View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Form 2£o. 131
/*\ff

i^

1

FEDERAL RESERVE

Urnce Correspondence
Governor Eooles
Mr. %att, General

B0ARD

Subject!
Counsels

iw

January s,

Gold suit
Reserve

B»nk n? ifew
• r•

16—852

CONFIDENTIAL.
This is written in accordance with your request to remind you
to discuss with Governor Harrison the gold suit filed against the Federal Reserve Bank of New York by the British-American Tobacco CompanytLtdf
of London, England, and the question whether the Bank should retain Honorable Newton D. Baker to represent it in the litigation.
Mr. Baker is probably the best qualified lawyer of national
repute to represent the Federal Reserve Bank in this litigation, and it
would seem proper for the Bank to retain him if he will accept the caset
since he has represented the Federal Reserve System in all litigation of
national importance since 1923, has a thorough knowledge of the Federal Reserve System and has dready made a study of the gold questions, about which
he was retained to advise the Board and the Federal Reserve banks•
The only possible question about retaining him in this connection
arises out of the fact that he apparently is not very sympathetic with the
Gold Reserve Act and the present Administration, and the Administration may
not feel very friendly toward him. However, this would not prevent Mr* Baker
from putting forth his very best efforts to defend the Federal Reserve Bank
if he should accept the case; because he is a man of such high character
that he would not accept the case unless he felt that he could give his
client his whole-hearted support.
This case is of such far reaching importance to the entire Federal Reserve System that the Federal Reserve Bank of New York should be
represented by the best counsel obtainable; and 1 believe that, in view of
his previous experience in Federal Reserve litigation, his familiarity
with the Federal Reserve System and the special studies he has made of the
gold problem as it affects the Federal Reserve banks, Mr. Baker is the
best man available.




Respectfully,

Walter
General

Counsel*

COPY

January 30, 1934#
Honorable Eugene R* Black, Governor,
Federal Reserve Board*
Washington, !)• C#
Dear Governor Blacks
H* R. 6976, known as the wGold Reserve Act of 1934" has now
passed both Houses and been signed by the President*
At all stages of the discussion of the subject covered by this
legislation we have been constantly in touch with the legal questions
involved and our views both as to the form the transaction should take
and as to the legal questions involved have been reported from time to
time to the Federal Reserve Board and to the Governors of the Federal
reserve banks*

Facing the practical question presented by the passage

of the legislation we have been asked to advise whether voluntary compliance with the requirements of the Act as it affects the stock of gold owned or controlled by the Federal Reserve System is safe and wise*
We are of the opinion that the Federal Reserve Board, the Federal
reserve banks and the Federal reserve agents can safely comply with
the provisions of this legislation as finally enacted and that no reservation or protest is necessary to save whatever rights they have
or to fulfill any duty imposed upon them by law, particularly in view
of the fact that the transactions are between them and the Government
of the United States* which is ultimately responsible for the monetary




Honorable Eugene R* Black - - 2

policy of the Nation, for the payment of Federal reserve notes and
for the credit and welfare of the Federal Reserve System established
by it as an instrumentality for the performance of public functions*
We therefore answer both questions submitted to us in the affirmative*
Respectfully yours,

Walter Wyatt,
General Counsel, Federal Reserve Board#

Newton D. Baker$
Special Counsel for the Federal Reserve
Board and the Federal Reserve System*

NDB/WW sad




1 26 34