View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

(T h e article on the last page describes what the reserve ratio m eans)

MONTHLY
O f C r e d it a n d
I n

By

th e

t h e

F ed eral

B u s in e s s

S e c o n d

R eserve

F e d e r a l

A g e n t,
New

REVIEW
R e s e r v e

F ed eral

York, December

1,

D is t r ic t

R eserve

B ank,

N ew

Y ork

1922

Since M arch of this year, when borrowing w as at a
minimum, the total loans and investments of member
banks in p rin cipal cities, where the effects of industrial
a ctivity would be felt most, have increased $1,250,000,000
or over 8 p er cent. B u t this increase is ascribable not
so much to loans fo r business purposes as to loans oti
stocks and bonds and to investments made fo r the p u r­
pose of p u ttin g surplus fu n d s to work. The amount lent
directly fo r business purposes, as fa r as it can be segre­
gated in the returns, declined un til the end of A u gu st.
Since that time, however, it has advanced $267,000,000.
W h ile the total amount o f credit extended b y banks,
m easured b y total loans and investments, is indi­
re ctly and in the long ru n available fo r business use,
loans made d irectly to business represent more closely
current needs fo r credit. The movement of loans of the
reporting member banks is illustrated in the diagram
below at the left.
The second diagram on this page shows the extent to
which the F ed eral Reserve B an ks have been called upon
to advance fund s to meet the increased demand fo r

C re d it Conditions
O V E M E N T S du ring the past month of the v a ri­
ous factors reflecting credit conditions were in
the same direction as last month but more mod­
erate in character. The volume of credit in use as indi­
cated b y the commercial loans of member banks, and b y
the earning assets of the Reserve Banks, increased at a
slower rate than in Septem ber and early October. Note
circulation of the Reserve B an ks fluctuated w ithin n a r­
row limits, and interest rates rem ained at substantially
the level reached about the first of November.
Th is
greater stability in the factors reflecting credit condi­
tions does not appear to indicate th at a n y pause has
taken place in general business activity. F o r the past
few weeks such figures as are available appear to show
a continued gain in industrial output and the distribu­
tion o f goods.
There has been a considerable increase throughout the
cou ntry in the volume of production and trade in the
past year, but this increase has gone fo rw a rd w ith a
relatively small demand upon the banks fo r credit.

M

BILLIONS
OF DOLLARS

BILLIONS
OF DOLLARS

BILLIONS
OF DOLLARS

C o n d itio n s

3.5
TOTAL LOAN!

& INVESTMEI rrs

,

3.0

/v/ >
\\
\

•

25
•
I
--------*

2.0

\

COMMERC
LOANS
_
_

Y e a r n in g % ASSETS

•

\

\

Vv
\

1
.5

B IL L S V
DI5C0UNTED * «

1.0
TOTAL
INVESTMENTS

..*•**

...

.......

.5

LOAN 5 On DTQvn

& BONDS

0
19 20

192.1

192,2,

Loans and Investments of 800 Member
Banks in Principal Cities




1
\

/ * * .......... ..
__T ,

ACCEPTANCES^**’
U.S. SECURITIES

1920

• /

192.1

19 2 .Z

Loans and Investments— all Federal Reserve Banks

Gold Stocks in the Country and in the
Reserve Banks

2

MONTHLY R E V IE W

credit. E a r n in g assets, which are the best measure of
the total accommodations w hich the R eserve B an k s are
extending to business, increased $146,000,000 between
A u g u st 9 and Novem ber 2 2 of this year. In recent weeks
there has been a change in the nature of the loans com­
prised in the general group of earning assets.
D is­
counts and advances to member banks have increased,
while holdings o f acceptances and U nited States securi­
ties have diminished.
The reason w h y increased production and trade,
accom panied b y higher w ages and prices, have not
resulted in a corresponding increase in the volume of
bank credit issued directly for business purposes, m ay
ap pear upon observing three factors, which among others
are im portant in the present situation.
Th e first facto r is the h eavy receipt of gold into this
country. Sin ce the middle of 1 9 2 1 , gold im ports have
totaled n early $600,000,000 and since J a n u a r y 1 , 19 2 2 ,
n early $250,000,000. T h is gold has found its w a y imme­
diately into the banks and thence into the Reserve
Banks. The gold has served to liquidate borrowings b y
b y individuals from their banks and borrowings b y
banks from the F e d e ra l R eserve Banks. Liquidation
from this and other sources has up to recently more than
offset new borrowing. These receipts of gold have more­
over been largely responsible fo r the power of the banks
to extend their investment accounts.
A second facto r has been the accum ulation b y m any
business concerns d u rin g the period of quiet business of
a considerable reserve in the form o f investments or bank
deposits which th ey could d raw upon to finance more
active operations, without the necessity fo r borrowing.
A th ird and probably more im portant facto r in the
v e ry moderate increase in commercial loans m ay be seen
in the fact that business is now being carried fo rw a rd
w ith a m inimum of fu tu re commitments.
A lth o u gh
there has been some change in the tendency in recent
months, both wholesalers and retailers still continue to
b u y cautiously, and m an ufactu rers hesitate to produce
goods without definite orders in sight. Stocks o f m anu­
factu red goods are in general low.
E x a c t figures on this aspect of retail trade are re­
ported each month to this bank b y 60 departm ent stores
in this district. T h e y show that the current ratio of the
amount of stock held to the amount of sales is now in
the neighborhood o f 3 y2 to 1 . The usual ratio is much
nearer to 4 to 1 : that is, $ 4 w orth of stock on hand to
every $ 1 of m onthly sales.
There are fe w definite
figures available in other fields which show the exact
situation, bu t general reports indicate that the p olicy
of c a rry in g sm all amounts o f stock on hand, and order­
in g only fo r immediate needs continues to p revail in
m an y branches of in d u stry and trade.
R a te

o f T u r n o v e r o f B a n k D e p o s its

The rate o f tu rnover o f bank deposits in N e w Y o rk
C ity du rin g the month o f October showed a m arked in­
crease over the figures fo r Septem ber of this year, and
October 1 9 2 1 . Reduced to an annual rate, the tu rnover
this October was 86.3, ind icatin g that deposits were




being checked out at the rate of 86.3 times a year. The
corresponding figure fo r Septem ber this y e a r w as 68.6,
and fo r October 1 9 2 1 w as 70.4. In fact, the rate of tu rn ­
over was more rap id than in an y month since Decem ber
1 9 1 9 . Th is high rate o f turnover m ay be accounted fo r
p a rtly b y a ctiv ity in the stock and bond markets, p a r­
ticu la rly the m arket fo r Governm ent bonds including
the new issue, and is fu rth er in keeping w ith a heavy
volume of sales b y departm ent stores, and wholesale
dealers, as reported to this bank.
The October figures fo r other im portant cities do not
show a n y such large increase, although in Buffalo,
Rochester, and Boston, the rate of tu rnover w as higher
than a month ago, or a y e a r ago. In general, the increase
in business a ctiv ity d u rin g the past y e a r has not been
accom panied b y m arked increases in the rate of turnover
of deposits. The figures fo r October of the past 4 years,
and Septem ber of 1 9 2 2 are shown in the follow ing table.
October

Sept.

1919
New York City.........
Albany.........................
Rochester...................
Syracuse.....................
San Francisco............

1920

1921

1922

1922

85.4
35.0
18.4
20.6
11.5
42.9
47.0
42.8

77.5
32.6
22.8
21.9
13.2
37.0
50.8
41.6

70.4
26.0
19.9
21.8
9 .0
32.2
46.6
42.2

86.3
24.0
22.6
23.6
8.8
34.6
43.7
37.4

68.6
21.6
20.4
21.1
8 .4
28.8
41.9
40.7

B ill M a r k e t
M arket rates fo r bankers acceptances wjere/ m ain­
tained du ring Novem ber at the levels established late
in October and the movement of bills increased substan­
tially. D u rin g the first h a lf of Novem ber the increased
demand came p rin cip a lly from out of town, but a fter
the fifteenth a strong c ity demand developed, especially
fo r bills m aturin g before the end of the year. A t p res­
ent rates the dem and fo r bills is greater and more
broadly distributed than fo r several months past.
B ills draw n to finance the im portation of ra w silk,
coffee, and sugar, the exportation of cotton and grain,
and the domestic movement o f cotton w ere most num er­
ous of new bills entering the m arket d u rin g the month.
C o m m e rc ia l P a p e r
P re va ilin g commercial paper rates became definitely
established at 4 % to 5 p er cent, ea rly in November, and
these rates were m aintained throughout the month, not­
w ithstanding easier conditions in some other m oney
markets.
The volume o f p aper distributed rem ained rath er
limited, due both to slow demand and to sm all supplies
of prim e paper. N e w Y o r k banks were only occasional
buyers, and m an y dealers reported distribution chiefly

FE D E R A L RE SE R V E AGENT A T NEW YORK

in the interior, where the higher rates appeared to in­
crease demand somewhat. B u y in g w as good in St. Louis
and through the southwest, but elsewhere w as generally
quiet. A s a rule, light b u yin g b y banks seemed to be due
less to dissatisfaction w ith rates than to a dem and fo r
funds from their own customers. The small su p p ly of
p aper in the m arket w as due in considerable measure to
the fa c t that borrowers gen erally found the cost of secur­
in g funds at their own banks lower than the cost o f
financing through the open m arket.
Reflecting lessened a ctivity in the market, this b a n k ’s
com pilation of the outstanding p aper of 2 7 dealers
showed a fu rth er decline at the end of October, as ind i­
cated in the accom panying diagram .
M ILLIO NS OF
DOLLARS
1500

3

points since J u l y . The reaction, which spread over a
broad range of stocks, w as the most extensive since
the advance began ap proxim ately fifteen months ago.
A ve ra g e s of industrial stocks showed losses of about
7 y2 points from the m axim um level o f the rise reached
in October. A v e ra g es of railroad issues continued a
decline w hich began in the e a rly fa ll w ith the publi­
cation of earnings statements which w ere regarded as
disappointing.
Total transactions on the Stock E x ch a n ge du ring
October were 26,000,000 shares, a larger volume than
in recent months, but 4,000,000 less than in A p ril, the
most active month o f the year. A c tiv ity lessened early
in November, but increased later in the month accom­
p a n yin g lower prices.
Bond

M ark et

1250

A f t e r steadying tem porarily late in October and
e arly in November, corporation bond price averages
declined one point fu rth e r to levels about 3 y2 points
below the Septem ber high point of the year. Influential
factors ap p aren tly were firm money conditions, lower
prices in the stock m arket, and a tendency fo r funds to
be tran sferred from investment in securities to more
active business employment.
A cco m pan yin g easier
m oney m arket conditions a fter Novem ber 1 5 , there was
a pause in the decline and a decrease in the volume of
trading.

lQ iO fr

750

500

£50

0

191a

1919

\9zo

\
9z\

m e

Commercial Paper Outstanding— Twenty-seven Dealers

Sto ck

M a rk e t M o n e y R a te s

Stock m arket money rates became somewhat firm er
e a rly in November, accom panying a loss of funds to
the interior, coupled w ith the usual first-of-the-month
financial transactions. C all loan rates twice touched 6
p er cent., and an average rate of 5y2 per cent, on new
loans d u rin g the week ended Novem ber 1 0 w as the
highest fo r an y week this year. A b ou t the middle of the
month, however, stock m arket liquidation and h eavy
transfers of funds to N ew Y o r k eased the m arket, and
call loan rates dropped to 3 y2 per cent, fo r the first
time in two months.
There were later reactions to
around 5 per cent.
Tim e money advanced to 5 per cent, fo r all m aturities
early in November, compared w ith 4% to 5 per cent, in
October. W h ile offerings became somewhat free r later
in the month and demand lessened, rates rem ained u n ­
changed,
i
Sto ck

The accom panying diagram shows the course of high
grade bond prices in this country and in G reat B ritain ,
and indicates that an interruption of the u p w a rd move­
ment has been common to both countries. I n both the
U nited States and G reat B ritain , the advance culm inat­
ing in Septem ber carried prices to the highest levels
since the w ar.

M ark et

F re sh weakness in the stock m arket in late October
and in November carried price averages below levels
reached du ring the Septem ber decline, and to the lowest




Average Monthly Prices of Liberty and Corporation Bonds at New
York and British War Loans at London

4

M ONTHLY R E V IE W

Domestic State and m unicipal issues shared w ith other
domestic bonds in the Novem ber reaction.
F o re ig n
issues were also lower in sym p ath y w ith declines in ex­
change rates, and about the middle of Novem ber Fren ch ,
B elgian , C entral European, and m an y South A m erican
issues fell to new low points fo r the year. L a ter, how­
ever, prices rallied strongly from these levels.
October trad in g in bonds cither than U nited States
Governm ent securities on the Stock E x ch a n ge totaled
$221,0 0 0 ,0 0 0 , a sm aller volume o f transactions than in
the most active months o f this y e a r when prices were
rising, but 79 per cent, large r than transactions in Octo­
ber last year.
U n ite d

State s

G o v e r n m e n t S e c u r itie s

The October decline in L ib e rty bonds w as halted tem ­
p o ra rily at the end of the month, and prices rallied from
around 98 to considerably above 99. A f t e r the first fe w
d ays of Novem ber, however, prices weakened in sym ­
p a th y w ith the general bond list and declined again to
approxim ately the October low points. P ara llelin g these
general movements, the new T re a su ry 4 14 s recovered
from below 99 to above par, but closed the th ird week of
Novem ber at 99*4.
T ra d in g in U nited States Governm ent issues on the
Stock E x ch an ge d u rin g October totaled $154,000,000, a
higher figure than fo r previous months, due chiefly to
the listing of the new T re a su ry loan. * A c tiv ity de­
creased notably around the m iddle of November, accom­
p a n yin g easing in m oney conditions.
D ealers in T re a su ry certificates and notes reported a
quiet m arket d u rin g the first three weeks o f November.
O ffering rates on the whole showed little fluctuation and
were generally about 1 4 o f one p er cent, higher than
in the first week of October.
BILLIONS
OF DOLLARS




The

G o vern m en t D e b t

The T re a su ry statement of the public debt fo r October
3 1 shows the changes in the debt resulting from the sale
of about $764,000,000 of long term 4 y4 per cent. T re a su ry
bonds. ^ The total gross debt shows a tem porary increase,
but this is larg ely offset b y the increased balance in the
general fund, and there w as at the same time a decrease
in the short dated debt o f about $450,000,000.
The diagram on this page at the left shows the growth
of the total gross debt, and the debt that m atures w ithin
5 years, fo r the period du ring and im m ediately follow­
ing the w ar, and indicates a grad ual reduction of $3,50 0 ,000,000 since the high point on A u g u s t 3 1 , 1 9 1 9 . The
reductions in the short dated debt (m atu rin g w ithin 5
y ears) have amounted to about $3,100,000,000.
The diagram on the righ t illustrates the m anner in
w hich the e a rly m aturin g debt has been g ra d u a lly re ­
distributed into more convenient m aturities.
D u rin g
the w a r it w as the p olicy o f the T re a su ry to refu n d the
floating debt at intervals into long term L ib e rty bonds,
a process w hich is reflected in the diagram b y the
changes in the amount of the certificates of indebtedness
outstanding. A f t e r the A rm istice, however, conditions
made it desirable that refu n d in g should take the form o f
relatively short term issues, and $4,500,000,000 of 3 %
per cent, and 4 % per cent. V ic to ry notes were sold m a­
tu rin g M a y 20, 1 9 2 3 , but callable in whole or in p a rt on
Ju n e 1 5 and Decem ber 1 5 , 19 2 2 .
G radual retirem ent
through revenue d u rin g 19 2 0 and e a rly in 1 9 2 1 had re ­
duced somewhat the short dated debt, but the T re a su ry
in A p r il 1 9 2 1 still faced the necessity of meeting, the fo l­
low ing two years or thereabouts, m aturities m ain ly of
certificates and V ic to ry notes am ounting to about $7,50 0 ,000,000. The refu n din g first took the form o f short
term T re a su ry notes and six issues am ounting in the
BILLIONS
OF DOLLARS

FE D E R A L R E SE R V E AGENT A T NEW YORK

aggregate to about $2,750,000,000 have been sold. This
fa ll there came an op portunity fo r long term refun ding
and the issue of 2 5-30 y e a r T re a su ry bonds w as success­
fu lly sold in October.

R e d e m p tio n of V ic t o r y N o te s
A p p ro xim a tely 7 5 0 millions of V ic to ry notes have
been called fo r redemption on December 1 5 . Th e notes
which have been called and upon which interest w ill
cease upon that date, bear the distinguishing letters A ,
B , C , D , E or F , and constitute about h a lf of the entire
amount of 4 % per cent. V ic to r y notes now outstanding.
U nder the auth ority o f the S e cre ta ry o f the T reasu ry,
which continues u n til fu rth er notice, the F e d e ra l
Reserve B an ks w ill receive these notes fo r immediate
paym ent, i f the holder desires. B oth redemption and
prepaym ent m ay be handled either through the banks
or d irectly with a F e d e ra l R eserve B an k.
The Secretary of the T re a su ry has also authorized
u n til fu rth er notice the immediate paym ent, i f the
holder desires, of V ic to ry notes of the uncalled series.
These amount to about $900,000,000 and bear the dis­
tin guishin g letters G , H , I, J , K or L .
A l l o f the
uncalled series m ature on M a y 20* 19 2 3 .

R e d e m p tio n o f W a r -S a v in g

C e rtific a te s

On Novem ber 1 3 , the T re a su ry announced its p lan fo r
redeeming about $625,000,000 o f W a r-S a v in g s certifi­
cates of the series of 1 9 1 8 which fa ll due Ja n u a r y 1 , 1 9 2 3 .
B egin n in g Novem ber 1 5 , holders w ere perm itted to
exchange their w ar-savings issues through the post office,
F e d e ra l R eserve Banks, or T re a su ry D epartm ent fo r
new T re a su ry Sa v in g s certificates dated J a n u a r y 1 , 1 9 2 3 .
Su ch transactions can also be handled through the banks.
C ash redem ption o f w ar-savings issues w ill not be made
before Ja n u a r y 1 , but beginning Novem ber 1 5 , holders
were invited to fo rw a rd them in advance fo r redem p­
tion as o f Ja n u a r y 1 .
The new savings certificates w ill m ature Ja n u a r y 1 ,
19 28 , and yield 4 per cent., compounded sem i-annually,
if held to m aturity. Certificates m ay be redeemed before
m aturity at redemption values yield in g 3 per cent, simple
interest.

N ew

F in a n c in g

N ew financing du ring Novem ber was in sm aller
volume than in the previous month, and dealers reported
that there was no great pressure of business aw aiting
offering.
Dealers estimate that yield rates required
on new corporation issues of good grade have recently
advanced b y over 14 to n ea rly % of one per cent.
C orporation issues du ring Novem ber were generally
of small size, and public u tility offerings preponderated.
Slow er demand w as also reported fo r State and m unic­
ipal issues, and dealers in some cases found it necessary




5

to raise yield rates on unsold portions of offerings as
much as
of ° ne P er cent, to effect their distribution.
These conditions, coupled w ith prospective financing
voted at the recent elections, tended to make dealers
cautious in bidding fo r new issues and to restrict the
volume o f offerings.
F in a l totals of foreign offerings in this m arket du ring
October reached $68,000,000, the largest amount fo r a n y
month since Ju n e .
D u rin g the first three weeks of
Novem ber foreign offerings amounted to $24,000,000,
including $18,0 00,0 00 Chilean Governm ent 7 p er cent,
bonds, offered a t 9 6 ^ , which w ere reported to have
had a good distribution.

F o re ig n E x c h a n g e
E x ch a n ge rates on F ran ce, Belgium , and Ita ly fell
du rin g the p ast month to the lowest prices fo r the
y e a r but later recovered p ra ctica lly to the levels p re ­
va ilin g in October. F u r th e r declines in the exchange
value o f the m ark carried the B erlin rate to near 1 / 1 0 0
of a cent, a depreciation of 7 5 p er cent, from the value
of a month before.
Sterlin g held steady around $4.4 6 until the latter
p a rt o f the month w hen quotations advanced to $ 4 . 5 2 ^ ,
which w as the high point fo r the year. E x ch a n g e on
N o rw a y advanced furth er, accom panying the tran sfer
to N o rw a y o f the proceeds of the N orw egian Govern­
ment loan placed in the N ew Y o rk m arket the month
previous.
South A m erican rates were somewhat firm er than
in the month previous. Exch anges on In dia and Ja p a n
were steady and without im portant change but rates on
H on g K o n g and Sh an gh ai declined slightly.
The follow ing table compares changes in the prin cipal
rates from a month ago and a y e a r ago.

Country

Nov. 20
Last

4.4938
.0744
.0476
Italy.................................
.0002
Germany.........................
.0697
.3928
Holland...........................
.1866
Switzerland.....................
.1529
Spain................................
.2674
Sweden (Stockholm). ..
.3634
Argentina........................
.1253
Brazil...............................
.4844
Japan (Yokohama). . . .
China (Hong Kong). . .
.5388
.7213
China (Shanghai)..........
.3006
India................................
Canada............................ 1.0003
.6450
Bar Silver in New York.
*Silver exchange basis.

Change
from
Oct. 20

Change
from
Nov. 19
1921

Per cent,
depre­
ciation
from par

+ .0300
+ .0006
+ .0056
-.0 0 0 1
+ .0014
+ .0021
+ .0042
- .0 0 0 7
+ .0008
+ .0027
+ .0146
+ .0044
-.0 1 7 5
- .0 1 2 5
+ .0093
-.0 0 1 1
-.0 2 2 5

+ .4963
+ .0022
+ .0059
- .0 0 3 6
-.0 0 0 3
+ .0411
-.0 0 0 4
+ .0159
+ .0344
+ .0370
+ .0003
+ .0069
- .0 1 0 0
-.0 6 2 5
+ .0312
+ .0865
-.0 5 2 5

7.7
61.5
75.3
99.9
63.9
2 .3
3.3
20.8
0 .2
14.4
61.4
2.8
*
*
38.2
+ 0 .0 3

6

M O N TH LY R E V IE W

The tendency tow ards a reduction in the excess bal­
ance of exports in the past two years is shown more
clearly b y the follow ing table from the D ep artm en t’s
annual sum m ary.

A verage M onthly
E xport B alance

Six months July 1 to Dec. 30, 1920.................
“
Jan. 1 to July 1, 1921.....................
“
July 1 to Dec. 30, 1921...................
“
Dec. 30 to July 1, 1922..................
Three months July 1 to Oct. 1, 1922..............

W o r ld P r ic e s a n d N o t e

Depreciation of Foreign Exchange Rates from Par Value

F o re ig n T r a d e
October exports of m erchandise from the United
States totaling $372,000 ,0 00 were larger than those in
an y other month since M arch 1 9 2 1 , and 1 9 per cent,
more than in Septem ber. Publication o f im port figures
fo r October w as delayed on account of changes in classi­
fications and rates made necessary b y the new tariff
law.
The increase in exports m ay be attributed in large
p a rt to higher prices and an increased volume of cotton
shipments, which more than doubled the Septem ber fig­
ure, to 798,664 bales, the largest total fo r a n y month
since the h ea vy exports of October last year. E x p o rts
of meats and d a iry products increased somewhat, but
those of grain and grain products declined. C urrent
foreign bu yin g of A m erican wheat w as reported to be
light.

$274,674,811
202,333,636
126,980,328
66,887,576
51,623,542

C irc u la tio n

W o rld prices showed, in general, an u p w a rd tendency
in October follow ing declines in the two months preced­
ing. H ig h er price levels in most E u ro p ean countries
reflected rising quotations fo r the ra w m aterials of
m anufacture, p a rticu la rly textiles and metals.
The follow ing diagram s compare wholesale prices in
three countries w ith changes in currency circulation d u r­
ing the present year.
P rices have tended somewhat
dow nw ard in E n g la n d throughout 19 2 2 , closely p arallel­
ing a decline in note circulation, and accom panying an
u p w ard tendency in sterling exchange rates. In F ran ce,
however, the general trend o f wholesale prices this ye a r
has been u p w a rd as in the U nited States. In spite of a
considerable recent reduction follow ing a bond issue,
note circulation shows a net increase since the sp rin g of
the year.
I9 2 .a

192.0

W h ile reports of exporters recently have seemed to
indicate a grad u a lly increasing movement of general
m erchandise products, sellers of cotton goods found a
more restricted demand in November, w hich is ascribed
to high prices. Steel continues in ligh t request, and
Septem ber figures showed a decline in shipments for
the fourth successive month. Im ports of iron and steel
fo r September, on the other hand, w ere the largest in
th irty years, and were more than h a lf as large as the
export movement in these commodities.
F ig u re s published b y a p rivate agency indicated that
silk im ports during October w ere larger than in a n y
previous month.

Note Circulation and Prices in Three Countries Compared with
the 1920 Average

A review of foreign trade changes du ring the fiscal
year ended Ju n e 30, 19 2 2 , b y the D epartm ent of Com ­
merce, indicated a fa ll of 28.6 per cent, in the value of
im ports and o f 4 2 .1 p er cent, in the value of exports
compared w ith figures fo r 1 9 2 1 .

The level of prices in G erm any rose over 1 1 4 p er cent,
du ring October, accom panying an expansion of circu la­
tion b y over 3 5 per cent., and a fall in exchange of
more than 60 per cent. A va ila b le price indices from d if­
ferent countries are shown in the follow ing table.




7

F E D E R A L R E SER VE AG EN T A T N E W YO R K

(1913 average=100 per cent, unless otherwise noted)
Per C e n t . C hange D

Country

u r in g

Latest
Quotation
Sept.

Oct.

2.3
0

+ 3.1
- 1.3

— 0.6

+ 1.8

+ 3.2
+ 0 .7
+ 3 .8

-I- 0.1

+ 3.5

+ 6.8

-

-

1.6

+

-

1.3

+
-

1.6
0.6
1.8
1 .2
1.0

Aug.
United States:
20 basic com­
modities!. . . .
149 (Nor. 25)
Dept, of Labor
154 (Oct. av.)
Dun’s ...............
151 (Nov. 1)
Bradstreet’s . . .
145 (Nov. 1)
Great Britain:
158 (Nov. 1)
Economist. . . .
Statist..............
150 (Oct.
1)
20 basic com
moditiesi. . . .
141 (Nov. 25)
France.................
337 (Nov. 1)
Italy......................
601 (Nov. 1)
Japan...................
190 (Oct. av.)
Canada................
162 (Oct. 15)
Australia*............
158 (Sept.av.)
Norway*...............
221 (Nov. 1)
155 (Oct. 15)
Sweden*...............
Denmark*............
180 (Nov. 1)
Germany*............ 94,492 (Nov. 1)
Shanghai?..............
106 (Oct.
1)

Increases of 8 or 9 p er cent, in the prices of wheat,
corn, and cotton w ere la rg e ly responsible for carry in g
the farm products group u p w ard .
The prin cipal in­
crease, reflected in the movement of the miscellaneous
group, w as a 40 p er cent, advance in rubber prices.

-

3.1
3.3r

+ 0.2
+ 1.9r
4- 2.5
- 2.9

-

1.1

-

1.3

-

2 .2
1 .2
1.1

+ 107.5

-

2.0

+ 1.9
- 0 .9
- 3.1

-

1.1

+ 5 2 .5

-

1.7

+ 2.7
+ 2 .4
+ 3.3

-

1 .2

-

0 .3

-

1.8

- 1.9
+ 2.3
+ 114.3

0 .1

The latest values of the groups m aking up the D ep art­
ment of L ab o r index together w ith recent changes are
shown in the follow ing table.

Commodity Group

Farm products..........
Foods......................
Cloths and clothing..
Fuel and lighting.. ..
Metals.........................
Building materials. ..
Chemicals and drugs.
House fum’g goods...
Miscellaneous.............
All groups..............

Computed by this bank. *July 1914 = 100. aDec. 31, 1913— June
30, 1914 = 100. <July 1, 1913— June 30, 1914 = 100.
*July 1912—
June 1914 = 100. tfuly 1914 = 100. ?Sept. 1919 = 100.
r— Revised.

G o ld M o v e m e n t
Prelim in ary reports fo r October show gold im ports of
$20,866,000 and exports of $17 ,5 9 2 ,0 0 0 , nearly all of the
latter to Canada. Th is is the largest amount exported
in an y month since Novem ber 19 2 0 and the net excess of
imports, $3,274,0 0 0 , is the smallest since the inflow of
gold began in Septem ber 19 20 . The sources o f im ports
are shown in the follow ing table.
(000 omitted)
Sept.
1922

Oct.
1922

England................................... $13,270
583
Sweden.....................................
393
Canada.....................................
870
China and Hong Kong.........
890
France......................................
1,115
Denmark.................................
333
Mexico.....................................
642
Colombia.................................
996
All other...................................

$8,442
114
232
971
2,070

$9,927
296
95
596
2,635

674
651
11,310

326
581
6,410

$94,368
32,798
9,041
6,408
19,605
17,769
4,850
6,236
39,300

Total................................. $19,092

$24,464

$20,866

$230,375

Country

Aug.
1922

Total
1922

D o m e s t i c W h o le s a l e P r i c e s
A continued decline d u rin g October in the price of
fu el w as more than offset in the D epartm ent o f Lab o r
index of wholesale prices b y considerable increases in
the farm products, clothing, and miscellaneous groups.
There w as some increase in all groups w ith the excep­
tion of fuel and lighting, and chemicals and drugs.




Value
of
Index
Oct.
1922

Per Cent. Change
Aug.
to
Sept.

Sept.
to
Oct.

Per
Cent.
Incr.
from
Low

138
140
188
226
135
183
124
176
120

+

1.5
0
+ 1.1
-1 0 .0
+ 6.3
+ 4 .7
+ 1.6
0
+ 0.9

+ 3 .8
+ 1 .4
+ 2 .7
-7 .4
+ 0 .7
+ 1 .7
0
+ 1 .7
+ 3 .4

21.1
6.9
9.9
24.9
23.9
18.1
2.5
1.7
5.3

June
Jan.
Apr.
Sept.
Mar.
Mar.
July
Sept.
June

154

-

+ 0 .7

11.6

Jan. 1922

1.3

Date of
Low

1921
1922
1922
1921
1922
1922
1922
1922
1922

Th is b an k 's index num ber fo r the prices of 20 basic
commodities showed an increase o f 1 p er cent, du rin g
the first 3 weeks o f November. The rise in prices of
wheat and cotton continued until the th ird week of the
month, when some reaction occurred.
C o st of L iv in g
F o llo w in g some months behind the increase in whole­
sale prices, the cost of liv in g index num ber of the
N ational In d u strial Conference B o ard fo r the U nited
States continued in October the rise begun in Septem ber.
The October increase w as sligh tly larger, am ounting to 1
per cent., and w as the largest advance since M arch of this
year. Fo o d prices increased 2 .1 per cent., and clothing
1 .3 p er cent., while other items rem ained unchanged.
The D epartm ent o f L a b o r reported an increase of
3 per cent, in October in the cost of food in N ew Y o rk
C ity . There has been a total advance of 6 per cent,
since the low level of M arch 19 2 2 and the index is
now 5 1 per cent, higher than in 1 9 1 4 .
E m p lo y m e n t a n d W a g e s
The N ew Y o rk State D epartm ent of Labor, in its
m onthly su rvey of employment, found an increase of
3 per cent, between Septem ber 1 5 and October 1 5 in the
number of w orkers employed in the factories of the
State. A l l groups of m an ufactu ring industries added
to their w orking forces w ith the exception of plants that
handle food products, in w hich a seasonal decline took
place, follow ing the close of the canning season.
Th e follow ing diagram compares the number of w ork­
ers now em ployed in each of eleven leading industries

8

MONTHLY REVIEW

in this State w ith the num ber employed in J u l y 1 9 1 4 ,
and at the lowest point since 19 20 . Th e increase in the
total num ber of workers since A u g u st 1 9 2 1 , when em­
ploym ent w as at its lowest point, has been 1 9 p er cent.,
and the num ber of workers is now n ea rly 5 per cent,
larger than in Ju n e 1 9 14 .
19T4-

tO O V o
LOW SINCE

INDUSTRY

J 1920

1922

Number of Workers Employed in Principal Industries in New York
State Compared with the Number in 1914 and at the Low Point
since 1920

Em ploym ent agencies in this district continue to
report a shortage o f common labor and o f certain typ es
o f skilled workers accom panied b y increasing w age
rates. The shortage has not extended to clerical w ork­
ers although there have been a num ber of isolated cases
o f w age increases among such workers.
D e p o s its

Deposits of reporting savings banks in N ew Y o rk
C ity declined sligh tly between October 1 0 and Novem ber
10 , follow ing an u n u su ally h eavy increase in the month
previous. In other cities o f the Second F e d e ra l R eserve
D istrict deposits showed a fu rth e r increase. In three o f
the five years d u rin g which these figures have been
tabulated, deposits of the reporting banks in N ew Y o rk
have declined and those in other cities have increased
at this tim e o f y ear.
P r o d u c t i o n in B a s i c I n d u s t r i e s
October w as a month o f largely increased production
in basic industries, p a rtic u la rly in iron and steel, and
other m etal industries.
O utput of bituminous coal fo r the month, as reported
in the prelim inary estimates of the U nited States Geo­
logical S u rv e y , w as 4 5 ,15 4 ,0 0 0 tons, an advance of
4 ,14 1,0 0 0 tons over Septem ber figures, and about 7 5 per
cent, of estimated norm al production. In the W e st V i r ­
ginia, and K en tu ck y fields, production is still ham pered
b y inadequate transportation facilities. I n the middle
west, on the other hand, reports of lack of m arket occur
w ith increasing frequency, due as f a r as can be ascer­
tained to b u y e rs’ dissatisfaction w ith current asking
prices rather than to absence of demand. Production




September 1.
October 1. . .
November 1.

22.000.000 tons
28.000.000 tons
35.000.000 tons

17 days’ supply
22 days’ supply
27 days’ supply

OCT.

BOOTS 8 SHOES
CAR BUILDINGLEATHER
COTTON GOODS
IRON&^TEEL
PAPER
WOOLEN G00D5
MEN'S CLOTHING
SILK GOODS
KNIT GOODS
CIGARS-TOBACCO
A INDUSTRIES
LL

S a v in g s B a n k

as a whole is in advance of requirements, and stocks in
the hands of commercial consumers, as reported to the
F e d e ra l F u e l D istributor, have increased since the te r­
m ination of the strike as fo llo w s: „

A n th ra cite coal mined du rin g October amounted to
8,530,000 tons, almost twice the Septem ber production.
Shipm ents from the mines w ere about 2,000,000 tons
less than the amount produced, and transportation fa c il­
ities of railroads were taxed to capacity.
Production of p ig iron d u rin g October totaled 2 ,6 38 ,000 tons, the largest output since Decem ber 19 20 . D a ily
blast furn ace c ap a city in operation increased from
77,0 0 5 tons at the outset of the month to 8 7 ,9 35 at the
close.
Th e month has been m arked b y a dow nw ard
revision o f prices. The m arket along the seaboard has
been affected b y im portation, inasm uch as 200,000 tons
of B ritish and Continental iron have recently been de­
livered at prices below A m erican quotations.
Steel ingot production fo r October w as 3,28 3,0 0 0 tons,
as com pared w ith 2 ,7 13,0 0 0 tons du ring Septem ber, an
increase of 2 1 p er cent. Unfilled orders fo r finished
products on the books o f the U nited States Steel C o r­
poration October 3 1 amounted to 6,902,000 tons, as com­
p ared w ith 6,692,000 tons Septem ber 30 , an increase of
3 per cent.
F r e ig h t embargoes contributed to this
increase. A s in recent months, r a ilw a y supplies consti­
tuted the bulk o f new business and dem and fo r general
products w as less active. O rders fo r stru ctu ral m aterial,
fo r example, w hich in A p r il amounted to 8 5 p er cent, of
shop cap acity, declined d u rin g October to 5 5 p er cent.
The follow ing table shows production fo r the past six
months, expressed as percentages of estimated norm al
production. I n estim ating normal, allowance has been
made fo r y e a r to y e a r growth, and seasonal variations.
(Estimated normal production = 100 per cent.)
Commodity
Anthracite coal.........................
Bituminous coalr.....................
Steel ingots...............................
Copper, U. S. mine..................
Tin deliveries............................
Crude petroleum......................
Portland cement.......................
Wheat flour...............................
Meat slaughtered.....................
Sugar meltings U. S. Ports. ..
Cotton consumption................
Wood pulp.................................
Tobacco consumption.............
Paper (total).............................
Wool consumption*.................

May June July Aug. Sept. Oct.
.4
41
73
81
70
92
51
111
119
100
108
146
88
108
91
100
96
116e

^Seasonal variation not allowed for.
ary. e — Estimated.

1.0
43
79
82
75
90
53
110
120
104
112
135
92
110
97
100
101
116e

1.4
32
82
79
75
75
60
110
128
142
99
131
84
105
90
93
109
103 e

1.9
46
61
70
86
77
59
112r
121
117
109
144
97
105
103
107
103
126e

61
72
68
74
80 r
92
62
111
123
112r
105
110
92
102
99
105
104
121 e

94p
7dp
83
85
84p
103
75
112p
126
109
103p
108
95
88

i3 i«

r— Revised, p— Prelimin-

FE D E R A L RE SE R V E AGENT A T NEW YO R K

PER

PER.
: ent

C ent
:
150

150

NM ^
OA
RL

A
A

100

100

h
50

50

PIG IRON

suerAR.
1 ....
.

0

0

150

150
i

100

^

A /v

n O R rlA L

/

- A
J

\ A'

100

Ir

50

50

U
J
X
£

BITM COAL
0

F CUR
L

KT

i

0

150

150

NM
OA
RL

100

V

“VvA
A

50

r

*

100

50

COT1‘ON
0

0

150

150

/A a\
V

100

Vs

NM
OA
RL

A
.

50

100

50

PETR.O
LEUM

TOB>\cco
.... 1 ..

0

0

-------- 1
150

150

100

y

/A - V---- V NM
OA
RL
\
1

100

50

50

R
PAPIE .
i

0

1916




1919

I9 £ 0

192.1

1922

1918

1919

0

192.0

192.1

Production in Basic Industries (Estimated Normal Production = 100 Per Cent.)

\9ZZ

10

M O N TH LY R E V IE W

Railway Traffic
A s a result o f the continued h eavy movement of coal
and of the delayed shipment of grain because of car
shortages in the northwest the seasonal decline in car
loadings which norm ally begins ea rly in October did not
begin this ye a r until ea rly in Novem ber and the decline
has been at a slower rate than usual. A f t e r the middle
of October car loadings were fo r some weeks even larger
than the h eavy traffic o f 19 20 .
The freigh t car shortage increased steadily through­
out October, reaching 180,000 cars on October 30, the
largest shortage ever reported.
Th is shortage w as
m ainly in the central western and northwestern States.
Recent operating statistics indicate higher efficiency in
handling cars. The average freigh t car load was raised
from 2 5 tons in J u l y to over 2 7 tons in Septem ber and
the average d a ily car movement increased from 2 1 miles
in J u l y to over 2 4 miles in Septem ber. M oreover the
num ber of cars needing rep air had been reduced b y N o ­
vem ber 1 to the lowest figure since M arch 1 9 2 1 .
W h o le s a le T r a d e
The gain in the volume o f wholesale business in this
district, which w as first noted in A u g u s t and Septem ­
ber, continued d u rin g October w ith increased momen­
tum.
The weighted average of wholesale trade, com­
puted b y this bank from reports of dealers in ten p rin ­
cipal commodities, shows that the dollar value of sales
w as 1 3 per cent, above th at of October 1 9 2 1 , as com­
p ared w ith a gain o f 1 0 per cent, in Septem ber over a
yea r ago. October sales were the largest of a n y month
since the autum n of 19 2 0 .
The trend of sales d u rin g the past fou r years is shown
in the diagram at the foot of this page. The dollar sales
figures have been adjusted, as n e a rly as it is possible to
do so from the available data, to make allowance for
normal seasonal changes. The trend of wholesale prices
du rin g the same period is also shown, computed from the
group price indices o f the Departm ent o f Labor. The
ph ysical volume of sales has been estimated b y d ividin g
the dollar sales b y the prices p revailin g du ring each
month.




The diagram shows that during 19 20 , when both dol­
lar sales and prices were highest, the actual amount of
merchandise distributed w as lowest, reflecting restricted
bu yin g b y retailers.
In 1 9 2 1 and 1 9 2 2 as retailers'
stocks were reduced, the volume of wholesale transac­
tions began to increase. In the past few months this
increase has been quickened, and the amount of m er­
chandise distributed b y these dealers d u rin g Septem ber
and October has probably been greater than du rin g a n y
other month fo r w hich figures are available.
The diagram also reveals the tendency of m erchants
du ring the past two years to b u y fo r immediate needs
only. The volume of business has not been distributed
du rin g the y e a r as form erly, but has been greatest d u r­
ing the sp rin g and fa ll months, coinciding w ith the bu sy
seasons fo r retail distributors.
W holesale m erchants whose business is nation-wide
report that sales to customers in western, m iddle-western, and southern States have been p a rtic u la rly good,
and the increase in sales in those States has been rela­
tiv e ly greater than the increase in sales in the northA tla n tic States.

T

otal

N

et

Sa l e s

(in percentages)
Oct.
1919
All Commodities (weighted). .
Machine Tools...........................
Jewelry........................................
Stationery...................................
Diamonds...................................
Hardware....................................
Drugs...........................................
Groceries......................................
Clothing......................................
(a) Men’s ...............................
(b) Women’s ..........................
Dry Goods..................................
Shoes............................................

Oct.
1920

Oct.
1921

Oct.
1922

Sept.*
1922

127
554
241
146
217
129
110
135
91
69
149
118
219

107
564
186
173
107
129
107
122
102
90
133
78
80

100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100

113
342
132
131
130
118
113
113
112
95
158
103
95

110
413
123
98
208
122
108
106
129
134
119
95
102

♦September 1922 figures are expressed in percentages of sales in
September 1921.

11

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW YORK

Department Store Business
Sales b y departm ent stores in this district were re­
tarded du ring the early p a rt o f October b y unseasonably
w arm weather w hich delayed the b u yin g of fa ll and
w in ter w earing apparel. D u rin g the latter p a rt of the
month sales increased and fo r the month as a whole
showed a gain of 4 .5 p er cent, over those o f October last
year. This compares w ith an increase of 1 6 per cent,
reported for the previous month.
Sales b y Buffalo, Rochester and N ew ark stores w ere
relatively larger than those b y N e w Y o rk C ity m erchants,
in contrast w ith the tendency, evident fo r several
months previous, fo r sales in the M etropolitan area to
expand more ra p id ly than those in other sections o f the
district.
A tendency to purchase a better q u ality of m erchan­
dise w as even more evident in October than in Septem ­
ber. There w as an increased dem and fo r fine furn iture,
oriental rugs, pianos and other m usical instruments, fine
linens and the highest q u ality of w earin g apparel. E v i ­
dence o f this change in the character of purchases is
found in an increase of 8.4 p er cent, in the average indi­
vidual sale from $ 2 .9 8 in October 1 9 2 1 to $ 3 .2 3 this year.
D etailed sales and stock figures are shown in the fol­
lowing table.

T

otal

N

et

Sa l e s

(In Percentages)

St o c k
(S e l l i n g P r i c e )

(In Percentages)

Nov. Nov. Nov. Nov.
Oct. Oct. Oct. Oct.
1,
1,
1,
1,
1919 1920 1921 1922 1919 1920 1921 1922
94
All Dept. Stores..
New York........
97
84
Buffalo...
Newark.............
91
Rochester. . . . .
87
Syracuse........... 102
Bridgeport........ 104
Elsewhere in 2d
82
District.........
Apparel Stores. . . 88
Mail Ord. Houses 178

98
97
99
102
104
107
113

100
100
100
100
100
100
100

104
104
109
110
107
104
103

98
98
96
98
118
126
103

118
118
115
121
136
150
118

100
100
100
100
100
100
100

98
97
92
96
97
98
100

94
93
116

100
100
100

90
106
124

84
89
**

102
110
***

100
100
***

93
108
***

Stocks held b y departm ent stores on Novem ber 1 were
2 per cent, below those held on the same date last year.
Th is reduction, coupled w ith the somewhat larger sales,
has resulted in a more rap id stock turnover.
M erchants are m aking plans fo r an u n u su ally large
Christm as business. D u rin g the past two weeks they
have received large shipments o f h oliday goods and the
sales forces are being increased. O utstanding orders on
Novem ber 1 amounted to 8.2 p er cent, o f the total p u r­
chases d u rin g the previous calendar y ea r as compared
with 6.0 per cent, one y e a r ago.
M ail order sales in October were 2 4 p er cent, above
those of last October, the largest gain since the autum n
of 19 20 . Th is increase is a reflection of la rg e r purchas­
in g pow er in farm in g districts, where the m ail order
houses find their chief market.
Th e follow ing diagram compares the sales b y m ail
order houses w ith sales b y departm ent stores in all sec­
tions of the U nited States, as compiled b y the F e d e ra l




Reserve Board. In each instance allowances have been
made fo r seasonal variations.
Throughout the latter
p art of 19 20 , d u rin g 1 9 2 1 , and thus f a r in 19 2 2 , sales of
departm ent stores in the larger cities have been larger
in comparison w ith 1 9 1 9 average sales than sales b y
m ail order houses, but recent increases in m ail order
sales have brought the two lines somewhat nearer to­
gether.
PER
CENT.

150

1.25

A
DEPARTM NT
f
STORE*

f \

\
10 0

1919 AVERAO&

h

V *
•
75

\

i

* ;/

’•
*./

\ .
• V*
*
MAIL DRDER
HOU SES

50

25

1920

\9ZZ

1921

192.3

Sales by Department Stores Throughout the United States Com­
pared with Sales of Principal Mail Order Houses (1919 Average
= 100 Per Cent.)

C h a in S to re S a le s
October sales b y chain store systems that report to
this bank w ere 8 per cent, larger than those o f last
October. The chief increase, am ounting to 1 2 p er cent.,
was reported b y chain grocery organizations and w as
due to the opening of about 2,400 new stores du ring the
y e a r ; average sales p er store were lower.
Sales b y chain shoe stores declined 1 3 p er cent, due
p a rtly to a decline of 7 .2 p er cent, in the average price
per p a ir from $ 3 .8 7 last October to $ 3 .5 9 this ye a r and
p a rtly to a decrease of 5 .7 per cent, in the num ber of
pairs sold.
Number
of Stores
Type
of Store

Grocery. . .
Apparel. . .
TenCent. .
Drug..........
Cigar
Shoe..........
Total. . .

Oct.
1921

Oct.
1922

6,378 8,765
433
370
1,598 1,666
280
281
2,248 2,670
218
192
11,067 14,032

Total Net Sales
(In percentages)

Oct. Oct. Oct. Oct.
1919 1920 1921 1922
94
69
76
88
80
95
83

104
100
92
101
109
105
100

100
100
100
100
100
100
100

112
112
110
100
92
87
108

Per cent,
change
in Sales
per Store
Oct. 1921
to Oct. 1922
-1 8 .6
- 4.0
+ 5.9
+ 0.5
-2 2 .5
-2 3 .0
-1 5 .1

W h a t

th e

R eserve

V E R Y week the F e d eral Reserve B o ard an ­
nounces through the press a statement of condi­
tion of all twelve F ed eral Reserve Banks, show­
ing their prin cip al assets and liabilities, and also showing
w h at is known as the reserve ratio, or reserve percentage.
This reserve ratio freq uen tly is singled out for editorial
comment, and is often considered an indicator of the
state of credit throughout the country.
B u t fo r its
proper interpretation, it is necessary to understand the
circum stances which influence it at all times, and to
make allowance for such special conditions as m ay occa­
sionally prevail, for exam ple the recent immense im ­
portation of gold.

E

F u n c t io n

of

B a n k R eserv es

G en erally speaking, a reserve is a fu n d set aside for
em ergency use. R eserves are m aintained b y business
men as well as b y banks. B u t in the case of banks
the law specifies w h at reserves shall be maintained, for
the better protection of their depositors. The amount of
reserve required fo r a bank which is a member of the
Fe d e ra l Reserve system depends on the size of the com­
m un ity in which the bank is located and the nature of
its deposits. On the average throughout the country the
reserve required fo r a member bank is about 10 per cent,
of the amount of its deposits p ayable on demand.
In the same w a y , Reserve B an ks must keep in reserve
a certain proportion of their funds, and because of the
fa ct that the R eserve B an k s c a r ry reserves fo r other
banks, the percentage is much higher— 3 5 per cent,
of the amount of their deposits, and 40 per cent, of the
amount of their n o te s; but fo r purposes of convenience
and ease of reference the published reserve percentage is
a single figure. Th is figure is the proportion which the
total reserves bear to the amount of both deposits and
notes. Thus a 7 5 per cent, reserve ratio (or percentage)
means that the Reserve B an ks have reserves in gold or
law fu l money which amount to three-quarters of the sum
o f their deposits and notes.

E lem ents

in th e

R atio

The reserve ratio of the Reserve B an ks m ay therefore
be affected b y a n y one of three factors,— a change in the
amount of cash reserves, a change in the amount of note
issues, or a change in the amount of deposits. Changes
in the cash reserves, however, affect the ratio more
than do changes in either of the other two items.
This m ay be illustrated best b y an example. On N ovem ­
ber 22, 19 2 2 , the cash reserves of the R eserve B an ks
were $3,219,000 ,0 00 .
Deposits were $1,895,000,000,
and notes in circulation $2,299,000,000.
The reserve
percentage is computed from the fraction
3,219,000,000
3,219,000,000
---------------------- ---------------------------- o r ----------------------- ,
2,299,000,000 plus 1,895,000,000
4,194,000,000
which equals 7 6 .7 per cent. I t is clear, arithm etically,
that an increase or decrease of $100,000,000 in cash re ­
serves, shown above the line, affects the percentage more
than a like change in deposits or notes, shown below
the line. This alw ays holds true as long as the reserves
are less than deposits plus notes.

E ffect

of

H ea vier

or

L ig h t e r C redit D e m a n d s

U nder ord in ary circum stances of w orld trade it is
probable that the stock of gold in the cou ntry would
not v a r y greatly, certainly not to the extent that has
occurred in recent years.
O rd in arily the p rin cip al
changes would take place in the figures below the
line, nam ely in the Reserve B an k deposits and note
issues.
The w a y in w hich such changes would come
about, and the reserve ratio be thereby affected m ay




R a tio

M ean s

be illustrated b y the follow ing example.
A m er­
chant of B ata via , N. Y ., finding his business growing,
is in need of additional funds w ith which to increase
his stock of goods. H e goes to his bank and obtains a
loan, p a rt of which he m ay wish to receive in the form
of a deposit credit against w hich he m ay d raw checks,
and p a rt of which he m ay wish to receive in currency.
I f his b a n k ’s reserve is high, it m ay be able to su p p ly
him without borrowing.
B u t if business is exceptionally active the bank itself
m ay have to borrow in order to accommodate the m er­
chant and its other customers.
I t borrows perhaps
$100 ,000 at the Reserve B ank, receiving in return F e d ­
eral Reserve notes or a deposit on the books of the R e ­
serve B an k which under the law serves as reserve against
the increased deposits of its customers. The Reserve
B an k does not p a y out or p a rt w ith a n y of the cash com­
posing its reserve, but the aggregate of its deposits and
notes is increased $100 ,000 and the reserve ratio is pro­
portionately lowered.
Conversely, when business a ctivity is dim inishing, the
B a ta v ia m erchant and m an y others like him, are p a yin g
off their loans at their banks and at the same time c u r­
ren cy is being released from circulation and deposited
in the banks. W ith these receipts the banks in tu rn re­
duce their borrowings at the Reserve Banks. The cash
composing the reserves of the R eserve B an ks is not in ­
creased, but their deposits and notes are decreased, and
the reserve ratio is proportionately raised.
Thus if conditions were such that the gold reserve
rem ained p ra ctica lly stationary, the reserve percentage
would reflect directly the changing needs of business and
agriculture. Its low ering w ould mean a grow ing vol­
ume of commercial activity, accom panied b y an increased
credit demand upon the banks and a grad ual n arro w in g
of the m argin of available credit. Its rising, on the other
hand, would mean a slackening pace of industry, an
easing in the credit demand, and a replenishing of the
credit reservoir.

E ffe c t

of

G old I m po r ts

or

E x po r ts

B u t present conditions are not such that the gold
reserve of the F e d e ra l Reserve B an k s rem ains station­
ary.
In the past two years it has increased more
th an a billion dollars, p ra ctica lly all of w hich represents
im portations of gold. In the e a rly stages o f the gold
movement, when the gold found its w a y into the Reserve
Banks it p aid debts owing b y the member b a n k s; latterly
it has perm itted the member banks to increase their
deposits to the highest point ever reached and at the
same time to m aintain the reserves th at the law requires
w ith v e ry little borrow ing from the R eserve Banks.
The combined effect of these huge gold im ports, in­
creasing the reserves, and of sim ultaneous h eavy
redemptions of F e d e ral Reserve notes, decreasing the
liabilities, has been to b rin g about the present reserve
ratio of about 7 7 per cent., which compares w ith the
ratio of 85 per cent, when A m erica entered the w a r and
the ratio of 4 2 .5 per cent, in the autum n of 19 2 0 when
the credit strain w as at its peak.
The present high reserve ratio, then, is in large p a rt
due to the recent flow of gold to the U nited States from
countries w hich fo r the time being are not on the free
gold basis which obtained before the w ar. A retu rn to
such a basis, under which gold would flow fre e ly into or
out of such countries in settlement of international bal­
ances, would, if our balances w ere adverse, cause a cor­
responding outflow of our gold. This would decrease
our reserve ratio, e xa ctly as recent im ports have in ­
creased it.