The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
§ lit f Fiferaarjr 6, m 11 A 1935 Mr* Parry ^ Mr. Thomas Mr* Currie Mr. Blattner Mr. Garfield Mr. Gardner Mr* Piser Miss Burr I am giving you a copy of a letter on the banking legislation, which was not sent, a memorandum which was to be attached to the letter and was not sent either, and an outline of the bill, which was not intended to be sent and was. These documents, together with the bill., may be helpful in suggesting points that can be brought out in support of the bill or in answer to criticisms. If you have criticisms of the bill, I should be glad to have them also. Duo car Ok&T Banking mA Curraacy ; * ted ttiflMM 9Hi D* • I &m ser: Com- Hitter: -'.-JWfM • i s AM .- aeeoK 1« 3i To M our \m • • I de&i; prior to th« ?*orld fcar, more 2 .e!i -.lling Mr of raoorary, and I f ttt# futWNi of ^ a r ,xcno " • \ *. . - •:, . fciftpa to fta the topftitfaWI or • HMler the at: .agalnet It* ~ 2 • m i ! • %s • » elMMKit mmi- in ma* MM . - . :. & Mi . to lai 53MM*- IP* Itft iliWiiA of t • of CM . |« c% n • a t r lagf aft assumption tluit tatn\rtrfi itre . -me t o ; :: t eag^r • •- ^ t^ " ;.;. . i ¥ i bar. the Mr] be r«a«i tor ,t##XX4 • -oeral • e r f . c*tly mJ * i * l * o f&9p09&c t o ,]-&&& o a r t a l a r«Yiftlaa& i n the ld<moo i n o u r bankjst a&ci T; Uli • ^SQ eattrei^lj :. I reXftt# t o + w y » * t l T f r a.^i c l ^ r t l y i a J th«J3 y f o r the • ..-T HdHr^Cf-' . . ' . . . . - •. mil ^^^1.1,- ^ - • U I i to pwrtda fa . i^ i:;i :; . .,-: '. , i H , r ; •' f*;-<L^c : l^^r • :• u : . MV§ • i l l t h a t waa • truly . In r.- „ 01 P&GFOSJB wmm la connection with the proposed amendments to the Federal Deposit Insurance law, i t will be recalled that daring the first i t s months of the year 193^ * * * s l t s were insured to the extent of $9,500 for each depositor. During the last six months ef the year the insurance was ex- tended to $5,000 for eaoh depositor and i t i* found th*t thi* protects 96.39$ of the depositors ia the insured banks ia f u l l , fhis degree of protection has proved adequate to restore eeafideaee ia the insured hanks as a whole and ia the nine hanks which closed during the year the peasants by the federal Deposit Insurance Oorporatiea have entirely relieved the oenraaltles of the hardships aad dletwoaaoes which heretofore have generally accompanied a hank failure. ttkder existing law the peraaaent plan would five increased benefit* to only 1.61% of the depositors hot i t would almost double the l i a b i l i t y of the Corporation by increasing i t from approximately $16,500,000,000 to more than $?9,000,000,000. I reeesnead, therefore, that the limitatioa of $5,000 for each depositor be continued aad nato a part of the peraaaent Insurance plea. fhe original ptarpose of the fefflporary Fund of the Federal deposit Insurance Corporation was to provide insurance of deposits Set a six months' period before the necessary arrangements could be completed for instituting the penaaaeat plan, fhe temporary fund has beea raised througi assessments contributed by the banks based upon their insured deposit liability, fhe peraaaeat plan ia the existing law eontaaplates assessaent?. i. eased upon the entire deposit liability of the insured hanks. It it »eiieved that the general benefits both to t:« public and to the banking structure of the Country resulting *"oa the insurance ©f deposits call for an assessment plan substantially as provided in existing law, out limited la aaount. fee plan of assessing upoa the insured deposit liability alone, considering the general benefits, throve a disproportionate share of the burden upon the smaller banks and upon banks in whieh small deposits predominate. Provision should ©e made which will enable the Corporation to allocate to surplus part of its existing eapltal of approximately $290,000,000, contributed by the Government and by the Federal Beeerve Banks, and to enable it to set up reserves from the proceeds of the assessments so that the insurance nay be continued at all times upon a sound basis, at no creator cost than is necessary and without becoming unduly burdensome la times of stress* In vie* of the liability of the foderal deposit Insurance Corporation to depositors of failed hanks, It is important to give to the Directors of the Corporation authority to protect the funds of the Corporation from the consequences of bad mwna<emeat and unsound bunking practices on the part of insured banks, this should eo aAeoaplished with due regard to the existing authority for direct supervision. fhe proposal* relating to the !%4eral Beserve System are in recognition of changes that have occurred in our economic life since the System ma established mure than tisoaty year© ago* fko whole enruing period Ms boon one of trmntn that %h® framer* of %h& Federal JM&t, sklUf-ully aad psnadontly us they claimed, could aettfea? have forotooa aor ivm0>m&. Uhllo tlm Foior&l Hosorro ^mltm ha« t#rrltt to lb# aatlon—turiag %bm mmr years t i i r i i period of roiid^mstewmt* taring tte years #f isprtstlom mmt p#rloi in iMdi M bmrm h^gm to <^#r^ from %h® tepretoloa, the of twrnty y#sr§ tout tteia thai im tom« iroortant respects Wm&mtsl i#»#rro %ttto m#tdt to ¥t etreo^theaed aad toprowd In to matt a&tioB^vide sad wrli-wide economic otem#is» Cto economic pfoblwit tauTt iomg touted t# become mare ami z&oro 3u&tional la scopef sad si^oolaliy ao la tim field of banking. Omr coaMercial thro^h tho creation of deposits, i^i>ly t^i groat Iraik of coxoatry^ moaa« of pny»oat~ for goods and tervicee of o i l kindsf for frodn0tl0B m& ei^loyment la tTory flold of eoaasmia endeavor* Beaoo MQT material changes la tho wlt^^ of tMi mmmn of p«ymeatf ^feoth^r tkron# enlargement or onrtaltatoat of tko 4tpo«it« oroatod by our ooimeralal feyaket MW aatloa^wldi la tholr economic effects* »or tM« rwttoa It ha*fcecomei ^ a m t l w tlmt rtpilttioa of t^i of omr mmm* of paymoat 1io oatrmstod to m tedy tMt rowowatt the nation at a wfc&ief rather than to hate a wide** read division of authority in a matter of guch grave national concern. It Is daelr&ble to retain regional gs&nmgemeiit and responsibility at the Federal tmtmrf tank* la matters of loe&l concern, and no change la thit retpeet i t contemplated 1ft the prepoted legislation. But It It recommended that for national policies %e plaead dlraetly on the Federal l&ardt who** atmbtrt are appointed %f tha Fratlteat with tka advice and consent of the Samt*. fo acoompli»h this aalarfltaMiat of tfc* StairA1^ rttpamtlliillty* It la propntad to elarify tha poiver &f tha Board to d#termine, In c i t a t i o n with rtpreta»tatiT#s of tha y«ieml r « t a m banks, tha market policy of tha ftderal laserre System* In this mammt national control will he estatdithad orar operations that are now tha most important single factor la deteradnlng change© im the volum© of availahl* credit and the rates to he paid fer Arrowed money. Since the Federal tMMVft Beard would thua hear the respoatilbility for national pollelen to he jrartaed ^y the federal Beearf* i t It alto proponed that the appointment of the prlnciml executive officer In eaeh federal retNinre hank he tub^eet to apfroval hy the federal BM«nr« Board, aai that thte effiotr $sawn feriftl l i Governor and at OBbudnHm of the i a a r i of StftfttMft* Bh* Ved«r?l H#ferre 141 Itstflf makee BO provision fs§ the office ttf iovsraor at %syafe§t l l r o # in ffNMttfl tot §#^#3PB0ir i s H i prtaeipal pffle«r t ita#0%t4 % H H d l r t t t ^ r t wtttemt tht r«f«l9«iK| of UPM % th« It&tral »#ttrt# Board* 1Sh» 4fliang9 h«3fa ?rop0tt4 wtuld rto^grtlit the off lee ®f $®mm®w in the lav aad 00mlin# tble office ^itfe Vtett ef Oliaif^^E of Use luajrd of M r ^ t o f i t %nt %h% appotatwmt of ifet toirtimor ami the dlreete?* wotald lie st^Jtet i t the ^MNNNMdl of the So«rA* A furfety effeet If thle pt^Med eliaaft voidd %# immete eeooovgr M 4 efficiency 1B the rm®rf^ I « A | % doing sway the pretest *m^l orgiaalsatlott aai %b# 00mt#fpeat ftlffoeloii of enl&rgmeat of Ilia ree90nslU.ilty of the FeAeral Seeetre and additional aoMnures KM^Mlii with a Tiair to » W n g s«©ili^?iMp 0m the Board mr® iHititMKli HPi a-ttraotiw* ciadt in a ?«mniary respect* ®or« i i M i ! eihaiadffirftoiI t l e s t difficult thaa I t hat eoaetl»et 1NMB 1m the p i d to lB^@e mm wbo have the vision aat eoi^a^i, at well as tfee vefoielte traiatsg m&A m^mimm$ t# w i t ^ t a t o tli# diffiemltt t t t a l f M i eftwt mpopiiar to^ of fdi«il&timg n a t i o n ^ mmtmy to f a c i l i t a t e H i ewrylng out of «MMI p o l l e i t t i t will N alto to renotre ^ a t if t3be restrictions aow plmotd oa the aetiTltlni of «hft fo&araX l n e m ^tmte % tim fftJtnl Batwrft Aat. B » M ••* atrlotlona w#rt largnXy pjrtdle&teA 011 aondi Moats f t H i l i l l f *han mm if§ HH a4apt#t H | | | $ i aal w#rs wtstXy lmpasad m a %nt«t that wa# tarn ami isttttrieds *ui In th# e^tirst af time tto and ^ # retti^etioBs haw# «amti»M f t i i l i !• fc# H i ^^r# Immful than In tuit raap«ot th# rigid infiBition af tke kinds of «•• aliglHa for iiswmii at te# ,r#strr# feudc* la edaarly to Trt at an i»#Si,»mt« Olia^pt in mix m®nm®&® Xlfat notably in of fimanoimg %mslEess antarptiaot &a^# natarlsCLXy tba foltaMi of th©rt-%*mt aAf~ltqul&atlft£ p p t f of #fc# 0lssi#t ^dok tho dloooimt prlTiI#g#s of t&o raaarra lafci w Xorftly atrietod Igr X^w# Aft a o^EsttiiiTOoe of t l i s f in tlaaa of atraaa* tha M#Xp of %&# fodor®! 2ta««r?a ayatatt feat %##n MMi wr^m%ly hwra %##a damt& of ^§#%s allciida tow %®wwlitg at tba aafvarity of tha tteitlHWMi pi a l i # M t m^dr wm p Mi tt^ wmm lagUlations ^t% tMi adtaM wa# m% Utttm WMI micfe iMHt bad dona to the imalflMia of tba eotantry aad «wa3ra^nt#d bardablp and Xotf OTrff#rad ly I w * itpetitors* iMfttftiMN *^r^ &® ^ prmmt ttet «haa« Xl»itati0ai art ^utrilrntiag to tiia difflmaty if M moo& mnt& m& posooss porfootly mm& atonto, Imt nhn a r t to ofct&ta tha r#fuij?0<i loaas tooanoo thoir a$g#t* are for Alooomtt i I t i t w ® i t tfeat th# l$0l itm&Utlmn m sid authority %« ^ v t n t® tlit in d#t^wiii# iM diMpa«t«r of » # * * MM riMil %# ali^LMt H i &iscowit at the rtserve Tbmmkm.. p p i # t otemgts in. t t e Fotaf with, t t e r«4uir*M&t for soevogaticoi of «oUat«ral ^*hl^ Itsorro otas* SbMo notes mtm obligations of tho United 3tat#o CtoTortawtt aaA prior lioas on all tho tOtOil of Roaonro fcMftfe Soippogfttioa of the coll ter 1 }&dt of tiie^ofofOt -adfto nothing to tfaeir oafoty* On tli« otbor reqoirottmt for t o ^ t ^ t i o a eaxtood seart^mt diffleuX^r # }y gold 0T#r aad al>oYe the ^0 per e@nt required reiorro, w&&n a foroicoi i r a t e OB omr ^ 1 4 in 1951 and 1932» ®bo fitmati0B waa not for tho w s r # p i ^ % pONttttaf ttO lA^ffi of M t t d State® mm% oMlgstions M oollatoral a^iiuit Fodwal Eoowte B&totj 1m% avkhoritgr of th® ros^nro iNgudoi 1B fhls matter i t only trnporary. aftrlsafe&o mmn% vmdLA HHM to r«^v# tMg gjjtilitligi adtoeothor« in #0sme0tiom with %hm f^oposalf rolatlmg t i r t e t l y t^ ooanorolal ^as&iBg# i t i t to b# l i l H M I *J»* *3Nf «»• AWi •pooAing wt MMPPMf« 1mt ^^^ u tll# Sboir p^«0s# in to i^iswvo rottrietioms in Imn that N M M o t l has nvovot to fe# not tmi •Wlfjgliy barNfal to fesako and borrowor* lllft§« *m the of rtal ootato »rtgrco iMMf* Ifel propoood ei&a*gonHmt -tif of otur %asdcai In atMag I4MH on MHft estate, nater th# ttav3l&%#& ttt HM pNffii^Mli «ottlA neto It w r t feMllAo to mnot tlto frooottt r«f^ir^«it# of aortgg^ iMnrrovero a^i to mm a^p^tstiTely In tbo roflwl gf a^tiirity am tho ednstwyetion lB4nttrj# etnont of tbio l^gi^latl^n witli roopoot to H i t ant towoTOimi \xrilm to f^rtti^ t f f w t in tbo ©cwitiy1! ottdtt nootoi f « It would oaafelo Hunt to glto uMtliitod fUjftHMttt to • wuanor not n^w pootiKUi for thoRt to that of intaotvy hi HJMII tho a-pporimity for s^etiag lioth • ooeial i t now groatoot* Ak The following is a brief running summary of proposed "banking legislation* The bill is to be known as the "Banking Act of 1935." Its principal provisions are: Title I ~ Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Amendments. !• Existing Temporary Funds are merged into the Permanent Insurance Plan, which becomes operative immediately upon enactment of the "Banking Act ofl$35.!l 2. $5f000 continues to be the maximum insurance protection f^r each depositor in any bank. Trust funds are insured up to $5f000 for each trust estate. 3. Maximum limit of assessment of l/l2 of 1$ of total deposits is substituted for obligatory stock subscription amounting to 1$ of total deposits with liability for repeated assessments thereafter. A uniformly lower assessment may be fixed by the Board of Directors for mutual savings banks. 4. Banks not members of the Federal Reserve System are permitted to withdraw from insurance after notice to their depositors and to the Corporation. Similarly, after adequate notice and after a hearing the Corporation may terminate the insured status of any bank. 5. The Corporation's present right to buy assets of closed member banks is extended until July 1, 1936, to open banks when it will facilitate mergers and avert loss. For this purpose, the Corporation may also make loans to insured banks or guarantee other insured banks against loss in assuming liabilities of insured banks. &% The proceeds derived from the sale of capital stock of the Corporation may be allocated between capitaLand surplus in such amounts as the Board of Directors may prescribe, so that in the event of losses exceeding the proceeds of the annual assessments -2the Corporation will not "be forced to operate with impaired capital* Dividends on capital stock of the Corporation are eliminated. 7« Detailed administrative and technical changes, which seem advisable in the light of the experience of the Corporation, include the following: (a) Certain important terms used in the Act have teen defined; (b) Mechanics of pay-offs have "been revised and clarified; (c) The Corporation is given the right to require insured "banks to maintain adequate fidelity and burglary insurance; (d) The standards for determining whether or not banks should became insured are set forth; (e) Insured banks not members of the Federal Reserve system are required to make reports of conditions, and the Corporation may order publication of such reports;" (f) Corporation approval is required "before a merger ot consolidation of insured banks with non-insured banks, t*r before a reduction of capital of non—member banks takes place; (g) Other miscellaneous changes: i. The use of the words "Deposit Insurance" in the name of a bank is prohibited; ii. Examiners of the Corporation are prohibited from borrowing from insured tanks; iii. Criminal provisions are extended to protect all insured banks. Title II ~ Federal Reserve Act Amendments^ With respect t« Federal Reserve Banks: 1. Combine offices of Chairman of the Board of Directors and Governor at each ©f the Federal Reserve banks, appointments to be made annually by the directors of the bank, after approval by the Federal Reserve Board. Vice-Governors are to be selected in the same manner. 2. No members of the Board of a Federal Reserve bank, except Governor and Vice-Governor, shall hold office for more than six consecutive years. With respect to the Federal Reserve Board: 3. Change qualifications for future appointive members of the Federal Reserve Board by providing that they shall be persons 3 - well qualified by education or experience or "both to participate in the formulatipn of national economic and monetary policies. The present geographical limitation shell rot apply to selection of future Governors, T^ie Governor1 s membership on the Board shall expire when he is no longer designated as Governor by the President* 4. Increase the salaries of future appointive members to $15,000 per annum, with compulsory retirement at 70 on $12,000 pension. Present members to be eligible for retirement at 70. Proportionate pensions., will be allowed for service of less than twelve years.m 5. The Board shall be empowered to., delegate specific powers and duties not involving the determination of national or System policies to individual members of the Board or its representatives. With respect to credit control: 6. Change Section 12A of the Federal Reserve Act so as to provide for an open-market committee to consist of the Governor and two members of the Board elected annually by the Board, and two • governors of Federal Reserve banks elected annually by the governors of the Federal Reserve banks* This committee shall make recommendations about discount rate policies and shall forxsulate the System1s open market policies which shall be binding on the Federal Reserve banks. With respect to collateral requirements: 7. Any sound asset of a member bank shall be eligible fo£ discount at a Reserve bank, subject to regulations of the Federal Reserve Board, and the Board shall also have authority to prescribe limitations on maturity of advances to member banks. 8. Section 14 is amended so that obligations the principal and interest of which are guaranteed by the United States shall be eligible for purcha.se by Federe.1 Reserve banks without regard to maturity, 9. Collateral requirements for Federal Reserve notes shall be repealed, and the office of Federal Reserve Agent shall be abolished. With respect to reserve requirements: 10. In order to prevent injurious credit expansion or contraction, the Federal Reserve Board may change reserve requirements ~ 4 - as to any or all Federal Reserve districts and/or any or all classes of cities, and as to time and/or demand deposits, With respect to capital requirements: 11. At any time prior to July 1, 1937, the Federal Reserve Board may admit any insured non-member bank to membership in the Federal Reserve System; and may waive the capital requirements for admission? provided tiiat such bank shall comply with all of the regular requirements of members within such time as the Federal Reserve Board shall prescribe. With respect to real estate loans: 12. Section 24 of the Federal Reserve Act is amended to permit loans to be made on amortization besis for periods of 20 years and up to 75 per cent of value of property. The geographical limitation as to location of real estate is removed. The aggregate amount of real estate loans plus other real estate (except bank premises) is not to exceed 60 per cent of time deposits or 100 per cent of capital and surplus, whichever is the greater. All real estate loans are to be secured by first liens, but second and subsequent liens may be taken to secure debts previously contracted in good faith. The limitations of Section 24 are made applicable to State member banks. Title III - Technical Amendments. Section 301 exempts "accidental11 holding company affiliates from voting permit requirements where not engaged as a business in holding bank stock. Section 302 provides that member banks need not divorce securities affiliates which are in formal liquidation. Section 303 (a) makes it clear that the prohibition against security dealers accepting deposits does not prevent banking institutions from deading in, underwriting, purchasing and selling investment securities to the extent permitted to national banks and does not prevent banking institutions from selling mortgages without recourse, (National banks are limited, in dealing In and underwriting, to Government obligations, general obligations of States or political subdivisions, obligations issued under authority of Federal Farm Loan Act, by Federal Home Loan Board or Home Oraeffe* Loan Corporation.) (b) Exempts business institutions accepting deposits solely from their employees, from examination and publication of reports of condition; and requires private banks to bear expense of their examination when made by Federal authorities. Section 304 terminates double liability of shareholders of national banks on July 1, 1937. Section 305 corrects omission of national banks in Alaska and Hawaii from benefit of amendment repealing law requiring directors of national banks to increase their shareholdings. - 5 - Section 306 gives Federal Reserve Board power to control con-* nections of officers, directors, and employees of tanks with securities companies "by regulation rather than "by issue of individual permits• Section 307 (a) eliminates any question of power of member "banks to buy or sell stocks solely for the account of their customers and pennits national "banks to purchase far their own account investment securities not to exceed 10 per centum of unimpaired capital and surplus, (b) Restates existing prohibition against national banks purchasing stock for their own account. Section 308 requires new national "banks to have paid-in surplus equal to 20 per cent of capital, subject to waiver as to State "bank converting into national bank* Section 309 eliminates possibility that present law prevents corporations other than a bank from conditioning transfer of their shares on transfer of bank stock* Section 310 (a) permits holding company to vote to place bank in voluntary liquidation without obtaining voting pemit. (b). Since shares held by bank as sole trustee cannot be voted, same are excluded from determination whether resolution adopted by requisite number of shares• (c) Eliminates any doubt that holding company with voting permit may cumulate its shares as may other shareholders. Section 311 gives Comptroller discretion to permit converting State bank to carry over sound assets not conforming to requirements as to assets held by national banks. Section 312 allows Comptroller to delegate manual labor of countersigning bond transfer. Section 313 permits national bank branches located outside United States to charge interest rate permitted by local law. Section 314 provides for national banks gradually increasing surplus out of earnings, until equal to capital. Section 315 extends criminal provisions applicable to member banks to include insured banks. Section 316 gives Comptroller closer supervision over banks in voluntary liquidation. - 6 - Section 317 extends present prohibition on use of word, "national", "by tanks other than national "banks, to include combinations of such word* Section 318 corrects oversight "by requiring member "banks to reduce stockholdings in Federal Reserve "bank upon a reduction of surplus. Section 319 requires State member banks to publish reports of condition* Section 320 places State member banks on parity with national banks as regards loans on government obligations. Section 321 permits Federal Reserve bank direct loans to private business to be made on adequate indorsement or security, instead of requiring both as under present law* Section 322* Reference to par value of Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation stock in the "Loans to Industry" Act changed to "amount paid for said stock," Section 323 (a) authorizes Federal Reserve Board to define "deposit" and related terms for reserve and interest requirements respecting deposits* (b) Permits amounts due from other banks to be deducted from gross deposits, instead of amounts due to banks, in determining reserve requirements* (c) Extends power to regulate payment of interest by member banks to include all insured banks, except mutual savings and Morris Plan banks not members of system* (d) Requires member banks to maintain same reserves against government deposits as against other deposits* Section 324 permits waiver of reports and examinations of barfs: affiliates where deemed unnecessary fully to disclose relationship* Section 325 (a)* Extends prohibition against loans and gratuities, to examiners of all insured banks, (b) Extends prohibition against disclosure of confidential information to Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation examiners* (c) Corrects impractical features of law prohibiting loans to executive officers, by vesting certain discretion in the Federal Reserve Board, substituting power of removal from office for present criminal provisions, and extending time within which existing loans must bo paid* Section 326* Excepts affiliates from existing requirements on loans whore affiliation arose out of foreclosure by bank on collateral* and excludes affiliate engaged solely in operating property acquired for bank purposes controlled by bank in fiduciary capacity* ~ 7 - Section 327 exempts loans for industrial purposes made with Federal Reserve Bank or Beconstniction Finance Corporation from existing restrictions on real estate loans by national "banks* Section 328 amends Clayton Act to permit Federal Reserve Board to supervise matter of interlocking directorates throtigh general regulations instead of by individual permits. Sections329 and 330 bring law governing consolidation of national banks into coriforaiity with that governing consolidations of State and national "banks, offer additional protection to dissenting shareholders, "but require notice of dissent to he given when vote to consolidate is had. Sections 331 and 332 extend to Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation protection now given other Federal institutions against misleading use of name and extend to all insured banks law making robbery of member "banks a Federal offense*