View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

r

\

(D
(D

G)

JZ
o
L_

(d

2

Business Review




s
cd
_Q_
0
"Ö

jd

Z
d
4—

o
c

(d
OQ
0
>

0
(0

0

ir
ld

L_

0
"Ö

0
LL

V____

Profits Out of Thin Air:
. . . Extracting elements from the atmosphere is a relatively new and rapidly growing
industry with widening markets, some ordinary, some extraordinary.

1966 Looks Even Better:
. . . Recent changes in the business environment have caused forecasters of economic
conditions to revise substantially their expectations for 1966.

B U SIN E SS REVIEW

is produced in the Department of Research. Donald R. Hulmes prepared the layout and
artwork. Evan B. Alderfer was primarily responsible for the article “Profits Out of Thin Air" and William F. Staats and Kathryn
Kalmbach for “ 1966 Looks Even Better.” The authors will be glad to receive comments on their articles.
Requests for additional copies should be addressed to Bank and Public Relations, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19101.



PROFITS OUT OF THIN AIR
Air, thought the early Greek philosophers, was a

Gas; General Dynamic’s Liquid Carbonic; Big

basic element along with earth, water, and fire.

Three; Standard of New Jersey’s American Cry­

They were wrong on all four counts. The first

ogenics; and others.

person to succeed in taking air apart was Karl

Together they constitute what might be called

Scheele. In 1772, he isolated nitrogen and oxy­

atmospheric adventurers but they go under the

gen. Nitrogen he called “ foul air” because it

more prosaic title of the Industrial Gases In­

would support neither combustion nor respira­

dustry. As an industry, the Census reports for

tion. Oxygen he called “ fire air” because it sup­

1963 a total of 460 manufacturing establish­

ported both. Two years later, Joseph Priestly,

ments, 10,000 employees, about half of whom

who once lived in Northumberland, Pennsyl­

are classed as production workers, and $429

vania, independently discovered oxygen and he

million worth of shipments of gases and liquids.

has been given credit for the discovery because

High purity oxygen in that year accounted for

he was the first to announce it to the world.

about a third of the dollar value of these ship­

Nitrogen constitutes seventy-eight per cent of
the

volume

of

the

atmosphere

and oxygen

twenty-one per cent. The remaining one per

ments, and when nitrogen, hydrogen, and argon
are included, the four gases together made up
half the total value, of products shipped.

cent, in successively smaller fractions, is made

The industry is not very large but it is grow­

up of argon, carbon dioxide, neon, helium, kryp­

ing rapidly. Its index of production in 1963 was

ton, xenon, hydrogen, methane, and nitrous

two and one-half times that of 1958. This year’s
sales of gases and liquids are expected to reach

oxide.
All of these elements and substances have their

$725 million.

own peculiar physical characteristics or person­
alities, so to speak, which make them useful for

An industry founded upon cryogenics

different industrial purposes. They are, however,

The industrial gases industry operates in the

great homebodies and offer terrific resistance to

cold, cold world of cryogenics— a strange word

separation from the parental air.

with Greek roots meaning “ born icy-cold.” Water,

This difficulty is surmounted by giving air a

as everybody knows, changes to ice at 32°F.,

cryogenic treatment, that is, subjecting air to

and boils at 212°F. Other substances, in like

extreme cold— the coldest cold you ever heard of

manner, have their boiling points and freezing

— so cold that air becomes a liquid. Then the

points. Carbon dioxide, which we exhale, when

various elements can be separated by a process

cooled to — 109°F. becomes “ Dry Ice” — the

akin to refining petroleum.

coldest stuff with which most of us ever came

Corporate practitioners of this occult art are

in contact.

concerns like Linde Company, a division of

Oxygen, when cooled way down to — 297°F.,

Union Carbide; Air Products and Chemicals;

becomes a liquid. Nitrogen becomes a liquid at

Air Reduction; Chemetron’s National Cyclinder

— 320, hydrogen at — 423, and helium at — 452,




3

business review

which

is

perilously

close

to

absolute

CHART1

zero,

— 460°F., which is total absence of heat.
Heat is not a substance, as once believed; it

STEEL PRODUCTION IN THE UNITED STATES
Millions of Tons

(. 1955-1965 )

is molecules in motion. In the gaseous state of
any material, the molecules are in violent agita­
tion like a riot of students running amok. In
the liquid state, the molecules are restless, like
an unruly class of students kicking and punching
each other, and in the solid state, the molecules
resemble the class put to sleep by the professor’s
dry lecture. End of the lesson.
Extracting oxygen and other useful products
from air is thus based upon the principle of lowtemperature gas separation by liquefaction and
distillation. A tour through an air separation
plant affords no dramatic spectacles like those
of a steel mill with its burning fires, flying
sparks, and huge presses crunching great chunks
of glowing metal. An air separation plant is an
aggregation of refrigerating machinery, towers
and tanks, valves, pipes and pumps, and varieties
of instruments to tell what’s going on. The raw
material, air, is invisible and so are the goods in

facturers improved the quality, and reduced the

process as well as the finished products. Every­

cost of steel with the new Basic Oxygen Furnace.

thing is internal. Power is a major cost in oper­

In the B.O.F., hot metal and scrap are charged
into the furnace and by blowing a stream of

ating an air separation plant— the huge electric
motors required to run the refrigeration machin­

oxygen into the furnace from the top with the

ery that reduces atmospheric gases to liquids eat

aid of a water-cooled lance, the charge is con­

up great gobs of kilowatts.

verted into steel in a matter of minutes instead
of hours as in the open-hearth process.

The markets

In the 1950’s steel mills in this country began

Oxygen has long done yeoman’s service in the

installing basic oxygen furnaces and the new

metal trades. Fires enriched with oxygen burn

process is now challenging the old workhorse

hotter, so metal fabricators use oxy-acetylene for

open-hearth furnaces. From 1955 through 1965,

cutting and welding. A goggled worker playing

basic oxygen steel production rose from less

a bright blue flame at the point of the weld on

than one-half million tons to almost 23 millions

a steel rail has long been a familiar scene.

while open-hearth production declined from 105

Revolutionary developments in the art of steel

million tons to 94 million tons, and the B.O.F.

production opened a big new market for oxygen.

seems

Prior to World War II, European steel manu-

shown in Chart 1. Oxygen is also used by the

4




destined to

supersede

open-hearth

as

business review

steel industry for smelting pig iron in the blast

“Over the fence” sales

furnaces, in the electric and Bessemer steel mak­

Oxygen and other major products of air separa­

ing furnaces, and in preparing scrap iron and

tion— nitrogen, hydrogen, and argon— are de­

steel for remelting.

livered to customers by pipeline, in bulk liquid

The effect of the new technology on the de­

form (cryogenic fluid), in bulk gas form (tube

mand for oxygen is portrayed in Chart 2 which

trailers), and in cyclinders (compressed gas).

shows the steel industry’s consumption of oxygen

The choice depends upon the amount to be

rising from about 25 billion cubic feet to almost

shipped and the distance.

125 billion in the short span of eight years.

For the sale and continuous shipment of oxy­

Moreover, the chemical industry is using oxy­

gen in large volume, producers have evolved

gen in ever-growing volume and is now consum­

what has been called “ over the fence” selling.

ing almost as much oxygen as the steel indus­

Under this arrangement, the producer of oxygen

try. About three-fourths of the oxygen used

builds an air separation plant just off, or some­

CHART 2

CONSUMPTION OF OXYGEN BY THE IRON AND
STEEL INDUSTRY
(

1956-1964)

Billions of Cubic Feet*

times on, the premises of the consumer steel mill
so that only short distance piping is required.
Ownership of the plant is retained by the sup­
plier but usually there is a “ purchase of gas”
agreement extending over a period of fifteen
years.
Such a contractual arrangement is mutually
satisfactory to both parties. The buyer is assured
of a continuous supply without the expenditure
of a large investment in facilities with which
he is none too familiar and the seller is assured
of a high operating rate extending over a period
of years. The seller also provides an experienced
work force to operate the plant, which in some
instances is built with sufficient capacity to sell

Source: Iron and Steel Institute.

“ merchant gas”

to

other consumers nearby.

in the chemical industry today is consumed by

“ Over the fence” selling is also growing in favor

the producers of acetylene, methanol, and am­

with oxygen customers in the chemical industry.

monia. Much of the remainder is consumed by

The economies of “ over the fence” selling ex­

the manufacturers of such chemicals as ace­

plain in part the widespread geographical dis­

taldehyde, ethylene oxide, and hydrogen cyanide.

persion of air separation plants. Air separation

Technically, the industrial gases industry itself is

plants are operating in all major industrial areas

a branch of the chemical industry. The sale of

of the country, which leaves comparatively few

products by one branch of the chemical industry

states without any. However, there is a rather

to another is quite common; chemical manufac­

heavy representation of plants, as might be ex­

turers have long engaged in the practice of
taking in each other’s wash.

pected, in the New York to Chicago axis where




steel, metal, and chemical manufacturing pro-

5

business review

has a boiling point just slightly below that of

CHART 3

UNITED STATES OXYGEN P R O D U C T IO N HIGH PURITY
(

1941-1964 )

oxygen. All traces of oxygen are then removed
from the argon by burning it with hydrogen
over a catalyst. Argon serves as a highly inert

Billions of Cubic Feet*

shield in welding metals. It is also used in elec­
tronics

and

in

processing

titanium

ore

to

titanium metal. Production of argon, a rare gas,
is measured in millions rather than billions of
cubic feet. Output in 1963 was 970 million.

Cryogenic sidelines
1945

1950

1955

Companies engaged in air separation usually

1960

In gaseous form.
Source: United States Department of Commerce.

make and sell things other than air products to

*

liferate. Note Chart 3 showing the skyrocketing

enlarge the stream of income. They sell arc weld­
ing materials and accessories like electrodes,

of oxygen production in recent years.

welding rods, cutting torches. Moreover, they
also make for sale major mechanisms, such as

Nitrogen
Nitrogen, though the most abundant of atmos­
pheric gases, nevertheless ranks below oxygen in
the amount produced cryogenically. Nitrogen
can be produced more economically by other
processes, but for a high-purity product con­
sumers patronize the air separators.

systems, high vacuum pumping devices, and
cryobiology refrigerators— almost anything hav­
ing to do with machinery for generating torrid
heat or frigid cold.
As knowledgeable experts in both extremes of
outlandish temperatures, air separation concerns

An inert gas, pure nitrogen has many useful
applications. It is used as a protective blanket in
the manufacture of certain chemicals as am­
monia, acetylene, and petrochemicals;

low temperature liquid handling and storage

in oil

field operations to stimulate the flow of oil and
gas; in the steel industry for bright annealing

sell portable air separation plants for the manu­
facture of tonnage oxygen which suggests that
they might be putting themselves out of business.
But not so. They have the know-how to stay well
ahead of their customers; in fact, supplying engi­
neering services is another source of revenue.

of stainless steel; in the food industry for the
freezing and preservation of perishable foods;
in animal husbandry to preserve bull semen for
artificial insemination; in space exploration for
flushing, precooling, and testing of rockets; and
in space simulation. Production of high-purity
nitrogen in 1963 came to 50 billion cubic feet.

On the fringe of absolute zero
Hydrogen and helium, as previously mentioned,
are cryogenic low-lifes— they refuse to become
liquid until chilled down to the very suburbs of
absolute zero. Another characteristic they have
in common is their scarcity in the atmosphere.

Argon

It takes a mountain of air to get a mite of either

By inserting a few extra plates in the air separa­

hydrogen or helium. Hence, air separation plants

tion column, it is easy to extract argon which

produce neither in commercial quantities.

Digitized for 6
FRASER


business review

Hydrogen is easily obtained from natural gas

liquid helium, which does such queer things like

its lightness, hydrogen was

flowing uphill, is put to practical use in missiles

formerly used to inflate balloons and other

and rocketry, and in atomic energy installations.

lighter-than-air craft. This use, however, was

The 330 million cubic feet of helium produced

shortlived because of the fire hazard. Hydrogen

in 1958 was considered phenomenal; production

is highly flammable and after the tragedy of

in 1963 was over two billion.

and because of

the Hindenburg zeppelin, hydrogen lost favor
as a lifting gas for airships.

Cryogenics unlimited

flammable characteristic of hydrogen,

The industrial gas industry is one of the fast­

however, is turned to other uses where energy is

est growing branches of the chemical industry.

required. The first hydrogen bomb depended

One reason is its newness, its comparative youth.

The

upon liquid hydrogen for its operation and

Another reason is its membership in the chemi­

today hydrogen in liquid form is also used as

cal industry where almost everything seems to

a rocket fuel. To change hydrogen gas into a

be closely related to something else either by

liquid, however, requires low temperature proc­

analysis— breaking down, as in air separation

essing and that is where cryogenics comes in.

— or by synthesis— building up, as in the manu­

Thus cryogenic technology is the basis for both

facture of plastics. For example, when ammonia

super cold and super heat to produce super

synthesis gas is produced by the partial oxida­

power.

tion method, it is only natural to build or

Helium, second only to hydrogen in lightness,
was discovered in the sun before it was found

acquire an air separation plant which provides
both the oxygen for synthesis gas manufacture

on the earth. It is obtained from helium-bearing

and the nitrogen for ammonia manufacture.

natural gas which contains from one to about

Cryogenic technology has ever-widening appli­

eight per cent helium. By a cryogenic process

cations, and in some of the most unexpected

utilizing very low temperature and very high

places. In addition to the numerous practical

pressure, all the other constituent gases are

uses already mentioned, deep-down-cold is al­

squeezed and teased out of natural gas until

ready finding application in biology to preserve

nothing but helium is left.

blood and live tissue, in cryosurgery in the hope

The largest known helium-bearing natural gas

of relieving Parkinson’s disease through blood­

field is found in an area extending from south­

less brain surgery, on shipboard for freezing

west Kansas through

Oklahoma into Texas.

freshly caught fish and smelting of undersea

Formerly marketed as a source of heat energy,

minerals; and in electronics where intense cold

this helium-rich natural gas, too valuable to

works

burn, is now being processed by five Govern­

computers may be shrunk down to the size

ment-owned and five privately owned plants for

of a bread box. And the restoration of hamsters

various purposes, some ordinary, some extraor­

that had been frozen stiff raises hopes that

dinary.

future

such

magic

astronauts

in

could

circuitry

survive

that

future

interstellar

For its inert quality, helium affords a protec­

journeys taking thousands of years. Meanwhile,

tive atmosphere in welding. For its light weight,

earthbound uses of air products continue to

it subs for air to inflate airplane tires. And

grow.




7

business review

Although profits are extracted from thin air, it

capacity has already brought about keen compe­

is not to be inferred that earnings come easily.

tition which is reflected in declining price trends

An air separation plant requires a substantial

of air products. Hence, the industry’s emphasis

outlay of capital, obsolescence is high because of

upon research and development to open up new

rapidly changing technology,

markets.

and expanding

EVEN BETTER
The semi-scientific art of forecasting business
conditions is practiced by a number of bold
economists in business, government and the
academic community. Their work is eagerly
awaited and examined by decision-makers in the
economy. Although the economists make no
claim of infallibility (and the record supports
this), the opinions of the authoritative forecast­
ers are respected.
Therefore, the Department of Research of the
Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia annually
compiles data on business forecasts made by a
key group of economists. These forecasts are
made during the last quarter— principally in
December— of each year, and the Bank summary
appears in January. This year rapidly changing
business developments along with release of the
federal budget, increased commitments in Viet­

TABLE 1

1966 ECONOMIC FORECASTS
Estimates for 1966
Early* January**
G.N.P. (b illion s of $)
713***
725***
457
Personal consum ption (b illion s of $) 454
109
112
Investm ent (b illion s of $)
6.4
5.5
Inventories (b illion s of $)
Plant & equipm ent expenditures
59
57
(b illion s of $)
6.9
Net exports (b illio n s of $)
6.8
148
Governm ent (b illion s of $)
146
130
121
Steel production (m illio ns of tons)
9.2
9.0
Auto sales (m illio ns of units)
Corp. profits before taxes
79
77
(b illion s of $)
4.3
3.9
Unem ploym ent rate (per cent)
W holesale price index
104.0
105.8
(1957-59 = 100)
Private nonfarm housing starts
1.49
(m illio ns of units)
1.50
Industrial production index
152
148
(1 9 5 7 -5 9 = 100)
* Median of estim ates com piled from published fore­
casts made during the last quarter of 1965.
** Median of estim ates from special survey made in
January, 1966.
*** Items do not add to total because not all respond­
ents provided forecasts for each item.

nam and publication of GNP data for the final

Gross National Product

quarter of 1965, have resulted in extensive re­

Chart 1 shows the pronounced upward trend of

visions of economic forecasts for 1966. Because

estimates of Gross National Product during the

of the recent sharp changes in expectations, it

past few months. It is evident that quite sharp

was decided to make a special survey of some

revisions have been made since December. The

of the economists to determine how much they

median of early estimates of 1966 GNP was

had revised their earlier predictions. Results of

$713 billion; but the median of the recent fore­

the

The

casts was $725 billion— some $49 billion more

changes in expectations are presented in this

than 1965 GNP. What accounts for the upward

report and summarized in Table 1.

revision of GNP?

8

late-January




survey

were

startling.

business review

CHART 1

CHART2

G RO SS NATIONAL PRODUCT

CHANGE IN INVENTORIES
Médian Projections for 1966

Projections for 1966
Billions of Dollars

Billions of Dollars

_____________________

1965-Actual

Sept.-Oct.
Nov.-Dec.
Jan.-Feb.
Dates Projections Made

were expected to account for $6.4 billion of
business investment— up over 16 per cent from
the median of earlier forecasts.
The median estimate of plant and equipment
expenditures was raised in January to $59 bil­
1965-Actual

Sept.-Oct. Nov.-Dec.
Jan.-Feb.
Dates Projections Made

Investment

lion from $57 billion in earlier forecasts. The
latest estimate for 1966 represents a vigorous 14
per cent increase over last year’s figure of $51.8
billion as shown in Chart 3.

Economic textbooks tell us that gross private
domestic investment— spending on inventories,

CHART 3

plant and equipment, and housing— is the most

PLANT AND EQUIPMENT
Median Projections for 1966

volatile component of GNP. Perhaps this is the

Billions of Dollars

trigger which can be counted on to propel GNP
to higher levels.

60 -

Forecasters predicted a sharp rise in business
investment which accounts for one quarter of the
estimated increase in GNP. Investment of $112
billion was expected in late January compared
to earlier predictions of $109 billion. This 2.7
per cent upward revision of the median fore­

1965-Actual

Sept.-Oct.
Nov.-Dec.
Jan.-Feb.
Dates Projections Made

cast indicates that economists got a good whiff

Government expenditures

of expansion and inventory accumulation plans

A second component— government expenditures,

of business firms. If total investment of $112

which account for roughly one-fifth of GNP—

billion materializes, it would represent an in­

has considerable impact in determining the ex­

crease of nearly 10 per cent over the 1965 figure.

pansion or contraction of total business activity.

Chart 2 shows that additions to inventories

Our survey indicated that business analysts ex­




9

business review

pected government spending to provide even

CHART 5

more stimulation to the economy than they an­

UNEM PLO YM ENT RATE

ticipated in December, largely because of the

Median Projections for 1966

continuing escalation of military operations in

Per Cent

Vietnam. Total government spending (Federal
and state and local governments) of $148 billion
was anticipated. This compares with December
estimates of $146 billion and actual 1965 spend­
ing of $135 billion (see Chart 4 ).
CHART 4

GOVERNMENT PU R C H ASES OF GOODS AND
SERVICES
Median Projections for 1966
Billions of Dollars

1965-Actual

Sept.-Oct. Nov.-Dee.
Jan.-Feb.
Dates Projections Made

of improved business conditions because the
increasing manpower requirements of the mili­
tary have absorbed some of the unemployed.

150

Many of the draftees and enlistees would other­
wise be among the marginally employed or un­
employed.

140

130

Other economic indicators
1965-Actual

Sept.-Oct. Nov.-Dee.
Jan.-Feb.
Dates Projections Made

The January forecasts of 1966 steel production
soared to 130 million tons from the 121 million

Consumer expenditures

ton estimate made in December. Similarly, fore­

Expanded expenditures by business firms and

casters recently have become more optimistic

governmental entities means that consumer in­

about new automobile sales which in January

comes are increased. And consumers with bulg­

were estimated at 9.2 million units, including

ing pockets can be counted on to satisfy some of

imports, for 1966.

their desires by pumping most of their income
back through the economy. The more after-tax
income people receive, the more they tend to
spend and the higher GNP is likely to go.

CHART 6

W HOLESALE PRICE INDEX
Median Projections for 1966

Estimates for personal consumption for 1966
were raised from $454 billion in December to
$457 billion at the end of January. This estimate
is up significantly from $428 billion actual con­
sumption last year.
As indicated in Chart 5, forecasters also ex­
pected the unemployment rate to average 3.9 per
cent of the work force— the lowest in a decade.
Reduced unemployment is not entirely a result

Digitized for 10
FRASER


Dates Projections Made

business review

Most of the data presented so far are ex­

Summary

pressed in current dollars. Therefore, the pro­

Recent changes in the business and political en­

jected increases in GNP and other series would

vironment have made forecasters much more

reflect price changes along with increases in the

optimistic than they were toward the end of

physical

1965. Expectations regarding

volume

of

goods

produced.

Conse­

1966 economic

quently, we are interested in the forecasts of

conditions have changed markedly over the past

price changes so that we can isolate the “ real”

few months. One wonders how much they might

increases in the various data. Our January sur­

change over the course of the year.

vey of forecasters indicated a growing concern

How good have these forecasters been in the

over inflationary pressures. The median pro­

past? It is interesting that actual performance

jected 1966 wholesale price index was raised

in every year in the current business expansion,

to 105.8— up from the 104 predicted earlier and

except 1962, has exceeded the forecasters’ ex­

from the 102.5 average for 1965 (see Chart 6 ).

pectations. Economists have almost consistently

The Federal Reserve index of industrial pro­

under-estimated in times such as the present. But

duction— a measure of output volume— was ex­

we can judge the accuracy of these forecasts only

pected to reach 152. This figure is substantially

after all of the 1966 cards are on the table and

higher than the 143 attained in 1965.

1967 rolls around.




11

FOR THE R E C O R D . . .
INDEX

BILLIONS $

Third Federal
Reserve District

United States

Per cent change

Per cent change

Jan. 1966
from

Jan. 1966
from

MEMBER BANKS, 3RD F.R.D.

Factory*
Employ­
ment

Payrolls

Department
Store Salesf

Per cent
change
Jan. 1966
from

Per cent
change
Jan. 1966
from

Per cent
change
Jan. 1966
from

Check
Payments

SU M M ARY

mo.
ago
M A N U FA C T U RIN G
Production.........................
Electric power consumed. . . .
Man-hours, total*...............
Employment, total................
W a ge Income*...................

-

-2 4

COAL PR O D U C T IO N ............

0

B A N K IN G
(All member banks)
Deposits............................
loans................................
Investments.........................
U.S. Govt, securities...........
Other..............................
Check payments..................
PRICES
W holesale.........................
Consumer..........................
*Production workers only
**Value of contracts
***Ad|usted for seasonal variation




mo.
ago

year
ago

+ 1
Ó
1
0
1

C O N S T R U C T IO N **..............

TRADE***
Department store sales.........

year
ago

LOCAL
CHANGES

+ 19

+ 12
+ 6
+ 3
+ 8

lehlgh V alle y... .

+ 18

-

9

+

-

+

1

+ 10

4

+

7

+

—
+
+

2
2
1
2
0
2t

+ 6
+ 10
- 1
- 8
+ 10
+ 15+

0Î

+

year
ago

mo.
ago

8

6

0

Harrisburg........

0
1
0

Lancaster..........

+

Philadelphia.......

mo.
ago

year
ago

mo.
ago

Per cent
change
Jan. 1966
from

year
ago

mo.
ago

year
ago

....

-

+ 13

3

0

+

4

+

3

0

+

7

-1 0

+

+

7

+

2

+ 14

+

3

+

6

-

4

+10

+

4

-

1

+ 11

+

7

+

8

-

2

+ 15

-

+

3

5

Reading...........

-

+
-

2
2
0
1
1
0

+ 9
+ 14
+ 2
- 5
+ 12
+ 13

0
0

+
+

-

4

+

2

-

4

+

6

+

8

0

2

+ 17

Scranton..........

-

1

+

4

-

4

+10

+

8

+ 14

— 2

+ 10

Trenton............

0

+

1

+

1

+

5

+ 12

+ 14

-

2

+

Wilkes-Barre. .. .

0

+

2

-

1

+

8

+

+

5

-

6

+ 11

1

+26

2

Wilmington.......
n

f20 Cities
^Philadelphia

4
2

-

1

+

1

-

5

+

1

-

2

-

4

+

York................

-

1

+

6

-

3

+ 10

+

3

+

3

-1 2

5

+ 18

*N o t restricted to corporate limits of cities but covers areas of one or more
counties.
fAdjusted for seasonal variation.