View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

a

i

PROCEEDINGS


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

OF A

O F THE FEDERAL RESERVE B O A R D

CONFERENCE

WITH THE

GOVERNORS

O F THE FEDERAL RESERVE B A N K S

ASSEMBLY R O O M
FEDERAL R E S E R V E B O A R D
METROPCLITAN B A N K BUILCING
WASHINGTON, D, C. —

APRIL 8, 1820 .

H L H PECHIN’

LUCIUS M. HULL” >
9.6, DISMUKES

M

A

I

N 4309

" W A L T E R $.COX
R O B E R T F. ROSE

ASSOCIATED SHORTHAND REPORTERS
SUITE 16-23 A P P E A L S BUILDING.

426 F I F T H S T R E E T , N. Ww.

WASHINGTON, D.C.

SECOND DAY.

Thursday, April 8th, 1920.

The C o n f e r e n c e r e a s s e m b l e d p u r s u a n t t o s d j o u r n m e n t

at

10 o'clock «. M.
Present:

Hon. David Franklin Houston, Secretary o f the
Treasury.

Hon. W. P. G. Harding, Governor o f the Federal
Neserve B o a r d .

Hon. Charles & . Hamlin, Member o f the Federal
Reserve Board.

Hon. Adolph C, Miller, Member o f the Federal
Reserve Board.
Hon. H e n r y A. Mohlenpah, Member o f the Federal
Reserve Board.

Hon. John Skelton Williams, Comptroller o f the
Currency, ex-officio member o f the Federal Reserve Board.
Present a l s o
The Governors o f the Federal Reserve B a n k a s

indicated o n yesterday.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman, (Governor McDougal). G e n t l e m e n , t h e
meé ting will please c o m e t o order.
Mr, Secretary Houston a n d Governor Harding, having
in m i n d y o u r e x p r e s s r e q u e s t

t o b e present w h e n w e dis-

cuss t h e topic o f credit control, while w e considered i t
very i n f o r m a l l y yesterday,

n o a c t i o n w a s t a k e n o r definite

concluSion reached, c o n s e q u e n t l y t h e d i s c u s s i o n w i l l b e a

general o n e this morning, a n d I think perhaps t h e best

course t o take would b e t o go around the table and ask
each of the Governor's opinions with regard t o the points
involved.

l. C R E D I T CONTROL.
The Chéirman. G o v e r n o r Wellborn, what has been the
effect o f recent rate increase u p o n liquidation i n your
district?

Governor Xellborn. I

cannot s a y that there has been

any appreciable effect o n lijuidation.

J I think i t has h a d

a splendid effect i n our district a n d h a s been a warning
to the bankers a n d t o the public.

T h e banks have ceased

to discount p a p e r f o r p r o f i t w i t h u s .


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman, G o v e r n o r Miller?

Governor Miller. M r . Chairman, t h e increase i n rate

has, I

think, h a d some effect; b u t i n spite o f the increase

in rate o u r loans have increased, t h e member banks claiming,
however,

aS a

cause, l a c k o f facilities

t o transport products

which are still h e l d i n the country a n d cannot g e t t o
market t o b e realized upon. I

think, though, t h e increase

ia the rate w o u l d have a n effect i f things w e r e normal,

if

transport: n
o
i
t was normal,

The Chairman. G o v e r n o r Young, what has been the
effect o f r a t e i n c r e a s e u p o n L i q u i d a t i o n i n . your d i s t r i c t ?

Governor Young. I

a m satisfied t h a t t h e rate i n -

erease produced some liquidation i n our district.

This

should b e t h e p e r i o d o f t h e y e a r w h e n w e a r e n o t l o a n i n g

any money t o banks i n our district, b u t because o f transportation w e are loaning a lot o f money.
lst

w e have reduced

S i n c e December

i n our o w n district approximately

624,000,000, although i t has inereaseq within the last
week.

~ L a m sure that the banks i n the disvrict are using

more caution t h a n they d i d before w e raised t h e rate t o

6%, s o I am satisfied that the raise o f rate has had a good
effect i n our district a n d has produced some Liquidation.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman,

G o v e r n o r Fancher, w h a t h a v e y o u t o

Governor Fancher.

T h e raise i n rate, w e think, h e s

had a n appreciable effect i n district No. 4 .

O u r high

peak- o
f borrowing n u n u s b y member banks w a s ree ched o n
December 2 3 r d , l a r g e l y b e c a u s e

o f t h e payment o f taxes

on

December 15th. S i n c e t h a t time, comparing totals w i t h «pril

Sth, w e have had liquidation o f about $31,000,000.

T h e

beorrowings o f our member banks were that much less o n April
1 as compared with December 23rd. T h i s has been brought
about i n the face o f a good deal o f congestion o f transportation a n d inability t o move products t h e t a r e ready for
market.

I t has h a d t h e further e f f e c t o f putting t h e bor-

rower i n a rather different frame o f mind with his bank.

I think the borrower has got the message, and, I think,
instead o f assuming t o make commitments, t h e matter h a s
first b e e n taken u p with t h e bank t o ascertain whether t h e
credit should b e granted. I

think t h e increase i n rates

has served @ very good purpose a n d hasbrought about r e a l
Liquidation.

Q u r district i s not a district that h a s

extreme seasonal demands,

I t i s largely manufacturing a n d

our demands run along pretty steadily, s o thet we feel
rether gratified over o u r situation, a n d w e think t h e
raising o f the rates h a s helped t h e matter very, v e r y


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

materially.

The Chairran.

G o v e r n o r Biggs, w i l l y o u speak f o r

the St.Louis district w i t h regard t o the effect o f the r e cent r a t e i n c r e a s e u p o n l i q u i d a t i o n ?

Governor Liges. T h e r e h a s been n o liquidation b u t
very heavy inflation,

t o the estent o f about forty p e r cent,

since t h e rate w a s reised. I

do not think that was d u e t o

the raising o f the rates a t all, b u t for 4a great m a n y years
it has b e e n the custom o f the Nest a n d Southwest t o build
up the ir bank balances, a n d t h e large commercial banks h a v e
been f u l l o f m o n e y a n d h a v e l o o k e d f o r c h e a p money.

They

are always looking f o r cheap money i n January, f r o m the
15th o f January o n until t h e 1 5 t h o f March, a n d quite a
few o f our banks a r e loaded u p heavily with commercial
papers a n d w e a r e h a v i n g t o c a r r y them,

The Chairman.
banks

‘ T h a t has been t h e situation i n your

a t this s e a s o n o f t h e y e a r f o r t h e l a s t five o r ten

years?

Governor Biggs.

I t has always b e e n easy.

I t

has always b e e n very easy, g o i n g back fifteen years.
have a l w a y s l o o k e d f o r e a s y m o n e y t h e r e ,

T h i s time i t

was rather a n d exception a n d i t rather fooled them.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

W e

The Chairman,

T o what d o y o u attribute t h e radical

change?
Governor Biggs.

Well,

i t was their mistake i n think-

ing their deposits were going t o increase, while some o f
them have gone o f f a good deal. A n o t h e r thing, t h e y d i d not
anticipate a

raise i n the rates,

o r some o f them did not.

They were getting paper a t five a n d three quarter a n d s i x
per cent a n d t h e y could borrow f r o m u s a t four a n d o n e
half, a n d w e are carrying a great m a n y commodities s u c h a s
rice, l u m b e r ,

a n d c o t t o n w h i c h h a s n o t moves, w h i c h h a s

been caused largely b y inability t o sell, and the car
shortage.
The Chairman. Governor Calkins, c a n w e hear from you?
T h e question i s the effect o f the

Governor Calkins,

recent rate increase u p o n liquidstion?
The Chairman, Y e s .
Governor Calkins.
effect i n our district. I

T h e r e h a s b e e n n o appreciable
think there h e s b e e n some i n -

clinination t o regard t h e warning given b y the increase i n
rate, b u t s o far a s t h e effect itself i s concerned i t i s

negligible o r absent.

T h e seasonal demands i n our dis-

trict a r e being anticipated, a n d t h e tendency a t the pres-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ent time i s t o increase demands upon the Federal Reserve
Bank.
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r V a n Zandt?

Governor Van Zandt, T h e r e has been n o effect b y

the recent raise i n rate upon liquidation i n our district
unless i t be, a s sugsested b y Governor a i g uie. t h a t t h e y
think t h e y Will b e further increased a n d are getting i n
now a n d b o r r o w i n g f o r l a t e r

rates.

i n the season a t the present

T h e r e h a s been a n increase, f r o m December 3 1 s t t o

April lst, i n our loans o f about 4 5 per cent, which i s
almost double w h a t t h e increase w a s a t the same season last

yeer; a little over double; i t was about 21 per cent last
yeer. I

cannot s a y that the recent rate increase h a s

stopped borrowing s t all i n our district.
The Chairman,
upon ligquidation

T h a t effeet has t h e increase h a d

i n N e w York, G o v e r n o r C a s e ?

Acting Governor Case,

I t is the judgment o f the of-

ficers and directors o f the New York Bank that the rate
increase h a s been effective, t h a t the marking u p o f the

rates was a stenal to the banks of which they have taken
notice, a n d the first effect i n the course o f sixty days
was t o reduce t h e borrowings

i n the country banks a n d

concentrate i t more i n the c i t y banks. S e v e r a l o f the

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

large c i t y banks t h a t owed u s comparatively little t h e first
of the year are n o w owing u s rather large amounts.
It has b e e n o u r practice t o discuss t h e credit sitvation with them from time t o time freely, a n d w e d o feel

that the rate i s having its effect.
indicated,

A s has @lready been

i t has doubtless caused some borrowing i n an-

ticipation o f future requirements, b u t w e d o think that
the marking u p o f the rate h a s b e e n very wholesome a n d

effective, a n d our judgment i s that s o fer a s our district
is concerned i t will n o t b e necessary t o mark t h e rates
higher a t the moment.

I have noticed here from figures that were furnished
me that the borrowings o f fifty-four o f the New York City

banks were {,675,000,000 on January 2nd and $639,000,000
on March 19th. T h e aggregate loans o f those banks have
been reduced f r o m {.5,600,000,000 t o {,5,300,000,000.

The

percentage o f reletion o f borrowed money t o reserves was
one hundred p e r cent i n January and ninety eight p e r cent

on March 19th.

I n other words, w e think w e can see some

real liquidation, t h a t t h e p o i s o m i
s working v e r y quietly
and slowly, b u t still i t i s working.
The Chairman. I

take i t from that, Mm. Case, t h a t

you a t t r i b u t e t h e s u b s t a n t i a l L i q u i d a t i o n y o u h a v e h a d t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

the increase i n the rate?
Acting Governor Case,
The Chairman,

W

e do, yes.

I t has resulted i n the shifting o f bor-

row ings ?

Acting Governor Case. Y e s sir.

w e were loaning

over four hundred banks i n November a n d t h e number n o w h a s
been reduced about twenty five p e r cent,
banks.

A

S I

say,

t o three hundred

i t i s concentrated m o r e o r less

i n the

city banks,
The Chairman,

Y o u aré loaning three hundred banks

out o f whut total?
Acting Governor Case. ‘ T e n hundred banks i n the district, s e v e n hundred o d d member banks.

The Chairman. G o v e r n o r liorss, what has the effect
of the increase r a t e b e e n upon liquidation i n your district?
Governor lorss,
Vecember,

T h e high point o f our loans w a s last

w h e n i t was v e r y h i g h indeed,

great m a n y factors,

d u e t o taxes a n d a

I n fact, w e s e e m t o have i n our dis-

trict a high point just before t h e l s t o f January and just
weeers t h e e t O r u l y .
loands reduced, a n d a

A f t e r t h e l s t o f January our
e

o f the terrible storms w e

have h a d a n d t h e i n t e r r u p t i o n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

t o transportation,

w e

have had quite a high point again i n February. S i n c e
that time o u r loans have h a d a tendency t o reduction
consistently a n d i t has gotten d o w n n o w t o quite normal
conditions f o r t h i s s e a s o n .

T h i s is the s e a s o n

e e

it ought t o g o d o w and i t is going down.
Our actual reserve i s really about Fifty per cent,
and t h e t e n d e n c y t o r e d u c t i o n

the banks,

W

i n loans s t i l l p e r s i s t s

i n

e think that t h e advance i n the discount

rate had a good deal t o do with this result.

I t was a

werning t o the banks, a warning t o pass o n to their cus.
tomers, a n d w e believe t h a t that i s where i t has done t h e

greatest good--the business man, t h e manufacturer, o r anybody w h o h a d oceasion t o use credit h a d notice b y that ad-

vance that credit was n o longer cheap, that they would

have to pay for it, and if it wasn't cheap i t was not
néarly s o plentiful, a n d that has had, I

fully good effect. I

believe, a

wonder-

think with some o f our manufecturers

they Would look with great dislike a n d disfavor o n any
further advance i n price, n o t only because a n sdvance from
this l e v e l i s dangerous
it tends

t o credit,

i n itself,

b u t t h e y appreciate t h a t

o f w r i c h t h e r e i s n o t e n o u g h t o spare.

I am Sure that w e will d o everything that we can t o pre-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

vent a n y further edvances.

w h a t t h e y c a n d o i n the w a y

of advance i s i n the buying o f raw material, f r o m that
point on.
me this:

F o r instance, o n e woolen manufacturer t o l d
h e Said a

year a g o I

was b u y i n g a n y w o o l t h e r e

was i n s i g h t a t almost a n y p r i c e w i c h s u i t e d m y purpose.

Todey I
with.

do not b u y a n y more w o o k than I

can just g e t along

N o w , t h a t chenge i n policy i s really v e r y signifi-

cant, a n d I

think will have v e r y good results.

T h e cotton

men ars not quite s o sure o f that, b u t I think the leather
men f¢el a good deal that way. A
brought about, I

believe,

good part o f that i s

b y the discount rate, t h e notice

which that was t o everybody that i t was getting low.
Mr, Williams.

M a y I

inquire w h e t h e r y o u t h i n k

that t h e attitude o f the Reserve B a n k i n extending a wern-

ing and i n advising the banks t o hold down the demands a s
far as possible, was not quite espotential a s the increase
in rate?
Governor M o r s s .

N o , n o t a s potential;

n o t nearly so.

A l o t o f p e o p l e d i d n o t h e a r a b o u t noua

Mr. Williams. Y o u have control. Y o u do not rediscount unless: y o u desire t o d o so, unless y o u think i t i s
wise t o d o so.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I f a bank comes t o y o u for a n unnecessary

loan, o r a bank i s expanding t o o much, y o u simply edvise
them that they cannot g e t t h e money unless i t becomes a
vital matter o f tiding over.
Governor Merss.
theywant

T h a t i s with the benks, b u t what

i s t o have t h e news carried back t o their cus-

tomers.

lr. Uilliams, Don't they carry that message back
to t h e i r c u s t o m e r s a n d s t o p t h e d e m a n d a t t h e s o u r c e ?

Governor Morss.

N o t b y talk. N o t h i n g b u t t h e rate

does that effectively.

Mr, Williams. N o t h i n g but the rate?
Governor Morss.

N o t h i n g b u t t h e rate carries t h a t

pack t o thé customers.
ify, Williams.

Y o u l d not inability t o get the money

be more effective than a very high rate?
Governor Horss.

Y o u must give some consideration t o

the f a c t that t h e bank's customers a r e liable t o take t h e
position that a bank does n o t know i t s business a n d they

will go somewhere else, but when there i s a discount rate
of the Federal Reserve B a n k staring t h e m i n the face,
there i s n o further argument about it.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Our banks i n New Englens, especially the biggest

ones, the most intelligent ones, begged ws to have our dig.
count r a t e s p u t u p t w o m o n t h s b e f o r e t h e y w e r e p u t up,

for thepurpose o f helping t h e r control their customers!
demands.

T h e fact is, there were several statements m a d e

would n o t p a y a n y a t t e n t i o n

Governor Harding,

t o it.

W e tried t h e merits o f conversa-~

tion h e r e l a s t f a l l a n d w e d i d n o t g e t v e r y f a r w i t h
it,

as y o u will remember.
The Chairman. G o v e r n o r Seay, w h a t has b e e n the effect
upon liquidation i n your district o f the recent rate i n crease?

Governor Seay.

U p t o the I s t o f January o u r loans

were §125,000,000, which was the peak o f the loans, efter a
certain a m o u n t

o f l i g u i d a t i o n h a d t a k e n p l a c e f r o m mid.

summer u
p t o t h a t pericdl, owing, t o r e a l i z a t i o n

o f crops.

Between t h a t period a n d Februery loth o u r loans declined t o
(111,000,000, &

reduction o f (14,000,000, a n d w e are sate

isfied t h a t t h e reduction w a s liquidetion w h i c h was d u e t o
two causes:

o n é directly tracesble

t o the increase

i n

rates a n d the other t o our admonitions t o place restraint
upon t h e b o r r o w i n g s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

o f c u s t o m e r s a n d t o reduce t h e i r l o s n s

wherever practicable.
There a r é certain banks, notably those t h a t are

large borrowers, which cannot well b e controlled except b y
the rates, a n d I think I can prove that t o you. S h o r t l y
after the increase o f our rates a large Richmond banker
proposed t o u s t o offer t o the consideration o f the

Federal Reserve Board whether o r not the maximum rate i n
Virginia, w h i c h b y law i s s i x per cent, might n o t b e in.
creaséd t o o n e p e r c e n t i n a d v a n c e

o f the maximum rate

charged b y the Federal Reserve Bank.

T h a t shows, I

think,

thet a s long as there was a profit i n i t he would continue
to lend, T h a t i s one illustration. T h e r e was actually
about t o b e introduced i n the Maryland legislature a

bill,

by a Baltimore banker, t o inerease the rate o f interest i n
that State.

I t was referred t o u s informally,

t o get o u r

personal opinion, t h e opinion o f our officers, a n d s o
forth. T h e r e were t w o direct things showing that there are
some banks which cannot b e controlled except b y the rate,

Ve know w e can trace liquidation i n the case o f certain
borrowers t o the increase i n the rate, a n d we think that
the reduction was d u e t o thease t w o causes--to admonitions
and increase I n the rate. S i n c e February 1 0 t h o u r loans,

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

nevertheless, h a v e increased, d u e t o t w o causes,

w e think.

Ordinarily f r o m that time o n until t h e l a s t o f M a y s e a
sonal demands f o r agricultural purposes inerease a n d i t
reaches t h e apex i n about May. T h e r e f o r e o u r loans have
increased a n d gone e v e n beyond what t h e y were about t h e l s t
of January.

A S 4 result o f very high prices o f crops a n d

the Sale o f crops, o u r country banks were flooded w i t h

money and they loaned i t out as though they were going
to have i t always.

S o m e o f them made miscalculations,

Deposits w e r e withdrawn b y the owners a n d used i n all
avenucs o f industry a n d some avenues o f speculation, a n d

\
naturally t h e y made some miscalculations a n d were compelled t o r e s o r t

t o t h e F e d e r a l Reser'’e B a n k t o m e e t t h e

heavy withdrawal o f Aeposkte.

The city banks, which held very lerge, unprecedently
large d e p o s i t s

o f c o u n t r y banks,

4 1 4 t h e s a m e thing.

T h e

depositsof such banks were not a s heavy a s they lookeacfor,.
Qne bank had deposits o f $24,000,000 about the lst o f
January, a n d they were reduced ¢10,000,000 here t h e other

day.

T h a t was i n the case o f & single bank.

therefore t h a t t h e increase i n rate d i d have a

H e feel
salutary

effect and was the direct cause o f some liquidation, b u t

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

loans have inercased nevertheless s i n c e thet time, d u e
to
the causes which I

have snumerated, a n d w e expect o u r

loans t o continue t o inerease until May, d u e t o causes
which have operated heretofore a t this time o f the year
and which will opcrate t h i g y e a r
The Chairman.

G o v e r n o r Norris, w h a t has b e e n the

effect o f t h e r a t e i n c r e a s e u p o n l i q u i d a t i o n

i n your dis.

trict?

Governor Norris,
ing liquidation,

I

I t has not had the effect of forces

t hes h a d a salutary a n a deterrent

effect, I think.
in order t o enable y o u t o properly appraise a n y re-

ports from the third district, I think I ought t o call your
attention t o the fact that there a r e t w o .
‘us that I

i t i o n s with

imegine exist t o a greater extent t h a n i n any

other Sistrict.

T h e first is thet eighty per cent of all

of our loans a r e o n paper secured b y Government obligations; secondly, t h a t eighty five p e r c e n t o f those loans
have b e e n loans t o forty t r o banks i n the C i t y o f Phil-

adelphia.

O u r country banks d o not u s e t h e Federal Re-

Serve B a n k t o a n y appreciable e x t e n t .

S i x per cent o f the

banks i n the district have eighty seven p e r cent o f our

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

loans,

a n d as I

say a t least four fifths

o f that i s o n

paper s e c u r e d y
b Government obligations.
The Chairman,

W i t h regard t o Chicago, there i s n o

doubt b u t what t h e increase i n rates h a s h a d some effeat,
notwithstanding t h e fact thatour loans there have i n creased v e r y miterfally since these rates went i n t o ef.
fect, J

think t h e sdvanee i n retes w a s made along about

January 25th, since which date our aggregate loans have come
up t o the extent o f about o n e hundred a n d sixty million
dollars.

I t i s customary o u t i n our district,

and i n the country district,

i n Chicago

t o look f o r a great demand f o r

money around about the lst o f March, which i s called
their March settlement period, a n d March lst really means
ordinarily f r o m March l s t t o March 10th, a t which time
leases expire, l a n d sales a r e adjusted, a n d everything o f
that s o r t i s done,

a n d there w a s a

great d e a l more o f that

this year t h a n a n y year i n the past,

s o much i n fact that

abstractors a n d others w h o h a d t o d o with drawing u p
papers f o r real estate transfers a n d other transactions
got away behind; a n d i n addition t o that demand,
we prepared,
tax payments.

o f course,

a s the rest o f y o u did, f o r t h e March 1 5 t h
O

n March 1 5 t h t h e deposits

i n the Chicago

banks w e r e probably a t the highest point i n their history,

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

and s i n c e t h a t t i m e w e h a v e h a d n o figures t h e r e

o n it.

Mr. Williams. O n March lst?
The Chairman, A b o u t March 15th, Mr. Williems.

Since

that time w e have hed no means, such as I believe y o u have
in New York, ifr, Case, o f getting the figures for deposits
weekly,
Acting Governor Case.
The Chairman,

Y e s , w é g e t that d a i l y .

W e d o not g e t those figures, b u t since

March 16th the deposits i n two o f the largest banks i n
Chicago have gone g o w n t o less t h a n %90,000,000, a n d i n
the other large banks t h e y have gone d o w n i n proportion,

according t o the report, a n d that has occasioned this demand
for money very largely. I

a m sorry that t h e increase o f

rates h a s n o t h a d the effect that w e wotld have liked t o
have s e e n i t have,

Governor Harding and Mr. Secretary Houston, a r e
there a n y questions t h a t y o u would like t o ask i n regard
to t h e subject,

o r d o y o u desire

t o h a v e u s p r o c e e d fur.

ther?
Secretary Houston.

X I should like t o hear a little

further from that group o f banks, including Chicego, where
there seems t o b e a considerable increase,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

a s t o whether

there i s need for further action, a n d i f so, what action?
The Chairman.

T h e q u e s t i o n o f rates h a s b e e n i n e

jected i n t o this discussion t o some extent, a n d i t was
not m y intention,

o r perhaps

i t was n o t yours o r Governor

Harding's intention, t o make this the time for discussing
rates, because that i s o n the program i n another case. I
noticed a s i t went cround t h e table t h a t the rates were
referred to, a n d I intended t o explain t h a t i t was n o t t h e
idea t o discuss rates.
Governor Harding: I

suggest i t might b e interesting

to a s c e r t a i n t h e v i e w s o f t h e G o v e r n o r s

a s t o the propriety

of applying t h e n e w amendment o f radical progressive rates.

The Chairman.

T h a t , o f course, i s a question thet

has t o d o with this same subject o f credit control.

Governor Harding. Y e s .
The Chairman,

T h e question is, i n view o f the pend-

ing amendment t o the Federal Reserve Act, authorizing progressive rates, what should b e the basis o f the norma] line.
That matter w e discussed inforrnally yesterday, b u t took n o
definite action.
Governor Harding. I

think first i t would b e inter-

esting t o know whether a n y o f the banks desire t o avail them-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

selves

o f the privilege immediately,

a n d i f so,

Lines; w h e t t h e i r i d e a i s a s t o t h e s p r e a d

o n what

i n t h e rates,

and what their opinion i s a s t o the basis o f u normal
Line.
Mr, Miller,

W o u l d i t .not clarify t h e whole thing

if w e found o u t precisely what t h e Reserve Banks a r e n o w
doing t o control credit operations

i n the districts?

Al-

lusion has been made here t o the effect o f raising the
rate, w h i c h h a s been effective i n some districts a n d inef-

fective i n others, a n d allusion has been made t o the warn.
ing issued b y the Board and b y the Reserve Banks, a n d m y
thought i s that perhaps w h a t i s equally a s important a s

either o f those fuctors, a n d perhaps more, i s just what
you a r e d o i n g t o control t h e c r e d i t situation,

a quéstion I

a n d that i s

would like t o have w s s e d around t h e table

for the purpose o f information--just w h a t methods a n d pract-

ices are used b y the different Reserve Banks for the pur.
pose o f e x e r c i s i n g c o n t r o l ,
general warnings,

b y m a r k i n g u p rates,

b y a d m o n i t i o n a n d s o forth,

b y issuing

s o that w e

can s e e precisely h o w f a r w e have gone i n ¢ xhausting t h e
potential means, a n d just what i s left t o d o a n d just h o w
that i s going t o b e handled.

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor S e a y . I

would l i k e t o s a y t h a t t h a t i s o n e

of t h e questions t o which w e were requested t o give a
written answer a n d I think w e are prepared t o give a written answer t o that question.

T r e f e r to

(Ya) W h a t steps h a v e y o u taken t o inform yourselves
as t o abuce o f credit i n hoarding commodities?
1 think that embraces t h e point raised b y you, Dr.

Miller.
have e @ written answer t o

Governor McDougal. I

(7a), b u t i t does n o t refer t o No, 7 .
Governor Seay.

O u r answer embraces b o t h 7 and 78.

Governor Norris.

When 1

asked yesterday afternoon

if the written report applied t o 7 as well 4 s 7a, m y ime

pression, géined from the Governor's reply, was thet i t
had b e e n constructed a s covering o n l y 7a.

The Chairman,

S o the written answer only covers

that point, Mr. Miller, a n d we can £0 around the table and

get an answer to Mr. Miller's question. Governor Yellborn,
what d o you d o i n your district, independent o f rates, o r
any additional obligetion t o inerease rates,

t o secure

cooperation w i t h t h e banks i n your dJistrict i n controlling
the c r e d i t s i t u a t i o n ?
Governor W e l l b o r n .

ing a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

W h e n w e

large a m o u n t o f paper,

find a

W e figure

bank that

i s offer-

a n excessive a m o u n t ,

and i s increasing borrowings f r o m time t o time, w e write
thet bank personal letters.

W e send letters t o each

bank o f t h a t kind, c a l l i n g t h e s r a t t e n t i o n

t o i t a n d ask-

ing them what the conditions sre i n the c o m unity which
causes such offerings and pointing out t o them the necessity o f d o i n g a

conservative b u s i n e s s , h o l d i n g l o a n s d o w n

@s much a s possible.
The Chairman. G o v e r n o r Miller, m a y w e hear from you?
Governor Miller.

M r . Ghairman,

w e have frequent meet-

ings w i t h t h e clearing house banks i n each o f the t r e e
large cities i n our district, Denver, Omaha a n d Kanses City,

to jiscuss the situation, a n d we are always confronted with
the argurent t h a t they are simply ansvering t h e demands
and t h e commercial needs o f the district; t h a t they are
oblige? t o have these accommodations, t h o u g h excessive.

They give u s the best r e a s o r s i
n the world, reasons that
you cannot g o behind, because y o u d o not know what i s going
on i n their o w n discount rooms.
Mr. Miller.

D o y o u make a n y attempt t o g o behind

tha t?

Governor Miller. Y e s , I do, but of course we do it
at quite a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

disadvantage, because t h e y present t o u s per-

fectly eligible paper, a n d the larger banks a r e t h e greatest

offenders i n that,
Mr, Miller.

H o w d o you know that, Governor Miller?

Governor filler.

H o w d o I know that the largest

are t h e greatest offenders?

My. Millers Y e s . C f f e n d e r s against whet?
Governor Miller, E x c e s s borrowing.
greater advances,

W i e have mede

i n proportion t o their capital a n d sur-

plus a n d their reserve deposits,

t o the larger banks t h a n

to the smaller ones.
Mr, Miller.

D o e s t h a t necessarily m e a n that t h e y

are borrowing f o r what a r e called non-essential o r imna-~
terial p u r p o s e s ?

Governor Miller, W o , I do not think i t does, but I
am simply quoting y o u the argument that they put up.

W e

know positively thet t h e y bowrow i n many cases t o make a
brokerage o u t o f the difference between o u r rate a n d the
rate t h e y get.
Mr, williams.

G o v e r n o r Norris h a s stated t h a t s i x

per cent of the benks hed eighty five per cent of the
loans i n his district.

I s the condition similar i n your

district, o r are the borrowingSmore widely ddstrdbuted?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Miller,

T v e m t y per cent o f the banks i n

the Omaha Zone are borrowing ninety per cent o f the loans
of that branch.
Mr, Williams.

a r e t h e y generally c i t y banks?

Governor Miller, N e a r l y all c i t y banks.

Thirty

mine banks i n the large cities o f Nebraska a n d “yoming
have n i n e t y p e r c e n t o f t h e total.

true o f Missouri a s well.
Mr. Comptroller, I

T h a t i s pretty nearly

I t is not true o f Cklahoma; b u t

know o f a case n o t long a g o where o n e

of the large banks wanted t o make a loan o f *300,000, a n d
one o f the junior officers, w h e n t h e question came u p and
I asked h i m w h y i n the world t h e y did it, said "Thy, w e

can make two per cent o n that and get i t from the Federal
Reserve Bank,”
Mr. Williams.

I t may interest y o u t o know that for

the first two months o f the current year, December 3lst t o
March lst, there w a s a shrinkage o f approximately o n e billion dollars

i n the deposits o f the reserve cities o f the

country.

Governor Miller, Y e s , T h e y refer t o thet also,
Me. Tilllams.
City;


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

a t least a

N e a r l y all o f that was i n New York

very large proportion

o f it, t h e larger

proportion

o f it.

T h e r e were s o m e reserve cities t h a t

showed a n actual increase, b u t the general tendency w a s
@ large fallingoff, particularly i n New York.
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r Norris, w h a t methods d o you
employ i n the matter o f putting o n the brakes?
Governor N o r r i s I

port, o f course.

can only make &

very imperfect r e -

S o far a s I have b e e n able t o learn i n

a few hours, t h e situation i n Philadelphia

i n regard t o

that has b e e n about this: there e r e three o r four banks t h a t
are borroring a n amount utterly disproportionate t o their
capital a n d surplus,

o r t o t h e i r depositess.

T h e officers

of the Reserve B a n k have h a d t h e officers o f those banks
in repeatedly insisting that t h e y must liquidate a n d that
they m u s t r e d u c e t h e i r l o a n s ,

T h e y have b e e n making prom-

ises f o r months a n d not keeping them,

tively small banks.

T h e y a r e compara.

O f the large banks i n Philedelphia,

who a r e t h e p r i n c i p a l b o r r o w e r s ,

not nearly s o disproportionate. I

t h e i r borrowings

ena

do not know that i t c a n

be s a i d t h a t t h e y a r e d i s p r o p o r t i o n a t e

t o their s i z e a t

all, b u t what t h e y are borrowing i s almost entirely what
they need t o carry their customers w h o have subscribed t o
Liberty Bonds a n d t h e Fourth Loan a n d have n o t been able


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

tO paye
The large banks i n Philadelphia a r e conservatively
operated

b y t r a i n e d bankers,

and I

think t h e y r e a l i z e t h e

eresit situation j u s t a s vell a s w e d o and are working
along t h e same lines, w i t h o n e exception.
has a

C n e large b a n k

president w h o t a k e s t h e p o s i t i o n t h a t t h i s i s t h e

time o f very active business, w h e n every bank ought t o
everything t h a t i t can t o help i n the production a n d dis-

tribution o f goods, a n d that therefore h e wants t o extend
accommodations a s generally a s possible and borrow all

that he can from the Federal Reserve Bank,
Secretary Houston.

exceptional,

i s i t not, Governor Norr is?

Governor Norris, J
yet. I

Y o u r condition there i s v e r y

haven't h a d time t o find o u t

presume i t is.

Secretary Houston, E i g h t y per cent o f your loans are
on G o y e r n m e n t p a p e r ?

Governor Norris,

v e n sir.

Secretary Houston,
Governor Norris.

A n d t o but s i x banks?

N o , Lds i x per cent-~-not s i x banks.

Our condition i s exceptional. I

want t o take opportunity

to discuss t h a t w i t h Governor Morss, because I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

think his

situation would naturally b e about t h e same a s ours.

This situation i s the aftermath o f the influenza
epidemic w h i c h struck Philadelphia j u s t a s the Fourth
Liberty Loan Campaipn w a s started.

T h e health authorities

put a n embargo o n all public meetings, m o s t o f the solic-

itors were taken sick, a n d those who were not taken sick
were unable t o g o into houses because o f the sickness

that existed there, a n d the result was that when the came
paign Was nearly over Philadelphia h a d o n l y subseribed a
very trifling proportion o f its quota,

& £ number o f

large business m e n a n d others i n Philadelphia subscribed
for bonds b y the hundreds o f thousands a n d millions o f

dollars worth.
phia, a

O n e very active business m a n i n Philadel.

man w h o i s competent t o borrow i n his business,

subseribec for four million dollers worth o f bonds,which
he still has.

T h e y p u t u p t o m e the statement t h a t

they weve first urged t o b u y and borrow, w h i c h they did,
out o f patriotism; t h a t theyrecopnized t h e fact t h a t
there w a s also a n injunction t o save a n d pay.

T h e small

people have very largely done that. T h e country banks report that their small subscriptions,

o n which t h e y made

loans, a r e v e r y largely paid up, b u t obviously a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

man i n

active business, subscribing t o four million dollars
worth o f bonds, has not been able t o pay four million
dollars

i n a couple

o f years.

v h e n h e was prepared

at

one time t o take h i s losses a n d sell his bonds, Secretary M c A d o o m a d e a n address
was r e p o r t e d

a t Philadelphia

t o have s a i d t h a t h e r e g a r d e d

i n which h e
i t as almost

treasonable for a man t o sell Liberty Bonds a t a discount; t h a t s u c h a man ought t o b e stood u p against a

wall

ang shot.
Mr, williams.

T h a t was during t h e placing o f the

Liberty Loans a n d not after t h e war?
Governor Norris, I
he a c t u a l l y said. I

do not know.

T I do not know that

a m just quoting w h a t h a s b e e n reported

to me, T h i s man, having first subscribed a n d then having
refrained from liquideting and teking 4 loss o f three o r
four per cent, i s now neturally losth t o take 4& loss o f ten
per cent, and i t does seem rather hard t o force h i m t o do

it. W h e n I say "him", I mean, o f course, there are scores
and hundreds o f others i n the same position.
The Chairmen.

H o w about Minneapolis, Governor Young?

Governor Young.

C u r usual method i n Minneapolis 1 s

this: t h e applicant f o r rediscount gives u s t h e inforné@tion


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

where

as to how much that bank is borrowing elses and if the
application i s i n a reasonable anount o f eligible p s e r ,

we put i t through without hesitency; b u t i f they increase t h a t i n e w e have a

s o r t o f fixed rule w i t h t h e

country b a n k s t h e r e , w h e r e t h e y g o t o t h e a m o u n t

tal a n d surplus,

o f capi«

o f retaining f i f t y per cent o f theidoffer

as additionao collateral, a n d w e write t o them at that
time a n d r e m i n d t h e m t h a t o u r r e s e r v e s a r e n o t i n e x h a u s t i b l e

and tell them t h a t any future offerings will b e handled
on the same basis.

T h a t throws t h e worry o n the country

bank instead of us carrying the worry. New, i f a bank
goes beyond that, w e hold the application u p and rake some
pertinent i n q u i r i e s ;

i f t h e y s t i l l g o b e y o n d t h s t, w e

usually wire thei t o send & couple o f their officers i n or
an officer a n d some o f t h e t directors,

W e r e l y for i n -

formation a great deal o n the examiners! r e p o r t that t h e y

get from the agents Department.

Y o u can usually find

there sufficient information t o determine whether t h a t

bank i s taking care o f the commercial a n d @ ricultural
needs o f the district o r whether t h e y are loaning f o r investment

o r speculative purposes,

a n d i f they a r e loaning

for speculative o r investment purposes, w e suggest t o them


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

that they liquidate some o f those loans. N o w , t h a t has

had a pretty good effect i n our district, T h e r e are some
banks that w e have hed a great deal o f t w uble with.
Mr, Williaws.

W h e r e d o y o u draw the line between

secured a n d unsecured credit,
Governor Youngp.
The Chairman,

a t what point?

T h e amount o f the capital and surplus.

O n e hundred p e r cent?

Governor Young.

O n e hundred p e r cent,

ply that a t all times.

W

e d o not ap--

I n the fall o f the yesr, w h e n w e

have seasonal demands, w e may allow a bank t o go over that.
+4 all depends o n the condition o f the bank, whether there
is a chop i n that district o r not.
Now w e have some trouble a t the moment w i t h one o f

the city banks,

I t is a good institution, i t is well con-

ducted, e x c e p t t h a t t h e y h a v e u s e d u s t o o f r e e l y e v e r

since w e have been organized.
Mr, Villiams. National o r tate bank?

Governor Young. A

National bank. ‘ v e have admon.

ished t h e offigers o f that bank several times-Me, tiilliams.

a r e t h e y o n the special list, d o y o u

Governor Young. N o , they are not.
clean, M r , Comptroller.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T h e bank was

I t i s a good institution.

They

have used u s f o r profit: there i s n o question about that,
Now w e received a n application f o r re-discount f r o m that
bank t h e o t h e r d a y o f ; 600,000.

T

e h a d t o t a k e i t even-

tuslly o r else let the bank close up,
Mr, Williams. " h e t percentage are they borrowing now
of their capital a n d surplus?
Governor Young.

T h e y are borrowing f o u r times their

capital a n d surplus a n d approximately thirty three p e r cent
of their deposits.
Wr. Shilianm.

T h a t 1 8 pretty stiff, 4 6 42% nest

Governor Young. Y e s , i t is.

i t resulted i n this.

Te g o t their directors together, a n d I spent a whole d a y

with them, going over all their loans.
of loans t h a t t h e y c o u l d reduce,

and a

T h e y hed a number
number

o f t e n per-~

cent loans thet i t was not necessery for them t o carry i n
order

t o r e t a i n t h e business.

T h e r e was a

sufficient

number o f the directorsof t h a t bank w h o assured m e that
Liquidation would start i n that bank right away, regardless
of whether t h e y lose bus iness o r not.
not a p p r o v e

o f t h e t condition.

T h o s e directors d o

I n fuot, y o u r e x a m i n e r h a s

yarned t h a t bank f o r t w o years,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr, Miller. W h a t were they doing with the proceeds?

Governor Young.

T h e y were loaning lergely t o country

banks.
Mr. Villiams.

S t a t e banks?

Governor Young.
Thet i s guite a

S t a t e banks a n d National banks both.

menace i n our district.

Mr, Williams.

T h a t i s wheat the Federal Reserve A c t

hoped t o prevent.

Governor Young. I
Wr. Williams.

know.

T h e State banks a r e loaning t o the non-

member banks?

Governor Young. Y e s ,

A

S a general thing, when a

bank sends i n an application, w e get information o n the back
of the application showing where the bank has redism unted,
say with a Chicago correspondent, a New York correspondent,
or a Twin-City correspondent.

W

e g o t o a certain point

with hiéHe banks and then we refuse t o take any more,

They

will take a lot o f ineligible paper, p u t i t i n the city banks,
and t h e c i t y banks i n turn offer their eligible paper t o

the Federal Reserve Bank-Mr, Williams (interposing).

D o a good deal o f the re-

discounts c o m e f r o m t h e n o n - m e m b e r b a n k s ? I

Do they?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

guess t h e y do.

Governor Young. i

did not quite c a t c h your question,

Mr, Williams.
Mr. Williams.
banks, a

O n money which y o u loan t o your National

good deal o f paper which y o u get i s paper which has

been s e n t t o t h e m b y t h e i r c o r r e s p o n d e n t n o n - m e m b e r b a n k s ?

Governor Young.

N o . T h e y give u s a lot o f other

in lieu o f that.
Mr, Williams.

O h , t h e y do?

Governor Young, Y e s .

Mr. Miller, I

have some figures here that touch upon

rates, which 1 think will b e interesting.

I t shows thet

the inter-bank loans o f banks i n the Federal Reserve System,
at Uns time o f the November 1 7 t h call, amounted t o

£453,000,000, loans from bank t o bank, I n t e r - b a n k loans

among member banks o f the “ederal Reserve System 139,000,000.
Loans f r o m members o f the Federal Reserve S y s t e m t o outs ide

or non-member banks amounted t o §:314,000,00C,

I n Minneapo-

lis o n that date inter-bank loans amounted t o $5,000,000, a
trifle over $5,000,000, o f which less than {:1,000,000 vent
to members o f the Federal Xeserve System, a n d member banks
were l o a n i n g o v e r { 4 , 0 0 0 , 0 0 0


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Y o u n g .

t o n o n - m e m b e r banks.

D o e s t h a t include Minneapolis a n d

St. Paul, o r just Minneapolis?
“Yr, Miller,

J u s t Minneapolis,

I

n St.Paul t h e

leans from member banks t o member banks were a little over
2,000,000 a n d of member banks t o non-member banks approximately 4,000,000.

H e r e y o u have pretty clear evidence t h a t

the member banks o f the Federal Reserve System are using
the f e e t l i t i e s

o f t h e Reserve Banks

t o carry non-member

banks, t h e bulk o f the inter«bank loans being f o r n o n m e m b e r
banks.

Governor Young. I
Dr, Miller.

W

do not think you can avoid that,

e have given a great deal o f thought and

study t o t h e t question.

The Chairman.

M a y we hear from you, Governor Fancher?

Governor Fancher.

T h e situation

i n t h e C l e v e l a n d Feda-

eral Reserve B a n k i s that a t the present time about eight p e r
cent o f the number o f banks a r e borrowing about eighty
seven per cent o f the amount o f our loans.
The Chairman, E i g h t p e r cent ere borrowing eighty
seven p e r c e n t ?

Governor Fancher, Eight per cent of the total number
are borrowing eighty seven p e r cent o f our total loans.

Of course that eight per cent includes banks i n our six


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

or s e v e n p r i n c i p a l c i t i e s .

The Chairman, I

do not think thet means anything

unless y o u tell u s whet those eight banks are, a s t o what
their resources amount to, a n d h o w they contribute t o
the l o a n a b l e r e s o u r c e s

o f y o u r bank,

Governor Fancher. I
The Chairman,

do not know that total.

T h e y are o f course v e r y lerge banks,

and t h e y contribute probably eight p e r cent t o your re-~

sources,
Governor F a n c h e r .

I

n our seven principal cities

sixty five p e r cent o f the total loans a t the present time
Is made o n Government securities a n d thirty five p e r cent
on commercial paper.

A S early a s last august I

had a

list prepared o f all banks t h a t were borrowing a n a ount
equal t o their capital a n d surplus, a n d I then began b y
correspondence a n d b y personal interview w i t h those banks
that ere located near Cleveland, h a v i n g t h e officers c o m e
in, a n d also come i n t o t h e branch cities,

i n a n effort t o

ascertain t h e occasion o f their borrowing s u c h amounts.
Gradually through thet procedure w e learned t h e cause,
the particular local cause f o r those borrowings.
number


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T h e total

o f banks a t t h a t t i m e w a s a b o u t t w e n t y f i v e o r

thirty.

T

h

a

t w e continued, a n d then later o n w e

changed thet basis, setting u p the amount that the bank
would b e entitled t o borrow b a s e d upon i t s reserve d e posits a n d capital payment, a n d i n discussing t h e situation
with our over-borrowed banks w e have shown t h e m what would
be their share o f our loanable resources, having f n mind
the duty o f o u r Board i n v i l e Featies distribution o f our

resources t o our member banks.
Mr. Williams.

O n what basis d i d y o u work that, Gov-

ernor Fancher?
Governor Fancher, 6
setaside a

t o o k t h e reserve deposit a n d

reserve o f thirty five p e r cent o f that amount,

the remainder plus capital payment o f the bank, multiplied
by two a n d o n e half,

o n the assumptio:. t h a t w e made pay-

ment o f the c edit b y Federal Reserve notes.
on t h a t b a s i s

I t has been

w e have discussed o u r loanable resources,

the question o f cresit w i t h our over-borrowed banks.

have not any very flagrant cases. I

and

w e

do not believe a t the

present time w e have a n y banks t h a t a r e using u s t o a n y
great extent f o r t h e sake o f carrying outside loans.

T e

have béen v e r y careful t o scrutinize e v e r y offering.

When

we have found a bank offering purchased paper, w e have
at
gone t o o u r loan record t o ascertain /the time w h e n t h e y

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

207
probably purchased that paper, w h a t their condition a s t o
borrowings w a s with us.

I f they were borrowing f r o m u s w e

called their attention t o the fact that t h e y must n o t use
our facilities f o r outside investments, t h a t o u r facilities

were for local demands a n d t o be used accordingly.

S o we

feel t h a t w e have o u r situation pretty well i n hand.
still have banks,

W e

o f course, t h a t are borrowing consider-

ably more t h a n their proportion o f our loanable funds, b u t
we have gone o v e r v e r y carefully t h e facts i n those cases

and find that they are a few large banks that have a large
line o f not o n l y commercial deposits, b u t o f bank deposits,
not only deposits f r o m local concerns, b u t desposits f r o m

concerns i n our smaller manufacturing cities where the
banking facilities have not been able t o take care o f
the demand.

I m some cases w e have h a d o u r banks v e r y

carefully classify their loans, showing t h e various lines
of i n d u s t r y t h a t t h e l o a n s a r e b e i n g m a d e upon,

a n d this,

and b y c o r r e s p o n d e n c e a n d p e r s o n a l i n t e r v i e w a n d p e r s o n a l

contact w i t h t h e officers o f our lerger banks h a s enabled
us t o k e e p p r e t t y c l o s e l y

i n touch w i t h

o u r situa-

tien a n d t o p r e v e n t w h a t w e believe w e r e flagrant

eases o f overborrowing o r cases where our funds were being


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

used f o r anytring b u t local, legitimate purposes.
The Chairman.

Y o u a r e loaning 4

preat deal o f money

to large banks a n d those large banks a r e loaning t h a t t o

Non-member banks?
Governor Fancher.

The Chairman,

Yes.

Y o u d o not make myeffort,

to f o l l o w t h e u s e t o which. t h e p r o c e e d s

o f course,

o f t h e l o a n s a r e put,

with respect t o whether t h e y g o t o non-member banks, b e -

cause you d o know that they g o there?

Governor Fancher. Yes, we know that. | We know that
is a situation thet has got t o be taken care of, because
there are a number o f nonemember banks that are not Gligible.

The Cheirman,
has

Y o u say that i t is a situation that

t o be teken oare of.

p

o y o u mean f r o m our point o f

view o r fron their point o f view?

Governor Fancher. F r o m their point of view, as a
customer,

The Chairman. Governor Biges, "111 you respond t o
the guestion?
Governor Biggs.
basis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i n our District

W e fipure v e r y much o n the same
a s does Governor Fancher.

W

e have

e

h

a

d a basie line for about t w o years.

O n o n e occssion,

several years ago, a few of the members were going over
that basie line, b u t that was o n l y for a short period,
About t e n days a g o I think seventy t w o o f the banks were
slightly over this basis line,
Mr. Williams.

T h a t i s about t e n p e r c e n t o f t h e banks

in your district?
Governor Biggs,
Mr. Williams.

No.

H o w many banks i n your district?

Governor Biggs.

W e have five hundred a n d forty one.

My, Villiamsa.

A b o u t fifteen p e r cent.

The Chairman.

Y o u r loans are largely t o St. Louis

and t o St. Joseph?

Governor Biggs.
We have a

T o St. Louis, Memphis a n d Little Rock,

great deal more borrowing f r o m banks, f r o m banks

that have never borrowed before,
The Chairman.

E o w many members h a v e you?

Governor Biggs.

The Chairman,

i n sml1l amounts.

F i v e hun-tred a n d forty.

H o w many borrowing members?

Governor Biggs. I

could n o t tell y o u exactly, b u t

think probably t w o hundred now,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman.

H a v e y o u given a n y consideration t o the

question o f controlling t h e u s e o f credit that y o u extend

to the banks that are carrying balances o f non-member
banks, knowing t h a t t h e y loan t o those banks?

Governor Biggs. N o , we haven't found it necessary,
because o u r banks offer scarcely none o f that class o f paper,
They have given u s Government securities, a n d when t h e y

have run out o f those they have given t s their commercial
paper.
The Chairman,

Y f course they wouldn't offer you that

paper because i f they did you would turn i t down.
Governor Biggs. Y e s .

T h e y are using funds borrowed

from u s t o take care o f non-member banks.

T h a t i s true

of three o f our largest’ banks i n St. Louis.
Mr, “Liler. Can you give u s a n approximate r a t i o . f
o
the borrowings o f your lergest’ St.Louis banks t o their reserve balances,

s o that w e c a n g e t some basis

t o approxi-

mate t h e extent o f their borrowings?
Governcr Blgps.

Y o u mean a

percentage b a s i s ?

Mr. Miller. Y e s .
Governor B i g g s .

W e l l ,

t h e large borrowings above

this m m sig line--~I will have t o give i t to you i n that
way, would r u n probable o n e t o three.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. Miller. A b o v e that line?
Governor B i g g s .
carry, w i t h a

C n e third above balances w h i c h t h e y

capital a c c o u n t f i g u r e d

o n t h e s a m e basis.

Governor Miller. T h a t i s one third above that?
Governor Bigs.

Mr. Miller,

H o w many?

Y o u say about o n e third above that.

Governor B i g e s .

S o m e o f them, y e s .

w

e o n l y have

two banks i n St, Louis t h a t a r é above t h a t line t o a n y ,
extent.
The Chairman,

A b o v e w h a t basic line i s that?
A p o u t o n e t o three.

Governor B i g s .

“ W e Ligure about

the same a s Governor Fancher.
The Chairman.

T h e basis, t h a t i s the amount o f loan-

able funds w h i c h the member banks contribute

i n the w a y o f

deposits t o your institution?
Governor Biggs.

Yes.

W e have a

few large banks i n

the city above t h a t a n d a few i n Memphis a n d Little Rock.
The Chairman. G o v e r n o r Calkins, c e n w e hear f r o m you?
Governor Calkins.

I : w i s h t o preface w h a t I

have t o

say b y calling ettention t o the fact, o r whet I take t o b e a
fact, t h a t t h e o p i n i o n s e x p r e s s e d a r o u n d t h i s t a b l e i n d i -

cate, i f they d o not show, t h a t t h e e f f e d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

o f the increase

of rates h a s b e e n t o e f f e c t l i q u i d a t i o n

i n t h e metropoli-«

tan district a n d i t had n o such effect i n the other districts. I

think t h a t i s p r e t t y c l e a r l y b r o u g h t o u t a n d

is a very significant fact.
take,

A

s t o the loans that w e

w e first scrutinize v e r y closely t h e paper offered

for rediscount b y banks t h a t are over what appear t o be
excessive amounts, a n d the statements accompanying them.
Second,

w e make v e r y close inquiry a s t o the necessity f o r

sum h e a v y use o f the Federal Xeserve B a n k a n d the justification f o r it.

W e next require t h e m t o put u p a certain

a n a r b i t r a r y amount,

amount,

calculation,

n o t b a s e d u p o n a n y scientific

o f excess collateral.

O f the methods pur-

sued, t h e close examination o f the paper end o f the sit-

vation o f the bank offering i t has much greater effect
than a n y o f the other methods.
In our district w e have seven hundred a n d thirty

one member banks, o f which, o n January 3lst, t w o hundred
and fifty s i x are listed a s banks a c c mnodatéd..
necessary t o remember t h a t w e have s i x districts

with a very wide diversity o f conditions.
reflected

another.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i

t is

i m one,

T h e conditions

i n one district s r e n o t comparable

t o those

in

T h e Salt Lake district, so-called, i s strictly

agricultural, a n d I should say that a t this time probably
sixty five p e r cent o f the member banks i n thet district

were borrowing. from the Federal Reserve Bank. I

think

that condition would hardly b e matched elsewhere,
perfectly o b v i o u s

t o m e that t h e anplication

which might p u t o n e benk,

t is

o f e Pate,

i n a sense, o u t o f business,

would have n o effect o n another bank.
where a

i

I n other words,

metromlitan b a n k loans a t five a n d o n e h a l f o r s i x

per cent, a n increase above t h a t rate will affect i t s
business v e r y seriously, a n d where t h e country bank
loans a t twelve o r fifteen p e r cent a n increase t o o r

above s i x per cent will have n o influence whatever.
The Chairman,

G o v e r n o r V a n Zandt?

Governor V a n Zandt.

I

n our district

w e have e a c h

offer accompanied b y a skeleton statement o f the condition
of the bank a s o f the date o f the offering,

v e analyze

that very carefully, a n d i f that does n o t show a neel, a

real need for the funds, w e hold u p the offering and wire
the bank that they rust furnish us with good and sufficient
reasons f o r d i s c o u n t i n g t h e paper.

T h e n w e argue t h e

point w i t h then and frequently w e turn d o w n offerings e n tirely just f o r t h e reason thet t h e y d o not show t h a t t h e y
actually need them,

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

214

The Chairman,
where y o u t o l d a

H a v e y o u ever gotten t o the point

bank definitely t h a t y o u would n o t l o a n

them a n y more money under a n y circumstances?
Governor V a n Zandt,

C h yes, frecguently; I

say fre-

guently, occas tionally.
The Chairman.

T h a t i s a difficult position t o p u t ther

Governor V a n Zandt.

T e l l , where w e find their oper.

ations a r e s u c h that w e think w e should tell them, w e d o
so i n that way.
Mr, Willer.

H o w d o y o u inform youself

o n the point

that their operations a r e not such a s t o entitled them
to a loan?

Governor Van Zandt. T h r o u g h information they furnish
us a s t o uses t h e y make o f the funds borrowed.
The Chairman.

T h e t i s declining t o loan money f o r

some specific purpose, really?

Governor Van Zandt. Y e s , i t really is.
ir, W i l l i a m s .

Y h a t , f o r example?

Governor V a n Zandt. I

recall a

D o y o u remember a

case w e r e w e r e f u s e d

to loan a bank funds because a bank, with which the same


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

215
management was associated, w a s i n a borrowing condition,
and while this b a n k did n o t need a n y funds f o r itself,

it

would borrow money a n d put i t o n deposit w i t h this asso-

ciated bank, and we refused t o lend that bank any more money
for t h a t purpose.

The Chairman:

G o y e r n o r Case, w i l l y o u please respond

to t h e i n q u i r y ?

Acting Governor Case,

W e undertake t o keep ourselves

closely informed f r o m time t o time b y asking o u r banks, par-

ticularly our New York City banks, t o come i n and report t o
us periodically, every two o r three months; t o come i n and
chat over the situation, telling u s just what conditions
exist with them, what changes that have taken place, a n d
all that sort o f thing.

W e keep pretty closely informed

in regard t o what our large c i t y banks s r e doing.
Cur position,

l i k e that indicated

b y G o v e r n o r Norris,

is that our group: o f city banks borrow ninety per cent o f
our total amount o f loans, a n d I

think t h a t i s a s i t should

be, a s their resources represent ninety per cent o f the
resources o f the district approximately.

W e have felt

that w e could d o more b y getting close cooperation b y the
element o f good willemd having t h e m come i n ani d i s m s s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

16
their affairs w i t h u s precisely a s the borrower a t @ commercial b a n k w o u l d d o o n c e o r t w i c e &

year a n d r e p o r t c o n -

ditions, whether they are losing deposits, a n d all that
sort o f thing.
We think w e have a

very efficient member bank rela-

tions department, a n d that departrient carries o n that sort
of & program.

“ e encourare o u r country bankers, certeinly

from the lerge citieslike Buffalo, Syracuse and iochester,
when they a r e i n tom,

t o come i n ans discuss their affairs

with us, and then representatives f r o m our Member Bank Relations Lepartment will visit t h e country banks, a n d v e
keep closely informed, f r o m the information that t h e y

furnish us, and b y reviewing the copy of the reports o f the
National Banks furnished b y t h e Comptroller, a n d fron

the inforre tion w e get from the ¢tate Banking Department.
vhere a bank i s inclined t o go too strong, after w e
have informed ourselves a n d arrived a t the conclusion t h a t
the bank i s not i n a strong condition,
eolliiteral,

W

w e require excess

e have t a k e n thet position i n numerous

instances, S o m e o f the banks d o not like thet, but a s a
matter o f fact i t is another rather effective means o f
control,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

a s w e have found out.

217
Governor Harding. I

would like t o say that that

method i s used generally i n all the other districts. I
know t h a t several o f them d o it.
Mr. Miller.

J u s t a s a n example, I

find t h a t o n e

of the smaller New York City banks, t h e City National,
has borrowed f r o m y o u about three a n d one half times t h e
amount o f its reserve balance,

Acting Governor Gase. T h a t i s true. T h a t i s one
of the up-town banks.

V e have a group o f up-town banks,

ten o r twelve i n number, t h a t deal with t h e cutting-up
trade, a n d a l l o f these banks w e have p u t i n a class b y

themselves, T h e y are all o f them borrowing a t the very
peak a t the present. time. N o w , that i s a bank from which
we have over a million dollars excess collateral.
have h a d t h e p r e s i d e n t

W e

i n o n t w o different occasions s i n c e

the lst o f January, a n d re are closely informed o n just
exactly what i s going o n there.

w

e have impressed upon

him the importance o f cutting down h i s loans.

A s a matter

of fact, t h a t loan has been reduced a million a n d a half t o
two million dollars within t h e last s i x weeks.

T h a t is

eon touy o f some o f those up-town banks. T h e r e a r e t e n o r
a dozen o f those banks o f just that type.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

My, Miller, S u p p o s e w e take a down-~town bank.

The

218
Chemical h a s b o r r o w e d t w o a n d o n e h a l f t i m e s i t s r e s e r v e

balance f r o m you,
Acting Governor Case, Y e s , t h e Chemical, t h e Park,
and t h e Citizens National Bank, a n d banks o f that kind, a r e
strictly commercial banks,

a s compared t o some o f the Wall

Street banks, where t h e business i s rather more diversified.
Every one o f those banks, t h e Chemical a n d t h e Park, h a v e

been riding along with large atnounts, simply because t h e

pressure that has been brought upon them has continued unabated right u p t o the present time.
A8 1

thinkims already been indicated, s o m e o f these

borrowers distributed throughout the country have been selling their paper i n the open market, a n d a s our advance i n

rate was made and became effective, i t tended t o close u p
the outside market temporarily.
My. Yillieams.

Y o u mean sold i n the open merket with-

out their endorsement?
Acting Governor Case.

No, I

mean a large concern

simply selling i t s paper i n the o p e n market.

V h e n the

market w a s c l o s e d up, t h e n t h a t l a r g e c o n c e r n w o u l d g o t h e

the Chemical Bank, o r the Park Bank, a n d ask for its Line
which i t had previously arranged for, a n d they are feeling


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

219
the w e s s u r e

o f that.

T h e r e i s n o question b u t that t h e

advance i n rate d i d force some borrowing i n anticipation,
because t h e y w o n d e r e d w h a t m i g h t h a p p e n next, t h i n ’ ing

the rate might g o higher a n d that they h a d better g e t
under cover while t h e going was good.
Mr. Miller.

D o y o u assume’ that a bank i s @ S0-

called commercial bank, n o t a Vall Street bank, n o t a bank
that i s k n o m t o loan hesvily o n call, t h a t i t s ‘orrowings
are f o r t h e purpose o r for a purpose t h e t entitled i t t o
accomnodation a t the Reserve Bank, wnless i t goes beyond
extreme bounds.

“ h a t method d o y o u use t o control

the use o f your resources indirectly f o r t h e purpose o f
‘commercial speculation, speculation i n commodities, t h e
lerge
buying o f commodities a n d carrying o f commodities b y
n
a n d s o forth?
erocers,
voods,
d
r
y
jobbers,
dealers a n d

Acting Governor Case.

I a m frank t o say, Mr.

Miller, t h a t w e only d o thet indirectly. I
the Chemical Bank.

r

mentioned

e have h : athe presijent o f that bank

in t w i c e s i n c e t h e I s t o f t h e year.

the situation with h i m very carefully.

w

e have gone over

& S y o u know, a l l

of those New York City banks furnish us very close detail
information. 1


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

think t h e Chemical B a n k h e s probably a

220
million a n d a

quarter

or a

million e n d a

half l o a n e d w i t h

“Wall Street, w h i c h i s a very nominal amount.
any funds loaned there t o a n y extent.

I t hus n o t

N e have

e e n s

upon t h e m t h e t t h e y w e r e b o r r o w i n g r a t h e r d i s p r o p o r t i o n -

ately rather t h a n more t h a n they were entitled to, a n d
the i m p o r t a n c e
essential

o f n o t loaning a n y o f those f u n d s f o r non-

o r less essential purposes.

Y

e think w e are

justified i n having confidence i n the mans gefient o f such
men & s the officers o f the Chemical National Bank.
There i s one thing t h a t impresses itself upon m e v e r y
strongly, e n d thet i s the f e c t that these c o m e r c i a l banks
do not convert their outstanding commitment business i n any
scientific fashion. &

life i n s u r a n c e c o m p a n y w i l l h a v e m

actuary f i g u r e o u t w h a t t h e p o s s i b i l i t i e s a r e a n d

e i

carry reserves t o meet them, but a comercial bank, taking
twenty o r twenty five million deposits, h a s outstanding per.
haps f i f t y o r sixty millions o f comzitments a n d i t Joes n o t
know what those commitments r e a l l y amount to.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. Williams.

t h e n y o u s a y "com :itments", y o u mean

times the balance?
Acting Governor Case. Y e s , “rn. Comptroller.

wr, Williams.

Y o u mean the general understanding?

221
Acting Governor Case. Y e s , A

Ary~goods company, f o r

instance, carries one hundred thousand dollars with them six
Months o f the year.

I t hos nothingtbhhere now.

been selling paper i n the open market.

I t has

N o w t h e y have f o u n d

that t h e open market going i s not very good.

T h e y come t o

the Chemical Bank a n d s a y w e want o u r line, a n d t h e y give i t
to them.

T h e y s a y they have h a d a hundred thousand dollars

there and they -ive the: half a million.

T h e r e are numer~

ous instunces o f that sort, which I think explain the situation with regard t o bunks like the Chemical National.
My, Miller.Italso explains w h y the loan account
Federal Reserve Benks penerally i s srelling.
acting G o v e r n o r C a s e .

My, iiller.

Yes.

T h e t which i s c u t out one w a y i s coming

throurh t h e other door?
Acting Governor Case. Y e s .

Governor Harding.
present. a

T h e r e i s one supgrestion I vant t o

Federal Reserve B o n k h u s presented t o i t b y a

member bank f o r discount paper w h i c h i s cleurly eligible
and which i s unobjectionable f r o m a credit standpoint.

Shoulda the “ederal Rese.ve Bank assume t o say that it Joes
not think t h e l o a n i s for a n essential purpose a n d there~-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

eee
fore will decline t o make i t ? S u p p o s e t h e Federal Reserve
Banks acted o n that policy, j u s t where would t h e system
be?

I

t seems t o m e that i n peace times,

i f we want t o

brimp a n y pressure t o bear a s t o discrimination i n loans
fror the standpoint o f whether o r not they are f o r essential o r non-essential purposes, t h a t w e have g o t t o apply

a rate, possibly this propress ive rate, and have got t o
bring about, o n the pert o f the users o f credit, a n d the
consumers o f goods, a

condition b y which t h e y will volun-

tarily make t h e distinction themselves.

T h e y will s a y

"ve connot afford t o b u y non-essential stuff; w e have p o t

to buy necessities."
regulate conditions.

T h s t i s the thing thet i s going t o
I f the “eaeral Reserve Board o r a

Federal Reserve Bank should undertake, o n its own judgment,
to s a y t h e t i t d o e s n o t t h i n k a

transaction

i s f o r a n eligi-

ble purpose, s n d therefore t h e y will n o t take t h e paper,

but that here i s other paper that might not b e quite s o
good f r o m a c r e d i t standpoint,

b u t i s eligible f r o m t h e

other standpoint, a n d will teke it, then i t seems t o me
thet w e a r e going t o pet into se very complex situation.

Mr, villiams.

p o n ' t you think they have got t o

4

exercise s o m e judgment o n thet subject?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ocd ¢

Governor Herding.

T h e r e i s nothing i n the l a w thet

permits i t .
‘yp, Miller.

T h a t i s not the question. I

concerned t o get information o n this question:

ain simply:
I

t may

be a n open question whether o u r Federal seserve System @
any other potential .merican banking s y s t e m c a n control
crezit.

I t i s very clear rates alone will n o t d o it.

It i s very cleur t h a t talk alone will n o t d o it.

T I am

trying t o find o u t whether there i s a possibility,

b y sup-

plementing either t h e o n e o r the other o r both o f those
forms o f oction b y some s o r t o f edministrative pressure,

of controlling it. T h e best informtion that I have got
in r e g a r d t o t h e a p p l i c e t i o n s

o f the large banks

i s not

from bankers, n o t f rom our own heserve officials, n o r from
the presi. ent o f the bank, but through the bank directors,
who a r e t h e m s e l v e s l s r g s m a n u f a c t u r e r s

a n d merchants. I

have talked within the lsst fev months with one o r tro o f
the very lergest merchants t n i, webougul's district
and they have civen ime more Inforrmtion rerarding t h e creda
44 s i t u s t i o n a n d o p e r u t i o n s

than I

o t his lesding member banks

have gotten from a n y other source.

C n e o f the

very largest dealers i n his line o f poods tells m e h e i s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

out o f the market entirely because one o f Mr. MeDougal's
lergest member Banke’ te carrying a

very considerable nwrber

of brokers w h o ure speculating, speculeting f o r the rise,
and h a v e p r a c t i c a l l y g o t t e n c o n t r o l

o f certein sources

of

supply.

Mr. i illiems,
Mr. Miller,

I n commodities, y o u mean?
I n comtodities.

lution, b u t c o m o d i t y speculation.
that I

I t i s n o t stock specu.

T h a t i s the type o f thing

have i n mind a s being something u p o n h i c h v e have

got t o i n f o r m ourselves a n d r e g a r d i n g w h i c h v e h a v e r o t t o
either t r y t o devise some. method o f o b t a i n i n r c o n t r o l

or

else w e are n o t going t o get control. P e r s o n a l l y I heave
long Since abandoned t h e iden that b y preuching t o the

americun consumer “ e ure goinr t o get anyvhere, I

think

on the contrary w e huve s o t t o rather incite h i m t o f o
ahead o n d spend e n d consume a n d enjoy amlivervhile Living
is still g o o d w n a t h e poods c i n still b e bought, rether
than t o put the brakes u p o n himself o n d perhaps f e c i l i t : e
t
the operation f o r t h e other f e low,

*y, Molenpsh. -

long the Line o f Governor Hurding's

suggestion w i t h repsrda t o scrutinizing t h e rediscounts c s k e d
for, i s i t possible f o r t h e Governors o f the different benks,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

225
in their dealings w i t h the large c i t y banks t h e t have a
large number o f non-member a n d member accounts, t o as~

eertain i n some way how many o f those accounts are
continusous o r chronic, o r how m n y o f them may be losns for
carrying o v e r certain comrodities s u c h e s live s t o d ,
wheat a n d cotton, a n d s o forth.

I s there w a y t o find

out h o w m a n y o f thogwe a c c o u n t s a r e c o n t i n u o u s ?

T h e r e are

cértain Chicago banks, certain Philadelphia banks, which
are carrying s large number o f country bank accounts a n d
that i s where a

lot o f our trouble will probably b e i n

petting those lines d o w n t o a legitimte basis. I

do not

know whether t h e t i s possible, b u t i t seems t o m e a s though
that might b e a lepitimeate line o f action.
The Chairman.

I n regard t o t h e bank, 1

a m sorry t o

have t o s a y that t h e Federal Reserve b a n k o f Chicago h a s
some continuous borro ers, u n d I

think t h e other districts

must have them, because o f the fact thet t h e Gove:nment s e x
curities a r e n o t adjusted, t h e y are n o t lodged permanently
in the hands o f the ultimate investor perhaps.

‘ v e are

offenders t o thet extent, a n d i f any one c a n help u s o u t o f
that difficulty w e will b e glxd t o have t h e m d o it.

I n re-

gard t o the mercantile borrowers, t h e large commercial banks


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

in Chicapo, and o f course elsewhere, have depertments
which m i k e « © speciality o f c o m p i l i n g r e c o r d s w h i c h c o v e r

the v e r y matters w h i c h y o u have i n mind.
Mr. Mohlenpuh,

The Chairman.

C o u l d y o u a s k f o r t h a t informetion?

t e could ¢ s k for it, b u t I do not

see how v e could m k e a n y practicul use o f the informetion,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

mere

Governor Morss, f e vould like you t o say
something i n regard t o Mr. Mohlenpah's inquiry, end vhether
or not w e c a n make practical u s e o f that information.
Governor Morss:

T h i s statement m a y pdrhaps bear o n that.

From our conferences w i t h these important benkers,

w e have a n

executive meeting every day, Mr. Alexander, R a n k Commissioner,
is serving o n that committee,
with what i s going on.

w e keep pretty closely i n touch

N o w these banks, s u c h a s the Chemical,

thet u s e lots o f money, are, figuratively speaking, sweating

blood; they d o not like it, they are very uneasy about it.
Occasionally w e Fill have a banker c o m e i n with a smile o n

his face and will sey, "Do you notice where we are today? f e
paid you off “ 1 5 , 0 0 0 , 0 0 0 or ©20,000,000,” T h e y ere very
much pleased, s n d i n our judgment that i s the best evidence,
the best indication that t h e y are n o t going t o lend money unnecessarily f o r speculative o r non-essential purposes, because
they a r e following their o w n affairs v e r y closely a n d tell u s

so, and w e believe from the information w e get from them, the
way they are donducting their account that they are pursuing

that policy, and we think it is just a natural condition to
exist a t a n abnormal time, s u c h a s w e are going through.
The Chairman: G o v e r n o r Case, w h a t i s your opinion i n
regerd t o the question, first, a s t o whether w e could secure


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

228
from our member banks

i n the large cities s u c h informstion

asMr. Mohlenpah has stated might be useful, end if ve did
what wre might d o rith it?
Governor Case:
matter

T I think i t would b e very difficult,

o f fact i t would b e j u s t a n O p a e i s &

as a

judgement m o r e

then anything else a s t o whether a n y certain concern i s earry-

ing goods logitimately, o r rhether h e has crossed the bordor
line and i s speculating.

I t is a question o f judgment, i t

Seeris t o me, rather t h a n a very definite question o f fact.

is a pretty difficult thing t o determine.

I t

O n e has got t o know

a1] the circumstances existing i n a given line, a n d t h e ques-

tion as t o what their policy i s I think would b e very difficult.

The Chairman: Tndoubtodly the New York banks, and certeinly ell the city banks are very well informed with respect
to such accounts a s they have among their borrowing element?
Governor Case:
The Chairman:

O f course, there i s n o question about it.
O f course t h e y are n o t very proud o f those

accounts a n d they maintain a s few o f them a s possible, I

am

satisfied.

Governor Case:

A s Mr. Miller indicates, t h e borrowers

themselves a r e discussing - - - I

walked u p the street t h e

other morning, a n d two o f our large banks said they had the


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

229

pressure right o n them t o liquidate, s n d both a r e mercantile

concerns doing a legitimate business.

T I think thet i s the

indication,
The Chairman: G o v e r n o r Morss, w i l l y o u speak briefly
as t o this point, what methods y o u employ over a n d above t h e
discount rate?

Governor Moras:

O f course w e have our method o f seeing

that the papers are eligible, a n d all that sort o f thing,
which goes through t h e junior officers a n d i s called t o the
attention o f the senior officers w h e n i t seems t o b e necessary.
I suppose t h a t w e u s e m e t h o d s a n d m e a n s s i m i l a r

t o those u s o d

in & commercial b a n k i n keeping d o w n the loans o f its customers.

" e then are t o sce whether t h e y are t o o big, o r whethe-

they should b e cut dorn, and how i t shovld b e done, and the
reason why.e " e use a l l sorts o f ways; w e write letters: a s k
them t o come i n and s e e us, o r w e d o anything o f that sort t o

get hold o f the facts, and w e ask them any facts w e want t o
knov that will help u s t o form a judgment.

D u r i n g t h e last t w o

“three m o n t h s o r so, w e have h a d a Similar experience t o Ner

York, T h e loans from the country banks have diminished very
much indeed, a n d that alone seems t o have b e e n thrown o n t o
the city banks.

U p t o three o r four months a g o w e had trouble,

I mean t o say we considered banks that were over loaned were


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

in the country; p e r h a p s t h e y might b e quite small ones,
perhaps t h e y w e r e i n t h e m i d s i z e d cities,

a n d t h a t i s where

we had t h e most trouble a n d h a d t o watch o u t t h e most, b u t
Since t h e n i t h a s s h i f t e d o v e r a n d i t i s i n B o s t o n w h e r e t h e

big banks a r e that have these borroving accounts, rhere t h e
market f o r t h e sale o f the customers' p a p e r h a s been c u t off,
it has come right back o n t o those b i g banks, a n d they have
had t o take care o f that.

N o w those banks i n Boston, e n d t h e

large ones especially, a r e headed b y men who a r e t h e most
responsible ‘ o f a n y o f t h e b a n k e r s

i n the district - - - neces-

sarily so. T h e y appreciate t h e condition, t h e goneral banking
conditions.

T h e y k n o w a t this t i m e t h a t loans m u s t b e kept

down t o the lovest possible point; t h e y know that n o loans
should b e encouraged which a d d t o speculation o r lead t o
speculation i n any way, shape o r mannor, a n d I have talked
with t h e m a n d knov h o w they feel, I

done quite drastic things. I

know some o f them have

believe they are doing all

they possibly c a n t o keep those loans G o w n where t h e y belong.
The Chairman: G o v e r n o r Seay?

Governor Seay: M r . Chairman, about the first o f January
72 per cent o f our total loans were against government securities.

A t the present time 6 2 per cent a r e against s u c h gocuri-

ties. A b o u t t h e first o f January 7 3 o f our banks were b o r r o w


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

231

ing about 7 5 per cent o f the total money loaned out. b y us,
but, a s y o u observe, v e r y heavily against Government securities.

T h e amount w e were lending t h e m about January l s t

against Government securities w a s about o n e a n d o n e half
times t h e amount o f their reserve deposits.

S i n c e that time

loans against Government securities have deep Kened 76,000 600:
and t h e loans f o r commercial purposes have increased
“11,000,000.

N o w a s t o the character o f the loans, f r o m the

benefit o f four years experience w e know pretty well t h e char-

acter o f the loans that are being offered to u s b y those
banks, b u t t h e trouble i s w e d o not know t h e character o f the
loans t h e y a r e making generally t o their customers, a n d i t i s
very difficult t o get a t that knovledge.

I n the case o f banks

not s o very large o n oxamination b y tho Federal Reserve B a n k
might determine that.

I t has been our uniform custom t o re-

quire f r o m b a n k s b o r r o r i n g m o r e t h a n t h e i r s h a r e f r o m u s f o r

commercial purposes, t o require collateral, c h i e f l y t o exercise some restraint against o u r country banks borrowing t o o

heavily.
It may have b e e n overlooked t h a t commercially o n l y about
the same volume o f business i s being done, b u t that i t takes
two a n d three times t h e credit t o d o that volume o f business,
and that i s the reason commercial credit i s being used, a n d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

232

of course I T understand w e all realize that, b u t that i s the

one thing w e are u p against i n dealing with our large borrowers, they say t o us, "Our commercial houses are not doing any
more business t h a n they formerly did, i t i s the customary

thing with them t o do this, but they need two and three times
the credit t o d o the business with, a n d w e feel that w e must
let them have it".

F o r about a year w e have b e e n keeping i n

the closest kind o f touch with o u r borrowers.

“ e have corre-

sponded w i t h them, a n d w e have h a d some o f the largest borrow-

ing representatives o f some o f our largest banks and have
talked with them,

Mr. Miller: r h y does i g M a p e s balance g o u p i f their
customers a r e doing t w o and three times t h e amount o f business?

Presumably the bank i s getting two o r *hree times the receipts.
Why d o they not show i n the reserve balance?
Governor S e a y :

A s a

largely i n the reserve,

matter

o f fact I

believe

i t does v e r y

T a k e f o r instance t h e Dallas banks,

their reserve balance has doubled within a yeer. O u r reserve

balance has gone from last summer from 750,000,000 t o as high
as“66,000,000.
Mr. Miller:

T h a t i s largely offset b y bills payable?

Governor S e a y :

Y o u must renember

w e only get from 7

to

13 per cent o f the increase o f reserve deposits o f member banks,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

233

so their lines

m

a

y increase enormously against their

own deposits, a n d t h e Federal Reserve Bankswould o n l y hold
their p e r cent o f deposits a s reserve.

Mr. Miller: B u t the balance ought t o reflect itself, i t
seems t o me, i n their reduction o f their borrovings f r o m you.
Governor Seay: I

think not, I

think i f you will work

out that percentage you will find that i n lending out to member banks and giving u s only 7 to 13 per cent, their borrowings can increase t o a very much greater amount than the percentage --Governor Harding: T h a t i s very clear, i f the customer's
balance increases a n d the l o a n volume increases faster t h a n
the balance “ < <
Governor Seay: (Interposing:)

T h a t i s a question o f per-

centage which i s a very curious thing.

ing results i n some cases.

I t works o u t surpris-

A s t o lending member and non-mem-

ber banks w e have been i n touch with o u r benks closely f o r
the l a s t y e a r a n d w e h a v e b e e n a s k i n g t h e m t o g i v e u s that i n -

formation, b o t h with respect t o member banks a n d non-member

banks, a n d o n December 51st our banks were loaning “11,000,000
to non-member banks.

Y o u must not overlook, however, that

those non-member banks a r e carrying already v e r y heavy bal-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

234

ances with o u r member banks, probably carrying twice t h e
amount w i t h their member banks that t h e momber banks a r e borrowing f r o m us,

s o that

i n some respects t h e non-member b a n k s

are supporting the Federal Feserve s y s t e m y
b susteining its
deposit

i n the member banks, a n d t h e reserve banks a r e get-

hing extended.

J I am not seeking t o hide the fact that i n my

judgment t h e Federal Feserve s y s t e m i s supporting t h e nonmember banks, because I

believe s u c h i s the case. Y

think T f

have alluded t o the fact that about 7 3 o f o u r banks t h e first
of the year were borrowing about 7 5 per cent o f the entire

money loaned b y us.

A t that time some o f our member banks

were borrowing t o lend t o the Stock Fxchange i n New York,
borrowing from us "19,000,000, s o that has come down very

materially and I think it has now diminished -+Comptroller Williams:

S o m e o f your banks have beon bor-

rowing from you and lending largely i n New York?
Governor Seay:

T o the extent, o n December Slst, o f

#19,000 000.
Now addressing myself t o your particular inquiry, Dr.
Miller,

w e have recently addressed a

communication t o those

of our member banks borrowing most heavily f r o m u s about a s

follows:


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

"Will you be good enough t o advise u s what i s your policy

235
in dealing w i t h those o f your customers w h o a r e meking t h e
heaviest demands u p o n you, a n d have lerge lines vith you?
May w e a s k whether y o u satisfy yourself i n such cases that t h e
demands a r e f o r c o m m e r c i a l p u r p o s e s a n d t h a t t h e l o a n s a r e n o t

for sreculation - - - either i n commodities o r otherwise, a n d
whether t h e y come within t h e usual commercial liquidating pertod?

"May we inquire also whether i t i s your practice t o investigate whether o r not loans y o u a r e cailed u p o n t o make
ere for t h e cspecial,

o r more especial, purposes, a n d whether

it i s not possible f o r you, i n order t o meet t h e demands f o r

especial purposes, t o call i n more o f your loess essential loans?”
Comptroller "illiams:

T h e r e i s still great speculation i n |

cotton mill projects?
Governor Seay: T h e r e h a s been.

Comptroller Williams: I
a charter f o r a

was told the other day they got

new cotton mill d o w n there a n d before t h e con-

struction was put u p it was selling a t “150,
Governor Seay:

I n some cases i t has gold a s high a s “400,

Comptroller "illiams:

J I meant t o ssy, before the mill

was started, before t h e machinery w a s e v e n contracted f o r o r

gotten the stock was bought u p at ‘150. -


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Seay:

T h a t i s merely a n example o f the degree

236
of the speculation i n certain matters.
has n o w c o m e i n some m e a s u r e

“ e believe t h a t thera

o f control, b e c a u s e t h e b e n k s

in those regions where this mill speculation i s going o n
have applied f o r losns i n the cities a n d have b e e n turned dovrn
frequently.

T h a t has, i n some cases, resulted i n a very

large reduction i n the market price o f certain cotten mill
stocks, b u t nevertheless

i t i s being done a n d being done very

largely, a n d i t i s simply t h e purpose o f m y remarks t o show
you that s o far a s w e are aware w e have nuglected n o means t o
keep i n the most intimate t o u c h with o u r member banks.

Mr. Miller:

H o w long have you been pursuing the policy o f

sending out letters o f the kind you have indicated?
Governor Seay: I

should say practically three months,

but further back than that w e have been keeping i n more intimate
touch b y correspondence and b y personal interviers a s to the
nature o f the business being done b y our member banks, with

the view of looking ahead t o see how far they expected t o go ar}

what demands were contempleted.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Comptroller Williams:

H o w d i d t h e y take it, a n d d o you

it rather restrains them i n their lending?
Governor Seay’

I n the majority o f cases TIT think they

4t very kindly end, a s Mr. C a s e said, t h e y are more u n than w e are i n many cases.

T h e y heave had this pressure

heey

b r o u g h
t
n othem
pu
b y their o w n borroring customers, e n d they
do not knor h o w t o resist it.

I n many cases I

am satisfied

they aro very glad t o have u s place some ~. restraint u p o n
them i n order that t h e y m a y pass i t along t o those o f their

customers who are inclined t o g o too far. Y o u know hor eager
banking institutions are for deposits, a n d what a powerful in~
- fluence a large depositor has i n seeking t o borrow from a member bank, t h e y will retain t h e deposit a n d make h i m the loan,

and that pressure has been brought t o bear. A l o n g about December, w h e n t h e time markets a n d time funds f o r commercial purposes were being asked, a

very heavy borrower, a s k e d a

loan o f

a million dollars i n Richmond a t 5-1/2 per cent. S u c h pres-~
“sure was brought t o bear they said they could not resist i t --Comptroller Williams:

f a s that used f o r purely commercial

purposes?

Governor Seay: T h a t was used for purely commercial purposes, and one large bank, not borrowing from us a t that time,
had s e t the pace b y naming a

rate o f 5-1/2 p e r cent, e n d t h e

other banks decided t o participate i n the loan, a n d they had
to follow along against their judgment.
Comptroiler Williams:

A t a loss?

Governor Seay: F v e n a t a loss, yes.
The Chairman: G o v e r n o r Morss, I

you wanted t o say?

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

believe y o u hed 4 Ford

238

Governor Morss:

T h i s morning I

telephoned t o Boston

and asked t h e m t o send m e some figures about t h e high point

of our loans.

T I have just gotten this tolegram and would like

to read it, because I

think i t bears o u t t h e statement which

I made b o t h r e g a r d i n g t h e q u e s t i o n o f rates, I

think i t was,

to show that our loans are being reduced a t a seasonable time,
and t o show that they have had very wide fluctuations and
that they have been brought into contbol

b y the efforts o f

the member banks, perhaps sometimes o n our urging t h e m t o d o

so to help them along.

O n December 22nd the loan o f the

Federal Reserve Rank o f Poston --~ I will read thesa loans a s
the loans o f the District, and I will ignore vhether w e borrow
or whether w e lend, but the actual borrovings i n the district
on December 22nd - - 26th, / o u r loan account was “281,000,000.
That w a s t h e high point.

O n February 1 0 v e had another h i g h

point of “236,900,000, and o n April 7, which wes the close of
business yesterday, o u r net loan was “174,000,000,

A s T told

you because o f transportation difficulties our loan went u p
again i n February after i t had fallen off from the high December point, b u t through efforts o f the momber banks, through
our efforts a n d because,

o f course,

o f the transportation

question, which has helped out, itt has been reduced t o

“134,000,000, w h i c h seems t o me a very good achievement.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

£39

The Chairman:

T m Chicago, i n the varly

operation o f the bank v e adopted a
loans r e a c h e d a

c a y fsothe

plan whereby when bank

point w h e r e t h e y r e p r e s e n t e d

a n amount e q u a l

to t h e capital a n d surplus w e systematically investmated t o
gee vhat t h e occasion was f o r t h e use o f money, a n d u p t o

thet point w e loaned the deserving banks, cheerfully and
promptly, a n d following that, a n d through personal interviews,
as a result o f that practice a n d personal interviews,I think
we wore able t o maintain very good control o f the situation,
and i t i s not.until quite recently that t h e demands u p o n u s

have been very heavy.

n Chicago
J I am sure that the b a n k s i

and Detroit a n d i n the other s e v e n reserve cities i n our district, where o f course t h e largost proportion o f our loans

are, are anxious t o sec their loans reduced, because conditions a r e uniform i n all the parts o f the district o n the
point they o u g h t t o b e i n a strong position h e e instead o f a
weak position.

O u r depleted reserve h a s o n l y developed

recently, a n d i t came very suddenly, comparatively speaking a t

least.

O u r policy has been t h e r e during the last month o r

gix weeks, particularly,
larger banks,

t o keep closer i n touch Frith the

t o a s k their cooperation i n our effort t o con-

trol the situetion,

t o urge t h e m t o use their credit f o r

legitimate purposes a n d not for speculative purposes, t h a t


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

249
applying, Dr. Miller,
best w e could. e

t o inventories a n d everything e l s e a s

h a v e n o means, o f course,

speculation there i s i n inventories; I

o f knowing what

think that probably i t

is less t h a n y o u have i n mind, b u t I + do not knor, but, never-

theless, that i s the policy w e have pursued, a n d I believe that
it i s going t o b e effective.

Mr. Miller: W o u l d such a bank as the First Trust and
Sevings i n Chicago,

i n your opinion,

b e a commercial bank, w i t h

its loans made mainly for commercial purposes?
The Cheirman:

T I should say not, although the Pirst Trust

& Savings R e n k i s a commercial b a n k for some purposes.

The

First National a n d t h e Continental National R a n k have demand

deposits.

Y o u know they g o upstairs, a n d what they d o not take

upstairs t h e y t a k e downstairs.

Mr. Miller:

I t works t h a t way.

Y e t i n proportion t o their reserve balances

they Yorrow i n excess o f the First National and the Continental
National, about three times their reserve balance they have
borrowed f r o m the Reserve Rank.

The Chairman: “ h i l e the Continental and the First National ere borrowing,

a t least seemingly t o m e very heavily, t h e y

are not excessive from the standpoing of the amount they contribute t o our l o a n resources.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. Miller:

T h a t i s the reason I

asked.

241

Comptroller “illiams:
The Chairman:

H o w much are they borroving?.

T h e Continental, w h e n I left, w a s borrow-

ing “80,097,000 and the First National I think about
“57 5000 ,000
Mr. Miller: I

have figures here, o f date March 19th, the

Continental “58,997,000 and the First Netional *46,00%,000;
the Continental borrowed o n e a n d tvo-thirds i t s reserve balance, b u t t h e First Trust &

Savings, w h i c h i s 8 non-commercial

bank, three times i t s reserve balance.
Comptroller Filliams:
The Chairman:

O n government bonds mainly.

N o , o u r government bonds a r e a

comparatively

sm@1l1 proportion o f our loans.
Governor Norris:

The Chairman:

N o t f r o m Philadelphia.

I t is just the other way. B u t I want t o

say in regard to the First National Bank, and to assure you
that b a n k will b e very happy v h e n they c a n reduce this in-~

debtedness, a n d trat i t i s a perfectly legitimate demand, a n d
it i s a strange fact they have had a reduction o f “9,000,000,

Mr. Miller: H o v do you Imow it is a perfectly legitimate
demand? I

have b e e n told i t was a perfectly illegitimate d e -

mend f r o m those w h o knor something o f it.

The Chairman: W h e n I spoke o f the logitivate demand, i t s
being a o legitimate d e m a n d , I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

refer n o w t o t h e d e m a n d u p o n u s ,

242

Mr. Comptroller, since particularly along about the middle o f
March when their deposits commenced t o g o down and w e had t o
teke care o f that situstion,

i t was necessary.

T h e Federal

Peserve R a n k h a d a n opportunity there t o render a

real service,

and I do not know whet w e rould have d o n e vithout i t .
Secretary Houston:

* ¢ 6 have listened t o these various

comments o f controlling credit i n addition t o the rates.

The

latest figures that were given m e show that from June 6 to
March 2 6 the holdings o f government paper were reduced a
billion dollers, e n d thet from Januery 2 to March 2 6 the

loans o n government paper were reduced 600,000,000, that the
other loans o f the banks f r o m June 6

t o March 2 6 increased

3.6 billion dollars, a n d that from January 2 to March 2 6 the
other l o a n s i n c r e a s e d a

billion a n d e

does not seem t o be controlling.
are v e going t o land?
control,

our d i s t r i c t

N o w that

I s this going on? W h e r e

t e are talking o f various methods o f

a n d apparently

The Chairman:

half dollars.

i t i s n o t effective.

M r . Secretary, i t i s m y opinion, s o fer a s

i s concerned,

remedy, t h a t i s the rate.

t h a t w e have n o t applied t h e best

T h e rates a r e t o o low, t h e y a r e t o o

low o n government secured paper.
Secretary Houston:

T h e loans

c n government p a p e r h a v e

been reduced #600,000,000 since January.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

243
The Chairman: I

understand, but r e are still loaning

perhaps s billion and four hundred million dollars o n government s e c u r e d p a p o r a t p r e f e r e n t i a l r a t e s .

Secretary Houston:

Y e t i t i s your other loans which have

increased most considerably.

The Chairman: I
ter d

think that i s natural, because a s a mat-

fact a s the loans expand I

suppose t h e banks used

practically all the government securities they had.
Secretary Houston: S t i l l our controlling rates o n government securities would not control the credit situation.
The Chairman:

I t would h e l p t o d o it.

Secretary Houston:

N o t unless you controlled aiso the

other rates.

Governor Seay: B o t h would g o u p together?
Secretary Houston:
Governor Case:

Yes.

I t seems t o m e that partly t h e answer

to the Secretary's figures there i s this, that you g o back t o
last June and the Treasury ves borroving very large suns o f
money, they were the big, dominant factor i n the market, the
big borrower t o the exclusion o f a good many o f these commercial interests.

A l l through the war, borrowing five o r six

billion dollars e v e r y little while, t h e y were absorbing
credit that ordinarily would g o for commercial purposes, a n d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

244
that after June, a s their requirements b e g a n t o taper off,

then very neturally some o f this commercial demand began t o
assert itself a s the government got out o f the way.
to m e i t i s just a

switching affair, a n d not a

I t seems

big increase,

but the government was taking less and the commercial interests were beginning t o manufacture automobiles a n d other things

while the government was getting that credit before.
Mr. Miller:

B u t i f you take just the recent period, since

the advance i n rates January 23rd, a n d simply take i t for t h e

860 reporting member banks, w e have got a n expansion o f over
helf a billion dollars, a l l o f which i s i n the commercial
loan account; there h a s been a reduction i n the government
secured paper.

Y o u r district i s a n exbepbion; y o u have held

yours about tight, i t is just about what i t was Tanuary 23rd,
but t h e other districts s h o w a n increase o f well over half a

billion dollars i n the loan account, a n d a n increase o f
over “ 4 0 0 , 0 0 0 , 0 0 0 i n their b i l l s p a y a b l e p u t u p w i t h t h e

reserve banks a n d rediscounted.
Governor Case: I

think,

a s Mr, S e a y pointed out, t h e

higher prices s r e requiring t h e u s e o f two t o tro a n d a half
Collars today t o d o the work o f one normally, a n d these credit
concerns, W h o were n o t i n the market a

year ago, t h e y rere

working for the Government and getting their money from it;


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

now they are coming i n the market and require tro dollars
where t h e y then required o n l y one.

I t seems t o m e that par-

tially answers thet situation.
Secretary H o u s t o n :
that e x t e n t

B u t t h e prices h a v e n o t gone u p t o

i n that period.

Comptroller Villiams:
and, f u r t h e r m o r e ,

T h e y have n o t g0ne u p a t all,

t h e c r e d i t e x p a n s i o n i n c r e a s e s t h e prices.

Governor Hording: J

think there i s n o question that a

great part o f this credit expansion comes f r o m personel e x travagance, t h a t t h e u s e o f non-essentials
blame f o r it, but, amplifying what I

i s very lergely t o

said e moment ego, I

think w e ought not lose sight o f the fact that nu preseht conditions are very different from what they vere during 1917
and 1918.

T h e country i s not a t war now, D u r i n g t h e war

people were working e n d willing t o put u p with a l l kinds o f
severe conditions, a l l kinds o f restrictions; t h e y went along
loyally e n d enthusiastically a n d supported t h e government.

N o w

ordinarily i n this country ~ - - I have b e e n a banker f o r twenty~
eight years, I

have b e e n o n this Board f o r s i x years, I

devoted s i x o f the better years o f m y life, that I
have, a n d I

have

will ever

a m very anxious t o see t h e Federal Reserve system

made a success, a s I know a l l o f you a r e anxious t o see i t made


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

246
& success, but I think w e would b e very blind t o the
facts o f
the case i f we fail t o realize that the average business
man,
the average p e n e o f directors o f a bank anywhere i n
the country feel that h e i s c a p a b l e , o
t some extent, o f attending t o
his

o n business.

I n o r d i n a r y t i m e s h e resents w h a t a p p e a r s

to b e dictation o r dominetion b y a central authority o r a

central board i n Washington.

T h e average banker throughout

the country, horever m u c h h e m a y respect t h e authorities
here, a s long a s they limit themselves t o the application o f
the written lew, i n ordinary times i f a governmental board

should undertake t o direct people along the lines o f which
they were perfectly willing t o b e directed i n war times, r e
would meke ourselYes, f

think,

i f not ridiculous, certainly r e

“ould p u t ourselves i n a n impos sible position.
force p e o p l e

" ™ e could n o t

t o follow o u r lead, b e c a u s e e f t e r a l l t h e a v e r -

age m a n i n a community cannot h e l p escape t h e conclusion that

he i s better able t o attend t o his own business, his o n
specialized a n d individualized business t h a n a board that i s
made u p o f seven m e n sitting here i n Yashington c a n attend t o
it for him.
“e have g o t plenty o f lew. S e c t i o n 4
Reserve A c t h a s v a s t possibilities.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

of the Federal

T h i s n e w amendment h a g

247
vast possibilities, a n d i t seems t o m e that w e have pretty

thoroughly tried out this matter o f warning end writing t o
banks. I

think the letter Governor “eay wrote was excellent

and tactful, but i t had got t o be exceedingly tactful; i f you
had written slong other lines y o u would h a v e done more h a r m
than good, a n d everything which tends toward t h e direction o f
private business b y governmental boards h a s g o t t o b e handled

with gloves; i t is a very delicate matter.

A s long a s you

keep within the law, the average national banker,whon the
Comptroller o f the Currency reminds h i m o f the law,

h e is

scrupulous t o kecp rithin the lan, pays 6 great deal o f respoct
to the rulings g i v e n t o him, a n d vhenever t h e Federal Reserve
Board adhere t o the law, point o u t t h e l a w and convince t h e
person i t i s the law, t h e n they commend respect, b u t i f they
should undertake t o assume a n arbitrary attitude,

o r give a

direction n o t clearly authorized b y the law, t h e n w e are going
to stir u p antagonism.
While i t i s very desirable w e should reduce t h e u s e o f
non-essentials,

w e cannot create a

thought overnight.

revolution i n American

W e have g o t t o work o u t some rate schedule

so that t h e shoe will begin t o pinch t h e m a n that does n o t
discriminate f o r himself, t h a t t h e m a n who i s extravagant a n d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

248
spending more money t h a n h e has a n d has g o t t o g o t o the bank
to morrow money t o keep u p his extravagant needs will meet

with the proposition a t the benk that, "Your paper i s good,
but t h e Federal Reserve B a n k has raised i t s rate o n us, s o v e
cannot take this paper, o r i f w e take i t a t all w e have g o t
to impose some restrictions

o n it,

o n which they will ellow

you t o borrow.” T h e n w e will b e d e a n etrontirs t o establish
a control. I

had hoped before v e left this morning there

would b e some discussion a s t o the possibilities o f this new
emendment. I
matter

think the wey t o control the situetion i s i n the

o f rates.

The Chairman: I

think, Governor Harding, w e have not had

the opportunity that a t least our Board desires i n undertaking
to control i t b y the rate fully.

Governor Harding: N o , I do not think you have.
The Chairman: I
we have. I

believe,

think that i s the most effective weapon
a s I have s a i d before, t h a t t h e rates

are t o o l o w a t the present time.

Comptroller Williams:

D o you think the commercial rates

should g o a b o v e s i x p e r c e n t ?

The Chairman:

O n discount?

Comptroller Williams:


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i

Yes.

249

The Chairman:

I f necessary I should like t o try the

rate o f s i x per cent straight through. I

do not believe t h e

fact that t h e loans e r e o n government securities, D r . Miller,
has, o r means anything a t all, because a n y bank, Frith ordinary
intelligence,

i f i t had a n y more govornient securities t o put

up would n o t p u t u p c o m m e r c i a l p a p e r .

wr, Miller:

B u t t h e fact i s they a r e putting u p commer-

cial paper a n d t h e other stuff has r u n out.
Governor H a r d i n g :

I f the s i x per cent rate does n o t hold

the bank d o w n vould y o u impose those h i g h rates?
Mr. Miller:

S i x per cent h a s been t h e effective rate, a n d

if thet does n o t control it, i t indicates, f r o m your point o f

view, that six per cent i s not high enough.
The Chairman: W h a t I wanted t o make clear, i f I can, i s
that with a preferential r a t e o n government securities a
with ordinary intelligence,

bank,

i s going t o borrow o n those

securities i f they can get their hands o n them, and the fact,
they have n o t gone a n y higher, a n d °

the fact w e have gone i n t o

commercial paper instead o f government bonds does n o t mean they

would not have gone higher --Mr. Miller:

B u t certainly, w h e n y o u are discussing t h e

question o f control f r o m the point o f view o f the rate, t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

250
rate that i s most nearly t o b e regarded a s the effective r a t e
ig the rate u p o n commercial peper.
Secretary Houston:

I t seems t o m e that what Governor

MeDougel says i s a sufficient indicatéon that merely raising
the r a t e o n paper s e c u r e d

be effective.

b y government securities w o u l d n o t

Y o u r mero statement t h a t t h e y cannot g e t t h e

paper i s a sufficient answer, a n d they a r e therefore going t o
borrow o n the commercial paper, a n d I have b e e n convinced, I

am

perfectly willing a s a member o f the Roard t o see anything done
that i s necessary,

i f anything i s necessary t o secure credit

control, b u t t h e very fact that y o u state that t h e y cannot g e t

the government paper, fortified b y the fact that the loans o n
government paper since January have decreased “600,000,000,

is

conclusive t o m y mind that y o u cannot g e t i t merely b y putting
the rate o n government paper v p t o the commercial rate, a n d

if there i s need for action, a n d that action should b e taken
through rates, I

should think w e would have t o consider t h e

whole schedule o f rates, b u t I

a m also convinced t h a t y o u will

not g e t i t solely through that, a n d t T have been hopeful that
through v e r y definite direction o f attention t o the fact that
businessn
e
m and member bankers must pay, must give t o this
matter, will solve this question o f credit extension, fortified


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

251
by the u s e o f this amendment.

B u t , repeating what I

have

said, IT am satisfied that the facts prove that merely. changing
the rate o n paper secured b y government paper will n o t effect
credit control, a n d that y o u have g o t t o consider whether
you will d o i t b y & general increase o f rates,
can e f f e c t

i

o r whether y o u

t b y these other methods.

Governor Seay: M r . Secretary, i t is perfectly plain that
the expansion i n credit has been brought about b y the interior
banks, I think.
Secretary Houston:
in that.

I t looks a s i f there were a good deal

N o w Iwill give you just one trifling illustration,

which n e v e r t h e l e s s

i s typical, A

little c o u n t r y b a n k i n t h e

agricultural region of South Carolina, we will say, whose
deposits l a s t summer were barely $200,000, through the srle

ofcrops were increased to $600,000. T h a t little bank
proceeded t o lend out the mnonsy and gad it, N o w , i t finds

that its deposits from $600,C0O are likely to go back to$300,000.

I t is mrely typical, although the amount is very

Sivali. . T h e y are finding that i s the CaIC.

T u e i r own

depositors have drawn upon the bank for ths money, ami have
used i t i n all avenues o f imlustry and speculation, beyond

question.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

852
Com troller Williaus.
Secretary Houston.

A r d i n luxury?

A n d luxury. T h e r e f o r e i t i s

perfectly plain how credit exypansion has bean drought
about b y expansion o f the interior, and, inasmuch a s that

involves some 20,000 banking institutions, i t all the
more @ffectsof control, but, with respect t o the owner~
ahip o f Goverment securities, Ithink that the amount
held b y our banks 4 s sone five o r six billion dollars, i s

it not?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Comptroller Williaus.

A l l kids, including certifi-

cates?
Secretary Houston.

Y e s .

Coup troller Williams. P r o b a b l y i n that neighborheod,
inoluding the amount o n which they are loaning, State

and National.
Seorstary Houston.

T h e Federaizem Reserve banks

only have about a billion and three quarters loaned
that
against Government securities, therefore there is
snbig volume o f Government seourad paper ‘back thers t o
able them t o make assaults,
Reserve Banks.

w e will say, U p o n t h e Federal

253
T h a t includes certificates

Comptroller Williams.
of indebtedness, o f course?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Y

Secretary H o u s t o n .
The Chairman.

O

e

s sir.

f course y o u must realizs that

a n d most o f
thoss a r s distributsd among a l l ths Danks,
resources;
@hich banks have n o a c c e s s t o our loaning
they a r e not memser banks.

Governor Seay.

Y o s .

S o that the point i s tais,

inoreases and is
that there i s a demand for credit Which
and those banks find
increasing, a n d ths rate goes Up,
will apply t o us for
they can lend profitably, a n d they
more and mors loans o n Government securities.
lication. I
still room there for very large app

There i s
am very

che remedy liss very
firmly i n agreement with you that
ratss i n those casss.
plainly i n the inerease o f

notwithstanding the
I an also o f the opinion that,
they have dons within
fact that loans have eaxpandsd a s
W e have brought + o
this period, that the measures which
not s a y that
p3en fait, a n d I can
bear have n o t fully y e t

at the moment I

a n inmediate ina m preparsd t o rscommenmi

I velisve that ths propaganda,
oreass i n rates, becauses

54

Which i s the popular word, i f you so care t o use it, a s
We have used it, i s having a n effect upon the country;
that ig, i t is permeating all the banks, anc that we have
not yet felt t h e full results o f cur efforts.
Ths Chairman.

M y . Sserstary,

i s there anything fur-

ther you would like to inquire o r state upon this subject?
Secretary Houston.

T h a t is all.

Governor Calkins. I

should like t o make this in-

quiry, Which seems t o me pertinent.

T h e purpose o f

banking a n d t h e purpose o f the Faderal Reserve system i s

the stimulating o f

t r a d e .

W o u l d not the most ef-

fective first step i n obtaining credit control b e that o f
getting o u t o f the Federal Reserve Banks G o v e r n m e n t s e -

cured paper, Which i s not self-liquidating, a s we vey
well know, and, ifnecessary, gatting in, i n its places,
trae paper, which i s self—liquidating?
The Chairman,

I

t is for that very purpose that we

should like t o have the opportunity o f adjusting
tates o n Government secured paper. <

o w

think i t is very

necessary that w e gst the Government secursd paper o u t

ifwe can. I

think in these times, Mr. Calkins, that

the banks should work with that object i n view, that w e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

355
Should eliminate f r o m our resources a t this time our

bankers’ acceptances, creating a warkst for them, i f we
can, a n d conserve o u r resources f o r commercial a n d indus-

trial uses.
ter, I

T h e fewer investments w e have now the bet-

think.

Governor Morss.

M r . Ghairman, I

should like t o s a y

one o r two things that are perfectly obvious, o f couuse.
Tae reason that w e have not got control c f this oredit
Situation i s because there i s a such a fearful extravagance amongst all kinds o f people, personal extravagance.
You take o u r mills: t h e y c a n sell everything t h e y c a n

turn out; price does not seem to make mich difference.
. They can sell automobiles the same Way, a n d everything
goes t o personal extravagance.

N o w , I believe myself

that the banks, a n d especially ths larger and more responsible banks i n the country, f e a r this situation, a n d

would fear further advances i n prices, a n d would b e very
glad t o see t h e loaning g o down, b u t i n the case o f this
extravagance t h e y a r e s o far comparatively helpless,

You do not know whethar you can control i t or not, b y any
means, D u t when y o u come t o talk too freely, t o o mich,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

or put your retes u p too far, y o u have g o t such a high
range o f prices that y o u might start something that would
be pretty bad; a n d y o u have t o b e a little careful h o w
you d o it.
Now, i n our District,

w e feel that w e would n o t want

to put u p the rates right now.
working.

W e think that t h e thing i s

‘ “ e would t r y t o get b y with these rates, without

raising them, but I would not want to say a month from now
that I

would s a y the same thing; I

might change m y mind,

but i f w e c a n g e t b y without r a i s i n g rates,
we o u g h t t o d o i t , f o r c e r t a i n l y a

t o m y mind, t h e n

commercial r a t e o f d i s -

count t o t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e R a n k a b o v e s i x p e r c e n t i s a n

emergency rate, and you want to be pretty careful how you
use it, but use i t i f necessary.
The Chairman:

O f course, Governor Morss, y o u arc

speaking f r o m the viewpoint o f Boston, and, f r o m the vier-~point o f its c m b e n t Situation, y o u are making progress,

and w e would not be i n favor, necessarily, o f uniform discount rates a l l over t h e country, vould you?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Morss:

N o , but I

feel that a little

257

wider t h a n t h e B o s t o n rate.

O f course

i f i n another d i s -

trict t h e y feel differently a n d want t o put u p their r a t e
I would n o t question that,
Secretary Houston:

Y o u have a

much more uniform, e s -

tablished condition i n Boston i n banking than they have i n
the west o r southrest,
Governor Morss:

‘ e d o not have c r o p demands, seasonal

demands, w e do, though, have heavy demands which come i n
December and June every year, but w e are kept going b y the demands f o r o u r goods.

Secretary Houston:

B u t you have very fer banks thet lend

at 10 to 1 5 per cent a s some o f these gentlemen said they
have?
Governor Morss:

N o , w e d o not d o that.

Secretary Houston: I
whet Governor Morss says; I

think there i s a great deal i n
think there i s much i n what

Governor Harding said about bankers resenting control, b u t
as a matter o f fact most o f our disasters o f the past have
come f r o m the fact that business m e n and bankérs d i d net
know their o w n business a n d d i d not exercise t h e requisite

restraint.

I n periods o f rapid dovelopment that i s where

the danger comes, and the trouble i s i t goes t o the point


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

258
that i t gets beyond control before anything i s done t o bring
about a change,
Governor Pellborn:

J u s t o n that point,

m y observation

4s that t h e member banks a r e vory anxious t o cut d o w n thetr
loans, e s these gentlemen have stated, b u t i t i s the competition between t h e banks.
Secretary Houston’

B u t that indicates need o f control.

Governor Tellborn: T h e r e f o r e i t needs some power t o
control. I

think this n e w amendment i s merely t h e safety

valve o f the system right now.

In v i e w o f p e n d i n g a m e n d m e n t s

t o t h e Federal Reserve

Act authorizing progressive rates f o r large borrovings what should b e the basis o f the normal line?

The Chairman: N o w , gentlemen, bearing o n this subject
we have No. 2 , which I think should b e considered a t the

present time,"fn view of pending amendments t o the Federal
Reserve A c t authorizing progressive rates f o r large borrowings what should b e the basis o f the normal line?” T h e n i t

goes on"{a) Capital and surplus of mevtber banks; (b) total
resources o f member banks;

( c ) deposits o f member banks;

(a) reserve balance o f member banks; (e) loan capacity of


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

259
Federal HKeseive Bank

p r o r a t e d e
- amenber
e m
h o n
tbanks
g
i n pro-

portion t o the reserve balance o f each.”
Mr. Secretary,

gestions

o r Governor Harding,

i f you have a n y sug-

a s t o how w e should proceed o n this w e would b e very

glad to consider and follow them. I

will say that we dis-

cussed these matters, these particular subjects, yesterday
informally;

w e t o o k n o action;

w e k n o w what t h e consensus

of

opinion is, that i s all. B u t i f you rwould like t o hear from
the individual representatives, I
upon them. G e n e r a l l y speaking,

should b e very glad t o call

a s I remember i t , t h e consensus

of opinion was that i n view o f the fact that o u r loaning power
is m e a s u r e d

b y t h e a m o u n t o f reserve d e p o s i t s a n d c a p i t a l c o n -

tributed b y the member banks, t h a t t h e amount o f that

c o n -

trollable b y each member bank, t h a t i s their reserve deposit
plus their capital investment, should b e used sas a basis f o r
determining t h e so-called normal loan.

I f TI am not stating

that correctly will someone correct me?
Governor Harding:

I n regard t o the application o f this

amendment , i f the President should approve i t , I

believe t h a t

a little uneertainty f o r a while would have a very good effect.

Y o u have g o t this club, a n d every bank that i s a heavy

borrower w i l l know that this i s liable t o apply t o him, é n d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

he d o e s n e t k n o w i n what w a y i t m a y apply, a n d t h e v e r y

uncertainty o f the situation may make him careful and tend
to reduce h i s loan.

T h a t period o f uncertainty e t the same

time would g i v e y o u a n opportunity t o study t h e situation
very carefully, a n d carefully mature your plans a s t o how

you would want t o make i t effective later on.
Governor Case:

N e w York would l i k e t o support t h e view

advanced b y Governor Harding a s he has just expressed it.

" e

feel i t might b e a very useful c l u b t o have tucked a w a y o n
the shelf, b u t o u r member banks should n o t knor i n just what
way i t would h i t them, a n d i f h e knows directly just h o w i t

will hit him he will adjust himself accordingly, b u t i f he
Goes not know, vhy3, I

say we will try t o keep under any-

thing that would sevor o f a n abnormal line,
Governor Fancher:

J I think already some o f the banks

borrowing v e r y s u b s t a n t i a l a m o u n t s a r e q u i t e c o n c e r n e d ,

quite apprehensive a s t o just what i s going t o take place,

what i s going t o happen, h o w i t is going t o be applied, and
TIthink the effect will b e yards very good, but I quite agree
with you and Mr. Case that I think w e should agree upon the
fundamentals,

g e t this t h i n g s e t up, h a v e i t s o w e c a n oper-

ate i t i f necessary, b u t rather hold i t back and let i t be


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

261
rather a n extreme situation where i t i s applied. r

think t h e

very fact w e have g o t t h e amendment, t h e very fact that i t c a n
be applied, w i l l h a v e a

very d e t e r r i n g e f f e c t ,

and I

hope i t

will not b e necessary, a n d I hope w e can correct the situation without applying i t i n any way.
Governor Harding:

Y o u can keep the whole situation a

little b i t hazy; y o u have observed t h e effect o f i t i n these

tariff revisions, a s long a s there was h b c r e n i a e a s t o
where the tariff was going t o be a check o n business things
quieted down.

T h e very moment t h e y know just what i t i s they

will adjust themselves t o it. T h e same thing applies t o banks;
the banker i s no fool; y o u know he knows how t o adjust himself
to conditions very well, i f he just knows what the conditions
&ree

Governor Mores:

M a y I express a little different view?

I found i n our experience i n our district t h a t t h e greatest

fear the bankers had was that the Federal Reserve Rank should
absolutely refuse them credit. T h a t i s what they ere afraid
of, and 1 f we talk t o a member. bank about a loanthe thing behind
us all i s the authority that w e have t o dis dnoat l y refuse any
credit o n thet,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Harding:

Y o u still have that authority under

Section 4 .
Governor Morss:

“ e have, a n d t h e y sre afraid o f that.

One o f the bankers i n Boston, then w e were talking about this
graduated discount rate bill, said, “That would b e fine, w h e n
we have that bill, w h e n i t comes along, w h e n the rules a r e
made b y the Federal Reserve Board o f what your monthly line
is, a n d what t h e advance shall b e i f you want a further l o a n

|

every bank will know exactly what i t can get at the Federal
Reserve Rank, and i t will b e a great relief t o the bankers
thet t h e y will n o t b e refused a n d practically c a n not b e re-

fused.”
Governor Seay:

B u t there i s a limit, t h a t i s t a the sup-

“ply of credit which the paderal Reserve Renks have.
Governor Morss:

T I understand that this bill, end the

rules o f theBoard d o not propose t o take away t h e actual
authority o f the officers o f the banks t o refuse credit, b u t

you fear the absolute discretion which i s known t o reside i n
the officers today, y o u establish a

rule b y the Federal R e -

serve Board,and t h e y a r e a board o f appeal f r o m the o f ficers
of the bank. P e r s o n a l l y I
the statute books, I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

would rather n o t have that l a w o n

would control i t better.

Governor Harding:

Y o u have had the right all along,

263
under Section 4 , t o decline t h e credit, b u t y o u have found i t
inexpedient t o refuse t o grant t h e credit a t all, b u t y o u
want t o get better control o f t h e situation, therefore y o u
have raised your rate.
books,

W i t h this present l a w o n the statute

i f you feel your present rates a r e t h e top, a s high

as they ought t o go, t h e n y o u have g o t t h e additional power
to impose a n additional rate o n the f e w excessive borrowers

that you may have without affecting the general level o f
rates o n all banks i n your district.
Governor Morss:
heve h e d

t

i

m

T h a t i s very true.

T h e point {4s te 4 1 1

e t o establish thet point o f vier, because

the natural point o f view, i t seems t o me, i s the o n e TI have

indicated by one of our member banks, that the authority of
the Federal Reserve officers h a s been transferred, practically

transferred into a ruling b y the Federal Reserve Board, a n d
yhen y o u tell t h e m that their normal line i s s o much, a
that w e have always avoided, a

thing

thing that w e have always avoid-

ed i n everything w e have ever said, when we state that minimum
rate w h y I think that t h e banks w h o a r e n o t borrowing thet
normal line, I

think i t will b e a n invitation t o them t o come

in and get it. T h e y will feel they are not using the Federal
Reserve Ranks f o r what t h e y are entitled to, a n d I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

should l i k e

264

to see those lines increased, a n d a s f a r a s the increase i n
rate, w h y i f they c a n arrange t o pass t h e extra expense along

to their customers, o r something like that, they will say,
"Of course w e can get it, all we have got t o d o i s t o pay the
price", a n d i t makes i t very much more difficult f o r t h e @ fi-

cers o f the banks, with that ruling between them and their discretion,

i t makes i t very hard - - -

Governor Miller: D o e s not each one know i t is entitled
certain line?
Governor Morss' W o , sir.

Governor Miller: T h e y d o
Governor M o r s s :

Governor Miller:

N o , sir.

T h e l a v says that.

Governor Morss: T h e y are entitled t o fair treatment
according t o circumstances a n d due regard t o ---

Governor Miller: (Interrupting: ) T h e y knor that i s 4
mathematical p r o p o s i t i o n ?

Governor Morss:

W o t with us, i t i s not «

mathematical

proposition a t all.

Governor Miller: T h e y knoy they are entitled t o a reasonable l i n e .


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Morss:

T h e y knov t h e y c a n come a n d borror, b u t

265

then there i s always t h e chance - - - suppose y o u came t o borrow

and told u s you wanted t o borrow mome money and put i t into
the N e w York call money market a t 1 5 per cent?

Governor Miller: T h a t would b e ineligible, o f course.
Governor Morss:

I f you had bills a n d therefore i t was

eligible p a p e r .

Mr. Miller: I

do not understand t h a t a n y bank i s re-

quired t o use this device.

I f you prefer t o offer i t through

the exercise o f your o w n discretion, dealing vith your members, y o u are free t o d o it.
Governor Morss: I

should hope that I

use i t or not just a s I pleased.

could b e free t o

B u t there i s always a little

bit o f fear that t h e reserve board might come i n between a n d
impose those regulations.
Governor Harding:
features o f the act.

T h i s does n o t change t h e essential
I t does n o t change Section 43; i t does

not change your right t o make i t function i n a particuler case.
Governor Morss: I
eral opinion, b u t I

do not like t o disagree v i t h t h e gen-

hope y o u will sxcuse m o i f I present

another p o i n t o f v i e w f o r t h e s a k e o f i l l u m i n a t i n g t h e w h o l e
question.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Mr. Miller: I

think o n the general proposition y o u are

266

perfectly right a n d I agree with you, a n d f o r m y o w n point
of view this i s for district governors w h o cannot control
by administration, b u t w e have g o t a situation which indicates 4 t i s s u f f i c i e n t l y
visable,

i c e

m e t s t h e amendment v e r y 3 d -

t h e supplemental amendment,

dnd I

should b e v e r y

loathe t o see this applied i n any district r h @ e reserve

banks shored that i t could cope with its credit situation b y
the more natural a n d usual methods t h a t t h e reserve banks
have employed, t h a t i s through pressure a n d administration.

The Chairman: W h e r e would you think the line o f demarketion might come, Dr. Miller? T h a t i s when w e are going
to get belor this arbitrarily fixed 4 0 per cent, o r where
and h o w l o n g after w e get’ under i t ?
for instance,

O f course, t a k e Chicago,

w e are r u n down i n that hill right nov, b u t w e

are going t o build i t u p pretty fast, I

think.

W e should

like t h e opportunity t o d o that before w e undertake t h e u s e
of this control.

Governor Case: M r . Chairman, i t is half past twelve
‘and w e have taken u p a good deal o f time discussing this
subject o f credit control.

‘ h i l e w e have t h e Secretary o f

the Treasury with u s vould i t not b e desirable t o take u p
subject No. 6 , Rates?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

267
G overnor Calkins: I

believe i t i s the opinion o f a very

large majority o f the Governors here present that Governor

Harding's suggestion that this amendment should not b e made
operative until there h a s been opportunity t o let i t sink in,
and opportunity f o r t h e officers o f the banks t o study i t s
provisions i s a good suggestion, a n d I should l i k e very much
to s e e that brought o u t b y discussion among t h e Governors
before w e p a s s o n t o another s u b j e c t .

Governor Seay: B r i e f l y , Mr. Chairman, while w e are all,
I think, p r e p a r e d

t o agree u p o n t h e basis

it i s established, I

o f the rule w h e n

for o n e a m sure that t h e difficulties

that will arise w h e n w e come t o apply i t will b e evident.

I n

the first place w e have been cautioned b y the Governor o f the
Board that t h e counsel o f the Board h a s given.an opinion that
when t h e rule i s applied i t will have t o b e applied uniformly
to the banks. I

should rather have i t a goblin lurking i n the

shadows a s a n element o f restraint.
come t o a p p l y i t a r e soiling

T h e difficulties w h e n r e

t o b e v e r y great,

and I

do not

think w e should b e prepared t o apply i t withvuut v e r y mature
consideration.

The Chairman:

I n viow o f Governor Calkins' suggestion I

should like t o ask whether o r not a n y o f the Governors here


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

would b e opposed t o folloving that plan?
Governor Calkins: I

make a

motion t o that effect.

(The motion was duly seconded.)
The Cheirman:

W i l l y o u repeat your m o t i o n ?

Governor Calkins:

T h a t i t i s not expedient t o put this

provision o f this amendment i n t o effect until i t has been

before the member banks t o familiarize themselves with it,
and f o r the governors a n d officers o f the member reserve
banks t o study the cuestion.

(The motion was seconded b y Governor Case.).
The Chairman:

I s there any comment o r discussion?

Governor Miller:
time. I

T h a t i s a relative term, a s t o what

think i t vould b e our purpose t o put i t i n just a s

quickly a s w e c a n get i t passed.

The Chairman: I

would suggest, i f you have n o objec-

tion, that you include there, "Until the Governors o r the
bankers themselves a n d the Board",

o f course w e are a l l a t

sea; l e t u s have t h e opportunity o f studying a n d forming o u r
conclusions.

Governor Calkins: T h a t i s what I meant t o say, and T
will supplement t h a t b y adding, " a n d until after a

confer-

ence has been held t o discuss it.”
Governor “ellborn: I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

differ with these gentlemen about

269

think n o w i s the time t o d o i t

putting this into effect. I

before matters g e t t o o far, a n d I

slso think i t ought t o b e

uniform throughout the whole ®edoral Reserve system, because
some o f the banks t h a t think they d o not need it, i t may turn,
out they d o need i t first.’ I

knor when I first came o n this

board i t was thought some o f the banks vould have t o rediscount
with others, especially d o w n i n our section, b u t w e did not
have t o d o i t } t h e y r e d i s c o u n t e d w i t h u s , a n d f o r t h a t v e r y

reason I think with this important matter controlling credit,
{t ought t o be anounced a n d put i n by all banks t o save time,
otherwise s o m e banks will have t o take care o f other banks i f
they are t o o lenient a n d l e t things g o along. G o v e r n o r Morss
has s a i d t h e y have h a d more t h a n anybody else, b u t his has n o t
been s o much contrdal a s seasonal deductions a n d things p a i d o f f
in their course.

H e has n o t controlled i t a t all; T I think i t

is the other way.
Tho Chairman:

A s I understood t h e matter yesterday Governol

Herding made i t very clear that i t was n o t t h e expectation n o r
the intention that w e make this uniformly applicable i n all
districts a t the same time, that circumstances would guide us.

Govornor Wellborn: I

think all ought t o have i t the same

time, because 8 1 1 a r e i n the same boat.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

270

Governor Miller: M r . Chairman, I

think i t would b e

rather remarkable f o r this conference t o resolve t o set aside
the operation o f a law passed b y Congress a n d passed a t a

time when i t was thought most dosirable t o enable the Board,
and the Federal Reserve Banks t o control credit.
think that a

T f do not

resolution should b e passed b y the Governors o f

this Conference t h a t would apply t o all districts, a
application.

dragnet

I f the Governor f r o m California does n o t want t o

put it in, why let us move that he need not put it in.
Governor Calkins: VYould you read the motion a s made?
Governor Harding: I

have very grave doubts myself a s t o

the binding effect o f a resolution passed b y the Governors

here, because the law i s very explicit i n its terms, a n d i f

the directors o f any particular Federal Reserve Bank want to
put i t i n they would have a perfect right t o put i t u p to the

Federal Reserve Board, say, "This i s what we want t o do", and
I do not know just what weight the edoral Reserve Board would
give t o a resolution passed b y this Conforenco.

The Chairman: I

think Mr. Calkins’ intention was not to

stop the workings o f the lew, but t o take time t o deliberately
consider h o w w e should proceed i n the matter o f putting the law

into effect. Y a s that it?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

271
Governor Calkins:

M y i

n

t

e

opinion o f t h e G o v e r n o r s h e r e p r e s e n t ,
it w a s u n d e s i r a b l e

t o put a

n ot vriuyz
t i- so vauntw the
a n d t o i n d i c a t e that.

rule i n t o e f f e c t w h i c h w e h a v e

not h a d time t o study o r understand.

The Chairman:

T h e n I think your motion will not convey

quite that idea, Mr. Calkins.’
Governor Harding: F ¥ o u l d t h e director

o f the Atlanta

bank, the Kansas City bank, o r the Dallas bank b e bound b y a
resolution passed b y this Conference?
The Chairman:

T I think not.

Governor Miller: A n y resolution of that nature would b e
embarrassing, because e a c h o f the directors o f the banks read

the report o f this conference, a n d they might b e constrained
to act upon this rosolution w h e n indeed t h e y should a c t otherwise.

h y n o t receive Governor Calkins' remarks a n d l e t them

go for what they are worth without encumbering the records o f
this conference w i t h a semblance o f such 4 suggestion.
G overnor Calkins:

M y remarks a r e o f n o consequence a n d

are not worth anything except s o far a s they are supported b y

the opinions o f the Governors here present.
Governor Miller: Y o u l d not the directors o f each bank
be c a p a b l e a n d c o m p e t e n t


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

t o determine t h e t question f o r them-

selves without t h e suggestion o f other districts?
Governor Norris: I

feel quite sure that i n the third

district the Board would consider this and study i t very carefully before they attempted t o act o n it.

I t would b e necos-~

sary they should, absolutely essential, a n d I

a m i n agreement

with a l l that has been said a s t o the doubt whether i t will

ever b e put into effect i n some districts, o r perhaps i n any,
but I

cannot s e e what vwscful purpose would b e served b y the

adoption o f this rcsolution, a n d i t docs seem to me that i t
would b e very inexpedient for this meeting t o adopt i t as a
resolution, because ¥

am afraid i t would cause the impression

to g o out i n 4 rough and ready way that people jump eat conclusions, that althdugh this act had been passod, t h e Governors
of the reserve banke i n session h a d decided t h a t t h e y were n o t

going to use it, arfd I think it would destroy the efficacy of
the thing a s a club.
The Chairman:

T h e progress w e have made s o far i s t o ex-

press a n opinion @ s t o the basis for the larger accommodations,
and I

think t h e general consensus i s that t h e l a w should n o t

be put into u s e @xcepting perhaps a s a matter o f last resort,

and i t seems t o tre that with respect t o the other points involved Governor Calkins! idea %#s that w e are not i n a position


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

2715
at the present time, without further study, t o determine.

Governor Calkins: I

should like t o ask Governor Harding

whether h e feels a n expression o f opinion o n the part o f the
Governors would b e considered?

Governor Harding:

T h e only point I want t o raise o n

this i s that I do not think the directors o f any particular
Federal Reserve R a n k would feel bound by®resolution o f thts
conference,

£

f you would amend your motion s o a s t o

make i t appear a s merely t h e sonse o f the various Federal
resefve banks a s represented a t this conforence b y these
Governors, a n d that s o and s o should b e dono, t h e n a l l tho
were i n favor o f that could s o express themselves, a n d those
not i n favor o f i t could b e recorded a s taking a n opposite
view, a n d t h e n there vould b e n o harm done.
Governor Calkins:

T h a t w a s m y intention, sir.

Governor Harding:

Y o u vould h a v e a

showdown here a s t o

just what the scntiments of the Governors of the benks is.
The Chairman: W i l l you again stato your motion?
Gavernor Biggs:

I

n view o f the fact that w e already

have t h e exprossion o f the Governors sround t h e table here,
I move t o table that motion.

(The motion was duly seconded and was carried, seven


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

voting i n the affirmative and five i n the negative.)
The Chairman: I
tebling the motion.

would vote myself i n favor o f not
J I think w e ought t o settle this thing

one way o r the other,
Governor Seay: I

should l i k e t o e x p r e s s t h e o p i n i o n

that I do not diffor from the Governor o f the San Francisco
Bank a s t o the expediency o f first carefully studying the effect o f this rule when put into effect, but I do at the same
time doubt the expediency o f taking any uniform action o f the
Governors here present; I believe the expression o f opinion o f
each individuel Governor w i l l cover t h e case entirely.
Governor C a s e : I

believe

w e could h a v e complete unanim-

ity o n this i f w e just h a d a little proamble indicating that
wo appreciate t h e advantage o f this a n d suggest that i t b o re~

ferred t o the Governors o r management o 1 each Foderal Reserve
Bank for their consideration. N o b o d y could object t o that.
Governor Norris:

I f you g o further and make the motion

read that w e think i t advisable o r important t h a t i t should
be carefully studied before being p u t into operation, 1

will

vote f o r that.
The Chairman:
amble a n d motion,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

M r . Case, i f you will formulate your proW e will give i t consideration a n d g e t i t out

of the way, I

think, v e r y quickly.

Governor Case: A l l right, g o ahead then rithm other
business.then.

The Chairman:

I t so happens that our next subject is

the o n e y o u are desirous o f getting into, Mr. Case, "Rates",
and I

know y o u are anxious t o have that taken u p while a l l the

Board a r e here.

T h a t i s topic No. 6 .

Governor Wellborn: I
information now. I

should like t o a s k a question f o r

should like t o know i f this c a n b e de-

termined b y each bank, e a c h board o f directors?

The Chairman:

L e t u s wait and see what this motion is.

-—

-

—

RATES.

The Chairman:

T h e question now i s should preferential

rates o n government secured paper b e discontinued.

The

Conference t o o k this subject u p yesterday and, a s I have i t
here, Mr. Secretary, t h e Board w a s nine t o three, w a s i t not,

in favor o f not discontinuing.

I s that enough?

I s there

anything y o u would l i k e t o s a y o n this subject, Governor

Harding o r Mr. Secretary?
Secretary Houston:

T h e o n l y question that would arise,

if that i s the view o f the Governors,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i s a s t o whether there

should b e a n y alteration o f the relation.

The Chairman:

I n what, sir?

Secretary Houston: I

understand y o u s a y they voted nine

to three against discontinuing t h e preferential rate?
The Chairman:

O r i n favor o f a continued preferential

rate a t the present time.
Secretary Houston:

D i d t h e Conference discuss whether

the rates should b o modificd?

The Chairman:

N o , not a t that time they did not. T h a t

expresses the position o f the Governors simply o n that point
as t o w h e t h e r

i t should b e continued

o r discontinued.

Shall there be a differential rate i n f a v o,r
f‘or
o
preference shown, paper secured b y receipts o f
warehouses operated under t h e Federal Yarochouse A c t
or complying with t h e terms o f that A c t i n essantial particulars?

The Chairman: T h e second topic under"Rates" is, "Shall
there b e a differential rate i n favor o f , o r preference shown,
paper secured b y receipts o f warchouses oporated under t h e

Federal “arehouse Act o r complying with the terms o f that Act
in essential particulars?"

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Our vote o n that was "No". M r , Case, I

do not think

that either o f these subjects really a r e what y o u had i n mind.
You r a n t t o discuss n o v t h e q u e s t i o n o f a d j u s t m e n t

o f discount

rates, i s that n o t it?
Governor Case: Y e s .

Governor Harding: T h a t particular topic came u p from the
Bureau o f Markets, Department o f Agriculture.

T h e y were v e r y

anxious t o have some consideration s h o w n warehouse receipts
issucd b y bonded warehouses under Fedoral jurisdiction.
Secretary Houston:

I t seems t o m e t h e more important

question a s t o whether t h e y are financing things o f that kind
in order t o hold t h e m off the market o r t o promoto orderly
distribution.
Mr. Hoxton:

T h e consensus o f opinion yesterday r a s

that n o preference should b e shown papers receipted b y any
single class o f warehouses; that i t was impracticable.
The Chairman: I

do not believe t h a t this i s a matter

that the members o f the Board are called upon t o take much time
to consider.

T h a t i s 4 question o f warehouse receipts, a n d i t

4s about one o'clock, a n d I suggest w e now adjourn t o accopt
the invitation t o lunch, unless Mr. Case h a s his resolution.

formed. I


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

should like very much t o have that out o f the way.

278

Governor Case:

I t is very simple.

I t would b e some-

thing like this:

"Whereas Congress has passed a n amendment t o the Federal
Reserve A c t authorizing progressive rates o n large borrowings
above normel line, s u c h line t o b e determined b y each Federal
Reserve R a n k ,

"Re i t resolved that this Act, when signed b y the President and becomes the law, b e referred t o each Federal Reserve
Bank for their careful study and consideration."
The Chairman:

A n d f o r areport back t o the Board?

Governor Case: N o t necessarily.

I f they want t o take

the m a t t e r u p , a s s o m e h a v e i n d i c a t e d ,

t h e y c a n d o it; i f

others d o not wish t o tare i t u p they will study it, t h e y are
asked t o d o that, t h e y d o n o t d o anything.

T h e a t would b e m y

thought.
Governor Vellborn:

M y question comes i n there. I

would

like t o know whether e a c h o f these Federal Resefve Ranks
separately i s t o determine f o r itself a

normal line a n d pro-

gressive rate?

The Chairman: T h a t i s subject t o the Federal Reserve
Board!s wishes, o f course.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Wellborn: I

want t o know under t h e l a r a n d

the amendment.

Governor Harding: T h a t i s wheat the law says.

T J do not

see h o w this Conference c a n change t h e lav.
Governor Seay:

T I should like t o s a y t o Governor vell-

born, a s far a s the opinions o f the Governors g o here, t h e y
commit themselves t o the principle o f the rule w h e n i t i s
once laid down, t h a t i s i t should b e based u p o n t h e reserve
deposit p l u s t h e capital.

(The following substitute for the motion last quoted
was offered a s follows: )
"Resolved i t i s the sense o f this Conference t h a t t h e
amendment providing unit rate o f discount f o r individual
borrowings beyond t h e normal line i s a good c l u b t o hold i n

reserve, but that such inerease should only be applied a s a

last resort,")
Governor Miller: I

The Chairman:
e

m o t i o n ,

do not think that ought t o be pass-

M y preference would b e for Mr. Caso's

i n which t h e banks a r e t o g o back home a n d consider

the whole thing.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Case:

T h e y are t h e ones w h o have g o t t o d o i t

in the last analysis anyway.

Governor Miller: I

second Mr, Case's resolution.

The Chairman: Governor Harding, will that answer ell o f
your purposes?

J I remember y o u had something t o say about it.

Governor Harding: I

have n o t had t h e opportunity o f con-

ferrine w i t h other members o f the Roard,

y e e

a n d t h e re-

marks I made a few moments ago I am just expressing m y own
views,

A s t o the effect o f the n e w l a w f T S o a

o p i n i o n

to you yesterday, signed b y the Board's counsel. I
very clear, I

think i t i s

think the amendment speaks f o r itself, a n d t h e

amendment does n o t alter t h e method o f making t h e application
or the povter o f the members o f the Federal Reserve Banks o r o f

the Federal Reserve Roard; they e11 stand exactly a s they did
before.

"Under the terms o f the law as i t reads a t the present
time each Federal Reserve B a n k has pover”™ t o establish f r o m
time t o time, s u b j e c t

t o t h e review a n d determination

o f the

b the
Federal Reserve Roard, rates o f discount t o b e c h e r g e d . y
Federal Reserve B a n k for each class o f paper w h i c h shall b e

fixed with a view o f accommodating commerce and business.

I t

remains e x a c t l y a s i t did.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Seay:

T I understand, since the Board asked the

281

question, i t would like t o know the opinion o f the Governors
as t o the basis o f a rule, a n d that opinion has been expressed
here.

Governor Wellborn: I

understood y o u t o say just now, Mr.

Seay, t h a t would b e binding o n all the benks, t h e opinion o f
the Govornors here#
Governor Seay: I

think that i s the basis o f the rule.

Governor Wellborn: I

would n o t like that t o bo, because I

can see t h e injustice o f that i f applied t o a good m a n y banks.

Governor Seay:

M a y I ask Governor Vellborn i f he agreed

on yesterday i n discussing this that was the most reasonablo
basis f o r laying d o w n t h e rule?

Governor Wellborn:
capital and surplus, I
other argument. I

N o , sir; I did not.

T I based i t o n

am more inclined t o that then t o any

can give you a n illustration. T a k e a bank

with “50,000 capital and “200.000 surplus, they could only
discount about “18,000 worth o f paper.
Governor Harding:

M r . Harrison tells m e that i t i s entire-

ly u p t o each Federal Reserve B a n k a n d t h e Federal Reserve

Board's epproval, if, for instance, a bank wanted t o make
capital and surplus the basis, t h e Board could take the con-+


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

282

ditions i n t o consideration, a n d i f another bank,

o n the con-

trary, wanted t o make the average reserve for the last thirty
days t h e

e e

t i Board approved,

i t could d o that.

T h e on-~

ly requirement o f the l a v i s the rule within t h e district shall
be the l e v o f the district. 7
Governor Miller:

O r i f i t did n o t want t o d o anything,

each bank c a n sit o n its o w n bottom and u s e i t s o v n method.
The Chairman:

U n d e r those circumstances I

a m not sure

but what Mr. Case's motion would b e quite i n order.

1 1 1 you

read that, Mr. Secretary, i f you can find it.
"Governor Case: "“hereas Congress has passed a n omendment
to the Federal Feserve A c t authorizing progressive rates f o r
large borrowings above t h e normal line, s u c h normal line t o b e
determined b y each Federal Reserve Bank,

"Be i t resolved that v e recommend that this meosure, when
signed b y the President,

b e carefully studied b y each o n e o f

the Federal reserve banks.”
You c a n improve that phraseology, I

am quite sure, b u t

that i s the sense o f it, 1 t should b e referred for their consideration a n d s t u d y , a n d t h e y w i l l k n o t w h a t t o d o w h e n t h a t

is done.
Governor Harding:

D o y o u not want t o put this i n there,

"That i n case the rule should b e applied i n any particular


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

285

district, that all other districts, a s a matter o f courtesy,
would l i k e t o b e advised a

day o r two i n advance o f the ap-

plication o f the rule." W o u l d you care anything about that?
Governor Case: I

have n o objection t o it..

Governor Harding:

Y o u know

w e keep each district a d -

vised o f any change i n the discount rates nov, a n d I think
we might k e e p them advised o f this, i f you vant to.
Governor Miller:

V h o n y o u approved i t , Governor Harding,

you would d o i t before t h e district would k n o w it?
Governor Harding:

B u t I say, would t h e other districts

like t o b e advised o f it?

(General response o f the members i n the affirmative.)
The Chairman:
and seconded.

T h e motion has been made b y Mr, Case

I s there any further discussion?

A s I under-

stand it, this i s simply t o refer i t back t o the banks, t h e
banks having i n mind that t h e y c a n apply t h e sliding scale

of rates, a n d they are t o work out their o w n plan, and o f
course that has t o be received

b y the Board i n Vashington,

Governor Harding?
Governor Harding:

T h e Board h a s t h e same power over

progressive discount rates a s over your normal rates.

(The motion was put b y the Chairman and carried.)
(Thereupon,

a t 12:30 o'clock p.m., t h e Conference r e -

cessed until 4:3° o'clock p.m.)

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

AFTER RECESS,

The Conference readsembled, pursuant t o recess,
at 3:30 o'clock p. m., Gor. MoDougal presiding.
The Chairman.

to order.

I

G e n t l e m e n , t h e meeting will come

t seems t o me that w e have not made very

satisfactory progress, perhaps, although w e have made
as mich a s we covld under the circumstances.
In regard t o credit control,

i f I a m not mistaken,

the various headings thers, down to and including Number four, have been pretty well taken cara o f my or dispos
of through ths motion made b y Acting Governor Case a t the
time o f adjournment.

A

Acting Gov. dase. I

n I right i n that?
would suggest that someones,

s
Governor Seay, h e being the only one absent, d é a p p o i n t d
@ cimmittes t o formilate the views o f the Confsrence.

The Chairman.

O

hoting Gov. Cass.
The Chairman.

n those points?
O n thoss points.

A n d , o f courss, giving consideration,

e haves taken o n
Mr. Gase, t o the motion a n d t h e a c t i o n w

that motion.
Acting Governor Case. Y e s .


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

285

Gov. Mores. I

would second that suggestion —

fT

it

donot suppose that/As exactly a motion.
The Chairman.

I t i s & suggestion, a n d I would a s k

Gov. Seay t o polish that mtter u p s o that i t will be
in presentable shape.

T h a t Will dispose o f t h e topic

down t o and including four.
Yesterday w e dealt very informally with number f i v e

5. W H A T STEPS SHOULD BSE TAKEN T O CONTROL T H E
ABSORPTION I N THE SYSTEM O F A N EXCESSIVE
AMOUNT O F PAPER MADE B Y BORROWERS W H O D O
A NATION WIDE BUSINESS 7
Cir answer t o that informally was: n o n e , o r n o

steps.

I

f someone will now put that i n the form o f &

recommendation that we could uss, yesterday's action
veing entirely informal, I
very quickly.

think we can dispose o f it

G o v . Calkins, I

Gov. Calkins.

I

will ask you t o do so.

f I am not mistaken, t h e conclu-

sions reachsd Was that i t was a matter for each dank
to deal with?
Mr. Hoxton,

I

s not that correct?
Y e s ,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

286

Gov. Calkins.

A L L zichkt. I

makes ths motion t o

that effect, a n d i f tha Secrstary Will writs t h e motion

I will appreciate it.
will Sscom thse motion.

Governor Young. I

Y o u do not Wish t o t n j s c t into

The Chairman,

that t h s feature that w s disoussed yssterday,

o f con-

necting ths Federal Rasarvs Board with i t i n any Way,
they having, o f course, t h e information?

I

t is with

the understanding that i t is left t o each dank?
Governor Calkins.

M r . Hoxton, could ths Board

give that information without commmicating vith all
the »anks t o gat it?
Mr. Hoxton.

Yes.

W

e have that i n ths report

of rediscounts, s a o h day.

Tne Chairman.

H a v e you a liavility ledger o n

that?
ir. Hoxton,

N o ;

w e have n o lianility ledger o n

have ths shssts.

I t will requires some

course, t o get the information.
Governor Calkins.

I

t would take nore time a n d

more digging out than i t would individually t o g o t e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

the banks and get the informtion ?
Mr, Hoxton.

Yas.

Governor Caltins,

T a s n I will accept the sugges-

Mir. Calkins will a d d t o that rasolution

that the oanks may ask the Baderal Resarve

Board t o obtain and furmish information regarding the
voluue o f paper w m d e r \

i 3 i n ths whole systen,

I will appreciate it.
The Chairman.

H a s t h t motion,

a s amended,bdeen

secomed?
Governor Fanchor. I

Tas Chairman.

will s e c o n d i t ,

A n y discus3icn? .

(The motion was carrisd unanimously.)
Tos Chairman:

T

a

s next i s mum>sr six?

6. I S IT PRACTICASLE TO DISGRIVINATE EFFECTIVELY AGAINST NON-ESSENTIAL GUSINESS

I N

FAVOR O F ESSENTIAL SUSI wEss ?
We discussed t h a t yasterday.

Governor Welloorm.
jsot, Mr, Chairman, I

I n connsction With that subdwould liks t o have the views o f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

288
toa Board.on this.

W e have discussed i t sous a t our

Chumittes mestings, w i t h regard t c leans o n automobiles
to daalers,

its. A

T h a t seems t o d é & Tunning away o f orede

dealer will get i n ten or fiftsen oars; a n d

he Will g o to the bank and cive his note for the whole
amount, a n d they will send the paper o n t o us. Z
suppose that the same thing occurs i n all the Districts,
and I have wonderad whethsr i t w o u l d »
s propsar o r right
to put some limit o n that paper, or,ratnher, a

limit o n

the amount that w e would discowmt for a memb:r bank,
The Chairman.

O

F cours? you havs got t o be

careful when y o u say automobiles.

Gevernor Wellborn.

W e all recognizes that auto-

mobiles ars ths most extravagant thing that v e have t o

cope with now. P e o p l e are »uying them that ar3
hardly able t o do it, and they are buying thom o n tine,
and 4 t i s preventing peoples from buying homes and wak~
ing proper investments t o take care o f them i n the
futures, a n d also i t is loading down ths sanks. T h a t
is the m o s t serious thing a t the present time. E v e r y
little town has half a dogen garages, a n d they have


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

289

very little capital, a n d they j u s t rely o n the bank for
it, Decause i t is such a werchanta>dlse Object,
The Chairman.

W s l l , o f course, y o u would not say

that the automobile businsss i s ths only non-essential?
Governor Wellborn.

N o , I

would not. I

would n o t

like to make a Strike or take a stand against amy particular busixs ss,
Tas Ghairnan.

N o ; and you would not want t o

direct y o u r remarks toward t h a automobils business with—
eut making soms reservations, because pleasure c a r s a n d
service cara, o f course, a r e very diffsrant.

T h e

question is, i s it pacticas]s t o discriminate sffeotive—
ly against non-essential businsss i n favor o f essential

business?
Governor Welloorn.
head.

O

T h a t would come under that

f course, y o u would not put trucks i n the

same category a s y o u would put pleasure cars, b u t I

would like t o havs that matter discussed,
The Chairiuan. I

firmly Delieve that i t was in-

practicable, e v e n during t h e war and u m e r t h o s e c i r —

oumstances, a n d I do not ses how we could d o i t now.

Acting Governor Case: I

move o u r answer t o that

be "No."
The Chairman:

I t i s a dangerous thing t o undertake.

anyone second that motion?
Governor Fancher:

T I do.

Mr, Hoxton: T h a t ras the decision yesterday.
The Chairman:

T h a t wes t h e informal decision yester-

MY SeeOrbOnt > Vea.

(The motion vas put and unanimously carried.)
7. W H A T MPTHODS NoORS YOUR BANK EMPLOY T O INFORM
AND SATISFY ITSELF O F THR TSFS M A D F B Y MrMBFR
BANKS O F CREDIT FACILITIES OBTATNFD F R O M THFIR
FEDERAL RESFRVF BANK - - MORE PARTICULARLY T H E
USES MADF P O R SPECULATIVE PTRFOSES A S CONTRASTED
WITH THOSE F O R PPODUCTIVE PURPOSES?

WHAT STFPS HAVE YOU TAKFN TO INFORM YOURSFLVES
AS T O ABUSE O F CREDIT I N HOARDING COMMODITIFS?

The Chairmen: N u m b e r s 7 and 7a, I believe, are
answered,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

o r c a n b e ansvered, through t h e discussion


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

291

wihich w e had o n the susject this morning. I

believe w e

have got a writtm statement covering a t least 7a.
I have and I presume others have.

C a n we turn those

in now? C a n we consider thoss subjects as having been
answered i n that way?
Governor Calkins, I

sent ons dirsct t o the Board.

(Written statemamts were subuitted a s requestad.)

at.
ADVISABILITY O F INVOLVING SYSTEM I N LESS
PUBLICITY WITH A VIEW T O REACHING MORE
READILY A PEACE TIM® AND NORMAL BASIS.

(1) SUGGESTIONS aS TO WHAT ACITIVITIES PRODUCE
UNDESTRABLE PUBLICITY A N D SHOULD THEREFORE
BE MODINIED O R ELIMINATED,

Tae Chairman.

T a e r e i s one thing w e ovsricoked

this morning, a n d that was t o get more definite infornation from Governor Harding a s t o what h e has i n mind i n
regard t o undesirable publicity and, failing t o secure
that, perhaps w e can pass that subject, a n d report t o
the effect that the question was indefinits.

O f courss,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

292

ths subject.

W h a t is ths wish of the Oomefarence i n

regard t o that?

Actixg Governor Case. I

hopes you de.. I

do

not rsmowosr it.

Tas Chairman,

W e l l , y o u advocat3a publicity i n

regard + o discount rates and perhaps other matters relating t o ths condition o f the 2anks.

Govirnor Wsillborn.
lioity I have s e m i

Tas Chairzan.

T a s only undesiradls pub-

i y . Uiltler's District.

t

h

a rs;ort o n it.

Gas? expressed sha opinion thit it is desiradl:
make puolic thse rssasrv3 susiness.

I

t i s deplored that

end a

taésre should 23 loose / irrisponslols newspaper comment
wen tAa3 rats policy. G e n s r a i l y tas Govsrnors ar3

not aWare of any activitios Waich ~woducs undssiradle
publicity.
stand o n that, W e Will consicer this

subject a S passed, and that #i11 dispess of nuwoer tio.

v

BANKERS! ACGGEPTAD
Th: Chairman.

T h e mattsr o f Danksrs! acceptances


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

293

has o2en deferred for furthsar conaideration until to-morrow morning, u n d I prasuas that ur. Kenzel Will os

here.

H a v s you heard from him, Ur. Cass?
Acting Governor Case.

N o ; dut I

sent h i n a wirs,
‘

and I suppose h e will > a hare.

oo R E T E B.,
Ths C h a i r w a n , d
w have discussed b o t h points with

respact $ 0 ratss that appear o n tis prograu.

T a s

qusstion now arises W o sthsr we wish t o uaks any rscor-

mendations with relation t o discount ratas, other
than those which havs doesn subodied i n ths discussion.

We have, o f courses, rates for discount o n Deankers' acceptances, a n d sous o f you, I
any rats in.

O u r vats i s fivs and a nalf.

are fives, I »>elisv3.

Aoting Governor Case. .

I think the consensus o f

opinion Was that t h r e should 2 ¢ no chang>.
Toe Ohairnan.

O

n vanksrs! acca, tances?

Acting Governor Cass,

N o , i n ths discout

rates.

Govarnor ilorss. I

make t h e motion taat n o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

chang? i n the discoumt rates d e made.
Govarnor Calkins.

acceptances?

W i l l that include bankers!

W i l l thas includs ths present five per

cent rats o n Danksrs! aceeptances, Governor Morss?
Governor Morss,

W e l l , put i t this way, that

there shall >be no changes i n the discount rate o n c o m
mercial paper a t ths present tine.
The Chairman.
ent time?
Governor Mores.

Y e s .

Governor Fancher.

Y o u mean the six per cant c o u

merolal rate?
Governor Morss,

Y e s .

Tos Chairman, W e l l , that means the discount
rat3s o n Dankers! acceptances, t h e rates o n leans se-

cured Dy Liberty bonis and Victory notes, which I
think should d e raised.
Governor ioerss.

T a x e s each ons.of t h e m i n turn,

if you likes.
Tos Chairman,

W e t , I

the certificats b u s i r ss?

think we have disposed o f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

W

Governor HMorss.

e have.

A n d we h a r disposed o f the

Governor Calkins.

Preferentkal rate o n Government securities?

W e l l , w e Will take liz. Morse?

Tae Chairman.

motion that t h e current rate o f s i x per cent o n c o m m e r

cial paper remain unchangad, o r that there D3 no cnangse
in that rate.

I s that it, Governor Morss?

Governor lorss.

Y 3 s .

Governor Fancher,

M r . Chairman, Sefors putting

that motion, I would like t o inject this thought into
the meeting.

t

T a m wondering h o w active sous o f the

banks are anid how thsy fezl acout the matter.
time ~ — t h i s may not be the tine —

I

Sone

would like t o

ering out here i n the meeting how the oth3sr Gorsrnors
to
fegl about the watter o f elving; a pefermtial rats
strictly trade acceptances. |

Tha Chairman.

W o u l d you oe Willing t o defar

I
that until w e get away f r o u this motion, w h i c h

do not

think will affect that?
Govsrnor Fancher.

Yes,

T o s commercial . aper

rate would apply t o i%.

The Chairman.

I t doss a t the prssent timeT
o

296

Gayvernor Fanchsr.

Y e s ; a n d I would like to know

how the Governors feel adout it.

W

e fesl i n our dank

that i t may not oa just the time now, but w e ars preach~
ing the gospel and getting a very mich larger volume o f
trade acceptances a l l the tims, a n d W e Oelieve that a

little preferential over ths so-called trads n o te WOULG
ye a furthsrance o f it, t o oring out and make m r e o f
that self-liquidating paper.

The Chairman.

W e l l , i n the z#2 interest of pro-

gress, i n stead o f going around the tacls, i f you gentiemen W i l l speak t o that freely, whosver Wants to, W e m a y

get the consensus o f the meeting.

Governor Fancher.

O u r board has disoussed i t in

the last two meetings; and the fsosling is this i n our

bank, that it would help us,

W e are saking very good

‘progress, and it would further help us if there were a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

slight differential for trade acceptances, s a y five and
three-quarters, a

quarter differential for trade accep t-

ances,
The Chairman.

M

y belie? i e that @ six per cent

rate f o r c o m m e r c i a l l o a n s o f a l l c l a s s e s

i s quite l o w

embugh under present conditions. .

Acting Governor Case.

T h a t i s the way we f:

and While i t i s parfectly natural a n d propsr that different districts should consider this rats question m d
makes adjustucnte

y

o

u Did i n Ghicago o n ths dankers'

acceptances, a n d I have expressed the view o f our dirsotors When I have said that w e have considsred this whole

Ssudjsct, and We think th: a r e too many c h a n gs
5~
made i n the discount rate; that w e must appear t o de
Standing pat; a n d t o kssp moving around constantly i s
vary detrimsntal, I

know that i s the view o f our

Board,
The Chairman,

Y o u

2 , then, oppSssed t o this.

Has anyone else anything t o say?
Governor Calkins. I

agres With Govsrnor Fancher

in What h e has said, a n d I confidently oslisve that
trade acceptancas should >: favored and Government borroWizgs disfavored, S u t I think i t is undesirables t o
make a n y change a t présent.

Govsrnor Young.

W e haves a preference

have alWays had ons o n trade acceptancss, a n d I see n o
reuson Why w e should change that.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

A l l the literature

‘hesarve Banks and
that has evanated from the Pederat
that out as an argument.
Federal Reserve system has put
I think that ©


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

b e given t o
preferential rate should

trade acceptances.

say in our district
Governor Morss. W e l l , I will
a n d i f we gave a
progress,
great
any
made
not
they have

lead, i n my opinion, if
only
would
i
t
rate,
preferential
Which i s not a real dethey increased, t o s o e abuses,
chang2d.
would not want t o sae i t
valopment. I
rate f o r
W e had a pr eferential

Governor Fancher.

eliminat.
our readjustments u p we
a time, a n d when we mads

acceptances and merged 4%
trade
for
preferential
-ed the
paper rate:
in the flat rate, thse Government
that We are
I t is very evident
The Chairman.
vote o n it, s o I suggest
maninous
a
get
t
o
not going
the
t u e r e f o r e , I pelisve
pank.
each
t
o
left
be
that i t
no
that thare should o e
i
s
seconied,
Was
motion, Which

time on commercial
inorease in rates at the present
paper, rediscounts.

(cries of *Question™. })

carried.
the motion was put and unanimously
The Chairman.

D

aisouss the ques~
o you want t o


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

tion o f the rediscount rate o ¥ bankers’ accertances?

Wy suggestion Would os t h a t ’ it be abolished?
Governor lores, I
The Chairuan.

ssoond ths motion.

T h a t is, t h s p r sferential rate.

Acting Governor Case.

D o away with t h s discount

rats entirely?
Governor Weilborn.

Y o u asean endorsed bankers!

acceptances should not have a preferential rate?
The Chairuan,
Govetnor Wellborn.

t h o u g h t that was highly de-

siradile.

The Chairuwan.

W e l l , o u r rats now for rediscount-

ing bankers! acceptances i s away Dslow t h e Open markst

rate for ths bills, which, o f courss, i s not consistent.
Governor Wellsern.
not t o changs.
tween therm.

W
W

I

t ssems t o w e that w s ought

e ought t o uaks some distinotion be-

e take them as ths sams rate a s oommer-

Glial paper.

Acting Governor Cas .

W e are going t o havs a dis-

oussion toxorrowW morning o n th: whole quastion o f oank~ers! a c e s p t a n c e s , n
e
h
w lir. Kengsl i s hers, a n d could not


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

We take u p the whole matter a t ons time?
The Chairman.

S e far a s I am concerned, I

fectly willing t o do that.

am per—

W e are going t o discontinue

that rate i n Chicago anyhow.

W e tave tried i t long

enough.
Is there any discussion with regard t o rates ourrent o n Liberty Loans a n d Victory Notes?

O u r bank a

short time ago asked for a rats o f five and three-quar—
ters, Which was not acceded t o b y the Board,

Governor Mores.

J I make the mtion that there be

no change a t the present tine.

Acting Governor Case. I
Governor Morsa. I

second that motion.

would liks t o make that motion

“at the present time."
Governor Fancher.

A

t t h e last mesting o f our

Board, m a r l y four weeks ago, w e asked for a n inorease
on our rate for Liberty Bonds and Victory Notes from
five and one half $ 0 five and three quarters; a n d o n

certificates from five to five and & quarter, and the
Board did not concur i n our request; b u t i t 4s going t o

be renewed at our meeting which will be held tomorrow.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Wi S-

301

The Chairman. I

should like t o

5

recorded a s i n

favor o f a n advance i n rates o n lsans sscursd b y Liverty
Bonds a n d Victory Notes.

has i + not?

H

o

T

h

s anther has b e e n made,

w many are i n favor o f no change be-

ing made i n the r a t e s a t present

o n loans secured b y

Viotory Notes and Liberty Loan bonds?
Governor Morss.

A

t th3 present tine.

(The motion ani carrisd b y a wte o f eight t o four)
The Chairman.
rates?

A n y t h i n g more oneths subject o f

H a v e w a left anything out there?
Mr. Hoxton.
The Chairman.

N o , six.
C e n t l e n e n , w h a t i s your pleasure

in regard t o the valance o f this program, wnich I think

islargely devoted to ofganization matters, ineluding
transits?
Mr. Hoxten.
The Chairman.

L e t us go down +o the next one,
W h a t i s the next one?

T h i s is

is.
@ question of what the pleasure of the conference
w
transit
Suall/proceed With t h e progrem b y taking U p t h e

matters?
Acting Governor Case. I

s o move.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

BR
GLEARIVG A N D COLLECTION SYSTEM.
The Chairman.

O

n page 2

o f tas program, t o p i c III

is CGlsaring and Gollection System, Number one under
that topic is:

(1) I N VIEW OF THE FACT THAT NO SYSTEM INVOLVING
DEFERRED AVAILABILITY I S STRICTLY A PAR SYSTEL,
SEOULD N O T I N ALL DISCUSSIONS A N D P U B L I C A
TIONS T H E TERM " P A R COLLECTION SYSTEM"

B E

CHANGED T O “ F E D E R A L RESERVE CLEARING A N D COLLECTION SYSTmu"

O R T O SOME NAME MORE EXACTLY

DESCRIPTIVE T H A N T H E O N E N O W I N USE?

Governor lUorss. . I

move that w e approve o f the

changs Which i s suggssted hers.
Governor Case. I

second it.

Y o u approve that?

The Chairman.

Governor Morss. : I

move that we approve o f the

Ghange suggested in number (1).
The Chairman.

W h a t s d o y o u base that on, Mr.

Morss?
Governor Morss.

W e l l , I

think t h e Board h a s h a d


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ay ‘te

303
& lot o f experience i n that sort o f thing, a n d they have

suffered a great deal from this tarm of "Par collection
System",

a n d ithsy svidently think that i t would b a bet-

ter and help t h e m i n their discussions i f thsy had a
changs; a n d : f i t would help them, w e ought t o approve
of 1%.
Tas Chairman.

b em 10% 0 % 1 2 S t e that: t h e

E

Board fscls that way, myself.
Governor Biges.

l e n ' t i t just a question o f

camoutlaging somthing?
The Chairman.

T h i s all goes back t o the time

When v e began t o develop the system. T h s r e ars very few
of the charter menbsrs around here.

is one o f thez.

I

G o v e r n o r Fancher

n the early stagss o f the develop—

ment of this system, there wers a good many vroblems
that came up, concerning which a number o f you gentlemen
were not awars, a n d you never canube fully informed. I
remember very Well ons meeting W e had after dark, when

the question came up as to what the definition o f ths
word par was.

D

o y o u r3call that, iim. Fanoher.

Governor Fancher. I

recall i t very vividly.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman.

M o s t o f the Governors had banking

experiencé, a n d most o f them believed that t h e definition

of the w ord par was that you coujd secure the proceeds

without deduction at any place Where you were i n the habit
of cashing checks; a n d a t that tims there was a disposition o n the part o f some o f the mowsers o f the Board t o
feel that the Federal Reserve Banks should proceed and
develop t h i s check collection system

immediate availability. |

o n tha basis o f

As I remember it, the Gover-

nors Were wmanimousi:y in the expression of their opinions
that that would bs impossible, for ths reason that, i f
we undertook i t we would have all tha business that w e

could take oare SF apes would bs Varrying What we

call... "float", perhaps sufficient to involva the invest~ment o f all the resources o f ths banking systou.

d u I

right about that, Govarnor Fancher?

Goveror Fancher,
The Chairman.

Yes,

T h e n i t Was suggested, I

believe, ©

that the counsel o f the Bo.rd, o r possidly the Attorney
General -~- I do not remember who -- anyway that legal
advice b s sought and a n interpretation givan o f the m e a n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

505

ing of the word "par", a n d i t was then that the opinion

Was rendsred that the word "par" meant that the proceeds
of ther item: could d e availed o f without Geduction, out
not necessarily o n presentation.
Governor Fancher. I

think i n effect that w a s it,

liv. Chairman.
The Chairuan,

Y e s ; and, a s I remember 1%, the in-

quiry resulted i n ths members of ths Board and the Govermors o f ths banks seing recorciled t o the new interpreta-

tion o f the word "par",

N o w , I say this i s a par col~

lection system; a n d i t i s a celisction system - - —

Bevernor Fanchaz. (ivterposi ng)

I t is no clearing

house.
Ths Chairman. I
name. I

do not s3e why We should change tke

do not bslieve i t will get us any place.

W e

are bound t o refer t o it as a Par collection system; a n d
I am not sure, a s I stated osfors, that the Board would
like t o ses a changs mado.
Governor Fancher.

J u s t how would you r3concile

the matter o f p a r collection system wasn you take into
consideration the schedule o f charges for the additional
tins that has been inaugurated o r is about t o be in-


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

306

augurated o y the various clearing houss aeeeculvunsl
Tae Ghairzan.

ent.

W e l l , I

think thay a r e very differ-

T h i s schedule o f chargss that thsy propose now

to inaugurates i s a n entirely different matter.

"Inmediate availability."

T h s y are going to vorrow

that monsy and pay four and a half t o six par cent. for

the privilege.

T h a t is the way I look upon it. ‘

think t h e createsat difficulty w e have t o contend with,

and have had, i s ths fact that perhaps whils the Gover-—

mors understand and parhaps ths mambers o f the Federal
Reséervs Board understand this interpretation o f the term
"par" t h a t the businzss o f the country does not s o un—
derstand it, and that i s ons reason they are dissatis~—
fied.

T h e y do not consider that i t i s a par collec

tion system,

T h e avsrage merchant and manufacturer

does not understand and appreciate our visws.
Governor Van Zandt.

I

s not this just exactly

What i t says, a "par collection system"?
Ths Chairman. I

think so.

Governor V a n Zandt. C o l l e c t i o n s b a n b s made a t

Te Chairman. I

think so.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

307
Govarnor V a n Zandt,

N o t “par vayyent", n o t inced-

fate payment o r immediate availaoility a t par, Sut par
t oan 23 collsctad a t par through

I

collsction systex,

ths Federal Reserves Danks.
The Chairuan. -

I

eo take it.

Deputy Governor Peples. S p e a k i n g for the Dis—
r
o
f
trict that i s just i n the middie o f this c a m p a i g n ,

what We have been calling "par points", I can not help
mut fasl that w e Will be very much embarrassed t o
change ths entire designation a t this tine.

W

e have

and to
gotten half the District o n under ths old name,
the rest in; would
chan,2 the name now and try to get
appear t o wany pPys

sone
L s that w e haves 222m making

w e already have o n
sort o f a comprouise, a n d thoss that

comromise, a n d inwould try to get the wenefit of that
I think we had bstter
yolv3 u s i n uany difficulties; a n d
first, a n d then we
get through with our par campaigns
cam, call i t what w e pisass afterwards.
Governor Mores. .

T h e Federal Raservs Banks have

collection

are trying to
. a feystenm which they have inaugurated and
perfect.

from
colisotion system i n nam,
chonepar
«
is
I t

system o f the
but i s i t not really the colleotion

wae

508

"Federal Reserve clearing and cOllection syatem"

I s it

not the system o f the Federal Reserve Banks and inaugutated b y then? W o u l d not i t bs a true nae?
The Chairman,

T a s proposacd name?

Governor Horss,
Tas Chairian.

Y s .
Y e s ; I think i t would be.

Aating Governor Case. C l e a r i n g ?
The Chairuan.

Y o u might strike out tos word

"glearing "but i t i s certainly the Federal Reserve Check
cOllisction saysten.

Aoting Governor Case. I

think, a s Mr. Peple has

said, i t i s not a mattsr that i s worth taking a

deal o f tims about. I

great

haves here a copy of the New

York Glisring House of{reuler w a i c h i s just a t u t t o go
out, a n d i n thekr rules and regulations, i n several


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

places, they speak of collection charg2s.
through hers.

I t is all

N o w yesterday Governor Harding, y o u

Will recall, spoke o f that, and, speaking informally t o
a nunbsr o f ths Govsrnors, thoy seem t o be unanimous o n

this point, that what happens is that a $10,000 cheok is
deposited i n ons o f the N e w York C i t y bans,

i s t u s say


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

on Akron, Ohio; they get credit for i t at part

N o .

Tiers is $2.50, say ons-fortieth of one per cent deducted.

T h a t i s nothing i n the world but a loan.

t h e

City Bank advances t h e m that money f o r t h s thres days.

It is immediately avaiable, and the City Bank charges
then interest a t four a n d one-half p e r cent.

B u t it

does n o t s e e m t o m e that i t i s a matter o f great import-

ance,ons that w e should spend a lot of tine discussing.
I think perhaps, a s Mr. Peple hao suggested, i f we can
let i t roll along w t i l after w e clean u p these twelve
Districts, w e might put. some othername o n it.

T t is

sort o f swapping horses while crossing the stretm t o Go
it now.

The Chairman.

I

n the meanwhile, might it not be

a good idea t o try harder than heretofors t o inform the
Collection system o f the country a s t o What i t is?
When a merchant goes + o his dank and wants the chack t o
be immediately available,

o f course i t i s securing a

loan.

Governor Wellborn. S u p p o s e a customer of a bank
cones i m and says that h e doss not vant the immediate


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

‘tm *

310

oredit; h e wants t o collect that a t par: h e can not get
it.
Governor Calkins.

T h e bank will send i t for col-~

lection and credit i % when paid.
Governor Welloorn. T h e r e f o r e i t is not a par
colisetion. I

think this correction ought t o es

made.

S h a l l w e pass this item and - ~

Th: Chairman.

Governor Wall>orn (interposing) I

second Gover-

nor Morss' motion.
To2 Chairman.

W h a t i s your motion now, Governor

Moras?
ii Hoxton.

T h a t the conference o f Governors

eoprove the change of name as suggested in topice three,
sub—top ic one.
The Chairman.

D o you Want t o include there the

name "Clearing House"?

would accept any amendGovernor Morss. W e l l , I

ment that ie desired.
Governor Calkins.

Y o u may change that if you like.
W o u l d i t not >

w e l l t o ascer-

w e taks actain t h s present views o f the Board »efore
tion?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman. I

would suggest that we modify

that and maks ths motion that the Govsrnors see n o objection t o such a changs, provided the Federal Resorve Board
gees any advantage i n making such a changes.

Governor Morss, I

will make the motion i n that

forn.

The Chaixman.

I s that motion seconded?

Gevernor Calkins. I

secorm it.

(The question was put Jo a vote and the Chairman announced that i t stood four in favor and seven against.)

Thé Chairman. T h e motion is dsfeated.
Weare coming to sub-topic uumber (2) under topic
beag
(3) A S S U M I N G T H A T T H E PROVISIONS O F THE FEDERAL
RESERVE A C T W I T S R E F E R E N C E T O E X C H A N G E

CHARGES WILL REMAIN UNNERCHANGED:

(a) W h a t will ">3 the most effective method of continuing the canpaign for par polats?
Governor Fancher,

M r . Chairman, I think the dis-

cussion o f that topic should rest wita the Governors o f
the Districtswho have uot complsted their campaigns.
Acting Governor Case.

L e t that o s referred t o a

committee o f those Governars,
Governor Wellborn.

W a i l e w e havs not olsansd up,

I would liks very much t o have a n ¢xprassion from you

Governors a s to the best way how to do it. M a y o s your
exp srience will throw some light o n it.

Governor Norris. I

second the motion, that (a),

(o) and (c) all vs referred t o a committee:
The Chairman.

I

t i s suggested t h a t t h e topics

under sub-title (3) and number (3 ) may de referred to
the same conmittes.
Governor Fancher,

M y . Chairuwen, I

would like % o

have some discussion on number (4).
Tie Chairman.

L e t us dispose of (2) and (3)

first. I s there a motion that the topics under (2) and
(3) be submitted to a committee?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Acting Governor Case.

The Chairman.

T h a t i s the wtion.

I s that motion seconded?

Governor Fancher, I

second it.

(The motion was put and wmanimously carried.)
fhe Chairman.

T h a t committes will be Governor

Young, Governor Seay and Governor Wellborn, and I would


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Stem ¢

313

suggest that that committee give consideration t o these
topics and report back tomorrow morning.

That orings us to topic number (4), ami I a m not
sure that I understand this myself:

(4) DIRECT ROUTING OF COLLECTION ITEMS BY MEMBER
BANKS I N ONS FEDERAL RESERVE DISTRICT T O
MEMBER A N D NON-MEMBER SANKS I N ANOTHER
FEDERAL RESERVE DISTRICT F O R WIRE TRANSFER O F
PROCEEDS T O SENDING BANK'S FEDERAL RESERVSAUZ.
BANK, )

My. Hoxton.

M r . Peple can tell you something

about that.

Tie Chairman. | lir.Peple will you epsak to that
subj scot?
Deputy Governor Peple.

Y e s , siz.

W e have had,

particularly i n the p a r t o f our district coverad d y
the Baltimore wanes @ great deal o f trouble.

W e have

had member banks i n other districts send t o member and
non-member banks i n our District collection items ,with

the instruction that they were t o be collected amd ths
procesds rewitted through the Federal Reserve Bank of
Richmond, o r through the Baltimore Branch, particularly

through the Baltimore Branch.

T h o s e remittances have

come i n frequently fxom wember banas, a n d have been
credited t o the member banks’ reserve accounts, a n d after

frantic inquiries and wiring and reconcilement o f accourtss,
we found out that tuey should have been remitted t o soms
Other Federal Reserve Bank.
They coms i n from non-meuiver banks, t o wuom w e had
Bent dirsc+ latters, w i t h checks 9 n themselves a n d with—

out any instructions from the non-member banks a s t o What

thie remittance was for. T a e y have naturally been deducted from the amounts owed d y the nor-member banks,and

mixed u
p the remittance accounts. I

snould say in

thres cases out of four they have caused confusion a m
Provably taken longer t o get t h s procesds where t h e y be-

longed, with the proper desigaation, far longer than if
they had gone avound throvgh the regular channel.

We lave had up the question of allowing weaber
banks i n other Districts t c sond orilection items under
pertain clroumsiaauas dircet t v the Federal Reserve
Bank of Richmond o r the Baltimore Branch, a s the case
may be, a n d w e have given the other Federal Reserve


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Banks the right t o allow thair members t o do that, out w e

do m t think that they ought t o be allowed t o send direct
to membsr banks i n our District, with instructions t o remit through us.
In the case o f sendings t o non-merbsr banks, i t
Places u s i n a position where, i f we allowed the practice
we could not refuse t o accept a payment from a non-member
bank,

t o b e transmitted o v e r o u r leased wire systeu,

just a s though i t wore a mezioer bank, a n d have consistent-

iy refused t o give non-member banks the privilege o f
Wire transfers.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman.

D o e s anyon? else wish t o sSp9gak on

this suoject?
Governor Fancher.

M r . Chairman, w e have had a vari-

ety o f expsrience with transactions o f that sort, a n d
they have been most annoying.

O u r bank: has taken the

position that while w e believe i n the senbing o f a certain class o f items, documentary items o r large items roquiring apecial attention, f r o m non-yember banks i n ons
District t o the Faderal Reserve Bank o r one o f its
branches i n another District, w e have taken the position


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

.
14iy

516

that we do not want t o open the door wide until there i s

some general plan of accounting and advices worked out.
It is leading t o all sorts o f confusion a t the present

time.
I want t o just touch for a minute o n certain cases
that have oome u p i n connsotion with collections sent b y
member banks o f the New York District t o the member banks
in our District.
Acting Governor Case.

A r e these cheoks o r collso-

tions?
Governor Fanohsr.

T a e s e are collections.

axe one o r two typical cases.

H e r e

H e r e i s an advice w e

Meceived April 3nd from one o f our meuber banks t o

charga their account with $38,575 and place a like amount
to their credit i n the Federal Reserve Bank i n New York.
We did not know what i t was and i t necessitated our call-

ing wp the particular bank on the telephone to fine out,

and it developed that it was a collection which was sent
byone of the New York member banks. T h e y gave us the

description mumber 471,594, and finally gave us enough
information t o clean i t up.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

State @

ol?

We had anothsr cass here where w e took from February
10th until March 10th t o clear

u p and get certain cred-

itz adjustmentson some school warrants payable i n one of
our small towns outside o f Cleveland.

Another case we had here, after two or three wires,
a couple o f collections that w e had a t Urbana, Ohio, i t
took from March 13th, the date o f maturity, wntil March

a7’th, a number of wires, and ths use of the 'phone.
Now, i t 4 8 leading t o all sorts o f confusion,

am

here i s a collection sent out b y the Corn Exchangs B a n k

of New York o n Youngstown, which resulted i n somes confu-

ston and 'phomesand wires.

O n the vack of the draft

the Gorn Exchange Bank ofNew York stamped the following:
"Remit t o your District Federal Reserve Bank with
instructions t o wire payment t o Federal Reserve Bank of
New York, account Gorn Exchange Bank o f New York,”

To that endorsement o n the draft, like any other
endorsement, t h e banks pay no attention, a n d we s i m l y
got a request t o gharge thsir account and oredit t h e
Federal Reserve Bank of New York a certain amount, and
then we are asked b y the New York bank t o trace certain
collections.

‘he

518

Here i s a n Akron transaction, where they advised u s o f
a credit o f a n amount which included three collections, a n d

then the New York bank traced two o f them, and before w e got
the matter entirely straightened out w e exchanged t w o o r three
wires and telephoned t o Akron, a n d there was a delay o f several days before credit was finally effected.
Now, i t is leading t o all sorts o f confusion, a n d unless
there i s some very careful plan worked out, our banks are going
to have a good goal o f trouble i n adjusting their accounts,
and w e are not giving service.

In other words, i t is a much slower operation than i f
they wore handled i n the regular order through regular channels.
Acting Governor Caso: I

would like t o ask, Governor

Fancher, whether y o u have got a fixed opinion a s t o whether
this i s undesirable i n principle, o r whether y o u think that
the machinery should o r could b e geared u p to handle those
properly? I

know those things are embarrassing which you

have stated, and give a great deal o f trouble. I t h i n k i t is
& cuestion o f principle, whether t h e y ought n o t t o b e sent i n
the first instance,

o r whether t h e y should b e s e n t a n d w e

undertake t o work out machinery t o facilitate transactions o f
that sort.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Fancher:

M y opinion is, Mr. Case, that I

think w o should make perhaps one step, and that i s permit the
member banks t o send these items t o a Federal Reserve B a n k t o
start with.
Governor Calkins:

T h e items themselvcs?

Governor Fancher:

T h e items themselves.

T h e r e might b e

extreme cases where there i s some specially large item, o r the

ribunite date i s close, o r something o f that sort, but start
vith t h e p r i v i l e g e

o f g i v i n g e a member b a n k t h e o p p o r t u n i t y o f

sending t o the Federal Reserve B a n k o r one o f the branches i n
some other distedets

Acting Governor Case: T h e same a s they have the privilage
nov o n checks?

Governor Fancher: Y e s . A n d then, i f we can let a member
bank send t o enother member benk, I

a m willing t o take that

step, but w e will have t o be very careful and have a very carofully worked out mechanism o r te will have all sorts o f confusion.

Acting Governor Case:
Governor Fancher:

W e are just going too fast.

V e are going too fast. T h a t i s the

position I took with Mr. Hendricks, a n d i t i s the position I

took with Governor Van Zandt on his collections.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman: V W o u l d y o u confine that t o itoms that
ere d r a w n o n the Federal Reserve cities o r their branch
efties, o r would y o u permit t h e Federal Reserve banks o r their

branches t o receive collections i n that way from other points
in their districts?
Governor Fancher:

I f the proper accounting system a n d

advice system c a n b e worked out, i t would b e m y judgment t o

permit the member banks i n one district t o send to the Federal
Neserve B a n k o r Foderal Reserve branches t h e collections

in

these entire districts, b u t l e t the collections g o through t h e

Federal Reserve Rank or branch t o start with and get our accounting a n d our advice system working,

a n d m m then i f w e

want t o have contact between member banks i n one State o r i n
another,

w e c a n d o it,

Acting Governor Case:
The Chairman: I

D o y o u make that a s a motion?

think that would necessitate t h e appoint-

ment o f a committee, t o rork out the details, a n d i n the meantime i t i s understood that w e slow d o w n o n this.
Governor Fancher:

I n other words, I vould move that w e

discontinue w h if we can the sending o f collections until w e
can v o r k o u t a


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

proper a c c o u n t i n g s y s t e m a n d a d v i c e s y s t e m .

Deputy Governor Peple: D i s c o n t i n u e t h e
structions t o remit through t h e bank?

Governor Fancher: Y e s .
Deputy Governor Peplo:

Y o u d o not care

t h e y send

If they send direct?
Governor Pancher:
to heve a

T h e confusion arises t h e n y o u attempt

credit made i n the Federal Reserve R a n k f o r another

Federal Reserve E a n k upon wire advice, because these small

banks will not follow detadled instructions, a n d unless w e worl
out a scheme here that applies t e the twelve banks, y o u will
have twelve differont schemes a n d twelve different ways o f
hendling items, a n d i t i s most i m p a tant that w e agree u p o n
some general p l a n o n d some committee o f

o

r

accountants w o r k e d o u t f o r t h e banks.

The Chairman: N o w , Governor Fancher, will you state your
views

i n e

f e v words, ys o v e e a n a c c e p t gt h o m a s « 4 motion?

Hoxton: I

The Chairman:

think I

have g o t h i s motion.

L e t the Socretary read it, then.

My. Hoxton: l i y understanding o f G overnor Fancher's
motion i s that t h e Federal Keserve Banks shell discontinue
the practice o f direct routing o f collection items b y member
banks


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i n one Federal Reservo district

t o member a n d non-member

banks i n another Federal Reserve district b y wire transfer
of proceeds o f items, until t h e mechanism c a n b e worked out,
and that a

committee o f this b o d y b e appointed t o study this

matter.
would suggest t h e t t h e committee n o t

Governor Fancher: I

be o f this body but o f --My. Hoxton: (Interposing:) T h a t a committee b e appoint-

Governor Fancher:
Governor Young: I

Y e s , t h a t a committee b e appointed.
second t h e motion.

(The motion was p u t a n d unanimously carried.)

The Chairman: I

will suggest that the committee b e

represontative o f the Cleveland, t h e New York and the Hichmond banks, and that the Governors o f those banks designate
individuals

t o serve o n that committee.

Acting Governor Case: I

would like t o nominate Mr.

Hendricks, o u r comptroller o f collections, right away.
Governor Fancher:

J I would like t o nominate Mr. Strater-

Deputy Governor Peple: J

would rather reserve the nom-

fnation f o r Richmond.
The Chairman:

A n d i t would b e necessary, I

think, f o r

that committee to come together i n the near future.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Deputy Governor Peple: T e l l , I
soon a s I

can appoint h i m a s

can get back t o Richmond.

The Chairman:

W i l l y o u notify t h e Secretary o f your

Selection?
Deputy G o v e r n o r P e p l e :

T I will n o t i f y M r . H o x t o n o f

Our member, yos.
The Chairman:
chairman o f that committee.
Governor Fancher:
‘The Chairman:

A n d will y o u s e e that 4

Governor Fancher:

The Chairman:

A l l right.
meeting i s held?

T I will.

W o . 5 is:

V. R o u t i n g o f c h e c k s t h r o u g h i n t e r m e d i a r y b a n k i n g

centers instead o f sending direct t o drawee bank.
Acting Governor Case:

I s that the matter o f Federal

Reserve Banks sending checks o n non-memher banks?

The Chairman: R e a l l y I do not understand. I

have a

memorandum here that mey throw some light-on the subject,
speaking f o r Chicago:
my c o l l e c t i n g c h e c k s

Be) Mahe

n

o n several hiunar
(
3
g cnecks o
n severel hundred non-member

banks through t h e correspondent banks, e n d i t has proven very
helpful i n securing their consent t o a par arrangement.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I t

has also secured t h e cooperation o f member banks i n the col-

lecting centers because the non-member bank i s not obliged

to divert its funds t o Chicago m to meet our roquirements for
payment i n Chicago exchange.

I f i t i s not convenient f o r a

non-member b a n k t o remit i n Chicago exchange t o this bank f o r
checks d r a w n o n them they m a y arrange w i t h their correspondents t o have i t receive t h e i t e m from ts.

T h e correspondent

remits t o this bank o n receipt i n Chicago exchange a t par sub-

ject t o final payment and the non-member bank receives the
items f r o m its correspondent f o r sottlement a t par”.
we have devoloped t h a t t o some extcent i n connection with

Des Moines and Milwaukee particularly, a n d some other collection centers.

V e have ten reserve cities i n our district.

Fach o f those cities m m o r a t least t h e smaller o f the reserve
citios, c a r r y & large number o f bank deposits t h a t a r e accumu~
lated i n their immediate neighborhood, a n d w h e n w e began t o

develop this check collection system there were a good many
complaints because o f their con¢lusion that w e were forcing
this thing i n the interest o f the Chicago banks, w h i e h o f
course w a s n o t true.
Acting Governor Casco: I
that where @

vould l i k e t o s a y i n our district

non-menber b a n k has been willing t o remit a t par,

and t h e m e m b e r b a n k i n most i n s t a n c e s h a s n o t d e s i r e d t h e


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

business,

w e did f o r a vhile s e n d t o member banks t h e items

in the same c i t y i f they were drawn o n @ non-member, b u t
many o f them said that t h e y d i d n o t care t o bother w i t h it.
Of c o u r s e t h e r e w e s n o p r o f i t

i n it, n o t h i n g b u t a

vork, t o handle a n d collect t h e same d a y a n d remit.

lot o f

O u r prac-

tice elmost universally i s t o send t h e m t o the non-member
banks,

o f courso o n the p a r basis.

T h e y héve come in, every

one o f the banks i n our district a r e remitting a t par.
Governor Young:

H r . Chairman, 3 o u know, t h i s interferes

with o u r p l e n i n Minneapolis, a n d I rould l i k e t o put i t before

the members here t o see that they d o d o i n the other centers.
¥

“e recently p u t ‘isconsin o n the p a r list jointly Frith the
Federal Reserve R a n k o f Chicago, a n d t h e Tederal Reserve B a n k
of Chicago entered i n t o e n agree with t h e First “isconsin
National B a n k rhereby the.checks o n some o n e hundred o r one
hundreé a n d fifty banks a r e sent direct t o the First risdonein
National Bank.

T h o y p a y off the check, subject t o final: pay-

ment, w h i c h delays t h e presentation a day.

A l l thé banks i n

Viseonsin vere circularized o n that same plan, a n d w e turned
it down all over o u r district, feeling thet a
does n o t p o s s e s s a

member b a n k that

Twin C i t y a c c o u n t h a s t h e o p p o r t u n i t y o f

opening
@& clearing account, t h a t is, o n very favoreble terms, p
g


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

which none o f them Till do.

I f they elect t o put o n Sioux

_ City o r Milvaukee,or where not, W e are not interested i n
their opening u p a Twin City account.

A l l v e require i s that

they g e t available funds t o u s a t a specified time.

S o we

the
permit those banks t o ask their correspondents t o place
funds w i t h u s .

Nov, that h a s worked o u t very satisfactorily, b u t i t i s

unfortunete thet Chicago has one method and v e have another
method.

J I do not sey that I am right about this, but I rould

f r o m the
like t o have i t u p for discussion a n d a n expression
Governors

a a a

t h e y d o that i n the other districts o r not,

the information
ané rhether s u c h ea plan i s i n keeping vith a l l
a n d t h e Fed-~
that h a s gone o u t from the Federal heserve Board
p a r collection syseral Reserve Renks i n connection w i t h our

tem. That ig avoiding the circuitous method of rovting checks,
and just h o w v e would b e legally,

i f a check vas n o t paid a n d

b e e n paid i f i t
a merber b a n k sould s h o r that i t vould h a v e
vas p r e s e n t e d t h e d a v before.

Acting Governor Case:

Y o u vould b e u p against Sia ik

think.

The Chairman: I
district


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

is @

think the situation in the Chicago

o f the
little d i f f e r e n t f r o m t h a t v h i c h m o s t

districts h a v e t o deal with,
cities i n our district,

i n that w e have t e n reserve

a s I have stated.

Governor Young: W e l l , w h y cannot t h e correspondent b a n k

ask that reserve city bank t o place funds with you? N o v , w e
do not require that they send i n a wire o n each single one.
Take Sioux Falls, f o r instance, t h e y have some 2 0 0 correspondent banks, a n d i f there a r e trenty-five banks t h a t elect t o

pay that way, they advise the Sioux falls bank and the Sioux
Falls bank wires u s the total, without a n y detailed informa-

tion a t all. T h e detailed information comes the next day b y
mail.

I t comes the same way as our gold settlement fund.
The Chairman: Y o u r plan i s identical with the plan that

n connection with Indianapolis.
we o p e r a t e t h i
Governor Young:
in Milwaukee,

Yes.

I f you would o n l y operate that w a y

v e would have n o trouble.

There i s another feature o f that.

T h e First Fisconsin

National R a n k i s anxious t o hold a l l the accounts t h e y c a n
in Wisconsin, a n d I

know t h e y are permitting State Banks i n

Wisconsin t o charge exchange, a n d t h e y are absorbing t h e

business. I

know that i s true i n Sioux City.

V e are defoat-

o that policy.
ing our whole plan b y the c o n t i n u a t i o n f


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Deputy Governor Peple: M r . Chairman, w e have had a

very little o f that same thing i n our district.

T h e trouble

has been with u s o r i n our experience t h a t that requires t h e

consent o f a bank o n which the items are drawn, a s well a s
the bank that i s supposed t o remit, and t o which the items
are supposed t o b e sent.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

aie ves m o s t f r e q u e n t l y h a p p e n e d t h a t o n e o r t h e

other would n o t mike t h e arrangement. N e v e r t h e l e s s w e

have made thet arrangement i n o very fev cases where
the b a n k o n w h i c h t h e i t e m s a r e d r a w n i s v e r y c l o s e t o

the other bank, s o that there i s not a preat deal o f
delay i n the presentation o f the item,

V e have solved

the problem i n our district b y the use o f our immediate
credit symbol. .

Number o f t h e benks h a v e b e e n allovred

the privilege o f granting t o their c u s t o m e r s e
h
t right
to use t h e immediate credit symbol o n their checks.

They

can now return their cheeks direct t o these c o u n t r y banks
and the country banks remit t o u s a n y checks i n their
correspondents, w h i c h checks b e a r t h e immediate credit symbol.

O n receipt o f those checks t h e y sre imveciately

charged t o the reserve account o f the bank o n which t h e y

are drawn and sent o n by mail. T h e r e are about fifteen
or trenty banks outside o f Richmond a n d Baltimore t h a t
are u s i n g t h e t i m m e d i n t e c r e d i t s y m b o l a n d s o m e t i m e a g o

we were petting about ,500,000 a day i n checks.

I t vorked

very well, because i t enables t h e larger banks t h a t h o d

the accountsof smaller banks scattered throughout the
country t o r e t a i n t h o s e a c c o u n t s


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

o n the same basis a s

if they themselves w e r e located i n t a F e d e r a l Reserve o r
branch c i t y .

T h e benks u s i n g i t are v e r y well satis-

fies,

The Chairmen, I

yould sey, i n connection with our

district, where this matter has been developed t o a cons
siderable extent, that the arrangement has never b e m
effective except i n the cases o f securing consent o f

both banks involved.
Deputy Governor Peple.

I t cannot b e done i n any

other vay.

The Chairman,

I t cannot be done i n any other way,

and should n o t b e done.
with us. I

I t i s o very important m t t e r

can s e e h o w i t has c a u s e d difficulty w i t h

Governor Young, a n d I will say i n response t o your remarks, Governor Young, that i f you sre correct i n your
statement that these arrangements are effected with banks
which are peying a n exchange, o r allowing exchange deduct.
ijons, o f course t h a t should b e stopped, a n d that will
be piven attention. U n f o r t u n a t e l y w e have s & divided State

there and i t creates complications that would not arise

perhaps in some of the other districts.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor Young. I

would like t o get a n expression

of opinion o n e w a y o r the other, whether I
right,

s o I] am goinep t o make a

a m wrong o r

motion thet i t i s the

recommendation o f the Governors t h e t a n y circuitous

method o f presenting checks for collection which delays presentation b e discontinued within a reasonable
length o f time,

Governor Fancher, I

second the motion.

(The motion, h:ving been duly seconded, was carried).

The Chairman, 1

will vote n o t o that myself, be-

cause o f our situation. I

think you have besed your ar-

gument largely o n the understanding t h a t exchange w a s
being charged.

Governor Young. N o , I

think the circuitous

method i s a very dangerous thing.

I f you d o this with e
it

non-member bank, e v e r y bank c a n request/
*
for &

i f you. do73%

Milwsukee b a n k , e v e r y l i t t l e b a n k i n g center,

if t h e y h u v e o n l y t v o o r t h r e e a c c o u n t s ,

even

w i l l request t h e

same thing, a n d y o u are going right back t o the long,
cumbersome c o l l e c t i o n s y s t e m w h i c h y o u h e d p r e v i o u s

t o

1915.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Acting Governor Case.

I t is wrong i n principle.

The Chairman,

T h a t brings u s t o Topic I¥.

LV. SCHEDULE O F CHARGES ALLOWED T O B E MADE B Y MEMBER
BANKS AGAINST THEIR CUSTOMERS UPON OUT-OF-TORN
CHECKS WHICH ARE CLEARED THROUGH THE FEDERAL
RESORVE SYSTEM,
(1) R e p o r t o f progress made i n preparation o f this
schedule,
(2)

I s the p l a n suggested b y the Board, Circular

Letter X-1844, February 26th, 1920, f a i r t o the member
banks?

i have a written reply t o that.

J I do not know

whether’ t h e othershave o r not.
Acting Governor Case,

a r e y o u speaking n o w o f No, 1

under Topic I V ?
The Chairman.

l o a m speaking o f Nos. 1

Acting Governor Case.

and 2,

N e w York has sent dorn a

written schedule a n d report showing that w e have prepared
this schedule.
Governor horss. B o s t o n h a s sent a schedule d o w n t o
the Board.
Governor Younr.
to t h e B o a r d ,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T e heave also have s e n t @ schedule

The Chairman, I

find t h a t w e have s e n t t o the Board

our recommendations w i t h respect t o our district.
Acting Governor Case, G o v e r n o r Harding spoke o f this
matter t o the Governors! Conference yesterday morning. I
think h e s a i d t h e y h a d d e f e r r e d a c t i o n ; t h a t t h e y c o n s i d e r e d

the l e w

t o b e mendatory, b u t they had deferred action u p

to t h e p r e s e n t t i m e , a l t h o u g h s o m e p r e s s u r e head b e e n

brought upon t h e m t o take some Zefinite stand.

H e also

stated that while they were getting the cooperation o f
eredit o r g a n i z a t i o n s

a n d chambers

o f c o m r e r c e a n d s o on,

to s u p p o r t o u r p r o g r a m t o c l e a r u p t h e p a r c o l l e c t i o n

system, t h a t the adoption o f the plan a s suggested vin
their circular letter,

b y regulation, fixing t h e charges,

and s o forth, w o u l d u p s e t that.

I move you, if. Chairman, t h a t i t b e t h e recommenda-

tion o f this body that the Board b e asked t o continue t o
defer action upon this m t t e r f o r t h e present.

The Chairman.

I s there a second t o that motion?

Governor Morss. I
seconding t h e motion, I
here &

will second t h e motion, a n d i n
would like t o s a y that I have

letter which w a s sent t o Governor Harding enclos-~

ing t h e s c h e d u l e w h i c h w a s s e n t t o t h e m a t t h e i r request,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

and the closing paragraph o f that letter i s this:
/

am enclosing herewith c o p y o f schedule covering this
district, prepared b y our transit Jepartment, b u t w e
sincerely trust that the Board will find s o m w a y
whereby i t will n o t oblige u s t o put t h e schedule

in

force,
The Chairman, I

will p u t the motion.

(The motion, heving b e e n duly seconded, w a s car-

ried, )
Acting G o v e r n o r C a s e ,
has j u s t r e c e n t l y a d o p t e d a

T h e N e w Y o r k Clearing H o u s e
regulation p r o v i d i n g f o r d e -

ferred interest ch-rge amounting t o four and o n e half w r
cent o n all thirty s i x par States.
Deputy Governor veple,

a n d thet will apply auto.

matically t o any other State a s i t becomes p r ?
Acting Governor Case, Y e s .
The Chairman,

‘ Y e will n o w t a k e u p topic No. 7 .
VII. B U I L D I N G OPERs+TIONS,
(1) P r e s e n t situation,

it seems t h a t t h e Bourd o r Governor Harding desires
to have a

discussion w i t h regard t o building operations,

particularly with regerg t o those banks w h i c h contemplate


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

building but have not yet bepun operations, I
the p u r p o s e

o f determining whether

presume for

o r n o t i t seemsnec.

essery to proceed,
Governor wellborn,

“ h e t i s your situation?

Governor \ellborn,

C u r building i s completed,

but w e a r e building a n extension that elmost doubles
the capecity o f our bank,

T h e t will soon b e finished.

The Chairman, G o v e r n o r ‘'iller?
Governor -iller.

O n yesterday w e received permissi o n

of the Board t o proceed with the closing o f the contract
tO construct o u r building.
The Chairman.

H o w about you, Governor Norris?

Governor Narris, T h e r e i s nothing n e w i n our situation.
The Chairman.

G o v e r n o r Young?

Governor Young,
not completed.

V i e have o u r site, b u t plans a r e

I t i s impossible f o r u s t o start o u r

building f o r another year, because w e cannot s ecure t h e
property until then, “ h e t h e r o r not w e will postpone
it a n o t h e r

y a r beyond t h a t w e have left t o the Board

and w e have n o t received a definite r e p l y asyet. I
our p e o p l e a r e i n c l i n e d t o postpone


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i t a couple

think

o f years.

The Chairman. G o v e r n o r Fancher, w h e t 4 s your s i t u a
tion?
Governor Fancher.
will n o t p e t p o s s e s s i o n

W

e have

s e c u r e gite
d a whichwe

o f u n t i l J a n u a r y Ist, 19281.

O u r

architect a r e i n the midst o f preparing plans o n d gettine
the program ready a t the present time.

4

8 v e approach

January 1st, w e will t h e n determine whether conditions will
warrant u s i n gaing shead,
project.

o r whether w e will postpone o u r

t e are badly hampered f o r room i n our present

quarters a n d unless building conditions a r e unusually b a d
I think i t will b e necessery f o r u s t o proceed w i t h o w

building imrediately after January lst.
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r Blgres?
Governor Biges. t i e have o n l y acquired t h e ground.

The Property i s under lease until M a r c h f
o next year, 8 0
we are i n statu q u o a t the present time.
The Chairman.

W h a t i s the situation i n San Franecileco,

Governor Calkins?
Governor Calkins.

V

e have progressed

t o the point

of getting bids for the steel, but w e have not yet determined a s t o how s o o n w e will proceed w i t h construction.

in view of the faci thet we expect to have t o take over


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

the S u b Treasury,

i t i s very necessary that o u r building

should b e conpleted a t t h e earliest possible moment.
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r V a n Zandt, w h e t i s your situation?
Governor V a n Zandt.

W e have progressed t o the stage

where w e are pouring t h e conerete o n our fourth floor this

week and expect t o be i n the building before the year i s
outs.
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r Case?
Acting Governor Case,

V e have acquired a site, b u t

our directors determined some months s r o that general c m ditions d i d not werrant their goine ahead w i t h the build-

ing program and w e have decided t o defer building a t present, M e a n w h i l e w e are making a very comprehensive s t u d y
of our plans. I

notice,

i n this connection, e

sugpestion

from our office, suggesting t h e propriety o f aprointing a
committee

t o make comparisons b e t w e e n t h e plans o f t h e

various Federal Seserve Banks f o r t h e purpose o f piving
the .énefit o f all suggestions
know whether there i s such a

t o all banks. I

do not

clesring house i n existence

now.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman. I

understands t h e r e i s s u c h a p i e c e

of

machinery a t work, w i t h offices i n your building, a

con-

sultines architect,
ACting Governor Case, M r . . . Hopf, o u r so-called
organization counsel,

i s a member o f our planning committee

ang i s i n t o u c h w i t h itr, T r o v b r i d g e ,

a n d h e m a k e s t h e Ssupg-

gestion o f the desirability o f heving a committee,

t o per-

haps v i s i t t h e o t h e r b a n k s a n d f a m i l i a r i z e t h e m s e l v e s w i t h
&ll t h e various f e a t u r e s f o r t h e b e n e f i t

o f those t h a t a r e

yet t o build,
Governor C a l k i n s ,
Quite a

E

e owes d e s i r a b l e ,

L f not-<too “te te.

number o f t h e b a n k s h a v e p r o g r e s s e d b e y o n d t h a t

point.
The Chairman.

A

S I

remember i t , t h e b a n k s w e r e a l l

instructed t o communicate f r e e l y w i t h ir. Trowbridge i n
order that w e might, throuch him, r e c e i v e : e
h
t benefit o f

Suggéstions made b y any of the banks.
The Chairman.

G o v e r n o r V e n Zandt, w h a t have y o u t o

Governor V a n Zandt. I

would like t o say t h a t I

have called o n Mr. Trowbridge v e r y frequently a n d have received lots o f assistance f r o m him, andlots o f help.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman,

Y o u r architects are our architects,

and they, together with representatives o f our bank,
have t e e n d o w n t o s e e Mr, Trowbridge a

number o f times

D o

to ask for suggestions a n d t o make recommendations.
You d e s i r e

t o make a

recommendation f o r t h e appointment

of a committee under t h e circumstances, Governor Cease?
Acting Governor Case, 1

should think not. I

have

just this moment noticed the Memorandum, a n d I was rather

surprised t o think there was not such a committee already
assumed that itr. Troworidge h a d a clearing

appointed, I

house there where h e h a d all these various plans.

The Chairman, W h a t i s your situation, Governor
Fancher?¢

Covernor Fancher, I

might say t m t I spent several

days i n New York with our architect i n Jenuary.

O n e day

was given over t o discussing w i t h 4 New York architect,
Vr. Y o r k , a n d t h e n r e h e e c t f o r t h e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k

of Boston, t h e question o f veults. T h e n the next day
we spent most o f the efternoon with t h e planning committee
of the Federal Reserve B a n k o f New York, Mr. Trowbridge
being there,

i n discussing t h e m a n y features

York building.

i n the N e w

I t was brought out i n our visit that that

isthe very thing that Mr. Trowbiiige has in mind. H e

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

stated t o our architect that h e would b e very ¢ l e d t o get
‘the benefit o f a n y ideas that were developed i n the study
of the Clweland building.

H e said h e would t r y to h a e

in his office all the good points a n d features developed
and brought o u t i n the study o f t h e other banks a n d thet

you would have a free exchange. i

think that mtter i s

very clearly i n Mr. Trowbridge's mind.

H e i s going t o

endeavor t o bring i t to his office and give out t o the
other banks, all the good things that developed i n studles o f the n e w buildings.
The Chairman,

W h t i s your desire, Governor Case?

Acting Governor Case,

I f there i s n o objection, I

think i t w o u l d d o n o h a r m i f t h e S e c r e t a r y w o u l d c l e a r l y

convey t o Mr. Trowbridge t h e thought o f this Conference a s
to the desirability o f seeing that there was comper ison
mede o f the plans o f the various Federal deserve B a n k

buildings i n order thet those which had not yet built
might have the benefit o f any features that the other
banks had.

The Chairman. I

ar sure there will b e n o objection

to thet,
what i s t h e s i t u a t i o n
Morss?

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i n regard

t o ctspee buildinre, M r .

Governor ‘‘orss.

W e secured a lot some time last

fall and began o n the plang and received permission from
the Board t o g o ahead with o u r operations.

f e have most o f

the buildings t o w n down o n our l o t a n a are n o w excavating.
The plans a r e well along t o completion. 6

h a v e sent Mr,

Trowbridge everything that h e asked for except that we
have not prepared setail drawings, b u t they will g o t o him
in a few days.

W e hope t o get o u r building enclosed before

cold w e a t h e r a n d h o p e i t w i l l b e f i n i s h e d s o r e t i m e i n t h e

fall o f 1921,

W e are pushing i t as hard a s possible.

The Chairman.

G o v e r n o r Case, m a y I inquire whether

or not your advisors encourage y o u t o believe that build.

ing conditions will be more favorable ayear from now?
Acting Governor Case. I

think, Mr, Chairman, that

there w a s v e r y divergent views a s t o that. 1

do not be-

lieve any one les a very clear belief; a t the least, the
directors h a v e n o t a

v e r y clear o p i n i o n

o n t h s t today. I

have heard o n e o r two recently express t h e opinion that
they d o u b t v e r y « u c h i f m a t e r i a l w o u l d b e l o w e r n e x t y e a r

then a t the moment, b u t o u r Board havinp elresdy taken
the action t o defer, a n d then t h e Federal Reserve B o a r d
coming o u t and suggesting t h a t action,

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

w e felt that w e

would employ this year i n a further s t u d y o f our plans

and pérhaps take the matter u p apein the early part o f
the year f o r consideration a s t o whether o r not w e
should g o ahead o r still further defer. I

do not be-

lieve w e will b e able t o go very much longer without ¢
building.
The Chairman, Y V i e r e y o u influenced t o any extent I n
that position b y conditions u n d e r which y o u might n o t have
been a b l e t o secure c o n t r o l
ACting G o v e r n o r C a s e ,

The Chairman,

o f your property this year?
N o .

Y o u r leases a r e all right, a r e they?

Acting G o v e r n o r C a s e ,

W

e a r e i n such shape t h a t w e

could have broken ground the lst o f May, W w e decided t o
defer.

O u r Board felt that i t was v e r y inconsistent f o r

us t o b e pre::ching economy a n d thrift a n d then g o out imme-

diately a m p u t u p ea building, unless i t was absolutely
necéssary,

a n d i t was f o r that reason t h a t t h e y deferred

action,
The Chairman, ‘ i h a t about Richmond, M r . Peple?
Deputy Governor Peple,
way.

C u r building i s weld under

T h e f o u n d a t i o n s a r e finished.

T h e s t e e l viork I s

practically all up, some o f the walls are being laid end
the floors a r e being poured.

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

v

e are hoping t o get i n

the latter p a r t o f this year o r the first o f next year,
The Chairman,

W

e have o u r site i n Chicago.

present t h e r e a r e f o u r b u i l d i n e s s t a n d i n g

A t

o n o u r lot.

All t h e tenants h a v e b e e n notified t o vacate t h e i s t o f
May.

Y e ave n o w asking f o r bids f o r vrecking t h e build-

ings. C o n d i t i o n s a r e s u c h e s t o m a k e i t i m p e r a t i v e t h a t

we proceed with t h e building a s soon a s possible,
We W i l l n o w p r o c e e d t o t o p i c N o . 8 ,

VIII.

D E S T R A B I L I T WF
O SEEKING FURTHER AMENDMENTS
TO THE ACT,

(1) Federal Reserve Board's attitude a s t o payment
of i n t e r e s t u p o n r e s e r v e b a l a n c e s .

Governor V a n Zandt, I

offer a resolution t o the

effect that t h e Governors o f the Federal Reserve Banks c o n cur i n the views o f the Board a s expressed i n letter
No. A-1862.
Governor Young, I

will second that.

(The motion, h a v i n g b e e n d u l y seconded,
(2) S u g g e s t i o n t h a t a m e n d m e n t

w a s @rried,

b e sought allowing

the use o f the 10% super-surplus fund i n the payment o f
extra d i v i d e n d s ,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman,

W h a t are your views o n that subject,

Governor Wellborn?
Governor Yellborn. I
topic,

i

l think e

have n o special v i e s

division o f profitsought

more liberally t o the member banks. I

o n that

t o b e given

think, t h e y ought t o

get & larger share o f the profits t h a t are earned b y the.
Federeal Reserve Banks.
The Chairman. G o v e r n o r Miller, w h e t i s your view?
Governor Miller, I

am not i n favor o f increasing t h e

rete o f i n t e r e s t t o s tockholders.

The Chairman.

Y o u mean increase the dividend?

Governor Miller, Y e s , increase t h e dividends.
Chairman,

u r .

w e follow u p the Reserve requirements v e r y closely

in our district, a n d during the year 1919 w e penalized one
hundred a n d fifty o n e banks.

T h e penalties c m i a e e d

to

about £110,000 f o r t h e year. E v e r y o n e o f those banks w a s
penalized because t h e y tried tokeepjust excctly what t h e y

thought they were entitled to keep and no more, and as a
result,

coun

t h e fault o f their bookkeeping and unex-

pected demands upon them, their reserve would get down too
low a n d w e would penalize them,

T h a t requires a

great

deal of bookkeeping and care o n the part of the member bank
and a great deal o f accounting and watching o f the bookkeeping o n our part,

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

why w o u l d i t n o t b e a

good i d e a t o p a y i n t e r e s t

on a n account n o t exceeding t e n per c e n t i n excess o f
the required reserve,

s o that transactions w o u l d b e

more free “between t h e member b a n k a n d t h e Reserve Bank.
The reason t h e y d o not keep. a n y more t h a n t h e y are required t o keep i s because t h e y g e t nothing o n it, whereas
if w e p u i g i n t e r e s t a t t h e r a t e o f t w o p e r c e n t o n n o t

excéeding t e n per cent o f the excess requirement, t h e transaction would b e s o much easier a n d they would n o t care
if t h e y were a

few thousand dollars more t h a n the r e -

serve a n d w e would n o t have t o penalize t h e : or would
not h a v e t o l o o k a f t e r t h e m a s c l o s e l y a s w e d o now.

I n

our district t h e reserve balances a r e about (90,000,000.

That would require u s t o pay interest o n %9,000,000 i f
everybody k e p t t h e n o r m a l a m o u n t , w h i c h t h e y w o u l d n o t

undertake t o do.

S u p p o s e i t averaged half w a y i n be-

tween and that would b e interest o n four ana one half
millions,

o r ;.90,000,

i

t i s c e r t a i n l y f a i r t o believe

that the increased res¢rve f o r whichye6 w o u l d b e paying
would p a y i t s o w n board, because i t would b e the basis o f
167 percent o f the anount.

T h a t would n o t b e paying i n -

terest o n deposits, b u t would simply b e a m t t e r


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

o f faci li-

tating - The Chairman (interposing). I

think w e are back-

Y e have alresdy decided the

stepping o n this point.

question f r o m thé viewpoint o f the Governors o f whether o @

not interest should b e paid. T h i s i s a n entirely different matter,

Governor V a n Zandt.

M a y Ll resd thelast sentence i n

the communication f r o m the Board which w e have just concurred
in,
The Chairman, C e r t a i n l y , Governor,

Governor Van Zandt.
put i t s e l f

+ t is: " T h e Board has therefore

o n reeord a s being opposed t o a n y proposition w h i c h

requires F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k s

t o p a y interest

o n member

banks’ balances."
The Chairman, I

think that o n l y confirms m y state-

ment, Governor Killer, that the subject has been disposed of.
The question i s rhether o r not the Governors w o u l d favor the
accumulation o f a fund, a

ten per cent super-surplus f u n d

to pay extra dividends which will n o t exceed three p e r cent.
&eting Governor Case, I

would like t o a s k Governor

Miller i f h e thinks i t desirable t h a t member banks should
possibly have a

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Little more participation i n the esrnings o f

the Reserve Banks? J u s t what i s your objection t o their
receiving, u n d e r conditions s u c h a s w e have h a d during t h e
last year o r two, W h e n w e have h a d large earnings, s o m e
slight increase i n the f o r m o f a n extra dividend precisely

as done i n the case o f the commercial bank?
Governor “iller,

T h i s investment i s very different

from t h e c o m m e r c i a l b a n k i n t h a t i t i s s i x p e r cent,

Very

few Stocks which are a s absolutely good as Federal Reserve
Bank s t o c k p a y a s m u c h a s s i x p e r cent.

I t i s Slmost l i k e

a Government bond, especially since w e have had this large
surplus,

N o t only that, but i t is non-taxable, Whenever

you commence t o pay interest o n that, t h e seme principle

would be involved, a n d there would be another bill later
on t o p a y more.

The Chairman,
this i s different.

N o t a t all, Governor Miller. I

think

W h a t rate o f interest d o the Kansas

City banks p a y o n < eposits?
Governor Miller.
The Chairman.

T w o and a quarter p e r cent.

T h e n this t w o p e r cent that y o u are

speaking o f would n o t o f course d r a w deposits?
Governor Miller.
deposits.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

w e would n o t b e seeking t o draw

W e would b e seeking t o relieve t h e necessity

for care, withreference

t o reserve balances,

of t h e m e m b e r b a n k s a n d t h e d i s p o s i t i o n

o n the part

o n the p a r t o f the

member banks t o keep j u s t t h e amount o f their reserve a n d

no more,
The Chairman,

I n any event, y o u would have t o bring

your interest rate u p t o ¢.ual the rate o f twenty four p e r
cent?

Governor Miller, N o .

W e would not care anything

about what the interest rate was o n deposits,

b e c a u s ee
w

would not b e seeking t h e deposits a t all, b u t i t would p a y

thei for the slight excess o f reserve which they would
carry with u s < n d would relieve t h e situation o f a great
many o f its difficultiés.
The Chairman, I

think that question h w s b e e n dis-

posed o f . G o v e r n o r U o r r i s , w h a t i s y o u r v i e w ?

Governor Norris, I

have n o views o n this subject.

The Chairman. Governor Young.
the q u e s t i o n


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

H o w d o y o u feel about

o f paying e x t r a dividends?

Governor Young. I
The Chairman,

Y o u say you would not be?

Governor Young.

The Chairman.

would not b e i n favor o f it.

No.

H o w about you, Governor Fancher?

Governor Fancher,

The Chairman,

a n a you, Governor Biggs?

Governor Biges. I
The Chairman.

would n o t a t this time.

W h a t i s your view, Governor Calyins?

Governor C a l k i n s ,

ly opposed t o it.

J I would be,

A

t the present time I

a m unqualified-

a n y change which tends t o necessitate t h e

making o f profits b y the Federal Reserve Banks w i l l g o far
to destroy the system.

T h e first result o f any amendment t o

the l e w which would make i t possible f o r u s t o pay additional
ividends would b e benk politics, w h i c h w e d o not need;

it

would m e a n t h e s e l e c t i o n o f d i r e c t o r s o f F e d e r a l hKeserve
who w e r e p rylve d g e d

t o p a y t h e highest dividends t h a t vere

mitted under t h e law, end, i f that w a s n o t h i g h enough,
amend thelaw again s o that more coulda b e paid.

to

i t would b e

an encrouchment u p o n t h e principle o f the Federal
Bank, W h i c h i s 8 non-profit makins institution.
There i s a

way for a

perfectly ¢ o o d w a y a n d a

perfectly proper

Federel Reserve B a n k t o inc. esse t h e profit o f

member banks,

ard

i

s b y extending t h e service w h i c h

they render t o those banks a n d perfecting i t i n every w a y
so that i t will b e useful t o the member banks . T h e t i s the
only l e g i t i m a t e w a y , h o w e v e r ,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

i n w h i c h t h e y c a n d o it.

The Chairman,

W h a t i s your view, Governor V a n Zanat?

Governor V a n Zandt. I

it. I

ar v e r y s t r o n g l y o p p o s e d

to

think the stock i n the Federal Reserve Bank is so

attractive t h e t within a n hour a

syndicate could b e f o r m e 4

which would v e r y gledly take o v e r a l l t h e stock o f the
Federal Xeserve Banks o f the United States today.
acting Governor Case, I

think w e would b e i n favor

of some plan which would enable the member bank t o get
some Slight increase other t h a n t h e s i x p e r cent, during

Periods when our earnings are very large.
The Chairman, Governor Morss?
Governor ilorss,

W é are opposed t o it,

V e think

that w i t h all t h e expenses t h a t a r e accumulating i n the
service t o member banks a n d i n other ways t h a t t h e time
will v e r y early come w h e n t h e s i x per cent would b e all
that w e could readily pay, a n d 1 would b e arreia,

i f that

time did come, w e might b e urges t o take o n business for
the Sake o f earning & dividend which h a d once been paid,
en extra dividend which h a d been once paid, a n d that i t
would b e a bad influe

w

e think t h e fact i s that t h e

stock i s very well paid today.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman,

M y understanding

o f this proposed b i l l

is t h a t i t provides

f o r t h e accumulation

a certain amount f r o m which extra
exceed three p e r cent,

m y b e paid.

of a

surplus

of

d i v i d e n d s , not to
A m I right o r wrong

in that?
Governor Fancher. I

did not know t h a t a bill w a

been p r e p a r e ?
4
Governor Calkins, A

bill has been introduced f o r

that purpose,
The Chairman.

D i d that Limit i t t o three p e r cent,

Mr, Calkins?
Governor Calkins.
The Chairman.

N o t i n exceess

o f three p e r cent.

H o w d o y o u f e e l o n t h e subject, M r .

Peple?
¢

Deputy Governor Peple, I

feel t h a t t h e practice o f pay-

ing extra dividends i s a dangerous one, Nevertheless there
is a tremendous d e m a n d that something should b e done o f

that kind, a n d i f i t is done I think care ought t o be
taken t h a t n o o n e F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k i s a l l o w e d

t o pay

a lerger dividend than another Federal Reserve Bank.

The Chairman. I

féel that w e might give some favor

able consideration t o a plan under which w e might b e able t o
Pay the member banks, w h e n able t o d o so, a n extra dividend.

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Ido n o t think I

know enough about t h e l a w t o d i s a s s

the question v e r y much.
Deputy G o v e r n o r P e p l e .

I s i t not a

f a c t t h e t opin.

jons are s o different a n d s o qualified i n a number o f instances t h a t i t w o u l d b e v e r y h a r d t o v o t e y e s o r n o ?
Would

i t not b e better

t o leave t h e expression

o f opinion

just a s i t stands?

The Chairman, W i l l you make a motion t o t m t effect?
Deputy G o v e r n o r P e o p l e .

I n a s m u c h a s there i s quite a

difference o f opinion o n the subject, a n d a s opinions o n

both sides have been qualified, i t would b e exceedingly difficult t o arrive a t a y e s o r n o vote, a n d I

therefore m o v e

that n o motion b e m d e a n d that t h e expressions o f opinion
in the record b e allowed t o stand.
Governor V a n Zandt. I

would second that,

(The motion, heving been duly seconded, was carried).
The Chairman,

T h s next i s Topic Ix,
IX. O R G A N I Z A T I O N D E T A T I S ,

(1) H o w m a n y o f the banks h a v e organized Member Banks
Relations Departments?


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman.

'

@ might consider sub-topic No. e

(2) H a v e t h e Boards o f Directors placed these departments under t h e authority o f the Governor o v the Federal

Reserve Agent, o r both?

Governor ellborn,
tions department.

W i e have no regula? public rela-

V e send o u t f r o m time t o time members

of our staff t o bankers' meetings, meetings o f bankers!
associations, a n d things o f that kind, a n d w e send some
of t h e m o u t t o w o r k u p S t a t e b a n k memberships,
Si

W

b u t that i s

e have n o regular p u b l i c relations department.

Governor Calkins. I

wonder i f this could not be

coveréd briefly b y resolution t o the effect that member
banks relations departments when organized should b e under
the control o f the executive officers o f the bank?

Acting Governor Case, T h e r e i s a distinct question

asked there, "How many of the banks have organized Member
Banks Relations Departments?”, a n d i t seems t o me that we
might answer that,
The Chairman.

H o w m e n y have?

(The following banks answered that they had: N e w York,
. e

e

San Francisco, Cleyeland, i.inneapolis and Chicago.)
ascot

Acting Governor Case. I

e

e

r

would like t o answer question

2 by saying that our member banks relations department i s

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

the Federal Reserve agent, Ur, Jay.
Governor Young.

D i d the Board o f Directors put i t

him?
Acting G o v e m o r Case, T h e y did.
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r Fancher?
Governor F a n c h e r .

being organized,

O u r department

is in ee

e o

o f

y e have three m e n that are o u t i n the

Field a t t h e p r e s e n t t i m .

y

e have n o t developed o u r

plans t o the point o f having t h e m submitted t o the Board,
but I think t h e y will b e a t a meeting which i s held t o
morrow, a n d i t i s contemplated t h a t i t will b e p u t jointly
under t h e Governor a n d the Federal Reserve Agent.
The Chairtan,.

T h a t i s a bad arrangenent.

I t seems

to m e that member banks relations i s a matter that should
be under t h e jurisdiction o f the executive officers o f the
bank,

W e have s u c h a department which i s working along

fairly well, a n d a l l questions relating t o member banks
relations a r e handled under t h e direction o f the executive

officers.

T h e 5ame department, however, i s working for

the agent i
n the mtter of stims ting interest of State
banks ‘to membership.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

I s that what you have i n mind?

Governor Fancher.

T h e r e i s exactly where y o u have

double contact.

A t the present time a

department f o r

encouratiag new State members i s under tne Federel Reserve
Agent,

I t i s rather felt with regard t o the Gwstion

of our member banks relations t h a t there might b e a pood
deal o f information that might come i n t h t would b e o f
benefit t o the various Jepartments o f the bank; there
might b e credit inforretion, t h e r e might b e a variety o f
informetion coming i n that t h e various depaertrents o f

the bank should have the benefit of, and while o u r Board
has not taken definite action o n it, i t i s unter conterplation.
The Chairman.

I t seems

t o m e t h a t problems develop.

ed i n o p e r a t i n g t h e t d e p a r t m e n t a f f e c t i n g t h e r e l a t i o n o f

member banks w i t h t h e Federal Reserve Banks should b e referred directly t o t h executive officers o f theba nk.
Deputy G o v e r n o r P e p l e .

J I would l i k e t o s e y t h a t

while t h e Federal Reserve B a n k o f Richmond h a s n o cleerly
defined o r separate department f o r bark relations,

v e hae

done a great deal o f work ever since the orgenization o f
our bank i n thet direction.

I t has b e e n done chiefly

through eniployes w h o are directly under t h e agent i n look.
ing t o the membership campaign a n d the p a r point campaign,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

ani t h e executive officers o f t h e bank have b e e n i n close
touch with the whole matter a l l t h e time,
Governor Norris. I

under this heading.

I

woula like t o ask a que stion

n the third district the operating

officers look after the relations with member banks i n
everything except i n the matter o f examinations.

T r e ex-

amination Jepartment is under the Federal Reserve agent.
I would like t o ask i n how m n y other banks that i s the

Case.

Governor Calkins.

T h e Federal Reserve Board has

indicated t h a t the department o f examination i s under t h e

control o f the Federal Reserve Agent.
The Chairman.

H a v e y o u a n y such department, Governor

Biggs?
Governor Biggs.

w e have not organized what might

be termed a Member Banks Aelations Department.
however,

W e have,

i n c o n n e c t i o n w i t h o u r p a r campaign, v i s i t e d n u m -

bers o f the member banks a n d have, wherever circumstances
jw tified, m a d e special trips t o visit member banks i n the

interest o f improving their relations with us.
matter s h o u l d b e u n d e r t h e c o n t r o l

of the banks., w e belive.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

f

h

e

o f t h e executive officers

Governor Calkins,

M y purpose i n submitting t h e

motion, w h i c h was n o t seconded, w e s t o bring o u t the opinion
of t h e Governors.

I t appears

t o m e that there i s a

point

here where there should b e differentiation between a State
membership c a m p a i g n a n d M e m b e r B a n k s R e l a t i o n s .

A

l

l of

the relations. o f the member banks o f the Federal Reserve
Banks, except merely routine matters, h a v e t o d o with t h e
executive officers a n d with t h e business transacted b y the
bank,

s o i t i s m y opinion t h a t Member Banks Relations

organization,

i f there a r e any, Should b e under t h e direct.

ion o f the executive officers.
The Chairman.

H a v e y o u such a

department, Governor

Calkins ?

Governor Calkins.

W e have a embryonic department o f

that kind,

The Chairman, G o v e r n o r V a n Zandt?
Governor V a n Zandt.
one now.

Y e are just preparing t o organize

W e have selected o u r manager f o r t m t department

and o u r assig tant manager, a n d have o u r recommendations u p
with the Federal Reserve Board f o r approval,
ie c h e k otins:

i

s i t your t#rsonal opinion that

Member Banks Relations s h o u l d b e conducted under t h e auspices

of the executive officers o r under the Federal Reserve Agent?.

https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

Governor V a n Zandt.

O u r idea w a s t o have i t under a

sort o f joint control, a l l matters pertaining t o the op.~
erations o f the bank a n d the relations between theFederal Reserve B a n k a n d its members t o b e under t h e supervis-

lon and direction o f the executive officers o f the bank,
and i t was our idea t o have that same department handle
Solicitation o f State bank memberships and carry thot cam.

paign on. T h t of course would be under the direction of
the Federal Xeserve Agent.
factory,

s o far a s I

I t would b e a little unsatis~

can figure

i t out,

a s to "here

t h e

real control would b e i n that ease, because the Federal
Reserve a p e n t might mant a certain m a n t o d o a certain
thing a n d t h e Government might want h i m t o d o s o m het
ing
else.

T h e r e woulda b e conflict o f authority there,

The Chairman.

W e have heard from Mr. Case. Governor

Morss, w h a t i s your view?
Governor l'orss,

sey that i

W e h a v e n o s u c h department. I

have ever felt t h e necessity o f it.

cannot

A n y complaints

of member banks a r e taken u p directly b y the officers.

V e

do have one man who travels around most o f his time among
the member banks, discussing questions relating t o the Fed.
eral Reserve Bank, t o get their ideas a n d t o exchange in.»


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

formation,

H e m k e s h i s report t o the executive officers

of the Federal deserve Bank, a n d i t seems t o m e that
whate

ever is done i n that direction should be done under the
jurisdiction o f the executive officers o f the bank.

The

campaign f o r non-member banks, t h a t is, t o g e t them into

the system, i s entirely under the control and direction
of the Federal Reserve Agent,

The “hairman. T h a t is, state bank memperships ?
Governor Morss, Y e s ,
Ueputy Governor Peple.

A s I said, w e a r e doing re-

dations work through the same body o f men who are looking
after t h e p a r point canvaign a n d the membership campaign.
So f a r t h e e x e c u t i v e o f f i c e r s
Reservé Apent.. h a v e w o r k e a

and I

o f t h e b a n k a n d t h e Federal

i n absojute h a r m o n y i n t h i s w o r k

see n o reason w h y they should n o t continue t o d o so,
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r Calkins,

d o you wish t o

make y o u r motion now?

Governor Calkins, W o , I withdraw m y motion.
The Chairman.

V h e t i s the concensus o f opinion,

Mr. Hoxton?

Mr. Hoxton. F o u r banks have stated that they have
established departments.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

T h e concensus o f Opinion i s that

560

while t h a t p o r t i o n o f t h e w o r k w r i c h c o n c e r n s c e m p s i g n s

for State memberships should perhaps b e ui.der Pederal R e serve Apents, @ 1 1 other matters

i n connection w i t h the

relations with member banks, conplaints b y member banks,
educttion o f member banks, a n d s o forth, shoulic ha under
the charge o f the executive orficers o f the bank.
Acting Governcr Case. I
as dissenting f r o m that view. I

would like t o b e recorded
do not want t o take a n y

time, but our Member Banks Relations Department i s an oute
growth o f the State Bank Membership Campaign.
& tMetter o f personnel,

I t i s dhargely

M r , Jay's assistant, Capt. Morgan,--

oné o f the things t h a t interested him, something t h a t h e
could bite o n i n taking t h e position, w a s t h e thought t h a t
he w o u l d d e v e l o p t h i s m e m b e r s h i p c a m p a i g n a n d r e l a t i o n s dJe-

partment. I

should dislike t o have i t appear a s though I

approve o f the expressions h e r e because i n our prticuler
instance w e have a

very happy a n d satisfactory arrangement.

Viith t h a t explan: tion T L will l e t t h e m a t t e r rest.

Governor Calkins.

M

v exoression was not because o f

any friction o r a n y fear o f friction.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman,

W e will n o w take u p Sub-topic 35.

(S)hat steps m v e been taken, o r are i n contemplation,
looking t o the satisfect ory adjustment o f all

differences w h i c h arise between t h e Federal R e .
serve B a n k a n d the member banks?
Is a n y action desired o n question?

Acting Governor Case.

D o n ' t you think i t might be

a fair statement i f we peport the opinion that all necess r y
steps are taken t o remedy and adjust all matters o f difference between the fejeral Reserve Bank and its members?
The Chairman,

M y sugpestion would be, i f this b e true,

that those banks which have established a relations depart.
ment, Should u s e that organization f o r t h e purpose o f handling
such matters a s arise under sub-topic No, 3

and t h e other

banks Which have n o such department a r e taking a l l necessary
steps through their officers t o meet t h e situation.
ACting Governor Case. I

would s o move, i f there i g n o

objection.
The Chairman.

W e will l e t that b e t h e sense o f the

meeting, i f that i s all there i s t o it.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The n e x t i
s sub-topic 4,
(4)

I s there a n y systematic p l a n for using
clerks, temporarily idle,
t

h

i n other than

e n i iepar
w rotments?

Governor Norris, P e r h a p s i t would b e better t o let a n y

bank Which has clerks temporarily idle state it.
The Chairman,

“ n a t have y o u t o s a y about thet, Gov-

ernor WeLllborn?
Governor Kellborn,

W e have n o clerks temporarily

idle.
The Chairman.

A n d you, Goveinor Miller?

Governor M i l l e r ,

w

e h a v e n o s u c h clerks,

n o idle

clerks.
The Chairman, G o v e r n o r Norris?
Governor Norris,
Governcr Young.

A l l o u r clerks a r e busy, Mr. Chairman.
T h e y a r e all busy a t our place,

v

e

shift t h e m about a good deal,
The Chairman,

D o y o u d o a n y night work u p your way?

Governor Younp. T h e y are working four nights a week.
The Chairman.

T Z do k n o w t h a t y o u s h i f t y o u r employes.

I happen t o know that.
Governor Fancher.

T h e officer i n our bank who has

charge o f the niring o f clerks has been given authority t o
move helpfrom o n e department t o the other where i t i s
néeded.


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman, D o e s h e d o that?
Governor Fancher.

Y e s , h e does,

The Chairman.

W h a t about you, Governor Biggs?

Governor Biggs.
. exactly.

T h e same condition exists with us

T h e m a n whe employs t h e m has authority t o shift

them wherever necessary.

W e have a

night force working

every night i n the week,
The Chairman.

W h e t i s your situation, Governor Calkins?

Governor Calkins.

W

e have a Chief Clerk, so-called,

whose d u t y i s t o supply, u p o n requisition, a l l additional
help for a n y department o f the bank,

I f h e d i d n o t d o that

he would n o t b e there.
The Chairman,

W h a t t i m e d o the m e n end women g e t ort

of your bank i n the afternoon?

Governor ‘alkins. Approximately 5 o'clock,
Tne Chairman. D o i t h e y a l l get a w a y a t the s a m e hour?
Governor Calkins.

V e r y close t o it, w i t h t h e usual

variations.
The Chairman. G o v e r n o r V a n Zandt, w h a t have y o u t o

Governor V a n Zandt, I
randum i n response


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The Chairman.

would l i k e t o r e a d a memo-~-

t o that.

Y o u m a y d o so, certainly.

Governor V a n Zandt. " E a c h department o f the bank

”

m a k e s & daily report t o the office service depsrtment o f
the number o f clerks vhich h e c a n release t h e following
day f o r u s e i n o t h e r departments,

a n d e a c h department

also reports daily t h number o f additional clerks which
it may desire f o r use temporarily, a n d the estimated

length o f time such service will b e required.

T h e office

service department assipns: s u c h clerks temporarily idle

to the depertments where needed and adjusts such changes
from time t o time,"

The Chairman. Governor Case, what is your situation?
Acting Governor Case,

W

e have a service depart-

ment t h a t i s charged w i t h thet responsibility, a n d i t does
it.

V

e have three shifts i n our transit departrent. I

do not know whether w e have i n one o r two o f the other departments, b u t i n the transit department they are working
tventy four hours a day.
The Chairrnan. G o v e r n o r Morss?
Governor ilorss.

V e have » chief clerk, so-called,

whose business i t i s t o look after these matters.

H e

hires them, a n d i f there i s need for extra h e l p temporerily
in a certain department h e i s expected t o get i t first f r o m
some o t h e r d e p a r t m e n t b e f o r e h i r i n g e x t r a p e o p l e .


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

W

e h a ve

dittle o r n o n i g h t w o r k n o w e x c e p t
quired

o f course t h e t r o -

i n the transit departmnt.
The Chairman.

D o y o u have a

night force

i n your

transit department?

Governor Moras,
force

Y e s , w o have the regular night

i n the transit department.

The Chairman,

W h a t i s the situation i n Richmond,

Mr. Peple.
Deputy Governor Pephe,
of clerks témporarily idle.

W
A

e have h e d very f e w eases
t one time i n tre fiscal

agents! department w e had some cases o f that kind and they
were taken care o f and shifted t o other departments.

W e

have a man i n charge o f employing the help whose business
it i s t o look o u t for matters o f that kind,
very well.

m d h e does i t

W e o f course have a night force, t h e necessary

night force, i t the transit department, b u t apart from that
we have v e r y little night work, e x c e p t temporarily n o w a n d

then.
The Chairman,

I a m n o t realiy informed o n this sub-

ject, except that T a m satisfied that our men snd women
are a l l worked t o the b e s t advantage a n d are shifted t o
some e x t e n t .


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

The next sub-topic i s No. 5.
(5) A d v i s a b i l i t y o f making efforts t o secure t h e u s e
of checks

o f standard s i z e b y the Federal Reserve

and member banks.

Mr. Hoxton has something t o say with regard t o this,
evicently, f r o m the Board.
Mr, Hoxton.

O n l y f r o m the Board i n the first place.

Back i n 1914 the Board got out regulations o r suggestions t o
the Federal Reserve Banks t o use a check o f standard size,

8: x 3k, and that the banks pass the word along to their
member b a n k s f o r t h e p u r p o s e o f m a k i n g t h e h a n d l i n g o f
checks m o r e u n i f o r m a n d easier.

T h i s immediate request

comes f r o m t h e f i r m o f t h e T o d d P r o t e c t o g r a p h Company, w h i c h

calls attention t o the Board's ruling a n d t o the fact t h a t

various actions have been taken b y bodies throughout the
United States. I

really know nothing about it, except Mr.

Emerson h a n d e d i t t o m e a n g a s k e d m e t o b r i n g i t up.

T h e

question is, d o you pentlemen w a n t t o agitate further t h e
question o f e l i m i n a t i o n

o f f r e a k checks,

o d d s i z e checks.

(after further discussion).
Governor Fancher, I

move t h a t i t i s the sense o f the

meeting that i t i s not advisable t o make anyeffort t o bring gpoy:


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis

\
\

\
stendrdizatione
‘evernor

V a n

V E N eae: s e c o n d

t h e motion

d u l y secondeg
@he motion, h e a v i n g p e e n

cerried, )

(After f u r t h e r 4 n f o r m a l
conferente adjourned,

9 % 5 o4a

Friday, April 9, 1920,


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis


https://fraser.stlouisfed.org
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis