View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

155

February 27, 1943
9:20 a.m.
FINANCING

Present: Mr. Bell

Mr. Graves

Mr. Buffington
Mr. Odegard

Miss Elliott

H.M.JR: What I wanted to ask of the War Bond
crowd was whether you were satisfied with the telegrams
that came in from the State chairmen or State administrators.
MR. GRAVES: I thought they were very good. Did
you see them?

H.M.JR: No, I haven't had a chance to see them.
MR. GRAVES: With one or two exceptions, there
was a complete approval on the part of the War Savings
people of this program, and those one or two exceptions,

I think, were not quarreling with the thing, but with

some of the details. For instance, our people in Rhode
Island referred to the days of Roger Williams and said

they seceded from Massachusetts once and didn't like to
be put back under Massachusetts. But, there was almost
unanimous acceptance of this other part of War Savings.
H.M.JR: Any loose--

MISS ELLIOTT: I don't quite agree with that, Mr.
Graves.

H.M.JR: All right, where do you-MISS ELLIOTT: There were about nineteen who said
yes without reservation - made no comments. About four

had very definite reservations to violently oppose -

156

-2Mr. Clement of Alabama, and Mr. Clark of Iowa. Then

there were about four or five that had - they accepted it
with very definite reservations.
When I got through reading them, I had the definite

feeling that it was imperative that underneath it all

there ran through them, as I read them and thought about

it, Mr. Graves, the feeling that it would be extremely
easy to create the feeling in these administrators that
this might destroy the War Savings Staff program.

Now, those telegrams that said, "Yes," said, "We
will cooperate." Then I went back through them a gain
and listed them, and there were so many that had reservations with that word cooperate that I had the feeling
that it was awfully important that these administrators
get assurance that there is no intention in any way in

this plan of destroying the War Savings Staff. Those

who were violently opposed brought that up.

MR. GRAVES: You have seen some telegrams that I

haven't then. I saw no telegram from Mr. Clement.
MR. ODEGARD: You saw the Clark one?
MR. GRAVES: No.

MR. ODEGARD: That was the only decidedly unfavorable
one.

H.M.JR: Harold, if you don't bring it to my attention-MR. GRAVES: I don't know where these telegrams have

gone. I assumed they had all come to me. I did not see
that one or Mr. Clark's.
MISS ELLIOTT: I saw these late yesterday afternoon.

H.M.JR: I had Mr. Bell's office send them up to

Miss Elliott.

MR. GRAVES: They have not come to me. I have seen
no telegram from Alabama or Iowa.

157

-3MISS ELLIOTT: I got very well acquainted with Mr.
Clement in Alabama, and he is really violent on the
subject. He wrote a very long telegram. There were
nineteen of those that said yes.
H.M.JR: What about - leaving Mr. Clement out, what
about the others?
MR. ODEGARD: The only wires I saw were those in

your office, Harold, and there were only one or two that
seemed to me at all unfavorable.
MR. GRAVES: That is right. Apparently there are
some telegrams that have come here that have not come

to me.

MR. BELL: That is the way I read them.
H.M.JR: Have you got them under your arm now?

MISS ELLIOTT: Yes, sir.

MR. BELL: I haven't read them all, büt the ones
I did read I thought were very cooperative.
MISS ELLIOTT: I read all of them, and teacher-like

I took them down and listed each one under the heading

of the State. Then I made a summary of the yes's, no's,
and the reservations, as one would do.

MR. BELL: I don't think they are all in.
MISS ELLIOTT: The States not in are Northern
California, Connecticut, Ohio, Texas, and Alaska and
Washington, D. C.

This is just a brief summary. Nineteen just said,

"Yes, we will cooperate. Four want F and G bonds back.

They are willing to go into this, but they want the F

and G bonds back, and gave a very definite reason for it.

Four stated that they would go on and that it
wouldn't make any difference in their plans, apparently,

158

-4 because they have been working together. They have

worked as a unit anyhow. I was surprised to see Mr.
Griffith in Kansas make that statement.
Then, Indiana recommends that this be adopted for

the duration, and I would interpret their telegram to

mean that we would abolish the War Savings Staff's
continuous program, except pay-roll savings, and go
into this kind of program permanently.
MR. ODEGARD: Mr. Fleming?

MISS ELLIOTT: No, Mr. Pulliam.
The Vermont man and one other believe that this

procedure will definitely kill the War Savings plan.

One interpreted it to mean that the War Savings plan

not only will do it, but it just automatically is

going out, and that this a complete reorganization

and change.

Only one definitely states that we ought to make
it clear, but these other imply that the War Savings
Staff will go on.
Then the one, that is Mr. Clement of Alabama, is
just completely and absolutely and violently opposed to

it.

H.M.JR: Who can I look to in the War Savings Staff
besides Miss Eiliott who is going to analyze these telegrams and then do something about it?
MR. GRAVES: I should, of course.

H.M.JR: It seems so to me.
MR. GRAVES: I apparently have been by-passed as
to some of these telegrams.

H.M.JR: Outside of the one- there is only one
other that you haven't seen?

159

-5MISS ELLIOTT: I would think there are a good many
he hasn't seen.

MR. ODEGARD: I saw them all in there, and I don't
think there were more than half a dozen that I saw

all together.
MR. GRAVES: I have seen more than that.
These telegrams have come to you?

MR. BELL: No, they go to Gamble, are distributed
to you fellows, and then wind up-MR. GRAVES: Where?

they merely wind up in my office
after the War Savings Staff has seen them.
MR. BELL:

MR. GRAVES: I had better collect them, Mr. Morgenthau.
H.M.JR: It seems so to me.
MR. BELL: The Secretary asked my secretary to get

them in a folder after they had been seen.

MR. GRAVES: There were two sets of telegrams;

one went out - the one you are talking about - over
your signature. Then I sent out one over mine; and
perhaps the ones that I have seen, that were, without

exception, favorable, were the ones answering my own
telegram.

H.M.JR: Well-MR. GRAVES: I will get them.

H.M.JR: I can't read them all; it is impossible.
I don't have the time. But, I called this meeting because
I sensed that they couldn't all be favorable. Therefore,
I asked you - that is what I am asking you to do - I asked

Miss Elliott yesterday afternoon whether she had seen them,

and she said that she hadn't, so I asked Mr. Bell to send

160

-6them up to her. I want them kept in one place 80 that

whenever I want them they are there. It seems to me
you had better get busy this morning.
MR. GRAVES: I will get them.

MR. BELL: That is one from Tom Hughes. That came

in last night. (Telegram handed to the Secretary.)
H.M.JR: Of course he never should have been
appointed.

MR. BELL: While he is against it, he says that if

the decision is made he will cooperate.

H.M.JR: He should never have been appointed.

MR. BELL: There is one telegram I recall seeing
that recommended to the Secretary that he reverse the
process and put the whole matter of selling securities
under the War Savings Staff instead of under the
Federal Reserve setup.
MR. ODEGARD: Who is that?

MR. BELL: I don't remember the name. That may

have been Iowa.

MISS ELLIOTT: Three, I think, were willing - feel

it is necessary to have this for the April drive, as I

interpreted their messages. They feel that it is imperative

to put the whole program under, insofar as the details
within the State - not set up a Treasury War Finance Com-

mittee in the State, but let that go through the State
administrator's office and use the same facilities and
all work together there, but let the direction come from

here as to the way they will work together, which seems to
me is a very good idea if we are not going to have con-

flicts in the States.
I feel very definitely, Mr. Secretary, after reading

these telegrams and thinking about them a long time, that

it is almost imperative that the State administrators have
some absolute assurance that this is not developing a

161

7-

trend in the direction of abolishing War Savings. I
think it is going to be easy to get that across to
them.

H.M.JR: Well, I don't want to say anything more,
but, I mean, a meeting like this shouldn't have to take
place. I have to push you fellows to look after your
own State chairmen and State administrators.

MR. ODEGARD: Mr. Secretary, none of this material

has ever come to me, either in routine--

H.M.JR: Look, I can't be office boy around here,
and I am not going to be office boy. I mean, I am fed
up on being office boy around here. I have Harold

Graves, I have you (Odegard), and I have Gamble. You

are all vocal, you all have your feet, you all can get
around. There is a telegraph room. I am not going to
deliver the telegrams personally. They are there, and
I cannot be office boy.
MR. ODEGARD: That is quite right, sir.

H.M.JR: I just can't do it. I knew something was

wrong, and I am not going to have this thing crumble
under me because somebody doesn't want to get busy.

Now, if you want to see this thing crumble, O.K.,
but please tell me.
MR. GRAVES: I certainly am the last man to want to

see it crumble, Mr. Morgenthau. I want anything but to
see it crumble.

H.M.JR: All right.
MR. GRAVES: I supposed that Mr. Bell was showing
you these telegrams.

H.M.JR: My gawd, if I can get them from Mr. Bell's
office and if Peter wanted to see them you can ask for
them, Peter, just the way I do.
MR. ODEGARD: That is right.

162

-8H.M.JR: I mean, you can come back at me - it is

only fair. You could take the initiative and say,

"Where are those telegrams?" You knew they went out.
You collaborated in writing them. You knew they would
be back Thursday, and here it is Saturday.

MR. ODEGARD: That is right. I did see some of

them. I didn't see all of them.

H.M.JR: I mean, let's all cal 1 a spade a spade.
If there is a movement here right under my feet to let
this thing crumble because it isn't going to be looked

at, I am entitled to know it.

Now, what about it, Harold?
MR. GRAVES: There is no such movement.

H.M.JR: Harold, you are sitting there not doing
anything about it.
MR. GRAVES: I didn't know you wanted me to do any-

thing about it.

H.M.JR: What is the purpose of sending them out?

MR. GRAVES: As I said, they were in Mr. Bell's

hands. I assumed he would be showing you these telegrams.

H.M.JR: I mean, the purpose of sending them out is
to give these fellows a chance to come back at me.- come
back at you. And now they have come back, and of course,
some of them are dissatisfied. There is the question of

explaining it. I have been working with Bell on these

bank presidents. They misunderstood something, and we

got busy and we have taken care of it - we explained it.

But we have asked you (Buffington) what your people -

if there was anything to do, and you told me it was all
right, didn't you?
MR. BUFFINGTON: Yes.

163

-9-

H.M.JR: Have you seen your telegrams?
MR. BUFFINGTON: Yes, sir.

H.M.JR: Is anybody there, George, that shouldn't
be-

MR. BUFFINGTON: I beg your pardon?

H.M.JR: Is there something that I should do?
MR. BUFFINGTON: There are one or two still interested
in not having the committee operation - would prefer

having it with no committee formalized, but they all

understand you decided that.

H.M.JR: If I am unfair, damn it, come right back
at me, but this is serious stuff. I mean, you people
keep telling me we have taken so long to build it up
and here it is - all right, a telephone call from one
of you three people here, including Gamble, or if

necessary, a telephone call from Bell, can explain some

of this. That is all I have been doing for two weeks.

But unless somebody brings it to my attention and rubs

my nose in it, I don't see why I should have to take the

initiative.

MR. BELL: Apparently there is a misunderstanding

along the route because I haven't read them all. I

tried three times tc read them and haven't gotten through
them. I assumed they were being analyzed by either you
(Graves) or Gamble, and then they were coming to me

for holding until such time as the Secretary might want
to call for them. Apparently that hasn't been done.
H.M.JR: Where do we go from here?

MR. GRAVES: I will get these telegrams from Mr. Bell
and make an analysis of them.

H.M.JR: I would like Peter, if you would read
them, please.

164

- 10 MR. ODEGARD: I would like to very much.
H.M. JR: And Gamble read them.

MR. GRAVES: I suspect he has.

H.M.JR: And Miss Elliott read them, and then if
you would do something about them today; and then if

you need me, or need Mr. Bell, I am available. But
don't let's let this thing crumble because nothing is
done about it.

Am I unfair, Harold?
MR. GRAVES: Well, no, except that, as I say, I
assumed that Mr. Bell was going to take up with you
all the answers to your telegrams.

H.M.JR: Well, I don't want to go over it again,

but I can't understand why you and Odegard - Peter should assume that.

Now let's - so that the responsibility for seeing

that these men and women are kept happy rests first
with you (Graves) and then also with Peter and Miss

Elliott and Gamble. Right?
MR. GRAVES: Right.

H.M.JR: Will you four people accept it?
MR ODEGARD: Sure. We will try to keep them happy.

H.M.JR: Well, I mean, I am here - I am avai lable.
You can go after me.

MISS ELLIOTT: Mr. Secretary, may I ask this ques-

tion here, to clear up one thing. I think I understand

it perfectly. There is nothing in this plan or in this

move, and so forth, that in any way ought to be interpreted as a move to destroy War Savings Staff?
H.M.JR: Let me answer that.

165

- 11 -

MISS ELLIOTT: I mean the policy of the voluntary
savings program - the whole fundamental policy.

H.M.JR: I will attempt to answer it, and you keep
questioning me until you say you are either satisfied
or not satisfied.
This is what is in my mind; I think I have told you

people - if I haven't, I have been neglectful - that I
was looking for somebody to come in here to help us
at the top. - who would head up this thing under Bell

and me. I think I have such a person; I will know

Monday. We were going to combine these two organiza-

tions for the April drive under complete authority in

the field of the presidents of the Federal Reserve Banks
who would be responsible to me. To one side would be

pay-roll deduction, but in the field for this drive, each
of the presidents of the Federal Reserve would be the
boss in his district. What we are going to do after
April, I don't know.

Now, one of the reasons that I don't know, is that

I don't know what is going to happen to compulsory sav-

ings. I don't know what is going to happen to deductionat-source. But I do want, and I feel that there is room
in the United States for a volunteer plan of buying bonds.

MISS ELLIOTT: That is what my question implied;
whether or not-H.M.JR: And my own feeling is that even though
there is deduction-at-source, even though there is com-

pulsory savings, there still will be a place for a volunteer plan. As somebody was talking to me last night -

I can't remember who it was - he was saying - they were
explaining to some Frenchman, or something, that there

were fifty million people in this country that bought
bonds on a volunteer basis, and they said if that could
be gotten across to the people in Europe - I know who it

was - it was the financial advisor to the Papal delegate Sullivan was telling me - or Swiss. He was telling him,

166

- 12 -

and he wouldn't believe it was so. He was asking,
"Wouldn't there be repudiations--" and all that. How
can there be when there are fifty million people? He said,
"If that could be gotten across, nothing would convince
them as to the solidarity of America as much as that."
He said he mentioned it around - Sullivan - but he
hadn't gotten anywhere.

All I can tell you is I still believe in it. I

am trying to do an organization job because we have

such a tremendous selling job. I still think there will

be a definite place - and should be a definite place for volunteer buying of bonds.

If I haven't satisfied you, you question me as much
as you want.

MISS ELLIOTT: That is the answer I wanted, because

there are some people who interpret a change of this and some of these telegrams indicated that - that is

why I think it is imperative that it be understood tis t
you still feel that as a Treasury policy we should have
this voluntary savings program, now. Of course, what

Congress will do, that, of course, is in the lap of
the gods. Nobody knows what they may do as far as

legislation is 8 ncerned.

H. M. JR: I have said that consistently, and Harold
knows, I was very hesitant to have the Kan sas City meeting I can't remember the date of that-MR. GRAVES: October 2 6.

H.M.JR: On account of what might happen, and I

wanted to be fair. I was very reluctant to have it as

far back as that, because I said, "I don't know whether

it is fair to go out and talk to these people. When
I came over to talk to the women I was reluctant because I didn't want to tell them one thing and have
something else happen.

167

- 13 -

But the only reason I got excited and angry this
morning was, I think it would be the best answer to anybody, because, damn it, I want to keep the War Savings
organization going and I get mad when I see that the

people are dissatisfied and you top people don't do
something about it.

Now, how could you get - if I didn't feel that way,

why would I get angry? If I didn't care, I wouldn't

get angry. It seems to me that my own spontaneous response this morning to what I considered was neglect
is the best answer that you get that I want to keep the

organization going. If I didn't care, I wouldn't get

angry.

Is that a good interpretation, psychologically,

or is it not?

MR. ODEGARD: I think that is very reasonable.

H.M.JR: Sincerely, I mean, if my innermost-MR. ODEGARD: Certainly, if you didn't give a dan n--

H.M.JR: If my innermost thoughts weren't that I
wanted to keep it, would I have gotten mad?
MR. ODEGARD: I shouldn't think so.

H.M.JR: And my stomach hadn't dropped, either - I
mean, that is my spontaneous answer. I don't know how
I could give you a more honest response. I don't want
the thing crumbling between my fingers.

So that is that. If you would get them all - I
don't know how they are routed - for a while everything
went to Mr. Gamble. I don't know, but certainly they
are available if they are asked for.
MR. GRAVES: I will get them.

168

-1 Alabama: J. H. Lyons (Wire answered by Marc Clement)

Absolutely opposed. Sees in this plan the destruction of the War
Savings Staff program. Advises about the same procedure as was

followed in December, 1942. (I have great admiration for Mr.

Clement. I believe he is a real liberal. He believes in the

voluntary program. On a recent trip to Alabama, I learned that
he fears the influence and power of certain financial leaders.
His opinions are worth more than the ones from Administrators who
seem merely to agree - without analysis.)
Alaska: Ernest Gruening
No reply.

Arizona: William Stuart
Received message. No comment.

Arkansas: R. G. Paschal
Yes. No analysis.
Northern California: James G. Smythe
No reply.

Southern California: Howard D. Mills
Yes. Enthusiastic.
Thinks F and G Bonds should be returned to War Savings

Staff. Needs these Bonds during interim - which
indicates that he thinks the War Savings Staff program
will be continuous.
Colorado: Ralph Nichols
Yes. Two agencies have been working as a unit.
Connecticut: Thomas Hewes

No reply.
Delaware: Donald Ross

Yes. Promises complete cooperation.

District of Columbia: H. L. Rust
No reply.

Florida: John L. Fahs
Yes. Desires that F and G Bonds be restored to the War Savings Staff.

-1 -

168

Alabama: J. H. Lyons (Wire answered by Marc Clement)

Absolutely opposed. Sees in this plan the destruction of the War
Savings Staff program. Advises about the same procedure as was

followed in December, 1942. (I have great admiration for Mr.

Clement. I believe he is a real liberal. He believes in the

voluntary program. On a recent trip to Alabama, I learned that
he fears the influence and power of certain financial leaders.

His opinions are worth more than the ones from Administrators who
seem merely to agree - without analysis.)

Alaska: Ernest Gruening
No reply.

Arizona: William Stuart
Received message. No comment.

Arkansas: R. G. Paschal

Yes. No analysis.
Northern California: James G. Smythe
No reply.

Southern California: Howard D. Mills
Yes. Enthusiastic.
Thinks F and G Bonds should be returned to War Savings

Staff. Needs these Bonds during interim - which
indicates that he thinks the War Savings Staff program
will be continuous.
Colorado: Ralph Nichols
Yes. Two agencies have been working as a unit.
Connecticut: Thomas Hewes
No reply.

Delaware: Donald Ross

Yes. Promises complete cooperation.

District of Columbia: H. L. Rust
No reply.

Florida: John L. Fahs
Yes. Desires that F and a Bonds be restored to the War Savings Staff.

169

-2Georgia: Marion Allen

Received message. No comment.

Hawaii: Fred H. Kanne

Yes. (F and G Committee out there - not a Victory Fund Committee)
Better means of communication should be worked out with them.
Idaho: John R. Viley
Yes. No analysis.

Illinois: Norman B. Collins
Yes. (Calls attention to fact that President of Federal Reserve
is not in favor.)
Indiana: Eugene C. Pulliam

Yes. Wants plan adopted for all financing for the duration.

Message seems to indicate that he is not in favor of continuous
War Savings Staff program. Payroll Savings will continue without
a War Savings Staff promotion program.

Advises that this is the opinion of the entire War Savings Staff
in the Indiana office.

Iowa: Vernon L. Clark

Will cooperate, but not in favor of plan. Believes it will kill the

Iowa state program in War Savings Staff.
Wants Victory Fund Committee and War Savings Staff both under his office.
Victory Fund Committee - sell special issues.
War Savings Staff - sell E, F and G Bonds.

(His opinion is valuable. One of the best organized states in the War
Savings Staff. It would be a great blow if voluntary savings were
discontinued. Clark and his associates have done an excellent
educational and selling job in Iowa.)

Kansas: Evan Griffith
Yes. Two agencies have been working together. Suggests AAA and
other farm organizations on the committee.
Kentucky: Ben Williamson

Yes. No analysis.

170

-Louisiana: Leon G. Tujague

Yes. No comments except willingness to cooperate.

Maine: Clinton Clauson

Yes. Will cooperate. No analysis.

Maryland: Walter Ruth

Yes. No analysis.

Massachusetts: D. J. Doherty

Will cooperate in April. Thinks it imperative to make it

clear that War Savings Staff will continue to be directed by
the State Administrators of the War Savings Staff.

Michigan: Frank N. Isbey
Yes. No analysis.
Minnesota: Arthur Reynolds
Yes. No analysis.

Mississippi: Eugene Fly
Yes. Desires E, F and G Bonds allocated to War Savings Staff.
Missouri: Dan Nee

Yes. No analysis.
Montana: W. H. Bartley

Yes. Gives approval of plan.

Nebraska: Leon J. Markham

Will cooperate. Message indicates he thinks that this is intended

as a plan to kill War Savings Staff. Critical of plan.

Does not think volunteers can or should sell special
securities. Does not think Victory Fund Committees

would sell E Bonds. Not interested. In reality, he
favors December plan.

New Hampshire: Winthrop Carter

Yes. Believes the new set-up will help War Savings Staff
Program.

171

-New Jersey: John E. Manning

Yes. No analysis.

New Mexico: Steven P. Vidal

Yes. But state should be under one Federal Reserve Bank President.
New York:

R. C. Patterson, Jr.

No comment. Recommends Walter Gifford National Sales Director.
North Carolina:

Charles H. Robertson

Yes. No comments, except preparing lists to put plan into
operation.

North Dakota: R. R. Wolfer
Yes. No analysis.
Ohio:

Roy D. Moore

No reply.
Oklahoma: H. C. Jones

Yes. No analysis.
Oregon: David Eccles

Yes. No comment except willingness to cooperate.
Pennsylvania:

Benjamin Ludlow

Rhode Island:

Roderick Pirnie
Believes in unified command. Wants a state War Finance
Committee - not regional. Opposes having Federal Reserve
Bank President direct Rhode Island (State Rights). No
conflict in Rhode Island between War Savings Staff and

Yes. No analysis except general agreement with plan.

Victory Fund Committees.

South Carolina: W. P. Bowers

Yes. Will cooperate. No analysis.

172

-5South Dakota: Charles A. Christopherson

Yes. Will cocperate. No analysis.

Tennessee: Jo Gibson, Jr.
Yes. Seems confused, since he states they will continue E Bonds
and Payroll Savings program.

Texas: Frank Scofield
No reply.
Utah: Charles Mabey

Yes. No analysis.

Vermont: Fred C. Martin

Will go along with plan. Is confused. He thinks this means
abolishing War Savings Staff program.

Virginia:

Robert F. Nelson

Yes. Two agencies have been working as a unit. In April campaign,
E Bonds should be emphasized.

Washington: Saul Haas
No reply.

West Virginia: E. R. Mowbray

Received message. No analysis.

Wisconsin: Frank Kuhl
Yes. Have been working as a unit. War Savings Staff and Victory
Fund combined.

lyoming: A. E. Wilde
No reply.

173

-ANALYSIS OF ANSWERS

A. Affirmative answers:

19 - Agree with plan, but give no indication why they agree. If

these people should hear that some people think the War Savings
Staff might be destroyed by this change in technique, I am
not sure what their answers would be.

B. Affirmative answers with reservations and comments:
4 - Agree to plan, but desire F and G Bonds given back to the War
Savings Staff.

4 - This will not change their policy, since they have united with
Victory Fund Committees in the financing work.

1 - Agrees, but wants this April plan to be permanent.
1 - Will cooperate, but believes it means the destruction of the
War Savings Staff program.

2 - Agree, but believe it will kill War Savings Staff program.
1 - Agrees, but interprets the plan to mean that the War Savings
Staff is abolished.

1 - Agrees, but thinks the Secretary should make it clear that the
War Savings Staff is to continue.
C. Negative:

1 - Absolutely opposed to plan.
D. No opinion:
2 - Simply acknowledge receiving the message.
E. No messages from:

Northern California
Connecticut
Ohio
Texas

These are very important states.
Their reasons for not answering should

Washington
Alaska
)

District of Columbia

be known.

174

-7GENERAL STATEMENT

The number agreeing without analysis is not encouraging to me. I
fear that they are yes people and have not really thought this through.
would give more weight to their statements if they had given reasons for their
I

answers.

We should not ignore the replies with reservations. These men should
be brought into Washington for a conference. For example, Mr. Clark, who has
done one of the best organizing jobs in the country, may see dangers in this
that are real. These men are nearer to the public than we are, and they know
what the effect on the morale of the people would be if suddenly they learned
that the voluntary program is dead.
I would give more consideration to the opinions of Clark and Clement
than I would to Pulliam. Clark and Clement are willing to do a hard job, and
they believe in the War Savings Staff policy. I have never thought that Pulliam

did believe in it.

I continue to think that it should be made perfectly clear to the War
Savings Staff officials in the states that the Treasury has two financing
programs--one to secure the necessary billions for war expenses, and the other
to spread the debt and to give millions of people an opportunity to assist

(according to their ability) in financing the war. Also an opportunity to

build up a reserve for the future. It should be made clear that both programs
will be continued (unless Congress kills War Savings Staff) and that this change
in technique does not mean that the Treasury plans to drop the War Savings

program. In my opinion, it will be a very easy thing to spread the fear that
the people are to be deprived of the opportunity to buy Bonds.

There is a growing feeling in the Washington staff that the War Savings
program is to be abandoned. This can be controlled if they are assured that
while it may be necessary and expedient to change the machinery of procedure,
that this does not mean that the Secretary of the Treasury desires to kill the
War Savings program.

I think it is important for us to remember that these messages have
come from men who have not had the benefit of all the discussion which has been
going on here in the Washington office.

175

February 27, 1943
11:59 a.m.

HMJr:

Hello.

Operator:

Nelson Rockefeller.

HMJr:

Hello.

Nelson

Rockefeller:

Hello, Mr. Secretary.

HMJr:

Hello, Nelson.

R:

How are you today?

HMJr:

Fine.

R:

Good. I called back to let you know that
after some very nice talks on the phone with
Mr. Welles and Mr. - and the Ambassador,
Spruille Braden

HMJr:
R:

Yes.

that we got our men off last Tuesday.

They're down in Cuba now
HMJr:

Oh, really?

R:

working on this situation, and we should
have a report for you, with the whole thing
pretty well crystallized, by early next week.

HMJr:

Oh, you sent somebody down?

R:

oh yeah, we've got two men down there; left
here Tuesday; and they've been there now three
or four days.

HMJr:

Wonderful.

R:

So that we're going to have this, and I want
you to know how much we appreciate your

HMJr:

interest and help in it.
if - if something comes out of it, you
Well, and I'11 have to take - go down there and
take the first sailboat ride.

176

-2(Laughs) Boy, and there're a lot of times when

R:

I'd like to be in a sailboat too. (Laughs)

HMJr:

Can you get the engines?

R:

Well, I think we can. We first - we've - why, I

HMJr:

Oh.

R:

Five hundred tone.

HMJr:

Well, that's good.

R:

And the Brazilians can make steam enginee

HMJr:

Oh.

hope we're going to get twenty engines of a little
heavier horse-power though than for these boats.
We're planning to build forty boats in Brazil.

R:

for twenty of them. They've got a production
capacity down there - which they will use - and
build them and use on our design but for their own
account.

HMJr:

Will these be river craft?

R:

No, they'11 be coastal boats.

HMJr:

Coastal boats.

R:

Yeah, coastal freighters that will do about ten
knots.

HMJr:

Oh, wonderful.

R:

Which isn't bad. They're pretty - pretty handy

and they can keep out of submarine danger by - by
plying along the shore.

HMJr:

Well, keep me posted, will you?

R:

You bet I will. I just wanted you to know on this
one, and - and thanks ever 80 much, and I'11 let
you know when these fellows come back. Perhaps

you'd be willing to spend a minute or two

HMJr:

I'd love to.

177

-3-

HMJr:

to get their report.
I'd love to.

R:

Okay.

HMJr:

Thank you.

R:

Thanks loads. Goodbye.

R:

178

February 27, 1943
12:00 m.

FINANCING

Present: Mr. Bell

Mr. Graves

Mr. Gambie

Mr. Buffington
Mr. Odegard

Miss Elliott

Mrs. Klotz

H.M.JR: What I want to say is this: Graves and
I had another talk, and he and I both misunderstood
what the other person wanted. He felt when I had
these people in here a week or ten days ago and told
them to go ahead by groups, that he and Buffington

would, so to speak, keep out of it.

You heard the explosion this morning, and I want
you to get the aftermath now.

He thought he was to continue letting the people
alone. That wasn't my understanding and I felt that
I couldn't understand why he didn't pick up and help
me with these people. He said he didn't understand
that that was what I wanted. I can see where he thought
that Bell was going to do this for me. So I can see
where Harold could understand that, because I didn't
specifically say, "When these people go back I want you

to continue as is."

But we understand each other now, and I have asked

Harold to feel it his responsibility, plus the assis-

tance of the rest of you; that I am looking to him in
the first instance to see that the War Savings organization gives me every possible assistance in selling these
securities in April. And Harold said he would.
(Miss Elliott entered the conference.)

179

-2H.M.JR: I will go through it again. Graves and I

had a talk since he was in here this morning, and Graves
was under the impression that when I asked him and
Buffington to leave these four districts alone when they
came here ten days ago, and let them make up their own
minds, that that order carried over and therefore he
has scrupulously not talked to any of the State chairmen,
to leave them alone to make up their own minds.
In my own mind, I was looking to him, after this
telegram went out, for suggestions to see that these

people were to be kept happy. We now understand each

other perfectly, as we always have, and following my
rule, I never let the sun set on any misunderstanding.
I had him come in here. Now I have asked Graves that

from now until the April drive is over, would he take
it as his personal responsibility, and continue to take
it as his personal responsibility, to see that the war
Savings people help me put this April drive over. He
has agreed to do it.
Have I stated it about right? Any amendments?
MR. GRAVES: No.

H.M.JR: I wanted you to get that because you got
the other. I can see where we could misunderstand each

other.

If there is anything out in the field, where anybody is sour, you will straighten them out, and so forth
and so on.

MR. GRAVES: That is right.
H.M.JR: Now, having gotten back on the track with
Graves, the same thing applies to you, George.
MR. BUFFINGTON: O.K.

H.M.JR: I don't know whether you misunderstood
me or not.

180

-3-

MR. BUFFINGTON: I didn't misunderstand. I talked
to every executive manager - not the presidents - having
the feeling that Mr. Bell was keeping in touch with them.
H.M.JR: Harold and I had an honest misunderstanding.

Now we are all right.

How about you, Peter? I mean, will you work?
MR. ODEGARD: I understood all along that the "ar
Savings organization would do everything possible to

facilitate the April drive.

H.M.JR: But how about - I want to count on you now.
MR. ODEGARD: You can always do that, Mr. Secretary.
H.M.JR:

Elliott.

and Gamble - I am not asking you, Miss

Graves has been responsible, and he is responsible,
and will continue to be responsible for the War Savings
staff to me, and you who are working with him, I hope,

do likewise. But I mean, I have had the sort of feeling I mean, there has been a sort of misunderstanding on this

thing.

Then we will go through - we get this thing, when
this man comes in - if he does come in - we expect him
in Monday, and we will get that thing straightened out

and have another talk. I don't want to bring up another
thing; one thing is enough at a time.
Now, Harold, you are all right?
MR. GRAVES: I am.

H.M.JR: Does anybody else have anything on his

mind that will keep us from all putting our shoulders

to the wheel and putting this drive over? If so, let's

have it.

181

-4MR. BUFFINGTON: Will there be an opportunity

Monday at this meeting of Fed presidents to clear in
their minds how they will work for this period of the
drive under this new leadership of this man?
H.M.JR: That is the whole thing.
MR. BUFFINGTON: Because they are all raising those

questions.

H.M.JR: Who?

MR. BUFFINGTON: How this thing is going to work

out for the combined functions of the two organizations.
H.M.JR: Well, these fellows are coming over here,
these twelve presidents, to have lunch with me Monday,

and certainly in the mind of Sproul it is straightened
out. He is at last straightened out.
MR. BUFFINGTON: I haven't talked to him.

H.M.JR: I have. I got a telegram from him. So
is Hap Young.

MR BELL: Williams, too.

H.M.JR: So they are all right.
MR. BUFFINGTON: You just said that Harold Graves

had, and would continue to work with the War Savings

Staff and report to you. How-H.M.JR: Well, that wasn't exactly - most likely

it won't be just like that.

MR. BUFFINGTON: The only reason for raising that

question, I was thinking again of the position of these-H.M.JR: It won't be like that, but I wanted to

get this thing straightened out. I mean, the office -

182

-5-

let's put it this way; whoever is attached to me - the
Office of the Secretary of the Treasury - has got to

look to somebody in the ar Savings Staff to keep them
going, and we are going to look to Harold Graves.

Now, if I take on new appendages, that is that,

but he is part of the Office of the Secretary of the

Treasury.

MR. BUFFINGTON: The only reason I bring that up -

to a man, they all say the time is getting awfully
short, and there is a lot to be done; they are getting
restless wanting to get the answer.

H.M.JR: Nobody knows it more than I. Nobody has
worked harder than I, and we will set the date Monday.

It may not be April 12. If they don't think they can
get ready April 12, we will make it April 19. There
is nothing sacred about April 12.
One of the things I will ask you (Bell) without

our doing a banking thing first, how long can we go

into April? I don't want to do that bank thing first;
I think that is bad.
MR. BELL: You do?

H.M.JR: I don't mind doing it within the drive,
but I don't want us to have a big issue outside of the

drive.

MR. BELL: The way we planned it, it will be pretty

well tied in. It will be before, but it would run
right into the drive.

H.M.JR: I will see you Monday morning? Would you be ready?

MR. BELL: Yes. What we are planning to do is to
have a meeting in my office at eleven o'clock, Monday

morning with Bob Rouse, Piser, and George Haas, to go

over the basket as to what we ought to do.

183

6-

Then we thought that you ought to have an Executive
Open
Market on
Committee
meeting Tuesday afternoon to get
their views
it.

H.M.JR: Will they be here?
MR. BELL: Yes, they are going to be here. The
Executive Committee will be here all day Tuesday. They

have their elections Tuesday morning. It is their
annual meeting.

Then after your luncheon Monday, I thought I would
take the Federal Reserve presidents at two o' 'clock and

go on for an hour; then you can take them at three, if
that is what you planned.

H.M.JR: I have got this LeRoy Smith and Henry Bruere

at three o'clock Tuesday. I can shift them around in
the morning. That is all? You won't want me Tuesday

morning? We will just shift this around.
MR. BELL: I won't--

H.M.JR: You won't need me Tuesday morning?

MR. BELL: Tuesday morning - it is Monday morning

I am going to be--

H.M.JR: But you want me to take the Open Market
Committee at three o'clock?

MR. BELL: Three-fifteen, if you can make it.
(Lt. Comdr. Stephens entered the conference.)

H.M.JR: When does that train go, if we go by train?
LT.COMDR. STEPHENS: Five-forty, sir.
H.M.JR: Do you want an Open Market meeting?

MR. BELL: I think you ought to have one.

184

-7 H.M.JR: Then it will have to be two-thirty.
MR. BELL: I am trying to get everything down so
you can make decisions on the points.
H.M.JR: This LeRoy Smith and Henry Bruere - who is
LeRoy Smith?

LT.COMDR. STEPHENS: Bruere made the call. He is

the president of the Investment Bankers, I think. I have

a note outside. I think he is affiliated with the Mutual
Banks.

MR. BUFFINGTON: Mutual Savings.

H.M.JR: Let's ask Bruere to let that go over for
a week. Tell him that I am on financing and will be in

much better shape to talk to him a week from Tuesday.
Then have the Open Market at two-thirty.

(Lt. Comdr. Stephens left the conference.)
MR. BELL: I don't know whether you want to see the
subcommittee of the ABA, which also advises you on market

securities, or not, but that could go over until you get

back.

H.M.JR: I am going out to Kansas for a breath of

fresh air.

Now, is everybody all right? I am all right. Is

everybody else all right?

MR. ODEGARD: I am a little puzzled about one thing -

Mr. Graves will be very angry if I raise it - and that
is the question of trying to resolve certain questions as

soon as possible so that the promotional material, advertising copy, posters, and so on, can go forward; we are getting closer and closer to deadlines, which we will miss.

H.M.JR: He doesn't look angry. (Laughter)

185

-8-

MR. BELL: We have also got the same thing on the

other side. we have posters and other things in the
mill which this fellow will have to make some decisions
pretty fast on, after he gets his feet under the desk.
MR. ODEGARD: I meant that, Dan, because we simply

can't operate independently as two separate organizations
on this because there is a limited amount of space,

limited amount of time, and all the rest of it.

MR. BELL: Better get together next week on it.

H.M.JR: Well, if they find, after listening Monday

and Tuesday, they haven't got time, we will postpone the

thing a couple of weeks. I don't want to.

MR. BELL: I am ready to talk to you Monday morning
any time between nine and ten if you want me to, just

to give you a picture of the financial situation. I
could do it in five minutes.

H.M.JR: You compliment me for my intelligence.

MR. BELL: No, I think it is rather simple. (Laughter)
H.M.JR: I am glad the ice is broken. We needed

a laugh around here.

MR. BELL: If it weren't simple I couldn't give it
to you in five minutes. (Laughter)
H.M.JR: Don't you people think that I haven't had

to make up my mind on more decisions the last two or
three weeks - and if I am wrong it is a hundred percent

H.M.Jr. and I realize it. Don't think I haven't weighed
these things carefully. But for better or worse, I

had to make up my mind; but I never weighed anything more

carefully, or worked harder on it.

Thanks for the laugh. (Laughter)

186

FEDERAL RESERVE OPERATIONS IN GOVERNMENT SECURITIES
Marketable issues:

Special one-day certificates 2/

Market purchases

Net increase

1/

Market sales 1/

Direct purchases
Maturities

Column 3 above price changes is 3Pade

Net decrease

free Treasury +

for all securities except certificates.

-4

For certificates Column , above

yield changes is decimals.

Last Veek

STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL

Saturday

Index

Full Week

Description

20

Monday

Tuesday

Feb 22

Wednesday

,

a

A

A

,

A

A

-81.9

+57.7

-49.7

+426.8

-36.5

-359-3

Market purchases
Market sales

-56.2

Holiday

+92.7

+234.6

+119.6

-79.1

44.4

-78.0

-62.1

-117.0

Direct purchases fres Treasury
Maturities
+3.5

+51.2

+55.4

+544.6

-60.9

-397.2

Hall1.7

Special one-day certificates:
5795.1

A

A

3

+53.2

-68.9

-22.6

Full Week

27

Marketable issues:

,

A

44.5

-67.8

+59.3

A

3

+139.6

-15.5

Saturday

26

,

A

3

25

1. Summary

+35.8

-32.0

Friday

24

+51.2

-3.)

Thursday

23

A

19

This Week

3

18

A

17

3

Friday

A

16

Thursday

3

Feb. 15

Wednesday

A

Tuesday

Montay

all.

Net change

-18.

Total set increase (+) or decrease (-).
Wednesday report of total portfolio

+13.6

+44.8

A

operations in millions of
dollars as follows:

3

Column A shows Federal Reserve

3

Page

+51.3

-68.5

5931.1

-5-5

+35.7

11. Taxable securities

+43.5

+33.8

48.5

-49.7

+139.6

-55.4

KT

+43.2

+67.7

-22.0

-32.5

-8.8

+21.2

-85.2
-5.0

-15.9

-2.0

+2.0

+4.0

-9.0
.01%

-12.5

-8.5

+.015

-272.2

+.01

+55.2

Market sales
Maturities

Total net increase (+) or decrease (-2

+89.5

*231.6

-58.4

-55.8

-35.4

-63.0

+64.0

+78.1

-14.6

+31.1

+113.6

448.4

Certificates

+10.0

+21.0

.015

C-

65%

5-1

7/8

-4.0

.01

.01%

.01

.01%

-

Market purchases

-85.2

.01%

015

Bills all issues combined

#403.1

-35.3+.01%
.02%

+.01%

+3.2

at

M-1

7/8

will.
+2.2

+160.1

+3.0

+6.2

.02%

-2.4

12-1

7/8

.02

+538.4

-265.9

as

11-1

7/8

+55.4

-53.2

2-1

+.02%

.015

>.02%

-2.4+.015

>.025

44

+.02%

Special one-day certificates
Treasury notes

3/4
-1
-1

-5.0

-5.0

-1

3-15

D-

3/4

1-1/4

-1.5

-1

-2.0

-2

14

is

12-15

1/4

-2.0

by

9-15
3-15
3-15

1-1/2

12-15

-10.2

46

-10.2

Treasury bonds
-6

-2

48-50

3-15

25

6-15 48-

1-3/4

6-15 49-51

-7

9-15 49-51
-9.0

12-15 49-51
3-15 50-52
12-15 51-55
3-15 52-54

-3

2-1/2
2-1/4

6-15 52-55
3-15 56-58

2-1/2

6-15 62-67
12-15 63-68
9-15 67-72

2-1/2
2-1/2
2-1/2

+1

-5.4

+1

-1

-1.0

-1.5
-1.0

-4.0

-2.5

-5.9

+1

-5.1

-4.8
-10.0
-2.0

-1.0

+1

-2.0

-2.0

-1.5

-6.3

-10.8

-2.1

-5.3

-10.0

-1.7

-2.6

.9

of

+1

Outrantend securities

CCC 1-1/85 2-15 45

7-15 43
4-15 44

RFC 1-1/8
RFC
-1

-1

All taxable securities
Marketable issues:
No.

+35.8
-58.7

+139.6

+59.3

+53.2

+47.7

4424.1

-67.9

-74.9

-32.5

-36.5

-325.0

Direct purchases free Treasury
-56.2

-85.2

Market purchases
Market sales

+92.1

-75.0

Maturities.

Special one-day certificates:
Net change

-6.0

-22.9

-14.5

-15.6

+20.1

+51.2

+12.5

Total not increase (+) or decrease (-).
Original figures revised.

+17.6

+113.6

48.4

+55.4

-62.6

-46.9

-90.7

-54.4

-

+60.2

+66.6

-42.2

+1.0

+103.2

-

+234.6

Office of the Secretary of the Treasury. Division of Research and Statistics
Less than $50,000.
Purchases and sales recorded as of day of transaction and not day of delivery. Transactions after 4 o'clock are included is the next day
Transactions are entered as of the day following that to which they apply. since data are not available until the following morning.
F

Note: Date are rounded and may not add to the totals.

+544.6

-329.1

187

187

FEDERAL RESERVE OPERATIONS IN GOVERNMENT SECURITIES

Page

Column A shows Federal Reserve

Market purchases 1/

operations in millions of
dollars as follows:

Column a above price changes is 32nda.

Market sales 1/
Maturities.

STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL

Last Veek
Saturday

Index

Full Week

Description

Monday

Tuesday

Wednesday

20

Feb. 22

Friday

Thursday

Saturday

Full Week

24

23

26

25

27

3

A

B

A

3

A

B

3

A

3

A

3

A

19

3

18

This Week

A

17

Friday

3

16

Thursday

A

Feb. 15

Wednesday

3

Tuesday

Monday

B

A

3

A

,

A

A

3

A

A

III. Tax-exempt securities

-1
-1

101

Treasury notes

102

-1

-2.0

-3.1

-4.5

-1
-2

-1
-2

-1

-3.9

-3.9

-1
-3

-1
-3

-1

-1
-3

-1

-1

-2

-1

-1

-1
-1

+1

5-1/4

3 103

3-1/4

2-3/4

106

2-1/2

107

-1/4

-1

-1

12-15

-1/8
4-1/L

111

is

-1.7

-11.0

3-15 46-56

-1.3

6-15 46-49
10-15 47-52

-1

-4.0

-5.3

-1

-1

12-15 47.

112

2-3/4

3113

2-1/2

$ 115

-12.7

-1

6-15 46.48

109

-5.0

-1

9-15 45-47

108
$ 110

-10.0

-5.0

4-15 44.46
12-15 44.54

3 105

-5.0

6-15 43-47
10-15 41-45

B 104

114

+1

-1

B 102

-5.0

44

bonds

1-3/89

101

3-15 48-51

9-15 4-

12-15 48-50
12-15 49-52

2

-

+2.7

-2

-1

3/4

Treasury

2

-2

6-15

9-15 44
3-15 45

106

I 107

-4.5

-1

3-15 -44
3/4

2

+2.7

# 104
N 105
,

-1.1

-8.0

-8.0

43

12-15 43

1-1/8
1

-1

-1

Holiday
-1

9-15

N 103

-2

6-15 43

1-1/89

3-1/8

+1

+1

-1

+1

-2.8

+1

-1

-2.8

+1

+1

+1

-10.5

-10.5
-6.0

*1

-6.0

+1

116

2-1/2

3 117
3 118
3 119

2-1/2

-1

+1
+1

-1

-1

-2.0

-1.0

+1

-3.0

+1

of

-1

-.5

-.5

-1

2-3/4

-.5

-1.1

-1.1

+1

-5.0

-2.5

12-15 51-53

-1.8

3 122

2-1/4

123

2-7/8

6-15 53-55
6-15 54-56
3-15 55-60

-1.2

3 124

MA

9-15 56-59

125

2-3/4

3 126

2-3/4

6-15 58-63
12-15 60-65

-1

-10.8

-4

9-15 51-55
2-1/4

$ 120

121
+1

12-15 49-53
9-15 50-52
6-15 51-54

2

+1

+1

3

+1

-1.6

-4.3

-7.7
-.5

-1.4

-1.0

-2.1

-.5

-1.5

-1.2

-2.4

-4
-.6

Quaranteed securities
-1

-2

-2

$ 101

$ 102
G 103

CCC 1/46 5-1
FFNC 1-1/4 1-15 46
44-52

$ 104

HOLC

-2

-2

$ 105

HOLD 1-1/2 x- 6-1 45-47

-1

G 106

-1

5-15 44.40

TTNC
A.

5-1

FPHA 1-3/8 2-1 44

All tax-exempt securities

-9.1

-1.0
-1.0

-7.0
-7.0

-17.2

Market purchases
Market sales

-17.2

-31.6

Total net increase (+) or decrease (-)

Office of the Secretary of the Treasury. Division of Research and Statistics.
Less than $50,000.

-4.1

-15.4

-15.3

-26.3

-6.5

-67.6

-4.1

-15.4

-15.3

-26.3

-6.5

-67.6

Maturities

r

-9.1
+2.7

-34.3

+2.7

+2.7

Original figures revised.

1/ Purchases and sales recorded as of day of transaction and not day of delivery. Transactions after 4 are included is the next day.
Note: Data are rounded and may not add to the totals.

.

m Klotz 188

THE UNDER SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY
WASHINGTON

February 27, 1943
Memorandum on Meeting of the Joint Committee
on Reduction of Non-Defense Expenditures
Thursday, February 25, 1943
-000-

Those present were Senator Byrd, Senator McKellar,
Senator Nye, Congressman Cannon and Congressman Tabor,
as members of the Committee. Mr. Lawton of the Bureau

of the Budget and Mr. Bell of the Treasury were also
present.

There was first a short executive session to
discuss the Farm Credit Administration set-up, on which
the Committee had held two hearings, and the National
Resources Planning Board, the appropriation for which
had been completely eliminated from the Independent
Offices Bill.
It was decided that the Chairman of the Committee
should draft a proposed report on the Farm Credit

Administration matter and circulate it for comment and
suggested changes to the members of the Committee.

On the National Resources Planning Board matter,
Senator McKellar asked that this Committee delay any

contemplated action as he would like to discuss it with
members of his Appropriation Committee.

Mr. Fahey and members of the Home Owners Loan
Corporation and Home Loan Bank Board representatives

appeared before the Committee. The reason for their
appearing at this time was the action taken by the House
in reducing the appropriation of the Home Owners Loan
Corporation from $12,000,000 to $8,000,000. There appears
to be a drive on by outside interests to force the Home

POR VICTORY

BUY
STATES

STAMPS

189

-2Owners Loan Corporation to liquidate by selling all
of its good mortgages to private interests. Mr. Fahey
gave testimony for approximately one hour and said that
the Corporation had originally made one million loans
valued at $3,481,000,000. They had received two million
applications for loans with a value of $6,000,000,000
so that they had really turned down about half of the
applications. On June 30, 1942 there were $1,472,000,000
in loans outstanding and on December 31, 1942 they had
780,000 accounts on their books, of which 500,000 are
being paid on schedule and 280,000 fluctuate and are
subject to some servicing. Of this last mentioned number,
about 30,000 are in foreclosure. Originally there were
about 164,000 foreclosures, valued at about $579,000,000.
There are now something less than 30,000 foreclosures,
valued at $221,000,000. 15,000 of these properties are
scattered throughout the country in war areas which are
controlled largely by O.P.A. rent ceilings and apparently
can not be sold without some understanding with the O.P.A.
authorities. 15,000 of the properties are concentrated
in the northeastern part of the United States, largely
New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, where there is
large unemployment.

Senator McKellar and Senator Byrd both seemed to

be in favor of directing the Home Owners Loan to sell
its mortgages and properties, taking any loss that might

result and getting out of the housing business. They
asked Mr. Fahey to supply for the record a great deal
of information. It seemed to me that the information
they were asking for was not the kind which would permit
the Committee to make a proper determination as to whether
we should dispose of these properties in this manner. I
therefore suggested that Mr. Fahey supply for the record
the costs of servicing the various types of property now
on his books. I assumed it would cost a great deal less
to service the 500,000 properties which are being paid
on schedule than it would to service the 280,000 which
are fluctuating; and that the 30,000 in foreclosure would
cost, per piece of property, a great deal more than any
of the others.

190

-31 also asked him to supply information as to

the amount Congress would have to appropriate to make

up deficiencies if the Corporation were authorized to
sell the 500,000 good mortgages. The Chairman authorized
him to submit that information for the record.
The Committee adjourned with the understanding
that it would have another meeting on the Home Owners
Loan Corporation as soon as Mr. Fahey had compiled the
information requested.

DWB

191

TREASURY DEPARTMENT
INTER OFFICE COMMUNICATION
DATE

TO

Secretary Morgenthau

FROM

Randolph Paul

February 27, 1943

We had another session this morning in which there was

further discussion of a plan very much resembling the

Robertson plan. The plan forgives the first bracket rate

for the period July 1, 1942 to June 30, 1943. It also has
a 10 percent discount with respect to the additional unforgiven tax. The subcommittee seems very interested in this
plan, even some of the Republican members, although no vote
was taken.

I was informed after the session this morning that the
subcommittee wished to discuss certain technical features

of withholding on Monday. There is, therefore, no objection
to my trip to Detroit on Monday to speak before the Economic

Club at noon. Before this distinguished audience of top flight
bankers I expect to take another crack at the Ruml plan very
much in the vein of the Brooklyn speech.

Ast

192

TREASURY DEPARTMENT
INTER-OFFICE COMMUNICATION
DATE

TO

FROM

Secretary Morgenthau

February 27, 1943

Randolph Paul

I have just received your message that you would
like to have sent to Cabinet members and heads of
independent agencies copy of my Brooklyn speech against

the Ruml plan. Letters are being written by my secretary

for your personal signature on Monday. The letters will
be to all Cabinet members and to the heads of the more
important independent agencies as listed in the Congressional

Directory. If there are any further persons to whom you
wish letters written this can easily be done by my office.
We are correcting one sentence on the third page of

this speech to avoid a slight criticism made in one letter
received about the speech. It is merely a matter of verbiage

but I think it better to rerun this page before sending it
to other Cabinet members. I am enclosing an additional

letter sending the new copy to Secretary Knox. If you do

not wish to send this letter forward the correction is not
too important.

All

193
FEB 27 1943

My dear Mr. Secretary:

The Treasury's position in
opposition to the Ruml plan is
stated in simple terms in the
enclosed copy of a speech given
on February 24 at Brooklyn, New
York, and I thought you might be

interested in reading it.

Sincerely yours,
(Signed) H. Morgenthau, Jr.

Secretary of the Treasury

Honorable Frank Knox

Secretary of the Navy
Washington, D. C.
Enclosure

REP:8

Copies in Diary

194
TREASURY DEPARTMENT

Washington

(The following address by Randolph E. Paul, General Counsel

for the Treasury, is scheduled to be delivered before the
Forum on World Affairs arranged by the Brooklyn Section of
the National Council of Jewish Women in the Academy of

Music, Brooklyn, N. Y., at 11:15 a. M., Eastern War Time,
Wednesday, February 24, 1943, and is for release upon

delivery at that time.)

PAY-AS-YOU-GO TAXATION

I had the opportunity of participating in your Forum a year ago,
and it was with genuine pleasure that I accepted your chairman's invi-

tation to join you again this year.

Some of you will recall that last year I discussed with you the
Government's critical need for raising $9 billion in additional taxes.
Today the Government's revenue needs are even more critical.

The reason is not far to seek. While our war effort has been
greatly intensified during the past 12 months, the strain upon our

economy has been correspondingly aggravated. Immediately after Pearl
Harbor we were spending for war at the rate of $2 billion a month.
Our war expenditures have now reached the rate of $6-1/2 billion a
month. In the next fiscal year average monthly expenditures will top

$8 billion. In early 1942 our revenue goal, as set forth by the
President, was an additional 09 billion. Today our sights are set by
the President's budget message for an additional $16 billion of collections. This increase is necessary to raise annual collections to

$50 billion. I review these figures deliberately. It is only in the
light of these urgent revenue necessities that I can intelligently
approach my subject of this morning -- pay-as-you-go taxation.

At the outset of my discussion, I want to make it clear that the
Treasury is in complete agreement with the objective of putting our
tax system on a pay-as-you-go basis. Indeed, the Treasury has been
recommending pay-as-you-go taxation for a long time. Congress has been
awake to the same need for a long time. Public interest has not lagged
far behind and has recently acquired great momentum. Today the question
is not whether we should have pay-ns-you-go taxation, but how we shall
get to such a system.

The growing interest in this subject is very natural. The income

tax' reaches ten times as many people today as it reached five years
ago, and the rates are higher than they have ever been in American
35 - 48

195

-2history. Under the existing method of income tax payment the tax for
any year is paid in four installments during the following year.
Paying in quarterly installments is obsolete for an income tax which
is imposed on millions of individuals who base their budgeting on
weekly, semi-monthly, or monthly pay checks. Paying in the year
following receipt of income is likewise obsolete when the tax is
imposed on millions of people whose incomes fluctuate violently from
one year to another, and who may have no income when the tax has to

be paid.

To meet the needs of these millions of people we need a system

which will collect income taxes bit by bit as the income is earned.

We need a system which will collect the taxes on 1943 income in 1943,

and which will to a large extent collect it out of each paycheck.
This is the heart of pay-as-you-go taxation. This is what we need to
make the income tax a more flexiblo instrument in combating inflation.
This is what the taxpayer needs to make the payment of the income tax

convenient. Host of us arc agreed up to this point. Differences of

opinion center upon the question: How can we get such a system started?

You may ask the question: Why not start the system by collecting
1943 taxes in 1943? This would mean that in 1943 we would pay taxes on
1943 income and also taxes on 1942 income. This 1/2 might do without

difficulty if rates wore lower than they are. Indeed, our pressing

revenue necessitics are a strong argument for doing so. However, it
must be recognized that many of our taxpayers failed to accumilate funds
out of 1942 income for the payment of tax on that income. The level of
rates is such that considerable hardship might result from paying in full
two years' taxes out of 1943 income, particularly in the case of those
taxpayers whose incomes will have declined in 1943.

One plausible solution that has been offered is to forgive taxes

on 1942 income. Why not let bygones be bygones, it is argued, and forget
about taxes on 1942 income? Since in 1943 an individual will be paying
a tax on his 1943. income, why require him to pay a tax as well on his
1942 income? Why not skip a year's taxes?
This solution has deceptive appeal. Most of us are human enough
to be pleased at the prospect of escaping tax on one year's income.
The appeal is deceptive because over a period of years the Government
has to raise a given amount of taxes; either the same people will have
to pay the same amounts despite the forgivoness or the forgivoness will
require that some pay more and others pay less. If we cancel a year's
taxes in getting to a pay-as-you-go system, the important-question is:

How will that affect individual taxpayers, and who will pay the additional taxes we need?

196

-3While the effect of forgiveness on an individual's tax payments is
not felt until his income declines or ceases, it has a significant

immediate effect on his economic status. The amount of taxes cancelled
represents an immediate addition to the taxpayer's wealth. This addition,
which would depend on his income in 1942, varies widely from individual

to individual. Cancellation would not improve the position of the

individual who had no income in 1942 and was not subject to tax.
A married person without dependents with a net income of $2,000 would

gain'$140 if the entire tax'were cancelled. If he had a net income of

$100,000, he would'gain $64,000. If he had a net income of $1,000,000,
he would gain $850,000.

The cancellation of taxes on 1942 income would in effect wipe out
much of the tax increases imposed to finance the war. In the case of
a person with a $2,000 net income, it would wipe out 77% of the tax
increases imposed in the last three years. At the $100,000 level, the
mount forgiven équals 102 percent of these tax increases and at the
$1,000,000 level, 320 percent.

Another way to judge the effect of cancellation on the individual's
economic status is in terms of the income he has left after taxes. This
the amount he may spend or save each year. For the individual with

$2,000 income the forgiven tax would be the equivalent of less than one
month's income. For the individual with a $100,000 income, the forgiven

tax would be the equivalent of almost two years income after taxes. In
the case of a million dollar income, the forgiveness of a year's taxes

would add to the taxpayer's wealth at one stroke as much as he could add

in nearly 6 years by saving every dollar he had left after paying taxes

and spending nothing.

Is it reasonable to suppose that certain individuals can gain

while nobody loses? Can we add to the wealth of one taxpayer the
equivalent of 6 years' income after taxes without being obliged as a
consequence to impose additional taxation on other taxpayers? I think
we all know enough about arithmetic to know that this is impossible.
When some people get something from the Government other people must

pay for it.

We can see this by turning to the question of how we can get the
additional revenue that we so badly need, if we cancel 1942 taxes.
We will, of course, have to raise income tax rates. But, it may be
asked, what difference does it make whether we raise additional revenue
by collecting the taxes we have already imposed or by cancelling these
taxes and imposing others? There are two important ways in which our

choice of method will affect the distribution of the tax burden. In
the first place, if we cancel 1942 taxes, the additional revenue will

be raised solely on the basis of the incomes of 1943 and subsequent
years without regard at all to the 1942 income. Those who had substantial

197

-4income in 1942, but who receive little or no income in 1943 and subsequent years, will contribute much less to the war costs than those
whose position is reversed. In the second place, and more important,
rates on the higher incomes are already so high that they can
scarcely be increased sufficiently to make up for the amount of 1942

tax S forgiven. The greater part of any increase in tax rates will
have to fall on taxpayers in the low and middle income groups. It is

not difficult to recover the taxes forgiven at the bottom, but it is
practically impossible to recover from the top incones the amounts
they would be forgiven.
These are the reasons why it has not been possible or the
Treasury to recommend to the Congress the complete cancellation of
taxes on 1942 incomes. It has not been possible for the Treasury
to recommond legislation which will bonefit a for at the expense of
the many.

In discussions of this problem some consideration has beon givon

to partial cancellation of 1942 taxes. In so far as such partial

cancellation bostows benefits on substantially all taxpayers, and
distributos those beno:its among taxpayors oquitably, sonc of the objections to complete cancellation do not apply. The cancolled taxes
could be replaced by increased taxation from substantially the same
individuals who benefited by cancellation. There would then be no
appreciable shift in the distribution of war tax burden.

In conclustion, lct mc rostate in exect terms the issue involved

in forgivonoss of taxes on 1942 incomes. Thoro is no issue botwcon
the Treasury and taxpayers. There is an issue betwoon different tax-

payers. It concorns their share of the tax burden. lic have to maintain
our revenues. Indood, WC are faced with the nocessity of raising additional rovonue in a timo of national poril. Should WO forgive taxos

on persons who had 1942 incomes when we shall bo obliged to increase
greatly the taxes to bo paid out of the incomes of 1943 and subsequent
'years? The decision WO mako on this question will determine to a con-

siderablo extent who will pay this increase in taxos.

198

4

TREASURY DEPARTMENT
INTER OFFICE COMMUNICATION

TO

Secretary Morgenthau

FROM

Harold Mager

Hm.

I thought you might be interested in reading the
text of the Sullivan-Vandenberg-Knutson nation-wide

broadcast Tuesday night, March 2. Here it is.

e

DATE February 27, 1943.

199

Draft of Assistant Secretary Sullivan's Introduction
Two weeks ago Secretary Morgenthau, through the

courtesy of the Columbia Broadcasting System, brought to

the microphone two of the Congress's distinguished leaders,
Congressman Robert L. Doughton, Chairman of the Ways and

Means Committee of the House of Representatives, and

Senator Walter F. George, Chairman of the Senate Finance
Committee. These eminent Congressional leaders joined

with Secretary Morgenthau to relieve the doubts and hesi-

tations that were preventing many taxpayers from filing
their income tax returns and to emphasize how urgent it

was to file returns promptly.
I am happy to report tonight that their simple and
straightforward message has had a striking effect. The
rate of tax payments in advance of the deadline on March 15th

is rapidly increasing.

200

-2-

Tonight it is my honor and privilege to bring you
two other distinguished leaders of Congress, both of them
members of the Committees in which tax legislation is
formulated: the Honorable Harold Knutson of Minnesota,
veteran member of the Ways and Means Committee of the

House of Representatives, and the Honorable Arthur H.
Vandenberg of Michigan, the ranking Republican member of
the Finance Committee of the Senate.

Politics, it is often said, ends at the water's edge.
If this was true in times gone by, it is a thousand-fold
truer today. Our country today is faced with the severest
test in its long and glorious history; our men in the armed
services, whether in the malarial swamps of Guadalcanal,

the treacherous ravines of Tunisia, or the death-laden

waters of the Atlantic and Pacific, are making sacrifices,

201

-3 often the supreme sacrifice, so that this world of ours
will eventually be a better and more decent place in

which to live. They are doing this for themselves, and

for their children; they are doing this, let us never
forget, for you and for me. Never was it so crystal
clear that the things today that really matter are the
things which bind us together, not the things which
separate us one from another. We dare not permit the

luxury of our differences, whether they be political,

religious, or racial, to interfere with the unity, cooperation, -and closing of ranks our fundamental Americanism
demands.

I know that the distinguished gentlemen who have

kindly consented to share this program with me feel the
same way as I do. It gives me great pleasure to introduce

202

-4to you Congressman Harold Knutson, who speaks at the

request of the Honorable Allen T. Treadway, the ranking
minority member of the Ways and Means Committee.
MR. KNUTSON:

203

Draft of Congressman Knutson's Speech

I am happy to speak to you tonight at the invitation
of Assistant Secretary Sullivan. I want you to know too
that I share the views he so eloquently expressed as to our
fundamental Americanism. I would go even further, however.

After all it is not only our Americanism which unites
us today in common brotherhood. It is also our common

humanity, our will to live and let live, our burning desire
to enjoy the comforts and blessings of liberty in common

with all the peoples of the earth. It is this which sets
us off from our enemies. They have enslaved their own unhappy

people as a prelude to the enslavement of the rest of the

world. We, however, will bring liberation and comfort to
the peoples of Europe and Asia and Africa precisely because

we struggle for our own freedom, our own liberty, our own

way of life. Our loss is their loss; and our gain, their
gain.

204

-2And here I would like to emphasize a fact that is
sometimes forgotten. This business of winning the war and

establishing a world in which men can live and prosper in

peace and security is not any one man's responsibility; it

is not even the responsibility of Congress. It is the responsibility of 135 million Americans. It is the American
people, acting through their representatives in Congress,
who pledged the nation's resources to the business of winning

the war. The task of the Government today is to convert
this expression of purpose into an expression of fact.
One of the methods by which the Government gives blood

and flesh to the people's determination to win is taxes.
Through taxes -- taxes to beat the Axis -- we will keep faith
with ourselves and, more important, with the men on the farflung fighting fronts of the world to whom we owe so much.

205

-3Taxes this year, to be sure, are much heavier than they

were a few years ago. They are trivial, however, in comparison to the sacrifices others are making in our behalf,
and to the sacrifices that would be imposed upon us if -God forbid! -- we ever lost the war.
Congress is at present engaged in working out some
method of tax payment more convenient to the taxpayer -- some
form of pay-as-you-earn. No plan that Congress may adopt

will alter in any way, however, your obligation to file a
return and make a first quarterly payment on or before
March 15th.

When a more convenient method of collection has been

agreed upon, Congress then will have the task of raising

additional revenues for the prosecution of the war. With tax

rates what they are, it isn't going to be easy -- neither for

206

-4Congress nor for the people as a whole. But of this I am
certain. No sacrifices we will be called on to make here
at home can begin to compare with those our brothers are
making day in and day out for you and me.

D-1

e

207
ASST. SECRETARY SULLIVAN:

Thank you, Mr. Knutson.

It gives me great pleasure to introduce Senator
Arthur H. Vandenberg of Michigan, the ranking Republican
member of the Senate Finance Committee. No higher tribute

to Senator Vandenberg can be paid than that during his
long service on the Finance Committee of the Senate he has

always considered revenue proposals on their merits with

the best interests of the country always in mind.
SENATOR VANDENBERG:

D-1

208

Draft of Senator Vandenberg's Speech
Congressman Knutson and Assistant Secretary Sullivan

have referred movingly to the things we share in common
as Americans. I could add many others, but the mere
catalogue would consume more than the radio time allotted

to me this evening. I would like to stress, however, one
of the things we share in common -- the burden of paying
for the war.
This war has often been described as "total war. "

If that term has any meaning at all it is simply this.
It means that all our resources in men, machines, and

materials above what is required to maintain essential
civilian needs must be devoted to waging war. It means

that in 1943, and until the war is over, more than one-half
of everything we as a nation can produce must be devoted
to waging war.

0-1

209

-2This is a far cry from the wars of long ago. Wars

then were luxuries of the leisure class -- the vocation
of kings and aristocrats who could find nothing better
to do. Very often they caused hardly a ripple on the
surface of society, hardly any change in the humdrum
routine of the average man and woman.

War today, however, is not a diversion for the few.
It is a tragedy which lays its heavy hand on the many.
Wars are no longer waged with only what a nation can spare.

It is waged with everything that a nation has got.
The men and women in the armed forces are giving all

they have. Are you?

Not until you put your dollars to work. Not until
you make your dollars fighting dollars. Only then can
the country engage effectively in total war; only then can

210

-3it provide our soldiers and sailors and marines with
the mountains of materials they need. We men and women

on the home front must be prepared not only to sacrifice
our comforts to their needs; we must be prepared also to

sacrifice our needs to their comforts.
Taxes are the best means of converting our dollars

into fighting dollars. Taxes, however, do lighten the
task of keeping the cost of living down, keeping Government

costs down, and distributing the costs of the war as
fairly and equitably as possible. Through taxes, moreover,
we can minimize the difficult problems involved in managing

the post-war debt and stimulate the revival of peace-time
industry in the post-war era.

The costs of the war are too gigantic, too intimately
bound up with our own welfare and the welfare of the nation,

211

-4-

to permit our indulgence in the luxury of illusion. We
cannot escape the fact to fight the war successfully we

must pay for it. We owe it to ourselves, we owe it to
our children and our children's children, to finance as
large a part of the costs of the war as possible by taxes
rather than by borrowing. We owe it, above all, to the
men and women of the armed services who are endangering

their lives every minute of the night and day for you and
me. By taxing more and borrowing less we will help create
an America for them richer in opportunities and achievements.
Those among you who have already filed your returns
and made your first quarterly payment on 1942 income and

those who will file returns and make the first payment
during the next two weeks should keep in mind that by so
doing you have not only mede a contribution to the winning

212

-5of the war but an important contribution to winning the
peace to come.

213

Draft of Asst. Secretary Sullivan's Conclusion
I want to thank Senator Vandenberg and Congressman

Knutson for their inspiring addresses this evening. Each
in his own way has emphasized fundamental truths about our

share in the burdens of this war we are sometimes apt to

forget. We would do well to take their remarks to heart.
I am reminded of a classic retort made by that great
and wise American, the late Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes.

One of his young law secretaries, fresh out of law school,
once asked the celebrated Supreme Court Justice, "Don't you
hate to pay taxes?" "No, young man," answered Justice Holmes,

"I do not. With taxes I buy civilization."
These are words to ponder over. True yesterday, they

are a thousand times truer today. With taxes we are buying
.

civilization. With taxes we are insuring that Hitler's
revolt against civilization will never succeed; and with

214

-2taxes we are protecting all that is sacred and dear in our
own way of life.
The payment of taxes in one form or another is a

universally accepted obligation of citizenship. A few years
ago the payment of personal income taxes, as Secretary
Morgenthau pointed out over this network two weeks ago, was

an obligation of the few; today it is a privilege of the
many.

With 35 million of our people paying income tax this

year it is important that a more efficient and convenient
machinery for collection be instituted. Congress is now
working day and night on that problem. You have the assur-

ance of the Treasury that nothing will be left undone to
inaugurate some form of pay-as-you-earn at the earliest
possible moment.

215

-3Meanwhile, income tax returns on 1942 income must be

filed and the first quarterly payment made on or before
March 15th. There is no longer any excuse for delay; there

is no longer any time for delay. And there should be no

desire for delay. The sooner you act the better for you
and your Government. Please file your return and make

at least your first quarterly payment as soon as you can -tomorrow, if possible.

-00o-

216

February 27, 1943

Secretary Germann Morgenthau's introduction

to captured German war film ma de for

Office of Strategic Services.

217

2/27/43

your

March 15th is income tax
day. Your tax money 18 buying guns
to match the guns of our enemies.
Captured enemy newsreels show us what

these new Nazi guns are like. Many
of these have been destroyed. But
the Germans are making more--and

we'll make still more with your tax
money.

high

n

218

TREASURY DEPARTMENT
INTER OFFICE COMMUNICATION
DATE
TO

Secretary Morgenthau

FROM

Frances McCathran

February 27, 1943

CONTROVERSIAL ISSUES BEFORE CONGRESS

1. Tax: Pay-As-You-Go - The Ways and Means Subcommittee appears

to be awaiting the return of Representative Doughton
expected next week from the Naval Hospital, to break a

deadlock between Republicans Reed and Knutson and antiAdministration Democrat Disney on one side, and proAdministration Democrats Cooper and Dingell on the other.

The two Republicans are said to be holding out for the Ruml
plan although Disney reportedly objects to certain of the
cancellation provisions. Reports to date indicate that
the subcommittee is most likely to vote either the Robertson proposal which would forgive the normal and first
surtax on 1942 taxes or Knutson's plan of withholding 1943
taxes immediately and thinking about 1942 taxes, like
Scarlett O'Hara, "some other day", specifically when the
general Revenue Bill is considered.

2. Deficiency Appropriations Bill - Without reinstating funds
for WMC McNutt (for the U.S. Employment Service) or for
Secretary of Labor Perkins (to be used chiefly to "cure"
absenteeism in war plants), the House passed yesterday a
Deficiency Appropriations Bill of more than six billion
dollars. It added $250,000 asked by Chairman Clarence
Cannon of the Appropriations Committee for salaries which
were termed an "immediate necessity", for the Treasury
Department. However, attempts to reinsert funds providing

for day care of children in industrial centers (WMC) and
Federal aid for the families of enlisted men (Dept. Labor)
failed again on the floor of the House as they had in the
Committee.

3. Wickard - Secretary of Agriculture Wickard continued to
receive the lion's share of criticism from Congress yesterday. In a Senate Agriculture Subcommittee, he was
accused of underestimating the seriousness of the food
situation specifically in acreage reduction figures which
varied from those obtained by the Subcommittee, and in

219

WMC McNutt's claim that Wickard had confused him with

misleading forecasts on food production. Meanwhile, a

formal report by the House Small Business Committee declared
that the OPA and the Secretary of Agriculture had displayed

"a regrettable lack of joint effort to correct conditions
"resulting in the worst black market in meats" in the Nation's history and subjecting "the population to the risk

of eating diseased meat" The Secretary himself, testifying before the House Agriculture Committee, heard various
members air their grievences on the farm labor and price
situations. But despite his argument that revision of
parity would equal inflation, another committee, the House
Banking and Currency, yesterday reported favorably the
Steagall Bill to include incentive, conservation and all
benefit payments in parity computations, and the Brown
Bill to include all farm labor costs in price ceilings
(similar to the Pace Bill reported by the House Agriculture
Committee). Furthermore, as if in answer to Wickard's
request for a "clear mandate" from Congress on his food

production program, a seven-member board, representative of

the farm bloc, will formulate a Congressional policy on
the farm issues, which will obviously be much at variance
with the "mandate" desired by the Agriculture Secretary.

4. McKellar Bill - Senator O'Mahoney yesterday submitted to
the Senate Judiciary Committee a substitute measure which
would require Senate confirmation of Federal appointments
paying $4,500 or over only if they were "policy-making"
or were made without regard for the Civil Service laws.

Certain policy-forming officials paid from the "appropriation for the White House Office in the Executive Office of
the President" would be excluded, however, because O'Mahoney
said he believed the "President should have the right to
select those around him without having to win the Senate's
approval" According to an editorial in this morning's
Washington Post, the McKellar Bill itself is merely 'an
obvious grab for power" on the part of its author to control the TVA, through approving its appointments, which is
centered in his home state.

220

COPY

February 27, 1943

My dear Mr. President:
In accordance with your memorandum of November 17. 1942,

I am writing you with respect to the Department's desire to
request occupational deferment under the Selective Training
and Service Act of 1940, for a period of six months for
John Wesley Lindow, Principal Economic Analyst, in the Division
of Research and Statistics in the Treasury Department.
Mr. Lindow is thirty-two years of age and is married.
Mr. Lindow has a major responsibility in working out
methods for financing the war and assisting in the planning
of Treasury borrowing operations and the designing of
specific securities. Government borrowings on the scale now
required must be planned with careful regard to their relation
to the economy as a whole and particularly their effect in
minimizing pressure on prices. Mr. Lindow's eight years of
experience in Treasury financing operations make him especially
valuable in the work on war financing. The only adequate
training for a replacement for this work is a number of years
of experience. Under wartime conditions of draft and labor
turnover, it has been impossible to keep qualified personnel
in subordinate positions long enough to train them to take
over the more responsible work. Efforts to secure a person
with the requisite qualifications to take over Mr. Lindow's
responsibilities therefore have not been successful, and the

loss of his services at this time would seriously impair this
part of the Department's work on the war program.

It is respectfully requested that approval be given for
occupational deferment in this case.

Faithfully,
/s/ H. Morgenthau, Jr.
Secretary of the Treasury

The President
The White House

Sent by SSAgent 12:28 2/27/43

221

FEB 27 1943

Dear Jesse:

I have for acknowledgment your letter of February 20,

1943, having further reference to the leasing of the
Empire Hotel Building in San Francisco.

One factor which has brought about some misunder-

standing in the above connection arises through the fact
that when my representatives first surveyed the city of
San Francisco for a suitable location for Treasury
activity they had in mind using the entire Empire Hotel
Building for Treasury purposes only. This plan was
changed by the War Department, who not only desired to

remain in the Empire Hotel in 18,000 square feet then
being used by then, but insisted on expanding their

activity in this location to the point where they are

now using 48,000 square feet, necessitating our holding
considerable commercial space outside of this building.
The Treasury desires to be as helpful as possible
in arriving at a workable arrangement which will be
satisfactory to the RFC Mortgage Company and will undertake immediate steps to have the Public Buildings Administration proceed with leases agreeable to all concerned.
Sincerely yours,
(Signed) Henry

Honorable Jesse Jones,
The Secretary of Commerce.

Photo file in Diary
CSB,
2-26-43

File to Thompson

THE SECRETARY OF COMMERCE
WASHINGTON

February 20, 1943
Dear Henry:

I have your letter of even date relative to the
Hotel Empire lease, and note your suggestion that the matter
be negotiated with Public Buildings Administration instead

of your Department.

Your letter to us dated July 14, 1942, to which you
refer, related only to eventual purchase of the building by
Public Buildings Administration, and not to the lease. Our
confirmed understanding with Mr. Bell and Mr. Berney has been
that your Department would lease the building directly, and
thereafter perhaps assign the lease to Public Buildings Administration for servicing. Last November we prepared the
leases in regular government form and transmitted them to Mr.

Bell for signature. A copy of the transmittal letter is
attached.

Since that time we have made no progress, which

prompted my letter to you. We do not object to having these
leases signed by Public Buildings Administration, if you now

desire, but feel that since we are acting in this transaction
solely for your accommodation and upon your assurances for

payment of a satisfactory rental that the necessary arrange-

ments should be made by your Department.

Sincerely yours,

Secretary of Commerce
VICTORY

Honorable Henry Morgenthau

BUY

Secretary of the Treasury

WAR

Washington, D. C.

BONDS
STAMPS

Enclosure

223

COPY NO. 13
NOT TO BE RE-TRANSMITTED

BRITISH MOST SECRET.
U.S. SECRET.

OPTEL No. 66.

Information received up to 7 A.M. 27th February,
1943.

1. NAVAL.

At 9.45 a.m. yesterday a U.S. Liberator sighted an
inward bound blockade runner when 500 miles West South

West of Cape Finisterre, she was shadowed by aircraft till
4 p.m. when one of H.M.cruisers sank her by gun fire.
The ship was an 8,000 ton tanker and 4 lifeboats were seen
to leave her. A convoy to No th Russia of 22 ships due
at Kola Inlet today was unsuccessfully bombed by enemy

aircraft yesterday. A Norwegian submarine is overdue from
patrol off the Norwegian coast and must be presumed lost.
2. MILITARY.

TUNISIA. 25th. 8th Army. Our troops advanced to
positions about 6 miles East of Mareth without meeting
opposition.

First Army. An attack started at 6 a.m. by U.K.
Armoured Brigade and U.S. armoured troops cleared the

Kasserine Pass by evening in spite of delay by mines and

Artillery. Our patrols pushed forward towards Kasserine
town and Feriana.

RUSSIA. South East of Lake Ilmen the Russians appear

to be increasing their pressure and extending their front
and in heavy fighting have made some progress both North
and South of Orel. The Germans claim considerable success

with their counter attacks in the Donets sector, they report
a thaw an the Tagenrog area and continued thaw in the Taman
sector.
3. AIR OPERATIONS.

WESTERN FRONT. 25th/26th. Nuremburg. All bombers
-1-

223

COPY NO.

13

NOT TO BE RE-TRAISMITYED
BRITISH MOST SECRET.
U.S. SECRET.

OPTEL No. 66.

Information received up to 7 A.M. 27th February,
1943.

1. NAVAL.

At 9.45 a.m. yesterday a U.S. Liberator sighted an
inward bound blockade runner when 500 miles West South

West of Cape Finisterre, she was shadowed by aircraft till
4 p.m. when one of H.M.cruisers sank her by gun fire.
The ship was an 8,000 ton tanker and 4 lifeboats were seen
to leave her. A convoy to No th Russia of 22 ships due
at Kola Inlet today was unsuccessfully bombed by enemy

aircraft yesterday. A Norwegian submarine is overdue from
patrol off the Norwegian coast and must be presumed lost.
2. MILITARY.

TUNISIA. 25th. 8th Army. Our troops advanced to
positions about 6 miles East of Mareth without meeting
opposition.

First Army. An attack started at 6 a.m. by U.K.
Armoured Brigade and U.S. &armoured troops cleared the

Kasserine Pass by evening in spite of delay by mines and

Artillery. Our patrols pushed forward towards Kasserine
town and Feriana.

RUSSIA. South East of Lake Ilmen the Russians appear

to be increasing their pressure and extending their front
and in heavy fighting have made some progress both North
and South of Orel. The Germans claim considerable success

with their counter attacks in the Donets sector, they report
a thaw in the Tagenrog area and continued thaw in the Taman
sector.
3. AIR OPERATIONS.

WESTERN FRONT. 25th/26th. Nuremburg. All bombers
-1-

223-A

heavy 724 tons were drooped in about equal proportion
H.E. and incendiary including 4 8000-pound and 135

4000 pound bombs. Weather cloudless but identification
hampered by ground haze and smoke which increased

during attack. Target indicators well placed by
Pathfinders and concentrated attack lasted 45 minutes.
Many good fires taking hold and spreading well. Many

crews reported terrific explosion in built up area.
Moderate defence lessened as attack progressed.
26th. Wilhalmshaven was bombed by 69 U.S. heavy

bombers and preliminary reports indicate good results.
34 escorted Venturas attacked an energy raider in dock
at Dunkirk. Several bcmbs straddled the dock and one
near miss was seen by the stern. 12 Mosquitos made an

effective low level attack on the naval storage depot
near Rennes. Many flashes probably from exploding
ammunition were seen. 6 Whirlwind bombers attacked

Maupertus airfield. From above operations, 7 U.S.
bombers, 3 Mosquitos and 2 Spitfires missing. Enemy

casualties 1, 2, 3. 13 enemy aircraft crossed the South
Coast. Bombs were dropped at Exmouth and a gasholder was

set on fire. 11 persons were killed, typhons destroyed
3 and damaged 1 enemy aircraft.

26th/27th. 461 aircraft sent out - Cologne 428
(10 missing), Aachen 2, sea mining 21, leaflets 4,
Intruders 6. At Cologne visibility was good with no oloud
but a slight ground haze, Attack was well concentrated,
Of 6 enemy aircraft operating in the Thames Estuary 2
were destroyed by a Beaufighter.
TUNISIA. Objectives near Gabes were attacked on

24th/25th by 21 bombers and on 25th by 70 escorted fighter
bombers. Escorted U.S. Fortresses attacked Bizerta. Enemy

casualties 25th. 4, 2, 9, Allied 4, Nil, 1.
-2-

224

MEDITERIANEAN. 24th/25th. A convoy of 1

7,000-ton and 1 5,500-ton ship with 3 destroyers was
attacked off North West Sicily by 6 Beaufighters and

7 Wellingtons from Malta. Larger ship hit by 2 torpedoes
and sunk, smaller hit by torpedoes and believed sunk.
One larger destroyer attached by torpedo and large
smoke column seen.

ITALY. 24th/25th. 6 U.S. Liberators attacked
Naples.

225

NOT TO BE RE-TRANSMITTED
COPY NO.

13

BRITISH MOST SECRET
U.S. SECRET

OPTEL No. 67

Information received up to 7 A.M., 28th February, 1943.
1. NAVAL

One of H.M. Trawlers sunk by E-boats during attack on a channel con-

voy off LYME BAY 26th/27th. Last night our light forces attacked a large south-

bound ship off the Dutch Coast. One of our motor gun boats was sunk and another set

on fire. No further details yet available. The armed raider recently located in

DUNKIRK was sighted off the Dutch coast morning 27th steering north. A Russian

warship has sunk an enemy destroyer in the BARENTS SEA.

SOUTH
AFRICA. rescued.
27th. A Dutch submarine depot ship torpedoed and sunk
off East London.
377 survivors
2. MILITARY

TUNISIA. 26th. In Northern TUNISIA E series of small enemy attacks

with infantry and tanks in the SIDI NZIR BOU ARADA and DJEBEL MANSOUR areas were

repulsed. Enemy seemed disinclined to press his attacks and withdrew after

suffering casualties and some losses in tanks and prisoners. Fighting still continues in the MATEUR BEJA Valley.

RUSSIA The Russiane continue to attack in the LAKE ILMEN area and
have mounted a series of local attacks against the western face of the RZHEV
Salient. Heavy fighting continues north nd south of OREL. In the DONETS Bend the
Germans claim to be counter attacking with success near IZYUM.
3. AIR OPERATIONS

WESTERN FRONT. 26th/27th. COLOGNE. Aircraft attacked dropping 1014
tons of bombs (compare 1516 tons dropped in "1.000 bomber" raid last May). Five
8,000 pound and 141 thousand pound. Weather good, no cloud, good visibility but
thick ground haze. Bombing somewhat scattered at first but concentration obtained

later. Many fires including two large ones and many reports of large explosions
in centre of town. Considerable searchlight activity, moderate A.A., few fighters.
27th. 62 U.S. heavy bombers attacked the port area at BREST. Bursts
were seen in the target area; as a diversion five Whirlwind bombers attacked MAUPER-I
TUS airfield. 24 Venturas dropped 26 tons of bombs on DUNKIRK docks hitting a small

ship. 18 squadrons of Spitfires provided escort and cover for these operations.
Enemy casualties 2, 1, 2. We lost 4 Spitfires. 27th/28th. 102 aircraft despatched:

sea mining 91 (one missing) RUHR 6, leaflets 2, Intruders 3.

TUNISIA. 24th/25th. Bisleys heavily bombed GAFSA and SBEITLA.
25th/26th. Allied bombers dropped 46 tons on GABES town and landing ground and
heavily attacked enemy positions in the MARETH area. 26th. A total of about 200
escorted fighter bombers of Western Desert Air Force attacked landing grounds and

other targets at GABES and in this locality. Enemy casualties 26th - 7, 3, 5. Ours
10, nil, 2.
SARDINIA. 20 U.S. Fortresses dropped 46 tons on CAGLIARI and on

ELMAS airfield. Bursts were seen on the docks, railway yards and airfield.
set

SICILY. 26th. U.S. bombers attacked shipping north of SICILY and

one ship on fire. 27th. 12 Fighter bombers attacked the power station and sea

plane base at SYRACUSE.