View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Form F. B. 131
BOARD OF GDVERNDRS
DF THE

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

Office Correspondence
Chairman Eccles
Frnm

n« te
Subject; Banking Legislation

Ronald Ransom




C 0NFI D E H T I A L
In connection with Title III of the Banking
Act of 1955 the term "technical amendments* came into
use in relation to certain types of amendments to
existing banking laws. The designation is generally
accepted as meaning amendments not of a controversial
nature, but which would strengthen and improve Federal
banking statutes. So used,many important amendments can
be suggested under this heading that could be favored
as part of a general legislative program which would not
constitute such a program or necessarily be recommended
in the absence of other legislation of which they might
be a part. Of course the necessity for such amendments
would depend in any instance on the nature of other proposals of a substantive kind. Such substantive changes
might eliminate necessity for some of the amendments that
would otherwise be in order.
Mr. Vest, Assistant General Counsel, has prepared
a list of possible technical amendments to the laws affecting the Federal Reserve System. The list is not intended
to contain proposals which should provoke any serious
controversy, although opinions may differ as to their
desirability. Mr. Vest states that the list includes
a large number of proposals, some of which are of relatively
small importance and a number of which he personally would
not favor. These have been included in order that the
list may be inade as complete as possible since others may
feel that they are desirable. A copy of his list is
attached for the information of the Board.

L-620
Confidential

September 12, 1938.
POSSIBLE TECHNICAL AMENDMENTS TO THE LAWS
AFFECTING THE FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

There is set forth below a list of possible technical
amendments to the laws affecting the Federal Reserve System to
which consideration might be given in connection with any proposed
banking legislation.
BOARD OF GOVERNORS
Assignment of duties. - An amendment authorizing the
Board of Governors to assign to designated members of the Board
or its representatives, under rules and regulations prescribed
by the Board, the performance of specific duties and functions,,
not including the determination of national or System policies,
the power to make rules and regulations, or any power which under the Act is required to be exercised by a specified number of
members of the Board. (Sec. 11 F.R. Act)
Facilitating hearings by the Board. - In connection with
all hearings conducted by the Board regarding the removal of directors and officers of member banks, the expulsion of State banks
from the Federal Reserve System, the revocation of voting permits,
and similar matters, an amendment giving the Board authority similar to that possessed by the Federal Trade Commission, the Interstate Commerce Commission and other administrative agencies to
have testimony taken by one or more members of the Board or by
such trial examiners as it may designate, and authorizing the Board
or its designated representatives to administer oaths and to subpoena witnesses and documents and to serve notice by registered
mail. (Sec. 11 F.R. Act)
Service of Board member as director of the Bank for International Settlements. - An amendment making it clear that a member of the Board of Governors, with the approval of the President of
the United States, may serve as a director of the Bank for International Settlements, in order to enable the Board more effectually
to carry out its functions under section 14(g) of the Federal Reserve
Act with regard to relationships of Federal Reserve Banks with foreign
banks and bankers. (Sec, 14(g) F.R. Act)
Correction of error in number of members of the Board. The last sentence of the fourth paragraph of section 10 in connection with vacancies in the membership of the Board of Governors
refers to six members when it obviously should be seven. This
might be cured by a clarifying amendment. (Sec. 10 F.R. Act)




- 2 -

L-620

FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS AND FEDERAL RESERVE AGENTS
Separation of offices of Chairman and Federal Reserve
Agent. - An amendment authorizing the Board of Governors in its
discretion to designate one of the class C directors to serve only
as Chairman of the board of directors of the Federal Reserve bank
and to appoint a different person, who need not be a director, to
serve as Federal Reserve Agent. Relieve the Chairman of all statutory duties except those of director and the duty of presiding at
meetings of the board of directors, provided that other present statutory duties of the Chairman and the Agent may, in the Board's discretion, be performed by the Chairman or by the Agent or by the
Federal Reserve bank. (Sec. 4 F.R. Act)
Assistant Federal Reserve Agents. - An amendment authorizing an Assistant Federal Reserve Agent to perform the duties of
the Agent during a vacancy in the latter1s office and eliminating
the requirement that an Assistant Agent be a person of "tested banking experience". (Sec. 4 F.R. Act)
By-laws of the Federal Reserve Banks. - An amendment providing that the by-laws of the Federal Reserve banks shall be subject to approval of the Board of Governors. (Sec. 4 F.R. Act)
Loans to groups of member banks. - An amendment eliminating the authority of Federal Reserve banks to make loans to
groups of member banks, inasmuch as the authority has never been
used and there will probably never be any occasion for its use.
Limitation of continuous service of Federal Reserve bank
directors. - An amendment forbidding Federal Reserve bank directors
to serve more than two consecutive terms of three yo&rs each. (Sec. 4
F.R. Act)
Subscriptions to Federal Reserve bank stock* - Amendments
making it clear that newly organized national banks are required to
subscribe for Federal Reserve bank stock and must comply with provisions of the Federal Reserve Act. (Sec. 5 i.R. Act)
Penalty for paying out notes of another Federal Reserve
bank. - An amendment repealing the provision which prohibits a
Federal Reserve bank from paying out notes of another Federal Reserve bank, except under penalty of a tax of ten per cent. (Sec. 16
F.R. Act)




- 3 -

L-620

Federal Reserve bank notes. - The authority contained in
this section and in other sections of the Act relating to the issuance of Federal Reserve bank notes might be eliminated in view
of the fact that this authority will cease in any event when the
President declares by proclamation that the emergency recognized
in his proclamation of March 6, 1933, has terminated. (Sec. 18
F.R. Act)
Approval of examiners by Board of Governors. - An amendment authorizing Federal Reserve banks to use their employees in
connection with the examinations of large State member banks without necessarily having such employees approved by the Board of
Governors as examiners. (Sec. 9 F.R. Act)

STATE MEMBER BANKS
Termination of membership of bank in an unsafe condition. An amendment authorizing the Board of Governors to terminate the
membership of a State member bank which is in an unsafe condition,
and a similar amendment to the National Bank Act giving the Comptroller authority to close a national bank before it becomes insolvent. (Sec. 9 F.R. Act)
Publication of reports of examination. - An amendment
giving to the Board the same power to publish reports of examination
of State member banks or their affiliates as is now given to the
Comptroller of the Currency in connection with national banks and
their affiliates for failure to comply with recommendations or suggestions of the Comptroller based on examinations thereof. (Sec. 9
F.R. Act)
Incorporation into law of certain of Board* s present conditions of membership. - An amendment requiring the Board's approval before a State member bank causes or permits any change to
be made in the general character of its business or in the scope
of its corporate powers, requiring each State member bank to conduct its business and to exercise its powers with due regard to
the safety of its depositors, and possibly incorporating into the
law some of the other standard conditions of membership now imposed on State member banks. Also, possibly an amendment authorizing the Board to regulate the powers exercised by State member
institutions, including trust powers, rather than merely to prescribe conditions of membership relating to such institutions. (Sec. 9
F.R. Act)
Removal of branches. - An amendment providing that the
removal of a branch of a State member bank from one town to another
shall be subject to approval of the Board of Governors. (Sec. 9
F.R. Act)




- 4 -

L-620

Waiver of membership requirements• - An amendment to make
effective immediately, instead of in 1941, the Board1s authority
to waive requirements for admission to membership for the purpose
of facilitating the admission of any State bank which is required
to be a member in order to continue in an insured status. (Sec. 9
F.R. Act)
Forfeiture of membership of State member banks, - An amendment authorizing the Board to require a State member bank to forfeit its membership whenever such bank has failed to comply with
provisions of State law to which the Bank is subject, (Sec. 9 F.R.
Act)

NATIONAL BANKS AND MEMBER BANKS aEWERALLY
Deposits of securities to secure trust funds. - An amendment making it clear that a deposit of securities must be made to
secure trust funds used by a national bank in its banking department whether such funds are considered as deposits or are investments. Also an amendment which would exempt national banks from the
necessity of pledging securities for trust funds used in the banking
department to the extent that such funds are insured under the Federal
Deposit Insurance Corporation. (Sec. ll(k) F.R, Act)
Authority of Board over trust powers of national banks. An amendment authorizing the Board to revoke trust powers whenever it may determine, under procedure similar to that prescribed
in section 30 of the Banking Act of 1933, that such trust powers
are being .unlawfully or otherwise improperly exercised and providing that the Board shall have authority when granting trust
powers to prescribe such conditions or requirements in connection
therewith as it may deem necessary or desirable. (Sec. ll(k) F.R.
Act)
Limitations on insured loans. - An amendment providing
that mortgage loans insured under Title II of the National Housing Act should not be subject to the limitations on the aggregate
amount of real estate loans which may be made by national banks.
At the present time this limitation is the aggregate of capital
and surplus or 60 per cent of time and savings deposits, whichever is greater, and applies to insured loans as well as other
real estate loans. (Sec. 24 F.R. Act)
Deposits with private bankers. - An amendment to make the
provision restricting deposits by a member bank with a nonmember
bank to not more than Jp per cent of the member bank's capital and
surplus applicable to deposits by a member bank with a firm of
private bankers. (Sec. 19 F.R. Act)




- 5 -

L-620

Payment of dividends by mutual savings banks, - An amendment to clarify the question whether the distribution of net earnings
by mutual savings banks is to be considered a payment of interest
within the meaning of section 19 of the Federal Reserve Act relating
to the payment of interest on deposits and of section 24 of the
Federal Reserve Act regarding the maximum rate of interest authorized by State law. (Sees. 19 and 24 F.R, Act)
Circulation of false statements about member banks. - An
amendment to make it a crime to circulate false statements about,
or to blacklist a member bank. (Sec. 22 F.R. Act)
Incorrect reference to section 20 of the Federal Reserve
Act. - An amendment to correct a reference in the statute to
"national banking associations" subject to the reserve requirements
set forth in "section 20" of the Federal Reserve Act and to make
the provision refer to member banks subject to the provisions of
section 1£. (Sec. ll(e) F.R. Act)
Loans on obligations of the United States and of States
and municipalities. - In view of the fact that there is no limitation in the law on the amount of obligations of the United States
or of States or political subdivisions thereof which a member bank
may purchase, an amendment to eliminate the limitations on loans on
the security of such obligations which are contained in section 11(m)
of the Federal Reserve Act and section 5200 of the Revised Statutes.
(Sec. ll(m) F.R. Act)
Loans to executive officers made prior to June 16, 1933. An amendment to extend or make permanent the period during which loans
made to executive officers prior to June 16> 1933, may be extended
or renewed. (Sec. 22(g) F.R. Act)
Reports of loans to executive officers. - An amendment
providing that the failure of an executive officer to make the required reports of his indebtedness to other banks is punishable by
removal from office under section 30 of the Banking Act of 1933.
(Sec. 22(g) F.R. Act)
Loans to executive officers out of trust funds. - An
amendment to make it clear that the law does not apply to any loan
which constitutes an asset of a trust estate acquired by the member
bank subsequent to the date of the loan, and also an amendment to
permit a member bank to lend trust funds to an officer of the bank
in accordance with directions contained in the trust instrument.
(Sec. 22(g) F.R. Act)




- 6 -

L-620

Loans to affiliates, - In order to prevent evasion of the
limitations on loans to affiliates by a member bank through making
loans to organizations which, although not technically affiliates,
are to all intents and purposes as closely related to the member
bank :as technical affiliates, an amendment might be adopted to make
the provisions of the statute applicable to all units which are
definitely part of a group and not merely to those which are technical affiliates. Also an amendment clarifying the question whether
a loan which is secured to any extent by stock of an affiliate must
be included in computing the limitations under section 23A at the
full amount of the loan or merely at the amount of the collateral.
(Sec. 23A F.R. Act)
Loans to examiners. - An amendment limiting the prohibition on loans to examiners to loans to examiners who at the
time the loans are made could reasonably be expected to be called
upon to examine the lending banks in the usual course of business.
The law might also be amended so as (1) to exclude from its prohibition the acquisition of loans by a bank in good faith in the
usual course of business, and (2) to make the provisions of the
first and second paragraphs of this section prohibiting loans to
examiners more uniform, and (3) to make the disqualification of
a convicted examiner from holding office as a national bank examiner or Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation examiner extend also
to disqualification as a Federal Reserve examiner. (Sec. 22(a)
F.R. Act)
Examiners performing other service for compensation. An amendment making Federal Reserve examiners subject to the provisions which prohibit national bank examiners from performing any
other service for compensation for a national bank. (Sec. 22(b)
F.R. Act)
Disclosure of information by examiners. - An amendment
forbidding examiners to disclose, not only the names of borrowers
of the collateral for loans, as under the existing law, but also
forbidding them to disclose any other information obtained in the
course of examinations. (Sec. 22(b) F.R. Act)
SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT
Credit by brokers not on registered or exempted securities. An amendment to broaden the Boardfs powers to permit brokers to extend
or maintain credit without collateral or on collateral other than
registered or exempted securities. (Securities Exchange Act of 1934)




- 7 -

L-620

Greater flexibility of provisions regarding margin requirements, - An amendment which would clarify the Board1s authority
to grant specific exemptions from its regulations regarding brokers1
margin requirements, and would eliminate the necessity for the regulation being confined to credit extended to persons who are technically "customers". (Securities Exchange Act of 1934)
Clarification of term "carrying". - An amendment which
would specifically authorize the Board to define the term "cariying"
in such a way that any loan made on the collateral of a security
could be held to be for the purpose of carrying the security.
(Securities Exchange Act of 1934)
Clarification of authority for margin requirements on
short sales, etc. - An amendment which would clarify the Boardfs
authority to prescribe margin requirements on certain transactions
such as short sales of securities and contracts to buy or sell unissued securities, about which there might be some question as to
whether or not there is technically an extension of credit. (Securities Exchange Act of 1934)
Power to exempt securities, etc. - An amendment authorizing the Board, as to the margin requirement provisions, to exempt
securities, define the term "equity security" and prescribe rules
to prevent evasion by means of the transaction of business in foreign countries. (Securities Exchange Act of 1954)

MISCELLANEOUS
Definition of the tern "bai debts". - An amendment to
the law to change the definition of the term "bad debts" in connection with the determination of the right of a bank to pay dividends. This might be done by providing that a debt should net be
classified as a bad debt if it is either fully secured or in
process of collection* Under the present law it must be both
fully secured and in process of collection to escape the classification of a bad debt if interest thereon is six months past due.
(Sec. 5204 U.S.R.S.)
Quorum for meetings of shareholders of national banks. An amendment providing that the holders of not less than a specified percentage of the shares of stock of a national bank shall
constitute a quorum at meetings of stockholders, in order to prevent evasion of the provisions of law relating to holding company
affiliates. (Sec. 5144 U.S.R.S.)




- 8 -

L-620

Interlocking directorates with securities companies, .An amendment to make this section applicable to interlocking directorates between member banks and organizations engaged in the
securities business, regardless of whether they are primarily so
engaged, (Sec. 32 Banking Act of 1933)
Definition of term "affiliate" and "holding company affiliate". - Amendments to these definitions to provide that stock
owned by the Reconstruction Finance Corporation shall not be considered in determining whether holding company affiliate or affiliate relationships exist. Amendments to the definitions clarifying the meaning of the phrase "more than 50 per cent of the number of shares voted for the election of directors of any one bank
at the preceding election". (Sec. 2 Banking Act of 1933)
Use of banking quarters for other purposes. - An amendment which would exclude from the banking quarters of a member
bank or a nonmember insured bank the offices of other organizations engaged in building and loan, brokerage, securities, insurance or trust business, the activities of which might prove
embarrassing to the bank. (Sec. 24A F.R. Act)
Compensation of members of the Industrial Advisory Committees. - An amendment providing that members of the industrial
advisory committees shall be entitled to receive from the Federal
Reserve bank a reasonable compensation as well as reasonable expenses. (Sec. 13b F.R. Act)
Use of the term "bank", etc. - An amendment restricting
use of the words "bank", "banker", "banking", and "tru3t" to banking and trust institutions which operate under the supervision and
regulation of State or Federal banking departments. (Sec. 21(a)
Banking Act of 1933)
Federal Advisory Council. - An amendment to provide for
the appointment and service of alternates in the case cf the absence or disability of members of the Federal Advisory Council.
(Sec. 12 F.R, Act)
Dividends on capital stock of insured banks. - An amendment to subsection (v)(3) changing the word "of" to "if" in order to
correct a clerical error apparent in the present law. (Sec. 12B
F.R. Act)

GBV:li