View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

The Monthly

Business Review
Covering business and industrial conditions in the Fourth Federal Reserve District

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF CLEVELAND
D. C. Wills, Chairman of the Board
VOL. I

CLEVELAND, OHIO, AUGUST 1, 1919

NO. 7

LTHOUGH our continually optim istic review o f business conditions may su bject us to the
/ ''ik
charge o f over-optim ism by our readers, the m ovem ent o f the past thirty days com pels us to
/
Ik continue such a view in this report.
The existing condition o f tw o basic branches o f industry has always been accepted as the
barom eter o f business conditions in general. T hese are steel and agriculture.
The steel barom eter has steadily been clim bing, as the unfilled tonnage o f one o f the largest steel
corporations, alone, on June 30 was 610,545 tons greater than the previous month. This tonnage w as
without the railroad dem and.
If w e are w illing to accept the statem ent that business prosperity is in proportion to the p ros­
perity o f the farm ers, then there can be little question as to a general favorable condition.
Added to this w e have the P eace Treaty sign ed; the security o f a President back in the W h ite
H ouse; restrictions lifted on exports, w ith a strong dem and from European countries, and the
financial m achinery for the extension o f their credit being assem bled. The w hole w orld is ju st b eg in ­
ning to feel at hom e with h erself again.
If other evidence be needed w e still have the fact that the per capita circulation o f m oney on
July 1 was $54.28, as com pared w ith $50.86 a year ago — an increase o f 6.7 per cent, and that
industrial and com m ercia l failures are the sm allest in num ber in 3 9 years.
However, there are blots on the business escutcheon. W h ile an abnorm al dem and w ith sub­
norm al supply necessarily means high prices, w e can see no justification for the open wave o f profit­
eering w hich has struck us. T h e constant rise in prices rem inds one o f a horse w hich was used as a
tread-horse for so lon g that through fo rce o f habit he w ould continue the m otion o f treading even
after the tread-m ill was shut off. The rise in price, for w hich there was, in m ost instances, a legiti­
mate excuse during the war, has so fixed itself that the general public continues to tolerate the now
illegitim ate rise.
T o stimulate earnings business dem ands a rapid turnover o f m oney. T o stimulate the redu c­
tion in the high cost o f food products, a rapid turnover o f such products is also necessary. T o enact
and en force laws w hich w ould com pel a reasonable and econ om ic storage o f produce w ould keep it
m oving and thereby reduce the prices.
The burden cannot all be shifted to the profiteers.
The public, in a m easure, is to blam e in
being too w illing to pay the prices w ith little com plaint.
The “ I-d o n ’t-ca re ” feelin g seem s to
be the attitude o f people o f all classes — a ten dency to let down. The feelin g o f relief w hich fo l­
low ed the term ination o f the w ar seem s to have transform ed itself first into lassitude and later into
utter indifference. W e may con cede that this is the natural reaction o f the high tension to w hich the
w orld was su bjected during the war, but it does not make for w h olesom en ess nor for national safety.
W e will, o f course, w ork our w ay out in spite o f it, but the outlook w ould be brighter if it did not
exist. The business situation cannot be w h olly sound until such an attitude is changed.
This is certainly no time for extravagance. W e have a national debt w hich am ounts to one
thousand dollars for every man in this country w h o is over 2 1 years o f age, and wealth is not created
by extravagance.




2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

As the supply o f labor continues insufficient and w ages high, there has been no low ering o f prices
to consum er. H ow ever, the gap betw en the producer, the m anufacturer, and the consum er is in many
cases far too w ide. P rice levels already reached are higher than the m axim um ones fixed by the G overn­
m ent under w ar-tim e regulations. Seem ingly, as long as the general public will continue to pay
exorbitant prices on nearly all com m odities, w ithout m aking com plaint, such unnatural levels are very
apt to be maintained.
The intrinsic value o f the Federal Reserve System is again being shown, now that the bu m per
crops throughout the District are being harvested and moved. Several years ago farm ers w ere on
the anxious seat for w eeks w henever they had large crops, w ondering ju st what the attitude o f W a ll
Street w ould be w hen they asked fo r m oney with w hich to move them.
Because o f the greatly increased cost o f farm labor, it has taken a great deal o f m oney to get
the crops into the fine condition in w hich they now are, but the farm er has been able to get all
the m oney he needed through his ow n hom e town bank. If that bank was short o f funds it w as
possible to secure them directly from the Federal Reserve Banks, or indirectly through their city
correspondents. T h e real effect o f the Federal R eserve System is to create twelve m oney centers in
as many sections o f the country, all w ork ing in close connection, so that the resources o f the w h ole
country can be m obilized fo r the purpose o f m oving crops if that is necessary.

Iron and Steel Industry Shaping Itself for a Very Active Market. Evidence fro m
all quarters show s that June definitely turned the tide in the iron and steel business. T he increase
o f 610,000 tons in the unfilled orders o f the steel corporation, as o f June 30, term inated heavy
m onthly declines since N ovem ber, 1918, and is a clear and accurate index o f the change in m arket
conditions. Independent producers have been booking business on a corresponding scale. Steel in g ot
production in June, was at the rate o f about 32,400,000 tons annually, com pared with 2 7 ,106 ,094
tons in May. This represents 71.6 per cent, o f the m onth o f highest production in history, w h ich
was O ctober, 1918, Operations have continued to increase so that they are represented today by
practically 70 to 7 5 per cent, o f in got capacity. P ig iron production show ed the first increase since
Septem ber, 1918.
A ccordin g to figures com piled by the Iron Trade Review , the output for June, a thirty-day m onth,
was 2,116,702 tons, com pared w ith 2,107,729 tons in May, a thirty-one day month.
Furnaces in
blast on July 1, w ere 200 as against 197 on June 1. Sinoe then several additional stacks have b een
blow n in.
The best buying continues to be done in lapweld tubes (representing the effect o f vigorous oil
and gas field operations) in sheets, w ire, bars, and in tin plate. Som e o f the heavier lines still are
lagging, such as plates, rails and shapes, and this can be readily accounted fo r by the abnorm ally sm all
railroad buying and the absence o f shipyard requirem ents.
T h e iron and steel industry virtually is m aking a surprising show ing in view o f the restricted
buying in these m a jor lines. Farm ing im plem ent m anufacturers are buying on increasing scale.
P ig iron sales in June w ere by far the heaviest since the arm istice. A careful com pilation shows
that the total sales w ere betw een 1,250,000 and 1,500,000 tons for last half shipment.
T he June sales w ere made up largely o f m alleable and foundry grades.
S teel-m ak in g
iron transactions have rem ained singularly few . W ith increased steel w orks operations, h ow ever,
these are expected to com e along m ore briskly. Som e buying o f iron for 1920 delivery is being done in
scattered cases, but furnacem en generally are not disposed to encourage future com m itm ents at this tim e.
R eports from the Pittsburgh district show that conditions are steadily im proving and it is an
assured fact that a distinct gain has been made. Mills in the District are operating at approxim ately
70 per cent, o f capacity. T h e payroll o f one o f the large independent mills has increased 33% per
cent, since our last Review, and is now within 20 per cent, o f the peak during the w ar period.
Collections fo r June w ere
than fo r the m onth o f May. It
senting material furnished to
still; and due to the reduction




a happy surprise, and a larger per cent was collected on the same basis
m ust be taken into consideration that very substantial accounts, repre­
the equipm ent com panies fo r railway cars, stood virtually at a stand­
in the dollar and cent valuation o f the shipm ents these outstandings

3

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

naturally represent a continuously increasing percentage o f the total. Confidence is expressed that
w hen the m ajority o f the Governm ent claim s are settled the situation w ill be a very satisfactory one.
Tin plate industries report that their business is rounding out into som ething like norm al stride,
and that mill operations are now on the heaviest scale since early last fall. A bout 80 per cent, capa­
city is claim ed, w hich show s a steady increase.
A large dom estic dem and for w ire products, including bolts, rivets, and chains, maintains a co m ­
fortable position for the w ire rod market. A g ood export dem and is also found fo r all classes o f
sem i-finished steel. Export orders fo r w ire nails are large. Dem ands for pipe in con n ection w ith the
oil boom are reported enorm ous, and plants are daily falling behind. Demand fo r eigh t-in ch pipe is
reported beyond all precedent. Orders for new business are being scaled dow n to 50 per cent.
Demand for structural steel continues to im prove.
trade is still som ew hat spotty.

Som e large bookings are reported, but the

The industry in general is m oving forw ard under favorable conditions, and shaping itself for a
very active market. T h ere is a m arked increase o f buying for export trade as shipping rates are now
getting m ore in line, and there is a steady im provem ent in the outlook for necessary credit abroad.
In a special study o f the ore tonnage carried b y the Great Lakes fleet, it is found that shipm ents
o f ore for the 1919 season w ill show quite a drop com pared with those o f 1918. During the 1918
period, the m ines in the Lake Superior district sent forw ard 61,156,732 tons o f ore by lake. That
the m ovem ent for this season w ill show a loss o f 1 0 , 0 0 0 , 0 0 0 tons is quite certain, and som e ship­
pers say that shipm ents w ill not reach the 50,000,000 ton margin. A loss o f 10,000,000 tons this
season com pared with 1918 w ou ld make the m ovem ent a little m ore than 51,000,000 tons, and in
order to reach that m ark the fleet w ou ld have to handle only 8,000,000 tons fo r July, August, Septem ­
ber and O ctober, and 3,000,000 tons in N ovem ber.
Shipm ents fo r that period last season w ere
10,659,203 tons in July; 9,725,331 tons in A ugust; 8,995,014 tons in S ep tem ber; 8,541,593 tons in
O ctober and 4,279,025 tons in N ovem ber.
The above figures indicate that if the m ovem ent does not exceed 51,000,000 tons the fleet and
docks can handle this business w ithout difficulty.
No m atter how heavy the late grain m ovem ent is, if furnacem en put off placing orders too long,
and try to get a supply o f ore the last tw o m onths, a car shortage is looked fo r ; and if it com es, the
m ovem ent w ill slow up all along the line. Ore shipm ents up to July 1 w ere 16,008,419 tons, w hich
was a decrease o f 2,941,311 tons com pared with the same period last season.
T h e m ovem ent fo r
July w ill show a big loss com pared w ith July, 1918.
That shipm ents up to A ugust 1 w ill be 5,000,000 tons behind last season for the same period is
alm ost certain, and that w ill be about half the estim ated loss in the m ovem ent fo r the season.
The outlook is im proving steadily and ore shippers figure that w ith the dem and fo r iron and
steel in all lines, furnacem en w ill not take the ch an ce o f g oin g into the closed season with short
supplies.

Manufacturing Gradually Regaining Pre-War Levels. M anufacturers o f screw m a­
chinery products in Cleveland report that business is not yet back on a pre-w a r basis, but rapidly
approaching it. Makers o f foundry m achinery rep ort a large volum e o f business w ith orders book ed
for several m onths ahead.
Autom obile m anufacturers say that p rod u ction is expected to reach a norm al output in the very
near future. W h ile business in this industry is reported satisfactory, yet com paratively few con cern s
have regained the p re-w ar basis. One large au tom obile m anufacturer reports that conditions in his
plant are far ahead o f the highest level reached b e fo r e the war.
T h ey have taken on hundreds o f
additional men since the signing o f the arm istic, and report a large volum e o f business.
In the chem ical m anufacturing industry the volu m e o f business is reported
ow ing to labor unrest and strikes, the situation is far below the peace-tim e basis.

satisfactory,

but,

Makers o f paints and varnishes can w ell take an optim istic view. W ith the increase in bu ild­
ing activity m anufacturers o f these products are experien cin g a very satisfactory volum e o f business




THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

4

and m uch buying w ill have to be done to cope w ith the new business anticipated up to the end o f the
year. V ery little labor unrest is noted in this industry, as these m anufacturers have been able to keep
their labor satisfied.
Generally speaking, it is thought m anufacturing conditions w ill soon regain the level maintained
b efore the war. The labor condition is som ew hat uncertain, as a great many plants report a co n ­
tinual dissatisfaction am ong the men, w hich in som e cases is difficult to analyze. Probably the high
cost o f living is responsible fo r a great deal o f this. W h ile there is little m anufacturing in the L ex­
ington district yet these few concerns are w ork in g full tim e and are behind in their orders.
M anufacturing in Pittsburgh is running 60 p er cent, o f capacity. Electrical supplies m aintained
a satisfactory volum e fo r June, w ith considerable increase over that o f April and May. T he continued
inquiries w ould indicate offerings o f considerable new business.
C ollections are good, w ith a decrease in the offering o f paper, w hich is a good sign.
Orders in the b oiler and radiator business are plentiful, but prices have been badly dem oralized.
Erie reports m ore orders than thirty days ago. The foundry business, w hich is the principal
industry, is m ore optim istic.
B oiler and engine m anufacturers are receiving orders from foreig n
countries and are m aking a special drive for this business. Men in the shops w ho, a few m onths ago,
w ere w ork in g three and fou r days a w eek, are n ow putting in practically full tim e, and there is very
little pessim ism , although m uch dissatisfaction is being show n on account o f the unreasonable cost o f
living.
Cincinnati reports that, broadly speaking, there has been som e im provem ent in m anufacturing
conditions. Orders are com in g in m ore satisfactorily, but prices are rising and in som e instances these
changes are very marked. For exam ple, copper and brass goods, soaps and shoes, show recen t
advances w hich are very pronounced. W a g es are firm and show n, a tendency to increase.

Wheat a Disappointment; Farm Labor Scarce.
A big surprise in the agriculture
report fo r this m onth is the unexpected condition o f the w heat berry. W h ile there w ill be an u n pre­
cedented yield, the results being revealed by the threshing-m achine are not w hat w ere expected.
T he yield per acre is far out o f proportion to the am ount o f straw.
In many places the berry is
shriveled and not w ell filled. Apparently the frosts in spring and the extrem ely hot w eather in June
proved harm ful.
The Cincinnati A rea reports about th ree-fou rth s o f an average crop, with the best grain running
from 49 to 55 pounds against a norm al o f 58 pounds a bushel. An interesting feature is that the
quality o f the grain grow n on p oorer ground is averaging better than that grow n on good soil.
P robably little grain threshed w ill grade No. 1, m ost o f the w heat being o f the second and third
grades. A disappointm ent fo r the farm er lies in the fact that in order to obtain the guaranteed price
o f $2.26 a bushel, his grain m ust make a No. 1 grade test. Three cents w ill be deducted on each
bushel grading No. 2 ; seven cents w ill be deducted on all wheat o f No. 3 grade, w hile that grading
below No. 3 w ill be bou gh t on its m erits at prices that w ill reflect its com m ercial value as com pared
w ith grade No. 1.
In m ost instances the binder was able to pick up the fallen wheat, and w herever this was im p os­
sible, hogs have been turned into the fields and fattened upon that w hich w ould otherw ise have been
w asted.
A nother disquieting feature in the life o f the farm er is the shortage o f labor. The heavy rains o f
May delayed them to such an extent that they have not been able to catch up; how ever, they are re ­
doubling their efforts and w ill no doubt be able to take care o f their crops.
W h a t farm labor is obtainable is only at such prices that the farm er is gradually tending tow ard
a “ on e-m an ” farm , or is undertaking only what he and his fam ily w ill be able to handle w ith occasional
outside help. This seem ingly continuing condition is causing the farm er to turn m ore and m ore to
m echanical means fo r re lie f and m eet the labor shortage by the introduction o f m otor pow er. T he
farm tractor com panies report few sales in the District, there being a feeling am ong the farm ers that
farm tractors w ill be reduced in price. A disposition is also noted to let m anufacturers do a little m ore
experim enting b e fo re placing their orders. The buying o f other farm m achinery is quite active.
Many farm ers in the D istrict are installing indiyujuad lighting system s.




THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

5

A hopefu l agricultural sign is that the farm ers are getting together to study the cost o f p rod u c­
tion. A nother is the interest being taken in tile drainage.
This w ill enable the farm er to obtain
greater production per acre, reduce the acreage if necessary, and result in m ore intensive farm ing.
E arly-sow n oats have grow n very rank, and in many cases have lod g ed ; but the late-sow n crop,
due to insufficient m oisture, has made a very short grow th. Corn, generally, is grow in g rapidly; its
appearance is healthy and present indications point to a norm al yield.
One o f the im portant crops o f the Ohio valley is tobacco. A Cincinnati paper has ju s t published
an annual forecast o f crop conditions, w hich shows an increased acreage o f 17,000, w ith an estim ated
yield increase o f 20,000,000 o f Burley tobacco. The dark tob a cco section o f K entucky prom ises
22,000,000 pounds m ore than in 1918. This is an im portant matter with the Cincinnati bankers, as
upon them falls the bulk o f financing this great crop, valued at approxim ately a quarter-billion
dollars.
Reports from the K entucky section list the crop conditions as fo llo w s : Oats, 89 per cen t; Burley
tobacco, 80 per cen t; dark tobacco, 81 per cen t; clover, 93 per cen t; orchard grass, 93 per cen t; blue
grass, 95 per cen t; cow -pea s, 82 per cen t; alfalfa acreage, 99 per cen t; garden conditions, 87 per cen t;
potatoes, 87 per cent, with fruits sh ow in g a short crop.
Many o f the tob a cco grow ers in Southern Ohio are still carrying in their barns last year’ s crop
o f what is know n as the Spanish and Dutch leaves.
The fruit situation is quite disappointing. The June drop has greatly reduced the crop prospects
o f both peaches and apples. This condition has also affected the grapes, in that the clusters contain
a sm aller num ber o f berries than they should. W e now have a condition o f large, open clusters,
w hich may be som ew hat com pensated fo r in the larger berries w hich w ill be produced.
P rices on
grapes will be higher than ever b efore, ranging in price from $120 to $140 a ton. T h ey have been
sold in the past as low as $ 2 0 a ton.
The developm ent o f agriculture is very largely dependent upon road conditions. There is m uch
road building in progress, but prices fo r road w ork are becom in g prohibitive. An e ig h teen -foot road
at from forty to sixty thousand dollars a m ile frightens nearly everyone. T h e material w h ich enters
into road construction has advanced in price from 150 to 500 per cent.

Warnings of Coal Shortage Are Becoming Louder.
“ BUY N O W ” is the keynote o f
the coal situation. W arn in gs are constantly being issued by G overnm ent officials and the National
Coal Association, both o f w h om have m ade a careful study o f the situation and are endeavoring to
prevent suffering such as occu rred during the w inter o f 1917-1918.
Several reasons contribute to
this shortage. It is estim ated that from one m illion to one and o n e-h a lf m illion foreig n -b orn w ork ­
ers, a considerable n um ber o f w h om have been w ork in g in and about our coal districts, are now sail­
ing and w ill continue to sail, a fact w hich w ill greatly ch eck production. Com bined with this con d i­
tion is the possibility o f a car shortage, due to the inability o f transportation com panies to obtain
sufficient labor to keep cars in the necessary repair. Goal should be plentiful at this season o f the
year, and it is really a serious condition to find ourselves facin g a shortage so soon. A nother factor
is the scarcity o f team sters and m en fo r yard labor. The w ise con su m er o f coal w ill secure enough to
carry him over any tem porary shortage.
The reported shortage o f coal produ ction in England and som e o f the other European countries
m eans that there w ill be a large export call. T he coal output in England to date is about 26 per cent
below that fo r the correspon d in g period last year.
The coal m ines in the vicinity o f Cincinnati have not so far this m onth done m uch to make up the
deficit in this country’ s production. T h is m eans constant w ork fo r the m iners during the balance o f
the sum m er, and throughout the com in g fall and winter. In eastern Ohio the production dropped
from 75 per cent to 70 p e r c e n t o f capacity since ou r last report. It is estimated that 90 per cent o f
the capacity production o f the sm okeless coal area o f eastern Kentucky and W e s t V irginia is under
contract to 1920. T h e dem and fo r bunkering and export purposes has been particularly heavy.
Sm okeless coal is being offered to the con su m er in this vicinity fo r the first tim e in m ore than three
years.




6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

C ollections are exceptionally good, with very few requests for extension o f tim e o f account o f
inability o f the purchaser to pay according to contract.
A special study w as m ade fo r this issue, at the coal docks in Cleveland, as to the coal tonnage
w hich is being handled by the Great Lakes fleet. The results show that lake shippers believe the ton ­
nage fo r this season w ill be at least 20 per cent less than in 1918, because, ow ing to the mild w eather
and the slow in g-u p o f business, a large am ount o f coal was carried over at the upper lake ports. By
reason o f small local dem ands, coal was rushed forw ard to the lake frontage during the early part o f
the season in order to keep the mines running; and as a result the m ovem ent up to July 1 was about
1,500,000 tons ahead o f last season fo r the same period. There has been quite a let-up in the m ove­
m ent since July 4, due very largely to the shortage o f labor and cars at the m ines, and even the c o n ­
tract boats have been experiencing difficulty in securing cargoes. Coal is slow going forw ard from the
upper lake district to the N orthw est, and in som e cases dock space is getting scarce. T h e bulk
freighters in 1918 carried 28,153,517 net tons o f bitum inous coal (w hich is a record fo r the tra d e),
but shipments fo r this season w ill drop considerably below that mark.

Exodus of Foreign-Born Labor Increasing• Many o f our foreign -b orn laborers are
leaving the country, a fact borne out by the issuance o f passports, as many are needed to rebuild their
ow n countries and to care for fam ilies w ho are victim s o f War conditions. It is reported that the
exodus from Cleveland alone w ill am ount to 35,000 before the end o f the year. The steel and coal
industries being large em ployers o f fO reign-born labor, their interests are being vitally affected by this
em igration.
The Pittsburgh district, w hich is the greatest steel center in the w orld, is facing a shortage o f labor
that threatens to seriously cripple its m anufacturing plants. Five thousand com m on laborers could find
w ork there im m ediately. In addition there are tw o thousand other places open fo r m echanics and
skilled w orkm en.
W h ile there w ill be always be som e idle m en in every com m unity, yet there is probably a sm aller
num ber o f unem ployed in this District than ever b efore known. Apparently the problem to be m et later
is not one o f w ages but o f the ability to get sufficient labor to offset the rapidly increasing exodus o f
foreign -b orn help.

Dwelling Construction the Gratifying Outlook of Building Activity. The trend
o f increased building activities is evidenced by the reports from m anufacturers o f building brick and
h ollow tile ; by the increased sale o f paints, the very noticeable increased demand for structural steel
and for lum ber fo r the construction o f hom es, notwithstanding its scarcity and high price.
The m ost h opefu l sign o f the entire building situation is found in the increased num ber o f hom es
w hich are being built. This condition exists throughout the District, but has not as yet reached the
required volum e.
T here can be no question that the present housing condition is aggravating the unsettled state o f
labor. Students o f the problem incline to the b elief that unless Government aid is offered in the
form o f Federal loans, there is no hope fo r relief on an appreciable scale.
The m ost serious problem in building construction is the inadequate supply o f skilled labor, resu lt­
ing in som e builders accepting contracts only on a cost-plus basis. Builders are also awake to the fact
that present prices will not be low ered, but, on the contrary, are likely to advance. It must be rem em ­
bered that it was approxim ately fourteen years after the Civil W a r before the quotations o f building
materials declined to p re-w a r levels, so it is not to be expected that present prices o f materials entering
into building w ill find an im m ediate reduction.
As an indication o f the extent to w hich building operations are being carried on, Cleveland reports
show that the value o f building perm its issued during the first six months o f this year exceeds that o f
any one year from 1913 to 1918, am ounting to $15,091,315, w hich is a gain over the same period in
1918 o f $5,937,805.
Akron estimates that the total cost o f new buildings for the first six months o f this year w ill amount
to $10,044,552. Perm its for new construction in the city o f Dayton am ount to but $812,000 yet there
are requests on file fo r perm its aggregating over one and on e-h a lf m illion dollars.




THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

7

A detailed com parison o f building operations in the larger cities o f the District w ill be found else­
w here in this Review.

The Realty Situation in Cleveland. Real estate conditions in Cleveland show a decided
im provem ent over previous years. T h e city is basically sound, and real estate is w ell regarded as an
investment. T here is a large volum e o f transfers and inquiries, and all indications point to a period o f
unusual activity in buying.
Vacant land is in great dem and, and allotm ent operators report big sales. There seem s to be
plenty o f ready m oney in the hands o f w ork in gm en and others w ho desire to acquire h om e-sites, and
larger dow n-paym ents are being made than ever b efore.
Factory properties are m oving briskly. Many o f the so-called non-essential industries w hose activi­
ties w ere restricted during the war are expanding rapidly and seeking new locations. Factory space is
at a great prem ium , although a considerable am ount o f new building is being done in this field. The
large expansion in factory property during the w ar does not seem to have acted as a drag on the
market, as factories w h ich w ere engaged in w ar w ork seem to have su ccessfu lly sw itched over into
peace-tim e activities, and apparently require all the space they now have.
Apartm ent house buying is brisk. Apartm ents as a class have probably advanced 15 per cent in
value in the past six m onths and probably 25 per cent in value in the past fou r years.

Merchants Unable to Obtain Better Grades of Goods. The general com plaint o f
m erchants in the District is their inability to secure the better qualities o f m erchandise. Cleveland
m erchants report very little change in textile trade. The supply o f piece goods has b ecom e m ore
m eager, and deliveries against contracts fo r fall consum ption in the garm ent trade have not yet reach ­
ed anything like a satisfactory state.
Mills are offering very p oor deliveries for spring, as they are
filled with orders for fall deliveries w hich w ill extend far beyond the norm al period.
Retail dem and continues large, w ith no apparent change in the tem per o f the buying public with
referen ce to prices. T h e dem ands seem s to continue for better qualities, irrespective o f cost. Sales so
far this year, as reported by one o f the largest departm ent stores in Cleveland, show a 37 per cent in­
crease, with collections during the m onth o f June 33 per cent better than last year.
Colum bus report says that retail business is unusually good, with reports continuing to com e from
the East o f a shortage o f m erchandise. Colum bus m erchants are m aking hurried trips to New Y ork City
to replenish their depleted stocks.
Erie m erchants report that it is m ore difficult n ow to obtain m erchandise than ever b efore, giving
as the reason the fact that the larger m ills in the East are receiving a great many orders for foreign
deliveries, and that they are being held up by the strikes o f their em ployes.
General w holesale and retail trade in the Cincinnati district has been active. Consum ers are lay­
ing in supplies o f both necessities and luxuries, w h ich had com e to low ebb because o f w ar-tim e sacri­
fices. They seem to be paying for these goods from their w eekly earnings, and not disturbing their
savings accounts, so the pickup in retail trade prom ises to be steady until these deficiencies o f hom e
demand have been filled.

Export Trade Steadily Gaining in This District. Foreign trade in the Fourth Federal
Reserve District is quietly but steadily on the gain. T he better-versed export m en w h o are returning
from Europe report that in spite o f the chaotic conditions there, they w ere able to transact considerable
business and consum m ate definite arrangem ents fo r future sales. The m a jo r ity 'o f the larger im ple­
ment, m achinery and tool m anufacturing plants have been quite busy filling their foreign orders dur­
ing the past several m onths o f dom estic depression. The increasing demand from the sm aller m anu­
facturers for inform ation on both markets and m ethods, indicates a grow in g realization o f the im port­
ance and possibilities o f foreign trade.
The relaxation o f restrictions by the W a r Trade Board together with increasing am ounts o f ship­
ping space is facilitating freight m ovem ents. R eestablishm ent o f the issuance o f through b ills -o flading by the railroads w ill be w elcom ed by inland shippers.
T he grow in g opinion that there is an



THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

appreciable volum e o f export business in this territory is substantiated by the appearance o f new fo r ­
warders, m anufacturers, agents, and local representatives o f coast insurance and steam ship lines. T h e
initiation o f ocean -bou n d freighters, either starting at or touching Cleveland, is arousing m uch interest.
Statistics from the C ollector o f Customs indicate that approxim ately $5,000,000 o f im ports and exports
passed through the Cleveland office during the first fou r months o f the present year. This does n o t
necessarily indicate a local even trade balance; many im ports cam e directly to Cleveland, and th ere­
fo r the im port figures may be considered as reasonably indicative o f that activity in Cleveland. T h e
export figures, on the other hand, represent a small proportion o f local products w hich ultim ately rea ch
the foreign field.
PHtPOSIP
The ■ ■ ■ ■ legislation perm itting all N ational
banks to becom e stockholders o f corporations engaged in prom oting foreign trade w ill doubtless b e
taken advantage o f by the National banks in this District. Financial experts o f the United States T r e a s ­
ury regard the B oard’ s action in m aking this recom m endation as one o f the m ost impprtant steps in
reconstruction yet taken. Banks generally in the District are in fine shape, w ith ample funds fo r a ll
legitim ate dem ands o f business. T he bankers are slow in lending m oney for speculative p u rp oses.
A healthy dem and fo r com m ercial credit is observed.
Brokers collateral loans are changing h an ds
m ore freely, w ith rates show ing a tendency to soften, although m ost loans are still being made at 5 yz
per cent to 6 per cent.

Money Plentiful for Legitimate Demands.

T he farm er’ s prosperity is the day-star o f the banking outlook at the present time. Deposits d u r ­
ing the last 30 days have not show n a depreciation, regardless o f the drain o f taxpaying.
The bank acceptance field has been practically at a stand-still since our last Review, as G overnm ent
requirem ents and high call m oney in New Y ork have made the demand very light. The red eem in g
feature, however, is that the sm aller country banks are beginning to buy bank acceptances as an in v est­
m ent for tem porary funds.
The transm ission o f m oney to Europe is increasing.
During one day one o f the the banks in
Youngstow n, alone, sold foreign exchange to the am ount o f $115,000.

Transportation Shows Encouraging Gains.
It is very encouraging to find that transporta­
tion is slow ly gaining. Statistics com piled by the Transportation Department o f the Cleveland C h am bei
o f Com m erce show the follow in g com parative statem ents:
May, 1919
Gars
Tons
June, 1919
Gars
T ons

Inbound
37,588
1,319,945

Outbound
22,250
655,929

Total
59,838
1,975,874

40,384
1,228,185

25,948
850,865

66,332
2,079,050

This makes an increase o f 6,494 cars handled during June, while the increased tonnage is 103 1 7 «
E quipm ent is reported as being about equal to present requirem ents, with passenger traffic u
usually heavy.
The city o f Pittsburgh is m aking trem endous plans for w idespread benefits in the w ay o f c o n
struction o f a boulevard system as a means o f relief to traffic needs.

Banks Entering the Federal Reserve System . The follow ing tw o banks have been a d
mitted into the Federal Reserve system o f the Fourth District since the publication o f our last Review
R esources
B ridgeport Bank & Trust Company, Bridgeport, Ohio ..................$915,000
Citizens Savings Bank, Upper Sandusky, O h i o .............. ................... 785,000
The Federal Reserve Board has received word from the Com ptroller o f the Currency that th e
new ly-organized First National Bank o f Pandora, Ohio, with a capitalization o f $30,000 has paid an in ­
stallm ent o f $3,000 on its capital.




9

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

B U IL D IN G O P E R A TIO N S F O R M O N T H OF JUNE
Valuations

Permits Issued
New Construction
1919—1918

Akron...............................
Cincinnati.......................
Cleveland........................
Columbus.......................
D ayton............................
E rie..................................
Lexington.......................
Pittsburgh......................
Springfield......................
T oled o .............................
Wheeling.........................
Youngstown...................

612
195
468
243
252
165*
29
392
66

219
46
228

Alterations
1919— 1918

203
144
92 508
168 931
104
95
126* 1 0 0
119*
10
69
244 148
14
18
77 160
24
18
198
43

62
435
737
94
37
137
4
63
41
30

Now Construction
1919

New
Construction
1918

2,266,772
780,605
288,105
623,755
4,101,300 1,276,400
249,995
531,655
395,112*
811,903
223,581* 285,925*
53,500
64,500
738,389
825,263
25,450
150,670
517,477
474,963
9,252
26,060
742,520
408,042

Alterations
1919

81,510
278,345
554,325
117,005
52,950
26,750
335,533
15,125
137,355
1,970
27,300

T O T A L ............... 2915 1383 2230 1640 10,885,456 4,985,738 1,628,168

Alterations
1918

Increase or

Per Cent of

Decrease o f total
valuations
1919 over 1918

Increase
or
Decrease

31,945 1,535,732
427,205
186,790
292,400 3,086,825
318,790
79,875
469,741
62,344—
33,895
3,855
184,577
237,830
138,155
2,190
32,571
147,298
8,597
10,181
34,525
327,253

189.
90.
196.8
96.6
118.7
2 1 .8—
57.8
18.8
511.1
28.9
57.
73.9

910,578 6,617,308

1 1 2 .2

•Figures include new construction and alterations.

C LE A R IN G S
June 16 to July 15
1919

1918

Increase or
Decrease

Percent of
Increase or
Decrease

Akron...................................
Cincinnati...........................
Cleveland............................
Colum bus...........................
D ayton................................
E rie......................................
Lexington............................
Pittsburgh...........................
Springfield...........................
T oled o.................................
W heeling.............................
Youngstow n.......................

32,526,000
248,637,660
496,419,254
58,463,700
21,617,004
9,683,837
5,410,499
629,135,731
6,978,822
55,387,024
21,724,489
26,316,478

27.892.000
243,929,013
411,569,550
44,174,400
17,185,105
9,193,808
3,665,147
578,705,724
5,964,770
44.210.000
16,556,794
16,828,499

4,634,000
4,708,647
84,849,704
14,289,300
4,431,899
490,029
1,745,352
50,430,007
1,014,052
11,177,024
5,167,695
9,487,979

32.3
25.7
5.3
47.6
8.7
17.
25.2
31.2
56.3

TOTAL

1,612,300,498

1,419,874,810

192,425,688

13.5




16.6
1.9

20.6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

10




STATEMENT OF
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF CLEVELAND.
July 18, 1919.

RESOURCES
Gold
Gold
Gold
Gold

coin and certificates............................................................................ $32,239,000
settlement fund with F. R . Board................................................... 44,259,000
with Federal Reserve Agent............................................................. 120,438,000
redemption fund................................................................................
1 ,0 1 1 , 0 0 0
T O T A L GOLD R E SE R V E ....................................................... 197,947,000

Legal tender notes, silver, etc.....................................................................

910,000

TO T A L CASH R E S E R V E ....................................................... ..............198,857,000
Bills discounted— Secured by Government War Obligations...............
Bills discounted— All other.........................................................................
Bills bought in open market..................................................................... ..

100,469,000
9,661,000
55,649,000

Total bills on hand....................................................................... 165,779,000
U. S. Government Bonds ..........................................................................
1,084,000
U. S. Government Victory N otes.............................................................
_o_
U. S. Government certificates of indebtedness.....................................
18,574,000
T O T A L E A R N IN G ASSETS...................................................

185,437,000

Uncollected items and other deductions from gross deposits..............
5 % Redemption fund against F. R. bank notes.....................................
All other resources........................................................................................

6g 449

qoo
897^000
1,388^000

455,028,000

T O T A L RE SO U RCES...............................................................

LIABILITIES.
Capital paid in ..............................................................................................
Surplus fund..................................................................................................

$9,255,000
5,860,000

15,115,000

Government deposits..................................................................................
14,597,000
Due to members— Reserve accounts....................................................... 126,924,000
Deferred availability items.........................................................................
56,798,000
Other deposits................................................................................................
8,319,000
TO T A L GROSS DEPOSITS.....................................................

206,638,000

Federal Reserve notes in actual circulation.........................................
Federal Reserve bank notes in circulation— net liability........ ............
All other liabilities........................................................................................

215 948 000
16,774,000
553^000

T O T A L L IA B IL IT IE S ..............................................................

455,028,000

11

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW.

PICKUPS ON BUSINESS TOPICS
AIL can now be sent by airplane from New York to
Chicago leaving New York abput 5 a. m. and reaching
Chicago about 1 p. m. Planes are changed at Belfont, Pa., and
Cleveland. The air mail arrives in Cleveland in time to catch
the plane leaving there at 9.30 a. m. for a non-stop flight to
Chicago. About 12,000 letters a day are taken for Pacific
coast points and through air mail service from New York to
Chicago will advance the delivery of mail for Seattle, San
Francisco, Los Angeles and other cities about twenty-four
hours sooner than if sent from New York through by train
mail. This applies to letters received in New York postoffice
for the 8.40 p. m. train westward.
Air mail from the west for Chicago and points east is
taken on at Chicago and Cleveland. A plane leaves Chicago
at 2.30 p. m. arriving in Cleveland at 5.30 p. m. in time to
connect with the 20th Century limited, and the mail arrives
in New York about 9 o ’clock the next morning. This gives
the business men about three more hours to dispatch mail
from Chicago than if sent by train about noon. An airplane
leaves Chicago in the morning at 8.30 taking on all air mail
from train connections and the mail arrives in New York
about 1 p. m., a stop being made at Belfont, Pa., to change
planes. This also gives the business man a late night service
by train to Cleveland, connecting with the morning plane at
that point for New York and points east and advancing mail
delivery many hours over that by through train service.

M

1.11IIII11IIIIIII)IIIH
ilIIIIIIII

United States mints established a new record for monthly
output in June by turning out 98,610,000 pieces o f money,
Director Ray T. Baker announced. Of the total pieces 91,364,000 were pennies which was 13,000,000 greater than the pre­
vious record made in December, 1917. The remainder con­
sisted of 6,427,000 nickles and 370,000 dimes.
iiiiiiiiitiiiiiiiiiiiiiiimiiitiiiiitH

Progress in reconstruction o f France Transportation
Systems is shown in a report made by the Minister o f Trans­
portation to President Poincare. Since the signing o f the
armistice 564 miles of double-track railway lines and 567
miles of single-track lines on the north and east railway have
been restored. Of 645 miles of canals closed to navigation,
198 miles have been reopened to commerce. Seven thousand
miles of highways, out o f 24,000 miles that were damaged
have been put in good condition.
iiiiiitfiuiiiiittinttim iitm tm iii

By a unanimous vote the Argentine Senate last week
approved without reservation the entrance o f Argentina into
the League of Nations. The Argentine Republic is the first
nation to assent, through its treaty-making body, to the
League of Nation’s covenant.
itiiiiiiiiiiimiiiHiiiiiiiiiiiiiiimi

A new steamship line has been established between the
ports of Boston and Buenos Aires. It is expected that other
vessels of the United States Shipping Board will be assigned
shortly for the South American service. This service has
long been needed, and will go far in bringing the two conti­
nents together.
imiiitiitiiiititiiiiiimitiHiitiiiti

Chicago takes on the role o f an export port. The first
steamer sailed on June 25 from Chicago to Great Britain.
It will mark the first big step in the development o f inland
water transportation by the Emergency Fleet Corporation.
The trip by way of the Great Lakes and Montreal, to the
Atlantic is expected to require three weeks.

.......... .

As a special compliment in honor o f Dr. Epitacio Pessoa,
President-elect of Brazil, Postmaster General Burleson
speeded up the completion o f the money order convention
between the United States and Brazil so that as far as action
by the United States is concerned the convention should be
concluded while Dr. Pessoa was the nation’s guest at
Washington.
The money order exchange offices will be located at New
York City and at Bio de Janeiro. When the treaty is signed
at Rio de Janerio it will then go into effect and will greatly
facilitate the commercial operations between the two
countries.




ALL national banks throughout the United States will be
f l permitted to become stockholders of corporations en­
gaged in promoting foreign trade if Congress enacts legisla­
tion that is now being urged by the Federal Reserve Board
and by bankers quite generally.
The amendments would permit any national bank until
January 1, 1921, without regard to the amount of its capital
and surplus, to invest an amount not exceeding in the aggre­
gate 5 per cent of its paid-in capital and surplus in the stock
of one or more corporations such as described, provided that
the total o f such investments by any one national bank shall
not exceed 10 per cent of its capital and surplus. As the
capital and surplus of national banks now exceeds $2,000,000,000, enactment of the proposed legislation would enable them
to devote about $100,000,000 for the purpose indicated.
iiiiiiiiitimimiiuiiiiiiiiiiitiMiii

Whatever may have been the fact three months ago,
there are few students of the business situation who now
hold that there must be or will be a general and important
decline in commodity prices and wages before the real busi­
ness activity of the world will be resumed, says the Iron Age.
From the present level no marked deflation need be expected
in commodities and wages without corresponding decrease in
the world’s currency, government bonds and bank deposits,
and in those items there is no present promise of more than
a very gradual decrease. Any approximation to prices com­
parable with pre-war standards would require great increases
in efficiency in production, or it might come after severe
industrial depression, making men much more willing than
they are at present to work very hard for what they secure
in the commodities or services they purchase with their
earnings.
iiitiiiiiiiiiiiHiiiiiniiHitiitiiinit)

The fiscal year beginning July 1 next will witness, it is
believed, the greatest annual expansion of trade between the
United States and Latin America that has ever taken place
in peace times, according to a statement by John Barrett,
Director-General o f the Pan-American Union. This fact was
emphasized at the recent Second Pan-American Commercial
Conference held here. Ever since the beginning o f the war
there has been an extraordinary growth in Pan-American
commerce due largely to war conditions. It increased approxi­
mately from $750,000,000 in the fiscal year immediately pre­
ceding the war, 1913-14, to about $1,750,000,000 last year,
1917-18, a gain of $1,000,000,000, or 133 per cent in only four
years. Of this total the growth in exports from the United
States to the twenty other American republics amounted to
157 per cent, and the imports from those countries to 119 per
cent.
iiiiiiiiiiMiiiiiiiiiinHiiiiiiiiiiini

President Wilson has created the position o f United
States Wheat Director, and Julius H. Barnes, president of
the Federal Grain Corporation, will be its first incumbent.
The Wheat Director will direct the handling of the 1919
crop and administer the $1,000,000,000 appropriated to sustain
the price guaranteed by the Government.

m
iim
im
iiH
iiiiiim
iim
iiM
iN
iii

There is a shortage o f one million homes in the United
States, according to William H. Garland of Los Angeles,
president o f the National Association of Real Estate Boards.
Delegates predicted a nation-wide boom in building.
They declared the only obstacle in the way is the failure of
the manufacturers to stabilize prices for materials.
IIIUIMtllllllttllltlllllllllltlllMllt

A bill has passed the United States Congress granting
permission for the construction of a vehicular tunnel under
the Hudson River between New York and New Jersey.
HIMIIItlttlllinllllllHIIIHIIIIIItt

The Peruvian Postmaster General has been authorized to
ask for tenders from several European and American firms
for the establishment of aerial routes for transportation of
mail, passengers and freight.
lUHHiMMiimiitmiMHimiHiim.

Sale of thrift stamps, which, at twenty-five cents apiece
provided $956,023,121 toward financing the war will be con­
tinued permanently by the Treasury, Secretary Glass
announced.