View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

F. A. TIMBY & SONS CO.
General Agents for Utah, Idaho and Montana
SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH

February 2, 1939

BYRON DE FOREST, State Agent
GREAT FALLS, MONTANA

Hon. Marriner S. Eccles, Chairman
Board of Governors
Federal Reserve System
Washington, D. C#
Dear Sir:
I have read in the United States News the tilings you and Mr* Byrd have said
concerning your respective ideas of borrowing and the balancing of the budget#
Certainly you two gentlemen have different ideas, and I am sure the great majority of all THINKING people think Mr. 3yrd has the right slant*
DEMORALIZATION.
In your radio talk appearing in the United States News of January 30, 1939
among other things, you say*
"The same Government Credit that can used to protect human lives in time of
war against the encroachment of a foreign enemy can also be used in time of
peace to protect these human lives against DEMORALIZATION and despair.11
Perhaps your logic is sound, but when it comes to DEMORALIZATION there has
never been anything in this National that has demoralized certain of our citizens as has the present relief set up*
For more than eighteen years I have been Manager of the retail credit bureau in
this city. As such Manager I have access to everything that goes on in our
community, including the names of all families who have to seek work relief or
relief work. I dare say, that not yourself or any member of Coi^ress or even
the President himself has the remotest idea of the things that go on in the
name of relief.
Let me, to illustrate w point on DEMORALIZATION, give you just one incident:
Sorx» months ago a young man wanted to rent from one of our rental agencies a
house and this young man had the cash laid down on the counter to pay the
first month s rent. Retail credit grantors in our community do not extend
credit until they first call our office for a report.




Marriner S. Eccles

-2~

2/2/39

In the instance of this young man, toe record for ten years buying from various
members of our organization was good, as good as anybody could have. He iiad
managed to pay all his accounts promptly and as agreed, and the only accounts
he owed at the time he wanted to rent the house, was a small current doctor
and hospital account.
All this information was disclosed to the rental agency, and then the girl said,
"Recently this subject has taken a W. F» A* job.11 The rental agency handed the
money back and told that man he did not care to rent a house to any W# F, A.
worker, fhe man asked the agency if his credit was poort and the agent assured
him he got an excellent credit report, but that his experience in renting to
I* P. A. workers was not at all satisfactory, and that often they paid the first
month s rent, refused to pay any rare, and it was a costly procedure to get
than out if they did not choose to move on notice*
Then the man came to see me and his first question was HCan I force a man to
take money for rent|M I assured him that he couil not under our laws. Up to
this time I knew nothing of the matter, and I called the girl who delivered the
telephone report to the rental agent* I looked at the past credit record and
assured the man it was first class, and then he asked me why they would not
take his money. I told him that very few credit grantors, and practically no
landlords or rental agencies would extend any credit to W. F# A. workers, that
the worst thing that can happen to ones credit is to get a W. P. A. job, and
THAT IS A FACT*
I further explained to this man that, while he would not believe it, that the
experiences of various credit grantors is that, once men get on W. P. A. they
start losing all self-respect and become demoralized • This man assured me
this would not be the case with him but I suggested he then thought so, but to
stay on for any length of time and he would see the results.
I then asked him "Why in hell did you get a W# P. A. job? lou have lived in
this city for more than ten years and managed to keep off relief•* And his
reply was flIt is easier to get a W# P. A. job than to spend the time rustling
for one in private industry.11
He also asked me "Do you suppose that man would have rented the house to me if
I had not even had a job?11 I assured him that with nis past fine credit record
I had every reason to believe ne could have had the house, and I am sure that
is a fact.
We have had hundreds of W. P. A. workers wiio are refused credit come to our
office to see WHY. The explanation in all cases is the same as was given to
the man who was refused the house. THEY ABE DEMORALIZED.
^o credit men the amount of money spent for relief is small loss, if a losst
in comparison to the demoralizing effect on these people*
You do not need to take my word for this. We have a credit bureau in every important city in the United States, one right there in Washington. It is called
"Associated Retail Credit Mens of Wasnington, Inc.11 and Mr. John K. Althus is
Secretary-Treasurer. Go and talk to the manager along the lines I am writing
you and you will see that I am telling you the truth.




Marriner S. Eccles

-3-

2/2/39

Ask any retail credit bureau manager in ANY city, and learn something of what
demoralization really means* H. Preston Shealey is the Washington correspondent for the Hational Retail Credit Association. Look him up and talk to him
and get an earful of what demoralization means.
Another angle to this W. P. A, work. A district Judge of tnis city—I will be
glad to give you hisname if you want it—has a few houses he rents. Not long
ago he was checking with me a tenant who owes him something like $75*00. The
record is that the man is making payments on a car, yet he will not pay his
rent. Is tnis DEMORALIZATION?
I had the girls in the office keep track for one year in this comity, population not more than 40,000, of reliefers, including W. P. A. workers, who bottght
cars on time, end there were 153 of them* They are still doing it. Fact is
most W. P. A. workers here own and operate cars of some kind.
For a time our State Association of Credit Bureaus in Montana was considering
having introduced in our Legislature a bill which would require all W# P# A.
common laborers to Lransfer their cars to the County Welfare Board to be sold
for casxi and the money given to the family. There was so much opposition that
we decided to forget the matter since it was not our business as credit bureaus
but one of taxpayers generally.
One auto dealer in this city, who is a member of our bureau took me to task for
even suggesting such a law. He said it was hard enough to dispose of second
hand cars asit is and if such a law became effective it would hurt the dealers.
Of course it would. I asked this man if he would sell a car to a msn on relief
if he knew the man had no food or coal for his family. He said he would if the
man had the required cash down payment. I then asked him if he still would do
it if he knew that casr, was all the man had and there was no food for the family and he said he would* Tnen I asked him why and he said MIf I do not, my
competitor will.11 I then asked him if he tn ought it was RIGHT, and he readily
admitted it was not right.
This week when in a barber shop a salesman for an auto company came into the
shop to ask where a certain man, who had worked in that shop only two days in
an emergency the week before, lived. The barber did not know where the man
lived and then asked "What do you want with him?" The salesman said "He has
a Model A Ford which he wants to trade in for a better car." The barber did
not attempt to restrain himself and remarked that the man was on relief, had
nothing to btiy a car witn, and had no business even trying to own a car.
Is this DBMORALIZATIONT I think it is of the worst kind. Adjoining my ranch
where I live and drive in 12 miles every morning is a family, consisting of
the man,his wife, and four children, one boy almost blind, who bought some
land--nothing down—from an insurance company. He has been on relief of some
kind most of the time for many years.
He had several hundred bushels of wheat some years ago and instead of keeping
it for food and seed, he sold it and traded in his old car and bought a better
one. I happen to know he has bought four second hand cars in the past five or
six years, but when he needs and must have food and coal he rushes in and gets




Marriner S. ^ccles

-4-

2/2/39

it. I would feed him myself, of course, if it became necessary, "but I 11 be
dajnned if I would buy him cars and gasoline• We have thousands of people on
W. P. A. who could get along and feed their families without relief, but they
cannot do it and spend so much for cars and gasoline.
I know a man, holding a good job as timekeeper in this city for years for the
Hm P. !•, who has two ranches, 6ne irrigated with a livable hou^e^on each one.
He used to hold a deputyship as a Eepublican in tne County Clerk s office in
this city* He is a Spanish American War veteran with a substantial pension,
just himself and wife, has money in the Pirst National Bank, has several head
of cattle on the ranch, but he has been the MOST AEDBKT ACTIVE worker for the
New Deal in our community. Wou£d it not be more in the line of JUSTICE to
give that good job to some man who NEEDS it? I will be glad to supply you
with his name if you wish.
What is neededmost is a thorough check up of ALL applicants for any sort of
relief, and this will never be done by the so-called Case Workers. If such a
cneck is made, in our community at least, half of all W. P. A. workers would
not be drawing taxpayers money.
I do wish you would get a roster of the credit bureaus of the United States
and send out some inquiry end really find out what is going on. As stated
before, neither you nor Congress nor the President, has any idea of abuses*
I think Senator ?yrd does know something of this, but very little.
Aside from being Manager of our credit bureau known here as the Great
Credit Exchange I am an insurance salesman and travel to all the larger cities
in Montana and in visiting the various credit bureaus we discuss the things I
have mentioned*
Senator Byrd used the word "Iron Lung" in one of his articles. It looks to me
that there has been so much DEMORALIZATION of so many of our citizens that the
H
Iron Lung11 has become a permanent thing.
Perhaps I may be somewhat prejudiced, but I am 62 years old and was brought up
in the "horse and buggy" days, only my horse was a mule and the buggy a dead-ax
wagon. Next to the oldest of 12 children born in poverty in South Missouri, I
think I can speak of what it takes to get along without going on relief. Eleven
of the DeForest brothers and sisters are alive and not one, but who has managed
to get along, IN SPITE of the New Deal.
The big thing that turned so many votes from the Hew Deal last November was
the steadily employed workers I have heard many of them say MI do not see how
my neighbor can drive a better car than we can afford and wear better clothes
when they are on relief.11
I realize in big cities the situation may be different, but there is the same
proportion of cniseling on relief, I am sure.
Just one more tnougnt for you to consider and I am through. Day do reliefers
spend every cent they can ahold of for cars? They know that if they get hungry
or cold all they nave to do is to apply for relief and get it. This same idea
is in the minds of the dealers who sell such people cars*




Marriner S. Eccles

-5-

2/2/39

It would be far less demoralizing to people if they were obliged to live on
plain bread and water than to teach them such habits, and unless this constant
deficit is stopped not only these extremely poor people, but mostof us will be
delighted to get the simplest food and forget driving cars. I can see no
other end, hence I have lived on c y ranch for the past four years where I
q
produce r y bread, milk, cream butter eggs vegetables and food for my livestock.
a
In short, I am hedging against the very thing which will come if your philosophy
is much longer continued*
Yours very trulyt
Byron Poorest




/