View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

PROCEEDINGS

CONFERENCE O F THE FEDERAL RESERVE B O A R D W I T H T H E G O V E R N O R S
OF THE FEDERAL RESERVE B A N K S

TREASURY BUILDING
WASHINGTON, D. C,

MARCH 2 9 1923

WALTER S . COX
SHORTHAND REPORTER
COLUMBIAN BUILDING
WASHINGTON, D.C.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

JOINT C O N F E R E N C E
of t h e
FEDERAL R E S E R V E B O A R D W I T H T H E G O V E R N O R S

OF THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS

Washington, D . Ce,
™hursday,

M a r c h 29, 1923.

11 o'clock a. m.
The Joint Conference o f the Federal Reserve Board with
the G o v e r n o r s

o f Federal Reserve B a n k s

w a s convened

a t

1l o'clock a. m. i n the Assembly Room o f the Federal Reserve Board, Treasury Building, Washington, D . ¢ .

Present: V i c e Governor Platt (presiding)
Mr. Hamlin a n d
Wr. Miller,
Members o f the Board.
Hon. D . R. Crissinger, Comptroller o f Currency,
and e x officio member o f t h e Board.
Hon. S . P . Gilbert, U n d e r Secretary o f the
Treasury.

PO
Governor wcVougal: I
Gentlemen,

G

e

D

o

a

e

will call t h e meeting t o order.

t h e G o v e r n o r s h : ve b e e n i n c o n f e r e n c e h e r e

wondsy morning a n d have dsvoted their tine t o going
through t h e i r o w n prograi, t h a t i s , t h o s e t o p i c s w h i c h w e r e
Subuitted

b y t h e v a r i o u s Fecésral R e s e r v e Banks.

disposed o f those topics,
&@re s u b m i t t e d

i n s o far s s u e can, until t h e y

t o s n d considered

b y t h s Board.

There a r e souie matters w h i c h w e r e o n t h e program,

Which I

would like t o rerer briefly.

t o

A l l matters dealt

with b y t h S Conference, w h e r e action has b e e n taken, ofr
36, @ r e subject t o review a n d final consideration sand
action b y the Bosrd, w h i c h I think i s elways und=rstood.
There a r e several matters which were discussed concerning which I will just make brier méntion a n d if, a s w e
go o n with this short state.ient, thers e r e a n y subiscts
that sheuld b e discussed,

w e will b e clsd t o proceed ac-

cordingly.
The p r o g r a m w i t h r e s p e c t

t o eredit transactions sand

policies, T o p i c I-(a), Report o f Com.it tee o n Centralizs
Ehxecution o f p u r c h a s e s a n d s a l e s o f Goveéerniisnt s e c u r i t i e s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

for Account o f Federal Reserve Ranks, a n d with regard t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

577
subtopic ( b ) , R e p o r t

o f standing C o m i t t e e

o n Open uarket

Conditions a n d Operations, t h o s e reports w e r e submitted
and placed o n file, w i t h t h e understanding t h a t t h e y would
be brought u p again f o r discussion a t t h e Joint Conference
with t h e Board,

Topic (c), Rates o f viscount, with subtopics (1),
automatic sdjustment o f - i s i t possible o r expedisnt,

(2), Uniform Rates, (3) Open market rates, were referred

to a committee, the committee has reported, and that report
has b e e n received a n d adopted with t h e understanding that
the s u b j e c t s t h e r e o f w o u l d b e d i s c u s s e d w i t h t h e B o a r d

in

joint conference.

With regard t o topic (f), Interpretation o f word
‘Borrower" i n section 1 3 of the Federal Reserve Act, i t was
voted t o r e uest o f the #ederal Reserve Board a ruling,

as

the o p i n i o n s r e c e i v e d r r o m t h e c z u n s e l o f t h e t w e l v e b a n k s

have b é e n somewhat -st variance.
Then w e have t o report t h a t Judge Lobdell a n d other
members o f the Farm Loan Board m e t with us.

T h e y requested

suggestions indicating t h e Judgment o f those present 4 s
to the probable demand f o r credit o n the n e w organizations
which w e r e i n process,

a n d also requested a

statement w i t h


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

578
respect

with.

t o w h a t t h e ciscount s h o u l d b e t o r t h e m t o s t a r t

W i t h regard t o the latter matter,

very careful.

W

o f course w e were

e Teit t h e subject would h a v e t o b e very

caréfuliy considered r r o m t h e standpoint o f a l l the unterlying circumstances, H e w e v e r ,

w e reviewed t h o s e matters

with t h e Board a n d they seemed,

a t least,

faction w i t h t h e r e s u l t s

t o express satis-

o f t h e i r b r i e f c o n r e r e n c e w i t h us.

dith r e g a r d t o T o p i c I v , Operations, R e p o r t

ance Committee,

o f Insur-

i t was voted t o submit t h a t report t o t h e

Federal R e s e r v e B o s r d f o r exaimination w i t h t h e r e q u e s t t h a t

it advise t h e several Federal Reserve Banks o f its concluSlons, w i t h t h e further understanding that i r i t i s s n p roved
by the Board,

i t will b e submitted t o t h e boardot directors

or each bank, w i t h t h e understanding that i f i t i s approved
il along t h e line these recouunendations w i l l b e put inte
effect.
Subtopic ( b ) Employes! Insurance,

I t was voted that

the group insurance r a t e should b e continued a n d that t h e
Federal R e s e r v e B o a r d b e r e q u e s t e d

t o approve r a i s i n g t h e

naximum t o »5,000.
Topic (e}, Comuittes o n Economy s n d fficiency.

I t

voted t o suggest t o the Bosrd's Committee the designa-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

579
tion o f a n opzreting representative o f t h e Feceral Reserve
Board t o clear infornation i n behsir o f the committees.

I t

Was brousht o u t i n aiscussion that w h e n ths federal Reserve
banks f i n d i t n e c ssary t o ask ror information w i t h regard
to the mechanical opsrations, v o l u m e o r itews, a n d things
or that sort, f o r t h e penefit o f thenselves a n d r o r the
benefit o f t h e cowslttee,

t h a t w e h a d n o u n i f o r m p o liey,

but w e had t o .rite t o each one o f t h e banks, a n d i t was
thought t h a t i r t h e C o m i t t e e

o n nconomy a n d »friciency

has souieone h e r e i t c o u l d a é s i g n a t e f o r t h e p u r p o s e

o r taking

Care o f thet correspondence, t h a t t h e ricures w o u l d probably
be available t o a grsater extent a n d would timplify t h e
matter u n d i t would probably b e more e @ nowicesl.
Bey i h teers

b o t h e Goverudrs generally know w h a t t h e

composition o f t h e s u - c a l l e d coiuwittee i s ?

Governor wcvuugal: I
wre willer:

think thsy do.

v o n t t h e y have what t h e Governors want?

Governor mwtou 22]

T h e feeling w a s that they did not

exactly w h e t w e want?

jite i

bs oot d h a t d o they want?

Governor Caikins:
the coisnlttee

T h e y have a h a t t h e y want s o rar 3 s

i s concerned,

b u t t h e purpose


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

580
to avoic t h e alinost continuscus c i r c u l a t i o n

o f cor-

Federal reserve banks t o get i n formetion w h i c h c c u l d b e c l e a r e d t h r o u g h o n e o p s r a t i n

clerk i n this office.
to B o s t o n t o f i n d o

i n s t e a d o f S a n Francisco w r i t i n g
v

t o handle a

particular transac-

tion under t h s .anual, S a n #rancisco m u l d write t o t h e
Clerk i n this o r r i c e .

wMe willer:

h

y uoesn't s a n rransisco d o that?

Governor Celkins:

B e c a u s e t h e r e h a s never b e e n any-

body t o write t o except t h e Board, a n d that would throw
ess smount o f routine
corresponaence.
ite willler:

T h a t i s precisely w h a t t h e committee

expects a n d what t h e committee i s prepared t o do. I t wants
to s e r v e s s a

clearing houses f o r thse t r a n s m i s s i o n o f inforna-

tion with respect t o practices i n tle dirrerent

b:

Y

o

u

Will recall that the Rosrd's ccnmittee has a so-called
auxiliary conmittes a s a n ald, w h i c h courmittse sonsists o f
officers

o f t h e Kessrve B a n k s and,

months ago, when uwr* Cramer left
né s e r v e c

u p until a

S

s

a s v~ecretary t o t h e Committee,

first o r April, ine, Rounds,

couple o r

3 a n k o f Chica go,
a n d beginninsz t h e

o f t h e N e w York Benk will b e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

581

secretary t o the mmmittee.

T h a t i s part o f t h e conmittee's

work.
Governor Calkins:
conference

T h e sugges stlon grew o u t o f t h e last

o f t h e conmittee---

i t m a y b e aue t o the fact

that aur. Cramer has gone out, I don't know.

I t may b e i n

view o f t h e f a c t t h a t t h e y t h o u g h t s o w e b o d y s h o u l d b e

Substituted f o r h i m a t once. I

do not know that;

wae f o r t h e p u r p o s e o f f a c i l i t i n g t h e e x c h a n g e

b u t it

o f inrorma-

tion between t h e Fed r a l reserve banks without burdening
the Board's c o u m i t t e e w i t h a

voluuwe c f p u r e l y c l e r i c a l c o r -

respondence,

ute miller: I
part w i t h t h e banks.

a m afraid that t h e trouble arises i n
T h e Governors c

n o t place tha.selves

in sufficiently close touch with t h e work o f tre erficiency
and economy couulttee,

o r else your representative o n the

General P r o c e d u r e Couiuittee i s n o t d o i n g h i s p a r t

i n keep-

ing you scquainted with tie work that i s i n progress, o r
with t h e work o f the Group Chairmen, w h i c h group h a s recently b e e n s e t up.

B u t t h a t i n f o r m a t i o n i s avallable. f

should s a y that t h e Governor o f any F e d r a l reserve bank,
by keeping i n contact w i t h those members o f his bank that
have t h e handling o f the erficiency problens assi gned t o

them b y the general comnittee,
ent position t e find o u t exactly w h a
it i s because s o m e o f the junior o r f
not d o i n g w h a t t h e y s h o u l d e
b doing.

isonth, a

statement,

you get a resume.
concerned,

do j
v

Y o u get, e v e r y

n o t , ochedule E ? E v e r y .juarter

e alir, s o f a r a s the committee here i s

t o kesp t h e banks, p e rticulsrly tune Governors,

constantly inicrued o f what i s going on. Y e s t e r d a y letters went o u t t o a c uaint y o u with t h e next step i n this
work a n d t o inform y o u o r the appointisent o f wr. Rounds a s
secretary o f t h e Board's coimittes.
we c a n do.

T h a t i s about a l l

I r y o u d o n o t t r e a t t n e s e t h i n g s s s matters

interest a n d concern,

of

p e r h a p s o u r method o f sx¢yusinting

you i s not r i g h t , b e c a u s e 1 % conics a S 4 filmeogranhed letter, a n d i t does n o t stiike y o u 8 s important.
Governor seay:

T h e r e was such a

demand f o r t h a t

analysis i n our bank that th: o n e m p y t h a t y e u sent vould


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

not b e g i n t o s u p p l y t h e ofricials w h o w a n t e d t o h a v e a c ~
cess t o i t r o r t h e p u r p o s e o f e x a m i n a t i o n a n d information.

Governor killer:
Governor seay;
that i s sufficient.

T w o : were sent.
Y o u s u p p l i s d t w o , b u t f £ do n o t t h i n k


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

583
Me. willler:

W

e would b e very g l a d t e have a

recom-

mendation from the Cenfrerence 3 s t o whether o r not you thi n k
it i s d e s i r a b l e

t o issue these i n such seasonable number

as the banks want.

w y own opinion is that w e ougnt t o give

you whatever is needsd for your use. I
come w h e n t h e s e n s i t i v e n e s s

is n o t t o

b e taken e s a

or t h o s e things.

I

think the tine has

i n the dirferent

cerious f a c t o r

banks perhsps

i n the distribution

t has b e e n done w i t h =

view, p e h a p s ,

of

not putting too many psopie i n any one bank i n possession
of inrormation that would enable t h e m t o craw invidious

echiparisons between their bank snd other banks; b u t I think

all of that is sonstling that is of very little importance
now, a n d that there i s a real spirit o f sarnestness a n d
coumunity o f i n t e r e s t

i n trying t o work o u t t h e s e problems
y

of economy a n d efricienty,

t o some satifactory c c neiusion. /

that i s the view o f tre Conference, t h s Board would
glad t o sustain t h e expense o f naving these monthly
reports s n a quarterly reports issued i n greater nuuber,
that t h e y m a y become more useful instruments a @ service
in-the dirferent banks,
it i s t h e source o f
amount

o f consideration

a n d work

i n o u s bank.

so


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

584
t, unless there i s objecthat t h e B o a z d i s s u c t h e m o n t h l y a n d j u e r t e r l y r e p o r t s
such r e a s o n a b l e nuniber @ s t h e b a n k s d e ~
the u s e o f t h e i r different d e r a r t n e n t s ,
n o r e s e n t p l a n i s t o send out

Governcr Plett:
only o n e ?
Governor seay:

L o o s

n o w .

y

Vics Governcr Platt:

o

u give u s saue

how many y o u want?
think esch bank should

Governor Seay: I

I

i n t h a t matter.

wishes

t i s uncerstood that

Will sup-ly e a c h bank with a s many copie
I think that w u l d b e a
factory sett l e m

L

f that

I

a

of opinion I would b e glad t e put i t t o a vote, i f
sary.
Governor mcbDougal: i
respect

t o t h i s subdjé (

Governor Calki

»

you snything rurther a i t

s r n o r Calkins?

N

e 1

sug.zesticn d i d
e

ginate.with ine.
Salt - o f d i s c u s s i o n s

S t t a s . L 0 5 u - a i s s t i n g ian) o f &

5 g m e n who

are r e s p o n s i b l e f o r c o m m u n i c a t i o n s w i t h t h e b a n k


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

585
Governor wcvougal:

w e have a l s o given consiu -ration

to t h e i n f o r m a l m e m o r a n d u m s u b m i t t e d h e r e a s k i n g r o r c o n sidsration o f t h e p r o p r i e t y o f r e - u c i n g t h e e x p e n s e o f

operation b y eliminating 2

considerable part o f t h e s:rvice

which w e are n o w giving t o our member banks.

i t was voted

that w e should proceed very carefully i n any movenient o f
this sort.

T h e r e i s one i t e m involved which i s one o f the

lost important items, a n d that i s the question o f doing away

with the handiing o f items other than cash items and collection items.

i t was voted, a s 1 remember it, t o request

the B o a r d t o appoint a

conmittee

Siacration t o t h a t mstter. I
submitted

t o give v e r y careful con-

might s t a t e t h a t t h e t o p i c s

b y t h e Ped-ral R e s e r v e B o a r d i t s e l f w e r e n o t s o n e

into.*:. T h e y sere matters o n which w e prezuned w e sheuld
avait t h e j . i n t conference,

a n d i f t h e B o a r d w i l l procsed,

that i s all w e have t o submit, unless y o u uesire t o wake
sone Iurther conuent o r a s k yuestions.

t h e r e were inany

minor mattors w h i c h were discussed, u p o n Which action was
taken, a l l c f w h i c h a c t i o n s w i l l b e r e p o r t e d

t o t h e Board

in the w a y that h e s b e e n custonary, a n d a l l o f which need
Soite a t t sntion b y t h e R o e r d s e f o r e

Governor Larding:

w e e a n p r o c s e d further.

i t h reference t o the stetement


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

586
just n a d e b y t h e C h a i r m a n o f t h e conference, r e g a r d i n g

Going a w a y with non-cash collections.
cleariy

T h a l a t e s very

t o t h e w o r k o f t h e e c o n o m y a n d e f f i c i e n c y conmittee.

L would l i k e t o suggest that t h e Roard t a k e under. consideration the propriety o f appointing some expert, w h o i s
famliiar w i t h t e a r a l reserve b a n k accounting, 8
type, p r o b a b l y ,
available

man o f the

o f wr. H a r r i s o n - - ~ [ I d o n o t k n o w t h a t h e

c r that h e wouid b e t h e m a n y o u w o u l d sant---

it ssems t o me that t h e Roard's C o m i t t e e w o u l d make
very much better headway i n bringing about fairly uniforn
efficient accounting,
ir they would have a n expert, acting scleliy for t h e Board,
go through e a c h Federal reserve b e n k a n d meke s n intensive
study o r t h e conditions t h a t h e f i n d s

i n e a c h bank.

H

e

will have opportunity o f discussing w i t h t h e officers o f
each b a n k t h e i m p o r t a n c e
as a 4 matter

o f f u n c t i o n s w h i c h arse p r o p o s e d

o f policy o r n e e d t o b e modified,

a n d s o forth.

By v i s i t i n g a l l t h e b e n k s h e could c o m e b a c k p r e p a r e d

to sake t o t h e Board a very intelligent a n d valuabie r e port,

I t may b e thet y o u might n e e d more t h a n one tian,

probebly t w o nen, a n d tust t h e study would involve a
of s a y s i x months. {

period

a m thoroughly m n v i n c e d t h a t with


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

537
proper

men

t o make t h a t

» men who coulc give you that
information

i n a

practical way,

that

i t would

be a

very

Sreat help i n bringing about thse conaitions w h i c h y o u deSire, anc, I

a n sure, w h i c h t h e Fed«ral reserve banks d e -

sire.
wP, Hamlin;

i o u l d such a report a s that ineluae t h e
of

answer t o the svesticn/making r g o s t o country banks for
services,

f o r instance?

Governor Harding:

T h e r e ere a

enter i n t o i t , b u t i t seems

good many Ltens t h a t

t o m e that i n connection w i t h

two o r three -tews, accounting methods a n d things o f that
sort, t h a t t h e y could maxe a report which would give u s
souething

t o g o cn.

Y o u cannot t a k e a

committee a n d

undertake t o d o it, except a t very great expense a n d over
it that t h e Committee o f
the B o a r d a r e n o t e x p e r t accountants.
you c o u l d g i a

n this cther w a y

picture o f t h e w n o l s thing.

hr. willser: I
are r e f e r r i n g

I

do not quite

t o the memorandum which w a s

yesterday w i t h respect t u certain sce-called controleble
expenci tures?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

588
Governor Harding:

Y e s , A

penditures s r e o r s u c h a

great m a n y o f t h o s e

nature t h a t w e w o u l d p e r h a p s

able t o say "We will c u t o u t this a n d that, a n d s o forth"
and bring about t h s a v i n g o f a tresentous amount o f money;
but y o u must take intc consiacration also t h e fsct that a
committee h a s been appointed t o find o u t w h y the state banks
gensrally d o n o t c o m e i n t o t h e system,
in mind t h a t t h e r e h a s b e e n a

persistent p r o p a g a n d a f o r t h e

rs against t h s system,

t against it.
reached sources t h a t I

a n d y o u rimst b e a r

a n d that litsrature h a s

T h a t literature h s s

never dreaued i f would reach, a n d i t

has stirrea u p feeling o n t h e part o f even meiber banks

that they should get more sccomiodations thah they are
getting, interest o n deposits, an: all thet sort o f thing.
Sous s e r v i c e s

t h a t a r e pérformed

regular bank functions;

a t great expense

t h e y a r e services which,

past. before t h e Federal reserve i

are

i n the

was established,

tre country b a n k w a s aczustomed t o get f r o u its city corresponau::nts. A

great m a n y o f ths country banks i n sciie

districts h a v e closed their accounts « i t h their c i t y core
responaents,
for services.

3 n d are dependent u p o n t h e
T a s y d o not want t o pay

589
if they were t o open u p e n account w i t h a city bank t h e y
would get the service gratis.

A l l these things ought t o

be borne i n mind i n figuring t h e efreet o f the abolishnucrt
of certsin services---~ a n d I

a m quite s u r e tre Federal re-

serve banks theuselves would b e glad t o have t h e m abolished
but f o r t h e fact that y o u have g o t t o consicer t h e b e aring
of i t upon t h e iieubership o f t h e system.
2
want t o s a y i t i s preciseiy
because

ur, miller: I

the “conomy a n d hfficiency Coiwiittee wants light o n that

thet i t wishes t o have the juaguent o f this conference o n
quéstions which w e recognize

t o bs primarily questions o f

policy.
Governor Harding:

I t y o u h a d 3 8 n expert u h o could g o

out a n d interrogate t h e officers o f t h e banks o n their o w n
ground a n d who could s a y t o them, “ Y o u have expressed s u c h
and such a n opinion, w h a t d o y o u base that opinion on", t h e y
probably w o u l d haves s o m e c o r r e s p o n d e n c e

o r some records

i n

their bank sna could give him a very valuable idea o f hoa
the matter was regarded i n the dirferent districts.
ur. Miller: I

wouid like t o ssy, Governor Harding,

that i f ycu would acguaint yourselves w i t h what has been
done b y the +2onomy a n d &friciency Conmit tee, y o u will find


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

596
it has gone f a r beyond what y o u have s u g ested t h e r

i

t

is, perhaps, because t h e committee h a s n o t h a d a news agent
that i t i s not s o well known just what i t s metliods have
been a n d just w h a t has b e e n accamplished, b u t w e are about
at t h e point where I

hope that within t w o o r three months, —

the comaittbee c a n make a

very exhaustive a n d conclusive r e -

port w i t h respect t o the operating methods o f t h e Federal

reserve banks, under the hesd of what w e call non-controliable functions @ & t h e banks, t h o s e functions t h a t have g o t
to b e yerformed, u n d e r t h e statutes.

d e are i n sight o f

the end o f that investigation, a n d we come now t o certain
funetiors which w e call controisble, a n d which depend,
really, u p o n what t h e policy o f t h e Federal reserve vystem
and t h e different Federal reserve banks i c g o i n g t o b e with
regard t o than.

w i t h o u t doubt w e want some sivice.-

it m a y b e that those functions a r e being very erriciently
performed b y a l l t h e banks, o r b y some o f them, a n d
aespite t h e y h a v e c a u s e d c o n s i a s r a b l e e x p e n s e ,

to continue them.

y o u m a y want

I z you do, t h e n our problem i s

simply t o s e e i n t h e a i i f e r e n t b a n k s w h e t h e r

o r not the

organiz:tion i s such thst t k e se functions a r e being performed a t t h e l o w e s t posci>vie u n i t cost.

i

t seems

t o me


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

591
that n o b o d y

i n the Federal keserve s y s t e m would b e i n a

better position t o advise o n the j;uestions o f policy t h a n
the G o v srnors.
in @

I

t w o u l d s e e m t o nis t h a t t h e y o u g h t

position t o d o i t b y c a n v a s

t o be

o f t h i s b o d y r i g h t now.

It wouldn't take over half a n hour a t the most.

Y o u

know whsther these things should b e continued, w h a t opposition would b e encountered, a n d how m u c h value should b e

attached t o the opposition, a n d s o on.
are g o i n g t o b e continued,

i f these things

t h e Economy e n d #friciency

Comittee w i l l take tnese different departiments s n d subject
theia t o some thorough-going review, b u t f o r those things

that are not t o be continued, w e will not g o into a study o f
them trom the standpoint o f operating efficiency.
Governor seay:
2S e x p r e s s e d

T h e , consensus

i n a résolution,

o f opinion,

D r * Miller,

c a n b e given t o you b y tle

Chairman i n a f e w words.
Governor Mcvougal;:

T h e consensus o f opinion w a s that

the services enumerated should not b e dismw ntinued, except

with respect t o No. 4, i t was voted that t h e tederal Reserve
Board a p p o i n t 8

coimlttee

t o consider a n d report r e @ mnenda-

tions o n t h i s topic, w h i c h w a s t h e t o p i c w i t h r e s p e c t
the c o l l e c t i o n o f n o n - c a s h itenis. I

to

think w e s h o u l d b e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

592
very careful, l e s t w e make a

mistake,

i n withdrawing f r o m

our m e m b e r b a n k s p r i v i l e z e s w h i c h w e h a v e a c c o r d e d t h m ,

#e considered t h e matter v e r y csliberately s n d very carefully f r o m all standpoints.

W

e considered i t -rom the

standpoint that, e v e n though w e might b e making large earnings a t that time, t h a t w e would come t o a tine w h e n i t
would b e difficult t o d o so.

T h e services w h i c h w e are

rendering t h e banks, a n d which a r e given t o t h a n k s , w e r e
given a t a

time w h e n w e sere considering w h a t w e might

do

for t h e banks o v e r a n d abeve t h e s i x per cent dividend, a n d
We said that t h e o n l y thing w e could d o was t o render t h e m
the greatest possible amount o f service.

w n a t w e are

giving t h e member banks n o w h a s b e e n a factor i n securing
their membership, a n d a very important factor,

i n m y opinion,

in retaining their membership.
Therefore, Ur. willer,

i t was thought t h a t i t would b e

inadvisable, a n d [ I do not think y o u o r your associates
intended that w e should thoughtlessly strike these out,
to discontinue then.

# w @ have thought i t advisable t o

consider t h e matter v e r y carefully before going into t h e
question o f discontinuing a n y o f these privileges,
ure Miller:

L e t m e put i t i n this way:

T h e question

593
is whether i t i s ussirable f o r t h e réserve banks t o continue
to p e r f o r m a l l o f t h e s e s s - c a l l e d v o l u n t a r y s e r v i c e s

the cost o f a n investment o f about a
lars & @ year.
of view.

at

hundred million dol-

T h a t i s a practical juestion f r o m our point

I t takes about a

hundred million dellars o f in-

véstnents i n reciscounts o r open market opsrations i n order
to ¢ a r n a n income t h e t w i l l a b s o r b t h e c o s t o f p e r f o r u i n g

these services.

T h a t i s one side o r t h e account, t h e cost

of perforiiing t h e services, a n d t h e other i s the psychological element o f keeping your clientelle o f ienber banks
satisfied a n d i n good huizior.

B u t there i s something dis-

tinctly t o b e considered f r o m t h e point o f view o f cost 3 s
well a s rrom t h e point o f view o f the axtra dividends t h a t
you g i v e y o u r m a n b e r b a n k s

Governor weVougal; I
about that.

i n t h a t way.

think there i s n o juestion

I t i s cold bleoded business a n d i t should b e

SG consiaered, b u t I believe w e should b e very careful
not t o make a n y mistakes.
ur, sillier: I

do not make a n y dissent f r o m that, but

fthope o n the other hand that w e won't b e s o careful that
you will make t h e terrible mistake o f making n o report o f
récomsendation,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Young:

I f I remember correctly, t h i s was t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

O94
be a coimmittes o f Governors a p p o i n t e d

b y t h e Board.

That

would take care o r your suggestion, vre wiiler.
Governor Harding:

T h a t w a s the recommendation o f t h e

Governors,
Governor Calkins:

h a t t h e B o a r d a p p o i n t t h e coumittese.

Governor harding:

S u p p o s e a n y recouwienaation would

include whether these services mignt b e continued a n d charged
for?
Governor wevougal:
wYe miller:

W

e discussed that.

Y o u r recommendation i s that none o f these

services b e discontinued, b u t that w i t h respect t o I t e m 4,
Non-cash c o l l e c t i o n s ,

t h a t b e studied 3 n d r e p o r t e d

o n by

a committee o f Govsrnors, w i t h a view o f ascertaining whether
or not i t might b e discontinued 7
Governor mcvougal:
Governor Calkins: i

T h a t w a s t h e sense o f it.
might s a y that that i s a small

question, a n d i t is comparstively small, that is, small
in cost compared w i t h a good isiany o f t h e other items, b u t
it hos a good wany ramifications a n d may have a
conse juences,

good many

T h e r e a r e &@ good imany cases where member

banks h a v e aiscontinued carrying accounts w i t h correspondents.

T h e r e a r e not m a n y i n our district a n d 1 presume

595
there are none i n Roston, but there certainly are i n some

districts, snd I understand there heve been already 4. good
many c o m p l a i n t s

o n the part o f the smaller banks thst t h e y

cannot get services,that they must get from come scurce,
frou the Federal -eserve banks, s n d consequently they are
maintaining correspondent balances a t a loss.

T h a t i s only

& small matter, b u t i t i s one o f the things that 1 think must
bs considered i n that connection.

Vice Governor Platt: G e n t i g u e n , I ani sorry t o have
had t o be away from .ashington a t a tine when you were beginning your conferences, b u t i t seeiied necessary t o g p t o

Cold harbor, a n d I was very glad I did go. I

attended the

funeral, a n d after that i'went t o Detroit a n d spent 4 day,

Tuesday, i n the Detroit branch, a n d I met the directors
of t h e Detroit b r a n c h o f the Federal keserve B a n k o f Chica ko.

i saw 4 little of the city, and lert at 11 o'clock Tuesday
night.

I suggest that w e take u p now t h e topic suggested b y
the Board t o be considered a t the joint session.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The first topic i s

Reserves against so-called “Special

Savings” deposits, o n which a limited
anount o f checking i s allowed.
The coument h e r e i s "This i s a .usstion which has b e e n
very w u c h c i s c u s s é d

b y t h e c a n Francisco F e d s r a l réserve

bank, with reisrence t : the special savings
California s t a t s banks.

s i m i l a r savings accounts h s v e

besn r o u n d i n o t h e r r e s e r v e d i s t r i c t s ,

o n which s o u s check-

ing i s slloved.
That juestion i s cone thet h e s puzzled t h Federal xeerve B o a r d f o r a

good while. I

gsnsrally s p e a k i n g ,

think i t i s o u r opinion,

t h a t c h e e k s shoulac n o t b e d r s w n o n

It does not seésiu to u s that t h e special
provisions

o f t i e C a l i f o r n i a l s w , w h i l e t h e y doubfiless

safeguard these deposits, a r e anything that w u l d b e considered a s vital i n view o f t h e woraing o f tne Federal
Act

The word “savins i

s

used, I

think i n the

National bank division o f t h e Federal keserve act, i t seems
to souwe o f u s 4 t l e a s t , h a s g o t t o b e i n t e r p r e t e d

i n the

way i n which i t has always b e e n interpreted sincs t h e
Reserve a c t w a s passed;

a n d whils t h e provisions o f t h e

Calirornia l a w a r e unique, y e t sowe o f them ars s o obvious


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

597
that they night well have been lert out.

T h e y s a y that

no savinss b a n k c a n uiske loans after i t has received thirty

aays' notice-=-= n o savinss bank could d o that anyway, i f
operated w i t h a n y d ° g r e e o f precaution,

and I

any r e a s o n f o r p u t t i n g s u c h o b v i o u s t h i n g s

d o not s é e

i n t h e lew.

That has n o bearing o n whetier checks should b e allowed t o
6 vrawn o n thai, o r o n the juestion whether t h e pess books

should b e required t o b e presented. I

will say thet w e

have tried t o craw rogulations w h i c h will apply t o Califrornia, a n d a t t h e same tine n o t s s e m t o throw t h e thing wide

open, but s o far we haven't h a d very much success.
is sousthing that I
ur, iniller:

This

think t h e Governors sjiould discuss.

H s v e t h e Governors d i s c u s s e d

i t t o reach

any conelusion o n it?

Vice Governor Platt: J

will ssy that t h e Roara's

counsel has rendered the opinion that tLese “special
savings" sccounts are demand .eposits.
Governor Harding: I

appreciate, o f course, t h e dirfi-

culty with which the Board has been contronted i n handling
this proposition. I

remember i t very distinctly, because

‘tt c a m e u p soiu.e years a g o i n connection w i t h @ bank here

in the District o f Columbis, which clsimed that a l l of its


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

598
deposits w e r e tine ueposits, because t h e y w e r e subject t o
sixty days’ m o t i c e , a t its option;

t h a t i t was angious t o

come i n t o t h e F e d s r a l R e s e r v e s y s t e m a n d would c o w e i n i f

the Board would construe i t s d-posits a s being time deposits,
carrying a

three p e r c e n t reserve,

not a f f o r d t o c a r r y a

b u t i t felt t h a t i t c o u l d

t e n p e r c e n t reserve.

A f t e r a

thor-

ough discussion o f t h e whole matter t h e Roard was unaninously o f the opinion that i t was a couwmnercial bank, a n d the
counsel representiny t n s Lank adwiltted that i t was, t o all
intents a n d purposes, @

cow esrcial bank doing a comieretal

business, t h a t i t had n o restriction o n checks i n ordinary
business, b u t paid t h e m just a s any national b a n k psys then,
inerely reserving t h e right, i f t h e y s o csired,

t o clsin

sixty days!’ notice.
The Board regulations, section 19, a r e based upon t h e
law itself, a n d + take i t that i n all regulations i:sued
by t h e Boerd they must b e strictly d r a w n i n confumraity w i t h
the law, because t h e Board hes n o power t o g o outside t h e
law t o legisiate.

I

n one o r two places, s u c h a s Section

13, t h e specific language i s used that t h e board has power
to make regulations i n conformity w i t h this act, i n conformity w i t h t h e provisions o f this act.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

599
demand
Now, i n this bref section, 1 9 , w i t h regard t o

of
dsposits, i t says, “peiiand deposits, aithin the weaning
within thirty
this act, shall comprise a i l deposits payable
deposits payzble
days, a n d tiue deposits shall comprise a l l

after thirty days, a l l savings accounts and certiricates o f

deposits which are subject t o not less than thirty cays’
notice b e f o r e payment,

a n d a i l p o s t a l s a v i n z s deposits.

«words
You will notice that there i s n o coisa after t h e

“sayings accounts", but i t says “all savings accounbs a n d
not less t h a n
certificates o f deposit w h i c h are subject t o

thirty days! notice before payment", a n d s o forth.
Now, 1 8 4 savings account n o t subject t o notice--- &
wight have a n acdon't k n o w that i t i s possible t h a t juan
)ef
woulcé not
a savings account,
count w h i c h i n his o w n mind h s recardg 9 6

the rescause he wants t o save his noney--- but i n rraming
threes parts.
sulation o n this t h e board uiviued i t into
They coumented o n deiand deposits;

t h e y Gefined tine de-

underteok t o give a
posits payable efter thirty cays, a n d
Gefinition o f s:vings accounts.

N o one disputes t h e pro-

terms a s
priety o f the Board's following these different
they appear i n the act.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T h e a c t gives i t power t c wiake

600

rules a n d regulations,

R u t t h e whole broad general princi-

ple i s o b s e r v e d t h a t t h e y m u s t b e i n conformity w i t h t h e
provisions

o f t h e Act.

On this juestion o f savings dcposits, w h e n that regulstion was rramed, t h e Board investigated a n d round that
to b e the rule i n savings banks--- y o u know there a r e some
banks which - .

have

o n l y savings deposits,

end that other banks have deposits w h i c h are called savings
deposits---

and I

belisve

i n Calira@ nia t h e r e i s a

isa

against certain banks having savings deposits o r sdvertising
them;

b u t there i s nothing i n the National B a n k Law, i f Ii

remeuber correctly, t h e t authorizes a n y national bank spscifically t o establish savings d s p a r t m e n t s , s i t h o u g hy
n
a
m
of t h e m have done so.

T h e whole savings i d e a has gone out

in this country f r o m t h e eastern mutual savings banks, a n d
California h a s elaborated o n the idea.
Hight years ago, w h e n t h e regulation w s s framed, t h e
Board found i t w a s t h e gen<cral system inhandling savings
accounts t o demand t h e presentation o f t h e psss book.
Now, o f course, t h a t limits t r e e circulstion o f chscks i n
the ordinary payment o f bills.

T h e requirement that a

man Should g o the bank s n d present h i s pass b o o k i s more o r


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

501
or less a @ a

restriction, I

think t h e Board a t thst t i n e

agéfined savings accounts correctly.

T

h

e point I

want

to stress i s that i n m y judgment t h e Boerd has n o power t o
say that s a v i n . sdeposits must necessarily,

t o be savings

dspesits r e q u i r e t h e p r e s e n t a t i o n o f t h e p a s s book.

Cer-

tainly legislative authority h a s t h e right t o define eav.. another way.

N o w , t h e question is, i f

isi: cure o f a state h a s given a uefinition t o savings
accounts which i s not i n conforiity w i t h t h e aefinition
which t h e Board wade s o e years ago, h a s t h e board t h e right,
in ruling o n what r e s e r v e o u g h t
deposits,

t o s a y “No, t h o s e

t o b e carried against savings

a r e n o t savin,js deposits;

w e

hela that there i s no savings deposit unless t h e pass book
is presented with the check.

A a good uwany of the mutual

Savings banks have liiuitations o n t h e aiiount that m a y b e received froin any one depositor.

c o m e o f them will only

receive »2,000, 93,000 o r .5,000, a n d I do not think t h e
Board w o u l d b e r e a d y t o s a y t h a t w e w o u l d r e c o g n i z e

n o ac-

count a s a savings account unless i t was limited i n totsl
acount t o ,2,000, o r souething o f that sort, because I
not k n o a w h e r e w e w o u l d c o n e out. I

do

have r e a d t h e o p i n i o n

of your counsel with a great c a l o f interest, a n d I have


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

602

eilsco Rescrvo Bank,
also r e a d t h e o p i n i o n o f t h e c o u n s e l o f t h e S u n F r a n / t t h i

your counsel has given a great deal of thought t o thissubject and that what h e has t o say i s a most admirable srgument r o r the Board t o use i n case t h e y desire t o g o before
4 committee o f Congress a n d have t h e act amended, b u t 1

do

not think that h e mests t h e objecticns raised b y the Cali-

fornia Bank's counsel.
ur. biller:

s u p p o s e w e lsave t h e l a w discussion a s

to what w e c a n s n d cannot do, a n d suppose y o u were going t o
frame a resolution o n the matter o f imisdiate policy i n

regard t o these socalled “special savings“ accounts i n California, bearing i n mind that shatever regulstion w e L a y
aqown must b e gsneral, a n d n o t m e r e l y a:plying t o California,
what w o u l d y o u r p r o p o s i t i o n b e ?

Governor harding: I
in this way, leavin.

think I might fraue a

resolution

i n the passbook restriction, w h i c h i s

a v e r y w i s e restriction,

b u t amplifying

it a

little b i t

and providing, u n d e r t h e dsfinition o f savings dsposits,
for recugnit ion o f t h e right o f the state legislature t o
define savings deposits, always ¢ i

reconciling that

With the requirement o f t h e law here thst ther: must b e a
provision thst t h e y a r s subject t o notice berore payment.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

603
If you d o that y o u might g o a little further a n d say, n o t
enly i n the cese o f a state which has. itself, setined
savings daposits,

b u t where t h e y have proviued r o r 3

gation e r t h e f u n d s o f s a v i n g s deposits, w h e r e t h e y i m p o s e

certain restrictions w h i c h inake t h e m conrorm t o the lLaw---

uy, willer:; (Interposing).
anmatter o f policy,

Y o u would not object, a s

t o regulations o r t h e Keserve Board

pemultting, a n d thereby encouraging, t h e establishment o f
accounts subject t o check, carrying 3

reserve o f three p s r

cent, und:cr the G-signation o f special savings account?

Governor Harding: I

think a regulstion could b e rrened

Which, while i t would b e unobjectionsble t o t h e Boston Bank,
because i

a o not believe t h e usssachusetts legislature would

liberalize t h e law s o as t o bring bank deposits gensrally
unuer that tera, because t h e y have t h e sutual savings
banks there that t h e y watch out for, b u t I

do think t h t t h e

legislatures o t the states generally would want t o enable

the banxs to clsim the right o f sixty days! notice before
paying checks.
Ye Libller:

H o w about national banks u n d e r a

tion o f this k i n d ?

regula-

d o u l d t h a t v i r t u a l l y p u t t h e m i n 4 posi-

tion where t h e y could have accounts, n o t t h e most active


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

604
accounts, but n o t what a r e Known a s checking accounts,
subject

to a

three p e r c e n t r e s e r v e r e q u i r e m e n t i n s t e a d o f

&@s e v e n o r t e n p e r c e n t r e q u i r e m e n t ,

o r whatever

i t hap-

pens t o b e ?
Governor Harding: I

d o n o t t h i n k y o u c o u l d d o any-

thing i n the case o f the National banks unless Congress
chose t o legislate, a n d i don't s e e h o w y o u a r e going t o
get a r o u n d t h a t , b e c a u s e y o u h a v e s t a t e b a n k uwenbership

Which i s provided f o r i n ths Act, a n d y o u have t h e state
laws t o consiaer w i t h regard t o the state bank meinbers.
ure Srissinger:

I f there w a s a n y l a w o f 8 stats,

cr the superintendent o f B a n k i n 2 f
o a state should make
regulations s u c h 42s you say, w o u l d the Board b e bound b y it?
Governor Harding:

but £

N o , I

would n o t r e c c g n i z e t h a t ;

do think i t i s a very serious thing, f r o m t h e

standpoint

o f t h e Board,

i n dealing w i t h t h e crsatures

the state,

t o s a y t o the legislature o f a state, w h i c h

of

grants charters t o its creatures and asserts reculetions
as t o the nature o f their business, t h a t t h e y cculd n o t

define “ssvings accounts" i n some other way, a n d i f they
chose t o cstine “savings accounts” a n d throw some safeguards


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

605
around them,

i t seems

t o m e there might

you t o r e t a i n y o u r p r e s e n t a

finition,

b e sowe w a y f o r
w i t h t h i s aimplifica-

tion, t h a t i n t h o s e s t a t e s w h e r e t h e l a w s a e f i n e s a v i n g s

accounts a n d where provision i s sigue f o r segreation o f t h e
funds, w h i c h I

understand a r e not u s e d i n couiercial loans,

that y o u could distinguish surriciently s o a s t o protect
the national banks s o far a s you c a n and a t the same tine
recognize t h e supremacy o f the state legislature within i t s
own dolsin,

o n a subject which comes under i t s jurisdiction.

Pe Crissinger:

U n d s r the b w o f California, t h e

Superintendent o f Banking o u t there particularly finds
agsinst national banks s n d savings accounts,--Governor Cslkins:

uur. Crissinger:

T h a t is, h e tries to.

H e effectively does so, doe. he not,

by his m e t h o d o
f handling deposit reserves?
Governor Harding: I

would n o t undertake t o discuss

the legal situation i n California.
Governor Calkins: I
tive.

do not think i t has been effec-

T h e national banks a r e gznerally carrying savings

accounts.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ur, Crissinger:

Y e s , b u t they d o n o advertise it.

Governor Calkins: A

great many are advertising.

H e

606
has d o n é o n e t h i n z r e p s a t e d l y e n d consistenbly;

has threatened t h e banks.

that is, h e

H e h3s b e e n told b y t h e National

banks w h o m h e has conmanded t o desist f r o m advertising
that t h e y w o u l d c o n t i n u e

t o sdvertise,

a n d h e has done

nothin z about it.
Governor i.c Dougal:

T h i s discussion i s particularly

interesting t o m e because o f the situation which exists
in wichigan, w n e r e certificates o f deposit a r e issued
Which a r e nominally payable o n aéuand, b u t which bear this
statsient , “Subjéct t o the rules a n d regulations o f the
Savings vVepartinent", w h i c h means,

o f course, notice.

I n

connection w i t h deposits o f that sort t h e banking laws
Or michigan require t h e segregation o f sssets o f a spscific
sort t o b e held against savings a n d time deposits.

T h e y

require the adoption o f certain by-laws which must b e approved b y t h e departinentand t h e : s b y - l a w s m u s t

in the public lobby and s o forth.

b e displayed

T h e Banking Conmis sioner

rules thet a certificate, stamped 3 s indicated, shall b e
classitied s s a tine deposit, a n d that sone sort o f specific
assets b e carried t o protect t h a t a s t h e l a w rejzuires i n
connection w i t h other savings deposits, t h a t is, those
represented b y books,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T h e state nenber banks o f michigan,

607
and I

a y referring n o w t o a

Letter w h i c h wr. N e a t h s e n t

down t 3 t h e Bosrd, t h : refore a r e u p a g a i n s t t h i s situation;

they a r e rejyuired t o carry these certiricates a s tinie deposits,

s n d t o segregate against t h a n specified securi-

tics prescribed b y the banking laws, a n d o n the other hend
the ruling o f the Federal reserve Board requires t h a t they
classify t h e m s s d e m a n d z e p o s i t s a n d h a n d l e t h e m i n s u c h

manner,
Vice Governor Platt:

Governor weDougal:
Which,

o f courss,

A r e checks d r a w n against them?

T h e p e are certificates o f deposit

s r e n o t subject

t o check.

T h s y are

payable, nowiinally, o n demand, b u t t h e bank reserves t h e
right, evidenced b y this inscription o n t h e certificate,

to treat then as though they were savings deposits represented b y books,

Governor harding:

T h e certificates have t o be present-

ed a t t h e bank t o get t h e money?
Governor kevYougeal:

Governor Herding;

e s .

Y o u cannot draw a check o n them

and s e n d t h e m s r o u n d o v e r t h e country?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor ucDougal:
Governor Calkins:

N o t a t all.
T h o s e c a n b e negotiated exactly t h e

sane a 8 a

c h e e k a n d u s e d f o r t h e s a w e purposes.

Vice Governor Platt:

I

n that case i

should think

thsy o u g h t t o b e d e n a n d deposits.

Governor Harding, apart f r o n t h e question o f law, y o u
think t h e regulation o f the Board i s all right a s i t stands,
and t h a t t h e p a s s b o o k o u g h t t o b s r e q u i r e d ?

Governor Harding: I

think i t i s very well t o leave

thet in, but 1 do not see how the Board, i n its dealings
With these state member banks,

i n view o f t h e rights that

they retain under section 9 , that is, t h e statutory charter

rights o f state banks, c a n ignore the Acts o f the Legislature o f the state.
Vice Governor Platt:

B u t i t seeus t o n e t h e legisla-

ture might g o t o the extent o f saying that all deposits
were t i m e deposits.
Governor harding:

i

t i s possible t h a t t h s best s o l u -

tion o f this t h i n g i s t o l e t i t r o c k a l o n g u n t i l C o n g r e s s
ueets agesin a n d w e tiay g e t S o m e l e g i s l a t i o n

ur. Case:

o n t h e subject.

i t seems t o me that from a legal point ard

a practical standpoint, this Conference has a great deal
of i n f o r m a t i o n a t i t s disposel.

T h e counsel

o f t h e Federal

Reserve B o a r d h a s m a d e & @ vary e x h a u s t i v e w r i t t e n r e p o r t


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

on

this subject and closes b y saying:
“The Federal hessrve Board u l a n o t exceed i t s powers

when i t prescribed i n Hegulation v tnet i n order for a deposit

t o b e considered a

‘savings account’

i n coiiputing r e ~

serve i t must b e = deposit w h i c h i s not subject t o withdrawal
without t h e presentation o f a pass book, certificate,

or

fimiler f o r i @ 9 receipt.

“The Federal Reserve Board would excesd its powers i f
it amended this regulation s o 2s t o permit asposits which
are s u b j e c t t o .ithcdrawl b y c h e c k w i t h o u t t h e o r e s e n t a t i o n

or @ pass book, certificate o f ceposit o r similer receipt

to be classified 9 s 'savin's accounts! f o r the purpose o f
computing reserves,

“The sozcalled ‘special savin.s deposits!

o f Califernia

banks c a n n o t p r o p e r l y b e c o n s i d e r e d ‘ s a v i n g s accounts!

within

the meaning o f Section 1 9 o f the Federal neserve Act, n o t
only because t h e y a r e subject t o withdrawal without t h e

prés 3

/

the psssbock, but also because they are

checking accounts a n d differ essentially f r o u thet class

of accounts which i s gsnerally known and recognized 3 s sayings accounts.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

emand ceposits

610

in computing the reserves t o be maintained under the tsrms
of S e c t i o n 1 9 , b e c a u s e t h e y a r e e s s e n t i a l l y c h e c k i n g accounts;

and t h e Board w o u R

v a i l i n the performance o f its duty i f

it p e r n l t t e d o n l y t h r e e p e r c e n t r é s e r v e s

t o b e maintained

agsinst them."
As I understand i t , t h e matter has b e e n before t h e
Board 2 number o f times during t h e last r i v e ysars a n d t h e
Board has taken t h e position, a n a constantly iaintained it,
and I
ago,

think s u m ejuently this matter w a s reviswed a

year

o r so, b y t h e Federal Keserve Council, w h i c h concurred

in the Board's conclusion, and if I sim not inistaken the
Governors! C o n f e r e c e last spring reariéirmed a

belief i n

the correctness o f this ruling o r reguiation.

Governor Calkins:

w a y I ask if the Governors! Con-

fsrence c i s c u s s e d t h i s p a r t i c u l a r q u e s t i o n a n d made a

reecne-

mendation, according t o your understanding?
ur, Case: I

a m s o advised, yes.

i t seems t o m e a s

a practical matter that w e should not j u s t confine ourselves t o the form, b u t rather l o c k through s n d s t e the
substance that t h e deposits tske.
co

T h e reserves requirsnents

have b e en very materially reduced since t h e federal nessrve
system w a s estsblished,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

a n d i n m y view i t would b e a

very

611
bad p r a c t i c e f o r t h e s y s t e m t o f u r t h e r l e t d o w n t h e b e r s

and permit deposits o f this sort t o have t h e reserve r e quirements reduced f r o m t e n per cent t o thrseper cent.
wPe willer;

J u s t as a

ustter

o f good banking policy

you say, i n your juaginsnt, i t would b e @ bad thing t o do?
mur, Case:

3

B

I should like t o move, wr. Chairian, that i t i s the
sense o f t h i s c o n f e r e n c e t h a t t h e r e s h o u l d b e n o c h a n g e o f
the present r e g u l a t i o n .

Governor Harding: I

would like to raise this point:

It is not a question of good banking policy, and I agree
with everybody o n that.

I t would b e morea matter o f

good b a n k i n g p o l i c y t o s a y t h a t t h e s e w e r e d e m a n d deposits;

but you have the law t o administer, a n d tke re is nothing i n
the law which says that savings accounts must have the
passbook presented i n order f o r checks t o b e paid.

I t oc-

curs t o m é t h a t y o u h a v e g o t t o c o n s i d e r t h i s q u e s t i o n
not o n l y i n t h e l i g h t o f s a v i n g s a c c o u n t s ,

b u t also s s t o

whether o r not these deposits a r e tine deposits.

T h e r e are

two angles there. A f t e r sll I think i t i s more s juestion:
of law, with a littie o r states’ rights mixed into it, than
it i s a question o f expediency o r banking policy.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

6l2
wPe killer:

L e t m e inject there t h a t 1

you o n t h e m a t t s r

agree with

o f t h e reguireiient o f t h e passbook,

that

it i s something i n which t h e Fedcral Keserve Board has exceeded its powers i n including i t i n its regulations.
Governor Harding:

I

t i s msrely a

dz:finition because

we had t o find o u t what savings accounts were, a n d w e under}
stooa, a s 4 tlattsr o f custom, t h e books were presented.
ur, miller: I

think i t i s very desirable t o consider

the jusstion o f policy.
time t h e r e g tu
o) l’ s t i o n s

i y recollection i s that a t t h e

w e r e drawn,

a n d I

think they w e r e d r a w n

up i n the first s i x months o f the Board, s o m e o f us--- [
knov I L felt v e r y strongly a t t h e time that t h e savings
passbock r e q u i r e m e n t w a s necessary,
by o u r c o u n s e l

a n d t h e s r g u i e n t inade

i n that r e s p e c t h a s u a a e n o i m p r e s s i o n

my mind watever, I

on

a m o f the opinion noi t h a t twas then,

that i t was highly important t h a t w e should stretch o u r
powers a little i n order t o protect t h e reserves o f the
ménber banks o f the Federal heserve system f r o m being
breken d o w n b y t h e c o n v e r s i o n o f w h s t w e r e i n effect c o n s e r -

cisl savings accounts.

A t the same t i m e 1

a m alive t o the

fact that i n California t h s situation i s rather unique,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

a method could b e f o u n d that w o u l d n o t bring i n its

a9

ols
train a

lot o f undesirable consequences, I

to see a n exception msae o f Calirornia,

would b e w i l l i n g

Y e t t h e Keserve

Bank o f San francisco h a s never proposed t o t h e Roard a
method b y which this could b e done.

Governor Herding:

T h a t is the point 1 santed to raise.

I recognize t h a t t h e G o v e r n o r s

o f t h e *eserve B a n k s a r e n o t

expert i n law, a n d s t t h e saime time I

do n o t think this par-

ticular juestion c a n b e decided purely a s a matter o f banking
policy.

Y o u have g o t t o consider t h e l a w a n d y o u have g o t

to take into consideration t h e legal situation i n California
with regard t o the California s t a t e banks.

mr. Crissinger: d o u l d n ' t you b e likely t o follow the
judgment

o f y o u r solicitor?

Governor Herding:

B u t suppose you adhere t o this rul-

ing snd one of the mémber banks i n California says: “ O u r
counsel advises u s that y o u ars wrong?" s u p p o s e there

should b e legislation o n this question snd the state courts
should a e c i d e a g a i n s t y o u ?

ir, OCrissinger: C h a n g e the regulation.
iur. Hamlin: £

think t h e point rsised b y ur. willer

and Governor C a s e i s a very g o o d one; t h e t w e a r e nat here
to s e t t l e t h e law.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

W

e a r e n o t lawyers,

a t least i n our

614
present capacity, b u t where I

think t h e Governors c a n help

the Board very much i s b y disregarding t h e l a w a n d taking
up this c y s t e m o f savings accounts i n California s n d #sking
this juestion:

A s s u m i n g that t h e Board i s within t h e law

and c a n m a k e a n y d e c i s i o n i t s i r e s ,

fornia a

i s this s y s t e m i n Cali-

proper a n d genuine savings system, a n d i f so, i s

a threes per cent reserve,
sufficient r e s e r v e

i n actual practice, a

t o carry? I

proper a n d

think o n t h a t p o i n t y o u

Will b e able t o help t h e Board very such.

O u r counsel h a s

given a legal o pinion. U l t i n a t e l y t h e question m a y g o
to the attorney General, a n d o f course i f h e rules adverssly,
that settles t h e whole question.
Governor Harding:

B u t does i t ? A

bank m a y take i t

to court.
wir, Hamlin:
concerned.

I

I t settles t h e question s o far 3 s w e are

t would b e o r great advantage

t o u s i f you

will tell us, a s t o this system, whether i n your opinion
it i s a safe s n c proper savings system, a n d whether i n practice the three p e r cent r e s e r v e i
s anple f o r t h e purpose.
I hope before t h e Conference i s over that Governor Calkins
can tell u s something about that.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ie h a v e h a d a n o p i n i o n f r o m o u r counsel,

a s y o u know,

615
who rules that a n y so-called savings system permitting
checking sgainst i t , a s a matter o f

l a w those dsposits

m w . Agnew, t o r t h e Feceral Reserve

becouse demand ceposits.

Bank of San Francisco, filed a very sbic brief, e n d he takes
the o p p o s i t e v i e w a s a

mattsr

o f law.

a matter o f l a w w e cannot c o n s i c e r

O u r counsel says a s

i t a s a savings systein

if there i s 2 checking account and =r, agnew says 3 S a imatter
of l e w thet t h e Calirornis banks literally comply w i t h t h e

lsw i n reserving the right o f notice snd thet therefors, a s
auatt r of lsi w e have got t o say that thet i s 4 savings
system. I

d o not agres w i t h either counsel. I

ssy, s v e n

ig the l a w literally i s positive, t h a t w e c a n 2lways g o
through that 2 n d look a t the sub. tance o r t h e transaction.

Assuning that w e have the pover, t h e jzuestion i s d o «se want
to e x e r c i s e

i t o r not. I

think o n t h a t p o i n t t h e G o v e r n -

ors c a n give u s sous very g o o d e n d helpful information.
we have g o t t o define what 2 a savings account is.

I t says

that savings accounts a r e a l l subjsct t o notice, a n d l
agree with ur. Jjyatt that w e have got t o vericm>cr w h e t a
savings account is, a n d w e also must deturmine that w e are


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

not talking about mutual savings banks, but w e are talking
about coniercial banks w h i c h have savin;s departments. T h a t

616
is the question w e have got t o settle i n this case. N o w ,
I do not think their counsel brought o u t t h e fact that w h e n
the Fed r a l Reserve a c t w a s passed b y the House o f Keprssentatives i t had i n itseztion 27, w h i c h laid down a complete
system f o r national banks carrying a savings dspartment.
Ultimately t h e senate rejected that a n d i t went out, s n d
they substituted t h e words “savings account subject t o

not ice,"
Now, t h a t i s some evicence, t h e fact t h a t t h e House o f
Repressntatives passed that Act, a s t o what t h e y meant b y
savings accounts;

a n d what d i d t h e y do? T h e y s s i d that

any national bank setting u p a savings departiment m u s t segregate a part o f its capital, a n d that a l l the assets o f the
savings b a n k h a d t o b e invested i n 9 certain line t o b e laid
down b y t u e Pedzral Reserve Board,

T h e r e i s a limitation

on the investments, a n d i t stated that t h e Board could d e cide what reservation a s t o notice should b e required.
Governor Harding:

I s not t h e definition o f “savings

account" practically uniform a l l over t h e country?
iur, Hamiins

N o .

Governor harding:

I

n ths State o f massachusetts,

as

you know, t h e legislature h a s practically defined “savings


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

617

accounts"3as deposits o f savings banks, a n d they tax savings
banks i n a different w a y f r o m other banks.

S a v i n g s deposits

in wassachusetts a r e exempt f r o m taxation.
ur. Hamlin; M u t u a l savings banks.
Governor Harding:

i u t u a l savings banks, yes.

T h e s t s-

tute refers t o savings accounts i n one place a n d says that
deposits i n mutual savings b a n k s a r e exempt f r o m taxation
because specially tax2d i n other ways.

ur. Hamlin:

B u t w e are speaking o f commercial banks

having savings departments, a n d not o f savin s banks suchas
the mutual savings banks.

# h e n Congress passed Section

27 i t had i n its mind a s essentials of’savings aco@ unts
two things: L i m i t a t i o n a s t o investment a n d strict rules
as t o the investment o f all deposits, a n d reservation o f
notice.

C o n g r e s s s a i d nothing about a

pass book, 4 n d said

nothing about a checking account, a n d t o my mind i t is
evidential o n the question that Congress intended that
savings accounts simply meant accounts w h e r e 911 deposits
are segregated, a r e limited a s t o investment, a n d t h e
reservation o f t h e right o f notice.

That, f

think, i s a

fair argument a s t o the intention o f Congress.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Harding:

S u p p o s e i n lhassachusetts a mutual

618
savings b a n k s a w f i t t o relax i t s rules a n d s a y that i f a
man didn't have his passbook t h e y would p a y t h c h e c k anyok:

T h a t account would b e none t h e less a savings account.
Mr. Hamlin: A b s o l u t e l y . I

would s a y this, t h a t i f

any bank reserving t h e right t o notice, m a d e a contract
with a depositor t h a t i t would not exercise that right, o f

course that would be a plain violation o f the statute, a n d
also i f they advertised i t they would not exercise it; b u t
ifa

bank,

i n its discretion, waives presentation o f the

pass book, a n d permits l i m i t e d checking o n accounts, I
should s a y that w o u l d still b e 8 savings account.

Governor Harding:

I t wouldn't make that account, i n

massachusstts, subject t o texation,
“ur. Hamlin:

U n d e r t h e laws o f sons states,

i n fact

in every state, i t has b e e n cslled t o m y attention thst t h e y
put sone limitation o n the u s e o f checks w i t h respect t o
savings accounts.

B u t i n every stats t h e y s a y that t h e

use o f checks shall n o t b e permitted except i n extraordinary
conaitions,

t o b e astermined b y t h e boerd. C a l i f o r n i a

goes durther, s n d t h e Califernia banks permit a

limited

use o f non-negotiable cheeks, w i t h a stamp o n them t o indi-

cate that the bank issuing i t has t h e right t o refuse it,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

619
except a f t e r t h e e x p i r a t i o n o f a

certain number

Now, o n the question o f regulations, I

o f Asys.

belisve thes

regulations a r e right a s t o national banks, because there
there l s n o segregation,

a n d w e are checking against t h e

funus o r t h e bank with n o segregation t h e samwe s s with a
COtu2zrclal check, b u t w e have t h e rignt,

a s $s national bank,

to s a y “Let u s hevs your pass b o o k when t h e check i s presented."

w i t h t h e state oanks I

think w e would haves 4 per-

fect rignt u n d e r the l a w t o establish a cirferent s e t o f
regulations, p s c a u s e t h e i m c t s a r e Girrerent.

I n other

words, t h e gist o f my argument i s that i n a¢fining savings
accounts w e mean essentially deposits i n the savings d e partuents o f banks w h i c h a r e n o t open t o checking o r t o
cojuiercial loaning, b u t which a r e strictly Limited a s t o in-

vestient o f those deposits t o get a rate o f interest higher
than the bank would g i v e o n its conmercial deposits, a n d
on those s a v i n .
s deposits t h e bank ressrves t h e right o f
notice.
Now, o n the question o f demand a n d time cepasits, t a k e
this particular case.

I f you s a y these s r e not savings

accounts, y o u cannot s a y that because t h e y become aeuand
deposits---


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

you camot

say a

depoesitob p u t t i n g m o n e y

in a

620

bank has made s aeémand deposit unless h e has t h e legal a n d
irrevocable r i g h t a t a n y t i m e t o c e m a n d payment o f t h e

money.

I n this c a s e n o depositor i n a savings b a n k has a

legal right a t any time t o aemand payment o f t h e money. T h e
bank,

i n its discretion, m e y waive t h e right n o t t o p a y i t

except o n notics, b u t t h e bank has a legal right t o s a y that
tne monsy shall not b e withdraw excepton notice, a n d how
you c a n s a y i n a n y i n s t a n c e t h a t t h a t i s a

I do not see.

d m a n d deposit,

A s I say, what I hope the Governors will

do, would b e t o examine t h e Caliyornia s y s t e m a n d tell us,
assuming that there i s n o legal obstacle, whether i t i s
wise a n d prepsr

t o mermit a

those accounts. I

three p e r c e n t r e s e r v e a g a i n s t

wish Governor Calkins would tell u s h o w

the thrse p e r cent reserve works o u t i n practice.

i

e know

thet t h e banks have b e s n carrying it, a n d have b e e n carry-

ing i t subject t o any finsl ascision that w e might make
in the matter. I

would like t o have Governor Calkins tell

us something about t h e Calirorn& s a v i n g s system, whether,
assuming there i s n o legal obstacle,
safe savings system, whether,

i t i s a genuine a n d

i n practice, a

reserve w o u l d b e ample.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

mPe miller:

l u a y I inject a

word here?

three p e r cent

Vice G o v e r n o r Platt:

mre kkilier:

Y e s .

d h e n w e attemot t o convert a

confsrence

too much into 4a debating soclety, i t always meens that the
time i s unproritably spent.
ferences, I

F r o m observation o f past con-

think that i s so, s n d w e also spent o u r time,

speak very deguatically,
when we a s b a t e a

t o very little sdvantage

question o f l a w o r s n interpretation o f

the Federal Reserve act. i

g

as f a r s l o n g i n t h e n e x t conferences

e

t anywhere, a n d # é are
2 3 w e a r e a t this one.

One o f the difficulties o f these conrerences--- a m d
this has been exhibited b y the whole ciscussion i n connec-~

tion with the special savings accounts o f Californis f o r
the l a s t y e a i

w

6 are t o o long o n ic3as a n d t o s

short o n wethods o f dealing with actusl probbms that present
themselves.

L

i a: familiar w i t h t h e s p e c i a l s s v i n . s a c -

counts i n Caliiornia, e n d i a m satisried, u n d e r t h e condi-

tions that exist there, that the law i s well devised there
in treating these 8 s savings accounts a n d i n not requiring
that t h e y carry t h e ordinary cousercial reserve. f

am

also satisfied that i f the Roerd's regulations
as t o siske i t possibe

t o institute accounts c f

this kind throughout t h e country gensralily, t h e t w e would


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

622
have precisely t h e situation that sire Case h a s i n mind, t h a t
is, that w e would begin t o eat u p t h e n e c ssary minimum
reserve requireusnts o r t h e Federal Reserve System.

I n other

words there would b s a degeneration o f t h e whole reserve r e -

quirements o f the act. T h e r e r o r : , I
ingenuity s n o u g h

t o susgest a

want t o ask who hss

iswethod b y w h i c h C a l i f o r n i a

can g e t w h e t i t w a n t s s n d t h e r e s t o f t h e c o u n t r y b e pre-

ventea rroii suffering t h e bad c o m ejuencss o r thet?
Governor Calkins o r anybocy s l s e c a n suggest a
which that c a n b e aone, i
it. I

i t

method b y

for one, a u ailling t o entertain

think i t i s rutile t o discuss here anether t h e

special savings accounts i n Califrornia a r e savings accounts.
I kno;

o f n o i e t h o d t o n a n d l e i t sxcept o n e , a n d t h a t i s

or v e r y d o u b t r u l propriety,

a n d t h a t i s r o r thse F e d e r a l

neserve B o a r d t o simply instruct i t s ¢xauiners t o ignore
the tact that these so-called special checking accounts,
in which t h e me¢esentation o f the passbock i s not required,
shall b e treated i n Calirornia a s savings accounts.

There

is n o method w h i c h I have yet s e e n b y which o u r regulations c a n b e siiiended s o a s t o give Califcrnis w h a t i t wants
ana not break d o w n what I

regard as a n essential safeguard

to the v r servereqguireients o f t h e meuber banks o r t h e system,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

throughout t h e l e n g t h a n d b r e d t h o r t h e country.

Governor Harding:
do i s t o incorporate

A l l i n the world you have got t o

i n your regulations a

full q u o t a t i o n

from t h e Calirornisa law.

re willer:

B u t would you ao that with respect t o

every state in the Union?
Governor Harding;

Y e s , follow the California b&b w---

you have either g o t t o d o that, o r you have t o say that
California h a s s u c h a superior mental atmosphere o u t there
that t h e y c a n carry out a

law which t h e other states camnot,

If y o u a p p r o v e t h s Caliisrnis l a w a n d y o u h a v e n o d o u b t t h a t
those a r e s a v i n g s a c c o u n t s

i n California,

me your problem i s very clear.

t h e n i t seems t o

A l l y o u have t o d o i s t o

enlarge y o u r reguletions a n d quote v e r y liberally f r o m t h e

California l a w and say this applies i n s1l cases where the
law provides s o and so.
wr. miller:

D e y o u mean, seriously, t h a t t h e Board

Snould put o u t a regulation o r thet kind?
Governor Harding:
iure Miller:

a d o .

F o r t h e Board t o put o u t 8 regulstion cone

taining a n 2laborats extract f r o m the California lawe--


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Harding:

I

t wouldn't havs t e b e a n é6laborate

extract;

y o u c o u l d t a k e thse substance

of it o

tisl Teature o f it.
Oe LiLller:

Y o u will find tnere a r s other states that
and

have their c o n c e p t i o n s o r savings accounts under t h e eonditions that prevail there, probably t h e i r conception i s a
good o n e ,

Governor sarding:

4

é Calitoruia i s sntitied t o it,

under t h e esue conuitions o t h e r states w o u l d b
e entitisd
to it.
we MLLler: I

think w h e n y o u g o that r a r that y o u

have really taken a long step toward disintegration o f
reserve reguireusnts.

Governor Harding:

Y o u ssid y o u 30preved California's

c@ition, e n a wished there w a s so.e v a y t o kelp t h e m out,
ar, Miller: I

say 4 know e f n o insthod b y

can b s done except 4 lusthoa which,
ly doubtful propristy,
consistently


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

t o m y mind,

a n d therefore I

i s o f exatreie-

voted a g e i n

o n t h e board.

Governor $2335 I s n ' t one o f the most vital and perkiconsi.crations t h e fact that t h e state prescribes t h e
oi investient

i n which s a v i n s
_accounts shell b e in-

625
d o n o t t h i n k i t i s practicable.

ure biljer: I

put yourself i n the positic

3

3 ard

Just

T h e Board must

lay aown national regulations e n d w s cannot regulate locally.
n a v e o n s s e t o f regulstions f o r

inet Eemlins: a

a
national banks, w h e r e they have n o segregation a n d n o L i n i t -

tion of investuents, a n d w e have t h e right t o 5 separate
class o f réguistions r o r banks t h s t d o segregate.

T o my

ming thst i s the very object o f section 9, which allows
the bank t o coue i n with all its statutory rights, e n c i t

stould b e our duty t o regulate them, except i n s o fap as
it would tend t o break doun t h e Federal Neserve oystem.

ies tillers

w e at once get back to s qyusstion o f law,

Governor hoarding;

N o bank soulé segregate eny lerge

portion o f i t s tlue deposits i n t o savin.s deposits w h e n i t

knew thet if it uld so every cent of its assets sould be
tied u p i n investients.

ur, biller:

B u t shat right has this board--- I

*o not

mean L e g a l r i g h t - - - b u t h o y c a n y o u j u s t i f y i t s s g o o d

e, t o v a y that w e will take t h e Calirornia law--there a r e s t a t e s

i n the Union that h a v e savings accounts

that d o n o t rsjyulre segregstion.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor s e a y *

T h e n t h e y ¥a r e w i t h o u t

t h e asrinition.

626
Governor Norris:

w a y I

make a

suggestion?

Could

not t h e Board adopt this reguliation--- o f course I
attempting n o w t o s t a t e t h e phraseology,

a m not

b u t simply t h e

thought--- that where there i s 2 question a s t o whether
savings deposits a r e strictly savings deposits o r not, t h a t
the l a w will accept t h e L a w o f sny state defining t h e a t o
be savings accounts,

i f i n the judgment o r t l e Boerd s u c h

state laws provide proper safeguards t o inake t h e reduced
reserve requirements sufficient?
lur. Crissinger:

v o e s n ' t t h a t bear o n t h e question

raised b y wir. Case, w h i c h really i s a banking question,
end t h s t i s w h e t h e r

w e should

h a v e a n y reserves

o r not?

Why have any?
Goverrmr Norris:
have reserves,

«

o f course;

6 a r e 6l]1 agrseéd t h a t w e o u g h t

t h a t w e should have t e n per cent

except o n savings accounts.
state d o not define a

to

N o w , i r t h e laws o f a

deposit t o b e a savinses deposit,

upon o n l y w h i c h o n l y t h r e e p e r c e n t r e s e r v e i s t o b e carried,

then the cuestion arises d o e s that s a m e l a w provide s u c h
provilons 3 8 t o segregation o f assets, e n d s s t o character
of assets, a n d 2 s t o ths r i g h t c f deniand, notice, s n d soe
rorth, a s t o justify t i t h r e e per cent reserve?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ur. Hamlin; I

egree w i t h that proposition entirely.

Ge 7

Vice Governor Platt:

w r , Case, d o e s your motion cover

the q u e s t i o n o f j h e t h e r t h e t h r e e p e r c e n t r e s e r v e

i s suffi-~

cient i n case o f segregation o f assets?
ua. Case:

N o .

I t i s that w e shall continue t h e pre-

sent regulation o f t h e Bosrd.
ur, Hamlin: I

think w e would like t o hear f r o m Governor

Calkins o n the question o r t h e effect o f t h e three p e r cert
reserve i n Caliisornia,
Governor Calkins; I

have a few words o n that subject,

but Ihave n o desireto prolong the dsbate, unless the Board
wishes t o hear me.
Vice Governor Platt;

I t i s n o t universally conceded

that i t woulk b e s good policy t o maintain special savings
eposits,

e v e n i n Calirornia.

Governor Calkins:

T h e r e i s n o u n i v e r s a l o p i n i o n witha.

regard t o anything, b u t there s r e differences o f opinion
among t h e Cailfornis S t a t e b a n k s a b o u t t h i s t y p e o f a c e

count; t h e r e 1 s n o jyuestion about that.

T h o s e who d o

n&d c a r r y this t y = a r e agsinst it; t h o s e w h o d o Carry i t
are

i n favor o f it.

T h a t i s numan nature. I

the iaatter i s o f a n y importance wmeatever, b u t I

do not think
did not

take a s applying t o m e what vr. miller s a i d about n o prac-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

628

tical sugsestion having come from the dan *rancsico Bank,
because I

have never y e t s a i d one w o r d o n the subject.

This i s t h e rirst a n d only occasion o n which I

have expres-

sed myself.

Everybody h a s agreed that w e should not t a l k sbout t h e
law, b u t I

cannot t a l k a t a l l unless I

start w i t h t h e lew.

I ammot going toe rgue a legsl question, but I say that
the conclusion reached b y mr. y a t t i s not what y o u 3 1 1 seem
to think i t is; y o u have not bolled i t down.

T h e conclu-

Sion r e a c h e d b y w r e w y a t t i s t h a t t h e r e c a n b s n o s a v i n g s

account unless t h e pass b o o k i s p r e s e n t e
nod
h
the
w deposit
is wade a n d w h e n the withdrawal i s made.

T h e t &

the exact

Substance o f his legal conclusion.
Now, i f ths Board accepts that, thersis o n l y o n e t h i r
tor the board t o do, 3 n d that i s t o put this regulation,
Wnich i s n o w o n your vooks, i n t o i:orce; t h e r e i s n o question
about thst.

I f that 1 s done t h e soecis] savings accounts

or C a l i f o r n i a becoi.e asniand c e p o s i t s a n d t h e l a w s s y s t h a t

deimana aéposits saith ths aeaning o f this act comprise a l l
G posits p a y a b l e w i t h i n thirty, days, w h i c h o f course,

b y

inrerence, excludes a l l deposits n o t peyabie i n tuat tlie,
and the g s j a l savin.s d s p o s i t s a r e n o t payabie within


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

thirty days.
L o n l y h a v e o n e t h i n g w o r e t o say. i

agree w i t h you,

mPe Hanlin, that, the legal question aside, t h e q u e s t i o ns
i
whether o r not the special provisions o f the l a w o f the state
in which the bank i s located s e t u p surrisient protection

to justify this Board i n applying the three per cent reserve,
and m y answer i s that t h e provisions o f the l a w o f California s e t u p ail that c a n possibly b e required, a n d d o
justify this Board i n peruitting t h e three p e r cent reserve.
There i s a l l s o r t s o f e v i u e n c e t h a t c a n b e p r o d u c e d

to support t h a t contention, including t h s evidence t h a t
there h a s never been a n y difficulty w i t h t h e savings banks
in the state o f Calirornia since t h e l a w w a s enacted.

ut. Crissinger:

N o difficulty a t all?

Governor Valkins:
vouptroller.

N o consiterable aifriculty, mur.

T n e point ofr the view o r the bank carrying

the deposit, s n d that i s what w e have t o deal with, i s that
the b a n k i s r e q u i r e d

b y t h e State o f California

its s p e c i a l s a v i n g s d e p o s i t s

ally speaking,
rate.

t o invest

i n a certain way, a n d , gener-

i n investiuients which G o not return 3 high

I f i t i s éslso required b y the Feaeral Reserve

Act end under the ruling o f the Federal Heserve Board, t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

55

e
Vv

3

agsinst ti:cni,

bet fa: cul o s

. u i s t sThe
y~

with which y o u aré cinfrontec

situation

a
stnu0.ui)
sg

t o just that,

otier t h i n s

2nG

i s

Lae,

i

b2elizve
a
m the

Federal R e s s r]= ve Bosra shoul. cunc:icer v e r y carerully
bEieee ee

3:
6.ip
s eu:o

t at thi

EL i s s

e2
~]

i

3 u

matter, b u t perticulsr ly s t

t

i

ther tiuwe, f o r thet

+

s

a

a n y

,

spsti oe

w e n Congress. &

gé t nioxe s t a t e b a n k s i n t o t h e t

g n wi hryl u da
gne nt h
ie

Fo
Ws

LoeW h y S o
gn e O F
o

s o cut, tt o pronos

S

or
banks having
fas§- i

That

younia i i k e t o
G

Ln
thiak
3

he

i-bzlisve
Demo @ e i c k b o s

745,009,000

sousthing l i k e that,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

. g naccounts.
i v a c

6.26

G

PSs
1 tN ALeO b Eee

is & ths m o r t consesrvatige,

i n specisl

winsged, 3 n d eer~

psnks t h e t

B a v a

531
ever caus i n contact with. I

think there i s a ssricus jues-

tion before the Board, a n d that i s this:

c a n w e find a

proper w a y t o prevent t h e withdrawal o f those banks;
exactly t h e s a m e s i t u a t i o n a r i s e s

Governor ucbougal:

a n d

i n wisconsin.

Y o u wean i n wichigan?

Governor Calkins: I

should s a y michizsan.

E v e r y dol-

lar deposited o n a certificate o f deposit i s just exactly
as tmch a demand deposit a s a special savings deposit i n
California, a n d the board must r u l e i n that w a y i f i t rules
on t h a t question.

we u l ller;

B u t have y o u tound 2 proper w a y i n whic h

the Board can d o it? I

haven't ztound any proponent o f

giving t h e Californias banks what t h e y want i n this particular w h o h a s e v e r s u g g e s t e d a

constructive m e t h o d

b y which

the thing c a n b e done, without breaking d o w n t h e safeguards that t h e Board has s e t u p i n its gensral regulations.

Governor Calkins: I

think you snswered that question

yourself.

Governor Harding:

Y o u heaves Governor Norris' suggss-

Governor Calkins:

T h e l a w o f California requires

tion.

banks t o invest t h e seggregated special savings accounts


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

532
in a special w a y f o r t h e protection o f t h e account, a n d
when i n v e s t m e n t s a r e m a d s

i n accordance w i t h that requirenent

of t h s law, t h e l a w provides t h e necesssry protection f o r
them.
mr. willer:

T h e question really i s here whether w e

shall strike out from our remilations t h e provision requiring presentation o f t h e pass book.
Governor Calkins:
lar. siller:

T h e a t i s t h e whole question.

O n the question o f policy, I

say i t i s

very doubtrul whether t h e Board strictly h a s t h e power t o
require that, b u t 4

think i t L s very good policy o n t h e

part o f the Board i n construing t h e Act t o assume that i t
hes thse power.

Governor valkins: I
answer

think i t i s covered b y the

t o t h e question whether

i t sould b e expedient f o r

the Board t o rule, a s i t must rule, under counsel's
opinion, t h a t there c a n b e n o such thing s s s savings account
unless t h s pass b o o k i s p r e s e n t e d

Governor seays &

o n b o t h occasions.

lover reserve,

i n m y opinion,

is

more jJustiried i n a stats where there i s legal a n d reasonable p r o v & i o n f o r t h e i n v e s t m e n t

o f s u c h deposits t h a n

it i s where there i s a requirement o f the banks f o r thirty


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

days’ notice,
Vice Governor Platt:

T h s t i s just t h e sort o f ques-

tion o n which t h e Roard really wants advice, Governor Seay.
Governa Seay:

J o u l d i t b e possible t o make a rule

applicable t o those states v r i c h have satisfactory requirements f o r t h e -egregatic.

o f sssets

of a

bank represented

by s a v i n g s d e p o s i t s ?

ur. willer:

m y answer t o that would p e that i t i s

for those who are proponents o f this thing, notably California,

t o coue f n aith t h e proposal o f a plan b y which

wnat they want can b e gotten without disintegrating our
necessary safeguards.

Governor seay:
mPe Willer:
idea.

I s that a proposal, mr. willer?

N o , t h a t i s not a proposal.

T h e Bosrd has cudgeled i t s brains,

I t is an

a t least I have,

to s e e w h e t h e r t h e r e i s a n y m e t h o d b y w h i c h w e t h i n k C a l i -

fornia c é n get what i t wants e n d a t the s a m e t i m e the Board
discharge i t s duty t o maintain g o a b a n k i n s conditions

throughout the rest o f the country, s h re they have not
developed this unique a n d isolsted type o f banking.
i want t o say, furthermore,

o n this proposition, t h a t

to m y mind there i s n o legitimate n e e d f o r reserve require-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

534
ments a t all, a n d when you get aown t o tne basic thing, a n d
study i t f r o m every point o f logic, y o u finally cone o u t
with @ proposition,

o r you come out w i t h a practical result

that y o u break aown the reserve requirements that a r e i n
the reserve banks, a n d with t h e thought, o u r position i s
that w e have g o t t h e m n a s n d w e had better h o l d tight t o
them, o r w e will g e t nothing i n the long run, because t h e
whole tendency a n d push will slways b e toward reduction o f
reserve r e q u i r e m e n t s ,

s n d has been ever since t h e system

has b e e n i n operation.

Governor Seay.
a proposal, I

I f your idea c a n b e converted i n t o

think Governor Norris h a s practically d o n e

it.
lure Gilbert:
Loan Act having a

I s n ' t there something i n the “edsral F a r m
bearing o n this?

Governor Norris:

T h e r e i s a provision that I

mind i n making this suggestion.

I

n the a c t t h e Fami Loan

Board i s specifically g i v e n authority,
directed,

had i n

i n fact i t i s

t o examine t h e laws o f esch state t o det armine

wiether o r not t h e lews o f the state give proper protection

to investors i n mortgages, s n d i n any state where they were
of t h e o p i n i o n t h a t s u c h l a w s d i a n o t g i v e p r o p e r protection,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

535
they were authorized t o declare t h e mortgages ineligible
for t h e systen,

t

h

e precedent

i n sxisting legis-

lation f o r a board t o determine whether t h e state lews d o
or d o not give adequate protection.
it would seem t o m e t o b e just i n line with that f o r
the Keserve Board t o s a y that t h e y would accept t h e state
law 3 s t o reserve, provided i n their judgient those laws
give p r o p e r p r o t e c t i o n

i n order t o justify reducing t h e r e -

serve.
ue, iat iier:

I t would seen t o i e that that w o u l d b e

the most vicious principle that y o u could g o o n i n the
discussion o f this topic. I
raise a

ado not think anyone could

serious q u e s t i o n a s t o w h e t h s r t h e s e s a v i n . s d e -

posits i n California a r e strictly savings i n the sense i n
which that w o r d i s used.

I n other words, a r e these moneys

Wisely invested, a n d i s the dspositor s u r e o f the eventusl
solvency o f his claim against t h e bank a s these securities
can b e liquicated i f they n e e d be.
AS r e s e r v e b a n k s

w e are not

s o much concerned about

security, b u t a s t o the safeguards t h a t w e set u p against
too L i b e r a l a n d t o o f r e e u s e o f t h e e x p a n s i v e p o w e r s
member b a n k s o f &¢* c o u n t r y ,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

o f the

i f w e ever drop that conception

636
we are letting d o w n the berriers t o a flood o f uncontrolsble
bank e x p a n s i o n

i n t h i s country.

to make t h e deposits secure.
the resson o f it.

not
T h e reserve 1 s put t h e r e

T h a t i s n o t t h e theory o r

T h a t i d e a has l o n g since disappeared,

especially since t h e rederal Reserve oysten has come into

being.

T h e question i s whether, i n reducing the reserve

requirements, t h e Reserve system i s not putting itself i n
a position where i t i s really n o t safeguarding a l l the banks
of the country.

T o m y mind i t i s better t o let sleeping

dogs lie---

wr. Hamlin:
inY

B u t they don't ide.

s i dleaL T h e t l i e s v e r y w h e r e e x c e p t

i n Calirornia.

i say w e are conrronted w i t h the situation o r either letting
down the bars o r o f letting banks g o out, a n d 1 regard i t
in this way, t h a t i t would b e better t o l e t t h e state banks
go out o f the system i n California.
Governor Calkins:

dogs lie".

Y o u used t h e term “let sleeping

b o you realize that these banks would edopt

a subterfuge s n d g é t a r o u n d t h e r e g u l a t i o n - - -

ite LiLller;

T h e n a h y aon't y o u encourage t h e m t o d o

that a n d not raise t h e question.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ur. Crissinger:

B u t d o you think t h e Board ought t o

recognize a

subterfuge?

Governor Calkins:
Governor Norris:
in a

N o , I do not.
w a y I have a

very s h o r t t i m e - - - I

word here. I

think

understand t h e q u e s t i o n i s already

raised i n wichigan--- that i t will b e raised i n various
other states. I

do n o t belisve t h e r e a r e anywhere a n y more

exclusively and distinct savings institutions than the mumal

savings banks i n Philadelphia; t h e y are very old, very
large a n d very conservative.

T h e y have a l l o f t h e m recently

given what they call a limited checking privile ge o n their
savings deposits.

E v e n where they won't accept m o r e t h a n

y500 i n any one year from a depositor and won't allow his
balance t o exceed 41,000, they have begun now t o allow the
limited checking privilege a n d s o forth, a n d the state banking de,ertment h s n o t required t h a n t o m a n g e their reserve.
ahnether t h e y will o r not, I
of i t yet;

don'f know.

T h e r e i s n o talk

b u t that thing having d s v e l o g d

i n such very

old and very conservative institutions a s those, d o e s present pretty good evidence t o m y mind that y o u a r e going t o
have this question arising i n various forms f r o m practically
every state i n the Union.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor iicvougal:

I

f there i s one thing thst t h i s

638
dis cussion clearly discloses, although i t i s unfortunate,
it i s the fact that w e have n o t considered a s a body t h e
questions presented b y the Board, a n d that w e have n o t soniething derinit e¢ to offer.

B u t this conference h a s taken

a different course r r o m previous ¢econrerences, t h a t have h a d
the sdvantage o f preliminsry mseting o f t h e Board, a n d suggestions f r o m t h e m a s t o procedure,

a n d { i have n o doubt, a

s

we approach t h e two reuaining subjects o n t h e Buerd's program, t h a t this will b e again evident.

w h e n w é reached

this part o f the program, t h e topics were locked over c4asually, a n d

i t was thought t h a t probably a

with t h e Board would answer t h e purpose.

brief dis cussion
f

t is cléorly

evident t h a t w e have inade a mistake.
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt: I

think t h e B o a r d e x p e c t e d y o u

to take these subjects u p and come t o us with a recommendstion.
Governor ucDougals

W e were not fortunste enough t o

have h e d a preliminsry t a l k w i t h the Board. I
this b e c a u s e I

see n o w i t was unfortunate

that

speak o f
w e have n o t

gone into this matter a n d possibly other matters.
Governor seay-

N o r did w e hsve t h e subjects bsfore

us very l o n g i n advance.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

639
Governor harding:

I t s e e s t o me that what t h e Board

wants t o kno, i s whether these reserves a r e t o b e reduced

ornot.

T h e Bosrd has the le gal right t o amend its regu-

lations a s i t stands, o r , o r sone regulation c a n b e formu-

lated slong the lines proposed b y Governor Norris, I
jieve i f such regulation w a s promulgated,

be-

i t would b e good

policy, regardless o f the law.
Vice Governor Platt:

i r , C a s e mad= a motion. I

do

not recall just h o w i t was worded.
uP, Case;

m y motion w a s that i t was t h e sense o f this

conierence that the present regulation should stand without
being disturbed,

Governor beay: i

would like t o ask ur. C a s e i f this

discussion h a s a t 3 1 1 m o d i f i e d h i s v i e w s ?

laPe Cases

N o , n o t i n sny way.

A s a matter o f fact,

frou t h e p r a c t i c a l standpoint, u r , C h a i r m a n ,

t h s State o f

Connecticut has a law which does not require any reserve
whatever

i n savings d e p o s i t s t h a t a r e s e g r e g a t e d a n d s p e -

Clally invested. I

think Governor Harding will bear i e

out i n saying this, a s h e has soie banks i n that district,
that there i s n o state i n the Union that I

know o f where

it i s more difficult t o get state member banks inte the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

640
Federal R e s e r v e S y s t e m t h a n i n t h e S t a t e o f Connecticut.

fe have o n l y h a d one o r two withdrawls f r o m t h e federal
Reserves Bank o f New York, s n d what w e have h a d have b e e n
froi: t h e s t a t e o f Connecticut.

d

e h e d t h e Norvalk Prust

Coimpany a s a member, b u t t h e Secretary o f t h e State Banking
Association, connected i i t h that bank, stated thet t h e y
were reluctant t o withdraw, b u t also stated thst t h s y
could n o t stand the gaff.
Governor harding: A
cut d o e s n o t b e l i s v e

certain State senator i n Connecti-

i n t h e Keserve tystsen, a n d

nethins will b e done until h e i s out o f t h e Legislature
because h e controls t h e Connecticut senate.
Vice Governor Platt:

I f you want m e t o put t h i s matter

yote, Z-will d o ik,
Governor i.cvougal:

u r e Chainruan, I

the Governors s p e d
snd u n d e r t a k e

t o forsulate s o m e definite recommenda-

with regard t o this subject.
Vice Governor Pistt: r

thers i s n o objection that

course w i l l b e pursued.

(jinereupon, a t lo'clock p. ,. the Joint Conference
thirty

adjourned until t w o o'clock p ; m., t h e Governors t o meet i n

conference a t 2 o'clock p. m.)


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

(The conference o f
o'clock 0.a%., cursuat t o
The Chairman:

order.

W

G e n t l e m e n t h e conference 7 i l l come t o

e have t i e s p o n s i b i l i t y no” of dealing vrimarily

vith topic No. 1 , subzitted o y the Het R e s e r v e Board,
Reserves against so-called special

i n g s deposits o n

sich a liuited amount of checking is alioved, that being
tae topic snich n a s been discussed j i ;

o i n t conference,

that t h e d i s c u s s i c n
and I

w u l d c a l l for d e f i n i t e r e c o :

to“hat ve may carry back to the Board then t h e y meet vith
us l a t e r t r i s afternoon.
Governor Y o u n g : I
ve Tecouzend
Teguiations

vould l i k e t o make a

motion t h a t

t o t h e Feieral Reserve B o a r d t h a t t h e present
o f the board

i n reference

t o savings accounts

remain a s they are, s i c h will take care o f national banks,
and a clause starting " o r b e added —
something

I nad i n mind putting

i n permitted s p e c i a l S a v i n g s d e p o s i t s u n d e r t h e

California lat, then “ichigan later a n d such other states
asmay h a v e t h e s a m e l a s —~—


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor McDougal:

F i t a regard t

d

e

p

o

s

i

t

s

642
we are considering, California isn't rejuired taat
taey b e
treated a s savings accounts t o the extent that
they a r e
compelled t o segregate certain funds?
Governor Calkins:

T h e y are regarded a s savings a c —

counts, t h e same a s a Savings deposit i n a bank, a n d
aze
su-ject t o tne laws applying t o Savings banks, including
this

the investment o f assess manner $ 2 <-a4 n / vay
b e repaid
and s o forth.

Y o u cannot embarass t h e bank i n California

by demanding repayment o f Special savings deposits,
nor at
any time, b e c a u s e t h e l a w Provides t h a t
t h e bank m a y proceed
in i t s b u s i n e s s a n d p a y d e p o s i t s

o n «sich notice h a s b e e n

Teceived, ‘ n e n i t c a n ,
Mr, Case:

B u t a s a practical matter v e knoy very

well that i f they once started t o give notice o n
these
deposits t h a t tnoere would b e a run o n the o p e n checking
account.
Governor Calkins:

department,

yes, Dut i t is perfectly possible under the law that
the
commercial department o f a bank Zignt b e closed u p
and
the savings department n o t closed ur.
Mr, Case:

T h a t sould make t h e m b e preferred depositors

in t h e institution,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Calkins:

T h e y are preferred

point.
E-sncile= t h i n k toat= s o n lS b r s

Governor Calkin:

assets o f the savings

It v a s s t a t e d

. e @ t h e other d a y

that there wasn't a savings account 3

h e c i t y o f Caicago

that could n o t b e # i t l d r a m r i t n o u

Governor Calzins: T h a t i s pethaps true.
The Chairman: ~

Fou

i k e t o a s k y o u again t h e

question which y o u have
Governor Calkins:' I

tacugnt I

did.

The Chairman: 3 Y a d e r the provisions o f your state
back laws a r e your banks required t o invest their savings
deposits i n a specified kind o f assets?

Governor Calkins:
The Chairman:

Y e s , very rigidly specified,

T h e n your situation i s dentical v i t h

that o f Michigan.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Calkins.
Governor S e a y :

J u s t t h e saue.

T h a t i s the seme situation

i n Conn

ecticut.

Governor Calkéns:
Wr, Case:

T n o s e a r e mutual banks,

T h e y a r e just t h e same; a n y trust

company, t o r instance t h e South Norvalk Trust Company.
The C o a rman:

Y o u will have t o repeat your motion,

Governor Young.
Governor Calkins:

L e t w e s a one taing more.

Tae banking act of tne State c f California, saich has
been neralded a l l over t h e country a s a perfect a c t
is absolutely built arouna t h e protection o f savings
deposits a s a specially considered class t o b e provided
vith s p e c i a l srotection.

Governor iicKinney: T h e r e i s n o suestion o f policy,
or even o f discretion inviived i n the matter,

Governor Calkins:

I t is a question o f 1 «#,

Governor YcKinney: C o n g r e s s ,

i n Section 1 5 o f the

Act, h a s attempted t o define w h a t shall constitute legal
reserves o f banks a n d has n o t empowered t h e Federal Reserve

Board to issue any regulations whatever, a s is the case i n
connection vith other secticns, a d d shat v e Tagadd a s a
regulation i s nothing i n the world b u t a n interpretation.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Calkins:

I t is regulation.

645
Governor McKinney:

I

n that v a y i t seems t o m e i t

is entirely a legal yuestion, a n d when congress put
tais
Provision i n the a c t i t seems t o m e that t h e weaning o f the
words i n that paragraph should b e given t h e general mean~

ing that yords are given i n the general acceptation o f them,
I think i t i s not u p t o u s t o make a n y recommendation t c
the Federal Reserve Board except that t n e l a w b e entorced,

Governor Young: I

think I have a suggestion that

Mill settle this whole matter.

I n Savings accounts regu-—

lations the Board says the term Savings accounts shall
be
held t o i n c l u d e t h o s e a c c o u n t s

of a

bank i n respect

to

Which i t has printed regulations accepted b y the
depositor
at the time t h e a c c o u n t . s
i opened.
A. T h e pass book, certificate o r other siwilar f o r m

or Teceipt must b e brought t e tae bank aenever derosit o r
withdravyal i s made,
B D e p o s i t o r m a y a t a n y time b e required b y the
bank t o give notice o f the intent o f vithdrawal n o t less
than thirty days before #ithdrawal i s made.

Now if I mead this correctly, Mr. Pyatt's opinion,
you d o comply v i t h B but y o u d o not comely with 4A. I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

was

646
6

going t c suggest taat tae sord "and" b e changed t o "or"? —
but no, that i a cot going t o do.
Governor Calkins:
Governor Young:

T s a t i s what t h e l a w says.

B u t that zould l e t t h e bars d o m

for national bankss
The Chairman:

H a v e y o u considered your suggestion,

Governor Young?
Governor Young:

N o , I

have not, Wr. Coairman.

I f

I had t h e suggestion cfifered b y Governor Norrs this usorning
I think I could w o r k i t out. I

will withdray a y resoiu-

tion for t h e moment.
The Chairman:
your p r a c t i c e

w i t h your knovledge o f the lav, a n d

i n t h e bank,

c a n y o u make a

constructive

suggestion, Governor Calkins?
Governor Calkins:

D r . Miller s a y s n o offers have

been made t o S a n Francisco. I

vouid v e r y much prefer t o

have t h e resolution made b y scozebody else, a
#nich I e x p e c t

resolution o n

t o v o t e neo.

The Chairman: P e r h a p s v e could appoint a

committee

of two t o g o t o sork o n it now and v e could g o ahead vith
something else,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr, Case;

I n this report o f counsel, Mr, Chairman,

647

there i s one paragraph t h a t I

did not see, o n page i n snich

he says "The only manner i n shich certain deposits c a n easily
be made subject t o 3 per cent reserve, vithout caanging t a e
terms o n vhich they are received,

i s b y a n amendment t o the

law,"
Governor Calkins:
Mr, Case:

go by.

T h a t i s Yr. "yatt's opinion,

T h a t i s shat t h e Board i s supposed t s

T o a t i s tne opinion o f taeir counsel.

Governor Calkins: A f t e r tasy got their opinion they
asked f o r the opinion o f our counsel a n d h e gave a n ex-

actly contrary opinion.

i i s opinion is that the Board

has n o authority t o caange tae lav, a n d taey are nov divided
on t h a t voint.

Governor McKinney: W r . *yatt is tne las ofticer of
this Board a n d i t seems t o m e the Federal Reserve Board shoulda

begoverned dy sis opinion until it is set aside by some
higher authority.
Governor Calkins:

H i s ofinion n a s n o force m a t e v e r ,

except that h e is advisory t o the Board
Governor Seay: T h e whole juestion here i s one o f
banking policy - -


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I do not s e e that t h e juestion o f

policy enters into it.
Governor S e a y : A

policy ‘ s i c h h a s p e r m i t t e d a

volume o f deposits t o come i n under t h e 3 per cent reserve,
Congress h a s s e t cut here i n the A c t sufiicient Teyuire—
ments a s t o reserve a n d n o attempted legislation o n tne

part o f the Federal Reserve Board cculd contravene that
law.
Governor YcKinney:

A n y regulation o r interpre-

tation b y the Federal Reserve Board thich sould be
out o f
harmony vith this, sould not k e effective.
Governor Seay: I

agree vith that.

The Caairman: G e n t l e m e n ,

v e only nave t e n tHinutes

more vithin waich t o consider this subject.

I

t i s doubt-

ful i f w e c o u l d r e a c h a n y agreezent b a s e d o n
the best judg-

ment o f all represented here, but I think ¥ e snould a t
least
dc one thing a n d that i s g o back t o the Board v i t h some
definite action disposing o f tae subject i n s o far a s v e
are concerned.

T h e Board i s entitled t o that.

Wr. Case: i

will move that i t i s the sense o f the

conference t h a t t h e y report t o the voard that t h e conference
has considered this subject o f Coanges i n the regulations
and

recommends that there b e no change made i n the existing
regu-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

9
lations,

(Tae motion naving been duly seconded vas car-ied b y
a vote o f 7 to +, Governor Harding, o f Boston, absent.)
The Chairman: N o x , l e t u s see i f v e cannot act i n
some way o n topic No. 3, Nex Regulations.
is &

very i m p o r t a n t matter.

O f course that

T n e croposed changes n a v e

been DSefore u s for a day o r two, a n d i t has been reported
by s o m e t h a t i t s o u l d b e i m p o s s i b l e i o r t n e x t o c o n s i d e r

them carefully i n tne length o f time given, a n d that i t
could not have been considered carefully i n the length o f
the time i f all o f t h e time h a d been devoted t o it.
Yr. Case:

I n comment here i t states? " T n e Board

will attempt t o nave a t least a

tentative draft o f the

proposed n e i regulations r e a d y before t n e Governor's con~—
ference s o that i t s a y serve a s a dDasis f o r discussion,"
is n o t t h e a n s v e r t o t h a t t h a t v e h a v e r e c e i v e d a

tentative

5

draft, out u p to the sresent time v e have not had sufficient
opportunity t o really discuss t h e m , a n d that i f i t meets
with the Board's views w e oropose t o take them uote and, i f
the Board “ishes, W e i l l b e glad t o s i t e our views #ita
respect t o them t o the Board,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

(Tm m o t i o n having been duly seconded w a s carried, )

650
Toe Cnoairman:

T h e next topic i s No, 3 , Limitation

on a n Aggregate Amount o f Agricultural P a p e r shich m a y b e
rediscounted b y Federal Reserve Banks.
Mr, Bailey:

M r , Chairman, I

tnink w e #ill have a

prac tical yuestion t o race v i t h regard t o that.

T a x e

tne Minneapolis District a n d t a e Zansas C i t y district a n d
#e ‘ill aave t o take much wore agricuitural paper t h a n
New York C i t y vill have t o take.
Governor Calkins:

M r , Chairman, I

offer a s a motion

to the Federal Reserve Board that n o change b e zade i n the
Beard's limit o f 9 9 per cent o f fuesources f o r agricultural
paper a n d t n a t t n e l i m i t

o n n i n e sonths!

p a p e r b e tized a t

10 per cent o f assets.
Case: I

sill second tnoat motion,

Governor ¥cKinney: I

aave n o doubt if, i n tae »rac—

tical operation o f tris amendtent i t should develop that

10 per cant lizit o u i d not seet the reiuirements o f some
perticular bank) t h a t that bank could sake applicati
extension?

I do not think there i s any .uestion
apout thit a t all, Governer YoKinney.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor ¥eKinn

" 1 t h that understanding I

will

11
be i n favor o f t h e motion.

-(T.e motion, having been duly seconded, was carried.)
The Chairman:

W r . Case suggests t h a t 3

prudence i t might b e a very zg00d taing t o have a

asmatter o f
statement

with regard t o the press, a n d a n y stateuwent that ensues a s
@ Fesult o f this srocesding nere, siould emanate f r o m the
Foard, a 3 i t has been o w practice

i n the past.

offer that a s a uotion, Yr. Chair—

(The m o t i o n H a v i n g b e e n d u l y s a r o n d d d w a s c a r r i e d , )

(Thereupon, a t 4:40 o'clock 2.u. tne conference o f
Governors entered into a

Reserve Board, )


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

joint conference w i t h t a e Federal


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

652
JOINT CONFERENCE O F T H E FEDERAL RESERVE B O A R
WITh T i e
COVERNORS O F THE FELERAL RESERVE BaNnys

(Tae Joint Conference o f the Federal Reserve Board
with t h e Governors o f t h e Federal Reserve Banks reconvensd
at 2:40 o'clock 5..:., o n Thursday, M a r c h oo,
Suant t o adjournment Sirrecess o n the same day.)
Present:

Vice Governor Platt, presiding;
Mr, Hamlin a n d Ur. “Yellion o f tne Federal
Reserve Board;
D. R. Crissinger, Couptroller o f Currency
and e x ofiicio member o f the Board.
Vice Governor Platt: G e n t l e m e n ,
come t o order. 2

t h a t 7 e have a

t h e meeting will
,uorum o f both bodies

here,

Governor WYcDougal:

i

. Chairman, I

have t o report

that since the morning session w e have convened i n session
and have given consideration t o your topic No. 1 , which
sag


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

653
discussed tais morning, a n d also have given some consideratio

to topics Noe. 3 and 3, o f the Board's program, with tais
result:

Topic No. 1 , Reserves against special so-called say—
ings deposits o n “nich a

limited amount o f checking i s

allowed: Voted; That, t h e conference having c o n
Sidered topic No. 1

suggested b y the Federal Reserve

ends t o the Federal Reserve Board that
there b e n o change made i n the existing regulations,
Tae vote w a s act unanimous, Governors Calkins, Norris, Y o u n g

and McDougal voting i n the negative, a n d Governor Harding
untortunately n o t being present.

Governor Harding: I

would have voted i n the negative

if I had been present,
Governor McDougal:

D o I understand y o u vould like

to b e s o recorded now?
Governor Harding:

Y e s , sir,

Governor McDougal:
k

W i t h resvect

t o topic No.

n e w &

regulations, i t *as voted that the conference, naving
re~
ceived t h e t e n t a t i v e d r a f t o f t h e p r o v o s e d n e v r e g u l a t i o n s

does not feel that i t has had sufficient time t o thoroughly
Study a n d d i g e s t t n e s a m e a n d i t i s s u g g e s t e d
that t h e Gover—

654

14

nors b e perzitted t o take t h e m home w i t h them, m a k i n g care~
ful s t u d y o f t h e m a n d r e p o r t t h e i r v i e w s

t o the Board k n

writing.

With respect t o topic No. 3 , limitation o n ageregate
amount o f a g r i c u l t u r a l p a p e r w h i c h m a y b e r e d i s c o u n t e d
Federal R e s e r v e Banks,

Voted:

T a a t v e recomuend

by

t o the

Federal Reserve Board that n o change b e made i n the minimum
of 9 9 per cent o f assets o f the Federal Reserve banks a s
Tespecting s i x x o n t h s paper,

a n d o n nine zonths Paper t h e

@inimum d e f i x e d a t 1 0 p e r c e n t o f assets.

Governor Seay:

R i g h t there I

vould like t o say, i f

I a u not tistaken, t n e a c t confers u p o n the Board t h e power
to limit i t t o t h e assets o f the bank a n d that t h e Board
in r e a l i t y s o m e t i m e s l i m i t s

of the bank,

i t t o 3 8 per c e n t o f t h e capital

i g y o u sill examine i n t o i t I think y o u

Will f i n d t h a t t o b e t a e fact,

Governor Hardang:

T h a t # a s modified a n d changed after—

wards.
Vice G o v e r n o r P l a t t :

T h e original limit s a s 3 2 per

cent o f capital,

Governor Harding:

Y o u are right about that.

T h a t

was five o r s i x years ago, b u t later o n z e found t h e error a n d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

1S
Changed it.
Governor Seay:

W e nave searched diligently, b u t v e

ago not find a subseyjuent correction.

Gogernor Harding:

“ y impression i s it was corrected,

i know i n one o f its reports t o Gonzress t h e Board stated
that i t had fixed t h e limit o f 9 2 per cent o f assets,

Governor Calkins: T h e law says that toe Board zay
by regulation limit the percentage o f assets but i t says
nothing o f capital.
Governor Seay: I

know that i t does not, b u t never—

theless I am calling attention t o what has been done.
Governor Harding: I

think t h a t w a s a t y p e o g r a p h i c a l

error more than anything else.
Vice Governor Platt:

T h a t disposes o f these topics.

Governor McJougal:' A n o t h e r matter h a s been called
to m y attention,

a n d that i s t h e action o f t h e conference

with respect t o the yuestion o f automatic adjustment o f
discount rates a n d unfform rates a n d s o fourth, a n d also

the action o f the conference with regard t o the formulation
of a committee report that was submitted t o the Board yes~
terday, copies o f shich I assume y o u have a n d i n which i t
is suggested tnat probably t h e Board might s e e fit t o make


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

656

16

some statement a l o n g certain linee, a n d asking t h e Board

to give, i f taey can, consiaerable consideration t o making
some footnote,

a s I remember it, i n connection v i t h t h e

published statements i n regard t o tais large surplus o f
gold reserve held b y the sy-ten.
Governor Plantt

Y o u ars veferring t o the Committee o n

Rates o f Discount,
Governor McDouge

T

h

e report t h a t h a s b e e n s u b —

mitted, yes.
Abdcut these regulations, I
like t o s a y a

word, I

a m living n o w i n a

community

vould

in

which t h e people a r e very particular about t h e language
used. I

notice i n reading proposed axendmentsa that a n y

Federal Reserve bank m a y rediscount f o r a n y o f its member

banks -—- I think that ought t o remain a s it stands, that
any Federal R e s e r v e D a n k m a y d i s c o u n t f o r a n y o r i t s m e m b e r
banks,

There is a

count. A

distinction b e t z e e n d i s c o u n t a n d r e d i s -

Federal R e s e r v e b a n k d i s c o u n t s p a p e r f o r b a n k s

Woich i n t u r n r e d i s c o u n t t h e i r p a p e r w i t h t h e F e d e r a l R e serve banks.

Rediscount

msans p a p e r w h i c h a

o n our national b a n k statements

national b a n k h a s d i s c o u n t e d f o r s o m e

other bank o r customez,and i n t u n rediscounts w i t h some
other


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

657
bank o r with the Federal Keserve Bank, a n d a rediscount f o r
the Federal Reserve Bank c f @allas, f o r instance, w o u l d b e
pager Weich i t had discounted f o r some other bank, maxing
a
rediscount o f that operation a s far a s they were concenred,
and then the Dallas bank i n turn rediacounts t h a t v i t n N e w
York, P h i l a d e l o h i a ,

o r B o s t o n ~——

Vice Governor Piatt:

Y o u mean f r o m a Federal Reserve

standpoint t h a t i t ougnt t o b e discount instead o f rediscount?

Governor Harding:

W h e n you talk about a Federal

Reserve b a n k d i s c o u n t i n g p a p e r i t i s n o t a

& primary proposition.

redisounit;

i t is

T h e y discount vaper w i c h has been

in turn discounted b y the member banks, o r the member re—
discounts p a p e r w h i c h t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e b a n k discounts,

Vice Governor Platt: I

notice,

o n the matter o f

nine months paper, that tyo banks have already made dis—
counts o f paper o f a maturity o f sore taoan six months,

The March 4th, 1923 amendwent t o the Federal Reserve
Act increases the maximuz maturity o f agricultural and live—
Stock paper acceptable t o r discount o y Federal Reserve
banks f r o m s i x t o n i n e months.

U n d e r t n e provisions

of

this amendment the Federal Reserve banks o f Atlanta and

San Francisco have estavlished discount rates of 44 per cent


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

658
cn agricultvral a n d livestock paper maturing betyeen s i x
and nine months, e n d hzeve discounted small amounts o f

such paper, t h e amount held o n Marca 26th being #15,300.
I suppose w e vill have t o make a

change i n cur

statement a f bills matured a n d discounted t o include this,
Governor S e a y :
the v i e w p o i n t

T a a t i s e n t i r e l y i n order, f r o m

o f t h e Board,

Vice Governor Platt:

Yes, I

do not know what

the legal aspect would be, b u t I do not s e e under pres—
ent conditions w h y a n y separate rate need b e made, unless
you expect

t o m a k e i t d i f f e r e n t -—~- p e r s o n a l l y I

tight j u s t a s w e l l b e o n e ~ h a l f

think i t

t o o n e p e r c e n t higher,

but that i s a matter o f debate, I

supose.

Governor Bailey: W o u l d n ' t w e d o that automatically —
Vice Governor Platt:

M y o m opinion vould b e that

you could d o i t automatically.
Governor Bailey: I

Vice G o v e r n o r Platt:

Governor McKinney:

s s e t h a t somes b a n k s n a v e a s k e d f o r

T w b a n k s h a v e asked f o r it.

W e felt that inasmuch a s the

Act says, "Subject t o rules a n d regulations o f the Federal
Reserve B o a r d * " —

t h a t t h a t a m e n d m e n t cGid n o t b e c o m e o p e r a —


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

13

6

5

9

tive until the rules and regulations o f the Board had been
promulgated,
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt: I

think y o u m&kght v e r y w e l l

take that point o f w s .

T r e Federal Reserve Board ought

to m a k e s o m e r e g u l a t i o n s

o r s a y t h a t i t i s n o t g o i n g to.

W e have declined t e give con-

Governor McKinney:

sideration t o nine months paper i n Dalls u p t o this time,
awaiting t h e r u l e s a n d r e g u l a t i o n s
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt: I

t o b e adopted.

think y o u a r e e n t i r e l y

justified i n taking that point o f view, but I do not see

guite why your present rates vont apply —- your resolution
Treads 4 s per cent rate f o r a l i maturities o f paper.

W

Boycadbesdnite 7 :

e applied for a n increased

rate o n the premise t h a t t h e maturities should n o t g o
beyond s i x months,

a n d t h e n w e have a

Governor Seay:

n e @ maturity.

D o you make a new rate?

Mir. Adleson: Yes, 43 per cent, the same Tate.
Governor Harding: I

sould think it sould be in

order for the Board t o issue a regulation i n which they
should either s a y that t h e FederdReserve Banks m a y dis—
ceunt n i n e m o n t h s p a p e r

o n the same basis

a s 4 5 their

other rates, or, i f the Board wants t o reserve the Trigat

20

660

to establish a special #ate, s a y s o i n the Tegulations a n d
that r a t e s w i l l b e a p p r o v e d

Vice Governor Platt:
maturities m e n t i o n e d

o n application,

S e m e o f the banks have specific

i n t h e i r resolutions.

Governoz Harding: I

think t h e safest tnoing for t h e

Board t o d o would b e t o issue a

Tegulation o n the subject

and s a y that t h e Federal Reserve banks a r e reyuested
to
submit their rates f o r s u c h paper, f o r
r o v i o v and dotern
mination c f the Board, a n d then y o u c a n either
approve t h e
Same r a t e f o r t h e s i x stionths p a p e r o r h a v e a

rate y o u m a y

cnoose,
Vice Governor Platt: I
expecting a

understand Mr. Gilbert i s

general discussion o f credit policies,

D

o we

understand that t h e Governors a r e a l l tarough t i t h
their

discussions regarding their program?

M r . Gilbert with-

drew this morning because h e was not particularly interested
in what w a s being discussed then,
talk about I

J u s t what h e w a n t s ‘
t
o

do not know.

Governor McKinney:

W o u l d t h e Board b e disposed

to

give a n expression o f its views with regard t o tais nine
months paper, that is, vith reference t o the rate which
Should b e fixed o n it, and whether w e shall avait
the issu-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

31

661

ancsé o f new rules a n d regulations. I

have a

request f r o m

toe Dallas bank about it,
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt:

T h e Board h a s already approved

the rate proposition, a n d i n the absence o f regulations
that vould stand,
Governor VcDougal:

W e have naturally considered

this informally, a t least, i n the Cuicago bank and w e
conCluded that w e have established a

rate f o r a l l times

and all maturities, a n d i f that paper beyond s i x months
Were offered t o u s that v e vould b e i n position
t o ac—

Cept it.

I f w e are wrong I would like t o know it.

seems t o m e i t works automatically.

I t

T h e r e i s only o n e

wuestion that remains, a n d that i s the limitation o f the
amount o f paper that w e m a y b e permitted
t o take.

Governor Harding: '

W e aaven't had any paper offered

vo u s i n Boston y e t o f naturities o f that length,
but i f
we did have i t offered o u r Position would b e that
we

couldn't take it, Pending promulgation o f rules and reguiations from the Board.

I f w e believed tha® s e snould take

it, w e would o f course take i t a t the same rate.

T h e law

says that this paper may be taken i n certain Rercentage
to
Proportion o f assets o f the banks that m a y b e fixed b y


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

662

3

the Federal Reserve Board, a n d i t i s conceivable t h a t
the Board might f i x i t a t one fiftxyeth o f one p e r cent,
or sometning like that.
Vice Governor Platt: I
certainly make a

regulation o f some kind o f that.

Governor Calkins:
for a p p r o v a l

of a

think t h e Board should

W e assumes t h a t v h e n v e a s k

rate a n d t h e B o a r d a p p r o v e s t h e rate,

that that permits u s t o accept t h e paper.
Vice Governor Platt:

I

t i s cnvered i n the

proposed regulations o f which y o u have copies, b u t i t
hasn't been adopted yet.

Governor Harding:

C o u l d not that regulation

pe used without waiting f o r t h e general revision, t h a t

is, covering just tnat particular matter?
Vios Governor Platt: I
Governor Harding:

I

think so, yes.

n viev o f the fact that t h e

banks take a different view of it.
Gice Governor Platt: Undoubtedly.

T h e Board vill

take that matter u p at the next meeting. I

understand

from Mr. Hamlin that Mr. Gilbert does n o t care t o s y


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

anything t o the Board.
Mr, Hamlin:

H e says t h a t i f there a r e a n y jueries


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

663
or juestions that h e wili b e glad t o answer them, b u t
that othervise h e will not come in.
Vice Governor Platt:

N o w , gentlemen, have t h e

Governors anything further t o suow#it?
Governcr McDougal:
were t o have a

N o , but I assumed that w e

discussion w i t n respect t o the general

credit s i t u a t i o n a n d s a t e policy;

mich that w e #ill have s u c h a

a t least I

hope v e r y

discussion w i t h the Board

of ocmedit conditions a s they aze a n d other pcints bear—
ing upon tne matter,
Governor Platt: I

nave n o t bsen tere f o r t h e

last f e w days and’ I do not know shat y o u have already
discuesed o r what y o u have n o t discussed.

Governor UoDovgal:

W e have not been i n conference

with the Board atall,

What do you think about it, Mr. Case, d o you think
we should have a

Mr, Case:
here a r e a

general discusdaon?

i t seems t o me, Mr. Chairman, that

group o f G o v e r n o r s f v o m a l l o v e r t h e c o u n t r y

who only g e t d o m here twice a

year a n d i t seems t o m e

it would be very helpful d o d o it, a n d personally I
Pa

ghould feel very badly to go back without having some


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

664

a4

expression o f opinion v i t h regard t o t h e present credit
condition,
Vice Governor Platt:

I t w u l d s e e m t o m e that F e

ought t o h a v e s o m e dincuission o f c r e d i t policies.

Governor McDougal: I

feel that i t i s the most

important m a t t e r t h a t c o n f r o n t s t n e s y s t e m a t t h e p r e s e n t

time, that is, t h e credit situation, a n d I

a m sure that

we vould b e very glad t o have a n y yzord that v e c a n from

the Boara itself, a n d I am also confident that those
who are here would be very glad t o state the conditions
as t h e y e x i s t w i t h r e s o e c t

t o their

o w districts a n d

any views t h e y might have < i t h regard t o the general situation,

Vice Governor Platt: I

suppose # e aad better start

the discussion o n this general resolution “ i t h regard t o
the o p e n m a r k e t policy.

Y o u have a l l s e e n t h i s o p e n m a r —

ket policy reaolution which t h e Board adopted, a n d 7hich
is a s follows:

"Whereas the Federal Reserve Board, under the powers
given i t i n Sections 1 3 and l s of the Federal Reserve Act,
has autaority t o limit a n d other tise determine t h e securities a n d i n v e s t m e n t s p u r c h a s e d

b y Federal v e s e r v e b a n k s :


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

"Whereas t h e Federal Reserve Board has never
prescribed a n y l i m i t a t i o n u p o n o p e n m a r k e t p u r c h a s e s

by

Federal reserve banks;

"hereas the atount, time, character, a n d manner o f
such Purchases m a y exercise a n ixportant influence u p o n
the money market};
""hereas a n onen market investment volicy f o r t h e

twelve banks composing the Federal reserve system i s
necessaty

i n tne interest

o f t h e maintenance

of a

good

relationship b e t w e e n t h e d i s c o u n t a n d p u r c h a s e o p e r a t i o n s

of the Federal reserve banks and the general money mar—

t3
"Whereas heavy investments i n United States securi-

ties, particularly short-dated certificate issues, have
occasioned embarassnuent *

t n e Treasury i n ascertaining

the true condition o f the money a n d investment markets f r o m
time t o time,

"Tnerefore,

B e i t Revolved, T h a t t h e Federal Reserve

Board, i n the exercise o f its posers under the Federal
Reserve Act, l a y d o m a n d adopt t h e following orinciples
vith r e s p e c t

t o o p e n market investment operations

Federal reserve banks, to-wit:

o f the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

"(1) T a a t the time, manner, character, and
Federal
volume o f open market investments purchased b y
t o the
reserve banks b e governed W i t h primary regard
t o the ertirect
accommodation o f commerce a n d business a n d
situaof such purchases o r saies o n the general credit
tion.

"(2) T h a t in making the selection of open market
bearing
purchases, careful regard b e always given t o the
of Mmited States Government securities, e s f o r such
pecially t i e snort-dated issvuss, u p o n s h e market
securities,

a n d that o p e n mariet purchases

b e primarily

certificates
coumercial investments, e x c e p t that Treasury
ry

'
be dealt in, a s a t present, under 30-called ‘repurchase!

agreement.
tBe i t F u r t h e r Resolved,

T h a t o n a n d after April 1 ,

33, the present Comittee o f Governors o n Centralized
Securities
Execution o f Purchases a n d Sales o f Governuent
committees
be discontinued, a n d b e superseded b y a new
for tne
known a s the Open Market Investment Committee

of
Federal Reserve System, said Comsittee t o consist
five r e p r e s e n t a t i v e s

f r o t h e regerve banks a n i t o b e

Reserve Board;
under t h e general supervision o f the Federal

s
and that i t b e the duty o f this Committse t o devise a n d
recommend plans f o r t a e purchase, s a l e a n d distribution o f
the open market purchases o f t h e Federal ponnees banks i n
accordance j i t h t h e a b o v e p r i n c i p l e s a n d s u c h r e g u l a t i o n s
as c a y f r o m t i m e t o t i m e b e l a i d d o m

o y t h e Federal R e -

serve Board,"
"Note:

T h e Board h a s cetermined that Government

securities o f short maturities should b e liquidated first,
and Wishes t h e opinion o f t n e Confernes o f Governors a s t o
ho? this m a y best b e done without disturbence t o the mar—
ket.®

Governor Harding:

i

leagues o f the conference I

f i t is agreeable t o m y col-—
yould like t o discuss t n i s

matter,

Vice Governor Platt:
C o m i n g from
y
o the Tirst district, y o u ate the proper person t o begin it, Governor
Harding.

Governor Harding: I

think that all of the Federal

Reserve banks a n d toeir Governors s h o a r e hire assembled,
are i n s y m p a t o y w i t h t h e g e n e r a l p u r p o s e s

tion o f the Board i n the preeent junctute:


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

o f tuis resolu-

668
"Whereas a e a v y i n v e s t m e n t s

i n United States

securities, particularly short—dated certificate issues,
have occasionad embarassment t o the Treasury i n ascertaining t h e true condition o f the money a n d investment
markets f r o m t i m e t o time,"

But a

condition aight arise i n future years where

that wight n o t b e a consideration.
diftidence t h a t I

I

t i s vith some

discuss t h e »roposition because I

am

obliged t o discuss i t from tne legal standpoint; that i s
I a m not going t o t r y t o discuss i t from the general l e g a l
standpoint, b u t simeliy from reading the Federal Reserve
Act, a n d pointing o u t certain features o f it.
I think t h i s i s fundamental;

i t involves t n e rela-—

tionship o f tas Federal Reserve Board t o the Federal R e —

serve banks, t h e relationsnip o f tae Federal Reserve basaks
to the Treasury a n d the relationship betteen t h e Treasury
and the Federal Reserve Board itself.
Board i s n o t & @ bureau

T a e Federal Reserve

o f thse T r e a s u r y Department.

I t is

an independent body, o f thich the Secretary o f the Treasury
is a member,

a n exofficio chairman, h a v i n g only one vote.

That yuestion has been threshed o u t tnaoroughiy a n d nobody
contradicts that.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

669

The d i r e c t r e l a t i o n s h i p b e t w e e n t h e T r e a s u r y a n d

the Federal Reserve banks i s defined i n the section o n

fiscal agency operations.

N o w , the sympathy that ex-

ists between t h e Federal Reserve banks a n d the Treasury

at the present time, vith regard t o tne condition o f the
money and investment market, arises from the fact that
for the past three years the Treasury has endeavored t o
sell its freyuent issues o f certificates n o t upon a n y

arbitrary basis, “ith artificial rates o n the part of
the Federal Reserve banks,

a s was necessary during t h e

war, b u t t h e Treasury has attempted t o devalop t h e policy
of selling certificates u p o n the actual market basis, l e a v —

ing the Federal Reserve banks and the Board free to estab-—
lish d i s c o u n t r a t e s a s t h e l a w i n t e n d e d t h e y s h o u l d b e es~—

tablished, according to the general money conditions, and
vith a view of accommodating commerce a n d finance.

o

f

course that means a vay sympathetic cooperation, but
the point I want t o bring out i s that nowhere i n the Federal Reserve A c t i s any consideration given t o the Treasury's
view o f the money market o r tocthe necessity o f Federal
Reserve banks buying o r abs&aining f r o m buying Treasury
certificates

o r Government b o n d s m e r e l y because s o m e officer

6'70
30
of the Treasury might f i n d i t objectionable f r o m nis point
of view,

Now, there i s no disagreement between the present
policy o f t h e T r e a s u r y a n d t n e p r e s e n t p o l i c y o f t h e F e d e r —

al Reserve banks, b u t such a
think v e w o u l d a l l r e g r e t

thing i s a precedent,and I

t o s e e a n y d e c l a r a t i o n o f prin-—

ciples l a i d d o w t h a t m i g h t b e b i n d i n g

i n future y e a r s

with a totally different s e t o f circumstances. I

do not

think there i s a n y Gisposition n o t t o cooperate w i t h t h e
wish o f the Treasury i n this matter; b u t this matter o f

credit policy, s o far a s the Federal Reserve Act i s concerned,

i s a responsibility which i s fastened u p o n the

Federal R e s e r v e B o a r d a n d n o t u p o n t n e Treasury.

T h e r e

isn't anything i n the Federal Reserve Act thaktsohdAlds the
Treasury o f the United States responsi»le f o r such a
tion.

condi-

I n all the discussions f o r t h e last t w o o r three

years there has been n o blame attached t o the Treasury;

the Federal Reserve Board nas been the target. I

tnaink

from that standpoint the Federal Reserve banks and the

Federal Reserve Board have a common viewpoint.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Now, t h e other matter relates t o the dealings between

31

671

the Federal Reserve banks a n d the Federal Reserve Board.
it i s rather a

delicate matter, b u t I think t h e o n l y way

to d o i s t o speak o f i t openly a n d frankly.

T h e r e are

tvelve autonomous banks, chartered b y the United States
Government; certain powers a r e delegated t o the directors

and through

t h e directors t o the officers o f these

banks, binder t h e provisions o f Section 4 , o f the Federal

Reserve Act, the Federal Reserve Board has general super-—
visory Dower.

I am not going t o discuss this i n a dogmatic way,
but I am sure that t o a man who i s learned i n the lay the
‘Point I shall submit i s a t least a

controversial point, a

point o n whica argument a n d question a t least might
arise i f the Board should bind itself hard and fast b y a

declaration of tnis as a fixed policy, a principle upon
waicn policies would b e based, which might, i n the last
analysis, a t some future time, lead t o judicial determination o f the whole question, which would b e vezy un~
fortunate.
Tais reads:
"Whereas t h e Federal Reserve Board, under t h e vowers

given i t i n Sections 1 3 and 1 4 of the Federal Reserve Act,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

33
672
has autaority t o limit a n d othervise determine t h e
securities a n d investments purchased b y Federal reserve

banks,"
Take t h e first, a n d opening paragraph o f section
1l# of the Federal Reserve Act, ‘wWaich i s very plain a n d
which reads} “ A n y Federal Reserve b a n k may, under rules
ed

and Tegulations p>oscrib/by the Federal Reserve Board,
Purchase a n d sell i n the open market,
either f r o m o r

a t home o r abroad,

t o d o m e s t i c o r foreign banks, firms,

corvorations, o r individuals, s.#abie transfers and bankers!
; a n d :
acceptances and bills o f excnanges o f the kinds
uaturities b y this a c t made eligible f o r rediscount, w i t h o r

without the indorsement o f a member bank,*
Nowz, i t does not qualify that b y saying ""henever i n
the opinion o f the Secretary o f the Treasury i t i s desir-—
adie t o d o so; "

it gives t h e a blanket power t o d o it.

These open market operations, I

take it, were nut “in the

Act, partly for the reason that, a s this was a reserve
system, a n d that i t vas not desirable t o encourage a member
bank t o expand s o a s t o b e constantly r e d i s c o u n t i n g , t
a
Federal Reserve banks, s o m e crovision should b e made b y

which these banks could pay tacir expenses and a 6 per


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

33

6

7

cent dividend t o the stockholding banks.

5

O n e method

provided i s t o e n a b l e t h e m t o b u y b o n d s a n d n o t e s o f t h e
M i t e d States,

I

t i s definite,

i t does n o t s a y with

the consent o f the Federal Reserve Board o r with t h e
sonsent o f the Secretary o f the Treasury a t all, b u t i s
an independent power,

T h e Board h a s t h e right t o pre—

scribe rules and regulations under muich they may purchase
and sell i n the open market bills o f exchange, domestic
transfers, c a b l e transfers a n d s o forth, b u t look a t the

language — “Every Federal Reserve bank shall have power"
to buy these notes a n d s o forth, s u c h purchases t o b e made

in accordance with the rules and regulations prescribed
by the Federal Reserve Board.
Now t h e g u e s t i o n i s h a s t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B o a r d

the desire o r the power, i f it had the desire, t o pre-

scribe rules and regulations which would prevent the
Federal Reserve banks from doing the very thing that Congress explicitly says t h e y c a n do.

‘ A l l rules a n d reguand

lations must b e reasonable rules and regulations/made i n

conformity with the provisions of this Act.”
I call your attention t o the paragraph under Section

13 of the Federal Reserve Act, wnich might throw some light


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

674
upon t h e intent o f Congress i n delegating t o the Federal
Reserve Board t h e right t o make rules a n d regulations.
Paragraph

t o which I

wish t o call y o u r attention

"Upon t h e i n d o r s e m e n t

which shall b e deemed a

T h e

i s tais:

o f a n y o f i t s member banks,

waiver o f demand, notice a n d vro-

test b y such banksasrtozits

o w indorsement exclusively,

any Federal Reserve b a n k m a y discount notes, drafts
and

bills o f exchmge arising out o f actual commercial
trans—
actions; t h a t is, notes, drarts, a n d bills o f
excnange
issued o r d r a m f o r agricultural, industrial,
cial purposes,

o r commer-—

o r tne proceeds o f waich aave been used,

or are t o d e used, f o r s u c h purposes, t h e Federal
Reserve
Board t o have t h e right t o deter: ine o r define t h e
char—

acter o f the paper thus eligible for discount, i t h i n
the meaning o f this act."
I take i t a n y r e g u l a t i o n w a d e b y t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e

Board must conform t o the l a w a s given t o t h e Board,
Boamd has n o legislative powers o f itself;

T h e

i t has n o power,

no matter n o w much i t m a y deem i t adivisabdle, t o change
any

of these provisions, o r to put anything new in tne Act.
They can only define and regulate i n accordance with the
provsions

o f t h e Act,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

675

Now, coming back t o this proposition, w e will refer
again t o Section 13.

I n section =

language a t the

bottom c f page 3 9 and t h e t o p o f page 3 0 is:
"The discount a n d rediscount a n d the vurchase a n d
sale b y any Federal Reserve b a n k o f a n y bills receivable
and o f domestic a n d foreign bills o f exchange, a n d o f
acceptances autnorized b y this Act, should b e subject t o

such restrictions, limitations, a n d regulations a s may be
imposed b y the Federal Reserve Board,"
It does n o t s a y that t h e purchase o f United States

bonds andnotes shall be subject t o any restrictions o r
limitations b y the Board.

I

t says "The discount a n d

Tediscount a n d the purchase a n d sale b y a n y Federal Reserve
bank o f a n y b i l i s r e c e i v a b l e a n d o f d o m e s t i c a n d f o r e i g n

bills o f exchange, a n d o t acceptances authorized b y this
Act, shall b e subject t o such restrictions, limitations
and regulations a s may b e imposed b y the Federal Reserve
Board, "

There isn't a particle o f right, i f you will read
this A c t literally, g i v e n t o the Board t o impose b y Tegulation a n y limit, unless y o u under t h e general laws o f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

=

676

supervision, t h a t s a y b e nut upon t h e right o f the bank
ag given i n paragraph B

o f Section 1 4 t o b u y notes a n d bonds

of the Mnited States,
Now, I

g o further a n d advance t h e opinion that,

even wita respect t o domestic a n d foreign bills o f exchange, ™ h i c h i s subject t o certain limitations,

o r the

purchase o f thich i s subject t o certain limitations a n d
regulations a s m a y b e imposed b y the Board, t h a t that
means rpasosadle a n d regulatory restrictions a n d not vrohibitions.

I f y o u have t h e right t o f i x t h e amount a n d

to say t o one bank, n o matter t h a t their r e s e r v e position
is, o r woat f r o m the standpoint o f sound benicing policy
thercondition m a y be, w e d o not tnink y o u snould purchase
more t h a n a million dollars o f such paper,
the p l a i n p r o v i s i o n o f S e c t i o n 4

i n spite o f

that t h e d i r e c t o r s

o f these

banks have powers ordinarily granted t o other bank directors,
the power t o make contracts, t h e power t o d o a banking busi~
ness ~ - i f y o u h a v e t h e p o w e r

t o limit i t t o a

million o r

two million o r five hundred taousand, y o u have t h e rignt t o
limit i t t o a dollar,

o r some other nominal amount, w h i c h

would mean a prohibition.
I want t o call your attention t o another part o f Section


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

37
ory

not

13, Which was/enacted originally, shich was an aftertaought
and came i n a s a n amendment t o the Federal Reserve A c t o n

September 27> 1916, i f I remember correctly =

i t was either

September 7, 1916 o r June 31, 1917; I think i t was September
7, 1916 ~ - and that i s the acceptance b y member banks o f

drafts and bills o f excaange d r a m under the regulations t o
be prescribed b y the Federal Reserve Board b y banks o r
bankers

i n iorsign countries

o r dependencies

o r insutar

Possesions o f the United States, for the purpose o f furnish—
ing dollar exncnage,

a s reuired

b y t h e desires

o f trade i n

the respective countries, dependencies a n d insuraar poss—
essions,.

T a e r e i s a limit imposed b y the l a v a s t o t h e

amount that a n y one member bank m a y accept under t h e provisions o f tnis paragraph.

Tae Board vas anxioua, as that sas nei business, t o
have a n undoudted control over a l l thdése transactions, I
am familiar v i t h the aistory o f tris a:endment. I
conference w h e n i t w a s d r a m . I

sas i n

Was o n e o r t h e m e m b e r s

£ tne Board ‘nich appeared before the House Committee o n
Banking and Currency when the amendment was discussed.
order t h a t t h e B o a r d m i g h t h a v e u n d o u b t e d r i g h t

trol t h i s prpposition a

I n

t o con~

definite limit: w a s fixed n o t only


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

678
upon t h e t r a n s a c t i o n s n i c h m i g n t d e m a d e b y
a n y o n e member

Dank, b u t t h e Board v a s given t h e power t o fix
the amount
of s u c h b i l l s

bank.

o r d r a f t s t h a t m i got b e a c y u i r e d

o y the

*,
N o v v a s thought
a t tne time that the language

at the t o p o f the page "Such Testrictions, lizitations
and regulations a s c a y b e i-posed o y the Federal
Reserve
Board" d i d not mean that pover F a s i n tais amendment
re—
lating t o dollar exchange draits.

T h e language i s tais:

"Such drafts o r bills m a y d e acyuired b y Federal
Peserve

banks i n such amounts and sudject t o sucn regulations,
restrictions

a n d limitations,

the Federal Reserve Board."

a s m a y b e prescribed

by

T h e vords "restrictions,

Tegulations a n d limittationg" being Tepeated, b u t a n
addition " i n s u c h amounts" b e i n g p u t i n
there, w h i c h a m o u n t s

evidently t o a n admission o n the vart o f Congress
that i t
did not intend t o give t n e Board definite rover t o limit
the a m o u n t s

i n the other transactions.

Bui the m a i n p o i n t I

vant t o bring o u t v i t h respect

to

Government s e c u r i t y i s t h a t t h e r e i s n o a u t h o r i t y
given the

Board a t all, unless y o u take refuge i n tne oroad s-pervisory
power, t o limit the amount o f Government bonds and notes
that
the d i r e c t o r s

o f t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e b a n k i n their d i s c r e t i o n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

$9

may purchase,

Now the supervisory powers o f t h e Comptroller
of
the Currency a r e very breac, b u t h e has n o
pover wnoatever
to s a y t o tne directors o f a national b a n k
that t h e y canno+
do t h o s e t h i n g s w h i c h t h e l a w S p e c i f i c a l l y
says they can

do.

I f the directors o f a bank think that a note
i s zood

they c a n discount Paper t o t h e @xtent o f 1 0 per
cent o f

its capital and surplus, f o r any one person, f i r m o r

Sorporation. T h e supervisory power of the Comptroller of
the Currency relates t o violations a n d t o excess
o f that
Power.

i f they g o beyond that, unéar h i s powers o f super—

vision, h e c a n cali t h e r d o m f o r it; b u t n e
has n o power
under h i s supervisory power t o s a y " I d o not
think Congress
wise i n this a n d I do not w a n t y o u t o take
over 5

per cent."

I think that sould be going beyond bis
power.
I want t o stress tzo points.

I t i s very doubtful,

atleast in ay mind, whether the Bedm®al Reserve Board has
specific p o w e r t o f i x a

definite l i m i t a s t o t a e a m o u n t o f

these legitimate o p e n market trangactions t h a t
a
Reserve dank m a y engage in.

Federal

T h e y nave t h e right t o

regulate it, but nowhere i n this act i s the Treasury
Department o f the United States charged with that
Tesponsi-~


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

40

6

8

0

bility f o r t h e credit policy o f tne Federal Reserve
bank; n o w h e r e

i n the Act i s the Treasury vested with t h e

power t o limit arbitrarily t h e purchases b y Federal Banks
of notes a n d bonds o f the United States, a n d nowhere i s
the Federal Reserve Board given specific power t o limit
the amount o f bonds a n d notes o f the United States t h a t
the b o a r d o f d i r e c t o r s

o f t h e Federal Reserve banks m a y

Wish t o buy.

I stated, Mr. Gilbert, before y o u came in, that
the G o v e r n o r s

o f t h e R e g e r v e b a n k s w e r e i n entire

sym

pathy with your general policies, that they apprettated
the attitude o f the Treasury i n tne last three years o f
regulating your affairs s o that instead o f asking t h e
Federal Reserve banksand t h e Board f o r a n arbitrary rate
to enable t h e Treasury t o float i t s certificates a n d other

obligations, that you had floated them o n the market a t
market rates.

W e desire t o cooperate v i t o you.

looking ahead t o the future;

W e are

w e are n o t reflecting u p o n

this administration o f the Treasury, f o r ‘zich w e have
the a i g h e s t a d m i r a t i o n ;

but it is a

very d a n g e r o u s t h i n g

to l a y d o w n a n u n s o u n d p r e d i c a t e f o r t h e future;

i t is

ccnceivable t n e r e m a y b e t o t a l l y d i f f e r e n t c o n d i t i o n s ,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

41

681

different public considerations, e n t i r e l y different methods
existing, a n d t o have a n official o f the Treasury o r o f

the Board say that you cannot d o what the law says i n plain
terms you can do, and does not limit anywhere, would i n our
opinion be a very dangerous attitude t o take.
My suggestion would be, therefore, t h a t i n any public

expression o f the Board o n this subject that these two first
paragraphe b e eliminated;

"Whereas the Federal Reserve Board, under the powers
given i t i n Sections 1 3 a n d 1 4 o f the Federal Reserve Act,
has a u t h o r i t y t o l i m i t a n d o t h e r v i s e d e t e r m i n e t h e s e c u r i ties a n d i n v e s t m e n t s v u r c h a s e d

b y Federal reserve banks:

"Whereas t h e Federal Reserve Board h a y never vre~
scribed a n y limitation u p o n o p e n market purchases b y
Federal reserve biunks,*
Just éliminate those andstate t h e fact:

whereas, t h e amount, time, character, d

manner o f such

purchases w a y exetcise a n important influence u p o n the

money market; a n d whereas a n open market investment
policy f o r t h e twelve banks composing t h e Fsderal reserve
system i s necessary i n the interest o f the maintenance
of a good relationship betzeen t h e discovnt a n d purchase


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

42

682

pparations o f the Federal reserve banks and the general
money market" etc., t h e n put i n the resolution:

"Therefore, b e it resolved, That the Federal Reserve
Board" - - J I would suggest tae elimination o f the clause
"in the exercise o f its powers under t h e Federal Reserve

Aot™" -—- and g o o n " lay down and adopt the following prin—
ciples w i t h respect t o open market investment operations

of the Federal reserve banks,"

I f the Board has the

powers, there i s no use referring t o them.

I f i t has

not t h e power i t i s obvious that those powers should n o t

be referred t o and tfould suggost that you simply say:

"Therefore, b e it resolved, That the Federal Reserve
Board, l a y down a n d adopt t h e following principles w i t h
Tespect t o open market investment operations o f the

Federal reserve banks, to-wit:"
In that w a y y o u will d o exactly what y o u want t o d o

and you do not run the risk o f laying d o m a precedent

here which may possibly be unsound i n law and which very
possibly might involve litigation i n the future, becuase
it i s conceivable t h a t i f this were a

definite ruling o f

683

the Board the time might come when the directors
o f some
bank wiyid s a y " W e have passed s o many dividends
that the

stockholdéng banks are dissatisfied a n d are tareatening
to
withdraw, w e have this power under the law and
w e direot
the officers o f this bank t o purchase s o many
Treasury
Certificates a n d bonds o r notes o f the United
States," a n d
then the auestion o f vower vould have t o b e threshed
cut
se Court. I

a m not s p e a k i n g r
o
f all the Governors here;

they a r e h e r e f o r themselves,

t n e y have a l l heard “ h a t I

have had t o say o n the subject. I

think that shat the

Board i s intending t o do o n the auestion o f policy
is
acceptable, b u t what they d o object to, that I
wuld object
to and object t o just a s strongly i f I
vere a member o f
the Board, i s the dangerous assumption o f
a doubtful Power,
because your counsel cannot s & o w m e anywhere
i n the A c t
any limitation prescribed o y the A c t o n the amount o f
Governmmntt notes a n d bonds t h a t m a y b e purchased
b y Fed~
eral Reserve banks.

T h e r e a r e Specitic limitations imposed

on other things, a n d the very fact that specific limitations
are i m p o s e d o n c e r t a i n t r a n s a c t i o n s ,

a n d not imposed

on

others, m a k e i t all the more evident that i t was
not t h e
intent o f Congress t o impose limitations ‘waich are not


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

44
prescribed,

Mr, Case:

W r , Chairman, I

have listenad with a

great deal o f interest t o what Governor Harding h a s s a i d o n
this subject a n d I find myself i n syzpatay v i t h t h e terms
of the proposal. I

think i f this suggestion w a s amended,

to a m t h d t h e t w o f i r s t p a t a g r p p n s ,

has suggested, a n d t o make a
that i t w o u l d b e a

a s Governor H a r d i n g

Change i n the resolution,

very h e l p f u l t z i n g f o r a l l o f t n e b a n k s

to have.
The suggestion o f a

caange i n tae Committee o f

nors i s a z~atter that n a s not been discussed a t all.

like other subjects that vere t o come u r when
the Board,

h a s n o t b e e n discussed

b y t n e conference,

do not k n o w s o w m y associates feel w i t h respect t o it, e u t
in general,

s o far a s I a m concerned, I

a m i n Sy:.pathy vith

the general terms o f this memorandum,
Vice Governor Platt:

I

n sympathy with t h e general

terms o f i t i n the statement o f policy?
Mr. C a s e :

Y e s .

Vice Governor Platt: W o u l d y o u care t o have anytning
to s y about vyhether t h e c o m m i t t e e s n o u l d h a v e c o n t r o l o v e r


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

685
all open market purchases o r only the purchases o f Government
securities?
Mr. Case:

M r . Chairman, I

can only s a y tais.

S o far

as I know the present committee o n the Centralization a n d

Execution o f Purchases and Sales o f Government Securities,
has vorked very smoothly a n d very satisfactorily s o far a s
the Treasury a n d the Federal Reserve Board a n d t h e banks
aombined a r e concerned. I
it.

O n the other nand, I

comments about it.

have n o t heard a n y criticiam o f
nave heard a

nuuber o f favorable

I t should a o t b e lost sight o f that

when that committee w a s appointed i t was desired t o bring
about @

gradual reduction i n the noldings, t h e ratner large

holdings o f Government securities i n Federal Reserve banks,

So far a s New York i s concemed,

i t i s underatood that the

Treasury didnot look with, favor upon t h e bank holding

so large a n amount and we, i n common vith all the other
Federal Reserve banks, have worked towards a gradual reduction
of our holdings, s o that today w e have disposed o f all of our
government securities w i t h the exception o f t e n million
dollars o f Treasury notes, w h i c h w e acyuired some months

ago i n exchange for Victory notes which were turned i n at
that time.

M

y recollection i s i t was last September.

When


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

686
the committee w a s appointed last W a y there waze Govern-

ment investments i n the Federal Reserve banks aggregating
roughly five hundred a n d sixty o r five hundred a n d seventy
million doliars.

A

t t o e present time, a f t e r deducting

the June 15th certificate, w a i c a I think n a s just b e e n
taken up, I

toink t h e total holdings a r e n o v approximately

two h u n d r e d a n d t h i r t y million;

s o that y o u see t h e committee

has worked v e r y harmoniously a n d very smoothly a n d has
been instrumental i n stabilizing conditions, a n d o f recent
montns a n y t r a n s a c t i o n s t h a t t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e b a n k s

have n a d have n o t been i n the open market, b u t between t h e
Federal Reserve banks,

N e w York h a s been very glad t o

Sell t o other Federal Reserve banks during recent months
several millions i n short t e r m caértificates,
Gevernor P l a t t :

T a e committee h a s n o t exercised

any particular jurisdiction over t h e purchase o f beasptances,
has it?
Wr. Case: A b s o l u t e l y none.

to do with that.

I t has not h a d anything

W e nave not discussed it. I

nave n o

doubt t h a t m a n y o f t h e G o v e r n o r s w o u l d h a v e v e r y d e f i n i t e

views about it, but v e have not discussed the matter.
Vice Governor Platt: I

might say, j u s t t o interject


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

687
anew angle t o the subject, t h a t t h e Board's counsel

has given m e the informal ofinion t o the effect that
the Fedsral Reserve banks have n o legal right t o sell

bonds securing circulations that nave been allocated
to them under Section 1 8 o f the Federal Reserve Act. I
think that i s true, I
sold. I

do not think t h e y cught t o b e

think t h e y ougnt t o b e held a n d I think more

of thez ought t o be curchased,
Vr, Miller:

i f possible,

I n your concluding remarks, M r ,

Case, y o u have s a i d s o m e t i n g t h a t t o m y mind i s very
illuminating, a n d that i s with respect t o the operation

of the acceptance market, that the Governors have not
discussed it, T h a t i s a very regrettable admission, b u t
@ cordially frank one, a n d one that I do not believe i s
Tegrettable o n your part o r anybody's part, but looking
at the thing objectively, from the point o f view of the
Federal Reserve system, i t is nevertheless a regrettable
fact that there a r e twhive so-called autonomous banks,

touse Governor Harding's expression that, among themselves, a r e really i n a position, f o r better o r for worse,

to exercise a very important influence upon the money
market and, i f y o u Please, t h e money markets o f the country.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

6

ie

8

8

It i s o f the utmost conseyeance, tnerefore, i f that i n fluence i s t o b e a good influence, t n a t there must b e
some general basis, s o m e general understanding, s o m e
line o f policy under t h i c h these banxs operate.

I

t cer-—

tainly sould n o t b e good administration o f tne Federal
Reserve System t o have t n e Federal Reserve Bank o f N e w
York o p e r a t e u n d e r o n e v o l i c y w i t h r e s p e c t

t o tne money

market a n d the Federal Reserve B a n x o f Caicago operate
upon a

dirrerent policy.

at cross purposes,

I

t zeans that t e are yvorking

i f each bank pursues i t s o m vdolicy

or irpolicy, j u s t a s i t
I think y o u yourself y o u l d probably b e one o f t h e
first t o a d m i t t h e n e c e s s i t y o f g e t t i n g s o m e s o r t c i c o n -

certed action a n d some general srinciples o f action that
will secure unifwrmity a n d that s u c a operation o f t h e Fed-

eral Reserve danks of their own initiative are conducive
to a good condition i n the money market rather t h a n t h e
reverse.
Looking oack over t h e year 1824, shen t n e open market
3

operations o f the Federal Reserve oanks f o r t h e rirst t i m e
in t h e i r h i s t o r y b e c a m e a

uwatter o f c o n s i d e r a b l e c o n s e q u e n c e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

689
before tais t h e rediscounting operations o f the Federal

Reserve banks, or, rather, t n e discount operations o f
the Federal Reserve banks were o f principle conse4uence —
do y o u think t h e record o n the h o l e i s one that reflects
great c r e d i t u n o n t h e f o r e s i g h t

o f t u e Federal Reserve

system? L o o k i n g back u p o n i t I do not tuink that i t is.

I think v e might have made a better saowing i f s e had
had some cowsmon platform u p o n which a l l o f tae Federal
Reserve banks stood, a

platform o f orincipies, a n d i n

addition t o that n a d s e t u p some agency, central

i

Character, I

think t h e result v o u l d have been very

Much better.

F r o m t h e point o f vier - - I do not k n o w

n

gust that t o s a y - - het m e s a y from the point o f view o f
courtesy,

a s s o m e t a i n g o f a n i n t r u s i o n i n t o y o u r province,

not because v e nave tne right t o do it, but from the

Oroad point of v i e v y i
t is a regrettable reflection, and
we @izht just a s well talk frankly nere — - that the oper—
ations o f the banks i n the past year, s o far a s their
OPfen market i n v e s t m e n t s a r e c o n c e r n e d -~- s o r e than,that,

I have n o hesitancy i n saying i t myself,

the Board —

a s a member o f

i t is a reflection upon taem and a reflection

upon t h e Federal Reserve Board a n d the system a s wnole,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

690

I turned t h i s t a i n g o v e r i n m y m i n d d u r i n g t h e w e e k s
of m y recent c o n f i n e m e n t ; I
anyone

could n o t S e l p b u t f e e l t h a t

n o h a s h a d a n y experience

i n business

any business judgment, m u s t feel that a

o r w h o nas

system taat h a s

invasted twelve hundred million dollars i n earning assets,
on the theory o n *:ich this w a s originally undertaken,
that i s for t h e purpose o f insufing t h e earning o f overhead e x p e n s e s a n d d i v i d e n d s

— — w h e n t w o o r three minutes

of calculation wiili s h o w that f o r t a e t e l v e banks approximately eight hundred million dollars vould have done i t —
Shove that i t sas not n a d a n y great coorination o f wind i n
tne develooment o f molicies, a n d w h y not? " h y have w e trig
condition?

W e l l , because there i s nobody that i s particu—

larly c o n c e r n e d a b o u t t r i n g s

i n general

i n tne Federal Reserve

system unless i t d e tne Federal Reserve Board.
In undertaking t o l a y tne predicate t o r tzis action
therefore, I

look a t certain facts i n the operations o f

the bank during the past year a s vell a s what the statute
says o n t h e y u e s t i o n o f n a t P o w e r s

have not.

w e have a n d that v e

I t i s m y opinion that where t h e Federal Reserve

Act has given the Board power, i t has also laid upon the
Board a

responsibility:

L e t m e s a y agan tnat I feel i t i s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Si

691

a reflection u p o n t h e whole Federal Reserve System a n d
we
Nave sort o f shouldered a l o n g sithout exercising very
much

foresight a s t o what i t meant and vhere i t vould eventually

lead, I

say it now with all the more emphasis because

there are certain Federal Reserve banks o f the aystex,
Chicago a n d Nez York, t h a t a r e aanifesting a

degree o f

anxiety a s t o credit conditions, apparently without a n y
preconception o f the fact that t h e y themselves a r e part—

ly and largely responsible for some o f those conditions,
at least.

W h a t i n God's world: r i g h t has a Federal

Reserve Bank t o b e sclicitious about t h e condition o f

tne “oney market, feeling that tnere i s too much i n
the
market, shen i t tself has put i n several hundred million
dollars a n d still maintains i t there?

T h e Logic o f

Teserve banking i s that i f y o u feel uneasy, p u l l
out. T h e r e

has been & gteat reluctance t o pull out, just a s there
zas
great reluctance t e go in.
Now, there must b e s e t u p the frame v o r k o f some sort
ef a

system policy.

As Governor Harding challenges — - perhaps that i g
too strong a word —
right o f the Board.

o r a t any rate h e yuestions the
H e may be right and h e may be wrong.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

53

I a m not a lawyer, a n d I confess h e talks certdnly v e r y
iearnedly,

i f not altogether convincingly. I

a m very

much impressed with the language o f the act, when i t
says particularly,

i n connection w i t h t h e Section o n

bonds a n d notes, " E v e r y Federal Reserve b a n k shall have
power

t o b u y a n d sell,

a t h o m e o r aoroad, B o n d s a n d n o t e s

of the United States, a n d bills, notes, revenue bonds,"

and s o forth, a n d then "such purchase i s to be made i n
accordance w i t h rules a n d regulations prescribed b y

the Federal Reserve Board,"
Now, w h a t kind o f rules a n d regulations a r e implied
there?

W h a t kind w e may properly make a n d not make m a y

be a @ question over which legal authorities m a y differ,
but

I am inclined t o sake this view, and if it is wrong, I wat
to find i t out, i n order that t h e reserves m a y b e oroperly
protected:
setiup,

R a t w h e n the Congress o f the United States h a s

a s the ultimate depository o f discrection i n the

operation o f the Federal Reserve system a board o f five,
now six men, not including the two e x officio members,
it means, v h e n i t says i n accordance v i t h rules a n d regulations prescribed b y them, s&o m e t h i n g more t h a n perfunctory 3
>

3

5

bureaucratic

sords —

695

i t means, t r a n s l a t e d i n t o
vlain English

in accordance w i t h t h e judgment o f
tais board which i s invested with discretionary

authority i n Matters woere i t
is

of the utmost importance t h a t
vise a n d temperate discretion
should b e exercised.

There i s therefore v e r y little

suestion i n m y mind that i n
the t e r n "rules a n d Tegulations®

Something more i s meant than i f
it were a Statute concerning
the operation o f the Postoffice Department,
t h e Pension

Bureau or some other such bureau,
I

may be srong, but

I have croceeded myself a n d t a e
Board n a s proceeded u p o n
S4€ assumption that i t has t n e
authority, a n d a s i t has

the authority, when circumstances have
scowm that better
Operating conditions i n the Federal
Reserve system could
be brought a b o u t t h r o u g h t h e
exercise

o f t h a t authority,

then i t i s its duty t o
exercise it.

Now, Governor Harding has called attention
t o this
Preamble. P r e a m b l e s a r e n o t o f much
conseyuence after

you have got the Tesults, and I am more
concerned with
the Tesults t h a n with t n e preamble.
I

Tead the preamble a little Carelessly.

think h e has

I t reads:

"Whereas, i e a v y investments i n
United States securi-

ties, particularly saort—dated certificate
issues, have


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

694

occasioned embarassment t o the Treasury i n ascertaining
the true condition o x t h e money a n d investment market f r o m
time t o time" — Governor Harding: I
Paragraph, I

indorse tnat.

take n o exception t o that
T h e o n l y exception I

took

was t o the first t v o paragraphs.

Mr. Miller: O h , I beg your pardon.
Governor H a r d i n g :

whatever t o that; I

N o , I

did n o t t a k e a n y e x c e p t i o n

approved o f it, I

merely raised t h e

Question a s t o the effect i n the future i f taose Paragraphs
were adopted a s the dictum o f the Board, L
involves a

think i t

dangerous «uestion waich tnere i s n o use

Opening up, i f y o u get t h e results y o u want.
Mr, Miller: I

say i t i s a legal guestion a n d this

is not t h e place t o settle it.

I f there i s a n y disposition

to 4uestion i t i t has g o t t o b e settled someshere else.
It i s m y opinion, G o v e r n o r H a r d i n g ,

i f the Board has not

the clear right, t h e Board's first duty i s t o get it.
Governor Harding:

Y o u will remember s o m e years a g o

purchase
the T r e a s u r y i n s i s t e d t h a t t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e b a n k s / a t t ¥ o

per cent fifty million dollars' worth o f Treasury certifi-—
Cates,

T h e Board didnit w a n t t h e banks

t o d o it.

T h e

35

695

Treasury insisted o n their buying
them, a n d y o u remember
& great s a n y other trzings that t h e
Treasury forced o n the
backs, a n d our position i s that
t h e Treasury relations v i t h
the Federal Reserve banks cannot
g o further t h a n the fiscal
agency relation,
Ur, Miller:

B u t where does t h e Treasury
Department

come i n o n this? T h e r e i s not
&
Governor Harding:

word here about that,

N o , n o t a t all, b u t t h e Treag-

ury Department comes i n
Mr. Miller:

Y o u told m e that y o u accepted that.

Governor Harding:

W e d o not take exception t o that

at dll.
Mg. Miller:

Y o u do?

Governor Harding:
¥e, W i l l e r :

W e d o not.

T a e n what i s tnere t o complain
about?

Governor Harding:

T h e taing that w a s dangerous
was

the assumption Here that t h e
Federal Reserve Board h a d
the right,, under t h e act, t o
limit t h e investment o f Feq—
eral Reserve banks i n United
States bonds.

Wm, Miller:
the Board.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

B u t that i s & Quection o f the
Povers o f

T h e Treasury has nothing t o
d o with it,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

696

Governor Harding:

W e think t h e credit policy does

not devolve u p o n t h e Treasury Department, b u t u p o n t h e
Federal Reserve Board,
=p, Miller: I
in.

do not s e e where t h e Treasury comes

Y o u are bringing t h e m in; these resolutions d o not

bring t h e Treasury in.

Governor Harding: I
We, Miller:

know they do not,

W h a t i 3 the point?

Governor Harding: I

nad i n mind the past a s well

as the present, a n d vas trinking about t h e future. I

do

not v a n t t h e t i m e t o c o m e i n t h e T u t u r e w h e n
a n y Secre~—
tary o f t h e Treasury,

W h o m i g h t h a p p e n t o b e here, c o u l d

Say that w e d o not want y o u t o d o certain tiings,
ur. Miller:

T a e point i s that t h e n the Board

assumes that i t has power that practically means
t o indicate t h a t t h e r o v e r v i l l b e e x e r c i s e d

i n such Ways a s the

Treasury sees f i t t o suggest a n d demand?

Governor Harding:
wants t h e cooperata:..

I

n other vords, that the Board

w i t h t h e Federal Reserve Banks w i t h

&@credit policy looking tovard real cooperation ~ - I would
not want t h e Board t o put itself i n the attitude o f laying
it a s a

predicate t h a t t o o m u c h i n d e p e n d e n t a c t i o n o n
the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

4

6

9

part o f t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e b a n k s

Treasury would bring about a

7

i n dealing w i t h t h e

situation b y which i n the

future the banks might o r might not d o something involving
the purchase a f Government bonds according t o the views o f
the Treasury officials a t that time —

Mr. Miller (interposing) T h a t is very illuminating,
and i t is particularly illuminating t t h e ieanee from
yourself who, w a s s o long a

member o f t h e Board, a n d there-

fore speak f r o m kno vledge.
Governor Harding:

A n d I remember v e r y well some

of your o w n views about some o f these transactions i n the
past —
Mr. Miller:

O h yes.

O n e o f r y o m hopes a n d ex-

pectations would b e that shen the Board puts itself upon
record v i t h a n assumed power t h a t t h e Board vill exercise
the power, P r a c t i c a l l y your position comes t o this:
want t h a t e l i m i n a t e d

Y o u

s o a s t o protect t h e B o a r d against

the Treasury?

Governor Harding:

N o t at the present time, because

I take i t there i s not any disagreement between the Board,
the Treasury a n d the Federal Reserve banks.

Certainly

the Federal Reserve banks have n o complaint against t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

5a

6

Treasury;

9

8

t h e y w a n t t o cooperate w i t h t h e Treasury a n d

they appreicate what t n e Treasury has done i n establish—

ing certain Tates based o n the market rates, instead o f
asking t h e banks a n d the Board t o f i x a n artificial rate.
I a m satisfied that each o f tne Federal Reserve b m k s
would g o t o the limit inccooperating w i t h the Treasury,
but what i s the use o f laying d o m dictum that might b e

embarassing i n the future?
Mr, M i l l e r : I

do not expect

i t t o b e embarassing

to the Board.
Governor Harding:

h e n I

was a «emoer o f the Board

I neld t h e belief, a n d I believe n o w that i n all inter-—
district operations o f the Federal Reserve banks, w h e r e
one bank deals w i t h another o r deals i n conjunction w i t h
another, t h a t those a r e matters t h a t t h e Board snould take
cognizance o f and should,
Therefore I

i f i t wants to, b e a part of.

have always b e e n i n favor o f this last part

of the resolution, t h a t t h e Board appoint tais central

committee, that i t snould put somebody else o n it, o r
do Whatever e l s e i t wants t o io. T h e s e gentlemen around
the t a b l e w i l l b e a r m e o u t t h a t I

save c o n s i s t e n t l y s a i d

for t h r e e o r f o u r d a y s t h a t i n a l l s y s t e m o p e r a t i o n w h e r e

one bank deals with another, t h e Board
snould supervise
and b e a part thereof; t h a t t h e Board
w a s the sole c o -

ordinating agency. I

do not see any power anywhere i n

the act w i c h gives one Federal Reserve
bank the right
to dictate t o another Federal Reserve
bank, o r a n y
authority for t n e Federal Reserve banks
t o g o ahead
Jointly,

i n hatterssaifectang t h e Federal Reserve system

except through t h e approval o f tne
Federal Reserve Board,

Mr. Miller: ‘ h e n you get down t o real
business,
Such terms a s "coordinating" d o not
mean very much t o
me,

Governor Harding: T h e real business
i s just the
elimination o f those t w o firat
Paragraphs, a n d this

change here (referring to elimination of a phrase.
)
“i. Miller: I

think i t i s important f o r t h e

Board t o know whether i t i s simply associated
<cith this

in a rather remote, indirect supervisory
and advisory
Capacity, O i t h n o power t o
enforce i t s views, a s t o

shat good Operating policies are and
snould 0a, o F
Shether i t h a s p o w e r a n d r e s p o n s i b i l i t y

i n t h e matter,

in imich case I an of course taking
a more definite stand
as t o tne Board's actually leading
i n tais matter a n d from

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

700

time t o time, always o f course i n the best tezper, a n d

with the single desire t o get the best results, sitting
with tais committee o f tae Governors,
to time,

a s I will from tine

a s t h e y a r e inconference v i t h a

vie? ort deter—~

mining suestions o f policy - - a n d let m e s a y here I

think

it i s important t o the probable future o f t n e Federal
Reserve system a n d I become m o r e a n d more o f the ooinion
that t h e o v e n m a r k e t o p e r a t i o n s

o f t h e s y s t e m a r e ec0ing

to b e t h e w o s t i m p o r t a n t p a r t o f t h e system, l a r g e l y

bécause i t i s tarough t h e o p e n market clause o f the A c t
that t h e e e

b a n k s a r e i n a Ddosition t o take t h e

initiative; t h e bank doesn't nave t o s i t back a n d wait
until s o m e b o d y c o m e s t o it, b u t i t i s i n a

vosition

to

go @heac and absorb funds for its ~urposes, w h e n i t deSires t o d o so,

Governor Harding:
no p r i m a r y c o n t r o l

T h e Federal Reserve banks nave

o r influence

o n the m o n e y market

as

long a s the member banks a r e discounting paper o u t o f
their o w n resources,

o u t t h e Federal Reserve banks c a n

exercise s o m e i n f l u e n c e

o n t h e m o n e y market.

Me. Vilier: E x a c t l y , when active rediscounting


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

St

7

0

1

dexands a r e s a d e a t t h e b a n k i t i s a l l right,
got t o b e i n a

position

t o a c k o n your

b u t y o u have

o m volition a n d

not vwait until s t r e s s a n d strain o f credit i s getting
so severe — —

Governor Harding:

C o u i d not the Board exercise

tne influence i t desires t o exercise, under i t s regulatory powers;

i s i t necessary t o assett a

Waich m a y b e open t o ,uestion,
or not?

legal power

a s t o “hetner y o u aave i t

W h a t i s the use o i bringing i t in?

Y o u nave

never n a d a n y difficulty i n getting action —

“ir, Miller (interposing)

N o , but the powers o f

this Board have been challenged i n t i s matter. I

regret

to s a y there h a s evemnbeen some juestion i n the Board it-—
self a s t o whether i t had power, A

doard taat doubts i t s

po#er doubts its responsibility, a n a a board that doubts
its responsibility i s very a p t t o b e caarged 7 i t h responsi-

bility later o n so that i t seems t o me t o be desirable t o
know o n just *hat basis v e are standing i n this matter. I

think w e have zot the vover; t o me i t is almost a s clear
as though i t Were there,
It is a fact that nothing has been done, nothing has


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

62

7

0

2

been developed i n the w a y o f open markets,policy, a x c e p t
as p r e s s u r e h a s c o m e f r o m "ashington;

t h a t i s a n actual

fact. T h e r e i s n o use i n denying it.

I t i s not o n the

whole surprising, a t t e r all, t h a t a
down here i n “asaington,

body o f men, t h o sit

i f they a r e ‘isely chosen, v i t h

notnaing else t o do besides tlay golf once o r tvrice a year
and t o w e t c h t h e o p e r a t i o n s

o f t h e < o n e y market a n d t h e

operations o f the Federal Reserve bans, t h a t t o e iorce o f
necessity m u s t d e t h a t t h e y a r e g o i n g t o be, i f anything,

in @ detter p o s i t i o n t o pass o n these larger u e s t i o n s o f
policy than tvelve . e n m o a r e c_ncerned v i t h the daily
Operations

o f t a e i r o a n p a r t i c u l a r b a n k s a n d wa0o, a s a

rule, h a v e trouble enough right i n their Bhailiwicks,

without looking around o n the outside. W h a t w e have
been short o n i n the Federal Reserve s y s t e m a n d wnat
We are still snort on, i s some agency f o r t h e form-—
lation a n d development o f policy.
Vice Governor Platt: G o v e r n o r Norsis, y o u come
next ® o the roll, i f you care t o s a y a

sord i n regard

the resolution,
Governor Norris: I
about t h e zatter. i

would like t o say a

taimk 2 % 6

f e words

fortimate t h a t sais


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

63

7

question h a s c o m e u p a t a

0

3

tise w a e n t h e r e i s n o t h i n g b u t

the utmost good feeling, “hen tnere i s no contiict o r
differences between t h e Board, t h e Treasury Department

and the Federal Reserve banks, u n d voen tae xaole thing
can be discussed i n perfect cood humor and zood feeling
as a n abstract proposition.
The first "whereas" h e r e nakes a

definite statement

that t h e Board has autnority n o t only t c limit b u t
also t o
Other tise deterzine t h e securities a n d investments purchased
by Federal R e s e r v e banks.

I f tne Board h a s autnority t o

limit i t also must have authority t o increase.

I

n other

words, t h e Board vould have actiority t o s a y t o a Federal

Reserve Bank you shall buy o r you snall not buy: y o u
shall
reduce your holdings o r y o u shall increase your aAcidings,

It seems t o me perfectly evident that, a s t o all the other
open market transactions tnat t h e a c t deals vita, i t not
only gives t h e Board authority t o make rules a n d regulations,
but i t gives t a e m autnority t o ispose restrictions a n d linitations a n d the omiasion o f a n y words o f restriction o r

limitation i n the provision a s to tne open market dealings
is conclusive evidence t o n y mind that t h e Congress didnot

intend t o give the Board any such power a s to those
opera~


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

704
tions.

T h a t onstruction o f toe language o f the a c t i s

verified, a n d tne reason f o r i t i s made perfectly obvious,
when y o u reflect that a s t o the other tnings Congress w a s

dealing vith powers which were new, o r co:paratively new,
in the banking aistory o f this country; t h e y were dealing
with things a s t o waich there w a s serhaps a

certain element

of risk, a n d certainly inexperience o n the part o f taose

yno were dealing vith them; but when i t came t o Govern—
ment securities manifestly Congress said, there i s a totally

different subject, there i s a tning a s t o w i c h w e can safely
give t h e banks unlimited power, a n d v e will simply make t h e
exercise o f that power subject t o certain rules a n d reguiations a s the Federal Reserve Board m a y establish; a n d o f
course tnose rules a n d regulations v o u l d have t o b e rea~

sonable and consistent vith the rest o f the Act, m d not
limiting the powers that were expressly given i n otaer
sections o f tne Act.
Now, i t seems t o m e that matter i s o f importance, b e cawse

i f t h e Governors

o f t h e Federal Reserve banks accept

and a g r e e t o t h e s t a t e m e n t t h a t t h e B o a r d h a s a u t h o r i t y

not o n l y t o limit b u t t o otherwise determine t h e securities
and investments that t h e y shall purchase, t h e n instead o f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

705
65
having a

regional system o f reserve banks w e would have a

central bank, w i t h the Federal Reserve Board a s that bank.

That i s the feeling that I have o n it.
Vice Governor Platt:

B u t y o u agree w i t h t h e general

policy outlined, a s i d e f r o m t h a t ?

Governor Norris: E n t i r e l y .
Willer: I

would like t o make o n e observation

with respect t o the Board's rower.
i9, w h e r e

O f course under Section

w e have t h e power t o review a n d determine rates,

you are o f course aware o f the fact that i f w e are e v e n t o
assume that that construction o r tne l a w i s vight w i t h

Tespect t o limiting the posers o f the Board i n the matter
of open market purches2s b y the Federal Reserve banks, t h a t
the Board could very effectively control tnose operations,

if i t desitedto d o s o , b y fixing the rates s o high that
you could cot buy them, ‘ W e have effective power there, s o
far a s open market operations a r e concerned,

s o that really

the y u e s t i o n d o e s n o t a r i c e b e c a u s e t h e B o a r d c a n d o w h a t

it wants t o d o i f i t really asserts i t s authority v i t h
respect b o n d s a n d n o t e s o f t n e U n i t e d S t a t e s G o v e r n m e n t —
but I

want t o a s k G o v e r n o r N o r r i s a n d I

would l i k e t o h a v e

Be

706

an e x p r e s s i o n o f o p i n i o n f r o m G o v e r n o r Harding,
interested
mean,

o r anyone

i n this a s t o # a a t t o e y understand t h e l a w t o

a n d g i v e u s a n exauple,

b y Saying " S u c h purchases

to

be nade i n accordance w i t h rules a n d regulations
prescribed
by t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B o a r d . "

Governor Harding:

¥ y ansver t o that i s this: A l o n g

the line o f what Governor Norris said a moment
ago, I will
point t o ancther part o f paragraph B

o f Section l4, " B u y

and reli, a t aome o r abroad, bonds and notes o f
tne United
States, a n d bills, notes, revenue bonds, a n d warrants
vith
a maturity f r o m date o f curchase o f not exceeding
six

months" a n d s o forth, a n d "such purchases t o be made
in
accordance with rules and regulations vrescribed b y the
Federal Reserve Board" -—- #hile o f course v e Will purchase
bonds a n d notes o f the tmited States mentioned i n the
para-

graph, there are certain other matters that are not a s aca~
demic a s the mere nurchase o f a dond o r a note o f the United
States, a n d the Board h a s made rexulations regarding them,
and v e r y p r o p e r l y s o —

Dr. “iller:

T h a t i s auite true.

Governor Harding:

I t i s much sore iszportant t o make

Tegulations regarding t h e m than i t i s t o make regulations


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

107
the time o f d a y that y o u b u y a Government b o n d o r -

“Willer (interpodng)
instance

B u t i f you take a vractical

i t i s n o t s o t e r r i b k y aypothetical,

S u p p o s e the

Reserve Bank o f Vinneapolis snould s a y v e are going
t o in-~
vest a l l o f our excess reserves i n tne purchase o f
drainage
and reclamation bonds a n d "nited States bonds?

H a s tnis

Board z . % - p o n e r u n d e r t h e t e r m s cof S e c t i o n 1 4 ?

Governor Harding:

Y o u have cxercised t h a t pover,

You have made regulations Tegarding that.
c o m l e x -atters.

Me. Willer:

B ua

Governor Harding:

talking about tae amount.
D o n ' t y o u concede

t o t h e directors

afdtaSiicers o f the reserve banks any judgment o r discre-—
tion?

We. Miller:

F e m u a s s u m that o f course — —

Governor Harding (interposing) R e a l l y , 7 i t h all
due respect t o tae Federal Reserve Board, a n d zyself included, I

think there are 3oze diretiors o f reserve banks

who a r e a s a d l e m e n a n d a s # e l l c o s t e d o n f i n a n c i a l
torics

as n n y e m b e r s o f the Board.
Mr, Willer: I
the o t h e r w a y around,
>

would s a y exactly t a e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

708
Governor Hariing: G o v e r n o r Norris brougat o u t a
izportant t o i n t t h e n h e c a l l e d a t t e n t i o n

ver

t o tie danger o f

this s y s t e m dDeing regarded a s a central banking system.
No, t h e Board i s already bound, unless i t s m t s t o
reverse itself, ody its o m pronouncement.

T a x e t h e annual

report o f tne Federal Reserve Board t o Congress f o r t h e
year 19s1, y a i c h

a s approved o y tne Board vitnout d i s —

Sent and sent t o Congress i t h a statezent o f approval o f
the Federal Reserve Board.

T h e latter vart o f that rerort

dealt a u l t e f u l l y w i t h t h e r u n c t i o n s
System,

a n d t h e povers

Rare

o f t h e Federal Reserve

Federal Reserve banks a n d s o

fortn, a n d i n that t a e Board disclaimed t a e exercise o f a n y
central b a n k i n g tover,

o r a n y sucn general control

a s you,

have seemed t o taink y o u signt w a t t o exer—

I cannot y u a r r e l

vith y o u o n your general statement o f crinciztls.
not a n aostract °romosition,

T h i s is

i t i s sometsing based u p o n con-—

crete experbance, a n d I cone right b a c x t o tne fact, a n d
state i t <ita all eupnasie, t h a t a
operations

revie.

o r the open market

o f t h e Federal R e s e r v e b a n x s f o r t h e v y
ast tv
Pelve

or fourteen months does n o t make a

very good record,

o r if it


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

69
does, I

a m yet t o b e convinced o f it,

Governor Harding: I

am keen a s you are tor

& general review - o f t h e policy o f open market operations

oy the Federal Reserve Board, f o r their indorsement o f
a "olicy and for tneir being part o f it, but the execution o f these o p e n market operations o f
course cannot b e
done b y the Board; y o u have n o t t h e facilities
f o r doing
that.
Yr. Miller: - T r e r e i s n o tnougzat o f that.
Governor Harding: I
any d i t i e r e n c e

toahat flnink v e r e a l l y h a v e

o f ovinion a t t u s botto.

have been debating a

Ur. S G lies:

o n t - i 3 thing,

M e

sort o f abstract “sroposition,

A s I say, you aave raised the yuestion,

Governcr Harding: I

think y o u nave raised t h e .ues—

tion yourself i n tnis preamble.
ur, Mitier:

A l l right.

" e nave taken action a n d

I shall b é the last xexber o f tue Federal Reserve Board,
after i t has assumed that i t nas t h e Tight t o c e r t a n
power,

t o rescind i t o r render v o i d o n protestation
of

the Governozs,

Gevernor Harding:

I t i s a declaration o f principie,

730

Mr. Miller: I

a m n o t a w a r e t h a t t h e r e i s a n y dec-—

laration o f principle. A n y h o w , I

vat t o come back once

more t o the zuestion that y o u did not answer s o far
w#nich
perhaps Governor Norris w i l l answer, a n d that i s t o give
me a f e w e x a m p l e s

o f v h a t y o u t h i n k t h i s clause, " S u c n pur-—

chases t o b e made i n accordance w i t h rules a n d regulations
prescribed

b y t h e Federal Reserve Board," r e f e r r i n g

t o bonis,

notes, irrigation, drainage, a n d reclamation sarrants
and
so forth; v h a t kind o f rules a n d Tegulations governing
the
purchase o f those things d o y o u think t h e l a w could
possibly
have h a d i n contemplation s h e n i t put that clause
i n section
i+?

Governor Seay: W i g h t I cite one o r t70 things that
might possibly throw light o n it? “ i t h respect t o
agri-~
cultural p a p e r t h e A c t g i v e s t a e B o a r d ~ ~
Wi, M i l l e r : I

a m speaking o f t h e specific t h i n g s

in

Section ls,
Governor Seay: I
Chsses o f paper, a

a m too; v i t h respect t o certain

part o f v h i c h y o u r e f e r r e d t o , " D i s c o u n t

or rediscount, a n d purchase and sale b y any reserve
bank o f
any bills receivable"

— - i y y o u claim power t o restrict t h e

Purchase a n d sale, y o u h a v e t h e s a n e D u v e r
t o restrict t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

val

y

e

n

:

bilis Teceivable a n d y o u c a n govern t h e whole discount
transactions o f the Federal Reserve banks a s t o amount,
description o f paper a n d s o forth} a n d yet a t other voints

in the Act i t gives the Board specific vover t o govern
the amount o f agricultuzal paper .aicn should b e taken
in proportion t o the assets o f the Federal Reserve bank,
and under this n e regulation gives tae Foard the pover
to limit t h e amount o f nine zontas paper t o b e taken.

I t

specifically states those t o descriptions o f paper, s i x
and nine zonths, a n d sny should i t speciyically give pover
to l i m i t t h a t p a p e r i f y o u h a v e t h e g e n e r a l p o w e r

t o limit

it under tiis provision t h a t y o u mention here?
Mr. Miller:

T h a t doesn't come under t h e o p e n market

clause o f the Act a t all. A c c e s t a n c e s do,
Covernor Seay: D i s c o u n t a n d rediscount, w h i c h i s not

open market business, t h e 7 h a s e a n d sale b y any Federal
Reserve bank, under Section 13, which rather confines itself t o the discounting vowers o f the Federal Peserve Banks,—
you have just a s much poser t o control absolutely,

i f your

contention i s right, t h e volume o f discounts o * a n y Federal
Reserve b a n k a s y o u R a v e t o l i m i t t h e p o w e r s o f p u r c h a s e
bills

i n t h e o p e n market,

of


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr, Miller:

T a e r e isn't a n y yuestion about t h e

powers w i t h respect t o tne balance o f tnem.

T h a t is

Clear under Section 13.
Governor Seay:
Mf, Miller:

A s t o azount too?

Yes,

Governor Harding: I

taink there i s a very serious

question,

Mr. Miller:

" T h e discount a n d rediscount a n d the

purchase a n d sale o y a n y Federal Reserve b a n k o f a n y bills

receivable a n d of domestic and foreign bills o f exchange,
and of acceptances authorized b y this Act, saall b e Subject
to s u c h restrictions, l i m i t a t i o n s a n d Teguliations
be i m p o s e d

a s may

b y t h e Federal Reserve Board,"

Governor Harding:

H o w d o y o u account f o r t h e in-

sertion o f t h e #vord "amounts"

Mr. Miller: I

dom

a t the bottom o f the

do not assume t h a t t h e legislators

use t h e same v o r d all the time; t h e y get tired o f using
the s a m e expression.
Mr. H a m l i n :

W h e n y o u s p e a k o f amounts,

i t of

course relates t o these foreign exchange bills —
do y o u c a l l t n e m ?

what


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governorgeay:

D o l l a r excnange bills.
hey vere tinance pills a n d could n o t

get into t h e systez a t all, s o tnere i s reason f o r Congress
3amount that snall come in.
in ¥ e c a n p u t a n y r e g u l a t i o n

W a e n tney nave come

o n them that v e wish to, t h a t

instead o f acceptiihe u p t o 5 C v e r c e n t o f t h e i r c a p i t a l

they should o n l y g o u p t o 3 5 per cent.
Governor Harding:

O i course tnere Y a s a reason f o r

it, T h e y realize that y o u have n o pover t o limit t n e arount
unless taney did so.

T u e y Gidn't s a y i t i n these particu-—

lar transactions.
Governor Seay:

T a e other t i o classes o f bills a r e

particularly specified i n the act, a n d vith reference t o
those tvo classes i t specifically ronfers upon the Board
pover t o limit the amount, a n d i t gives the amount; but
with T e s p e c t

t o these regular a n d d a i l y performances

of

the operations o f the Federal Reserve banks i n discounting,
they d o n o t specify.

Mr. Miller:

D o you think i t i s of conseyuence

that t h e volume o f open market operations o f the txelve
Federal Reserve banks shall b e regulated, s h a l l b e zoverned


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

74

7

1

by somebody, somehow, sometime?

4

O h , i s that sometnoing

to b e referred t o the sweet w i l l a m discretion o f the
individual banks, e a c h o n e t o deteruine f o r itself w h a t
it will do, irrespective o f what a n y other bank i s doing,
irrespective

o r t h a t anyoody e l s e thinks?

Governor Seay:

I f y o u attach a n y significance

to t h e t o r d s u s e d i n S e c t i o n l+# "Taat a n y F e d e r a l R e s e r v e

bank may",and t h e folloving section "That every Federal
Reserve B a n k shall" i t seems t o m e that there i s a ereat
deal o f signiticance i n the use o f those t # o terms right
there,
Governor Harding: I

would respectfully Boggest t h a t

this would b e a very interesting topic for t h e Board t o
take u p v i t h t h e F e d e r a l A d v i s o r y Council,

Wr.’ Hamlins I

sould like t o point out one thing,

when v e are talking about raising issues, a n d that i s
it seems t o m e that this i s a moot suestion, because i f
we issue a & regulation s u c h a s Governor Harding nroposes,
it i s a

regulation o f t h e B o a r d a n d i t n e c e s s a r i l y i m p l i e s

that s e have lawful a t b e r i s y t o isBue it.

I t i a not

necessary f o r t h e Board t o s a y that vthereas t h e Board has

been organized and as such and such i s the practice, a n d

yes

so forth and s o forth, but i f w e issue i t
exactly a s
Governor Harding suggests there i s of
course the implication that i t is a lavyful Tegulation and that
w e have
the power t o issue it, s c that i f there
i s any issue t o
be raised i t seems t o m e that doesn't
raise i t a t ali,

and for that reason I wouldn't+ object
a t all t o striking
out tuose preambles a n d Sizply issuing
i t exactly a s
Governor Harding wats it.

I f you raise a n issue the

issue will b e whether w e shall s a y t o
tne Federal Reserve
banks, please d o s o and s o O r Whether
w e shall l a y d o m

a Tule o f action for them t o pursue,
Therefore, i t
seemsto m e i t is immaterial just vyhat form
i t takes,
Vice Governor Platt:

I t seems t o m e that w e have

all quite generally agreed that some such regulations
ought
to be adopted and the thing t o be determined
i s whether
the regulations issued shall apoly oniy
t o Government
securities o r whether they shall deal with general
open
market operations,

I t would b e all right t o have a

Separate regulation i n Tegard t o warrants.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Harding:

Mr, Miller:

A n d a l s o w i t h r e g a r d t o acceptances,

W e have n o regulation, i f you Please,
in


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

716

76

regard t o any open market dealings i n accpetances, s u c n
as are provided for and contemplated b y these Tegolutions,
These resolutions d e a l v i t n markets primarily a n d
t h e others
deal vita quality a n d kind.

T h e uuestion o f volume i s one

that n a s become o f paramount interest i n toe last
rourteen
or iifteen months, a n d t h e distribution o t a

given volume

between t h e different classes o f open market investuents,
80 t h a t t a i s c o n t e m p l a t e s s o u e t n i n g , u i t e
n e w a n d different

from the o l d open market regulations; a n d for
that reason
it does n o t admit o f the same definite description
because
you are dealing w i t h magnitude a n d those have
Zot t o be
governed b y conditions a s conditions change,
T a m concerned I

would b e entirely Willing,

S

o far a s

i n fact I

vould

prefer it, t o strike o u t the first t w o ‘aragraohs
a n d let
itt Tread: "Therefore,

b e i t resolved t h a t t h e Federal Reserve

Board, i n the exercise o f its cowers under tae Federal
Reserve Act, l a y down a n d adopt t h e folloving erinciples"
and
so forth,
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt:

T h e s e resolutions

acthy regulations, o u t t h e y a r e Simply a

a r e nat ex~

declaration o f

policy.

Governor Harding: " i t h taose Changes I vould not
have


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

=

7

1

7

any e x c e p t i o n t o t a k e t o t h a t d e c l a r a t i o n o f policy.

Governor Fancher: I

do not want t o get into a

discussion s o far a s the preamble i s concerned, b u t I
in hearty accord w i t h what this document sets up. I
there should b e some committee,

am
think

o r someone w h o should have

charge o f o u r o p e n m a r k e t transactions.

Vice Governor Platt:
Governor Fancher:

W e all agree o n that, I

think.

I a m i n accord v i t h snat i s at—

tempted u n d e r t h i s p l a n here.

Governor Seay: I

do not believe, Mr, Cnairman,

that i t i s a t a l l essential,

t o bring u p t h e purpose

woich the Board has i n v i e ,

t o raise t h e yuestion o f

powyer o f autaority, w h i c h yuestion I

understand i t has

always b e e n the policy o f the Board t o refrain f r o m rais—

ing.

i t has never been called i n wuestion i n their regu-

lation o f the Federal Reserve banks, b u t I should b e very
happy a n d more a t ease i f this were confined t o a declara~
tion o f policy o n the part o f the Federal Reserve Board,

in ‘nich, I am inclined to think, you vould find very
ready acijuiescence o n thewatt o f the Federal Reserve
banks.

There i s only one tuiing I vould like t o say with


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

718
Tespect t o complete control over o p e n market purchases,
and that i s that i t ought n o t t o b e g 0 coercive a s t o
not leave a

certain measure o f liberty v i t h the individ—

ual F e d e r a l R e s e r v e b a n k s
accedtances,

w h i c h arise

t o conduct s u c h purchase
i n their d a i l y operations,

moderate amount a n d i n a retail vay. I
it c o m e s t o t h e i n v e s t m e n t

of
i n

do believe w h e n

o f a n y large amount o f funds

in open market operations i t i s advantageous t h a t i t
should b e done under s u c h federal policy, and, i f y o u
please, t h r o v g h s o m e c e n t r a l committee.
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt: I

suppose t h e p u r c h a s e

acceptances originating i n a district,

of

i n what y o u would

call a retail way, should b e regarded a s not orimarily
an investment Policy.

Governor Seay:

" e would not s o regard it, a n d I

do not think i t should b e extended t o such a

rigid e x -

tent a s t o interfere w i t h tnose powers o f daily overation, i n a retail way, o f t h e reserve banks under their
autonomous authority granted b y the law, I

do n o t think

it would be Ytholesome for the directors o f the Federal
Reserve b a n k s

t o feel that a n y such power would govern


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

"9

7

1

9

them i n s u c h d e t a i l a s t o p r o h i b i t t h e m f r o m c a r r y i n g
such operations, I

on

think t h e r e c u g h t t o b e s o m e u n d e r —

standing with reference t o that.
Governor Norris:

T h e r e a r e certain practical difirer—

ences betveen transactions i n Government securities a n d
transactions i n bills, “AnGovernment b o n d i s a Government
bond, o u t every bill i s not a a good a s every other i l l ,
Until recentiy I

believe Boston h a d a Ddolicy that taney

would not b u y a n y bill not indorsed b y member banks.
Among t h e o t h e r b a n k s t h e r e i s w u i t e a

difference

of

opinion a s t o the relative value o f the acceptance o r

indorsement o f foreign banks and of domestic banks and
of the discount a n d acceptance nouses, I

think i t vould

be very difficult f o r a n y central committee t o conduct
purchases,

i n view o f those differences

o f opinion o n t h e

part o f t h e various banks a s t o the kinds o f bills that
they prefer,

Governor Harding:

I t never occurred t o m e that this

latter part o f t h e resolution meant t o take away f r o m a n y
Federal Reserve bank t h e power t o purchase bills originating i n its o m district.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

720
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt: I

Governor Harding:
ity t h e h e a d w u a r t e r s

do not taink that y a s t h e

B e c a u s e i f y o u d o that o f neceas—

o f t h e committee v o u l d naturally b e

at the great money center o f the country, t n e great bill
market, a n d the Federal Reserve b a n k o f N e w York i s located
there, a n d i f this thing w a s given that construction i t
would m e a n t h a t w h e n anyodody i n S a n Francisco, M i n n e a p o l i s ,

or Dallag,wanted t o sell a bill taey sould

have t o say,

"You v i l l h a v e t o t a k e t h a t u p L t n M r . B o

anid s o i n t h e

Federal Reserve Bank of Nex Yors,"I do not

think t h a t 4

clid

tend t o s a k e e v e r y b o d y f e e l v e r y cheerful.
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt:

T i e vurpose i s

orinari l
y to

control t h e v o l u m e o f o p e n m a r k e t v u r c h a s e s

t o s o m e ex-—

tent a n d t o prevent t h e Rderal ReS3arge Banks f r o m con—

tributing t o the soney market funds .aich i t did not ask

Wr, Adleson: “ i t h o u t going into a
the first t v o paragraphs, I
principle l a i d d o m ,

discussion o f

a m 4guite i n syupatny v i t h the

a n d sith the establishment o f tais

committee t o handle both o p e n market investment operationsg
acceptances a n d Government obligations, except # i t h respect


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

to i n t r a d i s t r i c t a c c e p t a n c e s ,

Vice Governor Platt: W o u l d you not think that
that, even with regard t o certain acceptances, that
it
mignt b e reported t o the central committee, w i t h
the

idea of knoving whether they h a d any particular affect
on the outstanding volume?
ur. Adleson:

Gover .or Seay:

A s a

matter o f information, y e s .

T a e y a r e retorted Weekly b y the

Board, a r e they not?
Vice Governor Platt: I

Governor VoDougal:

think

I t i s vezy obvious, from Dr,

Miller's Temarks, t h a t i n ais judgment t h e policy pur-~
sued o y the Federal Reserve system u p t o date, w i t h
Tespect t o open market Cperations, h a s been such a s t o

not reflect credit upon the judgment o f those who.are
in c h a r g e o f t h e M a n a g e m e n t

o f t h e bunks, I

they a r e t h e directors a n d the officers. I

think

do not think

it i s a t all strange, Dr. Willer, t h a t y o u find the system
in possession n o w o f perhaps a

billion,

t o hundred million

in earning assets, three hundred million more perhaps

than w e need, whereas, a

few months ago w e were i n Possession


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

722

m=:

bs
of t x o o r three hundred million less t h a n W e are now, a t
Waich time i t was determined that w e should —

a n d [I think

it w a s a g r e e d u n a n i m o u s i y h e r e ~ - a t l e a s t o p e r a t e

t o the

extent o f tahing care o f our cozmittmemns i n the form of
dividends, expenses a n d s o forth, a n d I toink that toat
increase i n the assets, instead o f having come f r o m addi-

tionel pvrchases i n the open market, a s you vould seem to
have i n mind, h a s c o m e p r o b a b l y t o a

greater e x t e n t , i f .

not almost entirely, f r o m a n increase i n the loans a n d
discounts.

D r , Willer i s evidently unter t h e impression

that t h e system has been going along carelessly, e a c h bank
for itself, zegardless o f conse ,uences —
No - —

Governor M°Dougal (continuing) —

i n these open market

operations.

Dr. Willer:

N o , simply poor aim, simply poor marks—

mansnip.
Governor McDougal:

W h e r e a s t h e facts a r e that this g

very m a r k e t h a s b e e n c o n s i d e r e d f r o m t i m e t o t i m e t o r t w o

years o r more, a n d w e have a t all times, D r , Miller, operated
with the purpose i n mind o f avoiding t h e very tning vtaich


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

83
you seem t o feel that w e have been indulging in.
Mr, Miller:

D o y o u think y o u have succeeded v e r y

ad~irably?

Governor McDougal: I
“Mr. Miller:

think w e have.

h e t m e a s k y o u right there.

D o you

think i t is desirable, from tne -oint o f view of your bank,
and t h e o p i n i o n
on benalf

y o u have expressed

o f y o u r directors,

i n your

o m Dehalf a n d

t h a t a h B Federal Reserve banks

should have txelve hundred million o f earning 1750%

a

t

the present time, the great bulk of which is made u p of
open market purchases?

Governor McDougal:

I s the great bulk o f this

up o f open market c-erations?
Wr. Urijger<?- “Yes.

Governor McDougal:

I n answer t o that question I will

say t h a t i t i s not desirable, b u t what a r e w e going t o d o
about i t ?
Vir. Miller: I
about it, D u t I
incidentally

do not knoy what v e are going t o d o

know vhat h a s been done about it, a n d

a n answer t o y o u r suestion.

Governor McDougal:

h a t n a s b e e n done about it?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

724
Well, t h e market h a s g o t y o u b y the
tail o r perhavs y o u have t h e market b y the tail.
Governor YcDougal: I

Mr, Willer:
again.

think that i s inevitable.

L e t ' s not let that inevitable taing

T h i s thing i s set u p t o prevent t h a t v e r y

in the future, through having someshere a n agency

these thiuzs are surveyed a s a whole,
Governor McDougal:

I n any event I

feel that w e have

not teen acting carelessly o r torking a t cros7 purposes,
elther

i n t h e bill warket o r w i t h respect

t i the open

market operations.

Mr. Miller:

N o w I would n o t accent:those yords a s

a tnorougn reading o f what I said.

Cf 4 a

I t i s not a

juestion

h i S i n e s s i s all bad o r all good, o r a s

good a s could be, i t i s a yuestion o f whether w e should
Step i n here a n d s e t u p a mechanissm that v i l l insure better
results

i n t h e future,

.Governor McDougal:

I t has been gratifying

t o me, a s

&iocribor o f v h e committee wnich has n o w been discharged,

as

I understand i t , b e c a u s e t h i s p r o p o s i t i o n h a s b e e n p u t i n

the f o r m o f a

resolution which has already been adopted

by t h e Board, t h a t i f s o f a r a s t h e T r e a s u r y i s c o n c e r n e d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

725
and i n s o far a s tne Board i 3 concerned, a n d other parties,
that t h e committee h a s operated satisfactorily and. I

wish

to indorse Governor Harding's statement o f our desire a t
all t i r e s t o w o r k w i t h t h e T r e a s u r y i n s o f a r a s i t i s p o s ~

Bible - - and I

think, Mr. Miller, that v e have demonstrated

our desire a n d willingness t o d o that ~ - i n regard t o these
matters,

W i t h regard t o t h e proposed resolution, I

think

it i s v e r y r e g r e t t a b l e t h a t t h e B o a r d n a s f o u n d i t n e c e s s a r y

to take tris action, a n d I am speaking t o i t from the satand—
point o f a c t i o n h a v i n g b e e n taken,

and i

hope i f I

a m Tight

in m y o p i n i o n t h a t i t v i l l b e receongidered a n d m o d i f i e d

to

some extent; I hope 4 h will b e understood that saen tnis
comrittee i s appointed i t w#ill b e a committee o f a n advisory
nature,

n o t o n e o f control,

a n d that nothing that u a y b e

injected into this regulation o r resolution can be accepted a s a n i n d i c a t i o n o f a

desire

o n the part o f t h e

Federal Reserve board t o deprive t h e board o f directors o f
the s e v e r a l b a n k s o f t h e i r i n d e p e n d e n c e

o f action w i t h

Tespect t o open market transactions.

Mr. Miiler: D i d you read the resolution?
Governor McDougal:

O f course I did,

Mr. Miller: L e t ' s read i t again:

" a n d be superseded


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

by a new committee k n o w a s the Open Market Investment
Committee f o r t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e s y s t e m , s a i d c o m m i t t e e

to

consist o f five representatives f r o m the Reserve banks
and

t o be under t h e general superrtsion o f the Federal

Reserve Board" ~ ~
: G o v e r n o r “cDougal:

Y e s , a n d one o f the paragraphs

is "That t h e time, manner, character a n d volume o f open
market investments" a n d s o forth,

I t i s the volume that I

had i n mind a n d I felt that i t might b e modified i n that
way .
Mr, M i l l e r :

H o w d o y o u wish t o s e e i t wodified?

Governor McDougal: I

wish t o eliminate t h e volume.

I think w e can yell afford t o leave tnis matter t o the
discretion o f the Boards, I

do not think t h e open market

transactions have b e e n such a s t o c a s e a n y great anxiety,
but m a y b e I

a m arong.

Mr, Miller:

T h e y have caused some o f u s great

anxiety.
Governor McDougal:

M

y other suggestion i s that

it be clearly understood that there i s nothing i n this
plan w h i c h i s i n t e n d e d

t o depréie t n e boards

o f directors

and the managers o f the banks o f their independence o f action


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

727
87
in the matter o f buying,

i f i n their judgement t h e y feel

that they should buy, o r i n selling.
Vice Governor Platt:

D o n ' t y o u taink t h e volume

of securities i n tae system ought t o b e considered every

time? O u g h t not those things b e nandled a s nearly a s
possible f r o m t h e viewpoint o f t h e system a s a whole
rather t h a n a s the viewpoint o f a n y individual bank?

Governor McDougal: I

think that part o f i t is

all right, b u t I think there i s n o danger o f coming into
@ situation such a s has been intimated, w h e r e some banks
would want t o invest a l l o f their l o a n s , —

Mr. Miller (interposing)

D o you regard i t as an

important «zuestion -—- and o f course w e d o not want t o

talk about this thing indefinitely a s a theoretical propo—
sition —- but d o you think i t is a good situation for the
reserve banks t o have t o mark u p four hundred million t h a n
they need t o earn their dividends?

W e are confronted w i t h

facts a n d conditions a s well a s principles.

Governor McDougal:

M y ansyver t o that would b e i n the

negative.
Mr, Miller:

Y o u think i t i s not a

good idea?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

728

Governor VcDougal: I

do not think i t i s desirable

that v e have a large amount o f earning assets overour
reyuirements.

“r, Miller: Then how i n the sorld are w e going t o
regulate that i f tne yuestion o f volume i s to be outside
of t h e curview o f this committee?
Governor McDougal: I

do not s e e n o w y o u are going

to regulate i t i f i t i s within t h e purview o f the committee,
“hat gwonil the c o m m i t t e e
is c o u n d t o come.

I

d o today v i t h thss surplus? A

surplus

f y o u t a k e tnhex o n v h e n y o u n e e d t e m ,

and then y o u are confronted v i t h a large demand f o r credit
and rediscounts — Mr. Viller:

B u t i f y o u take o n sore t h a n y o u need,

Which i s w h a t h a s h a p p e n e d —

Governor “cDougal:
Governor Seay:
account.

L e t t h e m r u n ofi,

I s not this situation t o b e taken into

T h e aggregate o f a billion t w o hundred million i s

brought about b y investments,

w e vill say, i n Government

securities a t a time w h e n t h e banks sought these investments
largely for purposes o f revenue; conseyuently t h e Federal
reserve banks were n o t seeking these other things i n the
market w o e n they were offered t o them,

T h e n what should b e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

729

the policy,

t o take t h e m o r not t o take them, o r t o control

the rate s o that t h e y #ould not b e offered t o the Federal
Reserve banks?
Mr. “Miller: T a k e what?
Governor Seay: A c c e p t a n c e s = n d open market curchases
that were not scught b y the woank, b u t which were offered,
and faicn w e took a s the market offered them.
ur. Yitler: I

think that raises a

yuestion that i t

is not desirable t o bring into tais discussion, I

nave

very delinite ideas o n that, but I aave not discussed i t
very much “ith m y colleagues, tho, douctless, nave taeir
o™m definite ideas o n it. I

tuink that i s a tiing z e

have s o t t o cozxe t o i n the near future.

¥ y idea i s that

toe time i l l soon be at nand w e n the acceptance has

got to stand o n its own dottom, instead of sizply being
sozething that fits t h e market o f Federal Reserve banks.
My maj;or interest a t this tine, v i t h respect t o open market
Operations,

i s that volume i s a srimary consideration. T h a t

is t h e m a i n t h i n g v e have g o t t o vatcn.

I t i s p r e t t y Clear,

looking oack, f o r practically a year, t c a t t h e reserve banas
tawough taeir solicitude f o r vaying tneir exDenses a n d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

30

730

earnings, h a v e rushed into t h e market, n o t together, b u t

indiscrisinately, t o buy Government securities, a n d a
Government s e c u r i t y i s p e r h a p s t h e l a s t t h i n g , u n d e r o r ~

dinary conditions, that a Federal reserve bank ought t o
carry i n ita investment portfolio.

A

s far a s I can

observe i t is largely pressure from the outside o f the
reserve banks that has brought the different banks t o a
position where t h e y a r e ready t o let those co.
Governor McDougal: I

agree : i t h y o u i n regard t o

bankers' acceptances, t h a t t h e time w i l l a m e w h e n t h e y

#ill stand o n their own bottom, a n d if the rate o n bankers!
acéeptances a t the present time was i n harrony vith the rate
current there o u l d b e n o trouble i n disposing o f our ensesass
oven market investments; t h e y would g o out automatically.

Mr, Miller: I

should say, from the viewpoint o f

psychology, t h a t t h e Federal Reaerve banks were afraid o f

the market; that the market has got you; that instead o f
you controlling t h e market t h e market i s really controlling
you a n d y o u are afraid o f t h e market; y o u are afraid o f
what will happen i f y o u make legitimate u s e o f the open
market investments t h a t y o u are carrying i n your portfolios.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

751
me

It is because o f the vigorous and wise attitude o f the
the tmited States tnat v e are getting out o f
tais investment muddle vithout greater embarassient f h a n
othervise

v e v o u l d have,

I n s t e a d o f having twelve hundred

million t e probably v o u l d save h a d fourteen hundred rillion
at t h e e r e s e n t tine.

Governcr Seay:

“ o r e tnan s i x ‘ o n

nor‘s conference there v a s a

concensus o f

ingsor Government securities v o u l d b e alloved t o fun ofr
as biihks receivable accumulated.
ties were taken a t

T n e s e Government securi-

i m e v h e n the Federal Reserve banks

did not nave either o p e n market purchases i n v o l u m e o r dis-

counted oills receivable, a n d shen i t became evident, o r
appeared t o b e evident t h a t t h e bills sould b e offered t o
the Danks i n greater voluz

i t tas tnoen deemed advantageous,

and was tne concensus o f opinion, t h a t Government securities
snould r u n off gradually a s they matured a n d a s bills r e -

ceivable accumulated.

S

o this nas besn a matter for

consideration m o r e t h a n s i x months a g o .

Vr, Cnairman,

v e haven't u r c h a s e d

many bills for three years, i f I remewber correctly.

Y e have


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

:

7

2 3

5

always attempted t o cperate tirougn tais Central Cosiittee.

We Ovught a smatl amount o f bills a siort vaile ago a n d
wrote t o the coumittee t h a t v e vere zoing t o s u y taea,
and i f i t vould i n a n y s a y interfere Y i t n tae plans o f

committee, v e sould just cancel the order.

W e DSicked

those u p gradually a n d I taink i t took i n tae neizavor—
noed o f t e n days t o buy five rillion.
few 3 . 0 r t t i m e securities.

“

@ Rave v e r y

" e nave always cocperatei

ith

tae Treasury Departaent, e i t h e r i n buying o r selling, r e gardless o f waat our position s a y have b e e n a n d know o f
no reason w a y s e snould a c t continue t o j o tnat. I

ap>rove

oi this plan except i n sco tar a s i t saculd cover over—thecounter transactions t h a t v e iieht nave i n cur o m iistrict.
I do not taink t h e committee vould restrict u g a t all i n
reference t o taose transactions, a n d I also vould like t o
see t h e f i r s t t w o p a r a g r a p h s

Governor Bailey:

West.

¥

o f t n e p r e a s b l e eliminated.

e naven't struck tais b o o m c u t

T e haven't got rediscounts enough t o cause any

fear i n our hearts that anything i s wrong.

W e have only

asked i o r enough Government securities t o make o u r earnings,
We are falling behind this year > y t v o nundred taousand
dollars.

h a s t year v e paid o u r dividends, p a i d o u r over.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

93
head, a n d turned back 1 0 per cent o f cur casi
cnise tax. I

do act s n o w 107 J

G u a a be it

did nut come t o us.
2et tCAaem,

“jiler:

T a a t i s one advontaxne o f . t a e trodsosition,

any Dank toat i 3 o n n c x y reai )

i n g , 3ui-icient t o carry

itseli a l o n g w o u l d n a v e s u m e t a i n g t a a t c c u l d o e a l l o c a t e d

to i t without increasing tae velume i n tae systen.
Governor Bailey: I
make

have n o additional comment t o

o n it.

Governor “icKinney: I

want t o stres3 w a a t Governor

‘eay said i n si3 remarks, t h a t there should b e sote latiI believe
it i s generally conceded that a s t o these intradistrict
transactions tuere ‘ould b e n e E
Yommittee.

t

. I n our district z e nave, I

h

e Central

believe, a

little

ditferent situation f r o m that vaich obtains i n most o f

the other districts, ovine t o tne li-ited azount o f airculation that * e have, aaking i t necessary for u s t o keep
our f u n d s f a i r l y t e l l i n v e s t e d

i n order

t o insure e a r n i n g

dividends a n d the payment o f expenses a n d t o set u p some
sort o f reserve f o r depreciation a n d possible loss.

F o r


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

734
nearly a year i t sas been necessary f o r u s t o g o outside
to p r o v i d e t a e s e e a r n i n g assets.

our member banks :

n e

L

i

T

a

e demands

. @

6 n us from

not sufficient, and
+

for t o

o r t h r e e years,

earnings t o zest these re,uirements.
We n a v e p r a c t i c a l l y

n o c p e n market

i n our district a n d n o t

enough diiis receivable i n tae district t o afferdus t h e
necessary earning asseta.
Vice G o v e r n o r P l a t t :

D o n ' t t o u think t h a t oretty

liberal dexand vill coze alons peiore long?
c¢varnor Vetinney:

N o t frox present indications.

Tae meamder banks o n l y owe u s %7,000,909 a n d tnoere nas
been little indication tnat t h e y are z o i n
Vice Governor Platts

" h a t volusze o s rediscount,

at t h e p r e s e n t r a t e s , s o u l d y o u n e e d t o c a r r y y o u along?

Governor “cKinney:

O n 4 n average rate o f 4 per cent

verould nave t o 2ave ‘50,000,000.
Vice Gcvernor Platt:

A n d ‘nat s o u l d v o u aave t o

at 5 Der cent?
Governor VeYinney:

F o r t y siliion.

I t takes about

two willion aoliars gro3s, a n d atcoccurred t o me that o n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

735

35

account o f cur somewhat remote location frou tne committee,
not getting i n touch v i t h ther very often, t h a t * e migit
be given just a

little b i t o f latitude v i t h reference t o

deciding o n open market transactions.
Vice Governor Platt: ‘ n d e r t i s arrangement p e r haps y o u could have special latitutde given.
Governor McKinney:

“ n i l e t u e committee a a a d e e n

very kind a n d considerate o f u s v e nave sotetiaes found
it a little ditiicult t o get ready action o n our wcney.
Ye have t o svlit i t pretty fine d o m there t o get enough

money.
Governor Bailey: r

t e discovered over a

period o f

& tonta that s e were not waking our earnings, v e vould
Call o n you, o r o m tnis Comittee, a n d i t vould b e i n duty
Cound t o s u p - l y u s v i t a t a e n e c e s s a r y a m o u n t o f funds,

is

that t h e understanding?
I aicn't suppose i t i s necessary f o r
you t o make your dividends e v e r y zonth.

Governor Bailey: I

«nev, out v e cannot tell until

tae e n d o f the y e a r —
Vice Governor Platt: I
taken care of, o u t I

taina y o u i l ] probably b e

do net think i t i s necessary t o watch


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

GVery . o n t s 2 0 4

Governor Bali

F a t c i l n g every

Vice Governor
Yeserve o a n z s b u y s
“oney i n t o t a s
in t u e c c u n t r y
Taere i s n o o > j e c t i o n
meuber DANng3 l f t u e y

Vice Governor Platt: I

G

t o duying
a

n they

taink t i t a regard

retail tr.msacticns t a : t g o o n i n digzerent 5 Sarts
country t a a t t a a t i s G i f t i e r e n t uwatter,

;
be
or

n
‘

t
L

r
a

c

a
b

l
t

Coziittee
-

t o dete:

O F theo voiture.

te A O U
unreservedly

i n favor o f t a e

dDerore w e t o weaoranda, a n o
be t a e aunty o f
comtittes

t o advise a n d recor e n d tlans s o r t h e surra

he c t

c

o

T

t 3314. bS- t h s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

duty o f t i s coz:ittee t o
Sais" a n d i n m y crinion that i s avhetaing suite difierent,
i a m i n iavor o f t i e i i r s t

bills bougat b y tas Federai Reserve b a : r

Nev York

constantly since t a e oneration first b2.2n, s n a n a s done
SO because i t believed taat t i F e d e r a l R
S5OGie a c t S e i n t a

o

a

n gs

‘ i t s o u t seae kind o f control

and sao0uld
oat, I

socula tains,

Ol M i e t a s r I

is

s u i n cavor o z tris 3rccosed 5

I

say un-

favor o f it. T h a t d o e s not, aotever,
ann R i d e . t a i n e tact aiter t r e
aisoussion n a s zone arouni tais taols, :-ni I aave b e e n

reached last, a n d everytaing has b e

S i d taat covld o e

I still
Jefstsniing o f tae la? as i t applies t o tae
suca 123473, i s taat
the sadsinistrative S u b A o r i t y

Hit i n every sincle case
is given eutaority i n tais a c t t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

738
actiority i s Llisiteu t o p r e s e r i s i n g t a e l i v i t a t i o n s

to the Act, a n a not i n contravention o f t h e Act.
Tae interpretation t h a t

m

s t o d e mut u p o n t n e A c t i s

Federal Reserve Board h a s v o ver t o proehbit a n d t o
Tezuire t h e Federal Reserve banss t o perform a n y act that
it sees f i t a n d t o regulate v i t h respect t o them i n contravention o f the las. I

vill only refer t o a rex o r t h e

taings:
"Tae B o a r d o f D i r e c t o r s s n a l i p e r t o r m t a e d u t i e s
usually a p p e r t a i n i n g
associations

t o t h e ofiice o t directors

a n d a l l z u c n duties

o f danking

a s area p r e s c r i b e d

b y lay,”

he Board o f Directors o f these bangs cannot cozoly

vith that paracraph o f tae lay if tuis Board h a s t h e so-er
to prohibit a n d re,uire, : n d there i s only one single inStance i n this A c t vhere t h e Board i s Jiven authority t o
re,ulre t o e D a n a s t o d o anytsing,
Teyuire

tne

t o b u y oonds

a n a tnat i s there t a e y

i n TeLunding cperations.

Con3e—

auently i t occurs t o t e that this
tirely acceptable, vithout ~ualification,
eliminated.

“r, Miller: Haven't y o u overlooked, Governor Calking,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

=

7

5

9

that there i s nothing i n taese resolutions #uica Lre.uires
the banks t o d o anytiing?
Governor CGxlkins: I

realize taat. T n e r e a r e t o

memoranda nere,

Governor C a l
peraticons

Littee

o

r

e

s surchases

ing t c tne necessities o f the ommks,

Of tis

c o .

o e alloceted accord—

o r vili i t S e Lirst

ney v i l l b e ~ro-rated, every bank getting
tts t a d shore.

Governor ‘McDougal:
mr, Miller:

vr, Hamlin:

e

e

i z t h e y want taen.

Yes,

I f one bank needed t a e and another

bank d i d not, y o u could take care o f t h e First Dana i n that

say.

I t doesn't necessarily rollow that all purcnases x

be m a d e a t o n e Point, w h i c h I

taink v o u l d b e unfortunate.

Mr, Miiler: N o , I saculd hope t a t t n t ‘ould b e
avoided.
Governor Platt: I

thins M r . G i l b e r t v a n t s t c

ita Legara t o open iarket cperation


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

740
not £ 0 0 >

t a t taste 1 8 2uca

said. T 6 0 wuch o f t h e discussicn n a s seen
,uestion o f law taat, caving cence beea a
tate t o v a r t i c i p a t e

i n it; f u r t e e r s o r s , I

lavyer, I
duubt

aestz—

i i there

tue A c t taat t a e Board s a s
$2ins- t a n t t a i l s

SsLepily-s.tnc les
Pas o o sr. =
seartily

ON

i n savor

that t o e C e n t r a
adcut a

year a a 3

its a c t i o n s aAave
ang :

2 3 ]

2

,

A M Gites L O

of e t c i n g e o v e r t a r

S

o

e

a t ex

D o abd S a t e a t i o
n

n d r e i .iilion doilars

of Gcvernment securities, s n d

E 3

{

i n soliin:s

. a3atve :..ay

think adout t a e crizinal action o f t o e banss i n duyine. %..13
extraordinarily lacze volute c i Governient seaurities i t a o u t
erence t o the Bcard o r t o tue Treasury, I

taink taerte

3.ent t h a t t h e s u d s e , u e n t s t e p s thicna h a v e doesn


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

101
741
taken have been effective a n d seipful a l l around.
The Treasury has n o immediate concern jyith the
auestion o f accpetances, b u t from that z e d o see o f it,
it i s s o clear that they a r e interrelated ‘ i t n tne deal-—
ings i n Government securities o n the market, t h a t I

should

say i t vovrld b e a n excellent c l a n t o Aave t h e m combine

With the comnittee dealing vita open market operations.
The previous coumittee o f Governas having b e e n
superseded b y tiis n e v Gomsittee o n Open Market Operations,
the Treasury i s hopeful t h a t t h e Governors, Yorking through
that cozmittee, t i l l b e able t o make rurther material progress

i n liquidation,

and I

hope t h a t m a t t e r v i l l h a v e t h e

consideration o f t h e committee.

F r o m t h e Treasury point o f

viet, a s you all know, w e are out of the market until about
the middle o f May, when w e will have a large operation,
although m a y o e a smaller operation t h a n o f Jume 1lS5th. T h e

time between now and April 15th or thereabouts is therefore a

very free time s o far a s the Treasury i s concerned;

if market conditions permit, a n d the committee c a n work out
the necessary procedure,

w e vould b e very glad t o s e e a

considerably further liquidation, particularly o f the
holdings o f certificates.

T h e volume o f certificates o u t —


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

742
Standing i s n o v a little over a

billion dellars, a

and a 2ali dollars less t h a n i t vas a

billion

year o r t7o0 ago.

T h e

market o n certificates i s nct t o o Strong, b u t Probably a

little stronger than the warket for notes, o f which there
are accut three a n d 4 half billion outstanding.

O u r in-

Clination therefore i s t o prefer, f o r t a e t i e being, liguidation o f certificates rather t h a n o f notes. I
Will x e e p t h a t i n mind.

hope y o u

O u r relations v i t h t h e previous

committee a a v e been most cordial, a n d v e are looking
frorvard
to the same cooperation s i t h the »oresent committee.
Vice Governor Platt:

Y o u yould like t o s e e the banks

liquidate their aoldings o f certificates a s soon a s they
conveniently c a n ?

Mr, Gilbert:

¥ e would lixe t o see them take t h e r

in their order o f short time certificates rather t h a n notes.
Governor Harding:

Wr. Gilbert:

H o w many d i d y c u b u y t h e other day?

A b o u t fifty million. I

had vord froz o n e o f tne other banks, I
that h a s i n s t r u c t e d t h e c o m m i t t e e

since have

think from St. Louis,

i n N e w York t o seli five

million dollars i n St. Louis o f Bbcember certiiicates,

s o that

there i s a p p a r e n t l y s o m e i m p r o v e m e n t a l r e a d y i n t h e d i r e c t i o n
of f u r t h e r l i y u i d a t i o n ,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

743
Governor Norris:

T a e total holdings c f certificates

now are only sixty-eight million.
“r, Gilbert:
Tigcure.

Y e s , t h e y a r e d o m t o a very reasonable

T h e y a r e September andDecember.
Vice Governor Platt:

T h a t i s going t o have some

considerable effect o n the market r a t e for money.

“rT, Case:

V a y I wake just one observation, a n d

that is that this comrittee, vaen appointed, is going to
have i t s o m troubles.

Y o u cannot successfully ride

tvo horses a t the same time a n d one o f t h e difriculties

in c a m y i n g O
u
t such a

program a s laid d o m —

of u s recognize t h e i m p o r t a n c e

I think all

o f t h e principles

do not s e e 40@# v e c a n help b u t agree v i t h them ——- "“hereas

the amount, t i e , character and zanner o f such purchases
may exercise a n important influence u p o n t h e money market;

""hereas a n open market investment policy for the
twelve b a n k s c o m p o s i n g t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e s y s t e m i s
necessary

i n tne interest

o f t h e maintenance

of a

good

Telationship betieen the discount and purchase operations
oi the Federal Reserve banks i n tne general soney market"
and 3 0 o n — ~ now, t h e fact o f the matter is, Derhaps, t h a t

with this comparatively nev instrument w e have been riding


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

104
744
the w r o n g hosge. I

mean b y t o a t a l l o f t n e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e

banks have h a d a policy - - i t nas been referred t o nere
two o r three times tiis afternoon -—— and that i s t o always
have enough earning assets o n hand t o insure paying their
dividends,

N o w right h e r e i t i s p e r f e c t l y

say frankly that I

i n order t o

have s e e n times s h e n a bank would give

instructions t o the committee t o b u y s a y twenty million
dollars o f iscellaneous Securities, perhaps Government
Securities a n d perhups bills, a n d sithin a
very s a m e d a n k v o u l d h a v e a

fex weeks that

very u n a s u a l a n d v e r y s t r o n g

demand f o r money, i t s loans sould g o u p trenty, tuirty
or forty million doliars a n d i t would b e oversupvlied
within a

very weeks, a n d that accounts f o r u s having

three o r four hundred millions o f excess earning assets
in t h e s y s t e m a t t h e p r e s e n t moment.

Now, i t seems t o m e that under s u c h a

program a s

this, a n d I am glad t o find thatthere i s cordial feeling
with regard t o it, that v e have g o t i n some w a y t o modify
our views W i t h Tespect t o this other policy.

Governor

Strong, j u s t a s h e was leaving, rather indicated that
bBohaps w e had been a little t o o strong v i t h that policy
and that perhaps i t would n o t b e a bad thing i f some o f
us


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

105

7

4

5

did not earn t h e full amount o f our expenses i n dividends.

In other vords, these banks were not organized t o make
money, a n d i f w e lat nature take i t s due course n o w and

then and v e even show a slight deficit, i t might not be

an unwnolesome thing. B u t I do want t o point out the
fact, that i f you are going t o operate o n the principle
that y o u are always going t o nave enough earning assets
to c o v e r expenses,

i t means i n v a r i a b l y t h a t y o u a r e g o i n g

to nave four o r five o r nalf a

dozen banks i n the market,

which c o n f l i c t s w i t h t h i s principle,

a n d i t may b e a t a

time w h e n i t i s undesirable t o exercise t n i s influence o n
the money market b y putting funds i n t o it.

“rT, “illier: L e t a e say tais, that I believe tne
Reserve d a n k s a s a
are g 0 i n g ,

waole, t h e r e i s e v e r y r e a s o n t o believe,

w e t h e r t a e y want t o o r dont w a n t to, t o b e

hooked u p vith tae money market t o the extent o f a
of five hundred willion dollars a

year. I

minimun

think i t i s

more likely t c be around seven o r eight hundred million.
I think there i s every reason t o believe t h a t t h e Federal

Reserve banks are going t o be a neceseary element i n the
general credit situation a s i t nas worked out, a n d for
an indefinite tine. I

expect t h e time t o come w n e n t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

106

7

4

6

Federal R e s e r v e s y s t e r w i l l b e a n actual f a c t o r accKked u p
to t h e c r e d i t s n d p r i c e s i t u a t i o n i n a

very n e c e s s a r y d e -

that i s -oing t c b e sufiicient t o D a y t h e
system, p r o v i d e d

“rorata o i earning assets,
ne O i t o s tain.3

w e a r e likely t o come u p

the ,zuestion o r n e n i t i s zood 20licy t o
open market - - i f certain o f t a
Gaving v e r y active discount; demands, t h e n
it vYants t o r e c o m z e n d ' a n a p r o r t i o n m e n t

o r t h e earnings,

assets a n d rediscounts --— not bDecause t h e bank that a a s
got ther vants t o rediscount, b u t because t h e dank that
hasn't c o t anvtaing tants t o earn sometning - ~ i n ctner
words whether tnaere vill n o t b e i n time a

pooling o f t h e

earnings o f t n e Federal Reserve system; since w e cannot
do i t directly,

d o i t indirectly turough a

pooling o f

their earning assets, cithner b y selling t o one another
out o f their sortfolios o r , i t i s conceivadle, Trediscounting f o r t h e c o n v e n i e n c e

o f t a e bank that hasn't

got any Ousiness o y the bank that has got more than enough
to take care o f the expense dividends a n d reuuirements.
Governor S e a y

y o u l d like t o say, Yr. Cnairman,

747

although i t isn't very i m p ortant, t h a t w e are a n exceo tion
to the statement made b y Governor Case, t h a t a l l o f the Federal Reserve banks h a v e entered t h e o p e n market.

é e have

never done soe F o r a considerable t i m e during t h e past year
we h a v e b e e n w i t h o u t a

sufficient v o l u m e

o f bills receivable

to pay our expenses, b u t w e have believed t h a t later o n
the v o l u m e w o u l d increase.

. @ h a v e n e v e r purchased,

for

the sake ofincome, Government securities, n o r have w e ever
purchased

i n the c p e n

e e

a n y volume

o f acceptances f o r

that purpose, although w e have r u n along f o r a considerable
time w i t h o u t s u f f i c i e n t v o l u m e

Governor Bailey:

t o p a y c u r expenses.

F o r how long?

Govercor Seay: B e t w e e n thirty a n d forty-five days.
Governor Bailey: i

forget t h e average b y months, b u t

if w e hadn't been i n the oben market f o r s i x months,
aot have wade c u r earnings.

w e would

D r . Liller Says i t will come.

hope w e will h a v e some good times o u t there s o that t h e
people will want t o borrow ‘ioney, t u t I

cannot s e e i t now

in the tenth district any sore than m y friend from Texas
Can s e e a n y change o f the people i n his district borrowi

n g

any great amount o f money.
Er. Liller:

T h e F e w York bank h a s excess earning assets

at t h e p r e s e n t t i m e a n d p e r h a p s t h e y w o u l d s e l l
some o f t h e m


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Bailey:

. e have twenty-five million dollars

in the tenth district i n call loans, a n d w h e n they call
those loans t h e y have g o t t o g n t o the Federal Reserve
pank, p u t u p the tonds a n d g e t t h e money - Governor Seay* B & B h e ' : . e w York Bank m
them next month; t h e y might r u n out.

ght net have

Y o u could n o t s a y

because o n e d a y o r one week o r one month they h a d excess
earnings &Bhdt they should b e divided, because t h e following
month,

o r within sixty d a y

That i s true; w e sannot tell what i s going
nonth o r next q uvarter; b u t w e c a n work o u t
it.

Governer Calkins+ I

usuld like t - call attention, i n

comnectinon w i t h G o v e r n o r B a i l e y ' s a n x i e t y ,

remarks, t h a t i n cur cperationa w e cannot l e t nature t a k e
its coursé.

V

e a r e s o b dealing w i t h natural processes.

if y o u l e t n a t u r e t a k e i t s c o u r s e w i t h a
are o p e r a t i n g m a c h i n e s

machine - -

- ~ t h e machine stops.

S o m e plan must

be d e v i s e d w h e r e b y t h e m a c h i n e c a n b e e o n t i n u e d

i n operaticn

for the benefit o f all the banks, and t t 8

plan that

they h a v e p r o p o s e d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr, k i l l e r

i t i s one o f t h e plans, surely.

Governor iichinney:

I t would b e very unsatisfactory f o r

any Federal Reserve b a n k t o have t o encroach u p o n
its surp lus already established i n order t o pay expenses.

ur. Miller’ But i t would b e a very valuable lesso n
to C-ngress.

lire Case+ Aproposoof New York's excess, i f we have a n
excess a t the present t i m e it - f

a very limited amount,

but I am sure I am justified i n saying that “ew York w o uld
be very glad t
other banks.

a

r o m e o f that excess with some o f the

~ @ have t e n million Treasury antes o n the

4°10 basis, which we will sell t n any other bank for that,
if i t wants t h e m now,

Governor Nchinney: T h a t i s today; but how about sixty
days f r o m now?
Vice Governor flatt :

D o you

whether there i s going t o b e a n increased demand f o r credit
in the very near future; hr. C a s e ?
at matter i s discussed constantly,

a s you

know,,at every Coard meeting a n d a t o u r executive committee

meetings, a n d 1 think i t i s a fair statement t o say that
there i s a feeling that there i g already evidente o f a n
increased demand f o r credit.

I t i s a situati o n that

the directors a n d officers - f the bank a r e watcning
very


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

L1O

750

Glosely, a n d 1

a m act a t all certain b u t what t h e y m a y

presently have occasion t o make some reennnendation t o the
Beard w i t h respesttto a

d-ssible increase i n the rates there.

Vice Governcr rlatt:

D o e s anyone e l s e care t o s a y

anything along that line? ;

a

directors! meeting

at the branch - f the Federal Reserve b a n k i n Detroit a n d
have found t h e directors o f that branch pretty nearly a l l o f
would

ir. Hamlin:

T h e r e has

b e a

cansiderable

e na

increase

soc j e a l s a i d -abcut t h e

necessity o f earning overhead ex,enses a n d wtividends.
course t h i s c i r c u l a r

i n

o r régulation,

OF

o r uhatever y o u m a y

call it, i s based o n the assump t i o n that there
be amplelearning assets f o r toth surp oseg, a n d
say that t h e excess t h a t has been a warent
vossible,

b e avoided.
I do ant believe
to make a n y regulation

whatsoever which would fort F e d e r a l Reserve b a n k from
earning i t s overhead

a

n

d sossibly also i t s divi-

dend.

sow, I sat with the coumittee o n the Federal Reserve
Aet, a n d I

think I

know what their intention was, t h a t these

wepeeto b e living, g o i n g b a n k s a n d t h e o p e n m a r k e t v u r c h a s e s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

751
caeS
a
were given taea,

i n order t o make t n e rate effective, v h e n

they had relatively f e s discounts, a n d I think t h e purpose

was t o enatle them t o meet taeir overhead expenses and
dividends,

T h a t suestion, zovever, does not arise now

at all. I

am glad t o vote for tais resolution o n the

assucttion t h a t

v e have s o r e t h a n e n c u g h t o t a k e c a r e o f

our 6Verhead expenses a n d dividedds; I
this reso.iution i s a

aeartily agree that

cise o n e a t t a i s time, o u t I

vote t o r i t a s l a y i n g d o w n a n y p r i n c i p l e t h a t a

do not

Federal

Reserve Bank must shut u p its doors because, indirectly,

its continuance mizht lead t o a n inflation o f currency.

Governor Bailey: B u t are there actually enough
rediscounts i n the banks?
Governor Norris:

N o .

Mc. Hamiin: z

e e

l o o k e d i t up, but I think

not; still I am of the osinion that i f tae Government
securities v e r e a l l li.uidated there v o u l d be.
Governor Calkins: T h a t vould cause more borro7ing
at once,

Vice Governcr Platt: I
buy G o v e r n m e n t s e c u r i t i e s ,

think vhat you do when you

i s t o p u t store m o n e y i n t o N e w

York, Philadelphia o r Boston o r some o f the Eastemn centers


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

112

752

and s u o p l y e s t h e canks witth m o n e y w a i c h t h e y g e t v i t h o u t r e —

discounting, a n d i f thst w a s taken avay from tnem they vould
have t o rediscount i n all probability. I

do not m e a n that

it vould w r k o u t t o exact ficures, b u t that i s the effect
oseee a

Mr. Case:

W i t h regard t o the wuestion o f expenses

the r e p o r t o f t h e B o a r d t o C o n g r e s s s n o s s t h a t t h e e x p e n s e s

of the tvelve banks w e r e approximately thirty million dollars
in 1953, s o that t h e twelve hundred wmillion dollars earning
assets n o v i n t h e s y s t e m v o u l d a p p e a r

t o b e sore t h a n ade-

quate t o c o v e r t H e axbpense.

Vice Governor Platt: I

think there i s n o doubt t h a t

they a r e sore t n a n necessary — — that i s earning assets, n o t
discounts,

Mr, Hamlin: O n e - t h i r d o f the earnings comassfrom
Government securities.

Governor Norris:

O u r average rate i s 4 per cent,

so t o e a r n t h i r t y m i l i i o n s d o l l a r s

o n that w e need s e v e n

oundred a n d fifty o f earning assets, T a k i n g t h e last

statement, t n e discounts amounted t o 630,000,000, bills
bought 236,000,000 and Government securities 383,000,000,
This w e e k o f course t h e y a r e down.

T h i s week the total


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

113
earning assets were tvelve hundred million o f tnich seven
hundred million practically a r e discounts, 354,000,000 bilis

243,000,900 Government securities.
Governor Platt:
fifty o r a

T h e n t h e discounts a r e vithin

hundred w i l l i o n d o l l a r s

o f enough t o provide

sufficient S a r n i n g s f o r t h e w h o l e s y s t e m ?

Governor Norris:
lion.

Y e s , within fifty o r a hunttred mil-

O s course taese discounts h a v e b e e n going u p @

little, b u t just a s a bank cannot always avoid having

Some excess Preserves, a

commercial bank, v e cannot always

avoid having some excess earning assets,
Vice Governor Platt:

O n no. I

do not s a y that t h e

earning assets can be abso.iutely pro-rated s o taat the}¥iwill
be t o a

dot s u f f i c i e n t

t o enable e a c h b a n k t o e a r n i t s

expenses a n d dividends a n d nothing cver.

Are there any other subjects t o b e brought up?
Governor McDougal:

U r , Platt, i t i s the understanding

of our conference that any press statement that might possibdly
ensue f r o m this meeting should come f r o m the Federal Reserve

Board, a n d a t tunis point, i f i t is i n order, I mould like
to inguire a s t o whether t h e Board i s willing t o discuss w i t h


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

754
give u s the benéfit o f their o m opinion, a s t h
Tespect t o the suggestions contained i n tne memorandum
suomitted, a

copy o f v h i c h y o u h a v e a n d v h i c h W a s s e n t t o

the Board i n order that t h e y might simply have t h e benefit
of t a i s suggestion.

Vice Governor Platt:

Y o u have reference t o t h e

statement bezinning a t the bottom o f the page nere?

Governor McDougal: I

think i t should b e considered

in i t s entirety,

Governor Platt: I

think that t h e Board sould agree

with y o u o n auestion No, automatic adjustment o f discounts rates, t h a t i t i s l#possible;

with regard t o uniform rates, I

a n d also t h e same

understand this report

has b e e n a d o p t e d b y t h e c o n f e r e n c e ?

Governor YWoDougal:
themselves,

O n l y with respect t o the topics

T h i s suggestion

i s the o n e that v e yould

like t o have y o u consider.
Mr. Case:

I t i s a fact that tais wuole Paper n a s

been approved b y the conference,
Vice Governor Platt:

" H a v i n g i n mind t h e importance

of the general subject o f a n appropriate discount p o l i c y i n

the Federal Reserve System and that the public may be more


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

LD

795

fully informed o f the reasons f o r such a policy, y o u r
committee recoumend that a t the

i s i o n o f this c o n —

ference that t h e following statement b e sent t o t h e
Federal Reserve Board:
"During t h e semi~annial Conference o f Governors,
snich closed today, t h e Federal Reserve Board,

a s usual,

iiscussed v i t h the Governors m a n y matters o f operation,
including t h e amendments t o the Federal Reserve A c t con~
tained i n the Agricultural Credits Act, caanges i n the
Board's regulations made necessary b y these amendments,
the o p e n m a r k e t o p e r a t i o n s

o f t n e System,

matters o f routine operation.

a n d many

A s usual, t h e Board a l s o

discussed v i t h t h e G o v e r n o r s t h e v a r i o u s f a c t o r s

which

enter into t n e consideration o f the credit policy o f the
System, s u c h a 3 general economic a n d financial conditions,
the condition o f t h e reserves, o p e n market rates f o r

various classes o f paper, t h e demand for credit and the
volume o f credit i n use, < o l d movements, present a n d
prospective.

"In view of the in-flow o f over $1,C00,000,000
ot gold since Jawary, 1951, y a i c h n a g formed t h e basis
tor t h e recent great increase i n bank deposits a n d loang


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

756
and has kept t h e reserves o f Federal reserve banks f o r
Over a

year a t tneir present n i g h level, t h e Conference

has asked t h e Board t o call attention t o the fact that

this gold has come tainly from countries which before
the w a r were o n a gold b a s i s .

H o w much o f i t vill b e

Tejuired a n d vill remain here a s a permanent addition
to the credit basis o f the country cannot n o x b e
estimated, O u t a s experience shows that g o l d i n excess
tne r e s u i r e m e n t s

of a

country u s u a l l y f l o w s o u t t o

other c o u n t r i e s n e e d i n g i t more, s o m e p a r t o f t h e

System's present g o l d soldings i s liable t o flow back

to tae countries from jaich i t came, stabilizing their
commercial a n d financial condition t o the advantage o f
our trade a n d commerce,

S u c h a n out-flow o f gold vould

feduce t h e reserves f r o m their present level, a n d this
Should b e borne i n mind i n reading t h e statement o f the
Federal reserve banks.

I n order t o call attention t o

this element i n the reserves, t h e Confereace n a s asked t h e
Board t o refer t o i t for a

number o f weeks i n making the

weekly statements o f condition o f the Fedaral reserve
banks,

i n substantially t h e following form:

"Since January 1, 19:1 the gold held b y the
Federal reserve banks h a s increased b y more


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

757

Tais additional z o l d has come mainly

from countries not ne* o n a ,old basis.

A s they return

to a cold basis much o f i t i s liable t o flov back
again, thereby stabilizing their conditions, a n d bene-

titting cur agriculture, industry and commerce. S u c h a n
ent fins Would o f course reduce t o more moderate levels

the present high reserve ratio;, which should, therefore,
not b e regarded a s a measure o f the volume o f credit n o w

available for ordinary uses."
That i s what y o u s a y y o u desire t o b e incorporated
in t h e v e e k l y s t a t e z e n t s ?

Mr. Case:

A s a foot—note.

Vice Governor Platt: I

think that i s a very perot

tinent suggestion.

T h i s is/something tHat the Board

to a d o p t a t t h e p r e s e n t moment.

I

t i s already recommended

vy the Ccntcrence.
Mr, Hamilin: I
objection,

would like t o ask i f there i s a n y

o r i f y o u thinx i t would b e advisable,

i n the

future f o r t h e Board t o separate t h e reserves f o r each

bank weekly into Teserves against deposits and reserves
against Federal Reserve notes i n actual circulation a n d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

118

7

5

8

Would b e a n active reserve against t h e notes outstanding.

That vould snow the reserve, o n basis o f last seek, 5 2
per c e n t a g a i n s t deposits,

4 4 against f e d e r a l reserve n o t e s

in active circulation, b u t o n l y 8 0 per cent held b y the

agent a s reserve o r collateral against notes outstanding,
that i s t o s a y a i l t n e n o t e s t h a t a e h a s d e l i v e r e d

Federal Reserve bank,

t o the

I n other vords, i f the banks now

were t o “ut o u t a l l the notes i n their vaults t h e Federal
Reserve agents o f the system would aold only eightynper
cent o f the reserve o r collateral,

o r thatever y o u call it,

against the notes, B u t because the New York bank last week
had 168,000,000

i n its vaults i t made t h e technical reserve

of the agents 1 1 3 per cent o f t h e notes n o w outstanding.
Governor Harding:

S o m e years ago, i n the face o f

an emergency, t h e Board changed i t s method o f reporting
reserves, I

do not find anything i n the Federal Reserve

Act v a i c h r e q u i r e s t h e B o a r d t o r e p o r t r e s e r v e s p e r c e n t —

ages o n e w a y o r the other.

I t resuires certain information

in the weekly statements, w h i c h seema t o b e given.

Mr. Hamlin: I
which féxes a n y ratio.

agree vith taat. T h e r e i s no law


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

759

Governor Harding: H o w e v e r the public nas got these
reserves pretty well fixed i n its mind, a n d waen w e changed
the other w a y a n d made a

separate r e p o r t o f the reserve

against deposits a n d against note issues there w a s a reason
for it, a n d the press w a s not backward about commenting
on i t a n d there v a s more o r less talk o f juggling figures
and s o forth.
with a

N o w w e have come t o the reverse situation,

large holding o f gold.

I f y o u make another change

in t h e m e t h o d o f r e p o r t i n g t h e r e s e r v e s e v e r y w e e k y o u w i l l

get a great deal o f comment o n the subject, a n d I submit
for t h e consideration o f the Board t h e suestion o f #hether
it v o u l d b e v i s e e v e r y t i m e a

new situation o r emergency

arises i n one way or the other, t o change its established
method o f reporting the reserves. I

think i t vould have

a rather unfortunate effeot t o make any change under the
present situation.

Mr. Miller: T h e r e is a great deal of force to what
you say, Governor Harding, undoubtedly.

While I

am o%

the opinion that t h e reserve system i s going t o v e i n a
very p e r i l o u s D o s i t i o n u n t i l

i t does sometime w o r k o u t a

formal statement o f the reserve position that i t c a n stick
to through thick a n d think I think there h a s been i n the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

1*0

7

past d a n g e r s

6

i n the manipulation

and even though I

0

o f t h e reserve statements,

a m o f the ovinion that eventually v e have

got t o make, f o r our o m protection a n d i n order t o g e t
toe community i n step w i t h conditions v i t h which w e have

got t o deal, a n d with whish w e can deal eifectively only
as they a r e i n step with u s — - a form o f statement which
shows t h e n o t e r e s e r v e r a t i o s e p a r a t e a n d a p a r t f r o m t h e

deposit reserve ratio, s u c h a s we, after mature considera-

tion, announced i n our statement o f June 23, 1917, with a n
explanation t h a t i s just a s good today a n d vhich will
be just a s good t e n o r twenty years hence a s i t was then,
I think i t i s a

,ueation w h e t h e r n o w i s t h e o r o - e r time.

It seems t o m e i f y o u wait until conditions a r e more normal
that nobdody c a n c h a r g e y o u v i t h m a n i p u l a t i o n o f t h e figures.

Governga Harding: T h e r e i s nu manipulation o f the
figures,

ir, Viller: I

mean that tne public will get the

idea —- here i s a Board confronted vith u large volume o f
gold i n the Federal Reserve system, a n d some people a r e i n
favor o f raising t h e discount a n d some a r e not, a n d here
the Board has changed i t s form o f reporting reserves w i t h a
view o f producing certain results —


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Hardiig: ™ d o u b t e d l y that i s a subject for
consideration, b u t o n the other hand -—Me, Miller (interposing) T h e Federal Reserve s y s t e
has never developed a n y ruculty f o r icresignt.

T a i s is

@ toing that could aave b e e n dealt v i t h very easily t o
years a g 0 , W i t a v u t s t a r t i n g a n y comuent,

had the advantaze o f i t now, I

a n d v e ‘ould have

am airaid ‘nen w e get into

a coxtortable position again itvill b e forgotten. I

have

the same cbjsction Governor Harding urges against t a e
revision O i a

reserve state-ent, a n d even a more itorcible

objection against tais suggestion a s t o a state.ent. I

myself sould never, a s a vember o f tae Federal Reserve
Board, t a k e t h e resronsibility o f ‘utting o p t a

statement

of tiis character, icich i s open t o very serious objection
and great liabdility o f ziaconception.

B u t even a

statement

I thought wass:open t o less zisconstruction t a a n this,I

vould say vould b e zost inadvisable, t h e most inadvisable
thing v e c o u l d d o a t t a e p r e s e n t time.

T a e only publicity

that y o u vould g e t from i t would b e very undesirable pubiioity.

J u s t a s a matter o f tecaniyue, Governor Case,

you couldn't orint t:is o n a page - - h o v vould y o u send
YOu?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Taat footnote cov.ld b e very readily

WE Sieser: - Jou -coule net 7

t a a t Icotnote o n

page unless s30uetaing else #vas crowded out, o r unless w e
invented 2

longer vage.

T h a t would b e a perfectly numdrun

thing - -

Governor Harding:
Miller:

I t would o n l y b e crinted once.

I t vould b e o f intdrest o n l y w n e n i t waa

ong i f i t i s “rinted £5. tHe newspapers v e e k aiter
week i t would n o t o e o f a n y interest whatsoever.

I t

would b e a good deal like t h e veather reports i n California during t h e s u : m e r - fair tomorros, t h a t i s about
all, n o b o d y p a y i n g a n y a t t e n t i o n t o i t *hatsoever,
thing y o u v o u l d r e c e i v e

a

a n aitogetner w r o n g r e a c t i o n

t
o n it.

I think i t i s worth while t o ccnsider t c i s whncle situation
with a

view o f deteraing w h a t v e vill d o when w e get a con-

dition that i s favorable t o some action. I
this thing f o r years. I

have tnought

was interested i n looking a t cer-

tain memoranda yhich I prepared s i x years ago, w a i c n I
stumoled o n yuite accidentally, a n d I find that I
then v h a t I

tains n o w , I

taought

a m absolutely convinced t h a t

until t h e Federal Reserve banks understand clearly, f o r


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

their o w n good a n d t.eir o w n srotection, tnoat tney have
got t o s t a t e a

forz o t r e s e r v e ‘ o s i t i o n o f t h e b a n k s t h a t

helps t h e a

a

t

a

n cinders t h e s i n t h e verrormance

their duty a s credit adivinistrators, t h e y are going t o b e
in a n awkward vositicn.

D o e s anyone doubt, ‘ a c wasitn

the Federal Reserve system a t the time, t h a t i n 1213 t h e
thing that really scared t n e Federal Reserve banks a n d
Thich caused great interest i n tae positioncoz t h e
Federal Reserve banks i n the country a t large, W a s t h e
gradual descent o f our reserve ratio t o +40 per cent.

A s

we €0t there w e ineyv taat something n a d t o b e done, o r
that v e “Ould b e i n a n u n é o m f o r t a b l e p o s i t i o n ,

F o r my

o™m information I have cozputed a atatexent showing taat
"Aen tne reserve ratio o f t h e Federal Reserve banks would

have been d o m t o 40 per cent, o n tae dasis o f the 1319
figure, that i f v e had been operating o n t i s basis ~ - and
by a miracle i t tould have b e e n the xzonta o f November 4029)
we would have been d o m t o 4 2 per cent again, a n d that i n
July, 1519. w e would have b e e n more a n d nove 3eriocusly concerned a o o u t t h e c o s i t i o n o f t a e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e b a n k s

in

Telation t o t n e general credit situation t h a n a s a matter o f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

764
fact w e were, a n d t h a t m e r e d e v i c e w o u l d n a v e > r o b a b l y

given t h e Federal Reserve Board a

talking voint i n its

conferences vith the Treasury, that i t lacked a t the time.
I think tnere i s good reason t o believe that t h e aorrible
condition into taica w e drifted i n the e n d o f 1319 a n d 1920
iilpnt nave b e e n materially nitigated i f w e nad h a d a better
reserve statement, o n e that w a s sore educative t o the c o m
munity, a n d t o those right here i n t i s ouilding v i t h w h o m
we n a d t o deal, a n d I believe w e vould have h a d a reserve
that would have b e e n our a l l y rather t h a n our enemy —~Governor Seay:

Y o u mean that v e could have made

such a statement a t that time?
Mr, “iller: I

mean i f w e had done i n a t w e ougat t o

have done; i f instead o f tinkering v i t h t h e reserve ratio,
after v e had s e t u p o n mature congdderation a

form o f state-

ment vhich showed t h e note deposit ratio separately, s n o r t l y

after tie a-endient t o the act o f that year, i f v e had stood
by that tarcugh thick and thin, instead o f csanging —
Governor Seay:

I n view o f tae Treasury's attitude

on the Overman act, i s there anytaing that t h e Board could
have done i n that situation?
Mr. Milier: I

say tris —

I

say i n banking,

d o the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Tight thing,

T h e yuestion i s whether v e are #Oing t o have

@ Bank o f England o r vhether j e are going t o
Reichsbank
methods.

I n m y opinion t h e Bank o f England stood firm

veh thick a n d thin.

I t t h e public i s going t o look

at the reserve ratio, nave one that makes them look
in
the right direction instead o f tue #rong direction
—~I believe i f v e had adnered t o that a

lot o f this trouble

waich t h e country aas h a d i n the past tight
h a v e been
materially reduced,
Governor Harding:

I d o n o t kno#, a s long a s Wr,

Letiingwell w a s o f tue opinion h e was
--

Mr. Milier:

I i I vere ariting a aistory o f the
Fedpral

Reserve System vith a desire t o show its
Ppsycnology, I

should say that when it Shanged tae form of reserve statement

t h e Autumn o f 1917 t h a t t h e Board snoved
that i t

was i n a n intlationist i n its general point o f
view; i t
was beginning t o -vindow dress i t s statement.

Y o u can

say i t was done under tris pressure o r that pressure,
I

say

for the wost part i t was done because there were very few
men i n the Federal Reserve System a t that time that knew
anything about inflation o r the metaods b y which
inflation
finally puts iteelf across.

V e r y f e y z e n ever recognize.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

766
thexselves a s inflationists j u s t a s very f e w m e n recognize
themselves a s aabitual drunkards.
Governor Seay:

But I

don't understand n o w y o u could

have set u p any kind o f atatement t o ssov its condition
#aich would net have b e e n alarming.
Ee yelihiter:

W e nad a superb condition i n 1917.

Governor Seay: I

tanought y o u vere referring t o 1919,

at the height o f inflation.
Mr. Milier: I

said i i vse had carried over t n e 1917

form o f statement i n t o 1219 w e probably could nave avoided
some o f the conditions o f 1919.

Governor Harding: I
any d i t f e r e n s e

t o Wr, L e f i i n g y e l l ,

“Vr, Miller:
ence,

I

don't think tnat vould have made

I t vould have a d e a

great deal o f differ-—

t i s a terrible thing t o have t o admit - - a n d I

would n o t e x c e p t here, b e c a u s e I

nave s t a t e d j u s t t h e o p n o —

Site o t h e r v i s e w i t h a l w a y s a m e n t a l r e s e r v a t i o n t h a t I

had

stated m y o m personal soint o f v i e w — - but i t i s a terrible
thing t o a d m i t t a a t t a e o n l y t h i n g t h a t r e a l l y a w a k e n e d

us

was the fact that w e were i n sight o f the 40 ver cent ratio.
But v e were coming t o tae turn, a n d after v e came t o that
turn,

i n 1919, wtoen the Victory floatation w a s over, W e o u l d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

767

have h a d a talking coint t h a t + e lacked, a n d instead o f
shoving fifty-tw, f o u r a n d six, v e vould have showm probably forty-tso o r forty-four —

“e are i n g00d condition now, w h y not
do it?

Mr. “Miller: F o r she reason tnat Governor Harding
“oints out. I

would n o t take t h e caance o r doing it.

I think t h e taing c a n b e presented i n a way that reflects
credit

o n o u r i n t e g r i t y a n d u p o n o u r judgment,

b u t not

on t h e t n e o r y t n a t v e a r e g o i n g t o h e l p A m e r i c a n a g r i c u l t u r e

by helping i n the restoration o f the goid basis i n
Europe,

I think that vould b e a srong way. I

do not knov now the

others feel, b u t i f I vere going t e Present anything I
to

would sresent i t o n the ground o f restoring/the Federal
Reserve note i t s purchasing wuality, virtually a

gold cer-

tificate - - that i s something v e nave aone i n the past,
sometning w e have held u p a s a n ideal a n d sometnuing that

the American public vill take n o exception t o at all, I
believe.
Vice Governor Platt: A r t e r all, t n e people a a v e g o t
to get accustomed t o the fact. that t h e reserves a r e raised
or lowered w i t h regard t o different things, a n d not because o r


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

768

any one thing.

N

o iron clad rule can be laid d o m that

Will cover all conditions.

T h e y might just a s well know

that market conditions nowy demand increased rates,

i f they

do, a s t o knov that something else does too.
Mr, Silier:

T h a t i s perfectly rigat.

Woether y o u c o u l d w a k e 2

T s e yuestion i s

cocktail i t n o u t g i n , a n d t a i s i s

& gin cocktail.
Mr, Case::.

@ e are o u t o f step w i t h t h e public

moment a n d t h e y n e e d a

little education,

and I

a t this

thinx t h e y

are entitled t o look t c tae management o f the Federal Reserve
system a

little educational light a t tnis time.

Dr,

Miller has r e f e r r e d t o tae situation v h e n t h e reserve
ration ¢

d o w n t o + 0 p e r cent, t h a t t h e r e w a s a

of talk a n d discussion;

preat d e a l

n o w tsis year i t i s just t h e reverse,

it i s 7 5 o r 7 6 per cent a n d the average verson cannot under—stand w h y v e s h o u l d b e t h i n k i n g o f h i g h r a t e s v i t h t a a t

réserve ratio.

i t does sees t o m e if, without changing

the f o r m o f statement,

w e could make s o m e s o r t o f statement

to t h e p u b l i c — ~ n o t n e c e s s a r i l y o n e t h e c o n f e r e n c e n a s

suggested, b u t some sort o f statement - - i f w e could tell
the people that while x e have drained Europe's billion o f
gold that presently i t vill f l o v back, a n d w e should have


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Enat i r wind.

It i s a very ,uestionable tning,on t h e

ofaa banking system like ours, t o predicate a policy
& possibility t h a t m a y o r m a y n o t m a t e r i a l i z e ,

and

may o r m a y n o t b e remote.
Governor S e a y :

M r . Hoover thinks

i t i s more o r

imminent,

“gz, Willer: Y e s , a n d ur. Hoover's opinion i s cer~
tainly t o be taken vith great seriousness,
others tnat d o not agree w i t h him,

T h e r e are

I t i s a speculative

mattsr.
Vice G o v e r n o r Platt: I

both ways.

think t h e r e a t e P o s s i b i l i t i e s

I t seems toa me conceivable, possible, although

not probable, t h a t t h e Reichbank m a y give u p the ghost a n d

we would get all of their gold over nere. Consequently
I think the people have got to be taught that we may raise
or l o w e r t h e r a t e wvithout r e f e r e n c e

Governor Seay:

t o t h e r e s e r v e ratio,

W i t h respect t o Mr. Case's statement

it s s e m s t o m e t h a t t h e r e a r e s o m e p o e s i b i l i t i o s

i n the situa—

tion vaich might point tovsard a curtuner increase
i n the

reserve bank rates. I

do not say tnis a s a prophecy,

but i t i s conceivable t h a t i f the alarm
c f tne economists

is justifiable, that unless some eduational
>ropaganda
‘= something o f that nature,

o r o f similar character,

is

Dut out i n advnace o f ispending naigher reserve
ratio o f
toe Federal Reserve banks, a n d i t becomes
necessary t o
Taise t h e rates without a n y such educational
Propaganda,
you ¥ o u l d a a v e a

unless I

very c o n s i d e r a b l e r o l i t i c a l e x p l o s i o n ,

at very ereatly mistaken,

Mr, Willer: I

think whatever v e may think i t i s

desirable t o d o among ourselves, t n a t i t
i s a Brave yuestion
of what i s desirable t o inform t h e public a s
t o what w e are
doing,
Governor Seay:

W i t h refernece t o what some o f
uc

were inclined t o think a s a necessity, a n d
perhaps a n ur—
gent necessity,

o f giving t h e public 4

little better under—

standing than i t has o f the credit situation
o f the country,

I will say that the 4 4 per cent rate nas
caused more dis—
cussion than anything that h a g occurred
vithin t h e past

tWo years —

just a n increase o f a half o f a par cent
on

the p a r t o f t h r e e T e s e r v e b a n k s
is a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

matter o f d i s c u s s i o n

all over t h e country,
Mr, Miller:

I t wasnt™t a matter o f discussion because

it Was a n increase o f a nalf a

per cent, b u t i t was a matter

of discussion because i t t a s tne first Change i n direction
~~
you h a d c o m e t o a

stop, a n d n o # y o u W e r e g o i n g o n ,

Governor Seay:

I t occurred a t a tixze v e m t h e reserve

ratio w a s very high a n d notwithstanding that high
reserve
Tatio.

f t i s conceivable t h . t i t m a y b e necessary t o
do

the same taing again and unless there i s a n understanding
on
the part o f tae public o f the real underlying
reasons, s o m e —
what disclosed b y the Suggestion submitted, t h e r e
vill, inf
my judgment,

b e some oublic apprehension, a n d i t m a y b e o f

& disturbing character, that reserve bank rates have been

influenced by things outside of economic conditions, I
believe that i t is desirable t o inform the puolic —
Mr. Miller: I

think i t is —

Governor Seay: P a r d o n me, I am speaking o f the statement v e have submitted, +vhich y o u said y o u thougkt would b e
misleading a n d undesirable.

Mr, Miller: Y e s ,
Governor Seay:

T h a t particular statement, pernaps,

or something o f that charactery, I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

believe wery firmly i s

Do y o u t h i n k i t i s d e s i r a b l e

t o make

sometaning o f that kind a part o f a weekly conditional
Statement?

W h a t would y o u think i f y o u s a v a statement c o m

ing over from t h e Bank o f England -—~ this i s their discount
day, Thursday — - vhat yould y o u think o f a published statement
by them with a footnote o f tnis kind? I

sould begin t o

think that t h e Bank o f England h a d Torgotten i t s great
protective tradition a n d v a s going t o follow t a e lead o f the
Reichsbank,
Governor Seay:

I n thatever fori i t i s put cut there

is desiracility o f repetition,

I

t i s getting t o b e xore

and “ o r e t h e o p i n i o n o f m a n y p e o v l e t h a t v e d o h o l d t r i s

excess g o l d reserve, w a i c h has come t o u s from many causes,
partly i n trusteeship,

T h a t opinion i s aradually spreading

all over t h e country a n d I

do not think i t does a n y harm t o

emphasize i t nuw and taen, because a s sure a a
come a
panded,

time n e n o u r c r e d i t s i t u a t i o n i s s o r e o r l e s s e x a n d i f o n top o f that there comes a

demand f o r o u r

gold for export then w e will have a situation <vhich vill I
think a c c e l e r a t e o u r p a c e dowmvward.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. M i l l e r :

I t is a

matter o f opinion.

Persomally I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

773
have n o respect f o r a n y statexzent, a n d lieast o f all that o f
a Federal Reserve bank, t h a t h a s a n y embroidery around it.
Talk a l l y o u want outside;

v e nave monthly bulletins a n d

Teserve bulleting; s a k e speeches a n d talk a l l y o u want, b u t
when y o u come t o a Federal Reserve bank statement, I

want

that t o b e a plain matter o f fact statement.
Me. Case:

I

f t h e Board does n o t desire

t o out out

a footnote - - I infer o y wnat y o u s a y a n d vith your feeling
about it, d&. Miller,
ation,

i t might wery properly give consider-

i n view o f t h e fact t h a t here a r e tvelve Governcrs

from all over the country - - to give consideration t o pub—
lisning t h a t e v e r

i s desirable

i n t x i s statezent t h a t t a e

Governors fave passed on to the Board, and wich was
rather c a r e f u l l y prepared,

a n d let t h e rest go. I

think

if the Board ‘ould give consideration t o that i t would b e
helpful.
Vice Governor Platt:

note i s concerned, I

S o far a s »utting i t i n a foot-

do not taink the nevspapers would carry

it a s a rule.
Mr, Case: T a n e y would carry i f i f the Board p u t i t

Governor Harding: But tney vould carry it only once,

Vice G o v e r n o r Platt:

frou t h e Governurs, I

S u t a s t h e ststement c o m e s

do n o t knov¥, W i t h relation t o that

billion dollars o f gold, “hether i t w u l d n o t b e well
to
Publish i t .

Mr. Millegr

I f that i s your View, I

would s a y t o re—

The Federal Reserve l i e t i n .

t n e short issue.

woich w i l l b e r e a d y f o r r e l e a s e T u e s d a y d e a l s v e r y
largely i n

sold under certain conditions;

w e could o u t i t i n there,

and y o u vill g e t a l l y o u vant. I

thinx y o u ¥ili get sore.

My own vies is not t o do it, but i f tae conference wants
to
do i t i t c a n b e u t
Governor Seay:

i n the bulletin.
O

f ccurse this t a s submitted t o tae

Board f o r consideration, b u t t a e discussicn toat
z e had o n
tne t o p i c w a s t h a t a

statement

o f that k i n d w o u l d b e bene-

pSEa oS i
Mr. V i l l e r : I

w o u l d s a y i t i s important. I

not r e s p o n s i b l e f o r t n i s d i s c u s s i o n ,

am

h i c h vossibly i s

more o r less futile; b u t a s i t i s a n imoortant matter i t
can easily b e disposed o f [I Should a a y if, i n a
press state—
ment given out, i t stated that t h e conference h e r e
nad
considered t h e f o r m o f s t a t e m e n t

o f reserve Position a n d

concluded t h a t t n e t i m e w a s a u s p i c i o u s

t o return t o t h e

form o f statement adopted o y the Federal Reserve
Board afthes—


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

775

lately after t h e amendment t o the Federal Reserve A c t i n

June, 1:18, shen our gold xoeition vas a very strong one,
and taen follox that u p perhaps i n a #eek o r tio o r three
vith the statement that i t i s the belief that t h e reserve
Tatio gustthe revamped f o r m o r restored f o r m has a
far beyond t h e o l d form.as a
credit conditions.

value

veek t o veek index o f

A t a n y rate t h e matter w i l l have t o

be d o n e b y t h e B o a r d — -

Governor Seay: Y e s , a n d that i s the reason v e referred i t t o the Board,
wr, Miller:

I t w#ili have t o b e done b y the Board,

What Governor Harding said i s very important a n d I am not
sure t h a t i t i s n o t f a t a l

t o a n y n e w deparature

a t this

time o F a n y return t o old prac tices, because o f the mis—

construction i t will give rise to; but I am certain i n m y
mind, ur, Case, a n d I think y6u sould b e i f you had travelied ayay from the seaboard into t h e country, where Europe's
gold standard i s a matter o f n o concern whatever, b u t i f

we give a n e«planation o f the restoration o f gold coverage
for Federal Reserve notes, a s against the resotration o f
the gold standard i n Europe, I
one t o e x p l a i n a n d a

think that would b e t h e safer

better o n e t o a d o p t —


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

776

Governor Harding:

But I

aore some w a y c a n b e de-

Vised b y Which publicity thrthghaveouhrefer c a n b e a c c o m
Plished.

T h e business

o f tne country knows that t h e

Board i s conferring s i t h the Governors o n urgent matters
and I think i t vould b e a n oprortuné t i m e t o make a
tatexent t h a t w u l d create t h e right k i n d o f a n impress-—

do y o u suggest? N e w s i s scarce

May I make a

Governor Harding: I

think a

frank suggestion?

ccarefully prepared

Sstatexzent b y the Board, d u l y a n d -roverly Millerized sould
o
e
just adout T i x the thing u p right.
Governor Norris: I

a m very much interested b y what

we ate getting i n several ways indicating the sentiment
that i t i s undesirable

t o have cianges

rate upwards, b u t i t has a

i n the discount

disturbing effect, a n d I

am

wondering t h a t v e change t h e discount r a t e upsard f o r i f
it isn't t o have a

disturbing effect.

Vice G o v e r n o r Platt:
increase

M y personal o p i n i o n i s t h a t t h e

i n the Federal Reserve r a t e h a s already b e e n dis—


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

12%

counted, a n d y o u would s e e t h e stock market g o u p tomorron
if t a e r a t e s w e r e i n c r e a s e d today.

Governor Harding:

T h e r e i s anotner tnaing t o consider

in connection v i t h the discount rate, a n d that i s a n y statement that y o u m a y give o u t about t h e proceedings o f the
conference a n d the operations o f the Treasury n o w has a
much more direct a n d more intimate affectonn t h e money mar—

ket than i t used t o have, then rates were arbitrary and not
attempted t o be related t o reserve rates.

W e all realize

nov that the Treasury operations a r e a n important factor
and must be, o n account o f tne collection o f income taxes,

the payment o f matured securities, a n d the issuing o f new
securities a n d all that.

I

t ssems t o m e that a n y con-

sideration o f a change i n the discount rates a t any ir-—
portant bank, o r with the system a s a whole h a s z o t t o
oe considered w i t a relation t o the Treasury operations — —

not vith a view of adjusting your rate simply and purely
for t h e convenience o f the Treasury, b u t considering t h e
Treasury a s a n important f a c t o r
tion,

Wr. Case:

V e r y important,

i n the general m o n e y situa—


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

778

Governor Harding:

I t seems t o me, # i t h the under—

Secretary o f t h e Treasury fere, t h a t i f n e cares to,

hewight give us his views as to the croper time, other
hings being equal, w i t h reference t o Treasury operations,
when these changes i n rates should b e made, whether i m —
mediately f o l l o v i n g a n i m p o r t a n t T r e a s u r y operation,

o r

immediately preceding i t o r i n between times,
Mr, Gilbert:

M r . Chairman, I

think Governor

Harding i s suite right i n pointing o u t that t h e Treasury
operations

a r e a

factor

i n the situation a n d that t h e y

have t o b e taken into account,
disturbing t o have a

a t least.

unfair

t i s most

change i n discount rate either immed=

iately preceding o r immediately fcltiving.
it i s unfair I

i

I f i t precedes

think t o the Treasury a n d i f i t follows i t i s

t o t h e people t h o purchase t n e certificates,

cdhave already stated,

a n d as

w e are out o f t h e market n o w for

nearly t w o months a n d I should s a y that a n y changes t o b e
made b y the Federal Reserve bank, a n d realize t h a t conditions m a y arise under v n i c h t h e Federal Reserve banks m z y
want t o make a change, t h a t t h e y vould come better somewhere
around t h e middle o f April, w h e n the market w i l l have opvor-

tunity t o readjust itself, between the change i n the rates


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

and tne time w h e n the Treasury operations v i l l nave t o b e
financed,

A

n announcement o f the M a y operations # i l l prob-

ably h i v e t o c o m e r a t h e r early.

early i n May.

W

e m a y vant t o come o u t

7 e oad planned t o come o u t sometime shortly

after the first o f May, s o that around bhe middle o f April
is the natural t i m e -—- any time betveen n o w and the wsiddle
of April vould b e the natural time s o far a ; r e a s u r y opera—
tions go.
That i s something vhich should always

Governor Harding:

would lixe t o ask.

- T h e r e i s one other .uestion I

I s i t the Board's v i e r tnat, i f a n y

adjustment o f discount rates i s t o b e made, t h a t i t has
got t o b e general throughout t h e system,
immediate future,

i f made i n the

o r i s i t possible t h a t t h e wueation wight

arise i n one Particular district w a i c n vould call f o r a

re~

adjustment o f rates i n that district witnout calling for
corresponding a c t i o n i n other districts.
Vice G o v e r n o r P l a t t :

T h e Board h a s never h e l d that

uniform rates v e r e absolutely essential,

b y a n y means.

Governor Harding: H e r e i s the idea that o c c u r r e d +
p
If i n a n y o n e d i s t r i c t

certain c o n d i t i o n s s e e m t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

750

Teauire a d v a n c e

i n the discount rate w o u l d i t b e vise

to t r y out t h e operation w i c h would follov, w i c h ‘ o u l d
be analagous i n pre-war days t o a raise i n the rates b y
tne Bank o f England o r the Bank o f France, w a i c h checks
the I l o w o f f u n d s f r o m o n e c o u n t r y t o a n o t h e r . — — s u p p o s e

a district h a d a situation, v . i c h i t desired t o influence
one W a y o r t h e o t h e r b y a d v a n c i n g i t a r a t e s ? i

canlt

see the first effect o f that might b e t o bring about t h e
result desired; t h e n a little later on, o n the principle
that ~oney flows t o the Best investment market, t h e higher
rates i n that district w o u l d attract iunds f r o u other
sections o f the country, a n d then o f course there vould b e
@ reason t o r advancing t h e rates i n other districts t o
check that flow, a n d that imight immediately bring about
a sharp reaction a n d have t h e opposite effect froze what
you wanted t o produce.
Governor Calkins:

I s n ' t i t true that while there i s

an occasional f l o w o f funds f r o m Governor Bailey's district
to N e w York, there i s very seldom a

flow o f funds f r o m N e w

York t o Governor Bailey's district,
Governor iicDougal:

I n regard t o this rate situation

I a m sorry t h a t v e have n o t h a d a n opportunity

t o discuss w i t h


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

(goth
the Board t h e conditions i n each distriadt a s i t has been
discussed i n conference s e r e a n d I think i t i s perfectly
Tight f o r m e t o s t a t e t h a t i n t h e m a j o r i t y o f t h e d i s t r i c t s
it w a s felt. t h a t t h e r e w a s n o o c c a s i o n f o r a n increase

the rates. I

in

feel that i t might b e -roper t o say that

in Chicago w e save been considering this matter f o r a t

least t¥o xontos.

Y e have felt the time tas come wnen

should b e given t o some advance i n the rates,

Our board, a t the last meeting, held tne Friday before I
ileft felt that rather t h a n a c t a t that time i t would b e only
proper t o wait until w e found what t h e concensus o f opinion
was here.

T h a t i s all I nave t o s a y o n the subject.

There i s one matter w i t h respect t o which I think w e

had better reach a n understanding and that i s tnis: A s s u m i n g
that t n e Board has concluded that t h e present committee o f

Governors isa to be disbanded, that i s tne committee that has
been handling o p e n market transactions a n d Government securji~—

ties, a n d have recommended that another committee b e apoointed.,
I would a s k t h e Board a s t o their pleasure

i n the manner o f

the appointment o f tais committee. O r i g i n a l l y t n e committee
was a p c o i n t e d

a t t h e i n s t a n c e o f t h e B o a r d b y t a e Governor,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I vould l i k e t o have t h a t c l e a r e d up.
Mr, M i l l e r :

W h a t b a n k s a r e represented?

Governor McDougal: B o s t o n , N e w York, Philadelphia,
Cleveland, a n d Chicago.
Mr. “iller: I

saould s a y t h a t i s a

Vice Governoz Platt: I

ssould think v e vould g o Tight

sage committee,

Seay:

good committee,

b u t simply under a

n e w name,

D o e s t h e Board desire t h e conference

utcommittee?
sicht gust a s well.
Governor “cDcugal: I

think « a f t h e Board sould

Suggest that i t stand a s i t i s i t sould b e nerfectly satis—
factory.
I move t h a t t o e c o m m i t t e e y o u h a v e

named b e suggested t o the Board a s t h e comsittee t o have
charge o f open market operations, M r . Chairman.
Governor McKinney: I

second that,

(The motion being duly seconded was carried, )
Governor “cDougal: “ i r . Chairman, t h e recommendation
of the conference i s that t h e same committee b e permitted t o
Operate

i n i t s n e v capacity,

Vice Governor Platt:

T h e Board accepts t h e recoumendatar


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

783

There s e e m s t o b e n o o b j e c t i o n

the Board,

o n the part o f a n y member o f

s o i t vili b e understood that t h e com#ittee i s

appointed.
If there i s nothing further t o come up, i t mis suggested

that w e take the first varagraph o f the press statement which
has been suggested b y the Governors,

s o that i t will read:

"During t h e s e m i ~ a n n u a l C o n f e r e n c e

o f Governors,

which c l o s e d today, t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e Board,

a s usual,

gitn the Governors uwany matters o f operation,

including the amendments t o the Federal Reserve Act contained i n the Agriculural Credits Act, changes i n the Board's
regulations made necessary b y these auzsndments, t h e open
market o p e r a t i o n s
operation.

A

o f t h e System,

s usual,

a n d m a n y matters

o f routine

t h e Board also discussed v i t a t h e

Governors t h e varicus factors #nich enter i n t o t h e consider-—
ation o f t n e credit policy o f t h e System, s u c h a s general

economic and financial conditions, t h e condition o f the reserves, o p e n market rates f o r various classes o f paper, t h e
demand f o r credit a n d the volume o f credit i n use, g o l d
movements, present a n d prospective,"
I think t h e Governors,
discuss t h e reserve rate, I

a s they g o home, should n o t
know y o u d o not d o that anyway,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

but y o u snaculd not give a n y moze basis t o these numerous
rumors t h a t h a v e b e e n a f l o a t . +

Governor Seay:

T h a t i s one taing w e never do.

Vice Governcer P l a t t :
a condentrabibnkdictelegrams
why.

A

t tne present t i m e there i s

a n d things. I

do not k n o w

I t i s evidentsthat t h e newspapers h a v e b e e n talking

about r a t e s f o r s o m e t i m e a n d t h e r e n a z p e n e d

t o come a

break

in the stock market, a n d so.e exolanation h a d t o b e found
for i t and then here w a s tnis conference o f Governors coming
on right a t this time, and, o f course, t h e y must have dons
it.

N o w i f nothing happens immediately after this, per-—

haps t h e y m i g h t c o n c l u d e t h a t c t h e r

fluence o n it.
Mr. Miller:

W i t h tnat condition o f sind i n the

country now, w h e n pecple a r e attaching exaggerated istmort—
ance t o what w e may d o o r vhat w e may not d o a n d what w e
may h a v e i n contemplation, I

think t h e u t m o s t c a r e o u g h t

to b e exercjsed o y the Governors o f the banks i n preventing
any 2ossible leakage.

T h e r e have b e e n leaks a n d leaks

in t h e s y s t e m i n t h e p a s t a n d t h a t m u s t b e controlled,

otnervise w e are going t o g e t into a

o r

predicament here, o f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

pin l A

R I O

O O r

e

r

case

the k i n d s e a a d &

short t i m e a g o , a n d t h e y w i l l c o m e i n

increasing numbers,

i

f th

p

r

e

s

s

e

d they may

d actually b u i l d a-fire

erve System a n d vould t r y t o force u s into
sonetnhing o r force u s into a
as @ commitment,

declaration t h a t could b e used

i n the future.

Vice Governor Platt; I

a m almost inclined t o think

the opening paragraph vitn regard t o routine
would b e well t e send out, telling t o e m a

little b i t

aoout vhat t h e y are, s o that their minds vould probably b e
diverted into other chanzels.
Governor S e a y :

T h e majority o f t h e rumors w i t h

reference t o the discount r a t e emanate f r o m Washington.
Mir. Miller:

from elsewhere,

T h e y emanate f r o m here, b u t t h e y come i n

I t is said the recent rumor originated i n

Chicago.

Mr, Case: M r , Chairman, this i s a very imoortant
matter, T h e r e i s a little article i n tne N e w York Tribune
yesterday that i g really worth reading, becuase i t snows
ne g r e a t i n t e r e s t t h a t t n e p u b l i c has.
to say?

"fae expected statement f r o m t a e Federal Reserve Board,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

which has been conferring a t “asnsington wWitn tae governors

of the twelve banks, came yeeterday, o u t its content was
hardly t h a t h a d been anticipated,

I t took t n e t o r m o f

a blmket denial o f all rumors regarding projected action
and a reyuest f o r inforwation a s t o their source,

T a e

board declared that i t sould itself m a k e such announcements
as i t deemed advisacle a n d that n o one else v a s autnorized
to speak f o r it, B y implication t h e statement indicated
that a n offense h a d been committed,
preted i n the financial district.

o r s o i t was inter—
A

n offense against

what? Against t h e dignity o f the Federal Reserve Board?
Certainly there h a s been n o other offense t h a n this, u n —
less i t b e that f o r t h e financial community t o form a n
ovinion a n d express i t i s a crime where athe bank rate i s
concerned. S u b s t a n t i a l l y t h e same financial a n d economic
data are available f o r general consideration a s for consideration b y the Federal Reserve authorities, w h o c a n
hardly expect t h e financial district t o believe that t h e y
have gathered together t o talk o f inccnse.juential things.
It i s i n t h e r e a c t i o n o f m e n ' s m i n d s t o t h i s d a t a a n d t o

the meeting taat t h e rumors have h a d their source a n d n o
one has attempted t o sprak f o r the board."


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

787

Vice Governor Platt: D i s c u s s i o n i s going o n con~

stantly now, a n d you cannot stop it.
Governor Calkins: G e n t l e m e n , I
submit:

aave a

motion t o

" I t i s zoved a n d seconded that t h e conference

express t o Governor McDougal its thanks and its appreciation o f his unfailing courtesy a n d tact i n conduttigeg,
this meeting."
(The w o t i o n h a v i n g b e e n d u l y s e c o n d : d w a s u n a n i m o u s l y

carried.)
Vice Governor Platt:

N o w gentlemen i f there i s

by
nothing «wore t o be considered/tnis conference the Chair
Will entertain a

motion t o adjourn.

("hereupon, a t 6:30 o'clock D.m., upon motion duly

seconded, the conference adjourned.)


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis