View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

(letterhead of)
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW TOBK

March 1, 1940
S i r s :
As requested in your letter of February 14, Mr. Knoke has discussed the
technical aspects of the proposed Inter-American Bank with the Board's staff«
He tells me that members of the staff have expressed a desire to have our views
on the broader aspects of the matter, and that as the time for consideration is
short, any comment by us must be given as soon as possible• I have, therefore,
discussed the matter with some of the officer® of the bank and under the circumstances think it best to send this letter directly to you as an informal statement
of our views. If you should want a more formal statement of the bank's views,
time would be needed for further study and for presentation of the question to
the directors.
You will appreciate that we have less background on this proposal than
those who have been studying it for several months and we may not be aware of all
the considerations involved. Our comments are based entirely upon our reading
of the Charter, the *Draft of Convention* and the *Draft of By-Laws* prepared by
the Inter-American Economic and Financial Advisory Coaamittee*
The By-Laws, page 6-8, enumerate the purposes and powers of the bank*
The purposes are broad and the powers sweeping*

The proposed bank would be

apparently a commercial bank, an investment bank and a Western Hemisphere super-*
central bank after the model of the B«I«t8. The bank is to finance trade, promote
investment, economic development and trade, stabilize currencies, assist in roain«*
taining adequate monetary reserves, promote the use and distribution of gold and
silver, foster economic and financial cooperation, promote research and contribute




monetary and financial advice* To carry out these purposes the bank is authorized
to make short, intermediate and long-term loans, guarantee loans, buy and sell
government securities, issue its own securities, deal in gold, currencies, and
foreign exchange, aet as a clearing-house, discount and rediscount for, and carry
deposits for, governments, central banks, political subdivisions, and nationals*
After enumerating fifteen specific powers, which taken together are almost unlimited, the By-Laws add (5C, page 8) what appears to be a blanket mandate to the
bank to carry out its purposes:

»The Board of Directors shall determine the

nature of the operations which may be undertaken by the bank in the exercise of
its povrers and in order to effectuate its purposes**
In our judgment such broad powers and purposes wuld ran the serious
risk of arousing false hopes and expectations of *&at the bank could accomplish*
The use of such powers, or the failure to use them, could in many circumstances,
we believe, become a source of embarrassment to the United States, and a creator
of ill-will rather than of good-will*
We do not believe that an adequate economic foundation exists for the
successful functioning of such a bank. Virtually all the Latin American countries
are debtor countries, while the United States is a creditor country*

The Latin

American countries have little or no financial relations with each other. While
on its face, therefore, the proposal appears to call for mutual financial cooperation among all the participating countries, it seems to us practically certain
that the cooperation would resolve itself into lending by the United States and
borrowing by the other countries from the United States. And along with «uch
loans, under the terms of this proposal, would go a large measure of responsibility
by the lender for the monetary stability and the economic well-being of the borrowers*

It is true that under the By-Laws this country would have power to object




to the adoption of measures of i&ich it did not approve, but tlie exercise of such
po?*er might prove a source of great embarrassment if we should find ourselves,
as might easily be the case, the sole objector to some course of action which the
other countries wished to pursue•
It has long been and still remains a doubtful question how much economic
basis exists for loans by this country to Latin American countries, and perhaps
no broad generalization is possible* Much depends upon the nature of our trade
relations, which are different for different countries*

In a number of important

cases lending has not that close counterpart in mutually advantageous exchange of
goods Yihich has often characterized, for example, English financial and trade
relations with agricultural countries* But when acting through an institution
such as is here proposed it might well prove difficult for us to make discriminations on a strictly economic basis*
In our judgment the proposed bank suffers from the defects of all PanAmericanism in the economic sphere, in that it tries to put on a hemisphere basis
what is not really a hemisphere problem* Not only are financial relations among
the Latin American countries virtually non-existent* and even their inter-trade
relations of secondary importance, but in a number of cases their trade and
financial relations with European countries are closer, and planted on a better
economic basis, than their relations with this country.
To the extent that loans by this country to Latin American countries
may be desirable for political or economic reasons, it would seem wiser to approach
the problem in some manner more direct and simple and less likely to commit us to
purposes amd responsibilities beyond our power of accomplishment. This might mean
acting through some established agency such as the Export-Import Bank, or setting
up some new governmental agency of our own to accomplish whatever is desired in



the way of making political loans or facilitating or guaranteeing private loans
and private credits*
Such an approach to the problem need carry no implication of any lack of
desire on the part of this government to promote inter-American understanding and
cooperation in every feasible manner*

One of the purposes enumerated in the By-

Laws of the proposed bank is to * engage in research and contribute expert advice
on the problems of public finance, exchange, banking and money as they relate
specifically to the problems of American republics** This objective seems to us
botji desirable and practicable and we believe that the mechanisms of central banks
and treasuries already existing should be utilized, and developed further, for
this purpose*
Faithfully yours,

(signed)

G10RGE L* HARRISON
George L» Harrisonf
President*

Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve Systemf
Washington, D* C*