View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY REVIEW
of Credit and Business Conditions
S e c o n d

F e d e r a l

Money Market in M ay
The gradual tightening o f the New Y ork money mar­
ket, which has been in progress since last autumn, has
during the past month become more apparent, and open
market money rates have advanced to the highest levels
fo r this time o f year since 1923.
The follow ing table reviews the changes that have
taken place in money rates during the past month and
since last November.
Money Rates at New York

*6
5H
4 Vr-%
4-4 y8
f4.53
3.89
4H
4

April 27,
1928

Nov. 29,
1927

+ 1
+ M
+ Ys
+

+1H
+ Y%
+ %

+2H

+.06
+.06

+ .25
+ .72

+ H
+ H

+ 1
+ X

* Prevailing rate for preceding week
t Average rate of leading banks at middle of month

The table shows that the advance in rates has been
in keeping with the nature o f credit expansion in recent
months, which has been largely concentrated in security
toans.
Since last November the charge on loans to
security brokers has advanced from 3 % per cent to 6 per




June 1, 1928

cent on demand loans, and from 4 per cent to 5 % per
cent on time loans. D uring the same period the rise
in open market rates on commercial paper and accept­
ances has been less than 1 per cent, and average rates
charged on direct loans to customers fo r commercial
purposes by even the large New Y ork City banks have
risen only fractionally. Interest rates on business loans
made by banks in smaller localities have probably
changed even less.
C auses

Change since
May 29,
1928

Call Loan Rates and Volume of

D is t r ic t

Federal Reserve Bank, New York

Federal Reserve Agent

Call money.............................................
Time money—90 day............................
Prime commercial paper.......................
Bills—90 day unindorsed......................
Customers’ rates on commercial loans.
Treasury issues maturing in 6-8 months
Federal Reserve Bank of New York
rediscount rate...................................
Federal Reserve Bank of New York
minimum buying rate for 90 day bills

R e s e r v e

Member Bank Borrowing

of

H

ig h e r

M o n e y R ates

The causes o f this advance in money rates are to be
foun d in the changes in credit conditions that have
forced member banks to depend more and more heavily
upon borrowings from the Reserve Banks to maintain
their reserves at the required level, and in the discount
rates member banks pay on borrowings. These changes
have been taking effect gradually fo r the past six months.
Gold exports and earmarkings in the latter part of
1927, and substantial sales o f securities by the Reserve
Banks in January took about 300 million dollars of
reserve funds from member banks, but this loss was
largely offset by the heavy return flow o f holiday cu r­
rency from circulation in January. Since that month,
however, there has been no such offsetting factor and
losses o f funds to the market have been reflected in
increases in member bank borrow ing at the Reserve
Banks.

from All Federal Reserve Banks in 1928, Compared with 1926 and 1927,

MONTHLY REVIEW, JUNE 1, 1928

42

The combined statement of all Federal Reserve Banks
fo r May 23 showed discounts fo r member banks amount­
ing to 847 million dollars, an increase of 462 million
since January 25. The principal factors in this increase
were a continued loss of gold through exports and ear­
markings, amounting to over 200 million dollars, and a
further reduction of more than 200 million in the Govern­
ment security holdings of the Reserve Banks.
Notwithstanding this loss of reserves, weekly report­
ing banks, which represent in resources about two-thirds
o f all jnember banks, expanded their loans and invest­
ments by about one billion dollars during this period.
In order to extend this additional credit, member banks
were forced to borrow from the Reserve Banks amounts
sufficient, not only to cover the reserve funds withdrawn
from them, but also to provide fo r the further increase
in their required reserves. A s their indebtedness in­
creased, the rates at which member banks were willing
to make loans were successively advanced; the rise in
call loan rates has roughly paralleled the rise in member
bank borrowings. This close relationship between money
rates and the extent to which member banks are depend­
ent on the Federal Reserve Banks is illustrated in the
diagram on the preceding page.
The continuance o f the increase in member bank loans
and in their indebtedness at the Reserve Banks during
the past month has been accompanied by further ad­
vances in Reserve Bank discount rates.
Follow ing
advances in seven other districts, the discount rate of
the Federal Reserve Bank of New Y ork was raised from
4 to 4V2 per cent on May 18. This is the first year since
1920 in which the discount rate of this bank has been
advanced twice within a period o f a few months, and
the 4 % per cent rate now in effect is the highest since
early 1924.
M em ber

B ank

C r e d it in

M ay

Loans and investments o f weekly reporting banks,
both in this district and elsewhere increased further at
the beginning of May. A s the follow ing table shows,
about 60 per cent of the billion dollar increase during
the three months from February 21 to May 16 was in
this district.
(In millions of dollars)
February 21 April 25
May 16

Second D i s t r i c t .........
Other D is t r ic ts ...........

8,159
13,416

8,606
13,732

8,752
13,839

Total ...................

21,575

22,338

22,591

The greater part of the increase has been in loans on
stocks and bonds, and these loans continued to rise until
the middle of May, reaching a level nearly 600 million
higher than in the latter part of February. Loans to
security brokers placed by New Y ork City banks fo r
their own account and for correspondent banks increased
less than 400 m illion since February, but loans to
brokers placed fo r interests other than banks (the iden­
tity o f which is not definitely known) showed an addi­
tional increase of over 400 m illion; so that, as the
accom panying diagram shows, the total increase in
brokers’ loans in a little over two months was nearly
800 million dollars. In addition there was a less rapid
but substantial increase in the estimated volume o f
security loans made directly by banks to their customers.




L o a n s t o B r o k e r s a n d D e a l e r s in S e c u r i t i e s P l a c e d b y N e w Y o r k
C i t y R e p o rt in g B a n k s , a n d E s t im a t e d L o a n s D ir e c t ly to
C u s to m e rs b y A l l R e p o rtin g M e m b e r B a n k s .

Other loans o f reporting banks, which are assumed to
be largely fo r commercial purposes, both in this district
and elsewhere, declined somewhat in May, but remained
substantially larger than in the early part o f this year
or than in M ay o f last year. Investments showed no
important change.
B il l M a r k e t

Investment demand fo r bills was active throughout
May, due largely to foreign account orders. A s a result,
dealers’ portfolios were reduced somewhat, notwith­
standing the appearance in the market o f a continued
large volume o f new bills. Follow ing an increase in the
Reserve B an k ’s buying rates on M ay 18 open market
rates were also advanced. The 30 day maturities showed
the largest increase, rising % per cent to 4 per cent.
Longer maturities were raised % to % per cent, and at
the end o f May, ninety day unindorsed bills were being
offered at a range o f 4-4y$ per cent, the highest since
March 1924. The volume o f bills outstanding at the end
o f A p ril was only slightly below the record amount re­
ported fo r March, and remained $260,000,000 larger
than in A p ril 1927.
C o m m e r c ia l P a p e r M a r k e t

The commercial paper market remained quiet during
May. Not only was the bank inquiry fo r investment
purposes rather light, but dealers had difficulty in secur­
ing additional amounts o f new paper from open market
borrowers. The scarcity o f prime names was a contin­
uation o f the condition in earlier months o f the y ea r;
the amount o f paper outstanding through 25 dealers has
varied little during the first fou r months o f the year,
and on A p ril 30 was about 4 % per cent smaller than a
year ago. Rates fo r prime paper continued to harden,
and by the end of M a y sales were fairly evenly divided
between 4 % and 4^4 per cent paper.

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW YORK
G o ld M o v e m e n t

43

W LU O N S ofJJO L L A R S

The net export o f gold was substantially smaller dur­
ing May than during March and A pril, but amounted
to $82,500,000, and as gold earmarked during the month
exceeded releases from earmark by $26,000,000, the net
reduction in the cou n try’s stock o f gold during May
amounted to $108,500,000, an amount considerably above
even the previous record figure of last November. E x ­
ports during the month totaled $83,000,000, while im­
ports amounted to only $500,000; new earmarkings
totaled $69,000,000, but $43,000,000 was released from
earmark and shipped.
The follow ing table shows the principal destinations
o f gold exports since September 1 :
(In thousands of dollars)
Sept. 1, 1927
to May 31,
1928*
Argentina............
Brazil...................
France..................
Germany..............
Italy. . . . ............
United Kingdom.
Uruguay..............

129,790
54,994
175,001
27,140
16,000
31,068

11,000

*May figures preliminary, covering Port of New York only.

The monthly changes in the cou n try’s stock o f gold
in consequence o f exports, imports, and earmarking
transactions since the first o f September are indicated
b elow :
Gain or Loss of Gold through Exports and Earmarkings
(In millions of dollars)

Month

Through
Net
Exports

Through
Earmarking

Total

1927
September...........................................
October................................................
November...........................................
December............................................

— 11
— 9
— 53
— 68

— 9
— 25
— 40
— 8

—
—
—
—

1928
January...............................................
February.............................................
March........................................ ..
April.....................................................
May.....................................................

—
—
—
—
—

14
11
95
91
83*

+ 6
+ 3
+ 36
+ 46
— 26*

— 8
— 8
— 59
— 45
— 109*

— 135*

— 17*

— 452*

Total, 9 months..............................

20
34
93
76

Q u a r t e r ly P r o f it s o f 1 0 5 I n d u s t r ia l C o r p o r a t io n s a n d N e t O p e r a t ­
in g In c o m e o f C l a s s I R a ilr o a d s .

in profits were reported also by mining and smelting,
food and food products, machine and machine m anufac­
turing, chemical, and amusement companies. The mis­
cellaneous group o f companies showed a large increase,
half o f which represented the increase o f D u Pont de
Nemours.
A heavy decline continued to be reported in the profits
o f the oil com panies; first quarter earnings were less
than one-third as large as in 1927, apparently reflecting
the continuation o f conditions which developed in the
industry during 1927. Profits o f steel companies showed
a reduction o f about 18 per cen t; a reduction was re­
ported by the United States Steel Corporation as well
as the independent concerns. Other groups to report a
lower net return this year were the tobacco, and building
supply companies.
Telephone and other public utility companies con­
tinued to expand their earnings, though the increase this
year was not as large as that reported a year ago. Net
operating income o f the principal railroads was the
smallest fo r the first quarter o f any year since 1925,
accom panying the reduction in freight traffic.

*Preliminary
(Net Profits in thousands of dollars)

Business Profits
First quarter earnings reports o f 210 industrial and
mercantile companies indicated net profits about 4 per
cent larger than fo r the corresponding periods of 1927
and 1926, a smaller increase than was indicated by
earlier calculations based on a smaller number o f com­
panies. If, however, the large increase in the earnings
of General Motors and the related increase in the earn­
ings of D u Pont de Nemours be excluded from the tabu­
lation, the net profits o f the remaining companies would
show a decline o f 6 % per cent from 1927, and o f 11 per
cent from 1926.
The motor group had the largest increase over 1927.
Aside from a 32 per cent increase in the profits of
General Motors Corporation, net earnings o f 15 other
companies (exclusive o f Ford, for which figures are not
available) were 10 per cent above last year. Increases




1926

1927

First
Quarter

First
Quarter

First
Quarter

Miscellaneous........................................

16
16
21
16
26
16
24
10
10
5
6
44

76,100
8,826
27,222
47,760
27,370
8,813
14,753
11,089
5,187
1,515
7,389
32,949

77,778
6,515
25,587
45,680
29,259
8,645
15,041
11,850
4,964
2,099
8,525
32,732

97,230
6,680
7,509
37,231
30,875
9,261
15,981
13,132
3,820
1,709
10,360
45,015

Total 12 groups.................................

210

268,973

268,675

278,803

Other Public Utilities...........................

83
17

50,500
20,400

58,600
24,500

Corporation Groups
Motor accessories..................................
Oil...........................................................
Food and food products.......................
Machine and machine mfg...................
Mining and smelting............................
Building supplies...................................

dumber

Total Public Utilities.......................

100

70,900

83,100

Class I Railroads.................................

186

224,000

226,000

*Partly estimated

1928

62,200*
27,300
89,500*
217,000

MONTHLY REVIEW, JUNE 1, 1928

44

MillionsofDollars

F o r e ig n E x c h a n g e

Sterling tended to advance gradually during May,
despite the further advance in money rates in the New
Y ork market, and near the end of the month was higher
than a month previous.
Follow ing the re-establishment o f the gold standard
in Norway on May first, the krona rose gradually until
parity was reached on the 14th. Dutch exchange was
likewise strong, cable rates advancing to 40.37 cents,
and German reichsmarks advanced to the highest level
o f the year.
Spanish pesetas continued to fluctuate
irregularly, but on an average were slightly lower than
in A pril. Other European exchanges showed little varia­
tion in M ay from the levels reached in the previous
month.
Canadian funds went to a discount, somewhat earlier
than last year, Argentine rates were slightly stronger,
and Brazilian quotations were unchanged.
In the F ar Eastern exchanges, the rupee showed little
change, the yen weakened soon after the beginning o f
the month, but Chinese rates were strong.
A s the follow ing table shows, nearly all o f the prin­
cipal exchanges are substantially higher than a year ago,
notwithstanding the relatively high level of money rates
in the New Y ork market at the present time.
Cable rates
Country
Belgium...................................................................
England...................................................................
France......................................................................
Germany.
..........................................................
Netherlands............................................................
Norway....................................................................
Switzerland..............................................................
Canada....................................................................
Argentina ..............................................................
Japan.......................................................................
Hong Kong, dollar.................................................
Shanghai, tael.........................................................

May 31, 1927

May 28, 1928

.1389
4.8574
.0392
.2370
.0550
.4004
.2596
.1924
1.0006
.9627
.1183
.3626
.4621
.4923
.6296

.1395
4.8834
.0394
.2395
.0527
.4037
.2679
.1927
.9984
.9716
.1203
.3659
.4655
.5154
.6836

Foreign Trade
Both exports and imports of merchandise in A p ril
showed somewhat more than the usual seasonal declines
from March, as the accom panying diagrams show, and
were also smaller than last year, despite higher prices
in several commodities that are important in our foreign
trade. Exports, valued at $368,000,000, were $47,000,000
smaller than last year, and imports, at $345,000,000 were
$31,000,000 sm aller; both were the smallest fo r any A p ril
since 1924.
M any o f the leading commodities contributed to the
A p ril decline in exports.
Shipments abroad o f raw
cotton decreased about 40 per cent in volume, and
$11,000,000 in actual value from a year ago. Total
grain exports were only about half as large in quantity,
and were $17,000,000 less in value. Declines occurred
also in the exports o f coal, cotton manufactures, and
automobiles, the last two follow ing increases in the first
three months of 1928.
Quantity receipts of raw silk and crude rubber de­
clined from the com paratively high figures of March, and




Mltion3<JIhlfor3

500

50 0 ;

IMP 0 R T 5

450

;z6

1j
•/
'aeA

'27
. j __ 1__
V

300

r
vV

j r

M o n t h ly

a

\ /"
*/

l\ s

V\/

\

a

350

V

\

7

/ j
\\
•£6\/

r
1 1

_ _1_1_ .. r.. 1 _1_1_
_J__ L—__ __ __ 3 0 0 J_1
J FMAMJ J A S 0 N D
s 0 n d.

m a n j j a

Im p o rts
S t a t e s in

\

400

\ ........

35 0

rj

\ <26A

\

\j

h

450

(i
\

400

EXPORTS

a n d E x p o r t s o f M e r c h a n d is e o f t h e
1 9 2 8 , C o m p a re d w it h 1 9 2 7 a n d 1 9 2 6 .

U n it e d

were 21 and 24 per cent, respectively, below last year.
These reductions in volume, accom panying a slight de­
crease in the price o f silk and a decrease o f over 50 per
cent in the price o f rubber, largely account fo r the loss
in the value o f imports.

Security Markets
Stock prices continued to advance during the first half
o f M ay and representative averages o f industrial and
railroad shares again advanced to new high levels. A
succession o f days with a turnover o f well over four
million shares on the New Y ork Stock Exchange, and
the distribution o f trading among a large number of
issues, indicated a widespread participation in the
market. A round the middle o f the month, however, the
market became hesitant and the averages declined from
5 to 9 points. In the last week o f the month there was
a partial recovery from this decline, but movements o f
individual stocks were very irregular and the volume o f
trading was considerably reduced.
In the bond market there was a further gradual but
persistent decline in prices. United States Government
bonds reached the lowest levels o f the y ea r; domestic
corporate bond averages likewise declined to new low
points fo r the yea r; and foreign issues were somewhat
lower.
Present levels o f stock and bond prices, relative to
those o f a month ago, and to those o f May o f last year,
are shown in the follow ing table.
Change
Change
Current
from
from
quotations month ago year ago
197
31
228
40
7
10

Industrial stocks........................................
Railroad stocks...........................................
Industrial and rail stocks.........................
Domestic corporation bonds.....................
U. S. Government bonds...........................
Foreign Government bonds......................

242
166
220
98.2
1043$
106.4

+ 3 points +66 points
+13 "
—2
“
+2
“
+50
-%
“
+7
/s
—U “
—U
--- V2
+H

New Financing
A lthough security offerings in M ay were somewhat
smaller than the unusually heavy volume floated in
A pril, and were also slightly smaller than in M ay o f
last year, the total nevertheless was o f substantial size.

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW YORK

The principal reduction from A p ril was in domestic
public utility issues. F oreign borrowings, on the other
hand, continued to increase; the principal issues were
$50,000,000 of Commonwealth of Australia bonds, priced
to yield 5 per cen t; $30,000,000 German Central Bank
for A griculture bonds, yielding 6.62 per cen t; $20,000,000 Mortgage Bank of Chile bonds, priced at 6.30 per
ce n t; a $17,500,000 German Consolidated M unicipal loan,
yielding 6.50 per ce n t; a $15,000,000 City of Berlin loan
on a 6.38 per cent yield basis; and $10,000,000 General
Electric Company of Germany bonds, yielding 6.50 per
cent.
Although foreign loans floated in this market, have been
fairly numerous during the first fou r months o f this
year, the total of issues which represent only the secur­
ing of new capital funds in this country, eliminating all
offerings o f a refunding nature, has been $96,000,000
smaller than in the corresponding period o f last year.
The decrease has been in Canadian, Latin American, and
Asiatic and Oceanic borrow ings; European borrowers
have secured about $90,000,000 more of new capital than
in the corresponding period of last year.

Building
Construction contracts reported by the F. W . Dodge
Corporation fo r the 37 states East o f the Rockies were
larger than fo r any previous month. There was an
increase o f 9 per cent over the March total, and o f 6
per cent over A p ril o f last year. The most important
element in the large total fo r A p ril was a substantial
increase in industrial building, a good part of which was
in the Middle A tlantic district. Residential building
also was somewhat larger than a year ago, but the
volume of other types of building showed little change.
Total building contracts awarded during the first fou r
months of this year were 6 per cent larger than a year
ago, and fo r the first 25 days o f M ay an even larger
increase over the corresponding period o f last year was
indicated.
The A p ril report for the New Y ork and Northern
New Jersey district was not as favorable as fo r the
country as a w hole; contracts awarded were slightly
smaller than in March and were 8 per cent below a
year ago, due prim arily to a drop in residential work
which in the preceding months o f this year had been
heavier than during the corresponding period o f 1927.
F or the first fou r months of the year, however, building
in this district was 6 per cent larger than a year ago,
the same increase as fo r all districts combined.

Employment and Wages
F actory employment in the country as a whole de­
clined slightly less than usual in A pril, and our index,
in which allowance is made fo r seasonal variations,
showed a small advance from the low level o f March.
As in each previous month fo r a year and a half, how­
ever, employment remained below the level of the corre­
sponding month of the preceding year. In New Y ork
State, there was a reduction of about 1 per cent.
The State Employm ent Service reports, however, that
this seasonal decline in factories was accompanied by
increases in outdoor activities. There was a marked
expansion of employment in building, and in farm and




45

PER CENT

road work. The supply o f farm labor is larger relative
to the demand than in a number o f years, and wages
are lower than a year ago.
Although the largest volume o f unemployment con­
tinues among the unskilled workers, employment oppor­
tunities fo r this type o f labor have shown a pronouneed
increase in recent weeks; the work, however, is largely
o f a casual nature. There is still reported to be some
unemployment among the semi-skilled, but very little
among the highly skilled workers. In general, it may
be said that the situation has shown substantial im prove­
ment.
Indication o f this is foun d in the ratio o f orders fo r
workers to applications fo r employment at State em ploy­
ment offices, which is shown in the accom panying dia­
gram. This ratio has shown a rapid and fairly steady
increase from the low point o f m id-February, and on
M ay 12 was the highest since last October, and was
nearer the corresponding week o f the preceding year
than at any time since A p ril 1927. Another evidence
o f improvement is to be foun d in the rate o f voluntary
labor turnover, which showed an increase in A pril, after
allowance is made fo r the usual seasonal variations.
This indicates that workers are not holding quite so
closely to their jobs as was the case during the immedi­
ately preceding months.

Indexes of Business Activity
Car loadings o f both bulk freight and merchandise
and miscellaneous freight increased slightly in A pril,
after seasonal allowance, but remained below the levels
o f a year a g o ; in fact, they have been smaller than last
year in every week o f this year, and have exceeded the
corresponding week o f 1926 only twice. Foreign trade
showed a decline o f more than the usual seasonal propor­
tions in A pril, both in exports and imports. There were
increases in mail order sales and in advertising, after
allowance fo r seasonal variations, but department store
sales were practically unchanged, and life insurance
sales declined.
Financial activity continued at high levels, and this

MONTHLY REVIEW, JUNE 1, 1928

46

bank’s indexes of stock trading and bank debits in New
Y ork City advanced to new high points. Business fa il­
ures showed more than the usual seasonal decline, but
new incorporations also were less numerous than in
March.
A djustm ent is made in the follow ing indexes fo r sea­
sonal variations, year-to-year growth, and, where neces­
sary, for price changes.
(Computed trend of past years = 100 per cent)
1927

1928

Apr.

Feb.

Mar.

109
105
104
115

104
96
90
107

103
92
97
104
96

Apr.

Primary Distribution

Car loadings, merchandise and misc...
Car loadings, other...............................
Exports..................................................
Imports..................................................
Panama Canal traffic...........................
Wholesale trade....................................

102
102

104
95
87p
100p

(Computed trend of past years =100 per cent)

Distribution to Consumer

100

Department store sales, 2nd Dist.......
Chain grocery sales...............................
Other chain store sales.........................
Mail order sales....................................
Life insurance paid for.........................
Advertising............................................

104
103

102
114
101

104
103

102
98
113

97

102
100
97
111

1927

98

106
97

95

Bank debits, outside of N. Y. City. ..
Bank debits, New York City. . . . . . . .
Velocity of bank deposits, outside of
New York City........... .........................
Velocity of bank deposits, New York
City........................................................
Shares sold on N. Y. Stock Exchange.. .
Postal receipts.........'.................................
Electric power...........................................
Employment in the United States..........
Business failures.......................................
Building contracts, 36 States..................
New corporations formed in N. Y. State
Real estate transfers............................

109
127

102
135

107
159

112

107

104

111

115

134
195
97
106

138
196
95
107
96
114
151
127

162
281
90
104
95
115
125
115
92

164
306
87

*General price level..............................
*Composite index of wages.................

169

173

174
223

Apr.

100
111
128
114
96

220

101

221

162

Pig iron......................................................
Steel ingots...............................................
Cotton consumption.................................
Cotton movement.....................................
Woolen mill activity*...............................
Silk consumption*....................................
Petroleum..................................................
Bituminous coal.......................................

102
133
110

96

Copper, U. S. mines.................................
Lead...........................................................
Zinc............................................................
Tin deliveries.....................................
Leather, sole.............................................

175

Paper, total...............................................
Wood pulp.................................................

221

Feb.

Mar.

Apr.

Hogs slaughtered......................................
Cattle slaughtered....................................
Sheep slaughtered.....................................
Calves slaughtered...................................

Farm produce shipped................................

Productive activity in leading industries continued
irregular in A pril, and in general remained at about the
level of a year ago. The average daily production o f
steel ingots increased 3 per cent and established a new
high record fo r all time, in spite of a slight decline in
activity in the latter part o f the month. Average daily
production of automobiles also increased, and remained
above the level o f a year ago. Production o f coke and
of anthracite coal increased, after seasonal allowance,
but there were declines in bituminous coal and in petro.

115
111
106
136
87
122
117
88
108
94
102
114
94
104
113
122
106
102

105
115
104
65
88
124
115
86
100
103
104
107
93
88
112
114
109r
109r

104
109
95
89
86
140
109
87
100
101
96
100
93
114
109
106
107
101

107
114
89
110
83p
98
107p
83
103
96
98
92
94
105
113
113
107p
96p

95
110
108
88
112
99
77
108
94
98
108
98
101
106
95
118
118
92

126
100
114
98
105
107
116
115
76
99
85
95
104
107
103
126
128
92

128
94
106
83
95
134
158
103
88
97
76
91
103
105
100
116
132
87r

96
91
102
80

Consumers' Goods

*1913 average - 100 per cent.

Production

T iillio n s o f Tons

1928

100
Producers' Goods

General Business Activity

p Preliminary.

leum, the latter apparently indicating successful efforts
to restrict output, follow ing the over-production o f the
past year. There was also a substantial lessening of
activity in the textile industries; mill consumption o f
silk reached the lowest level since May 1926, and cotton
consumption declined further.
There is evidence that the irregularity in industrial
activity o f March and A p ril continued into May. E m ­
ploym ent in the Detroit automobile center increased
further, coal output showed a seasonal expansion, and
the production o f cotton goods was reported as slightly
above that o f A p r il; on the other hand, there were
declines in steel mill activity, and in petroleum produc­
tion.
This ban k ’s indexes, in which allowance is made fo r
year-to-year growth, and the usual seasonal variations,
are shown below.

T housands of Cars

Wheat receipts..........................................
Corn receipts.............................................
Wheat flour...............................................
Sugar meltings, U. S. ports.....................
Gasoline.....................................................
Anthracite coal.........................................
Newsprint.................................................
Printing activity.......................................
Tobacco products.....................................
Boots and shoes........................................
Tires..........................................................
Automobile, passenger.............................
Automobile, truck....................................
* Seasonal variation not allowed for.

iii
88
ioi
88p
lis
87

r Revised.

TrillionsofBbh

Thousands o f B ales

' 500

p Preliminary,

107
77

90r

900

400
^ \\
1926

300
!6 \

/\
,/

750

/ ft

\

'19A
2,7 \

\ 200
1,00

J F M A M J J A 3 0 N D

AUTOIs10BILE
PRODl
I.. .X iJCTION
i..i

J F M . A M J

70 \ /
V19&
..,

,/l92()

.... ./‘*1926

450

60
\ f

i ,j__

J A 5 0 N D

P r o d u c t io n o f S t e e l I n g o t s , P a s s e n g e r A u t o m o b ile s , a n d P e t r o le u m , a n d




1927

h
GOO

1921

\\

192/
STEEl
INGOT5 i i

1927

\

300

COTTON
CONSlJM
LP
I TIONJ

PETROILEUM
PRODUCTION
i i i—

J F M A M J J A S O N D
M i l l C o n s u m p t io n

of

C o tto n

in

1928

J F M A M J J A S ' O N D
C o m p a re d

w it h

1927

and

1926.

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW YORK

47

D e p a r tm e n t S to re T r a d e

Chain Store Sales

Total sales of reporting department stores in this dis­
trict in A p ril showed an unusually large decline from
those of a year ago, due at least in part to the fact that
there was one less business day in A p ril this year, and
in part to the fact that a larger proportion of the Easter
business this year was done in March. A fte r taking
these facts into account, however, the volume of business
in A p ril does not appear to have been large, and fo r the
first fou r months of the year, total sales were slightly
smaller than in the corresponding period o f last year.
Leading apparel stores in the district have made a
more favorable sh ow in g; their sales in A p ril were 3 per
cent larger than last year, and for the first fou r months
o f the year 8 per cent larger.
Stocks of merchandise on hand in department stores
remained slightly smaller than last year, but, owing to
the substantial decline in sales, the rate of stock turn­
over was lower than in A p ril 1927. F or the January to
A p ril period the turnover was about the same as last
year. The rate of collections on charge accounts during
A p ril was the same as last year, notwithstanding the one
less business day.

F or the first time in several years, the total sales of
reporting chain store systems in A p ril showed practi­
cally no increase over the previous year. Grocery
chains, which seem to be little affected by general trade
conditions, were the only type to show an increase; all
others reported declines of varying amount, even those
which have considerably increased the number o f units
operated during the past year. The declines in sales per
store were even larger.
Part o f the decline was due to the fact that there was
one less selling day in A p ril this year, but after allow­
ance fo r this, the daily rate o f sales com pared less favor­
ably with that o f a year ago than at any time in a con­
siderable number o f months. A partial explanation may
probably be foun d in the earlier Easter this year, as the
result o f which a larger part of the Easter buying was
done in March.
Percentage Change
April 1928 compared with April 1927
Type of Store

Number of
Stores

Total
Sales

Sales per
Store

+ 2.0
+ 9.0
+ 3.1
+ 1.3
+ 9.6
+17.7
+ 9.9

+14.1
— 0.2
— 2.8
— 11.8
— 14.8
— 2.9
— 9.4

+11.8
— 8.5
— 5.8
— 12.9
—22.3
— 17.6
— 17.5

+ 4.6

+ 0.1

— 4.3

Grocery. . ............................................
Ten cent..............................................
Tobacco...............................................

Percentage Change
April 1928 com­
pared with April
1927
Locality

Stock on
hand end
of month

Net
Sales

1.4
3.6
1.0
5.7
2.0
6.7
2.8

Per cent of Charge
Accounts Outstand­
ing March 31 Col­
lected in April

1927

1928

50.4
55.9
39.6

51.3
52.5
41.2

47 .*4

45 .‘ 6

36.6

34.4

New York.......................................
Buffalo.............................................
Rochester........................................
Syracuse..........................................
Newark...........................................
Bridgeport.......................................
Elsewhere........................................
Northern New York State........
Central New York State...........
Southern New York State.........
Hudson River Valley District .
Capital District..........................
Westchester District..................

— 6.7
— 7.0
— 9.1
— 12.0
— 7.3
— 13.0
— 9.0
— 9.3
— 10.2
— 12.1
— 5.5
— 9.7
— 5.1

—
+
+
—
+
—
—

All department stores....................

— 7.3

— 0.9

48.4

48.4

Apparel stores................................
Mail order houses...........................

+ 3.1
— 1.0

+10.2

48.4

48.1

Only a few departments showed larger sales than in
A p ril 1927; all the apparel departments were among
those showing reductions.
Net Sales
Percentage Change
April 1928
compared with
April 1927
Cotton goods...................................
Books and stationery......................
Furniture..........................................
Luggage and other leather goods. .
Toys and sporting goods................
Musical instruments and radio. . . .
Men’s furnishings............................
Toilet articles and drugs................
Linens and handkerchiefs...............
Shoes.................................................
Women’s ready-to-wear accessories
Home furnishings............................
Women’s and Misses’ ready-to-wear
Silverware and jewelry...................
Hosiery.............................................
Silks and velvets.............................
Men’s and Boys’ wear....................
Woolen goods...................................
Miscellaneous...................................




+ 7.2
+ 5.0
+ 2.2
+ 1.8
+ 1.7
— 1.4
— 2.1
— 2.7
— 2.9
— 3.2
— 4.4
— 4.4
— 7.9
— 10.6
— 13.3
— 17.4
— 19.9
—21.9
— 14.1

Stock on Hand
Percentage Change
April 30, 1928
compared w th
April 30, 1927
— 9.9
— 0.8
— 0.6
— 16.0
+ 0.3
— 21.4
— 12.3
+ 0.7
— 12.8
+ 12.5
— 2.1
— 0.6
+ 0.3
+ 3.8
— 5.1
— 3.4
— 0.2
— 14.7
— 8.4

Variety...................................... .........
Candy.................................................

Wholesale Trade
Reports from wholesale dealers indicated that A p ril
business was highly irregular in the various lines. H ard­
ware sales showed the largest increase over a year previ­
ous in nearly three years, notwithstanding the fact that
A p ril was a shorter business month this year, due to the
inclusion o f five Sundays. D rug sales also showed an
unusually large increase, and orders fo r machine tools,
reported by the Machine Tool B u ilders’ Association,
continued far above those o f last year.
Shoe sales declined sharply, however, and fairly large
reductions, partly accounted fo r by the short month,
were reported in sales o f stationery, cotton goods, m en ’s
and w om en’s clothing, and diamonds.

Commodity

Percentage
Change
April 1928
compared with
March 1928
Stock
Net
end of
Sales
month

Percentage
Change
April 1928
compared with
April 1927
Stock
Net
end of
Sales
month

Per cent of
Accounts
Outstanding
March 31
collected
in April
1927

1928

— 0.2

74.2
36.3

74.4
33.8

— 4 .7

31 A

30.5

47.2
49.9
48.7
46.6

45. i
46.0
53.4
43.0

77.8

66.4
25.8

67 *.o
65.4
) 29.4

Weighted Average.. . — 19.4
— 5.2
52.1
♦Reported by the National Machine Tool Builders’ Association.

50.9

Groceries......................
Men’s clothing.............
Women’s dresses..........
Women’s coats and
suits..........................
Cotton goods—Jobbers
Cotton goods— Com­
mission ......................
Silk goods.....................
Shoes.............................
Drugs............................
Hardware...............
Machine tools*............
Stationery....................
Paper............................
Diamonds.....................
Jewelry.........................

— 6.3
— 43.0
— 16.5
— 50.1
— 14.9

— 8.7

— 3 .9

— 25.6
— 27.2
— 36.2 —
+ 3.1
—
+26.0 —
+ 0.1
—21.2
— 6.2
— 3.0
— 7.7 } +

2.2
2.8
4.1

8.0

— 1.0
— 12.3
—24.8
— 16.0
— 6.4

— 10.0
+ 1.2
— 32.1 — 3 1
+16.5
+ 18.3
+ 8.6
+10.1
+76.1
— 8.4
— 2.7
—22.4
+ 3.7 } + 7.3 )

*

48

MONTHLY REVIEW, JUNE 1, 1928

TERCENT

Business C onditions in the U n ited States
(Summarized by the Federal Reserve Board)

\ J OLUME of industrial production continued large during April, reflecting
*
chiefly increased output in metal industries, while activity in industries
producing food and clothing decreased. Wholesale and retail trade also de­
clined. The general level of wholesale commodity prices increased in April
reflecting advances in farm products. There were large exports of gold in
April and May, member bank loans and their borrowings at the Reserve Banks
continued to increase, and money rates showed further advances.
P r o d u c t io n
In d e x N u m b e r o f P r o d u c t io n o f M a n u f a c t u r e s
a n d M in e r a ls , A d ju s t e d fo r S e a s o n a l V a r i ­
a t io n s (1 9 2 3 - 2 5 a v e r a g e = 1 0 0 p e r c e n t ) .

PERCENT

Production of manufactures remained in about the same volume in April as
in March, while output of minerals declined slightly, owing chiefly to a de­
crease in production of bituminous coal. Daily average output of iron and
steel, copper, and zinc, increased in April, but since the first of May there
has been some curtailment, in steel-mill activity. Automobile production was
maintained in large volume during April and according to preliminary reports
also during the first half of May. Textile mill activity, output of boots and
shoes, and meat production showed substantial declines during April. Volume
of factory employment declined slightly, reflecting chiefly decreases in the
food, leather, and textile industries. Building contracts awarded in April
exceeded those for any previous month, and awards during the first three weeks
of May continued in unusually large volume.

Trade

of

W h o le s a le P r i c e In d e x
U n it e d S t a t e s B u r e a u
o f L a b o r S t a t is t ic s (1 9 2 6 a v e ra g e =
100 per c e n t).
B ILLIO N S of.'DOLLARS

Sales by department stores and by wholesale firms in most lines of trade
declined in April and were in smaller volume than a year ago. Average daily
sales of department stores, after allowance is made for the earlier date of
Easter and the usual seasonal changes, were smaller in April than in March
and were also smaller than in April a year ago. This decrease was due largely
to unfavorable weather conditions. Stocks of department stores, after adjust­
ment for seasonal changes, were in about the same volume as in March and
slightly smaller than a year ago.
Freight car loadings showed an increase between the beginning of April and
the middle of May, but continued smaller than a year ago for most classes of
commodities.
P r ic e s

R e s e rv e B a n k C r e d it:
M o n th ly A v e ra g e s o f
D a ily F ig u r e s fo r 1 2 F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B a n k s
( L a t e s t fig u re s a r e a v e ra g e s o f
f i r s t 2 3 d a y s in M a y ) .




The general level of wholesale commodity prices, as indicated by the index
of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, increased from 96 per cent of the 1926
average in March to 97.4 per cent in April. This increase reflected sharp
advances in the prices of grains, cotton, livestock, and hide and leather prod­
ucts. Rubber prices continued to decline, and most of the other groups of
commodities showed little change. During the first three weeks of May there
were decreases in the prices of grains, flour, sheep, and hogs, and increases in
copper, zinc, and rubber.
Bank

C r e d it

At member banks, loans largely for commercial and industrial purposes,
following a rapid increase during February and March, have shown little
change since the early part of April. Loans on securities continued to in­
crease and total loans and investments of reporting member banks in the
middle of May were larger than at any previous time.
The outward movement of gold continued in May, the decline in monetary
gold stock during the four weeks ended May 23 being nearly $90,000,000.
This loss of gold, together with further sales of United States securities by
the Reserve Banks, was reflected in an increase of nearly $140,000,000 in mem­
ber bank borrowing at the Reserve Banks.
There were further advances in open-market money rates during May, and
discount rates at the Federal Reserve Banks of New York, Philadelphia, Cleve­
land, Atlanta, and Dallas were raised from 4 to 4% per cent.