View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE AND LABOR

BULLETIN
OF THE

BUREAU OF LABOR

V O L U M E




X X I -1 9 1 0

WASHINGTON
GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE
1 01 O




CONTENTS OF VOLUME X X L

N o. 89.—JULY, 1910.
Child-labor legislation in Europe, b y C. W. A. Yeditz, Ph. D .:
Page.
Introduction............................................................................................................
1,2
Austria......................................................................................................................
3-92
Earlier child-labor legislation......................................................................
3-7
Present regulations affecting child labor..................................................
7-21
Organization and work of the inspectors..................................................
21-38
Extent and nature of child labor...............................................................
38-92
Belgium.................................................................................................................... 93-143
93-97
The child-labor law of December 13, 1889...............................................
Legislative and administrative modification of the law of 1889.......... 97-111
Agencies for enforcing the labor laws and decrees................................. 111-115
Enforcement of the laws and decrees concerning “ protected per­
sonsM............................................................................................................. 115-130
Extent and nature of child labor................................................................ 130-143
France...................................................................................................................... 143-231
Beginnings of child-labor legislation......................................................... 143-152
Present laws concerning child labor.......................................................... 152-176
Organization and work of the labor inspectors........................................ 176-221
Enforcement of the child-labor laws in mines......................................... 222-224
The courts and the labor laws..................................................................... 224-231
Germany.................................................................................................................. 231-312
Child-labor legislation in the nineteenth century.................................. 231-241
The Industrial Code...................................................................................... 241-269
The l&w of March 30, 1903........................................................................... 269-280
The staff of inspectors................................................................................... 280-294
Methods and work of the inspectors.......................................................... 295-312
Italy.......................................................................................................................... 313-326
History of child-labor legislation.................................. ~ .......................... 313-316
Present regulation of child labor...................................................................316-326
Switzerland............................................................................................................. 326-413
Child-labor legislation prior to 1877........................................................... 326-337
The factory law of March 23, 1877............................................................. 338-342
Provisions of the law of 1877 which particularly affect children in
factories........................................................................................................ 342-345
Further federal legislation affecting child labor..................................... 345-347
Cantonal legislation affecting child labor................................................. 347-372
Enforcement of the child-labor laws.......................................................... 372-395
Extent, nature, and consequences of child labor................................... 395-413




m

I\r

BULLETIN OF TH E BUREAU OF LABOR.

Decisions of courts affecting labor:
Pags.
Decisions under statute law .................................................................................414-432
Combinations in restraint of trade—boycott—antitrust law— consti­
tutionality of statute (Grenada Lumber Co. v. Mississippi)............... 414-416
Employers’ liability—fellow-servants—course of employment—lia­
bility of foremen ( Moyse v. Northern Pacific By. Co.)....................... 416-419
Employers’ liability—railroad- companies—acceptance of relief ben­
efits— constitutionality of statute ( McNamara v. Washington Ter­
minal Co.).................................................................................................... 419-422
Employers’ liability—railroad companies—federal statute—con­
struction ( Tsmura v. Great Northern By. Co.)...................................... 422,423
Hours of labor of employees on railroads— commerce—regulation by
state law—federal regulation (People v. Erie R. B. Co.)................... 423-425
Hours of labor of employees on railroads—federal statute—periods
of sendee and rest— construction of statute (Atchison, Topeka and
Santa Fe By. Co. v. United States)..................................... *.................. 425,426
Hours of labor of employees on railroads—violation b y employees
as affecting claims for damages—state and federal regulation (Lloyd
v. North Carolina R. B. Co.).................................................................... 426-428
Hours of labor of women—police power— constitutionality of statute
(W. C. Ritchie & Co. v. Wayman).......................................................... 428-430
Safety appliances on railways—commerce— state regulation (Detroit,
Toledo and Fronton By. Co. v. State)...................................................... 430,431
Sunday labor—contracts to be performed on Sunday—recovery of
compensation (Knight v. Press Co., Limited)...................................... 431,432
Decisions under common law .............................................................................. 432-436
Contract of employment— consideration—release of claim for dam­
ages—breach of contract (Illinois Central B. B. Co. v. Fairchild).. 432,433
Contract of employment—reduction of rank of employee—violation
of contract—duty to seek other employment (Cooper v. Stronge A
Warner Co.).................................................................................................. 433,434
Contract of employment—term—renewal—breach—assignment of
claims (Allen v. Chicago Pneumatic Tool Co.)..................................... 434-436
No. 90.— SEPTEM BER, 1910.
Fatal accidents in coal mining, b y Frederick L. Hoffman:
Introduction............................................................................................................
The fatal-accident rate...............................................
The causes of fatal accidents...............................................................................
Falls of coal or roof.........................................................................................
Mine cars..........................................................................................................
Explosions........................................................................................................
Miscellaneous mine accidents......................................................................
Principal causes of fatal accidents, b y coal fields..................................
The fatal-accident rate due to principal causes..............................................
Falls of coal or roof.........................................................................................
Shaft accidents................................................................................................
Mine cars..........................................................................................................
Outside cars.....................................................................................................
Motors................................................................................................................
Explosions of gas or dust..............................................................................
Explosions of powder or dynam ite.............................................................




437-446
446-452
453-462
455-457
457
457,458
458,459
459-462
462-481
463-465
465,466
466
467
467,468
468-474
474-476

CONTENTS OF VOLUME 21.

Fatal accidents in ccal mining, etc.— Concluded.
The fatal-accident rate due to principal causes— Concluded.
Asphyxiation...................................................................................................
Mining machinery..........................................................................................
Mules.................................................................................................................
Electrocution...................................................................................................
Miscellaneous mine accidents.....................................................................
Statistical analysis of 2,660 fatal mine accidents in the United States
during 1908..........................................................................................................
Descriptive analysis of fatal accidents in Illinois, 1904 to 1908..................
Statistical analysis of fatal accidents in West Virginia, 1899 to 1908........
The fatal-accident rate in Pennsylvania, b y occupations............................
An estimate of the total loss of life in coal mines of North Am erica.........
The use of explosives in mines...........................................................................
Chronological account of the principal mine disasters..................................
Summary.................................................................................................................
Appendix (29 tables).............................................................................................
Bibliography...........................................................................................................
Recent action relating to employers’ liability and workmen’ s compensation,
by Lindley D. Clark, A. M., L L. M .:
Nature of liability and compensation systems................................................
Federal employers’ liability law ........................................................................
Statutes providing insurance...............................................................................
Statutes providing for compensation.................................................................
Proposed federal legislation.................................................................................
United States Workmen’s Compensation Commission..................................
Attitude of state legislatures toward the compensation system..................
Massachusetts..................................................................................................
Illinois..............................................................................................................
Connecticut.....................................................................................................
Wisconsin.........................................................................................................
Minnesota and New Y ork.............................................................................
New Jersey and O hio....................................................................................
Conferences of commissions.................................................................................
Minnesota b ill.........................................................................................................
Wisconsin b ill.........................................................................................................
New York statutes.................................................................................................
Report of New York commission........................................................................
Economic reasons for a compensation system..........................................
Attitude of employers and employees......................................................
Conclusions of the New York commission..............................................
Action b y employers and association of employers and of workmen.........
United States Steel Corporation.................................................................
International Harvester Company.............................................................
National associations of employers.............................................................
National Civic Federation..........................................................................
American Federation of Labor....................................................................
Legal principles in volved....................................................................................
Statutes....................................................................................................................
Essential features of a compensation law; Chicago conference of November,
1910...............................................................................................................................
Summary of foreign workmen’ s compensation acts................................................




V

Page.
470
476,477
477
477-480
480,481
481-486
486-557
557-577
577-609
609,610
610-612
612-614
615-622
623-671
671-674

675,676
676,677
677,678
678-680
680
680-683
683-688
684, 685
685,686
686
686
787
687,688
688
689, 690
690-692
693
693-698
693-697
697
697, 698
698-702
699
699,700
700,701
701
701,702
702-707
707-714
715-717
719-748

VI

BULLETIN OF TH E BUREAU OF LABOR.

Cost of employers' liability and workmen's compensation insurance, b y Miles
M. Dawson:
In tro d u ctio n ..........................................................................................................
Austria......................................................................................................................
Belgium....................................................................................................................
Denmark..................................................................................................................
Finland....................................................................................................................
France......................................................................................................................
G erm a n y..!.............................................................................................................
Great Britain...........................................................................................................
Ita ly ..........................................................................................................................
Netherlands.............................................................................................................
Norway.....................................................................................................................
Sweden.....................................................................................................................
Switzerland.............................................................................................................
Canada......................................................................................................................
New Y ork.....................................
United States..........................................................................................................
Decision of courts affecting labor:
Decisions under statute law ................................................................................
Employer and employee— interference with relation— enticement—
construction of statute (Abingdon Mills Co. v. Grogan)....................
Employers’ liability—actions for injuries causing death—rights of
alien beneficiaries (Cetofonte v. Camden Coke Co.).............................
Employers’ liability— contracts between Pullman company and rail­
way company—waiver of em ployee’s rights (San Antonio andAran­
sas Pass Ry. Co. v. Tracy).........................................................................
Em ployers’ liability—fellow-servant law— common carriers— consti­
tutionality of statute ( Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul Ry. Co. v.
Westby)..........................................................................................................
Em ployers’ liability— inspection of factories— violations of statutes—
defenses— construction (Caspar v. Lewin)............................................
Em ployers’ liability—railroad companies—hazards— construction of
statute— constitutionality— classification (Louisville and Nashville
R. R. Co. v. Melton)..................................................................................
Em ployers’ liability—railroad companies—hazards—repair work—
constitutionality of statute (Swoboda v. Union Pacific Railroad Co.).
Laundries—registration— police regulations— constitutionality (Dis­
trict of Columbia v. Shong Lee)................................................................
Payment of wages—semimonthly pay day for railroad employees—
constitutionality of statute (New York Central and Hudson River
R. R. Co. v. Williams)..............................................................................
Decisions under common law ..............................................................................
Blacklisting—conspiracy— evidence (Rhodes v. Granby Cotton Mills) .
Employer and employee— interference with relation— conspiracy to
destroy trade (Globe and Rutgers Fire Insurance Co. v. Firemen’s
Fund Fire Insurance Co.)..........................................................................
Employers’ liability—fellow-servants—association theory (Louisville
Ry. Co. v. Hibbitt)......................................................................................
Employers’ liability—safe place—low bridge over railroad track—
rules— defenses (West v. Chicago, Burlington and Quincy Ry. Co.).
Interference with contract of employment—procuring discharge—
damages (Ruddy v. United Association of Journeymen Plumbers, etc.,
Local No. 24)...............................................................................................
Labor organizations— closed-shop agreements— legality (Kissam v.
United States Printing Co. of Ohio et al.; Mills et al. v. Same)........




page.
749-831
752-759
760
760-765
765-768
769-773
774-783
784-792
791-794
794-797
797-801
802-809
810-815
815-818
819-823
824-831
832-855
832,833
833,834

835

836,837
837-848

848-852
852-854
854

854,855
855-866
855-857

857-859
859-861
861-863

864,865
865,866

CONTENTS OF VOLUME 21.

VII

No. 91.— NOVEM BER, 1910.
Working hours of wage-earning women in selected industries in Chicago,
b y Marie L. Obenauer:
Page.
Introduction............................................................................................................ 867-871
The candy industry............................................................................................... 872-875
The paper-box industry....................................................................................... 875-880
Woman ticket agents of the elevated railways................................................ 880-882
Steam laundries...................................................................................................... 882-885
The clothing industry........................................................................................... 885-890
The corset industry............................................................................................... 890-891
Neighborhood department and small retail stores.......................................... 891-898
Hours and earnings in detail............................................................................... 898-915
Labor laws declared unconstitutional, b y Lindley D. Clark, A. M., LL. M.:
Class of laws considered........................................................................................ 916,917
Basis of legislative action..................................................................................... 917,918
Constitutional restrictions.................................................................................... 918-922
Laws declared unconstitutional.......................................................................... 922-964
Laws affecting the contract of employm ent............................................. 925-927
Examination, registration, etc., of workmen........................................... 927-932
Employment of women and children........................................................ 932,933
Protection of local labor............................................................................... 933-936
Employment offices....................................................................................... 936,937
Rates of wages................................................................................................. 937-939
Mechanics’ liens............................................................................................. 939,940
Actions to recover wage debts..................................................................... 940,941
Garnishment and assignments of salaries and wages..............................
942
Time of payment of wages........................................................................... 942-944
Payment of wages in scrip........................................................................... 944,945
Company stores............................................................................................... 945-947
947-951
Hours of labor....................
Sunday labor................................................................................................... 951,952
Liability of employers for injuries to employees.................................... 952-955
Inspection and safety of factories, workshops, etc................................. 956,957
Protection of employees on street railways..............................................
957
Mine regulations.............................................................................................
957
Labor organizations....................................................................................... 958-960
Injunctions and contempts.......................................................................... 960-962
Arbitration of labor disputes.......................................................................
962
Protection of employees as voters..............................................................
963
Cases cited....................................................................................................... 963,964
Old-age and invalidity pension laws of Germany, France, and Australia:
Germany................................................................................................................ 965-1002
France.................................................................................................................. 1003-1021
Australia.............................................................................................................. 1022-1033
Review of labor legislation of 1910, b y Lindley D. Clark, A. M., LL. M.:
Introduction........................................................................................................ 1034,1035
Commissions........................................................................................................ 1035-1037
Regulation of the contract of em ploym ent......................................................
1037
Examination and licensing of workmen....................................................... 1037,1038
Public service.........................................................................................................
1038
Wages.................................................................................................................... 1039,1040
Hours of labor.........................................................................................................
1040
Sunday labor...........................................................................................................
1040




VIII

BULLETIN OF TH E BUBEAU OF LABOR.

Review of labor legislation of 1910—Concluded.
Page.
H olidays...................................................................................................................
1040
Inspection of factories, safety appliances, etc............................................. 1041,1042
Mine regulations................................................................................................. 1042,1043
Safety appliances, etc., on railroads..................................................................
1043
Protection of employees on street railways.................................................. 1043,1044
Em ployment of children and women............................................................ 1044-1046
Employers’ liability and workmen’s compensation................................... 1046-1048
A cciden ts.................................................................................................................
1049
Retirement and pension funds............................................................................
1049
Labor organizations...............................................................................................
1050
Civil rights of employees......................................................................................
1050
Em ployment offices........................................................................................... 1050,1051
Bureaus of labor.....................................................................................................
1051
Convict labor...........................................................................................................
1051
Laws of various States relating to labor enacted since January 1, 1910:
Illinois.................................................................................................................. 1052-1059
K entucky............................................................................................................. 1059-1061
Louisiana..................................................................................................................
1062
Maryland.............................................................................................................. 1063-1072
Massachusetts...................................................................................................... 1072-1084
Mississippi................................................................................................................
1084
New Jersey.......................................................................................................... 1084-1088
New Y ork ............................................................................................................ 1088-1109
O hio....................................................................................................................... 1110-1144
Oklahoma............................................................................................................. 1145,1146
Philippine Islands.................................................................................................
1146
Porto R ic o ................................................................................................................
1147
Rhode Island...................................................................................................... 1147-1151
South Carolina........................................................................................................
1152
Virginia................................................................................................................. 1152-1155
United States...................................................................................................... 1155-1159
Cumulative index of labor laws and decisions relating thereto....................... 1161-1196
Index to volume 21..................................................................................................... 1197-1209