View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
List of Subjects in 7 CFR Part 984
Marketing agreements, Nuts,
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements, Walnuts.
For the reasons set forth in the
preamble, 7 CFR part 984 is amended as
follows:
PART 984—WALNUTS GROWN IN
CALIFORNIA
1. The authority citation for 7 CFR
part 984 continues to read as follows:

■

Authority: 7 U.S.C. 601–674.

2. Section 984.347 is revised to read
as follows:

■

§ 984.347

Assessment rate.

On and after September 1, 2011, an
assessment rate of $0.0175 per
kernelweight pound is established for
California merchantable walnuts.
Dated: October 26, 2011.
David R. Shipman,
Acting Administrator, Agricultural Marketing
Service.
[FR Doc. 2011–28198 Filed 10–31–11; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 3410–02–P

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
12 CFR Part 243
[Regulation QQ; Docket No. R–1414]
RIN 7100–AD73

FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE
CORPORATION
12 CFR Part 381
RIN 3064 AD 77

Resolution Plans Required
Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System (Board) and
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation
(Corporation).
ACTION: Final rule.
AGENCY:

The Board and the
Corporation (together the ‘‘Agencies’’)
are adopting this final rule to implement
the requirement in a section of the
Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act (the ‘‘DoddFrank Act’’) regarding resolution plans.
The Dodd-Frank Act section requires
each nonbank financial company
designated by the Financial Stability
Oversight Council (the ‘‘Council’’) for
enhanced supervision by the Board and
each bank holding company with assets
of $50 billion or more to report
periodically to the Board, the
Corporation, and the Council the plan of

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

SUMMARY:

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

such company for rapid and orderly
resolution in the event of material
financial distress or failure.
DATES: The rule is effective November
30, 2011.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Board: Barbara J. Bouchard, Senior
Associate Director, (202) 452–3072,
Michael D. Solomon, Associate Director,
(202) 452–3502, or Avery I. Belka,
Counsel, (202) 736–5691, Division of
Banking Regulation and Supervision; or
Ann E. Misback, Associate General
Counsel, (202) 452–3788, Dominic A.
Labitzky, Senior Attorney, (202) 452–
3428, or Bao Nguyen, Attorney, (202)
736–5599, Legal Division; Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve
System, 20th and C Streets, NW.,
Washington, DC 20551. Users of
Telecommunication Device for Deaf
(TDD) only, call (202) 263–4869.
Corporation: Joseph Fellerman, Senior
Program Analyst, (202) 898–6591, Office
of Complex Financial Institutions,
Richard T. Aboussie, Associate General
Counsel, (703) 562–2452, David N. Wall,
Assistant General Counsel, (703) 562–
2440, Mark A. Thompson, Counsel,
(703) 562–2529, or Mark G. Flanigan,
Counsel, (202) 898–7426, Legal
Division.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
To promote financial stability, section
165(d) of the Dodd-Frank Act requires
each nonbank financial company
supervised by the Board and each bank
holding company with total
consolidated assets of $50 billion or
more (each a ‘‘covered company’’) to
periodically submit to the Board, the
Corporation, and the Council a plan for
such company’s rapid and orderly
resolution in the event of material
financial distress or failure. That section
also requires each covered company to
report on the nature and extent of credit
exposures of such covered company to
significant bank holding companies and
significant nonbank financial companies
and the nature and extent of credit
exposures of significant bank holding
companies and significant nonbank
financial companies to such covered
company.1 This final rule implements
the resolution plan requirement set forth
in section 165(d)(1) of the Dodd-Frank
Act.
Plans filed under section 165(d)(1)
will assist covered companies and
regulators in conducting advance
resolution planning for a covered
company. As demonstrated by the
Corporation’s experience in failed bank
1 See

PO 00000

generally 12 U.S.C. 5365(d).

Frm 00009

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67323

resolutions, as well as the Board’s and
the Corporation’s experience in the
recent crisis, advance planning
improves the efficient resolution of a
covered company. Advance planning
has long been a component of resiliency
and recovery planning by financial
companies. The resolution plan
required of covered companies under
this final rule will support the
Corporation’s planning for the exercise
of its resolution authority under the
Dodd-Frank Act and the Federal Deposit
Insurance Act (‘‘FDI Act’’) by providing
the Corporation with an understanding
of the covered companies’ structure and
complexity as well as their resolution
strategies and processes. The resolution
plan required of covered companies
under this final rule will also assist the
Board in its supervisory efforts to ensure
that covered companies operate in a
manner that is both safe and sound and
that does not pose risks to financial
stability generally. In addition, these
plans will enhance the Agencies’
understanding of the U.S. operations of
foreign banks and improve efforts to
develop a comprehensive and
coordinated resolution strategy for a
cross-border firm.
The final rule requires each covered
company to produce a resolution plan,
or ‘‘living will,’’ that includes
information regarding the manner and
extent to which any insured depository
institution affiliated with the company
is adequately protected from risks
arising from the activities of nonbank
subsidiaries of the company; detailed
descriptions of the ownership structure,
assets, liabilities, and contractual
obligations of the company;
identification of the cross-guarantees
tied to different securities; identification
of major counterparties; a process for
determining to whom the collateral of
the company is pledged; and other
information that the Board and the
Corporation jointly require by rule or
order.2 The final rule requires a strategic
analysis by the covered company of how
it can be resolved under Title 11 of the
U.S. Code (the ‘‘Bankruptcy Code’’) in a
way that would not pose systemic risk
to the financial system. In doing so, the
company must map its core business
lines and critical operations to material
legal entities and provide integrated
analyses of its corporate structure; credit
and other exposures; funding, capital,
and cash flows; the domestic and
foreign jurisdictions in which it
operates; and its supporting information
systems for core business lines and
critical operations.
2 See

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

12 U.S.C. 5365(d)(1).

01NOR1

67324

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

II. Notice of Proposed Rulemaking:
Summary of Comments
On April 22, 2011, the Board and the
Corporation invited public comment on
a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking:
Resolution Plans and Credit Exposure
Reports Required (the ‘‘proposed rule’’
or ‘‘proposal’’).3 The comment period
ended on June 10, 2011. The Board and
the Corporation collectively received 22
comment letters from a range of
individuals and banking organizations,
as well as industry and trade groups
representing banking, insurance, and
the broader financial services industry.
In addition, the Board and the
Corporation met with industry
representatives to discuss issues relating
to the proposed rule.
While the commenters generally
expressed support for the broader goals
of the proposed rule to require covered
companies to plan for their orderly
liquidation or restructuring in
bankruptcy during times of material
financial distress, many commenters
also expressed concerns about various
aspects of the proposed rule. The
comments the Board and the
Corporation received fit into four broad
categories: comments that focused on
the resolution planning requirement,
including the required informational
content, of the proposed rule; comments
that addressed the credit exposure
reporting requirement; comments
regarding the application of the
proposed rule to foreign-banking
organizations (‘‘FBOs’’); and comments
concerned with the confidential
treatment of information provided as
part of a resolution plan or credit
exposure report. These comments are
summarized below.

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

i. Substantive Resolution Plan
Requirements
With respect to the resolution plan
requirement, some commenters
suggested that the resolution plan
requirement adopt a ‘‘principle-based’’
approach with the specific content of
each plan developed through the
iterative supervisory process, and that
the Agencies’ review of each plan be
tied to the scope and planning decided
on between individual firms and the
Agencies as part of that process. In
contrast, another commenter suggested
that the plans be very specific and
operationally oriented; further
suggesting that such plans should
include, among other things, practice
exercises to test readiness and detailed
descriptions of actions to be taken to
facilitate rapid and orderly resolution.
3 76

FR 22,648 (April 22, 2011).

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

Similarly, another commenter suggested
that the final rule should provide
detailed guidance regarding the strategic
analysis, facilitate the creation of a
structured data source for requested
data, and adopt a submission framework
to be used in the creation and review of
the resolution plan. Commenters also
suggested that the final rule draw a clear
distinction between the limited
resolution plan required by the DoddFrank Act and the broader resolution
planning process that may be required
as a prudential matter.
A number of commenters argued that
insurance companies and other entities
that are not subject to the Bankruptcy
Code should be exempted from the
resolution plan requirement, be allowed
to file streamlined plans, or, where such
companies are a part of a covered
company, be excluded from such
covered company’s resolution plan.
Others questioned how a resolution
plan should address such entities. One
commenter suggested that managers of
money market funds should be
excluded from the requirements of the
proposed rule. Some commenters
specifically requested that (i) The final
resolution plan requirement reflect and
conform to section 203(e) of the DoddFrank Act, which provides that any
insurance company that is a covered
financial company or a subsidiary
thereof will be liquidated or
rehabilitated under applicable state law;
and (ii) the Agencies accept as a
credible resolution plan an insurance
company’s statement of its intent to
submit itself, or its insurance
subsidiaries, to applicable state
liquidation or rehabilitation regimes.
One commenter suggested that the
scope of the final rule should go beyond
bankruptcy and should explicitly
address questions of legal jurisdiction
and conflicting laws. This commenter
argued that a resolution plan should be
supported by a legal opinion addressing
which law would apply to each of the
covered company’s material entities in
the case of the covered company’s
resolution. On the other hand, another
commenter requested that the final rule
provide only that the resolution plan
analyze how the continuing operations
of a covered company’s insured
depository institutions can be
adequately protected in connection with
the resolution of the company under the
Bankruptcy Code. Still another
commenter suggested that resolution
under the Bankruptcy Code was
inconsistent with the requirement that a
covered company’s resolution plan
adequately protect the company’s
insured depository institution from the
risks arising from the activities of the

PO 00000

Frm 00010

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

company’s nonbanks because the
covered company cannot provide any
assurances of what will happen in a
bankruptcy proceeding and cannot
provide special protection for a
particular subsidiary in the bankruptcy
process.
A number of comments expressed
concern about the timing of the initial
submission of a resolution plan.
Commenters argued that the
requirement to submit initial plans 180
days from the effective date of the final
rule is too short. Instead, these
commenters suggested that covered
companies should have at least 270
days, 360 days, or 18 months after the
effective date of the final rule to make
their initial submissions. Commenters
suggested that submissions of the
resolution plan be phased in or
staggered to allow firms sufficient time
to prepare and collect the extensive
information required as part of the plan.
Another commenter suggested a pilot
program that would apply first to the
largest, most complex firms, rolling out
the entire process on a staggered basis
after experience is gained with the
largest firms.
Commenters also criticized the
proposed rule for not adjusting the
complexity of the reporting
requirements to match the differences
among bank holding companies subject
to the proposed rule. These commenters
noted that covered banking
organizations range from large, complex,
highly interconnected organizations that
have substantial nonbank and foreign
operations to smaller, less complex
organizations that are predominantly
composed of one or more insured
depository institutions, have few foreign
operations, and fewer interconnections
with other financial institutions. These
commenters suggested that the final rule
provide for a tailored resolution plan
regime for smaller, less complex
domestic bank holding companies.
Several commenters suggested that,
given the lack of supervisory and market
experience with resolution planning,
the final rule should communicate the
Board’s and the Corporation’s
expectations for ‘‘first generation’’
resolution plans and should provide for
meaningful feedback by the Agencies
within the 60 day period the Agencies
have to review an initial resolution
plan. Commenters also noted that
annual updates to the plan should not
be due at the end of the first calendar
quarter when firms have to meet other
important reporting requirements.
Commenters suggested that the timing
of the annual update should be
determined by agreement among the

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
Board, the Corporation, and the covered
company.
The proposed rule required interim
updates to a resolution plan shortly after
any material acquisition or similar
event. One commenter argued that the
requirement was not supported by the
Dodd-Frank Act and should be excluded
from the final rule. Other commenters
suggested that, if the final rule required
interim updates, such updates should be
triggered by a ‘‘fundamental change’’
standard instead of the material change
standard described in the proposed rule.
Some commenters suggested that the
size of events that trigger the update
requirement be raised and the time
period for filing the update be extended.
The proposal required that, within a
reasonable amount of time after
submitting its initial resolution plan, a
firm demonstrate its capacity to
promptly produce the data underlying
the key aspects of its resolution plan.
Commenters objected to this
requirement indicating that it would be
better addressed as part of the Board’s
and Corporation’s ongoing review of the
resolution-planning process conducted
by individual firms, rather than as a
regulatory requirement. Similarly,
commenters suggested that any
requirement related to data production
capabilities be omitted from the final
rule because such a requirement is
better addressed as part of the Agencies’
ongoing review of resolution planning
by specific companies. Commenters also
recommended that data required to be
collected through various Dodd-Frank
Act initiatives be coordinated to
minimize redundant data collections.
Other commenters recommended that
covered companies’ information
technology systems be able to integrate
and distribute essential structural and
operational information on short notice
to facilitate such companies’
resolutions.
Some commenters objected to the
requirement that multiple stress
scenarios be addressed as part of the
plan as burdensome and unworkable.
The commenters suggested that the
number of financial distress scenarios to
be addressed in a covered company’s
resolution plan should be limited, with
the specific number of scenarios to be
agreed to between the covered company
and the Agencies prior to the initial
submission. Commenters also expressed
concern about having to address a
systemic stress scenario, which
commenters considered more
appropriately related to the Orderly
Liquidation Authority in Title II of the
Dodd-Frank Act.
Some commenters criticized the
corporate governance requirement of the

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

proposed rule. These commenters
suggested that a covered company’s
corporate governance with regard to
resolution planning, unless determined
to be substantially defective in one or
more respects, should be deemed to
facilitate orderly resolution, as well as
to be informationally complete and
credible. Another commenter suggested
that the corporate governance
requirement should include
requirements for consistently
maintaining accurate asset valuations.
Commenters also noted the burdens
nonbank financial companies will face.
Where such firms have established an
intermediate holding company (‘‘IHC’’),
commenters asked that the resolution
plan requirement apply only to the IHC.
These commenters also suggested that
nonbank financial firms be permitted to
complete any restructuring involved in
the establishment of their IHC before
commencing resolution planning.
Commenters also asserted that the
requirement to provide an
unconsolidated balance sheet and
consolidating schedules was unduly
burdensome, costly, and impracticable.
A number of commenters expressed
concern about how the Board and the
Corporation will determine whether a
plan is not credible or deficient and the
possible ramifications of such a
determination. Some commenters
requested clarification of the standards
relevant to such a determination, and
others suggested that these standards
should be developed over time. Several
commenters sought clarification of
whether a covered company’s board of
directors (or its delegee in the case of a
foreign-based covered company) is
required to certify or confirm all the
factual information contained in the
company’s resolution plan. One
commenter asked whether an interim
update involves the submission of an
entire resolution plan or merely
involves additional information
describing the event triggering the
update, any effects the event has on the
plan, and the firm’s actions to address
such effects.
The Board and the Corporation were
also asked to clarify the relationship
that insolvency regimes other than
bankruptcy bear on the preparation and
assessment of a resolution plan.
Commenters also asked the Agencies to
confirm that the rule is not intended to
restrain the covered companies from
expanding through mergers,
acquisitions, or diversification of their
business; that the resolution plan is not
meant to impose on firms the need to
have duplicative capacity; and that the
Agencies will take into account the
companies’ own cost-benefit analysis in

PO 00000

Frm 00011

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67325

connection with whether financial and
human resources should be devoted to
providing duplicative capacity.
Additionally, commenters noted that
some key terms were not defined in the
proposed rule. Several commenters
suggested that the Agencies should
develop the meaning of key terms in the
final rule over time and through the
supervisory process by issuing
guidance, supervisory letters, or revised
regulations. Other commenters
specifically recommended definitions
for certain key terms, including
‘‘credible plan,’’ ‘‘rapid and orderly
resolution,’’ and ‘‘material financial
distress.’’ Several commenters requested
clarification of the term ‘‘extraordinary
support,’’ and suggested that Federal
Reserve Bank advances, Federal Home
Loan Bank advances, and the use of the
Deposit Insurance Fund not be
considered extraordinary support under
the regulation.
ii. Substantive Credit Exposure Report
Requirements
Several commenters suggested that
the provisions requiring credit exposure
reports be postponed or re-proposed as
part of the Board’s forthcoming proposal
to implement the single counterparty
credit exposure limits established under
section 165(e) of the Dodd-Frank Act.
Other commenters suggested that the
credit exposure reporting requirement
be phased-in over a period of time.
Commenters raised a variety of
questions about the definitions
proposed as part of the credit exposure
report and about the timing, scope, and
detail required by the proposal.
Some commenters noted that most of
the information contained in the credit
exposure report requirement is currently
reported by insurance companies to
state insurance commissioners on an
annual basis, and suggested that the
Board and the Corporation rely on these
annual reports instead of requiring a
separate credit exposure report from
insurance companies.
One commenter indicated that the
final rule should require covered
companies to be able to report on their
supply of liquidity to other firms and
their dependence on other firms for
liquidity, to estimate and report on the
likely effect of their sales on the prices
of major classes of assets, and to
produce these reports within 24 hours
notice, whether as part of the credit
exposure report or separately.
iii. Foreign Banking Organizations
With respect to foreign based covered
companies, some commenters suggested
that the applicability of the resolution
plan requirement be determined by

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

67326

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

reference to U.S. assets of the foreign
firm and not with respect to the
consolidated worldwide assets of the
foreign firm. Alternatively, these
commenters suggested that a foreign
banking organization (‘‘FBO’’) with less
than $50 billion in U.S. total
consolidated assets be subject to
reduced or streamlined reporting, and
that the rule should be tailored to take
account of the risk posed by an FBO to
U.S. financial stability by focusing on
the FBO’s U.S. structure and
complexity, the size of its U.S.
operations, and the extent of its
interconnectedness in U.S. financial
markets. Commenters requested that the
submission deadline be extended for
FBOs to allow more time for these
organizations to complete a resolution
plan.
Commenters suggested that the
resolution plan requirement be aligned
with other ongoing cross-border
initiatives so as to avoid overlapping or
inconsistent requirements for
internationally active firms.
Commenters also advocated for
international cooperation in developing
information-sharing arrangements,
including coordination with or reliance
on home-country resolution plans. One
comment specifically asked for
clarification concerning information
sharing with foreign regulators and
recommended consultation with a firm’s
appropriate home-country authority
prior to making a credibility
determination regarding the resolution
plan or imposing sanctions pursuant to
the rule. A commenter suggested that,
for those firms with an established crisis
management group, the resolution plans
developed through that process be
allowed to satisfy the section 165(d)
resolution plan requirement.
Commenters asked the Agencies to
clarify that any restrictions or
requirements imposed pursuant to the
rule would apply only to an FBO’s U.S.
activities, assets, and operations. In a
banking organization with multiple
covered companies, commenters sought
clarification on whether the
organization could submit one
resolution plan or whether each covered
company within such an organization
had to submit a separate individualized
resolution plan.
iv. Confidentiality
A frequent comment related to the
confidentiality of resolution plans and
credit exposure reports. Commenters
argued that the information required to
be included in resolution plans
represented sensitive, confidential
business information not otherwise
available to the public, and the

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

disclosure of which would significantly
harm the competitiveness of reporting
firms. Commenters expressed concern
that the proposed rule did not provide
a sufficient level of assurance that
resolution plans and credit exposure
reports submitted would be kept
confidential, particularly in light of the
disclosure requirements of the Freedom
of Information Act (‘‘FOIA’’).4 The
commenters suggested the proposed
rule acknowledge the applicability of
certain FOIA exemptions. In particular,
commenters expressed the view that
information submitted in connection
with the resolution plan and credit
exposure report requirements should be
treated as confidential supervisory
information. Moreover, commenters
suggested that the Board and the
Corporation put in place procedures
(either as part of the final rule or in
guidance) to minimize the risk of leaks
or inadvertent disclosures when
information contained in the resolution
plan and credit exposure report was
shared among the covered company’s
regulators, including home-country
supervisors.
The Board and the Corporation have
carefully considered the comments and
made appropriate revisions to the final
rule as described below.
III. Description of Final Rule
The final rule applies to any bank
holding company that has $50 billion or
more in total consolidated assets, as
determined based on the average of the
company’s four most recent
Consolidated Financial Statements for
Bank Holding Companies as reported on
the Board’s Form FR Y–9C. It also
applies to any foreign bank or company
that is, or is treated as, a bank holding
company under section 8(a) of the
International Banking Act of 1978 5 and
that has $50 billion or more in total
consolidated assets, as determined
based on the average of the foreign
bank’s or company’s four most recent
quarterly Capital and Asset Reports for
Foreign Banking Organizations as
reported on the Board’s Form FR Y–7Q
(or, if applicable, its most recent annual
Form Y–7Q). A bank holding company
that becomes a ‘‘covered company’’
remains a ‘‘covered company’’ unless
and until it has less than $45 billion in
total consolidated assets, as determined
based on the most recent annual or, as
applicable, the average of the four most
recent quarterly reports made to the
Board. A covered company that has
reduced its total consolidated assets to
below $45 billion, as described above,
45

U.S.C. 552(b).
U.S.C. 3106(a).

5 12

PO 00000

Frm 00012

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

would again become a covered company
if it has total consolidated assets of $50
billion or more at a later date, as
determined based on the relevant
reports. A firm may fall in or out of the
definition of a ‘‘covered company’’
because of fluctuations in its asset size.
This situation necessarily disrupts the
continuity of resolution planning and
increases regulatory uncertainty and
burden for many covered companies.
The $45 billion threshold was added to
facilitate continuity in resolution
planning for covered companies and
thereby reduce regulatory uncertainty
and its associated cost. In a multi-tiered
bank holding company structure,
covered company means the top-tier
legal entity of the multi-tiered holding
company only.
In determining applicability of the
final rule to foreign banks, the final rule
considers a firm’s world-wide
consolidated assets, rather than only its
U.S. assets. However, as described in
more detail below, covered companies
(including foreign banks) with relatively
small nonbanking operations in the U.S.
are permitted to file tailored reports
with reduced information requirements.
Given the foregoing, the resolution plan
of a foreign-based company that has
limited assets or operations in the
United States would be significantly
limited in its scope and complexity.
Moreover, the nature and extent of the
home country’s related crisis
management and resolution planning
requirements for the foreign-based
company also will be considered as part
of the Agencies’ resolution plan review
process.6
In addition, the final rule applies to
any nonbank financial company that the
Council has determined under section
113 of the Dodd-Frank Act 7 must be
supervised by the Board and for which
such determination is in effect.
Under the proposal, a firm would also
have been required to submit a quarterly
report on its credit exposure to other
‘‘significant’’ bank holding companies
and financial firms, as well as their
credit exposure to the firm. As noted
above, commenters expressed
significant concerns about the clarity of
key definitions and the scope of the bidirectional and intraday reporting
6 The Dodd-Frank Act requires that, in applying
the requirements of section 165(d) to any foreign
nonbank financial company supervised by the
Board or any foreign-based company, the Board give
due regard to the principle of national treatment
and equality of competitive opportunity, and take
into account the extent to which the foreign-based
financial company is subject on a consolidated
basis to home country standards that are
comparable to those applied to financial companies
in the United States. 12 U.S.C. 5365(b)(2).
7 12 U.S.C. 5323.

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

requirement of the proposal and
suggested that the credit exposure report
requirement be considered in
conjunction with the proposal to
implement the Dodd-Frank Act’s single
counterparty credit exposure limit.
The Board and the Corporation
believe that robust reporting of a
covered company’s credit exposures to
other significant bank holding
companies and financial companies is
critical to ongoing risk management by
covered companies, as well as to the
Board’s ongoing supervision of covered
companies and the Corporation’s
responsibility to resolve covered
companies, as appropriate. However,
the Agencies also recognize that these
reports would be most useful and
complete if developed in conjunction
with the Dodd-Frank Act’s single
counterparty credit exposure limits.
Accordingly, the Board and Corporation
are not at this time finalizing the credit
exposure reporting requirement and will
coordinate development of these reports
with the single counterparty credit
exposure limits.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Definitions. Section ll.2 of the final
rule defines certain terms, including
‘‘rapid and orderly resolution,’’
‘‘material financial distress,’’ ‘‘core
business lines,’’ ‘‘critical operations,’’
and ‘‘material entities,’’ which are key
definitions in the final rule.
‘‘Rapid and orderly resolution’’ means
a reorganization or liquidation of the
covered company (or, in the case of a
covered company that is incorporated or
organized in a jurisdiction other than
the United States, the subsidiaries and
operations of such foreign company that
are domiciled in the United States)
under the Bankruptcy Code that can be
accomplished within a reasonable
period of time and in a manner that
substantially mitigates the risk that the
failure of the covered company would
have serious adverse effects on financial
stability in the United States.8 Under
the final rule, each resolution plan
submitted should provide for the rapid
and orderly resolution of the covered
company. The final rule does not
specifically define or limit this time
period in recognition that a reasonable
period for resolution will depend on the
size, complexity, and structure of the
firm.
‘‘Material financial distress’’ with
regard to a covered company means
that: (i) The covered company has
incurred, or is likely to incur, losses that
8 If a covered company is subject to an insolvency
regime other than the Bankruptcy Code, the
analysis should be in reference to that regime.

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

will deplete all or substantially all of its
capital, and there is no reasonable
prospect for the company to avoid such
depletion; (ii) the assets of the covered
company are, or are likely to be, less
than its obligations to creditors and
others; or (iii) the covered company is,
or is likely to be, unable to pay its
obligations (other than those subject to
a bona fide dispute) in the normal
course of business. Under the final rule,
each resolution plan should provide for
the rapid and orderly resolution of the
covered company in the event of
material financial distress or failure of
the covered company.
‘‘Core business lines’’ means those
business lines, including associated
operations, services, functions and
support that, in the firm’s view, upon
failure would result in a material loss of
revenue, profit, or franchise value. The
resolution plan should address how the
resolution of the covered company will
affect the core business lines.
‘‘Critical operations’’ are those
operations, including associated
services, functions and support the
failure or discontinuance of which, in
the view of the covered company or as
jointly directed by the Board and the
Corporation, would pose a threat to the
financial stability of the United States.
This definition is revised from the
proposal to provide greater clarity as to
which of a firm’s operations would be
deemed a ‘‘critical operation.’’ Initially
defined as operations that, upon failure
or discontinuance, ‘‘would likely result
in a disruption to the U.S. economy or
financial markets,’’ the Board and the
Corporation revised this definition to
more closely reflect the purpose of
section 165 of the Dodd-Frank Act, i.e.,
‘‘to prevent or mitigate risks to the
financial stability of the United
States.’’ 9 The revised definition clarifies
that the threshold of significance for a
disruption to U.S. financial stability
resulting from the failure or
discontinuance of a critical operation
must be severe enough to pose a threat
to the financial stability of the United
States. For example, a critical operation
of a covered company would include an
operation, such as a clearing, payment,
or settlement system, which plays a role
in the financial markets for which other
firms lack the expertise or capacity to
provide a ready substitute. The
resolution plan should address and
provide for the continuation and
funding of critical operations.
‘‘Material entity’’ means a subsidiary
or foreign office of the covered company
that is significant to the activities of a
critical operation or core business line.
9 See

PO 00000

12 U.S.C. 5365(a)(1).

Frm 00013

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67327

Informational content of a resolution
plan. Section ll.4 of the final rule sets
forth the general informational content
requirements of a resolution plan. A
covered company that is domiciled in
the United States is required to provide
information with regard to both its U.S.
operations and its foreign operations. A
foreign-based covered company is
required to provide information
regarding its U.S. operations, an
explanation of how resolution planning
for its U.S. operations is integrated into
the foreign-based covered company’s
overall contingency planning process,
and information regarding the
interconnections and interdependencies
among its U.S. operations and its
foreign-based operations.
Under the final rule, a resolution plan
is required to contain an executive
summary, a strategic analysis of the
plan’s components, a description of the
covered company’s corporate
governance structure for resolution
planning, information regarding the
covered company’s overall
organizational structure, information
regarding the covered company’s
management information systems, a
description of interconnections and
interdependencies among the covered
company and its material entities, and
supervisory and regulatory information.
The executive summary must
summarize the key elements of the
covered company’s strategic plan,
material changes from the most recently
filed plan, and any actions taken by the
covered company to improve the
effectiveness of the resolution plan or
remediate, or otherwise mitigate, any
material weaknesses or impediments to
the effective and timely execution of the
plan.
Under the final rule, each resolution
plan submitted must also describe the
firm’s strategy for the rapid and orderly
resolution of the covered company in
the event of material financial distress
or failure of the covered company. This
strategic analysis should detail how, in
practice, the covered company could be
resolved under the Bankruptcy Code.
The strategic analysis should also
include the analytical support for the
plan and its key assumptions, including
any assumptions made concerning the
economic or financial conditions that
would be present at the time the
covered company sought to implement
such plan.
The Board and Corporation recognize
the burden associated with developing
an initial resolution plan as well as
establishing the processes, procedures,
and systems necessary to annually, or as
otherwise appropriate, update a
resolution plan. While an organization’s

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

67328

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

initial resolution plan must include all
informational elements required under
this final rule, the Board and
Corporation (as noted above) expect the
process of submission and review of the
initial resolution plan iterations to
include an ongoing dialogue with firms.
In developing their initial resolution
plans, covered companies should
therefore focus on the key elements of
a resolution plan, including identifying
critical and core operations, developing
a robust strategic analysis, and
identifying and describing the
interconnections and interdependencies
among material entities. To the extent
practicable, covered companies
should—with respect to the initial
resolution plan—try to leverage off of
and incorporate information already
reported to the Board or Corporation or
already publicly-disclosed, e.g., in
securities or other similar filings.
The final rule specifies the minimum
content of a resolution plan. The Board
and the Corporation recognize that
plans will vary by company and, in
their evaluation of plans, will take into
account variances among companies in
their core business lines, critical
operations, foreign operations, capital
structure, risk, complexity, financial
activities (including the financial
activities of their subsidiaries), size, and
other relevant factors. The resolution
plans of more complex covered
companies will be more complex and
require information that may not be
relevant for smaller, less complex
covered companies. For example, a less
complex covered company that does not
engage in a material number or value
amount of trades will not be required to
address that component of the
resolution plan, while a more complex
covered company may require an
extensive discussion of systems in
which it conducts trading operations
and how those systems map to material
entities, critical operations and core
business lines. To the extent an
informational element is not applicable
or the covered company does not engage
in the activity relevant to such
informational element to a material
extent, then a covered company should
indicate such in its resolution plan and
is not required to provide other
information with regard to that
informational element.
Several commenters requested
clarification of a provision in the
proposal that required that the firm’s
resolution plan not rely on the provision
of extraordinary support of the United
States or any other government to the
covered company or its subsidiaries to
prevent the failure of the covered
company. The provision is intended to

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

prohibit the covered company from
assuming in its resolution plan that the
United States or any other government
will provide the covered company
funding or capital other than in the
ordinary course of business.
A resolution plan must be sensitive to
the economic conditions at the time the
plan is triggered. To assist in
establishing the assumptions for the
economic conditions triggering a
resolution plan, the Agencies propose
referencing conditions developed
pursuant to Section 165(i)(1) of the
Dodd-Frank Act.10 Under that section,
the Board, in coordination with the
appropriate primary financial regulatory
agencies and the Federal Insurance
Office, will conduct annual stress tests
of covered companies. As part of that
exercise, the Board expects to provide
covered companies with different sets of
economic conditions under which the
evaluation will be conducted: Baseline,
adverse, and severely adverse economic
conditions. For its initial resolution
plan, a covered company may assume
that failure would occur under the
baseline economic scenario, or, if a
baseline scenario is not then available,
a reasonable substitute developed by the
covered company. Subsequent iterations
of a covered company’s resolution plan
should assume that the failure of the
covered company will occur under the
same economic conditions consistent
with the Board’s final rule
implementing Section 165(i)(1).
The strategic analysis should include
detailed information as to how, in the
event of material financial distress or
failure of the covered company, a
reorganization or liquidation of the
covered company (or, in the case of a
covered company that is incorporated or
organized in a jurisdiction other than
the United States, the subsidiaries and
operations of such foreign company that
are domiciled in the United States)
under the Bankruptcy Code could be
accomplished within a reasonable
period of time and in a manner that
substantially mitigates the risk that the
failure of the covered company would
have serious adverse effects on financial
stability in the United States. The
strategic analysis of the covered
company’s resolution plan must also
identify the range of options and
specific actions to be taken by the
covered company to facilitate a rapid
and orderly resolution of the covered
company, its material entities, critical
operations, and core business lines in
the event of its material financial
distress or failure.
10 12

PO 00000

U.S.C. 5365(i).

Frm 00014

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

Funding, liquidity, support functions,
and other resources, including capital
resources, should be identified and
mapped to the covered company’s
material entities, critical operations, and
core business lines. The covered
company’s strategy for maintaining and
funding the material entities, critical
operations, and core business lines in an
environment of material financial
distress and in the implementation and
execution of its resolution plan should
be provided and mapped to its material
entities. The covered company’s
strategic analysis should demonstrate
how such resources would be utilized to
facilitate an orderly resolution in an
environment of material financial
distress. The covered company should
also provide its strategy in the event of
a failure or discontinuation of a material
entity, critical operation, or core
business line and the actions that will
be taken by the covered company to
prevent or mitigate any adverse effects
of such failure or discontinuation on the
financial stability of the company and
the United States.
The final rule designates a subsidiary
that conducts core business lines or
critical operations of the covered
company as a ‘‘material entity.’’ When
the covered company utilizes a material
entity and that material entity is subject
to the Bankruptcy Code, then a
resolution plan should assume the
failure or discontinuation of such
material entity and provide both the
covered company’s and the material
entity’s strategy, and the actions that
will be taken by the covered company
to prevent or mitigate any adverse
effects of such failure or discontinuation
on the financial stability of the United
States.
A number of commenters asked how
this discussion of strategy was to be
applied when a major subsidiary was
not subject to the Bankruptcy Code, but
rather to another specialized insolvency
regime, such as the FDI Act, state
liquidation regimes for state-licensed
uninsured branches and agencies of
foreign banks, the International Banking
Act of 1978 for federally licensed
branches and agencies, foreign
insolvency regimes, state insolvency
regimes for insurance companies, or the
Securities Investor Protection Act
applicable to broker-dealers.
Recognizing many of the challenges that
may be posed by such a requirement if
a material entity is subject to an
insolvency regime other than the
Bankruptcy Code, the final rule
provides that a covered company may
limit its strategic analysis with respect
to a material entity that is subject to an
insolvency regime other than the

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

Bankruptcy Code to a material entity
that either has $50 billion or more in
total assets or conducts a critical
operation. Any such analysis should be
in reference to that applicable regime.
Thus, for example, if a covered
company owns a national bank with $50
billion or more in total consolidated
assets, the resolution plan of the
covered company should assume the
resolution of the bank under the FDI Act
and the actions that will be taken by the
covered company to prevent or mitigate
any adverse effects of such failure or
discontinuation on the financial
stability of the United States.
Under a separate rulemaking, the
Corporation is requiring insured
depository institutions with total assets
of $50 billion or more to develop their
own strategies to facilitate a resolution
under the FDI Act.11 The Corporation’s
rulemaking is intended to complement
the final rule and, together with the
final rule, provide for comprehensive
and coordinated resolution planning for
both the insured depository institution
and its parent holding company and
affiliates in the event that an orderly
liquidation is required.
The resolution plan must also
describe the covered company’s strategy
for ensuring that its insured depository
institution subsidiary will be adequately
protected from risks arising from the
activities of any nonbank subsidiaries of
the covered company (other than those
that are subsidiaries of an insured
depository institution). This
requirement is a specific statutory
requirement and is applicable only to
insured depository institutions and is
not applicable to other types of
regulated subsidiaries.12
Under the final rule, the description
of the covered company’s corporate
governance structure for resolution
planning should include information
regarding how resolution planning is
integrated into the corporate governance
structure and processes of the covered
company. It must also identify the
senior management official who is
primarily responsible for overseeing the
development, maintenance,
implementation, and filing of the
resolution plan and for the covered
company’s compliance with the final
rule. The requirements in the final rule
are minimums and the corporate
11 See Special Reporting, Analysis and Contingent
Resolution Plans at Certain Large Insured
Depository Institutions, 75 FR 27,464 (May 17,
2010) (to be codified at 12 CFR part 360). On
September 13, 2011, the Corporation approved an
interim final rule to implement this requirement.
The Corporation’s rule is available at: http://
fdic.gov/news/news/press/2011/pr11150.html.
12 12 U.S.C. 5365(d)(1)(A).

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

governance structure is expected to vary
based upon the size and complexity of
the covered company. For the largest
and most complex companies, it may be
necessary to establish a central planning
function that is headed by a senior
management official. Such official could
report to the Chief Risk Officer or Chief
Executive Officer and periodically
report on resolution planning to the
covered company’s board of directors.
The information regarding the
covered company’s overall
organizational structure and related
information should include a
hierarchical list of all material entities,
with jurisdictional and ownership
information. This information should be
mapped to core business lines and
critical operations. The proposal would
have required each covered company to
provide its unconsolidated balance
sheet and a consolidating schedule for
all entities that are subject to
consolidation by the covered company.
However, in response to commenters’
concerns, the Board and Corporation
revised the final rule to require only an
unconsolidated balance sheet for the
covered company, together with a
consolidating schedule for all material
entities that are subject to consolidation.
Amounts attributed to entities that are
not material entities may be aggregated
on the consolidating schedule.
Under the final rule, the resolution
plan should include information
regarding material assets, liabilities,
derivatives, hedges, capital and funding
sources, and major counterparties.
Material assets and liabilities should be
mapped to material entities along with
location information. An analysis of
whether the bankruptcy of a major
counterparty would likely have an
adverse effect on and result in the
material financial distress or failure of
the covered company should also be
included. Trading, payment, clearing,
and settlement systems utilized by the
covered company should be identified.
The covered company would not need
to identify trading, payment, clearing,
and settlement systems that are
immaterial in resolution planning, such
as a local check clearing house.
For a U.S.-based covered company
with foreign operations, the plan should
identify the extent of the risks to the
U.S. operations of the firm related to its
foreign operations and the covered
company’s strategy for addressing such
risks. These elements of the resolution
plan should take into consideration the
complications created by differing
national laws, regulations, and policies.
This analysis should include a mapping
of core business lines and critical
operations to legal entities operating in

PO 00000

Frm 00015

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67329

or with assets, liabilities, operations, or
service providers in foreign
jurisdictions. The continued ability to
maintain core business lines and critical
operations in these foreign jurisdictions
during material financial distress and
insolvency proceedings should be
evaluated and steps identified to
address weaknesses or vulnerabilities.
The final rule requires the covered
company to provide information
regarding the management information
systems supporting its core business
lines and critical operations, including
information regarding the legal
ownership of such systems as well as
associated software, licenses, or other
associated intellectual property. The
analysis and practical steps that are
identified by the covered company
should address the continued
availability of the key management
information systems that support core
business lines and critical operations
both within the United States and in
foreign jurisdictions.
The final rule requires the resolution
plan to include a description of the
capabilities of the covered company’s
management information systems to
collect, maintain, and report, in a timely
manner to management of the covered
company and to the Board, the
information and other data underlying
the resolution plan. Moreover, the
resolution plan must also identify the
deficiencies, gaps, or weaknesses in
those capabilities of the covered
company’s management information
systems and describe the actions the
covered company plans to undertake,
including the associated timelines for
implementation, to promptly address
such deficiencies, gaps, or weaknesses.
The Board will use its examination
authority to review the demonstrated
capabilities of each covered company to
satisfy these requirements, and will
share with the Corporation information
regarding the capabilities of the covered
company to collect, maintain, and
report in a timely manner information
and data underlying the resolution plan.
The final rule also requires the
covered company to provide a
description of the interconnections and
interdependencies among the covered
company and its material entities and
affiliates, and among the critical
operations and core business lines of the
covered company that, if disrupted,
would materially affect the funding or
operations of the covered company, its
material entities, its critical operations,
or core business lines. As noted above,
the continued availability of key
services and supporting business
operations to core business lines and
critical operations in an environment of

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

67330

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

material financial distress and after
insolvency should be a focus of
resolution planning. Steps to ensure that
service level agreements for such
services, whether provided by internal
or external service providers, survive
insolvency should be demonstrated in
the resolution plan.
The plan should identify the covered
company’s supervisory authorities and
regulators, including information
identifying any foreign agency or
authority with significant supervisory
authority over material foreign-based
subsidiaries or operations.
Section 165(d) applies to a number of
companies that operate predominately
through one or more insured depository
institutions. As discussed above, several
commenters argued that the rule should
make allowances for the significant
differences in complexity and structure
among the various bank holding
companies subject to the rule.
Commenters recommended that the
Board and Corporation modify the final
rule to provide for a tailored resolution
plan regime for smaller, less complex
bank holding companies and foreign
banking organizations.
In response to these comments, the
Board and Corporation have tailored the
resolution plan requirement applicable
to smaller, less complex bank holding
companies and foreign banking
organizations in order to focus the
content and analysis of such an
organization’s resolution plan on the
nonbanking operations of the
organization, and the interconnections
between the nonbanking operations and
the insured depository institution
operations of the covered company.
For covered companies with less than
$100 billion in total nonbank assets that
predominately operate through one or
more insured depository institutions,
i.e., the company’s insured depository
institution subsidiaries comprise at least
85 percent of its total consolidated
assets (or, in the case of a foreign-based
covered company, the assets of the U.S.
depository institution operations,
branches, and agencies of which
comprise 85 percent or more of the
company’s U.S. total consolidated
assets), the Board and Corporation have
tailored the resolution plan
requirements to focus on the nonbank
operations of the covered company.
Specifically, a firm meeting the above
criteria, and not otherwise excluded or
directed by the Board and Corporation
to submit a standard resolution plan,
shall in its resolution plan identify and
describe interconnections and
interdependencies pursuant to
§ [—].4(g) and provide the contact
information required under § [—].4(i)

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

with respect to the entire organization.
Such resolution plan must also include
the remaining resolution plan elements,
i.e., the strategic analysis, organizational
structure, description of management
information systems, and the other
content specified in § [—].4(c) through
§ [—].4(f) and § [—].4(h), only with
respect to the covered company’s
nonbanking operations. Importantly,
with respect to the information
concerning interconnections and
interdependencies, the resolution plan
must describe in detail, and map to legal
entity the interconnections and
interdependencies among the
nonbanking operations as well as
between the nonbanking operations and
the insured depository institution
operations of the covered company.
Covered companies with more than
$100 billion in nonbank assets are not
eligible to submit the type of plan
described above, regardless of whether
their operations satisfy the 85 percent
criterion described above. Under the
final rule, the Board and Corporation
may determine that a firm that would
otherwise meet the prerequisites for
submitting a tailored plan must
nonetheless submit the full resolution
plan.
Resolution plans required. Section
____.3 of the proposed rule required
each covered company to submit a
resolution plan within 180 days of the
effective date of the final rule, or within
180 days of such later date as the
company becomes a covered company.
Several commenters suggested that,
given the limited resources of the Board
and the Corporation to review
resolution plans and the industry’s
desire for additional time to prepare
resolution plans, the timing for
submission of plans should be
staggered.
Under the final rule, firms will be
required to file resolution plans in three
groups with a staggered schedule. The
first group comprises the largest, most
complex covered companies, i.e., any
covered company that has $250 billion
or more in total nonbank assets (or, in
the case of a foreign-based covered
company, $250 billion or more in total
U.S. nonbank assets). Covered
companies in this first group must
submit their initial resolution plans no
later than July 1, 2012.
Firms in the second group of covered
companies must submit their initial
resolution plans no later than July 1,
2013. This second group consists of
covered companies with $100 billion or
more in nonbank assets (or, in the case
of a foreign-based covered company,
$100 billion or more in total U.S.
nonbank assets).

PO 00000

Frm 00016

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

The third and final group consists of
the remaining covered companies, i.e.,
covered companies with less than $100
billion in nonbank assets (or, in the case
of a foreign-based covered company, in
total U.S. nonbank assets). Covered
companies in this third group are
required to file their initial resolution
plans on or before December 31, 2013.
The above phase-in schedule generally
applies to any company that is a
covered company as of the effective
date.
A company that becomes a covered
company after the effective date of this
final rule, e.g., a company the Council
has designated for supervision by the
Board or a bank holding company that
grows, organically or by merger or
acquisition, over the $50 billion
threshold, must submit its resolution
plan by the next July 1 following the
date the company becomes a covered
company, provided such date is at least
270 days after the date the company
becomes a covered company. The final
rule permits the Board and Corporation
to jointly determine that a covered
company must submit its initial
resolution plan earlier or later than
provided for in the final rule.
The Agencies have also revised the
requirements for updating the resolution
plan. After the initial resolution plan is
submitted, each covered company is
required to submit an updated
resolution plan annually on or before
the anniversary date of the date for
submission of its initial plan.
This annual filing provides a regular
opportunity for firms to update their
resolution plans to reflect structural
changes, acquisitions, and sales.
Moreover, the Agencies expect that
firms will integrate resolution planning
into their business operations.
Accordingly, the final rule no longer
requires that a resolution plan be
updated automatically upon the
occurrence of a restructuring,
acquisition, or sale. Instead, the final
rule requires that a firm update its next
annual resolution plan after the
occurrence of a material event, such as
a restructuring, acquisition, or sale. The
final rule also requires the firm to file
a simple notice with the Board and the
Corporation that such an event has
occurred. That notice must be provided
within a time period specified by the
Board and the Corporation, but no later
than 45 days after any event,
occurrence, change in conditions or
circumstances or other change that
results in, or could reasonably be
foreseen to have, a material effect on the
resolution plan of the covered company.
The final rule requires such notice to
summarize why the event, occurrence,

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
or change may require changes to the
resolution plan.
The Board and the Corporation jointly
may waive a requirement that a covered
company file a notice following a
material event. The Board and the
Corporation jointly may also require an
update for any other reason, more
frequent submissions or updates, and
may extend the time period that a
covered company has to submit its
resolution plan or notice following a
material event.
Like the proposal, the final rule
requires that a covered company
provide the Board and the Corporation
information and access to its personnel
necessary for the Board and Corporation
to assess the resolution plan during the
period for reviewing the resolution plan
as provided for under the final rule. The
Board and the Corporation must rely to
the fullest extent possible on
examinations conducted by or on behalf
of the appropriate Federal banking
agency for the relevant company.
The involvement of a firm’s board of
directors is critical to adequate
resolution planning. Under both the
proposed and final rules, the board of
directors of the covered company is
required to approve the initial
resolution plans and each annual
resolution plan. In the case of a foreignbased covered company, a delegee of the
board of the directors of such
organization may approve the initial
resolution plan and any updates to a
resolution plan. For a U.S. domiciled
company, the board of directors must
approve the resolution plan in
accordance with the procedures
applicable to other documents of
strategic importance. The rule does not
require the board of directors to make an
attestation regarding the resolution plan.
Review of resolution plans;
resubmission of deficient resolutions
plans. Several commenters requested
changes in the process and procedures
for reviewing resolution plans set forth
in the proposed rule. The Board and the
Corporation will work closely with
covered companies and, as applicable,
other authorities, in the development of
a firm’s resolution plan and are
dedicating staff for that purpose. The
Board and the Corporation expect the
review process to evolve as covered
companies gain more experience in
preparing their resolution plans. The
Board and the Corporation recognize
that resolution plans will vary by
company and, in their evaluation of
plans, will take into account variances
among companies in their core business
lines, critical operations, domestic and
foreign operations, capital structure,
risk, complexity, financial activities

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

(including the financial activities of
their subsidiaries), size, and other
relevant factors. Because each resolution
plan is expected to be unique, the Board
and the Corporation encourage covered
companies to ask questions and, if so
desired, to arrange a meeting with the
Board and the Corporation. There is no
expectation by the Board and the
Corporation that the initial resolution
plan iterations submitted after this rule
takes effect will be found to be deficient,
but rather the initial resolution plans
will provide the foundation for
developing more robust annual
resolution plans over the next few years
following that initial period.
Section ll .5 of the final rule sets
forth procedures regarding the review of
resolution plans. When a covered
company submits a resolution plan, the
Board and Corporation will
preliminarily review a resolution plan
for informational completeness within
60 days. If the Board and the
Corporation determine that a resolution
plan is informationally incomplete or
that substantial additional information
is necessary to facilitate further review,
the Board and the Corporation will
inform the covered company in writing
of the area(s) in which the resolution
plan is informationally incomplete or
with respect to which additional
information is required. The covered
company will be required to resubmit
an informationally complete resolution
plan, or such additional information as
jointly requested to facilitate review of
the resolution plan, no later than 30
days after receiving such notice or such
other time period as the Board and
Corporation may jointly determine.
The Board and Corporation will
review each resolution plan for its
compliance with the requirements of the
final rule. If, following such review, the
Board and the Corporation jointly
determine that the resolution plan of a
covered company submitted under this
part is not credible or would not
facilitate an orderly resolution of the
covered company under the Bankruptcy
Code, the Board and Corporation will
jointly notify the covered company in
writing of such determination. Such
notice will identify the aspects of the
resolution plan that the Board and
Corporation jointly determined to be
deficient and request the resubmission
of a resolution plan that remedies the
deficiencies of the resolution plan.
Within 90 days of receiving such
notice of deficiencies, or such shorter or
longer period as the Board and
Corporation may jointly determine, a
covered company will be required to
submit a revised resolution plan to the
Board and Corporation that addresses

PO 00000

Frm 00017

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67331

the deficiencies jointly identified by the
Board and Corporation. The revised
resolution plan will be required to
discuss in detail: (i) The revisions made
by the covered company to address the
deficiencies jointly identified by the
Board and the Corporation; (ii) any
changes to the covered company’s
business operations and corporate
structure that the covered company
proposes to undertake to facilitate
implementation of the revised
resolution plan (including a timeline for
the execution of such planned changes);
and (iii) why the covered company
believes that the revised resolution plan
is credible and would result in an
orderly resolution of the covered
company under the Bankruptcy Code.
Upon their own initiative or a written
request by a covered company, the
Board and Corporation may jointly
extend any time for review and
submission established hereunder. Any
extension request should be supported
by a written statement of the company
describing the basis and justification for
the request.
Failure to cure deficiencies on
resubmission of a resolution plan.
Section ll .6 of the final rule provides
that, if the covered company fails to
submit a revised resolution plan or the
Board and the Corporation jointly
determine that a revised resolution plan
submitted does not adequately remedy
the deficiencies identified by the Board
and the Corporation, then the Board and
Corporation may jointly subject a
covered company or any subsidiary of a
covered company to more stringent
capital, leverage, or liquidity
requirements or restrictions on growth,
activities, or operations. Any such
requirements or restrictions would
apply to the covered company or
subsidiary, respectively, until the Board
and the Corporation jointly determine
the covered company has submitted a
revised resolution plan that adequately
remedies the deficiencies identified. In
addition, if the covered company fails,
within the two-year period beginning on
the date on which the determination to
impose such requirements or
restrictions was made, to submit a
revised resolution plan that adequately
remedies the deficiencies jointly
identified by the Board and the
Corporation, then the Board and
Corporation, in consultation with the
Council, may jointly, by order, direct
the covered company to divest such
assets or operations as the Board and
Corporation jointly determine necessary
to facilitate an orderly resolution of the
covered company under the Bankruptcy
Code in the event the company were to
fail.

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

67332

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

Consultation. Section ll .7 of the
final rule provides that, prior to issuing
any notice of deficiencies, determining
to impose requirements or restrictions
on a covered company, or issuing a
divestiture order with respect to a
covered company that is likely to have
a significant effect on a functionally
regulated subsidiary or a depository
institution subsidiary of the covered
company, the Board shall consult with
each Council member that primarily
supervises any such subsidiary and may
consult with any other federal, state, or
foreign supervisor as the Board
considers appropriate.
No limiting effect or private right of
action; confidentiality of resolution
plans. Section ll .8 of the final rule
provides that a resolution plan
submitted shall not have any binding
effect on: (i) A court or trustee in a
proceeding commenced under the
Bankruptcy Code; (ii) a receiver
appointed under Title II of the DoddFrank Act (12 U.S.C. 5381 et seq.); (iii)
a bridge financial company chartered
pursuant to 12 U.S.C. 5390(h); or (iv)
any other authority that is authorized or
required to resolve a covered company
(including any subsidiary or affiliate
thereof) under any other provision of
federal, state, or foreign law.
The final rule further provides that
nothing in the rule would create or is
intended to create a private right of
action based on a resolution plan
prepared or submitted under this part or
based on any action taken by the Board
or the Corporation with respect to any
resolution plan submitted under this
part.
Most commenters requested that the
resolution plans be treated as exempt
from disclosure under FOIA. The Board
and the Corporation are aware of and
sensitive to the significant concerns
regarding confidentiality of resolution
plans. The regulation contemplates and
requires the submission of highly
detailed, internal proprietary
information of covered companies. This
is the type of information that covered
companies would not customarily make
available to the public and that an
agency typically would have access to
and could review as part of the
supervisory process in assessing, for
example, the safety and soundness of a
regulated institution. Moreover, release
of this information would impede the
quality and extent of information
provided by covered companies and
could significantly impact the efforts of
the Board and the Corporation to
encourage effective and orderly
unwinding of the covered companies in
a crisis.

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

Under section 112(d)(5)(A) of the
Dodd-Frank Act, the Board and the
Corporation ‘‘shall maintain the
confidentiality of any data, information,
and reports submitted under’’ Title I
(which includes section 165(d), the
authority this regulation is promulgated
under) of the Dodd-Frank Act. The
Board and the Corporation will assess
the confidentiality of resolution plans
and related material in accordance with
applicable exemptions under FOIA and
the Board’s and the Corporation’s
implementing regulations (12 CFR part
261 (Board); 12 CFR part 309
(Corporation)). The Board and the
Corporation certainly expect that large
portions of the submissions will contain
or consist of ‘‘trade secrets and
commercial or financial information
obtained from a person and privileged
or confidential’’ and information that is
‘‘contained in or related to examination,
operating, or condition reports prepared
by, on behalf of, or for the use of an
agency responsible for the regulation or
supervision of financial institutions.’’
This information is subject to
withholding under exemptions 4 and 8
of the FOIA, 5 U.S.C. 552(b)(4) and
552(b)(8).
The Board and the Corporation also
recognize, however, that the regulation
calls for the submission of details
regarding covered companies that are
publicly available or otherwise are not
sensitive and should be made public.
In order to address this, the regulation
requires resolution plans to be divided
into two portions: a public section and
a confidential section. The public
section of the resolution plan should
consist of an executive summary of the
resolution plan that describes the
business of the covered company and
includes, to the extent material to an
understanding of the covered company:
(i) The names of material entities; (ii) a
description of core business lines; (iii)
consolidated or segment financial
information regarding assets, liabilities,
capital and major funding sources; (iv)
a description of derivative activities and
hedging activities; (v) a list of
memberships in material payment,
clearing, and settlement systems; (vi) a
description of foreign operations; (vii)
the identities of material supervisory
authorities; (viii) the identities of the
principal officers; (ix) a description of
the corporate governance structure and
processes related to resolution planning;
(x) a description of material
management information systems; and
(xi) a description, at a high level, of the
covered company’s resolution strategy,
covering such items as the range of
potential purchasers of the covered
company, its material entities and core

PO 00000

Frm 00018

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

business lines. While the information in
the public section of a resolution plan
should be sufficiently detailed to allow
the public to understand the business of
the covered company, such information
can be high level in nature and based on
publicly available information.
The public section will be made
available to the public in accordance
with the Board’s Rules Regarding
Availability of Information (12 CFR part
261) and the Corporation’s Disclosure of
Information Rules (12 CFR part 309).
A covered company should submit a
properly substantiated request for
confidential treatment of any details in
the confidential section that it believes
are subject to withholding under
exemption 4 of the FOIA. In addition,
the Board and the Corporation will
make formal exemption and
segregability determinations if and
when a plan is requested under the
FOIA.
Enforcement. Section ll .9 of the
final rule provides that the Board and
Corporation may jointly enforce an
order jointly issued under section
ll .6(a) or ll .6(c) of the final rule.
Furthermore, the Board, in consultation
with the Corporation, may address any
violation of the rule by a covered
company under section 8 of the Federal
Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1818).
V. Administrative Law Matters
A. Paperwork Reduction Act Analysis
In accordance with the requirements
of the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995
(44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq.), the Board may
not conduct or sponsor, and the
respondent is not required to respond
to, an information collection unless it
displays a currently valid Office of
Management and Budget (‘‘OMB’’)
control number. The Board reviewed the
final rule under the authority delegated
to the Board by OMB. The OMB control
number for these information
collections will be assigned.
Two commenters expressed concern
about the Paperwork Reduction Act
analysis published as part of the
proposed rule, and noted that the Board
and Corporation omitted nonbank
financial companies designated by the
Council for enhanced supervision by the
Board from that analysis. While the final
rule applies to any nonbank financial
company supervised by the Board, no
such covered company exists because
the Council has, to date, not designated
any such company for enhanced
supervision by the Board. However, the
Board expects that the amount of
burden the final rule would impose on
a nonbank financial company
designated by the Council to be similar

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
to the amount of burden estimated for
other covered companies.
One commenter stated that the costbenefit analysis of the proposed rule
significantly underestimated the time,
effort, and expense associated with
compliance. The Board notes that
several of the changes described in the
Supplementary Information reduce the
burden associated with the final rule,
particularly for smaller, less complex
covered companies. Specifically, the
final rule streamlines the resolution
plan requirement applicable to covered
companies that operate predominately
through one or more insured depository
institutions (or, in the case of foreign
banking organizations subject to the
rule, U.S. insured depository
institutions, branches, and agencies).
The information required under a
tailored plan is generally limited to
information regarding the nonbanking
operations of the company and the
interconnections between the bank and
nonbank operations of the company,
rather than its entire operations.
Title of Information Collection:
Resolution Plans Required.
Frequency of Response: Varied—
annually, semiannually, and eventgenerated.
Affected Public: The final rule applies
to bank holding companies and foreign
banking organizations with total
consolidated assets of $50 billion or
more, and nonbank financial companies
designated by the Council for enhanced
supervision by the Board.
Abstract: The information collection
requirements of the final rule are found
in sections [—].3, [—].4, and [—].5 of
the final rule. Specifically, as explained
in the Supplemental Information,
section [—].3 sets forth a staggered
schedule for submission of initial
resolution plans by covered companies,
and requires covered companies to
annually submit an updated resolution
plan on the anniversary of the initial
submission date. Section [—].3 of the
final rule establishes a requirement that
a covered company provide notice to
the Board and Corporation of material
events that have the potential to impact
its resolution plan.
Section [—].4 of the final rule
describes the required informational
content of both a full resolution plan
and the tailored resolution plan
available to smaller, less complex
covered companies. In providing
organizational structure information
required in section [—].4, a covered
company may rely on the information it
previously reported to the Board (FR
Y–6, Annual Report of Bank Holding
Companies; FR Y–7, Annual Report of
Foreign Banking Organizations; and FR

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

Y–10, Report of Changes in
Organizational Structure; OMB No.
7100–0297).
Under section [—].5 of the final rule,
a covered company is required to
resubmit an informationally complete
resolution plan or additional
information as jointly requested by the
Board and Corporation to facilitative
review of the covered company’s
resolution plan within 30 days of
receiving notice that its resolution plan
is deemed incomplete. Section [—].5 of
the final rule also requires that, if the
Board and Corporation jointly
determine that a resolution plan of a
covered company is not credible, a
covered company must resubmit a
revised plan within 90 days of receiving
notice that its resolution plan is deemed
deficient. A covered company may also
submit a written request for an
extension of time to resubmit additional
information or a revised resolution plan.
As noted in the Supplemental
Information, the Board and the
Corporation will, in a manner consistent
with the Dodd-Frank Act, assess the
confidentiality of resolution plans and
related material in accordance with
applicable exemptions under FOIA and
the Board’s and the Corporation’s
implementing regulations (12 CFR part
261 (Board); 12 CFR part 309
(Corporation)).
These requirements would implement
the resolution plan requirement set forth
in section 165(d)(1) of the Dodd-Frank
Act. Since the Board supervises all of
the respondents, the Board will take the
entire paperwork burden associated
with this information collection.
Estimated Burden
The burden associated with this
collection of information may be
summarized as follows:
Number of Respondents: Resolution
Plan (Tailored Reporters): 104;
Resolution Plan (Full Reporters): 20;
Notice of Material Change: 3; Additional
Information and Extension Requests: 24.
Estimated Average Hours per
Response (Initial Implementation):
Resolution Plan (Tailored Reporters):
4,500 hours; Resolution Plan (Full
Reporters): 9,200 hours; Additional
Information Requests: 1,000 hours.
Estimated Average Hours per
Response (Ongoing): Resolution Plan
(Tailored Reporters): 1,000 hours;
Resolution Plan (Full Reporters): 2,561
hours; Notice of Material Change: 20
hours; Extension Requests: 1 hour.
Total Estimated Annual Burden:
700,000 hours for initial
implementation and 155,304 hours on
an ongoing basis.

PO 00000

Frm 00019

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67333

The Agencies have a continuing
interest in the public’s opinions of
collections of information. At any time,
comments regarding the burden
estimate, or any other aspect of this
collection of information, including
suggestions for reducing the burden,
may be sent to: Secretary, Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve
System, 20th and C Streets, NW.,
Washington, DC 20551; and to the
Office of Management and Budget,
Paperwork Reduction Project (7100–
NEW), Washington, DC 20503.
B. Regulatory Flexibility Act Analysis
The Regulatory Flexibility Act, 5
U.S.C. 601 et seq. (‘‘RFA’’), requires
each Federal agency to prepare a final
regulatory flexibility analysis in
connection with the promulgation of a
final rule, or certify that the final rule
will not have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small
entities.13 Based on the analysis and for
the reasons stated below, the
Corporation certifies that this final rule
will not have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small
entities. The Board believes that the
final rule will not have a significant
economic impact on a substantial
number of small entities, but
nonetheless is conducting the
Regulatory Flexibility Act Analysis for
this final rule.
In accordance with section 165(d) of
the Dodd-Frank Act, the Board is
adopting the final rule as Regulation QQ
and is proposing to add new Part 243
(12 CFR part 243) and the Corporation
is proposing to add new Part 381 (12
CFR part 381) to establish the
requirements that a covered company
periodically submit a resolution plan to
the Board and Corporation.14 The final
rule would also establish the procedures
joint review of a resolution plan by the
Board and Corporation. The reasons and
justification for the final rule are
described in the Supplementary
Information. As further discussed in the
Supplementary Information, the
procedure, standards, and definitions
that would be established by the final
rule are relevant to the joint authority of
the Board and Corporation to implement
the resolution plan.
Under regulations issued by the Small
Business Administration (‘‘SBA’’), a
‘‘small entity’’ includes those firms
within the ‘‘Finance and Insurance’’
sector with asset sizes that vary from $7
million or less in assets to $175 million
13 See
14 See

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

5 U.S.C. 603, 604 and 605.
12 U.S.C. 5365(d).

01NOR1

67334

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

or less in assets.15 The Board believes
that the Finance and Insurance sector
constitutes a reasonable universe of
firms for these purposes because such
firms generally engage in actives that are
financial in nature. Consequently, bank
holding companies or nonbank financial
companies with assets sizes of $175
million or less are small entities for
purposes of the RFA.
As discussed in the Supplementary
Information, the final rule applies to a
‘‘covered company,’’ which includes
only bank holding companies and
foreign banks that are or are treated as
a bank holding company (‘‘foreign
banking organization’’) with $50 billion
or more in total consolidated assets, and
nonbank financial companies that the
Council has determined under section
113 of the Dodd-Frank Act must be
supervised by the Board and for which
such determination is in effect. Bank
holding companies and foreign banking
organizations that are subject to the final
rule therefore substantially exceed the
$175 million asset threshold at which a
banking entity is considered a ‘‘small
entity’’ under SBA regulations.16 The
final rule would apply to a nonbank
financial company supervised by the
Board regardless of such a company’s
asset size. Although the asset size of
nonbank financial companies may not
be the determinative factor of whether
such companies may pose systemic
risks and would be designated by the
Council for supervision by the Board, it
is an important consideration.17 It is
therefore unlikely that a financial firm
that is at or below the $175 million asset
threshold would be designated by the
Council under section 113 of the DoddFrank Act because material financial
distress at such firms, or the nature,
scope, size, scale, concentration,
interconnectedness, or mix of it
activities, are not likely to pose a threat
to the financial stability of the United
States.
As noted above, because the final rule
is not likely to apply to any company
with assets of $175 million or less, the
final rule is not expected to apply to any
small entity for purposes of the RFA.
Moreover, as discussed in the
Supplementary Information, the DoddFrank Act requires the Board and the
Corporation jointly to adopt rules
implementing the provisions of section
15 13

CFR 121.201.
Dodd-Frank Act provides that the Board
may, on the recommendation of the Council,
increase the $50 billion asset threshold for the
application of the resolution plan and credit
exposure report requirements. See 12 U.S.C.
5365(a)(2)(B). However, neither the Board nor the
Council has the authority to lower such threshold.
17 See 76 FR 4555 (January 26, 2011).
16 The

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

165(d) of the Dodd-Frank Act. The
Board does not believe that the final
rule would have a significant economic
impact on a substantial number of small
entities or that the final rule duplicates,
overlaps, or conflicts with any other
Federal rules.
C. Use of Plain Language
Section 722 of the Gramm-LeachBliley Act requires the Federal banking
agencies to use plain language in all
proposed and final rules published after
January 1, 2000. The Board and
Corporation invited comment on
whether the proposed rule was written
plainly and clearly, or whether there
were ways the Board and Corporation
could make the rule easier to
understand. The Board and Corporation
received no comments on these matters
and believe that the final rule is written
plainly and clearly.
Text of the Common Rules
(All Agencies)
PART ø

¿—RESOLUTION PLANS

Sec.
ll.1 Authority and scope.
ll.2 Definitions.
ll.3 Resolution plan required.
ll.4 Informational content of a resolution
plan.
ll.5 Review of resolution plans;
resubmission of deficient resolution
plans.
ll.6 Failure to cure deficiencies on
resubmission of a resolution plan.
ll.7 Consultation.
ll.8 No limiting effect or private right of
action; confidentiality of resolution
plans.
ll.9 Enforcement.
§ ll.1

Authority and scope.

(a) Authority. This part is issued
pursuant to section 165(d)(8) of the
Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act (the DoddFrank Act) (Pub. L. 111–203, 124 Stat.
1376, 1426–1427), 12 U.S.C. 5365(d)(8),
which requires the Board of Governors
of the Federal Reserve System (Board)
and the Federal Deposit Insurance
Corporation (Corporation) to jointly
issue rules implementing the provisions
of section 165(d) of the Dodd-Frank Act.
(b) Scope. This part applies to each
covered company and establishes rules
and requirements regarding the
submission and content of a resolution
plan, as well as procedures for review
by the Board and Corporation of a
resolution plan.
§ ll.2

Definitions.

For purposes of this part:
(a) Bankruptcy Code means Title 11 of
the United States Code.

PO 00000

Frm 00020

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

(b) Company means a corporation,
partnership, limited liability company,
depository institution, business trust,
special purpose entity, association, or
similar organization, but does not
include any organization, the majority
of the voting securities of which are
owned by the United States.
(c) Control. A company controls
another company when the first
company, directly or indirectly, owns,
or holds with power to vote, 25 percent
or more of any class of the second
company’s outstanding voting
securities.
(d) Core business lines means those
business lines of the covered company,
including associated operations,
services, functions and support, that, in
the view of the covered company, upon
failure would result in a material loss of
revenue, profit, or franchise value.
(e) Council means the Financial
Stability Oversight Council established
by section 111 of the Dodd-Frank Act
(12 U.S.C. 5321).
(f) Covered company. (1) In general. A
‘‘covered company’’ means:
(i) Any nonbank financial company
supervised by the Board;
(ii) Any bank holding company, as
that term is defined in section 2 of the
Bank Holding Company Act, as
amended (12 U.S.C. 1841), and the
Board’s Regulation Y (12 CFR part 225),
that has $50 billion or more in total
consolidated assets, as determined
based on the average of the company’s
four most recent Consolidated Financial
Statements for Bank Holding Companies
as reported on the Federal Reserve’s
Form FR Y–9C (‘‘FR Y–9C’’); and
(iii) Any foreign bank or company that
is a bank holding company or is treated
as a bank holding company under
section 8(a) of the International Banking
Act of 1978 (12 U.S.C. 3106(a)), and that
has $50 billion or more in total
consolidated assets, as determined
based on the foreign bank’s or
company’s most recent annual or, as
applicable, the average of the four most
recent quarterly Capital and Asset
Reports for Foreign Banking
Organizations as reported on the Federal
Reserve’s Form FR Y–7Q (‘‘FR Y–7Q’’).
(2) Once a covered company meets
the requirements described in paragraph
(f)(1)(ii) or (iii) of this section, the
company shall remain a covered
company for purposes of this part
unless and until the company has less
than $45 billion in total consolidated
assets, as determined based on the—
(i) Average total consolidated assets as
reported on the company’s four most
recent FR Y–9Cs, in the case of a
covered company described in
paragraph (f)(1)(ii) of this section; or

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
(ii) Total consolidated assets as
reported on the company’s most recent
annual FR Y–7Q, or, as applicable,
average total consolidated assets as
reported on the company’s four most
recent quarterly FR Y–7Qs, in the case
of a covered company described in
paragraph (f)(1)(iii) of this section.
Nothing in this paragraph (f)(2) shall
preclude a company from becoming a
covered company pursuant to paragraph
(f)(1) of this section.
(3) Multi-tiered holding company. In a
multi-tiered holding company structure,
covered company means the top-tier of
the multi-tiered holding company only.
(4) Asset threshold for bank holding
companies and foreign banking
organizations. The Board may, pursuant
to a recommendation of the Council,
raise any asset threshold specified in
paragraph (f)(1)(ii) or (iii) of this section.
(5) Exclusion. A bridge financial
company chartered pursuant to 12
U.S.C. 5390(h) shall not be deemed to be
a covered company hereunder.
(g) Critical operations means those
operations of the covered company,
including associated services, functions
and support, the failure or
discontinuance of which, in the view of
the covered company or as jointly
directed by the Board and the
Corporation, would pose a threat to the
financial stability of the United States.
(h) Depository institution has the
same meaning as in section 3(c)(1) of the
Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12
U.S.C. 1813(c)(1)) and includes a statelicensed uninsured branch, agency, or
commercial lending subsidiary of a
foreign bank.
(i) Foreign banking organization
means—
(1) A foreign bank, as defined in
section 1(b)(7) of the International
Banking Act of 1978 (12 U.S.C. 3101(7)),
that:
(i) Operates a branch, agency, or
commercial lending company
subsidiary in the United States;
(ii) Controls a bank in the United
States; or
(iii) Controls an Edge corporation
acquired after March 5, 1987; and
(2) Any company of which the foreign
bank is a subsidiary.
(j) Foreign-based company means any
covered company that is not
incorporated or organized under the
laws of the United States.
(k) Functionally regulated subsidiary
has the same meaning as in section
5(c)(5) of the Bank Holding Company
Act, as amended (12 U.S.C. 1844(c)(5)).
(l) Material entity means a subsidiary
or foreign office of the covered company
that is significant to the activities of a

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

critical operation or core business line
(as defined in this part).
(m) Material financial distress with
regard to a covered company means
that:
(1) The covered company has
incurred, or is likely to incur, losses that
will deplete all or substantially all of its
capital, and there is no reasonable
prospect for the company to avoid such
depletion;
(2) The assets of the covered company
are, or are likely to be, less than its
obligations to creditors and others; or
(3) The covered company is, or is
likely to be, unable to pay its obligations
(other than those subject to a bona fide
dispute) in the normal course of
business.
(n) Nonbank financial company
supervised by the Board means a
nonbank financial company or other
company that the Council has
determined under section 113 of the
Dodd-Frank Act (12 U.S.C. 5323) shall
be supervised by the Board and for
which such determination is still in
effect.
(o) Rapid and orderly resolution
means a reorganization or liquidation of
the covered company (or, in the case of
a covered company that is incorporated
or organized in a jurisdiction other than
the United States, the subsidiaries and
operations of such foreign company that
are domiciled in the United States)
under the Bankruptcy Code that can be
accomplished within a reasonable
period of time and in a manner that
substantially mitigates the risk that the
failure of the covered company would
have serious adverse effects on financial
stability in the United States.
(p) Subsidiary means a company that
is controlled by another company, and
an indirect subsidiary is a company that
is controlled by a subsidiary of a
company.
(q) United States means the United
States and includes any state of the
United States, the District of Columbia,
any territory of the United States, Puerto
Rico, Guam, American Samoa, and the
Virgin Islands.
§ ll.3

Resolution plan required.

(a) Initial and annual resolution plans
required.—(1) Each covered company
shall submit its initial resolution plan to
the Board and the Corporation on or
before the date set forth below (‘‘Initial
Submission Date’’):
(i) July 1, 2012, with respect to any
covered company that, as of the
effective date of this part, had $250
billion or more in total nonbank assets
(or, in the case of a covered company
that is a foreign-based company, in total
U.S. nonbank assets);

PO 00000

Frm 00021

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67335

(ii) July 1, 2013, with respect to any
covered company that is not described
in paragraph (a)(1)(i) of this section, and
that, as of the effective date of this part
had $100 billion or more in total
nonbank assets (or, in the case of a
covered company that is a foreign-based
company, in total U.S. nonbank assets);
and
(iii) December 31, 2013, with respect
to any other covered company that is a
covered company as of the effective date
of this part but that is not described in
paragraph (a)(1)(i) or (ii) of this section.
(2) A company that becomes a
covered company after the effective date
of this part shall submit its initial
resolution plan no later than the next
July 1 following the date the company
becomes a covered company, provided
such date occurs no earlier than 270
days after the date on which the
company became a covered company.
(3) After filing its initial resolution
plan pursuant to paragraph (a)(1) or (2)
of this section, each covered company
shall annually submit a resolution plan
to the Board and the Corporation on or
before each anniversary date of its
Initial Submission Date.
(4) Notwithstanding anything to the
contrary in this paragraph (a), the Board
and Corporation may jointly determine
that a covered company shall file its
initial or annual resolution plan by a
date other than as provided in this
paragraph (a). The Board and the
Corporation shall provide a covered
company with written notice of a
determination under this paragraph
(a)(4) no later than 180 days prior to the
date on which the Board and
Corporation jointly determined to
require the covered company to submit
its resolution plan.
(b) Authority to require interim
updates and notice of material events.—
(1) In general. The Board and the
Corporation may jointly require that a
covered company file an update to a
resolution plan submitted under
paragraph (a) of this section, within a
reasonable amount of time, as jointly
determined by the Board and
Corporation. The Board and the
Corporation shall make a request
pursuant to this paragraph (b)(1) in
writing, and shall specify the portions
or aspects of the resolution plan the
covered company shall update.
(2) Notice of material events. Each
covered company shall provide the
Board and the Corporation with a notice
no later than 45 days after any event,
occurrence, change in conditions or
circumstances, or other change that
results in, or could reasonably be
foreseen to have, a material effect on the
resolution plan of the covered company.

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

67336

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

Such notice should describe the event,
occurrence or change and explain why
the event, occurrence or change may
require changes to the resolution plan.
The covered company shall address any
event, occurrence or change with
respect to which it has provided notice
pursuant to this paragraph (b)(2) in the
following resolution plan submitted by
the covered company.
(3) Exception. A covered company
shall not be required to file a notice
under paragraph (b)(2) of this section if
the date on which the covered company
would be required to submit the notice
under paragraph (b)(2) would be within
90 days prior to the date on which the
covered company is required to file an
annual resolution plan under paragraph
(a) of this section.
(c) Authority to require more frequent
submissions or extend time period.—
The Board and Corporation may jointly:
(1) Require that a covered company
submit a resolution plan more
frequently than required pursuant to
paragraph (a) of this section; and
(2) Extend the time period that a
covered company has to submit a
resolution plan or a notice following
material events under paragraphs (a)
and (b) of this section.
(d) Access to information.—In order
to allow evaluation of the resolution
plan, each covered company must
provide the Board and the Corporation
such information and access to
personnel of the covered company as
the Board and the Corporation jointly
determine during the period for
reviewing the resolution plan is
necessary to assess the credibility of the
resolution plan and the ability of the
covered company to implement the
resolution plan. The Board and the
Corporation will rely to the fullest
extent possible on examinations
conducted by or on behalf of the
appropriate Federal banking agency for
the relevant company.
(e) Board of directors approval of
resolution plan.—Prior to submission of
a resolution plan under paragraph (a) of
this section, the resolution plan of a
covered company shall be approved by:
(1) The board of directors of the
covered company and noted in the
minutes; or
(2) In the case of a foreign-based
covered company only, a delegee acting
under the express authority of the board
of directors of the covered company to
approve the resolution plan.
(f) Resolution plans provided to the
Council.—The Board shall make the
resolution plans and updates submitted
by the covered company pursuant to
this section available to the Council
upon request.

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

§ ll.4 Informational content of a
resolution plan.

(a) In general.—(1) Domestic covered
companies. Except as otherwise
provided in paragraph (a)(3) of this
section, the resolution plan of a covered
company that is organized or
incorporated in the United States shall
include the information specified in
paragraphs (b) through (i) of this section
with respect to the subsidiaries and
operations that are domiciled in the
United States as well as the foreign
subsidiaries, offices, and operations of
the covered company.
(2) Foreign-based covered
companies.—Except as otherwise
provided in paragraph (a)(3) of the
section, the resolution plan of a covered
company that is organized or
incorporated in a jurisdiction other than
the United States (other than a bank
holding company) or that is a foreign
banking organization shall include:
(i) The information specified in
paragraphs (b) through (i) of this section
with respect to the subsidiaries,
branches and agencies, and critical
operations and core business lines, as
applicable, that are domiciled in the
United States or conducted in whole or
material part in the United States. With
respect to the information specified in
paragraph (g) of this section, the
resolution plan of a foreign-based
covered company shall also identify,
describe in detail, and map to legal
entity the interconnections and
interdependencies among the U.S.
subsidiaries, branches and agencies, and
critical operations and core business
lines of the foreign-based covered
company and any foreign-based affiliate;
and
(ii) A detailed explanation of how
resolution planning for the subsidiaries,
branches and agencies, and critical
operations and core business lines of the
foreign-based covered company that are
domiciled in the United States or
conducted in whole or material part in
the United States is integrated into the
foreign-based covered company’s
overall resolution or other contingency
planning process.
(3) Tailored resolution plan. (i)
Eligible covered company.—Paragraph
(a)(3)(ii) of this section applies to any
covered company that as of December
31 of the calendar year prior to the date
its resolution plan is required to be
submitted under this part—
(A) Has less than $100 billion in total
nonbank assets (or, in the case of a
covered company that is a foreign-based
company, in total U.S. nonbank assets);
and
(B) The total insured depository
institution assets of which comprise 85

PO 00000

Frm 00022

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

percent or more of the covered
company’s total consolidated assets (or,
in the case of a covered company that
is a foreign-based company, the assets of
the U.S. insured depository institution
operations, branches, and agencies of
which comprise 85 percent or more of
such covered company’s U.S. total
consolidated assets).
(ii) Tailored resolution plan elements.
A covered company described in
paragraph (a)(3)(i) of this section may
file a resolution plan that is limited to
the following items—
(A) An executive summary, as
specified in paragraph (b) of this
section;
(B) The information specified in
paragraphs (c) through (f) and paragraph
(h) of this section, but only with respect
to the covered company and its
nonbanking material entities and
operations;
(C) The information specified in
paragraphs (g) and (i) of this section
with respect to the covered company
and all of its insured depository
institutions (or, in the case of a covered
company that is a foreign-based
company, the U.S. insured depository
institutions, branches, and agencies)
and nonbank material entities and
operations. The interconnections and
interdependencies identified pursuant
to (g) of this section shall be included
in the analysis provided pursuant to
paragraph (c) of this section.
(iii) Notice.—A covered company that
meets the requirements of paragraph
(a)(3)(i) of this section and that intends
to submit a resolution plan pursuant to
this paragraph (a)(3), shall provide the
Board and Corporation with written
notice of such intent and its eligibility
under paragraph (a)(3)(i) no later than
270 days prior to the date on which the
covered company is required to submit
its resolution plan. Within 90 of
receiving such notice, the Board and
Corporation may jointly determine that
the covered company must submit a
resolution plan that meets some or all of
the requirements as set forth in
paragraph (a)(1) or (2) of this section, as
applicable.
(4) Required and prohibited
assumptions.—In preparing its plan for
rapid and orderly resolution in the
event of material financial distress or
failure required by this part, a covered
company shall:
(i) Take into account that such
material financial distress or failure of
the covered company may occur under
the baseline, adverse and severely
adverse economic conditions provided
to the covered company by the Board
pursuant to 12 U.S.C. 5365(i)(1)(B);
provided, however, a covered company

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
may submit its initial resolution plan
assuming the baseline conditions only,
or, if a baseline scenario is not then
available, a reasonable substitute
developed by the covered company; and
(ii) Not rely on the provision of
extraordinary support by the United
States or any other government to the
covered company or its subsidiaries to
prevent the failure of the covered
company.
(b) Executive summary.—Each
resolution plan of a covered company
shall include an executive summary
describing:
(1) The key elements of the covered
company’s strategic plan for rapid and
orderly resolution in the event of
material financial distress at or failure of
the covered company.
(2) Material changes to the covered
company’s resolution plan from the
company’s most recently filed
resolution plan (including any notices
following a material event or updates to
the resolution plan).
(3) Any actions taken by the covered
company since filing of the previous
resolution plan to improve the
effectiveness of the covered company’s
resolution plan or remediate or
otherwise mitigate any material
weaknesses or impediments to effective
and timely execution of the resolution
plan.
(c) Strategic analysis.—Each
resolution plan shall include a strategic
analysis describing the covered
company’s plan for rapid and orderly
resolution in the event of material
financial distress or failure of the
covered company. Such analysis shall—
(1) Include detailed descriptions of
the—
(i) Key assumptions and supporting
analysis underlying the covered
company’s resolution plan, including
any assumptions made concerning the
economic or financial conditions that
would be present at the time the
covered company sought to implement
such plan;
(ii) Range of specific actions to be
taken by the covered company to
facilitate a rapid and orderly resolution
of the covered company, its material
entities, and its critical operations and
core business lines in the event of
material financial distress or failure of
the covered company;
(iii) Funding, liquidity and capital
needs of, and resources available to, the
covered company and its material
entities, which shall be mapped to its
critical operations and core business
lines, in the ordinary course of business
and in the event of material financial
distress at or failure of the covered
company;

VerDate Mar<15>2010

18:02 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 223001

(iv) Covered company’s strategy for
maintaining operations of, and funding
for, the covered company and its
material entities, which shall be
mapped to its critical operations and
core business lines;
(v) Covered company’s strategy in the
event of a failure or discontinuation of
a material entity, core business line or
critical operation, and the actions that
will be taken by the covered company
to prevent or mitigate any adverse
effects of such failure or discontinuation
on the financial stability of the United
States; provided, however, if any such
material entity is subject to an
insolvency regime other than the
Bankruptcy Code, a covered company
may exclude that entity from its
strategic analysis unless that entity
either has $50 billion or more in total
assets or conducts a critical operation;
and
(vi) Covered company’s strategy for
ensuring that any insured depository
institution subsidiary of the covered
company will be adequately protected
from risks arising from the activities of
any nonbank subsidiaries of the covered
company (other than those that are
subsidiaries of an insured depository
institution);
(2) Identify the time period(s) the
covered company expects would be
needed for the covered company to
successfully execute each material
aspect and step of the covered
company’s plan;
(3) Identify and describe any potential
material weaknesses or impediments to
effective and timely execution of the
covered company’s plan;
(4) Discuss the actions and steps the
covered company has taken or proposes
to take to remediate or otherwise
mitigate the weaknesses or impediments
identified by the covered company,
including a timeline for the remedial or
other mitigatory action; and
(5) Provide a detailed description of
the processes the covered company
employs for:
(i) Determining the current market
values and marketability of the core
business lines, critical operations, and
material asset holdings of the covered
company;
(ii) Assessing the feasibility of the
covered company’s plans (including
timeframes) for executing any sales,
divestitures, restructurings,
recapitalizations, or other similar
actions contemplated in the covered
company’s resolution plan; and
(iii) Assessing the impact of any sales,
divestitures, restructurings,
recapitalizations, or other similar
actions on the value, funding, and
operations of the covered company, its

PO 00000

Frm 00023

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67337

material entities, critical operations and
core business lines.
(d) Corporate governance relating to
resolution planning.—Each resolution
plan shall:
(1) Include a detailed description of:
(i) How resolution planning is
integrated into the corporate governance
structure and processes of the covered
company;
(ii) The covered company’s policies,
procedures, and internal controls
governing preparation and approval of
the covered company’s resolution plan;
(iii) The identity and position of the
senior management official(s) of the
covered company that is primarily
responsible for overseeing the
development, maintenance,
implementation, and filing of the
covered company’s resolution plan and
for the covered company’s compliance
with this part; and
(iv) The nature, extent, and frequency
of reporting to senior executive officers
and the board of directors of the covered
company regarding the development,
maintenance, and implementation of the
covered company’s resolution plan;
(2) Describe the nature, extent, and
results of any contingency planning or
similar exercise conducted by the
covered company since the date of the
covered company’s most recently filed
resolution plan to assess the viability of
or improve the resolution plan of the
covered company; and
(3) Identify and describe the relevant
risk measures used by the covered
company to report credit risk exposures
both internally to its senior management
and board of directors, as well as any
relevant risk measures reported
externally to investors or to the covered
company’s appropriate Federal
regulator.
(e) Organizational structure and
related information.—Each resolution
plan shall—
(1) Provide a detailed description of
the covered company’s organizational
structure, including:
(i) A hierarchical list of all material
entities within the covered company’s
organization (including legal entities
that directly or indirectly hold such
material entities) that:
(A) Identifies the direct holder and
the percentage of voting and nonvoting
equity of each legal entity and foreign
office listed; and
(B) The location, jurisdiction of
incorporation, licensing, and key
management associated with each
material legal entity and foreign office
identified;
(ii) A mapping of the covered
company’s critical operations and core
business lines, including material asset

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

67338

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

holdings and liabilities related to such
critical operations and core business
lines, to material entities;
(2) Provide an unconsolidated balance
sheet for the covered company and a
consolidating schedule for all material
entities that are subject to consolidation
by the covered company;
(3) Include a description of the
material components of the liabilities of
the covered company, its material
entities, critical operations and core
business lines that, at a minimum,
separately identifies types and amounts
of the short-term and long-term
liabilities, the secured and unsecured
liabilities, and subordinated liabilities;
(4) Identify and describe the processes
used by the covered company to:
(i) Determine to whom the covered
company has pledged collateral;
(ii) Identify the person or entity that
holds such collateral; and
(iii) Identify the jurisdiction in which
the collateral is located, and, if different,
the jurisdiction in which the security
interest in the collateral is enforceable
against the covered company;
(5) Describe any material off-balance
sheet exposures (including guarantees
and contractual obligations) of the
covered company and its material
entities, including a mapping to its
critical operations and core business
lines;
(6) Describe the practices of the
covered company, its material entities
and its core business lines related to the
booking of trading and derivatives
activities;
(7) Identify material hedges of the
covered company, its material entities,
and its core business lines related to
trading and derivative activities,
including a mapping to legal entity;
(8) Describe the hedging strategies of
the covered company;
(9) Describe the process undertaken
by the covered company to establish
exposure limits;
(10) Identify the major counterparties
of the covered company and describe
the interconnections, interdependencies
and relationships with such major
counterparties;
(11) Analyze whether the failure of
each major counterparty would likely
have an adverse impact on or result in
the material financial distress or failure
of the covered company; and
(12) Identify each trading, payment,
clearing, or settlement system of which
the covered company, directly or
indirectly, is a member and on which
the covered company conducts a
material number or value amount of
trades or transactions. Map membership
in each such system to the covered

VerDate Mar<15>2010

18:02 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 223001

company’s material entities, critical
operations and core business lines.
(f) Management information
systems.—(1) Each resolution plan shall
include—
(i) A detailed inventory and
description of the key management
information systems and applications,
including systems and applications for
risk management, accounting, and
financial and regulatory reporting, used
by the covered company and its material
entities. The description of each system
or application provided shall identify
the legal owner or licensor, the use or
function of the system or application,
service level agreements related thereto,
any software and system licenses, and
any intellectual property associated
therewith;
(ii) A mapping of the key management
information systems and applications to
the material entities, critical operations
and core business lines of the covered
company that use or rely on such
systems and applications;
(iii) An identification of the scope,
content, and frequency of the key
internal reports that senior management
of the covered company, its material
entities, critical operations and core
business lines use to monitor the
financial health, risks, and operation of
the covered company, its material
entities, critical operations and core
business lines; and
(iv) A description of the process for
the appropriate supervisory or
regulatory agencies to access the
management information systems and
applications identified in paragraph (f)
of this section; and
(v) A description and analysis of—
(A) The capabilities of the covered
company’s management information
systems to collect, maintain, and report,
in a timely manner to management of
the covered company, and to the Board,
the information and data underlying the
resolution plan; and
(B) Any deficiencies, gaps or
weaknesses in such capabilities, and a
description of the actions the covered
company intends to take to promptly
address such deficiencies, gaps, or
weaknesses, and the time frame for
implementing such actions.
(2) The Board will use its examination
authority to review the demonstrated
capabilities of each covered company to
satisfy the requirements of paragraph
(f)(1)(v) of this section. The Board will
share with the Corporation information
regarding the capabilities of the covered
company to collect, maintain, and
report in a timely manner information
and data underlying the resolution plan.
(g) Interconnections and
interdependencies. To the extent not

PO 00000

Frm 00024

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

elsewhere provided, identify and map to
the material entities the
interconnections and interdependencies
among the covered company and its
material entities, and among the critical
operations and core business lines of the
covered company that, if disrupted,
would materially affect the funding or
operations of the covered company, its
material entities, or its critical
operations or core business lines. Such
interconnections and interdependencies
may include:
(1) Common or shared personnel,
facilities, or systems (including
information technology platforms,
management information systems, risk
management systems, and accounting
and recordkeeping systems);
(2) Capital, funding, or liquidity
arrangements;
(3) Existing or contingent credit
exposures;
(4) Cross-guarantee arrangements,
cross-collateral arrangements, crossdefault provisions, and cross-affiliate
netting agreements;
(5) Risk transfers; and
(6) Service level agreements.
(h) Supervisory and regulatory
information. Each resolution plan
shall—
(1) Identify any:
(i) Federal, state, or foreign agency or
authority (other than a Federal banking
agency) with supervisory authority or
responsibility for ensuring the safety
and soundness of the covered company,
its material entities, critical operations
and core business lines; and
(ii) Other Federal, state, or foreign
agency or authority (other than a
Federal banking agency) with significant
supervisory or regulatory authority over
the covered company, and its material
entities and critical operations and core
business lines.
(2) Identify any foreign agency or
authority responsible for resolving a
foreign-based material entity and critical
operations or core business lines of the
covered company; and
(3) Include contact information for
each agency identified in paragraphs
(h)(1) and (2) of this section.
(i) Contact information. Each
resolution plan shall identify a senior
management official at the covered
company responsible for serving as a
point of contact regarding the resolution
plan of the covered company, and
include contact information (including
phone number, email address, and
physical address) for a senior
management official of the material
entities of the covered company.
(j) Inclusion of previously submitted
resolution plan informational elements
by reference. An annual submission of

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations
or update to a resolution plan submitted
by a covered company may include by
reference informational elements (but
not strategic analysis or executive
summary elements) from a resolution
plan previously submitted by the
covered company to the Board and the
Corporation, provided that:
(1) The resolution plan seeking to
include informational elements by
reference clearly indicates:
(i) The informational element the
covered company is including by
reference; and
(ii) Which of the covered company’s
previously submitted resolution plan(s)
originally contained the information the
covered company is including by
reference; and
(2) The covered company certifies that
the information the covered company is
including by reference remains accurate.
(k) Exemptions. The Board and the
Corporation may jointly exempt a
covered company from one or more of
the requirements of this section.

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

§ ll.5 Review of resolution plans;
resubmission of deficient resolution plans.

(a) Acceptance of submission and
review. (1) The Board and Corporation
shall review a resolution plan submitted
under section this subpart within 60
days.
(2) If the Board and Corporation
jointly determine within the time
described in paragraph (a)(1) of this
section that a resolution plan is
informationally incomplete or that
substantial additional information is
necessary to facilitate review of the
resolution plan:
(i) The Board and Corporation shall
jointly inform the covered company in
writing of the area(s) in which the
resolution plan is informationally
incomplete or with respect to which
additional information is required; and
(ii) The covered company shall
resubmit an informationally complete
resolution plan or such additional
information as jointly requested to
facilitate review of the resolution plan
no later than 30 days after receiving the
notice described in paragraph (a)(2)(i) of
this section, or such other time period
as the Board and Corporation may
jointly determine.
(b) Joint determination regarding
deficient resolution plans. If the Board
and Corporation jointly determine that
the resolution plan of a covered
company submitted under § ll.3(a) is
not credible or would not facilitate an
orderly resolution of the covered
company under the Bankruptcy Code,
the Board and Corporation shall jointly
notify the covered company in writing
of such determination. Any joint notice
provided under this paragraph shall

VerDate Mar<15>2010

18:02 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 223001

identify the aspects of the resolution
plan that the Board and Corporation
jointly determined to be deficient.
(c) Resubmission of a resolution plan.
Within 90 days of receiving a notice of
deficiencies issued pursuant to
paragraph (b) of this section, or such
shorter or longer period as the Board
and Corporation may jointly determine,
a covered company shall submit a
revised resolution plan to the Board and
Corporation that addresses the
deficiencies jointly identified by the
Board and Corporation, and that
discusses in detail:
(1) The revisions made by the covered
company to address the deficiencies
jointly identified by the Board and the
Corporation;
(2) Any changes to the covered
company’s business operations and
corporate structure that the covered
company proposes to undertake to
facilitate implementation of the revised
resolution plan (including a timeline for
the execution of such planned changes);
and
(3) Why the covered company
believes that the revised resolution plan
is credible and would result in an
orderly resolution of the covered
company under the Bankruptcy Code.
(d) Extensions of time. Upon their
own initiative or a written request by a
covered company, the Board and
Corporation may jointly extend any time
period under this section. Each
extension request shall be supported by
a written statement of the covered
company describing the basis and
justification for the request.
§ ll.6 Failure to cure deficiencies on
resubmission of a resolution plan.

(a) In general. The Board and
Corporation may jointly determine that
a covered company or any subsidiary of
a covered company shall be subject to
more stringent capital, leverage, or
liquidity requirements, or restrictions
on the growth, activities, or operations
of the covered company or the
subsidiary if:
(1) The covered company fails to
submit a revised resolution plan under
§ ll.5(c) within the required time
period; or
(2) The Board and the Corporation
jointly determine that a revised
resolution plan submitted under
§ ll.5(c) does not adequately remedy
the deficiencies jointly identified by the
Board and the Corporation under
§ ll.5(b).
(b) Duration of requirements or
restrictions.—Any requirements or
restrictions imposed on a covered
company or a subsidiary thereof
pursuant to paragraph (a) of this section
shall cease to apply to the covered

PO 00000

Frm 00025

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

67339

company or subsidiary, respectively, on
the date that the Board and the
Corporation jointly determine the
covered company has submitted a
revised resolution plan that adequately
remedies the deficiencies jointly
identified by the Board and the
Corporation under § ll.5(b).
(c) Divestiture. The Board and
Corporation, in consultation with the
Council, may jointly, by order, direct
the covered company to divest such
assets or operations as are jointly
identified by the Board and Corporation
if:
(1) The Board and Corporation have
jointly determined that the covered
company or a subsidiary thereof shall be
subject to requirements or restrictions
pursuant to paragraph (a) of this section;
and
(2) The covered company has failed,
within the 2-year period beginning on
the date on which the determination to
impose such requirements or
restrictions under paragraph (a) of this
section was made, to submit a revised
resolution plan that adequately
remedies the deficiencies jointly
identified by the Board and the
Corporation under § ll.5(b); and
(3) The Board and Corporation jointly
determine that the divestiture of such
assets or operations is necessary to
facilitate an orderly resolution of the
covered company under the Bankruptcy
Code in the event the company was to
fail.
§ ll.7

Consultation.

Prior to issuing any notice of
deficiencies under § ll.5(b),
determining to impose requirements or
restrictions under § ll.6(a), or issuing
a divestiture order pursuant to
§ ll.6(c) with respect to a covered
company that is likely to have a
significant impact on a functionally
regulated subsidiary or a depository
institution subsidiary of the covered
company, the Board—
(a) Shall consult with each Council
member that primarily supervises any
such subsidiary; and
(b) May consult with any other
Federal, state, or foreign supervisor as
the Board considers appropriate.
§ ll.8 No limiting effect or private right
of action; confidentiality of resolution
plans.

(a) No limiting effect on bankruptcy or
other resolution proceedings.—A
resolution plan submitted pursuant to
this part shall not have any binding
effect on:
(1) A court or trustee in a proceeding
commenced under the Bankruptcy
Code;

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1

mstockstill on DSK4VPTVN1PROD with RULES

67340

Federal Register / Vol. 76, No. 211 / Tuesday, November 1, 2011 / Rules and Regulations

(2) A receiver appointed under Title
II of the Dodd-Frank Act (12 U.S.C. 5381
et seq.);
(3) A bridge financial company
chartered pursuant to 12 U.S.C. 5390(h);
or
(4) Any other authority that is
authorized or required to resolve a
covered company (including any
subsidiary or affiliate thereof) under any
other provision of Federal, state, or
foreign law.
(b) No private right of action.—
Nothing in this part creates or is
intended to create a private right of
action based on a resolution plan
prepared or submitted under this part or
based on any action taken by the Board
or the Corporation with respect to any
resolution plan submitted under this
part.
(c) Form of resolution plans. Each
resolution plan of a covered company
shall be divided into a public section
and a confidential section. Each covered
company shall segregate and separately
identify the public section from the
confidential section. The public section
shall consist of an executive summary of
the resolution plan that describes the
business of the covered company and
includes, to the extent material to an
understanding of the covered company:
(1) The names of material entities;
(2) A description of core business
lines;
(3) Consolidated or segment financial
information regarding assets, liabilities,
capital and major funding sources;
(4) A description of derivative
activities and hedging activities;
(5) A list of memberships in material
payment, clearing and settlement
systems;
(6) A description of foreign
operations;
(7) The identities of material
supervisory authorities;
(8) The identities of the principal
officers;
(9) A description of the corporate
governance structure and processes
related to resolution planning;
(10) A description of material
management information systems; and
(11) A description, at a high level, of
the covered company’s resolution
strategy, covering such items as the
range of potential purchasers of the
covered company, its material entities
and core business lines.
(d) Confidential treatment of
resolution plans. (1) The confidentiality

VerDate Mar<15>2010

17:41 Oct 31, 2011

Jkt 226001

of resolution plans and related materials
shall be determined in accordance with
applicable exemptions under the
Freedom of Information Act (5 U.S.C.
552(b)) and the Board’s Rules Regarding
Availability of Information (12 CFR part
261), and the Corporation’s Disclosure
of Information Rules (12 CFR part 309).
(2) Any covered company submitting
a resolution plan or related materials
pursuant to this part that desires
confidential treatment of the
information under 5 U.S.C. 552(b)(4),
the Board’s Rules Regarding Availability
of Information (12 CFR part 261), and
the Corporation’s Disclosure of
Information Rules (12 CFR part 309)
may file a request for confidential
treatment in accordance with those
rules.
(3) To the extent permitted by law,
information comprising the Confidential
Section of a resolution plan will be
treated as confidential.
(4) To the extent permitted by law, the
submission of any nonpublic data or
information under this part shall not
constitute a waiver of, or otherwise
affect, any privilege arising under
Federal or state law (including the rules
of any Federal or state court) to which
the data or information is otherwise
subject. Privileges that apply to
resolution plans and related materials
are protected pursuant to Section 18(x)
of the FDI Act, 12 U.S.C. 1828(x).
§ ll.9

Enforcement.

The Board and Corporation may
jointly enforce an order jointly issued by
the Board and Corporation under
§ ll.6(a) or ll.6(c) of this part. The
Board, in consultation with the
Corporation, may take any action to
address any violation of this part by a
covered company under section 8 of the
Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12
U.S.C. 1818).
List of Subjects
12 CFR Part 243
Administrative practice and
procedure, Banks, Banking, Federal
Reserve System, Holding companies,
Reporting and recordkeeping
requirements, Securities.
12 CFR Part 381
Administrative practice and
procedure, Banks, Banking, Holding
companies, Reporting and

Frm 00026

Fmt 4700

Sfmt 4700

Adoption of Common Rule
The adoption of the common rules by
the agencies, as modified by agencyspecific text, is set forth below:
BOARD OF GOVERNORS OF THE
FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
12 CFR Chapter II

Authority and Issuance
For the reasons stated in the
Supplementary Information, the Board
of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System adds the text of the common
rule, as set forth at the end of the
Supplementary Information, as Part 243
to Chapter II of Title 12, modified as
follows:
PART 243—RESOLUTION PLANS
(REGULATION QQ)
1. The authority citation for part 243
reads as follows:

■

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 5365.

FEDERAL DEPOSIT INSURANCE
CORPORATION
12 CFR Chapter III

Authority and Issuance
For the reasons set forth in the
Supplementary Information, the Federal
Deposit Insurance Corporation to adds
the text of the common rule, as set forth
at the end of the Supplementary
Information, as Part 381 to Chapter III of
Title 12, Code of Federal Regulations,
modified as follows:
PART 381—RESOLUTION PLANS
1. The authority citation for part 381
reads as follows:

■

Authority: 12 U.S.C. 5365(d).

[End of Common Text]

PO 00000

recordkeeping requirements, Resolution
plans and credit exposure reports.

By order of the Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System, October 14, 2011.
Jennifer J. Johnson,
Secretary of the Board.
Dated at Washington, DC, this 13th day of
September 2011.
By order of the Board of Directors.
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.
Robert E. Feldman,
Executive Secretary.
[FR Doc. 2011–27377 Filed 10–31–11; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 6210–01–P

E:\FR\FM\01NOR1.SGM

01NOR1