View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

TO.

Members of the Board

FROM_______Mr. Clayton

1 1 /1 8 /3 8

The attached was received
by the Chairman without any
accompanying letter and is
circulated to you for your
information.




H E A D O F F IC E
San

F r a n c isc o .

CABLE A D D R E SS

C a lif.

"B A M E R IC A L "

iBt t nk a f A m e r i c a
N A T IO N A L SS^'R Tok A S S O C IA T IO N

November 10, 1938.

Honorable Henry Morgenthau, Jr.,
Secretary of the Treasury,
Treasury Department,
Washington, D, C*
Dear Secretary Morgenthaut
This will acknowledge your letter of November 5 , responding
to my telegram s ent to you on November
In order that you may clearly undejitand why I sent you the
telegram referred to, let me suggest /p«t you review briefly the relevant
circumstances which preceded my actic
tinder instruction of your Department, Mr. Palmer, National
Bank Examiner in Los Angeles, appefesMJsefore our Board of Directors on
September 13, 1933» on short notice ar» without previous correspondence,
and read a certain telegram which contained unwarranted criticisms and a
threat of legal action againswsbCfljters and directors of the Bank.
A copy of the tel££ram was mailed to each director personally,
and under date of Septomb^gCjtt, the Comptroller* a office addressed a
lengthy letter of criticismSwhb threat to our Board of Directors and sent
a copy of the letter to^MCh director in an envelope which was marked
neither *personal* nor "e^Tidential.*
Shortly following these happenings# there appeared in several
periodicals news i t a u linking the office of the Secretary of the Treasury
with reported disflftplmary measures employed against certain California banks.
1 regret that yoiT'a^Abt take time to read some of the articles to which I
refer* Had you reaat&ose articles, you would have been convinced, as any
reasonable person would be, that unwarranted criticisms of your Department
were divulged to the press instead of being kept in strict confidence, at
least until we had an opportunity of being heard. Articles, the source of
which Is attributed to your Department, which appeared in certain news services
having a broad circulation among business men throughout the country, prompted

C O R R K S -(X O )S 7

a -9 «




r- * ^
HEAD

CABLE

^r-r-,s~r-

OFFICE
^
_

F r a n c is c o

. ir_

ADDRESS

•BAM ERICAL"

C alif

H nor&ble Henry Morgenthau^iitWt k trf A-ttt CFtCEt

November 10, 1938

N A T I O N A L sA V T fJo s A S S O C IA T IO N

tome of our most valued clients, such as Woolworthfc, Penney1s, Safeway,
Montgomery T*ard, £.nd certain railroads, to make direct and indirect inquiry
hb to their se&niig*
As a result of the iUblicity fdven to theae setters, a whispering
campaign against the Bank got under way, and the rumor was circulated that
the Bans would discontinue dividend payments# To meet a possible emergency
arisinp in consequence of prevalent gossip, recently the management was obliged
to accumulate excessive cash reserves by selling large blocks of rov«rnaent
bonds and restricting lending activity, thereby suffering, unneces-arily, a
loss in income and prestige*
Therefore, when I recently read that po:
of October 30, 193$, carrying a blunt reference to
under discussion between your office nod our bank
that 1 did something personally to put an end to t
and printed, that is causinf so much damage to

Lon of the "Wilcox* letter
controversial matters
id it was uigh time
lious gossip, verbal

In the final analysis, Mr. 8eoreta^y^Ni6^aone must accept
responsibility for the damage caused to Bank of America by reason of the
unwarranted and damaging, method of attack ^pOiK^he Bank and its management,
and the making public of erroneous informati^i^c^loeming the affairs of the
Bank which, even had It been correct, should r^v^ been treated as strictly
confidential by your Department*
Appears in the American
Some of the publicityr to wh^^i>r>sf®r
w
Banker, October 4th issue, page 4,

Back^H^nt»#
•Washington Banking Trends and Back

■—
"*«■
(Wilcox and Aaaociates)

I*8u« of Septeaber 4v 1938^ Page 5
■
• October
•
3
•
• October 23,
»
3
•
• 0cteber/~3a, 1933
•
2
•
3
•
A
O
•
• ffoMtonOft/ '1938
•
5

Itaa (3) (a)
• (i) (r) (e)
* (1) (k)
• (1) U ) P a g e 1+
• (2) <b) (f) U ) (i)
■ fz}
/h}
W
V
Dl
• h ) (<•)

•The Kiplinger leshin^^bf^by^ter*
Issue o£-Qctober

• /jM^b^ber
•
•
^Op'^bar

1# 1933
6, 1938
15# 1938
2 2 , 1938

Fago
*
*
■

4
2
2
2

Paragraph 8
Paragraph 5
Laat 6 Paragraph#
Last 5 Paragraph*

In oase you have may difficulty in securing these artlclss for
reference, I shall be glad to send you photostatic copies of them*

Digitized for
C OFRASER
R R E S . - t 2 0 ) 57 4 - 3 7


H E A D O F F IC E
Sam F r a n c is c o . C a l i f .

CABLE A D D RES*
• B A M E K IC A L "

Honorable Henry MorgenthJf

November 10, 1933.

I did not communicate with you in my capacity a a an officer of
the Bank, but it was ay sense of responsibility as founder of the
institution that impelled me to act and to now write this letter. I
have already undertaken, and succeeded in, one tremendous task of
rehabilitation, and I do not propose to sit idly by vhile thoughtless and
inexperienced pereons take proceedings wyjich tend to destroy this bank,
which is a great public service institution and represent® my life’s work.
I say it is a public institution because it serves over 2,000,000 depositors
whose accounts average less than $675.

Bank
duty
Bank
said

1 am not concerned about any damage to myself, personally; the
of America is my real concern, and I felt that I had carried out my
when I sent you the telegram on November 2. I wanted to protect the
from further damage and to give warning tha^N^hose responsible for
damage would be held strictly accountable.

n my^lace/^lr.
Secretary, you
I feel sure that had you been in
ay
2rotecy<Jhe institution for which you
would have acted as I did in order to protec
felt responsible.
Sincerely,

CO «R E S- (2 0 )5 7

10-36