View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY REVIEW
of Credit and Business Conditions
S e c o n d

M a r k e t in

R e s e r v e

Federal Reserve Bank, New York

Federal Reserve Agent

M on ey

F e d e r a l

M a y

A most interesting feature of the money market dur­
ing the month of May was a decline in the call loan rate
from a very firm position in the first half of the month
to a comparatively easy position in the second half
of the month, without any accompanying basic change
in the credit position which appeared fully to justify
the change. A fter the third week of the month the
renewal rate was 6 per cent for 6 successive days, the
lowest renewal rate which has been touched since early
in February, and money was reported as available out­
side of the Exchange at rates even lower than 6 per
cent. This relatively low call rate was reached despite
the fact that there was no considerable gain of funds
to the banks of the country from gold imports or any
other quarter, and the total borrowings of member
banks at the Reserve Banks remained in excess of
$900,000,000. Moreover, other money rates remained
firm with the exception of a slight easing in time money
in the last day or two of the month. The average rate
charged by leading New York City banks for com­
mercial loans to customers continued to move gradually
upward towards the legal maximum of 6 per cent, while
rates on commercial paper in the open market and on
bankers acceptances showed no material change. The
general level of money rates is shown in the following
table.

D is tr ic t

June 1 , 1929

Similarly, the borrowings of New York City banks
may be taken as an index, though not a direct increase,
of the supply of funds available to the call loan market.
The New York banks are relatively less important as
lenders in the call loan market than in the past. A t
present the loans to brokers and dealers by New York
City banks total less than $775,000,000, or less than onesixth of the total loans to brokers and dealers, whereas
as recently as two years ago New York City bank loans
have been as high as one-third of the total. Neverthe­
less, New York City banks continue to be so closely con­
cerned with the movement of funds into and out of the
call loan market that the amount of the borrowings of
these banks at the Reserve Bank constitutes a very fair
index of the supply of funds to the call market.
The explanation is to be found not so much in the
amounts of funds that the New York City banks h^ye
available to invest for their own account in the
market, but in the fact that transfers of funds to and
from this Federal Reserve District for the purpose ~f
employment in or withdrawal from the call loan market
affect directly the reserves of the New York City banks.
I f a bank or business house in Chicago sends $1,000,000
to New York for employment in the call market, one of
the consequences is a transfer of reserves from the ac­
count of a Chicago bank at the Federal Reserve Bank
M ILLIO NS
OF DOLLARS

M oney Rates at New York
M ay 31, 1928 Apr. 30, 1929 M ay 29, 1929
Stock Exchange call loans..........................
Stock Exchange 90 day loans...................
Prime commercial paper.............................
Bills— 90 day unindorsed ..........................
Customers’ rates on commercial loans..
Treasury certificates
Maturing December 1 5 ..........................
Federal Reserve Bank of New York
rediscount rate...........................................
Federal Reserve Bank of New York
buying rate for 90 day bills.................

* 5 K -6 K
5H
4 M -H
4 -4 %
f 4 .53
3'.89

4

* 8 -1 6

t 5 .7 3

*6
8H
6
5K
t 5 .7 8

4 .9 4
4 .9 2

5 .1 0
5 .0 7

8J4
6

5H

5

5

5X

5H

* Range for preceding week
t Average rate of leading banks at middle of month

The accompanying diagram shows the two factors
which ordinarily are the principal influences upon call
money rates. They are representative of the two aspects
of the call money market, demand and supply. The
amount of brokers loans outstanding at any time may be
taken as representative of the demand. W hen brokers
loans are rising the demand for such loans is increasing
and additional funds are being called fo r ; and con­
versely, when the volume of loans is decreasing funds
are being released and the demand is decreasing.




Movement o f Call Loan Rates Compared with Fluctuations in
Borrowings o f New York City Banks from Federal Reserve
Bank and in Total Brokers Loans Placed by
Reporting New Y ork City Member Banks.

MONTHLY REVIEW, JUNE 1, 1929

42

of Chicago to the account of a New York bank at the
Federal Reserve Bank of New York, and thus $1,000,000
becomes available for some New York bank to reduce its
indebtedness at the Reserve Bank. Thus the amount
of borrowing of the New York City banks reflects di­
rectly and immediately transfers of funds to and from
the New York district. There is also a more direct con­
nection between the New York City banks and the call
market in that in all periods of acute stringency due to
withdrawals of funds by other lenders, the New York
banks find themselves called upon by their broker cus­
tomers to supply funds.
It is for these reasons that the position of the New
York City banks may be taken as an index of the supply
of funds to the call market. The accompanying chart
shows that the movement of call money rates is closely
related to changes in the position of the New York City
banks and to changes in the demand for loans as indi­
cated by the movement of the total volume of loans. In
the second half of May low rates in the call market may
be ascribed to a lessened demand for brokers loans due
to a decline of $275,000,000 in the volume, and to a
large flow of funds from other districts to New York
City, which is reflected in a decline of the borrowings
at the New York City banks from around $200,000,000
to between $100,000,000 and $150,000,000.
It is difficult to explain fully this flow of funds
from other districts. It does not reflect any general
easing of the situation, for it was accompanied by in­
creases in the borrowings of banks in other districts at
the Reserve Banks.
M e m b e r B a n k C r e d it

The security loans of reporting member banks have
been reduced further during the past month, and the
total loans and investments of these banks have declined
slightly below the volume of a year previous for the first
time in several years. A s the accompanying diagram
indicates, however, it is desirable in making comparisons
with a year previous to note that May 1928 marked the
culmination of a period of unusually rapid expansion of
credit which carried the total loans and investments of
reporting banks to a level more than 9 per cent above a
year previous. The following table shows the changes
in the loans and investments of the reporting banks
compared with a year ago, and with two years ago.
(In millions of dollars)

Loans:
On securities....................................
All other............................................
Investments:
U .S . G ov’t securities...................
Other securities...............................
T o ta l...............................................

M ay 29,
1928

M ay 29,
1929

M ay 25,
1927

M ay 29,
1928

6,003
8,636

7,097
8,857

7,102
9,100

+ 1 ,0 9 9
+
464

+
+

5
243

2,640
3,020

2,994
3,212

2,897
2,902

+
—

257
118

—
—

97
310

20,298

22,160

22,001

+ 1,703

—

159

The table shows that the growth in the principal types
of member bank credit over the two-year period has been
very uneven; security loans, notwithstanding the de­
cline in the past two months, remain over 18 per cent
larger than in May 1927; other loans, largely commer­
cial, have increased only about 5 per cent; U. S. security




191^ 1
J

I
F

I
M

1
A

M

I

1

J

1

J

A

I
S

1

I

O

___I

N

D

Total Loans and Investm ents o f A ll Reporting Member Banks.

holdings have increased about 10 per cent, due to
large purchases in 1 927; and other security holdings
have shown a small net reduction, due to substantial
sales during the past year.
B rokers L oans

for

“ Others”

During the recent period of contraction in member
bank loans, the volume of funds loaned to brokers and
dealers in securities by other lenders has increased to
new high levels. The changes in brokers loans during
the past two years are reviewed in the following table.
(In millions of dollars)
Change from
M ay 25,
1927
Total Brokers Loans as reported
by N . Y . City banks:
For own account............................
For out-of-town correspondents
For others.........................................
Borrowings of Stock Exchange
members from private bankers
and others*......................................

932
1,173
860

M a y 29,
1928

1,219
1,608
1,642

M ay 29,
1929

773
1,540
2,975

M ay 25,
1927

M a y 29,
1928

—
159
+
367
+ 2,115

—
446
—
68
+ 1,333

476

662

1,194

+

3,441

5,131

6,482

+ .3 ,0 4 1

718

+

532

+ 1,351

♦April 30 of each year
Chang e from

M ay 25,
1927

B IL L IO N S O F D O L L A R S

2 3 i---------------------------

From these figures it is evident that brokers’ borrow­
ings have practically doubled during the period in which
member bank loans and investments have increased less
than 9 per cent. Further, it is apparent that most of the
brokers loans have come from sources other than member
banks; in fact, the actual increase in loans from the
funds of New York banks and their correspondent banks
is probably smaller than that shown above, as the indi­
cated loans placed for out-of-town banks probably include
a considerable proportion of loans for customers of those
banks.
C o m m e r c ia l P a p e r M a r k e t

The volume of open market commercial paper out­
standing through 23 firms declined 9 per cent further
during April, and, at $351,000,000 on the 30th, was
38^2 Per cent smaller than the amount outstanding a

43

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW YORK

year ago. During May, there was little indication of
an increase in the amount of new paper coming into
the market. High borrowing costs to the user of the
open market and the difficulty experienced by the
dealers in disposing of paper to investors have resulted
in a continued curtailment of this form of business
financing. Dealers’ quoted offering rates for the usual
grade of prime paper generally remained at 6 per cent
but there were some sales of the paper of smaller con­
cerns reported at 6*4 per cent, on bids from the banks.
B il l M a r k e t

The amount of dollar acceptances outstanding in this
market declined $94,000,000 further during April, but
remained $40,000,000 larger than on A pril 30, 1928.
The reduction during the first four months of this year
totaled $173,000,000, or 13Y2 per cent, whereas there
were much smaller decreases in three of the previous
four years, and a moderate increase in the fourth.
Early in May, there was an advance of about Ys per
cent in open market bill rates, which brought the rates
back to levels approximately the same as those prevail­
ing before the temporary reduction of the latter part
of April. For the balance of the month, unendorsed
bills up to 4 months maturity were offered at 5 Y2 Per
cent, and 5 and 6 months bills at 5 % -5 % per cent. A t
these levels, investment demand was about equal to the
supply of bills.

average of stocks had declined toward the end of the
month by about 7 per cent. The net declines for the
period were most pronounced in the industrial issues,
which generally receded somewhat below the previous
low levels of the year reached on the February reaction.
Public utility stocks continued to advance during the
first half of the month, but in the latter half showed a
decline from their highest level about one-half as large
as that in industrial shares; the railroad stocks strength­
ened temporarily, following the decision of the Supreme
Court in the O ’Fallon case, and subsequently showed
only a small net decline. The turnover of stocks on the
Exchange was somewhat heavier than in April, but did
not approach that of the extremely active markets of
March.
Bond prices again turned downward in May following
a temporary recovery in April. Domestic corporate bond
averages generally receded over IYl points, more than
canceling the A pril recovery, and consequently reached
new low levels since early in 1926. A n average of 40
foreign bond issues likewise lost more than the % point
rise during April, and an average of the prices of the
eight United States Government bond issues now out­
standing declined about 2 1/4 points from the highest
prices reached on the A p ril recovery to a level approxi­
mately as low as that of mid-March, but subsequently
recovered about Y2 point.
G o ld

N e w F in a n c in g
New security issues by domestic corporations were
somewhat smaller in April than in the preceding month,
but were about $125,000,000 larger than in A pril 1928.
A considerable part of this increase over last year was
accounted for by a larger amount of issues by invest­
ment trusts, and other financial and holding companies.
Stock issues by domestic companies were again much
heavier than a year ago, with the increase largely con­
centrated in common stock flotations.
Financing by
domestic municipalities and States continued in smaller
amount than a year ago.
Foreign financing was in very small volume in April,
and the total amount of funds raised in this country,
including flotations of domestic corporations for employ­
ment in foreign countries, has been about $200,000,000,
or 45 per cent, smaller in the first four months of this
year than in the corresponding period of 1928.
In May, the larger domestic corporate flotations con­
tinued to take the form chiefly of stock issues. Prelim­
inary figures indicate that the total was somewhat larger
than in April, but smaller than a year ago.
S e c u r ity M a r k e ts

Stock prices during the first few days of May con­
tinued the upward movement of the latter part of April,
with the result that price averages, representative of the
market as a whole, again reached slightly higher levels
than ever before. Thereafter, however, the broad trend
of the market turned irregularly downward; substantial
reactions on a number of days were followed by lesser
recoveries. From the level of early May the general




M ovem en t

The only gold movements worthy of note during May
were the receipt of $15,683,000 in two shipments from
Germany, and $4,000,000 in four lots from Argentina.
Other imports were negligible, as were exports of gold.
In addition there was a further gain of $16,000,000 to
this country’s gold stock through the release of gold
which had been held under earmark for foreign account.
According to a preliminary calculation, the gold move­
ment during May was as follows: Imports, $20,196,000;
exports, $201,000; net decrease in gold earmarked for
foreign account, $16,127,000; net gain to country, $36,122,000. The net gain in the first five months of the
present year was $147,814,000, as against a net loss in
January-May 1928 of $229,105,000.
C e n tra l B a n k

R a te

C hanges

The National Bank of Rumania raised its rediscount
rate twice during May, first from 6 to 8 per cent on the
3d and again to 9 Y2 Per cent on the 14th. The 6 per
cent rate had been in force since September 1920.
These increases follow upon the stabilization of the leu
in February of the present year. Until these increases
were made, the official rate was out of line with private
rates ruling at Bucharest. On A pril 27 the ratio of
total reserves (gold and foreign exchange) to notes and
demand liabilities at the central bank was 42.1 per cent,
the gold ratio alone being 32.6 per cent. The statutory
minima are 35 per cent total cover and 25 per cent gold
cover. Gold held on A pril 27 was equivalent to $51,700,000; exchange was $15,100,000, and total cover was
$66,800,000. Liabilities covered by these reserves totaled
$158,600,000.
On M ay 9 the Imperial Bank of India reduced its

44

MONTHLY REVIEW, JUNE 1, 1929

rediscount rate from 7 to 6 per cent, after a reduction
from 8 to 7 per cent in April. The successful weathering
of the winter monsoon, and the end of the credit demand
stimulated by the export season, made possible these rate
reductions. Last year the seasonal lowering to 6 per
cent was not effected until June 21.

M IL L IO N S O F D O L L A R 'S

F o r e ig n E x c h a n g e

The exchanges watched with most interest during May
were the pound sterling and the reichsmark. A move­
ment of funds from London to New York was reported
in the early part of the month, stimulated by the recur­
rence of high call money rates in this market. Sterling
weakened after May 10, and dropped from the level of
$4 .8 5 % , around which it had hovered during the previ­
ous month, to a new low of $4.84 1 3 /1 6 on the 23d. It
was last reported at $4.84 3 1 /3 2 , which is about the
gold import point from London to New York.
The reichsmark was quiet and weak in the vicinity of
$.2371 until the 15th, when it rose to $.2376. Follow­
ing this, it moved to $ .2378% on the 20th, $.2380 on the
23d, and then to a new high of $.2385 in the course
of trading on the 28th.
A simultaneous firming in
London to 20.35 reichsmarks to the pound sterling from
a low of 20.47 reichsmarks (20.43 being parity with the
pound), gave rise to a report that Germany might be
in a position to take gold in London.
In contrast with the general firmness which they dis­
played in April, most of the other European exchanges
were weak during May.
The Dutch guilder opened
the month at $.4021, and declined to a low of $.4017
on the 23d, but closed the month well above its A pril
average of $ .4 014% . Other European exchanges which
fell off slightly during May were the Danish and Nor­
wegian crowns, the Italian lira, and the Swiss franc.
The Spanish peseta continued its decline, dropping in
the course of the month from $.1431 on the 1st to $.1416
on the 28th.
Canadian exchange showed no tendency to recover
and fluctuated only slightly around a discount of %
per cent. The Argentine peso and the Brazilian milreis
moved in a relatively wide range during the month, the
former closing below the A pril average of $ .9 560% and
the latter with a loss of four points at $.1188. The Far
Eastern exchanges continued weak: Japan slid off 43
points to $.4452 and the rupee was down from $.3628
to $.3617.
F o r e ig n T r a d e

Exports of merchandise, valued at $427,000,000 in
April, showed more than the usual seasonal decline from
the high figure of March, but continued to compare
favorably with the corresponding month of previous
years. Imports, valued at $409,000,000, showed a con­
siderable increase over the previous month, contrary to
the usual tendency, and were also larger than in April
of any year since 1920.
Shipments abroad of raw cotton and grains were sea­
sonally less than in March, and together were valued at
less than the shipments made last year. The value of
the exports of refined petroleum products also declined
from the previous month, but showed an increase over




Growth in Exports o f Finished Manufactures Compared with
A ll Other Exports.

a year ago. Quantity receipts of raw silk and crude
rubber were 30 and 45 per cent, respectively, larger than
in A pril 1928.
Since 1922, there has been a gradual change in the
composition of our exports, as the accompanying dia­
gram shows. A steady gain in the value of exports of
‘ 1 finished manufactures ’ ’ has occurred, while, except for
wide seasonal fluctuations, the value of exports of all
other products has remained practically constant. The
group of finished manufactures consists chiefly of auto­
mobiles, gasoline, and machinery. Exports of these prod­
ucts in the early months of 1929 have considerably ex­
ceeded those of the corresponding period in any recent
year. Important elements in other exports are cotton,
tobacco, raw and manufactured food products, lumber,
and metals, the total of which is strongly dominated in
its seasonal movements by shipments of farm products.
B u ild in g

A sharp rise in building contracts during A p ril car­
ried the total awarded in the 37 States from which re­
ports are received by the F . W . Dodge Corporation to a
level practically as high as a year ago, following sub­
stantial declines during the preceding months of 1929.
There were large increases over March in contracts for
residential buildings and for public works and utilities,
but the only type of construction to show an increase
over April 1928 was public works and utilities. The
increase in this group was 30 per cent.
The recovery in A p ril does not appear to have con­
tinued in M a y; there was a drop of about 22 per cent
from a year ago in the daily average amount of contracts
awarded during the first 24 days of the month.
A s a result of the large contract volume of April, the
decline from a year ago for the period from January 1
to April 30 was reduced to 11 per cent. The accompany­
ing diagram of building contracts awarded during the
first four months of each of the past five years indicates
that the total this year was the smallest since 1925, due
principally to the 27 per cent decline in residential con-

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW YORK
2*060
269

ALL OTHER

CO M M ERCIAL A N D
IN D U STR IA L

273

593

2,127

addition, losses charged off on loans and discounts and
on securities increased in 1928; consequently, the ratio
of net profits to gross earnings was smaller than in 1927.

2,003
316

Business Profits

|504|

388 r
300

PU BLIC W O R K S
AND U T IL IT IE S

256

898

849

1926

1927

RESID ENTIA L

1925

1928

1929

Building Contracts Awarded During the First Four Months o f
Each Year, Classified by Type o f Construction
(In millions of dollars).

tracts from the high level of last year. Public works
and utilities contracts were 3 per cent smaller than in
the corresponding period of 1928, but were larger than
in any previous year. Commercial and industrial build­
ing contracts combined were 16 per cent above the first
four months of 1928, and were the largest since 1926.
B ank

E a r n i n g s a n d E x p e n s e s in

1928

This bank's annual study of operating ratios of repre­
sentative member banks in this district, which has just
been completed for the year 1928, shows some interesting
changes compared with other recent years*. Gross earn­
ings of these banks expressed as percentages of total
available funds were the highest in recent years, but the
ratio of net earnings was approximately the same as in
the previous six years.
The increase in gross earnings was due partly to a
slightly higher average ratio of loans and investments to
total available funds, and partly to a somewhat higher
rate of return on loans and investments, especially in
the large New York City banks, which adjust their
lending rates to money market conditions more rapidly
than do country banks. The average rate charged by a
number of representative New York City banks on loans
to customers advanced from 4.38 per cent in December
1927 to 5.50 per cent in December 1928, whereas rates
charged on customers loans by banks outside of New
York, especially in the smaller localities, have shown
but little increase. The proportion of gross earnings
derived from the sale of securities was reduced in
1928, accompanying a declining bond market, but mis­
cellaneous income increased somewhat.
A rise in expense ratios offset the increase in gross
earnings, however, so that the ratio of net earnings to
total available funds was no larger in 1928 than in 1927
or in several preceding years. The principal increases in
the ratios of expenses to gross earnings were in interest
paid on deposits, due to a continued increase in the pro­
portion of time deposits, and in interest paid on bor­
rowed money, due to the increased indebtedness of mem­
ber banks at the Reserve Bank during the past year. In
* Circular No. 914 containing these ratios for the selected
banks, grouped according to size and according to the proportion
of time deposits, will be mailed on request.




45

Reflecting the high level of business activity during
the first quarter of this year, net earnings of 235 indus­
trial and mercantile companies were 33 per cent larger
than in the corresponding period of 1928, and were 42
per cent larger than in the first quarter of 1927, accord­
ing to a compilation made by this bank. The concerns
making quarterly statements, which are included in this
tabulation, comprise only a small proportion of all cor­
porations in this country, and while it is probable that
the returns for all companies, if available, would present
a less favorable condition than do the reports for the
limited number of corporations, it is still evident that
the first quarter of 1929 was a period of unusually large
corporate profits.
The copper and steel companies showed the largest
increases in net profits over a year ago; the former re­
ported net earnings two and one-half times as large, and
the latter more than double the profits of the first quarter
of 1928. These large increases were followed closely by
the reported earnings of the oil concerns, and of the
motor parts and accessories companies, but in the case
of the oil companies the increase represented chiefly a
recovery from the small earnings of a year ago. A num­
ber of other groups showed net profits from 10 to 50 per
cent higher than a year ago. The only types of com­
panies making less favorable showings in the first
quarter of 1929 than a year ago were the building sup­
plies companies, and the leather and shoe concerns, the
latter probably reflecting the effects of the decline in
hide prices.
The increase in earnings of telephone and other public
utility companies was about twice as large as occurred
in the first quarter of 1928. Net operating income of
Class I railroads was 19 per cent larger than a year ago,
and 15 per cent above that of the first quarter of 1927.
(N et profits in thousands of dollars)
First quarter
Number
1927

1928

1929

16
16

75,121
6,580

94,736
6,775

98,948
12,816

24
15
31
17

Miscellaneous.......................................

.6
12
11
11
5
6
4
5
6
43

21,727
44,911
32,338
9,630
6,770
3,186
6,835
12,996
4,592
5,502
9,032
1,994
703
1,042
44,707

12,081
36,276
33,662
9,656
8,684
1,383
7,032
14,729
3,936
5,371
11,393
1,701
1,471
678
57,159

23,524
73,835
38,075
12,586
21,724
2,329
11,892
19,269
3,381
6,004
14,315
1,965
D ef. 1,375
1,053
68,839

Corporation groups

(excl. tires)
Oil..............................................................
Food and food products...................
Machine and machine m fg..............
Coal and c o k e ......................................
Other mining and smelting.............
Building supplies.................................
Railroad equipment............................
Leather and shoe.................................

Total 17 groups...............................

235

287,666

306,723

409,180

Telephone (net operating incom e).
Other Public Utilities........................

88
95

58,700
206,100

62,700
226,100

69,600
263,000

Total Public U tilities....................

183

264,800

288,800

332,600

Class I Railroads.................................
(Net operating income)

183

225,500

217,400

259,500

46

MONTHLY REVIEW, JUNE 1, 1929

C o m m o d i t y P ric e s
In recent weeks there have been rather severe declines
in the prices of several commodities. The most pro­
nounced weakness has been in wheat prices which, ap­
parently due to a large carry-over and good prospects
for the new crop, have declined to around 95 cents a
bushel, as compared with $1.25 near the end of February.
Cotton has declined sharply since March from above 21
cents to below 19 cents, and there have been substantial
declines also in wool and other farm products. Livestock
prices, however, have remained moderately high.
Among the non-agricultural commodities, price move­
ments have been mixed. There have been reactions in
the non-ferrous metals which in March had reached the
highest levels since 1920. The largest decline has been
in copper, which, after advancing from around 14 cents
a year ago to 24 cents last March, has subsequently
declined slightly below 18 cents; zinc and lead prices
also have lost part of their recent advance. The most
consistent strength has been in prices of pig iron and
finished steel. Crude petroleum, following a decline in
January, was advanced sharply in the latter part of
May to the highest level since early in 1927.
This bank’s index of basic commodity prices, which is
strongly influenced by the movement of the few com­
modities which have recently fluctuated most widely,
declined steadily during the nine successive weeks
ended May 18. A s the accompanying diagram shows,
however, a more inclusive index such as that of the
United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, which com­
prises a large number of finished products as well as
basic commodities, declined only slightly in A pril and
in general has been relatively stable since last autumn.
PER C E N T

seasonal increase, but production of passenger cars
showed less than the usual increase. The average daily
rate of pig iron production reached a level that has
been exceeded only in May and June 1923. Produc­
tion of steel ingots declined less than usual from the
record level of March, and our index, which is adjusted
for seasonal variations and for year-to-year growth,
reached the highest level since 1918. In spite of this
large output, however, new orders kept pace with ship­
ments, and consequently production has been maintained
close to peak levels in May. Production of copper in­
creased further to a volume about one-third larger than
a year ago, and our index advanced to the highest level
since 1918. Increases occurred also in our indexes of
mill consumption of cotton and of silk, and in produc­
tion of lumber, cement, and a majority of other prod­
ucts. Output of coal, after seasonal allowance, recov­
ered the major part of the large loss sustained in the
preceding month, but production of petroleum was
curtailed further.
(Computed trend of past yea rs* 100 per cent; adjusted for seasonal variations)
1928
Apr.

1929
Feb.

M ar.

Apr.

Producers' Goods
Pig iron.................................................................
Steel ingots..........................................................
Cotton consumption........................................
Woolen mill activity*......... . .........................
Silk consumption*............................................
Bituminous coal.................................................
Copper, U. S. m ines........................................
Lead........................................................................
Zinc.........................................................................
Tin deliveries......................................................
Leather, sole........................................................
Cem ent..................................................................
Paper, total..........................................................
W ood pu lp...........................................................

107
114
89
83
98
107
83
103
98
99
92
101
105
113
113
106
95

116
122
107
95
109
119
99
110
81r
130
91
111
100
102
106
108
108r

120
121r
102
95
113
112
79
114
84
127r
99r
94
114
94
100
105
102

122
129
106
99p
130
109p
90
118
93 p
132
109
99
123
101
110

96
91
102
80
87
107
77
95
111
88
101
88
109
103r
87

96
85
103
77
103
103
90
102
107
86
107
97 r
130
138r
155

89
89
104
79
98
98
91
100
73
86
104
96
120
146r
136

102
96
124
79
113
109
91

Consumers' Goods
Hogs slaughtered..............................................
Cattle slaughtered............................................
Sheep slaughtered.............................................
Calves slaughtered............................................
Farm produce shipped...................................
W heat flour..........................................................
Sugar meltings, U. S. ports..........................
Anthracite coal...................................................
Paper, newsprint...............................................
Tobacco products..............................................
Boots and shoes.................................................
Automobile, passenger r .................................
Automobile, truck............................................
* Seasonal variation not allowed for

p Preliminary

100
87
120
9 6p
133p
137r
147

r Revised

I n d e x e s o f B u s in e s s A c t i v i t y

The United States Bureau o f Labor Statistics Index of W holesale
Prices said Federal Reserve Bank of New Y ork Basic
Commodity Price Index

P r o d u c tio n
Productive activity in leading industries increased
to new high levels in April. Automobile output for
the third successive month was larger than ever be­
fo re; in the case of motor trucks the increase over
the March figure was considerably larger than the usual




Business activity, in spite of some irregularity, con­
tinued at a high level in April. Merchandise and mis­
cellaneous car loadings increased more than usual, and
this bank’s index reached the highest level since June
1927; other car loadings also increased, whereas usually
there is an 11 per cent decline from March. Exports
declined more than usual, but imports, instead of show­
ing the decline which generally occurs, increased, and
this bank’s index rose sharply. Department store sales
declined somewhat from the high level of March, partly
due to unfavorable weather conditions, and partly to the
early date of Easter this year, but remained above the
level of a year ago. In 140 centers outside of New York
City, bank debits declined more than usual from March
to April.

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW YORK
(Computed trend of past years=100 per cent; adjusted for seasonal variations)
1929

1928
Apr.

Feb.

Mar.

Apr.

104
95
87
98
89
93

103
104
105
117
91
100

103
87
110
110
90
101

106
102
lOOp
123p
91
104

99
102
98
96
99
97

101
103
99
102
104
98

107
96
102
106
107
99

101
94
94
119
102
97

112
162

112
187

113
194

109
170

125
210
313
87
106
99
102
108
119

128
216
338
84
106
100
101
91
109

121
195
304
85

Building contracts, 36 States.......................
New corporations formed in N . Y . State

116
164
306
87
104
96
102
133
110

General price level............................................
Composite index of wages.............................
Cost of living......................................................

175
221
169

179
225
170

180
227
171

179
226
171

Primary Distribution
Car loadings, merchandise and misc.........
Car loadings, other...........................................
E xports..................................................................
Panama Canal traffic......................................
Wholesale trade.................................................

Distribution to Consumer
Department store sales, 2nd D ist...............
Chain grocery sales..........................................
Other chain store sales...................................
Mail order sales. ............................................
Life insurance paid fo r ....................................
Advertising..........................................................

General Business Activity
Bank debits, outside of N . Y . C ity ...........
Bank debits, New York C ity ......... . ...........
Velocity of bank deposits, outside of
New York C it y .........................................
Velocity of bank deposits, New York City
Shares sold on N . Y . Stock Exchange. . .
Postal receipts....................................................
Electric power.....................................................
Employment in the United States............

101
112
121
112

47

and increases of varying amount in stocks of cotton
goods, silk goods, and drugs.
D e p a r t m e n t S to r e T r a d e
Following the substantial increase reported in March,
the average daily sales of leading department stores in
this district in A pril showed practically no change from
a year ago, although, due to one more selling day than
in April 1928, total sales for the month were about 4
per cent larger. The decline from the March volume
apparently was due partly to the fact that Easter busi­
ness was done in March this year, and partly to unfavor­
able weather conditions in April. The New York City
and Newark stores reported moderately large increases
in their total sales, but the majority of the remaining
localities showed decreases. Following increases from a
year ago in each month since August, the sales of the
apparel stores showed a slight decline in April.
The percentage of outstanding charge accounts col­
lected during the month was slightly lower than a year
previous for the first time since August.
Per cent of
accounts
outstanding
March 31
collected in
April

Percentage
change
April 1929
compared with
April 1928

p Preliminary
Locality

W h o le s a le T r a d e
Although there were seasonal declines in several lines
from March to April, wholesale trade in this district in
general continued in substantial volume and was con­
siderably larger than in A pril 1928. One more selling
day in April this year than last was a factor in the in­
crease, but after adjustment to a comparable basis there
were substantial increases over a year ago in sales of
m en’s clothing, cotton goods, shoes, hardware, paper and
general stationery, and diamonds.
Mill sales of silk
goods showed an unusually large increase, and sales of
machine tool manufacturers continued much larger than
a year ago.
Stocks of merchandise held by dealers at the end of
April showed no consistent change compared with a year
ago; considerable decreases were reported in stocks of
groceries, shoes, hardware, and jewelry and diamonds,

Percentage
change
April 1929
compared with
March 1929

Percentage
change
April 1929
compared with
April 1928

Per cent of
accounts
outstanding
March 31
collected
in April

Net
sales
+
—
+
+
+
—
—
—
—
—
+
—
—

5 .8
1 .5
1 .1
0 .1
5 .6
1 .3
5 .3
1 4.1
1 1 .7
3 .7
3 .9
4 .6
13 .5

All department stores.....................................

+

4 .3

Apparel stores....................................................

— 0 .9

New Y o rk .................................................................
Syracuse....................................................................
Newark......................................................................
Bridgeport................................................................
Elsewhere..................................................................
Northern New York S ta te............................
Central New York S ta te ...............................
Southern New York S ta te............................
Hudson River Valley D ist.............................
Capital District.................................................
Westchester D istrict........................................

Groceries............................
M en’s clothing................
Cotton goods...................
Silk goods*........................
Shoes...................................
D rugs..................................
Hardware..........................
Machine tools**..............
Stationery..........................
Paper...................................
D iam onds..........................
Jewelry...............................
Weighted A v erage.. .

Stock
end of
month

+ 4 .5
+
— 3 6 .9
— 3 .8
+
— 1 6 .0 * —
— 2 9 .1
+
+ 0 .8
+
+ 1 7 .3
+
— 4 .4
— 5 .3
+ 0 .2
+ 9 .8
— 1 1 .6 } +
— 9 .4

5 .8

oli
3 .2 *
3 .5
3 .3
1 .0

9 .6

N et
sales

Stock
end of
month

1928

+ 3 .9
— 1 0 .7
7 3 .9
+ 1 4 .8
3 3 .8
+ 1 0 .4
+ Y .6
+ 3 1 . 2 * + 6 .7 * ' ’ 45*.i
— 1 4.1
4 4 .7
+ 1 1 .3
5 3 .4
— 1 .8
+ 2 6 .9
+ 7 .2
— 9 .2
4 5 .4
+ 4 4 .0
+ 9 .0
6 7 .0
6 5 .4
+ 1 2 .6
+ 2 8 .9
} — 1 0 .6 } 2 6 .9
— 4 .2
+ 1 2 .4

5 1 .8

♦Quantity not value. Reported by Silk Association of America
♦♦Reported by the National Machine Tool Builders’ Association




1929
7 7 .2
3 6 .7
“ 4 6 ’. 3
4 5 .2
4 9 .3
4 7 .6
‘ *741i
6 8 .4
}

2 7 .3
5 3 .8

1928

1929

+
—
+
+
+
+
—

1.1
2 .2
3 .6
7 .5
6 .1
5 .0
5 .6

5 2 .8
5 1 .3
4 1 .6
3 4 .2
4 5 .7

5 0 .7
5 2 .1
4 3 .1
3 7 .3
4 6 .2

“ 3 2 .2

“ 35! 7

+

1 .4

4 8 .8

4 8 .1

— 5 .4

4 8 .3

5 5 .2

Musical instruments, furniture, and home furnishings
were prominent among the departments which showed
the principal increases in April. Comparisons of sales
and stocks in major departments with those of a year
ago are given in the following table.
Net sales
percentage change
April 1929
compared with
April 1928

Commodity
N et
sales

Stock
on hand
end of
month

Musical instruments and radio............
Cotton goods................................................
Home furnishings.......................................
Linens and handkerchiefs.......................
Toilet articles and drugs.........................
W om en’s and Misses’ ready-to-wear..
Silverware and jew elry.............................
Toys and sporting goods.........................
Books and stationery................................
W om en’s ready-to-wear accessories.. .
M en’s furnishings.......................................
Silks and velvets.........................................
Luggage and other leather goods.........
M en’s and Boys’ wear..............................
Woolen goods...............................................
Miscellaneous...............................................

+ 3 1 9 .4
+ 23 .1
+ 1 6 .9
+ 1 4 .9
+ 1 1 .4
+
8 .2
+
4 .1
+
3 .8
+
1 .9
+
1 .8
+
1 .2
+
0 .3
—
2 .1
—
5 .0
—
5 .2
—
5 .5
— 1 8 .0
— 1 8 .2
—
2 .5

Stock on
percentage
April 30,
compared
April 30*
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
—
—

+
+
—

hand
change
1929
with
1928

8 .3
2 .0
3 .8
5 .9
6 .2
4 .4
5 .5
8 .6
6 .9
4 .4
1 .6
8 .3
7 .0
1 .9
8 .8
3 .6
1 .7
1 4 .3
4 .4

48

M ONTHLY REVIEW, JUNE 1, 1929

Business C on ditions in the U n ited States
(Summarized by the Federal Reserve Board)
N D U STRIAL activity continued at a high level in April, and the volume
o f factory employment and payrolls increased further. Loans and invest­
ments o f member banks in leading cities continued to decline between the
middle o f April and the middle o f May, and were at that time at approxi­
mately the same level as a year ago.

I

P r o d u c t io n

Industrial activity increased in April to the highest level on record. The
iron and steel and automobile industries continued exceptionally active during
April. Activity in copper refining, lumber, cement, silk and wool textiles,
and the meat-packing industry increased, and production o f cotton textiles
showed a less than seasonal reduction. Factory employment and payrolls
increased, contrary to the seasonal trend.
Output o f mines was also larger in April. Copper and anthracite coal pro­
duction increased and the seasonal decline in output o f bituminous coal was
smaller than usual. Petroleum production declined slightly.
Preliminary reports for the first half o f May indicate a continued high
rate o f operation in the iron and steel industry. Output o f lumber and
bituminous coal was somewhat larger during the first part o f May than at
the end o f April.
Building contracts awarded during the month o f April increased sharply
and for the first time in five months approximated the total for the corre­
sponding month in the preceding year. The increase was not continued, how­
ever, in the first part o f May wThen awards averaged 20 per cent below the
same period in May 1928. During April most classes o f building showed
seasonal increases over March, the largest being in contracts for residential
building and public works and utilities.

Index Number o f Production o f Manufactures
and Minerals Combined, Adjusted for Sea­
sonal Variations (1923-25 average =
100 per cen t).

D is t r ib u t io n

o f Labor Statistics (1926 average =
100 per ce n t).
MILLIONS

2000

or DOLLARS

MILLIONS OF DOLLARS

2000

Total |

Shipments o f commodities by rail increased during April and were the
largest for this month in any recent year. The increase from March reflected
larger loadings o f miscellaneous freight, lumber, livestock, and ore. During
the first half o f May shipments o f freight continued to increase.
Sales at wholesale declined seasonally in April, except in the case of gro­
cery and hardware firms. In comparison with April 1928 all lines of trade
reporting to the Federal Reserve System showed increases. Department store
sales were also smaller in April than in March, but continued above the level
of a year ago.
P r ic e s

1925
1926
1927
1928
1929
Reserve Bank Credit: M onthly Averages o f
Daily Figures for 12 Federal Reserve Banks
(Latest figures are averages o f
first 22 days o f M ay)
PERCENT

PER CENT

7

7

Wholesale commodity prices averaged slightly lower in April than in
March, according to the index o f the United States Bureau o f Labor Sta­
tistics, reflecting primarily declines in prices of farm products and their
manufactures. Prices o f mineral and forest products and their manufactures,
on the average, showed little change. There were increases in the prices o f
iron and steel, and sharp declines in copper, lead, and tin. Seasonal declines
occurred in prices o f coal and coke, while gasoline prices advanced.
Prices o f farm products and their manufactures averaged lower in April
than in March. Prices o f grain, especially wheat, moved downward more
sharply and wool and cotton continued to decline. Livestock and meat prices
continued the upward movement o f the previous month, but at a slower rate;
hides averaged slightly higher in price, and leather somewhat lower. Among
imported raw materials, rubber, sugar, and coffee showed marked price reces­
sions. Early in May cattle, hides, and wheat prices declined sharply and the
price o f rubber increased.
B a n k Cr e d it

r
r

‘

\l—

/F ~ 1
/

I

n
Commer

y r
^1?
:

.

—. fteserva,
— Acceph
-----I.
19Z5

T926

/<?
'ffcfe

1927

1928

1929

Money Rates in the New York Market.
(M ay rates are averages for first 24 days)




■

During the four weeks ended May 15 loans and investments o f member
banks in leading cities showed a decrease o f nearly $200,000,000, largely in
loans on securities together with some further decline in investments. All
other loans, chiefly for commercial and agricultural purposes, remained un­
changed at a relatively high level.
There was a further reduction in the average volume o f Reserve Bank
credit outstanding between the weeks ended April 24 and May 22, owing largely
to additions to the country’s monetary stock o f gold. The decline was in dis­
counts for member banks; holdings o f acceptances and o f United States
securities showed practically no change.
Open-market rates for commercial paper remained unchanged as did rates
on prime bankers acceptances, except for a temporary decline at the end of
April and a recovery in the first week in May. In the first three weeks of May
rates on collateral loans averaged considerably higher than in April.