View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

For use at 2:00 PM EST
Wednesday
March 1, 2017

The Beige Book
Summary of Commentary on Current Economic Conditions
By Federal Reserve District

February 2017

Federal Reserve Districts

Minneapolis

Boston

Chicago

New York
Cleveland

Philadelphia

San Francisco
Kansas City

St. Louis

Richmond

Atlanta
Dallas

Alaska and Hawaii
are part of the
San Francisco District.

The System serves commonwealths and territories as follows: the New York Bank serves the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin
Islands; the San Francisco Bank serves American Samoa, Guam, and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands.

National Summary
Boston

1
A-1

First District

New York

B-1

Second District

Philadelphia

C-1

Third District

Cleveland

D-1

Fourth District

Richmond

E-1

Fifth District

Atlanta

F-1

Sixth District

Chicago

G-1

Seventh District

St. Louis

H-1

Eighth District

Minneapolis

What is The Beige Book?
The Beige Book is a Federal Reserve System publication about current
economic conditions across the 12 Federal Reserve Districts. It characterizes regional economic conditions and prospects based on a variety
of mostly qualitative information, gathered directly from District
sources.
The qualitative nature of the Beige Book creates an opportunity to
characterize dynamics and identify emerging trends in the economy
that may not be readily apparent in the available economic data. Because this information is collected from a wide range of business and
community contacts through a variety of formal and informal methods,
the Beige Book can complement other forms of regional information
gathering.

How is the information collected?
Each Federal Reserve Bank gathers anecdotal information on current
economic conditions in its District through reports from Bank and
Branch directors, plus phone and in-person interviews with and online
questionnaires completed by businesses, community contacts, economists, market experts, and other sources.

How is the information used?
The anecdotal information collected in the Beige Book supplements the
data and analysis used by Federal Reserve economists and staff to
assess economic conditions in the Federal Reserve Districts. This
information enables comparison of economic conditions in different
parts of the country, which can be helpful for assessing the outlook for
the national economy. The Beige Book also serves as a regular summary of the Federal Reserve System’s efforts to listen to businesses
and community organizations.

I-1

Ninth District

Kansas City

J-1

Tenth District

Dallas

K-1

Eleventh District

San Francisco
Twelfth District

L-1

This report was prepared at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York
based on information collected on or before February 17, 2017. This
document summarizes comments received from contacts outside the
Federal Reserve System and is not a commentary on the views of
Federal Reserve officials.

National Summary
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Overall Economic Activity
Reports from all twelve Federal Reserve Districts indicated that the economy expanded at a modest to moderate pace
from early January through mid-February. Consumer spending expanded modestly since the last report. Retail sales
increased at a subdued pace across most of the nation, with a number of Districts noting an ongoing shift from in-store
to internet purchasing. Auto sales varied widely, but were said to be up in most Districts. Tourism activity was mixed
but mostly stronger. Manufacturing activity accelerated somewhat, with most Districts characterizing the pace of growth
as moderate. The energy sector showed modest growth in early 2017, and transportation activity was steady to somewhat higher across the nation. Home construction and sales continued to expand modestly in most Districts, while
residential rental markets were mixed. Home prices were steady to up modestly in most Districts, and a number of
Districts noted low inventories of existing homes. Commercial real estate construction grew modestly, and sales and
leasing activity grew moderately. Lending activity was steady to somewhat higher. Businesses were generally optimistic about the near-term outlook but to a somewhat lesser degree than in the prior report.

Employment and Wages
Labor markets remained tight in early 2017, with some Districts noting widening labor shortages. Employment grew
moderately in most of the nation, though three Districts characterized growth as modest and two reported that it was
little changed. A number of Districts noted that staffing firms were seeing brisk business for this time of year, and one
noted more conversions from temporary to permanent workers. In general, wages in most Districts rose modestly or
moderately, with a few reporting some pickup in the pace of wage growth. A number of Districts noted that shortages of
skilled workers—particularly engineers and IT workers—were driving up their wages, and there were also some reports
of labor shortages in the leisure and hospitality, construction and manufacturing industries.

Prices
Pricing pressures were little changed from the prior report. Most Districts reported that selling prices were up modestly
or moderately, though four indicated that prices had largely leveled off. Input prices were up modestly, on balance.
Energy prices and farm prices were mixed but mostly steady, on balance, while prices for construction materials
climbed in a number of Districts. Overall, businesses said they expected both input prices and selling prices to increase
modestly in the months ahead.

Highlights by Federal Reserve District
Boston

New York

Business contacts in most sectors reported modest to
moderate year-over-year increases in activity in recent
weeks. Staffing firms, by contrast, cited modest declines
in revenues. Some respondents expressed concern
about policy changes in the new administration and
associated uncertainty. Most contacts nevertheless cited
a positive outlook.

Economic activity has accelerated to a modest pace.
Labor markets have strengthened, hiring has picked up,
and wages continued to rise modestly. Input cost increases have become more widespread, and selling
prices have accelerated somewhat. Housing markets
have continued to weaken at the high end, while commercial real estate markets have picked up.

1

National Summary
Philadelphia

St. Louis

Overall, economic activity continued to rise modestly
with pickups to growth emerging from manufacturers and
homebuilders. However, activity was essentially flat in
several other sectors. Many contacts remained cautiously optimistic even as their uncertainty increased. In general, employment, wages, and prices continued to rise at
a modest pace.

Economic conditions have continued to expand at a
modest pace. Manufacturing contacts reported an uptick
in activity in the first quarter, while auto dealers reported
a slight decline in sales. The general outlook for 2017
among business contacts remained optimistic, even
improving slightly since mid-November.

Cleveland
Economic activity, which had picked up some after the
election, continued to rise at steady pace into February.
The expansion was attributed to rising consumer and
business confidence, although this confidence is only
reflected in a limited increase in business spending.
Retaining high-skilled workers is increasingly difficult.
Product pricing pressures diminished slightly.

Economic activity grew modestly. Employment rose, but
certain retail sectors saw significant closures and layoffs.
Activity in North Dakota slowed, though activity in the
Bakken was improving. Winter tourism conditions were
spotty. Manufacturing activity and outlook improved.
Commercial construction slowed, but residential construction had a strong January. Home sales were mixed
across metro regions.

Richmond

Kansas City

Economic activity grew moderately since the previous
Beige Book. Manufacturers reported increased shipments, along with stronger growth in new orders and
greater capacity utilization. Additionally, record volumes
of container traffic passed through the ports in recent
weeks. Commercial leasing increased, particularly for
industrial and retail space. In commercial construction,
multi-family and mixed use development dominated.

Economic activity continued to expand modestly, and
contacts in most sectors expected additional gains in the
months ahead. Retailers and auto dealers anticipated a
pickup in sales in the next few months, and manufacturers’ expectations for future activity were at their highest
levels in over twelve years. The energy sector continued
to expand, but the agriculture sector remained weak.

Atlanta

Economic activity grew moderately, and outlooks remained optimistic. The energy sector noted improved
demand and signs of a pickup in hiring. Manufacturing
and service-sector activity continued to expand, although
there was increased uncertainty surrounding the new
administration’s policy changes. Loan activity increased
and housing demand remained solid.

Minneapolis

Dallas

Economic activity expanded modestly. The labor market
remained tight. Overall, wages and non-labor cost pressures were subdued. Retailers cited flat sales, while auto
sales increased. Home prices increased modestly. Demand for commercial real estate continued to improve.
Manufacturers noted an increase in new orders and
production.

San Francisco

Chicago

Economic activity continued to expand at a moderate
pace. Sales of retail goods picked up, and activity in the
consumer and business services sector slowed slightly
to a moderate pace. Manufacturing conditions remained
mixed, and activity in the agriculture sector was largely
unchanged. Activity in the housing market was unchanged from the prior period, but remained strong.

Growth picked up to a moderate pace. Employment,
wages, business spending, and manufacturing production all grew at moderate rates, consumer spending
increased modestly, and construction and real estate
activity rose slightly. Financial conditions were little
changed, prices increased modestly, and farm incomes
improved slightly.

2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Boston

The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
First District businesses contacted in early February reported modest to moderate increases in activity from a year
earlier. Retailers cited flat or single-digit increases in sales, while two-thirds of responding manufacturers saw revenue
gains. Staffing firms mostly saw slight year-over-year declines in revenues, attributable in part to tight labor supply.
Commercial real estate markets in the region were steady, with “good but not great” office leasing activity in Boston,
Portland, and Providence. Residential real estate markets across the region saw increased median sales prices and
mixed sales results, partially attributable to ongoing inventory shortages. Across most sectors, input and selling prices
were stable, although staffing firms have raised bill and pay rates. While some responding firms expressed concern
about increased uncertainty, most continued to say they were upbeat about 2017.

Employment and Wages

Retail and Tourism

Retail firms cited a continuing tight labor market for
positions involving information technology. Retailers
planning to open new stores expect to hire sales associates and front-office personnel in line with that growth.
Manufacturing respondents reported that employment
was up, although for most it was a very minor change.
Manufacturers continued to say they had difficulty finding
skilled engineers and one added that the shortage of
engineers was a problem overseas as well. No manufacturers reported any significant wage pressure. Among
responding staffing firms, all observed strong overall
labor demand and tight labor supply. Two firms mentioned lower demand from the manufacturing sector;
sectors with particularly low labor supply were IT, accounting, and healthcare. Staffing firms indicated that bill
and pay rates had increased since the previous quarter;
most reported little pushback to increasing bill rates.

Retail contacts consulted for this round reported that
year-over-year sales growth in January to mid-February
ranged from flat to low single-digit increases. One furniture retailer reported that its January sales were up 4
percent year-over-year, but severe winter weather in the
Northeast during the first two weeks of February deterred shoppers. Demand for footwear, outerwear, women’s apparel, and outdoor goods was reportedly strong,
but there was some softness in sales of men’s and children’s apparel. Contacts expect to see modest growth
(in the low single digits) in 2017.
Boston area hotels posted an 81.1 percent occupancy
rate and another consecutive record high daily average
room rate for 2016. Based on advance hotel bookings,
projections for 2017 were similarly upbeat. However,
some hotel and restaurant groups feel that the executive
order limiting travel from certain countries may have
adverse business effects as the United States may not
be perceived as a welcoming country. Adding this worry
to other concerns raised by a strong U.S. dollar, the
possible effect of Brexit on the British exchange rate,
and the outcomes of upcoming elections in key European countries creates some significant uncertainty about
how the tourism sector will fare in 2017.

Prices
Retailers indicated that selling prices and vendor prices
were level or up 1 percent to 2 percent. Manufacturers
reported no exceptional pricing pressure from either
customers or suppliers. A manufacturer of milk products
said that it was the most stable pricing environment in
the industry in 10 years. A chemical manufacturer noted
that increased global production of olefins had driven
down the price.

Manufacturing and Related Services
Of nine manufacturing contacts, six reported sales gains
versus the same period a year earlier, two noted little

A-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Boston
change and one reported lower sales. For those reporting growth, it was generally stable. One of the firms
reporting no growth said it reflected an exceptionally
strong start to 2016.

ed partly to a longer-term trend among employers of
reducing the space allotted per worker. Office construction remains limited across the First District, and contacts
cite high building costs and a modest demand outlook as
restraining factors. Boston’s investment sales market
saw steady demand and prices remained high by historical standards, but investors continued to express caution
over the future direction of prices, especially in light of
rising interest rates. Construction activity continued to
increase in Rhode Island but was concentrated in multifamily, hospitality, and infrastructure projects. Investment
sales remained strong in Portland but continued to cool
in Connecticut. Contacts offered mixed reports on the
retail leasing environment: the region’s mid-market malls
saw increased store closings while demand for core
urban retail and high-end mall space remained strong.
Contacts are cautiously optimistic that fundamentals will
hold steady or improve in 2017.

Although contacts were generally positive about the near
-term outlook, many expressed concerns about policy
changes from the new administration. Three mentioned
that the border adjustment tax would present a problem
for them. A manufacturer of semiconductor equipment
said that restrictions on the H1B visa program would
affect its ability to staff positions. Another said that uncertainty about policy was the problem; for example, a
border adjustment tax would have a big effect on where
they located future production facilities and they would
be reluctant to commit to new investment without some
resolution of the issue. One contact noted that a risk in
the coming year was that a plateauing of sales in the
auto industry would lead to discounting of new cars and
resulting pricing pressure on suppliers.

Residential Real Estate
The end of 2016 continued recent trends for residential
real estate markets in the First District. Closed sales for
single-family homes increased in three of the six First
District states and decreased, though only moderately, in
the other three and in the Boston metro area. (Five of the
six First District states and Boston reported changes
from December 2015 to December 2016, while Maine
reported year-over-year changes to January 2017). For
condos, closed sales increased in four states and decreased modestly in Massachusetts, New Hampshire
and the Boston metro area. Despite sales being down
year-over-year, a Boston contact reported that the optimism going into 2017 is “overwhelming.” Record numbers of homes were sold in December in Rhode Island
and in 2016 as a whole in Maine. Pending sales were
also generally up, which indicated a good outlook going
into 2017. Many contacts again cited low inventory as a
strain on the market. Inventory decreased for singlefamily homes and condos in every reporting region.

Staffing Services
New England staffing services contacts reported mixed
changes in year-over-year revenue. Unlike recent reports, most firms saw declining year-over-year revenue;
nonetheless they said that the economy remained strong
and they were optimistic about the future of their firms.
Facing supply shortfalls, most contacts were trying out
new ways to fill their open positions, including partnering
with local non-profits, offering sign-on bonuses, and
increasing their social media presence. While all firms
expressed optimism about the next few months, several
were concerned about policy uncertainty with the new
administration. One healthcare staffing firm, for example,
lost a substantial number of listings a few weeks ago
when one of its clients issued a hiring freeze in Boston,
waiting to see what happens with Obamacare.

Commercial Real Estate
Commercial real estate activity was mostly unchanged in
the First District. In Connecticut, office leasing activity
was limited while industrial leasing was steady if not
robust, and one contact expects further development of
large retail fulfillment centers in the state in 2017. Demand for industrial property appeared to increase more
broadly across the District, driving new build-to-suit
construction in numerous locations. In Boston, Portland,
and Providence, office leasing activity was described as
good but not great, and vacancy rates remained low to
very low. A Boston contact says that the city’s office
absorption pace slowed in recent months, a fact attribut-

Median sales prices rose year-over-year for single-family
homes and condos in every reporting state and the
Boston metro area. A Rhode Island contact commented
that “as prices rise, more people will see gains in home
equity which will give them more freedom to move. That
should provide some relief to our supply shortage.” Overall, contacts were optimistic about housing markets
going into 2017. ■
For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.bostonfed.org/regional-economy

A-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

New York
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Economic activity in the Second District has picked up since the last report, expanding at a modest pace, and labor
markets have strengthened. Increases in both input costs and selling prices have become more widespread. Manufacturers noted a brisk pickup in business activity in early 2017, while service-sector contacts have continued to report
steady to moderately expanding activity. Consumer spending has been subdued in recent weeks, despite a surge in
consumer confidence. Housing markets have been mixed, with weakness continuing at the high end, while commercial
real estate markets were steady to stronger. Residential construction has remained sluggish, though office construction
has picked up slightly and industrial construction remains fairly robust. Banks reported that loan demand retreated and
that delinquency rates rose modestly.

increase in New York State’s minimum wage schedules,
a couple of contacts in the leisure and hospitality industry indicated that they have faced some challenges.

Employment and Wages
The labor market has strengthened in early 2017. Hiring
activity has picked up—especially among service firms.
In particular, businesses engaged in education and
health, information, professional and business services,
and wholesale trade reported that they have increased
staffing levels. On the other hand, manufacturers report
steady employment, and leisure and hospitality firms
mostly indicated steady or declining employment. Businesses in almost every industry sector plan to add staff
in the months ahead, on net.

Prices
Business contacts in all major industry sectors reported
widespread increases in input prices—generally more so
than in the last report. Contacts in most industries anticipate further increases in the months ahead, except in the
transportation sector, where input costs are expected to
remain steady. Selling prices are reported to be rising in
the wholesale trade and leisure and hospitality industries
but generally stable in other sectors, notably retail trade.

Contacts at employment agencies reported that the labor
market has remained tight and that hiring activity has
been fairly brisk for this time of year. One contact in
upstate New York noted a recent pickup in hiring at
manufacturing and tech firms, while an agency in New
York City reported brisk hiring from small to medium
sized financial firms.

Consumer Spending
Retail merchandise sales were generally characterized
as sluggish in January and early February. However, online sales have reportedly been robust, with one major
chain noting double-digit percentage growth over the
past year. Two contacts attribute some of the recent
weakness in seasonal merchandise to unseasonably
mild weather. Despite the disappointing sales performance, inventories were said to be at satisfactory levels.
Retail contacts continued to express concern about the
near term sales outlook, with one noting that a number of
store closings are in the works across the District.

Contacts in most industries reported continued modest
wage growth, though contacts in the leisure and hospitality sector noted a more significant pickup. Contacts at
major employment agencies across the District report
that starting salary offers have generally been steady to
rising modestly, though they have risen more noticeably
for some high-skill workers that are in short supply.
While it is too early to assess any overall effects on
wages and employment resulting from the January 1

Auto dealers in upstate New York reported that sales of
new vehicles were steady at a strong level in early 2017,

B-1

Federal Reserve Bank of New York
while sales of used vehicles picked up further. Inventories of new vehicles have come down but remain somewhat elevated. Retail and wholesale credit conditions
were reported to be in good shape.

inventory of resale units has risen but remains exceptionally low. Bidding wars have largely subsided.
Elsewhere across the District, market conditions have
been more favorable. Home sales in the suburbs around
New York City have been quite robust; prices have remained flat in northern New Jersey and Westchester but
have begun to pick up on Long Island. In upstate New
York, the market has continued to strengthen, with brisk
sales activity, rising prices, and extremely tight inventory.

Consumer confidence in the Middle Atlantic states (NY,
NJ, PA) continued to climb in January, reaching its highest level in more than a decade.

Manufacturing and Distribution
Manufacturers reported that business activity has picked
up sharply in early 2017, with new orders, unfilled orders, and shipments rising noticeably. Manufacturing
contacts also continued to express widespread optimism
about the near-term outlook. Businesses in the wholesale trade and transportation industries reported more
modest improvement but remain widely optimistic about
future business conditions.

Commercial real estate markets have been steady to
somewhat stronger in the first few weeks of 2017. Office
markets were little changed—both in and around New
York City, as well as in upstate New York—and asking
rents have mostly been stable. However, the market for
industrial space has continued to strengthen. Across the
New York City metro area, industrial vacancy rates have
declined further and rents have continued to rise. In
upstate New York, vacancy rates have been steady,
while rents have moved up noticeably.

Services
Service-sector businesses continued to report mixed but,
on balance, steady business conditions in early 2017.
Contacts in both the finance and health & education
sectors noted a pickup in activity, while those in leisure
and hospitality and information sectors reported some
softening. Looking ahead, service-sector businesses
remained generally optimistic about the outlook—
particularly those in the professional & business services
industry. Tourism activity has shown signs of continued
softening, with Broadway theaters reporting sharp declines in attendance in January and especially February,
and hotels generally reporting lower occupancy rates.

New home construction—both single-family and multifamily—has been sluggish across most of the District.
New office construction has picked up somewhat but
remains fairly subdued. However, there continues to be
a good deal of office construction in progress in New
York City. Industrial construction has been fairly strong.

Banking and Finance
Small to medium sized banks in the District reported
weaker demand for consumer loans and residential
mortgages, but no change in demand for commercial
mortgages or C&I loans. Bankers reported that credit
standards were unchanged across all loan categories.
Spreads of loan rates over cost of funds were unchanged across all loan categories except residential
mortgages, for which bankers reported widening
spreads. Respondents also reported an increase in the
average deposit rate. Finally, bankers reported higher
delinquency rates across all loan categories except
commercial mortgages, for which bankers reported no
change in delinquency rates. ■

Real Estate and Construction
Housing markets have been mixed across the District
since the last report, with the high end of the market
continuing to lag. New York City’s rental market has
weakened further. Rents on larger apartments have
continued to decline, while rents on smaller units have
been flat; moreover, landlords have been offering more
generous concessions in early 2017. Apartment rents
have been flat in the areas around New York City but
have continued to edge up across upstate New York.
Rental vacancy rates have edged down in New York
City, reportedly due, in part, to the increased concessions. Across the District overall, vacancy rates have
been mostly steady.
New York City’s co-op and condo resale market has
been flat in early 2017. There was a pickup in activity in
January, but that has subsided in the first half of February. Prices on larger units—especially new development—have continued to slip, while prices on smaller
apartments have been steady to up slightly. The inventory of newly developed units has continued to rise; the

For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.newyorkfed.org/data-and-statistics/regional-datacenter/index.html

B-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Philadelphia
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Aggregate business activity in the Third District continued at a modest pace during the current Beige Book reporting
period. Notable shifts in activity included manufacturing and homebuilding, which improved to a moderate pace of
growth. Four sectors — nonauto consumer spending, lending, and nonresidential construction and leasing — were
essentially unchanged, after growing at a modest pace in the prior period. Existing home sales appeared to have declined. According to most contacts, employment, wages, and prices continued to grow at a modest pace. Expectations
for firm growth have risen recently; however, the anticipated pace of growth over the next six months remains moderate
on average.

Employment and Wages

and other large service-sector firms noted no signs, nor
fear of inflation. Homebuilders continued to note the
greatest price pressures for their inputs, especially for
subcontracted labor. Overall, the sales prices of existing
homes decreased slightly, if at all, although this varies
across markets and price categories.

Employment has continued at a modest pace of growth
since the prior report. Manufacturing firms continued to
note increases in employment and in the length of average hours worked. Employment indicators from nonmanufacturing firms remained positive overall, but with smaller net increases as a growing percentage of firms reported a decrease in full-time and part-time workers.

Looking ahead one year, manufacturers anticipate a 2.0
percent increase in prices received for their own goods
and services, and nonmanufacturers expect a 2.5 percent increase. Manufacturers also reported expectations
of 2.2 percent annual inflation for consumers — slightly
higher than last fall, while nonmanufacturers continue to
expect 2.0 percent inflation.

Staffing firms described themselves as busy. In some
cases, activity picked up immediately following the holiday lull and continued at a steady pace.
Wage pressures continued to be modest with little shift in
reporting on wage levels or labor market tightness. Staffing contacts noted little change in overall wage pressures. A somewhat lower percentage of nonmanufacturing contacts reported wage increases than during the
prior period.

Manufacturing
A greater percentage of firm contacts in a broader range
of sectors reported increased manufacturing activity than
in the previous period, suggesting moderate growth
overall. Contacts reported that new orders picked up to a
moderate pace of growth, while shipments continued at
a modest pace.

Prices
On balance, price levels continued to rise modestly.
About two-thirds of firm contacts reported no change at
all in prices paid and prices received. Of the remaining
firms, more reported increases than decreases with the
exception of prices received by nonmanufacturing firms,
which were almost evenly balanced. Contacts in banking

Overall, gains in activity were indicated by most major
sectors, including the makers of lumber products, paper
products, chemicals, primary and fabricated metal products, industrial machinery, and electronic products.

C-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia
More than half of the manufacturing contacts were optimistic that orders, shipments, and general activity would
grow over the next six months, similar to the prior Beige
Book period. About one-third of the contacts expressed
expectations for increased capital expenditures, although
this was a bit lower than the prior period.

Financial Services

Consumer Spending

Consumer lending (other than for credit cards and autos)
was the only loan category to grow significantly during
the period. Commercial real estate loan volume grew a
bit, but less so than the same period last year. Home
equity loans and auto loans decreased slightly, while
volumes of home mortgages and of commercial and
industrial loans were mostly unchanged.

Third District financial firms reported little or no change in
overall loan volumes, after posting modest increases
during the prior Beige Book period. This excludes the
typically large seasonal decrease observed in credit card
volumes, which follows the annual holiday season.

Nonauto retail sales grew slightly at best during the
period, according to several analysts. One area chain
reported that sales were a little lower than the prior two
months, and a bit below expectations but the contact
was not yet worried about a changing trend.
Auto dealers noted concern this period, as sales only
slightly increased over last year after adjusting for much
milder weather (sales were hurt last year by a significant
January 2016 snowstorm). Dealers worry about too
much inventory and getting squeezed between manufacturers’ ongoing supply and slightly slumping demand.

Most contacts continued to note the increased optimism
of Wall Street investors and larger Main Street businesses but also noted increased uncertainty, especially for
consumers and small businesses. In general, banking
contacts continued to express cautious optimism for
slow, steady growth.

Tourism contacts generally indicated a continuation of
modest growth and positive prospects for the year
ahead. A Poconos contact indicated that the snow season had opened early and that there was a good base of
snow for Presidents’ Day, which coincides with the area’s biggest winter week because so many schools have
vacations. Meanwhile, area water parks continue to
attract an increasing number of visitors year-round.
Contacts at the Jersey Shore indicated that peak summer bookings are filling up earlier each year. Even casino revenues in Atlantic City have finally begun to register
some year-over-year gains on a more consistent basis.

Real Estate and Construction
On balance, homebuilders were pleased to report that
the new year began with moderate increases in traffic,
contract signings, and construction backlogs. Mild winter
weather helped year-over-year comparisons, but activity
has also outperformed firms’ expectations.
Brokers in most major Third District housing markets
reported a modest decline in existing home sales following moderate growth last period. They report no signs
yet that the very low inventory levels will be replenished
in time to boost sales this spring.

Nonfinancial Services

Nonresidential real estate contacts covering much of the
Third District reported little change overall to the relatively high levels of construction and leasing activity. Contacts reported strong growth for projects associated with
energy and pipelines and some ongoing growth for the
office market in and around Philadelphia. However,
contacts have begun to voice concerns as to whether the
industrial/warehouse market might be near a peak, as
they have previously said for multifamily construction. ■

Overall, Third District service-sector firms continued to
report moderate growth in general activity; moreover, the
pace was somewhat faster than the prior period. Specifically, contacts noted a pickup in the moderate pace of
sales and new orders. A transportation analyst reported
that truck freight was growing a bit better than the prior
period, as its market tightened at year-end. Spot rates
for hiring trucks had increased, so contract rates will
likely follow, according to the analyst. Along with steady
growth, one contact noted that the incidence of consumers not paying their monthly bills continues to fall. Generally, the high expectations of future growth reported in
the prior period were tempered this period — retreating
to more average levels.

For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.philadelphiafed.org/research-and-data/regionaleconomy

C-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Cleveland
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Economic activity grew moderately on balance across the Fourth District during the current reporting period. Labor
markets continued to show signs of tightening, with moderate wage gains. Upward pressure on prices paid and prices
received dampened slightly. Consumers continued to favor Internet and mobile shopping over brick and mortar. Motor
vehicle sales spiked higher in January. Production picked up at manufacturing plants. Nonfinancial services firms experienced slight revenue growth overall, but demand was strong for IT and data analytics services. The housing market
improved, with higher unit sales and higher prices. Commercial builders believe 2017 will be a solid year for their industry, though some expect that 2017 will also be the peak of the current construction cycle. Lending pipelines remain
relatively strong.

Employment and Wages

are clearer. A data analytics firm reported that brick-andmortar retailers generally are experiencing 1.5 percent to
3 percent price declines. One factor driving the declines
is competition from their Internet counterparts. An auto
dealer noted that the average transaction price is approaching a historic high mainly because of the popularity of light trucks, which have higher sticker prices than
cars. He believes that rising interest rates will help temper further sticker price increases. Manufacturers are
seeing modest increases in raw material prices, which
they attributed to the rising cost of steel products and
suppliers finally raising prices after having delayed such
increases during the past few years. Wellhead prices for
natural gas continue to trend slowly higher, but they
remain below the threshold that would significantly boost
upstream activity.

Reports indicated continued tightening in labor markets.
Staffing increases were prevalent in the nonfinancial
services and the real estate and construction industries.
Manufacturing saw a pickup in hiring after reporting flat
or lower payrolls since late last summer. Attracting and
retaining qualified employees in the skilled trades and
technical positions such as engineering and data analytics remain challenging and are fueling wage and benefit
increases across industry sectors. One large manufacturer noted that the average time required to fill skilled
production or professional job openings has risen from
two months to six months. Reports of average wage
increases during 2017 are generally expected to fall
within the 2 percent to 3 percent range, but there were a
few reports of 3 percent to 5 percent increases.

Prices

Consumer Spending

Upward pressure on prices paid and prices received has
dampened over the period. Several nonfinancial services
providers reported that they are holding their billing rates
in check, excluding inflation adjustments, because of
pushback from clients when they attempted to raise
rates. Similarly, suppliers of healthcare products sold to
hospitals indicated that they are holding their prices in
check until potential changes in the Affordable Care Act

Reports indicated that Internet retailers are experiencing
strong revenue growth, while same-store sales were flat.
Although traditional brick-and-mortar retailers are investing in ecommerce, their combined sales have increased
at a slower pace than the sales of Internet specialists.
That said, a furniture chain reported a significant boost in
post-election consumer confidence, which when com-

D-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland
bined with low interest rates contributed to fourth quarter
revenues at a historic high. Strong sales continued into
January. Similarly, car dealers reported a spike in unit
sales of new and used vehicles during January when
compared to those of the same time period a year earlier
and when compared to December’s transactions. One
dealer attributed the increase in sales to an ongoing post
election boost in consumer confidence and to rising
OEM incentives. Unit sales increases are reportedly
around 12 percent, with light trucks dominating sales.

and the likelihood of higher interest rates are factors
motivating buying decisions. Low inventory of existing
homes for sale is helping boost prices. Estimates of
single-family construction starts for 2016 were higher in
Ohio and eastern Kentucky, compared to those of a year
earlier.
Overall activity in the commercial construction market
remains elevated. Contacts expect that 2017 will be a
solid year for their industry, though some noted that 2017
may be the peak of the current construction cycle and
that they anticipate uncertainty surrounding business
activity in 2018. General contractors are seeing strong
demand from healthcare and industrial customers. The
latter group’s demand is especially pronounced for warehousing and distribution facilities. An Internet retailer
announced plans to construct a major hub in the District.
A commercial real estate services contact noted a large
post election spike in commercial property transaction
fees after business had been flat for most of 2016. General contractors cited two issues that may be dampening
multifamily construction: First, uncertainty about the
administration’s tax policies is causing worry among
sellers of affordable housing tax credits. Even though no
new tax policies are in place, firms are holding off on
purchasing tax credits because of speculation that they
won’t need to offset their taxes as much as in the past.
Second, banks are moving more cautiously when considering financing multifamily developments out of concern that some hotter markets may be overbuilt. As a
result, developers are being required to hold equity
positions that are about 10 percentage points higher
compared to requirements of a couple of years ago.

Manufacturing
Factory output picked up slightly since our last report.
Activity for suppliers to the aerospace, construction, and
motor vehicle industries remains elevated. Manufacturers of food service and warehouse automation equipment cited strong growth during 2016. Factors tempering
output growth for other manufacturing industries include
ongoing weakness in the oil and gas industry and the
strong dollar. The auto industry is concerned about the
possible impacts of a border-adjustment tax. Auto parts
cross borders multiple times prior to final assembly. A
border tax policy would likely result in higher sticker
prices and an increase in OEM incentives.

Nonfinancial Services
Activity in the nonfinancial services sector grew slightly
over the period. Strongest demand was seen in the IT
and data analytics, commercial real estate services, and
management consulting segments. Several contacts
observed that clients were in a wait-and-see mode prior
to the presidential election and that demand for services
picked up post election. An engineering design firm
reported that through much of 2016, clients had been
hesitant to move forward with projects, especially large
projects. That said, there was a noticeable pickup in
project feasibility studies since the presidential election.
Similarly, a law partner noted that demand for legal
services was stable through most of 2016. However, in
the fourth quarter, his firm saw a broad-based uptick in
demand. A landscape architecture firm reported a large
spike in RFPs during December, especially for nontraditional services. The firm indicated that many of these
projects had been postponed for years and that property
owners are now feeling confident about the economy.

Financial Services
Bankers reported that lending pipelines remain relatively
strong. The outlook is more positive since the presidential election because of an increase in consumer and
business confidence that bankers believe will fuel increased demand for their products and services. However, the boost in demand may not occur until after midyear 2017. In contrast, potential changes in US trade
policies could restrain the business activities of corporate
clients with large global business models. Another reported concern is that non amortizing loans issued to
commercial developers prior to the financial crisis are
coming due. Already there are some developers turning
over collateral rather than repaying loans because many
retail properties are worth less than the loan value. ■

Real Estate and Construction
Unit sales of new and existing single-family homes for all
of 2016 increased almost 7 percent compared to those
of a year earlier. The average sales price rose 4.5 percent. Realtors reported that rising consumer confidence

D-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Richmond
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Economic activity in the Fifth District grew moderately since the previous Beige Book report. Labor demand continued to
increase and there were more reports of employees being converted from temporary to permanent workers. Prices rose
somewhat more rapidly at services firms, while increases in manufacturing prices received were modest. Manufacturing
input price growth moderated slightly. Manufacturing strengthened, and producers anticipated continued improvement
during 2017. Retail sales rose on balance. Tourism grew at a normal seasonal pace. Residential real estate activity
increased slightly, while commercial leasing rose moderately. In banking and finance, commercial loan demand rose
and residential mortgage demand softened to typical seasonal levels. At non-financial services firms, revenues continued to rise at a modest pace. Energy markets strengthened modestly and agricultural conditions were largely unchanged at seasonal levels.

slightly elevated levels previously reported, while natural
gas prices edged lower in recent weeks.

Employment and Wages
Labor demand remained moderate, although hiring
increased at a slightly slower pace since the previous
Beige Book because of usual seasonal slowing at the
beginning of the year. District contacts reported modest
increases in wages in recent weeks. Recruiters continued to report tight labor markets, with strong demand,
particularly for higher-level skilled workers. Staffing firms
reported that the volume of worker conversion from
temporary to permanent increased modestly. Tourism
and hotel contacts were planning typical levels of seasonal hiring but were experiencing shortages of applicants; some businesses were offering higher wages or
incentives to fill those positions.

Manufacturing
Manufacturers reported increased shipments, along with
stronger growth in new orders and greater capacity
utilization since the prior Beige Book. Food producers
and metals fabricators were among those indicating
greater strength. A steel producer reported double-digit
growth in quotes. Additionally, an executive from a paper
products company said demand had increased for pulp
and specialty products. A producer of aerospace products expected his output to double in 2017. Surveyed
manufacturers anticipated stronger business conditions
during the next six months.

Prices

Ports and Transportation

Services firms’ prices rose at a moderately faster pace in
recent weeks while retail prices grew more robustly,
according to our most recent surveys. Manufacturers
reported modest growth in prices received and a slight
slowdown in average input price growth. Home prices
inched up, on balance. Residential home builders reported a modest increase in lot prices in some areas. Grain,
livestock, and poultry prices rose marginally but remained below historical averages. Beef prices, however,
continued to decline slightly. Coal prices remained at the

Port officials reported record strength in container volume since the previous Beige Book. At one port, volume
was described as “off the charts,” and another had its
best month ever for loaded containers. Imports of furniture, building supplies, and auto parts were strong. Auto
imports remained at high levels, but exports of used cars
to oil producing regions softened, which was attributed to
falling oil prices in those destinations. Exports of construction and agricultural equipment remained weak.

E-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond
Executives at trucking firms in the District said that demand for freight hauling services was somewhat softer in
recent weeks, but one contact noted that expectations
were for an improvement in the second half of the year.
A railroad industry source commented that capacity had
begun to tighten in freight transportation.

Banking and Finance
Since our previous beige book, loan demand grew moderately. Overall, bankers said that consumer and commercial demand was increasing at a healthy rate with the
exception of some small rural areas throughout the
District and in coal regions of West Virginia. In the District on the whole, residential mortgage demand softened
slightly to a typical seasonal level. Commercial loan
demand grew at a moderately faster pace. Demand for
small business loans and lines of credit continued to rise
at a modest pace. Credit quality was unchanged on
balance but varied by region; a West Virginia banker
said credit quality remained at an acceptable level while
a South Carolina lender said quality was at an all-time
high. Interest rates rose slightly in recent weeks. A lender in Virginia noted a sense of urgency from business to
borrow before interest rates increase further. Competition among banks remained fierce. The trend in mergers
and acquisitions continued. Bankers expressed optimism
that regulatory changes under the new administration
would be more favorable.

Retail, Travel, and Tourism
Retail sales rose on balance, particularly for building
supply and home and garden establishments, as well as
hardware stores. In contrast, sales at convenience and
grocery stores were lower. Auto sales remained strong.
Low fuel prices continued to spur sales of pick-up trucks
and reduce demand for compact cars. A large auto
dealer said that unit sales were down but gross profit per
unit was up.
Tourism grew at a normal seasonal pace in recent
weeks. A Virginia ski resort reported strong weekend
bookings and few cancellations, even during warm
weather, because of available alternate activities. A
contact on the outer banks of North Carolina said tourism was little changed at usual off-season levels. According to sources at coastal locations, advance bookings were at typical levels for this time of year.

Non-Financial Services
Revenues at services firms increased at a modest pace.
Entertainment venues, accountant services, and trades
associated with home-building reported increases.
Healthcare organizations reported robust demand since
the previous Beige Book. An executive at a large
healthcare organization said capital projects were being
considered to handle the growth. One hospital reported
the opening of many new physician practices associated
with the facility.

Real Estate and Construction
Residential real estate sales increased modestly since
the previous report. Contacts reported good levels of
buyer traffic in recent weeks; however some sources
said snow storms reduced buyer traffic in affected areas.
Brokers reported that inventories generally remained at
low levels, although a few contacts noted slight increases for some price ranges. Nonetheless, new listings sold
quickly. Residential builders reported that home starts
and closings increased to moderate levels.

Agriculture and Natural Resources
Energy markets strengthened modestly in recent weeks.
Coal production picked up marginally as the pricing and
regulatory environment improved for them. Natural gas
production was unchanged. A utility executive in Maryland reported a modest increase in energy demand from
commercial customers but a slight decline in residential
connections. Agriculture conditions were largely unchanged at typical seasonal levels. Demand for poultry
rose moderately. Some expansions were reported at
poultry farms in North Carolina. ■

Commercial leasing increased moderately in recent
weeks and was stronger than a year ago according to
contacts. Rents rose moderately while vacancy rates
edged down. Real estate agents said that industrial and
retail leasing remained robust, and available space was
limited. Meanwhile, office leasing increased modestly.
Overall, commercial construction remained steady at
modest levels, although a large general contractor reported the largest backlog in his firm’s history. Multifamily and mixed used developments continued to dominate new commercial construction projects.

For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.richmondfed.org/research/regional_economy

E-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Atlanta
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Business contacts indicated that economic activity in the Sixth District continued to expand, albeit modestly, from the
previous report. The outlook among contacts for the next three to six months remains positive.
The labor market remained tight and wage pressures were mostly subdued. Overall, non-labor input costs remained
modest. Retailers cited steady sales since the previous report. Automobile dealers indicated sales were better than
expected. Tourism activity improved. Residential real estate builders indicated that construction activity was up, and
new home sales and inventory levels were flat to slightly up compared with a year ago. Residential real estate brokers
reported that existing home sales increased and inventory levels were down from a year earlier. Home prices continued
to modestly improve. Demand for commercial real estate continued to improve and commercial construction activity
increased. Manufacturers noted increases in new orders and production.

Employment and Wages

tion expectations, year-over-year unit costs were up 1.7
percent in February. The survey respondents indicated
they expect unit costs to rise 2.0 percent over the next
12 months.

Contacts reported ongoing tightening in the labor market
since the previous report. Firms continued to struggle
finding workers across various fields and skill levels.
Firms continued to note growing partnerships with area
workforce development organizations, community colleges, and universities to develop customized training programs to help develop larger pipelines of talent. Additionally, many firms continued to increase investment in
internal training programs to develop existing personnel,
rather than seek qualified labor across a limited pool of
external candidates. Turnover picked up in banking and
finance, manufacturing, and construction, where some
industry contacts indicated they had to evaluate and
adjust compensation structures, such as, increasing
bonuses and incentive pay, to retain high-quality workers. There were scattered reports of plans to increase
employee headcounts over the next 12 months, though
overall, contacts indicated that they intend to keep employment levels steady. Wage growth continued to be
evident in select geographic locations and particular
occupations.

Consumer Spending and Tourism
On balance, District retailers reported that sales levels
grew at a steady pace since the last report. Merchants
noted that on-line sales levels continued to rise, while
brick and mortar sales remained sluggish. Automotive
dealers reported stronger-than-expected sales in December.
Hospitality contacts across the District reported growth in
business, leisure, and group travel since the last report.
Georgia contacts stated that business travel and convention bookings continued to be strong. The total number
of visitors to the state of Florida increased over the reporting period, however, there continued to be a slowdown in the number of international visitors. Louisiana
reported increases in hotel occupancies, average daily
rates, and revenue per available rooms since the last
report. The outlook remains optimistic with healthy advanced bookings through the first quarter of this year.

Prices

Construction and Real Estate

Most contacts reported modest non-labor input cost
pressures, except for manufacturing purchasing managers who noted greater increases in commodity prices.
According to the Atlanta Fed's survey of business infla-

Reports from District residential real estate contacts
continued to indicate slow but steady growth in January.
Most builders noted that construction activity was up

F-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
from the year-ago level. Builders continued to indicate
that home sales were flat to slightly up relative to the
year-earlier level, while brokers reported an increase in
home sales over the same period. The majority of builders and brokers noted that buyer traffic was equal to or
higher than the previous year’s level in January. Brokers
reported that inventory levels were down relative to a
year ago, while most builders indicated that inventory
levels were flat or rising. Builders and brokers continued
to note modest gains in home prices. Home sales expectations improved in January, with most brokers and
builders anticipating sales to increase slightly over the
next three months relative to the year-earlier level. Most
builders anticipate construction activity will hold steady at
the current pace or increase slightly over the next three
months.

Banking and Finance
Credit remained readily available for most qualified borrowers. However, some small and medium-sized businesses continued to have difficulty obtaining credit.
Some contacts noted that development projects were
being funded by hedge funds and private equity sources,
rather than banks.

Energy
Reports from District energy contacts indicated that
liquefied natural gas exports from the Gulf Coast region
increased. Refinery contacts reported that interstate
pipeline reversals have eased some of the transportation
costs for moving oil and gas to Gulf Coast refiners. Contacts noted crude oil inventories remain at historically
high levels. Utility industry contacts continued to upgrade
power generation plants to natural gas, and there has
been continued activity to expand wind generation
power.

Most commercial real estate contacts noted improvements in demand, resulting in rent growth and increased
absorption, but continued to caution that the rate of
improvement varied by metropolitan area, submarket,
and property type. Many commercial contractors indicated that the pace of nonresidential construction activity
had increased from a year ago, with many reporting
backlogs greater than one year. Reports on the pace of
multifamily construction continued to be mixed, with
roughly half indicating that the pace had increased from
the year-earlier level and the rest suggesting that the
pace had leveled off or slowed. Looking forward, the
majority of District commercial real estate contacts expect the pace of nonresidential and multifamily construction activity to increase slightly over the next quarter.

Agriculture
Agriculture conditions across the District were mixed. By
early February, rain brought some improvement to
drought conditions. However, much of the District continued to experience varying degrees of drought with small
areas of north central Alabama and northeastern Georgia categorized in extreme drought. Florida's February
orange forecast was down from January, remaining
below last season's production. On a year-over-year
basis, prices paid to farmers in December were up for
cotton, soybeans, and broilers, but down for corn, rice,
beef, and eggs. ■

Manufacturing
District manufacturing contacts indicated that overall
business activity expanded since the last report. New
orders and production levels continued to increase.
Supply delivery times were slightly longer, while finished
inventory levels fell. Expectations for future production
rose with nearly two-thirds of firms expecting higher
production levels over the next six months.

Transportation
Transportation activity in the District was relatively unchanged since the last report. District ports cited continued growth in shipments of containers, autos, and machinery. Trucking freight volumes declined further since
the previous report, and carriers indicated they are working to reduce capacity to improve pricing. Rail contacts,
however, reported that total traffic was flat compared
with year-earlier levels following several months of declines. Intermodal traffic was down slightly.
For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.frbatlanta.org/economy-matters/regional-economics

F-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Chicago
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Growth in economic activity in the Seventh District picked up to a moderate pace in January and early February, and
contacts expected activity to continue rising at a moderate pace over the next six to twelve months. Employment, wages, business spending, and manufacturing production all grew at moderate rates, consumer spending increased modestly, and construction and real estate activity rose slightly. Financial conditions were little changed, prices increased
modestly, and farm incomes improved slightly.

Employment and Wages

Consumer Spending

Employment growth picked up to a moderate rate over
the reporting period, and contacts expected it to continue
to rise at a moderate rate over the next six to twelve
months. Contacts continued to indicate that the labor
market is tight and that they are experiencing difficulty
filling positions at all skill levels. A staffing firm again
reported little change in billable hours and ongoing difficulty filling orders at the wages employers were willing to
pay. Wage growth remained at a moderate pace. Some
contacts noted larger wage increases for high-skilled
occupations, while a number indicated that they raised
wages nearly equally for all employees. Many contacts
also reported rising healthcare costs.

Growth in consumer spending remained modest over the
reporting period, with sales results weaker than expected. Contacts reported stronger sales in the food and
beverage, health and personal care, and general merchandise sectors and weaker sales in the apparel, grocery, and e-commerce sectors. Light vehicle sales
slowed somewhat, but the pace was still strong and
incentives remained aggressive. Used vehicle sales held
steady.

Business Spending
Growth in business spending continued at a moderate
pace in January and early February. Most retailers indicated that inventories were at comfortable levels. Manufacturing inventories were also at desired levels overall,
though steel service center inventories were very low.
Capital expenditures grew at a moderate pace, and
contacts expected that pace to continue over the next six
to twelve months. Outlays were primarily for replacing
industrial and IT equipment, though there was an increase in the number of firms reporting spending for
expansion.

Prices
Overall, prices rose modestly in January and early February. Despite reports of heavy promotional activity, retail
prices generally increased modestly. Most metals prices
rose again, and an increasing number of firms reported
that rising materials costs were leading them to increase
their prices.

G-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago
Construction and Real Estate

Agriculture

Construction and real estate activity increased slightly on
balance over the reporting period. Residential building
increased slightly, with growth concentrated in the single
-family segment and in urban locations. Home sales
increased modestly, while home prices increased slightly. Demand for nonresidential construction edged up,
with growth concentrated in the industrial and infrastructure sectors. The pace of commercial real estate activity
continued to be robust and even quickened some, with
growth in both the for-sale and for-lease segments. One
contact noted that banks continue to be conservative
about lending in the sector. Commercial rents, availability of sublease space, and commercial vacancy rates
were little changed.

Prospects for farm income in 2017 improved slightly in
January and early February, although the agricultural
sector continued to operate under stress. Futures prices
moved up enough so that – given expected costs –
some corn and most soybean operations could lock in
small profits for 2017. With profit margins looking to be
higher for soybeans than for corn, contacts expected a
shift in the mix of planting this year, with one reporting an
attendant pickup in sales of soybean seeds. Cattle,
dairy, and hog operations all benefitted from price increases . ■

Manufacturing
Manufacturing production again grew at a moderate
pace in January and early February. Growth was widespread across sectors, and even picked up for some
long-struggling sectors. Specialty metals manufacturers
reported increased shipments and steady growth in
order books. Demand for steel remained modest, but
there were early signs of a pickup as steel service centers began to replenish low inventories. Heavy machinery manufacturers reported an increase in sales overall,
with slow but steady improvements in construction demand outweighing weak agricultural demand. Manufacturers of construction materials also reported slow increases in shipments, in line with the modest pace of
improvement in construction. Activity in the autos and
aerospace sectors slowed some but remained at a high
level.

Banking and Finance
Financial conditions were little changed on balance over
the reporting period. Market participants again reported
steady growth in equity prices and low volatility. Loan
volumes to middle-market businesses increased slightly,
which contacts attributed to refinancing in anticipation of
higher interest rates rather than an increase in underlying demand. Contacts reported low delinquency rates,
with the exception of the energy and agriculture sectors.
Consumer loan demand was little changed overall,
though one contact reported an increase in auto loans.
An auto dealer also expressed concerns that standards
were loosening further for sub-prime auto financing.
Credit card volume was steady and delinquencies were
up a bit.
For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.chicagofed.org/cfsbc

G-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

St. Louis
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Economic conditions have continued to expand at a modest pace since our previous report. General retail sales growth
was modest, while manufacturing activity showed signs of strengthening. Conversely, reports from auto dealers indicated a slight decline in first-quarter sales. Business contacts surveyed in mid-February continued to hold an optimistic
outlook for growth in 2017. On net, 57 percent of contacts expect District economic conditions in 2017 to be better or
somewhat better than last year. This was a slight improvement since contacts were surveyed in mid-November.

Employment and Wages

quarter. On net, 44 percent reported non-labor input
costs were slightly higher or higher.

Employment has increased modestly since the previous
report. On net, 25 percent of business contacts surveyed
in mid-February reported that first-quarter employment
was higher or slightly higher than a year ago; 18 percent
reported hours worked were higher or slightly higher.
District contacts continue to report that the labor market
remains tight. Manufacturing, real estate, and construction contacts in St. Louis reported difficulties finding
qualified candidates, and contacts in Memphis and Louisville reported an inability to fill key positions.

A contact in the Louisville manufacturing sector reported
their raw material input costs were slightly higher due to
supply shortages of certain chemicals needed higher in
their supply chain. Since the previous report, cash prices
of rice and corn have declined slightly, while the prices of
sorghum and soybeans were slightly higher and coal
prices were modestly higher. House prices across the
District also increased moderately. A residential real
estate contact in the St. Louis area reported raw material
prices have climbed.

Contacts reported moderate wage growth since the
previous report. On net, 63 percent of contacts reported
wages were slightly higher or higher than a year ago.
Contacts in Little Rock reported that wages for skilled
workers continue to increase slowly, with more employees changing employers for higher wages. Contacts in
Memphis and Louisville reported upward pressure on
wages for both skilled and unskilled positions.

Consumer Spending
General retail sales growth has been modest since our
previous report and contacts continued to hold an optimistic outlook for 2017. Most general retailers reported a
slight increase in year-over-year sales halfway through
the first quarter. Similarly, the majority of hospitality
contacts in St. Louis, Memphis, and Little Rock indicated
that sales during this period met expectations and that
they anticipate sustained growth in the months to come.
On the other hand, a hospitality contact in Louisville
reported that occupancy rates are projected to decrease
this year after a strong 2016. Reports from auto dealers
indicate a slight decline in year-over-year sales in the
first quarter. Half of surveyed auto dealers reported a

Prices
Price pressures have increased modestly since our
previous report. A greater share of business contacts
surveyed reported higher prices charged to consumers
than in previous surveys. On net, 33 percent of contacts
reported prices were slightly higher than a year ago and
a similar share expect price increases during the second

H-1

Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
shift in demand toward used vehicles, and the remaining
dealers reported no change.

slim majority of local real estate contacts reported that
residential construction activity was slightly higher than a
year ago halfway through the first quarter, and a similar
fraction of respondents expect construction to continue
to increase into the second quarter.

Manufacturing
Manufacturing activity has increased at a moderate pace
since our previous report. Several companies reported
capital expenditure and facility expansion plans in the
District, including motor vehicle, food product, and wood
product manufacturers. In a recent survey, contacts
reported an improvement in manufacturing conditions. A
strong majority reported that production, new orders, and
capacity utilization increased in the first quarter relative
to one year ago. This is an improvement from our previous survey, when most contacts reported no change in
activity from one year earlier. Contacts were also optimistic about the second quarter, with three-fourths expecting further growth in production, new orders, and
capacity utilization. Despite the optimistic outlook, some
contacts expressed concerns about labor shortages and
possible trade restrictions.

Commercial real estate activity has improved at a moderate pace since the previous report. A majority of respondents indicated an increase in demand for both
office and industrial properties compared with the same
time last year. Meanwhile, most contacts reported no
change in demand for retail and multifamily properties.
These trends are expected to continue in the coming
months. Commercial construction activity improved
modestly. Local construction contacts continued to report
a rise in demand for office and retail properties.

Banking and Finance
Banking conditions in the District have improved at a
moderate pace since the previous report. Banking contacts report moderate to robust year-over-year growth in
demand for business and mortgage loans. District bankers also indicate that the credit quality of applicants for
these two loan categories was markedly higher during
the relevant period compared with last year. Since the
previous report, there has been an uptick in the number
of bankers reporting deteriorating credit quality among
agricultural loan applicants. Nevertheless, contacts
indicate that delinquency rates were slightly improved
across all loan categories. The overall outlook among
banking contacts is positive, with contacts citing expectations of modestly higher loan demand and the possibility
of regulatory relief reducing compliance costs.

Nonfinancial Services
Responses from the service sector have been positive
since the previous report. In particular, several firms that
provide information technology services, leisure and
hospitality services, and healthcare announced plans to
build new or expand current facilities and hire new employees. Reports from the transportation sector were
positive, with two large employers hiring new employees
and renovating facilities. Reports from the professional
business services and warehousing sectors were
mixed—some existing employers reduced employment
while new companies began hiring. About two-thirds of
service and transportation contacts reported sales met or
exceeded expectations in the current quarter, and twothirds of contacts expect dollar sales to be higher in the
second quarter than at the same time last year.

Agriculture and Natural Resources
Agriculture conditions were unchanged from the previous
report. As of the end of January, more than 94 percent of
District winter wheat was rated fair or better, a slight
improvement over crop condition at the end of January
2016 and the current crop’s condition at the end of December. However, contacts reported that lower grain
prices continued to affect farmers in the area, who have
further reduced investment in land and equipment.

Real Estate and Construction
Residential real estate activity has improved slightly
since our previous report. Real estate contacts reported
mixed home sales activity, indicating little change in
overall sales. Nearly half of respondents indicated that
sales fell short of expectations midway through the first
quarter, citing reasons such as low inventory levels and
higher mortgage rates. Still, many real estate contacts
expect demand to improve in the second quarter, pushing single-family sales above one year ago. Residential
construction activity has improved slightly since the
previous report. December construction starts ticked up,
while there was a minor decrease in permit activity. A

Natural resource extraction conditions improved slightly
from the previous report, with coal production stabilizing
and higher coal prices helping profits. District seasonallyadjusted coal production was little changed from December to January, while production was 10 percent above
last year’s level. ■
For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.research.stlouisfed.org/regecon/

H-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Minneapolis
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
The Ninth District economy grew modestly overall since the last report. Employment grew moderately, accompanied by
moderate wage and price pressures. The District economy showed growth in manufacturing, residential construction,
energy, and mining. But real estate and consumer spending were mixed, commercial construction slowed, and agriculture remained weak.

Employment and Wages

Wage pressure was moderate to strong since the last
report. A Minnesota state official noted that wages grew
4 percent in 2016, and manufacturing paychecks rose by
even more. Ad hoc surveys of employers in two regions
suggested that average wages in these locations grew
about 3 percent in 2016. Their wage expectations for
2017 were slightly lower; however, given tight labor
conditions, a lower wage outlook for 2017 might stem
from historical expectations of long-standing wage
stagnation. The owner of a southern Minnesota staffing
agency expected manufacturing wages in the region to
grow 8 percent to 10 percent in the coming year.
“There’s a huge demand and low supply. Wages need to
match in order to supply workforce.”

Employment grew moderately since the last report. Ad
hoc employer surveys in a Minneapolis-St. Paul suburb
and in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula found that more than
one-quarter were adding headcount, while only 5 percent
were cutting jobs. A monthly manufacturing index
showed strong increases in hiring expectations in
December and January for Minnesota and the Dakotas.
Initial unemployment insurance (UI) claims in January
were about one-fourth lower compared with a year
earlier. A staffing agency in southern Minnesota said that
client calls and overall business were increasing, and
another in Minneapolis-St. Paul said job orders were flat
in January, but clients expected activity to pick up. Job
fairs were held by a frac sand mine in western Wisconsin
and oil companies in the Bakken oil patch; a builders’
group in Minnesota held a job fair to fill 200 openings.
However, January online job openings in North Dakota
continued to decline compared to previous-month and
previous-year levels. Major upheavals continued in retail,
where national outlets have seen significant layoffs in
Minneapolis-St. Paul, Fargo, N.D., Sioux Falls, S.D., and
elsewhere. A South Dakota manufacturer announced
“substantial” but unspecified layoffs, and the closure of
an engineering facility in Minneapolis-St. Paul will affect
up to 72 workers.

Prices
Price pressures were moderate since the last report.
Sources in the construction sector noted that mounting
labor and materials input prices were driving up
construction costs. An industry report indicated that
Minneapolis-St. Paul construction prices were expected
to increase 3 percent in 2017, a faster pace than in
2016. A utility was increasing gas and electric rates.
Most prices received by farmers decreased in December
from a year earlier, with the exception of soybeans, milk,
chickens, and hogs.

I-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis
Consumer Spending

diversion project in Fargo. Residential construction was
strong. Permitted units in January for both single- and
multi-family units were significantly higher than a year
earlier in Minneapolis-St. Paul and Sioux Falls.
Residential construction was also higher in Fargo, but
lower in Billings, Mont., and Rochester, Minn.

Consumer spending across the District was mixed since
the last report. A Minnesota-based retailer reported
weaker sales due to a continuing shift toward online
shopping. Two large national retailers and two
nationwide clothing retailers closed their doors in the
Twin Cities market due to poor sales. However, analysts
report reason for optimism in the Twin Cities retail sector
overall. In Sioux Falls, S.D., retailers saw a slight uptick
in spending, “but not by much,” a retailer commented. A
mall manager in Montana reported that the mall was
expanding by 40,000 square feet, effectively doubling
the size of a mid-priced department store, while also
refurbishing the mall with updates and new amenities.
Reports from grocers were mixed; for instance,
Minnesota was seeing the entrance of new grocers,
while a large grocery retailer posted a loss in earnings
since the last report. A North Dakota-based construction
and farm equipment dealership announced the closure
of eight stores in the Dakotas and Minnesota.

Commercial real estate remained healthy, with some
softening. Vacancy rates in Minneapolis-St. Paul were
low but have risen recently in the retail and office
categories. Industrial vacancies there remained low, with
significant new space either under construction or in
development. Home sales in January were mixed from a
year earlier. They were slightly higher in western
Wisconsin and the Flathead, Mont., region, and flat in
Sioux Falls and northern Wisconsin. Home sales were
slightly lower in Minneapolis-St. Paul, though it was the
third-strongest January since 2005. Several sources
attributed the softness to late-2016 sales, as consumers
locked in rates before a mid-December rise in the Fed
Funds rate.

Tourism

Manufacturing

Tourism conditions were mixed. Snow conditions in the
northernmost regions of the Ninth District provided
steady recreational tourism activity, according to industry
officials. Regions to the south saw a decline in
recreational activity since the last report due to poor
snow conditions. Elsewhere, casino-related revenues in
Deadwood, S.D., suffered a significant decline—as much
as 25 percent at some operators—leaving one industry
spokesperson to comment that the drop was “alarming.”
At the same time, a large gaming firm was expanding
and improving its resort in South Dakota, stating
confidence in the local industry and an interest in
catering to changing consumer tastes.

District manufacturing activity increased moderately
since the last report. An index of manufacturing
conditions produced by Creighton University indicated
increased activity in January compared to a month
earlier in Minnesota and South Dakota; the index
indicated decreased activity in North Dakota. Two
contract equipment manufacturers reported an increase
in orders in late 2016 and optimistic expectations for
2017. A boat maker received a large contract to produce
barges. A Minnesota candy maker opened a new
production facility.

Agriculture, Energy and Natural Resources
District agricultural conditions remained weak since the
previous report. Respondents to the Minneapolis Fed’s
most recent (January) survey of agricultural credit
conditions indicated that farm incomes and capital
spending fell in the fourth quarter of 2016 relative to a
year earlier, with similar expectations for the coming
three months. Activity in the energy and mining sectors
increased since the last report. As of mid-February, oil
and gas drilling in the Bakken region of North Dakota
was up slightly from a month earlier. Federal regulators
granted a license to a potential $1 billion project in
Montana that would store energy from wind production
and other sources. Production at operating District iron
ore facilities was near full capacity, with an idled facility
scheduled to resume production in coming months. ■

Construction and Real Estate
Construction activity was mixed since the last report.
Commercial construction slowed. Projects out for bid in
early January were below levels of a year ago but
subsequently increased and by early February were on
par with last year, according to an industry database.
January commercial permitting was lower compared with
a year earlier in most District metros. However, sources
were optimistic about near-term activity, especially in
Minneapolis-St. Paul, where major projects were waiting
to break ground. In Montana, $144 million in previously
suspended road construction projects moved forward. In
North Dakota, preliminary work has begun on a $250
million airport in Williston and a $2.1 billion flood

I-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Kansas City
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
District economic activity continued to expand modestly compared to the previous survey period, and contacts in most
sectors expected additional gains in the months ahead. Consumer spending in January was modestly above year-ago
levels, with retailers and auto dealers expecting stronger sales in the next few months. The manufacturing sector continued to expand moderately, and contacts in the professional, high-tech, transportation and wholesale trade sectors reported increased sales. District real estate conditions were mixed as activity in the residential sector fell slightly and the
commercial real estate sector expanded modestly. Energy activity increased moderately, and energy contacts remained
optimistic, although some noted concerns about labor availability and increases in the costs of oilfield services. District
farm income remained subdued, and agricultural credit conditions weakened modestly. Employment and employee
hours edged up in January, and wages increased slightly. Prices rose slightly since the previous survey.

Employment and Wages

ing prices steady. Restaurant input prices were stable,
while menu prices edged up. In the transportation sector,
input prices rose moderately and selling prices increased
modestly. Both input and selling prices were expected to
grow moderately in the months ahead in the transportation sector. Construction prices rose slightly, and moderate price increases were anticipated in the coming
months. Manufacturers reported steady prices for finished goods, while raw material costs continued to edge
up. Manufacturers anticipated slight increases in both
finished goods and raw materials prices in the next few
months.

Employment and employee hours edged up in January.
Respondents in the professional and high-tech services,
real estate, health services and manufacturing sectors
noted an increase in employment levels since the previous survey, while respondents in the transportation,
restaurant, and tourism sectors noted a decline. Employment in the retail sector was higher than year-ago levels,
and employment in the auto sector remained steady.
Contacts across all sectors, except auto and tourism,
expected an increase in employment in the coming
months. Average employee hours picked up in both the
manufacturing and service sectors since the previous
survey period, and additional gains were expected in the
next few months. Respondents noted a shortage of
commercial drivers, salespeople, and service workers.

Consumer Spending
Consumer spending increased modestly in January
compared to year-ago levels, and respondents expected
additional gains in the months ahead. Retail sales remained above year-ago levels, despite being lower than
the previous survey period. Several retailers noted an
increase in sales for household appliances and sale
items, while luxury and seasonal products sold poorly.
Retailers anticipated sales to rise moderately in the next
few months, and inventory levels were expected to increase slightly. Auto sales decreased since the previous
survey, but remained modestly above year-ago levels.
Dealer contacts expected a solid pickup in sales in the
months ahead. Auto inventories were mostly flat but

Contacts in most sectors reported that the pace of wage
growth slowed compared to the prior survey, but wages
still rose slightly. In addition, moderate wage growth was
anticipated in the coming months.

Prices
Overall, input prices rose slightly compared to the prior
survey period, and contacts expected additional price
increases in the months ahead. Respondents in the retail
sector reported slightly higher input prices but held sell-

J-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City
were expected to rise slightly. Restaurant sales in January were above year-ago levels, and contacts in the
restaurant sector expected sales to remain relatively flat
heading forward. District tourism activity was well above
year-ago levels, but contacts expected a slight decline in
activity heading into the spring months.

Banking
Most bankers reported steady overall loan demand in
January and early February. A majority of respondents
indicated a steady demand for commercial and industrial, commercial real estate, residential real estate, agricultural and consumer installment loans. Most bankers
indicated loan quality was unchanged compared to a
year ago. In addition, a majority of respondents expected
loan quality to remain essentially the same over the next
six months. Credit standards remained largely unchanged in all major loan categories. Finally, a majority
of respondents reported stable deposit levels.

Manufacturing and Other Business Activity
Manufacturing activity continued to expand moderately,
and other business contacts reported increased sales.
Manufacturers reported considerable improvement in
durable goods production since the previous survey,
particularly for metals, electronics, and machinery, while
nondurable goods plants expanded at a modest pace.
Production, shipments, and new orders all increased
compared to the previous survey. Manufacturers’ capital
spending plans expanded moderately, and firms’ expectations for future activity were at their highest levels in
over twelve years.

Energy
Energy activity across the District increased moderately
in January and early February, and the outlook remained
optimistic. The number of active oil and gas drilling rigs
continued to increase modestly, primarily in Oklahoma
and New Mexico as activity focused on the Oklahoma
SCOOP and STACK plays and the Permian Basin in
New Mexico. Respondents expected global markets to
balance by mid-year, and thus, projected oil prices to
increase further throughout 2017. However, they remained cautious given the rapid increase in domestic
activity. Some respondents expressed concern about
labor availability and increases in the costs of oilfield
services. On the natural gas side, spot prices fell somewhat in January amid warmer-than-usual temperatures.
However, lower natural gas production was expected to
keep prices from falling significantly.

Outside of manufacturing, contacts in the professional,
high-tech, and transportation sectors reported moderate
increases in sales, with strong gains anticipated in future
months. Wholesale trade contacts noted a slight uptick in
sales and expected activity to increase sharply heading
forward. Professional, high-tech, and wholesale trade
firms reported favorable capital spending plans, while
transportation contacts expected capital spending to
continue to fall.

Real Estate and Construction
District real estate activity was mixed as residential real
estate conditions deteriorated slightly while the commercial real estate sector expanded modestly. Residential
home sales declined slightly, and inventories moved
moderately lower since the previous survey period.
Contacts expected a moderate increase in sales during
the spring months due to seasonal factors. Home prices
increased strongly, and sales of low- and medium-priced
homes outpaced sales of higher-priced homes. Housing
starts declined, but construction supply sales increased.
Respondents expected overall residential construction
activity to increase in the months ahead. Activity across
the commercial real estate sector expanded modestly in
January and early February as vacancy rates declined
and absorption, completions, construction underway,
sales and prices increased. Contacts expected the commercial real estate sector to expand further in the coming
months.

Agriculture
Farm income remained subdued in the Tenth District,
and farmland values declined modestly since the last
reporting period. Cattle, wheat, and corn prices were
lower than a year ago in early February and continued to
weigh on farm income in the District, despite slight improvements in hog and soybean prices. All District states
reported slightly lower farm income and expected further
declines in the coming months. Farmland values and
cash rental rates for farmland continued to trend lower at
a modest pace and were also expected to decline further
in the months ahead. Alongside persistent declines in
farm income and farmland values, agricultural credit
conditions weakened modestly, as farm loan repayment
rates edged lower and demand for short-term financing
remained strong. ■

For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.KansasCityFed.org/Research/RegionalEconomy

J-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

Dallas

The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Economic activity in the Eleventh District expanded moderately over the past six weeks. Manufacturing demand
strengthened, and activity among nonfinancial services firms increased. Retail sales generally rose, although there were
some reports of weakness. Housing demand was solid, with gains in home sales. Loan demand increased, and the
energy sector improved modestly. The agricultural sector improved thanks to favorable weather and rising crop and
cattle prices. Employment and wages increased, as did prices. Outlooks generally improved.

Employment and Wages

Manufacturing

Overall employment rose, with hiring relatively strong in
manufacturing and relatively weak in retail. Energy contacts reported that layoffs were mostly done, and that
there were even several signs of hiring activity ramping
up. Reports of skilled labor shortages continued, particularly in manufacturing and construction, and restaurant
contacts said hiring qualified people remains a huge
problem. Upward wage pressures were similar to the last
reporting period. One contact remarked that increases in
health care costs are more than they can pass on to
employees.

The manufacturing sector expanded again over the past
six weeks. Output growth remained a bit stronger for
durable goods than nondurables, although weakness
persisted in fabricated metals —a segment with strong
ties to the energy industry. However, a few fabricated
metals manufacturers indicated activity has begun to
increase in 2017. Exports remained a source of weakness for firms that sell internationally, with the strong
dollar and softness in Mexico’s economy hurting sales.
Overall, outlooks remained positive. A few manufacturing
contacts said their customers held a “wait and see”
approach and that there is considerable uncertainty,
including over the potential impacts related to policy
changes from the Trump Administration.

Prices
Input costs continued to rise during the reporting period,
with relatively strong upward pressure in manufacturing
raw materials prices. Selling prices generally rose, with
more widespread inflation reported among manufacturers and retailers. Some services companies noted that
input price increases remained difficult to pass along.
Railroad contacts noted downward pressure on prices
due to excess capacity. Oil prices held steady while
natural gas prices drifted downward. Agricultural commodity prices generally increased.

Gulf Coast refiners noted seasonally strong utilization
rates, despite lower margins in January. The competitive
advantage of domestic chemical manufacturers (who
use natural gas instead of oil as an input) has increased
in 2017 thanks to a larger spread between oil and natural
gas prices. The outlook for chemical firms remained
healthy because this feedstock cost advantage is expected to persist. Refinery business is not expected to
fare as well in 2017 as in 2016, as large inventories and
expectations of moderate demand growth will keep

K-1

Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas
margins modest.

Financial Services

Retail Sales

Loan demand increased over the past six weeks. Most
respondents noted increased total loan balances, paralleled by improvement in general business activity. Commercial real estate and mortgage loans were among the
better performing categories over the reporting period,
and consumer loan demand ticked up. Lenders involved
in auto loans noted that delinquency rates continued to
rise. Contacts reported higher interest rates charged on
loans as well as higher interest rates paid on deposits.
Respondents expressed optimism about loan demand
and general business activity over the next six months.

Retail demand continued to rise during the reporting
period, although at a slightly slower pace than the prior
period. One clothing retailer said sales in border cities
and energy-related areas remained sluggish. Auto sales
declined, with one auto dealer noting that the January
seasonal decline was greater than normal. Overall,
outlooks among retailers remained mostly optimistic.

Nonfinancial Services
Demand for nonfinancial services generally continued to
increase over the past six weeks, with numerous reports
of rising business activity. Most staffing services firms
saw a pickup in demand. Staffing demand remained
particularly strong in Dallas, with a surge in information
technology, and rose slightly in Houston, including in the
oil and gas sector. Professional and technical services
firms noted increased revenues, while several reports
from leisure and hospitality firms cited declines. Transportation services firms noted mixed movements in
cargo volumes. Overall, most services firms noted improved outlooks. However, several expressed concern
about uncertainty surrounding the new administration’s
potential policy changes and the resulting impact of
those changes.

Energy
Demand for oilfield services increased in the Permian
Basin, and the district rig count increased. Outlooks for
2017 were more positive than in the last reporting period,
but remain slightly guarded. Contacts were unanimously
negative in their expectations about the impact of the
proposed border adjustment tax on their firms. Regarding price risks for the year, firms noted a downward bias,
with inventories keeping a lid on oil prices at around $60
per barrel and lingering uncertainty around OPEC’s
ability to achieve its targeted production cuts for the first
half of 2017.

Agriculture
Moisture levels remained favorable across the district.
The wheat crop was in great shape, and row crop producers began field preparation in many areas and even
started planting in some of the southern parts of Texas.
Cattle prices continued to rally, due in part to seasonality
but also a combination of ample demand and a tighter
supply of cattle ready for market. Contacts noted an
increase in beef exports. Cotton exports have been
trending up so far this quarter, thanks in part to the
strong quality of the 2016 cotton crop. Cotton prices
were relatively strong, and contacts expect a large increase in cotton acreage this year. Other crop prices
trended up over the reporting period. Wheat prices still
generally remained below breakeven prices, but corn
and sorghum prices rose to a profitable level for many
producers. ■

Construction and Real Estate
Home sales rose during the reporting period, with contacts noting a good start to 2017. Lot prices continued to
escalate in DFW, were steady to up in Austin, and flat to
down in Houston. Home prices remained elevated, although some discounting was noted in Houston, and
contacts there said it was becoming difficult to pass
through further increases. Outlooks were positive, but
contacts expressed some concern about downward
pressure on builders’ margins and the potential impact of
rising mortgage rates.
Apartment demand stayed solid, and occupancy rates
generally remained high. In Houston, despite better-than
-expected demand overall, occupancy dipped and rent
concessions continued to be offered. This was particularly the case for class A product due to a surplus of new
deliveries and completions. Rents rose further in most
major metros, but contacts expect rent growth to moderate this year. Austin and DFW office markets remained
strong, while continued weakness was noted in Houston.
Industrial availability was tight in most major metros.

For more information about District economic conditions visit:
www.dallasfed.org/research/texas

K-2

Federal Reserve Bank of

San Francisco
The Beige Book ■ February 2017

Summary of Economic Activity
Economic activity in the Twelfth District continued to expand at a moderate pace during the reporting period of midJanuary through February. Overall price inflation was mild, while upward wage pressures strengthened. Sales of retail
goods picked up, and activity in the consumer and business services sector slowed slightly to a moderate pace. Conditions in the manufacturing sector remained mixed, and activity in the agriculture sector was largely unchanged. Contacts
reported continued vigorous activity in residential real estate markets, while activity in the commercial sector expanded
at a moderate pace. Lending activity grew at a moderate pace.

Employment and Wages

Retail Trade and Services

Wage pressures intensified in general as labor market
conditions remained tight throughout much of the District. Seasonal job loss in the retail sector was less pronounced at the end of the holiday season than in previous years. Talent shortages in the technology industry
have increased the time required to fill positions and the
cost per hire. Contacts in the agriculture sector noted
that proposed changes in immigration policy could limit
labor supply, particularly during harvest season, and
drive up wage costs. In the financial services industry,
shortages of skilled bankers and credit analysts have
boosted wages for those occupations. One contact in the
hospitality industry reported a continued shortage of
workers across all job categories despite wage increases, signing bonuses, and increased recruiting efforts.
Shortages of construction workers and contractors persisted.

Retail sales picked up from the previous period. On
balance, contacts continued to report that e-commerce
sales were strong, and retailers continued to shift investment away from traditional brick-and-mortar establishments towards online channels. Retail supermarkets
experienced solid sales volumes, and major chains
continued to improve online retail and store pickup options. Demand for apparel products was moderate and
flat relative to the previous reporting period. Sales of
automobiles softened somewhat but remained comparable to last year’s average pace.
Activity in the consumer and business services sector
slowed slightly to a moderate pace. Robust demand for
cloud computing services and investments in data centers continued to support strong growth in the technology
service sector. While demand for health-care services
expanded at a strong pace, and providers continued to
innovate delivery systems, uncertainty surrounding federal health-care policy slowed capital investment. Tourism picked up to a strong level, but contacts voiced
concerns that changes in immigration policy would reduce international visits. Activity in the hospitality industry weakened slightly, but advance bookings for the
summer months at Southern California hotels were
above levels experienced in the prior year. Contacts in
the nonprofit sector noted that uncertainty around environmental and alternative energy policy remained a
major concern for growth prospects over the near term.

Prices
Overall price increases were mild during the reporting
period. Prices of building materials increased from an
already elevated level. While global prices remained low
for many agricultural commodities, contacts reported that
prices for some grains recently picked up. Pressure from
online sellers slowed price inflation somewhat in parts of
the retail sector. Contacts in the apparel industry noted
that implementing a border tax could have a significant
impact on the prices of imported apparel products.

L-1

Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco
Manufacturing

Financial Institutions

Conditions in the manufacturing sector remained mixed.
New orders and production of manufactured pharmaceuticals remained strong. Conditions in the semiconductor
industry stabilized, but exporters remain concerned
about the value of the dollar and potential trade conflicts.
Contacts reported that steel mill capacity utilization remained below its long-run average, as a strong dollar
and weak global demand slowed exports and boosted
imports. Orders of commercial aircraft dipped, and deliveries were flat compared with the same period last year.
Contacts in the metals fabrication industry noted that
heavy equipment sales were weak, reducing demand for
manufactured parts and accessories.

Lending activity continued to expand at a moderate pace
over the reporting period. Loan demand grew at moderate pace, similar to the prior period. One contact noted
that consolidation in the financial services industry had
reduced financing options for small businesses. On
balance, deposits ticked up. Credit quality remained
strong, and liquidity was ample. ■

Agriculture and Resource-Related Industries
Activity in the agriculture sector was little changed from
the previous reporting period. Demand for timber remained strong, and contacts reported that domestic
wood products manufacturers expanded production as
input costs were low and margins remained favorable. A
major buyer of barley notified producers in Idaho that
their purchases would decrease by 30 percent in 2017.
Weak global prices and increased production costs in
California further reduced rice plantings. Overall, the
elevated dollar continued to suppress agriculture exports. Wet winter conditions increased snowpack in the
Sierra Nevada, and contacts expected increased water
supplies to boost harvests later this year.

Real Estate and Construction
Real estate market activity grew at a vigorous pace as in
the previous reporting period. On balance, activity in the
housing market remained strong, but conditions varied
by region. Shortages of land, labor, and materials in
many major cities in the West somewhat tempered the
rapid pace of construction activity, while a few rural
regions noted that tight financial conditions remained a
barrier to new construction. House prices edged up
further in much of the District, with contacts in Los Angeles reporting that many communities expect significant
gentrification in the coming years. Rents continued to
climb in parts of the District, making homeownership
relatively more attractive. Commercial construction activity expanded at a moderate pace, except in downtown
Sacramento, where construction activity continued to be
robust.

L-2