not.

I t may

be a case o f the officers lixing their n a m e o n the bill, I

don't “now.

A t all events they d o like it, and you would get

some criticism, I think, f r o m the smaller banks. H o w e v e r ,
it i s an issue that w e have t o a g e a t some time and I think
we should face i t now while the going i s good.
Governor Harding. T h e great majority o f the banks would
not c a r e a n y t h i n g a b o u t i t .

A s a

matter

o f fact I

supnose o n l y

about half of t h e m have eny circuletion now. Byt, a s sir. Young
says, s o m e o f them think very highly o f t h e orivilege. I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

393

of a
heard o f a case not very long ago where the president
in Maine

u o a t the
little national ban's/came down t o Boston and put

form. H e
hotel. H e brought with him some currency in sheet
and
had had the cashier sign i t but did not sign i t himself
he
did not cut them. H e put those i n his vocket, a n d when
went t o pay his bill h e asked the clerk + o give him a pen,
and h e signed t h e currency a n d handed { ° 3 u .
The Chairman,

‘ T h a t about y o u r bank, Governor Nellborn?

Governor Yellporn. I
“much d i f f e r e n c e

do not think i t would make very

t o t h e banks.

S , m e o f t h e smaller banks

wuld rather
probably look upon i t a s an advertisement a n d
there will
that i t be not discontinued, b u t I do not think
be any serious o b jection o n their part,

Governor Seay. A

considerable number o f the small banks,

I think, Mr, Chairman, would object, not s o much because of

distinction
the deprivation of income, but because of the
money.
they appear t o think it gives them to be able to issue

believe there
Onthe part of the larger banss 1 do not
would b e a n y objection.
Governor Calkins. I

have t h e s a m e report.

S

o far a s

voluge i s concerned there would b e no considerable objection.
any

t h a t i t was
o f t h e smaller banks m o u l d t a k e t h e position


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

393
them. Horfever, s o far a s the 7 5
wga
s o m e t h i ynafrom

taxing

million are concerned, I think i t i s timeto begin.
Governor Biggs. I

concur i n the position taken b y G o w

ernor Calxins and Governor Seay, 1

think the larger banks

will not care, but the smaller banks would, although not all
of them.
Governor Talley. T h e chief value that t h e banks attach

to the circulation privilege i s that o f advertising. T h e r e
would b e some kick from the small banks which have not amortized their premium o n circulation bonds.

S o m e o f the larger

banks h a v e a n idea they make a little vrofit o u t o f it.
There m a y b e some mild renonstrance f r o m them, i t y idea i s

that i t should b e done, because national bank circulation i s
just a fifth wheel o n the currency mchine, a n d that i s all
there i s t o it.
The Chairman. Yes, a n d very expensive.

Governor Talley,

I t becomes s o difficult i n our district

that w e have refused t o take a n y c i r c u l a t e d notes i n from
menber banks — —
The Chairman, T h e r e is: great d i f f i q lty i n getting t h e m
in circulation.
Governes Talley, Y e s , sir.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Fancher. I

think very little objection

will come from the larger banks,

I n fact many of our larger

banks have circulation now only i n a small emount.

But

there would b e some objection f r o m the smaller banks o n ac-

count o f the quite substantial profit. T n e n there i s the
advertising feature o f it. T h e y feel that i t would b e some-

for
thing taken away from then that they had been doing
some years, I

think w e could very easily test t h e situa.

dollars
tion b y & vrogram that would taxe in the 75 million

that c a n be called now. I think after we had started a orocirculation
gram t o absorb those and reduce the national bahk
we could then chart a pretty clear course a s to what t o do
with a lerge program.

Governor Norris. : ir. Cheirman, I

would only repeat

statements that have already been made.

Governor .icDougal, M r . Cpairman, I am sure that the
small banks f i n d a lot o f satisfaction i n this currency issue

privilege. I

do not know how the larger banks feel about 4t

or how i t affects then.
Governor Bailey,

I n our district I think the change has

been discounted anyway,
act a n d f r o m a l l t h o s e I

I t w a s the purnose o f the original
have t a l k e d t o I

have l e a r n e d t h a t


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

395
the t e n d e n c y h a s a l r e a d y b e e n t o discount i t .

O f course,

these little fellows who lixe t o write their name o n it
might object, but that would b e incidental and I do not
think there would b e any adverse reaction a t all,
The C h a i r m a n I

in our district. I

do not t h i n k there would b e much X i c k

a m certain that t h e larger banks would

make no objection. T h e president o f one of the larger banks
said t o me, when I asked him about it, that they are waiting
for t h e t h i n g t o h a n p e n anyway.

f this matter was had, which the
(Further discussion o
Reporter w a s directed n o t t o take, a t the conclusion o f which
Under Secretary Mills retired f r o m the Conference Room. )
The Chairman. N o w , g e n t l e m e n , I

have p r o m i s e d

t o make

some progress o n this Open wiarket Committee revort. I

think

if the committee h a d a very brief meeting n o w i t would b e i n
a position imnediately after luncheon t o submit t h e commit—
tee!s repor t

e could then a s k t h e
before the C o n f e r e n c e . W

Federal Reserve Board t o meet w i t h t h e committee i n t h e
course o f the afternoon,

(hereuvon, a t 12:35 o'clock p.m., upon motion duly
seconded, t h e Conference recessed until 2 o'clock p.m. o f
the same day.)


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

CcHSS.
The Conference reassembled pursuant t o recess,

at

o'clock p.m.
The Chairman, T h e meeting will kindly come t o order.

Before taxing u p the Open warkxet Committee Teport suppose w e take u p the next item o n the program, which can b e
taken u o i n Mr. Dewey's absence, a n d that i s "Proposed Revi-

sion o f the Federal Reserve Board Regulations 4 A , " which will
involve considerable discussion.

Governor Calkins. Have not all the banks been asked t o

submit suggestions direct to the Federal Reserve Board, and
have not they done so?

The Chairman I

imagine 80>

Governor Fancher.

i r s Chairman, I will make a motion

that the Conference recomme,ds t o the Board that, i f agree—
able, a committee from the operating staff o f some o f the
Federal Reserve Banks b e asked ceetgist t h e counsel o f the
Board i n giving consideration t o the suggested amendment t o
the Board's regulations,

t o put i n definite shape m o d i f i c a

tions o r amendments t o the regulations, a n d that i n that form
these m o d i f i c a t i o n s a n d a m e n d m e n t s

b e submitted b a c k t o the

Reserve banks for final consideration, after taxing into ac-

397
b y the various
count a l l suggestions that have b e e n offered
reserve banks.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Talley, I

will second that motion.

(The motion, having been duly seconded, was unanimously
carried.)
The Chairman,
by N e w York.

T h a t c a n b e referred t o the committee a n d not

discussed here.
rather a

L e t u s take Tonic 1V-0, which was suggestec

I t does relate t o regulations, b u t i t i s

domestic question w i t h us.

IV. O P U R A T I O N a N D ADMINISTRATION.

C. R e g u l a t i o n relating t o method o f commuting member
bank reserves f o r penalties.

The Chairman. Unless some one wants t o discuss this generally,

i t will b e passed a n d referred t o this committee.

Governor Young.

o l f . Chairnan

d i d I see somewhere

b e figthat N e w York h a d madé a suggestion that t h e reserves

ured over night?
The Chairman W o , w e never made that suggestions although
the Board understood something w e did say as implying that.
What w e did say was this:

T h a t i n the Oentral Reserve

cities o f Chicago a n d N e w York t h e computation o f reserves
re—
and t h e imputation o f penalties b y the present method

398

is imsulted in a very distorted picture, inaemuch as it
i n Chicago t o adjust
possible for the bank i n New York and

its reserve every day because the most of the payments they
reserve
receive are i n clearing house funds that are not
funds until the next day, W e suggested that two continuous
i n penalties, a n d that
days o f impaired reserve would result

the banks would be required t o pay for three days instead


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

of one.

you. ‘
Governor Young, I can pass this suggestion o n to
in
do not know whether you can use i t or not. T h e spread
dolMinneavolis i s always between five and seven million
lars betwee Tuesday and Wednesday,

T h e banks all cover

banks i n
on Wednesday, a n d w é just take eight o f the large
reserve
Minneapolis and St. Paul, and w e have o n e figure the
Thursday a n d

n
a
w we cut the
Tuesday, another Wednesday, another/Friday, d
spread about two million dollars. t

do not know whether

can divide your
that i s vossible f o r C h i c a g o o r not, b u t y o u

banks u p four ways.

Young,
The Chairman, I t is a good suggestion, Governor
S o “any o f them.
It would b e difficult because there are
Governor Young,

I t wouldn't make any difference t o

399
them o n what d a y they settled.

I

h
t situat has c o r r e c t e d e

o f it,
tion somewhat i n our district but hasn't corrected all
The Cnairmen,

T h e understanding i s that all the c o m

ments b y the different banks o n the proposed draft o f regula-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

tions will b e sent b y each reserve bank t o Mr. Harrison,
excepting those that h a v e already h a n d e d :them.

Ne can g o ahead now with the report o f the Open Market
Committee.
This report i s submitted a s the recomnendation o f the

have advised Governor Crissinger

Open Market Committee. I

that some time after t w o o'clock this afternoon w e would

like t o have a meeting with the Board, that this committee
wants t o submit t h i s report t o the Board.
at—
Governor Calkins. T h e first paragraph refers t o the

tachedmemorandum.
The Chairman.

I s that memorandum t o be attached?
T y a t i s & memc andum which y o u gentl emer

just gave pack t o Mr. Harrison, a n d it i s being mimeographed,
Governor Calkins.

W e will get that layer.

The Opairman. Y e s .

W e had all the drafts returned t o

(ir. Harrison because o f the changes made i n the final draft.
They d o not amount t o m c

but I

went t o b e sure that y o u

all have t h e yvroper copies.
t o offer
Now, gentlemen, h a v e y o u comments t h a t y o u wish


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

400

with regard t o the recommendations “in this report?
committee offered this a s its v

e

T h e

after
r t ‘judgment,
y
s e. b

discussion w i t h
“quite a good deal of, discussign and. after

the Federal Reserve Boards « 0 5

3Guecruiet Calkins. T h e question comes up whether we
elpbor-—
are to discuss merely . this memorandum. or ‘the much more
ate memorandimn to be attached...
. ‘ T h e Onetmman.

office
T h e firet document prepared i n the

in e w York was saberited =

b e the Committeels report.

I t

did nit aretine se. iareteen ane m e a s being the method that

was best designed to deal with this situation, because it did
8 0 instead o f prenot g o into the subject thoroughly enough,
the committee w e prepared a
paring a draft o f t h e report o f
that t o
memorandum a s t o the present situation a n d submitted

o f it t o the Boarc
the Committee, submitted a preliminary draft
o f the report
“fer Acequaeion ae. shh basis o f the preparation
t h e recommendations
ar t h e Oommittee, w h i c h m o u l d c o n t a i n

of the Comittee.

n
o recomnendaT h e memorandum c o n t a i n e d ‘

tions at h l n o suggestions that anything should be done,
a s certain
but w a s simply a statement o f what w e regarded

facts upon which the Committee would base its report. T h e
a n d you will a l l
report will b e attached t o the memorandum

401
have i t and the committee i s going ahead a n d considering
t h e question o f
some o f the possibilities o f dealing w i t h
| the retire—
the portfolio, s u c h a s w e discussed this morning
ment o f national b a n k notes.

Governor Seay, I
that w o u l d c o v e r w h a t I

did not catch that expjanation, a n d
h a d i n mind. I

notice t h a t i n t h i s

sales o f
report i t makes a recommendation that n o further
system securities b e made.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman.

I % does not make that.

the report.)
Governor Seay, (Governor Seay quoted from
matter.
The Chairman, That i s 8 very different
already s o l d i s
Governor Seay-e T h e amount o f securities

about fifty~odd million?
The Chairman,

6 3 or 6 4 million,

o n l y t o offset g o l d
Governor Seay, T h o s e sales a r e not

b u t t o a certain
importations which had already taken place,
forward?
extent thee which were ‘nown t o be coming
fhe Chaiman.
memorandum.

N o , the figures are all contained i n the

to
S o m e 6 8 millions I think w e sold i n order

pay f o r gold which remains i n London.

London remains
Governor Seay. I f the gold purchased i n
h e r e w h i c h n e e d s t o b e o f fi.
there i t c a n h a v e n o effect o v e r

met, can it?

i

The bi i n c a

e

t

e tay

T s o u l d i f we pay for i t by giving. our

menbéer banks -a credit, b u t t f w e pay for i t b y giving t h e n
jaomeethas o u t o f our Ppuettorie,:; A f

a t e r iii see it, to u s e

a feahionanie phrase. N o w , of course, i f we eetd that, as
I said this morning you get paid in deers for it. T h a t
would take back out of the marxet the credit which would have
been p u t i n a s i t ngghved a n d enable iaieh puy back t h e 6 0
3 million ‘securities whioh were turned over t o the banks t o
pay for it, :

4

-

Governor Calxins.

W h e n Under A c c é h n e e

iss

came in

4

tt
upon an explanation, onwhich
a b o ouembark

Mr, Hartison was

ae x
he was’ cut. off.

I s that what y o u are now asking him t o ex.

plain?The Chairman. 1

do riot think Governor S e a y really g o t

the full details of exactly what this gold movement amounted
“¢o and how it was handled.’
Mr. Harrison. The diffioulty is that the full story about
the gold movenent has been told only t o the Open Market Investment Committee andnot t o the whole Conference.
The Chairman, T h e whole story i s in the memorandum,
Mr. Harrison.
cerned,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

S o far as the effect o n the market i s con—

i f the Federal Reserve B a n k o f N e w York buys g o l d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

403
and pays for i t i n dollars, i t i s quite insignificant a s
or
a-matter o f fact whether w e hold the gold i n New York
in London.
asked
Governor Seay, That.is true, b u t t h e question I
is have y o u already done that?

Mr.-.Harrison.
happens i s this:

W e have actually paid for it. W h a t
O n arecent date w e got advice fron the

Bank o f England that: they were holding approximately 6 0

the
million dollars for credit for our account, o n order o f
Bank o f Fpancee

a t the same time we got instructions from

the Bank o f France t o pay for that gold b y crediting their
got another
account a n equivalent amount o f dollars. Then w e

60 milinstruction fran the Bank of France to please invest
w e had t o de.
lion dollars i n securities, a n d a t that point
cide whether w e wanted t o o t e e t

i n securities o n the market

own securities.
or whether w e wanted 4 s Y a d Rice some o f our
unknomm s o
Governor Seay, T h a t was t h e fact that w a s
far a s I a m concerned.

T h a t h a s not been done?

Mx. Harrison. Yes, that was completed on May Oth,
were
Governor Seay, T h o s e sediniicie that were sold
sold practically t o the Bank o f Francs.

Mir, Harrison. That is right, on May 6th. Entirely


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

404
apart f r o m that particular transaction o f 6 0 million d o l —
lars i n gold that w e bought a n d “ept i n “hendionton, there

were other shipments o f gold that had already been des—

patched under a contract between the Bank of France and a
member bank i n New York, which were sold t o us by the mem-

ber bank in New York, and the proceeds o f which we had to
invest upon order o f the Bank of France just exactly as we
in:
had invested the proceeds o f the gold which w e bought.London,
The total amount o f investments o u t o f the proceeds o f

gold which was actually s hipped t o us, about nine million

dollars, I have not the figures before me on that. T h e
total reduction o f the holdings o f the System o n account
of this Bank o f France gold transaction t o date has been
about 6 8 millions o f dollars.

T h e r e i s another shipment

of s i x m i l l i o n d o l l a r s w h i c h a r r i v e s

i n N e w Y o r k today,

the proceeds o f which will b e paid t o a member bank f o r t h e
account o f the Bank o f France.

T h e n w e will g e t instruc-

tions f r o m the Bank o f France t o invest t h o s e proceeds i n

securities, a n d under this resolution o r recommendation
which t h e Open Market Investment Committee h a s finally adopt—

ed, instead o f selling the securities t o the Bank o f France
out o f o u r i n v e s t m e n t a c c o u n t

w e will g o o u t i n t o t h e market

and p u r c h a s e t h e m f o r then.

Governor Fancher.

T h a t will i n effect m e a n that t h e

gold h a s found i t s w a y into t h e open market a n d there will
have been that m u c h added.
Mr. Harrison,

T h a t i s right.

I n other words,

by

having gone into t h e open market instead o f going t o our investment account w e have not sterilized it. T h e r e isn't

much more coming now, about 1 7 million after this s i x million.
Governor Calkins. a

matter w h i c h Mr. H a r r i s o n a p o r o a c h -

ed, but did not finish, owing t o the arrival o f the Under Secretary, w a s some discussion i n regard t o the participation

by the banks i n the holding o f gold abroad.
iv. Harrison,

A s I explained,

w e purchased bars o f

gold a t bar value, t h e mint value o f which was approximately
$59,700,000,

W e paid for that gold a n amount approximately

$210,000 less than the mint value o f it and we credited that
$210,000 t o suspense account.

W h a t will happen t o it will

depend o n what happens t o the gold, a t what price w e sell

the gold.

B y t the thing that the men i n New York are very

anxious t o decide u p o n n o w i s whether o r not various other
Federal reserve banks w i s h t o participate i n the purchase o f
the gold which i s being e a r marked i n London.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

406
Governor Young-

D o you want u s t o participate?

Governor Galkias.. Iy,asmuch a s the other banks -——
The Chairman,

J u s t a moment.

L e t u s answer Gover—

nor Young's question first, which is?
Governor Young, D o e s Nee York want the other Federal
reserve banks t o participate?
The Chairman,

W e want t h e m t o u s e t h e i r o w n j u d g m e n t

about i t , : Governor Bailey. W h a t would you advise u s to do? W e
usually follow your smoke.

Governor Young. P e r h a p s I didn't put the inquiry i n
the manner i n which I should have put it.

The Chairman | L e t me tell the story, and then you
can ask the question.

Governor Young.

L e t m e correct m y question a little

bit. W h a t I want t o tnow is whether i t i s too much account—
ing trouble for New York.

The Chairman, O h , no, I t goes further than that.
Governor Young, A l l right, I

will recommend t o our

people that w e participate.

The Chairman, T h e real point i s this: W h e n wé paid
a n interest,
sy
for this. gold b y taking y o u r s e c u r i t ir eotook


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

407
but i f you d o not participates i n the sale o f the gold,

if

there i s any profit i n it, w e would get all the profit.
It i s only progr aucfair that y o u should participate i n

that.

I f we are iucky w e might make a couple o f hundred

thousand dollars o n it and i t ought t o be divided up. I f
you d o not want t o b e bothered with i t o r think there i s
@ chance o f not selling a t a profit w e would t a k e it.

M y

best judgment i s t hat w e are not going t o lose anything
on i t but that

w e will make a

Governor Young, I

nice little profit.

am not going into i t for profit, b u t

I a m gradually getting educated t o some o f these foreign
transactions a n d I will b e glad t o recommend t o our people
that w e gointo it.

The Cpairman. I f we can sell this for dollars today at
substantially t h e mint price ebroad,

o r anything like it, w e

would make that yrofit.
Governor McDougal. I s n ' t i t true that w e are already
participating i n this? H a v e n o t t h e securities b e e n i n
effect delivered a n d each bank charged accordingly?

ix. Harrison. I

cannot vouch for it, but the book.

keeping that should have taken place e t t h e moment h a s been
that y o u h a v e k e e n c r e d i t e d w i t h t h e p r o g e e d s

o f the sales

408
of securities.

N o w the question i s whether y o u want t o

give back that c r e d i t a n d take o n e i n London.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Harding.

O u r officers meet next Wednesday.

if there i s a n sAtciedind

i d e will let m e get back for

that time I will recommend t h a t w e take o u r participation.

The Chairman,

W e can carry i t for a week i n our a c

count.

iy. Harryson.

T h e only advantage i n doing this a t

once, i f w e are t o d o it, i s this;
matter

o f considerable c o m m e n t

I t t s going t o b e a

i n the newspapers w h e n i t

is disclosed that there i s a n increase i n the gold holdings

abroad amounting to some sixty millions of dollars, and if
we d o i t a t once t h e N e w York statement w o u l d b e the only

one which would show a n inerease i n gold abroad.
Governor Harding.
mr. Harrison.

W h e n d o y o u make that statement?

Today.

Governor Harding,

I f it will help matters any, with

the understanding that, i n the very improbable event that
the Directors should turn me down o n this, I will take the
participation now.
Governor Norris.
Governor Fancher.

a n d I will.
Y e s o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governer Young, I

ir. Harrison.
you a r e n o t i n a

will take a chanoe,

W e can agree t o buy back any gold that

p o s i t i o n t o take.

Governor Norris.

W e are in a position todo it. 1

have always participated i n every foreign account. I

do not

think there i s a shadow o f doubt b u t what o u r directors will

approve it, b u t I have always given them a n opportunity
to pass o n it.

Mr. Harrison. ‘Thete is only one factor that might
be considered, a n d that i é whether any one o f the reserve
banks has got a reserve position that might i n any way b e

affected substantially and where i t might b e their best judg
ment t o keep out o f the participation.
Governor McDougal,

I t seems t o me t h e banks ought t o

be notified o f what i s going t o take place because i t will
affect our statements.
Mig. Harrison. W i t h t h e authority o f t h e Conference I

will have the New York Bank participate the total amount o n

the usual basis and advise each Federal reserve bank that —
that h a s been d o n e a n d mention that t h e action h a d the approval o f the Governors! Conference.

Governor w m Dougal.

W e can report this t o our boards


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

410

I t will be all right, and it seems to

when the time comes.

me i t i s identical w i t h what w e have been doing.

The Gpairman. Quite. T h i s i s 4 sort o f emergency situation a n d w e had t o act a s promptly a s possible.

W e realiz

ed i n New York that i f any reserve bank felt a reluctance
to carry some part o f their gold abroadawhere i t would not
count a s reserve w e would have t o take i t over; b u t unless
we had acted a t once w e would have hadnall that g o l d over
here with little likelihood o f getting i t o u t again,

W e

conferred with t h e committee b y telephone a m i they a l l agreed

to do it as a committee protedure.

W e took it Up with the

Federal Reserve Board and told them exactly what the s i t u a

tion was and that it might work out very happily with a
profit.
got a

I f we can short cut the gold over there w e have

chance t o make a profit.

Governor Seay ,

I s this gold in the form of American

bars, Governor Strong?
The Chairman,

N o t a l l o f it.

S o m e o f i t i s i n South

African bars and some British bars. There i s some little coin,
I do not knov h o w much,
gold value.

W e have bought i t all at its fine

O f course there isn't a

very large amount o f

coin, b u t t o the extent that there i s coin there w e probably

411
tender

value and make
Will b e able t o dispose o f i t at its legal
a profit there.
about t h e
Now the question i s how t h e Conference feels

Committee's recommendations i n this document.
Governor Young, I

move its approval,

I
The Chairman. P e r h a p s a s a menber o f the canumittee
should m o v e i t s approval.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Young. T h e n I will second it.
unanimously
(The motion, having been duly seconded, was
carried, )

b y New
The Chairman, The next topic is D, suggested
Mdfadden bill.
York and Minneapolis, having t o do with the
a
Each district h a s been asked t o submit

report a s t o the

districts o f
effect tpon branch banking i n the different
the passage o f the weFad ten Bill.

IV. OPERATION A N D ADMINISTRATION.

D.M@addcen Bill, (H.R. 2 )
banking i n the
1. E f f e c t s o f McFad?%en bill o n branch

asked t o submit a
different districts. (Each district i s
report.)

into national
9.-Prospects of State banks converting
( E a c h district
banks i n view o f terms o f McFadcen bill.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

is asked t o submit a report.)

3, A r e there any other questions requiring discussion
which are raised b y enactment o f udadcen bill?

w have no branch
Governor Bailey, Mr. C h a i r m a n , e
banks i n our district.

Governor e

n

I a w i l l report i n a moment.

Govern N o r r i s . W i l l you please pass m e for a moment?
Governor Fancher.

I n some parts o f our district, parti-

cularly in Ohio, they permit branch benking. However, i t
seams a little early yet to tell just what effect the passage o f the McFadden A c t has had.

W e have h a d only o n e

and
application for a branch ; from a bank i n Cincinnati,
the
that raises the question now a s to interpretation o f

act as to city limits. I t is pretty squarely up to the Board
surrounded b y
to intérpret i t beoause i t i s almost entirely

the city o f Cincinnati and really within the corporate limits
o f the act.
It will b e necessary t o interpret that pro vision
t o national
fle have had n o state banks that have converted
banks.

re—
I t i s a little early t o note t h e effect b o t h with

state banks
gard t o branch banking a n d also with regard t o
taking o u t national bank charters,
well
Governor Bailey, Y o u are discussing Topic I I a s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

as Topic 1 ?

Governor Fancher.

Y e s , sir.

Governor Bailey,

W e are going t o get some additions

4%. 4
to the National bank system a s @ result o f

dasrow of

i s going t o
two cases where they had a savings bank: which
i s doing t h e same
convert t o a national bank a n d another o n e
thing o r contemplating it.

N e have h a d more inquiries since

t o taking
the bill was passed b y state banks with regard
out charters than w e had before.

Gevernor iicDougal.

only
I n regard t o topic 1, there i s

which permits
one o f o u r States i n the Sefenth District

branch baniing.

has
W e have not seen that this bill

o f Michigan, except
had a n y noticeable effect i n the State
h a s been a
some inguiry a s t o some points involved. T h e r e

there, having for
lot o f discussion and some inquiries out
the advisab—
their basis the determination o f the question o f
National banks.
11437 S t converting State banks i n t o

O n e

but I do not
or two large banks have been considering it,
know o f any steps that have b e e n taken definitely.

Governor Norris.

I n New Jersey, i n anticipation o f

the MicFadden bill passing, they passed an act providing for
worked
branch banking and i t i s being very satisfactorily


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

414
out b y a system o f cooperation petween t h e State bagking

department and the Comptroller's office. I
details o f it, a n d I

do not know the

haven't h a d o p p o r t u n i t y t o l e a r n them,

but I know i t i s being worked out i n a very satisfactory
and cooperative way.

At the last session of the Pennsylvania Legislature,
which closed a few weeks ago, they passed a bill which,
while i t i s i n the f o r m o f a bill prohibiting branch bankp

ing, actually legalizes and authorizes and permits i t in
those cities where banks have heretofore maintained branches o r branch offices,

I t i s practiced i n Delaware,

in

Pennsylvania t o a limited extent, and in New Jersey gener—
ally,

I t will result i n extending the operations o f estaby

lished banks through the opening o f branches.

As to the second inquiry, i n some sections of the district, particularly thae where there i s a large foreign population, t h e national banks are i n much better standing

than the State instuttons, and i n those sections w e expect
to get some conversions; and further, when a national and

state institution consolidates, we should now expect to see
under
a greater number o f consolidated institutions continuing
the n a t i o n a l charters.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

415
Governor Talley,

h a v e areport here,

M r . Chairman, T

but t h e effect o f the McFadden A c t will b e 6 0 unimportant
in the Eleventh District t h a t I

d o not believe i t i s o f

sufficient consequence t o take u p the time o f the Conference.
Governor Biggs.

T h e present s

os
banking
t a tf ubranch

in the Eighth District i s a s follows:
Branches a r e p r o h i b i t e d

b y statute

i n Arkansas,

none a r e i n operation b y member banks.
Branches a r e prohibited b y statute i n Tilinois, a n d none
State
are i n operation b y member banks i n that part o f the
included i n District No. 8 .
Branches a r e prohibited b y statute i n Indiana, a n d none
part o f
are none a r e i n operation b y member banks i n that
the State included i n the Bighth District.

In Kentucky full-fledged branch banks are prohibited
by a court ruling, but additional offices o r tellers’
parent
windows may be established i n the saw city where the
bank i s located. F o r a number o f years the Bank Commissioner
o r S O ago
had permitted s u c h additional offices, b u t a year
n Louisville t o estabhe refused t o permit t h e state b a n k s i

court, a n d
lish any more o f them, T h e matter was taken + o
State issu:
on February 8th, 1927, the highest tribunal o f the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

416

an opinion upholding the right o f a state bank t o establish
additional offices i n the same c i t y where i t i s located f o r
n
a paying checks, a n d e n —
purposes o f receiving d e p o s i t s d
joining t h e Bank Commissioner f r o m interfering. Therefore a
m many o f
non-member bank i n Kentucky m a y n o w e s t a b l i s h s

s it desires without asking anyone. However,
such o f f i c e s a
the member state banks are required b y condition o f member—

beship t o obtain permission of the Federal Reserve Board
fore doing so.

The only member banks i n that part o f Kentucky included
in District No. 8

having branch offices a r e located i n

Louisville. They are as follows: National Bank of Kentucky,
which has one branch office; Gtizens' Union National Bank,
which has one. Louisville National Bank , which has five;
First National Bank w h i c h has two a n d has been authorized
to open four others, a n d Lyberty Insurance Bank, w h i c h has

six and has been authorized t o open another.
In Mississippi b r a n c h e s a r e prohibited, excenot t h a t
banks

i n cities

o f t e n thousand

o r o v e r May, w i t h a p p r o v a l

of

the ban king department | establish additional offices i n

the same city where the parent bank is located, and that out—
side branches already established may b e removed with the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

417
consent-of-the banking department, f r o m o m e municipality t o
another. T h e only member b a n k i n that part o f Mississippi
included i n the eighth district having branches i s the Grenada

Pank, which has 1 2 branches lbcated i n other fowns.
Branches a r e prohibited b y statute i n Myssouri a n d n o
member b a n k s h a v e any.

In Tennessee branches a r e permitted i n the same county
in which t h e parent b a n k i s located. T h e only member bank i n
that part o f Tennessee included i n this District having branch—
es i s the Union a n d Planters! B a n k a n d Trust Company o f Memphis, w h i c h h a s t w o branch offices i n that city.
So far, t h e o n l y effects o f the McFadden Bill o n branch

banking i n the Eighth District have taken place i n Kentucky.

Before the bill was passed. the First National Bank of Louisville had n o branches.

A f t e r the bill became a law, i n o m

der t o meet competition o f the local banks having branches,

it applied for six additional offices,
the Lyberty Insurance Bank, @

A t the same time,

state bank, applied f o r permis—

sion t o increase i t s branch offices f r o m five t o seven, T h e
Chief National Bank. Exeminer’ and the Assistant Federal Reserve

Agent visited Louisville, looked over the proposed locations,
and d i s c u s s e d t h e s i t u a t i o n w i t h t h e j o a } b a n k e r s ,

w h o agreed


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

418
to limit t h e number o f branches they: would request.

S

o

far a s we know, t h e only other member bank i n Louisville
now desiring branches i s the Citizens Union National Bank,
Which has only one and may want another.
Governor Calkins.

I t seems t o me I have heard s o m e

thing about branch banking, although I

am a little hazy

about i t right now.
Most o f the effects o f t h e iicFadden Bill, a s applying

to branch banking, were anticipated i n California. T w o o f
the seven States i n our district permit branch banking —
4rizona andCalifornia, T h e others d o not. T h e r e have
been very few, practically no, important developments that

were not under way at the time the bill was passed, S i n c e
its passage i t i s too early t o judge o f the effect

o n the

disposition o f state banks w i t h regard t o joining t h e

national system, although we anticipate @ movement i n that
direction.

T h e r e have b e e n t w o conversions o f state t o

national banks.

O n e the Benk o f Italy and the other the

Commercial Bank, a small bank, There has been one conversion
from state t o national bank applied for and refused b y the
Comptroller.

T h e r e has been o n e consolidation o f a national

bank w i t h a state bank, w i t h t h e operation o f the former

state bank a s a branch o f the national bank.
Three non-member banks h a v e aoplied f o r branches locat—
ed a t points other than t h e c i t y o f their h o m e offices a n d

have received permission from the state department i n California.

T h e r e have been quite a

number

o f additional c i t y

branches established, that i s established i n the city o f the
head office.

W e have informal. information that there has

been some discussion about the consolidation o f state and
savings banks n o w owned o r controlled b y national

etka

The points under consyderation are, first, that they bejieve more economical operation would b e possible w i t h
the affiliated savings b a n k merged with t h e national bank,
@ somewhat m o r e flexible movement w i t h regard t o savings
deposits t h a n under t h e State law; a l s o more liberal c o h oads

requirenents for national banks, There is, o f course, o m
opportunity a t this early date t o say what t h e net results
of the passage o f the woFad den Bill upon t h e conversion o f

state banks will be. 3

M y own impression i s that there

will b e i n our district, not only i n the State o f California, b u t elsewhere, a disposition o n the part o f state banks
to c o n s i d e r w h e t h e r t h e y w o u l d b e better o f f i f t h e y g o t

into t h e national system o r whether t h e y would b e just a s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

420
well off without becoming members o f the Fedral Reserve

System and without nationalizing. I

think that inquiry i s

quite general among the better banks that are outside o f
the s y s t e m now.

Governor Seay,

branch banking.

I n our district, W e s t Varginia p e m i t s

T h e r e a e n o developments i n branch bank-

ing s o far a s I xnow, which c a n properly b e tracmil t o the

passage o f the McFadden Bill, o r :

t o its effect upon state

banks i n inducing t h e m t o convert i n t o national banks.

W e

feel that i t i s premature t o venture a n expression o n that.

Governor Wellborn,

I n the Atlanta District the States

of Louisiana, Tennessee, i ssissippi and Georgia permit
branch banking, a n d Alabama t o a limited extent. Tyat i s

banks that already have branches there cmkeep them, but
they cannot have a n y more.

The sicFadden bill had a marked effect inGeorgia, I t
has resulted i n the largest state bank w e have i n Georgia
being converted i n t o a national b a n k a n d they have received

their charter already, That i s a bank with 65 millions i n
deposits. They immediately took stepe t o convert and the
Comptroller approved i t .

I n Nashvillg the First National

has established five o r s i x branches i n their o m city.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

421
Governor Harding. .

T h e banks

i n Byston a n d Providence

and some o f the larger Maine c i t i e s w r e already pretty well
provided with branch offices before t h e McFadden A c t w a s
passed. I

do not think a n y o f them have added t o their

number o f b r a n c h e s since,
An interesting development t o o k place about a

month ago.

One o f the non-member suburban trust companies went t o the
Massachusetts Legislature and asked for a special act t o
enable them t o establish a branch i n a tom outside o f their
own county,

S o m e o f the suburban national banks objected

and pointed out that the object o f the iicFadcen Act was t o
equalize competitive methods between national banks a n d trust
companies, a n d this would result i n a n inequality, a n d succeed—

ed i n having the Legislature turn i t down.

T h e effect b e

the M c F a d d e n t
c
A I think willit b e most favorable f o r t h e p e r
petuation o f national banks i n the district.
past a

F o r some time

merger h a s been under w a y i n Hartford between t h e Hart—

ford National Bank and a large trust company, the trust company having considerably larger deposits thah the Hartford
National Bank, T h e consolidation i s all fixed a n d I expect
it has gone through already,

T h e y hung i n the balance, e v e n

after t h e passage o f the wcFadden Act, a s t o whether t h e c u a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

423
consolidated institution would take o u t a national charter
or a state charter. ‘the trust company i s strong f o r a state

charter, a n d sowe o f the national bank people had cold
T h e sticking point w a s t h e

feet o n t h e n a t i o n a l charter.

t t seems that some lawyer “ + e

continuity of trusts,

in Cincinnati g a v e a n o p i n i o n t h a t t h e wicFadden a c t d i d
not p r o v i d e f o r t h e c o n t i n u i t y
companies.

T h e Comptroller

o f trusts c a r r i e d b y t r u s t

o f the Currency sent o n e o r two

of his denuties o u t there a n d finally convinced these people

that the trusts would not b e disturbed,

N o w it has been

definitely decided that t h e combined institution will continue business

a s anational bank.

The Chairman. G o v e r n o r Young?
Governor Young.

I

n answer

t o No. ‘ y s t h e r e i s n o o c c a —

sion for branch banxifig anywhere i n the Northwest, except
t
S Paul and Dyluth.
iinneapolis, .

T h e towms are too small.

In winneapolis, St. Paul and Dyluth the state lew prohibits
then.
In answer t o No. 2 , w e have h a d a great number o f inGuiries with reference t o national Qan‘*s. I

comes about for three reasons,

think that

T h e first reason is, be-

cause, a s Governor Norris said, t h e public for some reason


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

4 33
or other, seems t o prefer the word "national".
some very S

e

a r e e e

W e have

o f that right i n mynneavolis.

The First Wational o f iiinneanolis owmed t h e Bloomington B a n k

through stock owmership.

T h e Bloomington Bank lost some

$250,000 i n deposits out there. T h e y took out a national
charter a n d g o t i t b a c k a n d s o m e more,

knows i t i s the s a m e organization,

a n d still everybody

Y o u just cannot e x -

plain it,
The second reason i s the fear o f the passage o f guaranty

laws i n wontana and sijnnesota.

T h e good banks out there

are going t o get out o f the State system i f the guaranty
law i s passed.

I n signnesota i t i s killed f o r t w o years a n d

won't come u p again,
The t h i r d r e a s o n f o r t a k i n g o u t n a t i o n a l c h a r t e r s

i s that

in Mjnneapolis a n d St. Paul t h e large banks have h a d t o un—
scramble their branches.

B e f o r e t h e McFadden b i l l w a s vassed

it was not »orofitable for them to take out $200,000 capital.
Now that t h e wcFadden Bill i s passed I thin every one o f
those outlying banks will b e national banks.

I

n ad“ition

to that w e have h a d some consolidations between state banks

and national banks.
way,

T h e good consolidations have come our

T h e poor ones have n o t c o m e o u r way, n o t because they


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

424
didn't want to, but because the Chief National Bank Examiner
nushed t h e m the other way.

S o , a l l told, I

feel that t h e

idcFadden Bill h a s been beneficial i n the agricultural s e c

tions. I

do not think w e are going t o get s o many national

banks, b u t those that w e d o get a r e going t o b e the good ones.
The Chairman, I
of it.

think N e w York has noticed t h e effect

W e have t h e northern h a l f o f New.Jersey a n d there

have been 23 new branches opened there.

I n New York I think

there are 26, mating 4 9 altogether, T h e r e i s one noticeable
thing, I

think | with us, a s with you, andthat i s the tendency

to taxe out State charters i n these consolidations basbeen
arrested.
One thing that strikes u s i s that there certainly h a s

been a n impetus given t o membership i n our district, I
memoer t h e report I

got w h e n I

re-

was a b r a o a d w a s t h a t w e h a d

nine

just gotten S a r o i d edtimenber. I

notice since m y return

that i t is up to 934, and I think @ted@-. higher now. N o t withstanding that the surplus has not yncreased.

O u r capital

and surplus together h a s crossed t h e o n e hundred million dol-

lar mark, d u e t o increase i n capital f r o m the new banks, t o
consolidation w i t h n a t i o n a l c h a r t e r s o f m e m b e r s

o f t h e system

and increases i n c a p i t a lof.. some o f t h e larger banks,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

425
I do not k n o w whether there. are any particular develoo~

ments i n connection with the passage of the McFadden Act
which raise a n y questions which could b e disposed:.of -at*:

this meeting.

I t was ‘put os a nrograd, but me h a v eon

queetion i n our district. |

Governor Fancher.
Governor Norris, I

W e have none.

S e r e

e s

‘would like t o ask one, question that

is applicable t o the whole piecees T h e r e has been.very con—

i iy a e kus of the Federal Reserve Board
siderable variancen
onthe question of reserves, 2 to. what is the outlying section o f ' & city,

I n Chicago I think the whole. city i s out—

lying except a-little block i n the financial center.

I n

Philadelphia we have no sone van sections a t all, although
there are points 1 4 m i l e s distant from the City Hall.

Now, under the .ioFadden Bill, if the Comtrolier allows
t b e incorporated with a smaller capital bean i n s t i t u t i o n o

cause i t is i n an outlying secelaa. a a n the Federal Reserve
s not a n outBoard, o f which i t i s & member, s a y that t h a t i

lying section as Sie ke HeeeeTes are concerned?
Governor Young. I

thins so, I

f that bank i s handling

country b a n k a c c o u n t s a n d b a n k b a l a n c e s I

think t h e y w o u l d

be justified i n saying that t h e y would have t o cariy a

higher


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

426
reserve,

T h a t would b e taxen under consideration a n d d e t e r

mined b y the Board.

Governor Norris. T h e y have not done so.
Governor Young,

T h a t i s what t h e y have done with ue.
W e had a number o f cases that w e have

Governor Norris.

put u p t o them, small banks i n residential sections, most
distinctly outlying sections o f the city, which had definite
names, although they were within the corporate limits o f Philadelphia| T h e s e were just local institutions, Little institu.
tions, that had n o outside bank accounts a t all, but they
have always held that they were not outlying.

Governor Young,

D i d your board make a favorable r e c o m

mendation?

Governor Norris.
Governor Young.

Yes,
T h a t i s peculiar, because they have

always g r a n t e d i t t o Minneapolis.

Governor Harding,

T h e r e i s another important t h i n g i n

connection with t h e passage o f t h e wicFadden legislation,

i n my

opinion, and that is the desirability of statytory definition
of savings deposits, T h e powers o f national banks t o lend
money o n real estate i s very greatly increased, because n o w
they c a n lend I think 5 0 per cent o f their savings deposits,

427
In the Boston banks, most o f the national banks there
have a

savings d e p a r t m e n t w i t h a

pay four p e r cent interest.

savings p a s s b o o k a n d t h e y

T h e y place n o limit whatever

upon t h e a m o u n t o f s a v i n g s t h a t c a n b e c a r r i e d i n o n e p a s s

book, O n e o f the large Boston banks recently put i n a rule
thet they would pay four per cent only o n the first ten thousand dollars, a n d over and above ten thousand dollars the rate
would b e three per oent. U n d e r that limit that bank has sone
accounts o f a hundred a n d fifty a n d two hundred thousand dollars. A n o t h e r b a n k which has n o limit a t a l l o n the amount
of savings t o b e carried i n a n y o n e pass book, h a s issued
one pass book t o a corporation f o r a million dollars savings
account,

a t 4

p e r cent.

The Chairman,

A n d $30,000 reserve with you o n that.

Governor Harding.

Yes.

I t seems t o m e that sooner o r

later w e have got t o have legislation from Congress with a
view o f having a

statutory definition

f what a
made o

savings

account is.

Governor Bailey. H a s n ' t that been the question i n California f o r a good while?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Calkins.

T h e y have the half andhalf situa—

tion, t h e savings certificates.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Govetnuor wiclougal.
one, I

think.

This questioni
s a very imoortant

W e h a d s o many cases with t h e Board i n r e

gard t o i t that tre feel very strongly t h e necessity f o r some

authority ruling s p e c i f i c a l ltay
his
w meant b y savings deposits.

i t do not know whether a n y attention has been given

to 1%.-or not, b u t u n l e s s ‘it i s d o n e t h e r e i s g o i n g t o b e c o m

fusion and everything that goes with it, I

t

h i e
nh
aver—
kt

age bank under present conditions a n d i n t h e - f a fc the
o
e

‘law vill continue t o use time devosits until they are stopped.
Governor Calkins. -Isrift i t true that t h e Comptroller

of the Currency i s now considering:a ruling o n that question?
There i s a very urgent need for a n intelligent definition
of time deposits and savings deposits.

T h e situation i s

growing rapidly worss, a n d gpowing repidly worse faster i n
the N e w England a r e ,

t h a n a n y other part o f the country.

The time deposit e v i l - — and I think that i s the proper thing
to call i t —

i s growing everywhere.

B a n s everywhere a r e

carrying a s time deposits funds that have n o business t o b e

classified a s time devosits,
The Chairman.

6 0 per cent o f the jpctreased bank de—

posits i n the last ten years consist o f those deposits that

carry three per cent reserve. B e a r i n g o n this development

429
that y o u referred t o i n New Zngland, Governor Harding,
I recall

i t there was a

as

case o u t i n C a l i f o r n i a s o m e y e a r s

ago where e a bank m e t t h e requirement o f the three p e r cent
reserve b y holding t h e original pass book i n its o w n posses-

sion and giving a duplicate t o the depositor, s o that the
depositor could d r a w a check o n his savings account. I

wonder

if Governor Calkins will tell u s whether that matter has ever
been disvosed o f ?

Governor Calxins.

N o , I think not. I

think that p r a c

tice s t i l l prevails,

The Chairman,

T h e n y o u have a lot o f banks carrying

savings d e p o s i t s o u t t h e r e w h i c h c a r r y t e n p e r c e n t reserve,

and some that c a r r y three per cent reserve?
Governor Oalxins.

Yes.

T h e fact is. n o t t h e bank y o u

referred to, but another one out there, there was some discus—
sion about meeting the definition o f the Board exactly, b u t
the discussion stopped right t h e r e a n d n o action w a s ever
taken.

The Chairman,

D o you realize that i f there had been a

reasonably strict definition o f what type o f deposit would b e
permitted t o carry o n l y three p e r cent reserve that w e wouldn't

be bothering about our portfolio very much?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

430

Governor Caltins. T h a t i s true, n o t only i n California
but i n othes p a r t s o
f the country, N e w Y o r k Chicago, Cleve-

land, Pittspurgh, and so forth.
The Chaivman, O h , yes, that is. ail admitted; but i f
is*

this Great. grooth. o f devosits i n t h e guise o f savings ‘devosits

=

n o t deen permitted to dpee ‘the fora of...savings: devosits

the reserve. requiren,ents today vould have n e essitated a
sufficient volume o f bor rowing from the r eserve banks s o

that we would have had no difficulty i n m a i n t a i n in nade—
ag
quate portfolio a n d the whole b a n k ing position would have

been very much stronger: ©
Govemor Calxins: - If ‘the reserve amounts t o anything,

inthe sense, that it is usally suposed to mean something,
it is perfectly absurd for a baspebakibe t o carry a million

tiene t h € savings account and the bank carry three mer cent
‘ e d i t s a g a i n s t it.’ 3

Governor aeay, . Ft would have ea marzed effect o n the e x
pansion o f credit: sir, Chairman,

Governor Glkxins. I

do not think any more vital question

could b e considered b y this Conference o r the Federal Reserve
System than t h e correction o f the tendency that has been

growing s o strong t o evade proper complicance with reserve


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

requirements.

Govermor Seay,

I n the amendnent t o its regulations I

think the 2oard has attempted i n some way t o deal with that
situation,

I t might b e a subject f o r t h e committee, w h i c h

is t o b e appointed,

t o taxe u p with the counsel f o r t h e F e d e r

@l Reserve Board.

Governor Harding. I

think I appreciate some o f the

difficulties encountered b y the Board o n this particular p r o b
len, I

do not think i t is anything which i s very wel 1

cured b y a regulation. I
needs legislation,

think i t goes déeper than that and

- I think t h e reserve section o f the F e d

eral Reserve Act ought t o be amended s o that i t would carry
a definition o f savings deposits b y providing sone limitation
on the amount t h a t could b e cenvied 1 6 the pass book.
The Chairman, T h a t w a s a

provision a s t o mutual Savings

banks -——~
Governor Harding, T h e question o f time certificates i s
a little more complicated t h a n i n the California case, w i t h
which y o u a r e familiar.

Q u i t e recently o n e o f the Boston

trust c o m p a n i e s h a s g o n e G a l i f o r n i a o n e better.

out t h e slickest proposition y o u ever saw.

T h e y have got

I t i s 4 demand ce.

tificate o f deposit which they claim i s a time certificate


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

4 32
and carries only three per cent reserve against it. L o o k i n g
at i t one way it i s a time certificate a n d looking a t i t
another w a y i t i s a demand certificate.

Governor Talley,

W e have banks carrying vublic funds,

and i n view o f the experience t h e y c e e

e y regard t o the

time consumed i n withdrawing these public funds, t h e y a r e

undertaking t o get letters from public authorities obligating
themselves t o give more than 3 0 days! notice for withdrawal,
and treat t h e public funds a s time deposits, although i t i s

very Clear that any political subdivision has a right t o lend
its funds which i t has eocomujated f o r @ particular purpose.

We have had that u p with the Federal Reserve Board and also

with the Comtroller, and it still goes.on.

I n some instances

it is mitigated b y the fact that the banks are cartying good
secondary reserves; b u t i t 18 a deposit that requires a ten
per cent reserve and only a thrée per cent reserve i s being
carried against it.
The Chairman,

T h e matter suggested b y the N e w York Dis.

trict i n connection with thet c a n b e disposed o f without a n y

discuesion here, a n d we won't take the time.

Topic F has been acted upon. Topic G is the air mail service.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

IV. OPURATION A N D ADMINISTRATION.
G A i r Mail Service,

1. T o what extent i s i t being used or should b e
used b y Federal Reserve Banks?

Be I t s effect o n Time Schedules.
Governor Harding,

T h e Boston post office h a s been s e n d

ing o u t a number o f circulars t o banks a n d business corpora.

tions advising them t o use the Air Mail Service,

T w o or

three o f our larger member banks have been experimenting
with i t i m some o f t heir direct sendings.

I n the reserve

bank we have taken the position that if we could cut the
corner b y saving a

day's time o n some o f t his stuff b y send-

ing i t b y air mail, thebanks that send the stuff could d o
let
the same thing, a n d that w e a r e just a s well off i f w e
it r u n f o r a while.

O Q y t attitude i s that w e are not going

to use t h e air mail except i n self defense...
this
I have a memorandum f r o m m y transit department o n
which says:

"In order to’ test out the air mail, w e sent letters
three
Federal reserve banks and branches during the first
days o f the month o f March,

O n o n e day t h e mail njane o u t

n the other
tests o
a,
of Boston broke down a t F r a m i n g h adm the
t h e mail arrived
two days showed s u c h a variation i n the time


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

434
that t e w e r e u n a b l e

t o draw satisfactory definite c o n c l u

sions.

"The First National Bank and the Nationa] Shawnut Bank
have been forwarding b y air mail a s h letters t o selected
points since warch 9th. D u r i n g this time 8 5 letters have

been sent to other Federal reserve banks, and 32 of these
letters arrived a t their destination a t t h e same time a s i f

they had been sent b y railway mail.

4 5 arrived one day

earlier than if they nad been sent by railway mail, and 8
which were sent t o Dallas arrived at their destination two
days earlier. 'Pxperierce t h u s f a r i n d i c a t e s t h a t n o t i m e c a n b e gained

on letters t o Detroit, a n d the time to Chicago, Cleveland,
M i n n e a p o lw iOrleans
es N,
and Xensas City i s quite uncertain.

Onletters t o St. Louis, Omahe, Dallas, San Francisco and
their branches @ gain of from one to two days is quite con-

sistently shown, "
Of course any general use o f the air mail would involve
@ revision o f the time schedules.

I f Boston uses i t t o San

Francisco, 8ean Francisco would quite naturally u s e i f t o Bos-

ton, a n d the net result would b e just about the same, and w e
have a l l t h e uncertainties, delays, a n d s o forth,

S o our


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

438

attitude-1s° wé-srefer—po.let- At alone wndil it a
general u s e and stabilized.

i n more

I t i s t o o uncertain a

Governor Fancher, -I, have a

Strater bearing: on this:..

a a c vibacmiaaner| prepares b y | Mr,

e 2

o

"The Standing Commit tes, on Celi sey sone a

zepeatediy

discussed t h e possible development of, bas ‘ade wail Service!
to a point w h e r e the, Federal |

reserve b a n k s m i g h t r e c o g n i z e :

the method o f air. transportation b y revising its time

S a

hoe

ules.
"At present there i s only o r

‘ c c n a

a i r mail p r e

vice, a n d that i s the Trans—Continental one. T h e r e are a
number o f feeder routes which are more o r less effective and
dependable.
o
m o r e: r
.less

T h e rates, hoever, a r e practically

ten times thé rates charged for ordinary mail and are prohibitive for: the ordinary volume o f checks. =It is only i n
cases w a t e t i t i amounts are involved and long distances
to b e covered that a n y real advantage c a n accrue f r o m the

means o f air mail transportation. 3
"In m y opinion,
vice i s d e v e l o p e d

i t will b e many

c e

t e eee t h e sere

t o a n extent w h e r e i t w i l l h e o f a n y p r a c

tical usefulness for transportation o f mail for short dis.
tances, a n d naturally t h e more renote t h e point o f collec-

tion t h e less volume there will be.

member
"It has been our experience that some o f our
o f large
banxs taxe advantage o f the service when checks

amounts are concerned but these are relatively infrequent
and ate all handled as special cases.

W e permit certain

to
of our larger banks t o send checks o f $50,000 o r more
other F e d e r a l r e s e r v e b a n k s a n d b r a n c h e s

b y a i r mail routes

which is adjusted
and give them an estimated availability date
in their teserve i f the schedule fails. "
Governor iicDougal,

W e are not using the air mail service.

w i t h items
Some o f o u r member banks h a v e used i t i n connection
cities.
sent t o N e w Y o r k a n d s o m e o f t h e w e s t e r n r e s e r v e

A s i d e

from that I d n o t think they make much use of it.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Cpaiman,

D

o any other Governors wish to reoort?

air mail
Governor Seay, R i c h , o n d i s about t o become a n
city,

T h e problem i s not a t all pressing w i t h us.
Governor Calkins,

T n e u s e o f air mail with u s has been

confined t o the direct royting b y member banks.

W h e n it

shorter time schedule
gives t h e member banks t h e benefit o f the

it is done i n all such cases, they vaying the cost.

a

L

o r have used
member banks i n the principal cities a r e using
the a i r mail.

covernor Seay.

D o you require t h e member banks t o pay

the additional postage?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Calkins.

Y e s ,

Governor Talley.

N e have three member banks t h a t make

a daily practice o f using the air mail from the Dallas stetion,

W e have made a complete analysis o f their sendings

over a period o f three months a n d note that 1 1 6 cash letters
were received a n d credited b y other federal reserve banks,

every one a four day letter. F i n d i n g that our member banks
were c r e d i t e d o n t h e i r b o o k s w i t h o n l y f o u r d a y s w e c r e d i t

on that date, t h e credit dates pass t o the accounts o f our
members.

T o encourage the sending b y air mail w e have been

absorbing this float, but our idea i s it i s not a t all prac
ticable a n d w e d o not u s e i t ourselves.

Governor Wellborn,

I n the Atlanta District there were

two air mail routes established a t different times, p u t they
found t h a t t h e y d i d n o t p a y a n d t h e y h a v e d i s c o n t i n u e d t h e

service.

O n e of them is in the hands: o f a receiver, t h e one

that went t o Florida.
vir. Harrgson, Theree Federal reserve bangs have sent. items
to us b y air mail, ifinneapolis, St. Louis and the Seattle
branch,

2 2 member banks have sent air mail t o us direct.

W e

ourselves have not used the air mail for outgoing items, A l may
though w e have advised o u r various member banks that t h e y

438
nee.

-a %

. :
~v

send checks direct t o other Federal reserve banks b y air
mail there i s only o n e o f o u r member banks t o our knowledge


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

who has ever used it., and then very occasionally, and only
for large items,

When this matter was referred to the standing committee
on collections b y the F a l l Conference o f 1924 that Committee

reported back that they thought the air mail service was too
inexperienced a n d t o o unstable t o justify changing s chedules,

The committee said, however, that they would watch the develop—
ment o f the air mail service, a n d i f the time shoujd come when
experience justified i t s general u s e o r the changing o f the

time schedules, the committee would advise the Governors.
We have considered that the matter i s i n the lap of the c o m
mittee and that the next move will b e u p t o them s o far as
we are concerned.

The Cpaimnan.

N o w ~e have had a general review of it,

which i s not altogether encouraging.

Governor Biggs. A b o u t a yeaT ago we inaugurated the air
mail service between St. Louis a n d Chicago a n d the first mont?
the results o f t h e operation were very satisfactory, a n d w e
gave o u r member banks schedules based o n air mail service, b u i

required that they assume the vostage.

J u s t about the time

439

the schedules were changed daylight éaving went into effect.
The air mail service thereafter did not @ m e u p to the stand
ard Maintained for the few weeks w e had been observing it,
and i n t h e f a l l a n d winter

i t b e c a m e v e r y erratic,

T h e r e

cord beginning with October based o n dollar amount o f cash let~
ters handled b y air mail showed that the following percentage

of cash letters arrived o n time:
October, 5 9 per cent.
November, 3 6 per cent.
D ecember,

5 5 per c e n t ,

January, 4 5 per cent.
February, 6 3 per cent.
wat ch | 68 per cent.

Last fall due to the irregularity o f the air mail service, t h e matter w a s taken u p with t h e Board a n d i t was de-

cided that w e should discontinue guaranteeing the air mail
schedules.

S i n c e then w e have b e e n accepting checks t o b e

forwarded b y air mail, b u t o n l y subject t o our regular p u b l i s h

ed time schedules, except that i f i n the regular course o f
business w e find that w e obtained earlier credits than our
regular schedules called for, w e give the interested member
bank t h e benefit


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

o f t h e earlier availability through credit


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

in the analysis o f their reserve account,
The Chairman

I f there i s n o further discussion o f

this, we will go to Topic IV-K, report of the committee on
safe-~eeping of securities,
IV. OPERATION AND ADMINISTRATION.
Ke Report o f Committee o n Savekeeping.
The Chairman, T h i s i s a committee appointed b y the
Federal Reserve Board between meetings o f the Governors.
(The report o f the committee i s as follows: )
March 11, 1987.
REPORT O F THE COMMITTED O N THE FUNCTION O F CUSTODIES
IN FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS.

Pursuant t o a letter f r o m t h e Federal Reserve Board,

dated January 5, 1927, in‘regard t o the safekeeping o f securities b y Federal Reserve Banks, t h e committee designated b y
the Board | consisting o f
R. a

Y o u n g , G o v e r n o r , F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k o f iiqnneapoli.

Wa. McO. Martin, Chairman and Federal Reserve “gent,
Federal Reserve Bank o f St. Louis,
J.H. Case, Deputy Governor, Federal Reserve Bank o f
New York, Chairman,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

442
duly m e t a t t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k o f N e w Y o r k o n M a r c h

4 and 5, 1927.
The Board requested that this committee give considera—
tion t o all phases o f the safexeening problem,

T h e comnit—

tee, therefore, after careful consideration, h a s divided
the problen into s pecific questions and makes the follow
ing responses and recommendations i n respect thereto, i n
which a r e incorporated their views a s t o t h e questions
spetifically raised b y the Board | as well a s t o other

questions involf¥ed i n a general consideration o f the safekeeping problem, T h e s e questions a n d responses a n d recommenda.
tions follow:
1. S h o u l d Federal reserve banks receive f o r safekeeping

securities which are the ,roperty o f member banks, and, i f
80, should a n y distinction b e made a s t o the location o f t h e
member bank;that i s , should t h e same service b e rendered

to both city qgnd country banks?
The Federal reserve bants are all rendering a safekeeping

service to their member banks and it is doubtful if the banks
could avoid the rendering o f this seryice t o a t least a
ed extent, e v e n i f they desired t o d o so.

limit—

F o r instance, t h e

banks necessarily hold large amounts o f securities a s col-

4.43

lateral t o loans. T h e loans are vaid off and the securities
generally are permitted t o remain with the reserve bank a s
a matter o f convenience a n d i n anticipation o f the need f o r
further borrowing. €Cecurities s o held, e v e n though originally
would
phedged a s collateral, a r e held i n safekeening a n d i t

be very difficult, i f not qhite impossible, t o avoid the hold

ing of securities i n such oases.

I n addition, a large number

of banks have lodged with their Federal reserve panke f o r

safekeeping all o r a substantial part o f their security holdings,

I n some districts the reserve banks are already holding

a majority o f all o f the securities o m e d b y the country
menber banks within t h e districts.

T h i s represents a

ser

vice o f very great value t o the country member bank and, incidentally, t o the public interest generally, f o r the reason
that the majority o f country banks d o not have vaults o f
proper strength f o r t h e safdguarding o f their property. Y o u r

committee belives that the value o f this service t o the member
banks i s far beyond i t s comparatively small cost t o the Federal
Reserve System a n d that i t i s a service which i s incident t o
the maintenance o f the reserve account.

It recommends, therefore, that the Federal reserve banks
receive f o r safefeeping securities which a r e t h e property o f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

f44
their counsry member banks.

A s t o whether o r not this ser—

vice should b e rendered t o both city and country banks,

it

ig t h e v i e w o f the comnittee that i n general t h e polity

should be to limit the safexeeping of securitiés to member
banks outside o f reserve a n d branch ‘cities, b u t that t h e re-

serve banks should exercise discretion i n the dase o f banks
which d o not have adequate vault protection o f their o m ,
regardless o f location.

2. S h o u l d Federal reserve banks receive for safekeeping securities t h e property o f correspondents other t h a n

member banks, agencies o f the Government, etc.?
It i s the v i e w o f the committee that t h e reserve banks m e
properly r e c e i v e s e c u r i t i e s

t o b e heldfor t h e account

o f the

Secretary o f the Treasury a n d other agencies o f the Governi n cases where t h e banks a r e svecifically authorized

ment,

oy law t o render-this s e r v i c e , o
r where they have been spe—
cifically requested b y the Secretary o f t h e Tyéeasury t o

render i t as fiscal agents o f the United States Government.
The committee a l s o believes t h a t t h e holding o f securities
for foreign o r other correspondents m a y properly b e undertaken °

Se 2 S h o u l d Federal reserve banks receive f o r s a f e

keeping from member banks, securities i n which third parties


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

have a n interest proprietary o r otherwise?
Your committee i s o f t h e opinion that Federal reserve

banks shovld not i n any case render this service, for the
reason that i t would impose liabilities which i t is felt
the Federal reserve banks should not. assume.

A s i d e from

the question of vossible lack of legal authority, numerous
difficulties c o u l d arise i n connection w i t h this service i f
it were undertaken, incident t o the accounting f o r securi-

ties held which were known t o be the ,roperty o f a third party,
or i n which a thi party has a n interest; f o r example, t h e
administration o f the inheritance t a x laws, etc,
connection t h e committee considered a

I n this

letter addressed b y

ir, wlartin to wir. Case under date of February 1, 1927 a copy
of which i s attached a s Exhibit A . Furthermore, a n d a s a

practical matter, i f the reserve banks were t o undertake
to render @ service o f this character, t h e possible volume
of business which might viltimetely b e offered i s enormous

and would impose a very great burden upon the reserve banks,
not o n l y f o r t h e expense which would b e involwad, b u t f o r
the liability incident t o the handling o f a great volume o f
securities. T h e r e would a l s o arise t h e element o f competition
which menber banks which a r e especially equipped t o handle
such b u s i n e s s f o r nrofit.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

446

Federal
The committee recommends, therefore, that the
f r o m member
reserve banks should n o t receive f o r safekeeping
deposit—
banks securities which a r e not t h e property o f the
ing Member bank.
5, i f Federal reserve banks a r e t o hold securities
for safekeeping should a

charge b e made f o r this service with

respect t o any particular class o f safekeeping?
where
Tt i s the v i e w o f the committee that i n all cases
render
4+ recommends t h a t t h e Federal reserve banks should
a safekeeping s e r v i c e

t o m e m b e r banks, t h i s service,

t h e cost

b e rend
of which t o the reserve banks i s not great, should
ered free o f chargé.
f o r other
In the case o f securities h e l d i n safekeeping
than member banks, a s , f o r instance, foreign correspondents,
that t h e matter
agencies o f the Government, eto., i t believes
o f the reserve
of a charge should b e left t o the discretion
bank handling t h e business.
in
6. W h a t a r e the legal respcnsibilities involved
a n d would this
the handling o f securities f o r safekecping,
imposed?
legal liability b e increased i f a charge were t o b e

of
There i s attached a s “xhibit B copy o f an opinion
counsel o f the Federal Reserve Bank o f New York, dated

44°7
January 20, 1927, which the committee considered and adopted.
This opinion was rendered with reference t o the law of the

State of New York, The rule of law is that reserve banks
holding securities i n safekeeping for member banks are not
in a n y case insurers against loss..

I n a n y case where

a,reserve bank i s expressly paid for these services, o r where
it might b e found that i n fact there i s a lawful considera.
tion passing f r o m the member b a n k t o the reserve b a n k (and
the opinion anticipates that inall these cases there would
be found t o b e i n fact a real consideration passing f r o m the

memberbank t o the reserve bank), t h e reserve bank would b e
liable i n the event o f loss o f property h e l d b y i t only i f

it should b e >roved that the reserve bank had omitted t o
give t o t h e p r o p e r t y h e l d i n o u s t o d y t h e s a m e c a r e t h a t

would b e given b y a n ordinary prudent banker t o the conduct
of his o w n business i n lite circumstances.

I n any case where

it might b e found that the custody of the reserve bank i s
gratuitous, t h e reserve b a n k would b e liable for a n y loss

occurring only i f gross negligence were proved, T h e s e are
definitely settled rules o f law i n the State o f New York,
and while there might b e slight variationg, i t i s believed
that t h e y are o f quite general application,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T h e opinion e x -


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

pressea@ t h e view that while, theoretically, t h e r e i s a
vossible charge t o a jury that t h e re-

difference between a

serve bank i s liable i f i t failed t o use t h e care that a n

ordinarily prudent banker would give t o the conduct o f his
own affairs, a n d a charge that the reserve bank would b e

liable only if gross negligence were proved, yet as a oractical matter i t i s doubted that there would b e any great
advantage t o the bank i n the event o f the latter o f those
two possible charges.
The opinion refers, also,

t o the legal effect o f t h e

clause i n the safekeeping receipt issued b y the Federal Re-

serve Bank of New York, a s follows:
"Me Federal Reserve B a n k will give t o property l e f t
in its custody t h e same care that i t gives i t s o w n property;
but beyond that will not assume responsibility . "

At the time the opinion was written i t was thought that this
provisicn would. b e o f doubtful effect, However,

i n a n opinion

decided i n the last month i n N e w Yor“ i t w a s held that t h e
liability o f a bank holding securities

i n safexeeping w e s

limited t o that expressed i n the receipt.

T n e l e w i s contrary

to this i n many states, where the courts hold that contracts
seeking t o exempt a

party f r o m t h e consequences o f his o w a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

negligence w i l l not b e given effect.
The opinhon a l s o discusses t h e liability o f t h e banks

in safekeening operations o n behalf o f various Government
departments, and, a f t e r expressing t h e view that possibly
there would b e found t o b e a consideration moving f r o m the
Treasury t o t h e r s s e r v e b a n k s f o r t h e p e r f o r m a n c e

o f these

services, states that the liability o f the reserve banks is
to use i n the custody o f these securities that degree o f

care which an ordinarily prudent banker would give to the
conduct

o f his o w n affairs

i n l i k e circumstances.

7. S h o u l d any distinction b e m d e a s t o the class o f

securities thich will be held i n safekeeping?
It i s the v i e w o f the somenbies t h a t n o distinction should
f securities t o b e held, i f i t s reconbe made a s t o the c l a s s o

mendations in other respects are accepted. That is to say, if
the s € c u r i t i e s

t o b e held f o r member panks a r e restricted

to

thes €which are the property o f the meber banks for whom
held t h e n a n y securities which t h e member banks o w n should
be h e l d b y t h e r e s e r v e banks.

In submitting this reoort t h e committee desires t o point
out t h a t i t h a s g i v e n c a r e f u l c o n s i d e r a t i o n

t o the value o f

the s e r v e which t h e reserve banks might render t o t h e member


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

450
service.
banks i n relation t o the cost o f that

I t believes

great, especially t o
that t h e velue o f t h e service i s very

cases, a r e without
the countzy member banss, who, i n many
securities. I
proper facilities for carimig for their

t be-

f o r member banks t o
jieves that b y restricting t h e service

securities actually omed bymember banks, theburden on
a n d that t h e expense
the reserve system will not b e great,
value o f the service
will t e very small compared w i t h t h e
t h e service should
rendered, T h e committee i s convinced that
a r e t h e property
pe restricted t o t h e e securities which
n o t done, t h e volume
of the member banks, 4 s , i f this were
f i n d their w a y t o r e
of securities which would ultimately
imoose a
serve bants would b e very great a n d would

burden

b e unwarranted i n as—
on the reserve banks, which they o u l d
suming,

t o enter i n t o
i t 7rould a l s o cause t h e reserve banks

which a r e equipped t o
@irect competition w i t h member banks

which i t berender a sefekeeping service for individuals,
dO.
Lieves t h e reserve banks should n o t
Respectfully submitted,

*R, “A. Young,
im w c . wartin
J. H. Case, Chairman.
adopted b y the commi
X While t h e above report w a s unanimously
t o have noted his
tee, nevertheless Governcr Young desired


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i one regard, a s follows:
exceptionn
"Governor Young desired t o make a n ‘exception t o
the rule described b y n e p e r e n

t

o allow

n
a possibly
the Federal isd erve. Bank o f M y n n e a v o l i sd
other reserve banks similarly situated t o continue

to receive from member banks and hold i n safekeeping

collateral deposited by member banks to secure State
o
r such exor other public deposits, t h e r e a s o n s f

ception being that the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis,

a n d p o s s i b l y o t h e r reserve, banks, h a v e d o n e a

substantial amount o f this business for member banks
with mutual a

a

n

O e a n d further that local con-

ditions a r e such that t h e Federal Reserve Bank o f

Minneapolis, and possibly other reserve banks, have
relatively f e w o p p o r t u n i t i e s f o r r e n d e r i n g s e r v i c e s

to members and hence are unwilling t o refrain fron

giving this substantial aid."

EXHIBIT &
r

E 32
e

FEDERAL RESERVE B A N K
OF
ST. L O U I S

February 1, 1987,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ir. J . H . C a s e , D e p u t y Governor, _

Federal Reserve Bank,
New York, N . Y .
Dear Mr. “Case:

w i t h which
Referring t o -your™ Letter ‘of ‘January 14th,
com
you enclosed agenda for: meeting o f our ‘safe keeping

least seis
mittee, 3 Del SENS there i s something w e ‘should a t
tne q u e s t i o n as
in mind i n connection: with consideration o f

‘of securities
to ‘Whether o r not w e should. accept custody
that i s the effect
owned b y customers. of:member benks, “and

of the state inheritance tax tawslaws, s h o u l d w e
Under t h e iisgouri, inheritance ‘tax

b y customers o f
accept t h e custody o f securities otmed
paedies v a n s

responsibil-—
w e undoubtedly would b e i n der t h e

i n t h e event o f t h e
ity o f notifying t h e tax guthorities

addition t o this
death o f the judividugh® customer, and i n
we, o f course, would b e under the responsibility,

i n the

o f seeing
event of the death ofa’ member bank's customer,
legal representative
that t h e securities Konched s h e proper
scrutiny o f letters :
of t h e deceased, w h i c h would necessitate
of administration,

obviated
A l l o f this resognsibility i s

member banks,
if w e deal only w i t h securities o m e d b y


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

453

We all here think that you have covered the matter very
thoroughly i n your agenda and that after consideration o f
this o u r c o m m i t t e e s h o u l d h a v e a n e x c e l l e n t s t a r t i n g p o i n t

for its discussion, I
not still sick,

hope very much that Mr. Young i s

A s i t may b e o f assistance t o you i n set-

ting a date for o u r meting, I

a m advising that I have en-

gageMents o n Februery 9 t h and February 14th.
Yours v e r y truly,

Wa, Mo. C. Martin,
Chairman of. the Board.

EXHIBIT B
Januar y 20, 1927.
To My. Kengel
From L . R . M e s o n

MEMORANDUM
re
BANK'S LIABILITY I N CONNECTION WITH
SAFEKEEPING ACCOUNTS:
Referenge i s made t c the letter o f the Fedsral Reserve Board o f January 5, yidressed t o iy. Case, i n conneotion w i t h t h e w o r k o f t h e q o m m i t t e e a p p o i n t e d

t o make a

stud


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

454

of the question o f the safekeeping o f securities b y reserve
banks.

The Board asks to be advised specifically (a) as to the
legal liability o f reserve banks acting a s bailees o f secur-

ities for pay and (b) a s to the legal liability o f reserve
banks acting a s baiilees o f securities without compensation,

I shall endeavor t o answer these questions with reference
to the law of the State o f New York,

I n order t o answer

fully, i t seems desirable, first, t o state the various c i r
cumstances under which this bank engages t o act a s bailee
of securities.

V e shall then i n each case reach a conclu

Sion upon the question o f whether the bailment i s for hire
or gratuitous and, having determined that question, express
an opinion a s t o the measure o f care required o f the bank.

First, then, this bank receives securities from member
banks solely f o r purposes o f safexeeping, U p o n t h e receipt o f
such securities t h e bank issues a

receipt,

o f which t h e fol-

lowing i s a provision:

"the Federal Reserve Bank will give t o property
left i n its custody t h e same cane that i t gives
its o w n property; b u t beyond that will n o t assume
responsibility."


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

A55
no o
In. these transe i o n s ‘there. is
for p a y m e n t f o r t h e

s o o s

*

uate

r e

e

provision

However,

ites members,
of the relation o f the bank w i t h

i n ver

— — fact n i g h t

involves mutual
well b e established that tne transaction
benefits a n d i s based upon & real consideration,
a.

M y best

in fact to be bailees
b
d
i that we w o u elfound
judgments
ow

.
for hire i n these C A S E S e
sort.
Now a s % 0 itability i n cases o f this

I n t h e first

or a pailee
place, wealaer the bank is a gratuitous bailee
against loss.
for hire, i t is not “in any sense a n in-surer
a s anticipated,
If we should be found t o be # bases f o r hire,
t h e courts o f this
we are responsible tacos the decisions o f

is, the measure
state f o r he use o f ordinary care -— that
tiakee would render
of c a r e w h i c h a n o r d i n a r i l y p r u d e n t

the i

o

in

a
f his o m business i n 1ike oiroumstances.

a
onthe, other hand,, we were found t o be in these cases
instruct a
garuitous bailee, t h e courts would

.jury consider

only i f o n e neghiing the matter that t h e tank was Liable
@ practicsl matter
gence were proved. it i e doubtful a s

ay to the bank, s o far
that any eebotent tal benefit vows ices
result o f the latter
as legal liability i s ‘concerned, a s a
of these two possible charges -

a acudite


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

456

A

It ii gee o e contended that the c.lanse-quoted from
the receipt i s a general avoidance o f liability,

i f w e had

as
shown t h e property o f a member i n our bank t h e same care

our own. However, t h e courts d o not look with favor upon
contracts

i n which parties s e e k exemption f r o m consequences

of their own neglect, a n d I doubt that this provision would
be o f a n y effect a t all i f there was proof o f negligence
or i f there were circumstances giving rise t o a n inference

of negligence, These remarks concerning the receipt apply,

ofcourse, t o all cases in which the receipt is issued. 2s
X(Note.) I n the case of Sagendorph v. First National
Bank o f Philmont, (reported 218 N.¥., Supp., 191),
decided after this opinion was written, i t was held
that a

stipulation against liability contained i n

the safekeeping receipt, identical w i t h t h e o n e under

consideration, limited the liability o f the bank h o l d
ing property i n safekeeping t o that expressed i n the
receipt, T h i s sites feo b e the l a w i n New York. H o w .
ever, t h e r e i s much authority contrary t o this i n

other states, where itt re quite generally held that
effect.
stipulations against negligepce are o f no
Another class o f cases j n which this bank has o n
occasion i n the past received securities f o r safekeeping


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

457
from member bahks i s identiéal with the one just considered
and i n t o a

receipt containing the same provisions a s the

one above referred to, except that the. bank i s on notice

that the securities i n this class are the property of
some person o r corporation other than the.menber bank.

I t

securihas long been t h e policy o f this bank n o t t o receive
ties o n this basis. H o w e v e r , s i n c e the question appears t o
be involved

o e

c o n s i d e r a t i o n s o f the Board, w e shall

consider t h e question o f liability i n transactions o f this
sort.

S o far a s concerns t h e question o f whether w e are

bailees for hire o r gratuitous bailees and our consequent
liability, t h e considerations are exactly the same 4 6 i n

the case first discussed. T h e r e is, however, another
to
aspect o f the question o f liability applying peculiarly

cases of the sort now under consideration, This question i s
as to our duty t o inquire into the terms o f the trust under
which t h e member bank acts f o r i t s customer.
in the State o f N e w York i s that where a

T h e rule o f l a w

trustee deposits

funds belonging t o a trust the bank acting a s bailee i s
trust,
under n o obligation t o inquire a s t o the terms o f the
It i s entitled t o assume that t h e trustee will apply t h e

funds t o their proper purposes.

I f the trustee misapplies


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

458
the funds without this bant's «xnowledge, i t i s not Trespons—
ible therefor.

O f course, i f this bank had knowledge o f

such v i o l a t i o n

o r i f i t profited

i n a n y w a y v y it,

it

would b e liable; otherwise not.

A&A further question which might arise i n this class o f
cases i s as t o the duty o f this bank if, i n @ given case,
it should b e advised b y a customer o f the member bank o r b y
the member bank o f a n y dispute between t h e m a s t o l d
disposition should b e made o f property h e l d i n custody,

I n

such cases i t i s clear that t h e duty o f this bank would b e

to release the securities only upon the consent o f both
parties, o r to deliver them over i n accordance with a n o r
der o f court.
The next class o f cases f o r consideration i s the o n e i n
which w e hold securities a s collateral f o r loans t o member
banks o r where w e hold them with t h e understanding t h a t w e

may use them as collateral i f required. T h e receipt i n this
Class o f cases contains t h e same provision a s the o n e quoted

above, a n d the same remarks a s t o the Legal effect o f the
provision apply.

in these instances I think we are glearly bailees for
hire and are i n consequence chargeable not a s insurers but


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

with the duty o f using the care a n ordinarily prudent
banker i n the conduct o f his o m m business i n like ciroum.
stances would exercise.
There i s @

large c l a s s o f s a f e k e e p i n g o p e r a t i o n s a r i s i n g

out o f our relation a s fiscal agent o f the Treasury o f
the United States a n d a s fiscal agent o f other corporations
organized under Federal law.

W e i n fact h o l d i n many

accounts securities o f various departments o f the Govern—
ment, either b y virtue o f a special request o f the Treasury

orunder the Treasury's Circular No. 154 of May 15, 1982,
end letter o f Mr, Gilbert, addressed t o Governor Orissinger
under date o f July i?7, 1923, authorizing reserve banks t o
take s e c u r i t i e s t e n d e r e d b y T r e a s u r y o f f i c e r s

course o f their d u t i e s .

i n the ordinary

A s l Also, w e hold collateral

pledged b y banks t o secure special Government deposit accounts.

T h e s e securities a r e held under letter o f w a y 29,

1917, addressed b y Secretary iicd doo t o the bank and letter

of April 25, 1919, addressed t o the bank b y Assistant S e o
retary Leffingwell.
In none o f these cases d o w e make a n y

direct charge f o r

our service o f safekeeping, except t h a t o f the Alien Property

Custodian, However, i t is thought that in the event of any


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

460
question about liability i t would probably b e determined
that i n fact there i s some consideration passing t o us, i n

view of our relations t o the Treasury as its banker.

I t

is not adequate compensation i n any safekeeping transaction,
but i s nevertheless a

real consideration.

As t o liability i n these cases, there i s no judicial
t o the
authority, t h e question never having been presented

courts, However,

i n my opinion, o u r responsibility i n all

agent
these cases i s not that o f insurer b u t that o f a n
them w e
to his principal, a n d i n m y judgment i n all o f
would b e held t o that degree o f care which a reasonably
his
prudent banker would ordinarily g i v e t o the conduct o f
own business i n like circumstances.

I t i s true that t h e

letters of wessrs. wicAdoo and Leffingwell, above referred to,
are open t o the construction that t h e intention w a s t o maxe
this b a n k a n insurer f o r t h e receipt, c u s t o d y a n d disposi-—

tion o f collateral f o r Government deposits.
In some o f these accounts w e have notice that t h e pro-

perty held i s subject t o rights o f third persons,

I n these

cases t h e same considerations o f liability apply a s anpear ed
heretofore when w e discussed those cases i n which the bank
has i n the past received securities f o r safekeeping f r o m


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

461
menber b a n s where this bank i s o n motice that t h e securities a r e the property o f some person o r corporation other
than t h e member bank.

Governor Young,

clusions that t

A r e there a n y objections

t o the con-

he committee h a s arrived a t ?

The O,airman,

f only heard the objection voiced b y

one o r two members o f the Federal Reserve Board, w h o
seemed t o think that i t would b e desirable f o r some o f the
reserve banks t o undertake t o receive securities o n deposit

for safekeeping f rom their menber banks for account of the
customers o f the bank members, a n d this report i s designed t o

o doing so.
point out some of the d a n g e r s f

I n New York we

do not d o i t except where w e cannot avoid.

W e try t o keep

them out.
Is there a n y further discussion o f this report?

Governor Calkins. I

have not a copy of the report

before me, but m y understanding i s the report does not contemplate any change i n the nrocedure o r practice o f any
Federal Reserve bank; t h a t is, n o c o m u l s o r y change;
correct?
Governor Young. T h a t i s correct.

i s that


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

462
Governor Biggs. T h e r e i s one point t h a t Mr. Martin,

who wes o n the committee, raised, a n d that i s if we should
accept securities ormed b y customers o f member banks w e
would undoubtedly b e under t h e responsibility o f notifying

the public authorities in the event of the death of the
individual customer a n d also under t h e responsibility,

in

the event o f the death of a customer, o f seeing that the
securities reached the proper legal representatives o f the
de edent, T h a t would necessitate careful s q u t i n y o f t h e
letters o f administration.

T h e s e things w o u l prove v e r y

annoying i n the State o f Myssouri i f w e took the securities
of member b a n s .

Governor Young. This committee recommends that w e avoid
that, b u t t h e y will creep in. T h e y creep i n everywhere.

They

get i n our bank, i n New York and everywhere else.
Governor Fancher.

O u r procedure p r a dically conforms

to the procedure I find i n the report, w i t h the exception o f
a few instances w e have received securities f r o m banks t o

be held for county commissioners, t o secure deposits. T h o s e
are only i n a few cases a n d a receipt j s issued t o the bank

o the County Commissioners.
for the account f

I t 18 very

carefully safeguarded a n d I d o not think w e are assuming a n y


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

undue liability,

W e only have 4

The Gyairman,

few casese

I t is quite Hrge with us, o f course.
W e do not invite it. T h e cases are

Governor Fancher.

Special rather t h a n t h e rule.
Mr. Harrison,

W h e n -this committee w a s appointed i n

January b y the Federal Reserve Board, Governor Orissinger
comstated i n the letter appointing t h e committee that t h e
mittee s h o u l d m a k e a

report

o f t h e findings, t o g e t h e r w i t h

such recommendations a s might seen advisable, a t the next
Governors’ Oonference,

I n a subsequent letter h e indi cated

that the findings and recommendatione of this committee
Conference,
appointed b y the Board should b e reported t o this
so that I think even though the committee was appointed b y

b proper for this Conference t o approve
the Board it w o u l d e
the recommendations o f the committee.
The Chairman,

M a t i s your pleasure about t h e report?

Governor Young w a s a member o f t h e committee.
Governor McDougal. I

move that t h e report b e received

and approved.

Governor Talley, I
Governor Calkins.

second the motion.
N o t having a copy o f the report and

but I
not knowing what i t contains I would hesitate action,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

464
am willing, however,

t o waive a n y consideration o f the report

its elf upon Governor Young's statement t h a t 2 6 does n o t carry
any compulsory change a s applied t o any Federal Reserve Bank.

There are a number o f things that are done b y other Federal

Reserve Banks that we do not do, and if the reptrt imposes
an obligation o n the Fedéral Reserve Bank t o conform t o uni-~
form practice, I

think I ought t o know i t before I pass o n

it.
Governor Seay.

T h e report a s we read it, conforms 8 0

nearly t o the practices w h i c h t h e reserve banks h a v e reported

here a s being i n vogue, that w e see no occasion t o take exception t o anything i n the report, a n d w e would b e prepared
to accept a n d approve o f i t e
Governor Wellporn. I

have & @ memorandum o n this which I

would like t o read:
"l have carefully reviewed t h e report o f the committee

f Custodies i n Federal Reserve Banks, a n d
on the f u n c t i o n o
am pleased t o advise that our practice conforms t o the recom
mendations contained i n the report i n every respect, w i t h
the exception o f receiving securities f o r safekeeping f r o n

state officials which are deposited with those officials b y
member banks a n d par renitting banks, s a i d securities being


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

the property o f the respective banks,
"In issuing o u r trust receipts t o the various State

officials w e do not recognize third parties.

O u r receipts

are issued direct i n the names o f the differen t

state

officials without regard t o the names o f the banks depositing
the securities w i t h t h e state officiais.

I n making deliver—

ies of, o r detaching coupons from, a n y o f these securities,
we recognize o n l y instructions received f r o m the state official t o whom our trust receipts a r e issued.
"It wis recommended that w e continue o u r present policy

inaccepting securities fron state officials, for the rea.
Son i t i s our opinion that w e a r e rendering a distinct s e r —
vice n o t t o the state officials themselves, b u t t o member
banks a n d par renitting banks, a n d w e are also of the opinion

that the vault facilities throughout t h e district, with the
possible exception o f some o f the larger cities, d o not
afford adequate protection t o member a n d p a r renitting

banks, nor the different state officials.”
The Gus iemad,

W e have motion t o aceept the report and

approve it.

Governor Norris. I

will second the motion.

(The motion, having been duly seconded, was carried.)


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

466
The Chairman, Govemor Calkins has placed his reservation o n the record and the motion i s carried.
Governor Seay, a r e you ready t o report for the advisory
committee o n legislative matters?
REPORT O F ADVISORY COMMITTEE O N LEGISLATIVE MASTERS.

Governor Seay.

T h e Last Governors! Conference seemed

to b e o f the opinion that t h e time was not auspicous t o conSider t h e proposal o f any amendment t o the Federal Reserve
Act.

T h e r e has therefore b e e n n o subject o f that nature f o r

the committee t o consider and there have been n o subjects o f
any collateral nature, s o far a s they have been communicated
to the Chairman, which would oall for any special meeting o f
the committee. T h e r e f o r e there h a s been n o meeting o f t h e
committee.

T h e r e was one subject alluded t o a t the last Con-

ference, contained i n the reserve report o f t h e Agents' c o m m i t
tee, b u t t h e r e h a s n ' t s e e m e d t o h a v e b e e n a n y n e c e s s i t y f o r

action b y this committee o n that report.

T h e Federal Reserve

Board w a s communicated w i t h b y the committee

and asked i f it had anything t o propose t o the committee for
its consideration and a reply i n the negative was received.
pe Chairman:
of course t h e most important o f all subjects t o b e
considered, w h i c h h a s not y e t b e e n referred t o your committee

by the Board, but which i n fact was withdrawn from considera-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

467
tion,

a s I remenber i t , w a s t h e o n e r a i s e d b y Governor H a r d .

ing, t h e q u e s t i o n o f t i m e a n d s a v i n g s deposits,

Governor Seay.

S o far a s I understand the duties o f

the committee which was appointed b y the Board, t h e specific
matters which were referred t o i t for consideration, w e r e

those relating t o the first and second McFadden Bills. T h o s e
relating t o the first Mdfadden Bill were disposed o f a t length

and i n detail and a report was made t o the Federal Reserve
Board, a n d based uvon that revort the Federal Reserve Board
made certain representations t o the committees o f Congress
to which more o r less respectful attention w a s given,

T h e

second McFadden Bill was withdram from consideration practically,

s o there have been n o matters requiring t h e special

consideration o f this committee s o far a s I

a m aware o r 8 0

far a s other members o f this committee h a v e c o m m n i c a t e d
them t o me.

Governor Harding. With regard t o this question o f time
and savings deposits, I will b e very glad t o offer the follow.
ing resolution:

T h a t the Governors o f the Federal Reserve

banks view with grave concern the weakening o f the reserve
position o f the banks o f the country cusoto t h e constantly
growing tendency t o transfer w h a t a r e i n effect demand d e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

468

posits i n t o so-called time denosits o r savings accounts,
and S a e t e

s c o u t that,

i n case t h e Board fynds that

it cannot adequately c o p e with this tendency b y r egulation,
that steps b e taken t o impress unon Congress,

a t its next

session, t h e importance o f amending the reserve provisions
of the Federal Reserve A c t i n such manner a s t o safeguard
the banking position o f the country.

Governor Calkins. I

will second that motion.

(The motion, having b e e n duly seconded, w a s unanimously

carrked. )
Governor Seay, I

would like t o s u ggest that t h e matter

ssbrought to the attention of the Confermce by Governor
Fancher w a s quite a

differmt o n e a n d covers’ quite a dif-

ferent subject.
Governor Fancher. I

do not want a n y action, I

simply

brought i t up just t o get the reaction.
Governor Seay, Inasmuch a s Governor Fancher h a s asked

for the reagtion, I

would 1iké t o say that I consider the

ruling o f the Board as quite a n importgnt one a s affects
the reserves,

i n that i t permitted certain deductions f r o n

deposits, a n d actually permitted deduct}gons f r o m deposits

of items which are not the property o f the bank.

H e r e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

469
~
. ewe

N e e s

is a case’ in’ our bank whieh bears exactly o n the point (reads

memorandum) , e e

3Governor” Fancher. 1 move: that the Sine ireude’ eemmaek
fully call -to the ‘attention of the Federal, Reserve Board
the. fact that: the railing in its letter o f Mareh a

1987

(X-4816) , int “reply ‘to letter from, the- Federal” ‘Reserve Bank
of New-York dated ‘ravember 8. 1926:» rebihiary i ‘1987,
wills have: the effect, af generadly. adopted a s a practice
by member, ‘banks, o f reducing very aotteateahl'o the lia—

bility in the item "due to: banks! upon whieh the reserve
calculation “tg Gils. nical appears t o be unjustifiable b e —

cause of the fast that the items so deducted need not

have been aredited to the depositors’ accounts under the
terms o f the’Boardts mikaee.

Governes Seay. I

will second that,

(The motion, :having been Bice seconded, was carried, )
The Chairman.

S h a l l we now’take u p Topic F on Pees a s

TzCREDIT TRANSACTIONSD
N
a POLICIES
F,Strong Stabilization Bill. (H. R. 7895).


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

470

The Chairman (contimuing:) I

suppose you have all re-

ceived letters from Congressman Strong. I

received a letter

o£ from him and was not aware o f the fact that h e had been
in correspondence w i t h t i e F ederal Reserve Board o n the

subject o f his bill, a n d had made a request o f the Federal
Reserve Board which i t had not thought wise t o
accede to; b u t because o f m y contact w i t h h i m during t h e

hearings I thought I ought t o write him a polite letter.
He i s under t h e impression that i n some w a y there h a s been

& concerted effort made, after a n exchange o f views between
the reserve banks, t o oppose his bill. I

told him that

there did not seem t o be anything that I could d o about the
Fabt that

matter, i n view o f the/Federal Reserve Board had taken the
matter under advisement a n d h a d given h i m a n answer t o his
request. I
ing what I

did think i t was only fair t o explain t o t h e meet—
had done i n m y correspondence w i t h him.

It i s rather unfortunate, I

think | that h e should gain

the impression t h a t there i s a sort o f concert o f opposition
among t h e reserve banks t o his legislation, I

do not believe

in his bill, a n d certainly said s o plajnly enough t o the
committee, b u t i t may be that some sort o f formula can b e
devised that will satisfy his views and not leave that impreswvdpe,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

471
sion i n his mind.

H e is a very earnest, and, I think, a
H e i s a lawyer f r o m Kansas. I

very intelligent fellow,

told h i m that I had plenty o f sympathy with h i s purpose,

but that the method o f handling this responsibility o f
the Federal Reserve System was a wrong one.
The only suggestion I made t o the committee was that

inasmuch as this was a declaration of purpose of Congress,
and i f it was t o b e made i t should be-in the preamble o f
the bill and should b e rather i n effect a statement o f the
purpose o f the Federal Reserve System t o maintain t h e gold
standard.
a m curious t o learn h o w many wrote

Governor Fancher. I

him i n response t o the letter which h e sent t o all o f us.

Governor Young. I
Governor Harding.

did.
H e did not write m e a letter.

Governor Wellborn, I
Governor Seay.

did not reply t o the letter.

I n a letter h e wrote t o me he expressed

the opinion strongly you have just communicated t o the Conference, a n d that i s that h e i s really impressed with t h e fact
that there must h a v e been some exchange o f views a n d some concert o f action.

The Chairman,

I f you will authorize m e t o tell him

472
that there was n o exchange o f views a n d that there w a s n o
concert f a c t i o n I

will take t h e first opportunity t o d o

that.
Governor Calkins. I

wrote t o him and, curiously enough,

-he incorporated the only suggestion that I made i n the se. cond provision o f his bill.
Governor Fancher. I

wrote t o him a n d expressed s y m

, pathy for What he was attempting t o do but that I did not


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

#gree with the manner i n which i t was done and suggested
that i t might b e something i n the preamble o f the Federal

Reserve Act. I

expressed the opinion that I thought t o o

gteat responsibility would be placed upon the Board.
Governor Harding, I

wrote him about a year-ago and

made a suggestion, which I see he has incorporated i n this
last bill o f his. I

thought y o u were referring t o a recent

letter, b u t this was about @ year ago.
) G o v e r n o r McDougai.

a r e you talking about a new letter

now?
Governor Fancher. I

hevent w e i t ten. him eithia ®t year.

I think i t was nearly a year ago. I t mas when his bill
was first u p for discussion. .
Governor Young. I

received a

letter f r o m Congressman


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

473
Strong about t w o months a g o i n which h e sent m e a copy o f

the redraft o f his bill and asked my opinion o n it. I

tid

him I had studied i t quite carefully and would not thange
my opinion a s expressed i n my previous letter. I

got a n

acknowledgment o f my letter i n which h e said that h e was
satisfied that there was something i n the idea and he thought
that when the proper time came h e would get cooperation from
the splendid men who were Governors o f the Federal Reserve

System. I

thought h e was i n rather a friendly frame of

Mind.

The Chairman |

H e i s a very good friend o f the Systen.

Governor Bailey.
Governor Fancher.

Y e s , h e is.
I n replying t o my letter h e did not

Seem particularly pleased with t h e suggestions I made.

Governor Bailey.

H e nhope t n to see m e almost every

time h e goes through Kansas City. I

have known him for a

great many years and he is quite an able man and a hard work—
ere
The Chairman. ( A f t e r a little further discussion:)
There i s no action required o n this matter , and I would
like t o call u p the last unfinished business o n the program,
with t h e exception o f the report t o the Federal Reserve bard.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

WON CASH COLLECTIONS.
vipi,

4

7

4

W e left the discussion of our dear old fiend

non-cash collections u p i n the air yesterday. I

do not

want t o be raising a n old ghost but I will tell you i n
o matters n o w unless t h e Board does something
the p o s i t i o n f

4t will take care o f itself. W h a t action does the Confer—
ence wish t o take?
Governor Seay.

A t the last conference o f Governors,

which you were prevented from attending, Governor Strong,
the matter was referred t o a committee

b y the Conference

and a formal co munication addressed to the Board.

I t

strikes m e that t h e matter could b e reached b y reaffirming

that and respectfully requesting andurging that the Board
take the action pointed out therein, f o r the reasons therein given.

Governor Calkins. The last varagraph o f the action
at the Fall @nference states: " U n d e r these circumstances
it i s the sense o f the Conference that, i n order t o preserve that uniformity w h ich i s believed t o b e s o essential
and t o the best interests o f t h e Federal Reserve System
and i t s member banks .

— &x

t h a t t h e Federal R e -

serve Board should reconsider i t s letter o f Septanber e4,

1926, a n d determine whether, f r o m the point o f view o f the

475
Federal Reserve System a s a whole, a l l Federal reserve banks
shall, o r whether a l l Federal reserve banks shall not,
continue t o handle f o r collection items which a r e payable

at street addresses. "
Governor Harding,

I t seems t o me that we might lead

to some progress i f w e took i t u p i n steps.
somebody offers a

F i r s t , suppose

motion that i n the opinion o f this Confer-

ence all action o n the subject o f these non-cash collections
shall b e uniform a t all banks? T h e n those i n favor o f the
proposition c a n vote f o r i t a n d those opposed t o i t c a n vote

against it. T h e n take u p the next step.

T h a t is, that

the matter has been pending for three o r four years and i t
is the opinion o f the Conference that i t i s very important,
in order t o pregent disintegration o f the collection systen,

that w e have a prompt ruling one way o r the other o n this

subject, T h e n those who feel that way about i t can vote
Aye and those who are opvosed t o it can vote No, T h e
Board will then b e able t o see how each man has stood o n
the proposition.
Governor Norris,

W e have voted o n this question sever~

al times and had a nine t o three vote.
as divided u p like that


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I f we vote o n it

a n d get a nine t o three vote w e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

haven't gained much,
Governor Wellborn, I

think i f you split i t u p that

way y o u just simply middje t h e question. O t h e r w i s e w e would

just throw out ourstrongest card, t o be frank with youe 1
have n o t consul%ed with these other gentlemen a b o u t it.
We have h a d n o concerted action o n it.
our individual views. I

W e have just given

hav e not written Govermor Bailey

@ line o n i t nor h a s h e written t o me. I
non-cash collection practice. I

e m sorry i t ever started

and I want t o see i t discontinuéd. I

for i t time and again,

a m against t h e

have given m y reasons

I t i s t o your interest t o have them

and t o m y interest n o t t o h a v e them.

The Chairman (Governor McDougal presiding:) G o v e r n e r
Norris has made a suggestion. G o v e r n o r Harding has made a
suggestion,

H o w would i t do t o let these men who want t o con-

sider these matters consider t h e m between ncovand tomorrow
morning's session a n d seeif t h e y cannot make some nrogress.

Governor Norris.
majority.

T n e suggestions have come from the

P o s s i b l y some i i i a n a e suggestion m a y come f r o m

the minority tomorrow morning.

Governor Wellborn.

I n answer to that, w e are of record.

We have discussed i t time and again. I

wouldn't want t o do


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

anything here contrary t o the wishes o f o u r Board. I

could not change m y position i f I wished towithout consult—
ing m y board.
Governor Bailey, Y o u mean the board o f the Atlanta Bank?
Governor Wellborn. Y e s .
Governor Fancher.

W h a t action did your Board take,

Governor Wellborn?
Governor Wellborn.

O u r board adopted the same resolu-

tion as that adopted by Governor Bailey's board.
Governor Fancher. That was not t o receive them?
Governor Wellporn.

T h a t w e would receive certain items,

as Governor Bailey read o n yesterday» G o v e r n o r Bailey's
position was a little more liberal than mine, but I came t o

his position, I

did that not for the sake of getting any-

thing through but because I thought it was the proper thing
to do.

Governor Seay. I
how h e thinks

would like t o ask Governor Wellporn

h e would compromise t h e committee

o r his board

in any way i f he voted i n favor o f a proposition t o ask the
Federal R e s e r v e B o a r d t o m a k e a

Governor Wellporn.

decision o n e w a y o r t h e other*

A s i t now stands i t i s in the air,

and I think i t i s faorsble t o us, I

d o not want

t o d o any—

e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

478
thing t o hurt m y cause.

T h a t i s t h e way T feel about it.

I never t r y t o hurt myself a t a n y rate.

Governor Harding. I

think i t i s the duty o f this Con-

ference t o g o ahead a n d take a vote on. it a n d s a y something
positive about i t .
Governor B a i l e y e

t o a vote f o r o r
ir
W h e n e vt ecomes

against i t I am going t o vote no.
Governor Fancher. I

think i t would b e interesting t o

determine whether w e believe i n uniformity.

I f w e d o not

believe in uhiformity that. is all there is to it,
The Chairman,

W e will t a k e a vote o n i t i f y o u wish,

Governor Fancher.

A l l t h e Governors a r e not here.

Governor Harding. T h e question i s are w e i n favor o f

having i t settled o r i n favor o f having i t stay u p in the
air?

we
Governor Fancher. There are three o r four questions
might v o t e o n tomorrow morning.
The Chairman, Yes, a n d I think i t i s important t h a t a l l
the Governors b e here.

Governor Harding. T o m o r r o w morning would b e the best
time t o take i t up, when we are all fresh.
that
Governor Wellborn, T h e n I suggest, Mr, Chairman,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

we pass i t until tomorrow morning.

The Chairman,

I f satisfactory t o the Conference w e

will let this matter rest until all the Governors are here.
Mr, Harrison has a topic that h e would like t o submit a t
this time.
Mr. H

other. I

arrison. I

have n o preference o n e way o r the

want t o take u p the question o f the relation o f

foreign banks.

M r , Strong asked m e to d o s o i n his absence,

if the Conference wished t o take i t u p tonight, M y report
on the subject will b e very informal and not for the record.

Governor Harding,

M r . Chairman, I move we adjourn

until 9:30 tomorrow morning.

(Whereupon, a t 4:50 o'clock p.m,, upon motion duly seconded, t h e Conference adjourned until tomorrow, Thursday,

May 12, 1927, a t 9:30 o'clock a.m.)

POUR

T S

c e G e ee

May 12, 1927,
9:30. o'clock a . m
CONTERENOR O F GOVERNORS
of the

FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS.
The Conference o f Governors o f the Federal Reserve
Banks reassembled i n the Hearing Room of the Federal Reserve Board, Treasury Building, Washington, D.C., o n
Thursday, M a y 128, 1927.

PRESENT:

(As indicated in the record of the first day's proceed
ings.)

The Chairman (Governor Strong presiding:) Gentlemen,
the meeting will come t o order. I

a m advised b y Governor

CGrissinger that t h e Oj,en Market Committee i s t o have a
ing with the Board i n his office a t 10:¢0.

me et

W o further d i s —

cussion o f the report i s necessary, a s that was approved
yesterday, a n d w e c a n deal with o u r uitinighed business.
I suggest i f a n y action i s t o b e taken i n regard t o the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

481
take i t
unfinished: business o f the last f e w years that.we
this morning.
Governor Harding, I

-would like t o offer a. resolution

|
miich Ithink comes under the head of unfinished; business,
Mir. Chairman.
n , Ithe suggestion that w e confine
The C h a i r m a offer
‘it t o the non-eash collections - —

Governor Harding, I

will offer a resolution pertaining

to’ that.
i n order.
The Chairman. That i s always
74

"von CASH COLLEUPIONS.
Govermoz Harding. I

move that a s definite recommenda

made
tions 6 s the subject o f non-cash collections have been

at successive conferencés: of i c a n

f o r the past three

the
years, following full ‘discussion, and as all members of
Reserve
Conference a s well: as the members o f the Federal
further
Board are fully informed o n the subject, there i s no
t o vote in.
information necessary i n order t o enable anyone

telligently o n this subject.
Governor Biggs. I
Governor Talley,

will second that.
I s that all there i s t o it?

Governor Harding, T o that one, yee.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

482
' Governor McDougal. I

would like t o inquire o f Gover

nor Harding what the object is, to lay it before’ the Board?
Governor Harding, I
sive

would like t o find out, b y succes-

how
j fat w e are i n accord and how far w e difs t e p s ::tsu

fer. .«-I will -réad.it again. ( R e a d i n g motion) - ms.

o or the other? ~*
‘ V o ten
eway

Geverné: Séay,

. Goverfior Harding, Y e s .
The Chatman,

T h e motion has been seconded.

I call for the question.
Governor S e a y . -

(The motion was put on an aye andnay vote, Governors
Bailey and. Wellporn voting no.)
-.Governor Young.™ f

do not quite get the resolution,

and.I will ask that I°be recorded a s not voting.
Governor Harding, “ I have another resolution t o offer.

Governor Wellporn, I-Would like to explain my vote in
the negative’on that. “The B,ard has it under consideration
and I do not believe there i s any use i n pushing them o n the
matter.

f the opinion that further inThe Chairman, You a r e o
formation i s necessary? ,
Governor Young.

my own bank t h a t I

[ I think so. There a r e many things i n

am not quite satisfied about all the way


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

through — —
Governor Wellborn. I

d o not see a n y use i n pushing

the Board o n the subject.
Governor Norris. I

would like t o know what t h e vote o n

that motion was, Mr, Chairman.
The Chairman. T h e Chair announces that the motion was
carried, Governor Young not voting, Governor Wellborn voting
in the negativec—
Governor Young. I

think I will vote i n the negative

on that.
Mr. Bailey, I

will also vote i n the negative.

The Chairman, T h e motion i s carried eight t o three»
Governor Harding.

M r , Chairman, I

move that this C o n

ference believes that this question should not b e held i n
abeyance any longer and requests the Federal Reserve Board

to make, a t an early date, a definite ruling upon the subject.
Governor Talley, I
Governor Seay, I
Governor Vellpern.

will second that.
will second it.
I s that another resolution?

Governor Harding, Yes, that we do not want it held i n
the
abeyance but have a ruling o n the subject o n e way o r


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

484

Governor Bailey. I

am i n favor o f settling i t and I

will vote a y e o n that.
Governor Wellporn, I

w u l d l i k e t o have y o u read that

again.
(Governor Harding then read the motion.)
Governor Wellporn, I
Governor Young, I

will vote no.

will vote no.

(There were calls for the question and the motion

was put on an aye and nay vote and the Chair declared the
motion carried n i n e t o two.)
Governor Harding. i r . Chairman, I

move that i n the opin.

ion o f the Conference i t i s desirable t h a t a n y ruling made
should b e uniform with respect t o its application a t all reserve banks. ;

Governor Fancher. I
Governor Wellborn.

will second that.

I f this Conference wishes t o invoke

the doctrine o f absolute uniformity, a

great m a n y i n our dis—

trict would take t h e position t h a t t h e discount rates should
also b e uniform.

Governor Harding, T h e law provides that i t need not be.
It distinctly says s o i n the l a w

Governor Wellborn,

I t has been discussed i n (Ongress


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

485
and discussed b y the Press, a n d i f you are going t o have abs

solute uniformity I think you ought t o have i t with inter
est rates.

The Chaiman,

I t is uniform now.

W e all have the four

per c e n t d i s c o u n t r a t e .

Governor Wellborn, I t just s o happens a t this time.
Governor Harding. This is not a question of uniform ‘»ro+
cedure i n regard t o discount rates.
call f o r the question,

Governor Fancher.e I

(The motion was put o n an aye and nay vote and the Chair

announced it carried eight to three, Governors Young, W ell»
porn and Bailey voting in the negative. )
Governor Harding. .Mr, Chairman, I move it is the sense
of the Conference that the dollection o f all non-cash collection items should b e contintied a t all Federal Reserve banks.

will second that.

Governor Fancher. I
Governor Talley, I

second it.

Governor Bailey, I

want t o b e recorded a # voting no.

Governor Young. I

wish t o be recorded a s voting n o o n

all o f this.
Governor Wellporn, I

will vote no.

(The motion, having been put o n an aye and nay vote, t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

486
Chair declared the motion carried eight t o three, Governors
Bailey, Wellborn a n d Young voting i n the negative.)
Governor Calkins. M r , Chairman, a s I was absent when
the vote o n the motions just passed was taken with regard
to non-cash collections, I

desire now to be recorded a s v o t

ing i n the affirmative o n those motions, which I have read.

(Whereupon Mr. Harrison reported t o the Conference, informally, o n the subject o f relations with foreign banks,
and a t 10:30 ofclock a.m. t h e Gonference o f Governors re~
cessed t o allow t h e Open Market Committee t o confer w i t h
the Federal Reserve Board.

A

t 12:15 o'tclack p.m., t h e

(bnference reconvened a n d t h e following progmeedings were had):

The Chairman, T h e meeting will come t o order. I

think

first w e should report t h e result o f our conference w i t h

the Federal Reserve Board.

A l l members o f the Open Market

Committee and all members o f the Board were there, including the ex-officio members.

[ I will ask Governor Harding

to m a k e o u r report.

(Whereupon Governor Harding reported t o the Conference
the result o f the meeting o f the open market committee with
the Federal Reserve Board, which the Reporter was directed
not t o record,

a t t h e conclusion o f which report Mr. Harri-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

487
son c o n t i n u e d h i s discussion o f relations with foreign

banks, which the Reporter was directed not t o record,. a t
the conclusion o f which discussion, a t 1 o'clock p-m.,.
the Conference recessed until 3 o'clock p.m. o f the same
Reserve Board.)
day, f o r its j o n t conference w i t h t h e Federal
a

a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

wOL

NT

C O N F E R E N C E
of t h e

FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD

with the

GOVERNORS O F THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS.

The Joint Conference convened, pursuant t o recess

of the Governors! Conference,

a t 3o'clock p.m., o n Thurs

day, M a y 12, 1927-~
PRESENT:

D.R. MISSINGER, Governor, Federal Reserve Board.
Edmund Pyatt, Vice-Governor, Federal Reserve Board.

Adolph ©. Myller, Member, Federal Reserve Board.
Charles &. Hamlin, iiember, Federal Reserve Board.
George R. James, Member, Federal Reserve Board.
Edward H. Cunningham, Member, Federal Reserve Board.

The Governors o f the Federal Reserve Ban ks, a s
previously recorded i n the first day's record.

Mr. E. A. Goldenweiser, Director, Division o f Research and Statistics, Federal Reserve Board.
PROCEEDINGS.

Governor Crissinger, Gentlemen, w e are ready n o w t o
hear t h e repvort o f the Conference o f Governors.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

489
Governor Strong, T h e question i s what the Board wishes
us t O report o n .

W e h a v e m a d e o n e o r t w o reports.

Governor Crissinger. T h e n report o n something y o u have
not reported on. T h e r e i s a lot o f stuff here.
Governor Strong. I

did n o t know whether y o u wanted

us t O g o over t h e w h ole thing. I

uaderstood y o u wanted t o

have a discussion o f the business situation and I understood
that M r . G o l d e n w e i s e r w a s g o i n g t o m a k e a

Governor Crissinger.

report.

H e has a report t o make, but I

think W e can wait f o r your written renort w i t h regard t o a ~

lot o f these things.
Governor Strong,

I t will all b e reported t o you.

Governor Crissinger.

h e n we will ask Mr. Goldenweiser

to make his statement,

Mr. Goldenweiser.

M r , Chairmen and gentlemen, I

think

the most important single fact i n the business situation,
and t h e one that h a s attracted o u r attention most, h a s been
the continuous decrease i n the price level i n the last t w o

years, a t a time when business activity has continued t o
be i n exceptionally large volume. I

think that probably

the general level o f business activity and the latest
developments i n business activity a r e n o w familiar t o y o u

and you have been comparing notes o n them.

430
I think there will b e a general agreement that t h e

first quarter o f this year has been very active.

‘And that the declines o f the last quarter o f last year,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

or the ground last during the last quarter o f last year,
has been regained.

T h e r e a r e some serious difficulties i n

that situation, s u c h a s the Mississippi floods which affect
that part o f the country very unfavorably,

T h e r e i s over—

production i n some industries, particularly i n oil, a n d
also i n the lumber industry.

I n the mining industry there

has been some recession i n coal production, o w i n g t o the

strike, a n d probably largely a s 4 result o f that there has
been s o m e decline i n the freight movement a n d distribution

of commodities.

B u t with all these bad spots, the general

outlook a n d the general basis o f business i s favorable.
GI

think i t might d é o f interest t o y o u i f I gave y o u

a Little more analysis o f the price factor. P r i c e s
have been going down, with some interruption, f o r two years,

gince the summer o f 1925. T h e decline during that period
has been —- I have a chart here that shows i t _- about ten
per cent,from 160 t o 145, o n the Bureau o f Labor and Statis—
tics index.

O y r own weekly index, compiled here, which has

lower
only about two-thirds o f the commodities, h a s gone d o w

491
i e t

e

n

2k c o a t

e e e

only about two-thirds o f the commodities, h a s gone down lower
than that, but has recently been stable and shows a slightly
ypward tendency i n the last week o r two. I

believe that

the indications a r e that t h e most rapid decline i n prices

has come t o an end and that now the curve i s flattening out.
This decrease f r a m 160 o n the pre-war basis t o 145,

brings the price level about four per cent above the low point,

Post war, which was i n January, 1922, when it was 138.
This decline i n prices i s coincidental with, a n d has

followed upon the return o f a great many o f the countries t o
the gold standard,

T h a t h a s raised t h e question whether there

is not something i n the situation that tends t o bring t h e

price level t o the pre-war lgvel, t o the level that prevailed

at the time the world was on the gold standard. T h e r e is
good authority for that expectation, a nd we have felt that
it was very much worth while t o analyze t h a t statement.

That

general impression i s strengthened b y the fact that the
price decline h a s been world-wide a n d wherever currency
has been o n a stable basis, I
want

have a chart here -—— I d o not

t o s h o w y o u t o o m a n y charts,

and I

think t h e p o i n t s s t a n d

out well enough without t h e charts — - showing that t h e vrices


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

492
have declined i n the goid standard countries — ~ i n England,
Germany, Sweden, Switzerland a n d Holland t h e prices h a v e gone

down (demenstrating with chart).
This raises a number o f questions.

f h e first i s why

should prices g o down t o the pre-war level, a n d maybe the
first s e e d :

t o that i s that I feel t h a t there was n o such

thing as a pre-war level. There was a level before the war,
but that level w a s a slope:

i t was a n upward slope; prices

had been going up from 1896 to 1913.
I have a chart here that I do want t o call t o your attention o n that point,

T h i s chart shows the price develop—

ment since 1882 to 1806, and fron 1896 to 1913 (indicating),
and there was a n increase o f t h e rate represented b y this

red line (indicating),

a a d

r a t e o f increase had continued

just a t t h e s a m e r a t e t o t h e p r e s e n t t i m e t h e p r i c e s w o u l d

now be just about where they are.

T h i s last dot i n rela-

tion t o the red line shows where prices would h a v e been

if the situation had continued (indicating),


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

N o w the signifi-

cance o f t h a t i s n o t t h a t I think t h a t t h i s w a s g

condition, t h a t w

normal

eccould therefore expect prices t o g o u p

in that way, but i t does seem to indicate that selecting
the year 1913, which was i n the middle o f the Upward swing,

493
as normal, a n d teking the adjustment that existed before
the war, there would b e a tendency t o return

n o w-— I do

not think that i s supported b y the facts. I

think i t

would b e a n important thing, espeolally f o r t h e men working

with bank credit, t o forget t h e pre-war situation and consid.

er the present level and changes from months t o month and
from y e a r t o y e a r o n t h e i r o w n basis, w i t h r e f e r e n c e

to

other developments, andnot t o have in mind at all the fact
that we are 145 now, and therefore 45 per cent above the

basis that was artificial. I think our reaction to the
price index would t

very different i f w e recognized that

prices a r e 9 4 per cent now, 9 4 o n the basis o f 2 3 t o 25,
which i s the basis I think most o f our indexes a r e computed

on, a 8 compared with that price being 145. I

think i t would

be a desirable thing for the Federal Reserve System t o put

the price index on the same b a s i s o
n which it pute its other
indexes,
Aan analysis o f the price decline divided first i n t o

agricultural and non-agricultural commodities, shows that

since 1925 there has bem a somewhat larger decline i n agricuitural commodities than i n non-agricultural commodities.
But they are now closer together than they were a t the time


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

494
= t h e decline began and closer than they were two nonths
ago, Agriculture o n the whole has advanced i n the last two
months, t h a t i s i n prices, w h i l e industry prices have declined,
The reason that i s not s o clearly realized i s the fact that
while agricultural commodities have yndergone much fluctua-—

a
h now been
tion, t h e decline i n the industrial c o m m o d i t i e ss
fairly continuous since 1923 a n d industrial prices a r e n o w

at the lowest level i n ten years, whereas agricultural prices
have h a d a big rise i n 1924, a n d are n o w very materially

above their low point i n 1922.
Taking not the last year o r two, b u t the last five
years, there has been more pronounced decline i n industrial
prices t h a n i n agricultural vrices.
I have here t h e prices o f different industrial commodi-

ties analyzed somewhat, but I do not want t o stop t o talk
details. T h e r e i s a decline i n building material, M e t a l

and chemicals have gone dom. Olothing materials have gone


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

dom, F u e l s are subject t o so many fluctuations, owing t o
the irregularity both o f oil and ooal, that i t is difficult
to say, b u t t h e y a r e v e r y m u c h b e l o w t h e peak, w h i c h w a s 8 0

high that I

did not spoil t h e chart b y putting i t in.

would have been u p here (indicating above chart).

1 0

495
House furnishings have been going down. There has been

& pretty wide decline i n the prices of all classes o f com
modities, with industrial commodities showing the larger
decline. I

am going through the list o f the 480 commodi-

ties that enter into the wholesale price index and have
found that o f those commodities 3 0 0 are lower than they
were t w o years a g o , w h i l e h u n d r e d c o m m o d i t i e s a r e highe”,

but the decline having been much more substantial than the
increase.

This last chart shows world prices, which I mentioned

e few moments ago, and a

complete series of price charts

that I want to calh t
o your attention.
Now, i f the gold standard has been instrumental i n
bringing down the prices i t seems t o me that that would
have t o be reflected i n a soramble for pace and would have
been reflected i n a stiffening o f money rates, because I
cannot see how the operation o f the gold standard would
influence prices exoept i f there was a

shortage o f gold,

which would result i n contraction a n d a higher price f o r
funds.

The facts again d o not support that theory, T h e price

of money, money rates, i n nearly all the countries o f the

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

world, i n all the stable countries o f the world, have
been going down. T h e r e has been a decline i n Berlin,

London, a n d i n Amsterdam, 4

in

decline i n the money rate,

and i n general there h a s been a cheeatening o f money f r o m
the high level which preveile d
tion a n d then o f deflation.

I

i n the early years o f inflan going o v e r t h e positions

of the central banks a n d o f t h e commercial banks o f t h e

principal countries o f Europe, there i s a clear indication
that credit has been increasingly plentiful and that the
decline i n the cost o f credit h a s been accompanied b y a
growth i n the u s e o f oredit.
countries.

T h a t i s true o f most o f the

T h a t i s true o f some o f the countries t h a t

have been through t h e period o f deflation preliminary t o

o a gold te sis, There has bees bos deflation
reestablishingn
in Denmark prior t o her recent return to the gold basis;
there h a s b e e n s o m e i n N o r w a y a n d i n Italy;

b u t i n the vrin—

cipal countries, t h e bigger countries, a n d these which have
already secured monetary stability, t h e r e has been a

conti-

crenuous decline i n money rates and a n increasing use of
:

dit.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor fivtnec W h a t commodities are those charts
based upon?

Y o u mean t h e money rates?

wir. Goldenweiser.

Governor Strong, No, the commodities.
T h o s e a r e the official price i n -

Mr. G,idensweiser.

dexes, including the wholesale price index, including this
number o f commodities i n the different countries.
B y t they a r e generally wholesale

Governor Strong,

prices?
Mr. Goldenweiser. W h o l e s a l e prices, probably o v e r
weighted with r a w material.

Mr. Cunningham, I

would like t o ask you about the

first c h a r t y o u h a d t h e r e a n d w o u l d l i k e t o a s k y o u a b o u t

the inorease shown fron May, 1896, t o 1913, and from 1913
up to the present time.

W h a t pernentage o f increase have

you got there?

Mr. Goldendweiser. T h e r e was practically 5 0 per cent
increase here {indicating o n chart), a n d 5 0 per cent increase there (indicating o n o hart),
Mr. Cunningham.

f l e have practically been maintain-

ing the same level between the present point and that point,
and the 1896?

Mr. Goldenwiesery I f we had increastlat the same
rate a f t e r 1 9 1 3 t h a t w e h a d b e f o r e t h a t w e w o u l d n o w b e

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

just about where w e are.

Mr. Cunningham. W h e r e would the line b e o n the 1913
basis?

ip. Goldenweiser. Right here (indicating o n plat).
Mr. Cunningham,

A n d carrying i n our minds that w e

t o that
are going back t o t h e 1913 basis, g o i n g back

point (indicating) ?
Mr. Goldenweiser. Y e s , sir.
A n d realizing t h e steady increase

Mr, Cunningham.

for t h e last — - h o w many years?
Mr. G o l d e n w e i s e r .

F r o m 1 8 9 6 — — t h i r t y years.

W e have gradually increased u p t o

Mr. Cunningham,

dividing
the present time about 5 0 per cent between the two
points there?
Mr. Goldenweiser.

Y e s . T h i s i s o n the 1913 basis.

h a s been
This w a s fran 6 7 t o 100 i n 1 7 years, a n d this

in
ghoreased f rom a hundred t o a hundred and forty-five

nineteen years (indicating).


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I t is just about the same

rate of increase (indicating o n plait).
I d o not w a n t t o attach

percentage curve; I

t % m u c h importance

t o the

do not think i t is a normal curve and

that w e can expect it, b u t I

d o want t o s a y that 1913 —

but a
that there was n o such thing a s a pre-war level,

499
Slope, a n d i f we are going back t o that slope, a l l this
projection into the future i s o n the same level, a n d i s
Something w e cannot determine, a n d for that vreason i t i s
best for us t o think i n terms o f the current basis.

I t

has been the Board's position f o r a long time that t h e y
W e d o not make a n analysis o f them

do distort figures.

and they are hard t o forecast, a n d we believe i t i s best
to have a basis that i s as close t o the current time a s
possible.

W e are using 1923 t o 1925 i n our big business

index.
Governor Strong.

I t would be just a s fair t o assume

that o n the present level w e a r e just a s near Tight a s w e
could b e o n a

basis

o f 1913?

ir. Goldenweiser.

Governor Norris.

J I think s o .

h e n y o u speculate.voever a fifteen-

year period, f r o m 1881 t o 1896, w e have had a decline i n
iagae

t h e 17-year period from 1896 t o 1913 w e have had

an advance i n prices.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. Goldenweiser.
Governor Norris.

Yes.
A n d assume that that was the peak,

then w e oan assume that there might have been another 15.

year dip then (indicating o n chart)?

500
Mr. Goldenweissr.
point I

Y e s , sir. T h a t i s t he very

want t o bring out, t h a t there i s n o such thing

as a level,

Vice Governor Platt, 1 9 1 3 i s a convenient period which
everybody thinks of.

Mir. Goldenweiser. Y e s , a n d if people would only consider movements and not levels, I

think i t would not make s o

much differerice what basis i s used.

B u t when that i s inter-

preted t o mean that w e are 4 5 per cent above something a n d
that t h e chances a r e something i s going d o m 4 5 per cent
more, I

think that i s a n undesirable condition,

I d o not k n o w whether there i s anything else I want

to say.

T h e general developments i n the credit s i t u a

tion of the country are familiar t o yous B a n k credit, which
increased a t a very rapid rate i n 1924 and 1925, grew relatively little i n 1 9 2 6 .

I n the present y e a r i t has started

out t o grow a t a fairly rapid rate,
shows t h e r eporting member banks.

- I have a chart which
Y o u c a n see that t h e

latest figures show the highést level of loans and invest—
ments o n the top line (indicating o n chart). Naturally the

high level is not a surprising thing, because i n most
countries o n e expects a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

certain amount o f constant growth

501
in loans and i n bank operations; b u t i t does show something .
of a rapid growth efter the little liquidation following
the season o f pear. i n December - - the movement h a s been exceptionally rapid. I

think a n element i n the raoid growth

has been the growth o f investments.

T h e Treasury certifi-

cates which were taken i n large volume o n the 15th o f March
have not been marketed a s easily a s usualland they are still
to a considerable extent i n the possession o f the member
bankeé.

Commercial credit has grown a t a normal rate, t h e usual
rate (indicating),

T h e use o f bank credit f o r loans o n

securities, much o f which goes into stock exchange operée~
tions,

i s usual,

a n d this l i n e shows t h e total loans t o

brokers and dealers a s reported b y member banks o f the

System i n New York, T h a t is at a high level with the e x
ception o f the extreme peak i n the early part o f 1920, when

these figures first became available, and the growth has
been very rapid i n the last couple o f months.
The reserve bank credit shows t h e usual reflection o f

the condition o f their banks. T h e reserve bank credit this
year has been fluctuating very close t o the billion line,
about ahundred millions above last yaar, t h e hundred million


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

502
being substantially t h e gold imports f o r that year.

Governor Strong, The reserve bank credit shows a
volume of a hundred million greater than the previous year_Mr. Goldenweiser. Y e s .
Governor Strong.

A n d that almost exactly offsets t h e

amount o f gold we r e c e i v e d i
n that period?
it. Goldenweiser. ‘Yes.
Governor strong: How. does i t happen that w e have a n

expansion of bank credit to that amount in that period
without increasing the reserves proportionately?
Mr. Goldenweiser. T h e answer t o that i s the fact that
the credits that arise from the loans have been chiefly

in the form of time deposits, which require only three
per cent, Lhatead o f demand deposits, which require ten t o

thirteen. T o some extent also, the credit has been chiefly
not o n the 13 yer cent basis but o n the ten and seven basis.
Governor Strong.

‘ A very large part o f the growth has

been received i n the form of time deposits carrying three
‘per cent =- ,
Mix. Goldenweiser.

T h i s chart shows a very large

growth i n time deposits, while demand deposits have not
grown s o much.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

503

Governor Strong,
into the systémn,
a e

I f there is any poison getting

e e

i n that way, a n d i t i s running

t h e reserve s y s t e m -

Governor Crissinger.

Y o u mean the time deposits?

Governor Strong. Y e s , o f course.
Mr. Goldenwiser. There has been n o growth i n the reserve bank credit, broadly speaking, f o r five years.
up around a billion.

I t is

I t has gone u p sometimes above, a n d

sometimes i t has gone somewhat below.
just around t h e billion line.

t t has fluctuated

T h e last figures brought

in show that the latest reports bring i t down t o 9 0 million,
which i s the l o w point.

Governor Strong, Nearly 300 million.
Mr. Goldenweiser. There has been 60 million just now
taken out o f earning assets i n connection with gold imports
ation.

ilpe Hamlin. Wouldn't. that amount to, under this lower—
ing o f reserve o n time deposits,

Mr. Goldénweiser. I

t o a releasing o f reserves?

t it has been
think i f you a n a l y z e i

equivalent i n its effect t o about 200 million dollars ~ ~
Governor Strong.

g 0 0 million...

Mr. Goldenweiser.. Y e s . I

do not swear b y that figure,.

504
beoause there a r e s o many different elements that enter into

ite:
Governot Strong,

I n other words, t h e amount o f the re-

serve which w e had supporting X ; the amount o f deposits,
without a n y change except a reduction o f a hundred millions
in our credit,.is n o w supporting X plus a billion and a half.
Mir, Goldenwesier. Y e s .
Governor Strong,

H o w far i s that going t o go?:

Mr; Goldenweiser. I
Governor Strong,

Mr. Goldenweiser,

do not know.

I t i s our idea i t i s going t o g o vretty

I t i s necessary, a n d very desirable,

to have that question o f time deposits v e r y carefully a n a l y z

edby the System with a view of arriving at a definition
of them and a change i n the requirements , which I understand
igs a part o f your report.
Governor Strong.

W e merely call attention t o i t a s

we have f o r the last s i x o r ¢ight years, I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

think,

Mr. Goldenweiser. N o w , unless you want t o look a t some
industrial statistics, which I personally think you perhaps
have i n mind, that i s about all I wish t o say.
Governor Crissinger.

W h a t have you t o suggest about


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

these time deposits?

Governor Strong,

W e have discussed i t at our meeting

and passed a resolution offered b y Governor Harding, after
a statement o f t h e situation i n Boston. I

happened t o hear

Mr. Mellon describe what was hapoéning i n Pittsburgh, b o t h

of which conditions are alarming, ahd when you learn that
there are large commercial banks i n both cities, a n d i n other

cities, receiving deposits as savings deposits in amount
from @ hundred thousand to a million dollars in each ac-

count, subject to the regular guides, and so on, the effect
of which i s t o reduce t h e reserve requirement b y a pronounced
amount, o u r resolution w a s directed t o alliage t h e Board's

attention to the fact that it seemed an important matter, t o
be dealt with either b y a redefinition o f what constitutes
a deposit requiring only three per cent reserve - —

Mir, Goldenweiser (interrupting:) I

forgot t o Bay

that the Board, i n its review this month, h a s @ discussion
of the price situation, I

have some copies o f t he page

proof run off and I would like t o distribute them.
There i s one point that I did not mention i n discussing prices, which I think i s a n important factor i n the
decline o f prices, a n d that h a s been t h e plentiful output

506
and the increased productivity o f laber., T h e r e has been,
Bince 1925, a n i n orease i n productivity that i s striking,
while the employment statistics show that the volume o f
persons employed b a s inoréased v e r y little,

S t i l l produc

tion has increased very greatly, and in general, i n the
last three o r f our years, there has been an inorease o f
about t e n per cent i n output which, I F believe,

i s ungquestion-

ably one of the important elements i n the price decline.
The other thing I meant t o say, and I em sorry I did

not think of it i n time, and that i s the paradoz of business
increasing very rapidly while prices are declining i s a w
Companied b y another phenhomenon, a n d that i s that business
hag been profitable a n d during the same period earmings o f
corporations h a v e been v e r y lerge. D u r i n g 1926 they were

larger than i n almost any previous year.

I n the first quar-

ter o f the present y s a r they have been large, T h e r e has, hom.
ever, b e e n a

tendenoy towards selection.

T h e r e have been

@ good many corporations, the smaller and less important
corporations that have not been s o successful, and the large
volume o f total carnirigs has b e m d u e t o the very great
suucess

o f s o m e corporations,

T h a t i s accompanied

b y the

fact that commercial failures i n the first quarter have been


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

507
very large a n d the aggregate liability v e r y large,

s o that

this large volume o f production, t h e decrease i n the price
level, d o e s s e e m t o result i n keen competition,

i n greater

difficulty f o r a number o f concerns t o b e successful, a n d
yet t h e earnings continue exceptionally high.

Governor Crissinger.

W h a t have you t o say as to the

gold standard being responsible f o r t h e lower prices?

Governor Strong, I

am not at all sure about that, be-

cause those index prices are s 0 heavily weighted with commo~
dities that represent world prices, they readjust themselves
automatically t o the common level o f the goldbasis, a n d

I wouldn't attach s o much significance t o that a s I would
o a very wide differenace
to our o w n price index b a s e d n

in commodities.

T h e thing that impresses m e about t h e

price movement here i s t he fact that a t a time when the
discount rates o f the Federal reserve banks exerted n o pressure whatever u p o n t h e member banks, t h e fact that w e bought

securities very heavily —- certainly the price situation
is not o n l y steady b u t has shown a tendency t o advance,

and since wesold some three hundred million dollars o f
these securities, t h e first effect was t o put the banks
more heavily i n our debt, t h e y borrowed more money f r o m us,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

508

and they don't like to borrow money from us, and they have
now succeeded i n this year i n redecing their borrowings

to a great extent, although not entirely, a n d that coincides with the tendency o f prices t o fall - - i f w e are going

to arrive a t any conclusion o r analogy from that i t would
seem t o m e that t h e pressure o f liquidating a t t h e Federal

Reserve Banks might have some connection - - I won't s a y
how much - ~ o n the general movement o f prices

i n some way.

It may be just coincidence, b u t i t certainly i s a fact
that a t t h e t i m e w h e n t h e b a n k s w e r e o u t o f o u r d e b t w e

were experiencing a

price decline, a n d n o w they have suc-

ceeded, after having been forced t o borrow through a period
when w e sold three hundred millions o f securities —

in

managing t o liquidate andget m o r e o u t o f o u r debt t h a n they

were last year, a n d we have this continued price decline
rather accelerated.

Mir. Goldenweiser. I

do not think so. I t was 147 i n

December and January, 140 i n February, 1 4 5 t n warch and

April,

O f course we haven't the Byreau of Labor Stat istics,

but ours s h o w that i t has been steady.

Governor Bailey, H o w many items are included i n the
Bureau o @ Labor Statistics?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. Goldenweiser.
Governor Bailey,

4 4 0 .
A n d i n yours?

iy. Goldenweiser. 2 8 8 , that i s all w e can gét.

O u r

fluctuates more because i t i s unfinished articles, w h i c h
are Stable i n price.

T h e y a r e hard t o get.

O u r s has more

of the nature o f a raw material index than theirs,

T h a t line showing the increase i n

Governor Strong.

thirty

prices over a period of/years h a s been accompanied b y a
very great increase i n the volume o f business, h a s i t not?
Mr. Goldenweiser.

Yes.

Governor Strong, T h e question i s whether there i s any
way t o ascertain whether t h e raté

o f increase i n bank cre-

dite h a s reasonably followed t h e rate o f increase i n both
prices a n d volume.

I f i t has not, n a t u r a l l y t h e r e i s s o m e

possible pressure upon credit, not expressed i n our rate 680
much a g i n a n a b s o l u t e l a c k o f desire o r r e l u c t a n c e

to

borrow from the reserve banks, a n d that i s being furnished

probably b y the weakening of the reserve position through
the conversion o f demand into time denosits,
My. Goldenweiser. I
actly, b u t I

haven't t h e figures i n mind e x

do not think there i s evidence that t h e growth

of bank credit h a s fallen behind t h e growth o f business.

510
do not know that there a r e

Governor Strong. I

I do someany figures t o fall back o n t o relate to, but


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

liabilities—
thing o f the rate o f growth o f bank assets a n d
wir. Goldeaweiser.

loans i s s i x
T h e rate o f growth o f

per cent.

Governor Strong.

I t will average over t h e year s i x t o

seven.
years i s
Mr. Goldenweiser. T h a t average through many
per cent during
very high because o f the growth o f 1 3 t o 1 4
the war inflation.
Bovernor Strong,

I t i s like that l i n e y o u projected

in prices (indicating o n plat).

I f you project the line

will
of growth o f bank deposits during that period you
or
find i t works out just about the way that works out,
the w a y a n y projected line does.

T h e point i s that this

b u t with some
last year with a large volume o f business,
h a s been arrested
price decline, t h e growth o f bank deposits
to gome extent.

Mr. Goldenweiser.

A s I say, i f you take out the war

o f increase, y o u get
years, w i t h their larger percentage

six o r seven per cent (indicating).

Governor Strong, I

say if you draw the line exactly


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Sll
as you have d r a m i t there, a n d take the average —- w e have
done i t i n New York — - w i n WEEK find that t h e averga works
out just about a s your price average there.
wr. Goldenweiser.

T h e bank credit i s just about what

it would b e if it was continued (indicating).

Governor Strong, O r a little bit below.
ilr. Goldenweiser. Y e s .

I t wouldn't b e very much be-

low, I do not think.
Mr. James. M r . Goldenweiser, m a y I ask wat effect, o n
both t h e v o l u m e o f business a n d p r i c e level,

t h e change

in

the price o f cotton has, with particular reference t o the
exports o f cotton i n 1925 and ! 267 T h e r e i s a very vast
difference i n the value, yet, I imagine, there were more
bales a n d pounds o f cotton exported than there were i n the
previous year.
Mr. Goldenweiser.

Yes. I

haven't t h e figures f o r that

exactly, b u t the decline i n the cotton price was a n import.
ant element i n the decline i n the nrice level.

ilp, James. W h a t I have i n mind is with reference t o
bank deposits.
Mr. G o l d e n w e i s e r .

Yes.

Mr. James. E x p o r t e d cotton from this coun try i s a

raw Material, sold abroad,
Mr. Goldensweiser. Y e s .
Mr. James.

A n d the assumption i s that the value o f that

is reflected immediately back i n our deposit accounts, i s i t
not?
wir. Goldenweiser.

ir. James.

Y e s ,

a n d i f they fell off t w o hundred million

or three hundred million i n value, o n e year against t h e
other, w o u l d that i n itself account f o r the stopoage o f

these bank devosits a t a level, without reference t o what
they a r e i n this country —
think i t mould. I

Mr. Goldenweiser, I

haven't t h e

figures i n mind, b u t m y impression i s that w i t h the lower
price o f cotton t h e imports a n d exports increased sufficiently t o make i t up.
wr, James.
figures

T h e value w a s less. I

can get t h e exact

i f y o u w a n t them,

idr. Goldenweiser.

Y o u say the value was less?

wr, James. Y e s , considerably less.
Mr, Goldenwieser.
Mr, James.
MtL2ion.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

O f c o u r s e t h e t w o u l d b e a n element.

M y recollection

i s i t w a s something l i k e 8 0 0

Mr, Goldenweiser.
Governor Strong.

T h a t sounds reasonable, yes.
Y o u mean the decline i n the value

of the total crop?
wir. James,

N o , t h e decline i n the value o f the e x —

ports o f raw material.

T h e minute that i t lands a t the

shipping port t h e money comes i n t o this country a n d that

money i s deposited hpre against that exportation.
Mr, Harrison.

ir, James.

2 0 0 million less?

T h e value o f the cotton exported, a s I

recall, i n round figures, was $200,000,000 less i n 1926
than i t w a s i n 1925, a l t h o u g h t h e n u m b e r

was larger;

o f bales e x p o r t e d

s o that your volume o f business i s increased but

your return i s lessened a n d your bank denosits directly a r e

affected quicker b y that than b y any other thing that I
know of.

wir, Goldenweiser.

O f course $200,000,000 i s not a very

big factor i n that.
Mr. James. W o , but w e were talcing about a n approximate
figure i n the matter o f bank deposits.

Governor Strong,

T h a t has been offset b y other things.

Wheat has also declined. W h e a t was second i n 1985. N o w
automobiles a r e second.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr, James, Y e s , b u t t h e point i

a m trying t o get

exports t o bank dethrough m y head i s the real Telation o f
i s reflected
T h e minute a n export i s made that

posits.

right bace i n our bank deposits, i s it not?
Mr, Goldenweiser. I
wir, James.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

t

for
T h e cotton t h a t i s exported i s paid

i t l e a v e s t h e s e shores.

before
o

would doubt that.

an

e me h e

Mr, miller.

4
Y o u have i n the price commodities

a n d wheat a t prices o n
great many commodities Like cotton
the world market — wir, Goldenweriser,
ir, Miller.

Yes.

T h i s movement

o f domestic eredits follows

a s @ normal relationthe price a n d y o u assume t h e other
o f credit.
ship, o f price following t h e volume
iir+ Goldenweiser,

wir, Miller.

Y e s .

eliI s there any method b y which you can

charts
minate t h o s e f r o m y o u r p r i c e

s o a s t o s h o w the domes—

factors are intic movenent o f orices where purely domestic
volved?
Mr, Goldenweiser.

fully. I

success—
Y e s , t h a t c a n b e done very

a distinction
understand what sik seni T h e r e i s

non-sheitered industries,
between what w e call sheltered a n d

515
and the cost o f living enters into the sheltered industries —

Governor Strong, T h e consumers’ goods?
wt, Goldenweiser. Y e s .

T h a t i s stuff that cannot

beexported, T h a t i s about 170 (indicating),
iir, James.

T h e r e i s another factor that enters i n t o

the proposition, through the character o f credit that i s
eligible f o r rediscount a t t h e Reserve Bank a n d that which

is not,

I n other words, automobile paper i s per s e inel-

igible, but we all know that automobile paper i s about the
most liquid thing a bank can have, a n d i t i s very desir—

able paper. N o w in order to take care of a lot of that
it may be possible that the banks are using eligible paper
arising out o f some other transactions t o provide funds
which they may invest i n the other. T h a t may have a bearing o b it.

lir, Goldenweiser. A
ir. James.

bearing o n what, Mr, James?

. 4 bearing o n the volume o f credit, t h e

‘voluidel: c r e d i t used a n d i t s relation t o the Federal R e ~
serve oredit.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr, Goldenweiser.

Yes.

Governor Crissinger. I

think Governor Calkyjns wants t o

516

is
say something and I know we would like to hear what


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

going o n i n the empire state o f California.
Governor Calcins. I
very i n t e r e s t i n g

d o not k n o w that I

can add anything

o r informing, e x c e p t t o s a y t h a t I

think

little more
conditions o n the Pacific Coast are perhaps a
favorable t h a n t h e y are i n the country a s 4 whole.

Agri-

u p to
culturally t h e season has been extremely favoradile
this time. I

mean i n the entire district.

T h e r e a r e a few

of
bad spots o f course, o n e of them being the unscrambling
the situation i n the lumber industry i n t h e Northwest,
which was pretty badly demoralized, without a n y apparent
prospect

o f e a r l y improvement.

good,
The banking situation appears t o m e t o b e fairly

except i n some spots, about which you are informed.

One question which seems t o me to be of importance,
is
and which has been mentioned once o r twice publicly,
b u t that h a s
the expansion o f branch banking i n California,
sufficient
not y e t brought a n y developments t h a t a r e o f

importance t o determine what its future will be, T h e r e
the
is just now a stopping point, o f course, b u t how long
expansion w i l l r e m a i n s t a t i o n a r y i

termine.

think w e cannot y e t d e -

W e haven't a n y conditions, except individual


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

517
conditions, a n d w e all have those, which are disturbing.
We h a v e s o m e i n d i v i d u a l c o n d i t i o n s w h i c h a r e n o t satisfac.

tory a n d w e will continue t o have t h e m f o r some time.
If anyone wishes t o ask m e any questions 1 will b e
glad t o answer then.
Vice-Governor Platt..

I

s there a n y tendency shown

yet on the part o f non-member State banxs t o extend branches, t o amount t o anything?
Governor Calxins.

have been a

N o c o n s i d e r a b l e tendency.

There

few applications m a d e t o the State department

o
f non-member S t a t e banks.
for b r a n c h e s r

Vice-Governor Platt. Small banks, o r the larger ones?
Governor Calkins. S e v e r a l branches have been established b y the California Bank, w h i c h i s the largest b a n k

outside of the System; and several b y smaller institutions,
but none o f any particular importanoe.

Mr, Myller. H a s the pride of California been affected
any since i t has one of the three o r four largest national
banks i n the country?

Governor Oalkins. I

think so, T h e y seem to be in-

clined t o mention the fact occasionally. T h e y spend a good

deal of money i n advertising.

T h e y have the largest


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

518
anywhere.

national bank accounts o f I don't k n e w where —

After having prepared some expensive engraved announcements

to that effect they had t o back dom, because the Bank o f
Italy nationalizes a n d far outstripped them.

Governor Crissinger. I

think i t would b e interesting

to know how the weather conditions are affecting t h e agricul.
tural situation i n the Mississippi watershed.

T h a t would

include Iowa, Illinois, Indiana, myssouri, a n d all that agricultural country, Governor Biggs.

Governor Biggs.

I

t has affected i t very seriously

in the f looded s e cion o f the district, b u t not very much
in wissouri, except t h e extreme southern part.

I t seems

to have passed on. There has been a great deal o f damage
4n Arkansas a n d wississippi, b u t t h e danger,

s o far a s I

can s e e now, h a s almost passed.
Govemor Crissinger. I

was not referring t o the high

water condition a s much a s I was t o the lateness o f the crop,
Governor Biggs.

T n e y a r e feeling q u i t e a

little d l a r m e d

over that, over the fact o f the extreme weather, a n d wonder—
ing whether the water will get off i n time for them t o make
anything

o f acrop, p a r t i c u l a r l y

i n t h e Delta.

T h e y think

that the strong winds will help and that they may be able t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

get i n their cotton a s late a s Juné d e

W h a t about the effect o n the

Governor Crissinger.
corn crop i n Iowa? ,

Governor Biggs. I
seriously a t all,

do not think it has affected them

o n yet.

O f course i t will b e late o n

e
h
t out o f the fields, a & well
account o f the rain k e e p i n g m
as the water from the idississipol and the rivers that over—
flow.

Y o u take away that factor, t h e operations a
:

e a ae

Darr x

ahead about as usual. Although they are ten-er-twelve
weeks l a t e , t h e y h a v e a m p l e t i m e t o m a k e ac r o p w i t h a n y

seasonable weather,

Governor Crissinger. ‘ h a t have you to say about that,
Gavernor McDougal?
Governor MeDowgal.

t h y S e n e t t o the crop prospects

in Iowa, t h e y have h a d a n abundance o f rain, perhaps more

than normal, Fortunately i t has been general and i t has
covered the whole i t i , b a t bas left a soil condition, ac-

cording t o the reports, which is more favoreble than they
have had for a number o f years, T h i s i e Putty fortunate
condition for t hose distzicts where they have been suffering s o long and where they have had repeated crop failures.
and
Gorn planting i s just starting now, which i s unusual,

520
the rains have delayed t h e planting o f the small grains,
particularly oats.

T h e result i s some reduction i n the a c r e

age, which i s not a bad things O a t & d o aot produce much
anyhow.

But as the result of the unusually good soil conditions,
as I have stated, there has been very much improvement.
That does not have very much effect o n the banking situation
but i t has o n the ctop prospects, a n d we are told that
the farmers generally speaking a r e feeling very mich better.
Governor Crissinger.
Governor McDougal,
4s somewhat similar.

I s that true i n Illinois?

T h e situation i n Ijlinois I

think

O f course w e were unfortunate l a s t

year, a s you *now, i n that we had too mich rainfall there.
I think oonditions a r e very favorable f o r planting i n I11inois. I

do not k n o w whet h e r y o u want m e t o cover t h e gen-

eral business situation o r not.
Governor Crissinger.

Y e s .

Governor iipDougal, T h e general businéss situation, a s
reported t o us, i s very satisfactory out there.
stopped t o some extent,

I t has

Y o u knev the situation pretty well

in regard t o the automobile industry, I

was i n Detroit

_two o r three weeks ago and I was told at that time that ship-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

521
ments o f automobiles f r o m Detroit during t h e year u p t o

date had been not t o exceed 5 0 per cent o f what they were
last year.

car
T h a t i s speaking numerically w i t h regard t o

shipments a n d not i n volume o f dollars.

I t i s due very

largely t o the slowing d o w o f the Ford industry, w h i c h
F o r d employs

Means more t o the city than anything else.
normally about 116,000 m e n i n his plant.

M o s t o f those men

are employed now but they are o n part time, n o more than
half time, worting about three days a week, a n d that o f
course i s unfortunate, T h e r e i s some grievance i n regard
to the real estate operations, particularly i n the outskirts,
and that i s true i n Chicago t o some extent.

T h é building

situation, according t o reports, seems t o be going along
about the same a s last year, although there are some chenges
in the character o f construction, a n d has been slowing d o m
@ good deal i n the outskirts.

V e have a bad condition i n

Wisconsin, with which you are probably familiar, caused
by the canning situation u p there.

T h a t State c a n s a very

large part o f the peas that a r e »vut out a n d there i s a n accumWlation o f i n v e n t o r i e s

u p there, h e l d o v e r f r o m l a s t year,

and some held over from the year before.

T h e canning indus—

try i s not i n good shape i n our district. U n f o r t u n a t e l y


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

that applies t o corn too.
However, generally speaking, t h e business situation,
with t h e exception o f those spots,

i s pretty satisfactory.

The credit situation i s very satisfactory.

T h e banks a r e

not calling unon t h e Feder Reserve Bank f o r a great d e a l o f
credit, except t h o s e districts that have n o t y e t recovered
from t h e situation t h e y have been i n for s o long a time.
Governor Orissinger.

ernor McDougal?

A r e there a n y questions o f G o v

I f n o t , %will hear from Governor Bailey.

Governor Bailey,

W e are late i n our planting o f

winter wheat i n Kansas, which i s the big thing i n the State.
That holds good i n Oklahoma. I

would say we are estimating

@ 150 million bushel crop o f wheat i n Kansas this year.

I t

is wheat weather, b u t they have h a d s o much moisture i n
the fields that t h e wheat i s growing pretty rank a n d a good
deal o f apprehension i s being felt about whether o r not t h e
wheat will get moldy, I

never s a w the wheat look better.

In most o f the States there has been a good deal o f i t cut
as a result o f the d r y weather. A

good many o f the central

counties i n Kansas have h a d partial failures f o r four o r five
years, b u t they have n o w the best prospect t h e y have h a d i n
the history o f the State. I

think o u c district i s going


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

along o n an even keel,
In Nebraska t h e y are late i n getting their corn in.

They ought t o have the corn planted b y the 15th o f say,
and therewasn't t e n per cent o f i t planted w h e n I left a

week ago, but i f the weather gets good they will b e able
to come out all right.

I believe the State o f Colorado i s further ahead i n
her general prosperity than any State i n our District.
There has bean a

wonderful snow-fall o n the mountains. I

have some irrigated land o u t there. I

was o u t there about

three weeks ago. T h e r e has been a n awful rainfall.

Governor Orissinger.

M h a t about the live stock situa-

tion? ,

Governor Bailey, That i s likely t o get u s i n trouble
again —

|

Governor Orissinger.

T e l l u s how.

Governor Bailey, The people are selling their steers
at twelve and a half dollars i

tettae i n the pasture.

When @ man pays eight or nine dollars a hundred and feeds

the steer, and then can sell it for 12-1/2, there is too
mich spread tere and they will sell them off,

I f we

could ever vet the thing so we could have a decent spread,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

524
steer
that i s s 0 a man when h e wnaid eight dollars f o r @

h e fed
was pretty sure o f getting ten dollars for i t then
him, l i k e i t u s e d t o b e i n t h e g o o d o 1 d cays,

get along.

w e could

B u t this i s too much o f a gamble — - there i s

too much p e n t .

a n d I think t

h e danger i s i n vaying s o

much for these feeders,
Governor Crissinger.

H o w about the old co”, Governor

Bailey?
Governor Bailey,
all over t h e District,

T h e old cov is coming into her o m
T h e y a r e going into t h e cattle

of
business a n d there i s some t a l k right n o w o f shartage

cattle o n the range, T h e old c o w that used t o bring $15,
they a r e n o w getting fifty t o sixty dollars f o r her,
You take hogs, a n d with a n old s o w you get a

a 2

lot o f vigs

in a little while, but it tates longer to get catyes.It
want
is getting t o b e the fashion u p there f o r people t o

that
yearling calves, a n d they are selling s o many of them
look
they won't have a n y three y e a r o l d steers i f they don't
out.

F o r instance,

i n one county u o there, one o f the big-

gest f e e d counties, a

man had cattle that would average

fifteen t o sixteen hundred pounds, a n d he would get eight
more i n
or nine dollars i n Xansas C i t y a n d fifty cents


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

525
Chicago. Everybody said i t was a mistake and they ought
to put i n lighter cattle.

T h e result was that the fellow

who had the light cattle w u l d get ten dollars and a half
and the man that h a d the thousand pound steer would g e t t e n

dollars and a half a t the same place, instead o f the man
with the lighter steers getting eight and a half.
Mr. Mgller. Governor wicDougal, what i s the vacking: sit.
uation i n Chicago?

Governor McDougal. I

think the big packers this year,

particularly i n the early part o f January, February a n d
idarch, have not hadvery satisfactory business.
sion i s i t has been a

M y impres-

little b i t better since then.

O n e

of the great difficulties with the lerger packers curing
the last fewyears has been the South American situation,
I t has been

which has been very unprofitable t o then.
unprofitable

t o both §

wift a n d Armour.

I

t i s hard t o

tell from the book-keeping, because i n one o f the companies
they include the South a merican operations i n their domestic
statements. S w i f t & Company d o that,

W e know Swift & Com—

pany h a d a pretty profitable business year last year p u t
a material loss i n South America.
Governor Strong.

T h a t w a s brought a b o u t

b y t h e sitva-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

526

tion i n the British market, t h e selling o f stuff below cost.
Governor McDougal,

Competition, yes.

T h e r e have

been reports indicating that that trouble i s being recon-

ciled, but i t is not reflected i n their results o f operations.

O n the other hand, while i t is curious, I think i t

is true t h a t agoa many of the small packers have been
doing very well, those tho understand their business.
They have a

very good c r o p o f what t h e y call soring vigs. I

guess Governor B a i l e y c a n tell u s about that better t h a n I

can.
Governor Bailey, S p r i n g pigs a r e pigs that a r e born

in the spring.
Governor Crissinger. G o v e r n o r Wellborn?

V e will hear

from you,

Governor Wellborn, _ ily district i s getting along pretty
well, Florida, I believe, h a s attracted more attention
throughout t h e nation than a n y other State i n our district.

Two-thirds o f the Florida banxs that are menber banks are

not borrowing anything at all.
The manufacturing business i n our district i s doing
exceedingly well, b o t h t e x t i l e andiron. I

think o n t h e

whole w e are getting along very well down thers T h e r e has


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

527

been some recession i n building, which has caused some
unemployment.

Governor Bailey, T h e 011 industry, w h i c h i s some indus—

try i n Oklahoma and Kansas, i s showing a reduction i n crude
Oil and they are laying off their men, I t i s affecting business i n the cities imnediately aijacent t o the oil fields.
have o n our board n o w wr. Phillips,
Company, a

most excellent man,

W e

o f the Phillips Petroleum

W e have a

plan o f holding

oyemdirectors' meeting each year with our Board at our
branch.

W e went d o w n i n t o O r l a h o m a t o s e e t h e c o n d i t i o n

and w e met a

lot o f the oil men, t h e most representa.

tive bunch of oil men that I ever saw, and they were very
blue. I
there, I

wanted o u r board t o see h o w w e handled loans d o m
think w e will have t o furnish a

good deal o f

money t o our oil banks Adie there during the summer and I
do not xnow whether i t would b e interesting t o you how we
lend t h e money o n oil.
Governor Orissinger. I
Governor Bailey,

T

think i t would.

e have t v o ways o f doing it.

O n e

way i s where t h e y put i t i n these b i g tanks a n d cruise it,

tell how many gallons i n the tank, o r how many barrels,
Then s o m e o n e t e l l s u s about t h e g a s o l i n e c o n t e n t o f t h e

528
oil. T h a t i s extracted, a n d i t i s sealed u p and padlocked
and a trusteeship m a d e a n d a warehouse r é eipt issued ‘against

the’ oil. T h e banks loan a certain per cent o n the oil.
Right n o w we wouldn't take a very big margin, ‘ h e n the
luctuate,

price o f o i l d o e s n o t f

t h e situation i s a

little

different. T y a t i s one way o f handling it. Tne other way
is o n settled production.

ex.

T h i s aoplies t o the smaller d e a l

H e will show his production for the last sixty days

after t h e production h a s settled —
oil -—— b u t a f t e r i t h a s s e t t l e d

to a

n o t h i s overleflow o f
certain n u m b e r

of

barrels and has shown thet constantly for the last sixty
days.

W e investigate i t very carefully.

T h e n t h e y make

an assigh ment t o the vive linecompany, a n d t h e oil i s d e l i v

ered and paid for each week, vaid into the bank which maxes
the loan. R i g h t n o w they would loan about 7 0 per cent.
Governor Seay,

I s the o i l insured?

Governor B a i l e y ,

I

t i s i n s u r e d i n t h e tanss,

b u t not

insured i n the pipe line.

Governor Crissinger.

h e there any way o f them putting

o the tanks o n you?
water i n the b o t t o m f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Bailey, I

have never heard o f it. T h e y might.

Governor strong, W h y d o you say that the banks re-

529
quire more margin o n laans o n oil i f i t declines a dollar
a barrel, t h e n when i t i s a dollar higher?
Governor Bgiley.

T h e margin must b é maintained a n d I

would ask for extra collateral, I t is just the same a s hav—

ing a steady market here. I

think you would loan more

money o n wheat w h e n t h e marxet i s steady t h a n y o u would w h e n
it i s fluctuating fifteen o r twenty cents a day.

Governor Strong, Y o u wuld want more margin selling a t
three datiees than y o u would a t a dollar?

Governor Bailey, Y e s .
Governor ebons.

I t strikes m e that t h a t i s one thing

that might h a v e agreat effect o n their profits.

I f the vro-

ducers are forced t o put u p moremargin 4,t might force them
to sell the oil a t a lower r i c e .

Governor Orissinger. Governor Talley, will you let u s

hear from you?
Governor Talley. w i r , Qhairman and gentDemen, our dis—
trict has nothing speciel t o complain about a t the present
time; there has been sane deley i u getting the farm operations started.

J e have had pretty heavy rdins i n sone

~etts of the district The cotton planting is pretty well
opepleted u p as f a r as, I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

would say, t h e @ n t r a l a n d scuth


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

530
part o f Texas.

W e are just beginning t o study the probable

W e estimate there i s

effects o f the Mississippi flood.
about a

million a n d a half bales o f cotton which was produced

last year i n the flooded area, a n d that i s bound t o have
some effect o n prices later, according t o what they are
able t o d o after t h e floods recede.

I t i s getting s o late

that i t seems that they a r e pretty well up,against i t a s
far a s producing a n y cotton i n that area i s concerned,

A n y

price changes probably will become more pronounced after w e

are through with that crop, which is considered t o end about
the 31st o f July.
I do not think i t will increase the acreage any, be@use t h e y usually plant a s much crop a s they c a n i n our district anyway.
age. I

T h e r e won't b e very much.rreduction i n a c r e

should s a y a million acres would probably cover i t

so f a r asTexas i s concerned, a n d i t rrobably won't b e that
large.

The outstanding thing right n o w in the district i s what
Governor Bailey refers t o as the petroleum situation ~ - over
production and decline i n price.

N o t only that, but for

the last six weeks o r two months, almost every week they
have discovered a new oil area, particularly i n Tems.

Sev-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

531
eral new fields have been brought in. S o m e o f them con—
tain oil o f high gravity and the reduction i n price o f

course affects that materially, although the high gravity
fields are not always heavy producing fields.
Dr. Goldenweiser spoxe c f the decrease i n business
at a certain time i n the agricultural areas but that after
the first o f the year i t seemed t o move along pretty well.
I think what i s partially responsible for that i s t he fact
that t h e cotton c r o p was not o n l y larger b u t i t was v e r y
late a n d the realization that a

lot o f cotton, t h e abéndon-

ment o f which w a s contemplated, w o u l d b e picked, h a d come

rather late. I n other words I

do not think we can begin ’

to get t h e major portion o f our return f r o m the cotton crop,
as affecting business i n the Disirict, u n t i l pretty well

after the first o f the year.

T , i s shows i n the increase

in bank deposits i n the District between t h e call o f Sep-

tenber 8 1 and of March 23, a s directly reflected i n the
increase o f the level o f our rescrve deposits.

When the price decline i n cottoa began t o overtake the
district, t h e r e w a s a t first 8

g u c d d v e l o f disappointment,

then demorlization and disorgaiination. A l o n g i n Januery
there came w very strong effcrt fer some sort o f expecicnt


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

532
action. T h a t was reflected i n o u r — I

won't s a y operations—

t o persuade a
but i n our activities i n the bank i n trying
must borrow heavily
lot o f banks o u t o f the idea that t h e y
increase
simply b e c a u s e t h e y d i d n o t h a v e t h e

i n bank d é —

fall a n d spring.
posits that t h e y usually have every
advisedthem

t o wait a

bit.

W

W e

u
o own assets pretty
e examinedr

part o f January
carefully. L a t e r o n i n January, t h e latter
a considerable deand the lst o f February, there was quite
agricultural c o u n
cline i n bank loans, particularly i n the
comes a t the end
try banks, a n d then o f course, a s always
o f that kind, t h e
of a veriod o f that kind o r a situation
application o f sound principles.

T h e result has been that

are under—
not only the banks, but the communities themselves
taking t o get along economically i n refermce

t o t h e crop

been @
production a n d therefore there h a s not

very great d e -

tibia:
mand f o r credit. N o t w i t h s t a n d i n g t h e disappointing
vick u p anything
last f a l l w e d o not expect o u r loans t o
won't g o over
like as: high a s they w e r e lass y e a T h e y

sixty per cent o f what they were last year.
Governor Crissinger.

H o t generally i s your c o w country

restocked?

Governor Talley. Restocked i n livestock?

Governor Crissinger. Y e s , your cow country.
Governor Talley,

T h e banks generally seem t o be re—

pretty well

fraining/from following the increase i n cattle prices.
Governor Crissinger.
Governor Talley,

W h o furnishes the cattle?

B y loaning o n cattle a t these high

prices f o r restocking purposes. I

should s a y i n our district

there h a s been v e r y little restocking done.

W h a t restocking

has taken plage h a s come f r o m t h e natural inorease i n the
last t w o years.

T h e r e was a

time when i t looked like t h e

range prices were a l l out o f line with the packer market

prices. However, packer prices have recededto a point where
they a r e more comparable with range nrices t h a n t h e y were

ayear ago. T h e r e i s a distincet and pronounced disinclina—
tion o n the yart o f the. banks t o follow these prices u p and

to lend for testocking purposes.

W i t h regard t o the range

course
prices being out o f line with the packing prices, o f
the condition o f the grass has quite a n effect o n that and
as l o n g a s t h e y h a v e p l e n t y o f g r a s s t h é r e i s n ' t

sure o n the market.

I

a n y pres—

n that part o f our district which

adjoins Governor Bailey's district, particularly i n New
idexico, i t only goes back t o 1919 and 1920 when those ranges
“were o v e r s t o c k e d —


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

t h e y w e r e overstocked e v e n before t h a t o n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

534
@ normal basis, a n d consequently when t h e grass began t o
let down a terrible condition s e t in, a n d they are remember—
ing that lesson.
Governor S e a y ,

Fifth District.

T h e r e a r e n o noteworthy changes

i n the

T h e aggregate value o f the two principal

crops, cotton a n d tobacco, w a s very much less last y e a r i n

comparison with the preceding year, a n d that has had its
effect.

O u r banks are borrowing but little more than half

of what they were borrowing from us jast year+ T h e lower
price o f cottom has h a d some compensating effect o n the
i s experiencing consid—

textile industry a n d that industry
erable revival.

There i s a feeling o f depression i n South Carolina,
particularly, w h e r e there have been a
ures i n the last t w o o r three years.
has f a l l e n t o a

great m a n y bank failT h e value o f farm lands

v e r y l o w l v e l a n d a t t h i s t i m e t h e r e i s prac-

tically n o sale f o r f a r m land.

T

h

e season i s somewhat b a c k

ward, but that i s not unusual, a n d that its effect will b e
upon the outcome, whether favorable o r unfavordle, cannot b e
told a t this time.
n one o f our States, N o r t h
The value o f the c r o p g : i
Cavo7ina,

i s very high, a n d North Carolina i s i n 2 much Det-

ter s h a p e t h a n h e r sister—State,

S o u t h Carolina...

, I m y statement i s correct that there
Onthe w h o l ethink
i the situation which have not
aré n o noteworthy c h a n g e s ’ n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

t you for some time.
been k n o w n . o

Governor Harding..

W e have heard a great deal about ex,

h
T Boston District
cessive rain. in some o f the d i s t r i c t s , e
fires
has been v e r y dry,., There have been 4 good many forest

m they had close calls for a while,
in Massachusettsd

A t

o f rain
the time I left Boston but three-quarters o f an inch
are
had fallen i n the entire year o f 1927, T h e reservoirs

pretty low. There has been nothing i n the way of crop Tea yet.
t a r d a t i o ns

W e won't begin until about the lst of

o f this
June, although w e may get etarted about t h e middle

month.

T h e mills are doing a little better.

I n two

but as a
or three companies dividends h a v e been resumed,

rule the textile situation i s depressed.

T h e woolen t rade

up
has been bad, although some o f the wool dealers have used
stocks b y sales abroad.

T h e railroads s e e m tote

i n very

advancing,
good condition, B o s t o n & laine securities a r e

lines
They have gotten r i d of a number o f unprofitable
cut orf.
which the Interstate Commerce Commission Let them
o v e r these little lines
The c o m m u n i t i e s i n t e r e s t e d h a v e t a k e n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

536
and they have been able t o keep t h e m i n operation.

wany

of the textile mills have made connections i n the South.

Itis getting to be quite the thing for New England mills
to have a

southern connection.

I n some Spates efforts have

been made torrelieve the mills o f excessive taxation.

N e w

Hampshire recently passed @ law, which i s before the Supreme
Court, a u t h o r i z i n g t o m s

property,

t o make special discounts

o n mill

I n other cases they have reduced the assessments.

I am inclined to think + hat we have a situation in the
mills t h a t will w o r k out i n the course o f three o r four

years b y the process o f natural selection and the survival

think theré will be aegood many mergers

ofthe fittest, I

of mills i n the same tow, effecting economies i n overhead,
a
h been depressed but reand s o forth, T h e shoe b u s i n e s s s
cent reportstare that i t is improving. S a v i n g s banks de-

posit s have increased. F e d e r a l Reserve Bank deposits have
shown a tendency t o increase u p to t he last thirty days
from t h e banxing s t a n d p o i n t , Probably t h e most interesting thing, /is the yarge increase
in time deposits.

I

t i s a general r u l e t o a e jnterest

on all deposits, t w o per cent o n open accounts subject t o

gheck, a n d they have special agreement accounts.
A good many-of t h e large banks have savings departments

537
that allow & per cent interest o n savings accounts.
orominent banker t o l d m e that h e has, o r had, a

O n e

number o f

accounts i n his savings department runni n g from a hundred
to a hundred and fifty thousand dollars.

H

e had decided

that h e would pay four per cent o n savings deposits u p t o
ten thousand dollars, a n d three per cent o n all above that,
He put that rule in,

A s a result i n the first thirty days

he lost a million dollars i n deposits.

I t went from 3 4

Million t o 33. H i s principal cometitor h a d n o such rule
and his deposits shaved a n increasing tendency.
The mutual Savings banks have a limit o n the amount t h e y

will receive from any one depositor.

I n view of the fact

that t h e iicFedden Act emphasizes t h e distinction between s a v

ings deposits and other denosits because i t makes savings
depostts a s one basis f o r real estate loans made b y banks,

b a better
I think it is very important that there s h o u l e
defi ition o f time deposits a n d savings deposits.

I t was

discussed here the other d a at this conference and I pointed
out t h e difficulties that t h e Feceral Reserve Board h a d i n

meeting that problem, expressing the opinion that nothing
gould b e done except b y legislation. I

really think i t would

be a good idea t o suggest t o Congress that i t define i n t he


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

538
law what a savings account is, end place a limitation o n
it. I

should think i t could say that n o member bank, n o

dedeposit i n a member bank shall b e construed a s a savings

posit unless i t i s issued against t he pass-book, which must
be presented with a check, a n d that n o account will b e received f r o m any o n e person, f i r m o r corporation,

o r b y any

five
bank i n the savings department amounting t o more t h a n
or ten thousand dollars. I

effect. I

think that might have a good

think the mutual savings banks would agree t o

increase their limit.
Governor Seay.

Y o u would consider what effect that

might have i n driving deposits into the State institutions.
Governor Harding,

i l y information i s that the State

their sav—
institutions haven't t h e extremes t o deal with i n
ings department a s have the national banks.

Governor Seay.

I t would b e well t o consider, i n ask-

it
ing Congress t o pass a law like that, t h e effect t h a t
might have i n driving deposits f r o m national banks i n t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

state banks.

Governor Strong.

T h e state barks a s a Tule have re-

nro
quirements o f higher reserve then t h e McFadden A c t
vides f o r t

h e n a t i o n a l banks.

Governor Seay. S o m e have and some have not.
Vice Governor Platt.

I n N e w York there i s n o reserve

requirenent f o r savings deposits.

Governor §trong.

I n the mutual savings banks,

Vice Governor Platt.

I s there any reserve requirement

in any o f them?

Governor Strong. T h e y have t o have a reserve, I

forget

whether i t is three per cent o r five pr cent, i n cash i n
their vaults.

O f course they are very strictly limited i n

the u s é they may make o f their funds.

Vice Governor Platt, T h e y are strictly limited i n investments, but there was a controversy i n the case o f combina~

tion of two banks, one of thioh is a trust company, and
@ non-mewber, whether that combined bank would become 4
member o f the Federal Reserve System, a n d o n e o f the argu-ments presented w a s that there w a s n o requirenent f o r réeserve o n savings deposits a t all.

Governor Harding,

I n New England there is no reserve

requir emmt for trust companies’


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ir, Harrison. T h e t i s true i n state banks and trust
companies.
Governor Strong,

T h e mutual savings banks have t o keep

540
a cash reserve i n their vaults.

I t i s small, b u t t h e y

dehave t o keep it. T h e y have t o keep a reserve o n time
posits after t h e y reach a certain period before maturity.
I forget that i t is.

Governor Fancher.

I n reading this F e d e r a l Reserve

bulletin here, ‘ the Statement a s to business conditions, I
might say i t reads a s though i t was prepared i n our office.

Itpretty closély fits conditions i n the Fourth District
as to the steel business, the automobile business and the
bituminous coal business.

T h e r e has been some l e t down i n

the volume o f steel business. A
four months w a s had.

pretty fairly satisfactory

W e h a d occasion t o analyze i n our office

some few weexs ago the earnings statements o f 35 large manu—
facturing establishments, representing 1 9 types o f business,

as t o their earnings for the first quarter o f 1927. ‘ T h e

increase in net earnings for the first quarter a s compared
with the last year i s reported b y fourteen concerns, a s compared with 2 2 concerns i n 1926; a

decline b y 12 and n o change

by nine. T h e first quarter's business o n the whole was a

little better than 1926. i
The only very b a d condition i n the Fourth District h a s

been the bituminous coal situation, which has been depressed

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

541
—-

bas

G r e

t

c

N e r e4

a

p

e

for t w o y e a r s

T h e r e w a s s o m e r e t u r n t o operations g r o w i n g

out o f the British strike last year, which stimulated production, with a n increase i n price; then came a lull and then
there was a definite prospect that t h e r e would b e a closing
down o f the mines b y lack o f a renewal o f the Jacksonville
agreement, T h e r e was a good deal o f coal produced i n the
last three months prior t o the first o f April which resulted
in stocking u p large supplies o f coal outside o f the mines.

Now the operators and the miners are simply marking time.
They stand a t a n impasse s o f a r a s maxing a n y settlement i s
concerned,

a n d i t i s known t h a t until t h e stocks o f coal a r e

pretty well used u p there will not be very active negotiations toward a n y settlement.

S

o I rather think t h e coal

situation will drift along until well into the summer. T h e r e
is, however,

s o m e effort being made o n the part o f some o f

the larger operators t o remime operations o n the non-union
basis, and that seems t o be gaining some ground i n certain
parts o f Ohio and in Pennsylvania.
The automobile industry i s going along a t pretty fair
volume b u t not i n the volume o f a year ago.

T h e tire s i t u a

tion in Akron is fairly stable, and it is believed that the
first s i x months! b u s i n e s s w i l l b e m o r e s a t i s f a c t o r y t h a n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

for t h e same period i n 1926.
Tere h a s been quite a falling o f f i n the matter o f
new building permits; q u i t e a marked decrease i n March a n d

in April, F o r the first quarter the permits were nearly
13 per cent less than i n the same period o f 1926.

T h e fall-

ing o f f in March was about 2 5 per cent, 3 0 per cent i n April,
indicating that building conditions are considerably off from
what they were f o r t h e same period a

year agoe

As to banking conditions, o u r member banks are borrow
ing a b o u t t h e s a m e a m o u n t f r o m u s a s t h e y w e r e b o r r o w i n g a

year ago,

A t our peak period i n December w e had 304 member

banks b o r r o w i n g a n d o n M a y 6th, t h e d a y I

came away,

w e had

209. T h e gross amount o f borrowing i n December was a little
in excess o f a hundred millions a n d they a r e n o w d o w t o
about 4 0 million,
We are detecting t h e same condition that Governor Harding

mentions in his district, a gradual, I might say rather
n time deposits which seems t o be occur—
marked, i n c r e a s é i

ring in the banking situation generelly.
Governa Crissinger.

H a s the agricultural situation atf-

fected your country banks t o a n y extent?

Governor Fancher. Not very mich,

I t i s quite surprising.

543

‘Our agricultural banks, the country banks so-called, are


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

borrowing t e n t o eleven million dollars f r o m u s at t h e
present time. I

think a g r i c u l t u r a l c o n d i t i o n s g e n e r a l l y

speaking are fairly satisfactory, except i n some parts
where they have h a d a n excess amount o f rain a n d are a little
late i n getting t h e planting i n s

B u t with a n y sort o f

weather I think on the whole the conditions will be fairly
normal.

Governor Young, I

think y o u can describe the conditions

in our district b y saying that everyone i s marking time hoping
and waiting for a good crop. Prospects o f a crop are good.
There i s plenty o f moisture i n t h e soil, m o r e than w e have

had for a great many years.

W e t weather has delayed planting

AY1 the sm&il grains should be in by May 15th, When I left
there a b o u t a week a g o s o m e p l a c e s h a d p l a n t e d a

hundred

per cent, others eighty, others seventy, a n d all the way down
to 3 5 per cent. I

am in hopes that the grain will all get

in.

The situation in South Dakota and North Dakota; where
they thought it was so bad, and Congress had to make an appropriation o f eight a n d a half million t o take care o f seeding
requirements - — a n d that w a s inoperative because o f the

544
second deficiency bill failing —

I

recertly checkedthat

Situation i n South Dakota a n d t h e secretary o f the South
Dakota Bankers' Association tells m e that there a r e very
few c a s e s w h e r e s e e d : . h a s n o t b e m s u p p l i e d

i n s o m e way,

shapeor manner i n South Dakota.
There i s some concern

i n our district about t h e amount

of Durham wheat t h a t i s going in, T h a t comes about f o r t w o
O n e i s that t h e Durham wheat i s a rust-resisting

reasons.

wheat. O r d i n a r i l y i t does n o t bring a s good a price, b u t
it p e e

crop.

L a s t year t h e people w h o h a d Durham wheat

made a very handsome price o n it.

I t sold a t a premium all

the w a y f r o m 1 5 t o 2 5 cents o v e r t h e best grades o f bread
wheat,

W e are afraid that t h e y will put t o o much Durham

wheat in.
Governor Crissinger.

I s not that a

bread wheat?

Governor Young, N o , i t i 8 a macaroni wheat.

used for bread.

I t i s not

I f we come through with a good crop it is

going t o help the banking situation very materially,
the other hand,

I f , on

w e have another p o o r c r o p this year i t i s

going t o b e very severe o n the banking situation.
Governor Crissinger.
nor Ngrris.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

W e have not heard f r o m you, G o v e r

545
Governor Norris. I

d o not think I can report quite

as favorable conditions i n our district a s have been report—
ed i n most o f t he others.

I

n the extreme western p a r t o f

our district w e have a certain amount o f the soft coal business, where conditions are as Governor Fancher has described
them i n his district.

I n the anthracite district t h e high

price for anthracite and the uncertainty a s to supply has
led to an enormous substitution of o11 burners for coal burners i n residences.

T h e mines have never h a d any trouble i n

selling their domestic sizes, a n d the small sizes have h a d
some c o m p e t i t i o n w i t h s o f t c o a l ;

as a

result

o f t h e British

strike a n d the strike i n the non-union fields i n western
Pennsylvania, O h i o a n d Indiana, t h e r e i s a ready market f o r

smaller sizes, but there i s a very poor market for the domestic Sizes. M o s t o f the mines are now working only about
three days & week.
There i s a very c o n s i d e r a b lruck
e traising a n d canning

industry i n southern New Jersey and i n Delaware, a n d conditions there are similar t o those that have been described

‘gs prevailing, I think i n Wisconsin. L a s t year @ greater
part o f the pack was carried over; i t had t o be.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

There has been i n a good many sections i n our district,

546

aamoss the
particularly i n and around Camden, N e w Jersey,
a tremen—
river from us, and all along the New Jersey coast,
dous r e a l estate speculation,

T h e r e have been advancing

4
prices for real estate there and increasing rents over
long period o f years.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T h e people have gotten into t h e

habit, whenever t h e y have made a n y money o f gotten a

ahead i n business, t o go into real estate.

little

a t the New Jersey

the two
Seashore resorts, r e a l estate a n d hotel-keeping a r e
has
businesses, a n d practically t h e only tWO.. W h i l e there
been n o collapse o f that, i t has been impossible during t h e
last year t o effect sales, Fortunately t h e people have been
only
in almost e v e r y case able t o carry on. T h e r e has been
one c a s e o f a large operator, opening @

new development n e a r

withwhis cre-,
Atlantic City, w h o has h a d t o make arrangements

a marked.
ditors; b u t the rest are all holding on. U n l e s s
have
revival comes i n the market s o m e o f these people will

i n the
to let go, and d n that case there may be some trouble

banks there.

I t is impossible for those banks to avoid real

estate loans. d J y s t a s a n illustration,

w e had a n informal

in
application from some people organizing a trust company
a place near Atjantic City.

T h e y said they wanted t o be-

come members o f the system from the start.

I t i s contrary t o

547
our usual practice t o admit s u c h mewbers immediately o n incorporation; b u t w e got s u c h good reports o f these people
and they gave u s such #esurance o f t+ heir intention t o avoid

real e state loans that we made an appointment for them to
come t o our office a n d talk i t over.

I n t h e course o f the

conversation i t developed that w h i l e they had this firm in-

tention of avoiding real estate loans that about $245,000


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

out of t heir $275,000 capital and surplus was in their building; t h a t t h e y h a d already p u t i t in, s o that instead o f

loaning o n real estate they were buying real estate,
The cotton textile business has disappeared from Philadelphia, There isn't a single concern left i n it.

T h e

woolen a n d woisted people h a v e h a d a very hard time, T r e large

€st mill there, that has been i n existence for ageneration o r

more andout of which séveral large fostunes were made, has
been o p e r a t i n g f o r several y e a r s a t a

million dollars a

loss o f a b o u t a

half a

year, a n d I wdSretand t h e y a r e going t o

close down.
I am rather surprised at the fact that corporation reports f o r t h e f i r s t q u a r t e r

o f this y e a r s h o w larger profits

than for the same quarter o f last year, I

think that must

be due t o very large profits b y a few very large corpora-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

548

tions, because the average small o r medium sized business
people i n Philadelphia are making very small profits.

W e

get constant complaints f r o m the retailers that with increased

assessments, meaning increased taxss and rents, inorease i n
wages a n d other expenses, t h a t t h e y are being eaten u p b y
overhead a n d that t h e retail business i s not what i t ought
to be. T h a t situation does n o t s e e m t o b e altogether satisfactory.

As far as the banking situation i s concerned, outside o f
this p,jossible trouble t h a t I have alluded t o that m a y develop
along t h e Atlantic Seashore,

t h e situation i s very good.

There i s one matter t h a t h a s excited o u r attention. I

donot knorto what extent it has developed in other districts,
but we find that a great many trust companies and small
national banks a r e issuing what t h e y call mortgage certifiCates. T h e y b u y a n aggregate o f say half a

million dollars

of real estate m o r t g a g e s d
n
a then sell t o their customers
mortgage participation certificates.

T h o s e certificates

Contain a n agreement o n the part o f the bank t o repurchase

from the certificate holder o n notice.

Governor Crissinger.
are doing that?

Y o u say that the national banks


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

549

n
a state banks are
Governor Norris. B o t h national. d
doing it. T h o s e certificates d o not, i n time, coincide with
the maturity dates o f the mortgages themselves, still they
s a liability a t ali.
do not treat t h e m a

W e have taken i t

up with the State Banking Department and the Commissioner

feels that they shouldbe treated as aliability, but feels
that h e requires some Legislation before h é can enforce that.

The Chief National Bank Examiner has also taken it up and
I think h a s —

I

know h e has a

form prepared i n the Comptrol-—

ler's office that would enable the business to be done without creating liability. I

do not know whether that form

would b e satifactory t o the purchasers o f t h e certificates.

No acute trouble has developed about it but i t is a matter
that gives u s some little concern. I

d o n o t think there i s

anything else that would'be of any possible interest to the

Conference.
Governor Strong. I

have been back i n New York but a

very short time, a n d most o f that time I have been i n Wash~

ington, I

cannot give any detailed report o f the industries

and so on of the District, as I would like to do; but in a
general way I thins I can say that there has been n o very
great change i n the recent pericd.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

550
returning
I think t h e strixing thing that I noticed o n

is the influence o f the passage o f the McFadden Bill.

A s

I understand it, since the McFadden Bill became a law, w e

have had 23 branches approved for banks i n New Jersey and
26 i n N e w York. T h a t development h a s been going o n for some

time and has resulted i n a good many bank consolidations
in our district. N o t w i t h s t a n d i n g that fact there has been

quite a n accession o f membership i n the Federal Reserve

that
System. W h e n I was abroad I remember I got a report
we had reached 900 member banks i n the district. W h e n I
about 935,
got b a c k t o the office l noticed t h e figure was
and therehave b e e n seventeen members added since t h e first
of the year.

O n e o f the striking things about i t i s that

the growth o f bank capital i n our district h a s l e d t o the
our
situation that w e are n o w nine million dollars below

authorized surplus,

O u r capital and surplus now exceeds

a hundred million doliars, a n d the rapid growth, f a r more
entirely
rapid than I had a n t i c i p a t e d ayear o r t w o ago, i s

due t o the increase i n the amount o f banking capital paid
in, Tather than t o the enlargement o f our surplus a n d
earnings.

I t i s quite natural that these influences should

be felt i n NewYork, which i s the largest city and presents


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

551

the largest field for development o f branches. I
will prove t o be a wholesome thing. I

hope i t

think i n the end it

will be.
Possibly t h e other most striking thing that I notice

is i n connection with the largest crop that w e produce i n
New York, a n d that i s investment securities.

T h e issues

are Maintaining about the rate o f last year, i f not going
a little faster.

I n looking over the offerings o f securities

it i s pretty difficult t o find any serious f a l t with their

stability, and I think on the whole they are pretty good.
The foreign loans that have been offered i n New York

lately —

there are exceptiois——- o n the whole I think are

a
h
t they were a year
as good, i f not better i n t r i n s i c a l l y n

have been
ago, T h e borrowings o f Germany, a s you know,

very mich reduced, and the reoent heavy new borrowings have
s same question a s to the
been those o f Italy. W h i l e t h e r e i

a much abroad as they are just
wisdom of Italy borrowing s
now, I

do not think there i s any doubt that those loans have

good.
been v e r y carefully selected a n d are probably
the
I suppose t h e most important financial problem,

the bor~
most striking financial problem, i s the problem o f

rowings i n New York ard in the London market by countries


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

552
that a r e gradually feeling t h e influence o f the weturn o f
prosperity a n d have a desire f o r n e w enterprises.

I f any

steps should b e taken t o arrest i t ultimately, t h e time
probably has not come.

I f i t does come I hope nothing i n

the nature o f arbitrary control will b e applied, b u t that

itwill b e allowed t o work itself out, a s i t always has i n
the past b y conditions gradually being satisfied and their
stopping o f t heir o m accord.
The attention o f the country i s always focused o n
what i s going o n inthé stock market i n New York. I

d o not

know very much about the movenmt o f prices, except that i t
has been upward .

I

n a broad way, w h a t h a s happened i n

the last cycle, s o t o speak, i s that the total decline i n
the outside figure o f the stock exchange loan account

o f

between eight and nine hundred million dollars, a n d a recov—
ery o f that amount i n a recent period o f roughly one-half o f

that, and of that one-half, about $200,000,000 has taken

place in a period of about three months last past. Oonsidering t h e e n o r m o u s i n c r e a s e

i n t h e securities l i s t e d

on

the board, a n d t h e fact that t h e y have h a d a very prosperous

period for a few years, I do not know that there i s anything
alarming i n what i s happening there.

I t got t o a point where


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

555.
people were alarmed a year o r more ago, a n d went through

a very considerable liquidation, with n o great damage result
ing, I

do not think there i g anything else.

Governor Crissingér. D o e s eny member o f the Board
care t o say anything?

Vice Governor Platt, Governor Strong spoké i n the begin
ning about the considerable increase i n membership i n new
banks,
Governor Strong, P r o b a b l y due t o organization o f new
state banks a n d some conversions.

Vice Governor Platt.

D o you think all o f that has re~

sulted from the passage of the wcFadden Act?
Governor Strong, T h e development o f these newbanks
is directly t o b e attributed t o the fact that t h e n e w l a w

in New Jersey permitting branch banking became operative
when the .icFadden Bill passed. T h e r e were twelve branches
established b y State banks, w h i c h a r e not members o f the

Reserve System, i n addition t o those that I have mentioned.
Vice Governor Platt.

W e e r e t h e banks w h o started

getting branches t o some extent non-members a n d enaller
banks?

Governor Strong, S p m e o f it was the result o f small

554
passage
banks having been acquired i n anticipation o f the

of this act, the people owning these small banks taxing
them i n a s branches.

Governor Crissinger.

I s there anything further?

I f

not, t h e Chair will entertain a motion t o adjourn.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. Hamlin, M r , Chairman, I move that w e now adjourn.

(Whereupon, upon motion duly seconded, the Conference
adjourned, a t 5 o'clock p.m., o n Thursday, M a y 12, 19387,

subject t o the call of the Federal Reserve Board. )


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis